California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 13, 1999
Student v. San Francisco Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 855-99 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
San Francisco Unified's middle school special day class upheld as least restrictive environment over guardian's request for general education with resource help.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision refers to a prior decision between the same parties, San Francisco Unified School District v. STUDENT, SN 1340-98 (Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait, March 11, 1999). That decision ordered a special day class placement and a triennial assessment. No remand, vacatur or correction of this decision is noted.
Summary
The student's guardian filed for due process against San Francisco Unified School District about where an 11-year-old boy with a specific learning disability would attend sixth grade. A few months earlier, in SN 1340-98, a different Hearing Officer had ordered him placed in a special day class (SDC). This Hearing Officer found that claim preclusion did not bar the new case. The move from elementary school to a different middle school campus counted as substantially changed circumstances.
Both sides agreed that an SDC at Giannini Middle School could give the student educational benefit. The dispute was about the least restrictive environment. The guardian wanted a general sixth grade class with three resource specialist periods. She relied on an evaluation by Kathleen Peters, Ed.D., of UCSF. The Hearing Officer applied the Rachel H. factors. He found Dr. Peters' opinion unpersuasive: she had not observed the student in class or spoken with his teachers, she based her view of his reading comprehension on one subtest, and her testimony was inconsistent. Every District witness testified that he needed intensive one-on-one help, modified lessons and repetition. The Hearing Officer found that the social benefits of a general class were only marginally greater. The District prevailed. It was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 10 days and to provide an SDC like Michael Paurowski's class, with mainstreaming for PE and an elective. A mid-year IEP meeting was required to consider more mainstreaming.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO weighed the Rachel H. factors for least restrictive environment. An outside evaluator who did not observe the student or talk with teachers got little weight. Small social gains in a general class did not outweigh a lack of academic benefit. A transition to a new school allowed a recently decided placement dispute to be heard again.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
Applying Rowley and Rachel H., the Hearing Officer found that a middle school special day class with mainstreaming for PE and an elective was the least restrictive environment where the student could get educational benefit; a general education class with three resource periods would not provide benefit.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 10 days to develop a 1999-2000 IEP that conforms to the order.
- Placement ordered. District to provide a program at Giannini Middle School with the general characteristics of Michael Paurowski's special day class: a credentialed, experienced special education teacher, one-on-one instruction as needed, and a small teacher-student ratio. The student attends the SDC for no more than four periods daily (math, reading, science, social studies) and is mainstreamed for PE, one rotating elective, assemblies and other appropriate activities.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. No later than one month before the end of the first semester of 1999-2000, District to convene a second IEP meeting to decide whether to add mainstreaming in the second semester.
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District
People named in the decision
- Kathleen Peters, Ed.D., Educational psychologist and independent evaluator; expert witness for Student, University of California, San Francisco, Division of Behavioral and Developmental Pediatrics
- Elizabeth Dray, Psychology intern who co-conducted the private evaluation, University of California, San Francisco
- Anna Lai, School psychologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Sylvia Bailey, School psychologist (triennial assessment), San Francisco Unified School District
- Laura Keenan, Speech-language pathologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Susan Clarke, Fifth grade general education teacher, Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School
- Michael Paurowski, Special day class teacher, Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School
- Maggie (Margaret) Englesbe, Resource specialist program teacher and early literacy intervention teacher, Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School
- Andee Abramson, Program consultant / program specialist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Katherine McCauley, Program administrator for compliance (district representative), San Francisco Unified School District
- Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer in the prior case SN 1340-98, California Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Temple City, California, on July 8 and 9, 1999.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Sheila O'Connor and Paul Foreman. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his aunt, AUNT. Respondent San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Diane E. Finkelstein. Also present on the District's behalf was Katherine McCauley, program administrator for compliance.
The following witness was called by Petitioner to testify: Kathleen Peters, Ed.D.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Anna Lai, psychologist; Laura Keenan, speech therapist; Susan Clarke, general education teacher; Michael Paurowski, special education teacher; Maggie Englesbe, resource specialist program teacher; Andee Abramson, program consultant.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The same parties were involved in a due process hearing before Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait on January 21 and February 25, 1999, in San Francisco, California, San Francisco Unified School District v. STUDENT, SN 1340-98. There were three issues in the previous hearing: (1) Is the District's proposed program for STUDENT appropriate for STUDENT and should it implemented? (2) Should STUDENT be placed in the special day class of Mr. Michael Paurowski at the Robert Lewis Stevenson Elementary School? (3) Should the District be allowed to perform a triennial assessment of STUDENT?
Hearing Officer Fait rendered a decision on March 11, 1999. He found for the District with regard to all three issues. He ordered the District to immediately implement its proposed program as set out in the IEPs of March 13, 1998, and December 18, 1997, and to immediately place STUDENT in Mr. Paurowski's special day class at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. Additionally, he ordered the District to convene an IEP meeting to review STUDENT's goals and objectives within 30 days of STUDENT's placement in Mr. Paurowski's class and to perform a reassessment of STUDENT in the areas set out in its assessment plan dated January 19, 1999. Finally, he ordered the District to perform an assessment in the area of communication development.
The parties now agree that STUDENT should attend the sixth grade during the 1999-2000 school year. The parties also generally agree that if STUDENT is placed in a special day class at Giannini Middle School for the 1999-2000 school year, as the District proposes, it will meet STUDENT's unique academic needs and provide him with educational benefit. The principal disagreement between the parties, as in the previous hearing, is in regard to the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT can receive some educational benefit.
Despite the substantial congruity between the issues presented and decided at the previous hearing and the issue presented at the present hearing, Petitioner's issue is not barred by the doctrine of res judicata. The Hearing Office has required a showing of substantially changed circumstances in the past when a party seeks to revisit an issue recently decided by a hearing officer. STUDENT, through agreement of the parties, will transition from elementary school to middle school and the middle school and elementary school are not located on the same campus; together, these facts constitute "substantially changed circumstances."
BACKGROUND FACTS
At the commencement of the present hearing, the parties stipulated that the "background facts" in Hearing Officer Fait's decision in the matter San Francisco Unified School District v. STUDENT, SN 1340-98, are accurate and complete, and requested that they be made part of the record. The background facts in the previous decision are as follows:
"STUDENT will turn eleven years old in March 1999. He is currently attending the regular fifth grade class taught by Ms. Susan Clark at the Robert Louis Stevenson elementary school and, at the insistence of his guardian, is not receiving special education services.
"From the beginning of his schooling, STUDENT has failed to develop his skills at the same rate as his peers. In June of 1994, after a full year of kindergarten, STUDENT was not able to write his name. He repeated kindergarten and was conditionally promoted to first grade. During the 1995-96 year, while STUDENT was enrolled in second grade, a student study team was convened to review his progress. In the Spring of 1996, STUDENT was referred for an assessment because of his poor academic achievement. The assessment, dated May 13, 1996, concluded that even though STUDENT had average cognitive abilities, his academic achievement was two to three years below his current grade placement. He was determined to have a ‘specific learning disability as reflected in the psychological processes of sensory motor integration.' The assessment concluded the STUDENT was eligible for special education services and recommended that he be placed in a special day class.
"An IEP meeting was held on September 12, 1996, to review the assessment of STUDENT. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services and developed a specific plan for his educational program. It included goals and short-term objectives in the areas of sensory-motor integration, reading skills, math skills, and expressive and receptive language. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class and that he receive sixty minutes of speech and language services each week. The IEP team agreed that he would be integrated with regular students for physical education, recesses, school assemblies and ‘other as appropriate.' STUDENT's guardian approved the September 12, 1996 IEP.
"At the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was placed in a special day class at the Lawton Elementary School. In January 1997, STUDENT's guardian requested that STUDENT be removed from the special day class and placed in a regular third grade class. The IEP was revised on January 1, 1997, to implement this request. STUDENT's special day class teacher objected to STUDENT's placement in a regular class, stating: ‘I do not agree with the decision to demit STUDENT from special education due to significant delays in academic areas. His current placement is an appropriate setting.' In February 1997, STUDENT transferred from Lawton Elementary School to Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. He was placed in a regular third grade class. An IEP meeting was conducted May 6, 1997, during which it was agreed that STUDENT would receive resource specialist services for 200 to 300 minutes per week and speech and language services for 60 minutes per week. District personnel believed that a special day class was the appropriate placement but agreed to provide resource specialist services rather than have him receive no special education support. STUDENT's guardian agreed to the new IEP, which also contained new goals and objectives. The IEP provided that STUDENT's progress would be reviewed in November 1997.
"The IEP team next met on November 18, 1997, to review STUDENT's progress. The team concluded that STUDENT was not making adequate progress in the resource specialist program. Achievement testing performed prior to the IEP demonstrated that while STUDENT had made progress in reading he was still one to two years behind grade level. The testing also showed that he was still performing at the first grade level in spelling and math.
"A review of STUDENT's progress on his goals and objectives revealed that he had completed 100% of the goals related to decoding and 75% of the goal relating to vocabulary and fluency. The IEP team formulated a new goal to improve reading comprehension. STUDENT had made no progress toward meeting the written language goal. The IEP team developed two new written language goals in the areas of composition and editing skills. STUDENT had met 70% of one math computation goal and had made no progress on the other computation goal. The IEP team continued the math goal on which he had not made progress and added a new goal relating to money skills. The team also approved a goal to improve language skills with four short-term objectives. The IEP team developed on November 18, 1997, continued speech and language services twice a week for a total of 60 minutes. The team determined t hat wile STUDENT was a friendly and kind young student, ‘he struggles to work independently and has a tendency to wander off into fantasy play. It is also difficult for him to work in groups and to assume responsibility for tasks.' "The District members of the IEP team concluded that STUDENT could not make appropriate progress while placed in regular class with over 30 other students. The IEP team concluded that he needed small-group instruction with a small teacher-student ratio with lots of opportunity for one-to-one attention. The team believed that STUDENT should be returned to a special day class setting in order to achieve necessary progress. Because STUDENT's guardian refused to approve the November 18, 1997 IEP, the District continued to provide the program called for in his prior IEP, including resource specialist and speech and language services.
"STUDENT's IEP team met again on March 14, 1998, in an attempt to reach agreement with STUDENT's guardian. District members of the team again strongly urged STUDENT's guardian to agree to placing STUDENT in a special day class. The IEP team also further refined the description of activities in which STUDENT would participate with his nondisabled peers. These included physical education, electives for 30 minutes per day, lunch, and school assemblies. STUDENT's guardian again refused to sign the IEP and STUDENT continued to receive the services provided for in the May 6, 1997 IEP.
"STUDENT was enrolled in the regular fifth grade class in August 1998, with continued resource specialist and speech and language services. On September 17, 1998, STUDENT's guardian requested that all special education services be discontinued. The District discontinued the resource specialist and speech and language services but continued to encourage STUDENT's guardian to visit the special day classes and consider placing him in one of them. On September 21, 1998, the District filed a request for a hearing to determine the appropriate program and placement for STUDENT and to request a reassessment of him.
"On January 22, 1999, the District sent a letter to STUDENT's guardian proposing Mr. Paurowski's special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson as an appropriate placement for STUDENT and requesting her approval of a triennial assessment of STUDENT. A copy of the assessment plan was enclosed with the letter. The assessment plan provided for an assessment of STUDENT in the following areas: cognitive development/thinking strategies, motor/perceptual development, social/emotional/adaptive behavior, and educational/academic. STUDENT's guardian did not approve the placement or the assessment plan."
***
Hearing Officer Fait found that the principal disagreement between the parties in the first hearing was whether STUDENT could make progress in a regular class, with or without resource specialist services, or whether STUDENT needed a small special day class setting in order to achieve academic progress. He held that STUDENT could not progress in a regular class, even with resource specialist services:
[T]he appropriate placement for STUDENT is a small special day class with a low teacher-to-student ratio and much one-to-one instruction. STUDENT was not able to make appropriate progress in a regular class with or without the resource specialist services. All of the witnesses at the hearing testified that a special day class for the learning disabled was the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT's IEP does provide for him to participate in physical education, recess, assemblies, lunch and electives with his non-disabled peers. However, the evidence supports his need for a small, structured class to address all of his academic needs.
On April 6 and 7, 1999, pursuant to Hearing Officer Fait's decision, the District completed a triennial assessment of STUDENT. School Psychologist Sylvia Bailey evaluated STUDENT. She administered selective tests to provide current information, including the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), the Beery Visual-Motor Integration Test (Beery), the Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (TVPS), the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R) and the Incomplete Sentences Test. Based on the tests, interviews of STUDENT's Aunt and teachers, and with "informal assessment procedures," Ms. Bailey found as follows:
Current testing using the MAT indicates that non-verbal cognitive functioning falls in the borderline range. STUDENT did have difficulty focusing and taking his time on this test so this score may be somewhat lower than ususal and I would suspect that STUDENT probably falls in the low average to below average range of ability. General information on the Peabody Individual Achievement Test, thinking and reasoning tasks on the TAPS, and oral language proficiency scores indicate that STUDENT's overall verbal skills fall in the below average to low average range of ability.
STUDENT's fine/visual motor skills on the Beery Visual Motor Integration Test are a weakness.
Overall Visual Perceptual skills fell at the 1st percentile and Auditory Perceptual skills also fell at the 1st percentile. Scores were scattered on both assessment tools with word discrimination skills falling in the average range and short term auditory memory significantly a weakness. STUDENT's difficulties are not primarily explained by poor school attendance, limited academic/school experience, environmental, cultural differences, unfamiliarity with English, emotional disturbance, visual handicap, or economic disadvantage.
The current assessment indicates that STUDENT does display a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement in reading comprehension. He displays a learning disability or processing deficit in visual perceptual and short term auditory memory along with weaknesses in attention and concentration. STUDENT also exhibits weak fine motor skills. This student meets the Federal and State Criteria for Special Education Services.
An IEP meeting was held on April 9, 1999. Goals and objectives were developed to improve STUDENT's reading comprehension, expressive and receptive language and writing skills, expressive and receptive vocabulary and his money skills. According to the IEP, STUDENT was to remain in Michael Paurowski's special day class for the remainder of the school year. Regarding mainstreaming, the IEP states that STUDENT will be integrated with the regular sixth-grade students during lunch, recess, library and "integration." It also provides that "in STUDENT's 6th grade year, he should be mainstreamed for non-academic activities." The IEP further provides that STUDENT receive speech therapy from April 12, 1999, through April 12, 2000, two times each week for thirty minutes. (Footnote 2)
STUDENT attended Michael Paurowski's special day class at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School for the remainder of the school year. Although he participated in commencement ceremony practice with the other students in the special day class, STUDENT did not participate in the commencement ceremony.
Thereafter, STUDENT attended a summer transition program at the Giannini Middle School (Giannini). STUDENT received no special education services while attending the summer transition program.
On April 5 and 7, 1999, shortly before the April 1999 IEP, STUDENT was evaluated at the University of California, San Francisco, at the request of STUDENT's guardian, AUNT. Kathleen Peters, Ed.D, and Elizabeth Dray, a psychology intern, evaluated STUDENT. Ms. Peters is an educational psychologist and assistant clinical professor at the University of California, San Francisco, Division of Behavioral and Developmental Pediatrics, a position she has held since 1986. Her primary responsibility in her present position is to conduct psycho-diagnostic evaluations of children for various clinics within the Division. In addition to a doctorate in curriculum and instruction, Ms. Peters has a master's degree in counseling and school psychology.
A majority of the tests given to STUDENT during the evaluation were administered by the intern, Ms. Dray, who also drafted the bulk of the initial report. She administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scales for Children (WISC-III), the Ravens Progressive Matrices, the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT), the Beery-Buktenica Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI) and the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT). Ms. Peters was present while Ms. Dray administered the Ravens Progressive Matrices, WRAT and the VMI. Ms. Petersen administered the Boder Test of Reading-Spelling Patterns (Boder Test), the Motor Free Visual Perception Test - Revised (MVPT-R) and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Interview Addition - Survey Form (Vineland). (Footnote 3) Ms. Petersen and Ms. Dray also utilized the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) in evaluating STUDENT. Additionally, both Ms. Drey and Ms. Peters conducted play observations and interviewed STUDENT. They also considered information submitted on a form dated January 1999 by Ms. Susan Clarke, a fifth grade regular education teacher at the Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. No teachers were interviewed. STUDENT was not observed in class. Neither Ms. Peters nor Ms. Dray observed the special day classes at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School or Giannini Middle School. (Testimony of Kathleen Peters)
Ms. Peters and Ms. Dray (hereinafter, "the evaluation team") assessed STUDENT's cognitive, academic and basic learning skills, as well as his behavior. The results of the WIAT, WRAT and Boder Test, along with "applied assessment procedures," were used to assess his academic skills. Based on these tests, the evaluation team determined that STUDENT "demonstrated significant learning capabilities." According to their initial report, his scores on WRAT suggest that STUDENT reads at a fourth grade level. The results from the Boder Test suggest that STUDENT is an excellent decoder – he was able to read all of the words on the test through the fifth grade level, missed three words at the sixth grade level and missed only eight words at the seventh grade level. To evaluate STUDENT in the area of reading comprehension – the most significant area of disagreement between the parties – the evaluation team administered the WIAT. They found that STUDENT performed in the "average range," suggesting adequate reading comprehension. The evaluation team also found that STUDENT performed at a fifth grade level in spelling and arithmetic and found that his writing skills are an area of weakness, in part, from his performance on the WIAT. They also concluded that "despite STUDENT's difficulty processing visual and auditory information, STUDENT is clearly developing academic skills" and that "although STUDENT's reading comprehension was not found to be below grade level, his listening comprehension skills also appear to be an area of weakness." (District's Exhibit No. 2)
The summary section of the evaluation team's initial report reads:
STUDENT is a sensitive, aware, and extremely resilient, eleven year old boy who is struggling with severe weaknesses in visual and auditory processing, most likely the result of a head injury he suffered at three years of age. The results of the WISC-III suggest that STUDENT has strengths in verbal reasoning, but weaknesses in more rote auditory processing. In the non-verbal area, STUDENT is also struggling with weaknesses in more rote auditory processing. In the non-verbal area, STUDENT is also struggling with weaknesses in visual sequencing, and in synthesizing visual information. STUDENT's score on the Beery demonstrates erratic motor control and weaknesses in visual processing. In addition, his performance on the MVPT further suggests weaknesses in visual processing. Despite these weaknesses in visual and auditory processing, STUDENT has developed near-grade level academic skills in all areas. In fact, his reading skills are very strong, and he is spelling at a fifth grade level. STUDENT is having difficulty developing writing skills, and will need additional support in this area
Adaptive behavior ratings, and individual interactions with STUDENT, suggest that his social skills are an area of strength for him . . . Despite severe, most likely neurologically based, weaknesses in visual and auditory processing, as well as emotional trauma, STUDENT is progressing academically, and is developing strong skills in all academic areas, though he will need additional support.
In their initial report, the evaluation team recommends that STUDENT "return to his regular education placement, with specific classroom modifications, and with additional resource services to support the development of his reading, spelling, writing and math skills." They also recommend that STUDENT receive "maximum resource specialist help" [emphasis in original] and that he "requires support in all basic school skills with special emphasis in the development of writing skills." Their initial report concludes, in pertinent part, that:
STUDENT will need additional, individual attention in the classroom, but a special day class is not an appropriate placement at this time. STUDENT can obtain individual help in the regular classroom through the support of a resource, or full inclusion, specialist or aide, who is trained in working with students with specific learning disabilities. If he is unable to obtain the individual attention, and academic support he requires in a public school, then a non-public school placement should be investigated.
The District convened an IEP meeting on June 2, 1999, to consider the initial report of Ms. Dray and Ms. Peters.
Following the IEP meeting on June 2, 1999, Ms. Peters and Ms. Dray revised several aspects of the report, including the recommendations. With regard to STUDENT's placement, the revised report no longer recommends "individual help in the regular classroom through the support of a resource, or full inclusion, specialist or aide. . . ." The revised report suggests that STUDENT may not be able to receive the support he requires in a "large, urban middle school" and that "he may progress more adequately in a non-public placement with children with average intellectual abilities who have learning disabilities." The report, however, dismisses placement in a special day class within the regular school setting because it "[cannot] meet his important emotional need to feel that he is a part of a group and that he belongs."
Additionally, the revised report recommends a special aide to assist the resource specialist in the resource room for two periods each day. It recommends that the resource room be STUDENT's home base and that the resource specialist select STUDENT's regular education teachers with an eye towards those "who are best able to accommodate special education students," that STUDENT be "graded as a special education student" and that the resource specialist help STUDENT organize his books, binder, homework assignments and classroom work on a daily basis. The report also recommends curriculum modification, modified testing, videos and books on tape, and frequent review of progress in all courses.
On June 1, 1999, the IEP team met to consider the assessment conducted by Ms. Peters and Ms. Dray. The IEP report from the June IEP meeting was attached as an addendum to the April 4, 1999 IEP and indicates that it is to be implemented from June 2, 1999, through January 2000. Under "general education participation," STUDENT is to participate in physical education and "an elective" with the regular education students from August 1999 through June 2000. After a summary of Ms. Peters and Ms. Dray's recommendations, the IEP further provides:
The IEP team disagrees with the findings in this UCSF report and agrees with Anna Lai's review of the psychological report from UCSF.
An IEP team will be convened on January 10, 1999 to:
(1) review placement (2) review elective choices (3) review progress
STUDENT's guardian refused to agree to the recommendations of District members of the IEP team. She indicated on the signature page of the IEP that she "seeks a full inclusion placement with appropriate support." (District's Exhibit No. 1)
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
The parties agree that STUDENT should be placed in the sixth grade class for the 1999-2000 school year. They also generally agree that STUDENT will receive some educational benefit if placed in a special day class.
The parties disagree as to the least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year. Petitioner argues that if STUDENT is placed in the regular sixth grade class at Giannini Middle School and receives only three resource specialist classes (math, study skills and a "push-in" language arts class), he will receive some educational benefit. Respondent argues that STUDENT will not benefit from his education unless he remains in a special day class with a low teacher-student ratio and much one-on-one instruction.FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to a obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25) (1997). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1991)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b) (1983).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
In determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the proper focus is on the adequacy of the District's placement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's proposed program reflects STUDENT's needs, provides some benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parent or guardian prefers another program, and even if the preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate program must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate placement: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comport with his IEP; and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
Is a Middle School Special Day Class Designed to meet STUDENT's Unique Needs, Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit and Does it Comport with his IEP?
The first, second and third steps are to determine if the District's proposed program, a special day class at Giannini Middle School, along with mainstreaming in physical education and one elective with the regular education students, is designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit and comports with his IEP. While the first three steps are usually examined separately, for the reasons discussed below, the first three steps will be examined together.
In the March 11, 1999 decision, Hearing Officer Fait determined that STUDENT required a small class with a small teacher-student ratio, much one-on-one instruction, a multi-sensory program and much repetition to receive educational benefit. He found that the District's proposed program was designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit and ordered the District to place STUDENT in a special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School, taught by Michael Paurowski, for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year.
The Parties agree that STUDENT should transition to Giannini Middle School for the 1999-2000, where his older brother currently attends. They also agree that the program provided by the District during the final eight weeks of the 1998-1999 school year pursuant to the hearing officer's order (i.e., the special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School) was designed to meet STUDENT's unique academic needs and that it actually provided STUDENT with some educational benefit.
Regarding prospective placement, there is general agreement between the parties that STUDENT can receive educational benefit if placed in a special day class at Giannini. Petitioner's sole witness, Kathleen Peters, testified that it is "very possible" that STUDENT could be helped with his problems in a special day class. (Footnote 4)
Andee Abramson, the District's program administrator, testified regarding the program and placement offered at Giannini Middle School. Ms. Abramson has a master's degree in early childhood development and previously taught special education classes at the elementary level for over fifteen years. She testified that the special day class mirrors the regular education program in that the students remain in the same class for four periods and attend other classes for the remainder of the day.
According to Ms. Abramson, if STUDENT is placed in the special day class, he will remain in the special day classroom for individual reading, focused math and for "adapted" science and social studies. Initially, he will be mainstreamed for one elective and for physical education. She also testified that it would be "possible" for STUDENT to be placed eventually in the special day class for three academic classes instead of four, but only after the special day class teacher assesses STUDENT. She did not testify, nor did any other witness, with regard to the specific makeup of the class, including the amount of one-on-one instruction STUDENT would receive, the teacher-student ratio, the name of the teacher and his or her qualifications, or how STUDENT's current goals and objectives could be implemented in the class. (Footnote 5)
The Hearing Officer finds that a special day class with the general characteristics of the program STUDENT attended at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School is reasonably calculated to meet STUDENT's unique needs, provide him with some educational benefit, and will comport with his April 9, 1999 IEP. This determination is based on the following: (1) the recent decision in which the Hearing Officer determined that the Robert Louis Stevenson special day class offered STUDENT a free, appropriate public education; (2) the parties agreement that STUDENT should move on to Giannini Middle School from Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School; and (3) the parties' general agreement that STUDENT will receive academic benefit if he remains in a special day class like the one at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School. The general characteristics of the Robert Louis Stevenson special day class include a small teacher-student ratio, a credentialed and experienced teacher, frequent opportunities to interact with typically developing peers and a small number of students.
Least Restrictive Environment
Special education law provides that a student such as STUDENT must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). U.S. Code § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
To determine whether a disabled child should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental services, four criteria must be considered: the educational benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aides and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom; the nonacademic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; the effect of the disabled student's presence on the teacher and the other children in the regular classroom; and the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. V. Rachel H., (Holland) 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). (Footnote 6)
The parties dispute whether STUDENT can receive some educational benefit if he is placed in the regular sixth grade classroom with appropriate aides and services. Respondent argues that even with three periods of resource specialist services, along with a one-on-one aide who would work primarily with STUDENT inside the resource room, STUDENT will fall further and further behind and not receive educational benefit. Petitioner argues that STUDENT will benefit educationally in the regular classroom with appropriate aides and services, and that the nonacademic benefits, particularly STUDENT's social and emotional strengths, should be emphasized by a regular classroom placement.
Petitioner's sole witness, Kathleen Peters, testified that STUDENT can receive educational benefit if he receives three resource specialist classes and is placed in the regular sixth grade class for the remainder of his classes. Because of the "stigma" associated with an aide, she recommends that STUDENT not have an aide in the regular classroom. Two of the resource specialist classes – math and study skills – would be provided in the resource specialist room. In the resource room, in addition to the resource specialist teacher, STUDENT would be assisted by a one-on-one aide. The third resource specialist class, language arts, is a "push in" program and is taught in the regular education program. STUDENT does not require a one-on-one aide, according to Ms. Peters, in the language-arts class. (Footnote 7) (Testimony of Kathleen Peters)
Ms. Peters testified that STUDENT could progress in the regular sixth grade class with three resource specialist classes because he has made "remarkable progress" in the past with only minimal special education support. Her opinion that STUDENT made "remarkable progress" is based in large part on STUDENT's scores on the Peabody Intermediate Achievement Test (PIAT) administered in September 1996 and again in November 1997. (District's Exhibit Nos. 6 and 9) His reading recognition score rose from 82 to 87 and his reading comprehension score rose from 67 to 75 on the PIAT, although his math score dropped during the same period. STUDENT was placed in a special day class at the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year and was removed in January 1997 at the request of his guardian. (Footnote 8) From May 1997 through November 1997, STUDENT received one hour of resource specialist services per day (excluding the summer break).
The Hearing Officer finds that, while STUDENT's PIAT scores indicate that he made some improvement, they do not reflect that STUDENT made "remarkable progress" during the period from September 1996 to November 1997. STUDENT's reading recognition scores indicate an increase from the ninth percentile to the nineteenth percentile over the period, and his reading comprehension scores reflect that he moved from the first percentile to the fifth percentile. STUDENT remained significantly below grade level in both areas. Moreover, STUDENT's improvement can also be attributed to his placement in a special day class for a significant portion of the time between tests – from September 1996 through January 1997. Additionally, the hearing officer determined in the previous hearing involving the same parties that STUDENT was not able to make appropriate progress in a regular class during the period, with or without resource specialist services during this period.
Ms. Peters also testified regarding STUDENT's reading comprehension skills, general cognitive abilities and social-emotional needs. Regarding reading comprehension, the District contends that STUDENT's reading comprehension skills are extremely poor and a major reason why STUDENT cannot receive educational benefit in the regular sixth grade classroom, even with resource specialist support. In sharp contrast, Ms. Peters found that STUDENT's reading comprehension skills were "adequate" and "at grade level" based on his performance on the reading comprehension subtest of the WIAT. Anna Lai, the District's psychologist, testified that STUDENT performance on the reading comprehension subtest of the WIAT was not an accurate measure of STUDENT's reading comprehension skills because of the manner the subtest is administered. Unlike other tests designed to measure reading comprehension skills, when the WIAT is administered, the written passage remains in front of the student while the student answers the corresponding questions. Because the student is able to refer back to the written passage while answering the questions, the memory component of reading comprehension is not tested. Ms. Lai testified that the PIAT is a more accurate measure of a student's reading comprehension skills because the passage does not remain in front of the student. STUDENT's April 1999 score on the PIAT places him below the first percentile in the area of reading comprehension. (Footnote 9)
To test STUDENT's cognitive abilities, Ms. Dray administered the WISC-III. STUDENT achieved a verbal IQ of 78 (seventh percentile), a performance IQ of 69 (second percentile) and a full-scale IQ of 71 (third percentile). Ms. Peters testified that, while STUDENT's scores were significantly low, he is likely in the "normal range" of intelligence. She testified that his low scores are likely the result of his perceptual difficulties, rather than a reflection of his cognitive abilities, and that formal testing cannot measure STUDENT's true strengths and weaknesses. She indicated that the fact that STUDENT is in the "normal" range of intelligence is made clearer through interactions and every-day conversation. Finally, Ms. Peters noted that on the "similarities" subtest of the verbal portion of the WISC-III, STUDENT scored in the fiftieth percentile and that this subtest is a "good measure" of his cognitive abilities.
Ms. Peters testified that STUDENT's social and emotional needs demand that he be placed in the regular education class. She testified that STUDENT's social skills are an area of significant strength that should be emphasized by placing him in the regular sixth grade class. According to Ms. Peters, STUDENT was "devastated" when he was removed from the regular fifth grade class and placed in Mr. Paurowski's special day class for the final eight weeks of the 1998-1999 school year.
Ms. Peters' testimony was inconsistent. The first report prepared by Ms. Peters and Ms. Dray suggests that STUDENT needs a one-on-one aide in the regular sixth grade class to benefit from his education. The revised report, prepared after the June 1999 IEP, no longer recommends an aide in the regular sixth grade class. Petitioner's counsel inquired regarding the reasons leading to that change in recommendation. Ms. Peters responded that, after considering STUDENT's self-image issues, she and Ms. Dray concluded that it would not be helpful for him "at all" to have an aide accompany him to the regular education program. Her chief concern was the stigma associated with an aide. Later, she indicated that the initial report did not recommend a one-on-one aide in the regular education program. Later, after a break in her testimony, Ms. Peters clarified her recommendation once again. She indicated that she had "always visualized the aide being in the RSP classroom," not in the regular sixth grade class. She explained that it was her intern, Ms. Dray, who likely changed her position with regard to whether STUDENT requires an aide in the regular classroom.
All of the District's witnesses testified, as the hearing officer found in the previous hearing, that STUDENT cannot progress in the regular education program, even with resource specialist services. Anna Lai, the school psychologist, testified that there was "nothing new" in the report prepared by Ms. Dray and Ms. Peters. She testified that STUDENT's deficiencies have been consistently diagnosed in the areas of visual processing, auditory processing, reading comprehension, written expression, as well as math problem solving and other memory-related problems. Ms. Lai also emphasized that classroom observations, or, at the very least, communications with STUDENT's teachers regarding their day-to-day observations of STUDENT, are necessary to get a complete picture of his difficulties. She testified that when STUDENT transitions to the sixth grade, his deficiencies will become more apparent because the curriculum requires more abstract and high-order thinking.
Laura Keenan, the District's speech pathologist, evaluated STUDENT in March of 1999. She provided speech and language services to STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year. She testified that, based upon his March evaluation, STUDENT would be eligible for special education solely because of his language deficits. She testified that his language deficits have actually increased, and opined that STUDENT cannot comprehend or process oral language. He is unable to keep oral language in his memory. He also cannot understand the vocabulary that is used in the classroom. Ms. Keenan recommended that every lesson should be modified for STUDENT because he requires shorter lessons, repetition and one-on-one support.
Margaret Englesbe is a resource specialist program teacher at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School and an early literacy intervention teacher. She has worked with STUDENT in the past for a total of approximately one school year. Ms. Englesbe testified that STUDENT is not performing at or near grade level in any subject. She indicated that while STUDENT is a "good decoder," there is a "huge discrepancy" between his oral reading skills and his reading comprehension skills. Because his comprehension is so poor, STUDENT cannot be a member of a regular class, according to Ms. Englesbe. She recommends that STUDENT be placed in a special day class, that he be monitored by at least two adults every day, and that he receive intensive one-on-one assistance.
Susan Clarke was STUDENT's fifth grade regular education teacher. She taught him from September 1998 until March 1999. She testified that STUDENT was reticent about speaking in class, was not at grade level in any subject, and that while he was good decoder, his reading comprehension was poor. She also observed that he had difficulty organizing his thoughts and difficulty retaining what he had been taught from day to day.
Michael Paurowski was STUDENT's special day class teacher for the final eight weeks of the 1998-1999 school year. Mr. Paurowski, who presented as an excellent witness, has a bachelor's degree in elementary education and a master's degree in special education. He testified that three periods of resource specialist services for the 1999-2000 school year would not be sufficient to meet STUDENT's educational needs. STUDENT needs much small-group and one-on-one assistance, along with daily reinforcement, according to Mr. Paurowski. He agreed that STUDENT is an excellent decoder, but noted that his reading comprehension skills are low – he estimated that there is a three to four and one half year discrepancy between STUDENT's decoding and comprehension skills. He also said that, academically, STUDENT fit well in his class, never appeared to be bored, and that STUDENT was not the highest functioning pupil in the class. (Footnote 10)
Mr. Paurowski testified that, with regard to STUDENT's interactions with the other special day class students, he initially kept to himself. However, after the first couple of weeks, STUDENT began to socialize with the other students in his class, and actually preferred to eat and play with them instead of the regular education students. Additionally, towards the end of the school year, STUDENT told Mr. Paurowski he wished that he could stay in his class, but that he understood he could not. He told Mr. Paurowski that he would continue to visit, and for the first two weeks of summer, he stopped by every day.
Andee Abramson, the District's program specialist, observed STUDENT for one hour at the summer transition program at Giannini Middle School. Ms. Abramson has a master's degree in special education with emphasis on early childhood special education. She taught elementary education classes for fifteen years prior to her present position. She talked briefly with STUDENT's teacher at the transition program at Giannini. The teacher told Ms. Abramson that STUDENT was falling through the cracks and that, although she did not know that STUDENT was a special education student, she was not surprised. (Testimony of Andee Abramson)
The weight of the evidence supports the fact that if STUDENT were placed in the regular sixth grade class with three resource specialist classes at this time, he would not receive educational benefit. First, as the hearing officer recently found in the previous hearing, the evidence supports the fact that STUDENT did not make progress in the past with support of resource specialist services. Second, the Hearing Officer finds that it is significant that neither Ms. Dray nor Ms. Peters spoke to STUDENT's former or current teachers or observed STUDENT in his current educational placement prior to preparing their report. (Footnote 11) Third, as noted above, Ms. Peters' testimony regarding STUDENT's current level of functioning in the area of reading comprehension was not persuasive and not supported by the evidence. Her opinion was based on a single subtest of the WIAT, which she admitted fails to encompass STUDENT's working memory deficits because the written passage remains in front of him during the answer portion of the test. Fourth, Ms. Peters' testimony that STUDENT is currently at or below grade level in various subjects was not persuasive and not supported by the evidence. Her opinion differed significantly from that of every other witness who has worked with STUDENT over the past several years and, as noted above, she failed to consult STUDENT's teachers. Fifth, as noted above, Ms. Peters' testimony was inconsistent. Moreover, every other witness testified that STUDENT cannot benefit from placement in the regular sixth grade classroom at this time because of his need for intense one-on-one assistance, modified lessons and repetition in nearly every academic area.
STUDENT's social skills are an area of strength that should be emphasized. However, the nonacademic benefits STUDENT might reap in the regular sixth grade classroom with resource specialist services would be moot if STUDENT received no academic benefits in the regular classroom and, as a result, fell further and further behind his peers academically. Additionally, the nonacademic benefits of Petitioner's proposed placement, which includes two classes taught in the resource room and a third "push-in" resource class, are only marginally greater than those of Respondent's proposed special day class, which includes four classes taught in the special day class and mainstreaming for one elective and physical education.
Ms. Peters's testimony that a special day class cannot meet STUDENT's emotional needs, including "the need to feel that he is part of a group and that he belongs," is not supported by any evidence. She also testified that STUDENT was "devastated" by being placed in a special day class at the end of the 1998-1999 school year. No other witness observed this devastation. In fact, according to Mr. Paurowski and others, STUDENT continued to visit the special day class for the first two weeks of summer, long after he was obligated to attend. STUDENT also preferred to play and eat with the other special day class students during school. In sum, the principal nonacademic benefit of placement in the regular sixth grade class for up to three periods a day (i.e., emphasis on and nurturing of STUDENT's social skills and his need to feel part of a group) is only marginally greater and does not support his placement in an environment where he will not progress academically.
Based on all of the documentary evidence and testimony, and in large part, the credibility of the various witnesses, the Hearing Officer finds that Respondent has shown by a preponderance of the evidence that the special day class is the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT can receive some educational benefit at this time.
ORDER
(1) Respondent shall convene an IEP team meeting within 10 days to develop an IEP for the 1999-2000 school year. The IEP shall conform to this order.
(2) Respondent shall provide a program at Giannini Middle School with the general characteristics of Michael Paurowski's special day class at Robert Louis Stevenson Elementary School for the 1999-2000 school year. The special day class shall be taught by a credentialed and experienced special education teacher and shall provide opportunity for one-on-one instruction as needed and a small teacher-student ratio. STUDENT shall attend the special day class for no more than four periods daily. He shall receive math, reading science and social studies in the special day class. He shall be mainstreamed for physical education and one elective (the elective will rotate every nine weeks) as well as for assemblies and other appropriate activities.
(3) No later than one month prior to the end of the first semester of the1999-2000 school year, Respondent shall convene a second IEP meeting to determine if STUDENT's program should be adjusted to include additional mainstreaming during the second semester.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Has the District offered STUDENT a placement for the 1999-2000 school year which will enable him to a obtain a free, appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment? -Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(j).
DATED: September 13, 1999 _________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issue listed here differs from those noticed by Petitioner prior to the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, and to reflect the discussion held the first day of the hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer with regard to the issues for hearing, as well as the testimony of the witnesses over both hearing days.
2. The speech and language services offered (and currently provided) by the District are not at issue in this hearing.
3. Only STUDENT's guardian, Ms. AUNT, was interviewed during the administration of the Vineland.
4. Petitioner conceded in his opening statement and in his closing brief that a "special day class might provide STUDENT with some educational benefit" but that neither Mr. Paurowski's special day class nor the special day class at Giannini Middle School will meet STUDENT's unique social and emotional needs, and thus, the District has not offered STUDENT a free and appropriate public education. STUDENT's social and emotional needs will be examined under the fourth step of the test – whether the Giannini Middle School special day class is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
5. The appropriateness of STUDENT's goals and objectives, listed in the IEP dated April 9, 1999, are not in dispute.
6. The appropriateness of STUDENT's goals and objectives, listed in the IEP dated April 9, 1999, are not in dispute.
7. Initially, Ms. Peters testified that STUDENT should have two periods of resource specialist classes and that she would be "willing to talk about three." Later in her testimony, after she learned that there would be a language-arts "push-in" resource specialist class at Giannini during the 1999-2000 school year, she recommended three resource specialist classes.
8. In his closing brief, Petitioner argues that STUDENT attended the special day class for only "one month" at the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year. However, the stipulated background facts indicate that STUDENT was placed in a special day class at Lawton Elementary School at the beginning of the 1996-97 school year and was removed by his guardian in January 1997.
9. The District administered the PIAT to STUDENT on April 6, 1999.
10. Ms. Peters testified that STUDENT's guardian and STUDENT told her that STUDENT was bored with the special day class because the course work was too easy.
11. Ms. Peters testified that the teachers' input, as well as observations in the classroom, are important.
