California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 1, 1996

Student v. San Francisco Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 788-95 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

San Francisco Unified must reimburse 1993-94 private school costs for an eligible student with serious emotional disturbance; 1994-95 claim denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parent of a 19-year-old filed for due process against the San Francisco Unified School District. From 1990 to 1993 the student attended the district's Wallenberg High School. She earned almost only D's and F's in academic classes even though her intelligence and achievement scores were above average. The district assessed her in 1991 and 1994. Both times it considered only specific learning disability and found her ineligible. It never addressed serious emotional disturbance, even though its 1991 assessor wrote that an emotional disturbance was affecting her schoolwork. After the 1992-93 school year, her parents placed her at New Learning School, a private independent-study high school in South San Francisco.

Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel found that in 1993-94 the student met the "general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression" test for serious emotional disturbance. He relied on her private school teacher's testimony, clinical reports from August 1993, and the parent's expert psychologist. The district should have found her eligible by fall 1993. Its duty to find her continued after she enrolled in private school. Because the district offered no appropriate services, the private school counted as an appropriate placement, even though it was not ideal. The parents' refusal of transfers to other public high schools did not reduce the award. The district must reimburse 1993-94 out-of-pocket costs. The record shows tuition was $6,800. For 1994-95, depression no longer significantly affected her schoolwork, so she was not eligible and reimbursement was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a student assessed only for a learning disability when the records pointed to an emotional disability. It also shows that eligibility can change from one year to the next, and that a private placement does not have to be ideal for parents to be reimbursed under Burlington.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partEligibility

    Issue 1. Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of serious emotional disturbance?

    The student met the 'pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression' criterion for serious emotional disturbance in 1993-94, and the District should have found her eligible by fall 1993. She was not eligible in 1994-95, when depression no longer significantly affected her schoolwork.

  2. Issue 2. If so, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the private New Learning School for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years?

    Full reimbursement was ordered for 1993-94 because the District offered no appropriate services and the private school was appropriate though not ideal. Reimbursement for 1994-95 was denied because the student was not eligible that year.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof of payment, the District must reimburse Petitioner for out-of-pocket expenses for the student's attendance at New Learning School in 1993-94. The record shows 1993-94 tuition was $6,800.
  • Declaratory order that the student was eligible for special education during the 1993-94 school year by reason of serious emotional disturbance.

Total: $6,800 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Lapides v. Coto; 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9); Education Code §56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Michael Zatopa, attorney for Student
  • Katherine Fleury, compliance officer, District representative, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Dr. Pam Mills, school psychologist, District witness, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Amy Rosenbluth, English teacher and contract manager, witness for Student, New Learning School
  • Dr. Vincent Nunno, psychologist, independent evaluator and expert witness for Student
  • George Matranga, head counselor, District witness, Wallenberg High School
  • Georgia Freeman, school psychologist (1991 assessment), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Rosemary Jalovaara, school psychologist (1994 assessment), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Dr. Hope Salinger, private psychologist
  • Dr. McNamara, private counselor
  • Kevin Rist, M.D., treating psychiatrist, McAuley Neuropsychiatric Institute, St. Mary's Hospital
  • Adrienne Crandall, psychological intern (psychological testing), McAuley Neuropsychiatric Institute, St. Mary's Hospital
  • New Learning School, private school (unilateral placement), South San Francisco

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on December 12-13, 1995.

Petitioner was represented by attorney Michael Zatopa. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent was represented by Katherine Fleury, compliance officer. Also present on behalf of Respondent was Dr. Pam Mills, school psychologist.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner: PARENT; Amy Rosenbluth, English teacher, New Learning School; and Dr. Vincent Nunno, psychologist. The following witnesses testified on behalf of Respondent: George Matranga, counselor, Wallenberg High School; and Dr. Mills.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties, the record was left open until January 18, 1996, for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of serious emotional disturbance?

2. If so, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the private New Learning School for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years?

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

STUDENT is nineteen years old. She lives with her family in San Francisco, attends the local community college, and works at a downtown clothing store. She has not received a high school diploma. This case concerns the events of STUDENT's five years in high school, at both the public Wallenberg High School in the District (1990-1993) and the private New Learning School in South San Francisco (1993-1995).

A. Testimony of Petitioner's Witnesses

1. MOTHER

PARENT, STUDENT's mother, testified that STUDENT is one of seven children. At age four STUDENT was sexually molested on one occasion by a thirteen-year-old neighbor. At age seven she was sexually molested on one occasion by her then twelve-year-old brother. PARENT described this incident as emotionally traumatic but not physically invasive. Additionally, STUDENT was emotionally affected by the molestation of her younger sister by another older brother. The molest incidents resulted in an investigation of the family by the Department of Social Services.

STUDENT attended a parochial school, St. Paul's Primary School in San Francisco, through eighth grade. According to her mother, STUDENT was a "C" student during her tenure at St. Paul's. Socially, she had close friends, was well-liked, and had no behavior problems.

Beginning at age eight and continuing through approximately age fourteen -- about the time she completed the eighth grade at St. Paul's -- STUDENT received private counseling from psychologist Dr. Hope Salinger. When STUDENT was fourteen, Dr. Salinger observed that STUDENT was not talking much in their sessions and seemed uninterested in the therapy. Dr. Salinger gave STUDENT the option whether to continue; STUDENT chose not to.

In the fall of 1990, STUDENT enrolled in the ninth grade at Wallenberg High School, a public high school in the District. During this time, PARENT was working between seventy and eighty hours per week as a nurse in addition to caring for her seven children. Therefore, she testified, her memories of STUDENT's experiences at Wallenberg High are short on detail.

During ninth grade, STUDENT received very poor grades. STUDENT's teachers informed PARENT that, while STUDENT attended class regularly and had no behavior problems, she was not turning in her work. However, the teachers offered no extra help to remedy this problem. STUDENT appeared to spend time at home working on school assignments, but rarely completed an assignment sufficiently to her liking that she would turn it in. She seemed stable at home and had no social difficulties. She was excited about joining the school's cross country team and later disappointed when she was ruled academically ineligible for athletics.

Toward the end of STUDENT's first semester at Wallenberg, in January of 1991, the student study team and PARENT agreed that a referral for special education was called for. District school psychologist Georgia Freeman conducted an assessment of STUDENT to determine whether she was eligible for special education. (Exh. 1) At an IEP meeting in late May 1991, the District, based on Ms. Freeman's written assessment report, found STUDENT ineligible for special education because she did not have a specific learning disability. (Exh. 2) The District did not refer STUDENT for special education again during her tenure at Wallenberg, which was to last three years.

PARENT did not have any specific recollection of the events of STUDENT's tenth grade year at Wallenberg (1991-1992). She recalled, generally, that STUDENT continued to receive poor grades and had no behavior problems.

In approximately November 1992, when STUDENT was in eleventh grade, the school provided her with a tutor. PARENT believes that the tutoring was performed by an aide in a study hall monitored by the school's resource specialist. At first, STUDENT was excited about the tutoring. However, after a short while, she became unresponsive to the tutor's help and didn't seem to care about the tutoring. Eventually, she stopped showing up for appointments. At the tutor's recommendation, in approximately February 1993, the tutoring relationship ended. STUDENT continued to receive poor grades during eleventh grade.(Footnote 1)

According to PARENT, STUDENT began to be noticed socially by boys during eleventh grade because of her physical attractiveness. During the first few months of 1993, PARENT later learned, STUDENT became sexually active. STUDENT became somewhat vague and evasive when discussing her social activities with her mother, and began to have some emotional difficulties. On one occasion during the spring of 1993, STUDENT slapped two boys at school and was suspended for one day. According to PARENT, this was the first time STUDENT had ever received discipline at school for misbehavior. By that spring, STUDENT rarely spent time at home working on school assignments. Instead, she often wrote notes to herself about interpersonal relationships and emotional troubles.

During the early morning of August 13, 1993, several weeks before STUDENT was to enter her twelfth grade year at Wallenberg, PARENT discovered that STUDENT had stayed out all night. PARENT found handwritten notes in STUDENT's room indicating that STUDENT had also stayed out all night on other recent occasions, engaging in sexual activity in various locations, including cars, with various partners, including some boys whom she hardly knew. The notes indicated that STUDENT was scared, felt bad about herself, and wanted her mother to find out about these events. That morning, when STUDENT came home, PARENT took her to the adolescent unit of the McAuley Neuropsychiatric Institute at St. Mary's Hospital in San Francisco, where she was admitted.

Upon STUDENT's discharge from McAuley on August 30, 1993, her parents unilaterally enrolled her in New Learning School (NLS), a private school in South San Francisco. For approximately a few months thereafter, STUDENT received infrequent, private counseling from a Dr. McNamara that was not associated with her attendance at NLS. STUDENT attended NLS, at her parents' expense, during the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years.(Footnote 2) On April 4, 1995, when STUDENT was nearing completion of her first year at NLS, PARENT, through her attorney, Mr. Zatopa, requested that the District assess STUDENT to determine whether she was eligible for special education. (Exh. H) An assessment plan was prepared on May 3 and signed by PARENT on May 16. Id.

In September 1994, early in STUDENT's second year at NLS, District school psychologist Rosemary Jalovaara conducted an assessment of STUDENT. (Exh. 3) Ms. Jalovaara did not ask PARENT for copies of the McAuley reports and PARENT did not offer to provide them. At an IEP meeting on November 22, 1994, the District, based on Ms. Jalovaara's written assessment report, again found STUDENT ineligible for special education because she did not have a specific learning disability. (Exh. E) In the spring of 1995, STUDENT lived with a relative for approximately six weeks due to conflicts with her mother. That spring, PARENT sought an independent evaluation from psychologist Dr. Vincent Nunno. (Exh. F)

STUDENT stopped attending NLS after the spring semester of 1995, when she was still a few credits shy of graduation. In the fall of 1995, she attended City College of San Francisco, where she obtained failing grades in all of her classes and eventually withdrew from most of them. That fall, STUDENT began work at a clothing store in downtown San Francisco. Currently, based on the recommendation of Dr. Nunno, she attends weekly psychotherapy with a licensed clinical social worker.

2. Amy Rosenbluth

Ms. Rosenbluth was an English teacher at New Learning School (NLS) in South San Francisco during STUDENT's two years of attendance, 1993-94 and 1994-95. NLS is a private, nonsectarian, college preparatory high school. It is not certified to provide special education services. The students at NLS generally have average to above-average achievement test scores but have not performed well in a traditional public school setting due to boredom, special learning needs, and/or truancy.

At NLS, each student pursues an individualized program, working at his or her own pace. The program is described as "guided independent study." Students spend the majority of their time working on their own. They also spend time in one-to-one tutorials with staff, and in small seminars in groups of five students. At the beginning of each day, each student signs a contract of assignments to complete. At the end of each day, each student's progress is reviewed by his or her contract manager. (Ms. Rosenbluth was STUDENT's contract manager.) A staff member is available for informal counseling.(Footnote 3)

NLS does not give "D" or "F" grades, nor does it require that coursework be completed within any definite time period such as a traditional school semester. Whenever a student completes 90% of the coursework in a particular class, the student receives a letter grade ("A", "B" or "C") and credit for the class. If a student has not satisfactorily completed the coursework by the time a report card is issued, the student may receive a grade of "IP" (In Progress). If it appears unlikely that a student will satisfactorily complete the coursework within a reasonable amount of time, the student may receive a grade of "NC" (Not Completed) and be removed from the class.

NLS did not give STUDENT transfer credit for courses in which she received a "D" at Wallenberg. Therefore, at NLS STUDENT repeated some courses she had already taken. Although she had already attended three years of high school at Wallenberg, she spent an additional two years at NLS pursuing her diploma.

a. The 1993-94 School Year

According to Ms. Rosenbluth, during the 1993-94 academic year, STUDENT often worked hard on her individual assignments, but she did not complete enough of them. The writing in the papers she did turn in was of college-level quality. She referred to herself as a "perfectionist," and was very critical of her own work. It often took her a long time until she felt ready to turn in an assignment. Additionally, she socialized too much with friends in class, and often signed out of class to take long social breaks in the student lounge. She rarely did homework.

Emotionally, during the 1993-94 school year -- particularly during the first few months -- STUDENT's moods were cyclical, going dramatically up and down. On occasion -- perhaps one or two days per week -- she seemed down on herself and distracted by nonschool concerns. She seemed to be having problems with relationships, in particular with boys and, to some extent, with her mother. She never said she was depressed, but did exhibit low self-esteem and often made critical comments such as "this is stupid." She stood out as depressed in comparison to the other students. During those times when she was feeling bad about herself, she would just sit, do no work at all, show no motivation, and perhaps take less care of her physical appearance. During these times it seemed she was never ready to take a test or turn in an assignment.

STUDENT's NLS report cards included the grades for which she was on track and Ms. Rosenbluth's comments on her academic progress. (Exhibit D) According to Ms. Rosenbluth, NLS does not address emotional concerns in report cards. Significant information from the report cards for the 1993-94 school year is summarized below:

November 1993 (2 A, 1 C, 5 NC)

STUDENT is an exceptionally bright young woman; she has the ability and potential to do extremely well in her academic work but most of her time is spent socializing with other students . . . [she] has not been handing in homework assignments on a daily basis . . .

January 1994 (1 B, 3 C, 4 IP)

STUDENT works diligently during her time in school. However, STUDENT needs to do homework every night to catch up in her courses. Her attitude has been positive and I've had no problem with her behavior in class . . .

Spring 1994(Footnote 4) (1 B, 3 C, 3 NC)

STUDENT has made excellent progress this quarter in algebra . . . STUDENT's attitude continues to be positive and I see her following through with her goals.

b. The 1994-95 school year

During the 1994-95 school year, academically, STUDENT was still a perfectionist but was able to focus more on her work. Emotionally, STUDENT was much more self-aware, connected, and under control. She did not appear to be having problems with boys, and liked herself better. She had fewer ups and downs, and did not stand out as depressed. Report cards included the following information:

November 1994 (4 C, 2 NC)

STUDENT has been working much more consistently this quarter. Her assignments show thoughtful and attentive work.

January 1995 (3 C, 2 IP)

STUDENT focuses on completing roughly two assignments a day. Her work is excellent and thorough. However, she must work on home assignments . . . STUDENT's attitude is fine . . . she still takes a while to get started with her work.

April 1995 (4 C, 1 IP)

. . . Has worked consistently [in] American Government.

In the spring of 1995, when she turned nineteen years old, STUDENT learned that she could attend community college without graduating from high school. At that point, she lost some of her motivation to pursue her diploma. When she left NLS in June 1995, she was still a few credits shy of graduation.

3. Dr. Vincent Nunno

Psychologist Dr. Vincent Nunno evaluated STUDENT at Petitioner's request in April 1995, shortly before the end of STUDENT's tenure at New Learning School. (Exhibit F) On testing, Dr. Nunno found that STUDENT had above-average to superior intelligence. He also found that she had good basic academic skills, as evidenced by the fact that she performed on achievement tests at above twelfth grade level. He found that she had attention problems, which were substantially controlled by Ritalin. On tests of emotional functioning, she showed significant depression and anxiety. In his interview of STUDENT, Dr. Nunno found her to be meek, passive, and depressed, and to exhibit low self-esteem.

Dr. Nunno reviewed STUDENT's report cards from Wallenberg High School (1990-1993), the 1991 assessment by Ms. Freeman, and the 1994 assessment by Ms. Jalovaara. He did not review records concerning STUDENT's performance at New Learning School (1993-1995). He noted that STUDENT's poor grades at Wallenberg were not consistent with her high ability. He acknowledged that he had no evidence that STUDENT had exhibited depression in the classroom at Wallenberg, but noted that each of the three diagnoses from her stay at McAuley in August 1993 included an element of depression. While none of those diagnoses rose to the level of major depression, the fact that Dr. Rist prescribed lithium indicated a significant degree of depression.

Dr. Nunno concluded that STUDENT has a serious emotional disturbance (SED) and attention deficit disorder (ADD). He determined that the SED is based on dysthymia (minor depression) and a generalized anxiety disorder. He stated that STUDENT's emotional condition could be a long-term consequence of the early molestations.(Footnote 5) Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT's emotional troubles are consistent with those of other children who have experienced a violation of trust at an early age. He stated that her sexual activity in 1993 is consistent with that of other adolescents who have been molested. He stated that such experiences at a very young age can lead to confusion between love and sexuality -- especially when the molester is a family member. He stated that the molestations may have led STUDENT to devalue herself and place herself in dangerous sexual situations. While she experienced some mother-daughter conflict typical of teenage girls, her emotional troubles were more complicated than those of typical peers. Dr. Nunno recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy.

With respect to academics, in Dr. Nunno's opinion, STUDENT's inability to produce and poor grades at Wallenberg were a direct result of both her SED and ADD.(Footnote 6) More specifically, the ADD contributed to her difficulties with organization and focusing on her work in class. Because of SED, she was unable to value herself and her work, and therefore unable to open herself up to judgment of her work. She was a perfectionist, and was never satisfied that her work was good enough to turn in. She saw herself as a failure. When she received failing grades because of her inability to produce, this reinforced her low self-esteem.

B. Testimony of District's Witnesses

1. George Matranga

Mr. Matranga is the head counselor at Wallenberg High School. His duties include disciplinary and academic counseling. He testified that, in comparison to other high schools in the District, Wallenberg is considered more intensely academic. The curriculum is college preparatory. Upon their graduation from high school in 1994, seventy-two percent of STUDENT's classmates entered four-year universities, and all but one or two of the remaining class members went to community college. In addition to its focus on academics, Wallenberg is smaller and considered physically safer than other high schools in the District. For all of these reasons, the school is attractive to many parents and students.

Despite its academic standing, Wallenberg has no minimum academic requirements for admission. Students are admitted at random by computer. This is how STUDENT gained admission despite her undistinguished performance at St. Paul's.

During STUDENT's three years at Wallenberg, Mr. Matranga estimated that she was sent to his office for classroom misbehavior -- typically talking in class or talking back to the teacher -- approximately twice per week, perhaps thirty to fifty times per year. He referred to her as a "chatterbox." Mr. Matranga stated that this was not an unusual number of contacts, and that he saw many of STUDENT's fellow students that often. He did not consider STUDENT to be a "behavior problem."(Footnote 7)

In his interactions with STUDENT, Mr. Matranga found her to be friendly, pleasant, verbal, outgoing and social. She did not seem depressed, although she was perhaps worried about her grades. She expressed some emotional concerns, typical of teenage girls, regarding relationships with peers and friends. She did seem to dwell on such relationships more than other students did.

Mr. Matranga met and spoke with PARENT frequently during STUDENT's tenure at Wallenberg -- both individually and as part of of STUDENT's "student study team." Mr. Matranga believes that at some point the school provided some special assistance to STUDENT, either tutoring or consultation between the school's resource specialist and STUDENT's teachers. However, he has no specific recollection as to what was provided. Mr. Matranga testified that, in his opinion, STUDENT received the maximum amount of special assistance a regular education student could receive at Wallenberg with the resources available. He noted, however, that there are "not a lot of options" for students at Wallenberg who cannot keep up academically.

On several occasions, Mr. Matranga discussed with PARENT the possibility of STUDENT's transferring to a high school with less rigorous academic requirements. However, PARENT preferred to keep STUDENT at Wallenberg.

2. Dr. Pam Mills

Dr. Mills is a District school psychologist. She had no involvement with STUDENT's case prior to the hearing and has not met or evaluated STUDENT. She reviewed records about STUDENT in preparation for her testimony.

Dr. Mills stated that, in her opinion, STUDENT was not SED at any time, with the possible exception of during her stay at McAuley in August 1993. She noted that, while STUDENT may have had problems with self-esteem, they were not affecting her achievement test results, which were above grade level. She stated that, in her opinion, STUDENT's poor grades at Wallenberg High School were primarily attributable to (1) socializing too much with peers in class; (2) not doing her work in order to rebel against her mother; and (3) cutting classes in order to spend time with friends. She believes that emotional issues linked to the molestations were a contributing factor, but not the major factor, in STUDENT's poor grades.

Dr. Mills testified that she is currently the liaison between the District's special education unit and McAuley Hospital's adolescent psychiatric unit. She testified that, commonly, when a District student is hospitalized at McAuley, hospital staff make a referral to the District for evaluation for special education eligibility. She testified that, while the McAuley psychological report on STUDENT did recommend that such a referral be made in this case, to her knowledge the District did not receive the report. (Exh. 6)

In her testimony, Dr. Mills criticized Dr. Nunno's 1995 assessment report. She testified that Dr. Nunno's diagnosis of dysthymia was inappropriate because, according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), one of the criteria for that diagnosis is that the patient has not previously been diagnosed with cyclothymia, as STUDENT was during her 1993 stay at McAuley. DSM-IV, pg. 349. She testified, however, that she does not have an opinion as to the proper DSM-IV diagnosis of STUDENT's emotional condition at any time because she has not personally evaluated STUDENT.

Dr. Mills also criticized the conclusions Dr. Nunno drew from his testing of STUDENT's emotional functioning. She testified that by permitting STUDENT to take home the Milton Adolescent Clinical Inventory (MACI), Dr. Nunno compromised the validity of the results of that test. Additionally, the MACI results in a standardized, computerized interpretive report. (Exh. F) Therefore, Dr. Mills asserted, not all of the conclusions contained therein necessarily apply to STUDENT.

C. Significant Documentary Evidence

1. 1991 District Assessment

In February 1991, District school psychologist Georgia Freeman performed an assessment of STUDENT to determine whether she should be found eligible for special education.(Footnote 8) (Exhibit 1) Ms. Freeman found, based on standardized ability testing, that STUDENT had above-average to superior intelligence. Additionally, STUDENT's performance on standardized achievement testing was above-average -- she achieved at a twelfth grade level, although she was in ninth grade at the time. Ms. Freeman noted that STUDENT was not turning in her work regularly, was having difficulty with organizational skills, and was receiving very poor grades, and that her teachers believed "she needs individual attention before or after school." Ms. Freeman determined, however, that STUDENT did not have a specific learning disability, and, for that reason, recommended that she not be found eligible for special education.

In her assessment, Ms. Freeman did not specifically address whether she believed STUDENT had a serious emotional disturbance (SED) which would qualify her for special education. (Exh. 1) However, significant portions of the written assessment report addressed emotional issues:

STUDENT had therapy secondary to anxiety around family issues from ages 6 to 13 years . . . PARENT regards family private matters as privileged information that should not be discussed with non-family members. (p.2)(Footnote 9)

The social/emotional dynamics of STUDENT's family have been rather stormy in terms of the sibling interactions. These difficulties have apparently impacted STUDENT's learning development. She obviously has more potential than she is currently using, at this time. (p.2)

[the family's] reticence about sharing private family matters with outsiders . . . has an adverse effect on STUDENT's ability to express her emotions [and] could exacerbate STUDENT's existing defense mechanism of "denial" of the traumatic situation that occurred when she was seven years of age. (p.3) I sense that STUDENT is unable, at this time, to expend enough energy to maximize her intellectual potential. It appears that considerable energy is pent up in coping with anxiety around the past stressful events which have impacted the family. These issues were apparently suppressed by STUDENT when the projective tests were administered because they were obviously too painful to confront. She is apparently using denial as a means of coping with the anxiety around these issues . . . the emotional stress needs to be worked through. [Then] STUDENT should be able to invest enough energy to perform successfully in the school arena. STUDENT is especially more vulnerable during adolescence when she has to deal with more developmental issues. (p.4)

[STUDENT has an] impaired need to experience success. (p.4)

Projective tests suggest some anxiety around family issues and the use of denial in terms of coping with her emotional stress. (p.5)

Ms. Freeman concluded that:

STUDENT has an emotional disturbance which is apparently impacting her academic performance. (p.5)

At an IEP meeting in May 1991, based on Ms. Freeman's determination that STUDENT did not have a specific learning disability, the District found STUDENT ineligible for special education. (Exh. 2)

2. 1994 District Assessment

In September 1994, when STUDENT was eighteen years old, Rosemary Jalovaara, District school psychologist, performed an assessment of STUDENT to determine whether she should be found eligible for special education.(Footnote 10) (Exh. 3) This was approximately one year after STUDENT's hospitalization at McAuley and early in STUDENT's second, and final, year at the New Learning School.

Ms. Jalovaara determined, based on testing, that STUDENT had average to above-average ability. She also found that STUDENT's performance on achievement testing was at grade level (twelfth grade) or above, "within the expected range," and showed that she was working to potential in all areas. She noted, based on discussions with New Learning School teachers, that it appeared STUDENT was doing well there and performing "at or above level." She noted that STUDENT stated she was able to perform better at New Learning School because she was able to work at her own pace and was better able to attend in a small group. Ms. Jalovaara concluded that STUDENT did not have a specific learning disability, and, for that reason, recommended that she not be found eligible for special education. (Exh. 3)(Footnote 11)

Like Ms. Freeman, who performed the District's 1991 assessment of STUDENT, Ms. Jalovaara did not specifically address whether she believed STUDENT had a serious emotional disturbance which would qualify her for special education. However, Ms. Jalovaara did perform testing to evaluate STUDENT's emotional functioning. Like Ms. Freeman, Ms. Jalovaara devoted significant portions of her written assessment to emotional issues. The report noted that STUDENT stated that she had been admitted to McAuley Hospital in the summer of 1993 because of emotional issues. However, there was no indication in the report that Ms. Jalovaara obtained documents from McAuley or interviewed any persons at McAuley who treated STUDENT. (Dr. Pam Mills, the District school psychologist who appeared at the hearing, testified that, in her opinion, Ms. Jalovaara should have investigated the McAuley hospitalization in more detail.)

In her interview of STUDENT, Ms. Jalovaara did not observe STUDENT to be depressed, and noted that STUDENT did not report depression. Ms. Jalovaara's written summary of the interview noted:

STUDENT believes that she is doing well, has friends and believes that her difficulties are due to problems with her mother over-reacting to her dating situation. STUDENT states that she has difficulty getting along with both of her parents . . . She is not taking any medications. STUDENT does not report any depression or difficulties with mood swings, appetite, or sleep. (Exh. 3)

On projective tests, Ms. Jalovaara found that STUDENT had difficulties with her mother, whom she viewed as "controlling," and desired greater independence from her family. She found that STUDENT showed some difficulty with self-confidence but had respect for herself and perceived herself as well-liked.

3. McAuley Hospital Reports a. Psychiatric Admission

A Psychiatric Admission report was prepared by psychiatrist Kevin Rist, M.D., upon STUDENT's admission to McAuley Hospital on August 13, 1993. (Exh. 4) The admission diagnosis was "rule out" Bipolar Affective Disorder. Dr. Rist noted that STUDENT reported she lost her virginity in the spring of 1993, that since then she had been sexually active with several boys, and that her school peers thought she was "loose." She reported sneaking away from home on several occasions to have sex. She also reported significant difficulty sleeping.

Dr. Rist found that STUDENT exhibited rapid, pressured speech and racing thoughts. He determined that because of several "stressors," STUDENT had shown poor judgment and become impulsive sexually, and her school performance had taken a steep decline.(Footnote 12) He recommended a period of hospitalization.

b. Psychological Report

During STUDENT's stay at McAuley, psychological testing was performed by Adrienne Crandall, psychological intern. (Exhibit 6) Ms. Crandall met with STUDENT on several occasions and administered a variety of tests. Based on testing, Ms. Crandall found that STUDENT had high-average to superior intelligence. As for emotional issues, she noted:

STUDENT is currently feeling high levels of anxiety and likely suffers from chronic depression. STUDENT experiences her significant level of anxiety as diffuse and overwhelming. Furthermore, she feels much sadness and psychological pain.

STUDENT has impaired self-esteem . . . She experiences herself in negative terms and may feel that she has failed to meet familial and personal expectations. She feels exploited, violated, and damaged. Moreover, she feels pessimistic about the future and hopeless regarding her current set of circumstances.

She acts out [her distress over molestation] in impulsive sexual activity.

Ms. Crandall diagnosed STUDENT with (1) depressive disorder not otherwise specified, (2) "rule out" cyclothymia based on clinical symptoms, and (3) post-traumatic stress disorder secondary to abuse. (Exhibit 6) She recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy for depression. She also recommended that STUDENT be referred to the District for educational testing to assess whether she had a specific learning disability. Ms. Crandall did not address whether or not she believed STUDENT had SED.

c. Discharge Summary

A Discharge Summary was prepared by Dr. Rist upon STUDENT's discharge from McAuley Hospital, after a two and one half week stay, on August 30, 1993. (Exhibit 5) The discharge diagnosis was "Cyclothymic Disorder." In the report, Dr. Rist recalled that on admission STUDENT was giddy and hypomanic, and exhibiting poor judgment and sexual inappropriateness. He noted that he had prescribed lithium for her, and that the medication seemed to have made her less giddy, more appropriate, and more able to concentrate on activities on the unit.

Dr. Rist noted that during STUDENT's stay at McAuley he held extensive discussions with her parents. In these meetings, Dr. Rist and the parents discussed STUDENT's feeling that she had been abandoned by her family and allowed to be too out of control. The parents indicated that, upon her discharge, STUDENT would attend New Learning School in South San Francisco. STUDENT was discharged on August 30, 1993, in stable, satisfactory and somewhat improved condition with instructions to continue taking lithium and participating in individual psychotherapy.

DISCUSSION

A. Applicable Law

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), children with disabilities are entitled to a free, appropriate education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); California Education Code §56000. The term "children with disabilities" includes children with one or more specified disabilities, including serious emotional disturbance (SED), who, by reason thereof, need special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(1)(A); California Education Code §56026(a-b). Serious emotional disturbance is defined by IDEA's implementing regulations as follows:

(i) The term means a condition exhibiting one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affects a child's educational performance -- (a) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory or health factors;

(b) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;

(c) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances;

(d) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (e) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

(ii) The term includes schizophrenia. The term does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance.

34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9).(Footnote 13)

Petitioner does not assert that STUDENT met the criteria in either (a), (b), (c), or (e) above. The evidence showed that, in fact, STUDENT did not meet those criteria. She was able to acquire knowledge, as evidenced by above-average scores on standardized achievement tests. Subsection (a). She had many friends. Subsection (b). School personnel never viewed her as a significant "behavior problem." Subsection (c). She did not develop physical symptoms based on personal or school problems. Subsection (e).

However, the regulations require only that a student meet one of the five listed criteria in order to establish eligibility. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9); see also Lapides v. Coto, 1987-88 EHLR 559:387 (N.D. Cal. 1988). Petitioner asserts only that she met the criteria in (d), that is, "a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression." Petitioner asserts that this depression existed over a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that it adversely affected STUDENT's educational performance. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9)(i).

The following discussion addresses whether the evidence shows that STUDENT met criteria (d) during the relevant time period herein.

B. Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of serious emotional disturbance?

1. Events prior to August, 1993

The evidence showed that, despite above-average to superior intelligence, STUDENT received extremely poor grades at Wallenberg (1990-1993). She received exclusively D's and F's in academic classes. Upon entering the school in ninth grade, STUDENT quickly fell behind the pace necessary to achieve sufficient credits to graduate with her class in four years. By mid-year in ninth grade, the student study team determined that STUDENT should be referred for special education. According to Education Code §56303, such a referral should be made only after "the resources of the regular education program have been considered and, where appropriate, utilized."

The February 1991 assessment by Ms. Freeman noted that STUDENT was not turning in her work, was having difficulty with organizational skills, was receiving very poor grades, and that her teachers believed "she needs individual attention before or after school." While Ms. Freeman's report did not address whether STUDENT had SED,(Footnote 14) it appeared to conclude that STUDENT's poor grades were a direct result of her emotional troubles. Ms. Freeman clearly believed the molestations still haunted STUDENT to such a degree that she could not perform adequately in school. The report stated:

The social/emotional dynamics of STUDENT's family have been rather stormy in terms of the sibling interactions. These difficulties have apparently impacted STUDENT's learning development. She obviously has more potential than she is currently using, at this time. (p.2)

I sense that STUDENT is unable, at this time, to expend enough energy to maximize her intellectual potential. It appears that considerable energy is pent up in coping with anxiety around the past stressful events which have impacted the family . . . the emotional stress needs to be worked through. [Then] STUDENT should be able to invest enough energy to perform successfully in the school arena. (p.4)

[STUDENT has an] impaired need to experience success. (p.4)

STUDENT has an emotional disturbance which is apparently impacting her academic performance. (p.5)

(Exhibit 1, emphasis supplied.)

Ms. Freeman did not testify at the hearing, and therefore it is not known whether she considered the "emotional disturbance" which was "impacting [STUDENT's] academic performance" to be a "serious emotional disturbance" as defined by federal and state law. The quoted passages, however, would have supported a conclusion that, as of February 1991, STUDENT had SED. That is, the report establishes that STUDENT's unhappiness and anxiety over the long-ago molestations was so overwhelming that she was not able to perform adequately in school. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9). While Mr. Matranga, the counselor, testified that in his discussions with STUDENT she did not seem depressed, he did not offer any contrary explanation for STUDENT's poor grades. Mr. Matranga did not assert, for instance, that STUDENT's excessive talking in class was the cause of her poor grades; nor was there any other evidence that this was so.

During tenth grade (1991-1992) and eleventh grade (1992-1993), STUDENT continued to receive very poor grades. PARENT testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT began having more significant emotional troubles in early 1993 when she turned seventeen years old and became sexually active. According to PARENT, STUDENT lost interest in her tutoring program and was suspended for slapping two male students. The evidence shows that her attendance worsened. That summer, STUDENT began staying out all night and engaging in impulsive sexual activity, and became, in her own words, "out of control."

2. The 1993-94 school year

By August 1993, STUDENT required two and one-half weeks of psychiatric hospitalization at McAuley. Clinical staff diagnosed her with depression linked to the long-ago molestations, and prescribed lithium. Psychological intern Ms. Crandall noted:

STUDENT is currently feeling high levels of anxiety and likely suffers from chronic depression. STUDENT experiences her significant level of anxiety as diffuse and overwhelming. Furthermore, she feels much sadness and psychological pain.

STUDENT has impaired self-esteem . . . She experiences herself in negative terms and may feel that she has failed to meet familial and personal expectations. She feels exploited, violated, and damaged. Moreover, she feels pessimistic about the future and hopeless regarding her current set of circumstances.

She acts out [her distress over molestation] in impulsive sexual activity. (Exhibit 6.)

Ms. Crandall's report recommended that STUDENT receive psychotherapy for depression and that she be referred to the District special education unit for an evaluation. Dr. Mills, the District school psychologist who is the District liaison with McAuley, acknowledged that STUDENT was most likely significantly depressed at the time of her hospitalization. She stated, however, that the District did not receive Ms. Crandall's report recommending a special education evaluation. The evidence showed that the District did not perform an evaluation at that time. Although STUDENT enrolled in private school shortly after her discharge from McAuley in August 1993, she remained a resident of San Francisco. Therefore, the District still had an obligation to seek her out and assess her to determine whether she was eligible for special education. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. §300.220; California Education Code §56300.

Ms. Rosenbluth, STUDENT's English teacher and contract manager at New Learning School, testified that during the 1993-1994 school year -- and particularly the first few months of the fall semester -- STUDENT was often so depressed about interpersonal relationships that she could not function in school. Ms. Rosenbluth stated that on these occasions STUDENT appeared down on her self and distracted. She just sat, did no work at all, showed no motivation, took less care of her physical appearance, and frequently made critical comments such as "this is stupid." She turned in no work and did not take tests. According to Ms. Rosenbluth, STUDENT's depression during that school year was noticeable and she stood out as depressed. While STUDENT certainly spent too much time socializing in school, it is clear that her depression had a negative impact on her performance.

Although a cursory glance at STUDENT's report cards from NLS suggests that she received better grades at NLS than she did at Wallenberg, a more in-depth examination reveals that her academic performance remained marginal. NLS does not give D's or F's, and does not require that coursework be completed within any specific time frame such as a traditional academic semester. In many of her classes, STUDENT had not completed enough work to receive a grade by the time report cards were issued. Report card comments for some classes included notations such as "Has not worked at all in this class." (Exhibit D) In those classes in which she completed enough work to receive a grade, she received mostly "C's" -- the lowest grade NLS gives. Had her academic performance at NLS been evaluated using the same grading system employed by Wallenberg, it is clear that STUDENT would have continued to receive a significant number of D's and F's.

The expert witnesses at the hearing, Dr. Nunno and Dr. Mills, disagreed as to the cause of STUDENT's poor academic performance. Dr. Nunno, Petitioner's expert, testified that, in his opinion, STUDENT's inability to produce was, in substantial part, linked to her depression. With respect to the 1993-94 school year, the Hearing Officer places greater weight on Dr. Nunno's opinion because it has greater factual support in the record. The reasons for placing greater weight on Dr. Nunno's opinion for that school year are as follows.

First, Ms. Rosenbluth's testimony regarding the 1993-94 school year at NLS described a bright student who was noticeably depressed and often so preoccupied with emotional concerns that she could not function adequately in school. Second, the McAuley reports from August 1993 indicated that STUDENT was suffering from significant depression. Third, the evidence concerning STUDENT's emotional condition and its effect on her academic performance during 1993-94 was very similar to the information contained in Ms. Freeman's February 1991 report -- a report that arguably supports the conclusion that STUDENT had SED at that time. Fourth, there was no evidence involving contemporaneous observations of STUDENT during 1993-94 which rebutted either Ms. Rosenbluth's testimony or the McAuley reports.

The Hearing Officer finds that, with respect to the 1993-94 school year, the opinion of Dr. Mills, the District school psychologist, has less support in the record than does that of Dr. Nunno. Dr. Mills testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT's academic deficiencies were attributable to (1) too much socializing in class, (2) not doing her work to rebel against her mother, and (3) poor attendance. She testified that emotional issues were a contributing factor, but not the major factor, causing STUDENT's poor grades.

As for (1), while it is true that STUDENT spent too much school time talking with friends, that fact alone does not explain her anemic academic performance. As for (2), while there was evidence that STUDENT had conflicts with her mother, there was no evidence that she failed to turn in her work in order to spite her mother. As for (3), while STUDENT's attendance varied, her academic performance was just as poor in academic classes in which her attendance was fairly good as it was in academic classes in which her attendance was poorer.

Based on the evidence presented at the hearing, it is concluded that STUDENT had a serious emotional disturbance that adversely impacted her education during the 1993-94 school year. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9). The District should have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of SED during the fall of 1993, if not several years earlier.

3. The 1994-95 school year

Ms. Rosenbluth testified that during the 1994-95 school year at NLS, STUDENT did not exhibit noticeable depression, and seemed to have her problems with boys under control. Academically, she was able to focus more on her work than she had the previous year. The major factor in her failure to graduate in the spring of 1995, after three years at Wallenberg and two years at NLS, was her discovery that she could attend community college without receiving a diploma. According to Ms. Rosenbluth, when STUDENT -- who turned nineteen years old that spring -- learned that fact, she lost motivation to get her diploma.

Ms. Rosenbluth's testimony is consistent with the assessment report completed by District school psychologist Ms. Jalovaara in September 1994, which found that, as of that date, STUDENT was doing fairly well at NLS and was not exhibiting significant depression. (Exhibit 3) Although Dr. Nunno testified that, as of May, 1995, he believed STUDENT was still suffering from significant depression, he did not evaluate STUDENT's 1994-95 academic performance at NLS. The focus of the IDEA's definition of SED is on the school environment. Policy Letter, U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), 1988-89 EHLR 213:247, 249 (1989). For that reason, and because it is contradicted by Ms. Rosenbluth's testimony, Dr. Nunno's opinion that STUDENT still had SED in spring, 1995 is not entitled to significant weight.

It is concluded that STUDENT did not have a serious emotional disturbance which adversely impacted her education during the 1994-1995 school year. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9). Therefore, she was not eligible for special education during that school year.(Footnote 15)

The Hearing Officer recognizes that one federal court has noted that "finding that a student does not need special education services because he or she performs well while in a special education program is circular." Lapides v. Coto, 1987-88 EHLR 559:387 (N.D. Cal. 1988). The finding of ineligibility for the 1994-95 school year is not premised on the fact that STUDENT experienced some emotional and academic improvement that year in relation to the previous year. Rather, it is premised on the fact that STUDENT no longer exhibited in school a "general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression" that had a significant adverse impact on her performance. 34 C.F.R. §300.7(a)(9)(i)(d). While the emotional issues that STUDENT had grappled with since childhood had not gone away, they were no longer having the significant effect on her schoolwork which they had had the previous year.

C. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the private New Learning School for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years?

1. The 1993-94 school year

Under the IDEA decision-makers have authority to award "appropriate" relief. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Appropriate relief may, under certain circumstances, include reimbursement for private school tuition. Parents are entitled to be reimbursed for private school expenditures if it is determined that the school district failed to offer a free, appropriate education and the private school placement was proper. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). Reimbursement can be ordered even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 114 S.Ct. 361, 365-366 (1993).

It has been determined herein that the District should have found STUDENT eligible for special education by the fall of 1993, if not earlier. Accordingly, STUDENT was entitled to a free, appropriate education (FAPE) during the 1993-94 school year. The evidence showed that STUDENT did not receive an appropriate education at Wallenberg. Despite her high intelligence, she received all D's and F's in academic classes for three successive years. While there was some evidence that the school offered tutoring from an aide -- briefly -- and informal counseling from Mr. Matranga, it is clear that STUDENT needed more intensive, specialized assistance.

Because the District did not offer appropriate, specialized, services, the parents were entitled to seek out an appropriate, private placement. The weight of evidence showed that NLS was an appropriate placement. It provided specialized assistance such as an individualized program, daily contract, additional time to complete work, and smaller class size. By her second year at NLS, it appeared that STUDENT had received some benefit from these modifications. In September 1994, STUDENT told Ms. Jalovaara that the modifications seemed to have helped her, and Ms. Rosenbluth testified that STUDENT showed some improvement -- both emotionally in terms of her ability to focus on academics -- that year.

Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, supra, at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Therefore, it is proper to examine the overall quality of the education STUDENT received at NLS. Admittedly, NLS may not have been the best possible placement for STUDENT. Most importantly, there was no evidence that she received much-needed mental health counseling there. In addition, her academic performance remained marginal, and she did not graduate. However, in this case the District had failed STUDENT, and the parents risked shouldering the cost of what they perceived -- correctly -- to be an appropriate placement. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the reasoning of the Fifth Circuit in Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986). The court in Alamo stated:

The Burlington rule [on reimbursement] is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the interim placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act.

Based on the reasoning of Alamo, the Hearing Officer finds that, under the circumstances, the fact that NLS was not the ideal placement for STUDENT does not warrant a reduction in the award of tuition reimbursement for the 1993-94 school year.

The Hearing Officer must also examine the parents' conduct in determining whether a reimbursement remedy should be limited. Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F. 3d at 1496. Between 1990 and 1993, the parents consistently turned down the District's much-repeated offer to have STUDENT transfer from Wallenberg to a less academically rigorous public high school in the District. That fact does not warrant a reduction in the reimbursement award. There was no evidence that STUDENT would have fared any better in a regular education program at a less academically rigorous public high school than she had at Wallenberg. In any event, the District should have found STUDENT eligible for special education services by no later than the fall of 1993.

In conclusion, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the full amount of NLS tuition for the 1993-94 school year.

2. The 1994-95 school year

It has been determined herein that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during the 1994-95 school year. Therefore, she was not entitled to FAPE. Accordingly, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for New Learning School tuition for the 1994-95 school year is denied.

ORDER

1. STUDENT was eligible for special education during the 1993-94 school year by reason of serious emotional disturbance.

2. Within twenty (20) days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for out-of-pocket expenditures associated with STUDENT's attendance at the New Learning School for the 1993-94 school year.

3. Petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue #1: Should the District have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of serious emotional disturbance?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent it was determined that STUDENT should have been found eligible for special education during the 1993-94 school year.

Issue #2: If so, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the private New Learning School for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years?

Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue to the extent it received reimbursement for 1993-94 tuition.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: February 1, 1996 _____________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: STUDENT's grades in academic subjects at Wallenberg during 9th grade (1990-1991), 10th grade (1991-1992) and 11th grade (1992-1993) were as follows (column headings are "F" for fall semester and "S" for spring semester):

9th F S 10th F S 11th F S Lit F F Lit C D Lit F F History F D Biology F D History F D Math F F Algebra D F Science D D French D F French D D Algebra D F French D D Footnote 2: Tuition was $6,800 in 1993-94 and $7,200 in 1994-95. (Exh. G) Footnote 3: Ms. Rosenbluth testified that she did not know whether STUDENT received counseling at NLS. Footnote 4: This particular report card was undated, but based on the information contained therein and viewing all of the report cards together, it appears that this one must have been issued sometime during the spring of 1994. Footnote 5: Dr. Nunno testified that, at PARENT's request, he did not describe either the molestations or STUDENT's high school sexual activities in detail in his written assessment report prepared in May 1995. (Exhibit F) Instead, the report referred to "some unfortunate activities at eight years of age" and noted that "the details of her early family problems and adolescent behavioral difficulties will not be discussed here at her parents' request." At the hearing, Dr. Nunno discussed his knowledge of these events in more detail. He concluded that these events seriously damaged her self-esteem. Footnote 6: Petitioner does not assert that the District should, at any time, have found STUDENT eligible for special education by reason of ADD. Even assuming, without deciding, that STUDENT has ADD, a student with ADD is eligible for special education only if he or she meets eligibility criteria in the categories of other health impairment, specific learning disability, or serious emotional disturbance. Education Code §56339(a); U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, 18 IDELR 116 (1991). Footnote 7: On average, STUDENT missed the following number of days of each of her academic classes, per semester, during her three years at Wallenberg:

Grade Fall Spring 9th 4.5 9.5 10th 4.5 8.5 11th 9.2 12.0 (Exhibits A, C) Her attendance was poorest in classes immediately before and after lunch. Id. Footnote 8: Ms. Freeman, who has since retired from the District, did not testify at the hearing. Footnote 9: PARENT testified that Ms. Freeman's original written assessment report made specific reference to the molestations and that, at PARENT's request, Ms. Freeman revised the report by deleting the reference. Footnote 10: Ms. Jalovaara, who is on medical leave, did not testify at the hearing. Footnote 11: Ms. Jalovaara did note that STUDENT would likely have some difficulty focusing in large groups in a public school, regular education program. Footnote 12: Dr. Rist wrote that the most significant of these stressors was the recent return to the family home of the older brother who had molested STUDENT when she was a young child. At the hearing, PARENT testified that this portion of Dr. Rist's report was incorrect, and that, in fact, the older brother who molested STUDENT never left the family home. It also appears, based on STUDENT's report cards from Wallingberg, that during the difficult events of the Spring semester of 1993 her grades did not take a steep decline. Rather, her already poor grades remained poor. (Exh.A,C) Footnote 13: California's definition of serious emotional disturbance is almost identical to the federal definition, with the additional requirement that the "inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances" in (c) must be "exhibited in several situations." Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3030(i).

Footnote 14: The report found only that STUDENT did not have a specific learning disability because there was not a severe discrepancy between her ability and her achievement as measured by standardized testing. Education Code §56337; Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3030(j).

Footnote 15: Petitioner does not seek a ruling that STUDENT is currently eligible for special education by reason of serious emotional disturbance. Petitioner simply seeks reimbursement for NLS tuition for 1993-94 and 1994-95. Because STUDENT -- who will turn twenty years old in April, 1996 -- is not yet twenty-two years and has not yet received a high school diploma, she would still be eligible to receive special education from the District if she currently met the criteria for SED. 20 U.S.C. §§1401(a)(18); 1412(2)(B); Education Code §56026; Letter to Richards, 17 EHLR 288 (OSEP 1990). However, the evidence showed that during the 1994-95 school year STUDENT did not have SED, and no evidence was presented that she currently has SED.