California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 22, 1996
Student v. Not stated in decision (referred to only as "the District"; schools named are Los Angeles Unified School District schools)
SEHO Case No. SN 807-95 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel
District must reimburse parents for a one-to-one aide at a private religious school and for 18 private speech sessions.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 5 notes the parties settled prospective speech therapy services in late February 1996. No remand, appeal or correction is noted.
Summary
Parents of a six-year-old girl filed for a hearing over her 1995-96 kindergarten year. She is eligible for special education because of an orthopedic impairment and a hearing impairment. She had spent the prior year in a special day class with a one-to-one aide. At June 1995 IEP meetings, district staff agreed she could succeed in a regular kindergarten with supports. They adjourned to bring in an inclusion specialist, but the team never reconvened. The IEP named no placement and had no academic goals. It did not describe supplementary aids or curriculum changes. It also had no plan for moving her from a class of six to eight children to one of about 35. The parents enrolled her at Ohr Eliyahu Academy, a private religious school, and paid for a full-time aide.
The Hearing Officer found that these gaps denied her a FAPE. Under Union School District v. Smith, the district had to complete the IEP and make a formal written offer, even if the parents seemed unlikely to accept it. The district must reimburse the aide's cost for the afternoon general studies portion of the day from September 1995 through June 1996. Relying on Zobrest, the Hearing Officer held that the Establishment Clause did not bar this. The parents recovered 18 of 48 private speech sessions. That covered half the missed summer sessions and the 12 sessions the district therapist missed. Claims for sessions during a delay the parents asked for, and for more speech therapy, were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith: an unfinished IEP with no named placement, goals or supports denied FAPE, even though the district agreed in principle to full inclusion. It also ordered reimbursement for an aide at a religious school for secular instruction and reduced speech reimbursement for equitable reasons.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?
The June 1995 IEP was never completed. It named no placement, had no academic goals, described no supplementary aids or curriculum modifications, and had no transition activities into regular class. That denied FAPE, and the parents' apparent reluctance did not excuse the district.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If not, must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of a privately obtained one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program at STUDENT's private, sectarian school, Ohr Eliyahu Academy?
Because no FAPE was offered and the aide let the student take part in class, the district must reimburse the aide's cost for the general studies portion of the day through June 1996. Under Zobrest, the Establishment Clause does not bar this reimbursement.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of privately obtained speech therapy from July 1995 to February 1996?
Parents get reimbursement for 18 of 48 private sessions: 6 of 12 summer sessions, because responsibility was shared equally, and the 12 sessions the district therapist missed. Sessions during the delay the parents requested were denied, and there was no proof the IEP's level of speech therapy was insufficient.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents' out-of-pocket payments to Ohr Eliyahu Academy for the student's one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program, from September 1995 to the date of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Continue reimbursing parents for the one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program at Ohr Eliyahu Academy through the end of the school year in June 1996.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, reimburse parents' out-of-pocket payments to Barbara Vasser for 18 sessions of speech therapy, July 1995 to February 1996.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; Board of Education of Sacramento City USD v. Holland; Christen G. v. Lower Merion School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Lynn Karz, director of general studies and resource specialist; witness for Student, Ohr Eliyahu Academy
- June Downing, assistant professor of special education; expert witness for Student, California State University, Northridge
- Ruth Hiland, private speech therapist; witness for Student
- Lisa Basiri, case manager; witness for Student, Westside Regional Center
- Barbara Vasser, private speech therapist
- Shaun Clarke, sign language interpreter for Student's counsel
- Connie Schultz, sign language interpreter for Student's counsel
- Shirley Brown, due process coordinator; District representative, District
- Dorothy Jackson, special education coordinator, District
- Rosalie Saxman, educational audiologist, District
- Nancy Algotson, teacher of deaf and hard of hearing students (DHH specialist), District
- Nancy Franklin, inclusion specialist, District (Canfield Elementary School)
- Rebecca Kahn, DHH specialist, District
- Paula Barak, least restrictive environment counselor for students with physical disabilities, District
- Ruth Springer, speech therapist, District
- Katie Webb, special day class teacher for orthopedically handicapped students, District (Richland School)
- Ohr Eliyahu Academy, private sectarian school (unilateral placement), Culver City
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Encino, California, on March 5 and 6 and April 23 and 24, 1996.
Petitioner was represented by attorneys Alexis Kashar and Valerie Vanaman. Sign language interpreters Shaun Clarke and Connie Schultz assisted Ms. Kashar. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were her parents, PARENTS. Respondent was represented by Shirley Brown, due process coordinator. Also present on behalf of Respondent was Dorothy Jackson, special education coordinator. The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner: PARENTS; Lynn Karz, director of general studies and resource specialist, Ohr Eliyahu Academy; June Downing, assistant professor of special education, California State University at Northridge; Ruth Hiland, speech therapist; and Lisa Basiri, case manager, Westside Regional Center.
The following witnesses testified on behalf of Respondent: Ms. Jackson; Rosalie Saxman, educational audiologist; Nancy Algotson, teacher of deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) students; Nancy Franklin, inclusion specialist; Rebecca Kahn, DHH specialist; Paula Barak, least restrictive environment counselor for students with physical disabilities; Ruth Springer, speech therapist; and Katie Webb, special day class teacher for orthopedically handicapped (OH) students.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the request of the parties the record was left open until May 14, 1996 for the receipt of written closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?
2. If not, must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of a privately obtained one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program at STUDENT's private, sectarian school, Ohr Eliyahu Academy?
3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of privately obtained speech therapy from July 1995 to February 1996?
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE
1. Background
STUDENT is six years old and lives with her parents, PARENTS, in West Los Angeles within the District. STUDENT, who has above-average intelligence, is eligible for special education by reason of orthopedic handicap (OH) and hearing impairment.(FOOTNOTE 1) STUDENT was born with cerebral palsy and a bone deformity in her right arm and left leg. Currently, she walks with the aid of braces and uses an orthopedic chair. Her hearing impairment is severe with respect to high range sounds and mild to moderate with respect to low range sounds. She wears hearing aids, and her teacher wears an FM transmitter which amplifies the teacher's voice for STUDENT.
STUDENT currently attends regular education kindergarten at Ohr Eliyahu Academy (OEA), a private, sectarian school in Culver City. She receives certain specialized services from the District, pursuant to her IEP, at a public school site. These include speech therapy, deaf and hard of hearing (DHH) teaching services, and occupational therapy. The District also provides STUDENT's FM system at the private school. However, although STUDENT's IEP calls for one-to-one classroom assistance, the District has declined to provide such assistance on the private school premises.
As an infant and toddler, STUDENT attended early intervention programs for children with disabilities at UCLA. The UCLA program closed in the spring of 1994, when STUDENT was four years old. In June 1994 the IEP team including the parents agreed to place STUDENT for the 1994-95 school year in Katie Webb's special day class (SDC) for OH students at Richland School. (P 9) At the IEP meeting, the parents requested that the District provide STUDENT with a one-to-one classroom aide to assist her in numerous ways. The IEP document stated that the IEP team acknowledged STUDENT's need for one-to-one assistance but could not authorize it. (P 9) Following an informal conference requested by the parents in July 1994, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one assistant trained in the needs of hearing-impaired students. (P 7)
2. The 1994-95 school year
STUDENT's SDC at Richland School included 6-8 students, a teacher, two aides, and a one-to-one aide devoted almost exclusively to STUDENT. The aide assisted STUDENT with physical safety -- at the time she used a walker and also walked on her knees. The aide also assisted her in accessing the computer, getting puzzles and other items from shelves, and opening lunch items, as well as by repeating and rephrasing instructions not heard and/or understood. STUDENT made educational progress that year. (P 4) For example, her sentence lengths increased and the intelligibility of her speech improved. By the end of year she was more independent and required less assistance from her aide.
However, the parents were not pleased with STUDENT's experience in the SDC that year. Among their concerns were: (1) There was a delay in providing a one-to-one aide; then, a series of one-to-one aides -- each of whom lacked adequate training in the needs of hearing-impaired students -- came and went; (2) STUDENT was not mainstreamed into regular education classes for any portion of her day because the regular education classes were located too far from the SDC; (3) Ms. Webb told the parents that she was frustrated by all of the related service providers involved in STUDENT's program; and (4) STUDENT often fell asleep in class late in the morning and was not enthusiastic about school.(Footnote 2)
In the spring of 1995 the parents contacted District administrators to inquire about alternative programs for STUDENT for kindergarten in the 1995-96 school year. The District mentioned a number of SDCs that the parents had previously seen, including Richland, but the parents had concerns about each class. The District also mentioned a DHH class at Cowan School, but stated that it was inappropriate for STUDENT because it was located a significant distance from the school's restroom. Finally, the District arranged a visit to an SDC at Castle Heights School. PARENT observed that the class included students with cognitive disabilities and behavior problems. PARENT and a District representative agreed that STUDENT would not be physically safe in the class.
The IEP team met on June 7, 1995. (P 4) The IEP document prepared that day included present levels of performance in hearing, communication, auditory skills, academics, social skills, self-help skills, and motor abilities. The IEP also included annual goals with corresponding short term objectives in auditory skills, speech, adapted physical education (APE) and motor skills, but not academics. The IEP called for the following related services to be provided to STUDENT: APE, speech, DHH teaching services, occupational therapy and physical therapy. It was noted that "student continues to need one-to-one assistance for toileting, computer, eating and mainstreaming." With respect to placement, several SDCs were discussed; however, none was formally offered or accepted. The possibility of full inclusion in a regular education class was mentioned only briefly. The parents indicated that they would like to adjourn the meeting to visit some more SDCs. The IEP team agreed to reconvene on June 26. In the interim, at the parents' request, the District arranged a visit to the SDC at Cowan School. Upon visiting the class, the parents agreed with the District's conclusion that it was inappropriate for STUDENT.
The IEP team reconvened on June 26. At the meeting, the parents requested that STUDENT be fully included in a regular education kindergarten class in the fall. District representatives agreed that, given the progress STUDENT had made in the previous year, she could successfully participate in regular education with appropriate classroom supports and continuation of her related services. However, at that point, the District representatives stated that it was necessary to adjourn the meeting to obtain the participation of a full inclusion specialist -- that is, a special educator who assists in ensuring the successful participation of disabled students in regular education classrooms. The District representatives stated that the IEP team could not write academic goals and objectives for which a regular education teacher would be primarily responsible. Rather, an inclusion specialist would draft academic goals and objectives for which the inclusion specialist would be primarily responsible. The inclusion specialist would also identify, and describe on the IEP document, any adaptations or modifications to the regular education curriculum necessary to ensure STUDENT's successful participation.
It was agreed that the IEP was not yet complete because it lacked the "full inclusion" component described above. Additionally, the IEP was silent as to a recommended placement. (P 4) District representatives suggested that the IEP team would reconvene later in the summer to complete the IEP.
Within a few days of the June 26 meeting, Nancy Franklin, inclusion specialist with responsibility for Canfield Elementary School, STUDENT's neighborhood school, telephoned PARENT.(Footnote 3) Ms. Franklin stated that because it was now summer, the regular education kindergarten class at Canfield would not be available for observation until the start of the new school year in September. During this conversation, PARENT expressed concern about the large number of students in regular education classes. Ms. Franklin stated that, upon her return from summer vacation in mid-August, she would contact PARENT to arrange an observation. Ms. Franklin did not discuss reconvening the IEP team to complete STUDENT's IEP.
In mid-August the PARENTS enrolled STUDENT in the private Ohr Eliyahu Academy (OEA) and filed a request for a due process hearing. In September PARENT observed the Canfield class with Ms. Franklin. PARENT believed it was not an appropriate placement. There were 35-40 children in a small classroom. One student had significant behavior problems. PARENT believed the high level of background noise and activity in the room would make the class too overwhelming for STUDENT and that she would not be able to follow the instruction. PARENT had other unresolved concerns based on prior difficulties in coordinating STUDENT's aide, FM system and related services, and the District's assertion at the June 26 IEP meeting that the regular education teacher could not be held accountable to STUDENT's IEP.
PARENT did not indicate that she wished to enroll STUDENT in the Canfield class. By that time the parents were pleased with STUDENT's progress at OEA. Consequently, Ms. Franklin did not observe STUDENT at OEA or reconvene the IEP team for the purpose of adding a "full inclusion" component and completing the IEP. Ms. Franklin testified that she would have done so only if the parents had indicated they wished to enroll STUDENT in the Canfield class. In October, District special education coordinator Dorothy Jackson wrote the PARENTS a letter stating that she believed the District had an "appropriate placement" for STUDENT and briefly summarizing the June IEP meetings and Canfield visit. (R 22) STUDENT has remained at OEA for the entire 1995-96 school year.
3. The 1995-96 school year
OEA's program consists of Hebrew language and religious studies in the morning and general studies in the afternoon. STUDENT attended a regular education kindergarten class taught by one teacher and one aide. She was assisted by a full-time, one-to-one aide. She also received thirty minutes per week of resource specialist assistance in reading and writing from Ms. Karz, a credentialed special education teacher and speech therapist.
STUDENT's aide assisted her with both physical and communication needs. Physical needs included posture, playing safely at recess, holding the pencil, opening items at lunchtime, and toileting. Communication needs included repetition and rephrasing of instructions not heard and/or understood, and prompts and/or reminders as to what to do next. The aide employed from September to November had low energy and at times showed an inability or unwillingness to properly assist STUDENT. In November, an aide was hired who performed the duties appropriately.
STUDENT had a successful year at OEA. She made progress in all areas, including reading, writing, motor skills and socialization. (P 61) In language, the intelligibility of her speech improved and her sentence lengths increased. She participated in class and took pride in being a full member of the class.
In February 1996 June Downing, an assistant professor of special education at California State University, Northridge retained by the parents to testify at the hearing, observed the same Canfield regular education kindergarten class that Ms. Franklin and PARENT had observed in September 1995. Professor Downing observed that the teacher did an excellent job keeping the children motivated, together, eager and positive. She felt that this could be an appropriate placement for STUDENT if she received appropriate support services.(Footnote 4) Ruth Hiland, a private speech therapist retained by the parents to testify at the hearing, also observed the Canfield class in March 1996. She believed that the class was too noisy for STUDENT.
4. Speech therapy
STUDENT has received speech therapy throughout her school career. During the past several years the parents have, at times, supplemented the District's service by paying privately for additional speech therapy from Barbara Vasser. During 1994-95, while attending Richland School, STUDENT received speech therapy from the District pursuant to her IEP. Therapy was provided at the school twice weekly for 30 minutes per session. STUDENT also received therapy once weekly from Ms. Vasser.
The parties agree that STUDENT made progress on the speech goals contained in her IEP during 1994-95. Her speech became more intelligible, and her sentence lengths increased. The June 1995 IEP called for a continuation of the previous level of service, although the parents requested additional service. (P 4) STUDENT's IEP also called for "extended school year services."
During the summer of 1995 STUDENT attended summer school in Ms. Webb's class at Richland for only one or two days. Because no aide was present to assist STUDENT, the parents enrolled her in a private summer camp. Ms. Webb telephoned the parents but they did not return calls. There was no discussion between the parties regarding provision of speech therapy that summer, and the District did not provide any such therapy to STUDENT during that period. Beginning in late July, STUDENT's private sessions with Ms. Vasser increased in frequency from once weekly to twice weekly. (P 63) STUDENT received twelve sessions of speech therapy from Ms. Vasser that summer.
Beginning in September, once STUDENT had enrolled in the private school and the District's fall semester had begun, the District advised the parents that speech therapy was available to STUDENT at Canfield Elementary School, STUDENT's neighborhood school. The parties agreed to schedule the service twice weekly from 8:30 a.m. to 9:00 a.m. However, the parents requested, because of the large number of Jewish holidays in September and early October, that the District's service not begin until October 11. STUDENT continued to receive therapy from Ms. Vasser during this time.
Between October 11, 1995 and February 28, 1996 District speech therapist Ruth Springer provided therapy to STUDENT pursuant to her IEP. During this time, Ms. Springer missed 12 scheduled sessions and STUDENT received thirty-six sessions of private speech therapy from Ms. Vasser.(Footnote 5) (P 18) STUDENT continued to make progress in speech during this period. The intelligibility of her speech improved and her sentence lengths increased.
DISCUSSION
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?
Disabled students are entitled to a free, appropriate education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §1401(a)(16-18). In order to provide a disabled student with a FAPE, a school district must develop a procedurally appropriate Individualized Education Plan (IEP) that is reasonably calculated to provide the student with substantive educational benefit. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).
Another element of a FAPE is that the student must be educated in the "least restrictive environment (LRE)." 34 C.F.R. §300.550. More specifically, the federal LRE mandate provides that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities . . . [should be] educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B). The IDEA's LRE provision reflects Congress' preference for educating disabled students in regular classrooms with their nondisabled peers. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1403 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).(Footnote 6) The federal regulations note that the term "supplementary aids and services" is synonymous with "modifications", and describes what is done to the regular education program to ensure a disabled student's satisfactory participation. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48. Such supplementary aids and services must be described in the student's IEP. Id. Common examples include a one-to-one aide, curriculum adaptations, and assistive technology.
In order to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year, one must examine the June 1995 IEP. (P 4) The evidence showed that the IEP was procedurally deficient in several significant respects. First, the IEP was silent as to a recommended placement. The IDEA requires a formal, written offer of a specific placement. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ____ (1994).(Footnote 7) Second, it is undisputed that the IEP was never completed.
The law requires that an appropriate IEP be in effect at the beginning of the school year, before special education and related services are provided to the child. 34 C.F.R. 300.342. Although the District agreed in principle with a "full inclusion" placement at the June 26, 1995 IEP meeting, it never reconvened the IEP team, with the presence of a full inclusion specialist, to add the "full inclusion component" necessary to complete the IEP. The District's full inclusion specialist, Ms. Franklin, testified that, had PARENT accepted the Canfield Elementary School placement, she (Ms. Franklin) would have observed STUDENT at OEA and then reconvened the IEP team for the purpose of adding the missing components. However, the Ninth Circuit has stated that a school district cannot escape its obligations to complete the IEP, formally offer a placement and indicate what educational assistance is being offered to supplement the placement by arguing that a disabled child's parents expressed an unwillingness to accept the placement. Union School District v. Smith, supra, 15 F.3d at 1526.(Footnote 8)
Third, as a result of the District's failure to complete the IEP process, the IEP document lacked a description of the specific supplementary aids and services, including curriculum modifications, necessary to ensure STUDENT's satisfactory participation in regular education. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48. Without a completed IEP, the parents were unable to evaluate "what educational assistance was offered to supplement [the] placement, if any." Id. Union School Dist. v. Smith, supra, 15 F.3d at 1526.
Fourth, the IEP lacked the necessary description of activities to support STUDENT's transition from a special education preschool class with 6-8 children to a regular education kindergarten class with approximately 35 children. The law requires that, in such a case, the IEP include a description of activities to (A) integrate the disabled student into regular education and (B) provide support to transition the student from the special day class to the regular education program. Education Code §56345(b)(6).
Fifth, the IEP lacked academic goals and objectives. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20)(B). Goals and objectives must be written prior to placement. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 42. The District argued in its closing brief that no academic goals and objectives were required because STUDENT would be attending regular education classes and therefore would not be receiving special education instruction. The argument is without merit. All special education are entitled to an IEP that meets IDEA's requirements, regardless of whether they attend regular or special classes. 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(20); cf. Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. 874, 883 n.11 (E.D. Cal. 1992), aff'd sub nom Rachel H., supra (disabled students need not receive all of their "instruction" from special educators).
Goals and objectives are required in those areas where necessary to "offset or reduce the problems resulting from the child's disability that interfere with learning and educational performance in school." 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 40. While STUDENT has above-average intelligence, her IEP for 1994 nevertheless included goals and objectives in academic readiness. (P 9) Although STUDENT made progress in academic readiness that year, the evidence did not show that the District concluded she no longer needed goals and objectives in academics. Rather, the District deferred writing such goals and objectives until it could obtain the participation of a full inclusion specialist. After observing STUDENT, the full inclusion specialist would be primarily responsible for determining what academic goals and objectives, if any, were necessary, and what supplementary aids and services, (including curriculum modification) if any, was necessary. The observation never took place. These procedural deficiencies in the IEP were not insignificant. Although the parties were encouraged by the progress STUDENT had made in preschool special education programs, because of her unique needs she continued to require significant specialized services. She had previously exhibited a need for significant assistance from a one-to-one aide in numerous areas including following the class presentation -- even in a very small setting. In order to ensure STUDENT's successful participation in regular education, it was necessary to address a number of issues including the need to (1) familiarize her aide and teacher with STUDENT's FM system and logistical needs in the classroom, and (2) coordinate all of her "pullout" related services in such a way as to enable STUDENT to remain a full member of the class.
Thus, as of PARENT's visit to Canfield in September 1995 -- and her observation of a large, noisy class in a small room -- the parents still had legitimate unresolved concerns as to whether the class was appropriate. Not the least of these was the fact that they had been told at the June IEP meeting that a regular education teacher could not be held accountable to STUDENT's IEP. Clearly, there was a need to complete the IEP process before it could be determined whether the Canfield class was appropriate.
In fairness to the District, Petitioner's own expert witness, Professor Downing, stated that, with appropriate planning and supports, the Canfield class could be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. However, the District did not complete the necessary planning and identify the necessary supports in a timely manner for the 1995-96 school year.
Because the District failed to complete a procedurally appropriate IEP and offer an appropriate placement for the 1995-96 school year, the District denied STUDENT a free, appropriate education.
2. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of a privately obtained one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program at STUDENT's private, sectarian school, Ohr Eliyahu Academy?
Under IDEA, decision makers have the authority to award "appropriate" relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Appropriate relief may, under certain circumstances, include reimbursement for privately obtained educational services. For example, parents are entitled to be reimbursed for private school expenditures if it is determined that the school district failed to offer a FAPE and the private school placement was proper. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985).
Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington at 374; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Accordingly, the Supreme Court has held that reimbursement can be awarded even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 114 S.Ct. 361, 366 (1993). The rationale is that the parents, in seeking a proper private education for their child, should not be limited to private schools that have "the stamp of approval of the same public school system that failed to meet the child's needs." Id.
In this case, the District failed to complete a procedurally appropriate IEP and failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1995-96 school year. The parents unilaterally enrolled her in a private school, OEA, and paid for a one-to-one aide -- as called for in her IEP -- there. The evidence showed that STUDENT received a proper education at OEA. The evidence further showed that the aide provided STUDENT with the one-to-one assistance she required in order to successfully participate in regular education classes at OEA.(Footnote 9)
Because the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, it is required to reimburse the parents for the cost of the aide to support the afternoon, general studies (i.e. non-religious) portion of her education at OEA.(Footnote 10) The fact that the aide supported an educational program at a private school that is not certified by the state to provide special education services is not a bar to reimbursement. Florence County, supra. Further, the fact that OEA administrators found the first aide, employed from September to November, unsatisfactory, is not a bar to reimbursement for that period. The presence of the aide allowed STUDENT to participate in the class -- something she could not have done without the aide. See Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986) (parents need not procure best possible private services in order to be entitled to reimbursement). The District must continue to reimburse the parents for out-of-pocket expenses for the aide for the general studies portion of the program through the end of this school year in June 1996.
The Hearing Officer recognizes that this Decision requires reimbursement for the cost of an aide on the premises of a sectarian school. Although Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the aide only for the general [i.e. non-religious] studies portion of the day, the Hearing Officer finds that the issue nevertheless merits some discussion.
In Zobrest v. Catalina Foothills School District, 114 S.Ct. 2462 (1993), the parents enrolled their deaf child in a private Catholic school. The parents did not claim that the public school district had failed to offer an appropriate placement, and did not seek reimbursement for tuition. Rather, they asked the school district to provide a sign language interpreter to accompany the student to classes, and, when the request was denied, ultimately sought reimbursement for the cost of hiring their own interpreter. The Court in Zobrest held that the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment to the U.S. Constitution does not prohibit a public school district from furnishing a publicly paid sign language interpreter to a child with a disability on the grounds of a sectarian school. The Court stated:
. . . government programs that neutrally provide benefits to a broad class of citizens defined without reference to religion are not readily subject to an Establishment Clause challenge just because sectarian institutions may also receive an attenuated financial benefit . . .
Id. at 2466. The Court continued:
The service at issue in this case is part of a general government program that distributes benefits neutrally to any child qualified as handicapped under the IDEA, without regard to the "sectarian-nonsectarian, or public-nonpublic" nature of the school the child attends. By according parents freedom to select a school of their choice, the statute ensures that a government-paid interpreter will be present in a sectarian school only as a result of the private decision of individual parents. In other words, because the IDEA creates no financial incentive for parents to choose a sectarian school, an interpreter's presence there cannot be attributed to state decision-making.
Id. at 2467.
The Court concluded by reiterating that the child, not the private school of choice, is the primary beneficiary of the IDEA. Id. at 2469. The Court added:
. . . to the extent sectarian schools benefit at all from the IDEA, they are only incidental beneficiaries . . . the IDEA creates a neutral government program dispensing aid not to schools but to individual handicapped children. If a handicapped child chooses to enroll in a sectarian school, we hold that the Establishment Clause does not prevent the school district from furnishing a sign language interpreter there.
Id. at 2469.
As noted above, Zobrest held that the Establishment Clause does not bar public funding of a supplementary aid or service when the parents voluntarily place their child in a private sectarian school despite the existence of an appropriate public placement. Here the parents were forced to enroll STUDENT in the private sectarian school because the District failed to offer a FAPE. Therefore the Establishment Clause certainly should not bar reimbursement here. See also Christen G. v. Lower Merion School District, 23 IDELR 813, 827-828 (E.D. Pa. 1996) (Quaker school). The Hearing Officer finds that the Establishment Clause does not bar a school district from reimbursing the parents of a disabled student for the cost of an aide for the general studies portion of her education at a private, sectarian school, when the school district has failed to offer the child a FAPE.(Footnote 11)
3. Must the District reimburse Petitioner for privately obtained speech therapy from July 1995 through February 1996?
STUDENT's IEP provided that she was entitled to two weekly 30-minute sessions of speech therapy. The IEP also provided that she was entitled to extended school year services. The evidence showed that the District failed to provide STUDENT with speech therapy during the summer of 1995. However, the evidence also showed that once the parents withdrew STUDENT from summer school, shortly after it began, they declined to return phone calls from STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Webb. As noted above, reimbursement is an equitable remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra. It is concluded that responsibility for missed summer speech therapy should be borne equally by the District and Petitioner. Therefore, the parents are entitled to be reimbursed for six of twelve sessions with the private speech therapist, Ms. Vasser, during July and August.
In September the District advised the parents that speech therapy was available from Ms. Springer at Canfield School. However, the parents requested that therapy not begin until approximately mid-October because of the large number of Jewish holidays in September and early October. STUDENT received approximately eight sessions with Ms. Vassar during this time. (P 62, P 63) Reimbursement for these eight sessions is denied for equitable reasons, in that the District reasonably relied on the parents' request that the District not provide therapy during that time.
The evidence showed that between mid-October 1995 and February 1996 the District's speech therapist, Ms. Springer, missed twelve scheduled sessions with STUDENT. Ms. Vasser provided twenty-eight sessions of private therapy to STUDENT during this time. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to be reimbursed for twelve of those twenty-eight sessions. In conclusion, the parents are entitled to be reimbursed for a total of eighteen of the forty-eight sessions provided by Ms. Vasser between July 1995 and February 1996.
Petitioner asserts that further reimbursement is warranted on the grounds that the speech therapy actually provided by the District was insufficient and/or inappropriate. The evidence does not support Petitioner's position. First of all, there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required more than the two weekly 30-minute sessions called for in her IEP. Second, there was no evidence that the speech therapy actually provided by Ms. Springer was substantively inappropriate. It is undisputed that STUDENT made progress in speech during this time period, and there was no evidence from which it could reasonably be determined how much of that progress was attributable to Ms. Springer, how much to Ms. Vasser, and how much to other causes.
ORDER
1. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for out-of-pocket payments made to the Ohr Eliyahu Academy for the cost of STUDENT's one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of her educational program from September 1995 to the date of this Decision.
2. The District shall continue to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of the one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of her educational program at Ohr Eliyahu Academy through the end of the school year in June 1996.
3. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for out-of-pocket payments made to Barbara Vasser for eighteen sessions of speech therapy from July 1995 to February 1996.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue #1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue #2: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of a privately obtained one-to-one aide for the general studies portion of the program at STUDENT's private, sectarian school, Ohr Eliyahu Academy?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue #3: Must the District reimburse Petitioner for the cost of privately obtained speech therapy from July 1995 to February 1996?
Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated: May 22, 1996 ________________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Orthopedic impairment means a severe orthopedic impairment that adversely affects a child's educational performance. The term includes impairments caused by cerebral palsy. 34 C.F.R. 300.7(a)(7).
2. STUDENT's self-esteem increased, and she was less sleepy in school, after arm surgery in February 1995.
3. Canfield is two blocks from the family's home.
4. In Professor Downing's opinion, STUDENT needed to be able to see the teacher and the board, to receive help following directions/instructions and to have the curriculum modified as necessary by a special educator.
5. In late February 1996 the parties reached a settlement agreement with respect to prospective provision of speech therapy services.
6. California's Education Code notes that a goal of "early intervention" special education services for disabled preschoolers is to reduce the need for special class placement once children with disabilities reach kindergarten. Education Code §56441(f).
7. See also Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3042(a), defining "specific educational placement" as " . . . that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program . . . "
8. Although the District sent the parents a letter in October, 1995 stating that it believed it had an "appropriate placement" for STUDENT, the letter did not identify the placement, but rather simply made reference to the IEP meetings in June and the Canfield visit in September. (R 22) Even assuming that the letter was intended to constitute a formal offer of the Canfield placement, the District had not prepared an IEP providing the parents with sufficient information about the placement in order to reasonably evaluate whether it was appropriate.
9. Some District witnesses testified that in their opinion STUDENT did not require an "assistant", but only "assistance", and that in any event she did not require full-time assistance. However, the District's DHH specialist, Nancy Algotson, who has served STUDENT, testified that because of her hearing impairment STUDENT does not understand significant portions of what her teacher says, and therefore requires an aide to repeat, rephrase, paraphrase, explain and demonstrate instructions so that she knows what is expected of her in class. Thus, the evidence showed that STUDENT required a one-to-one assistant for classroom instruction.
10. Petitioner does not seek reimbursement for the cost of the aide for the morning, religious portion of the day. Nor does Petitioner seek reimbursement for tuition.
11. Because it has been determined that the District failed to offer a FAPE, it is unnecessary to determine whether the District would have been required to reimburse the parents for the cost of the aide if the District had offered a FAPE. That issue would involve analysis of the federal regulations known as EDGAR (Education Department General Administrative Regulations). 34 C.F.R. §76.651-662. See also 20 U.S.C. §1413(a)(4)(A); 34 C.F.R. §300.403(a); 34 C.F.R. §300.450-452.
