California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 5, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 817-02 · Hearing Officer My T. Huynh

Los Angeles Unified must reimburse $18,934.50 for private full-day kindergarten and a behavioral consultant; prospective private placement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 7 issuesVanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a kindergarten-age girl with high functioning autism filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. They challenged her April 11, 2002 IEP. It offered a half-day general education kindergarten at Colfax Elementary with a temporary support assistant and an inclusion facilitator. It also offered one hour per week of speech-language therapy, 60 minutes per month of occupational therapy (OT), and behavior intervention. Instead, the parents enrolled her in a full-day kindergarten at The Country School, a private school without state certification, and hired behavioral consultant Shannon Troy.

The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for 2002-2003. Developmental pediatrician Dr. Audrey Griesbach and speech expert Dr. Ann Mastergeorge both testified. Their testimony showed the student needed a full school day for repetition, for generalizing skills, and for time with typical peers. District witnesses had little direct knowledge of her. The District's speech and OT assessments were incomplete or improperly scored. As a result, they missed her language needs and her balance and body-awareness needs, and the services offered were too low. The Hearing Officer did find that the District's classroom could have been adapted with small groups, a trained aide, and the inclusion facilitator. The private school and Ms. Troy's services were appropriate. The District must reimburse $16,354 for The Country School, including required fees and finance charges, and $2,580.50 for Ms. Troy. Under state law, the Hearing Officer could not order placement at the uncertified school for 2003-2004.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed providers who knew a student well against district witnesses who had never assessed her. It also treated incomplete or nonstandard testing as unreliable. It shows the era's split rule: parents could be reimbursed for an uncertified private school under Carter, but Education Code section 56505.2 barred ordering prospective placement there.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1a. For the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to offer Student an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs by failing to provide a full-day kindergarten program with normally developing peers?

    The half-day kindergarten offered in the April 11, 2002 IEP did not meet the student's needs for repetition, generalization and social interaction; she needed a full-day class.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Did the District fail to offer a small group setting with trained and experienced educational and behavioral personnel?

    Open Court instruction could be adapted to small groups and short lessons, and the trained temporary support assistant and inclusion facilitator were adequate; a dedicated aide or the prior aide was not required.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1c. Did the District fail to offer adequate speech and language services?

    The District's speech-language assessment was improperly scored and understated her receptive, expressive and pragmatic needs; cutting services to one hour weekly when prior goals were unmet was inadequate.

  4. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1d. Did the District fail to offer adequate occupational therapy services?

    The District relied on an incomplete sensory integration test, missed her balance and body-awareness needs, and offered only a sensory diet, so the OT offer did not meet her needs.

  5. Issue 2a. If the District failed to offer an appropriate placement, are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Student's placement for the 2002-2003 school year at The Country School?

    The Country School met the student's needs and provided educational benefit; tuition, required fees and installment finance charges of $16,354 were reimbursable even though the school was not certified.

  6. Issue 2b. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of educational and behavioral services provided by Shannon Troy?

    Ms. Troy's school-readiness and behavioral services were appropriate and provided benefit; the requested partial reimbursement of $2,580.50 was awarded.

  7. Issue 3. Is Student entitled to prospective placement for the 2003-2004 school year at The Country School?

    Education Code section 56505.2 barred the Hearing Officer from ordering prospective placement at a noncertified private school.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse parents $16,354.00 for the costs of attending The Country School in 2002-2003 (tuition, building fund, new parent fee, installment finance charges).
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receipt of proof of payment, the District shall reimburse parents $2,580.50 for Shannon Troy's educational and behavioral services during 2002-2003.

Total: $18,934.50 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2

People named in the decision

  • Ann Mastergeorge, Ph.D., expert witness for Student (speech pathology; UC Davis M.I.N.D. Institute researcher)
  • Audrey Griesbach, M.D., developmental pediatrician; witness for Student
  • Paul Singer, Head of School, The Country School
  • Shannon Troy, private behavioral and educational consultant
  • Deborah (Debbie) Jacobowitz, school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Pat Grayson-DeJong, autism program support specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Alana Ronen, speech therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Erin Green, speech therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Carol Steiber, inclusion specialist/facilitator and resource specialist, Colfax Elementary, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Rejielyn Cerdenio, occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Nathalie Alusi, occupational therapist (administered SIPT), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Anita Boxer, M.A., private speech-language pathologist
  • Vivian Deckard, therapeutic companion (preschool aide)
  • Laura Parmalee, therapeutic companion during kindergarten
  • Ms. Louis, kindergarten teacher, Colfax Elementary
  • Ms. Walker, kindergarten teacher, Colfax Elementary
  • Tonya Gregory, District representative, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Barbara Baum, District representative, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Lisa Kendrick, District representative, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Barbara Helfing, educational advocate (hearing observer)
  • George Cook, attorney (hearing observer)
  • Antonia Perez, legal assistant (hearing observer)
  • The Country School, noncertified private school (unilateral placement)
  • Smart Start Preschool Program, nonpublic developmental preschool
  • The Neighborhood School, private general education preschool
  • Therapy in Action, nonpublic agency (behavior intervention and OT)
  • North Los Angeles Regional Center, regional center funding stay-put services
  • H.E.L.P., public agency where Ms. Troy formerly worked

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Los Angeles, California, on June 26-27, July 1-2 and July 15-18, 2003.

Petitioner Student (Student or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Valerie Vanaman, and Student’s parents, Mother and Father. Additionally, Petitioner requested that the hearing be open to the public, and the hearing was observed at times by educational advocate Barbara Helfing, attorney George Cook, legal assistant Antonia Perez, and family friend Julie Schemitz.

The Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Alexa Jackowski, and at various times by District representatives Tonya Gregory, Barbara Baum, and Lisa Kendrick. Diane Pappas, the District’s Office of General Counsel, was also present on one day of the hearing.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Mother; Father; Ann Mastergeorge, Ph.D.; Audrey Griesbach, M.D.; Paul Singer, head of The Country School; and therapist Shannon Troy.

The District called the following witnesses: Deborah Jacobowitz, school psychologist; Pat Grayson-DeJong, autism program support specialist; Alana Ronen, speech therapist; Carol Steiber, inclusion specialist; Rejielyn Cerdenio, occupational therapist; and Erin Green, speech therapist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s written closing brief by mail on August 8, 2003, and the District’s closing brief was received by mail on August 11, 2003. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (footnote 1)

1. For the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to offer Student an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs by failing to provide the following components:

a. A full-day kindergarten program with normally developing peers?

b. A small group setting with trained and experienced educational and behavioral personnel?

c. Adequate speech and language services? and d. Adequate occupational therapy services?

2. If the District failed to offer Student an appropriate placement, are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following:

a. The costs of Student’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year at The Country School? and b. The costs of educational and behavioral services provided by Shannon Troy?

3. Is Student entitled to prospective placement for the 2003-2004 school year at The Country School?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District’s April 11, 2002 individualized education program (IEP) did not offer her a “free appropriate public education” (FAFE) because it was not designed to meet her unique needs. Petitioner asserts that the District’s program of a general education half-day class was not acceptable for Student’s needs because she requires a full-day class. Further, the “open court” teaching method employed in the proposed kindergarten class did not suit Student’s limited attention span. Petitioner asserted that the proposed program would create an environment that Student could not tolerate and in which she could not learn. Moreover, Petitioner claims that the proposed classroom with a teacher or aide with limited experience working with autistic children would only compound Student’s difficulties. Lastly, Petitioner believes that the amount of speech and language and occupational therapy services offered was inadequate and would cause Student to regress and deny her access the regular educational curriculum. (footnote 2)

Because of Petitioner’s disagreement with the District concerning the IEP of April 11, 2002, Student’s parents unilaterally placed Student at a private nonpublic school, The Country School, during her kindergarten year. Petitioner contends that this placement met Student’s unique needs and conferred educational benefit to Student and thus Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost incurred in this placement. Further, Petitioner asserts that the District’s failure to offer a FAPE required Student to enlist education and behavior intervention services from a private consultant, Shannon Troy. Petitioner seeks partial reimbursement for costs associated with Ms. Troy’s services during the 2002-2003 school year. Lastly, Petitioner seeks prospective placement at The Country School for the 2003-2004 school year at the District’s expense.

The District contends that it properly determined Student’s unique needs from the assessments it conducted and reports from Student’s service providers at the April 11, 2003 IEP team meeting. In the District’s view, the April 11, 2003 IEP offered Student a FAPE by meeting her unique needs. It provided a program in a general education half-day kindergarten class at her neighborhood school, Colfax Elementary, with typically developing students. The District also asserts that Colfax’s kindergarten teachers have the willingness and experience to work with children with autistic characteristics. In addition, the District contends that its offer properly addressed Student’s unique behavioral needs by providing a qualified full-time temporary support assistant (TSA) to assist her throughout her school day. Further, the District contends that the levels of speech and language and occupational therapy services were adequate to meet Student’s unique needs. Thus, the District contends that the placement was appropriate and Petitioner is not entitled to any reimbursement. Lastly, the District claims that because The Country School is not a certified nonpublic school, prospective placement is not available as a remedy as a matter of law.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Student is a seven-year-old first-grader eligible for special education and related services as a student with high functioning autism. As a result of her autism, Student has deficits in areas of verbal and nonverbal communication, motor skills, and behavior and social interactions. These deficits adversely affect her educational performance. (Pet. Exh. 44.) She currently attends The Country School.

At eighteen months of age, Student was diagnosed with high functioning autism at the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA. (Pet. Exh. 2.) Student immediately began treatment including music therapy and “Floor Time” therapy. (footnote 3) Student also began receiving speech and language services from speech therapist Anita Boxer, M.A. (Pet. Exh. 5.) These services were provided by the North Los Angeles Regional Center (Center). At age two, Student began attending Smart Start Preschool Program, a nonpublic developmentally based preschool.

Following a referral from the Center, the District began providing related services to Student in February 1999 while she continued to attend Smart Start. At that time, Anita Boxer provided two hours per week of speech and language therapy. Further, Student began receiving two hours per week of behavioral intervention and occupational therapy at Therapy in Action, a nonpublic service provider.

In September 2001, Student began attending the Neighborhood School, a private general education program preschool. She was accompanied by a therapeutic companion, Vivian Deckard. Student also continued to attend Smart Start in afternoons following her classes at the Neighborhood School. In addition, Student received services after school and on Saturdays including occupational therapy, speech and language therapy, and Floor Time programming.

On December 6, 2001, the District conducted its annual individual education program (IEP) meeting for Student. (Pet. Exh. 33.) The IEP contained goals to be met and services to be provided in the areas of speech and language, social/emotional, language, and school readiness skills for the period December 2001 to December 2002. However, the IEP’s goals with respect to motor and behavior skills were to be met by the next IEP meeting scheduled for late March 2002, following the mandated triennial assessment.

The December 2001 IEP indicated that Student had needs in the area of motor skills as indicated by Goals 1 and 2. The goals sought to improve Student’s organization of behavior/sensory modulation and her motor planning skills. The District recommended 60 minutes per week of school-based therapy and 60 minutes per week in outside therapy to address these needs.

The December 2001 IEP also delineated Student’s needs in speech and language skills as indicated by Goals 3 through 9. The IEP team determined that Student’s expressive language skills needed improvement in the areas of answering questions and pronoun use. They also recognized that Student had receptive language deficits and auditory inattentiveness with answering questions without external prompting. Further, Student’s social language use was inconsistent in describing the logical order of events and she required assistance in engaging appropriately in social conversation with peers. To meet the IEP speech and language goals, the District recommended 90 minutes per week of school-based therapy and an additional 120 minutes per week of therapy by a nonpublic agency (NPA).

The December 2001 IEP also identified Student as requiring assistance with behavior skills in her play and interaction with others, classroom strategies to deal with being stressed, increasing eye contact when speaking with peers and adults, and initiating play in structured, small-group activities. In times of stress, Student might hit another student or begin to cry. In particular, in larger groups, Student had more difficulty engaging with peers and staying on task. The IEP set forth Goals 18 and 19 to improve Student’s social interactions and her recovery skills when interrupted in play or classroom activities. The District recommended 540 minutes per week of behavior intervention implementation (BII). Further, the District recommended 300 minutes per month of behavior intervention supervision (BID).

Following the December 6, 2001 IEP meeting, both the District and Student’s parents conducted assessments in various areas of concern regarding Student’s development to determine her present levels of performance in preparation for the upcoming IEP meeting. Due to scheduling conflicts, the parties agreed that the IEP meeting scheduled for March 2002 would take place on April 11, 2002, following completion of the triennial assessment. (Pet. Exh. 44.) Student’s parents, school psychologist Debbie Jacobowitz, speech therapists Alana Ronen and Erin Green, occupational therapist Rejielyn Cerdenio, and other District and NPS personnel attended the IEP meeting. The District and Petitioner separately assessed Student for speech and language needs. Student was also evaluated for occupational therapy consideration. The IEP team also received reports regarding behavior issues from Shannon Troy, Student’s private behavioral and educational consultant. (Pet. Exh. 41.) Student’s developmental pediatrician, Dr. Audrey Griesbach submitted a report also discussing Student’s behavior intervention progress. (Pet. Exh. 42.) At the meeting, Student’s parents provided the reports of Shannon Troy, Dr. Griesbach and others for review by the IEP team. The reports were read and summarized during the meeting.

The IEP set forth sixteen goals and recommended for Student a placement in a typical general education half-day kindergarten class at her local elementary school with related services. The services enumerated one hour per week of school-based speech and language in four 15-minute increments, 60 minutes per month or 720 minutes per year of occupational therapy, in-school behavior intervention of 10 to 15 hours per week during specified periods of the school year, 8 hours per month of out-of-school behavior intervention, and an in-class Temporary Support Assistant (TSA). The April 11, 2002 IEP replaced the existing IEP of December 6, 2001 and constituted the District’s placement offer for the 2002-2003 school year.

Student’s parents disagreed with the half-day kindergarten program and the amount of related services to be provided under the IEP. As a result of the disagreement, Student was unilaterally placed at The Country School (TCS), a noncertified nonpublic school. Student attended TCS’s full-day kindergarten class consisting of a small class ratio of two teachers and one aide to no more than 27 children. In addition, a therapeutic aide accompanied Student during the school day.

Under a stay put arrangement, Student continued to receive related services for speech and language, occupational therapy, and behavior intervention at the prior December 2001 IEP levels. The services were paid for by the North Los Angeles Regional Center at no cost to Student’s parents. They paid separately for the costs of Student’s attending TCS and the private behavior and education support services of Shannon Troy.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. For the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to offer Student an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.

An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, of the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343 and 56345.

To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Rowley Court concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). Furthermore, the amended IDEA specifies additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE that is not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. (See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four substantive requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and (3) comported with her IEP. (footnote 4)

Student’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the program offered to Student by the District at the April 11, 2002 IEP meeting was designed to meet her unique needs through the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer must first determine what those needs are. Next, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the placement offered by the District was designed to meet those needs.

Unique Academic, Social and Behavior Needs

The evidence demonstrates that Student has unique cognitive and academic needs arising out of her autism. The parties agree generally that Student requires repetition to learn and retain materials. On a social level, the parties do not dispute that Student requires time to generalize sufficiently to maintain social interaction with peers and others. Accordingly, Student needs interaction with typical children and adults to develop her social skills. Further, typical children provide positive models for Student’s development in the areas of language and behavior. Student also has behavioral issues such as anxiety, rigidity and overreaction that severely impair her learning performance and social competence. The parties do not dispute Student’s behavior problems as manifested by her rigidity and high level of distractibility and anxiety in large groups. Specifically, Student suffers from a low level of tolerance when asked to complete tasks she does not prefer and throws tantrums frequently with transitions or when frustrated, overwhelmed or anxious. Further, Student exhibits anxiety when placed in large groups. As a result, Student often requires individualized attention or small-group settings. In addition, the parties generally agree that Student has a short attention span and is easily distracted and unable to engage in activities over 30 minutes without losing focus. Even then, it is often necessary to prompt Student and provide reinforcements to keep her on task. The deficits cause Student to have tremendous difficulty with behavioral organization and self-regulation, contributing greatly to her negative and atypical behavioral responses.

Because of these deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that Student requires a general education class with typically developing peers requiring adequate time to allow generalization of materials and socializing with peers. Student also requires a structured classroom with typically developing peers staffed with qualified personnel experienced in working with high functioning autistic children such as Student. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s lessons should be limited to no more than 30 minutes of instruction and provided in a small-group setting. Thus, Student required a structured classroom setting with sufficient time to meet her unique academic, social and behavioral needs.

Speech and Language Needs

Although the parties dispute the severity of Student’s speech and language needs, the evidence also shows that Student has unique speech and language needs in the areas of receptive, expressive and pragmatic language. These deficiencies interfere with Student’s ability to learn and communicate. The parties generally agree that Student has these needs but disagree as to the severity of those needs and to the level of services necessary to address these problem areas. Specifically, Petitioner claims that the District’s assessments prior to the April 11, 2002 IEP meeting erroneously underestimated her level of need and improperly offered only one hour per week of speech and language services. Petitioner contends that the assessments and observation of its experts demonstrate that Student had higher levels of need than determined by the District and Student required more intensive speech and language intervention.

District speech therapist Alana Ronen performed examinations over a three-day period prior to the April 11, 2002 IEP meeting. (Pet. Exh. 34.) (footnote 5) The assessment completed by Ms Ronen in determining Student’s potential speech and language needs found she was within the average range in auditory comprehension. However, Student’s expressive communication was below the average range. Ms. Ronen testified that although Student’s expressive communication score fell below the standard score mean, a confidence interval was used to raise Student’s scores. The use of a confidence interval provided a revised score within normal ranges. (footnote 6)

Petitioner asserts that Student had difficulties in several speech and language areas above the levels indicated by the District’s assessments and determinations. Ann Mastergeorge, Ph.D., testified that Student had receptive language needs based on the scores provided by Anita Boxer’s CELF-P assessment indicating difficulty with linguistic concepts, recalling sentences and total language. (footnote 7) Ms. Boxer’s report noted that Student’s receptive language scores were two standard deviations below mean. In addition, her expressive language scores fell below one and a half standard deviations. Further, the report indicated that Student showed moderate to severe impairment with auditory memory. Dr. Mastergeorge concurred with the findings of Ms. Boxer.

Dr. Mastergeorge further testified that Student’s score showed moderate to severe impairment in auditory memory. Specifically, Student had difficulty with “wh” (who, what, where) questions and the temporal order of events. Lastly, Student also demonstrated problems with pragmatic or social communication. Student was inconsistent with eye contact during conversations. Further, she exhibits problems in maintaining conversation topics beyond short interactions. She asserted that Student needs intensive intervention over time to maintain adequate skills to generalize. With respect to the District’s assessment, Dr. Mastergeorge disagreed with the use of the testing procedures used by Ms. Ronen. Dr. Mastergeorge testified that by design, the use of the One-Word Picture test could not accurately show adequate auditory comprehension. Further, Student struggled with the exam to the point that the District could not obtain a standard score. (Pet. Exh. 34.) (footnote 8) Dr. Mastergeorge concluded that Student needed at least two hours of services per week to meet her speech and language needs.

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Petitioner’s determination of Student’s speech and language needs as proffered by Dr. Mastergeorge. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds Student had difficulty in receptive language with passive constructions where close attention to word meaning and modification is required. Further, Student struggled with “wh” (who, what, where) questions and the temporal order of events indicating auditory memory deficits. In expressive language, Student required additional assistance with pronoun, question and preposition use. In pragmatic language, Student also had inconsistent eye contact during conversations and has difficulty in maintaining conversation beyond short interactions. As a result, Student required intensive levels of speech and language services to address these needs, as will be discussed below.

Occupational Therapy Needs

The parties also generally agree that Student has occupational therapy needs. The parties, however, dispute the severity of Student’s occupational therapy needs, particularly in the area of proprioception (body awareness). It is generally accepted that Student’s occupational therapy problems manifest themselves in her aberrant reaction to classroom interruptions and unexpected touching.

The parties differ in their respective beliefs regarding the severity of Student’s proprioceptive needs. Petitioner contends that in addition to Student’s aberrant reactions to touching and disruptions, she also has gross motor deficits when navigating around obstacles or maintaining balance. Further, Petitioner claims that Student has fine motor needs with her pencil grip. Petitioner asserts that the District failed to identify these needs and that the amount and type of service offered by the District do not address these needs.

The District assessed Student prior to the April 2002 IEP meeting using the Sensory Integration and Praxis Test (SIPT) and The Sensory Profile (SP). (Pet. Exh. 39.) At hearing, Ms. Rejielyn Cerdenio, District occupational therapist, testified that she helped administer and score the SP. However, only Ms. Nathalie Alusi, another Districtoccupational therapist, administered and scored the SIPT. (footnote 9) At the April 2002 IEP meeting, the District recommended one OT goal, a sensory diet. The goal sought to improve Student’s proprioceptive skills by assisting her to remain seated and calm when unexpected touching or classroom disruptions occurred. In addition, the sensory diet would address Student’s deficits in tactile input.

Ms. Cerdenio stated that the SIPT and SP results, coupled with interviews with Student’s teachers and parents in accordance with the District’s protocols, provided an accurate profile of Student’s needs and were proper to assist the IEP team in recommending levels of services. Ms. Cerdenio disagreed with the Petitioner regarding alleged deficits in Student’s pencil grip. Instead, Ms. Cerdenio stated that Student’s grip was normal for her age and it was both appropriate and functional. Furthermore, Ms. Cerdenio testified that Student could negotiate around obstacles and walk across uneven surfaces without falling. Ms. Cerdenio concluded that the recommended level of OT service with the collaborative team working with Student at Colfax would provide occupational therapy throughout the day. The District asserted that the hour per month or 720 minutes per year of OT coupled with the collaborative team would have met Student’s motor skill needs.

The District determined that Student’s gross motor skills were not as severe as Petitioners claim. Rather, Ms. Cerdenio characterized Student as awkward but not warranting gross motor OT services. In particular, the District found Student presented adequate postural stability, adequate motor planning abilities and a functional tripod pencil grip. Instead, the District concluded that Student’s OT needs would be met with a sensory diet aiding her to sit still when encountering unexpected touching or distractions.

In contrast, Petitioner counters that Student required more occupational therapy to address both fine and gross motor skills than proposed by the District. Dr. Griesbach testified that Student had significant problems with her motor skills. Specifically, she testified that Student had poor proprioception. Dr. Griesbach noted that Student moved impulsively, tripped over things and often stumbled or fell. Dr. Griesbach testified that from her observations that unless Student received clinical OT, she would suffer regression in her motor skills. Dr. Griesbach explained that in recent observations of Student, she found Student’s pencil grip had improved due to the current higher level of OT services. Dr. Griesbach stated that Student had an abnormal pencil grasp, with a fisted right hand with thumb overlapping, also called a “quadrapod” grip. Further, Student continues to struggle with balance and body awareness. Her findings regarding Student’s poor body awareness and stumbling and falling and need for proprioceptive input was also supported by observations of Student’s parents and Ms. Troy. Both parents also testified that Student would often bump into objects and would have trouble navigating around obstacles.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not accurately determine Student’s OT needs. First, Ms. Cerdenio testified that Student could not complete the SIPT. According to the District’s report, Student could not attain a score in 6 of the 17 areas covered in the SIPT due to Student’s behavior issues. Of the remaining 11 categories with scores, Student was below average in 4 areas. Although the SIPT alone is not conclusive in determining needs or levels of recommended services, the fact remains that Student was below average or unable to complete 10 of 17 categories related to OT. Moreover, Ms. Cerdenio testified that where a SIPT cannot be completed, the assessment’s validity overall is questionable. (footnote 10) In the area of somatosensory that includes the sensation of touch (tactile perception) and the awareness of body position (proprioception), Student was unable to complete 5 of 6 categories. (Pet. Exh. 39.) In light of Student’s history of difficulties in this area, it was incumbent on the District to fully explore this area prior to determining her needs and recommending the appropriate level of services to address them. The reliance on the incomplete SIPT test in this important area cannot be overlooked for purposes of determining Student’s needs and appropriate level of services.

Second, the District’s SP assessment scored Student within the below average range on the Standing and Walking Balance test. These scores relate to processing of the vestibular, proprioceptive, and visual system. During the course of the testing, the District reported that Student would often “laugh and fall to the floor” during the testing, which may have impacted her ability to maintain a balanced position for increased periods of time. Again, the District was aware of the concerns of Dr. Griesbach, Student’s parents and her classroom teacher, all who indicated Student’s awkward movements and tripping over obstacles, yet the District failed to properly determine Student’s level of performance and need. Instead, the District proposed only a sensory diet to meet Student’s responses to unexpected touching or distractions.

The Hearing Officer finds the evidence presented by Dr. Griesbach and Student’s parents more persuasive than Ms. Cerdenio’s. Given Dr. Griesbach’s educational emphasis in pediatric development, her professional training, and continual experience with Student since age two, Dr. Griesbach’s testimony was given greater weight in establishing Student’s proprioception deficits. The District’s inability to fully determine the type and extent of Student’s occupational therapy deficiencies resulted in its failure to establish Student’s unique needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence shows that Student had gross motor skills needs in addition to the District’s determination of abnormal behavior due to class disruptions and unexpected touching. Student also had needs in gross motor skills with navigating around obstacles and maintaining her balance. Therefore, Student required the proper level of OT services to meet these needs.

The District’s April 11, 2002 IEP Offer

The Hearing Officer now turns to the offer proposed by the District at the April 11, 2002 IEP meeting and whether it met Student’s needs. The IEP set forth sixteen goals and recommended for Student a placement in a typical general education half-day kindergarten class at her local elementary school with related services. The services enumerated one hour per week of school-based speech and language in four 15-minute increments, 60 minutes per month or 720 minutes per year of occupational therapy, in-school behavior intervention of 10 to 15 hours per week during specified periods of the school year, 8 hours per month of out-of-school behavior intervention, and an in-class Temporary Support Assistant (TSA) and inclusion facilitator.

Petitioner contends that the District’s offer was not designed to meet Student’s unique academic, social and behavioral needs because the whole-group structure, unqualified staff and half-day class would not allow Student an opportunity to learn academically and develop her social skills. Petitioner contends that the appropriate class would be a full-day general education kindergarten in small-group setting with personnel trained and experienced in working with autistic children.

Within the proposed half-day program, Petitioner claims that the Open Court methodology emphasizes whole-group instruction, an environment too overwhelming for Student. (footnote 11) Moreover, Petitioner asserts that the District’s instruction entails lessons extending beyond 30 minutes, Student’s capacity to engage in an activity. Dr. Mastergeorge (footnote 12) testified that Open Court is based on an auditory environment that is inconsistent with Student’s behavioral issues and Student would find herself easily agitated and unable to tolerate the teaching system. (footnote 13) Student’s parents and Student’s educational and behavioral consultant, Shannon Troy, each testified as to visiting kindergarten classes at Colfax and described observations of Open Court whole-group instruction. (footnote 13) Petitioner’s witnesses agreed that whole group instruction would not meet Student’s needs due to her behavioral issues.

The District countered that the Open Court and whole-group instruction could have been adapted to meet Student’s unique needs. (footnote 15) Colfax Elementary Resource Specialist Carol Steiber testified that the Open Court method could have been modified for shorter time periods and smaller groups to accommodate Student’s behavioral concerns. Although a large-group setting with lessons beyond 30 minutes would have been inappropriate for Student, the District did offer substantial evidence that accommodations could have been made to meet Student’s needs. Ms. Steiber testified that Open Court could be modified to accommodate small group settings. Student could have been exposed to the same curriculum with the assistance of an aide in a small group. Given the accommodations that could have been provided to assist Student, the District’s utilization of the Open Court instruction could have been consistent with Student’s educational and behavioral needs.

Petitioner also raised concerns that the inclusion facilitator would not be appropriate to meet Student’s behavioral needs. Petitioner claims that Ms. Steiber, the inclusion facilitator, (footnote 16) would not provide an adequate amount of services to Student. Specifically, given Ms. Steiber’s caseload of special needs children, she would not be able to provide individualized services to Student. Currently, Ms. Steiber has more than 40 hours per week of service she is to provide to various special needs children at Colfax. However, Ms. Steiber testified that her services are not required to be individual to be effective, rather Student could receive some of her services in a small-group with other students. Because it is undisputed that Student is able to learn in small-group settings, the District has provided persuasive evidence that Ms. Steiber could have provided the required proper level of service to meet Student’s needs.

Next, Student claims that the TSA’s role and qualifications would not appropriately meet her needs in the classroom. Father testified that the District proposed to assign to Student an unspecified high school graduate with on-the-job training as Student’s TSA. Petitioner asserts this proposal would have hardly met Student’s need for a trained, behavioral specialist. At the time of the IEP, Petitioner sought to have Student’s then therapeutic companion, Vivian Deckard, to continue as Student’s one-on-one aide. (Pet. Exhs. 35, 40, 42 and 43.) It was asserted that only an aide with Ms. Deckard’s education and experience would be appropriate for Student. (footnote 17) Further, Petitioner claimed that Student required the aide to herself alone, whereas the District would not necessarily assign a TSA to Student solely.

The District countered that the TSA would have been trained and prepared to attend to Student’s needs at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Steiber testified that she would have convened a meeting with the TSA, classroom teacher, related services providers, parents and herself prior to the school year to discuss the timing and structure of the program to meet Student’s needs. Nonetheless, the TSA would have been a person trained to provide adequate assistance to Student. Although a specified person had yet to be determined to be Student’s TSA, Ms. Steiber testified that the District would have placed a properly trained individual at the beginning of the school year. (footnote 18) District witnesses also testified that it would be improper to have a TSA assigned solely to Student. Ms. Grayson-DeJong testified that this relationship would have created a stigma for Student with her classmates and exacerbated her difficulties with isolation. (footnote 19) In addition, the District contended that Student did not need to have the same therapeutic companion. Instead, all children must learn to transition with relationships, including aides.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed use of a TSA to assist Student was proper to meet her needs. District witnesses credibly testified that Student would have been provided with an adequate aide. Petitioner’s assertion that an unspecified high school graduate would have been assigned is disingenuous given the qualifications and training that the TSA would have to meet prior to working with Student. Because Student does have issues with isolation, the use of a TSA solely for Student would be detrimental to her needs. Petitioner’s witnesses testified that Student needed to increase her social interactions with typical peers. Given this need, the District’s proposal to have a TSA facilitate this interaction was proper. Lastly, Mother conceded that Student transitioned to a new aide upon commencing kindergarten. Although the transition was “bumpier” and took more time than previous transitions, Student adjusted well at TCS with the new aide. In light of the fact that Student did not have the same aide in kindergarten and nonetheless adjusted well, the District was not obligated to provide Student with her previous therapeutic aide. (footnote 20)

Petitioner also contends that Student required a full-day kindergarten class. Dr. Ann Mastergeorge testified that for Student to make progress and make grade level standards, repetition is necessary. Dr. Mastergeorge stated that a full-day class with a one-on-one behavioral aide was required for Student, at minimum. The full-day class would have allowed Student enough time to process information and generalize interactions. Moreover, Dr. Mastergeorge explained that Student could not meet all the objectives and goals set forth in the April 11, 2001 IEP if she were to attend only a half-day class. She concluded that the objectives and goals could be met in only a full-day class setting.

Dr. Audrey Griesbach testified that Student would have been vulnerable to regression had she attended a half-day class. (footnote 21) Dr. Griesbach testified that prior to the April 2002 IEP meeting, Student was progressing with social interactions with the help of an assistant. Student had made substantial progress and had the capacity to do well in the future in expanding her social interaction and language skills. However, Student was vulnerable to regression and required high levels of support. Without additional time, regression would have occurred further setting Student back and adding to her existing problems. At that time, Student had not generalized sufficiently to maintain social interactions. (footnote 22) Student required additional opportunities to converse and interact with her peers to incorporate the interactions. These interactions would have been reinforced had Student been afforded more class time with her peers. Dr. Griesbach noted that an additional two and a half hours per day of instruction above the half-day amount would have been necessary to provide language enrichment, academic learning and social connection with other children. At the time, Student made progress while attending Smart Start and the Neighborhood School simultaneously with related services, demonstrating that full-day instruction was necessary. Dr. Griesbach concluded that a full-day class was required for Student to meet her learning needs.

The District countered, asserting that the half-day class was of sufficient duration to meet Student’s needs. District autism specialist Pat Grayson-DeJong, in addressing the need for a full-day class, stated, “more [classroom time] is not necessarily better for autistic children.” Instead, autistic children may not need constant instruction to make educational progress. For instance, all of the District’s general education kindergarten classrooms are half-day programs and many include high functioning autistic children such as Student. These classrooms are able to meet the needs of autistic children.

Debbie Jacobowitz, District psychologist, concurred that the half-day general education kindergarten class would have met Student’s needs. She testified that Student would have been successful in the half-day kindergarten class through accommodations to participate in grade-level activities and, ultimately, meeting the goals indicated in the IEP. Specifically, as a whole, the half-day class together with a TSA, inclusion facilitator and related services, would have met Student’s academic and social needs. (footnote 23)

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s evidence less persuasive. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of witnesses Pat Grayson-DeJong, Debbie Jacobowitz and Carol Steiber does not establish sufficient knowledge of Student’s unique needs to overcome the evidence of Student’s need for a full-day class. Not one of these witnesses could cite assessment data, valid observational data, or provide any other evidence to support their position. Ms. Grayson-DeJong admitted never meeting, assessing or otherwise observing Student. Ms. Grayson-DeJong has extensive experience working with autistic children. However, she could only testify generally regarding how autistic children performed in half-day classes. Although Ms. Grayson-DeJong had reviewed records regarding Student, she admitted having no personal knowledge regarding Student.

Likewise, the District’s other witnesses failed to provide persuasive evidence regarding the appropriateness of half-day instruction. Ms. Jacobowitz had limited experience with Student and testified as to never assessing her prior to the April 2002 IEP. Ms. Jacobowitz did not recall her observations of Student in her classroom setting prior to the IEP meeting. Nor did she observe Student during any sessions of her related services. Similarly, Ms. Steiber admitted never working directly with Student. Prior to the IEP, she did not review Student’s records and performed no assessments. In her observations of Student at the Neighborhood School prior to the April 2002 IEP, Ms. Steiber did not observe Student individually. Ms. Steiber last assessed Student at age three, at Smart Start. Nonetheless, Ms. Steiber declared that a half-day classroom would be appropriate for Student’s needs. However, the Hearing Officer finds the weight of Ms. Steiber’s testimony wanting due to the nearly exclusive use of leading questions during direct examination by the District’s counsel.

The Hearing Officer finds that the April 11, 2002 IEP was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs because it failed to provide for a full-day kindergarten class. First, the weight of the evidence from witnesses who worked with Student persuasively established that she has benefited from and requires a full-day of classroom instruction. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Griesbach’s testimony particularly persuasive due to her extensive work with Student since age two. In her opinion, Student was on the verge of incorporating and retaining both academic and social skills prior to starting kindergarten. At this juncture, it was necessary to provide Student additional time to generalize and retain new academic materials. Moreover, Dr. Griesbach’s testimony established that Student required more time to interact with typically developing children both inside and outside of the classroom to continue progress with social interaction. Without this opportunity, Student could not grow in her language skills. The Hearing Officer finds that a full-day kindergarten class was necessary to meet Student’s unique social skills needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the half-day program was not designed to meet the important unique academic needs to allow Student to generalize and process information. In addition, the District failed to show how a half-day program would permit Student adequate time to develop social skills with typically developing peers. In summary, the District failed to show that a half-day program was designed to meet Student’s unique academic, social, and behavior needs.

The Hearing Officer must now determine whether the type and levels of related services offered by the District were designed to meet Student’s needs. Ms. Ronen asserted that the proposed one hour of speech and language services was proper based on the assessment she conducted coupled with the observations and discussions with Ms. Erin Green, District speech therapist and the IEP team. Ms. Ronen originally determined that Student’s scores fell within normal ranges for speech and language and she did not qualify for services. (footnote 24) In addition, Ms. Green also testified that the level of service was adequate. Ms. Green stated that the school-based services in conjunction with Student’s placement in a typical kindergarten class were designed to meet Student’s language needs.

As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s speech and language needs were not identified accurately by the District’s proposed program. Instead, Dr. Mastergeorge persuasively testified that Student had receptive, expressive, and pragmatic language needs beyond those determined by the District. In addition, the Hearing Officer determined that assessments administered by the District did not fully discovery Student’s areas of difficulty with speech and language. As such, the type and level of speech and language services offered did not account for all of Student’s needs in that area.

Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds that the level of proposed speech and language services were inadequate because Student was unable to achieve the goals and objectives from her December 2001 IEP where the District gave her a greater level of service. At the December 2001 IEP meeting, Student was given five speech and language goals each with two objectives to be reached by December 2002. The December 2001 IEP provided for two hours per week of services to meet these goals and objectives. At the time of the April 2002 IEP meeting, none of the goals had been achieved and only four of the ten objectives had been met. Nonetheless, the District expected Student to meet 4 new goals with eight objectives by the following year with only one hour per week of services. Such expectations cannot be seen as reasonable with the reduction of services where the initial goals and objective had yet to be met. This coupled with the District’s failure to determine accurately Student’s speech and language needs, leads the Hearing Officer to find that the District’s program failed to provide adequate services to meet Student’s unique speech and language needs.

The Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s offer for OT services did not properly determine the needs of Student in this area. As a result, the District did not provide the proper types and levels of services required to address Student’s unique needs. As discussed above, the District’s assessment of Student’s OT needs failed to accurately identify her issues with proprioception. Specifically, the District did not fully explore her difficulties with navigating around obstacles and maintaining her balance. Instead, the District only offered her a sensory diet designed only to address Student’s problems with abnormal reactions with unexpected touching and classroom disruptions and tactile input. The sensory diet did not address the other gross motor concerns relating to proprioception. The District failed to identify these OT needs and correspondingly offered only a sensory diet that did not address them. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer OT services designed to meet Student’s OT needs.

In summary, the Hearing Officer determines that the District’s offer of placement for Student made at the April 11, 2002 IEP meeting was not designed to meet Student’s most pressing needs. Specifically, the evidence established that a half-day class would have been inappropriate; instead a full-day kindergarten class was required. Although, the structure of the classroom may have included qualified teaching and support staff and modified to accommodate Student’s behavioral needs, the half-day setting would still not be adequate to meet Student’s needs. Furthermore, the District’s offer did not meet Student’s speech and language and occupational therapy needs. As indicated above, the District did not properly identify Student’s needs in speech and language and occupational therapy nor recommend a proper level of service to meet these needs. Thus, the April 11, 2002 IEP was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Student Educational Benefit

For the reasons expressed above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s April 11, 2002 IEP offer of placement and services is not designed to meet Student’s most critical needs. Because the District’s offer is not designed to meet Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer now finds that the placement is not reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit.

*** The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Although the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed methodology of small-group lessons with no more than 30 minute sessions supported by qualified staff, the lack of a full-day kindergarten did not meet Student’s needs for repetition, generalization and social interactions. Further, the District did not properly identify Student’s speech and language and occupational therapy needs nor provide an adequate level of services to meet those needs. Thus, the District failed to provide Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.

II. Are Student’s Parent Entitled to Reimbursement?

Placement for the 2002-2003 school year at The Country School

When a school district denies a FAPE to a child, that child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. V. State Bd. Of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents’ placement still must meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement addresses the child’s needs and provides him educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993). Reimbursement may be awarded even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Id. at 14.

Petitioner contends that Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her attendance at The Country School for the 2002-2003 school year. It was concluded in Issue No. 1 that the District failed to offer Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Given the denial FAPE, the parents must prove that their placement at TCS was appropriate.

As discussed above, Mr. Singer testified regarding Student’s attendance at TCS. Mr. Singer is the Head of School at TCS. He has met and observed Student throughout the kindergarten school year and discussed her progress with her classroom teachers and parents. The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Singer a credible witness who is knowledgeable about Student’s kindergarten class and the progress she made during the last year.

Mr. Singer testified that Student attended a full day kindergarten class with a total of 27 students. The class included two teachers and one aide bringing the teacher to student ratio to roughly 1:9. (footnote 25) The class uses “center group activities” which are small groups of children working with a teacher on a lesson. Mr. Singer testified that Student is able to stay focused and engaged in this learning environment. He has observed an increase in her affect and ability to respond to non-verbal cues. Further, her communication skills have improved in communicating with teachers and connecting with peers. Student now plays more with others rather than spending time isolated. Moreover, Student was able to meet the kindergarten academic standards and will be progressing to the first grade in the fall.

Mr. Singer’s testimony was supported by the testimony of Dr. Mastergeorge and Father. Dr. Mastergeorge testified that Student’s learning at TCS was augmented by the classroom’s use of visual reinforcement. Dr. Mastergeorge’s observations of Student at TCS indicated Student’s increased social skills as exemplified by her “asking of lots of questions.” This reflects Student’s comfort in the setting and encourages her motivation to interact and learn. Father added that, academically, Student can read, add and subtract. Further, he noted that Student has an increased awareness of the world and is better able to interact with her brother.

In light of the credible testimony of Mr. Singer, Dr. Mastergeorge and Father and no evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement at TCS met Student’s unique needs and she received educational benefit from the TCS kindergarten program. Therefore, an award of reimbursement is appropriate. Next, the Hearing Officer must determine how much reimbursement is appropriate.

Mother testified that the tuition, related school costs and installment plan fees were all necessary in order for Student to attend TCS. This evidence was supported by Mr. Singer’s testimony regarding the allocation of costs for the kindergarten program. Mr. Singer testified that in addition to tuition, TCS requires payment for a building fund and new parent’s fee. The Hearing Officer finds that these costs were required to attend TCS. Further, Student’s parents paid the costs through an installment plan incurring finance charges because they were unable to pay the entire school year costs at the beginning of the school year. The parents should not be penalized for their inability topay all costs at the forefront; as such, reimbursement of the finance charge was necessary. This was supported by the uncontroverted testimony of Mr. Singer and Student’s parents based on invoices provided at hearing. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs she incurred to attend TCS during the 2002-2003 school year in the amount of $16,354.00.

Educational and Behavioral Services Provided by Shannon Troy

Petitioner also contends that her parents are entitled to partial reimbursement for the educational and behavioral consulting program and related supervisory services they procured from Shannon Troy during the kindergarten school year. Petitioner seeks only partial reimbursement that constitutes the amount directly attributable to work done in relation to Student’s educational program. In sum, Petitioner’s parents seek a total amount of $2,580.50.

Ms. Troy testified that she has been a behavioral consultant in private practice for 3 years. She also worked for 2 years at a public agency, H.E.L.P., as a coordinator, working with special needs children with a variety of disabilities. Ms. Troy holds a B.A. degree from UCLA in psychology and is currently working towards her Ph.D. in special education. Ms. Troy’s consulting includes work with special needs children for pre-kindergarten readiness.

With respect to Student, Ms. Troy testified that Student’s behavior issues required her to be exposed to new academic subjects and materials prior to actual classroom instruction. Ms. Troy’s services were not intended to assist Student with retention, rather to help Student acclimate to the new materials to prevent behavioral tolerance breakdowns during non-preferred activities. During the kindergarten year, Ms. Troy assisted Student with letter identification, phonemic awareness, tolerance with using a pencil and paper, sitting still in her chair and asking for help appropriately. Since January 2003, Ms. Troy has provided 1 hour per week of educational services with Student in her office, 3 hours per week of school support including observation and working with Student’s teacher and aide, and 2 hours a week of family behavioral services. (footnote 26) Ms. Troy further testified that the services are educational supports with a behavioral component required for Student to learn and progress.

The Hearing Officer finds that these services were also appropriate and were reasonably calculated to meet Student’s school readiness and behavioral needs. Further, it is also undisputed that Ms. Troy’s work provided educational benefit to Student. Ms. Troy and Student’s parents testified that Student had shown improvement in her behavioral deficits and social skills. These improvements can be attributed to the work of Ms. Troy as reflected by Student’s improved proprioception, receptive and expressive language skills and overall tolerance with disruptions and ability to stay on task. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents are entitled for partial reimbursement for the services of Ms. Troy in the amount of $2,580.50.

In summary, Petitioner’s parents have shown that Student’s placement at TCS and the services provided by Ms. Troy met Student’s unique needs and provided educational benefit under the requirements of Burlington. Petitioner’s parents are therefore entitled to reimbursement for these costs.

III. Is Student Entitled to Prospective Placement for the 2003-2004 School Year at The Country School?

Cal. Educ. Code section 56505.2 prohibits the Hearing Officer from awarding prospective placement at a noncertified private school. Student seeks prospective placement at TCS’s first grade class for the 2003-2004 school year. However, TCS’s Head of School, Mr. Singer, testified that TCS is not certified under California law. Thus, the Hearing Officer cannot award prospective placement for Student for the 2003-2004 school year at TCS and her request is denied.

ORDER

1. Within 30 days of receipt of proof of payment from Student’s parents, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the costs associating with attending The Country School for the 2002-2003 school year in the amount of $16,354.00.

2. Within 30 days of receipt of proof of payment from Student’s parents, the District shall reimburse Student’s parents for the cost of Shannon Troy’s educational and behavioral services during the 2002-2003 school year, in the amount of $2,580.50.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue 1: For the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to offer Student an appropriate placement designed to meet her unique needs at her April 11, 2002 IEP? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2: Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following:

a. The costs of Student’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year at The Country School; and b. The costs of educational and behavioral services provided by Shannon Troy.

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: Is Student entitled to prospective placement at The Country School, a noncertified public school, for the 2003-2004 school year? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505 (i).

DATED: September 5, 2003 ____________________________________ My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues presented in this action were reorganized by the Hearing Officer to reflect the changes made by Petitioner seeking withdrawal and modification of some issues. Further, Petitioner for the first time raised alleged procedural violations in her closing brief. Because these issues were not raised prior to or during the hearing, they are deemed improper and will not be addressed.

2. Because these services were provided by the North Los Angeles Regional Center under a stay put agreement, at no expense to Petitioner, she seeks only a finding in her favor that the April 2002 IEP’s proposed levels of services were inappropriate.

3. Floor Time is a one-to-one systematic developmental approach of working with a child to help her climb the developmental ladder. The developmental milestones the child must achieve during Floor Time therapy are, in sequence, developing shared attention, engaging in relationships, engaging in two-way purposeful communication (a “circle of communication”), increasing the number of circles of communication, creating mental representations (i.e., emotional symbols, ability to pretend play), and creating bridges between internal representations or complex ideas (making connections between different representations).

4. Because Petitioner disagreed with the April 11, 2002 IEP placement and Student was unilaterally placed at a private school, the District did not have an opportunity to place Student according to the IEP. Accordingly, the District could not attempt to comport its program with the IEP; thus this element need not be determined. Likewise, there is no dispute as to whether Student would be educated in the least restrictive environment as additionally required by the IDEA. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

Similarly, this component did not require determination by the Hearing Officer.

5. Due to Student’s behavioral issues, the testing on Day One was difficult requiring Ms. Ronen to try again on two separate dates.

6. Ms. Ronen administered the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test-R and Student received a score of 99, falling within the average range for Student’s age. Student received a score of 92, a score within the average range, in the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test. In the Preschool Language Scale 3, Student received a total score of 83, indicating expressive communication was weaker than auditory comprehension. This score fell in the low average range. Further, Student could not complete the Language Processing test and no score was received for that exam.

7. Student also received a speech and language assessment from Student’s therapist Anita Boxer, M.A. (Pet. Exh. 35.) Ms. Boxer has been Student’s speech therapist since Student began attending Smart Start. Ms. Boxer determined that Student’s Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary and Semantics score fell within normal ranges. Ms. Boxer also gave the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Preschool (CELF-P) test. The CELF-P indicated that Student’s receptive language scores ranged from normal to below two standard deviations. Further, her expressive language scores ranged from normal to below one and a half standard deviations. Ms. Boxer concluded that the results showed significant auditory comprehension and memory deficits requiring continuing intervention. Ms. Boxer conducted the Test of Auditory Processing & Memory that showed severe to moderately impaired auditory memory and processing skills. Overall, Student showed improvement but overall skill delays of one and a half years. Ms. Boxer recommended 2 hours per week of speech and language therapy.

8. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s administration of the Preschool Language Scale 3 exam was not properly administered and thus of little evidentiary value to determine Student’s speech and language needs. Ms. Ronen admitted using nonstandard methods in questioning and scoring of Student. In order to report a score within the average range, Ms. Ronen applied a “confidence interval” that resulted in a score higher enough to fall within the average range for expressive communication. The confidence interval is a factor that can be used in scoring a test to take into account the perception of the examiner on how the student is performing during the test. This confidence interval was not used in any other portion of the test and the District failed to provide any explanation for its arbitrary use.

9. Ms. Alusi was not presented as a witness during the hearing.

10. Further, Ms. Cerdenio declined to respond to questions regarding the SIPT stating that she was unqualified to give opinions relating to the exam’s results.

11. It is uncontroverted that Student would be placed in a kindergarten class that utilizes the “Open Court” teaching system of reading. Open Court uses whole-group instruction consisting of one teacher and the entire class involved in one reading activity.

12. Dr. Mastergeorge holds a Ph.D. in speech pathology. She is a researcher at UC Davis’ Medical Investigation of Neurological Disorders Institute studying human development and particularly how children learn. Her emphasis includes children from birth to five years old with high functioning autism.

13. Had Student attended kindergarten at Colfax Elementary, she would most likely have been placed in either Ms. Louis or Ms. Walker’s classroom. The parties agree that the third Colfax kindergarten class is primarily Spanish speaking and Student would not have been placed in this classroom.

14. Father testified as to visiting all the Colfax kindergarten classrooms. He observed both Ms. Louis’s and Ms. Walker’s classes were engaged in whole-group activities.

15. Ms. Steiber described Open Court as a comprehensive, multidimensional reading program that involves multimodal presentations, including both visual and auditory materials and a mixture of whole-group, small-group, and self-directed instruction.

16. During the course of the 2002-03 school year, Ms. Steiber was given the title of resource specialist but retained her inclusion facilitator responsibilities.

17. Ms. Deckard had at least a B.A. degree at the time she served as Student’s therapeutic companion prior to the April 11, 2002 IEP.

18. Ms. Steiber testified that TSA receive both district-wide and individual training to meet the needs of their assignments.

19. Ms. Grayson-DeJong has an adult child with autism and has been working with autistic children for over 30 years.

20. Laura Parmalee served as Student’s therapeutic companion rather than Vivian Deckard during Student’s kindergarten school year.

21. Dr. Griesbach has been Student’s developmental pediatrician since age two.

22. Ms. Shannon Troy also indicated that Student required a full-day class to give Student examples of typical children as models and develop her expressive and receptive language skills.

23. District inclusion facilitator Carol Steiber also testified that the half-day program would have been sufficient to meet Student’s needs.

24. Nonetheless, the District offered to provide Student one hour per week of services. Subsequently, at hearing, Ms. Ronen indicated that the denial of eligibility was an error and Student should have been eligible for such services.

25. In addition, a therapeutic companion provided by the Center accompanied Student throughout the school day.

26. These services were in addition to the services already being provided since December 2000.