California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 23, 2002
Student v. Anaheim City School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 833-01 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy
Anaheim City School District must provide 100 hours of compensatory speech-language therapy; Savanna Elementary found to have provided FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A student now eligible for special education under speech and language impairment filed for due process. He sued Anaheim City School District over four school years (1997–2001) and Savanna Elementary School District over fall 2001. He argued that both districts failed to address his language and behavior needs. The Orange County Health Care Agency was dismissed at the start of the hearing.
The Hearing Officer found that Anaheim provided a FAPE in first grade. That year, detailed language and behavior goals followed school psychologist Steve Wayne's assessment. From 1998–99 on, however, Anaheim's IEPs mostly ignored the student's known expressive and receptive language deficits. In 1999–2000, speech-language pathologist Loranna Hightower's assessment showed significant deficits, yet the IEP offered only a monthly 30-minute consultation, with no proof it was delivered. In 2000–01, the IEP's "language" goals addressed only behavior. The Hearing Officer rejected Anaheim's argument that good grades proved FAPE. Anaheim handled behavior appropriately until 2000–01. That year, the team noted serious regression at Rossier School, a nonpublic school, but changed nothing.
Savanna acted promptly. It agreed to an interim placement, started behavior assessments, proposed appropriate language goals and looked for a nonpublic school before the family moved away.
The Hearing Officer denied the request for Lindamood-Bell services because no evidence supported it. Instead, Anaheim must provide 100 hours of compensatory language therapy plus transportation. No compensatory behavior services were ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated academic progress as only one part of FAPE under Rowley. An IEP also had to address identified needs and be carried out. Grades did not excuse years of unaddressed language deficits. The decision also shows compensatory education based on current needs and testimony, not an hour-for-hour award.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year? (language and behavior needs)
The 1997 assessment identified the student's language and behavior needs, and the IEP's detailed goals, special day class and resource services addressed them, so Anaheim provided a FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 2. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year? (language and behavior needs)
The IEP offered only one listening goal and no expressive language goals for previously identified deficits, which denied FAPE; behavior needs were addressed appropriately, including a behavior support plan when behavior worsened.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year? (language and behavior needs)
Despite significant language deficits, the IEP offered only a monthly 30-minute speech consult with no evidence it was delivered and goals had no objectives, which denied FAPE; the FAA, BIP and nonpublic school placement met behavior needs.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 4. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year? (language and behavior needs)
The IEP's language section addressed only behavior and provided no language services, and the team changed nothing in the behavior program after documenting significant regression, so Anaheim denied FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5. Did Savanna fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE between September and November 2001?
Savanna agreed an interim placement, promptly started behavior assessments, proposed appropriate language goals and services, and searched for a nonpublic school before the family moved, so it did not deny FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If either Anaheim or Savanna failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE, what if any compensatory education services should STUDENT receive?
Student's request for Lindamood-Bell services was denied for lack of supporting evidence, but Anaheim was ordered to provide 100 hours of compensatory language therapy; compensatory behavior services were denied.
- Not reachedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 7. If Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, does the statute of limitations bar STUDENT from receiving a remedy for denial of FAPE that occurred prior to April 25, 1998?
The issue was not reached because Anaheim was found to have provided a FAPE in 1997-1998.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. Within 30 calendar days of the order, Anaheim must provide two 30-minute sessions per week of language services from a credentialed speech and language therapist over 100 school weeks, for a total of 100 hours. These sessions are in addition to any speech-language therapy and educational program in the student's present and future placements, and may not be scheduled so that he misses any part of his regular program.
- Anaheim must provide any additional transportation the student needs to receive the compensatory language services.
Total: 100 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Todd v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696 (1996) 951 F.Supp. 867; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3040(c); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56325 (cited as 'Section 5325'); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Sherry Blakely, director of special education, Anaheim City School District
- Dr. Joan Roberts, Ph.D., director of special education; witness (speech pathology background), Savanna Elementary School District
- Manuel Robles, agency official present at hearing, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Steve Wayne, school psychologist (1997 assessment), Anaheim City School District
- Toni Brown, school psychologist (1999 assessment), Anaheim City School District
- David Bastin, school psychologist (1999 psychoeducational assessment), Anaheim City School District
- Loranna Hightower, speech-language pathologist (1999 assessment), Anaheim City School District
- Sandy Agajanian-Renner, second-grade special day class teacher, Jefferson II Elementary School, Anaheim City School District
- Brenda Bryant, director, Rossier School (nonpublic school)
- Raelynn Nelson, counselor, Rossier School (nonpublic school)
- Michele Slaffey, special day class teacher, Rossier School (nonpublic school)
- Jan Gortz, speech-language pathologist, independent assessor (July 2001), Independent assessment provided through Anaheim
- Dr. Terry J. Tibbetts, Ph.D., clinical and educational psychologist, independent psychoeducational assessor; witness, Independent
- Elizabeth Sobral, mental health counselor, Orange County Mental Health
- Vista Behavior Consulting, behavior consulting agency asked to conduct FBA/FAA, Private agency
- Kristen Keller-Kolde, speech-language pathologist (June 2002 assessment), Corona-Norco Unified School District
- Michael Nagano, special day class teacher; witness, Corona-Norco Unified School District
- Christopher Russell, educational advocate for Student
- Tania Whiteleather, attorney for Student
- Lauri Lafoe, attorney for Anaheim and Savanna
- Jan Martin, deputy county counsel, Orange County
- Mardan School, nonpublic school considered for placement
- Barbara Dawson School, nonpublic school offered by Savanna
- Lindamood Bell, private provider requested by parent
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on July 24, August 6, 7, 20, and 21, 2002, in Anaheim, California.
STUDENT (hereinafter “Student”) was represented by attorney Tania Whiteleather and educational advocate Christopher Russell. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was his mother. The Anaheim City School District (hereinafter “Anaheim”) was represented by attorney Lauri Lafoe. Anaheim’s director of special education, Sherry Blakely, was present on behalf of Anaheim. The Savanna Elementary School District was also represented by Ms. Lafoe. Dr. Joan Roberts, Ph.D., Savanna’s director of special education, was also present on behalf of Savanna. Orange County Health Care Agency (hereinafter, “Orange County” or “Health Care Agency”) was represented by deputy county counsel, Jan Martin. Manuel Robles, an official from Orange County Health Care Agency, was also present on its behalf.
The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. On October 10, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the parties and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the outset of the hearing, Respondent Orange County Health Care Agency made a motion to be dismissed from the hearing. The Hearing Officer took the motion under submission. Thereafter, Petitioner voluntarily dismissed Orange County from the case.
ISSUES:
1. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year?
2. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
3. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
4. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
5. Did Savanna fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE between September and November 2001?
6. If either Anaheim or Savanna failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE, what if any compensatory education services should STUDENT receive?
7. If Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, does the statute of limitations bar STUDENT from receiving a remedy for denial of FAPE that occurred prior to April 25, 1998?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], was 11 years and six months old at the time the hearing closed. STUDENT currently lives with his parents and siblings in Riverside County, California. He is presently eligible for special education as a child with a speech and language disability. As of the time the hearing closed, STUDENT had completed the fifth grade and was attending school in the Corona-Norco School District.
The 1997-1998 School Year
STUDENT attended the first grade in the Anaheim City School District during the 1997-1998 school year. On October 7, 1997, STUDENT was evaluated for special education services. The purpose of the assessment was to evaluate STUDENT academic progress and review behavior concerns that had been raised by school personnel. To that end, STUDENT was assessed by Anaheim’s school psychologist, Steve Wayne. As part of the assessment, Mr. Wayne reviewed STUDENT’s educational, family, health, and social-emotional development history and administered various standardized tests.
In his assessment report, Mr. Wayne concluded that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement in the areas of listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics, and mathematics reasoning. Mr. Wayne opined that the discrepancy was due to “attention and auditory processing concerns.” He noted that STUDENT’s needs could not be met in a regular classroom. Mr. Wayne’s report indicated that STUDENT’s needs required that he receive a “modified curriculum with a reduced student teacher ratio to better address [his] auditory processing concerns.”
On October 20, 1997, an IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. The team found STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with a specific learning disability that included attention and auditory processing concerns. The IEP team identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance for eight academic and functional areas and then set goals and objectives relating to each of those areas. The areas included reading, arithmetic, spelling, communication, social adaptation, self-help, psychomotor and perceptual, physical education, and prevocational.
To address STUDENT needs, the IEP team placed him in a first grade special day class at Anaheim’s Revere Elementary School.
1998-1999 School Year
In October 1998, an annual IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. At the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT advanced to the second grade and the team set new goals and objectives for him. At this time, STUDENT’s placement was changed to Anaheim’s Jefferson II Elementary School. In April 1999, the IEP team convened and adopted behavior interventions for STUDENT.
1999-2000 School Year
STUDENT IEP team met in October 1999 to plan his educational program for the 1999-2000 school year. That same fall STUDENT progressed to the third grade. STUDENT’s IEP noted that various assessment test results placed him at beginning third grade level for oral reading, reading comprehension, word recognition, spelling, and math. His IEP goals and objectives called for him to progress to the fourth grade level in each of these academic areas. The team noted on the IEP that STUDENT had strong academic skills, but that his behaviors interfered with his being in a regular education program. In that regard, the IEP team designed additional goals and objectives to address his behavior needs. The team then agreed to place STUDENT in a third grade special day class back at Revere Elementary School.
In October of 1999, Anaheim administered new assessments to STUDENT. The Anaheim assessors, including two school psychologists, Toni Brown and David Bastin, and speech and language specialist Loranna Hightower, noted that STUDENT’s difficulty understanding and using spoken language interfered with his educational progress. Specifically, the assessors noted, STUDENT demonstrated a disorder in language comprehension and expression. The assessors also recorded that STUDENT displayed significant difficulty sustaining attention. They added that “his diagnosed condition of ADHD is felt to affect both his overall language development and emotional responses at school.” The assessors concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education as a student with other health impairments, emotional disturbance, and language disorders.
On November 10, 1999, STUDENT IEP team met again. In light of the new assessment data, the team adjusted STUDENT’s present levels of performance and drafted new goals and objectives for him. Regarding STUDENT’s language and communication needs, the team noted that STUDENT demonstrated deficits in receptive and expressive language. Specifically, the team identified weaknesses in the area of semantics (word meanings), syntax (the order of words in sentences), and morphology (grammatical word structures). The team set corresponding goals and objectives for STUDENT to address his language disorder. As for STUDENT’s behavior needs, the IEP team reviewed the results of a Functional Analysis Assessment (FAA), and a Behavior Intervention Plan was drafted. The team then recommended that STUDENT’s placement be changed to Rossier School, a certified nonpublic school (NPS). The IEP indicated that Rossier would provide STUDENT with a highly structured behavior setting, which he required to meet his needs. The team noted that STUDENT required a more structured behavioral setting to help him succeed academically and to improve his language development. The IEP also called for speech and language services in the form of consultation services to be provided to STUDENT’s classroom teacher once a month for 30 minutes each session. The following week, STUDENT’s mother, STUDENT, signed the IEP document approving the changes.
In March 2000, the IEP team met and updated STUDENT’s Behavior Intervention Plan. In April 2000, the IEP team reconvened and designed STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year.
2000-2001 School Year
In the fall of 2000, STUDENT began the fourth grade. The annual IEP drafted in April of 2000 established new present levels of performance and goals and objectives for STUDENT. The IEP, which was drafted before STUDENT finished the third grade, indicated that STUDENT was functioning in the average range in reading, math, spelling, science and social studies, pre-vocational, and sensory-motor. Regarding language, STUDENT’s IEP noted that he was impulsive, had difficulty controlling his anger, and that he used extremely inappropriate language with staff and peers. The IEP team set goals and objectives that corresponded to STUDENT’s present levels of performance as they were set forth in the IEP. To address STUDENT’s needs, the IEP team returned him to a special day class at the Rossier School. The team also called for him to receive counseling services from both Rossier and Orange County Mental Health.
In September 2000, the IEP team reconvened and updated STUDENT’s Behavior Intervention Plan. On January 12, 2001, the director of Rossier Elementary School, Brenda Bryant, sent a letter to Anaheim requesting that STUDENT’s placement be changed. Ms. Bryant cited concerns relating to STUDENT and STUDENT’s mother’s conduct. An IEP meeting was held on January 16, 2001, to discuss Ms. Bryant’s concerns. At the meeting the IEP team discussed their disagreements regarding the nature and source of the problems, and the team members discussed alternative placements. The IEP team met again on February 6, 2001, to discuss STUDENT’s behavior and intervention strategies. On April 13, 2001, the IEP team again modified and updated STUDENT’s behavior plan.
On April 25, 2001, STUDENT filed for a due process hearing. On April 28, 2001, STUDENT’s mother removed STUDENT from the Rossier School, and Anaheim placed him in a home schooling program. In July of 2001, Anaheim provided STUDENT with independent educational assessments.
On July 24 and 26, 2001, STUDENT was given a speech and language assessment by Jan Gortz, a speech and language pathologist. Ms. Gortz administered three standardized speech and language assessments–the Comprehensive Receptive and Expressive Vocabulary test (CREVT), the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF–3), and the Test of Language Development (TOLD–1:3). Ms. Gortz concluded from her speech and language evaluation that STUDENT had significantly delayed skills in both receptive and expressive language.
On July 25, 2002, Dr. Terry J. Tibbetts, Ph.D., a clinical and educational psychologist, administered a battery of psychoeducational tests to STUDENT. The tests included:
The Symbol Imagery Test (SIT)
Matrix Analogies Test (MAT)
Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT)
Roberts Apperception Test for Children (RATC)
Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC)
Gray Oral Reading Test–Third Edition (GORT–3)
Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML)
Woodcock Reading Mastery Test–Revised (WRMT–R): Word Attack Beery-Buktenica Development Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA): Reading Comprehension
Dr. Tibbetts concluded from his psychoeducational evaluation that STUDENT demonstrated a severe attentional disorder, a language disorder, and behavior problems–specifically, oppositional and episodic “erratic” behavior.
2001-2002 School Year
At some point in the summer of 2001, STUDENT moved with his family into the Savanna Elementary School District, which is also located within the City of Anaheim. On September 24, 2001, an IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. The IEP document indicated that the purpose of the meeting was to determine an interim placement for STUDENT. Savanna proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT and offered to place him in a fifth grade special day class at its Cerritos Elementary School. Christopher Russell, STUDENT’s educational advocate, noted on the IEP document that STUDENT’s mother agreed to the “program and placement” on an “interim basis,” but she did not agree with the proposed goals and objectives. Mr. Russell also noted on the document that the plan was a “limited agreement until [the] next IEP.”
On October 1, 2001, an addendum was added to the September 24 IEP. According to the addendum, STUDENT’s mother had been on the campus to observe STUDENT in his placement, and Savanna offered to draft a behavior support plan. At that time, STUDENT’s mother requested a functional analysis assessment. The addendum also indicated that an IEP meeting would be held to prepare speech and language goals and objectives. STUDENT’s mother expressed concerns regarding STUDENT’s placement, and she indicated that she was interested in placing STUDENT at Lindamood Bell. The addendum noted that Savanna would present nonpublic school options at the next IEP team meeting. On October 1, STUDENT’s mother also signed an assessment plan that called for STUDENT to receive a functional behavior analysis (FBA) and a functional analysis assessment (FAA) to be done by the school psychologist and Vista Behavior Consulting. Additionally, on October 1, STUDENT’s mother signed a release allowing STUDENT’s mental health counselor, Ms. Elizabeth Sobral from Orange County Mental Health, and Savanna to release information to each other. On October 4, 2001, Savanna faxed a letter to Vista Behavior Consulting requesting that it conduct an FBA and FAA.
On October 9, 2001, the IEP team met again to discuss STUDENT’s program and new behavior problems. At this meeting, Savanna also proposed five specific goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of receptive and expressive language. Additionally, the team, including STUDENT’s mother, agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to home-hospital instruction. In that regard, Savanna agreed to contact the home-hospital service providers from Anaheim who had previously furnished STUDENT with that service in the spring and summer of 2001. Savanna also agreed to provide STUDENT with transportation to his mental health counselor, including transportation to six previous sessions that STUDENT had missed. The team discussed nonpublic school programs to address STUDENT’s needs, particularly the Mardan School. Savanna informed the team that it would need to forward Dr. Tibbetts and Ms. Gortz assessments to Mardan to determine if Mardan would be the right placement to meet STUDENT’s needs. The team agreed to reconvene in two weeks.
On October 25, 2001, the IEP team reconvened. At the meeting, Savanna informed STUDENT’s mother that the Mardan School did not have an opening, and the team discussed other nonpublic schools in Orange and Los Angeles counties that Savanna had researched. At the meeting, Savanna offered to place STUDENT at the Barbara Dawson School, a nonpublic school, and to provide speech and language services once the parties agreed to speech and language goals and objectives. The IEP notes state that STUDENT’s advocate, Mr. Russell, agreed that it would be acceptable to finalize the speech and language goals and objectives at a future IEP meeting. Savanna also offered to provide STUDENT with transportation to both school and counseling. STUDENT’s mother requested that STUDENT be placed at Lindamood Bell. The District rejected the proposal, indicating that it did not believe that Lindamood Bell could address STUDENT’s behavioral and academic needs.
Thereafter–the actual date is disputed by the parties–STUDENT moved with his family to Corona in Riverside County. STUDENT received educational services from the Corona-Norco Unified School District from at least February 1, 2002 through the end of the school year. The Corona-Norco District is not a respondent in the present action.
POSITION OF THE PARTIES
STUDENT contends that Anaheim failed to provide him with a FAPE between September 1997 and the summer of 2001 because it failed to appropriately address his language and behavior needs. In addition, STUDENT claims that the Savanna Elementary School District did not provide him with a FAPE between September and November 2001.
Anaheim responds that it provided STUDENT with all of the appropriate programs and services to meet his needs. Anaheim also argues that even if it did not meet STUDENT’s language and behavior needs, it did not deny STUDENT a FAPE because he made academic progress in his education program. Savanna also contends that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE while he was enrolled in its District.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year?
STUDENT contends that Anaheim failed to provide him with a FAPE because it failed to adequately address his language deficits and address his behavior needs.
Under both the federal Individual with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, disability is understood as a natural part of the human experience that in no way diminishes the right of individuals to participate in or contribute to society. Improving educational results for children with disabilities is an essential element of our national policy of ensuring equality of opportunity, full participation, independent living, and economic self-sufficiency for individuals with disabilities. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 (c)(1); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1.) Students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet State educational standards, and that conform with the Student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).) “Special Education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) Additionally, In Board of Education of the Hendrick Huson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley an appropriate educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, (2) conform with his IEP, and (3) provide him with some educational benefit. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et. seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.)
Thus, for the 1997-1998 school year, the Hearing Officer must determine whether Anaheim provided STUDENT with specially designed instruction to meet his unique needs, and whether they provided him an educational program that conformed with his IEP and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. To that end, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain STUDENT’s language and behavioral needs for the 1997-1998 school year.
As noted above, STUDENT was assessed by the Anaheim school psychologist, Mr. Wayne, in October 1997. Mr. Wayne gave STUDENT three assessment tests to evaluate his communication and language needs. The first test, the Receptive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test, assessed STUDENT’s abilities in the area of receptive single word vocabulary. Here, STUDENT demonstrated low average ability. Mr. Wayne also noted that STUDENT needed frequent reminders to listen and look at the pictures before pointing to an answer. The next assessment, the Structured Photographic Expressive Language Test, measured expressive formulation of critical syntactical structures within a controlled language sample. On this standardized test, STUDENT scored in the sixth percentile. Mr. Wayne recorded in his report that STUDENT’s performance indicated below average ability in using correct grammar to describe photographs. Mr. Wayne noted specific difficulties with various structures, including the preposition “on,” plural nouns ending in “ez,” irregular past tense verbs, infinitive complements, and conjoining sentences with “and.” On the Test of Language Development–Primary, which measures receptive and expressive competencies in the major components of language–phonology, morphology, semantics, and syntax–STUDENT performed in the average range in oral vocabulary, grammatical understanding, word discrimination, and word articulation. However, STUDENT performed below average in picture vocabulary, sentence imitation, and grammatic completion. Mr. Wayne also reported that STUDENT demonstrated inappropriate pragmatic skills throughout the testing sessions. Mr. Wayne observed that STUDENT did not use appropriate greetings when he came and left the testing sessions, asked inappropriate questions, gave inappropriate answers to questions, interrupted others, and had difficulty maintaining a topic during conversations. Mr. Wayne also reported that STUDENT followed only one oral direction, which, he observed, is inadequate for following directions in class. Mr. Wayne added, however, that STUDENT’s teacher said he could follow three-step directions in class. Additionally, Mr. Wayne found that STUDENT could only repeat a ten-syllable sentence, which was below grade level.
Mr. Wayne utilized the Connor’s Rating Scale Revised, which included information from STUDENT’s mother and classroom teacher, to determine STUDENT’s behavior needs. In his assessment report, Mr. Wayne recorded that the information provided by STUDENT’s teacher indicated that STUDENT was oppositional and hyperactive; that STUDENT placed high on the ADHD scale, which, Mr. Wayne noted, would place STUDENT at risk for such a diagnosis; and that STUDENT had greater emotional responses–like crying or anger–than is normal. Mr. Wayne observed that STUDENT appeared to meet many of the parameters for hyperactive impulse behavior noted on the DSM-IV. Mr. Wayne also reported that information on the Connors Scale that was provided by STUDENT’s mother supported that of STUDENT’s classroom teacher. STUDENT’s mother, however, noted additional concerns relating to anxiousness and shyness, perfectionism, and social problems. Mr. Wayne opined that these factors may point to STUDENT’s being overly sensitive to criticism, having a very “factitious” manner of doing things, and having a tendency for low self-esteem and low self-confidence.
Following Mr. Wayne’s assessment, an IEP team met and set specific goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s language deficits. Language goals and objectives were established that called for STUDENT to increase his vocabulary, his story comprehension, and his ability to write a simple sentence at the first grade level. Additionally, specific “interim objectives” were set forth in the IEP that required STUDENT to recite the 26 letters of the alphabet; read numbers 1-100; print from dictation 26 upper and lowercase letters; identify 21 different initial consonant sounds presented orally; pronounce 21 different consonant sounds when presented a visual list of vowel-consonant combinations; identify 18 consonant sounds orally; pronounce 150 of the 400 basic sight vocabulary words; discriminate like or different sounds of one-syllable words presented orally for 26 of 26 sounds; repeat a 12-syllable sentence; follow three-step directions in the sequence given; tell which words in a list of four words presented orally at the second grade level does not belong; answer comprehension questions from a passage at the first grade level that is read aloud; spell dictated words at the first grade level with 50% accuracy; write 21 of 21 initial consonants presented orally in one sentence words; and write one of 33 initial blends and digraphs presented orally in one sentence words. Additional goals and objectives were set for reading, writing, and math.
The IEP team also established behavior goals and objectives for STUDENT. The goals and objectives called for STUDENT to respond to adult redirection in the classroom and on the playground, follow adult direction, and interact with classmates and peers at school without aggressive or defiant behavior.
To assist STUDENT in meeting his goals and objectives, the IEP team modified STUDENT’s curriculum, placed him in a special day class for learning handicapped children, and provided him with an additional resource (RSP) class.
STUDENTs mother testified that she was not aware of STUDENT having any academic difficulties in the first grade. She testified that at some point during the school year the principal informed her that it was difficult to teach STUDENT because he would not remain in his seat in class. STUDENT’s mother said she did not recall any of the discussions surrounding STUDENT’s initial assessments, the IEP, eligibility, or speech and language services. Neither party called Mr. Wayne or STUDENT’s first grade teacher to testify. Moreover, no expert witnesses were asked to evaluate the assessments given STUDENT in the first grade or the services Anaheim provided him. Both parties submitted documents that included STUDENT October 1997 assessments and his IEP.
As noted above, Mr. Wayne’s evaluation included three language assessments that generated specific information regarding STUDENT’s language deficits. From the assessments, Mr. Wayne determined that STUDENT had both expressive and receptive language needs. Thereafter, the numerous goals and objectives established by the IEP team specifically addressed STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language needs. At a minimum, eight of STUDENT’s goals and objectives–as set forth above–directly addressed his deficits in expressive language. And at least that many–also set forth above in detail–directly addressed his receptive language needs. From the behavior assessments, Mr. Wayne also determined STUDENT’s behavior needs. The behavior goals and objectives developed by the IEP team–as set forth above–specifically addressed the behavior needs that Mr. Wayne identified for STUDENT in the assessment. To assist STUDENT in meeting his goals and objectives–language and behavior, the IEP team modified STUDENT curriculum, placed him in a special day class for learning disabled children, and gave him an additional class in the resource room. The program followed Mr. Wayne’s recommendations.
In the annual IEP update held in October 1998, the team noted that STUDENT could accurately read a passage at a first grade, first semester, level; read 208 of 400 sight words; pronounce 20 of 21 initial sounds; identify 14 of 18 final consonants; pronounce 28 of 31 initial blends and digraphs; spell at a second grade level; follow three step directions, and answer comprehension questions at a first grade level. In contrast, STUDENT did not present any evidence that Mr. Wayne’s assessments were inadequate, that they failed to identify STUDENT’s language and behavior needs, or that the program provided by Anaheim did not address those needs. Thus, the weight of the evidence supports a finding that Anaheim adequately identified year, in which STUDENT’s IEP included numerous goals and objectives relating to his receptive or STUDENT’s language and behavior needs and provided him with special education services to address those needs. Thus, the program provided by Anaheim met STUDENT’s unique needs, was provided in accordance with the IEP, and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Anaheim provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year.
Issue Number 2: Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
STUDENT contends that Anaheim did not provide him with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year because it did not adequately identify his language and behavior needs nor provide him with adequate services to address those needs. Applying the applicable legal standard as set forth above under issue number one, the Hearing Officer must again ascertain STUDENT’s speech and language and behavioral needs for the 1997-1998 school year and determine whether the program that Anaheim provided STUDENT addressed his needs, was provided in conformance with his IEP, and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
No new assessments were administered to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year and none were requested; thus, Mr. Wayne’s assessments remained the operative assessment data. In October 1998, the IEP team established new goals and objectives for STUDENT–one each in the areas of reading, math, listening comprehension (receptive language), and behavior.
The October 1998 IEP did not address STUDENT’s language deficits, which Mr. Wayne had identified a year earlier. In fact, the IEP included only a single goal for listening comprehension, a goal that called for STUDENT to listen to a second grade passage and accurately answer questions relating to it. This is in stark contrast to the previous school expressive language needs.
The IEP team placed STUDENT in Ms. Sandy Agajanian-Renner’s second grade special day class at Anaheim’s Jefferson–II Elementary School. Ms. Renner testified that although STUDENT was “not too far below grade level” in reading, he was able to complete work in most academic areas. In a progress report prepared by Ms. Agajanian-Renner for the 1998-1999 school year, she noted that STUDENT was making academic progress. Ms. Renner also testified that STUDENT was progressing toward meeting his goals and objectives.
The problem, however, is that STUDENT’s IEP did not set adequate goals and objectives to address his expressive and receptive language needs, which Mr. Wayne had previously identified. Again, at best, a single listening comprehension goal generally related to STUDENT’s receptive language needs. The IEP did not include any other goals and objectives to assist STUDENT with his language needs. And Anaheim did not present any evidence that the academic progress that STUDENT did make even related to his language deficits.
Anaheim did not present any evidence to indicate that STUDENT had overcome his previously identified language deficits. Yet STUDENT’s IEP did not set any expressive language goals for him. It arguably included only one receptive language goal–a single listening comprehension goal, and there is no evidence that Ms. Renner adequately addressed STUDENT’s previously established language needs. Thus, in sharp contrast to the previous school year, Anaheim did not address STUDENT’s language needs in the 1998-1999 school year. As to STUDENT’s behavior, at the time the IEP was prepared, the IEP team recorded that STUDENT’s behavior did not impede his learning. The team did note that STUDENT had a tendency to speak out loudly in class before raising his hand to respond to questions. The team also indicated that STUDENT needed redirection at times, and that at other times he did not respond to prompts to redirect but continued his disruptive behavior. The IEP team set specific goals and objectives for STUDENT to respond to adult redirection the first time it is given on every occasion. In light of the fact that STUDENT’s misbehavior at the time the IEP was drafted was limited to his not responding to adult redirection, the goal set by the team was appropriate.
Ms. Agajanian-Renner testified, however, that after STUDENT returned to school in April 1999 from a month of being off-track, his behaviors became notably worse. She explained that STUDENT responded less to redirection, and he began to engage in more disruptive behaviors, threats, intimidation, and defiance. In response to STUDENT’s behaviors, the District implemented a behavior support plan. The plan identified each of STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors, their triggers, alternative behaviors, reinforcement procedures, reactive strategies for repetitive problems, and alternative outcomes. The plan addressed each of STUDENT’s behaviors that was identified as a problem. Thus, as STUDENT’s behaviors changed, Anaheim took appropriate steps to address them. Petitioner did not present any evidence to the contrary. Thus, the evidence supports a finding that Anaheim addressed STUDENT’s behavior needs.
Accordingly, Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE because it did not address his language needs.
Issue Number 3: Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
STUDENT contends that Anaheim did not adequately address his language and behavior needs for the 1999-2000 school year. Again, the Hearing Officer must utilize the same analysis as in issues one and two.
As mentioned above, Anaheim undertook new assessments in October 1999. STUDENT was given a speech and language assessment by Loranna Hightower, a speech and language pathologist employed by Anaheim. Ms. Hightower administered three assessment tests: the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals–3 (CELF–3), the Language Processing Test–Revised (LPT–R), and the Test of Language Development–Primary:3 (TOLD–P:3). On the CELF–3, STUDENT scored at the second percentile on two receptive language subtests, sentence structure and concepts and direction. In the area of expressive language, STUDENT scored at the second percentile on the CELF–3's word structure subtest, at the fifth percentile on the formulated sentences subtest, and the fifth percentile on the recalling sentences subtest. On the LPT–R, STUDENT scored below the seventh percentile on two of seven subtests–multiple meanings and attributes. On the TOLD–P:3, which measures receptive and expressive competencies in the major components of language–phonology, morphology, semantics, syntax–STUDENT scored below the seventh percentile on five of eight subtests, and he did not score above ninth percentile on any subtest. Subtests in the TOLD–P:3 measured STUDENT’s abilities in the areas of picture vocabulary, oral vocabulary, grammatic understanding, sentence imitation, grammatic completion, word discrimination, relational vocabulary, phonemic analysis. Ms. Hightower recorded that the assessment appeared to be a valid estimate of STUDENT’s functioning, and that he qualified for special education in the area of langauge under C.C.R. § 3030(c) as a result of a significant delay or disorder in the areas of semantics, morphology, and syntax. Ms. Hightower recommended that the IEP team implement speech and language interventions.
Thus, STUDENT had significant needs in the area of expressive and receptive language that required speech and language interventions.
Additionally, Anaheim also undertook a new psychoeducational evaluation in October 1999. Anaheim school psychologist David Bastin assessed STUDENT’s behavior needs. Mr. Bastin administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales for both parents and teachers, interviewed STUDENT’s classroom teacher, and made his own observations during testing. To measure STUDENT’s academic achievement, Mr. Bastin also gave STUDENT the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). Mr. Bastin concluded that STUDENT was impulsive, oppositional, and erratic. STUDENT’s episodic behaviors tended to escalate and at times lasted one to two hours, requiring the intervention of two to three adults. Mr. Bastin stated that STUDENT was not easily redirected. He summarized STUDENT’s behavior as impulsive, oppositional, and defiant. Mr. Bastin also observed STUDENT to exhibit ADHD. Mr. Bastin added, however, that when STUDENT was motivated he could attend, follow directions, and complete his activities. Regarding academics, Mr. Bastin reported that STUDENT reading comprehension was at or above grade level, but his listening skills were significantly lower. Mr. Bastin also indicated in his report that STUDENT mathematical computational skills were average, but that his math application and work completion were much lower. Mr Bastin testified and noted in the assessment report that STUDENT’s ADHD affected his language development. Additionally, Mr. Bastin concluded that STUDENT impulsive, oppositional, and defiant behavior accounted for his inconsistent academic achievement.
Thus, STUDENT had significant attention and behavior needs that affected his language development and underlay, at least in part, his inconsistent academic progress.
To address STUDENT’s language deficits, the IEP team adopted a single broad goal that called for STUDENT to increase his receptive and expressive language abilities in the areas of syntax, semantics, and morphology. The team noted that STUDENT’s progress would be measured by therapy records or speciality tests. In a section of the IEP form-document labeled “short term benchmark or objective,” the team specified three annual goals for STUDENT to complete by November 2000. STUDENT was to match, compare, or describe shapes, objects, and pictures, including color words, with 90% accuracy. This goal was to be measured by therapist records or specialized tests. According to the IEP document, the persons responsible for the goal were a specialist, STUDENT, and STUDENT’s mother. STUDENT’s teacher was not indicated as one of the persons responsible for the goal. Additionally, there were no short term objectives or benchmarks stated for this goal although such objectives are required by law. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d). See also C.C.R. § 3040(c).) Under the heading “short term benchmark or objective” was a second annual goal to be completed a year later by November 2000. This goal called for STUDENT to place common words into categories–colors, shapes, foods, symbols–with 90% accuracy. The goal was also to be measured by therapist records or specialized tests, and the only persons marked on the form as responsible for the goal were a specialist, STUDENT, and STUDENT’s mother. In the third box under the same heading as the first two, was an annual goal that called for STUDENT to indicate with 90% accuracy whether a given sentence was grammatically correct. The goal too was to be measured by therapist records or specialized tests, and the only persons marked on the form as responsible for the goal were a specialist, STUDENT, and STUDENT’s mother. Again, no short term benchmarks or objectives were set for this goal.
To address STUDENT’s behavior needs, the IEP team set a goal for STUDENT to reduce aggression, disruption, and the use of inappropriate language. The IEP team also set three more specific goals for STUDENT: Follow a one step direction 80% of the time with minimal prompting, stay seated 90% of the time until given permission to leave, and verbalize hostile feelings 90% of the time instead of acting out on those feelings. The IEP form noted that STUDENT teacher and one-to-one aide were responsible for these goals.
To assist STUDENT in meeting his goals, the IEP team placed STUDENT in a special day class at the Rossier Elementary School, a nonpublic school that serves students with behavioral difficulties. His IEP also provided that a speech and language therapist would consult with his classroom teacher one time per month for 30 minutes each session. Additionally, Anaheim undertook a full Functional Analysis Assessment (FAA). The FAA specified the inappropriate behaviors that were to be reduced, identified the antecedents to those behaviors, included an analysis of antecedent behaviors, provided an analysis of the consequent events relating to the behaviors, recorded a history of previous behavioral interventions, identified the possible functions of the behaviors, selected replacement functional behaviors, included reinforcer information, and specified the behavior goals and objectives. Utilizing information derived from the FAA, the IEP team designed a Behavior Intervention Plan (BIP) for STUDENT. The Behavior Intervention Plan included a plan to enable STUDENT to replace his inappropriate behaviors and to reduce both the target behaviors and the behaviors that preceded the target behaviors.
Regarding speech and language, Anaheim presented documentary evidence, a report card, indicating that STUDENT received “outstanding” marks in his core courses for the 2000-2001 school year and referenced documents that indicated STUDENT had improved on standardized achievement tests in some academic areas. Anaheim contends that these grades indicated that STUDENT made academic progress in these courses and thus benefitted from his educational program. However, Anaheim’s contention, even if accurate, falls short of the legal standard. As discussed above, educational benefit is but one of three factors required for a FAPE. STUDENT program must also be designed to meet his unique needs and conform with his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18)(25).) Anaheim’s contention addresses only one of the three required factors.
First, STUDENT’s program was not provided in conformance with his IEP. Briefly setting aside the question of whether the program provided by Anaheim met STUDENT’s unique needs, STUDENT’s IEP called for him to receive the services of a speech and language therapist to act as a consultant to his special day class teacher at Rossier School. STUDENT’s IEP also stated that in addition to himself and his mother, a “specialist” would be responsible for his language goals and objectives. However, Anaheim did not present any evidence that STUDENT received any speech and language services, that anyone worked with him on his language goals, or that he received any educational benefit relating to his language goals. Thus, there is no evidence that STUDENT’s special education program and related services conformed to his IEP. This alone is sufficient to find that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
Second, federal law defines special education services as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. It has already been established that STUDENT had significant language deficits. To address his significant language needs, STUDENT’s IEP called for a speech and language therapist to consult with his classroom teacher once a month for 30 minutes each session. Notwithstanding the fact that there is no evidence that such a service was ever provided, or, if it was provided, that STUDENT’s teacher ever utilized the information to assist him with his language goals, Anaheim provided no evidence as to how such minimal language services could constitute specially designed instruction to meet STUDENT’s unique needs–i.e., significant language deficits.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Anaheim did not provide STUDENT with special education and related services that conformed to his IEP or met his unique needs.
As to STUDENT’s behavior needs, Anaheim identified each of his behavioral deficits. To address those deficits, Anaheim drafted specific goals for STUDENT. Each of the goals adopted by the IEP team directly corresponded to STUDENT’s behavior needs, which had been identified by all members of the team including STUDENT’s mother. To get a better picture of STUDENT’s behavior needs, Anaheim undertook an FAA. As discussed above, the FAA assessed and analyzed all aspects of STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors, their antecedents, and replacements. The behavior plan adopted by the IEP team called for specific interventions to enable STUDENT to replace his inappropriate behaviors and to reduce both the target behaviors and the behaviors that preceded the target behaviors. Additionally, Ms. Raelynn Nelson, STUDENT’s counselor at Rossier during the 1999-2000 school year, testified that Rossier school was a highly structured setting designed to assist students with behavior problems such as STUDENT’s.
On March 25, 2000, the IEP team met again to address STUDENT’s behavior. The team noted that STUDENT had made progress in some areas of his plan, taking responsibility for his actions and in his peer and staff relationships, but that he still engaged in verbal aggression when he did not get his way, particularly on the school bus. In light of STUDENT’s progress and remaining deficits, the team updated his BIP. In the plan update, the IEP team articulated STUDENT’s problem behaviors and adopted replacement behaviors.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program as it related to his behavior needs was appropriate.
Issue Number 4: Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year?
STUDENT contends that Anaheim did not adequately address his language and behavior needs for the 2000-2001 school year. Again, the Hearing Officer must utilize the same analysis that was applied to the previous issue–i.e., whether Anaheim properly met STUDENT’s language and behavior needs.
The IEP team met in April 2000 to establish STUDENT’s annual IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. The IEP included a page in the goals and objectives section labeled “language.” On that page, under the heading, “present levels of performance” the team noted that STUDENT was impulsive, he had a “lot of thoughts and questions on his mind at once,” he shared his thoughts at inappropriate times, he had difficulty controlling his anger on the bus, he used inappropriate language with staff, peers, and on the bus, and when he was asked what was bothering him, he frequently “shut down.” The team drafted a single goal for STUDENT to “improve his expressive language skills.” Three short term objectives called for STUDENT to relate his comments and questions to the topic being discussed, to use appropriate language in problem situations, and to use words to solve his problems. To assist STUDENT in achieving his goals and objectives, the team continued STUDENT’s placement in a special day class at Rossier. STUDENT’s IEP, however, did not call for him to receive any language services.
STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Rossier, Ms. Michele Slaffey, testified that STUDENT improved in math and science and that he generally worked at a fourth grade level. She also said that STUDENT was an imaginative writer. Ms. Slaffey did say that STUDENT received an unsatisfactory grade in phonics and grammar as well as spelling on his first quarter report card. Anaheim also noted that standardized academic achievement tests given to STUDENT in 2000 and 2001 demonstrated that he had progressed academically. Thus, Anaheim argued again, STUDENT benefitted from his educational program because he improved academically.
However, as discussed above, academic improvement is but one test for determining whether a district has provided FAPE. The question for the 2000-2001 school year is whether Anaheim provided STUDENT with specially designed instruction to meet his unique needs.
The parties did not present any evidence to suggest that STUDENT had overcome or even reduced the significant language deficits Ms. Hightower identified in her October 1999 speech and language assessment. (In fact, the independent speech and language assessment that Ms. Gortz administered to STUDENT for Anaheim at the conclusion of the 2000-2001 school year indicated that STUDENT remained severely deficient in nearly every aspect of expressive and receptive language.) Yet STUDENT’s 2000-2001 IEP virtually ignored his language needs. The present levels of performance that were discussed on the page labeled “language” referred to behavior. The team discussed STUDENT’s impulsiveness, anger, and conduct on the school bus. The only reference to language came in the context of STUDENT using profanity and inappropriate words when he was angry or frustrated. The present levels did not address STUDENT’s language deficits, which involve syntax, morphology, phonology, and semantics. As for his language goals and objectives, the IEP set one broad goal calling for STUDENT to improve his expressive language and it did not address his receptive language needs. Moreover, to the extent the goal referenced expressive language, the short term objectives for that goal related to the use of appropriate language in a behavioral context, i.e., what STUDENT said, and not his skills or abilities relating to syntax, morphology, phonology, and semantics–each of which had been previously identified as significant needs for STUDENT.
Thus, STUDENT’s IEP was not designed to meet his unique language needs.
Regarding STUDENT’s behavior needs, the IEP team did not note any new behavior issues, and it carried over the October 1999 Behavior Intervention Plan (including the March 2000 update), which included specific goals and objectives. The team continued STUDENT’s placement in a special day class at Rossier, which, again, was a highly structured nonpublic school that served children with behavior problems. The parties did not present any information to indicate that at the time the annual IEP was adopted in April 2000, there was a measurable change in STUDENT’s behavior needs since the March 25, 2000, update to his Behavior Intervention Plan. However, on September 25, 2000, the IEP team met again to address STUDENT’s behavior problems and update his Behavior Intervention Plan. At this meeting, the team noted a significant regression in STUDENT’s behaviors. The team recorded that STUDENT had regressed in taking responsibility for his actions and in his relationships with his peers and staff. The team also indicated that between March 2000 and September 2000, STUDENT’s replacement behaviors had declined substantially, in some instances from 80 or 90 percent to 10%. However, although the IEP team noted these significant increases in behavior problems, it did not make any changes to STUDENT’s behavior program–not to his goals and objectives, services, or interventions. Furthermore, the parties did not dispute the fact that STUDENT engaged in more frequent and serious misconduct as the school year progressed. Thus, Anaheim did not adequately address STUDENT’s behavior needs.
Therefore, Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
Issue Number 5: Did Savanna fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE between September and November 2001?
STUDENT alleged that Savanna failed to provide him with a FAPE between September and November 2001.
Section 5325 of the California Education Code states:
(a) Whenever a pupil transfers into a school district from a school district not operating programs under the same local plan in which he or she was last enrolled in a special education program, the administrator of a local program under this part shall ensure that the pupil is immediately provided an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days. The interim placement must be in conformity with an individualized education program, unless the parent or guardian agrees otherwise. The individualized education program implemented during the interim placement may be either the pupil's existing individualized education program, implemented to the extent possible within existing resources, which may be implemented without complying with subdivision (a) of Section 56321, or a new individualized education program developed pursuant to Section 56321.
(b) Before the expiration of the 30-day period, the interim placement shall be reviewed by the individualized education program team and a final recommendation shall be made by the team in accordance with the requirements of this chapter. The team may utilize information, records, and reports from the school district or county program from which the pupil transferred.
The parties agreed that STUDENT began school at Savanna, which is not in the same local plan (SELPA) as Anaheim City, in September 2001 when the school year began. The parties also agreed that STUDENT’ program at Anaheim immediately prior to his entering Savanna was a home-hospital school program. Thus, Savanna was only required to provide STUDENT with a home-hospital program as a 30-day interim placement. STUDENT, however, did not request that Savanna provide him with a home-hospital program as a 30-day interim placement, and he did not claim that Savanna denied him a FAPE because it failed to provide such a program.
Initially, STUDENT attended a special day class at Savanna’s Cerritos School. Thereafter, on September 24, 2001, an IEP team meeting was held. The purpose of the IEP was to agree on an interim program for STUDENT. At the meeting, Savanna offered to place STUDENT in a fifth grade special day class at its Cerritos Elementary School. Christopher Russell, who was attending the meeting as STUDENT’s and his mothers’ educational advocate, represented to the IEP team that STUDENT’s mother was in agreement with the “program and placement” on an “interim basis.” Mr. Russell noted, however, that STUDENT’s mother did not agree with Savanna’s proposed goals and objectives. Savanna agreed to draft new goals and objectives, and Mr. Russell agreed to the September 24 IEP as a “limited agreement until [the] next IEP.”
On October 1, STUDENT’s mother requested an FAA. On that same day, Savanna prepared and STUDENT’s mother signed an assessment plan that called for STUDENT to receive both a functional behavior analysis (FBA) and a functional analysis assessment (FAA). On October 4, 2001, Savanna faxed a letter to Vista Behavior Consulting requesting it to conduct an FBA and an FAA. Thus, by October 1, Savanna had taken appropriate steps to meet STUDENTs’ behavioral needs.
On October 9, 2001, the IEP team met again. Dr. Roberts testified that she and Savanna’s speech and language therapist had reviewed Ms. Gortz’s July 2001 speech and language assessment report and protocols. She testified that she and Savanna’s speech and language therapist prepared five language goals to address STUDENT’s needs in the areas of receptive and expressive language. The language goals included accurate statements of STUDENTs’ present levels of performance as they have been identified by Ms. Gortz in her assessment, and the goals called for STUDENT to progress in every aspect of his identified language deficits. Savanna also offered to provide speech and language services for STUDENT to implement the goals. Mr. Russell, on behalf of STUDENT’s family, rejected the language goals. Mr. Russell agreed, however, that the language goals could be addressed at the next IEP meeting.
Dr. Roberts credibly testified that each of the speech and language goals and objectives proposed by Savanna addressed each of the deficits identified by Ms. Gortz’s speech and language assessment. Indeed, each of the goals and objectives in Savanna’s proposal corresponded to the deficits identified by Ms. Gortz in her 2001 report. Petitioner did not provide any evidence to the contrary. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence supports a finding that the goals and objectives proposed by Savanna met STUDENT’s unique needs.
At the meeting, the IEP team also discussed new inappropriate behaviors by STUDENT that had arisen since the last meeting. The team noted that STUDENT had engaged in oppositional and disruptive behavior, including pushing a teacher. All of the IEP team members, including STUDENT’s mother, agreed to place STUDENT on home-hospital until the team could agree on an appropriate alternative placement. After STUDENT attacked his special day class teacher, the team agreed that STUDENT needed a more restrictive setting and sought anonpublic school placement for him. The parties agreed to a home-hospital placement in the interim. Additionally, Savanna, which had previously undertaken a search for an appropriate nonpublic school to address STUDENT’s increasing behavior needs, continued its efforts to locate a placement that was acceptable to STUDENT’s mother. Savanna acted with appropriate care and speed in its effort to find an appropriate placement for STUDENT, but STUDENT had moved from the Savanna District before Savanna could finalize his placement.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Savanna acted in a timely and reasonable manner and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
Issue Number 6: If either Anaheim or Savanna failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE, what if any compensatory education services should STUDENT receive?
At the beginning of the hearing, STUDENT requested that as a remedy for his claims the Hearing Officer order Respondents to provide him with 480 hours of Lindamood Bell services as compensatory education. STUDENT asserted that Lindamood Bell was the appropriate remedy to compensate him for Respondents failures to address both his language and his behavior needs.
In this case, the Hearing Officer found that Anaheim denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to meet his language needs during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and the 2000-2001 school years. The Hearing Officer also found that Anaheim had denied STUDENT a FAPE by not meeting his behavior needs for the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer found that Savanna did not fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE and, thus, the issue of compensatory education is not relevant to Savanna.
Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1415(i)92)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such "relief as it determines is appropriate." "The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services." (Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996).) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. (Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).) There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. "Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief... Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA." (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994).) Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. Because the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE, the question is what, if any, compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.
To determine which, if any, compensatory services are necessary to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education under the law, the Hearing Officer must first review the services that were not provided by Anaheim in the past and then look to STUDENT’s present needs.
During the time that STUDENT was at Anaheim, his language needs were assessed three separate times in 1997, 1999, and 2001. The results of each of these assessments established that STUDENT had significant expressive and receptive language deficits. In fact, STUDENT’s performance on each of these speech and language assessments showed no discernable improvement. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that Anaheim did not address these deficits. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was attending school in the Corona-Norco School District in Riverside County. In June of 2002, Ms. Kristen Keller-Kolde, a speech and language pathologist for the Corona-Norco District, gave STUDENT a new speech and language assessment. Thus, the Hearing Officer has contemporary information regarding STUDENT’s language deficits and the services he needs.
Ms. Kolde administered four standardized speech and language assessments to STUDENT. From her assessments, she concluded that STUDENT’s most significant difficulty was in the area of receptive language. She also noted weaknesses in expressive language and delayed to low-average skills in vocabulary. Ms. Kolde also noted that STUDENT’s difficulties with attention and auditory processing probably affected, or were affected by his language problems. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Anaheim’s failure to address STUDENT’s significant language deficits for three school years, and the fact that STUDENT continues to have significant language deficits, makes it appropriate to award him compensatory language services.
As to the nature and scope of the service, Petitioner did not provide any evidence at the hearing as to the nature and scope of compensatory education he required. However, Dr. Roberts testified that had STUDENT’s mother accepted the goals and objectives that Savanna had drafted to address STUDENT’s language needs, she would have offered to provide him with three 20-minute speech and language sessions. She added that she would have expanded each session to 30-minutes as STUDENT’s ability to attend improved. Dr. Roberts also stated that once STUDENT’s attention became more focused she would probably add an additional 30-minute small group session with one or two other children.
It is only reasonable to conclude that STUDENT’s not receiving appropriate language services for three years undoubtably contributed to his current language deficits. However, since STUDENT is presently receiving speech and language services, it is not necessary to provide him with an hour-for-hour remedy for each hour of service that he missed in order to provide him with those compensatory services that are necessary to ensure that he receives an appropriate education under the law. For purposes of determining an appropriate remedy, it is reasonable to assume that STUDENT’s present program is addressing his language deficits. Moreover, Dr. Tibbetts testified at the hearing that STUDENT has significant attention deficits. He noted that STUDENT’s attention span for receiving remedial language services would be limited during any one session. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT was receiving language services in 30 minute increments, which was consistent with Dr. Roberts’ testimony regarding the appropriate duration for each language session STUDENT attends.
Based on the totality of the evidence presented in this case, the Hearing Officer determines that the appropriate compensatory education for STUDENT is two 30-minute sessions of language services with a credentialed speech and language therapist for two school years. To simplify the order, the Hearing Officer will order 100 hours of language services to be provided in two 30-minute sessions over the course of 100 school weeks, which approximates two school years. The sessions are to be in addition to any speech and language therapy and any educational program that STUDENT receives in his present and future placements. Anaheim is also required to provide STUDENT with any additional transportation that is necessary for him to receive the services.
As for STUDENT’s behavior needs, Mr. Michael Nagano, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Corona-Norco during the second half of the 2001-2002 school year, testified that STUDENT had some behavior issues when he first arrived in his class. He explained that these issues like those of other students usually involved inattention and not following directions. Mr. Nagano testified, however, that even those behaviors dissipated over the course of the semester. In contrast, STUDENT did not present any evidence that compensatory behavior services were necessary to provide him with an appropriate education under the law. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not necessary to award STUDENT with compensatory behavior education services to provide him with an appropriate education under the law.
Issue Number 7: If Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, does the statute of limitations bar STUDENT from receiving a remedy for a denial of FAPE that occurred prior to April 25, 1998?
Because the Hearing Officer found that Anaheim did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, it is not necessary to address the statute of limitations issue. The statute of limitations was only an issue for the portion of the 1997-1998 school year that preceded April 25, 1998.
ORDER
Within 30 calendar days of the date of this order, Anaheim is ordered to provide STUDENT with two 30-minute sessions of language services from a credentialed speech and language therapist over the course of 100 school weeks for a total of 100 hours. The sessions are to be in addition to any speech and language therapy and any educational program that STUDENT receives in his present and future placements. Anaheim is also required to provide STUDENT with any additional transportation that is necessary for him to receive the services.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statue:
1. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year? Anaheim prevailed on this issue.
2. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year? STUDENT prevailed on the portion of this issue that related to speech and language. Anaheim prevailed on the portion of this issue that related to behavior.
3. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year? STUDENT prevailed on the portion of this issue that related to speech and language. Anaheim prevailed on the portion of this issue that related to behavior.
4. Did Anaheim fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
5. Did Savanna fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE between September and November 2001? Savanna prevailed on this issue.
6. If either Anaheim or Savanna failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE, what if any compensatory education services should STUDENT receive? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
7. If Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1997-1998 school year, does the statute of limitations bar STUDENT from receiving a remedy for a denial of FAPE that occurred prior to April 25, 1998? Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties in this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Date: October 23, 2002 Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Petitioner also claimed that Anaheim failed to assess STUDENT for speech and language services in 1997. However, Petitioner did not request a remedy for this alleged failure. Ultimately, the question is subsumed into the larger issue of whether Anaheim failed to provide STUDENT with speech and language services for the 1997-1998 and the 1998-1999 school years, for which Petitioner has sought a remedy. Notwithstanding the fact that Petitioner did not seek an independent remedy, i.e., a remedy other than that sought for an alleged denial of FAPE, STUDENT 1997 psychoeducational assessment, which included standardized speech and language tests, did adequately inform the District of STUDENT’s language needs. As discussed in detail below, the information derived from the assessment was used to create detailed goals and objectives for STUDENT 1997-1998 IEP. Additionally, the information obtained from the 1997 assessments relating to STUDENT’s language deficits was confirmed by similar results in speech and language tests administered in subsequent years.
2. Because the IEP is required to be an annual plan, it actually covered the period of time between April 24, 2000 and April 24, 2001.
3. Given the role of educating children with disabilities in achieving these policies, the development of language must be given heightened attention inasmuch as it underlies and serves as the foundation not only for education in general, but also for each of Congress’s specified policy objectives.
4. In fact, a speech and language assessment given to STUDENT by Anaheim the following year would underscore the severity of his language deficits.
5. Ms. Renner did testify that she helped STUDENT with pragmatic language within the context of his behavior problems by helping him replace inappropriate language with appropriate words when he was angry. However, Ms. Renner did not claim to assist STUDENT with his deficits in syntax, morphology, or phonology, only pragmatics within the limited context of behavior.
6. To elaborate, the upper half of the IEP form-document was utilized for recording present levels of performance, annual goals, and implementation strategies. The lower half of the form included three boxes that were labeled “short term benchmark or objective.” The boxes appeared to be for the purpose of specifying short term benchmarks or objectives relating to the goal set forth at the top of the page–although in this case, the IEP team wrote three annual goals into the boxes and did not include any short term benchmarks or objectives. Located at the bottom and within each of the three boxes, were the words “person(s) responsible” followed by a series of five very small check-boxes labeled “teacher,” “specialist,” “student,” “parent,” and “other.” On this IEP, the boxes labeled “specialist,” “student,” and “parent” were checked, and the boxes marked “teacher” and “other” were not checked.
7. The report card denoted “outstanding” by marking an “O” next to the courses listed on the document. Anaheim did not provide any evidence as to the basis for these grades. In light of the fact that STUDENT tested extremely low on three speech and language assessments over four years and he continually functioned below grade level in most of his academic subjects, the Hearing Officer gives little weight to these unexplained marks that were generated from a special day class in a nonpublic school.
8. The term “goal” is used instead of “goals and objectives,” because Anaheim did not provide STUDENT with any short term benchmarks or measurable objectives as required by law. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d). See also C.C.R. § 3040(c).)
9. Moreover, Dr. Joan Roberts, Ph.D., who has both a Masters of Arts degree and Ph.D. in speech pathology, and who is also the director of special education for Respondent Savanna Elementary School District, testified that in light of the results of the speech and language assessment administered by Ms. Gortz in July 2001, which were substantially similar to those derived from the assessment given by Ms. Hightower, she would have recommended three 20 minute one-to-one sessions with a speech and language therapist. She added that once STUDENT adjusted to the sessions, she would have increased them to 30 minutes each and added a small group session. Dr. Roberts testified that one-to-one services were necessary for STUDENT because his attention and behavior issues would have made it too difficult for him to learn in his special day class.
10. Although Anaheim failed to set forth short term benchmarks and objectives for each of STUDENT’s behavior goals, the Hearing Officer finds the error to be harmless in light of the fact that the ensuing Behavior Intervention Plan contained very specific and measurable objectives to help implement STUDENT’s behavior goals.
11. See footnote 7, which is as applicable to the 2000-2001 school year as it was to 1999-2000 .
12. STUDENT’s mother testified that she and STUDENT were residents of the Savanna School District until January 2002. However, her testimony is not credible as Orange County Mental Health records indicate that Mr. Russell had informed Mental Health in late November 2001 that his client, STUDENT, had already moved to the Corona-Norco District. In contrast, Dr. Roberts credibly testified that she received records requests for STUDENT from the Corona-Norco District on November 1, 2001. Additionally, Dr. Roberts testified that she personally went to STUDENT’s family’s home in Anaheim in early November 2001 and found that the residence was vacant. She credibly testified that neighbors told her that STUDENT’s family had already moved out. Thus, the Hearing Officer will analyze Petitioner’s claim against Savanna only from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year until November 1, 2001.
13. Although Savanna, Anaheim Union, and several other school districts in and around the City of Anaheim are part of the Greater Anaheim SELPA, Anaheim City School District is not.
14. Although STUDENT’s mother, in response to a single question, testified that STUDENT did not receive home-hospital services between October 9 and November 1–the only dates relevant to this issue–STUDENT did not make this an issue for hearing. Even if it were an issue, STUDENT did not present any evidence regarding the nature and scope of a compensatory remedy.
15. At the hearing, STUDENT’s representatives requested compensatory education in the form of 450 hours of Lindamood Bell services. Although Dr. Tibbetts testified that he believed that some programs offered by Lindamood Bell would benefit STUDENT, he did not provide any specific information as to how those programs would meet STUDENT’s language needs. Moreover, Dr. Tibbetts testified that he was not a speech and language expert and, thus, he is not in a position to determine the nature and scope of compensatory education that STUDENT needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not have any information to support a finding that Lindamood Bell services are necessary or would even help to meet STUDENT’s educational needs.
16. As noted above, the Hearing Officer found that the goals and objectives proposed by Savanna in 2001 were appropriate. Thus, Dr. Roberts’ testimony regarding the services required to advance those goals is particularly helpful to determining the appropriate compensatory education in this case.
17. The Hearing Officer is not ruling on the appropriateness of STUDENT’s educational program at Corona-Norco, as it was not at issue in this case. Petitioner presented evidence regarding the appropriateness of STUDENT’s present program, and the Hearing Officer is merely utilizing that information as one factor in determining an appropriate compensatory remedy for STUDENT.
18. “School weeks” is defined as those weeks that STUDENT is regularly scheduled to attend school in his placement at the time.
19. Thus, the language services provided by Anaheim cannot be delivered at such a time as to cause STUDENT to miss any of his regularly scheduled present or future educational program.
20. Again, “school weeks” is defined as those weeks that STUDENT is regularly scheduled to attend school in his placement at the time.
21. As previously noted, the language services provided by Anaheim cannot be delivered at such a time as to cause STUDENT to miss any of his regularly scheduled present or future educational program.
