California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 5, 1998

Student v. Calaveras Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 867-98 · Hearing Officer JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman

Calaveras Unified must offer a qualified shadow aide for a student with autism; four other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None. The decision notes two earlier dismissed due process cases on the same aide dispute: SN 82-98, filed by the parents and withdrawn April 7, 1998, and SN 589-98, filed by the District and withdrawn May 27, 1998.

Summary

The parents of a nine-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Calaveras Unified School District over who would serve as his classroom aide. He attended a general education class and also had an in-home Lovaas program. In January 1998 his IEP team agreed he needed an aide. The District assigned a classroom aide, Roseanne Powers. His behavior consultant, Mila Amerine-Dickens of the Central Valley Autism Project, believed Ms. Powers was not qualified. The parents kept him home for parts of the year.

The Hearing Officer found that he needed a highly skilled, unobtrusive shadow aide to carry out his behavior plan. That aide had to know him, have worked in his home program, be skilled in applied behavior analysis, avoid prompt dependence, and coach his teacher. Ms. Powers did not meet these criteria. Meeting state hiring standards for aides did not show she could meet this student's needs. The District therefore denied a FAPE for this service in 1997-98 and 1998-99.

The District won the other four issues. The student did not prove he needed a full inclusion specialist. Conflict within the IEP team did not deny the parents' participation. Reimbursement for home instruction was denied for three reasons: no proof the services were appropriate, no proof of benefit, and no written notice to the District. Compensatory education was denied because the equities were balanced. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to offer a qualified shadow aide. It may not assign Ms. Powers.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO judged whether a specific aide could meet one student's needs, apart from general hiring standards. The Hearing Officer set detailed aide qualifications and barred one aide. It also shows that reimbursement for home instruction required proof that the services were appropriate and helped the student, plus the written notice required by the 1997 IDEA amendments.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer Student an appropriate shadow aide (classroom aide) for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?

    Student needed a highly skilled shadow aide who knew him and had worked in his in-home program; the only aide offered did not meet these criteria, so the District denied FAPE as to this service for both years.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did Student require the services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year? Does he require such services for the 1998-99 school year?

    Student did not prove he needed a full inclusion specialist or show what services one would provide.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3. Was Student denied a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because of the composition of his IEP team?

    Team friction and the superintendent's and principal's participation did not deny parent participation; parents attended and actively participated, and fuller discussion of the aide would not have changed the outcome. The Hearing Officer encouraged the District to limit team membership.

  4. Issue 4. Are Student's parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services which they have provided since January 1998?

    Reimbursement for home instruction was denied because the parents did not show the services met his unique needs or gave educational benefit, and they did not give the written notice required by the 1997 IDEA.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Is Student entitled to compensatory education services, including full inclusion consultation and social skills programming, for the alleged failure of the District to provide an appropriate shadow aide?

    The equities were balanced, significant harm was not shown, and repeating third grade would allow remediation, so compensatory education was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the order, the District must convene an IEP meeting to discuss with the parents, identify, and offer an appropriate, highly skilled shadow aide for 1998-99. The aide must help implement Ms. Amerine-Dickens' behavior management plan and assist the teacher. The aide must meet six criteria: know Student and have worked in his in-home program; act as home-school liaison; be skilled in applied behavior analysis; avoid prompt dependence; coach the teacher; and have experience with high-functioning autistic children.
  • The District may not offer or assign Roseanne Powers as Student's shadow aide during the 1998-99 school year.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed.; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; 20 U.S.C. 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii); 20 U.S.C. 1414(d); Cal. Ed. Code 56363

People named in the decision

  • Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer (first two hearing days), Special Education Hearing Office
  • Jim Frost, Superintendent; IEP team member, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Dr. Keri Mills, Director of special education, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Betty White, Principal; IEP team member, Jenny Lind Elementary School
  • Diane Haupt, Second grade teacher, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Joy Stockard, Third grade general education teacher, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Roseanne Powers, District classroom aide proposed as shadow aide, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Don Spalding, Psychology intern (baseline data collection), Calaveras Unified School District
  • Becky McNeese, Special education teacher; interim shadow aide; later private consultant to family, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Sheila Mendoza, Instructional aide in third grade classroom, Calaveras Unified School District
  • Nancy Rutherford, Resource specialist, Jenny Lind Elementary School
  • Sonna McKee, Speech therapist, Jenny Lind Elementary School
  • Mila Amerine-Dickens, Clinical director and behavior consultant; witness for Student, Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP)
  • Erin Brunmeier, In-home Lovaas program assistant, Student's in-home program
  • Robin Eliason, Behavior analyst; expert witness for Student, Applied Behavioral Consultants
  • Dr. Ennio Cipani, Licensed psychologist; expert witness for District, California School of Professional Psychology
  • Dr. O. Ivar Lovaas, Supervisor of clinic where Student received discrete trial training, UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children
  • Kristine Ford, Witness regarding IEP team functioning
  • Debra Wright, Paralegal for Student
  • Valley Mountain Regional Center, Regional center funding in-home Lovaas program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

The first two days of hearing on this matter came before Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Andreas, California on July 7 and 8, 1998. The hearing was completed before JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Andreas, California on July 22-24, and August 25-28, 1998.(footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Maureen Graves during the first two days of hearing. Attorney Rick Ruderman of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy was also present on those days. For the remaining seven days of hearing, Petitioner was represented by attorney Bob Varma of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy. Petitioner’s parents, PARENTS, were present throughout the hearing on his behalf. Debra Wright, paralegal, was also present throughout the hearing. Respondent Calaveras Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Nancy Stephens. Ms. Stephens was joined by co-counsel Ray Dunn of Stroup & DeGoede for the last four days of hearing in August. Jim Frost, superintendent, was present throughout the hearing on behalf of the District. Dr. Keri Mills, director of special education, was also present for the final two days of hearing.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. The arguments were received, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate shadow aide for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?

2. Did STUDENTrequire the services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-98 school year? Does he require such services for the 1998-99 school year?

3. Was STUDENTdenied a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because of the composition of his individualized education program (IEP) team?

4. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services which they have provided since January 1998?

5. Is STUDENTentitled to compensatory education services, including full inclusion consultation and social skills programming, for the alleged failure of the District to provide an appropriate shadow aide?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a nine-year-old boy who was diagnosed with autism and found eligible for special education services at the age of three and one-half years old. STUDENT has received intensive discrete trial training at home and through the UCLA Clinic for the Behavioral Treatment of Children supervised by Dr. O. Ivar Lovaas. During his stay at the Lovaas Clinic, STUDENT was identified as a high-functioning autistic child who had the potential to perform successfully in a regular education environment. STUDENT has now moved on to the "Next Step"(footnote 2) phase of his in-home Lovaas program supervised by the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP) and has attended regular education classes from kindergarten through third grade. During kindergarten and first grade, STUDENT had the assistance at school of a shadow aide(footnote 3) who had also served in his in-home program.

At the end of second grade, in June 1997, both STUDENT’s teacher, Diane Haupt, and his consultant with CVAP, Mila Amerine-Dickens, noted that STUDENT was having difficulty with task start-up and completion and with attending during group instruction . (Pet. Exh. 12T, 12S.) STUDENT’s teacher recommended that a behavior plan be developed to address these problems. Likewise, Ms. Amerine-Dickens recommended that the concerns she had identified be considered when planning STUDENT’s third-grade year.

On September 8, 1997, the IEP team met and developed STUDENT’s educational program for the 1997-98 school year.(footnote 4) STUDENT was placed in a second-third grade combination class in regular education with resource program consultation to the teacher for 30 minutes per week, speech and language services four times per week for 30 minutes, consultation by a behavior analyst and a speech therapist, and computer services using the Fast ForWord program, a language processing program. (Resp. Exh. B-123.) In addition, STUDENT continued to receive his in-home Lovaas program funded at 17 hours per week by Valley Mountain Regional Center (VMRC).

Over the fall, FATHER visited STUDENT’s class on a regular basis, and MOTHER came to class for special events. By November, PARENTS had become very concerned that STUDENT was not making progress and would need a classroom aide to complete the year. STUDENT’s teacher, Joy Stockard, was also concerned about STUDENT’s academic progress and social behaviors, which she summarized in a progress report dated October 18, 1997. In December 1997, Ms. Amerine-Dickens was contacted by the District and told about STUDENT’s difficulties in class. In early January 1998, Ms. Amerine-Dickens observed STUDENT in class and noted that he was having difficulties receiving instruction, staying on-task, and displaying appropriate social behavior with his peers.

On January 14, 1998, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss the concerns about STUDENT’s progress and behaviors. Ms. Amerine-Dickens presented her observations and recommendations at the meeting and later in a written report. She recommended that baseline data be collected and that a behavior management plan be developed for STUDENT and implemented by the teacher and a classroom aide who had certain specific qualifications. (Resp. Exh. B-64.) Ms. Amerine-Dickens also recommended that STUDENT’s in-home and school programs work more closely together and that STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties be resolved as soon as possible because he had "no time to spare." (Resp. B-64.) The team adopted these recommendations, including the recommendation for an aide, but the District did not agree to hire Erin Brunmeier, STUDENT’s in-home assistant, as recommended by Ms. Amerine-Dickens and requested by the PARENTS. A follow-up meeting was scheduled for January 21 to develop the behavior management plan after data collection was completed. The parents requested that the classroom aide begin working with STUDENT the week following the January 14 IEP team meeting.

On January 15 and 16, Roseanne Powers, a District classroom aide, and psychology intern Don Spalding observed STUDENT in class and gathered baseline data for the behavior plan. Ms. Powers was also assigned by the District to serve as STUDENT’s classroom aide. Ms. Amerine-Dickens found that she could not use the baseline data which had been collected and prepared a draft behavior management plan without it in anticipation of the January 21 meeting. On January 22, 1998, the PARENTS withdrew STUDENT from Ms. Stockard’s class because of their concerns about the classroom aide selected by the District to work with STUDENT. On the same date, the PARENTS filed a request for due process hearing (SN 82-98) against the District concerning the issues raised in the January 14 IEP team meeting.

After the due process request was filed, the District and the PARENTS discussed the need for interim educational services for STUDENT pending resolution of the due process case. On February 13, 1998, they agreed that special education teacher Becky McNeese would serve for a maximum of 30 days as an interim shadow aide for STUDENT upon his return to school. The parties also agreed to further training for the assigned aide and an alternate aide, and reached several other points of agreement concerning STUDENT’s interim program.

STUDENT received educational services at home until he returned to school on March 5, 1998. When he returned, Ms. McNeese began working as STUDENT’s classroom aide and also provided assistance to help his teacher better understand STUDENT’s autistic behaviors. From March 5 through March 27, 1998, Ms. McNeese collected baseline data on STUDENT’s behaviors for Ms. Amerine-Dickens to use in preparing a revised behavior management plan and implemented the draft behavior management plan from January. On April 1, 1998, Ms. McNeese provided a written report to the District summarizing her activities during her assignment and recommending several follow-up steps, including the recommendation that she continue in the classroom for at least two weeks after the off-track period. On April 5, 1998, the revised behavior plan was completed by Ms. Amerine-Dickens.

On April 7, 1998, the first day of due process hearing in SN 82-98, the PARENTS withdrew their request and the case was dismissed.

On March 27, STUDENT went off-track and was scheduled to return to school after the break on April 29. He did not return to school when the off-track period ended and has not returned since. Instead, MOTHER worked with STUDENT at home and hired Ms. McNeese as a private consultant to assist her and supervise STUDENT’s educational program.(footnote 5). In late April, the District also required Ms. McNeese to provide a 21-hour training course for Ms. Powers, Ms. Stockard, Sheila Mendoza, an instructional aide in Ms. Stockard’s classroom, and Dr. Mills, apparently to carry out the terms of the February 13 interim agreement.

On May 1, 1998, the District filed a request for due process hearing (SN 589-98) on essentially the same issues as were presented at the January 14 IEP team meeting and in the PARENT’s previous due process request (SN 82-98). On May 27, 1998, the second day of hearing in the District’s case, the District withdrew its request for due process and the case was dismissed.

On June 10 and 16, 1998, STUDENT’s IEP team met for his annual review. Upon recommendation of Ms. Amerine-Dickens, the team decided to have STUDENT repeat third grade during the 1998-99 school year. STUDENT was also offered RSP consultation services for 30 minutes per week, language, speech and hearing services four times per week for 30 minutes each session, speech and behavioral consultation services, "behavior support," a 1:1 aide(footnote 6), and assistance during off-track times.

On June 12, 1998, the PARENTS filed this request for due process hearing, again raising the issues from the January 14 IEP team meeting.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that he has been denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-98 school year because the District did not provide him with a qualified shadow aide and a full inclusion specialist. Petitioner also claims that he was denied FAPE on procedural grounds during that year for two reasons. First, Petitioner asserts that the District refused to discuss the recommendation and proposed qualifications for the aide, thereby denying his parents the opportunity to fully participate in the IEP process. Second, Petitioner states that the composition of his IEP team included individuals who served no "useful or legal purpose" and effectively created a hostile environment preventing team decision-making. (Pet. Closing Arguments, pg. 45.) Petitioner requests that the Hearing Officer determine the composition of the IEP team.

Petitioner claims entitlement to retroactive reimbursement for educational services provided by his mother and others at home during 1998 when he was not attending school. Petitioner also claims that he is entitled to compensatory education for significant educational harm that he suffered because his needs for an aide and inclusion specialist were not addressed by the District. He requests remedies of full inclusion consultation and social skills programming by Ms. McNeese.

The District contends that STUDENT has been provided a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because the aide proposed had "adequate qualifications" and even exceeded state standards for education, training and experience. The District states that FAPE has not been denied on procedural grounds because Petitioner has not shown that any hostility between IEP team members affected his education. The District also contends that assignment of individual staff duties is the prerogative of the governing board and not the Hearing Office. The District argues that Petitioner does not need a full inclusion specialist for several reasons. Finally, the District asserts that Petitioner’s requests for retroactive reimbursement and compensatory education should both be denied given the circumstances under which STUDENT was removed from school and other contractual constraints affecting the District.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate classroom aide for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?

The IEP team determined on January 14, 1998, that STUDENT needs a classroom aide. (Pet. 9D.) The only dispute regarding the aide concerns what qualifications the aide must have to meet STUDENT’s needs and whether the aide assigned by the District, Roseanne Powers, is appropriately qualified. Petitioner contends that he has been denied FAPE because Ms. Powers does not satisfy the criteria and qualifications to be his shadow aide. Petitioner also claims he has been denied FAPE on procedural grounds because District members of the IEP team refused to discuss the criteria and qualifications for his aide during IEP team meetings in January and June 1998. The District contends that Ms. Powers is an appropriate aide for STUDENT because her background, education and training "exceeds state standards" for instructional aides and she has sufficient education and experience in the field of autism to work with STUDENT.

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) 20 U.S.C. Secs. 1400, et. seq., and state special education law, STUDENT is entitled to related services (known in California as "designated instruction and services" or DIS), such as a classroom aide, if necessary for him to benefit educationally from his instructional program. (20 U.S.C. 1401(22); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) Such services must be appropriate to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs. (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(25); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56031.) The IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services, or that the services maximize each child’s potential. (Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176) Rather, "the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. (Id. at 200.) Based on these provisions, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the aide assigned by the District was appropriately qualified to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and help him benefit from his education.

The evidence established that on January 14, 1998, STUDENT’s IEP team met and determined that "an aide will be assigned to the classroom to assist STUDENT, but be unobtrusive and subtle. This person will be there initially 7:45-1:45. Mila [Ms. Amerine-Dickens] recommends this person be someone trained in beh. analysis, someone who knows STUDENT’s abilities, and also works in the home to facilitate consistency." (Pet. Exh. 9D.) In her January 19, 1998 report to the IEP team, which was the basis for this statement in the IEP, Ms. Amerine-Dickens noted that STUDENT’s classroom aide "should have extensive hand’s-on (sic) experience working with STUDENT and children like STUDENT. She should have extensive knowledge in applied behavior analysis, the application and implementation of the principles of applied behavior analysis, know how to effectively prompt, fade and reinforce, and work with STUDENT in the in-home program." (Resp. Exh. B-64.)

At hearing, Ms. Amerine-Dickens, Ms. McNeese and Ms. Eliason, who each have expertise in the field of autism and applied behavioral analysis, testified for Petitioner concerning the type of classroom aide STUDENT needs. Mila Amerine-Dickens testified that she has a master’s degree in clinical psychology, is a marriage, family, and child counseling (MFCC) intern, and a registered behavior analyst with the California Association of Behavior Analysts since 1993. She is a vendor with the Department of Developmental Services and qualified to provide behavioral consultation and consultation to families with autistic children. She is currently employed as clinical director of CVAP and previously was a behavioral consultant for the Lovaas Clinic at UCLA, and a private behavioral analyst. Ms. Amerine-Dickens testified that CVAP is a Lovaas replication site relying on the Lovaas approach, and that CVAP has special expertise in treating high-functioning autistic children. Ms. Amerine-Dickens has worked with STUDENT since he began the Lovaas program in 1993.

Becky McNeese has been a special education teacher for 20 years and has credentials to teach students with severe handicaps and communicative handicaps. She is employed by the District and will soon be licensed as a behavior analyst. Ms. McNeese testified that she knew STUDENT from having worked with him at Jenny Lind Elementary School one or two years ago. She also worked with STUDENT in Ms. Stockard’s class during March 1998, and at home thereafter. Robin Eliason has a master’s degree in clinical psychology with concentration in applied behavior analysis, and is employed by Applied Behavioral Consultants. She is also a vendor for the Department of Developmental Services. Ms. Eliason has worked with young autistic children since 1991. (Pet. Exh. *A.) Ms. Eliason stated that she had observed STUDENT at home in 1995 and again recently.

From the credible testimony of these three witnesses, Petitioner established STUDENT’s need for a highly skilled shadow aide in the classroom to implement the behavior management plan prepared by Ms. Amerine-Dickens and to assist the classroom teacher in working with STUDENT. According to their testimony, the aide must: (1) know STUDENT well and have worked with him in his in-home program; (2) act as a liaison between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs; (3) understand and be skilled in applied behavioral analysis and be able to carry out observational learning, effective reinforcement, data collection, social skills training, rule-governed behavior principles, effective prompts and fades; and an evolving behavior plan; (4) avoid prompt dependence; (5) coach the teacher in implementing the behavior plan and in using effective behavior principles with STUDENT throughout the day; (6) have experience and training in working with autistic children, particularly high-functioning autistic children such as STUDENT.

Dr. Ennio Cipani, a professor at the California School of Professional Psychology, testified on behalf of the District concerning the aide’s qualifications. Dr. Cipani is a licensed psychologist who specializes in behavior analysis and has developed many behavior intervention plans under the Hughes Bill. Dr. Cipani testified that he worked with STUDENT briefly several years ago, but has not seen him in class recently. Dr. Cipani provided general comments on behavioral analysis and reviewed the behavior plan, but acknowledged that he was unfamiliar with the concept of a shadow aide in the context of the Lovaas program and did not know STUDENT’s issues requiring behavioral analysis and an aide. Thus, the Hearing Officer gave little weight to his testimony in this area.

Three other District witnesses who testified concerning the aide’s qualifications differed from Petitioner’s witnesses on only one or two significant points. Dr. Kerri Mills, director of special education, testified that she disagreed with Ms. Amerine-Dickens recommendation that the aide be the same person who was working with STUDENT in his in-home program because STUDENT could become aide-dependent. Dr. Mills also believed it would be helpful for the aide to know the third-grade curriculum. Nancy Rutherford, the resource specialist at Jenny Lind, re-stated these same two points in her testimony. Sonna McKee, the speech therapist at Jenny Lind, testified that she believed STUDENT’s aide should know the curriculum and described several other qualifications which were consistent with Ms. Amerine-Dickens’ recommendations.

The disagreement over whether STUDENT’s aide must have known him and have worked in his in-home program appears to go to the heart of the parties’ dispute regarding STUDENT’s aide. In her testimony, Ms. Amerine-Dickens explained STUDENT’s need for an aide with this type of experience. She stated that STUDENT learns the majority of his skills in his in-home Lovaas program on a 1:1 basis and then generalizes his learning in peer play and in the classroom. Because of this approach, it is vital to have collaboration between home and school, and it is critical for STUDENT’s shadow aide to understand the home program and to carry over STUDENT’s skills in both settings.

Ms. McNeese testified that some of STUDENT’s behavior which appears "normal" to the untrained observer could be inappropriate self-stimulatory behavior or other non-functional behavior that is characteristic of autistic children. Without an aide who knows STUDENT and has worked with him, such behavior could easily be overlooked, defeating the purposes of the behavior plan. In her testimony, Ms. Eliason gave an example of this, stating that she had observed but had not properly identified self-stimulatory behavior in STUDENT. She testified that her oversight indicated how subtle STUDENT’s "stimming" can be, and how important it is that his aide know him.

The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of these three witnesses persuasively substantiated STUDENT’s need for an aide who knows him and has worked with him in the in-home program. Further, all of STUDENT’s prior shadow aides during kindergarten and first grade had worked with him in his in-home program. (Testimony of Ms. Amerine-Dicken and, MOTHER) The District presented no persuasive educational reasons for departing from what has worked for STUDENT in the past, and apparently has resisted Ms. Amerine-Dickens’ recommendation on this point for personnel reasons not related to STUDENT’s needs.

The second area of disagreement concerns the aide’s need for knowledge of the school curriculum. Petitioner’s witnesses were clear that such knowledge was not necessary because STUDENT requires a shadow aide to help implement the behavior plan rather than an aide to assist with instructional matters.(footnote 7) Because STUDENT does not require a 1:1 instructional aide, the Hearing Officer finds that his aide need not have knowledge of his school curriculum.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a highly skilled shadow aide in the classroom to help implement the behavior management plan prepared by Ms. Amerine-Dickens and to assist the classroom teacher in working with him. The shadow aide must have the following knowledge and abilities to meet STUDENT’s needs: (1) know STUDENT well and have worked with him in his in-home program; (2) be able to act as a liaison between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs; (3) understand and be skilled in applied behavioral analysis and be able to carry out observational learning, effective reinforcement, data collection, social skills training, rule-governed behavior principles, effective prompts and fades; and an evolving behavior plan; (4) be able to avoid prompt dependence; (5) be able to coach the teacher in implementing the behavior plan and in using effective behavior principles with STUDENT throughout the day; (6) have experience and training in working with autistic children, particularly high-functioning autistic children such as STUDENT.

The next question is whether the aide proposed by the District, Roseanne Powers, is appropriate under the above criteria to serve as STUDENT’s shadow aide. Ms. Amerine-Dickens, Ms. McNeese, and Ms. Eliason each testified that Ms. Powers is not an appropriate aide for STUDENT. Ms. Amerine-Dickens stated that Ms. Powers is not qualified to be STUDENT’s aide because she does not have the necessary experience, does not know STUDENT, and has never worked with him in the in-home program. Ms. Amerine-Dickens also documented these concerns over the assignment of Ms. Powers to be STUDENT’s aide in a letter to the superintendent dated January 18, 1998. (Pet. Exh. 7U.) Ms. McNeese provided training to Ms. Powers during April 1998 and was also familiar with Ms. Powers’ work as an instructional aide at Jenny Lind. (Testimony of Ms. McNeese.) Based on these experiences, Ms. McNeese testified that Ms. Powers is not qualified to be STUDENT’s shadow aide and that she could easily fall into "heavy prompting," which is common for persons with a beginning level of training and experience in autism. Ms. McNeese even expressed concern that Ms. Powers might prove harmful if she became STUDENT’s aide and caused him to become prompt dependent. Ms. Eliason stated that she had observed Ms. Powers in the classroom and believed that she did not have the level of skill needed to serve as STUDENT’s aide.

Dr. Cipani testified that he observed Ms. Powers for about one hour while she was doing discrete trial training in class with a severely/moderately retarded student. He also interviewed her briefly afterwards. From this limited contact, Dr. Cipani concluded that Ms. Powers was a "capable behavior aide" and could serve as STUDENT’s aide. Dr. Cipani testified that it would take only one-half hour to train STUDENT’s aide for the tasks required. While Dr. Cipani is very knowledgeable in the area of behavior analysis, his knowledge of STUDENT and his needs was, by his own admission, very limited. Thus, Dr. Cipani’s testimony concerning Ms. Powers appropriateness to serve as STUDENT’s aide was not particularly persuasive.

Ms. Powers also testified about her background, training and qualifications to serve as STUDENT’s aide. She has never worked with STUDENT except to observe him for two days in January 1998 for purposes of data collection. Ms. Powers has not worked with STUDENT in his in-home Lovaas program and has not worked in the in-home program of any other child. She has been told how to shadow a fully included student but has never actually done so. Ms. Powers attended training provided by Ms. McNeese for seven and one-half of the 21 hours scheduled in late April 1998. Despite this and other training in applied behavioral analysis, Ms. Powers could not define key behavioral terms such as negative reinforcement and rule-governed behavior. Many of Ms. Powers responses to questions about her qualifications were nonresponsive, leaving the Hearing Officer with doubts about Ms. Powers’ actual experience and preparation. Ms. Powers testified that she feels qualified to shadow STUDENT because of the two-day training she received from Ms. McNeese and because the tasks described in STUDENT’s behavior plan "didn’t seem difficult to do." Ms. Powers maintained this view even after learning that several of Petitioner’s witnesses who knew STUDENT and his needs had testified that they did not consider her to be qualified.

The District argues in its Closing Brief that Ms. Powers’ experience and training "exceeds state standards" spelled out in various employment and hiring provisions under the Education Code for paraprofessionals, assistants and instructional aides. This argument misses the point, because the question is not whether Ms. Powers is qualified to be hired by the District or meets other labor standards, but whether she is an appropriate shadow aide to meet STUDENT’s needs as identified above.

From the foregoing analysis, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Powers’ qualifications do not sufficiently satisfy the above-noted criteria for her to serve as STUDENT’s shadow aide. The testimony indicated that Ms. Powers was the only aide offered by the District to serve STUDENT in the classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Powers was not an appropriate shadow aide for STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year, and is not an appropriate shadow aide for STUDENT prospectively for the 1998-99 school year. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to offer Petitioner an appropriate classroom aide for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. Because the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate classroom aide, it has denied him a FAPE as to that DIS service. Petitioner’s contention that he was also denied a FAPE on procedural grounds will be considered in Issue No. 3 below.

Issue No. 2: Did STUDENT require the services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-98 school year? Does he require such services for the 1998-99 school year?

Petitioner contends that the District has denied him a FAPE as to full inclusion services because the District has never offered him a full inclusion specialist. Petitioner claims that the District’s multidisciplinary team at Jenny Lind has not effectively supported full inclusion for STUDENT, as the District contends. Petitioner asserts that he needs a full inclusion specialist "to oversee his program, monitor the services being provided and ensure that appropriate services are provided to attain successful full inclusion, including teacher training." (Pet. Closing Argument, pg. 41.) The District contends that STUDENT does not need a full inclusion specialist to benefit from his education and that he performed adequately in class when he was in attendance. The District also claims that STUDENT has a team of professionals assisting him currently (i.e. regular education teacher, resource specialist, speech and language specialist, director of special education, a 1:1 instructional aide,(footnote 8) and two nonpublic agency consultants--a behavior specialist and an additional speech and language specialist) and that he does not require an additional person to be a successful full inclusion student in the classroom.

Under state and federal law, the District must provide a full inclusion specialist for STUDENT if such a specialist is determined necessary for him to benefit from his instructional program. (20 U.S.C. 1401(22); Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56363(a).) The evidence indicates that a full inclusion specialist was not offered to STUDENT by the District in either the September 8, 1997 IEP or the addendum of January 14, 1998.(footnote 9) (Resp. Exh. B-123; Pet. Exh. 9D.) The June 10 and 16, 1998 IEPs also do not reflect a District offer of a full inclusion specialist for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year. (Pet. Exh.**O.)

Several witnesses testified in general about full inclusion but little meaningful evidence was presented to document STUDENT’s need for this type of specialist. In her January 19, 1998 consultation report, Ms. Amerine-Dickens made virtually no reference to STUDENT’s needing a full inclusion specialist. In fact, Ms. Amerine-Dickens suggested in her report that providing STUDENT with a shadow aide in the classroom to help implement the behavior plan and assist his teacher would promote full inclusion goals.(footnote 10) In written recommendations made by Ms. McNeese on April 1, 1998, there is also no reference to STUDENT’s needing a full inclusion specialist. (Pet. Exh.*2C.) Dr. Keri Mills testified that STUDENT does not need a full inclusion specialist because he has other consultants on his IEP team who work with the teacher.

Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to prove that he needs the services of a full inclusion specialist. Petitioner has also not shown what services such a specialist would provide and how these services are necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Because Petitioner did not need a full inclusion specialist during the 1997-98 school year and has not shown a continuing need for such services in the 1998-99 school year, his request for a full inclusion specialist is denied.

Issue No. 3: Was STUDENT denied a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because of the composition of his individualized education program (IEP) team?

Under special education law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. (IDEA, 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8)(A)-(D), Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56000, et seq.) This right includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an IEP and placement for a disabled child. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees (9th Cir. 1992) 18 IDELR 1019, 1021; Hendrick Hudson Central School District Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 181.) Among the most basic of these is the parents’ right to participate in the development of IEPs and placement decisions regarding their child. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56341, 56342; 34 CFR Sec. 300.345, 300.533.)

Here, Petitioner contends that his parents have been denied open and full discussion of the aide issue and that he has been denied educational opportunity due to the participation on the IEP team of District Superintendent Jim Frost and the principal of Jenny Lind, Betty White. Petitioner contends that these two individuals were not necessary under the law and prevented the team from working collaboratively from January through June 1998. Petitioner requests that the Hearing Officer determine the composition of the IEP team in the future.

The District contends that its governing board, not the Hearing Office, has the authority "to assign or not assign specific individuals respecting STUDENT’s program of special education and related services." (Dist. Closing Brief, pg. 10.) The District also asserts that Ms. White maintained an appropriate professional demeanor during IEP team meetings and did not create a hostile environment. The District claims that Petitioner has presented no relevant evidence to justify removing Mr. Frost from the team.

Several witnesses testified that the IEP teams of January and June 1998 did not function effectively or work collaboratively to discuss and determine STUDENT’s program. (Testimony of Ms. McNeese, Kristine Ford, MOTHER, FATHER.) The evidence also indicated that the participation of Mr. Frost and Ms. White may have distracted the team at times due to personal matters. Although the team was not working in a highly effective manner during this period, the evidence does not support a finding that the team’s failure amounted to a denial of parental participation. STUDENT’s parents were either in attendance or represented at each of the IEP team meetings, and transcripts of the meetings indicated that they actively participated. While the parents were not able to gain full District agreement with the recommendations made by Ms. Amerine-Dickens, lack of agreement does not amount to a denial of FAPE on procedural grounds.

Petitioner’s contention that lack of full discussion of the aide issue in the IEP team amounted to denial of educational opportunity for STUDENT also is not adequate grounds to find a denial of FAPE. Even had there been full discussion, the record indicates that the parties would still have disagreed as to the individual appropriate to serve as STUDENT’s aide and what qualifications that individual should have. Thus, any lack of full discussion did not result in a denial of educational opportunity to STUDENT. It appears to the Hearing Officer that both the parents and the District were acting out of the strongly held beliefs that have led to the present dispute. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not been denied a FAPE due to the composition of the IEP team during the 1997-98 school year or the lack of full discussion of the aide issue.Although the IEP team’s difficulties do not rise to the level of denial of FAPE, it nevertheless appears to the Hearing Officer that the IEP team might have functioned more effectively if Mr. Frost and Ms. White were not members. The personal issues between these two individuals and the FAMILY NAME family apparently clouded the issues for discussion and, at times, diverted the focus of the team away from STUDENT. Further, there was little evidence that either Mr. Frost or Ms. White has special education expertise, background in autism or knowledge of applied behavioral analysis that would have assisted the team with decision-making regarding STUDENT’s program.

Thus, the Hearing Officer strongly encourages the District to review the composition of the IEP team and to limit its membership to key individuals required under federal law in IDEA1997, 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1414(d)(B), namely: (i) the parents of a child with a disability; (ii) at least one regular education teacher of such child; (iii) at least one special education teacher, or where appropriate, at least one special education provider of such child; (iv) a representative of the local educational agency who--(I) is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of children with disabilities, (II) is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, and (III) is knowledgeable about the availability of resources of the local educational agency (such as Dr. Mills); (v) an individual who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results, who may be a member of the team described in clauses (ii) through (vi); (vi) at the discretion of the parent or the agency, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child, including related services personnel as appropriate; and (vii) whenever appropriate, the child with a disability. (See also Education Code Section 56341(b) and (c).)

The District is also encouraged to consider re-configuring STUDENT’s 1998-99 IEP team in accordance with the recommendations of Dr. Keri Mills, who suggested that the team be reduced to include only STUDENT’s parents, his regular education classroom teacher, the resource program specialist, an administrator from Jenny Lind, and herself as facilitator.

Issue No. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services which they have provided since January 1998?

In Burlington School Comm. v. Mass. Dept. of Ed. (1983) 471 U.S. 359, the U.S. Supreme Court held that parents of disabled children may receive retroactive reimbursement for the tuition and related expenses of unilaterally placing their child in a special education program of their choice. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide the child with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) and the parents’ placement is determined to be proper under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. (Burlington, supra, at 369-370; see also Rowley, supra, at 207.) Reimbursement may be awarded even if the parents’ placement does not meet state educational standards. (Florence County School District Four, et al., v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 20 IDELR 532.)

Here, the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate classroom shadow aide during the 1997-98 school year. Because the assigned aide, Roseanne Powers, was not appropriately qualified to meet STUDENT’s needs, Petitioner’s parents seek reimbursement for educational services provided to STUDENT at home for those time periods from January 22, 1998, to the present, when he was not in school. The parents are requesting reimbursement for the services of: (1) Becky McNeese, a credentialed teacher who provided teaching materials and program consultation to MOTHER; (2) Erin Brunmeier, a 1:1 instructional aide at home; and (3) MOTHER for 1:1 instruction. (Pet. Exh. 17W.)

Although there was some testimony concerning the nature of services provided by these three individuals, Petitioner presented virtually no evidence concerning his unique educational needs, in general, and how these services were designed to meet those needs. Without such evidence, the Hearing Officer is not able to determine whether the educational services STUDENT received were appropriate under the IDEA.

As for the question of educational benefit, the evidence was conflicting and unclear concerning STUDENT’s progress as a result of his home educational program. Achievement testing using the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery-Revised (WJ-R) was completed in June 1998 by Ms. Rutherford, the resource specialist. The results indicated that STUDENT’s performance, compared to other children his age, was average in basic reading skills, reading comprehension, basic mathematics skills and broad written language, and low average in mathematics reasoning, basic writing skills and broad knowledge. (Dist. Exh. AA22.) However, when STUDENT’s performance was compared to his 1997 performance in three areas on the WJ-R, his scores reflected slight decline in broad math, broad reading, and broad written language. (Dist. Exh. AA2, AA3, AA5.)

Despite this performance on standardized tests, Ms. Amerine-Dickens reported on June 10, 1998, "In general, it appeared that STUDENT has made gains in the home school environment, with his mother as the ‘teacher’." (Pet. Exh.**Y.) This general statement was not supported with specific examples or documentation for the conclusion reached in either the report or in Ms. Amerine-Dickens’ testimony. Therefore, the Hearing Officer found the comment to be of little use in determining whether STUDENT had received educational benefit.

Perhaps the most significant evidence on the question of educational benefit was the IEP team’s acknowledgment of STUDENT’s lack of progress in both the academic and social areas at the June 1998 IEP team meetings. (Testimony of Ms. McNeese.) Because appropriate progress had not been made, the team agreed to have STUDENT repeat third grade. (Pet. Exh.**O.) Ms. Amerine-Dickens testified that she recommended retention because STUDENT did not do well, did not take instruction or complete instruction. She emphasized that her retention recommendation had nothing to do with STUDENT’s absence from class for much of the year. However, the Hearing Officer found this view to be less than credible considering other evidence presented concerning STUDENT’s academic progress.

The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT was absent from school for only about five months (February, May-July, and September) and received services from the District during off-track times (April and August). Thus, even if STUDENT did receive some benefit, it would be very difficult to determine whether such benefit was attributable to his home program or may have been a result of other services.

Finally, the record indicates that the PARENTS did not comply with the IDEA1997 provision requiring written notice to the District of their intention to remove STUDENT from public school and place him in a setting of their choice. (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii).) Because of this omission, even if STUDENT’s home educational program was otherwise proper, the IDEA provision would require the Hearing Officer to reduce or deny any award of retroactive reimbursement for failure to comply with this new federal statutory requirement.

Therefore, based on all the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner has failed to show how the educational services he received at home were designed to meet his unique educational needs in general. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT has not persuasively shown that he received educational benefit from his home program. The Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are not entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services provided at home from January 22, 1998 on when STUDENT was not in school.

Issue No. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services, including full inclusion consultation and social skills programming, for the alleged failure of the District to provide an appropriate shadow aide?

Petitioner claims that he is entitled to compensatory education because he was offered classroom aide services which were inappropriate. He argues that the harm which he suffered was denial of opportunity to have his needs addressed from January 1998 to the end of the 1997-98 school year. The District contends that the parents’ conduct in withdrawing STUDENT from school does not entitle them to an award of compensatory education.

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available where the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, No.3 (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489.) In considering whether such a remedy is appropriate, the conduct of both parties must be reviewed. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479.)

Here, the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate classroom shadow aide, thereby denying him a FAPE as to that service during the 1997-98 school year. Because STUDENT’s parents believed that the aide assigned was not appropriate for STUDENT, they removed him from school from January 22, 1998 through March 4, 1998. The PARENTS also immediately filed for due process hearing on January 22 in order to resolve the dispute. After the due process request was filed, the parties mediated and signed an interim agreement on February 13, 1998 which was subsequently implemented when STUDENT returned to school on March 5, 1998. (Dist. Exh. B-44.) STUDENT attended school from March 5 through March 27, 1998 and received some assistance from classroom aide Becky McNeese during that time. (Testimony of Ms. McNeese.) Ms. McNeese also provided assistance to the teacher, Joy Stockard, and did data collection for a revised behavior management plan. (Testimony of Ms. McNeese.)

STUDENT was off-track during the month of April. As required in his September 1997 IEP, the District provided STUDENT with extended school year services during off-track time. (Dist. Exh. B-123.) STUDENT received 10 hours per week of service from his in-home aide, Erin Brunmeier, and 10 hours per week of consultation services from Ms. McNeese. (Testimony of MOTHER.) On April 7, the parents withdrew their request for due process hearing. On April 29, when STUDENT was due back in school, his parents decided to keep him at home and continue his educational program there because of their ongoing concerns about the aide assigned to assist STUDENT.

On May 1, 1998, the District filed a request for due process hearing. That request was subsequently withdrawn on May 27. A second request for due process hearing was filed by the parents on June 12, 1998. At about the same time, the IEP team met and decided that STUDENT would repeat third grade during the 1998-99 school year because he had not mastered the necessary academic and social skills to promote into fourth grade. Over the summer, STUDENT did not attend school during July when a new track started and would have been off-track again in August. STUDENT received services from the District during the August off-track time. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

From these facts, it is apparent that the equities are relatively balanced between the parties. The PARENTS attempted to resolve the dispute promptly by filing a due process request on January 22. Both parties acted in good faith by entering into an interim agreement on February 13 as another way to resolve their differences. The District continued to fulfill its responsibilities under STUDENT’s IEP by providing extended school year services during STUDENT’s off-track time. The District also tried to resolve the dispute by filing its own due process request. Petitioner has not demonstrated that he suffered any significant harm as a result of the loss of about five months of classroom time. However, even if harm had been proven, the decision of STUDENT’s IEP team to have him repeat third grade will provide the opportunity for remediation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support the award of compensatory education remedies which Petitioner seeks.

ORDER

1. Within 15 days of the date of this order, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to discuss with the PARENTS, identify, and offer, an appropriate, highly skilled shadow aide to help implement the behavior management plan prepared by Ms. Amerine-Dickens and to assist the classroom teacher in working with STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year. The shadow aide must have the following knowledge and abilities to meet STUDENT’s needs: (1) know STUDENT well and have worked with him in his in-home program; (2) be able to act as a liaison between STUDENT’s in-home and school programs; (3) understand and be skilled in applied behavioral analysis and be able to carry out observational learning, effective reinforcement, data collection, social skills training, rule-governed behavior principles, effective prompts and fades; and an evolving behavior plan; (4) be able to avoid prompt dependence; (5) be able to coach the teacher in implementing the behavior plan and in using effective behavior principles with STUDENT throughout the day; (6) have experience and training in working with autistic children, particularly high-functioning autistic children such as STUDENT.

2. The District may not offer or assign Ms. Roseanne Powers to be STUDENT’s shadow aide during the 1998-99 school year for reasons discussed in this decision.

3. All Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate shadow aide for the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2: Did STUDENT require the services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-98 school year? Does he require such services for the 1998-99 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 3: Was STUDENT denied a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because of the composition of his individualized education program (IEP) team?

The District prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 4: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to retroactive reimbursement for educational services which they have provided since January 1998?

The District prevailed on this issue.

5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services, including full inclusion consultation and social skills programming, for the alleged failure of the District to provide an appropriate shadow aide?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Ed. Code Sec. 56505(i).)

DATED: October 5, 1998 _________________________________________ JoAnn Irwin-Eshelman, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1.The parties agreed to a change in hearing officers (necessitated by Hearing Officer Nolan’s departure from the Hearing Office) before the hearing reconvened on July 22, 1998. The parties also agreed that this hearing officer would listen to the tapes of the initial two days of hearing, which this hearing officer did. 2.STUDENT’s in-home assistant, Erin Brunmeier, testified that the Next Step phase of the Lovaas program involves community activities to help STUDENT generalize behaviors and learn social skills. 3.Mila Amerine-Dickens, clinical director of CVAP, testified that a shadow aide goes to school with an autistic child to prompt the child as needed in the academic and social environment. A shadow aide is unobtrusive, does not do work for the autistic child, and is not identified to other children as the autistic child’s aide. 4.Mila Amerine-Dickens, clinical director of CVAP, testified that a shadow aide goes to school with an autistic child to prompt the child as needed in the academic and social environment. A shadow aide is unobtrusive, does not do work for the autistic child, and is not identified to other children as the autistic child’s aide. 5.Ms. McNeese also provided some services to STUDENT during the off-track period under District auspices. 6.The June IEPs do not state the specific individual proposed, but the evidence indicated that Roseanne Powers was the only aide ever proposed by the District to serve as STUDENT’s classroom shadow aide. 7.Confusion concerning the difference between a shadow aide and a 1:1 instructional aide was apparent in testimony throughout the hearing and in the District’s closing argument. The evidence is clear that STUDENT needs a shadow aide who is unobtrusive (like a shadow) in the classroom, does not do work for him, is not identified to other children in the class as his aide, and is present to help implement STUDENT’s behavior plan. 8.This is apparently a reference to the assigned classroom aide discussed in Issue No. 1. 9.Members of STUDENT’s multidisciplinary team made efforts to assist his teacher, Ms. Stockard, when he was having difficulties in fall 1997. Ms. Rutherford, the resource specialist, and Ms. McKee, the speech therapist, offered several written suggestions to Ms. Stockard, apparently directed at STUDENT’s off-task behavior. (Dist. AA13.) However, Ms. Rutherford testified that she is not a full inclusion specialist and was not acting in that capacity. 10.In the comment, Ms. Amerine-Dickens states, "It once appeared that STUDENT would be fully included, however it currently appears that STUDENT will require some extra attention in the classroom and in the home program to reach that goal." (Dist. Exh. B-64.)