California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 30, 1999

Student v. Santa Barbara High School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 839-98 · Hearing Officer William Reyes

Santa Barbara High School District, SELPA, and County Mental Health must fund a court-ordered residential placement and a year of tutoring.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 9 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated. The decision notes an August 18, 1998 ruling that SEHO had jurisdiction and that the mother had standing, which was reaffirmed when Respondents' motion to dismiss was denied.

Summary

A mother filed for her 14-year-old son, who was eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. In seventh grade (1997-98), at Goleta Valley and La Colina junior high schools in the Santa Barbara High School District, his behavior got worse. He had repeated suspensions totaling more than 16 days, fights, and failing grades. The district moved him to a special day class and adopted general behavior plans, but his behavior did not improve. In May 1998 the juvenile court detained him. It later placed him at Kings View Center in Fresno, where he attended Rio Canyon School and improved.

Hearing Officer William Reyes found the district's behavior responses "completely ineffective." The district never identified the student's attention deficit hyperactivity disorder or how it was linked to his behavior. He received no educational benefit, so he was denied FAPE. The district should have held a manifestation determination once his suspensions passed ten days in February 1998. It also should have done a functional analysis assessment and a behavioral intervention plan under California's Hughes Bill rules. The claim about the timing of the mental health (AB 3632) referral failed: once the mother asked, the assessment and IEP meeting met the legal timelines. The County Office of Education denied FAPE in juvenile hall, where he attended only 14 of 41 possible school days. The district, the SELPA, and County Mental Health must pay for the residential placement. The district and SELPA must also provide one year of tutoring in study skills and in written language, five hours per week each. The bad-faith and intentional-disregard claims were denied because they are not separate claims.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO linked a district's failure to address escalating behavior to paying for a later residential placement ordered by a juvenile court. The district held no manifestation review after ten suspension days and no Hughes Bill functional analysis. Costs were split: the district and SELPA pay educational costs, and county mental health pays noneducational costs.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1A. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year by failing to offer an appropriate placement?

    The district's behavior responses were completely ineffective, it failed to identify the student's ADHD and its link to his behavior, and he received no educational benefit in 1997-98, so he was denied FAPE.

  2. Student prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 1B. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE by failing to conduct a manifestation determination?

    The student was suspended more than ten days by February 5, 1998, and kept being sent home on 'time-outs'; the district should have started a manifestation determination at that time.

  3. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1C. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE by failing to develop and implement an appropriate Behavioral Intervention Plan in a timely manner?

    The student had serious behavior problems (assaultive conduct, pervasive defiance) that significantly interfered with his IEP goals; the district's general behavior plans were not Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plans, and it should have done a functional analysis assessment.

  4. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1D. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a FAPE by failing to make an AB 3632 referral in a timely manner?

    Although the district did not respond promptly to warning signs, once the mother asked, the AB 3632 assessment was done and the IEP meeting was held within the statutory 50-day timeline; no authority required an earlier referral.

  5. Issue 2. Should one or more of the Respondents be required to reimburse Petitioner's mother, or otherwise pay, for Petitioner's residential placement at Kings View Center and Rio Canyon School pursuant to Court order?

    On equitable grounds, because the district's failures likely led to the juvenile court placement, the district, SELPA, and County Mental Health must reimburse the mother for any residential placement costs charged to her.

  6. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did one or more of the Respondents violate Petitioner's rights under IDEA and/or California law, and thereby deny Petitioner a FAPE, during the time Petitioner was detained in juvenile hall in Santa Barbara County?

    The student attended only 14 of 41 possible school days in juvenile hall and the County Office of Education could not explain why, so it denied him FAPE.

  7. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. Upon his release from Kings View Center, should Petitioner be placed in a residential, nonpublic school as compensatory education at the expense of one or more of the Respondents?

    No residential nonpublic school placement was ordered outright; if the IEP team finds on release that residential placement is still needed, the district pays the educational costs and County Mental Health pays the residential costs. The decision states that neither party prevailed.

  8. District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue 5. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or their employees act or fail to act with intentional disregard for Petitioner's rights under IDEA and/or California law?

    Intentional disregard may be weighed when deciding a remedy but is not a separate cause of action, so relief was denied.

  9. District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue 6. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or their employees act in 'bad faith'?

    Bad faith, including the claim that a record date was altered, is an equitable consideration and not a separate cause of action, so relief was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 15 days of receiving any bill or invoice for the student's care at Kings View Center or education at Rio Canyon School for 1998-99, the mother forwards it to Santa Barbara High School District, Santa Barbara SELPA, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health. Within 15 days of receipt, those agencies pay it: Mental Health pays the noneducational portion and the District and/or SELPA pay the educational portion.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. The District and SELPA continue to pay the educational costs, and County Mental Health the noneducational costs, of the Kings View Center placement until the student is discharged by the Probation Department or the Juvenile Court.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. An IEP team must meet 30 days before discharge from Kings View Center to decide whether residential placement is still needed. If it is, the District and SELPA pay the educational costs and County Mental Health pays the noneducational costs. If it is not, the District and SELPA provide re-entry support services for the move back to a nonresidential public school.
  • Compensatory education. Within 30 days of the decision, the District and SELPA arrange one year of tutoring in study skills, five hours per week.
  • Compensatory education. Within 30 days of the decision, the District and SELPA arrange one year of tutoring in written language skills, five hours per week.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education of Massachusetts; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4)(A)(ii); Education Code § 56520 et seq. (Hughes Bill); 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001, 3052; Government Code § 7576 (AB 3632); Education Code § 56344

People named in the decision

  • Keltie Jones, SEHO Hearing Officer who first convened the matter and granted a continuance, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Denise Williamson, paralegal for Student
  • Diana Rigby, director of student services, Santa Barbara School District / Santa Barbara High School District
  • Marcia McClish, SELPA director, Santa Barbara County SELPA
  • Lowell Boldt, district psychologist and behavior intervention case manager; conducted functional analysis assessment, Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District
  • Burt Romotsky, program manager, MISC Program, Santa Barbara County Alcohol, Drug, and Mental Health Services
  • Sally Kingston, assistant principal, La Colina Jr. High School
  • Becky Riley, health teacher, La Colina Jr. High School
  • Mr. Ormbrek, special day class teacher (also described as a counselor), La Colina Jr. High School
  • Donald Slutzky, private psychiatrist who recommended residential treatment
  • Dr. Lenchner, family physician; witness
  • Randy Wood, Ph.D., author of hospital discharge summary, Vista Del Mar Hospital
  • Dr. Solomon, psychologist who did the court-ordered evaluation and AB 3632 assessment, Santa Barbara County Mental Health
  • C. Forssell, school psychologist (1996 assessment)
  • Mr. Dahmen, industrial technology instructor, Goleta Valley Junior High School
  • Mr. Hubble, vice principal, Goleta Valley Junior High School
  • Eve Kelemen, school psychologist who drafted the February 1998 behavior plan, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Marguerite Noto-Bianchi, school psychologist, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Florence Bednersh, assistant superintendent, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
  • Dr. Caston, superintendent, Santa Barbara High School District
  • Kings View Center, residential treatment placement (court-ordered), Fresno, California
  • Rio Canyon School, school attended during residential placement
  • Vista Del Mar Hospital, psychological treatment facility
  • Fighting Back, youth counseling organization recommended in IEP
  • SAFE, youth counseling organization recommended in IEP

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter first convened before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Barbara, California, on August 18, 1998. Before any testimony or documentary evidence was received, the hearing officer granted a continuance for the purpose of adding an additional party. The matter was then heard by William Reyes, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Barbara, California, on October 27, 28, November 17, and December 3, 4, 1998, and February 2, 3, 8, 9, 10, and 11, 1999.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Steven Wyner. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner were MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother, and Denise Williamson, paralegal.

Respondents Santa Barbara High School District, Goleta Union Elementary School District, Santa Barbara County Office of Education, Santa Barbara County SELPA, and Hope Elementary School were represented by attorneys Sharon Watt and Andrew Arczynski. Respondent Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District was represented by attorney Raymond Dunne. Santa Barbara County Probation Department and Santa Barbara County Mental Health were represented by Linda Seals, deputy county counsel. Also present on behalf of the Santa Barbara High School District was Diana Rigby, director of student services, Santa Barbara School District. Present on behalf of the Santa Barbara County SELPA was Marcia McClish, director of the Santa Barbara County SELPA. Present on behalf of Kings Canyon Unified School District was Lowell Boldt, district psychologist for Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District. And present on behalf of Santa Barbara County Mental Health was Burt Romotsky, program manager for the Santa Barbara County Alcohol, Drug, and Mental Health Services MISC Program. Oral and documentary evidence was received, and the record remained open until written closing arguments were received by the Hearing Office. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On October 27, 1998, Respondents submitted a written opening brief and made a motion to dismiss this case, alleging that the Hearing Office did not have jurisdiction to hear this matter because (1) MOTHER had no standing to request a due process hearing, and (2) only the juvenile court could change STUDENT’s placement. Respondents’ opening brief also asserted that the Petitioner would not be entitled to reimbursement from Respondents for a placement ordered by the juvenile court. Petitioner submitted a written response in opposition to Respondent’s motion stating that Respondents’ motion was, in fact, a motion for reconsideration, as a hearing officer had already ruled on August 18, 1998, that the Hearing Office had jurisdiction over the issues being raised and that MOTHER had standing to request a due process hearing. The Hearing Officer found that since MOTHER’s parental rights with respect to making educational decisions for STUDENT had not been limited by the juvenile court, she had standing to initiate a due process hearing, and that the Hearing Office had jurisdiction over the issues raised by the Petitioner.

Mr. Wyner, Petitioner’s attorney, stated he would withdraw Issue Number Four because he no longer believed that the Petitioner’s placement at Kings Canyon was inappropriate. Mr. Dunn, attorney for Kings Canyon, then requested that Kings Canyon be dismissed as a party. Mr. Wyner objected to the request and asserted that Kings Canyon might bear responsibility for some of the costs of STUDENT’s residential placement. As this was a factual issue to be determined during the course of the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied Kings Canyon’s request to be dismissed.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by:

(A) Failing to offer an appropriate placement.

(B) Failing to conduct a manifestation determination.

(C) Failing to develop and implement an appropriate Behavioral Intervention Plan in a timely manner.

(D) Failing to make an AB 3632 referral in a timely manner.

2. Should one or more of the Respondents be required to reimburse Petitioner’s mother, or otherwise pay, for Petitioner’s residential placement at Kings View Center and Rio Canyon school pursuant to Court order?

3. Did one or more of the Respondents violate Petitioner’s rights under IDEA and/or concomitant provisions of California law, and thereby deny Petitioner a FAPE during the time that Petitioner was detained in juvenile hall in Santa Barbara County?

4. Upon his release from Kings View Center, should Petitioner be placed in a residential, nonpublic school as compensatory education at the expense of one or more of the Respondents?

5. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or any of their respective employees act or fail to act with intentional disregard for Petitioner’s rights under IDEA and /or concomitant provisions of California law?

6. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or any of their respective employees act in "bad faith?"

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old student who first qualified for special education services in 1993 based on a specific learning disability. At the beginning of the seventh grade in the 1997-98 school year, pursuant to an IEP dated April 22, 1997, STUDENT was receiving resource specialist services (RSP) once a day and counseling services once a week for 20 minutes. STUDENT began having academic and disciplinary problems at the beginning of the 1997-98 school year at Goleta Valley Junior High School (Goleta Valley), a school located in the Santa Barbara High School District. STUDENT’s progress report dated October 7, 1997, indicated that he was failing his art class, and in danger of failing three other classes. The report noted that STUDENT was wasting time, failing to complete work, and disregarding class procedures. STUDENT was then suspended from school for fighting.

On October 17, 1997, an IEP team meeting was held. The IEP team changed STUDENT’s placement from one period of RSP per day to four periods of special day class (SDC) per day. STUDENT’s behavioral problems continued and, by December 15, 1997, STUDENT had accumulated 11 days of suspension based on 9 incidents of misconduct. By February 1998, STUDENT had accumulated 16 total days of suspension for the school year. STUDENT’s mother contacted Diana Rigby, district director of student services, and requested a school transfer. STUDENT was then transferred to La Colina Jr. High School (La Colina). La Colina is also a school within the Santa Barbara High School District.

An IEP team meeting was held on February 25, 1998. STUDENT’s four periods of SDC were continued, and his counseling was reduced to once a month. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT work with "Fighting Back" or "SAFE," two youth counseling organizations. STUDENT began attending La Colina on March 2, 1998. One month later, STUDENT was failing PE and receiving unsatisfactory citizenship marks in his SDC. On March 24, 1998, STUDENT was arrested at Goleta Valley for trespassing on school grounds and for possession of antique coins that he had stolen from his physician and family friend, Dr. Lenchner. STUDENT was released to his mother pending a court appearance. On March 29, 1998, MOTHER was called to pick STUDENT up from La Colina because he was "out of control." On April 8, 1998, Sally Kingston, assistant principal at La Colina, called MOTHER to school because STUDENT was disruptive and belligerent in the hallways. MOTHER requested that the psychological assessment team (PAT) be called. PAT recommended that STUDENT be admitted to Vista Del Mar Hospital (Vista), a psychological treatment facility.

STUDENT was admitted to Vista on April 8, 1998, and was diagnosed with a DSM-IV, Axis I- depressive disorder. STUDENT was discharged from Vista on April 13, 1998. The discharge summary prepared by Randy Wood, Ph.D., noted that STUDENT required inpatient hospitalization in order to "contain his acting out, evaluate his depressive disorder, and to prepare him for a safe discharge to an outpatient level of care." The discharge summary diagnosed STUDENT as having depressive disorder as well as oppositional defiant disorder.

STUDENT returned to school at La Colina, and his difficulties continued. On April 21, 1998, Ms. Kingston gave MOTHER a letter written by STUDENT’s health teacher, Becky Riley. The letter stated that STUDENT had done no classwork, homework, or tests. Ms. Riley also wrote: "I seriously think he is incapable of being in a classroom setting at this time. He can’t be learning and he prevents others from being able to do so." On April 22, 1998, STUDENT was suspended for two days because he disrupted class activities or "willfully defied valid authority."

On April 23, 1998, MOTHER submitted a written request for an IEP meeting "as soon as possible." On April 28, 1998, STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Mr. Ormbrek, sent MOTHER a letter informing her that STUDENT "continues to come to class tardy repeatedly."

On April 29, 1998, MOTHER met with Ms. Kingston and Mr. Ormbrek to develop a behavior plan. On April 30, 1998, STUDENT was again suspended from school for one day. On May 4, 1998, MOTHER conferred with psychiatrist Donald Slutzky. Dr. Slutzky wrote a brief letter, addressed to "To whom it may concern, " stating that STUDENT’s behavior was out of control and that his condition constituted an emergency. MOTHER agreed to hand-deliver the letter to the District. On, May 7, 1998, STUDENT ran away from home, and was picked up by the sheriff’s department. STUDENT was interviewed by the PAT team and voluntarily admitted to Vista Del Mar for the second time. On May 8, 1998, STUDENT received a progress report that indicated he was failing SDC math, SDC social studies, and was in danger of failing health and a class called "teacher’s aide." On May 11, 1998, Dr. Lenchner, STUDENT’s family physician, sent a letter to Sally Kingston, assistant principal at La Colina, informing her that he had formally consulted with a psychiatrist and that the psychiatrist recommended a residential placement for STUDENT. On May 12, 1998, Dr. Slutzky sent a follow-up letter to Ms. Kingston stating that he had spoken with STUDENT and his mother and that he fully agreed that STUDENT needed placement in a residential treatment center. In addition, MOTHER also sent a letter dated May 12, 1998, to Ms. Kingston, Ms. Rigby, and Dr. Caston, Superintendent of School, requesting a referral to an "outside residential school immediately."

On May 14, 1998, STUDENT was discharged from Vista Del Mar. His prognosis was described as poor, and placement in a "locked residential setting" was recommended. STUDENT also appeared in juvenile court on May 14, 1998. MOTHER, believing that STUDENT was beyond her control and that she had no other alternative, requested that STUDENT be detained in juvenile hall. The court detained STUDENT and ordered Dr. Solomon, a psychologist with Santa Barbara County Mental Health (Mental Health), to conduct a psychological analysis of STUDENT and to submit a report to the Santa Barbara County Probation Department (Probation).

On May 28, 1998, an IEP team meeting was held, while STUDENT was still in custody. STUDENT was again considered eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability. The IEP dated May 28, 1998, continued STUDENT’s placement in the SDC program, increased his DIS counseling from once a month to twice a month, and included AB 3632 counseling.

On May 29, 1998, Dr. Solomon sent his report to Probation. Dr. Solomon concluded that "STUDENT is in need of mental health services in order to benefit from an educational placement." In addition, Dr. Solomon’s report stated, "Therefore, I must recommend out of home placement for this teen. He needs a highly structured residential treatment program...."

STUDENT was subsequently placed at Kings View Center in Fresno, California, by the juvenile court. As part of his placement, STUDENT entered Rio Canyon School on August 3, 1998. An IEP team meeting was held on September 11, 1998, at Kings Canyon. At this meeting, MOTHER requested that a functional analysis of STUDENT’s behavior be conducted. At that IEP team meeting, MOTHER informed the team that STUDENT had a history of severe behavior problems at Goleta Valley and La Colina. A functional analysis assessment was performed and a report completed on October 16, 1998, by Lowell Boldt, STUDENT’s behavior intervention case manager. In the report, Dr. Boldt noted that "the combined treatment milieu of Kings View Center and Rio Canyon School appear to be effective in reducing the target behaviors to a rate of zero.... In addition, STUDENT seems to be producing some positive replacement behaviors."

STUDENT is currently living at Kings View and attending Rio Canyon School.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner contends that:

(1) The Respondents failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE by (a) not addressing STUDENT’s unique needs, (b) not providing adequate support and services that would enable STUDENT to receive some educational benefit, and (c) providing a program that did not comport with STUDENT’s IEP;

(2) The Respondents failed to place STUDENT in the least restrictive environment;

(3) The Respondents failed to conduct a manifestation determination as required under IDEA;

(4) STUDENT’s behavior problems rose to the level of a "behavioral emergency" as defined in Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations § 3001(e) and the Respondents failed to conduct the required functional analysis assessment and prepare a behavioral intervention plan;

(5) The Respondents failed to make an AB3632 referral in a timely fashion;

(6) The Respondents changed STUDENT’s placement from Goleta Valley to La Colina without first convening an IEP meeting to develop a functional behavioral assessment plan;

(7) The Respondents failed to identify STUDENT as SED;

(8) The Respondents failed to develop appropriate IEPs for STUDENT;

(9) The Respondents acted in bad faith with intentional disregard to STUDENT’s rights.

The Respondents contend that:

(1) STUDENT was not denied a FAPE;

(2) A functional analysis assessment was not necessary;

(3) An SED classification was not proper for STUDENT;

(4) STUDENT’s current placement is based on juvenile offender status;

(5) STUDENT was under control of the court as of May 14, 1998, and (6) The Respondents did not act in bad faith.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Findings Regarding Respondents’ Liability

Oral and documentary evidence presented at the hearing was based on incidents that occurred during the 1997-98 school year. At that time, STUDENT was a student in the Santa Barbara High School District. With the exception of evidence related to the short period of time that STUDENT was in juvenile hall, and under the jurisdiction of the Santa Barbara County Office of Education, no evidence was presented by the Petitioner that would support a finding that STUDENT was denied a FAPE by any of the other Respondent local education agencies. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Hope Elementary School District, Goleta Union Elementary School District, and Kings Canyon Joint Unified School District are not liable regarding any of the issues raised in this due process hearing. In addition, no evidence was presented that would support a finding of liability of Santa Barbara County Probation Department regarding the denial of FAPE to STUDENT. Therefore, the analysis set forth below applies only to the Santa Barbara High School District, the Santa Barbara Special Education Local Plan Area, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health. The two schools STUDENT attended while under the jurisdiction of the Santa Barbara High School District were Goleta Valley, and La Colina. The SELPA is involved because it entered into a joint powers agreement with the District. Marcia McClish, SELPA director, testified at the hearing that the SELPA is authorized to act as a school district. Ms. McClish also testified that the SELPA has special education responsibilities including funding attorney representation in due process hearings. She also testified that she would need to approve any residential placement made by the District.

Issue 1: Did Respondents deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year by:

(A) Failing to offer an appropriate placement?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code §56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). "Related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C.§1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided "when instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); California Education Code §56363(b). Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management. In addition, medical services may also be a necessary related service, but only to the extent that such services are for diagnostic and evaluation purposes. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA (IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. The Court set forth the standard that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 207-208.

Federal and state special education law also require that a special education student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); California Education Code §56031.

Therefore, the combined requirements of IDEA and Rowley, provide that the educational program STUDENT attended in the 1997-98 school year must:

1. Have met STUDENT’s unique needs;

2. Have provided STUDENT with some educational benefit;

3. Have comported with STUDENT’s IEP; and 4. Have provided STUDENT with all of the above in the least restrictive environment.

The following is a discussion of the four elements required to provide STUDENT a FAPE.

Did STUDENT’s 1997-98 placement meet his unique needs?

The Hearing Officer’s first task in this analysis is to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year. STUDENT had been found eligible for special education services due to specific learning disabilities (SLD) in 1993. In October of 1993, STUDENT was found to have difficulties with his short-term memory and attentiveness. At that time, his assessors found that he had adequate social skills. STUDENT was again assessed in 1996 by school psychologist C. Forssell. STUDENT’s scores on the WISC-III were in the low average range. Dr. Forssell’s report noted low average range of cognition with adequate visual motor development and perceptual organization, possible difficulty with short-term memory and attentiveness. An IEP team convened on April 22, 1997. (Respondents Ex. 4). At that time, STUDENT was preparing to transition from the Goleta Union School District to Goleta Valley Junior High School in the Santa Barbara High School District.

STUDENT immediately began having academic and disciplinary problems at Goleta Valley. On October 7, 1997, STUDENT received a progress report that showed he was failing his art class, and in danger of failing three other classes. The report noted that STUDENT was wasting time, failing to complete work, and disregarding class procedures. STUDENT was then suspended from school for fighting. STUDENT stated in his declaration that he recalls being suspended for three days about this time of the school year for fighting. No record of this three-day suspension was offered into evidence. However, Petitioner’s exhibit number 2 is a notice of suspension that documents STUDENT’s suspension for two days on October 23, 1997. The notice states the he was suspended because he "caused, attempted to cause, or threatened physical injury." None of the District’s staff could recall any details regarding this suspension(Footnote 2). The Hearing Officer concludes that this two-day suspension was the suspension that STUDENT described in his declaration.

On November 25, 1997, STUDENT was suspended another day because he "disrupted school activities or willfully defied valid authority. On December 2, 1997, a notice was sent to MOTHER indicating that STUDENT had been tardy 13 times. On December 5, 1997, STUDENT’s industrial technology instructor submitted a student referral form, an administrative form documenting disciplinary action taken against a student, regarding STUDENT. Mr. Dahmen commented in the referral that he observed STUDENT spitting on a poster on the wall, and that he found "a large amount of spit (body fluid) in the module instruction book" that STUDENT was using. Mr. Dahmen went on to state that STUDENT’s behavior was beyond his control and that he needed help. On December 12, 1997, Mr. Dahmen again completed a student referral form for STUDENT, and noted that STUDENT choked another student that was trying to work. Petitioner alleged in his declaration that he was very angry with the student and that he choked the student as hard as he could. Mr. Dahmen testified that he saw STUDENT choking the student with one hand, and that STUDENT immediately stopped when told. Mr. Hubble, vice principal at Goleta Valley, testified that after speaking with both STUDENT and the other student about the incident, he concluded that it was "horseplay," and not an attack. The Hearing Officer finds that this incident involved more than mere "horseplay." Mr. Hubble did not witness the incident. Mr. Dahmen wrote the referral specifically stating that STUDENT was "choking" the other student. He did not say that STUDENT and the other student were "playing around." STUDENT stated in his declaration that he was very angry and choked the other student as hard as he could.

On December 15, 1997, STUDENT was suspended five days for possession of a razor knife. At this point, according to the District’s records, STUDENT had been suspended for eight days and had been disciplined at least six times. STUDENT’s final grades for the Fall 1997 semester were as follows:

PE - D English SC - C Science SC - C Soc Std. SC - C Tchr Aide - B Tech Expl - F

STUDENT was transferred pursuant to his mother’s request to La Colina, which is also in the Santa Barbara High School District. STUDENT’s first day at La Colina was March 2, 1998. The very next day, STUDENT’s mother was called to school because STUDENT was exhibiting "disruptive behavior." One month later, STUDENT was failing PE and receiving unsatisfactory citizenship marks in his SDC. On March 24, 1998, STUDENT was arrested at Goleta Valley for trespassing on school grounds, and for possession of antique coins that he had stolen from his physician and family friend, Dr. Lenchner. STUDENT was released to his mother’s custody pending a court appearance. On March 29, 1998, MOTHER was called to pick STUDENT up from La Colina because he was "out of control." On April 8, 1998, Sally Kingston, assistant principal at La Colina, called MOTHER, to school because STUDENT was disruptive and belligerent in the hallways. MOTHER requested that the psychological assessment team (PAT) be called. The PAT arrived and recommended that STUDENT be admitted to Vista Del Mar Hospital (Vista), a psychological treatment facility.

STUDENT was admitted to Vista on April 8, 1998, and diagnosed with a DSM-IV, Axis I- depressive disorder. STUDENT was discharged from Vista on April 13, 1998. The discharge summary prepared by Randy Wood, Ph.D., also diagnosed STUDENT as having depressive disorder.

On April 21, 1998, Ms. Kingston gave MOTHER a letter written by STUDENT’s health teacher, Becky Riley. The letter stated that STUDENT had done no classwork, homework, or tests. Ms. Riley also wrote: "I seriously think he is incapable of being in a classroom setting at this time. He can’t be learning and he prevents others from being able to do so." On April 22, 1998, STUDENT was suspended for two days because he disrupted class activities or "willfully defied valid authority." On April 30, 1998, STUDENT was again suspended from school for one day.

On, May 7, 1998, STUDENT ran away from home, and was picked up by the sheriff’s department. STUDENT was interviewed by the PAT and voluntarily admitted to Vista Del Mar for the second time. He was discharged on May 14, 1998, and his mother took him directly to court. MOTHER, feeling that STUDENT was beyond her control, and that she had no other alternative, requested that STUDENT be detained in juvenile hall. The court detained STUDENT and ordered Mental Health to perform a psychological analysis of STUDENT and to submit a report to Probation.

Two important witnesses who provided key information about STUDENT’s unique needs were his family physician, Dr. Lenchner, and Dr. Solomon, the psychologist who prepared the psychological analysis and report pursuant to the juvenile court order.

Dr. Lenchner wrote a letter to Sally Kingston, principal of La Colina on May 11, 1998. Dr. Lenchner’s letter stated in part that "as well as a severe conduct disorder, STUDENT has repeatedly exhibited many behaviors consistent with attention deficit hyperactivity disorders of the predominantly inattentive type.... Some children have both ADHD as well as conduct disorder, and I believe this to be the case with STUDENT."

Dr. Solomon confirmed Dr. Lenchner’s diagnosis of ADHD. Dr. Solomon diagnosed STUDENT as follows: Diagnostic impressions: This teen’s ADHD (DSM IV, 314.01) with its concomitant Disorder of Written Expression (315.2) over the years has evolved into more serious problems. At this point he has a Conduct Disorder (314.01) and at least Cannabis Abuse (305.2). He may have other forms of chemical dependency as well....

I also believe that he has a mood disorder. While I [sic] the staff at Vista del Mar diagnosed him with a Depressive Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified (311.00), I would also want to rule out a Cyclothymic Disorder (314.13). In other words, STUDENT evidences many features of manic behavior.

Dr. Solomon also noted in his report that STUDENT was exhibiting "the kind of psychological sequelae that learning disabled/ADHD children often do in response to years of frustration in school." Dr. Solomon went on to state that "this teen’s adjustment in recent months demonstrates what long term research on children with ADHD has found: over 50% of them become conduct disordered adolescents. STUDENT’s hyperactivity, poor impulse control, and anger with and alienation from his mother and school have led him into a variety of antisocial activities."

Dr. Solomon concluded that STUDENT’s behavior problems were in response to his frustration at school. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Solomon’s testimony credible in that he was not testifying on behalf of either the District or the Petitioner. Dr. Solomon is a neutral party who evaluated STUDENT pursuant to an order from the juvenile court.

By the time of STUDENT’s first admission to Vista Del Mar on April 8, 1998, his behavior was completely out of control. The Hearing Officer concludes that one of STUDENT’s most significant unique needs was in the area of behavior intervention. The Hearing Officer will now review the actions taken by the District in response to STUDENT’s need for behavior intervention.

MOTHER stated in her declaration that STUDENT did not have any behavioral or emotional problems at school before his enrollment at Goleta Valley. MOTHER’s statement is supported by the fact that the IEP dated April 22, 1997, set goals including improving reading comprehension, improving written language, and improving organizational skills, but did not list any goals or objectives related to STUDENT’s behavior.

On October 17, 1998, after STUDENT received a progress report that showed he was failing his art class, and in danger of failing three other classes, and that stated that he was wasting time, failing to complete work, and disregarding class procedures, an IEP team meeting was held. The IEP team changed STUDENT’s placement from RSP one period a day to four periods a day of SDC. The rationale for changing STUDENT’s placement was stated on the IEP as, "STUDENT needs specially designed instruction to be successful with core curriculum." At this point STUDENT had begun to exhibit behavioral problems, but no behavioral goals or objectives were included in his IEP. As described above, STUDENT’s behavioral problems escalated. The District response was to discipline STUDENT with suspensions and other warnings and minor disciplinary actions. MOTHER requested that STUDENT be transferred out of Goleta Valley and, in response to her request, an IEP team meeting was held on February 25, 1998, at Goleta Valley. By this time, STUDENT had accumulated 16 total days of suspension for the school year. The IEP dated February 25, 1998, included academic goals and objectives and the following behavioral goals and objectives:

Annual Goal Objective

To improve behavior. STUDENT must follow all teacher /aid/sub.-given directions promptly and without interfering with lesson’s progress in any way.

To be respectful of adult authority. STUDENT will be respectful towards adult authority 75% of the time.

Appropriate behavior in classroom Respect other students and complete assignments 50% of the time by 6/98.

Respect other students and complete assignments 75% of the time by 2/99.

The IEP dated February 25, 1998, maintained STUDENT’s placement in four periods a day of special day class, but reduced his DIS counseling to once per month for 20 minutes a session. There is a notation included under the Additional Information/Recommendations Section that states, "There is a recommendation that STUDENT work with ‘Fighting Back’ and ‘SAFE.’" Although the IEP mentions these two programs, it does not give any information on what these programs do, or what benefit STUDENT could expect to gain from working with them. The IEP team also did not make a recommendation as to the frequency and duration that STUDENT should work with either "Fighting Back" or "SAFE."

A behavior plan was drafted by school psychologist Eve Kelemen. Dr. Kelemen brought the behavior plan to the IEP team meeting and it was attached to the IEP dated February 15, 1998. The Behavior Plan described STUDENT’s current behavior as "disruptive to other students" and "disrespectful" to teachers." It also stated that "STUDENT also has problems with completing homework and remembering to bring materials to class. The behavior plan listed desired behavior including entering the class in a quiet respectful manner, to remain seated unless given permission to move, and to treat people an property with respect. Some "general recommendations for supporting STUDENT at school" were included in the behavior plan. These included:

1. Establish a predictable routine for STUDENT. Review it and his behavior plan at the beginning of each day.

2. A place for STUDENT to go when he is having a difficult day should be available. He should be helped to monitor himself and be given a way to "escape" when he is beginning to escalate.

3. Provide choice whenever possible (activities he prefers, individuals he wants to spend time with, etc.).....

8. Teach STUDENT individual alternative behaviors that serve the same function as the problem behaviors, such as how to make friends instead of receiving negative attention.

The behavior plan contained these general recommendations but it did not include any specifics. It did not identify who would establish STUDENT’s routine. It did not specify what place STUDENT could go when he was having a difficult day. It did not specify who would provide choices for STUDENT, and it did not state who would teach STUDENT alternative behaviors. The plan included interventions such as counseling about problems, but, again, it did not specify who would provide these counseling services. The plan also listed consequences for inappropriate behavior including "time outs" and "time outs at home."

Although the behavior plan and IEP were implemented on February 25, 1998, STUDENT’s behavior did not improve. STUDENT started school at La Colina on March 2, 1998, and MOTHER was called to school the next day because STUDENT was exhibiting "disruptive behavior." He continued to be disciplined for being disruptive and defiant. He also continued to defy authority, and, as stated above, he eventually was arrested and detained at juvenile hall.

The District’s next formal action regarding STUDENT’s behavioral problem came on April 29, 1998, when MOTHER met with Ms. Kingston and Mr. Ormbrek, one of STUDENT’s counselors at La Colina, to "prepare" another behavior plan. The next IEP team meeting was held on May 28, 1998, while STUDENT was still in custody. STUDENT was again determined to be eligible for special education due to specific learning disability. The IEP dated May 28, 1998, continued STUDENT’s placement in the SDC program, increased his DIS counseling from once a month to twice a month, and included AB 3632 counseling. It also attached a second behavior plan, which was less detailed than the plan drafted by Dr. Kelemen. This second behavior plan dated April 5, 1998, was in fact a discipline plan. It stated in part,"STUDENT is fully expected to follow all directions from adults at school. If STUDENT does not follow school and classroom rules, he will receive progressive discipline. If he refuses to respond to progressive discipline, he will be sent home for the day." The plan further states that for "minor disruptive, defiant, threatening, or physically aggressive behavior" STUDENT will sit in the office during lunch period or be sent home for the remainder of the day as a "time out." If STUDENT engaged in more serious disruptive behavior, he would be sent home for the remainder of the day, or be transferred to another school.

The District’s attempts at behavioral intervention were completely ineffective. STUDENT continued to be disciplined through suspensions and time outs, but the District failed to effectively control STUDENT’s behavior. The District failed to identify STUDENT’s ADHD and the causal relation between his disability and his behavior problems. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to adequately meet STUDENT’s unique need for behavioral intervention.

Did STUDENT’s 1997-98 program provide him with educational benefit?

STUDENT’s problems during the 1997-98 school year resulted in his missing a great deal of school due to suspensions and "time outs." When STUDENT was in school, his behavior was so dysfunctional that he was not in control of himself. He did not pay attention in class and frequently needed to be admonished by his teacher. Dr. Solomon testified that STUDENT’s problems were so serious that he was having trouble in school, at home and in the community. He went on to state that STUDENT was not benefiting from his education. Dr. Boldt also testified that, based on the information he received about STUDENT’s seventh grade performance, STUDENT was not benefiting from his education, and needed a residential placement to benefit from a special education program. Dr. Boldt also testified that STUDENT is currently behind as a result of the problems he had during the 1997-98 school year. Dr. Boldt also testified that STUDENT has some deficits in study skills and written language, and that while it would be difficult to say what would compensate STUDENT, tutoring in these areas would be a benefit.

Based on STUDENT’s academic record and the above testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive educational benefit during the 1997-98 school year(Footnote 3).

Did STUDENT’s educational program comport with his IEP

The Petitioner raised questions were raised about the legal sufficiency of STUDENT’s IEPs for the 1997-98 school year. However, the Hearing Officer will not address these questions as he has already made a finding that the District’s educational program did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs or provide educational benefit.

Least Restrictive Environment

The Hearing Officer will not address whether or not the program was offered in the least restrictive environment as he has already made a finding that the program offered did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs and did not provide STUDENT some educational benefit.

Since the educational program offered by the District did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs and did not provide him with an educational benefit, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year.

(B) Failing to Conduct a Manifestation Determination

The Petitioner argued that given STUDENT’s pattern of misbehavior, under IDEA, the District should have conducted a manifestation determination to determine if there was a relationship between the STUDENT’s disability and the behaviors that caused his numerous suspensions. Under Federal law, a district has to "conduct a review of the relationship between the child’s disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action" if a student has been suspended for ten or more days. 20 U.S.C. §1415(k)(4)(A)(ii). The District suspended STUDENT for more than ten days, and continued to send him home on so-called "time-outs." The Hearing Officer concludes that the District should have conducted a manifestation determination to see if STUDENT’s disability was the cause of his serious behavior problem. STUDENT was suspended for more than ten days by February 5, 1998, and the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have initiated a manifestation determination at that time.

(C) Failing to Develop a Behavioral Intervention Plan

The Petitioner also argued that the District was required under California law to draft a "behavioral intervention plan." As discussed above, Dr. Kelemen drafted a behavior plan for STUDENT. A behavior plan is not a behavioral intervention plan as defined by the California Education Code. In 1990, California passed Education Code Section 56520 et.seq., which is commonly known as the "Hughes Bill." Regulations implementing the Hughes Bill are contained in Title 5, California Code of Regulations §§ 3001(c)-(h) and 3052. Subsection (h) of §3001 states that "the "behavioral intervention plan" is a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP." The regulations define serious behavior problems as "behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective." 5 C.C.R. § 3001(ah). When members of the IEP team find that the instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective, a functional analysis assessment must be conducted. 5 C.C.R. § 3052 (a)(6)(b). The Hearing Officer will now discuss if STUDENT had a serious behavior problem as defined by the regulations.

Serious Behavior Problem

As discussed above, STUDENT was suspended for fighting, was disciplined for choking a student, and was suspended for five days for possession of a razor knife. The Hearing Officer finds that fighting and choking another student are assaultive behaviors. In addition, STUDENT was continually disciplined both at Goleta Valley and La Colina for defiant and disruptive behaviors. His mother was called to school twice while STUDENT attended La Colina, and the second incident resulted in STUDENT’s being admitted to Vista Del Mar. As analyzed above, the behavioral approaches specified in STUDENT’s IEPs and behavior plans were ineffective. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT exhibited serious behavior problems as defined in the California regulations. The next step in determining whether or not the District should have prepared a behavioral intervention plan is to analyze if STUDENT’s serious behavior problem significantly interfered with the implementation of the goals and objectives of his IEP

Significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the IEP

The IEP dated February 25, 1998, listed academic and behavioral goals as described above. STUDENT’s behavior interfered with the implementation of the goals and objectives because he continued to be disruptive, defiant, and tardy to class. On April 21, 1998, Becky Riley, STUDENT’s health teacher, wrote a statement regarding STUDENT’s behavior. She stated that STUDENT was often late to class without a pass, and had done no classwork, homework, tests or quizzes. Ms. Riley also stated that she was concerned with "his lack of respect for property, his rudeness, and his need to disrupt class." She also stated that "he can’t be learning and he prevents other from being able to do so." (Petitioner’s Ex. 18) STUDENT received a progress report dated May 8, 1998, which indicated that he was failing SDC math, SDC social studies, and "in danger of failing" health.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s serious behavior problem interfered with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the IEP dated February 25, 1998. The District should have conducted a functional analysis assessment as required by 5 C.C.R. §3000 et. seq. The functional analysis assessment should have been the basis for implementing a behavior intervention plan.

(D) Failing to Make an AB3632 Referral in a Timely Manner

The Petitioner also argued that the District did not make an AB 3632 referral in a timely manner. Under California Government Code § 7576(b), a student who is suspected of needing mental health services can be referred to a community mental health service for assessment if certain criteria are met. The student must be an individual with special needs as defined in section 56026 in the California Education Code. It is undisputed that STUDENT has been defined as such a student. Other necessary criteria include:

(1) The pupil has been assessed by school personnel in accordance with Article 2 (commencing with Section 56320) of Chapter 4 of Part 30 of the Education Code, Local education agencies and community mental health services shall work collaboratively to ensure that assessments performed prior to referral are as useful as possible to the community mental health service in determining the need for mental health services and the level of service needed.

(2) The local agency has obtained written parental consent for the referral of the pupil to the community mental health service...

(3) The pupil has emotional or behavioral characteristics that: (A) Are observed by qualified educational staff in educational and other settings as appropriate. (B) Impede the pupil from benefiting from educational services. (C) Are significant as indicated by the rate of occurrence and intensity. (D) Are associated with a condition that cannot be described solely as a social maladjustment or temporary adjustment problem, and cannot be resolved with short-term counseling. (4) As determined using educational assessments, the pupil’s functioning, including cognitive functioning, is at a level sufficient to enable the pupil to benefit from mental health services. (5) The local education agency has provided counseling, psychological, or guidance services to the pupil pursuant to Section 56363 of the Education Code, and the individualized education program team has determined that the services do not meet the pupil’s education needs,.... California Government Code § 7576 (b).

The time lines for completing IEPs that are convened as a result of an assessment are governed by California Education Code Section 56344, which states that " an individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days,..."

The evidence presented at the due process hearing shows that STUDENT was observed by qualified educational staff in educational settings; that STUDENT’s behavior did impede him from benefiting from educational services; that the behavioral events were significant; that STUDENT’s level of cognitive functioning was at a level sufficient to enable him to benefit from mental health services; and that services being provided by the District were not meeting STUDENT’s educational needs. The District’s school psychologist, Marguerite Noto-Bianchi, did suggest that STUDENT had a conduct disorder and stated in her report that "STUDENT functions as a socially maladjusted individual." However, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s problems were more complex. His family physician, Dr. Lenchner, testified that STUDENT was depressed and was taking anti-depressant medications. Dr. Boldt, district psychologist for Kings Canyon, testified that STUDENT probably met the criteria for being "seriously emotionally disturbed" during the 1997-98 school year. Dr. Solomon concluded that STUDENT’s "hyperactivity, poor impulse control, and anger with and alienation from his mother and school have led him into a variety of antisocial activities."

MOTHER testified that on April 23, 1998, she requested an "immediate IEP as soon as possible." She also testified that on April 30, 1998, she made an oral request for an AB 3632 assessment. The AB 3632 assessment was completed by Dr. Solomon at or about the same time he completed the probation assessment. Dr. Solomon attended an IEP meeting held on May 28, 1998, where he informed the IEP team of his recommendation of a residential placement for STUDENT(Footnote). The IEP team did not follow Dr. Solomon’s recommendation and did not recommend a residential placement at this time. The District did, however, hold the IEP meeting within the required fifty days. While Petitioner argues that the District did not make the referral in a timely manner, the legal authority he presented states that a district may make a referral to a mental health agency. He did not provide the Hearing Officer with any authority that prescribes when a school district must make a referral to mental health. While the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not promptly respond to the many warning signs that STUDENT presented to school staff with respect to his behavioral issues, once MOTHER requested an assessment, the assessment was done and the IEP meeting was held within the time limits set by statute. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the AB 3632 referral although not promptly made, was made within the time limits prescribed by law.

ISSUE 2: Should one or more of the Respondents be required to reimburse Petitioner’s mother, or otherwise pay, for Petitioner’s residential placement pursuant to Court order?

The Hearing Officer must consider whether or not Santa Barbara High School District should be required to reimburse Petitioner’s mother for petitioner’s residential placement made by court order. In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts 471 U.S. 358 (1985), the United States Supreme Court determined that equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. The 9th Circuit also affirms this principle. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 96 F.2d 1479,1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. V. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489,1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needs a residential placement in order to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer also finds that had appropriate steps been taken earlier in the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT’s current needs would now be very different. If the District had conducted a functional analysis assessment, conducted a manifestation determination, and made an AB 3632 referral before MOTHER requested one, STUDENT’s behavior would have either improved, or he would have been placed in a more restrictive and appropriate setting. The probability of STUDENT’s behaviors improving is supported by Dr. Boldt’s testimony of STUDENT’s marked improvement at King Canyon. STUDENT was placed at Kings Canyon by the juvenile authorities and has made significant academic and behavioral improvements. Had the District and the SELPA acted in accordance with the law, STUDENT in all probability would not have been placed in long term juvenile detention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that should MOTHER be held responsible for any costs of STUDENT’s residential placement under Welfare and Institutions Code §§ 903 and 905, the Santa Barbara High School District, the Santa Barbara SELPA, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health must reimburse her for those costs.

Issue 3 Did one or more of the Respondent’s deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education during the time that Petitioner was detained in juvenile hall in Santa Barbara County?

The Petitioner additionally raised the issue of a denial of FAPE for the period of time STUDENT was incarcerated at juvenile hall. While STUDENT was detained at juvenile hall, he could have attended school for forty one days. Of those forty one days, STUDENT only attended school for fourteen days. STUDENT missed approximately two thirds of the possible school days. Although STUDENT was enrolled in math, English, U.S. history, physical education, and health, he only received 2 credits for P.E. Neither Petitioner nor the Santa Barbara County Office of Education was able to explain why STUDENT missed this amount of school. Florence Bednersh, assistant superintendent Santa Barbara County Schools, testified that she did not know why STUDENT missed so much school. She further testified as to some of the reasons a youth might miss school while detained at juvenile hall, but could not specifically address STUDENT’s case. The Santa Barbara County Office of Education did not meet its burden of showing that STUDENT’s unique needs were met, or in the alternative, why STUDENT’s unique educational needs could not be met while he was incarcerated. The Hearing Officer finds that the Santa Barbara County Office of Education denied STUDENT a FAPE during the period of time he was incarcerated.

Issue 4 Upon his release from Kings View Center, should Petitioner be placed in a residential, nonpublic school as compensatory education at the expense of one or more of the Respondents?

STUDENT is currently doing very well at Kings View Center. Upon his release, if the IEP team determines that STUDENT still needs a residential placement at a nonpublic school in order to for him to receive benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer finds that the Santa Barbara High School District must pay for the educational portion of the costs of that placement and Santa Barbara Mental Health will be responsible for paying for the residential costs of that placement.

Other Remedies

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the Petitioner is entitled to compensation for any costs in relation to STUDENT’s incarceration and residential placement at Kings View Center and Kings Canyon School. Now the Hearing Officer turns to the question of what other remedies are appropriate for STUDENT. The District and SELPA must provide compensatory education to STUDENT for his lack of educational benefit in the 1997-98 school year.

Dr. Boldt testified that STUDENT has deficits in study skills and written language. He also testified that STUDENT would benefit from tutoring in those areas. Dr. Boldt also testified that when STUDENT returns to a non-residential setting, he will need re-entry support services to help him transition appropriately. These services would include academic and mental health supports. The Hearing Officer finds that the District and SELPA must provide STUDENT with one year of tutoring services in the areas of study skills and written language as compensatory education.

Issues 5 & 6 - Bad Faith and Intentional Disregard

The Petitioner asked the Hearing Officer to make a finding regarding the Respondents’ actions and whether or not they acted or failed to act with intentional disregard for Petitioner’s rights under IDEA and /or concomitant provisions of California law; and in denying Petitioner a free, appropriate public education, whether one or more of the Respondents or any of their respective employees, acted or failed to act in "bad faith." The Petitioner raised allegations of intentional disregard for the Petitioner’s rights. He also alleged that the District illegally altered the date on one of STUDENT’s school records. While these issues could be considered by the Hearing Officer as equitable considerations in fashioning a remedy, they do not constitute separate causes of action. Therefore, Petitioner’s requests for relief on these issues are denied.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen days after the receipt of any bill or invoice for the care and maintenance of STUDENT in relation to his residential placement at Kings View Center or education at Rio Canyon School for the 1998-1999 school year, MOTHER will promptly forward a copy of the invoice to the Santa Barbara High School District, the Santa Barbara Special Education Local Plan Area, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health. Within fifteen days of receipt of such invoices, the above agencies will pay the amounts set forth in the invoices. Mental Health will pay the noneducational portion of the placement, and the District and/or SELPA will pay for the educational portion of the placement.

2. Santa Barbara High School District and Santa Barbara County Special Education Local Plan Area shall continue to be responsible for the educational cost of STUDENT’s residential placement at Kings View Center, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health will continue to be responsible for the noneducational costs of STUDENT’s placement at Kings View Center until STUDENT is discharged from these institutions by the Santa Barbara Probation Department, or the Juvenile Court.

3. Thirty days before STUDENT’s discharge from Kings View Center, an IEP team will convene to determine whether or not a residential placement will continue to be necessary for STUDENT to benefit from special education. If the team determines that a residential placement is necessary for STUDENT after his discharge from Kings View, the Santa Barbara High School District and Santa Barbara Special Education Local Plan Area will be responsible for the educational cost of STUDENT’s residential placement, and Santa Barbara County Mental Health will be responsible for the noneducational cost of the placement. If the IEP team determines that a residential placement is no longer necessary, the Santa Barbara High School District and Santa Barbara Special Education Local Plan Area will provide re-entry support services to STUDENT to help him transition back to a nonresidential public school.

4. Within 30 days of the date of this decision, the District and SELPA will arrange for STUDENT to receive the following:

(A) One year of tutoring in the area of study skills for a period of five hours per week; and (B) One year of tutoring in the area of written language skills for a period of five hours per week.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute.

1. Did Respondents deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education by:

(A) Failing to offer an appropriate placement?

The Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.

(B) Failing to conduct a manifestation determination/

The Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.

(C) Failing to develop and implement an appropriate Behavioral Intervention Plan in a timely manner?

The Petitioner prevailed on this sub-issue.

(D) Failing to make an AB 3632 referral in a timely manner?

The Respondents prevailed on this sub-issue.

2. Should one or more of the Respondents be required to reimburse Petitioner’s mother, or otherwise pay, for Petitioner’s residential placement pursuant to Court order?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

3. Did one or more of the Respondent’s violate Petitioner’s rights under IDEA and/or concomitant provisions of California law, and thereby deny Petitioner a FAPE during the time that Petitioner was detained in juvenile hall in Santa Barbara County?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

4. Upon his release from Kings View Center, should Petitioner be placed in a residential, nonpublic school as compensatory education at the expense of one or more of the Respondents?

Neither party prevailed on this issue.

5. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or any of their respective employees, act or fail to act with intentional disregard for Petitioner’s rights under IDEA, and /or concomitant provisions of California law?

The Respondents prevailed on this issue.

6. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE, did one or more of the Respondents or any of their respective employees, act or fail to act in "bad faith?"

The Respondents prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code §56505(i).

Date: April 30, 1999 William Reyes Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues were consolidated by the Hearing Officer for the sake of clarity.

Footnote 2: The Hearing Officer notes that District staff could not recall any details regarding any of STUDENT’s many suspensions, and this lack of specificity made analyzing the seriousness of STUDENT’s behaviors much more difficult.

Footnote 3: While the Petitioner raised questions as to the validity of some of STUDENT’s "passing" grades, the Hearing Officer has decided that these questions do not merit a detailed discussion.

Footnote 4: Ms. McClish testified that the IEP meeting held on May 28, 1998 should not have been held, as STUDENT was no longer a student within the Santa Barbara High School District. Ms. Rigby testified that she held this IEP meeting over Ms. McClish’s objection as a "show of good faith." The Hearing Office did not address what transpired at this IEP meeting because he has already made a finding that STUDENT’s unique needs were not met in the 1997-98 school year.