California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 28, 1999

Student v. La Mesa-Spring Valley School District

SEHO Case No. SN 807-98 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

La Mesa-Spring Valley School District offered a 3-year-old with autism a FAPE; parents' request for 40-hour in-home Lovaas program denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 3-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against La Mesa-Spring Valley School District. He was moving from Early Start to preschool services. He received in-home discrete trial training (DTT) through the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE). The District and the San Diego County Regional Center together funded 21.5 hours a week of this training. The parents wanted the District to fund 30 to 40 hours a week of in-home DTT, all year, and to reimburse their private costs. The District offered to keep 21.5 hours of DTT and add a preschool class, a one-to-one aide, speech-language therapy, adapted physical education, and occupational therapy. The class began with a short Early Start transition, then extended school year, then Julie Laing's special day class at Glen Street Preschool.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote ruled for the District on every issue. The parents' witnesses relied on Dr. Lovaas's research. The District's expert, Dr. Laura Schreibman, and its teachers testified that the boy needed peers to build social and language skills and to use what he learned at home in new settings. The Hearing Officer found that he was ready for a classroom. She found no proof that his earlier Early Start class caused him to lose speech. She also found that he needed therapy from a qualified speech-language therapist. The offers met the Rowley standard and the least restrictive environment requirement. The claimed procedural violations, including predetermination, were not proven. Reimbursement and all other relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled 1990s disputes over intensive Lovaas-style programs. Under Rowley and Gregory K., the Hearing Officer looked at whether the district's offer was adequate, not at whether the parents' preferred 40-hour home program might do more. She weighed the child's need for peers, generalization of skills, and speech therapy from a licensed provider.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer Student a FAPE from his third birthday on June 1, 1998, to the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year?

    The District's transition offer (June 1-18), ESY offer (June 24-July 21), and post-ESY offer of 21.5 hours/week of in-home DTT plus classroom, speech-language therapy, OT and APE met Rowley; Student did not need 35-40 hours/week of in-home DTT, and the claimed procedural violations (predetermination, failure to consider a continuum of placements) were not proven.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did the District offer Student a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

    The Glen Street Preschool special day class with reverse mainstreaming, a 1:1 aide, 21.5 hours/week of in-home DTT, speech-language therapy, APE and OT was designed to meet Student's needs, provided educational benefit, and satisfied LRE.

  3. Issue 3. Are the Parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the private educational services they have provided for Student?

    Because the District offered a FAPE for all periods at issue, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for services beyond what the District offered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range

People named in the decision

  • Marcy Beaty, director of special education, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Julie Laing, preschool special day class teacher (proposed placement); assessor, Glen Street Preschool, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Kate Provine, school psychologist; assessor, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Roxanne Beltran, adapted physical education (APE) specialist; assessor, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Debbie Murrell, Early Start classroom teacher, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Marcia Frischknecht, Early Start home teacher, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Rhonda Manion, program specialist, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Cynthia St. Clair, speech and language therapist, Glen Street Preschool, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Kathi Lemli, instructional assistant, Glen Street Preschool, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Mary Fransway, instructional assistant, Glen Street Preschool, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Denise Cosar, instructional assistant, Glen Street Preschool, La Mesa-Spring Valley School District
  • Laura Schreibman, Ph.D., expert witness for District (autism), University of California San Diego
  • Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE), nonpublic agency providing in-home DTT
  • Monica Eastin, senior therapist, witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention
  • Miriam Bakcht, case supervisor, witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention
  • Jacqueline Wray Wynn, Ph.D., assistant director, expert witness for Student, Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention; UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children
  • Mary L. Kawar, private occupational therapist (Regional Center-funded)
  • Colleen Sparkman, private speech-language pathologist (independent assessment)
  • Debra Wright, advocate for children with disabilities (requested independent speech assessment)
  • Lynn Gregory, Ph.D., psychologist (evaluation for Regional Center), San Diego County Regional Center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in La Mesa, California, on September 10, 11, 15, and 16, October 13, 27, and 28, 1998. (Footnote 1) Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Ralph O. Lewis of the Law Office of Ralph O. Lewis. Also present on behalf of STUDENTwere his parents. (Footnote 2) Respondent La Mesa-Spring Valley School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget Flanagan of Miller Brown & Dannis. Also present on behalf of the District was Marcy Beaty, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Did the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District offer STUDENTa free appropriate public education (FAPE) from his third birthday on June 1, 1998, to the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year?

(2) Did the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District offer STUDENTa FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year (ESY)?

(3) Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the private educational services they have provided for STUDENT?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a three-year-old student. STUDENTis eligible for special education because of the diagnosis of autism. STUDENTcurrently participates in an in-home program of intensive behavioral intervention therapy in the form of discrete trial training (DTT), which is provided through the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention (LIFE). (footnote 3) STUDENTreceives approximately 30 hours of DTT each week. (Footnote 4) The District and the San Diego County Regional Center (Regional Center), have agreed to fund 21.5 hours of STUDENT’s weekly DTT. STUDENTalso receives weekly occupational therapy (OT) pursuant to his individualized educational program (IEP). (footnote 5)

The initial assessment of STUDENTfor special education services took place when he was approximately 15 months old. As measured by the Rockford Infant Developmental Evaluation Scales (RIDES), STUDENTwas functioning at the 12-month-old level in cognition, perceptual and motor skills, receptive communication, and social/emotional areas. STUDENT’s expressive language skills were at the eight-month-old level and his self-help skills were at the nine-month-old level. (Footnote 6) (Respondent’s Exhibit 2.) On October 7, 1996, the Regional Center developed an initial individual family service plan (IFSP) for STUDENT. (Footnote 7) (Respondent’s Exhibit 3.) Pursuant to the IFSP, it was agreed that STUDENTwould receive services through the District’s Early Start Program, which consisted of a minimum of two home visits per month of approximately 30 to 45 minutes. In January 1997, MOTHERconsented to STUDENT’s participation in a District classroom program on two days per week for three hours. In March, MOTHERwithdrew STUDENTfrom the class; however, he continued to receive home visits. (Respondent’s Exhibit 4.) Beginning in the spring of 1997, the Regional Center funded weekly OT with Mary L. Kawar, a registered occupational therapist (OTR).

STUDENT’s home teacher re-administered the RIDES to STUDENTin May 1997 when he was 23 months old. Test results indicated that STUDENThad made progress since the previous testing. He scored in the 14 to 16 month range in personal/social/self-help skills, in the 13 to 17 month range in fine motor and adaptive skills, in the 13 to 16 month range in receptive language, and in the 9 to 12 month range in expressive language. STUDENT’s gross motor skills fell in the 15 to 24 month range. (Respondent’s Exhibit 7.)

On July 16, 1997, Colleen Sparkman, a speech and language pathologist in private practice, completed an independent speech and language assessment at the request of Debra Wright, an advocate for children with disabilities. Ms. Sparkman administered the Rossetti Infant-Toddler Language Scale and the Sequenced Inventory of Communication Development (SICD) to determine STUDENT’s language strengths and weaknesses. On the Rossetti, STUDENTscored in the six to nine month range in play skills, language comprehension, language expression, and pragmatics. On the SICD, STUDENT’s receptive language skills fell in the 12 to 16 month range, and his expressive language scores fell in the 9 to 12 month range. At the time of Ms. Sparkman’s assessment, STUDENTwas 25 months old. Ms. Sparkman recommended an “individualized, language based program which incorporates activities to facilitate generalization. . . .” She also recommended that STUDENTparticipate in an in-home program. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.)

At the next IFSP meeting on August 4, 1997, STUDENT’s parents requested an “intensive in-home one-to-one behavior based program” and rejected the proposal to place STUDENTin either a center-based program or in a parent participation program with home visits continuing, as well. (Respondent’s Exhibit 8.)

On a third administration of the RIDES in October 1997, when STUDENTwas 28 months old, he scored in the 15 to 17 month range in personal/social/self-help skills, in the 18-20 month range in fine motor and adaptive skills, in the 13 to 16 month range in receptive language, in the 9 to 12 month range in expressive language, and in the 30 to 33 month range in gross motor skills. (Respondent’s Exhibit 9.)

On December 16, 1997, the PARENTS, the Regional Center, and the District reached an agreement regarding STUDENT’s placement through May 31, 1998. As a result of that agreement, STUDENTbegan LIFE’s in-home DTT program. LIFE’s services also included a monthly workshop with staff and parent participation, and administration of the program. Additionally, the agreement provided for STUDENTto attend one session of the Early Start class each week and for the District to make one home visit each month. (Respondent’s Exhibit 8.)

In January 1998, STUDENTenrolled in the District’s Early Start class. Over a period of the next two months, STUDENTattended the class for a total of seven school days. The PARENTS then withdrew STUDENTfrom the class because of their perception that, as a result of his attending school, STUDENThad lost all of his spontaneous speech. Additionally, they asserted that when STUDENTdid speak, he would do so only in a whisper.

In May 1998, Lynn Gregory, Ph.D., completed a psychological evaluation of STUDENTon behalf of the Regional Center. Dr. Gregory reported that STUDENTwas imitating gestures and words; however, he was not using language spontaneously. She stated that STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary consisted of “many labels.” Dr. Gregory concluded that when compared to the results of her assessment one year earlier, STUDENTwas showing more awareness of his environment, was playing more effectively with toys, and was “under excellent instructional control.” Dr. Gregory concluded that STUDENT’s DTT program was meeting his needs and that he should continue to participate in an “educational/treatment program for autistic youngsters.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 12.)

In anticipation of STUDENT’s transferring from the infant program on his third birthday, which was June 1, 1998, the District also undertook a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENTin May 1998. (Respondent’s Exhibit 13.) On the RIDES assessment of cognitive, perceptual, and fine motor skills, STUDENTscored at the 18 month level with scattered skills to 48 months. On receptive communication skills, STUDENTscored at the 24 month level with scattered skills to 30 months. On expressive communication skills, STUDENTscored at the 24 month level. On self-help, social and emotional skills, STUDENTscored at the 15 month level with scattered skills to 30 months. (Respondent’s Exhibit 11.) The District’s assessment also consisted of administration of the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R), parent report, and a review of progress notes from STUDENT’s in-home program. (Footnote 8) On the PEP-R, STUDENTobtained the following estimated age-level scores: 18 to 19 months on verbal and motor imitation, 34 to 41 months on visual and auditory perception, 27 to 28 months on fine motor development, 34 to 39 months on gross motor development, 26 to 29 months on visual-motor integration, 31 to 32 months on receptive language, and 25 to 26 months on verbal/expressive language. The assessors concluded that STUDENTcontinued to be eligible for speech and language services and special education placement. (Respondent’s Exhibit 13.)

On May 21, 1998, the District convened an IEP meeting to plan STUDENT’s educational program as a three-year-old student. At the IEP meeting, the District proposed that STUDENTcontinue participating in the Early Start program through June 18, 1998. Hence, from June 1 through June 18, 1998, STUDENTwould participate two days per week for three hours each day in the Early Start classroom and would receive two home visits each month. The District also offered to provide individual speech and language therapy three times a week in sessions of 20 minutes each and the Regional Center offered to provide one hour weekly of OT. The District and the Regional Center also offered to continue funding STUDENT’s in-home program provided by LIFE. The IEP stated that the District would fund 11.5 hours per week and a monthly workshop meeting, and the Regional Center would fund 10 hours per week for up to 86 hours per month. (Footnote 9)

The District proposed to transition STUDENTto the Glen Street Preschool special day class (SDC) for the ESY program, which met daily for four hours from June 24 through July 21, 1998, and to maintain all other services at the same level offered for June, including 21.5 hours of in-home DTT. The District also offered to provide STUDENTwith a one-to-one aide at school. For the period from July 27 to August 14, 1998, when school was not in session, the District and Regional Center offered to maintain STUDENT’s in-home program at the same level they offered during the ESY.

For the 1998-1999 school year beginning on August 31, 1998, the District offered to place STUDENTin the Glen Street Preschool special day class (SDC) taught by Julie Laing. The class meets for five hours a day Monday through Thursday and for 3.5 hours on Fridays. It was proposed that on the shortened school day, STUDENT’s teacher, or possibly another District employee, would make a home visit to consult with the PARENTS. The IEP also calls for STUDENTto be integrated with nondisabled peers for 10% of his school day. The IEP identifies integration activities as “reverse mainstreaming.” The District’s offer related to OT and speech and language remained the same. (Respondent’s Exhibits 14 and 17.)

In a letter dated June 5, 1998, to Mr. Lewis, Petitioner’s attorney, the District reiterated its proposed placement for STUDENT. As set forth above, the offer included classroom placement, speech and language therapy, OT, and the LIFE in-home DTT program. The letter also set out the District’s offer of a 46 week in-home program provided by LIFE, which included:

Tutorial Services up to 10 hours/week [Regional Center]

up to 10.5 hours/week [District]

not to exceed 86 hours/month [based on 4.2 week/month]

Supervision/Training/Other one LIFE Workshop/month up to 2 hours/week [Regional Center]

Tutors to attend Workshop/Meeting - up to 5 tutors at $10/hour [6 hours each] Administrative Tasks/Consultation - up to 10 hours at $10/hour (Respondent’s Exhibit 15.) (Footnote 10)

The PARENTS did not consent to the District’s proposed placement; however, they consented to implementation of OT and to the in-home behavioral intervention services to the extent offered by the District and the Regional Center. The PARENTS contend that the District should be required to fund LIFE’s intensive program for 30 to 40 hours each week for all 52 weeks of the year. They declined speech and language services; however, they consented to a new speech and language assessment and to an APE assessment. (Footnote 11)

On June 5, 1998, the District completed the APE and speech and language assessments and, on June 17, 1998, the IEP team met to discuss the results of the assessments. The IEP team determined that STUDENTqualified for APE and recommended two sessions a week of 30 minutes each. The speech and language assessment confirmed that STUDENTwas functioning well below age-appropriate levels and recommended therapy at the same level previously recommended--three sessions a week of 20 minutes each. The PARENTS declined speech and language therapy and APE services. (Respondent’s Exhibits 16 and 17.) The matter proceeded to hearing on the issues of whether the District offered STUDENTan appropriate placement from his third birthday on June 1, 1998, through the 1998-1999 school year and whether STUDENTrequires an intensive in-home LIFE program.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: Did the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District offer STUDENTa free appropriate public education (FAPE) from his third birthday on June 1, 1998, to the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; California Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provided instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)

In determining whether the school district has offered a FAPE, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307. If the district has offered a FAPE, the district is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if their preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit to the student than the district’s program. Id.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must (a) be designed to meet the student's unique needs, (b) provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.) Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (Education Code § 56301.)

STUDENT’s unique and individual needs

It is necessary to have an understanding of STUDENT’s unique and individual needs prior to determining the appropriateness of the placement proposed by the District. STUDENT’s deficits were described similarly in reports of assessments and by the witnesses. STUDENThas scored below age-level on all measures of communication, pre-academics, motor, and self-help skills. STUDENT’s social skills are also deficient and his social experiences with age-appropriate peers are limited. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT.) STUDENT’s expressive language skills are particularly low, whereas gross motor skills are a strength for STUDENT. (See e.g. Respondent’s Exhibits 2, 7, 9, 11, 12, and 13; Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.)

The witnesses also uniformly described STUDENTas “compliant and cooperative.” Kate Provine, school psychologist, Roxanne Beltran, APE specialist, and Julie Laing, the preschool SDC teacher proposed for STUDENT, described his eye contact as “fleeting” and his attention “limited;” however, they testified that STUDENTgenerally was able to sit and attend without much difficulty during testing. (Footnote 12) Monica Eastin, senior therapist for LIFE, also described STUDENTas “attentive and responsive to rewards.” (Footnote 13) MOTHERtestified that STUDENThas difficulty with transitions; however, neither the assessors nor STUDENT’s teachers observed STUDENTto have great difficulty transitioning from one activity to another. For example, Debbie Murrell, STUDENT’s Early Start teacher, testified that STUDENTrequired some visual redirection to task; however, he did not have significant problems transitioning from one activity to another. Ms. Laing also stated that, following a break during her portion of the testing, STUDENTresponded without difficulty to her first request to return to testing. Ms. Eastin testified that STUDENThas some self-stimulatory behavior when not redirected; however, there are no reports of STUDENTengaging in self-stimulatory behavior or tantrumming to any significant degree.

The Hearing Officer finds the evidence discussed above describes STUDENT’s needs as they existed in June 1998. In summary, STUDENThas deficits in all areas of functioning. His greatest needs are in the areas of expressive language and social skills. STUDENTcan be distractible; however, he is generally compliant and does not exhibit significant behavioral problems.

It is agreed that discrete trial training (DTT) is an appropriate method of instruction for STUDENT. At the heart of the dispute is the amount of in-home DTT STUDENTrequires and whether an appropriate program also should include participation in a preschool class, speech and language therapy, and APE. (Footnote 14) Petitioner contends that he requires 35 to 40 hours weekly of in-home DTT to meet his needs. The District contends that a combination of DTT, classroom, and related services offers an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

All of Petitioner’s witnesses testified in support of his request to be placed in the intensive in-home DTT program offered through LIFE. LIFE’s intensive program includes 40 hours per week of individual treatment at the student’s home, a weekly meeting of approximately 1.5 hours, and 3.5 hours of other supervision. Supervision includes meeting with the parents, writing reports, and making school visits, as appropriate. Petitioner’s witnesses testified that he needs to learn new skills through one-to-one instruction in a distraction free environment. In fact, MOTHERtestified that the only way STUDENThas learned has been through DTT. Petitioner’s witnesses included Ms. PARENT, Ms. Eastin, Miriam Bakcht, STUDENT’s case supervisor for LIFE, and Jacqueline Wray Wynn, Ph.D., assistant director of LIFE. (Footnote 15) Petitioner’s witnesses who administer his current DTT program, including Ms. Bakcht and Ms. Eastin, testified that STUDENT’s current DTT program does not provide enough hours weekly to allow trainers to do practice drills with STUDENTthat he has already mastered, to engage him in drills of skills he is currently learning, and to also introduce new drills. They testified that the number of hours of DTT STUDENTreceives at home should be increased gradually from the current level to 40 hours per week.

In support of the request for an intensive DTT program, Dr. Wynn described a research study completed by Dr. Ivar Lovaas of the Clinic at the University of California Los Angeles. Dr. Lovaas drew the conclusion that students with autism participating in 40 hours per week of an intensive treatment program obtained the best outcome when compared to students receiving fewer hours of treatment. The students receiving 40 hours of treatment attained verbal language, improved their behavior, and were able to be placed in a less intensive environment than students receiving fewer hours of treatment. The LIFE program is based on the studies of Dr. Lovaas. Dr. Wynn testified that generally, students participating in the LIFE program receive 20 to 30 hours per week of services by age three years and, thereafter, increase to 40 hours per week. Dr. Wynn testified that if the program consists of fewer hours, the student’s acquisition of skills is decreased and negative behaviors or self-stimulatory behaviors are increased. Dr. Wynn has monitored STUDENT’s program. She testified that STUDENT’s skills increased in correspondence to the number of hours his program increased. Dr. Wynn testified that for these reasons, STUDENTrequires the intensive program offered by LIFE.

MOTHERtestified regarding an additional reason she has requested that STUDENTparticipation in LIFE’s intensive program. MOTHERstated that she has had to undertake all of the administrative tasks related to STUDENT’s LIFE program, including locating and hiring tutors. MOTHERtestified that these responsibilities are very time consuming and have interfered with the time she prefers to spend with her children. (Footnote 16)

Because of STUDENT’s success with DTT, the PARENTS oppose limiting the amount of DTT STUDENTreceives to 21.5 hours to allow him to attend school. Additionally, Dr. Wynn testified that to be successful in a school environment, STUDENTwould need expressive language abilities, independent play skills, and self-help skills. He should also possess the ability to make his needs known to others. In Dr. Wynn’s opinion, STUDENTdid not possess these skills in June 1998, or at the time of the hearing. MOTHERand Ms. Bakcht also testified that STUDENTdid not make progress when previously attending the classroom component of the Early Start program in January and February 1998, and there is no reason to believe that he would have been successful in the school placement proposed by the District a few months later in June 1998. Specifically, MOTHERtestified that STUDENT’s communication skills decreased as a result of his attending school. She testified that, among other things, STUDENTbegan whispering and his language decreased to the extent that he was not using spontaneous speech outside of therapy sessions.

All of the District’s witnesses testified that, in addition to his in-home DTT program, STUDENTneeds opportunities to play with other children, to use his developing language skills with other children who provide him with appropriate language models, and to generalize the skills and concepts he has learned during his in-home DTT program. The District’s witnesses included Marcia Frischknecht, STUDENT’s Early Start home teacher since September 1997, Ms. Murrell, STUDENT’s Early Start classroom teacher in January and February 1998, Rhonda Manion, program specialist, who consults with the Early Start and Glen Street programs, Marcy Beaty, director of special education, and Ms. Laing. (Footnote 17) Ms. Laing testified that STUDENThas a “great” foundation with DTT and now needs to learn to generalize the skills he has learned in a less restrictive environment. The District’s witnesses testified that appropriate peers and opportunities to generalize can be provided in a classroom environment, whereas they are not available in STUDENT’s one-to-one in-home program.

The District also called Laura Schreibman, Ph.D., to testify on its behalf as an expert in autism. (Footnote 18) Dr. Schreibman discussed some of the shortcomings of Dr. Lovaas’ study. Dr. Schreibman completed doctoral work with Dr. Lovaas, which included providing services to the children in the study. Dr. Schreibman testified that Dr. Lovaas did not undertake a comparison study whereby the effectiveness of one type of treatment, such as DTT, was compared to another type of treatment, such as TEACCH. For this reason, no conclusions can be drawn from the results about the efficacy of one treatment over another. Dr. Schreibman testified that because of way subjects were selected in Dr. Lovaas’ study, it is difficult to generalize the results to all children with autism. For example, the argument can be made that Dr. Lovaas selected only children with autism with higher cognitive skills to receive the intensive therapy. Dr. Schreibman also noted that Dr. Lovaas’ results have not yet been replicated independently. Finally, Dr. Schreibman testified that based on her studies of children with autism, she has concluded that it is not necessary to use only one method to address the needs of a child with autism. In her opinion, the student’s treatment plan must be individualized to obtain the best learning outcome.

Dr. Schreibman testified that in STUDENT’s case, his deficits in language and social skills are indicative of his need to participate a preschool classroom program. In support of her opinion, Dr. Schreibman cited professional research done at Emory University that concluded that it is better to learn social skills in social or classroom settings. Dr. Schreibman testified that it is also important for STUDENTto learn classroom skills, such as sitting and attending, and class routines so that he will be ready to integrate into a less restrictive placement with regular education peers.

As to whether STUDENTis ready to participate in a classroom environment, Dr. Schreibman testified that STUDENThas appropriate skills to benefit from participation in a classroom environment. STUDENThas good social behavior, which Dr. Schreibman described as “not avoidant of social activities.” He engages in toy play, uses some language, has fairly good attention, and is cooperative. STUDENTalso is able to sit in a chair and does not engage in behavior that is dangerous to himself or to others. Dr. Schreibman could think of absolutely no benefit to STUDENT’s waiting to attend school. The District’s teachers and assessors also testified to their belief that STUDENTpossesses the requisite skills for school attendance and that STUDENTbenefitted from his previous experiences in the Early Start classroom. For example, Ms. Murrell testified that when she first observed STUDENTin November 1997, his conduct indicated to her that he was ready to attend an Early Start classroom. At that time, STUDENTexhibited appropriate behavior, was able to follow directions, was oriented to task, and possessed the ability to share his focus and attention with others. Ms. Murrell disputed the parent’s claim that STUDENTregressed or lost communication skills while attending her class. Ms. Murrell shared her observations of STUDENTat each class session he attended. She stated that on the first visit, STUDENTwas occasionally distracted and would go to his mother for reassurance. He also made a few sounds of protest but did not cry or scream. At the second session, STUDENTparticipated and was appropriate during play. He did not have any behavioral problems and his attention improved. Ms. Murrell testified that STUDENTrequired less redirection from aides and teachers with each subsequent class and his attention continued to improve, as well. Ms. Murrell testified that STUDENTnever arrived at the beginning of the class and did not attend an entire school day. Ms. Murrell testified unequivocally that despite the limited time STUDENTwas in her class, he made progress.

Everyone agrees that the ultimate goal for STUDENTis participation in school and other activities with regular education peers to the maximum extent possible. This is the legal requirement as well. (Education Code § 56301.) All of STUDENT’s current educational program, except for OT, takes place one-to-one with his adult tutors in his home. (Footnote 19) The evidence establishes that the in-home program does not provide STUDENTwith opportunities to learn social skills, to expand his developing language skills with peers, or to generalize the skills he is learning to environments other than his home or with other children. It reasonably can be concluded that the skills STUDENTlearns in DTT are of limited use to STUDENTand will not result in a school placement if he is only able to use the skills in his home environment with another adult. Additionally, witnesses from LIFE testified that there is not enough time in the home program for STUDENTto practice the skills he has mastered, to address his developing skills, and to introduce new skills and concepts. The Hearing Officer concludes that placement in an appropriate classroom is necessary to provide STUDENTwith opportunities to practice the skills he has mastered through DTT so that his in-home program can focus on teaching him new skills. Moreover, participation in an classroom would be a step toward that the goal of integrating STUDENTand also would alleviate the need to spend time during the in-home program to address skills STUDENThas already mastered in that environment.

As to whether STUDENTis “ready” to attend school, there was no evidence that STUDENT, or any other child, must meet specific prerequisites to attend a preschool SDC. The teachers of both the Early Start and preschool classes testified persuasively that STUDENThas adequate skills to participate in a classroom environment. STUDENTis compliant and does not engage in behavior that would interfere with his participation. Ms. Murrell’s testimony is persuasive because she is the only witness to actually have STUDENTin a classroom, whereas Petitioner’s witnesses who testified that STUDENT’s skills would not allow him to benefit from placement in a class do not teach young children in a school environment. Moreover, the evidence is not persuasive that if STUDENTlost expressive language skills in January and February 1998, it was a result of his participation in the class component of the Early Start program. MOTHERconcedes that STUDENTwas ill on three occasions during the period he attended school or shortly thereafter. Additionally, Ms. Murrell and other District witnesses testified that MOTHERhad informed them that STUDENTwas not attending school because he was ill. They testified that they were not informed at that time by MOTHERthat she was in any way displeased with the program or that she had any concerns about STUDENT’s language skills declining. Ms. Murrell further testified that it was her understanding that STUDENT’s tutors also were pleased that STUDENTwas receiving opportunities in her class to generalize skills that he was learning during his in-home program. Regarding STUDENT’s significant deficits in expressive language, MOTHERstated her belief that STUDENTdoes not require speech and language therapy because his in-home program sufficiently addresses his attaining language skills. Ms. Bakcht supported Ms. PARENT’s testimony. Dr. Schreibman and Cynthia St. Clair, speech and language therapist at Glen Street Preschool, testified that speech and language therapy must be taught in the developmental sequence children generally learn language. (Footnote 20) The witnesses also testified that instruction by a qualified therapist is essential because speech and language therapists have the background and knowledge to teach language, whereas others generally do not. There is no evidence that any of STUDENT’s LIFE tutors or program supervisors are speech and language therapists or have any special training to teach language. There also is no evidence that LIFE consults with a speech and language pathologist in developing a program to address STUDENT’s language deficits. The evidence is also not persuasive that STUDENThas made great strides in language development while solely receiving in-home instruction from LIFE tutors. Therefore, given STUDENT’s significant language deficits and the lack of qualified personnel to provide a language program for STUDENT, the Hearing Officer concludes that speech and language therapy from a qualified speech and language therapist is a necessary component of an appropriate program for STUDENT.

In summary, it is undisputed that STUDENThas benefitted from his in-home program of 21.5 hours per week and it has been determined that STUDENTalso requires opportunities with peers to address social skills, language development, and to generalize skills he has learned through DTT. As discussed above, professional studies have concluded that children with autism benefit from an intensive program. In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the combination of an in-home program of 21.5 hours per week, related services, and daily participation for up to 23.5 hours each week in an appropriate classroom will provide STUDENTwith an intensive program.

Because the District offered different placements (1) to transition STUDENTto a school environment from June 1 to 18, 1998, (2) for the ESY, and (3) for the period following the ESY until school is in session for the 1998-1999 school year, each is analyzed separately below to determine whether the offers were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit, conformed with his IEP, and satisfied LRE requirements.

The period from June 1 through June 18, 1998

For the period from June 1 through June 18, 1998, the District proposed a program to transition STUDENTfrom his in-home program to a preschool program. The District proposed for STUDENTto continue receiving 21.5 hours weekly of in-home DTT from LIFE with the additional services of program supervision, administration, training, and monthly workshop meetings. The proposed placement also included one hour weekly of OT, three sessions weekly of 20 minutes each of individual speech and language therapy, participation in the Early Start preschool classroom on two days per week for three hours each day, and two home visits each month.

There is no dispute regarding the appropriateness of OT to address STUDENT’s motor deficits. To address STUDENT’s significant communication deficits, the District has offered individual speech and language therapy. Because all of the witnesses concur that STUDENTlearns new concepts best when they are introduced one-to-one, individual rather than group speech and language therapy is appropriate. It has been concluded above that 21.5 hours of the in-home DTT program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Additionally, a FAPE for STUDENTmust also provide him with opportunities to participate with peers to develop social and language skills, and to have opportunities to generalize the skills he is learning with peers and in environments other than his home. The evidence establishes that these needs can be met through placement in an appropriate classroom.

Ms. Murrell, the Early Start classroom teacher, provided information regarding the Early Start classroom program. During the 1997-1998 school year, the class had six students and two aides. Two students were dismissed from special education in June 1998. Ms. Murrell testified that all of the students offered good language and social models for STUDENT. The students functioned at approximately a 2.5 year old level in language. None of the students had behavior problems. The class was organized into learning stations. Students also participated in circle time, free play, and had outside play periods. Ms. Murrell testified regarding the class schedule. The children arrived and toileted. The students then went to the play area where staff encouraged them to play. From 11:30 a.m. to 11:45 a.m. was circle time, which was followed by lunch. At 12:30 p.m., the students engaged in activities at three different learning stations. One station emphasized language, another art, and the third station included structured play activities. At 1:15 p.m. there was another circle, which was followed by outdoor play.

Ms. Murrell’s testimony establishes that the class had a small number of students and a low student-to-teacher ratio, which would have provided STUDENTwith opportunities for individual and small group instruction. Her testimony also establishes that the class curriculum and activities stressed language development, which was an area of need for STUDENT. Ms. Murrell testified that STUDENT’s communication goals and objectives would have been addressed by having him imitate words and sounds in words, doing matching activities, modeling, and by having him following directions during circles and learning center activities. There also were students with age-appropriate language skills to serve as models for STUDENT.

The testimony of Ms. Murrell establishes that the Early Start class would have addressed STUDENT’s need to develop social skills. There were students in the class that could serve as social models for STUDENTand many of the classroom activities were designed to encourage socializing amongst class members. During learning center time, the students engaged in activities to specifically teach them appropriate play skills.

The testimony of Ms. Frischknecht establishes that STUDENT’s development of language and social skills also would have been addressed during home visits. Ms. Frischknecht testified that the general purpose of home visits through the Early Start program was to engage the student in activities and to provide information to the parents to follow up on at home. Ms. Frischknecht testified that each visit to STUDENT’s home generally included seven to eight activities to address fine motor skills, language, pretend play, and following directions. Ms. Frischknecht testified that each visit included at least one lesson specifically addressing language development. She also employed pivotal response training (PRT) techniques with STUDENTAs an example, Ms. Frischknecht described how she would have STUDENTselect a toy of some interest to him and, while he played with the toy, Ms. Frischknecht would expand on his language. Ms. Frischknecht also described a “dress-up” activity designed to elicit language. Ms. Frischknecht’s testimony establishes that she also would provide pretend play activities that would mirror activities taking place in the class.

Because STUDENThad not been in a classroom program following his parent’s removing him from school, placement in the Early Start classroom would have provided him with an opportunity to transition from an program exclusively delivered at home to the daily program at Glen Street Preschool. STUDENThad previously attended the Early Start class and would have some familiarity with the program. This would make the transition to a school program easier for STUDENTand would enhance his chance for a successful transition. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, based on the testimony of Ms. Murrell and Ms. Frischknecht, the Hearing Officer concludes that the transition program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as they existed in June 1998. (Footnote 21)

It was concluded above that the evidence did not substantiate that STUDENT’s language skills decreased as a result of his attending school. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. Murrell and Ms. Manion that STUDENTbenefitted from his previous placement in the Early Start program. The evidence establishes that STUDENTwas more likely than not to have benefitted from attending the Early Start classroom as part of his transition to a preschool program.

There are no issues related to whether the placement offered by the District conforms with STUDENT’s IEP. Therefore, because the placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to allow him to benefit from his education and conforms with the IEP, it is concluded that the District’s transition placement satisfies the requirements of an appropriate placement under IDEA and Rowley. The placement also satisfies LRE requirements because it provided for STUDENTto participate with his nondisabled peers to the maximum extent appropriate at that time.

The period from June 24 through July 21, 1998

The District proposed that STUDENTattend the Glen Street Preschool SDC taught by Julie Laing for the ESY program from June 24 through July 21, 1998. The District offered to provide STUDENTwith a one-to-one aide to accompany him to school, APE, and to maintain all of the other related services, including speech and language therapy, OT, and DTT that were offered beginning on June 1, 1998.

There is no dispute that DTT met STUDENT’s needs and it has already been determined above that the level of DTT offered by the District was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. There also is no dispute related to OT.

All of the witnesses who testified on behalf of STUDENT, including Dr. Wynn, Ms. Bakcht, and Ms. PARENT, concluded that Ms. Laing’s class was not appropriate for STUDENTbecause he is distractible and requires a one-to-one, distraction-free environment to learn. Petitioner’s witnesses also testified that the class does not offer appropriate social or language peer models for STUDENTand expressed concern that he would imitate the inappropriate and self-stimulatory behavior of the other children in the class. Dr. Wynn identified appropriate peers for STUDENTas those demonstrating age-appropriate language and social skills. In support of her testimony, Dr. Wynn discussed the results of a study by Nina Lovaas which concluded that when autistic children are placed with other children with inappropriate behavior, their positive behavior decreases and their negative behavior increases.

MOTHERtestified that she had concerns related to Ms. Laing’s class. MOTHERtestified that Ms. Laing’s use of DTT differs from the way LIFE uses DTT, which would confuse STUDENTbecause he requires consistency to learn. MOTHERquestioned Ms. Laing’s handling of a student who refused to participate in a lesson being observed by Ms. PARENT. MOTHERtestified that the child engaged in a “moderate volume of squealing interspersed with protest” during a one-to-one session. Ms. Laing continued to attempt to engage the student in the lesson. MOTHERtestified that the noise from the other student would have been distracting for STUDENT. She stated that STUDENTeven may have started screaming in response to the other student. MOTHERalso described her observations during outdoor play. She stated that the aides “stuck” together and spoke to each other rather than mingling with and engaging the children in activities. She stated that the aides allowed one child to engage in perseverative behavior for a long period of time.

Dr. Schreibman observed Ms. Laing’s class on two occasions at the request of the District. Dr. Schreibman concluded that Ms. Laing employed a variety of effective treatment strategies. She found the atmosphere of the class generally quiet and the children engaged. She also observed that the staff was well-trained and engaged regularly with the students and that Ms. Laing appeared prepared and skilled at various treatment interventions. Dr. Schreibman disputed the assertion that children with autism pick up self-stimulatory behavior of other children. Dr. Schreibman testified that some children occasionally engage in self-stimulatory behavior, such as rocking, because the behavior feels good to that child. Similar behavior will not necessarily feel good to STUDENTand, therefore, he would not copy it. Dr. Schreibman concluded that the District offered STUDENTthe “ideal”combination of DTT, services, and school.

Ms. Laing testified regarding the composition of the students in her class, the class schedule, and the ways in which she would have implemented STUDENT’s IEP, if he were placed in her class. Ms. Laing’s testimony establishes that there were six students in the class. They ranged in age from two and one-half years old through approximately six-years-old. Ms. Laing was assisted by two full-time aides. Next to Ms. Laing’s class is a therapy room that has equipment for OT and sensory activities. Ms. Laing used this class for individual sessions, including DTT, with the students. Ms. Laing’s class shares the school facility with the Community Day Class (CDC), a State preschool program for typically developing children. One of the CDC preschool classes is for three-year-old children and the other class is for children who are four years old. The CDC children are “reverse mainstreamed” into Ms. Laing’s class and share outdoor play time with the SDC students. The CDC also provides opportunities for the SDC students to be mainstreamed with typically developing peers as appropriate. Ms. Laing testified that she communicated daily with the parents of the students in her class through a communication book. In addition, she generally spoke with the parents weekly. Ms. Laing testified that she provided activities for the parents to do at home with their children during the break between the end of ESY program and the beginning of the regular school year. For example, she made social stories to help the parents work with their child on toileting and other self-help skills.

Ms. Laing testified that data was maintained for each child. The IEP goals and objectives were numbered and broken down on data sheets so that she and the aides could record information daily. A log of DTT activities was graphed and anecdotal data were maintained regarding the child’s behavior. To address goals and objectives related to developing community and daily living skills and to generalize skills, the class also took trips into the community. For example, the class went to a produce store to locate items that were orange and to a pet shop to identify the animals.

Ms. Laing testified that the schedule on STUDENT’s IEP reflects the schedule for her class during the ESY program. A typical day began at 8:00 a.m. with opening circle. From approximately 8:20 a.m. to 9:00 a.m., the students received intense individual instruction. From approximately 9:00 a.m. to 9:45 a.m., the students participated in play with typically developing preschool students from the CDC. The preschool students who participated in reverse mainstreaming with Ms. Laing’s class were screened on eight criteria and then trained by Ms. Laing. She employs an outline for integration developed by Phil Strain. The successful students participated with Ms. Laing’s students for the remainder of the school term. From 10: 00 a.m. to 10:45 a.m., the students received intensive one-to-one instruction. From 11:45 a.m. to 12:00 p.m., the students participated in a closing circle.

Ms. Laing testified regarding the way in which she would have implemented STUDENT’s IEP in her classroom during the ESY. She described many opportunities during the day that were available to address STUDENT’s communication goals and objectives, including circle, during one-to-one activities, snack, lunch, and DTT. Specific words or concepts could have been included as Icons for a picture exchange system. To teach plurals, Ms. Laing would have employed activities that used a number of objects requiring STUDENTto use plurals. Ms. Laing also employed a technique called “social stories,” which teaches the student a skill through a story. For example, rather than telling the students to “be on their best behavior,” Ms. Laing developed a story to help the students remain focused when visitors enter the classroom.

Ms. Laing testified that STUDENT’s IEP does not indicate whether a specific method of teaching, such as DTT, PRT, TEACCH, was to be employed. She stated that she would have used whichever approaches were appropriate to address STUDENT’s goals and objectives. Ms. Laing testified that behavioral problems would have been addressed on-going. She would have had STUDENTpractice specific behaviors in the context of daily activities. Ms. Laing expressed the need to postpone determining how to address any tantrumming or noncompliant behavior that STUDENTmay engage in until after having an opportunity to observe the behaviors and to identify antecedents to the behaviors. Ms. Laing testified that independent living or self-help skills such as feeding himself, would have been worked on during snack and lunch. Ms. Laing stated that she initially would have worked on STUDENT’s holding utensils properly. Ms. Laing testified that TEACCH tasks would have been employed to address pre-academic goals and objectives. To enhance STUDENT’s ability to generalize, she first would have taught STUDENTthe skill in the classroom and then would have engaged him in the skill elsewhere. For example, she would have had STUDENTpractice putting items in a grocery cart in the classroom first and then would have gone to a store and had him perform the same task. Ms. Laing testified that she would have broken down tasks to teach STUDENTskills step by step. Ms. Laing has three binders of tasks that have already been broken down into developmentally appropriate steps. She also has materials from Autism Partnership, a resource for parents and educators of children with autism. Ms. Laing testified that if STUDENTwas not ready to independently select an activity during outdoor play, she would have structured activities for him.

Ms. Laing testified that she would have coordinated STUDENT’s preschool program with his in-home providers so as to provide a consistent program. Ms. Laing testified that two students currently in her class have concurrent home therapy programs. To coordinate their programs, the students receive some of their DTT in the classroom from the home therapist. Ms. Laing meets with the therapist and also observes the students’ home programs.

Ms. Laing testified that all of the activities STUDENTengaged in during her observation of the home program in October 1998 could have been generalized in the classroom. For example, STUDENTwas learning directionality at home. During outdoor play, STUDENTcould have been directed to “get on the slide” or “go through the tunnel.” Ms. Laing testified that the word matching drill he was doing at home could have been made a TEACCH task for the classroom and the animal sounds he was practicing at home could have been done with a song at circle time or with play farm equipment during activity time. Ms. Laing stated her belief that STUDENTwould have benefitted from the opportunities available in the preschool setting for socialization and for expansion of his language skills. Ms. Laing testified that in consultation with the speech and language therapist, she first would have shaped the sounds STUDENTmakes and the would have expanded his language. The preschool program also would have provided STUDENTopportunities to generalize skills he had learned at home.

Ms. St. Clair, the speech and language therapist, proposed to meet STUDENTfor therapy on three days each week for 20 minute sessions. Ms. St. Clair testified that she would have worked on STUDENT’s speech phonological and oral-motor skills by teaching STUDENTwhere and how to make sounds with the goal of better intelligibility. Ms. St. Clair stated that she also would have worked on STUDENT’s expressive language skills by building his vocabulary. Initially, she would have worked with body parts and pronouns by asking him to point to concrete objects and move to pictures. Ms. St. Clair testified that she coordinates with other team members and trains them to support what she does during therapy. The other staff also observe her working with students. Ms. St Clair also indicated that she would be willing to work with STUDENT’s tutors to ensure that they are using appropriate techniques to teach STUDENTspeech sounds. She testified that it is important that speech phonology be taught developmentally.

STUDENTparticipated in OT during the ESY to address motor deficits. The District also offered to provide APE as part of STUDENT’s program. The testimony of Ms. Beltran, the APE teacher, established the following regarding the APE program she provided to students in Ms. Laing’s class. Ms. Beltran was in Ms. Laing’s class two days each week. The classroom aides were present while she worked with the students so that they could do follow-up activities with the students on the days Ms. Beltran was not in the classroom. Each session began with music, which was followed by motor movements. Ms. Beltran testified that she would break down the skills for a given task, such as balancing, and then teach each of the steps necessary to do the task. For example, to teach balancing, she would work with the student to stand up. Then she would have the student hold on to the aide while beginning to lift one leg at a time. Ms. Beltran also models the movements. The students then work on the skill targeted for the session. Each session ended with music. As to providing APE for STUDENT, Ms. Beltran proposed to have him in a session with a few other students, including students from the CDC, because of his potential to imitate the other students and to have social interactions with them. She would have addressed STUDENT’s goals and objectives following the model described above.

The testimony of District witnesses establishes that the program offered to STUDENTfor the ESY during the summer of 1998 was comprehensive and was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. The program would have addressed STUDENT’s motor deficits through OT and APE. STUDENT’s language deficits would have been addressed through individual speech and language therapy and in classroom activities described by Ms. Laing. The only objection raised by Petitioner concerning speech and language therapy was the assertion that his language needs were sufficiently addressed through his in-home DTT program. It was determined above that DTT does not sufficiently address STUDENT’s significant language deficits and that he requires speech and language therapy. Ms. St. Clair’s testimony regarding the ways in which she would address STUDENT’s speech and language needs was not otherwise challenged. The speech and language therapy would have been delivered individually to STUDENT. It is also undisputed that STUDENTlearns new concepts particularly well when introduced one-to-one. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language therapy offered by the District was designed to address STUDENT’s deficits.

Petitioner expressed concern about the appropriateness of the language models in the SDC classroom. The CDC students who participate in Ms. Laing’s class were specifically selected and trained by Ms. Laing to participate in activities with her students. The CDC students are near in age to STUDENTand are described as having “age-appropriate” language skills. Petitioner did not present any evidence to contradict Ms. Laing’s testimony regarding the language levels of the CDC students. Ms. Laing’s class also offered opportunities for STUDENTto engage in social activities with other special education students and with students from the CDC. There was no evidence that the CDC students have other than age-appropriate social skills. The Hearing Officer does not find Petitioner’s concerns compelling regarding his potential to model inappropriate behavior of other students in the class. Ms. Laing testified persuasively that the students in her class generally did not have significant behavioral problems. Moreover, there was no evidence that STUDENTmodeled the inappropriate behavior of students when he previously attended school. The evidence establishes that there were appropriate language and social models for STUDENTthroughout the school day. Various CDC students participated in the SDC classroom activities throughout the school day. The SDC students also had opportunities to engage in activities with all of the CDC students during recesses. Moreover, if STUDENTwere ready, he also could have mainstreamed in the CDC classrooms with age-appropriate language and social skills models. Thus, STUDENThad opportunities throughout the school day for STUDENTto model the language and social skills of age-appropriate peers and to practice the language and social skills he was acquiring with them.

Because of the small number of students in Ms. Laing’s class and the number of staff, there also were many opportunities for STUDENTto receive individual instruction. The additional aide would have allowed for STUDENTto receive additional one-to-one instruction. The ESY class schedule specifically allotted time during the school day for individual instruction and the fact that Ms. Laing has access to a second classroom provided space for the students to receive individual instruction in a relative distraction free environment.

As to concerns regarding teaching techniques that would be employed with STUDENT, Ms. Laing testified persuasively that while a number of techniques are used with students in her class, the programs and instructional methodologies are individualized for each student. Specifically, appropriate techniques for each individual child are employed during periods of individual instruction. Some students receive individual DTT and others participate in TEACCH activities. The Hearing Officer finds no basis for assuming that Ms. Laing would have subjected STUDENTto teaching techniques that were not identified as appropriate for him. There also is no basis for assuming that Ms. Laing would have used TEACCH activities with STUDENTthat were below his then-current functioning level. Ms. Laing’s testimony as discussed above establishes that she coordinated with parents and with tutors of other students receiving in-home programs, which would allow the program provided to STUDENTto be consistent.

Based on the evidence as discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Laing’s class and the services proposed by the District for the ESY were designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, including language, motor, and social skills, and also to participate in activities with appropriate peers and to have opportunities to generalize skills he had been learning in his home program.

As to whether the program was designed to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit, the evidence establishes that STUDENTlearns in one-to-one situations but has not had the opportunity to practice his language skills, develop social skills, or generalize all of the skills. The in-home program, in conjunction with the classroom, provided for STUDENTto receive a great deal of one-to-one instruction. The testimony of STUDENT’s LIFE tutors and his mother establishes that he did learn new skills and, thereby, benefited from the one-to-one instruction. The classroom component of the District’s offer of placement for the ESY offered opportunities for STUDENTto receive additional one-to-one instruction in a different environment and also offered him access to age-appropriate peers to develop social and language skills and to practice all of the skills he has been learning one-to-one with adults. With these opportunities, it is probable that STUDENT’s language and social skills would have improved and he would have used language and other skills in practical and meaningful settings. Moreover, STUDENT’s learning to use skills in a number of environments would allow for STUDENT to be placed at some future time in a less restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s ESY program was designed to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit.

There are no disputes regarding the District’s ESY placement conforming to STUDENT’s IEP. Because the ESY placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and to provide him with educational benefit, and conforms with his IEP, it satisfies the requirements of an appropriate placement under the IDEA and Rowley. The ESY placement also satisfies LRE requirements because it provided for STUDENTto participate in activities through reveres mainstreaming and on the playground with regular education peers to the maximum extent appropriate at that time.

The period from July 27, 1998 until the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year

For the period from July 27 until the beginning of the 1998-199 school year, the District proposed that STUDENTwould continue with his in-home DTT program provided through LIFE with a two week break after August 14, 1998. It is undisputed that DTT meets STUDENT’s needs and that he benefits from DTT. It has already been determined that 21.5 hours of DTT constitutes an appropriate level of DTT for STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents contend that he requires a year round DTT program. The District proposed that STUDENTwould have a 46 week program with breaks from DTT not to exceed two weeks. One of the two week breaks would have occurred during the period from August 15, 1998, until the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year. Ms. Laing testified that if STUDENThad enrolled in her class, she was willing to provide the parents with activities to do with STUDENTat home just as she did for the parents of other students in her class. The parents could elect to do these activities during the break. Moreover, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that he will significantly regress during a two-week break from DTT. For all these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer to continue DTT during the period set forth above was appropriate.

Moreover, the school district is not required to place a student in the program preferred by the parents--in this case the intensive in-home program--even if that program could be more beneficial to the student. Gregory K. 811 F2d. 130. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ participation in the IEP process may result in the denial of a free appropriate public education to the student. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479. Petitioner contends that the District committed procedural violations that resulted in the denial of FAPE to him. For example, Petitioner asserts that in recommending a placement for him, the District did not consider the full continuum of educational placements, had predetermined the appropriate placement for him, and would only adopt goals and objectives. Petitioner’s parents have participated in the IEP meeting to transition STUDENTto the District from an infant program and were represented by counsel at this meeting. The District’s offer of placement included continuing STUDENTin his in-home DTT program, as well as providing him with related services and participation in a preschool classroom. The fact that the parents dispute the appropriateness of the placement proposed by the District does not establish that their right to participate in the IEP process has been infringed on or has resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contentions regarding procedural matters.

ISSUE NO. 2: Did the La Mesa-Spring Valley School District offer STUDENTa FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?

As stated above, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. For the 1998-1999 school year, the District proposed that STUDENTwould attend Ms. Laing’s SDC with 10% of the school day spent integrating with nondisabled peers. The District’s offer of placement includes 21.5 hours of DTT and all of the other related services offered previously including a one-to-one aide, APE, speech and language, and OT.

The witnesses concur that STUDENT’s needs for the 1998-1999 school year remained nearly identical to his needs as described above. The record establishes that STUDENTcontinued to exhibit deficits in all areas of development, particularly in expressive language and in social skills. STUDENT’s LIFE tutors noted improvement in some areas and Ms. Laing testified that STUDENTappeared more mature when she observed him during OT at or near the beginning of September.

The evidence establishes that except as set forth below, the placement offered to STUDENTfor the 1998-1999 school year was substantially similar to the program offered during the ESY program. Ms. Laing’s testimony regarding her class for the 1998-1999 school year establishes the following. During the regular school year, the SDC meets for five hours a day Monday through Thursday and for 3.5 hours on Fridays. Home visits and staff meetings take place on Fridays. Ms. Laing testified that she would also attend STUDENT’s LIFE workshops on Fridays, when appropriate. Ms. Laing is assisted in the classroom by three instructional assistants. Two of the assistants are employed full-time and one assistant is employed for four hours daily. One of the assistants, Kathi Lemli, has a B.A., was trained by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) in discrete trial training techniques, and has delivered an in-home DTT program for children with autism for four to five years. Mary Fransway, another assistant, holds a B.A. in English and has been trained by the District to work with children with autism. Denise Cosar, the third aide, has experience as a one-to-one aide for a child with autism. There are six students in the class. Four of the students in Ms. Laing’s class have been diagnosed as autistic. Ms. Laing described the other two students as “communicatively handicapped with global delays.” She stated that one of the students is in the process of being identified as autistic. The students are between the ages of two and one-half years old to four years old. One student does not attend school every day. When asked to describe the behavior of the students, Ms. Laing testified that some of the students have behavioral intervention plans (BIP) to address their behavior. Two of the students tantrum occasionally. None of the students have consistent self-stimulatory behaviors. Their self-stimulatory behavior consists of the student fluttering his eyes, putting things around the mouth, and moving his arms. One student engages in verbal stimulation several times each week. Ms. Laing testified that none of the students require physical restraint to stay in a chair or on a carpet square during circle time.

Ms. Laing testified that the school has a monthly theme, which she modifies to meet the needs of her class. For example, for the month of October Orange and pumpkin were the themes. There also are shapes, numbers, and sounds of the month. The speech and language therapist is on campus four days a week. The APE teacher works in Ms. Laing’s class two days each week and the occupational therapist provides OT to those students whose IEP calls for OT. The occupational therapist also consults with Ms. Laing and provides vestibular activities to students in her class.

Ms. Laing outlined the general schedule of her class. (See also Respondent’s Exhibit 38.) All of the students have a picture schedule for their school day. Ms. Laing uses Meyer-Johnson icons to inform the students where they are to go for an activity. Ms. Laing stated that three of the students can independently follow their schedule and she has begun to fade their use of icons. The students arrive at 8:00 a.m. Students then use the restroom. Some students have cereal and pivotal response training (PRT) begins for those students whose IEPs call for PRT. Ms. Laing described PRT as “child driven play therapy.” Either Ms. Laing or one of the aides sits with the student on the floor and expands on whatever language the student may using a toy in which the student has shown an interest. At 8:30 a.m., the students are divided into two groups. One group participates in circle time while the other group engages in vestibular activities to “center” and calm down the students. The groups then switch activities. Ms. Laing testified that the focus of circle time is to have the students imitate the words of songs and their accompanying movements. Vestibular activities may include swinging, brushing, bouncing on a ball, playing in bubbles, or crawling through barrels.

At 9:00 a.m., the students are divided into small groups. One group of two students and one aide participates in TEACCH activities. Their “jobs” are based on the individual student’s IEP goals. TEACCH activities are designed to teach students to independently complete tasks. Each student has his or her own TEACCH schedule. From the schedule, the students pulls off an icon and matches it with an icon of a basket containing a TEACCH “job.” Jobs include putting items in certain locations, and matching and sequencing. When the student completes a task, the student returns to his or her schedule to determine the next task. During this period, a second group of students work on language activities. Generally one student works with Ms. Laing and another student works with the speech pathologist. After approximately 15 minutes, the students switch activities. During this period, and intermittently throughout the school day, two students from the CDC come to Ms. Laing’s class and participate in the activities with her students. One or two of Ms. Laing’s students go to the CDC class for integration. An aide accompanies Ms. Laing’s students. At approximately 9:30 a.m., the students engage in play activities based on PRT and then have a snack. At 10:00 a.m., all of the students in Ms. Laing’s class, as well as all of the CDC children, have outdoor play. Outside activities include a sand box, slide, individual activity tables, bikes, and water tables. At 10:30 a.m., students return to the class for individual or small-group instruction pursuant to their IEP goals and objectives. Two four-year-old students from the community participated in the classroom until 1:00 p.m. Some of Ms. Laing’s students are grouped with one other student. The students work in cubicles in another room, in a cubicle in Ms. Laing’s class. On Tuesdays and Thursdays, the students have APE at 11: 15 a.m. On Mondays and Wednesdays, the students have sensory activities and arts and crafts activities. One student does not participate in art. From 11:45 am. to 12:00 p.m. the students have a play period. The students then have lunch and all of the students participate in outside integration with the CDC students. At 12:30 p.m., students use the restroom and then participate in a closing circle. School ends at 1:00 p.m. except on Fridays, when school ends at 11:30 a.m.

Petitioner expressed the same general concerns about Ms. Laing’s class as discussed relative to the ESY program. The Hearing Officer does not find their concerns persuasive for the same reasons previously discussed. In general, Ms. Laing’s testimony establishes that her class did not change significantly from the ESY to the regular school year. The services offered by the District also were the same. Therefore, because neither STUDENTnor the proposed placement have substantially changed, all of the findings in Issue No. 1 related to the ability of the District’s proposed placement to meet STUDENT’s needs apply to the District’s offer of placement for the 1998-1999 school year. In summary, the testimony of Ms. Laing and Ms. St. Clair establish that the combination of class activities and speech and language therapy would address STUDENT’s language deficits. The testimony of the APE teacher and the occupational therapist, which was undisputed, establishes that the services they offered would address STUDENT’s motor deficits. The class offers opportunities for STUDENTto generalize skills and provides him with social and language models to practice the skills he is learning in the home program. The combination of DTT and the classroom program also addresses STUDENT’s need to receive individual instruction when new skills or concepts are introduced. Ms. Laing also has set in place means for the family, the school, and LIFE personnel to communicate for the purpose of providing STUDENTwith a consistent program. In short, the evidence establishes that the placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

Also for the reasons discussed above and the findings made in Issue No. 1, it is also concluded that the District’s offer for the 1998-1999 school year is designed to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit and conforms with his IEP. Therefore, pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley, the District has offered an appropriate placement for STUDENTfor the 1998-1999 school year. Because the placement provides STUDENTwith opportunities to engage in some activities with regular education peers to the maximum extent currently appropriate, it also satisfies LRE requirements.

ISSUE NO. 3: Are the PARENTS entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the private educational services they have provided for STUDENT?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the private placement or services are determined to be appropriate under IDEA. It has been determined that the District offered STUDENTan appropriate placement for all periods at issue. Therefore, Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the services they have procured that are above what has been offered by the District.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 28, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The hearing also was scheduled to convene on October 14, 1998; however, MOTHERbecame ill and the hearing was continued prior to the taking of evidence on that date.

2. FATHER’s employment and the need to provide child care prevented him from attending the entire hearing.

3. LIFE is a certified nonpublic agency. Its primary location is in Los Angeles and there is a satellite office in San Diego. STUDENTcurrently participates in LIFE’s “workshop model,” whereby the family recruits tutors who are then trained by LIFE. The family, trainers, and LIFE administrators meet periodically at workshops to monitor and revise the student’s program.

4. Prior to October 1998, STUDENTwas receiving approximately 20 hours of DTT.

5. STUDENT’s parents have declined other special education services, including APE and speech and language therapy, offered at IEP meetings on May 21, and June 17, 1998. (Respondent’s Exhibits 14 and 17.)

6. RIDES is a checklist designed to informally assess developmental functioning. (District’s Exhibit 13.)

7. Except for infants with solely a visual, hearing, or severe orthopedic impairment, or any combination thereof, California special education law designates the State Department of Developmental Services and regional centers responsible for the provision of appropriate early intervention services for children under three years old. Title 14 Government Code § 95014(b)(1).

8. The PEP-R is an “inventory of behaviors and skills which uses a framework designed to identify learning patterns in children with autism or related disorders. . . .Its primary purpose is to identify emergent skills which can be used to develop individualized curricula for students.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 13.)

9. Regional centers often are responsible for providing collateral services to special education students with developmental disabilities; however, at the hearing, the District stipulated that it would ensure that STUDENT’s DTT is maintained at 21.5 hours each week if the Regional Center’s level of support decreased.

10. The District’s letter indicates that its offer of DTT is for 10.5 hours per week. In all other correspondence, including the IEP, and at the hearing, the District stated that its offer is for 11.5 hours per week.

11. The PARENTS have stated their belief that the LIFE program sufficiently addresses STUDENT’s language needs.

12. 1 Ms. Provine, Ms. Beltran, and Ms. Laing assessed STUDENTin 1998 on behalf of the District.

13. Ms. Eastin has a B.A. in psychology. Since February 1998, Ms. Eastin has provided direct services to STUDENTfor approximately eight and one-half hours each week. For approximately three hours each week, Ms. Eastin overlaps with the other therapists to ensure consistency to STUDENT’s program. She also performs administrative duties for LIFE that include reviewing the log books of STUDENT’s DTT program, typing up notes, and making changes to STUDENT’s program in consultation with her supervisor. She spends approximately six hours in LIFE workshops every four to six weeks and occasionally attends a clinic meeting.

14. There is no dispute about STUDENT’s participation in OT.

15. Ms. Bakcht has a Bachelor’s Degree in psychology. Dr. Wynn also is the assistant director of the Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children (Clinic) and a lecturer at the University of California Los Angeles (UCLA). Dr. Wynn has supervised the treatment of 300 children with autism and has worked directly with 150 of those students. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 65 for Dr. Wynn’s curriculum vitae.)

16. STUDENThas two brothers. One brother is autistic and participates in an intensive in-home program provided by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). STUDENT’s other brother also receives special education services. There is some dispute between MOTHERand the District regarding whether she must undertake all of the administrative tasks related to STUDENT’s program. There also is a dispute regarding paying the tutors. MOTHERhas been paying the tutors and then seeking reimbursement from the District for their portion. There was a delay in reimbursement, which the District attributed to some discrepancies in paper work. The District has offered to make the tutors District employees and to pay they directly. MOTHERperceived this arrangement as resulting in additional paper work for her. These are matters that must be worked out between the District, the Regional Center, and MOTHERand are not addressed by this decision.

17. Ms. Frischknecht has a Master’s Degree in early childhood education and holds regular and special education teaching credentials. Ms. Murrell holds a Master’s Degree in special education and is a credentialed speech and language therapist. Ms. Murrell has been an Early Start teacher for 12 years. She previously was a speech and language therapist at the elementary school level for 7 years and an SDC teacher for 7 years. Ms. Manion has a Master’s Degree in special education and holds regular and special education teaching credentials. Ms. Beaty has a Master’s Degree in special education, holds regular and special education credentials, and an administrative credential, and has been employed in the field of special education for 24 years. Ms. Laing holds a master’s degree in special education, a multiple subjects teaching credential, and a credential authorizing her to teach students with severe disabilities (SH). Ms. Laing received training related to delivering DTT from Autism Partnership, a nonpublic agency that specializes in training and delivering services to children with autism. Ms. Laing first met STUDENTwhen she administered the PEP-R to him. She has also observed him participating in his home DTT program and in OT.

18. Dr. Schreibman is a professor in psychology at the University of California San Diego. She has conducted extensive research in the area of autism. Because parental consent was denied, Dr. Schreibman has not met STUDENT; however, she observed approximately six hours of tapes of STUDENTand reviewed his educational records.

19. It is the Hearing Officer’s understanding that STUDENT’s work space is in his parents’ bedroom.

20. Ms. St. Clair observed STUDENTat home and conducted an assessment of him. Ms. St. Clair is assigned to provide speech and language therapy to the students in Ms. Laing’s class.

21. The parties stipulated that a new transition plan will need to be developed if the PARENT’s enroll STUDENTin the District’s program.