California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 19, 1999
Student v. Lowell Joint Elementary School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 860-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Student must return from La Habra City to his home district, Lowell Joint; Hearing Officer finds Lowell's elementary placement offers a FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 12-year-old student filed for due process. His parents represented him. He has a genetic syndrome that affects his facial appearance and requires a health aide and hearing equipment at school. For five years he attended special day classes in La Habra City School District under an informal agreement between superintendents, not a formal interdistrict permit. He lived in Lowell Joint Elementary School District. Before sixth grade, La Habra said its middle schools were overcrowded and that he must return to Lowell. In Lowell he would spend another year at Macy Elementary School. The family agreed that either district could meet his academic needs and that no statutory exception to the residency rule applied. They argued he had a unique psychological need to stay with peers who accepted his appearance, and that La Habra was his least restrictive environment. They also said a former SELPA program specialist had promised he could stay in La Habra for his whole education. The Hearing Officer held that residency law controlled and that Lowell was his district of residence. She found no evidence of the alleged promise and no legal basis for an implied-contract or reliance theory. Placement is set each year at the annual IEP meeting. She found the timing appropriate because he would change schools anyway. She also found that both districts credibly committed to planning his transition and that Lowell's offer at Macy is a FAPE. All claims were denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a student's wish to stay in a district where he did not live. Residency law controlled. An informal superintendent arrangement and peer relationships did not create a right to stay. The Hearing Officer still reviewed whether the home district's offer, with transition planning, met the student's emotional needs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Is the Petitioner being denied a FAPE because La Habra and Lowell School Districts are requiring him to return to Lowell, his district of residence, after five years of attendance at La Habra? (Reframed to whether he has a unique psychological need to remain in La Habra, and whether La Habra rather than Lowell has an appropriate program.)
Student resides in Lowell and fits no statutory exception to the residency rule. No implied promise or detrimental reliance gave him a right to stay in La Habra, and Lowell's offer of placement at Macy Elementary is a FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims for relief denied. The Hearing Officer said an IEP meeting before Student starts at Macy, as Lowell proposed, is required, and strongly suggested convening it immediately to record the transition plans. This was not part of the formal order.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Joshua and Anita O. v. Board of Education of Wichita Public School; McCabe Union School District (SEHO 1993); Arcadia Unified School District (SEHO 1997); Education Code 48200; Education Code 48207; Education Code 46600; Education Code 48204; Government Code 244
People named in the decision
- Jane Schaefer, regional center representative present on Petitioner's behalf, Orange County Regional Center
- Margaret Herron, assistant superintendent for curriculum instruction; district witness, Lowell Joint Elementary School District
- Ronald Randolph, superintendent, Lowell Joint Elementary School District
- Tim Harvey, assistant superintendent; district witness, La Habra City School District
- Donald Green, SELPA administrator/director; district witness, NOCSELPA
- Rick Snyder, principal, Sierra Vista Elementary School; district witness, La Habra City School District
- Marcia Schoger, program specialist; district witness, NOCSELPA
- Elisabeth Peterson, school psychologist; district witness, La Habra City School District
- Linda Brant, former program specialist who arranged the original transfer (did not testify), NOCSELPA (former)
- Ms. Martin, first grade special day class teacher, La Habra City School District
- G. Robert Roice, educational advocate for both districts, G. R. Roice & Associates
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Whittier, California, on August 19, 1999. Petitioner Student (hereinafter Petitioner or Student) was represented by his parents, Mr. and Mrs. Parent. Also present on the Petitioner's behalf was Jane Schaefer from the Orange County Regional Center. Respondent Lowell Joint Elementary School District (hereinafter District Lowell or Lowell) and Respondent La Habra City School District (hereinafter District La Habra or La Habra) were both represented by educational advocate G. Robert Roice with the firm of G. R. Roice & Associates. Also present on Respondent Lowell's behalf were Margaret Herron, assistant superintendent of Lowell, and Ronald Randolph, superintendent of Lowell. Tim Harvey, assistant superintendent of La Habra, was present on La Habra's behalf. Donald Green, administrator for the North Orange County Special Education Plan Association (NOCSELPA), was present on behalf of both Districts. The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Petitioner and Mrs. Parent, mother of Petitioner. The Respondent called the following witness to testify: Tim Harvey, assistant superintendent of La Habra; Margaret Herron, assistant superintendent for curriculum instruction for Lowell; Donald Green, administrator of NOCSELPA; Rick Snyder, principal of Sierra Vista Elementary School in La Habra; Marcia Schoger, program specialist for NOCSELPA; and Elisabeth Peterson, La Habra school psychologist. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Officer received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS Before the hearing began, the parties discussed the issues to be addressed at hearing. The Petitioner acknowledged that he was not disputing whether either La Habra or Lowell could meet his academic needs. The Petitioner also acknowledged that he did not qualify for any of the statutory exceptions to the requirement that children attend their home school district. The Petitioner and Respondents therefore determined that the issue should be reframed to address whether the Petitioner is being denied a free and appropriate education (FAPE) because he has a unique psychological need to remain in La Habra, his district of nonresidence, which he attended the previous five years. The Petitioner also raised the issue of whether La Habra, rather than Petitioner's home District of Lowell, has an appropriate program for him. As a result of the above agreement, the Petitioner waived his statutory right to a ten-day notice of the witnesses to be called by the Respondent Districts, and agreed to proceed immediately with the hearing by allowing the Districts to augment their witness list and add three witnesses to address the Petitioner's unique psychological need to remain within the La Habra District. The Petitioner further waived his statutory right to the five-day notice of documentary evidence to be introduced at the hearing and allowed the Districts to include La Habra's May 1999 Individual Education Plan (IEP) team assessment report in their evidence at the hearing. The Districts consented to Petitioner's adding three written exhibits to his hearing evidence without the required five-day notice. ISSUE l. Is the Petitioner being denied a FAPE because La Habra and Lowell School Districts are requiring him to return to Lowell, his district of residence, after five years of attendance at La Habra? BACKGROUND FACTS Student is a twelve-year-old student entering sixth grade in the fall of 1999. He has qualified for special education since 1990 with a diagnosis of Pfeiffer Syndrome. His medical syndrome results in facial and cranial deformities, hydrocephalus with a shunt, a tracheotomy, an arched palate, a gastrointestinal tube (GI tube) that is used when he is unable to succeed with pureed foods, and phonic ear receivers in both ears that necessitate an FM device for hearing assistance in school. Student uses a Passy-Muir valve during speech therapy, and occasionally in the classroom, to improve his breath support and resulting speech utterances. Student requires the assistance of a health aide at school for medical reasons, including trach suctioning as needed. His visual skills are generally within the average range and he no longer wears corrective glasses. However, he displays some weaknesses in his ability to visually perceive and locate shapes when specific characteristics such as shape, size or color are changed. Academically, Student's math skills are at a mid-third-grade level and his reading skills are at an ending-third-grade level. His spelling skills are at a level equivalent to the end of the fifth grade. Student's auditory skills are significantly lower than most of his visual abilities. He has difficulty remembering reversed numbers, sentences, unrelated words and verbal directions. His greatest weakness is in the area of applying thinking and reasoning skills to unique thought problems. He also does not possess the general information he requires to solve some thought problems. Prior to the 1994-95 school year, when Student was to attend the first grade, his parents expressed dissatisfaction with the staff's acceptance of their son at Macy Elementary, his home school in Lowell School District. Mr. and Mrs. Parent had heard very positive things about a particular first grade teacher, Ms. Martin, in the La Habra School District. As a result, NOCSELPA program specialist contacted the superintendent at La Habra, Student's neighboring school district, on his behalf to determine whether he could attend that school district. Through an informal agreement between the superintendents of La Habra and Lowell, rather than a formal inter-district transfer, Student was allowed to attend Ms. Martin's first grade special day class (SDC). Each year thereafter at his annual IEP meeting, Student was continued at a La Habra school (footnote 1) without disagreement between the parties. Near the end of the 1998-99 school year, Student's parents were contacted by Marcia Schoger, a program specialist for NOCSELPA who worked with Student. She advised them that he would not be allowed by La Habra to continue on to its middle school for his sixth grade in the 1999-2000 school year. Instead, he would be required to return to Lowell, his district of residence. The decision by La Habra to return Student to his district of residence was based upon the fact that La Habra was severely impacted by overcrowding on all of its middle school campuses, including the SDC Student would have attended at Washington Middle School (Washington). La Habra's fifth grade students all transitioned to middle school at Washington, and Student and his parents had understood that he would be attending Washington with the classmates he had throughout elementary school. Thus, the information that he would not be authorized to attend Washington was extremely disturbing to them. Unlike the students at La Habra, Lowell District students do not begin middle school until the seventh grade. By returning to the Lowell School District for the 1999-2000 school year, Student would continue at Macy Elementary School for an additional year (sixth grade). The Petitioner has filed for a due process hearing because he believes he should be allowed to continue attending school in the La Habra school district at the middle school which services the elementary school he has attended. He further maintains that he is entitled to complete his entire educational career in the La Habra School District. CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES The Petitioner contends that the original NOCSELPA program specialist who arranged Student's transfer to La Habra School District advised them that Student would be able to continue in that district throughout his educational career. (footnote 2) The Petitioner also alleges that as a result of his facial deformities, strangers have extreme difficulty accepting him. He has made several friends at his elementary school. Moreover, the student body, with whom he has attended school for five years, has accepted him, and the students no longer adversely respond to his disability. These are the students with whom he expected to transition to middle school and then high school. It is the Petitioner's belief that if he is moved to a new school he will be ridiculed and unaccepted, and will thereby suffer psychological difficulties that will result in a denial of a FAPE. Moreover, his home school for sixth grade in the Lowell District would be Macy elementary. He claims that he did not have a positive experience when he attended there five years ago because the staff did not want him on the campus. He also states that, as a result of the above, the LRE environment for him is the La Habra School District with the students who know him. The District's position is that Student's attendance within the La Habra District was on a year-to-year basis and was determined at each annual IEP meeting. The agreement was informal between the superintendents of the two involved districts, and there was never any suggestion that Studentcould attend La Habra for his entire school career. In fact, such an agreement would be contrary to the requirement that a special education child's needs be reevaluated each year, and it would not have been possible to project Student's needs years into the future. The Districts also assert the statutory provisions of the California Education Code mandating that a child attend his or her district of residence, and point to the parents' acknowledgment that none of the statutory exceptions to the home district requirement applies to Student. Both La Habra and Lowell state that this is a good time emotionally for Student to return to Lowell District. It is a natural transition time; he would be required to change schools, in any event, if he remained at La Habra. In addition, the Districts state that another year at Macy, Lowell's elementary school campus, will be in Student's best interests because, rather than having to adjust to a large middle school, he will have an additional year in a small class like the one he has been in at La Habra. Returning to Lowell now will also allow Student to develop relationships with the students with whom he will attend middle and high school. Finally, La Habra contends that it does not have space for Student at its middle school as it is extremely overcrowded, and, as a result, it has had to deny Student's request, as well as the requests of other students, for interdistrict transfers. ISSUE ONE IS THE PETITIONER BEING DENIED A FAPE BECAUSE LA HABRA AND LOWELL SCHOOL DISTRICTS ARE REQUIRING HIM TO RETURN TO LOWELL, HIS DISTRICT OF RESIDENCE, AFTER FIVE YEARS OF ATTENDANCE AT LA HABRA? DISCUSSION Both La Habra and Lowell Districts contend that this case should be resolved exclusively on the legal issue of whether Student has a right to continue to attend school in a district in which he does not reside. They cite the California residency statute (California Education Code 48200) and the agreement of Petitioner's parents' that Student does not meet any of the statutory exceptions to the requirement that a child must attend his or her home school district. (California Education Code 46600, 48207.) The Hearing Officer agrees that if there is no implied or explicit exception that would allow Student to remain in a school district in which he does not live, this case will turn on Student's residency. The parties agree that the Petitioner resides within the Lowell School District. Residency under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the California Education Code is determined pursuant to the applicable laws of general residency. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F3d 1519 9th Cir (1994), held that "we ... find no basis for holding that the determination of residency under IDEA or the California Education Code should be different from the ordinary determination of residency." Education Code 48200 provides that a child will attend school in the district "in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located." Government Code 244 provides further guidance on the general definition of residency for both adults and children. This code section addresses the residency of minors in subsection (d) and states in relevant part: "The residence of the parent with whom an unmarried child maintains his or her place of abode is the residence of such an unmarried child." It is undisputed, and the Hearing Officer therefore finds, that Student's school district of residence is Lowell. Thus, the next relevant question is whether there are any exceptions to the general residency requirement that would entitle Student to remain within the La Habra School District.Statutory Exceptions to School Attendance within a Pupil's District of Residency The parties agree that the Petitioner is not exempt from the general residency requirements as a result of qualification under any exceptions enumerated in Education Code 46600 or 48207. However, the Hearing Officer briefly identifies these exceptions. The exception contained in Education Code 46600 specifies that two or more school districts may enter into an agreement for a term, not to exceed five years, for students to attend a district of nonresidence pursuant to an approved interdistrict permit. In this case, it is acknowledged that there was never a formal interdistrict permit granted to Student to attend La Habra. Instead, he attended pursuant to an informal agreement between the superintendents of the Respondent school districts. Moreover, even assuming arguendo, that this statutory exception applied, and a verbal agreement between two district superintendents constituted an approved interdistrict permit, Student has attended La Habra from the 1994-95 school year through the 1998-99 school year. Thus, the five years referenced in the statute have elapsed. In addition, if the verbal agreement between the two superintendents were construed as an effective interdistrict transfer permit, California Education Code 48204(F)(3) provides that an interdistrict permit may be revoked if the cost of continuing to educate the nonresident student is financially prohibitive. Arguably, providing an education for nondistrict students in light of the undisputed fact of overcrowding in La Habra's middle schools could constitute a financial hardship on La Habra. Further, the Districts cite decisions in which it has been held that districts are not required to accept nonresident students when they are impacted by overcrowding. (See McCabe Union School District (CA) 9/223/93 IDELR 20 1078, and Arcadia Unified School District (CA) 1/10/97 IDELR 26 883.) California Education Code 48207 provides for the following exceptions to the general residency statute and allows attendance in a school district in which the child's parents do not reside: (a) a child is placed in a foster home in a district in which his parents do not reside pursuant to California's Welfare and Institutions Code, (2) an interdistrict transfer request is approved per Education Code 46600 as described in the preceding paragraph, (3) the student is emancipated and resides within a school district other than the district of his or her parents. (4) the child lives in the home of a caretaker located in a school district in which his or her parents do not live, and (5) one or both of the parents of the student work within the district of nonresidence (this exception is at the discretion of the receiving district and is not an absolute right possessed by the parent(s) employed within the district of nonresidence). All parties state that none of these exceptions pertains to STUDENT, and there was no testimony presented to the contrary. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is not entitled to remain in the La Habra School District pursuant to any exceptions enumerated in Education Code 48207. The Hearing Officer recognizes the exception that a child attending a district of nonresidence because his parent(s) work within that district may be allowed to remain within that school district through the remainder of his public educational career. There is support for this claim contained in Education Code 48204(f)(7), which provides for a child's attendance in a district of nonresidence through the twelfth grade when a parent is employed within that district. However, this provision applies only when the student is attending a district of nonresidence pursuant to an interdistrict permit granted because his parent(s) works within the receiving district. Although, prior to the hearing, Mr. and Mrs. Parent submitted a document to the Hearing Office alleging that one of them worked within the La Habra School District, they retracted this assertion during the hearing. The Petitioner therefore does not contend that Student received, or was entitled to, an interdistrict permit based upon his parent(s)' place of employment. Implied Agreement that Petitioner Could Attend La Habra and/or Detrimental Reliance Mrs. Parent testified that the original NOCSELPA program specialist promised them that Student could remain in La Habra for his entire education and that they relied upon this promise when deciding to transfer him to La Habra. Mrs. Parent further asserted that during her son's five years at La Habra, they were never advised that he could be removed from the La Habra District and returned to his home district. Student's mother also testified that throughout his fifth grade school year (1998-99), he, along with the other students in his class, was prepared by the teacher to transition to La Habra's Washington Middle School. Finally, Mrs. Parent submitted correspondence from Washington Middle School welcoming Student as an incoming student, and cited this as additional evidence of La Habra's promise that Studentwould continue in its district(footnote 3). These arguments by the Petitioner are tantamount to assertions of either an implied contract and/or detrimental reliance. The Petitioner's support for these contentions is based upon the alleged representation of the prior NOCSELPA's program specialist, Linda Brant, that Studentcould attend La Habra through the conclusion of his school career, La Habra's alleged failure to advise him that his attendance in its district was year-to-year, and the letters from Washington indicating that Studentwas expected there as an incoming student. Each of the Districts' witnesses testified that Student's attendance within the La Habra District was determined on a yearly basis at his annual IEP meeting. This testimony is consistent with the purpose of California Special Education law which requires an annual IEP meeting to determine appropriate placement and services for a special education student based upon his or her current needs. California Education Code 56343(d) specifies that the purpose of an annual IEP meeting is to review the student's achievement of his annual goals, determine his or her appropriate placement, and make any necessary revisions to the pupil's program. Thus, to find that placement has been determined years into the future would be contrary to the statutory intent to reevaluate a special education student's needs each year. The Hearing Officer is further persuaded by the fact that the Petitioner has not provided any legal support for the proposition that a school district of nonresidence can be bound through education law by an implied contract or promise to allow a student to permanently attend its schools. The Hearing Officer also has not located any law supporting the position that accepting another school district's student places the district of nonresidence in the position of permanently educating that other district's student because the student has relied upon receiving his or her education in the district in which he does not live. To the contrary, the case of Joshua and Anita O. v. Board of Education of Wichita Public School, 26 IDELR 279 (1997) finds that a student who does not reside within a district attends at the pleasure of the receiving district. Ms. Brant did not testify at the hearing. However, Donald Green, the director of the NOCSELPA for the previous twenty years, did testify that even had Ms. Brant made the statement that Studentcould permanently attend La Habra School District (which he denied), she had no authority to make such a promise. The Hearing Officer does not accept this argument, as Ms. Brant would have appeared to the parents to be acting as an agent of NOCSELPA with the authority to make such a commitment. Instead, the Hearing Officer notes that there was no evidentiary support for the Petitioner's contentions, as Ms. Brant did not testify and Petitioner did not introduce any written evidence that such a promise was made. In addition, Ms. Schoger, the current NOCSELPA program specialist that works with the Petitioner's family, testified that Mrs. Parent requested a tour of schools in both Lowell and La Habra Districts in May 1999 for the stated purpose of exploring all options available to Student. Although Mrs. Parent obtained testimony from Ms. Schoger during cross-examination that she (Ms. Parent) ultimately decided to leave Student in the LaHabra's District, Ms. Schoger's testimony does provide evidence that the parents were aware Student could leave the La Habra District. The Issue of FAPE as it relates to the Petitioner's Unique Needs Although the Hearing Officer has concluded that the applicable statutory authority requires Student to return to his district of residence, she will briefly address the Petitioner's concerns that returning Student to his school district of residence, rather then transitioning him to the middle school at La Habra, will result in a denial of FAPE based upon consequent emotional damage and the loss of an LRE. These issues are noted because they relate to an appropriate program for Student within Lowell, the arrangements necessary to accommodate his return to his home school and they are important to the Petitioner's sense of well-being and acceptance at his home school district. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. 1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. 1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform to the students individual education program. Special education law provides that as part of an appropriate education, the child is entitled to "related services." Related services include transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. 1401(22). California Education Code 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, aide assistance, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management. Lowell has acknowledged that it will need to provide some of these DIS services. In determining whether a district has offered the services necessary to make a free, appropriate public education available, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed services. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another type of program, or whether their preferred services would result in greater educational benefit to the child. Services are adequate if they are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987). In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) identifies and addresses the student's unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, (3) conforms to the IEP, and (4) is provided in the LRE. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq. The Petitioner acknowledges that either Lowell or La Habra can meet his academic needs and provide services conforming to his IEP during the 1999-2000 school year. To reiterate Student's contentions, he claims that he has a unique psychological need to remain with the students with whom he has attended school for the past five years because he has made specific friends, and the school's student body has become accustomed to the physical deformities resulting from his medical syndrome. As a consequence, he asserts that returning to his school district will cause him emotional harm and distract him from focusing on his studies. Student also alleges that the school where his peers know and accept him is his LRE as he can comfortably move around the campus with students who know him and that he will not be able to do this in a new environment. Thus, Student's concerns for a FAPE consist of the components of addressing his unique emotional need and LRE. Again, the Hearing Officer addresses these issues to respond to Student's need for an appropriate program when he returns to Lowell, to include the evidence of the Respondents' sensitivity to his needs, and to memorialize the testimony under oath by witnesses from both Districts of the efforts planned to respond to the Petitioner's legitimate concerns in these areas. Student testified that he has made friends in his SDC and with the general population at La Habra's Sierra Vista Elementary. He wants to stay with his friends and transfer with them to Washington Middle School. The Hearing Officer understands Student's desires, as well as his parents' anxiety that the students at a new school will have to adjust to their child's medical conditions and that this may cause him emotional pain. However, the Hearing Officer also is cognizant of the Respondents' position that Student cannot be entirely protected his entire life, and that for his own future benefit he must enhance his skills in responding to people's reactions to him. La Habra District provided testimony that three and one-half elementary schools will be flowing into Washington Middle School. Thus, although Student would transition to Washington Middle School with friends he has made and students he knows, he would also be encountering a larger number of new individuals who are unfamiliar with him than he would if he returns to his home elementary school. The new people at the middle school would be as likely to respond in a negative way to Student's appearance and to require information and a period of time to get to know him, as would the students and staff at Macy Elementary School. Therefore, potential for emotional harm also exists on the Washington campus. Because a special education student's placement requirements are redetermined annually, and Student does not fall within the exceptions granting him a right to remain in a district of nonresidence, he could be required to return to his home school district for any future school year. Since he will be changing schools for the 1999-2000 school year in any event, any adjustments to ensure a smooth transition can be addressed now in a smaller environment if he returns to his home elementary school for an additional year, makes new friends, and then moves to Lowell's middle school in the seventh grade with his classroom/neighborhood peers. Each of the witnesses for the Districts, who know Student, testified that he is extremely personable, outgoing, and well adjusted, and that he makes friends easily. La Habra's witnesses described the brief transition period Student underwent when he changed from a La Habra second grade to another La Habra campus for his third through fifth grade years, and felt he would adjust just as quickly to this proposed transition. Further, the Districts' witnesses credibly stressed that now is an appropriate time to return Student to his district of residence as he would be transitioning anyway to a middle school if he remained within the La Habra District. The witnesses from both La Habra and Lowell indicated a genuine understanding of the need to prepare Lowell's students for Student's arrival and to provide him with any emotional support he may require on the Macy campus. They are already contemplating and discussing these issues. Lowell's witnesses also testified to the commitment of its District and the Macy school staff to provide a transition that is sensitive to Student's needs. With the assistance La Habra has agreed to provide, Lowell plans to follow the successful strategies used by La Habra in introducing Student to his new school peers, and to arrange any counseling Student may require to make the adjustment to his home school. The Districts' witnesses further testified that they had already conducted meetings together to plan for Student's transition to Macy, and they were hopeful the parents would participate in the transition planning. Following a consideration of the law and the evidence, the Hearing Officer determines that the law is dispositive of this case and requires Student's return to Lowell, his district of residence. The Hearing Officer further concludes that this is an appropriate time for Student to change schools and that Lowell can offer an appropriate educational program for him. Change is inevitable, and Student would be transitioning anyway if moving from elementary to middle school in La Habra. Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that Lowell is cognizant of Student's potential emotional needs at a new school, as well as the need to prepare its staff and student population for his attendance. Lowell's witnesses appeared genuinely concerned about responding to Student's needs at a new school. Lowell has expressed interest in meeting with Student's parents to prepare for Student's return to his home district. The Hearing Officer agrees that an IEP meeting before Student begins attending Macy, as proposed by Lowell, is required. CONCLUSION The evidence establishes that Student is not legally entitled to remain in La Habra, a district in which he does not reside, and that he must return to his district of residence. The Hearing Officer also finds that Lowell District's offer of placement at Student's home school, Macy Elementary, constitutes a FAPE and strongly suggests that the IEP meeting proposed by Lowell be convened immediately to memorialize the transition plans testified to at the hearing by Lowell's and La Habra's witnesses. ORDER 1. All of the Petitioner's claims for relief are denied PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issue heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i). Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
1)In the third grade, Student followed a La Habra special day class (SDC) teacher he had had for the extended school year (ESY) and transferred to Sierra Vista, another La Habra elementary school. He has remained at this school for his third, fourth and fifth grades.2)This NOCSELPA program specialist is no longer employed by the SELPA and was not produced by either party to testify at the hearing.3) Apparently, all students currently enrolled in a La Habra fifth grade class received these types of letters. The undisputed testimony was that the letters were sent to all fifth-graders listed on La Habra's student rosters to welcome them in their transition to middle school. Consequently, the letters were not sent exclusively to Student.
