California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 1, 1996

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 86-96 · Hearing Officer Mark Paxson

Los Angeles Unified must reimburse Landmark West tuition and fund 1996-97 placement after wrongly finding a student ineligible.

Student prevailed on all issuesVanaman German LLP represented the student

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted in the decision. The decision mentions an earlier mediation that led to a planned Section 504 meeting, which was never held.

Summary

The parents of a 15-year-old filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District after the district found him ineligible for special education in September 1995. The student had diagnoses of attention deficit disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder. He attended a small private school through eighth grade with heavy modifications and private tutoring. His parents then enrolled him at Landmark West School, a nonpublic school, for ninth grade. The district offered only regular education with accommodations.

The Hearing Officer found the district's assessment inadequate. School psychologist Anne Kaplan did not test listening comprehension or attention, did not look at how his conditions affected learning, and used several tests normed for younger children. The district relied on achievement scores alone and never considered the state rule allowing an IEP team to find a severe discrepancy by other means. Relying on teacher reports, private evaluator Dr. Barbara Silton, and treating psychologist Courtney Jacobs, the Hearing Officer found the student eligible under both specific learning disability and other health impairment. The regular education offer did not meet his needs in 1995-96, and the district offered nothing new for 1996-97. Landmark West gave him educational benefit, and he made the honor roll both semesters. The district must reimburse Landmark West tuition for 1995-96 and for 1996-97 through the decision date. It must also hold an IEP meeting within 15 days that places him at Landmark West at district expense for the rest of 1996-97. The Hearing Officer did not decide transportation costs.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO found a student learning disabled without a test-score discrepancy. It relied on classroom evidence that heavy modifications and private help were masking his struggles. It also shows that an ineligibility finding was not upheld when the assessment used tests normed for younger children and skipped attention and listening skills.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1(a). Is Student eligible for special education services as a result of a specific learning disability?

    District's assessment was inadequate (no listening comprehension or attention testing, tests normed for younger children) and ignored the 5 CCR 3030(j)(4)(C) alternative method; classroom evidence showed a severe discrepancy despite heavy modifications, so the student had a specific learning disability.

  2. Student prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1(b). Is Student eligible for special education services as a result of other health impairment?

    Chronic ADD and OCD limited the student's alertness and adversely affected his educational performance, so he was eligible as other health impaired.

  3. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Did Los Angeles Unified School District fail to offer Student an appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?

    The regular education placement with modifications would not have met the student's unique needs or given educational benefit; he needed a much more structured setting and more services.

  4. Issue 3. If the District failed to offer an appropriate education for 1995-96, is Student entitled to reimbursement for his placement at Landmark West School for the 1995-96 school year?

    Under Burlington, enrolling before the IEP process ended did not bar reimbursement because the district's offer was inappropriate; Landmark West gave educational benefit and the equities favored reimbursement of tuition.

  5. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. Did Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for Student for the 1996-97 school year?

    The District offered no other placement or further assessment for 1996-97, and the student's disabilities continued, so no appropriate placement was offered.

  6. Issue 5. If the District did not offer an appropriate placement for 1996-97, is the District required to provide Student with placement at Landmark West School for the 1996-97 school year?

    Landmark West was meeting the student's needs; the District must reimburse costs to the date of decision and keep him there at District expense for the rest of 1996-97.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Upon proof from Petitioner, District shall reimburse tuition for Landmark West for the 1995-96 school year and for the 1996-97 school year up to the date of the decision (November 1, 1996). No dollar amount stated; transportation costs not reached.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the decision to develop an IEP consistent with the decision.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. The IEP shall provide for Student's placement at Landmark West at District expense for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; 34 CFR § 300.541; 34 CFR § 300.532(f); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(j); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(f); Education Code § 56337; Education Code § 56339; Education Code § 56320(f)

People named in the decision

  • Linda Michel, coordinator of special education services, West Valley, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Shirley Brown, coordinator of student services for special education; District representative at hearing, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Anne Kaplan, school psychologist (District assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Robin Sales, school nurse (health assessment by records review), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Patricia Trenhaile, program specialist, West Valley Unit; District witness, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Dr. Barbara Silton, educational and clinical psychologist; private evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Courtney Jacobs, licensed clinical psychologist; treating clinician and witness for Student, Neuropsychiatric Institute, UCLA
  • Chris Battle, academic counselor; witness for Student, Landmark West School
  • Landmark West School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement), Encino, California
  • Dr. Lawrence Simons, private vision evaluator (optometric report), Private
  • Anne Salzman, licensed psychologist; private psychological evaluator, Private
  • Dr. Alan Sandler, treating physician, psychiatry and neurology, Private
  • Ellen Howard, administrative vice principal of student's prior private school, Private school (name redacted)
  • Dr. Audrey Griesbach, developmental pediatrician; private evaluator, Private
  • Dr. Kyle, private evaluator, Private
  • Farryl Dickter, private educational therapist, Private
  • Leslie Neiman, private academic skills provider, Private
  • James Sparing, medication provider, UCLA
  • Larry Andre (Dr. Andre), private cognitive behavioral psychotherapist, Private
  • Ron Doctor, private behavioral therapist, Private
  • Children's Enrichment Center, private provider (motor/handwriting recommendations), Private
  • Encino Pediatric Medical Group, private medical provider (report), Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Reseda, California, on August 27 and 28, 1996.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Valerie Vanaman. Also present on Petitioner's behalf were his parents MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by Shirley Brown, the District's coordinator of student services for special education. Also present on behalf of the District was Linda Michel, coordinator of special education services, West Valley.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the parties agreed to submit written closing briefs. Closing briefs were received by the Hearing Office on September 23, 1996, and the record was closed at that time.

ISSUES

(1) Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a result of a specific learning disability or other health impairment?

(2) Did Los Angeles Unified School District fail to offer STUDENT an appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?

(3) If Los Angeles Unified School District failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for his placement at Landmark West School for the 1995-96 school year?

(4) Did Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?

(5) If Los Angeles Unified School District did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year, is Los Angeles Unified School District required to provide him with placement at Landmark West School for the 1996-97 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a 15-year-old young man currently classified as ineligible for special education services. STUDENT has been diagnosed as having attention deficit disorder (ADD) (FOOTNOTE 1) and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). He currently attends Landmark West School in Encino, California, a nonpublic school where he was unilaterally enrolled by his parents at the beginning of the 1995-96 school year.

In October 1991, STUDENT's vision was evaluated by Dr.

Lawrence Simons. Dr. Simons determined that STUDENT had deficiencies in eye movement control, focusing ability/facility, eye teaming ability, eye-hand coordination, visual directional concepts, and visual form perception/reproduction. Dr. Simons concluded that these deficiencies resulted in difficulty with reading and that STUDENT's academic performance may be affected because his ability to process visual information may be compromised. Dr. Simons recommended vision therapy and corrective lenses.

In May 1994, Anne Salzman, a licensed psychologist, conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT at his parents' request. Ms. Salzman administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Revised (WISC-R), Rorschach, Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), Sentence Completion, Kinetic Family Drawing, Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test (Bender), and House-Tree-Person. Ms. Salzman found that STUDENT was functioning within the normal range of intelligence, but that "[h]is test performance is very uneven, so his intellectual capacity is undoubtedly better than average." Ms. Salzman also found that STUDENT's short-term memory was "significantly below average, suggesting marked distractibility and anxiety." Ms. Salzman concluded that STUDENT's current program appeared appropriate but that he might need "a tutor to help with homework to avoid that kind of stressful relationship with parents."

Until June 1995, MOTHER was director of the parenting center at the NON PUBLIC SCHOOL. One of the benefits MOTHER received as a result of her employment there was that STUDENT was able to attend school at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLfree of charge. STUDENT attended school at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLfrom preschool through the eighth grade. The middle school at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLcontained approximately 200 students with approximately 20 students per class.

STUDENT's report cards from the eighth grade at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLshow that at the end of the school year, he had grades ranging from A's in Phys. Ed., Drama, Hockey, Basketball, and Volleyball, to a C- in English. His overall grade point average was 2.94. Teacher comments were positive overall but two teachers noted that his quality of work was declining, that he did not make consistent effort, and that he needed to be more organized.

Following MOTHER's departure from NON PUBLIC SCHOOLin June 1995, MOTHER and FATHER began looking for other educational alternatives for STUDENT. On July 24, 1995, Dr. Alan Sandler, an M.D. certified in Psychiatry and Neurology, submitted a letter outlining his work with STUDENT. According to Dr. Sandler, he had treated STUDENT since November 1994, and STUDENT had been diagnosed with ADD and OCD. Dr. Sandler stated that STUDENT's "obsessive thoughts and compulsive urges cause significant distress, undue preoccupation, and interference with his academic and social function." Dr. Sandler recommended a "structured educational setting, preferably on a small non-public school campus relatively free of stressful psychosocial 'noise' and distraction."

On July 10, 1995, Ellen Howard, administrative vice principal for the NON PUBLIC SCHOOLCommunity Middle/High School, prepared a letter regarding STUDENT. In that letter, Ms. Howard states that this has not been the correct environment for STUDENT to succeed academically. STUDENT's academic classes have been modified. In math he was in a remedial class of 12 students.

STUDENT was allowed not to take Hebrew, (a requirement for our students) and to use this period to get help from his teachers. However, with all the modifications STUDENT was not successful. STUDENT's grades reflected how much he tried.

They are not a measure of how much of the material he mastered. Unfortunately, STUDENT reacts poorly to stress and could not keep up in his classes.

Even though we are a small school (200 students in 7 and 8), on a small campus (7 classrooms) and small classes (approximately 20 students per class), STUDENT was not able to keep up with the work and not feel overly stressed.

In July 1995, STUDENT was evaluated by Anne Kaplan, a District school psychologist. Ms. Kaplan reviewed STUDENT's school history as reported to her by MOTHER. Ms. Kaplan also reviewed several reports, including the evaluation completed by Anne Salzman. Ms. Kaplan conducted her own assessment of STUDENT at his home during two separate visits. Ms. Kaplan administered the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R), Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA), Wide Range Achievement Test-III (WRAT-III), Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills (TAPS), Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills (TVPS), Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test (Bender), and Sentence Completion test. Ms. Kaplan determined that "[a]cademically, STUDENT appears to be working on grade level, or commensurate with his ability." Ms. Kaplan concluded that "[n]o learning disability is noted."

On September 12, 1995, Robin Sales, a school nurse with the District, prepared a health assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Sales' report was based solely on a review of records and that Ms. Sales did not see STUDENT. Among the reports Ms. Sales relied on were Dr. Sandler's letter, dated July 1995; Dr. Simons' optometric report, dated October 1991; and reports from Dr. Griesbach, dated December 1990 and February 1991.

On September 19, 1995, the District convened an IEP meeting to determine STUDENT's eligibility for special education. The IEP team considered Ms. Kaplan's report, and also reviewed a report from Dr. Alan Sandler relating to STUDENT's OCD; the Children's Enrichment Center's recommendation in October 1990 that STUDENT participate in exercises to improve muscle tone, posture, and handwriting; an October 1991 optometric report from Dr. Lawrence Simons, who recommended eyeglasses and vision therapy; a report from Encino Pediatric Medical Group dated August 17, 1995. The IEP team also appeared to have information from Anne Salzman regarding STUDENT's OCD.

The IEP team determined that STUDENT's general ability was in the average range and that his math reasoning, writing, and general information skills were also within the average range. In the various processing and memory areas, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was in the average to above average range except in auditory and visual short term memory, which were described as "a weaker area, but not to a significant degree." The IEP team determined that most of STUDENT's academic skills were at or near grade level. The IEP team also found that STUDENT had weak visual motor skills, as indicated by his difficulty with handwriting. The IEP team noted that Ms. Salzman reported that "STUDENT spends a great deal of emotional energy holding off his feelings in order to attend to the major job he has assigned himself -- keeping everyone happy."

The IEP team acknowledged STUDENT's diagnosis of ADD and OCD but determined that his achievement was within the average range and, without the parents' approval, concluded that although STUDENT may require some accommodations within a regular education program, he did not meet eligibility criteria for special education services.

In February and March 1996, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr.

Barbara Silton, an educational and clinical psychologist. Dr. Silton administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale-Third Edition (WISC-III) to STUDENT. His results were a verbal IQ of 101, performance IQ of 99, and a full scale IQ of 100. Dr. Silton also administered the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revision #3 (WRAT-R3), and STUDENT's results on that test were standard scores of 104 on spelling, 107 on arithmetic, and 99 on reading. STUDENT was also administered the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), on which he received a standard score of 95, and the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised (PPVT-R), on which he received a standard score of 94. Dr. Silton also administered the Spadafore Diagnostic Reading Test, House-Tree-Person, and Draw-a-Family.

Dr. Silton's summary of her report included the following statements:

Based on past and present testing, it appears that STUDENT shows a significant learning deficit in visual motor skills (tests provided on this exam indicate weakness in visual motor symbol tracking and visual motor planning where he scores 20-23 points below his ability).

STUDENT has also shown a significant learning deficit in auditory sequential memory. Another processing area that has been identified as being weak but not necessarily in the deficit range is in the area of factual retention.

STUDENT struggles with extreme difficulty in his ability to process new information. If STUDENT is attempting to gather information through his visual channel, through silent reading, he tends to become dysfunctional at approximately the 4th grade level. If STUDENT is reading aloud, he tends to decompensate around the 6th grade level. If STUDENT is listening to new information, he tends to show extreme dysfunction around the 7th grade level.... Subsequently, it appears that STUDENT's problems with processing new information may be a major contributing factor to his past reported school adjustment failures.

One of Dr. Silton's recommendations was that STUDENT remain at Landmark West until he gains more confidence and skill. Dr. Silton also recommended that STUDENT receive training in his weaker processing areas with special attention placed on comprehension training, and that he continue receiving counseling for his "OCD, LD, and ADHD issues."

In May 1996, when STUDENT was in the ninth grade at Landmark West, STUDENT was administered the Stanford Achievement Tests. At that time, STUDENT received the following scores

Subtest Grade Equivalent Percentile Reading Vocabulary 7.9 33 Reading Comp. 8.2 37 Mathematics 10.7 56 English 11.1 55 Study Skills 6.3 20 Science 6.8 20 Social Science 6.5 21

At the conclusion of ninth grade, STUDENT received the following grades:

Algebra lab B+ World History 9 A- English 9 A Physical Science A- Study Skills A Choir A Phys. Ed. A

As a result of the above grades, STUDENT was on the honor roll. He had also been on the honor roll for the first semester of the school year, which ended on February 2, 1996.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses

MOTHER

MOTHER, STUDENT's mother, has a master's degree in education and has taught at the high school and community college levels. Until June 1995, MOTHER was the director of the parenting center at NON PUBLIC SCHOOL. MOTHER testified that STUDENT attended school and the summer program at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLfrom kindergarten through the eighth grade.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT began to demonstrate problems with his school work in the third grade. Specifically, STUDENT took a long time to do his homework and was getting frustrated in class. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has continued to demonstrate problems at school and with homework. MOTHER testified that STUDENT's principal and teacher recommended in Fall 1990 that STUDENT be evaluated because of his poor performance in school. As a result, STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Kyle in October 1990 and Dr. Griesbach in December 1990. The evaluators worked with STUDENT for several months on his memory, writing, and other basic skills.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT also worked with an educational therapist, Farryl Dickter, for approximately two years during the fourth and fifth grades. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was evaluated by Dr. Simons in October 1991 based on the recommendation of the school principal. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT did get corrective lenses, but did not receive vision therapy because of a lack of money to pay for it.

According to MOTHER, STUDENT worked with Leslie Neiman on his academic skills. In addition, STUDENT's teacher made accommodations in the form of reduced homework and, when doing group work, STUDENT was assigned the art work rather than reading and writing. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was also allowed to sit in the front of the class.

MOTHER testified that the seventh grade was probably STUDENT's worst year due to bizarre behaviors associated with his OCD.

MOTHER testified that the behaviors were so severe that she was concerned that STUDENT would have to be hospitalized. In addition, for approximately two months, STUDENT came home from school at lunch and did not return because of anxiety and increased OCD behaviors. MOTHER testified that STUDENT had a hard time holding himself together. During that year, STUDENT saw James Sparing at UCLA for medication, received tutoring, and saw Larry Andre for cognitive behavioral psychotherapy once a week. STUDENT also received some behavioral therapy from Ron Doctor for a couple of months.

In regard to accommodations during the seventh grade, MOTHER testified that STUDENT's assignments were cut in half, he was allowed to tape record assignments rather than write them, he did not have to take Hebrew, which is a required course, he was in remedial math, his teachers spent extra time with him, and he was allowed to repeat tests if he was having a bad day. MOTHER testified that STUDENT could study for a test but then go to school the next day and lose all of the information.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT would have been accepted into NON PUBLIC SCHOOLHigh School for the ninth grade, but that she had been told that the teachers would not be as accommodating as STUDENT's prior teachers had been. As a result, she started looking for other schools, including Landmark West. MOTHER also testified that she contacted the District and requested an assessment during Summer 1995. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was accepted by Landmark West in August 1995. MOTHER testified that Landmark has not made any special modifications for STUDENT.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs to be taught in steps, that it is difficult for him to follow multiple-step directions unless he is given them one step at a time. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT has consistently had problems with his attention span. MOTHER gave an example of having a conversation with STUDENT and his "not being there." MOTHER testified that she needs to sit him down and make him focus and respond to make sure he is paying attention.

MOTHER also indicated that STUDENT has always had problems with homework. For instance, it would take STUDENT three to four hours to do his homework each night, even though his homework was usually half of what the other students were assigned. MOTHER also testified that he would become frustrated by the homework and state that he felt stupid. Homework involved a great deal of stress and OCD behavior. MOTHER testified that when STUDENT is trying to control his OCD, he cannot deal with what's going on around him.

Regarding the teacher behavioral observations filled out by some of STUDENT's teachers (District Exhibits 6, 7, and 8), MOTHER testified that she had never seen the forms and that the information in the forms was not discussed at any IEP meetings with the District. MOTHER also testified that she was not asked to have any of the teachers or administrators from NON PUBLIC SCHOOLattend the IEP meetings. Regarding the IEP meeting in September 1995, MOTHER testified that she felt it was a "done deal" before she even walked in the door. MOTHER testified that there was nothing she could say to change the opinion of the IEP team. MOTHER also indicated that the IEP team did not discuss making modifications for STUDENT.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT enrolled at Landmark West in Fall 1995. MOTHER testified that for the first time STUDENT has become independent enough to know all of his homework assignments. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is not currently receiving any therapy, tutoring, and is not on any medication because his school anxiety is minimal. In addition, STUDENT has not said that he feels stupid since enrolling at Landmark. MOTHER also indicated that the assignments at Landmark West are broken down into specific parts and that STUDENT does well on the assignments. Finally, MOTHER testified that STUDENT's OCD symptoms have decreased since starting at Landmark West and that she noticed the decrease around April 1996.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT's public high school would be Birmingham High School, which she visited three times. MOTHER testified that she does not believe STUDENT could cope on a regular education campus with regular education classes. MOTHER testified that he would have difficulty moving from class to class and remembering things. MOTHER testified that STUDENT used a suitcase for his books at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLso that he would not have to go to his locker in between classes. When he did go to his locker, he would engage in ritual behaviors which made it difficult to get to his next class. MOTHER also expressed concerns that STUDENT would not get the necessary one-to-one attention at Birmingham and that the students and teachers would not understand OCD.

Barbara Silton

Barbara Silton is an educational and clinical psychologist who conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in February and March 1996. Dr. Silton testified that she reviewed records (FOOTNOTE 2) and consulted by phone and in person with STUDENT and his family prior to conducting the evaluation.

Dr. Silton testified that she administered the WISC-III because it had been awhile since STUDENT had taken an IQ test, the VMI because his records showed a strong profile for VMI problems, the PPVT-R to determine if vocabulary was playing a role in his comprehension problems, and the Spadafore Diagnostic Reading Test to measure various forms of comprehension. Dr. Silton also administered the WRAT-R3, an academic achievement test. However, Dr. Silton testified that, while the WRAT-R3 is useful, it does not present a complete picture of STUDENT's achievement. Dr. Silton testified that, in general, academic achievement tests are not comprehensive enough to assess where a student breaks down academically in the classroom.

Dr. Silton testified that, on the Spadafore, STUDENT was functioning between the sixth and seventh grade level on listening comprehension and between the fourth and fifth grade level on reading comprehension. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT has good vocabulary but that when a lot of information is delivered to him, he cannot retain it. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT is a better concrete learner through the use of manipulatives than a conceptual learner through the use of ideas.

Regarding the District's assessment, Dr. Silton testified that the TAPS and TVPS administered by the District are normed for a group of children younger than STUDENT. Dr. Silton testified that both tests are normed up to twelve years of age and that, at the time STUDENT took them, he was fourteen years old. Dr. Silton testified that the effect of using a test, such as the TAPS, that is normed for a younger population is that the test can provide information useful for clinical observations, but that it should not be used as an indicator of primary deficits.

Dr. Silton also had similar concerns with the use of the Bender. She testified that the Bender was initially normed on five- to ten-year-olds. Dr. Silton did acknowledge, however, that the Bender has been used a lot with older children. On the District's assessment, STUDENT received a score of 2 on the Bender. Dr. Silton testified that based on the norms for five- to ten-year-olds, a score of 2 is equivalent to where a nine-year-old should perform. Dr. Silton also indicated that a score of 2 from a child with an IQ of 100 would be equivalent to how an eleven-year-old should perform. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT's score on the Bender indicated that he has a delay in visual-motor integration. Dr. Silton also testified that the District's assessor should have included in the evaluation more interpretative information regarding the score on the Bender.

Regarding the achievement tests administered by the District in July 1995, Dr. Silton testified that the Kaufman and PIAT are not comprehensive enough to assess a student's breakdown in the classroom. Dr. Silton also testified that the Kaufman and PIAT do not include any standardized tests covering listening comprehension. Dr. Silton testified that the District's report does not address listening comprehension and that focusing on reading, writing, and math produces an incomplete assessment of STUDENT because his problems are so complex. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT's score on the TAPS did show that he has a hard time processing auditory information and that the score was significantly discrepant from his disability.

Dr. Silton acknowledged that testing does not reveal a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement to determine if STUDENT has a learning disability. However, Dr. Silton testified that alternative measures show that he is not making it in the classroom; that he works very hard, but needs a lot of help; and that he has a very strong deficit in visual-motor integration areas. Dr. Silton testified that she identified learning problems in visual-motor integration, listening skills, and silent reading comprehension. Dr. Silton testified that she found deficits in auditory memory skills, visual tracking, and visual memory. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT's records indicate he has had problems focusing in class, difficulty listening to lectures, and slow reading and writing skills.

Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT's ADD impacts his ability to learn because, while he can initially concentrate, he cannot sustain that concentration and is sensitive to distractions. Dr. Silton testified that, as a result of his deficits and ADD and OCD, STUDENT cannot obtain information at the same speed as other children.

Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT could not have functioned in a regular education high school during the 1995-96 school year without tremendous amounts of support from his parents, psychotherapy, and medications. Dr. Silton testified that the anxiety of adjusting to a new environment and new teachers would have caused STUDENT to shut down. Dr. Silton also testified that STUDENT's listening skills are not sufficient to allow him to function in a regular education ninth grade english class because of the level of concentration required and the amount of reading and reading comprehension required.

Dr. Silton testified that placement at Landmark West removes the pressure of a regular education environment and that the population is matched to STUDENT's needs. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT is learning skills during the entire school day rather than having to spend part of the day in educational therapy, which he would have to do if he were on a regular education campus. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT will eventually be able to return to regular education once he learns the necessary skills.

Furthermore, Dr. Silton testified that a regular education placement with educational therapy would not be appropriate currently because of the complexity of STUDENT's needs.

Dr. Silton testified that she did not speak to any of STUDENT's teachers at Landmark West, although she did speak with his counselor about the program at Landmark West and the modifications STUDENT was receiving. Dr. Silton testified that she learned that STUDENT is not receiving any special modifications. Dr. Silton also testified that she has not been to Birmingham High School for several years.

Courtney Jacobs

Courtney Jacobs is a licensed clinical psychologist who treated STUDENT for his OCD at the Neuropsychiatric Institute at UCLA from March 1996 until June 1996. Her work included thirteen sessions with STUDENT. Ms. Jacobs described OCD as recurrent intrusive thoughts which a person cannot get out of his or her mind (obsession) and which produce great anxiety, and repetitive motions (compulsion) that are done to allay the obsessions. Ms. Jacobs testified that OCD has a combination of genetic and chemical causes, and that OCD is treatable but not curable. In addition, according to Ms. Jacobs, the symptoms of OCD wax and wane depending on the stressors in an individual's life.

Ms. Jacobs testified that STUDENT is one of the most severe children she has treated at the clinic. Ms. Jacobs testified that STUDENT fears serious harm to himself or his parents, AIDS, public restrooms, and germs. His compulsions include saying goodnight or goodbye to his parents repeatedly, holding his breath until he gets dizzy, and taking a certain number of steps before getting into bed, while he holds his breath.

Ms. Jacobs testified that, as a result of treatment, STUDENT has shown significant improvement. While there are clinical signs of the OCD, he has been symptom free for the last several months. Ms. Jacobs described STUDENT's current state as being in remission. Ms. Jacobs testified that, prior to his improvement, STUDENT spent six to sixteen hours per day dealing with his obsessions and compulsions. He could not go for more than twenty minutes without an obsession or compulsion. Ms. Jacobs testified that the degree of STUDENT's OCD would make it difficult for him to concentrate in the classroom.

Ms. Jacobs testified that placement at Landmark West helped with the treatment because STUDENT felt comfortable and in control at Landmark West. Ms. Jacobs testified that she did not observe STUDENT at Landmark. Ms. Jacobs testified that if STUDENT were placed at a regular education high school, the OCD symptoms would return slowly. Ms. Jacobs testified that the most effective treatment for OCD is medication for STUDENT's chemical imbalance and behavioral therapy.

Chris Battle

Chris Battle is an academic counselor at Landmark West and was STUDENT's counselor during the 1995-96 school year. As STUDENT's counselor, Ms. Battle worked with STUDENT's teachers to ensure that his needs were met in the classroom. Ms. Battle testified that she meets with teachers at least once per month in round table discussions or informal meetings and that she sees most teachers on a daily basis. Ms. Battle also met with STUDENT on a formal basis approximately six times during the school year and saw him on campus on a daily basis.

Ms. Battle testified that STUDENT has deficits in auditory short term memory and visual motor integration. Ms. Battle testified that these deficits are impacted by his anxiety and emotional problems. Ms. Battle testified that when STUDENT feels he is falling behind, he beings acting out and acting immaturely in the classroom. In addition, during finals, STUDENT is noticeably distracted and has increased misbehaviors in the classroom. Ms. Battle testified that if STUDENT were placed on a regular education campus, he would be overwhelmed by the size and number of students and would fall behind.

Ms. Battle testified that STUDENT's teachers deal with his OCD by providing him with more encouragement than other students, giving him time outs when necessary, and giving him one-on-one instruction to help him organize his thoughts and help him feel comfortable with the subject matter. Ms. Battle testified that there is a big difference between what STUDENT can do in a group setting and in one-to-one instruction, and that he does not perform at grade level in the classroom without one-to-one assistance. Ms. Battle testified that STUDENT's grades at Landmark West demonstrate that he is at grade level in algebra, world history, English, physical science, and study skills. However, Ms. Battle testified that material is modified at Landmark West in the following ways: material is presented using multiple modalities (orally and in writing); assignments are broken down into small, sequential steps; instruction and class time is highly structured; and notes are provided for students who cannot take notes. In addition, books, while presenting grade level content, may be at a lower reading level.

Ms. Battle testified that Landmark West services student from second to twelfth grade and is designed for student with language-based disabilities. She stated that the classes at Landmark West have approximately 6-10 students with one teacher and no aides. The student-to-teacher ratio is 4:1. Ms. Battle testified that all of the teachers at Landmark West are credentialed special education teachers or are in the process of obtaining their credentials. During the 1995-96 school year, Landmark West had approximately 227 students and, for the 1996-97 school year, approximately 240 students. Ms. Battle testified that STUDENT should remain at Landmark West because of the size of the program and the teachers can meet his needs. Ms. Battle testified that the size of the program is relevant because STUDENT's anxiety directly impacts his learning disabilities.

FATHER

FATHER, STUDENT's father, testified that when STUDENT was at Stephen Wise, there were times when he was unable to understand what a teacher was talking about. FATHER testified that when this occurred STUDENT told him that he felt stupid. FATHER also testified that STUDENT told him that sometimes all he heard from a teacher was "blah, blah." FATHER testified that while STUDENT was at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLhe was able to mask a lot of the OCD behaviors. STUDENT would internalize the rituals and not be able to pay attention. FATHER also testified that oftentimes STUDENT would be so focused on the rituals that he would not be able to respond to a simple question.

FATHER testified that similar problems have not occurred since enrolling at Landmark West. In addition, FATHER testified that STUDENT participates regularly in the classroom and has become very communicative. FATHER testified that the teachers at Landmark West have told him that they use fewer words and other techniques to get lessons across.

FATHER testified that on September 19, 1995, the IEP team discussed the school psychologist and nurse's reports and concluded that STUDENT was not learning disabled because of the test scores. FATHER testified that he discussed STUDENT's school history, but school personnel indicated that they believed STUDENT would be fine in a regular education setting. FATHER testified that nobody from the District has contacted him or STUDENT's mother regarding a placement for the 1996-97 school year.

FATHER testified that if STUDENT had gone to Birmingham High School during the 1995-96 school year, he would not have been able to understand or process information given to him by the teachers because of his ADD, inability to follow a lecture, and overall lack of focus. FATHER testified that the result would have been an increase in his anxiety and OCD. FATHER testified that the cost for Landmark West for the 1995-96 school year was $17,600, which includes the cost of transportation.

District Witnesses

Patricia Trenhaile

Patricia Trenhaile is a program specialist for the West Valley Unit of the District. Ms. Trenhaile testified that she does not know STUDENT and has never attended any IEP meeting for him. Ms. Trenhaile testified that, as a result of a mediation, she was asked to set up a "504 planning meeting" for STUDENT to discuss modifications for STUDENT if he were placed at Birmingham High School.

Ms. Trenhaile testified that she initially scheduled the meeting for June 24, 1996. However, she learned from STUDENT's parent's attorney that the parents would be unable to attend. Ms. Trenhaile testified that it was agreed that the meeting would be rescheduled for the fall. Ms. Trenhaile testified that the meeting has not been rescheduled.

Ms. Trenhaile testified, based on her review of STUDENT's records,(FOOTNOTE 3) that the District could modify class assignments, provide a note-taker, and set up a weekly assignment sheet for STUDENT at Birmingham High School. Ms. Trenhaile testified that STUDENT's regular education teacher could also give STUDENT extra time on tests and have STUDENT take tests in a special day class so that there are fewer students present. Ms. Trenhaile also testified that there is a school psychologist at Birmingham and tutoring available for regular education students. Ms. Trenhaile testified that STUDENT does not need to be eligible for special education to receive the modifications she thinks he needs.

Regarding Landmark West, Ms. Trenhaile testified that she had visited the campus as recently as June 1996, and that she has observed classes there on several occasions. Ms. Trenhaile testified that she was disappointed in the behavioral intervention plans at Landmark West, the way in which the curriculum was applied, and the lack of teaching credentials. Specifically regarding behavioral management, Ms. Trenhaile testified that there was no plan available and there was no positive reinforcement in a second grade class she observed. Regarding the curriculum, Ms. Trenhaile expressed concern regarding a reading assignment she saw given to a second grade class. Ms. Trenhaile testified that the reading assignment was too difficult for the students and the teacher let the frustration level of the students get too high.

Anne Kaplan

Anne Kaplan is the school psychologist who assessed STUDENT in July 1995. Ms. Kaplan testified that she was unable to observe STUDENT in a classroom setting because the assessment occurred during the summer, when NON PUBLIC SCHOOLwas closed. She was also unable to get information from the teachers until September 1995, because she was unable to contact his teachers. Ms. Kaplan testified that she did have an opportunity to speak with one of the directors of NON PUBLIC SCHOOLregarding STUDENT.

Ms. Kaplan testified that her assessment took place during two visits to STUDENT's home. Ms. Kaplan testified that she spoke with STUDENT's parents for background information. She also reviewed the reports from Dr. Sandler, Dr. Griesbach, Dr. Simon, and Ms. Salzman, and talked at length with Dr. Andre. Ms. Kaplan testified that Dr. Andre told her that a significant part of STUDENT's problems were due to family dynamics.

Ms. Kaplan testified that she administered the TAPS and TVPS for children younger than STUDENT because the District did not get the versions normed for older students until a month after she conducted the assessment. Ms. Kaplan testified that the Bender showed that STUDENT had some difficulty with visual-motor integration and that the PIAT-R and KTEA showed that his reading comprehension was at grade level.

Regarding STUDENT's OCD, Ms. Kaplan testified that the only information she had was from Dr. Sandler's diagnosis and MOTHER's information regarding examples of STUDENT's OCD behaviors. The only OCD-like behavior that Ms. Kaplan observed was STUDENT's lack of eye contact. Ms. Kaplan testified that in one-on-one situations, like testing, STUDENT does not have problems with concentration or attention.

In the area of a specific learning disability, Ms. Kaplan testified that STUDENT's short-term auditory memory was weak based on his score on the TAPS. However, Ms. Kaplan testified that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement based on scores on the other tests and that his auditory skills as a whole are not weak.(FOOTNOTE 4) Ms. Kaplan testified that she did not specifically test listening comprehension although the TAPS does include this area and he did well on that test. Ms. Kaplan testified that with older children she does not read a paragraph to them to assess listening comprehension. If an older child can read a paragraph and comprehend it, she assumes he or she can listen and comprehend. Ms. Kaplan also testified that she was unsure if she assessed oral expression. Finally, Ms. Kaplan testified that there was no teacher or other specialist with knowledge in the area of STUDENT's suspected disability who participated in the assessment.

Ms. Kaplan attended the IEP meeting on September 19, 1995.

Ms. Kaplan testified that the team concluded that although STUDENT has ADD and OCD, these are not having an impact on his education. Ms. Kaplan testified that this conclusion was based on his achievement test scores, the group testing he received at NON PUBLIC SCHOOL(CTBS), and his grades from Stephen Wise.

DISCUSSION

(1) Is STUDENT eligible for special education services as a result of a specific learning disability or other health impairment?

Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability and other health impairment. The District contends that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services as determined by the IEP team in September 1995. (a) Specific Learning Disability

Both state and federal law provide that a student is eligible for special education due to a specific learning disability if he or she has a severe discrepancy between achievement and ability in one of several areas. These areas include oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, and mathematics reasoning. State law also requires that the student have a disorder in a basic psychological process, including attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, and cognitive abilities. To qualify for special education services, the learning disability must be of the type that cannot be corrected through other regular educational resources. 34 CFR § 300.541; California Education Code 56337; and California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(j)(1). State law provides that the discrepancy shall be demonstrated by a comparison of scores from valid standardized achievement and ability tests, and the law provides a specific formula for determining if such a discrepancy exists. California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(j)(4)(A). The testimony of all witnesses who testified on this point, and the tests administered by the various assessors, establish that no such severe discrepancy exists, as measured by the test instruments.

Section 3030 provides an alternative means by which a student can be found to have a specific learning disability. Section 3030(j)(4)(C) states that

[i]f the standardized tests do not reveal a severe discrepancy ... the individualized education program team may find that a severe discrepancy does exist, provided that the team documents in a written report that the severe discrepancy between ability and achievement exists as a result of a disorder in one or more basic psychological processes. The report shall include a statement of the area, the degree, and the basis and method used in determining the discrepancy. The report shall contain information considered by the team which shall include, but not be limited to:

1. Data obtained from standardized assessment instruments;

2. Information provided by the parent;

3. Information provided by the pupil's present teacher;

4. Evidence of the pupil's performance in the regular and/or special education classroom obtained from observations, work samples, and group test scores;

5. Consideration of the pupil's age, particularly for young children; and 6. Any additional relevant information.

The Hearing Officer notes that the District's assessor concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services as a result of a specific learning disability based on the scores he received on standardized achievement scores. The assessor's conclusion was adopted by the IEP team. However, there is no evidence that the assessor or the IEP team considered the alternative means approach included in § 3030. Furthermore, there is strong evidence to support the conclusion that the District's own assessment did not adequately assess all of STUDENT's suspected disabilities, in compliance with special education law. 34 CFR § 300.532(f) and Education Code § 56320(f). The District's assessor, Ms. Kaplan, testified that she did not assess in the area of listening comprehension and that she was unsure if she assessed in the area of oral comprehension. Although attention is a processing disorder, there is no evidence that Ms. Kaplan assessed STUDENT's attentional difficulties and the impact those difficulties may have on his ability to benefit from his education. The assessment also did not address STUDENT's OCD, did not include an IQ test, and did not adequately assess his vision needs. Instead, Ms. Kaplan accepted the earlier diagnoses of ADD and OCD without conducting any testing of her own to determine the impact ADD and OCD may be having on STUDENT's education.

The evidence also establishes that the District's assessment included several tests, including the TAPS, TVPS, and Bender, which were not normed for a child of STUDENT's age and, therefore, not valid tests for the purpose for which they were administered. In other words, the only valid tests on which the District based its conclusion that STUDENT was not eligible for special education were the standardized achievement tests administered by Ms. Kaplan.

Although the District's assessment is lacking in any significant information regarding many of the areas of suspected disability, there is sufficient information from other sources to establish that STUDENT had a specific learning disability at the time of the District's assessment.

As stated above, for a child to qualify with a specific learning disability, there must be a disorder in a basic psychological process, there must be a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in one or more of several academic areas, and the discrepancy cannot be corrected through regular education programs. It was undisputed that STUDENT had ADD. One of the psychological processes which may give rise to a learning disability is attention. Based on the fact that STUDENT's diagnosis of ADD was undisputed and that there was evidence that his attentional problems were interfering with his schoolwork, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did have a disorder in attention, a basic psychological process, at the time of the District's assessment.

Regarding whether STUDENT has a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement in one or more of the academic areas listed in federal and state special education law, there is a significant amount of evidence that STUDENT was experiencing such a discrepancy across the board. Even though STUDENT was able to score within the average range on the standardized achievement tests administered by the District, in the classroom STUDENT was receiving a significant amount of help in the form of modified homework assignments, modified grading, and one-on-one assistance. Additionally, STUDENT was receiving a significant amount of help privately through tutors and therapists. STUDENT was also enrolled in a small, private school in which there were no more than 20 students in each class. With all of this assistance and modifications, STUDENT's teachers noted that he still had problems with attention, frustration, understanding material, note-taking, and writing skills, and required significant one-to-one assistance, and his parents testified that he spent three to four hours per night on homework, which was half of what the other students were assigned.

(District's Exhibit Nos. 6, 7, 8) The fact that STUDENT's grades were based on effort rather than actual academic achievement indicates that he was not achieving commensurate with his ability. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's substantial academic difficulties at Stephen Wise, even with the substantial modifications he received, establishes that STUDENT had a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement.

The next issue to be addressed is whether STUDENT's learning disability could be addressed in the regular education environment. The Hearing Officer finds most compelling the fact that, although STUDENT was enrolled in a small private school and received substantial private assistance from therapists, tutors and other professionals, was provided with a modified educational program and was graded on his effort rather than his actual achievement, he was still, according to his parents and teachers, unable to do the work. It is also important to note that his program was modified by school personnel who had worked with him since preschool. If any individuals knew how best to meet STUDENT's needs, it would seem to have been the educators at Stephen Wise.

Also of significance is the unanimous opinion of the teachers and other professionals who had worked with STUDENT that he needed a small, structured educational environment and would not have succeeded on a regular education high school campus. Dr. Silton testified that STUDENT did not have the skills necessary to function in a ninth grade academic class such as English and that his needs were too complex to be met in a regular education environment, even if he were receiving educational therapy. The evidence establishes that STUDENT's learning disability was not being corrected in the regular education environment.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did have a specific learning disability at the time the District assessed STUDENT and determined that he was not eligible for special education.

(b) Other Health Impairment

Regarding "other health impairment," California Code of Regulations, Title 5, § 3030(f) provides that a child is eligible for special education if he or she has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil's educational performance. See also 34 CFR § 300.7.

Petitioner contends that he qualifies under "other health impairment" (OHI) because of his ADD and OCD. Education Code § 56339 provides that a student whose educational performance is adversely affected by ADD and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by satisfying the eligibility criteria for, among others, other health impairment is eligible for special education. While § 56339 appears to allow for ADD to be considered under the eligibility criteria for other health impairment, there is little case law regarding how to apply the other health impairment criteria to ADD. Therefore, the Hearing Officer relies on the plain language of the regulation as applied to the facts of this case. Both federal and state special education law require the same elements to establish eligibility under other health impairment. Those elements are:

1. Limited strength, vitality, or alertness;

2. Due to chronic or acute health problems; and 3. Adversely affects educational performance.

Looking at STUDENT's ADD and OCD(FOOTNOTE 5), there is no dispute that STUDENT has been medically diagnosed as having ADD and OCD. The District did not dispute those diagnoses at hearing and the District's assessor and IEP team accepted them during the evaluation process. STUDENT's diagnosis of ADD came as early as December 12, 1990. He has also exhibited OCD characteristics for several years. Therefore, STUDENT's ADD and OCD are chronic or acute health problems because of their duration.

STUDENT's ADD and OCD also adversely affects his educational performance as evidenced by his teachers' comments that he is easily distracted and frustrated, has difficulty taking notes from a lecture, and has difficulty focusing and following directions. (District's exhibits 6, 7, and 8) Additionally, Ms. Jacobs testified that STUDENT was spending six to sixteen hours per day dealing with his OCD and did not go for more than twenty minutes without to. Based on the comments of the teachers at NON PUBLIC SCHOOLand Ms. Jacobs' testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's ADD and OCD were adversely affecting his educational performance.

Finally, the same evidence also establishes that STUDENT's ADD and OCD caused him to lave limited alertness. Ms. Jacobs testified that the degree to which STUDENT had to deal with his OCD would have made it difficult for him to concentrate in class.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was eligible as "other health impaired" due to his ADD and OCD at the time the District completed its assessment. Additionally, as already stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability.

(2) Did Los Angeles Unified School District fail to offer STUDENT an appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year?

State and federal law requires that students with disabilities receive a free appropriate public education. California Education Code § 56000 et seq. and the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 USC § 1400 et seq. Pursuant to 20 USC § 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized education program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institutions."

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the child. 458 U.S. 176, 200.

The IDEA and the Rowley Court's interpretation of the IDEA provide a three factor test for determining whether a school district's proposed placement is appropriate. Those three factors are:

1. whether the placement is designed to meet the student's unique needs;

2. whether the placement conforms to the student's IEP; and 3. whether the placement is designed to provide educational benefit to the student.

In the present case, the District had found STUDENT ineligible for special education services and had proposed a regular education placement with modifications for the 1995-96 school year. Among those modifications are modified class assignments, provision of a note-taker, weekly assignment sheets, extra time for tests, counseling from a school psychologist, and tutoring.

The evidence establishes that the District's proposed placement would not have met STUDENT's unique needs or provided him with educational benefit during the 1995-96 school year. The testimony of those familiar with STUDENT, including Ms. Battle, Ms. Jacobs, MOTHER, and Dr. Silton, establish that when it came time for STUDENT to enroll in ninth grade he was in need of a much more structured environment than a regular education high school program could have provided him. Furthermore, the testimony of those witnesses establishes that STUDENT was in need of many more services than the modifications proposed by the District.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement of regular education for the 1995-96 school year was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.

(3) If Los Angeles Unified School District failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for his placement at Landmark West School for the 1995-96 school year?

The Supreme Court has held that parents may be awarded reimbursement for placements in which they unilaterally enroll their child when a school district has failed to provide an appropriate placement. Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, EHLR 556:389 (1985). The Burlington Court stated that "'such relief as the court determines is appropriate,' within the meaning of § 1415(e)(2), means that equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief."

The District contends that Petitioner should not be entitled to reimbursement for the 1995-96 school year because STUDENT was enrolled at Landmark West before the District had a chance to complete the IEP process. However, the portion of the Burlington decision which addresses this issue states that, in such a case, the parents would be barred from reimbursement if the IEP the school district proposed was ultimately deemed to be appropriate. That is not the case here. Burlington also does not preclude reimbursement when a parent unilaterally enrolls a child in violation of the stay put provisions of the IDEA.

In the present case, the District conducted an inadequate assessment of STUDENT which did not assess him in all areas of suspected disability and concluded based on the achievement test scores, that he was not eligible for special education services. The District's only proposed placement for STUDENT was in regular education with some modifications if needed, a type of placement which would not have succeeded as demonstrated by the difficulties STUDENT had at Stephen Wise. Furthermore, since the District's initial determination of ineligibility, the District has not proposed any other placements or offered to conduct any additional assessments. The testimony of Petitioner's witnesses also establishes that were STUDENT placed in a regular education high school without special education services his needs would not have been met and his condition would have deteriorated.

The evidence also establishes that Landmark West provided STUDENT with a beneficial educational program during the 1995-96 school year. From all reports, STUDENT had a successful year at Landmark West, including making the honor roll during both semesters. Testimony also indicated that STUDENT's OCD has been controlled, due in large part to a reduction in school-related stress. There was no evidence submitted that Landmark West was not an appropriate placement during the 1995-96 school year.

Applying the Rowley test to Landmark West, the Hearing Officer finds that Landmark West is providing STUDENT with educational benefit as demonstrated by his grades and the credible testimony of Ms. Jacobs and Ms. Battle. Furthermore, Landmark West is meeting STUDENT's needs by providing him with a structured educational program in a small environment.

In balancing the equities, it must be noted that the District's task was made more difficult by the fact that STUDENT was never enrolled in a public school program. The District did not have access to the type of information it might have had if STUDENT was enrolled in a District school. In addition, NON PUBLIC SCHOOLwas out of session during the assessment process and the District experienced some delay in obtaining information from his teachers at Stephen Wise. However, there is no evidence that the District took any extra steps to obtain additional information regarding STUDENT once the assessment and IEP process were completed. There is no evidence that the District ever proposed conducting additional assessments, obtaining additional information from STUDENT's teachers, or having his teachers participate in the IEP process.

Considering the totality of the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to adequately assess STUDENT, identify him as an individual with exceptional needs, and offer an appropriate placement deprived him of a free appropriate public education and warrants requiring the District to reimburse Petitioner for tuition and related costs associated with his placement at Landmark West during the 1995-96 school year.

(FOOTNOTE 6)

(4) Has Los Angeles Unified School District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year?

There was no evidence submitted to indicate that the District has offered any other placement for the 1996-97 school year, or offered to conduct any additional assessments to resolve the disputes between the parties. There was also no evidence submitted to indicate that STUDENT's disabilities have disappeared.

Therefore, for all of the reasons stated in issues #1, #2, and #3, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not offered an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year.

(5) If Los Angeles Unified School District did not offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year, is Los Angeles Unified School District required to provide him with placement at Landmark West School for the 1996-97 school year?

As already stated, pursuant to Burlington, parents may be entitled to reimbursement for nonpublic school costs when a school district fails to provide an appropriate placement and the parents unilaterally enroll their child in a nonpublic school. A determination of whether to allow such reimbursement requires a weighing of equitable considerations.

The evidence establishes that the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT and has not proposed any additional assessments or alternative placements other than regular education. The evidence establishes that STUDENT would not have been able to succeed in a regular education environment as proposed by the District in September 1995. While STUDENT's OCD has improved since September 1995, there is also no evidence to suggest that STUDENT's other disabilities have improved to the point that he would be able to succeed in a regular education environment at the present time.

In response to their concerns regarding STUDENT, his parents enrolled him at Landmark West. Once the District concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services, his parents maintained his placement at Landmark West for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT's parents have decided to continue his placement at Landmark West for the current school year also. MOTHER testified that she believed STUDENT needs two years of success at Landmark West before he is placed on a regular education high school campus.

The evidence establishes that Landmark West has provided STUDENT with an opportunity to benefit from his education and is meeting his individual needs by providing him with a structured educational program in a small environment. Furthermore, while enrolled at Landmark West, STUDENT's OCD symptoms have improved to the point where his medication has been removed and he is virtually symptom-free.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with Landmark West up to the date of this decision, and to maintain STUDENT's placement at Landmark West for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year.

ORDER

(1) Los Angeles Unified School District, upon presentation of proof provided by Petitioner, shall reimburse Petitioner for tuition associated with placement at Landmark West for the 1995-96 school year and for the 1996-97 school year up to the date of this decision.

(2) Los Angeles Unified School District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the date of this decision to develop an IEP for STUDENT in compliance with this decision. The IEP shall provide for STUDENT's placement at District expense for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year at Landmark West.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Ed. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 1, 1996 ______________________________ Mark Paxson, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Report of Dr. Audrey Griesbach, developmental pediatrician, dated December 12, 1990. 2. Dr. Silton testified that she did not see the behavioral observation forms from STUDENT's teachers at Stephen Wise prior to her evaluation. However, upon reviewing those forms, Dr. Silton testified that the information provided by STUDENT's teachers supports her own conclusions. 3. According to Ms. Trenhaile, she reviewed the District's assessment, Dr. Griesbach's report dated December 12, 1990, the optometric report dated October 1, 1991, and possibly the teacher reports filled out by STUDENT's teachers at Stephen Wise. However, Ms. Trenhaile did not review STUDENT's IEP, Dr. Silton's evaluation, Ms. Salzman's evaluation, Dr. Kyle's report dated October 22, 1990, or the Children's Enrichment Center report dated October 20, 1990.

4. The District administered achievement tests. However, it is District's policy not to administer IQ tests to any student. Therefore, the District's assessment of STUDENT did not include ability tests to compare his achievement scores with. Ms. Kaplan testified that she compared the scores STUDENT received on the PIAT-R and KTEA with the IQ test administered by Ms. Salzman.

5. The facts of this case make it difficult to distinguish between STUDENT's ADD and OCD. While some behavioral problems can be attributed to either ADD or OCD, the witnesses did not make such a distinction. In addition, much of the evidence relating to STUDENT's behaviors in class came from "Behavioral Observation" forms filled out by his eighth grade teachers at Stephen Weiss. The information provided by the teachers did not distinguish between ADD and OCD behaviors. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will look at ADD and OCD in combination.

6. It should be noted that although FATHER testified that the 1995-96 school year at Landmark cost $17,600, including transportation, Petitioner's statement of issues simply refers to "costs of that placement" and Petitioner's closing brief refers to "costs they have incurred and will incur in providing STUDENT with an appropriate placement." At no point in either the statement of issues or closing brief does Petitioner expand those phrases to include transportation costs. Whether or not a school district is responsible for transportation costs is a separate issue and since it was not addressed during the hearing, the Hearing Officer does not reach that issue in this decision.