California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 6, 2000
Student v. Clovis Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 858-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Hearing Officer finds no authority to order Clovis Unified to let a student with a disability walk at graduation.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
A tentative decision granting the District's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction was issued on the hearing date, June 6, 2000. This written decision followed on July 6, 2000.
Summary
An 18-year-old senior eligible for special education under specific learning disability requested an expedited hearing against Clovis Unified School District. He disputed a manifestation determination that his March 2000 conduct was not caused by his disability. The District had recommended expulsion and also took away his "senior privileges," including walking at graduation. On May 25, 2000, the District withdrew the expulsion recommendation and returned him to Clovis High School under his November 1999 IEP. It kept the loss of senior privileges in place. The student had completed all diploma requirements, and the only relief he sought was to take part in the graduation ceremony on the evening of the June 6 hearing.
Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard issued a tentative ruling that day and a written decision later. She found the student had been suspended only five school days, March 27–31, 2000. He and his mother had agreed to the temporary independent study placement. Because the suspension was under ten school days, it was not a disciplinary change of placement. Losing senior privileges did not change the facilities, staff, location, or equipment in his IEP. His behavior support plan already listed school activity privileges as a reinforcement tool. She also found the family had enough notice through the student handbook, a senior activities pamphlet, and senior class meetings. She ruled she had no authority to order the remedy and denied relief. The District prevailed.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a lost graduation ceremony as a lesser disciplinary sanction rather than a change of placement. In this case, the suspension totaled fewer than ten school days, and the student's IEP and behavior support plan allowed privileges to be restricted. The Hearing Officer separated the diploma, which is a change of placement, from the ceremony.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDiscipline
Issue 1. Whether the District's continued withholding of Student's "senior privileges," including his right to participate in the graduation ceremony, after it rescinded its expulsion recommendation, constituted a change in placement or a denial of a free appropriate public education.
Student was suspended only five school days, losing senior privileges did not change his specific educational placement or conflict with his IEP, and the Hearing Office lacked authority to order him into the graduation ceremony.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's request for relief (participation in the June 6, 2000 graduation ceremony) denied.
Key authorities
Student v. Novato Unified School District (1995) 22 IDELR 1056; Robert H. v. Nixa R-2 School District, 26 IDELR 564 (W.D. Mo. 1997); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k); 34 C.F.R. § 300.519; 34 C.F.R. § 300.122(a)(3); Education Code § 48911; Education Code § 48915.5; 5 C.C.R. § 3042; SN 449-00; SN 1357-97; SN 754-98
People named in the decision
- Janet Van Gelder, SELPA director, Clovis Unified School District
- Steven D. Ward, deputy principal, District witness, Clovis High School
- Richard Lee Watson, learning director, District witness, Oxford College within Clovis High School
- Mr. Logan, school psychologist, Clovis Unified School District
- Ms. Taff, case manager overseeing independent study, Clovis Unified School District
- Dr. Rogers, principal, Clovis High School
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 858-00 Case Year: 2000 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 10-62117 District: Clovis Unified Disability Type:
Case Details This matter was heard on June 6, 2000, in Clovis, California, before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer with the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter referred to as Petitioner or STUDENT) was present and was represented by attorney Harry M. Drandell.(Footnote 1) Also present on Petitioner's behalf was his father,
STUDENT'S FATHER.
Respondent Clovis Unified School District (hereafter referred to as Respondent or the District) was represented by attorney Ivette Pena. Also present on the District's behalf was SELPA director Janet Van Gelder.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: STUDENT and STUDENT'S FATHER.
Respondent called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Steven D. Ward, deputy principal of Clovis High School, and Richard Lee Watson, learning director at Oxford College within Clovis High School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the end of the hearing, the parties made oral closing arguments and the record was closed. The remedy Petitioner sought was to be allowed to participate in the senior class graduation ceremony scheduled to occur on the evening of June 6, 2000. Due to the time constraints involved, the Hearing Officer issued a tentative decision granting the District's motion to dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction, with this written decision to follow. While lack of jurisdiction was the general basis for the tentative decision, this memorandum of decision addresses the issue in terms of the Hearing Officer's authority to award Petitioner the remedy he sought.
ISSUE
The sole issue presented was whether the District's continued withholding of STUDENT'S "senior privileges," including his right to participate in the graduation ceremony, after it rescinded its expulsion recommendation, constituted a change in placement or a denial of a free appropriate public education.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On May 5, 2000, the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) received Petitioner's request for an expedited due process hearing, based upon his disagreement with the District's manifestation determination. A copy of an individualized educational program (IEP) manifestation determination dated April 28, 2000, was provided in support of his request.
This IEP indicated that STUDENT was alleged to have violated Education Code § 48900 (k), in that he disrupted school activities, willfully disregarded the valid authority of school officials and attempted to incite a riot. It was also alleged that, pursuant to Education Code § 48915(e)(2), due to the nature of the violation, STUDENT'S presence at school caused a continuing danger to the physical safety of himself or others. Expulsion was recommended.
At the manifestation determination, all IEP team members agreed that, in relation to STUDENT'S behavior, the IEP and placement were appropriate and that the IEP services and behavior intervention strategies were implemented. The District members of the IEP team further concluded that STUDENT'S disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior. Under this finding, the IEP notes indicated that "student's anticipated behavior was discussed prior to incident with administrative staff. Appropriate options were presented to him. STUDENT chose to proceed with the incident." The District IEP team members also concluded that STUDENT'S disability did not impair his ability to control his behavior. Under this finding, the IEP notes indicated that "student's actions appeared to be deliberate and planned." STUDENT specifically disagreed with these two findings and with the overall finding that his behavior was not a manifestation of his disability.
An expedited hearing was scheduled for June 6 -7, 2000.
On June 2, 2000, the Hearing Office received the District's motion to dismiss the case. The District noted that STUDENT is a student who is receiving special education due to a specific learning disability. The District alleged that on Friday, March 24, 2000, STUDENT was suspended for five days. His total suspensions were alleged to be less than ten school days in the current school year. Following this suspension, several IEP meetings were convened.(Footnote 2) At the April 3, 2000 IEP meeting, both STUDENT and his mother agreed to a change in placement to site-based independent study. At the April 28, 2000 IEP meeting, all IEP team members except STUDENT found that his alleged behavior was not a manifestation of his disability.
The District alleged that, in addition to the proposed expulsion, it also suspended STUDENT'S "senior privileges," which included his ability to participate in the graduation ceremony. On May 25, 2000, the District rescinded its recommendation for STUDENT'S expulsion. A copy of the letter was filed in support of its motion (Exhibit 1). In it, STUDENT was advised that he could return to Clovis High School on May 30, 2000, pursuant to his IEP of November 5, 1999. The letter concluded that "the decision of the IEP team regarding the manifestation determination issues are no longer relevant." The District continued to withhold STUDENT'S senior privileges. According to the District, STUDENT'S parents were asked to dismiss the pending hearing, but declined to do so because they wanted STUDENT to participate in the graduation ceremony. The District represented that STUDENT has completed all the requirements for his Clovis High School diploma and would receive his diploma.
The District urged that the case be dismissed as moot, based upon its rescission of the expulsion recommendation, its reinstatement of STUDENT to his pre-discipline placement, and the absence of any current issue as to the District's original manifestation determination.(Footnote 2) It also asserted that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to address the senior privileges issues. While STUDENT'S discipline involved a five-day suspension and a loss of senior privileges, his total suspensions for the school year were under ten days.
On June 2, 2000, the Hearing Office received Petitioner's response to the motion to dismiss. Petitioner conceded that the senior privileges issue may be outside the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. In this case, he would not oppose the dismissal. Nonetheless, Petitioner stated that he wished to be heard on the issue of senior privileges, i.e., his ability to attend the graduation ceremony, if this issue is within the Hearing Office's jurisdiction.
On June 5, 2000, in a minute order, the Hearing Office denied the District's motion to dismiss the case. Neither that motion, nor Petitioner's opposition to the motion, was supported by declarations under penalty of perjury. Based upon the absence of sworn testimony and the severity of the sanction of dismissal, the Hearing Office ordered that "the parties should be prepared to present evidence and legal argument on whether the District's continued withholding of Petitioner's "senior privileges," including his right to participate in the graduation ceremony on the evening of June 6, 2000, constitutes a change in placement or a denial of a free appropriate public education."
At the outset of the due process hearing, the District renewed its motion to dismiss the case for lack of jurisdiction. This motion was taken under submission pending receipt of evidence. During the hearing, neither Petitioner nor Respondent presented evidence about the underlying facts which led to STUDENT'S suspension and loss of senior privileges.
Relevant Testimony a. Total Days Suspended During 1999-2000
Petitioner declined to stipulate that his total suspensions for the 1999-2000 academic year were fewer than ten days. STUDENT testified that he did not know the exact number of days of his suspension. On March 24, 2000, Mr. Watson told him he was suspended until further notice. STUDENT believed that he was suspended from the afternoon of the March 24, 2000 until he was allowed to return to the Clovis High School campus on Tuesday, May 30, 2000. He conceded that he was on independent study pursuant to the IEP of April 3, 2000. (District Ex. 3). STUDENT'S FATHER, STUDENT'S father, testified that STUDENT'S mother had participated in the IEP meeting of April 3,
2000. He acknowledged that the agreed-upon placement was independent study. STUDENT'S FATHER expressed his opinion that STUDENThad in fact been expelled and not suspended, because STUDENT was not allowed on campus until recently to turn in his senior materials and finals.
Mr. Ward, the deputy principal at Clovis High School, testified that STUDENT had been suspended for a total of five days during the school year. These dates were Monday, March 27, 2000, through Friday, March 31, 2000. (District Ex. 8)(Footnote 4) According to Mr. Ward, STUDENT was not suspended on Friday, March 24, 2000, the afternoon of the alleged incident. STUDENT was removed from the campus by the police at approximately the lunch hour. Mr. Ward testified that suspension days which involve police action do not start until the student is released by the police. After a student's release, he or she must miss four full class periods before it will be considered a full- day suspension. For this reason, the District did not include March 24, 2000 as a suspension day for
STUDENT.
Mr. Watson, the learning director of Clovis High School's Oxford College, also testified that STUDENThas been suspended a total of five days during the 1999-2000 school year, from Monday, March 27, 2000, through Friday, March 31, 2000. STUDENT began independent study on Monday, April 3, 2000, and remained on independent study until his return to Clovis High School on Tuesday, May 30, 2000. Mr. Watson reiterated the policy outlined by Mr. Ward on how suspension days were calculated. He conceded, however, that STUDENT was not in good standing on March 24, 2000.
b. District's Senior Privileges Policy
The District submitted evidence of its senior privileges policy, both generally and as it applied to STUDENT. According to Mr. Ward, the senior privileges policy is derived from School Board policy granting schools the ability to prohibit a student's participation in co-curricular activities outside the classroom based on the student's behavior. Typically, anyone who commits a suspendable offense automatically goes on nonprivilege status. Nonprivilege status is a broad term which encompasses senior activities. Ten days of nonprivilege after a student is off suspension is the general punishment, but the District has the authority to deny participation in any noneducational activity beyond the ten days depending upon the type of behavior involved.
District witnesses testified that seniors were advised about the policy in three ways: (1) through the District's Student/Parent Handbook for 1999-2000 which was provided to all students and parents (District Ex. 1); (2) through the Clovis High School Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet which was handed out and mailed to all seniors (District Ex. 2); and (3) through a series of senior class meetings (District Ex. 5).
Mr. Ward testified that the District's Student/Parent Handbook for 1999-2000, under "Student's Rights and Responsibilities ±Rights and Regulations," provides "students are expected to observe high standards of good conduct, to have respect for the property of others, and to comply with the regulations of the school. Failure to observe these rules can result in confiscation of materials, curtailment of privileges, or when necessary, disciplinary actions, including suspension and/or recommendation for expulsion" (District Ex. 1, bold in original). School Board Policy provides that, in addition to major disciplinary consequences, "other means of correction may include, but are not limited to, ... restriction of activities." Mr. Ward testified that restriction of activities means a nonprivilege status during which the student is not allowed to participate in co- curricular activities. This could be for a single activity or for a period of time. Examples of restrictions included exclusion from athletic events, nongraded field trips, dances, or commencement ceremonies.
Mr. Ward also testified that the Clovis High School Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet includes the graduation ceremony within senior activities. The pamphlet advised seniors that inappropriate behavior may result in exclusion from some, or all, senior activities. (District Ex. 2)
Seniors were also informed of the expectations for their behavior in a series of meetings throughout the year. According to Mr. Ward, at the initial senior meeting of September 3, 1999, seniors were advised of ways they may not be allowed to participate in graduation. Behavioral expectations and consequences, including possible nonparticipation in graduation ceremony, were mentioned in each subsequent senior meeting. At the senior meeting of March 10, 2000, the Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet was handed out to all seniors and then mailed home on March 15, 2000.
c. STUDENT'S Knowledge of Senior Privileges Policy
District witnesses testified that STUDENT had been involved in two Board Hearings during the 1999- 2000 school year, due to his behavior. One occurred in the fall of 1999 and the second occurred in early February 2000. According to Mr. Ward, the Board for these hearings is composed of the deputy principal, the learning director and the coach or activities director of the activity in which the student is involved. Progressive discipline is employed. The Board determines the status of the student's continuing participation in the activity based upon the behavioral incident. STUDENT was involved in both soccer and student government. Following the second hearing in February 2000, the Board determined that STUDENT could no longer continue to participate in soccer or in student government.
Mr. Watson testified that he was involved in the development of a behavior support plan for STUDENT on October 27, 1999. STUDENT was present at this meeting. According to Mr. Watson, the use of privileges was discussed. STUDENT'S MOTHER had asked the team to remove STUDENT'S off-campus lunch privileges due to behavior concerns. The team discussed that STUDENT'S privileges to participate in co-curricular activities could be removed if his behavior problems continued. They also discussed that, with appropriate behaviors, STUDENT'S privileges could be regained. The Behavior Support Plan dated October 27, 1999, includes "school activity privileges" under the heading "reinforcement procedures." (District Ex. 10) Mr. Watson agreed that the term "senior privileges" was not used. The behavior support plan was attached to STUDENT'S IEP of November 5, 1999, as modified by the IEP of April 3, 2000, changing STUDENT'S placement to independent study. (District Ex. 3) The IEP team agreed that "relevant disciplinary procedures applicable to students without disabilities should be applied" to STUDENT in the same manner. (District Ex. 3) This IEP was signed by STUDENT and STUDENT'S MOTHER.
Both STUDENT'S FATHER and STUDENT testified that they signed an acknowledgment card which indicated they had read the Student/Parent Handbook and understood the regulations regarding student behavior. (District's Ex. 4) STUDENT testified that he had seen the Clovis High School Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet (District Ex. 2) but did not recall whether he received it or read it. STUDENT testified that he did not remember being told at any of his disciplinary conferences that he could lose his senior privileges based upon his behavior. STUDENT'S FATHER testified that he understood generally that privileges could be lost based on behavior but that he was never informed at any conferences he attended that senior privileges could be lost as a result of misconduct. While STUDENT was not present at the last four senior meetings, no evidence was presented that he did not attend the first three senior meetings. (District Ex. 5)
d. Denial of Senior Privileges
According to Mr. Ward, the initial decision to deny STUDENT'S senior privileges occurred on March 27, 2000, at the time of his referral for expulsion. Privileges are automatically suspended at the time of referral for expulsion. On March 28, 2000, Mr. Watson mailed a letter to STUDENT'S parents advising them of STUDENT'S suspension and indicating that, during this time, STUDENT was not to be on or around campus or to attend any school functions either on or off campus. (District's Ex. 9)
On April 3, 2000, an IEP meeting was convened. Both STUDENT and his mother signed their agreement to a change in placement to "site-based independent study." The IEP indicated that this was a "temporary placement to be in effect until conclusion of manifestation determination proceedings." (District's Ex. 3) Mr. Watson testified that, while STUDENT was on independent study, he came to the Clovis High School campus possibly one to two times each week to test, to meet with a teacher or to pick up work. He believed that STUDENT came to campus when someone from the District arranged it, but he was not sure what the limitations were on STUDENT'S ability to come onto the campus.
On May 10, 2000, a meeting was held with Mr. Ward, STUDENT'S attorney Mr. Drandell, school psychologist Mr. Logan, STUDENT'S FATHER and STUDENT. Mr. Ward testified that, at that meeting, proposals and counter-proposals for settlement were made. The District maintained its position that STUDENT would receive a Clovis High School diploma, but would not be allowed to participate in senior activities. The Student and his father rejected this offer.
Mr. Ward testified that on May 25, 2000, he mailed a letter to STUDENT informing him that the expulsion recommendation had been rescinded and that he could return to Clovis High School on May 30, 2000.(Footnote 5) The letter did not include any discussion of senior privileges. (Petitioner's Ex. 1) According to Mr. Ward, the purpose of this letter was simply to inform STUDENT of the decision not to proceed with expulsion. It was not intended to reduce other discipline imposed. Mr. Ward testified that he and Clovis High School Principal Dr. Rogers made the decision that this aspect of the discipline would still be enforced after the expulsion was rescinded. This position was similar to what he had told STUDENT and STUDENT'S FATHER at the May 10, 2000 meeting. Mr. Ward then spoke to STUDENT'S MOTHER by telephone twice on May 25, 2000, to let STUDENT know that he could return on May 30, 2000, but that he would not be allowed to attend the graduation ceremony or to participate in any other senior privileges. Mr. Ward testified that he spoke to STUDENT on May 26, 2000, and told him the same thing. STUDENT shook his hand and said "that's fine." On May 30, 2000, STUDENT met with both Mr. Ward and Mr. Watson, and the senior privilege issue was again reviewed. Mr. Watson testified that STUDENT was told he could get his Clovis High School diploma if he finished all his academic requirements, but that senior activities were not included. STUDENT was advised that he could pick up his diploma on Wednesday, June 7, 2000, if he met the graduation requirements. Both Mr. Ward and Mr. Watson testified that STUDENT has completed all graduation requirements. He only needed to turn in his senior check-out form.
On cross-examination, Mr. Ward testified that there are no pre-revocation procedures to give a student an opportunity to be heard on the loss of senior privileges. Notice of the potential for the loss of these privileges is provided by the Handbook and the Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet. Senior privileges can be revoked at any time, even up to the night of graduation. Depending on the timing, a due process "conference" is held to allow the parent or student to express his or her side of the issue. Mr. Ward stated that STUDENT had an opportunity to discuss the loss of senior privileges at the initial post-suspension meeting of March 27, 2000. Mr. Ward was not present at this meeting. Mr. Ward also testified that STUDENT had an opportunity to discuss the continued loss of senior privileges at the meeting of May 30, 2000, but that he did not raise the issue. He conceded that both STUDENT and STUDENT'S FATHER objected to this at the May 10, 2000 meeting with the District and their attorney.
On rebuttal, STUDENT testified that he was not advised on either March 27, 2000, or May 30, 2000, that he would lose senior privileges. He did hear from his mother on May 25, 2000, that he could not participate in graduation. At the meeting of May 10, 2000, both he and his father said how much they wanted him to participate in the graduation ceremony. On May 30, 2000, the majority of the meeting was spent discussing another issue STUDENT had about the return of a skateboard.
DISCUSSION
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). Special education includes instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings, and instruction in physical education. Id. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Education Code § 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program."
Both federal and State law provide procedures and standards for imposing discipline on a disabled student. These standards and procedures are not fully consistent. Generally, special education students in California are subject to discipline in accordance with federal special education due process requirements and the California Education Code. See: Education Code § 48915.5(b). Where California law is more protective of students than the federal law, the Hearing Office has consistently held that California law controls. (See: SN 449-00, SN 1357-97, SN 754-98)
The IDEA requires that, if disciplinary action is contemplated for a student with a disability which involves a change of placement for more than ten school days, no "later than 10 school days after the date on which the decision to take that action is made, a review shall be conducted of the relationship between the child's disability and the behavior subject to the disciplinary action." 20 U. S. C. § 1415(k)(4)(A)(ii)(1997). This review is to be conducted by the IEP team and "other qualified personnel." The persons conducting the review are required to review all relevant information. This includes evaluation and diagnostic results, other relevant information supplied by the parents, an observation of the child and the child's IEP and placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k) (4)(c)(1).
If, in conducting the review, the team determines that the behavior which is the subject of the discipline was not a manifestation of his/her disability, the disabled student may be disciplined in the same way as a nondisabled student. In order to conclude that the behavior was not a manifestation of the child's disability, the team must determine (a) that, in relationship to the behavior subject to disciplinary action, the IEP and placement were appropriate and the special education services, supplementary aids and services, and behavior intervention strategies were provided consistent with the IEP and placement, (b) that the disability did not impair the student's ability to understand the impact and consequences of the behavior subject to disciplinary action, and (c) that the disability did not impair the student's ability to control the behavior subject to disciplinary action. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(4) and (5) (1997). If the review team makes all of the above determinations, the special education student may be expelled in the same manner as a nondisabled student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(5)(A)(1997); 34 C.F.R. § 300.524. However, if any of the above standards are not met, the student's behavior must be considered a manifestation of his disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.523(d). If the review of the above standards result in a determination that the IEP was deficient, the IEP team "must take immediate steps to remedy those deficiencies." 34 C.F.R. § 523(f).
Under California law, expulsion cannot be ordered unless the IEP team determines that the disabled student's "conduct was not caused by, or was not a direct manifestation of, the pupil's identified disability" and that "the pupil had been appropriately placed at the time the misconduct occurred." Education Code § 48915.5(a)(2) and (3).
Jurisdiction
Under the IDEA and California special education law, due process hearing procedures may be initiated by the parent(Footnote 6) and the public education agency where there is a proposal or a refusal "to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child," or where the parent refuses to consent to the assessment of the child. 20 U. S. C. § 1415 (f), Education Code § 56501 (a). In the disciplinary arena, if a parent disagrees with a determination that the child's behavior was not a manifestation of his or her disability or with any decision regarding placement, the parent may request a hearing and an expedited hearing must be scheduled. 20 U. S. C. §1415 (k)(6)(A), Education Code § 48915.5(g). The Hearing Office has jurisdiction over matters falling within the parameters of these statutes. For expedited hearings, the issues are limited to a review of the procedures used in making manifestation determinations pursuant to 34 Code of Federal Regulations §§ 300.523 through 300.528. It is generally not within the Hearing Office's jurisdiction to determine other issues such as whether the alleged conduct occurred or whether the proposed discipline is appropriate.
Petitioner's request for a due process hearing related solely to his disagreement with the District's manifestation determination.(Footnote 7) However, as a result of the District's May 25, 2000 rescission of its recommendation for expulsion, there was no longer a contested issue relating to the manifestation determination.(Footnote 8) The sole argument raised by Petitioner at the hearing was in response to the minute order of June 5, 2000, denying the motion to dismiss. STUDENT argued a "change in placement" had occurred when the District rescinded its expulsion recommendation yet retained the withholding of senior privileges and, in particular, the right to participate in the graduation ceremony.
Whenever the issue of a special education student's placement is raised, the Hearing Office has jurisdiction. In this case, an evidentiary hearing was required to determine the factual basis of Petitioner's assertion that a change in placement had occurred. Accordingly, the proper inquiry is whether the Hearing Office has the authority to grant the remedy Petitioner requested.
Authority to Grant Remedy
Graduation, as opposed to the ceremony of graduation, constitutes a change of placement. 34 C.F.R. § 300.122 (a)(3). The Hearing Office has long recognized that "the award of a diploma to a student with a disability has significant consequences. Whereas prior to graduation the student is entitled to receive a multitude of services from one central source (the school district), after graduation the student is responsible for identifying and establishing eligibility for appropriate services from a potentially vast array of adult agencies. Because graduation constitutes a change in placement, a school district seeking to award a diploma must notify the parent of the intent to award a diploma and confirm that the student has completed his IEP criteria for graduation." Student v. Novato Unified School District (1995) 22 IDELR 1056. In this case, STUDENT did not contest that he had completed the requirements for graduation and would receive a regular diploma from Clovis High School. No issues were raised and no evidence was presented about the merits of STUDENT'S graduation. As previously noted, such issues would not be appropriate for an expedited hearing.
The Hearing Officer concludes that, in this case, the Hearing Office does not have the authority to grant the remedy sought of ordering STUDENT'S participation in the graduation ceremony. The disciplinary action did not affect a change of placement which would call into play the procedural protections of the statutes and regulations pertaining to manifestation determinations. Under California special education law, an individual with exceptional needs may be suspended for up to, but not more than 10 consecutive school days if he or she poses an immediate threat to the safety of himself or to others. A suspension may exceed 10 consecutive school days, or the pupil's placement may be changed, or both, only if the pupil's parent agrees or if a court order authorizes this action. Education Code § 48911 (h).(Footnote 9)
Evidence was taken on the suspension issue. Petitioner attempted to establish that he had actually been suspended on the afternoon of Friday, March 24, 2000. While it is possible that partial day suspensions may cumulate to exceed 10 consecutive school days (See, 34 C.F.R. § 300.519(b)), there was no evidence that STUDENT experienced additional suspensions during the 1999-2000 school year. Although both STUDENT and his father believed that STUDENT'S removal from campus was a suspension (if not an expulsion), the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had only been suspended for 5 days during the academic year 1999-2000. That suspension extended from Monday, March 27, 2000, through Friday, March 31, 2000. On April 3, 2000, following the suspension, an IEP was signed by both STUDENT and his mother placing STUDENT in independent study. Petitioner did not dispute this agreed- upon placement.(Footnote 10)
Testimony of District witnesses indicated that, when the decision was made to rescind the recommendation for STUDENT'S expulsion, the decision was also made to continue to suspend STUDENT'S senior privileges. Petitioner argues that, because the rescission did not also remove the suspension of senior privileges, he was not returned to his status prior to the disciplinary action. As a result, according to Petitioner, a change in placement occurred.
As indicated above, however, under both California and federal law, the District was authorized to suspend STUDENT for up to ten school days. The law does not regulate lesser disciplinary sanctions which a school may impose where the total period of suspension is under ten school days.(Footnote 11) Furthermore, there was no change in STUDENT'S specific special education placement occasioned by the loss of his senior privileges. California law defines a "specific educational placement" as "that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program, in any one or a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings." 5 California Code of Regulations § 3042. Petitioner offered no evidence that the District's withholding of STUDENT'S privilege to participate in the graduation ceremony altered "facilities, personnel, location or equipment" required for his instructional services. The evidence presented indicated that the withholding of these privileges did not conflict with
STUDENT'S IEP.
At the time STUDENT'S privileges were suspended and he was referred for expulsion, the IEP of November 5, 1999 was in effect. The IEP indicated that STUDENT'S specific learning disability was based upon a significant discrepancy between his cognitive ability and his academic functioning in written language due to language and auditory processing deficits. STUDENT was receiving services from the resource specialist program. Under "discipline and behavior," the IEP team agreed that STUDENT'S disability did not interfere with his ability to understand and follow school rules. The IEP team also agreed that relevant disciplinary procedures applicable to students without disabilities should be applied to him in the same manner. On November 5, 1999, a behavior support plan dated October 27, 1999 was incorporated into the IEP. This behavior plan indicated that "school activity privileges" are within the types of reinforcement procedures to be used. If new behaviors emerged, then STUDENT would be able to go to school activities. STUDENT'S individual transition plan (ITP) did reference participation in co-curricular activities under the community experience component of his ITP. This provision, however, must be read in context of the whole IEP, including the behavior support plan. These provisions were not altered by the April 3, 2000 IEP which changed STUDENT'S placement.
It is clear that the IEP team, which included STUDENT and his parents, contemplated the use of restrictions in privileges to deal with STUDENT'S less serious behavioral problems. STUDENT did not contest the IEP or the general use of these disciplinary techniques. In fact, he agreed with the District members of the IEP team that, at the time of the behavior, the IEP and placement were appropriate and the IEP services and behavior intervention strategies were implemented. The Hearing Officer finds that the use of restrictions in privileges, including the loss of senior privileges, did not conflict with STUDENT'S IEP.
The thrust of STUDENT'S argument was that he did not have notice that he could lose the specific privilege to participate in the graduation ceremony. There was a conflict in the evidence over when STUDENT was advised that he could lose the specific senior privilege of participation in graduation. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT and his parents received sufficient notice through the Student/Parent Handbook, the Senior Activities 2000 pamphlet, and the senior meetings which STUDENT attended. It was also undisputed that notice of this continued loss of privilege was given at the meeting of May 10, 2000. In Robert H. v. Nixa R-2 School District, 26 IDELR 564 (August 9, 1997, U.S.D.C. W.D. Missouri), the district court held the school district did not deny FAPE or violate the IDEA where it refused to allow a disabled student to attend a field trip. The court concluded that the district "encourages the use of field trips as incentives and privileges for non-disabled and disabled to earn." In that case, the student had the opportunity to meet the requirements to attend the field trip and his parents were aware of the fact. Because the student "did not earn the privilege of going on the field trip," there was no IDEA violation. Similarly, in this case, the evidence established that senior privileges, including the right to participate in the graduation ceremony, were both available to and subject to loss by non-disabled and disabled students alike.
In summary, STUDENT was suspended for under 10 school days and there was no change in his specific educational placement. There is nothing in STUDENT'S IEP which conflicts with the use of restrictions on privileges for lesser disciplinary consequences. The District's withholding of the specific senior privilege to participate in the graduation ceremony did not conflict with STUDENT'S IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Office does not have the authority to grant the remedy sought by the Petitioner.
ORDER
The Petitioner's request for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: July 6, 2000 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
Footnote 1: STUDENT turned eighteen years old on October 23, 1999. Footnote 2: According to the District, IEP meetings were convened on March 30, 2000 (which Petitioner and his parents allegedly refused to attend), on April 3, 2000 (which resulted in an agreed-upon placement in independent study), on April 13, 2000 (which resulted in a new assessment of STUDENT), and on April 28, 2000 (which resulted in the manifestation determination disputed by Petitioner). Footnote 3: The District's motion also alleged that the matter was moot because the graduation ceremony was scheduled to occur before the due process hearing. Petitioner responded that the issue was not moot because the ceremony was scheduled for the evening of June 6, 2000, at the conclusion of the first day of the hearing. Footnote 4: The District's Ex. 8, which gives the number of days suspended, contains a number of more recent entries labeled "uncleared." Mr. Ward testified that this means that the entries have not been updated. He testified that STUDENTwas attending independent study at this time. Mr. Ward knew this because he regularly called Ms. Taff, STUDENT'S case manager, who was overseeing the independent study to make sure STUDENT was getting his regular assignments. It should be noted that, other than the dispute over whether March 24, 2000 was a "day of suspension," Petitioner did not raise any issues about his school status on any other date, including these "uncleared" dates. Footnote 5: The letter stated that "the Clovis High administrative team has decided to rescind the consideration of recommending you for expulsion from the Clovis Unified School District. Since the expulsion is rescinded, you may return to Clovis High on Tuesday, May 30, under the former IEP dated November 5, 1999. ¶ Therefore the decision of the IEP team regarding the manifestation determination issues are no longer relevant." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1). Mr. Ward testified that he believed that there would not be a need for a special education due process hearing after the District rescinded its expulsion recommendation, because the manifestation determination would not be relevant. Footnote 6: Pursuant to Education Code §56041.5, the parents' rights transferred to STUDENT when he turned eighteen years of age. Footnote 7: An issue statement pursuant to Education Code § 56505(e)(6) was never filed and Petitioner did not seek to expand the issues to encompass a general allegation of a denial of FAPE. The District's motion at the hearing to dismiss based upon Petitioner's failure to file the issue statement required by Education Code § 56505(e)(6) was denied. The Hearing Officer construed Petitioner's response to the District's written motion to dismiss, in which he stated he would like to be heard on the senior privilege issue, as an issue statement sufficient to put the District on notice of what it must defend at the hearing. Footnote 8: Petitioner argued that there was a reasonable inference from the rescission of the expulsion that the District had in fact agreed that the conduct was a manifestation of STUDENT'S disability. The District argued that the only effect of the rescission was to convey their intent not to pursue expulsion. Footnote 9: Similarly, under the IDEA, a school official may order a change in the placement of a child with a disability to an appropriate interim alternative educational setting, another setting, or suspension, for not more than 10 school days, to the extent that such alternatives would be applied to children without disabilities. 20 U.S.C. 1415(k)(1)(A). The IDEA regulations specifically define "change of placement" for disciplinary removals as occurring only where the removal is for more than 10 consecutive school days or where the child is subjected to a series of removals that constitute a pattern because they cumulate to more than 10 school days in a school year, and because of factors such as the length of each removal, the total amount of time the child is removed, and the proximity of the removals to one another. 34 C.F.R. § 300.519. Footnote 10: The Hearing Officer notes that, pursuant to California Education Code § 48911(a) , a principal, principal's designee or school superintendent may suspend a pupil for no more than 5 consecutive school days. An informal conference must be held with the pupil prior to the suspension. If a pre- suspension conference is not held, the pupil and his/her parents must be notified of the pupil's right to be heard at a conference, which must be held within 2 school days. Education Code § 48911 (b). If expulsion is being processed, the school superintendent or designee may extend the suspension until a decision is rendered only if he or she has determined that the pupil's presence at the school would cause a danger to persons or property or threaten a disruption of the instructional process. Education Code § 48911(g). Petitioner offered no legal argument on the effect of a 5.5 day suspension. Footnote 11: fact, the Comments to the IDEA regulations address the types of disciplinary tools which may be used by schools "in the case of less serious infractions." In such cases, "schools can address the misconduct through appropriate instructional and/or related services, including conflict management, behavior management strategies, and measures such as study carrels, time-outs, and restrictions in privileges, so long as they are not inconsistent with the child's IEP." Vol. 64 No. 48 Federal Register 12415 (March 12, 1999).
