California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 8, 2003

Student v. Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 876-03, SN02-02786, SN03-00876 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Panama-Buena Vista Union must revise behavior plan on bus safety and restraint; autism eligibility and other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 6 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Panama-Buena Vista Union School District filed for hearing to defend its psychological assessment after the parents of an eight-year-old asked for an independent evaluation. The parents then filed their own case, and the two cases were consolidated. The student was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. He attended Linda Aguilar's special day class with aide support. His parents pointed to a private psychiatrist's Asperger's diagnosis. They argued that he should be eligible under autism or autistic-like behaviors and that he needed an autism-specific program, occupational therapy and speech-language services.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that Dr. Julie Daggett's assessment met Education Code requirements, so the district did not have to pay for the private evaluations. The Hearing Officer gave the most weight to school staff who observed the student in class and to standardized testing. She held that he met neither the state autistic-like criteria nor the federal autism definition, so he remained eligible as emotionally disturbed. The district offered FAPE in 2001-2002 because it changed the IEP and placement as his behavior changed. District assessments showed no need for occupational or speech-language therapy. For 2002-2003, the Hearing Officer found two departures from the behavior support plan: staff locked his bus seatbelt and once used an extended physical restraint. Neither made the placement inappropriate. The district had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to address bus safety and, if needed, when restraint may be used. All other relief, including compensatory services, was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO weighed school-based observation and standardized testing against clinical diagnoses from private psychiatrists in an autism-versus-emotional-disturbance dispute. It also shows that staff actions outside a behavior plan, such as restraint or a locked bus seatbelt, could lead to an order to revise the plan without a finding that FAPE was denied.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Was the District's assessment by Julie Daggett, Ph.D., appropriate?

    Dr. Daggett's multi-method assessment, by a qualified credentialed school psychologist, met Education Code sections 56320, 56322 and 56324; reaching a different conclusion from the private psychiatrist did not make it inappropriate.

  2. Issue 2. If the District's assessment was not appropriate, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained by his parents from Ruby Bayan, M.D., and Roxy Szeftel?

    Because the District's assessment was appropriate, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement for the private evaluations under Education Code section 56329(b).

  3. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with autism or autistic-like behavior or does he continue to be eligible as a child with an emotional disturbance?

    The student did not meet the state autistic-like criteria (5 CCR 3030(g)) or the federal autism definition; he continued to meet emotional disturbance criteria based on an inability to maintain relationships and inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

    The May 2001 general education placement with resource support was appropriate when offered, and the District responded to escalating behavior with repeated IEP meetings, new goals and an SDC placement; the student had no OT or speech-language needs.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

    The IEP and SDC placement were appropriate, but locking the student's bus seatbelt and an extended physical restraint departed from his behavior support plan; these departures did not make the placement inappropriate, and an IEP meeting to amend the plan was ordered.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech services (LAS)?

    Because the District offered FAPE, the requested compensatory OT and speech-language services were denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of receipt of the Decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to amend the behavioral support plan so that it includes appropriate ways to address the student's safe bus rides to and from school and, if the IEP team finds it necessary, to decide the circumstances, if any, under which physical restraint is necessary.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg

People named in the decision

  • Tara Lemes-Jones, special education coordinator, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Janis Spinozzi, director of special services, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Rita Pierucci, Ed.D., coordinator for special education, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Micky Hennen, educational advocate for Student, United Cerebral Palsy of Central California
  • Terry Ohler, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
  • Troy Tickle, speech-language pathologist (2003 assessment), Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Shannon Howry, speech-language pathologist (2002 assessment), Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Gregory Rhoten, special education coordinator, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Penny Kelly, resource specialist teacher, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Linda Aguilar, special day class teacher, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Julie A. Daggett, Ph.D., independent clinical and school psychologist; District-contracted assessor, Family Institute of the Central Coast
  • Cindy Kaul, school counselor and MFT intern; social skills group facilitator, Kern County High School District; Kern County Department of Mental Health
  • Holly Graham, recovery specialist aide, Kern County Department of Mental Health
  • Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist (OT assessor), Kern County Superintendent of Schools
  • Ruby Bayan, M.D., treating psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Kaiser Permanente, Bakersfield
  • Roxy Szeftel, M.D., child psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Cedars-Sinai Hospital
  • Bonny Hulsy, registered nurse, telemedicine coordinator; witness for Student, Kern Regional Center
  • Heather Barrus, after-school program manager; witness for Student, Valley Achievement Center
  • Valley Achievement Center, nonpublic school / after-school social skills program, Funded by Kern Regional Center
  • Kimball Hawkins, Ph.D., psychologist (Regional Center assessment), Kern Regional Center
  • Richard Roy, school psychologist, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • John R. Magner, psychologist (neuropsychological consultation), Kaiser Permanente
  • Ms. Sweeney, general education first-grade teacher, Laurelglen Elementary School
  • Debra Ragsdale, school nurse, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
  • Lisa Gonzales, daycare manager (completed rating scale)
  • Fred, 1:1 aide, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on June 12, 13, 17, 18, 19, and 20, 2003, in Bakersfield, California.

Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (District) was represented by attorney Stacy L. Inman of Schools Legal Service. Tara Lemes-Jones, special education coordinator, was present on behalf of the District. From June 17-20, 2003, Janis Spinozzi, director of special services, also was present on behalf of the District. Rita Pierucci, Ed.D., coordinator for special education, was present on June 17, 2003. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Donnalee H. Huffman. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents and Micky Hennen, educational advocate from United Cerebral Palsy of Central California. Hearing Officer Terry Ohler was present as an observer on June 12 and 13, 2003.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of the District: District speech and language pathologists Troy Tickle and Shannon Howry; District special education coordinators Tara Lemes-Jones and Gregory Rhoten; Penny Kelly, District resource special education teacher; Linda Aguilar, District special day class teacher; Julie A. Daggett, Ph.D., independent clinical psychologist, Family Institute of the Central Coast; Cindy Kaul, school counselor, Kern County High School District, and marriage family therapist (MFT) intern with the Kern County Department of Mental Health; Holly Graham, recovery specialist aide, Kern County Department of Mental Health; and Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of STUDENT: STUDENT’s stepmother; STUDENT’s father; Ruby Bayan, M.D., psychiatrist, pediatric psychiatry, and behavioral health medicine chief of service, Kaiser Hospital, Bakersfield; Roxy Szeftel, M.D., child psychiatrist and director of child psychiatry at Cedars-Sinai Hospital; Bonny Hulsy, registered nurse and coordinator of telemedicine services for Kern Regional Center; and Heather Barrus, program manager of the after school program, Valley Achievement Center (VAC).

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Was the District’s assessment by Julie Daggett, Ph.D., appropriate?

(2) If the District’s assessment was not appropriate, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained by his parents from Ruby Bayan, M.D., and Roxy Szeftel, Ph.D.?

(3) Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with autism or autistic-like behavior or does he continue to be eligible as a child with an emotional disturbance? (footnote 1)

(4) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

(5) Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

(6) If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech services (LAS)?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eight-year-old student attending Wayne Van Horn Elementary School within the Panama-Buena Union School District. STUDENT’s special education designation is emotionally disturbed (ED). STUDENT also has been diagnosed with Asperger’s Disorder, an autism spectrum disorder. (footnote 2) STUDENT is placed in the special day class (SDC) taught by Linda Aguilar and receives the services of an aide in the classroom. (footnote 3) Although STUDENT was not participating in therapy at the time of the hearing, he remains eligible for services through Kern County Department of Mental Health. Kern County Regional Center funds the services of a behavioral specialist to assist STUDENT and his family at home. The Regional Center also provides for STUDENT’s attendance at an after-school social skills program at the Valley Achievement Center (VAC). (footnote 4)A private psychiatrist, Dr. Ruby Bayan, manages STUDENT’s regimen of medication. At the time of the hearing, the following medications were prescribed for STUDENT: Trilepta, a mood stabilizer; Seroquel; a neuroleptic and antipsychotic medication; and Wellburten, an antidepressant. (footnote 5)

STUDENT was exposed in-uterine to methamphetamines, marijuana, cocaine, and alcohol. However, FATHER indicated that there was no report of withdrawal or positive testing of drugs in STUDENT’s system at birth. During the first six months of his life, STUDENT lived with his mother. STUDENT’s father assumed custody of STUDENT at age six months and STUDENT’s stepmother, has cared for STUDENT since before he turned two years old. (footnote 6)

At age two years, STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in preschool. Because of behavioral difficulties, including behavior that was described by his parents as “aggressive” and “dangerous to himself and other students,” STUDENT’s parents were asked to remove him from preschool. One of STUDENT’s preschool teachers referred his parents to the Henrietta Wild Child Guidance Center for assistance. STUDENT experienced similar difficulties at several other preschools he had previously attended. (footnote 7)

In July 1999, STUDENT was hospitalized at Memorial Center, a psychiatric hospital, because of severe temper tantrums. He remained at Memorial for approximately one week. STUDENT’s pediatrician referred him to Dr. Bayan, a pediatric psychiatrist. STUDENT was hospitalized again in October 1999 to wean him of Trazadone, the medication then prescribed for him. The second hospitalization was at College Hospital and lasted for approximately 10 days. Dr. Bayan saw STUDENT monthly to monitor his medications.

In February 2000, the Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) assessed STUDENT for special education. At the time of the assessment, Ritalin and Clonidine were prescribed for STUDENT. (footnote 8) On April 10, 2000, the Individualized Educational Program (IEP) team determined that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria as ED.

In the fall of 2000, STUDENT entered kindergarten at Ronald Reagan Elementary School within the District. He was placed in an SDC with mainstreaming in a general education kindergarten class for approximately one hour daily.

In January 2001, Kimball Hawkins, Ph.D., assessed STUDENT at the request of the Kern Regional Center. Dr. Hawkins found that STUDENT’s intelligence fell within the average to above-average range. As to STUDENT’s adaptive skills, Dr. Hawkins found that communication and daily living skills fell within the low average range and that social skills fell in the significantly sub-average range. Dr. Hawkins also described STUDENT as exhibiting symptoms of a mood disorder and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Dr. Hawkins noted that, by parent report, STUDENT was exhibiting symptoms of an autism spectrum disorder.

The IEP team met on May 31, 2001, for the annual IEP review and to determine STUDENT’s placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The IEP team noted that STUDENT was performing academically at grade level, was beginning to play well with other students, and was exhibiting age appropriate motor skills. STUDENT’s general education teacher commented on the IEP that “STUDENT has done a wonderful job in my class this year. He has met his kindergarten goals. He interacts well with others in the class. At times STUDENT may need time to himself or away from others, but overall has done a wonderful job fitting in as part of our class.” The IEP team agreed to place STUDENT in a general education kindergarten for 75 percent of his school day for the remainder of the school year and to place him in a general education first-grade class with consultation from the teacher of the resource specialist program (RSP) beginning in the fall of 2001. To specifically address behavioral problems, STUDENT’s IEP called for RSP support and modification to the class including preparation for transitions, preferential seating and line placement, and transition planning prior to STUDENT’s entering a new school. The IEP additionally noted that STUDENT should be redirected when frustrated before tension built and that adults should give directions and “back off” rather than engaging in a power struggle with STUDENT. (District’s Exhibit 24)

In the fall of 2001, STUDENT entered a general education first-grade class with RSP support at Laurelglen Elementary School. On September 21, 2001, the IEP team met to develop behavior management strategies to address STUDENT’s aggressive behavior and failure to complete work. A goal and several objectives were added to STUDENT’s IEP to address STUDENT’s talking out in class and failing to follow directions. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred to Mental Health for services. On October 16, 2001, the IEP team met again to review STUDENT’s placement. Concerns were raised regarding STUDENT’s behavior in class, which included shouting, having difficulty coping, refusing to follow directions, and being aggressive. The IEP team agreed to change STUDENT’s placement to an SDC with daily mainstreaming for mathematics. The IEP also called for modifications related to preparation for transitions, preferential seating and line placement, personal space, and redirection when frustration built. (District’s Exhibit 23)

The District convened another IEP meeting on November 29, 2001. Academically, STUDENT was reading at the first-grade level. He named numbers to 100 and could complete basic addition of numbers. STUDENT’s motor and language skills were described as “age appropriate.” However, STUDENT was exhibiting deficits in social, emotional, coping and adaptive behavior skills. He exhibited difficulty completing tasks and following directions. STUDENT’s behavior was described as follows:

disruptive, defiant and refuses to follow directions on request. Behavior escalates to hitting, kicking, pinching, name calling, shouting obscenities, destroys property, and attempting to run away. High level of attention demands.

(District’s Exhibit 22, page 2)

STUDENT’s IEP indicates that he met eligibility criteria for special education because of an emotional disturbance and autism spectrum disorder, which impaired his ability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers and interfered with his ability to work in a general education setting. The autism spectrum eligibility designation was added following Dr. Bayan’s diagnosis of Asperger’s. Goals and objectives on the IEP addressed STUDENT’s staying on task and improving written language, reading, and mathematics skills. Modifications included providing STUDENT with visual cues, small-group and one-to-one instruction, grade-level literature on tape, charts, maps, models, manipulatives, a visual schedule, additional classroom aide support, use of an office area to work, frequent breaks, and changing activities on a frequent basis. STUDENT’s IEP called for placement in an SDC. The IEP team also determined that a reevaluation of STUDENT was warranted. (District’s Exhibit 22)

In January 2002, the District began its assessment of STUDENT. District psychologist Richard Roy completed the psychoeducational portion of the assessment. Mr. Roy found that STUDENT was functioning in the average range in both ability and achievement. In December 2001 and January 2002, Deborah Hazel, registered occupational therapist (OTR) for the Kern County Office of Education, conducted an occupational therapy (OT) assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Hazel made several recommendations to address STUDENT’s short attention span, fidgeting, and letter spacing. However, she did not find that STUDENT required OT. Shannon Howry, District language and speech pathologist, undertook a language and speech (LAS) assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Howry concluded that STUDENT was demonstrating age appropriate language skills in all domains of language and that he did not meet the criteria for LAS therapy. The District also contracted with Julie Daggett, Ph.D., a clinical and school psychologist in private practice, to assess STUDENT. Dr. Daggett concluded that STUDENT did not meet special education criteria as a student with autism or autistic-like behaviors.

The IEP team reconvened on January 24, 2002. As to present levels of performance, the IEP indicates that STUDENT’s communication, language, and daily living skills fell within the average range. Academic skills fell at the first-grade level. The IEP describes STUDENT as a “bright and engaging student who exhibits symptoms of ADHD, mood disorder-not otherwise specified and oppositional defiant disorder. . . . Impulsivity and reduced attention to task can limit success in independent, small group and whole class learning situations.” (District’s Exhibit 7, pages 2 and 3) The IEP team concurred that STUDENT met eligibility for special education as ED. To address behavioral problems, the IEP calls for at least monthly group therapy from Mental Health, behavioral objectives focusing on social skills and anger management, and a behavior support plan. The IEP calls for the following additional supports: visual aids, extended time, one-to-one assistance, small group instruction, charts, maps, models, preferential seating, grade-level literature on tape, and additional classroom aide support throughout the school day. The IEP team agreed to continue STUDENT’s placement in the SDC with five percent of his school day in a mainstreamed environment. STUDENT began group therapy with Mental Health.

On July 8, 2002, Kaiser Permanente psychologist John R. Magner, conducted an outpatient neuropsychological consultation of STUDENT at the request of Dr. Bayan. The purpose of the consultation is stated to “rule out childhood schizophrenia.” Dr. Magner’s report describes STUDENT as defiant and resistant. STUDENT’s I.Q. scores on testing administered by Dr. Magner fell in the borderline range of general intelligence. However, Dr. Magner attributed the low scores as “repressed secondary to psychiatric disorder.” (District’s Exhibit 10) In August 2002, STUDENT was again hospitalized to adjust his then-current medications.

STUDENT returned to Ms. Aguilar’s class for the second grade. On November 19, 2002, the IEP team met for the annual review of STUDENT’s IEP. Both Dr. Daggett and Dr. Bayan attended, as well as the parents and various representatives from the District. The IEP notes that STUDENT continued to exhibit challenges in social/emotional areas. Specifically, the IEP states that STUDENT was having difficulty adjusting to change and with following adult direction. In reading, STUDENT was functioning at a 1.7 grade level, and in mathematics, he was functioning at a 1.2 grade level. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a structured setting with a low student-to-teacher ratio and that he receive small-group instruction, preferential seating, extended time to complete class assignments, aide support throughout the school day, weekly mental health therapy, and a behavior support plan. The team determined that STUDENT would continue to attend the SDC taught by Ms. Aguilar. The parents disagreed with STUDENT’s designation as ED and asserted that the proper diagnosis for STUDENT was Asperger’s Syndrome. FATHER requested that the District fund an independent assessment to resolve the issue of whether STUDENT is ED or autistic. The District declined to fund an independent assessment and filed for hearing on December 9, 2002, regarding the appropriateness of its assessment. (SN02-02786)

On January 14, 2003, the IEP team met to discuss mainstreaming. STUDENT’s parents continued to express their disagreement with STUDENT’s special education designation of “emotional disturbance.” The team agreed that STUDENT would be mainstreamed daily in a second grade class for 30 minutes during the subjects of social studies, science, art, and literature and weekly for music. STUDENT’s parents expressed concern about STUDENT’s speech and requested an assessment. Troy Tickle completed the LAS assessment on behalf of the District.

On February 20, 2003, the IEP team met to discuss the results of the LAS assessment. The IEP team concluded that test results did not indicate that STUDENT required LAS services to meet his needs or to allow him to benefit from his education.

On May 2, 2003, STUDENT requested a due process hearing on issues related to whether the District appropriately assessed him, properly designated him eligible for special education as ED, and provided a FAPE during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. (SN03-00876) STUDENT’s case was consolidated with the District’s case on May 20, 2003. On June 10, 2003, STUDENT was admitted to Memorial Hospital for reasons that included agitated behavior and the need to adjust his medications.

The parties continued to dispute what constituted the appropriate special education eligibility designation for STUDENT and the appropriate placement and services for STUDENT. The matter proceeded to hearing on June 12, 2003.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. (1): Was the District’s assessment by Julie Daggett, Ph.D., appropriate?

To be appropriate, the District’s assessment must have met the statutory requirements set forth in Cal. Educ. Code section 56320 et. seq., which provides, in pertinent part:

(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist . . . (f) The pupil is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. A developmental history is obtained, when appropriate. . . .

Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e).

In addition, the assessments must be performed by persons knowledgeable of the disability and who are competent to perform them, as determined by the district. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(g) and 56322. Any psychological assessment of a student by a district must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324.

On November 29, 2001, FATHER consented to the District’s plan for STUDENT’s triennial assessment, which proposed to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic performance, self-help, social and emotional status, motor abilities (including an occupational therapy assessment), language, speech, general ability, health, development, vision, hearing, and behavior. The assessment plan indicates that Dr. Daggett would assess STUDENT’s self-help, social, and emotional status. (footnote 9) The remainder of the assessment would be completed by a District school psychologist, nurse, and occupational therapist. (District’s Exhibit 14) (footnote 10)

At issue is the portion of the assessment undertaken by Dr. Daggett in December 2001 and January 2002. (District’s Exhibit 12) STUDENT contends that Dr. Daggett did not appropriately administer the assessment, failed to properly consider relevant materials provided by the parents indicating that he is a student with Asperger’s, and incorrectly concluded that he is emotionally disturbed (ED). The District contends that its assessment was appropriate.

STUDENT’s allegations related to Dr. Daggett’s administration of the assessment were somewhat unclear and little testimony was elicited from STUDENT’s witnesses on this issue. (footnote 11) However, because STUDENT has requested reimbursement for an independent assessment and the District is required to conduct an assessment that comports with legal requirements, the Hearing Officer will determine whether test materials and procedures employed by Dr. Daggett in assessing STUDENT satisfied the requirements of Cal. Educ. Code section 56320. (See above.)

Dr. Daggett described in detail each of the test instruments she used, including whether the test has been validated for the specific purposes for which it was used. (footnote 12) Dr. Daggett testified that the Robert’s Apperception Test for Children is a standardized projective test and was administered to STUDENT to evaluate his perception of relationships. Dr. Daggett testified that STUDENT’s parents and his teacher, Ms. Aguilar, completed the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, which measured STUDENT’s adaptive skills in the areas of communication, daily living skills, socialization, and adaptive behavior. To assess STUDENT’s social and emotional skills, Dr. Daggett provided the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) to be completed by STUDENT’s parents, teacher, and daycare manager, Lisa Gonzales. To identify characteristics of autism, Dr. Daggett had STUDENT’s parents, teacher, and aide complete the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS), which is a standardized assessment. The Asperger Syndrome Diagnostic Scale (ASDS) also was completed by STUDENT’s parents, teacher, and Dr. Daggett. Dr. Daggett testified that the ASDS is a standardized test to aid in identifying individuals who exhibit the characteristics of Asperger’s. Dr. Daggett testified that she administered each test in a standardized manner by following the instructions in the test manual.

As to whether STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability, Dr. Daggett testified that she assessed him in social, emotional, and behavioral areas. She also assessed whether he was exhibiting behaviors characteristic of autism. The testimony of all of the witnesses establishes that the primary areas of concern regarding STUDENT were his behavior and social skills. STUDENT’s witnesses were particularly concerned whether he is eligible for special education under the category of autism or autistic-like behavior. As described above, Dr. Daggett’s assessment included a number of measures to identify behaviors that may be consistent with autism. Additionally, the discussion above describes other measures that she administered regarding STUDENT’s social skills. Thus, Dr. Daggett’s assessment addressed the primary areas of suspected disability. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Daggett’s testimony regarding the multiple tests and methods she employed to evaluate STUDENT establishes that she did not rely on a single procedure as the sole criterion to make determinations regarding STUDENT’s educational program.

None of the witnesses called to testify on behalf of STUDENT provided persuasive testimony that challenged Dr. Daggett’s testimony regarding the validity of the tests she employed in assessing STUDENT or in the way she administered the tests. Dr. Szeftel expressed the opinion that the one report created by Dr. Daggett was insufficient to explain STUDENT’s behavior and asserted that additional projective testing would have been helpful in understanding STUDENT’s condition.

As to Dr. Daggett’s credibility, Dr. Daggett’s undisputed testimony establishes the following regarding her credentials and experience. Dr. Daggett is a licensed clinical psychologist and holds a professional clear pupil personnel services credential with a specialization in school psychology. She earned a B.A. in psychology, an M.S. in behavior analysis and therapy, and both an M.A. and a Ph.D. in child psychology and human development. Dr. Daggett participated as a pre-doctoral intern and as a post doctoral fellow in multiple clinics at the Child Development Unit, a Kansas University affiliated program. Included in her clinical experience was the Autism Evaluation and Treatment Clinic. She also participated on a multidisciplinary evaluation team. Dr. Daggett testified that since 1988 she has assessed, developed programs, and treated children with autism and behavioral disorders. (See also District’s Exhibit 19.) The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Daggett to be well-qualified and experienced in assessing students suspected of having autism or behavioral disorders and, for these reasons, finds her testimony persuasive as to the tests and procedures she used in assessing STUDENT.

STUDENT also asserted that Dr. Daggett did not consider information from the parents, including a diagnosis of Asperger’s by Dr. Bayan. Dr. Daggett’s testimony and a review of the assessment report establish that the assessment undertaken by Dr. Daggett was extensive and did not rely on a single measure. As part of the assessment, Dr. Daggett interviewed STUDENT’s parents. They also provided input to her assessment by completing test questionnaires regarding STUDENT and his behavior. Additionally, Dr. Daggett testified that she reviewed educational records that included Dr. Bayan’s diagnosis of Asperger’s dated September 28, 2001, Dr. Kimball Hawkins’ psychological evaluation dated January10, 2001, an evaluation from Kern Regional Center, and records from Kaiser Permanente that included information regarding medication prescribed for STUDENT and a neuropsychological consultation report from Dr. Magner dated July 8, 2002. The above leads the Hearing Officer to conclude that Dr. Daggett did consider information from the parents and their assessors as part of her assessment. Additionally, it is noted that Dr. Daggett’s assessment took five days to complete and included a review of background information and direct observation of STUDENT for at least nine hours in multiple environments including home, school, and day care. As discussed above, Dr. Daggett also administered several assessment instruments. The final assertion by STUDENT is that Dr. Daggett’s assessment was inappropriate because she reached the conclusion that he is not autistic. As previously discussed, Dr. Daggett undertook to assess STUDENT using a variety of methods which included a review of reports finding STUDENT has Asperger’s. Dr. Daggett testified that her conclusions were based on the observations, tests, and records, which she determined supported her conclusions. Therefore, given the breadth of Dr. Daggett’s assessment, the Hearing Officer concludes that the fact that Dr. Daggett reached a conclusion that differs from Dr. Bayan’s diagnosis of Asperger’s does not render Dr. Daggett’s assessment inappropriate and finds that Dr. Daggett’s assessment satisfied the requirements of an appropriate assessment pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code sections 56320, 56322, and 56324.ISSUE NO. (2): If the District’s assessment was not appropriate, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained by his parents from Ruby Bayan, M.D., and Roxy Szeftel, Ph.D.?

A parent may obtain reimbursement for an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist, as defined by regulations of the board, if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).

It has been concluded above that the District undertook an appropriate assessment of STUDENT. Therefore, his parents are not entitled to reimbursement for assessments they obtained from Dr. Bayan and Dr. Szeftel.

ISSUE NO. (3): Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with autism or autistic-like behavior or does he continue to be eligible as a child with an emotional disturbance?

To be eligible for special education, a student must have a disability as defined by federal law and, because of the disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b). There is no dispute that STUDENT is eligible for special education. While it is not generally necessary to determine whether a student meets more than one eligibility criteria, the parties cannot agree on the proper special education designation for STUDENT. STUDENT contends that it is necessary that his special education eligibility reflect that he is a student with autistic-like behaviors so that he will receive appropriate services to address his social and behavioral needs arising from his disability. STUDENT also asserts that the District improperly determined that he meets special education eligibility as emotionally disturbed. The District contends that STUDENT does not meet the criteria for autism or autistic-like behaviors and that his current eligibility classification as ED is appropriate.

Both autism and emotional disturbance (ED) are included in the federal definition of a disability. “Autism” is defined in federal regulations as “a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age three, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences.” Title 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(1)(i).

In addition, State special education law provides that autistic-like behaviors may entitle a student to special education if the results of an assessment demonstrate that the degree of the student’s impairment requires special education. 5 Cal. Code Regs.§ 3030 (g). To meet eligibility for special education because of autistic-like behaviors, California special education regulations provide that the student must exhibit any combination of the following:

(1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness.

(4) Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both. (5) Extreme resistance to controls.

(6) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. (7) Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.

5 C.C.R. § 3030(g).

Pursuant to the criteria set forth in Title 5, California Code of Regulations section 3030(i) a student meets eligibility criteria as ED when he/she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (1) an inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors; (2) an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers; (3) inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations; (4) a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (5) a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. tit.5 § 3030(i). The student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED if the student is socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that the student has a serious emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(ii).

The eligibility criteria and whether STUDENT satisfies the criteria for each will be addressed individually below. The Hearing Officer will first address the federal and State requirements to meet special education eligibility because of autism or autistic-like behaviors.

Does STUDENT meet special education eligibility criteria as a student with autism or autistic-like behaviors?

Testimony of Student’s Witnesses

Witnesses appearing on behalf of STUDENT, including both of his parents, his treating psychiatrist Dr. Bayan, and child psychiatrist Dr. Szeftel, who assessed STUDENT, and Heather Barrus, program manager at VAC, testified in support of his contention that he should be identified as a student with autistic-like behaviors. Their testimony is summarized below.

STEPMOTHER testified that since age two years old, STUDENT has engaged in unusual behaviors. She cited as examples, STUDENT’s rocking, having tantrums, and banging his head on the ground and also on his pillow to go to sleep. STEPMOTHER testified that in preschool STUDENT became agitated when other children brushed against him or when a strict schedule was not adhered to. Regarding STUDENT’s current behavior, STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT needs to know his schedule every 15 minutes and failure to follow the schedule may result in STUDENT’s having a tantrum, crying, or throwing things. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT wears a watch at all times and believes that his watch must match up with other clocks in his environment. STUDENT also wants his bed to be located in specific place–one foot from the wall. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT continues to rock.

STEPMOTHER described STUDENT’s present social skills as poor. She stated that STUDENT prefers to be alone and generally does not interact well with his three siblings, who are five, ten, and eleven years old. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT does not have friends that come to play with him and, on those few occasions when he goes outside to play with children in the neighborhood, he does not get along with them for very long.

FATHER similarly described STUDENT’s behavior. He also testified that regardless of the weather, STUDENT likes to wear a vest given to him by his grandmother. FATHER described the vest as tight, because he has outgrown it, and offered his opinion that STUDENT “does better” when he wears the vest. FATHER also testified that STUDENT tightly wraps himself in his comforter and sleeps between the mattress and wall on his bed’s box spring mattress. FATHER expressed the opinion that these behaviors demonstrate that STUDENT “likes to be compressed.” FATHER described STUDENT’s eating habits as “unnormal.” He stated that STUDENT “stuffs his face” and gets food all over his face. STUDENT has told his father that he does not feel his face. FATHER stated that STUDENT only likes to eat hamburgers, hot dogs, and chips and does not like to eat anything with texture, such as vegetables. FATHER additionally testified that STUDENT cannot tell if someone is angry with him, cannot express his feelings, and does not follow directions fifty percent of the time.

Dr. Bayan testified on behalf of STUDENT and supported his contention that he meets special education eligibility as a student with autistic-like behaviors. Dr. Bayan is a pediatric psychiatrist and is chief of service of behavioral health medicine at Kaiser Permanente, Bakersfield, and has treated STUDENT for approximately four years. Dr. Bayan diagnosed STUDENT with Asperger’s approximately two years ago. At that time, she added Asperger’s to the prior diagnosis of attention deficit disorder and possible mood disorder. (footnote 13) Dr. Bayan presently states that STUDENT has a bipolar affective disorder.

Ms. Barrus testified that STUDENT’s behavior is consistent with the behavior of other children with autism with whom she has worked. Specifically, Ms. Barrus testified that STUDENT lacks sustained eye contact and prefers to be alone or in the company of adults. She also testified that STUDENT has difficulty understanding the feelings of others. As an example, Ms. Barrus stated that STUDENT walked up and told someone he was fat. Ms. Barrus has supervised the after-school program at VAC in which STUDENT has participated since June 2002. She divides her time between two groups of students. She has been employed by VAC for the past three years and has been in her present position for one half of that time. Ms. Barrus characterized her training regarding students with autism as “extensive.” She is one course shy of completing her B.A. in child development.

Testimony of District’s Witnesses

All of the witnesses testifying on behalf of the District concluded that STUDENT does not meet special education criteria as a student with autism or autistic-like behaviors. The following is a general summary of their testimony.

Dr. Daggett, whose assessment was discussed above in Issue No. 1, concurred with other witnesses that STUDENT has challenging behaviors but testified that his behaviors are “not best” described as Asperger’s. Dr. Daggett concluded that STUDENT exhibits symptoms of ADHD, mood disorder, and oppositional defiant disorder. Dr. Daggett testified that STUDENT does not exhibit the two primary symptoms of Asperger’s, lack of socialization skills and ritualistic behavior. Dr. Daggett testified that STUDENT’s social skills are delayed. However, he has the ability to read and manipulate people, thus lacks the symptoms of Asperger’s. STUDENT’s profile also shows that he has “common sense,” manipulates adults, and lies, whereas children with Asperger’s do not generally understand the concept of lying or how one’s behaviors cause reactions in others. Dr. Daggett testified that she also did not observe STUDENT to have obsessive, repetitive, or ritualistic behavior, excessive interests in unusual topics, or peculiar reactions to sounds, smells, textures, and physical affection. Dr. Daggett testified that her conclusions are based on multiple observations of STUDENT in a variety of environments and the results of standardized assessment instruments designed to identify the characteristics of autism/Asperger’s.

Dr. Daggett testified that she administered the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS) to STUDENT’s parent, teacher, and aide. The CARS measures certain aspects of autism spectrum disorders, including Asperger’s, such as difficulty relating to people, problems with imitation, unusual emotional responses, perserverative and disordered language, unusual activity level, and atypical developmental profile. Dr. Daggett testified the responses by STUDENT’s parents, teacher, and aide on the CARS placed STUDENT in the range of not having an autism spectrum disorder/Asperger’s. Dr. Daggett also administered the Asperger Syndrome Diagnostic Scale (ASDS) to STUDENT’s teachers, parents, and to herself. Dr. Daggett testified that the ASDS is a standardized test to aid in identifying individuals between the ages of 5 through 18 years old who exhibit the characteristics of Asperger’s. Dr. Daggett’s testimony establishes that the responses of STUDENT’s parents on the ASDS placed STUDENT’s symptoms on the border between unlikely to possibly having Asperger’s. The responses by STUDENT’s teacher placed STUDENT in the unlikely category and Dr. Daggett’s responses placed STUDENT in the very unlikely category of having Asperger’s. (See also District’s Exhibits 12, 25, and 26.)

Ms. Aguilar, STUDENT’s teacher for the past two school years, including the ESY, testified that she has not observed any characteristics of autism in STUDENT. She has not observed STUDENT rocking or engaging in repetitive behaviors. She believes STUDENT is able to interpret facial expresses and has good eye contact.

Mr. Rhoten, special education coordinator, testified that although STUDENT has some serious behavioral incidents, he is not autistic. Mr. Rhoten testified that during his six or more observations of STUDENT in his classroom, he did not observe STUDENT to exhibit signs of autism nor did his teacher, Ms. Aguilar, report any signs of autism to him. Mr. Rhoten testified that he did not observe STUDENT to experience difficulty with language, poor social skills, restrictive interest, or inflexible thinking.

Mr. Tickle is a language and speech pathologist. He assessed STUDENT’s speech and language in January 2003. Mr. Tickle testified that he did not observe any characteristics of autism. Mr. Tickle testified that STUDENT followed eye-to-eye gaze. Mr. Tickle testified that he observed STUDENT’s ability to problem solve and to “think outside the box,” which would not be characteristic for a child with autism. As an example, Mr. Tickle recounted that during testing, STUDENT commented that “if there is broken glass, it would need to be cleaned up so someone would not get hurt.” Ms. Howry, language and speech pathologist, testified that she also did not observe signs of autism during her assessment of STUDENT in January 2002.

Autistic-like Characteristics

Inability to use oral language for appropriate communication

Turning to whether STUDENT meets the specific characteristics of a child with autistic-like behaviors as set forth above in Title 5 Cal. Code Reg. section 3030(g), the first characteristic is an inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. STEPMOTHER and Ms. Aguilar testified and other witnesses acknowledged that STUDENT does not always express his feelings appropriately. Rather than using words to express his feelings, the testimony establishes that when STUDENT is agitated or upset, he may have a tantrum, cry, hit, or throw things. However, the evidence establishes that STUDENT does have the ability to use oral language for appropriate communication. Two recent speech and language assessments and the testimony of the assessors, Mr. Tickle and Ms. Howry, establish that STUDENT’s communication skills fall within the average range. (See District’s Exhibits 17 and 44) Mr. Tickle’s assessment included administering of tests and three observations of STUDENT in the classroom and two observations on the playground during recess. To assess STUDENT’s pragmatic or social language skills, Mr. Tickle observed STUDENT and administered the Test of Pragmatic Language (TOPL). He also took a sample of STUDENT’s language. Mr. Tickle stated that STUDENT exhibited “strong” expressive language skills. Mr. Tickle further testified that during his observations of STUDENT, STUDENT initiated conversations and appropriately changed topics during conversations. He also observed that STUDENT was able to recognize nonverbal cues during conversation.

Ms. Howry’s assessment in January 2002 included formal and informal measures of STUDENT’s speech and language. To assess STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language skills, Ms. Howry administered the Test of Language Development-Primary Third Edition (TOLD-P3). Ms. Howry found that STUDENT’s overall test performance was in the average range with strengths in listening, speaking, and syntax development. To assess STUDENT’s pragmatic language, an area described by Ms. Howry as typically deficient for a student with Asperger’s, Ms. Howry administered the TOPL. In comparison to same age peers, STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills were average. Ms. Howry stated that on the TOPL, STUDENT demonstrated knowledge of social etiquette, sarcasm, humor, and an understanding of others’ feelings or thoughts.

The testimony of Mr. Tickle and Ms. Howry establishes that they each conducted thorough assessments of STUDENT that included administration of tests and multiple observations of STUDENT in the school environment. Although Ms. Howry’s assessment occurred during the 2001-2002 school year, she routinely observed STUDENT throughout the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. Howry testified that she was in STUDENT’s class three times weekly for 15 minutes to one hour to provide language and speech services to children in the class. Both assessors are well qualified, have experience assessing and working with children with autism, and have spent considerable time evaluating STUDENT. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds the evidence, particularly the testimony of Mr. Tickle and Ms. Howry, establishes that STUDENT uses oral language for appropriate communication.

History of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood

The second characteristic of the special education eligibility criteria of autistic-like behavior requires that the student have a history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. There is no evidence that STUDENT is withdrawn.

There was a great deal of testimony regarding STUDENT’s difficulty with social skills. Mr. and STEPMOTHER described difficulties STUDENT has in social situations since preschool, with siblings, and with children in the neighborhood. Ms. Barrus also noted that STUDENT has poor social skills. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s ability to get along with peers in the school environment also is impaired. In fact, STUDENT is eligible to participate in a social skills group provided by Mental Health.

The District witnesses most familiar with the characteristics of autism, Dr. Daggett, Mr. Rhoten, and those most familiar with STUDENT, Ms. Aguilar and Mr. Tickle, testified that STUDENT’s impaired social skills do not rise to the level or have the same quality of children with autism. The Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive over the testimony of Dr. Bayan and Dr. Szeftel, who have limited or no observations of STUDENT interacting with other children. Dr. Bayan’s observations of STUDENT are limited to clinic visits and hospitalizations. Dr. Szeftel testified that she did not observe any characteristics of autism during the one hour she spoke with STUDENT and his family via the telemedicine hook up.

Moreover, there was persuasive testimony that STUDENT is able to relate appropriately to peers. Several witnesses, including Mr. Tickle and Mr. Rhoten, observed STUDENT engage in games with other children. Ms. Aguilar described STUDENT’s ability to show empathy for a younger child. She testified during a game of Around the World, STUDENT purposefully gave the wrong answer to a mathematics problem so that a younger child would have an opportunity to remain in the game. The evidence establishes that STUDENT is able to understand feelings of others. For example, STUDENT told Ms. Lemes-Jones that he had been scratched by a sibling because he had punched the sibling in the stomach. STUDENT then commented to Ms. Lemes-Jones that “[the hit in the stomach] did not make him feel very good.” Dr. Daggett testified that she observed STUDENT reading body language of others and responding appropriately to his teacher. Additionally, Ms. Kaul, who provided social skills training to STUDENT through Mental Health, stated that STUDENT demonstrated self-awareness in the social skills group. The Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive and concludes that the fact that STUDENT has poor social skills does not establish that he cannot relate appropriately to people.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has social skills deficits but they do not rise to his meeting the above characteristic of autistic-like behavior.

Obsession to maintain sameness

The third characteristic to meet the criteria of autistic-like behavior is an obsession to maintain sameness. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT requires a strict schedule and is upset if the schedule is disrupted. She also testified that he becomes upset if his bed is not in the same location. STEPMOTHER also testified that she believes STUDENT’s behavior deteriorated each time his aide was changed during the spring of 2003 and when the regular school term ended in June.

Dr. Daggett acknowledged that STUDENT performed better in school when he was required to follow a routine. However, District witnesses testified persuasively that STUDENT does not require strict adherence to sameness. For example, Mr. Tickle and Ms. Howry testified that STUDENT was not upset by the disruption to his schedule when pulled out of class for testing. Ms. Aguilar did not cite any examples of STUDENT’s obsession to maintain sameness. In fact, she testified that STUDENT recently began attending the extended school year program without difficulty although the summer program is located at a different school than the regular school year program. Ms. Aguilar also testified that the class routine differs somewhat during the summer. Again, her testimony was that STUDENT did not exhibit any difficulty with changes to his summer program. She noted that the summer program the prior school also was located at a different school than the regular school year program and STUDENT also had not experienced problems adjusting to the new location.

Although there is some persuasive evidence that STUDENT’s behavior is better when there is a schedule, the evidence fails to establish that his perceived preference for sameness related to scheduling and to the location of his bed rises to the level of an “obsession” to maintain sameness. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet the characteristic above of exhibiting an obsession to maintain sameness.

Extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both

The fourth characteristic for eligibility as autistic-like is an extreme preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects or both. Although STEPMOTHER described STUDENT’s interest in watches, her testimony does not establish that STUDENT has an “extreme” preoccupation with objects. There was no other persuasive testimony related to STUDENT’s preoccupation with objects or inappropriate use of objects. Ms. Aguilar, who sees STUDENT daily in her class, did not observe STUDENT to have an extreme preoccupation with objects. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet the above characteristic of autism.

Extreme resistance to controls

A fifth characteristic to establish eligibility as autistic-like is extreme resistance to controls. The testimony establishes that STUDENT can be defiant at home and school. No one testified or argued that the defiance STUDENT exhibits meets the characteristic of autistic-like behavior.

Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns

There was no argument or testimony establishing that STUDENT displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns.

Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior

The final characteristic is self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior. STUDENT’s parents described self-stimulating behavior at home that includes wearing a vest, rocking, head banging on his bed, wrapping himself in a comforter, and sleeping in a small space between his mattress and the wall. Ms. Barrus noted that STUDENT has worn his vest to VAC. She also noted that STUDENT likes to give “hard” high fives.

None of the assessors testified that they have observed STUDENT engage in self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior. Nor have the District’s witnesses observed STUDENT rocking or engaging in other self-stimulating behavior in the school environment. Although STUDENT’s parents testified that STUDENT likes to wear a tight vest, Ms. Hazel, who conducted an OT assessment of STUDENT during the winter of 2002, concluded that STUDENT does not seek deep pressure or stimulating behavior. Ms. Hazel assessed STUDENT in his class, on the playground, going to and from the bathroom, and in a separate room. Ms. Hazel routinely sees STUDENT in his classroom when providing OT activities for students in his class. Ms. Hazel noted that she includes students who are not eligible for direct OT services, including STUDENT, in activities she does in the classroom.

The Hearing Officer does not dispute the parents’ testimony regarding STUDENT’s behaviors at home. However, there is no persuasive evidence that these sensory-seeking behaviors are ritualistic. The behaviors are also not pervasive, given the credible testimony by multiple witness to the absence of self-stimulating ritualistic behaviors in school. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet the criteria of self-stimulation, ritualistic.

Federal eligibility criteria for autism

To meet the federal definition of “autism,” STUDENT must have significantly affected social interactions, nonverbal and verbal communication. As previously discussed, the parties generally agree that STUDENT’s social interactions are impaired. As to STUDENT’s communication skills, multiple witnesses who have worked extensively with STUDENT testified that he is able to engage in nonverbal communication and verbal communication. For example, Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT is able to interpret facial expressions. She noted that he responds to her putting her finger over her mouth signaling to STUDENT that he needs to be quiet. Dr. Daggett also noted that STUDENT responded to Ms. Aguilar’s body language. For example, Dr. Daggett observed STUDENT to be pleased when he received a “thumbs up” sign of approval from Ms. Aguilar. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that STUDENT responded to her holding up her hand to signal to him that he should not approach her. Ms. Barrus expressed some concern about the quality of STUDENT’s eye contact. However, witnesses in addition to Dr. Daggett and Ms. Aguilar, including Mr. Rhoten and Mr. Tickle, testified persuasively that STUDENT makes eye contact and follows eye gaze without difficulty. The only time Mr. Tickle observed STUDENT not to make eye contact was when he purposefully avoided eye contact because he did something inappropriate. In fact, Dr. Szeftel testified that she did not observe any signs of autism during her telemedicine evaluation of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that there is persuasive evidence from the witnesses who have worked with STUDENT within the school environment that he engages in nonverbal communication. Moreover, it has already been determined that STUDENT does not have significant verbal communication difficulties.

Summary

After carefully weighing the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not meet either the State eligibility criteria of “autistic-like behavior” or the federal definition of “autism.” The Hearing Officer finds this determination somewhat difficult to reconcile with the diagnosis of Asperger’s by Dr. Bayan. However, Dr. Bayan has made a clinical diagnosis on limited information available from STUDENT’s parents. Although Dr. Bayan has provided medication monitoring for STUDENT for four years and has seen him monthly for this purpose, she has not observed STUDENT in settings other than her office and the psychiatric hospital. Dr. Bayan’s sole observation of STUDENT with peers occurred in a hospital setting. It is not unexpected that STUDENT, or any other child, would experience social difficulties while hospitalized. Moreover, the hospitalizations were generally for the purpose of modifying STUDENT’s medication, which would also account for his difficult behavior. Additionally, Dr. Bayan did not administer any tests to STUDENT or have his parents and teachers complete questionnaires routinely used by assessors to identify characteristics of autism in children. Finally, the sole characteristic that Dr. Bayan testified STUDENT meets is related to his social difficulties. Social difficulty is not sufficient to meet eligibility criteria as autistic or autistic-like. Moreover, not all children with social difficulties satisfy the educational criteria as autistic or autistic-like.

The Hearing Officer also does not find Dr. Szeftel’s diagnosis of Asperger’s persuasive as to STUDENT’s meeting special education eligibility criteria. Dr. Szeftel’s diagnosis also was based on very limited information. She spent a total of one hour with STUDENT and his family. Dr. Szeftel testified that she did not observe any signs of autism during that time. Although Dr. Szeftel testified that objective testing would be useful in understanding STUDENT and in resolving his diagnosis, Dr. Szeftel did not undertake any testing of STUDENT and had not reviewed Dr. Daggett’s assessment of STUDENT prior to her diagnosing STUDENT. She also did not obtain information from anyone in the educational environment regarding STUDENT. Ms. Aguilar, who has been STUDENT’s teacher for several years and has seen him on a regular basis during the regular school and extended school year programs, could have provided both Dr. Bayan and Dr. Szeftel with vital information regarding STUDENT’s behaviors in the classroom.

On the other hand, witnesses testifying on behalf of the District who reached the conclusion that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria for autism or autistic-like, had a great deal of training and experience working with children with autism in general. The District’s witnesses are distinguished from Dr. Bayan and Dr. Szeftel in that they have worked with children with autism in an educational environment and with STUDENT in particular. Moreover, their conclusions that STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria were based on information from a variety of sources. For example, Dr. Daggett conducted a thorough assessment that included observations of STUDENT at home, school, and in after-school care, answers to standardized assessment instruments that were provided by STUDENT’s parents, teachers, and after-school caretaker, and testing of STUDENT. Therefore, the information that Dr. Daggett relied on in reaching her conclusion that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility as autistic or because of autistic-like behaviors was derived from a variety of people, including STUDENT’s parents. Dr. Daggett was not alone in her conclusion. Her testimony was supported by the testimony of Mr. Rhoten, who has observed STUDENT on multiple occasions and who has extensive training in autism, by the testimony Ms. Aguilar, who has worked with STUDENT daily since he entered her class in the fall of 2001 and who previously provided applied behavioral analysis therapy to children with autism, and the testimony and assessment results of Mr. Tickle and Ms. Howry.

Taking into consideration all of the evidence as discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria as autistic or as having autistic-like behavior.

Does STUDENT continue to meet special education eligibility as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED)?

Dr. Szeftel and Dr. Bayan testified that STUDENT should not continue to be deemed eligible for special education as ED. However, neither Dr. Szeftel, Dr. Bayan, nor any other witness testifying on behalf of STUDENT provided specific testimony rebutting the credible testimony of District witnesses that STUDENT meets ED criteria. Both Dr. Szeftel and Dr. Bayan relied solely on clinical observations in concluding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education as ED. As discussed more fully above in the section on autism, neither Dr. Szeftel nor Dr. Bayan has observed STUDENT at home or in an educational environment, administered any tests to STUDENT, or consulted with STUDENT’s teachers, daycare provider, aides, or Mental Health personnel. Moreover, neither Dr. Szeftel nor Dr. Bayan expressed knowledge of or considered special education criteria for ED although both concluded STUDENT has serious emotional problems. Dr. Szeftel and Dr. Bayan gave STUDENT DSM-IV diagnosis of mood or bipolar disorders and Dr. Bayan continues to treat STUDENT for emotional difficulties.

Moreover, the credible testimony of STEPMOTHER, Ms. Aguilar and Dr. Daggett establishes that STUDENT continues to be eligible for special education as ED because of an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers and because he exhibits inappropriate reactions and behavior under normal circumstances.

Turning first to the evidence of whether STUDENT meets ED eligibility because of an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, STEPMOTHER described STUDENT’s lack of friends at home. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT rarely goes outside to play with neighborhood children because after a brief time STUDENT gets into some type of a disagreement with them. She testified that no children come to visit STUDENT at home. In her opinion, STUDENT does not have friends. He also does not get along with his siblings.

Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT argues with other students, sometimes hits them, and does not have friends in the class. For this reason, Ms. Aguilar has a desk away from the other students to which STUDENT is directed for reasons that include an inability to get along with peers. Ms. Aguilar further testified that STUDENT shared with her that he does not have friends. Ms. Aguilar and Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that relations with staff have also been difficult. STUDENT had several aides during the spring of 2003. There was evidence that at least one of the aides quit because of difficulty getting along with STUDENT.

After multiple observations of STUDENT in various environments, a review of documents, and administration of several instruments to STUDENT, Dr. Daggett also concluded that STUDENT’s social relationships with peers and adults are stressful. She testified that STUDENT meets the ED criteria of an inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships. (See also District’s Exhibit 12, p. 15.) It is also noted that Mental Health has determined STUDENT eligible for the services of social skills groups because of difficult peer relationships. (Testimony of Cindy Kaul and Holly Graham.)

The testimony of STEPMOTHER establishes that STUDENT has exhibited the inability to maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers for a long period of time. She testified that STUDENT was asked to leave four preschools because of difficulty getting along with peers and aggressive behavior toward them. STUDENT’s lack of friends was documented in an assessment by Kern County on March 28, 2000. (District’s Exhibit 48) Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has exhibited the above characteristic for a long period of time.

As to whether STUDENT exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships to a marked degree, STEPMOTHER testified to STUDENT’s difficulties at home and with peers, and Ms. Aguilar testified to STUDENT’s difficulties at school. Dr. Daggett testified that the results of her assessment substantiated that STUDENT is depressed and experiences feelings of rejection. The testimony of STEPMOTHER, Ms. Aguilar, and Dr. Daggett was undisputed on this issue. Therefore, because STUDENT experiences an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships in multiple environments, the Hearing Officer determines that he meets the criteria to a marked degree.

In summary, in reliance on the testimony of Dr. Daggett, Ms. Aguilar, and STEPMOTHER, and in the absence of persuasive testimony to the contrary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers to a marked degree and has so for a long period of time. There is no dispute that STUDENT’s condition adversely affects his educational performance.ED eligibility is met by satisfying one of the criteria and, therefore, it is unnecessary to make a determination as to the other criteria. However, because the District has asserted that STUDENT also meets ED criteria because he exhibits inappropriate types of feelings or behavior under normal circumstances, the Hearing Officer briefly addresses the District’s assertion. (footnote 14)

Dr. Daggett testified that STUDENT exhibits inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances. Dr. Daggett testified that STUDENT does not know how to resolve conflicts and, instead, relies on adult structure. Dr. Daggett further testified that without the imposition of adult structure, STUDENT responds to a dispute by engaging in physical aggression. Ms. Aguilar described situations in the classroom in which STUDENT resorted to swearing, yelling out, and acting aggressively toward peers and teachers in response to a relatively minor dispute. In her opinion, STUDENT has difficulty restraining his anger, handling feelings, and refraining from having outbursts when things do not go as he anticipates they should. Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT’s behavior has resulted in her moving him to a desk away from other children, requiring him to miss recess, removing him from the classroom, and application of physical restraint in the most severe incidents. STEPMOTHER also described STUDENT’s tantrums. A behavioral assessment and intervention plan developed by Kern Regional Center further supports STUDENT’s meeting the above characteristic. The report describes STUDENT’s being aggressive and tantrumming in response to structure. (District’s Exhibit 16)

The testimony of STEPMOTHER, which is supported by reports prepared by STUDENT’s preschool teachers, establishes that STUDENT has engaged in inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances, including hitting, kicking, and spitting in preschool, for a long period of time. The Hearing Officer concludes from this persuasive testimony that STUDENT engages in similar behavior at home and at school, and that the behavior has resulted in his suffering consequences in school. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior is to a marked degree.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found the evidence persuasive that STUDENT continues to meet ED criteria because of the inability to maintain interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers and because of inappropriate feelings and behavior under normal circumstances. The evidence further established that STUDENT has exhibited these characteristics for a long period of time and to a marked degree.

ISSUE NO. (4) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (footnote 15) 20 U.S.C. § 1418. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, etal. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (footnote 16)

The Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA, which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479, 1483-1484; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District (9th Cir. 2001) 267 F.3d 877.

STUDENT contends that the District failed to address his needs as a student with Asperger’s. STUDENT also asserts that to receive a FAPE, he required designated instructional services to address social, behavioral, sensory, and language deficits. STUDENT asserts that his needs required that he be placed in an SDC serving students with high functioning autism. The District contends that at all times during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received a FAPE because the program, services, and placement were designed to addressed STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and provided him with educational benefit. The District asserts that pursuant to his IEP dated May 31, 2001, STUDENT was appropriately placed at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year in a general education first-grade class with RSP support at his home school, Laurelglen. The District also asserts that when STUDENT experienced problems in the general education first-grade class, it took appropriate steps to address his needs first by modifying the IEP and then by placing him in Ms. Aguilar’s SDC, which served students with mild to moderate disabilities. The appropriateness of the IEPs and STUDENT’s class placements will be addressed individually below.

September to October 2001

Offer for 2001-2002 school year contained in IEP dated May 31, 2001

STUDENT’s unique and individual needs

The first inquiry regarding whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE is whether the District’s offer was designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. Before evaluating whether the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as he entered the first grade.

STUDENT is of at least average intelligence and, in May 2001, was performing academically at age-level. Therefore, he required academic instruction appropriate to his age-level. STUDENT’s IEP dated May 31, 2001, identified STUDENT’s needs as “patience, anger management, control, social skills, friends.” Behaviorally, STUDENT was acting out verbally and failing to follow adult direct. To address behavioral concerns, the parties concur that STUDENT needed to learn self control and anger management. There also is no dispute that STUDENT was exhibiting social difficulties at home and school and that he needed to develop social skills with peers.

Additionally, STUDENT contends that he had sensory deficits for which he required occupational therapy (OT) and speech or language deficits for which he required language and speech (LAS) therapy. The District contends that STUDENT did not require OT or LAS therapy. As to sensory deficits, both Mr. and STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT sought sensory stimulation by wearing a tight vest and sleeping between his mattress and the wall. There was no testimony that the parents shared this information with anyone from the District or that they raised sensory concerns at the time the IEP was developed. Ms. Kelly, RSP teacher, who provided STUDENT with RSP services during the 2001-2002 school year and had participated in the IEP meeting on May 31, 2001, testified that she was not aware of STUDENT having any sensory needs. In assessing STUDENT for OT later during the school year, Ms. Hazel reviewed STUDENT’s records. Although Ms. Hazel found a history of STUDENT’s having a short attention span, she testified that she did not find evidence of any sensory difficulties for which STUDENT required OT. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT had sensory needs requiring OT at the time the IEP was developed in May of 2001.

Regarding STUDENT’s speech and language skills in May 2001, the IEP states that “STUDENT can answer personal data questions, hold a conversation and repeat what is spoken.” No speech or language deficits were noted on the IEP. At the hearing, there was no testimony identifying any speech or language deficits that were present in May 2001, when the IEP was developed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have speech or language needs for which the District was required to provide LAS therapy at that time.

STUDENT additionally asserted that he required specific instructional methodologies to address his needs because of the diagnosis of Asperger’s. In STUDENT’s closing brief, he raises for the first time that he is entitled to applied behavioral analysis (ABA) as a compensatory remedy implying that the District should have met STUDENT’s needs by providing ABA as a teaching strategy. However, STUDENT did not request that the District provide ABA as part of an issue or proposed remedy for hearing either during the prehearing conference or during the hearing. He also did not present any evidence on ABA in general or specifically related to him. For these reasons, ABA is neither addressed as an alleged need nor remedy in this Decision. None of STUDENT’s witnesses identified specific methodologies that STUDENT required to meet his needs. Moreover, STUDENT’s witnesses were clinical psychologists and did not provide evidence of expertise in instructional methodologies. For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has failed to establish that he needs specific instructional methodologies.

In summary, a FAPE for STUDENT required components addressing his need to develop social skills with peers and appropriate behavior.

Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

STUDENT did not raise any specific objections nor was testimony elicited on behalf of him alleging that goals and objectives drafted for his entry into the first grade failed to address his needs. STUDENT’s IEP dated June 28, 2000, remained in effect in May 2001, and includes objectives related to following directions of an adult supervisor, initiating tasks with moderate adult supervision, working in a group setting, adapting to change, interacting socially, and using a mild tone of voice with peers. The May 2001 IEP added objectives related to STUDENT’s improving interactions with other children, transitions, and following directions of adults. A review of IEPs dated June 28, 2000, and May 31, 2001, and the testimony of Ms. Kelly, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, establish that goals and objectives were designed to address STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs. (See District’s Exhibit 24.)

Additionally, the May 2001 IEP includes the following supplemental aids, modifications and supports to address STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs and also to assist him to transition successfully to his fall placement:

Preparation for transitions; preferential seating-allow personal space; preferential line placement; redirection when frustrated before the tension builds; and no power struggles, give direction and back off. To help STUDENT transition to his first grade class, the IEP called for him to visit the school a week before class began and to come to school early on the first day.

(District’s Exhibit 24)

STUDENT’s IEP for the fall of 2001 called for his placement in a general education class with one hour weekly of RSP support. Mr. and STEPMOTHER testified that they had concerns about STUDENT’s being fully mainstreamed, given that he had received a great deal of individual support in kindergarten that they did not believe would be available in a general education first-grade class. They also expressed concern that a general education first-grade class would have more students than the kindergarten class. There was no other testimony on behalf of STUDENT regarding the specific placement offered for the 2001-2002 school year.

On behalf of the District, Ms. Kelly testified that the mainstream placement was recommended because STUDENT had been successful academically and socially in kindergarten, particularly during the last part of the school year when he was mainstreamed for 75 percent of his school day. (footnote 17) Ms. Kelly testified that STUDENT had met his IEP goals and objectives and was academically functioning at grade level. The general education kindergarten teacher in whose class STUDENT had been mainstreamed commented on the IEP that “STUDENT has done a wonderful job in my class this year. He has met his kindergarten goals. He interacts well with others in the class. At times STUDENT may need time to himself or away from others but overall has done a wonderful job fitting in as part of our class.” The special education teacher also commented that STUDENT can work appropriately in a group setting. (District’s Exhibit 24, p. 3 of 9) Ms. Kelly also testified that to help STUDENT be successful in the general education environment, RSP consultation was offered weekly to provide STUDENT with support toward reducing his anger and frustration level.

Ms. Kelly’s testimony was essentially undisputed and was supported by comments made contemporaneously to the development of the IEP by STUDENT’s general and special education teachers. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the offer of mainstreaming in a general education first-grade class with RSP consultation was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP goals and objectives, supports, services, and placement were designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual social and behavioral needs. Therefore, the District’s offer satisfied the first prong of an appropriate education under Rowley and the IDEA.

Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?

The May IEP addressed improving STUDENT’s social skills, which would have allowed STUDENT to develop friends and get along better with his peers. Additionally, by placing STUDENT in the general education first-grade class, he was able to attend his neighborhood school, where he would be involved with other children from his neighborhood. Friendships likely would be more easily fostered by opportunities to participate in the same class and school activities with neighborhood peers. The accommodations, modifications, and RSP consultation services offered STUDENT support to allow him to be successful in the general education environment by helping him to reduce anger and frustration. The Hearing Officer, therefore, concludes that STUDENT’s IEP calling for his participation in a general education class with RSP support was designed to allow him to benefit from his education and progress in the general education curriculum with his peers. Did the District provide STUDENT with a program and services that conformed to his IEP?

There is no dispute regarding the provision of a program and services that conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.

Summary

It has been concluded above that the IEP in place for STUDENT at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The placement and services provided conformed with the IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered an appropriate education to STUDENT.

IEP dated September 21, 2001

Unfortunately, although the District offered STUDENT a FAPE to begin the school year, he experienced problems in his first-grade placement. Ms. Kelly testified that STUDENT was engaging in aggressive and defiant behavior and was not completing all of his class work.

The law requires a school district to make an appropriate offer of placement based on information reasonably available at the time an offer is made. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)). It has been concluded above that the District’s offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year contained in the IEP dated May 31, 2001 was appropriate. The fact that STUDENT experienced difficulty in his placement does not render inappropriate the offer made by the District. However, the District cannot be relieved of its obligation to revise a student’s educational program or placement if it becomes apparent during the course of the school year that the student is not benefitting from his/her education. An IEP must be convened whenever the student demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b). The question that must now be addressed is whether the District responded properly to STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year.

Ms. Kelly testified that to address the behavioral problems STUDENT was experiencing, the IEP team convened on September 21, 2001, to plan behavior management strategies for STUDENT. Ms. Kelly’s testimony establishes that as a result of the IEP meeting, a behavioral goal was added to the IEP and a reward system was developed to provide positive reinforcement for appropriate behavior. Specifically, STUDENT would earn tickets or points for compliant behavior. Additionally, the testimony establishes that the District initiated a referral to Mental Health for an assessment of STUDENT to determine eligibility for Mental Health services. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Kelly’s testimony, which is substantiated by information included in the IEP regarding the changes to STUDENT’s program, to be credible. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that, in light of STUDENT’s deteriorating behavior, the District took reasonable steps to provide STUDENT a FAPE by modifying the existing IEP and making a referral to Mental Health. Moreover, as STUDENT continued to experience difficulties in the general education first-grade class, the District convened another IEP on October 16, 2001, to further review STUDENT’s program and placement. The appropriateness of the October 2001 IEP and the resulting placement in Ms. Aguilar’s class with mainstreaming in general education for arithmetic are discussed below.

IEP dated October 16, 2001

Did STUDENT’s unique and individual needs change?

STUDENT’s deficits remained in the same general areas as discussed above, namely, social and behavioral. However, Ms. Kelly’s testimony and supplemental information contained in the IEPs of September and October 2001, and the Mental Health referral form completed by STUDENT’s general education teacher, Ms. Sweeney, establish that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior continued to escalate. Ms. Sweeney reported that STUDENT was engaging in physically aggressive behavior, spitting, and losing his temper. The IEP drafted on Oct. 16, 2001, also indicates that STUDENT was engaging in off-task behavior, shouting out in class, and disturbing others. Ms. Sweeney also noted that STUDENT was behaving defiantly and refusing to work. (See District’s Exhibit 33) The evidence establishes that STUDENT continued to require behavioral interventions to address the behaviors described above. STEPMOTHER’s testimony and the report of Ms. Sweeney also establish that STUDENT was having increasingly more difficulty interacting with peers and forming friendships and, therefore, required social skills training. Although STUDENT had previously been successful in mainstreaming, his then-present difficulties with off-task behavior, peer interactions, and aggressive behavior resulted in the need for him to receive instruction in a small group for a significant portion of the day.

Was the change of placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

Because of STUDENT’s needs described above, the IEP team determined that a change of placement was needed. As a result, in October 2001, STUDENT was placed in Ms. Aguilar’s SDC with mainstreaming for arithmetic in a general education first-grade class. The District’s offer to change STUDENT’s placement to Ms. Aguilar’s class is contained in the IEP dated October 16, 2001. (District’s Exhibit 23)

Goals, objectives, and supplemental supports remained the same as described in the May and September 2001 IEPs. The goals, objectives, and supplemental supports have been found appropriate above. There is no persuasive evidence that the IEP team needed to develop new or additional goals or objectives in October 2001.

As to the parents’ concerns regarding Ms. Aguilar’s class, Dr. Bayan asserted that STUDENT required a placement specifically designed for children with autism. STUDENT’s parents testified briefly regarding STUDENT’s placement during the 2001-2002 school year, primarily concurring with Dr. Bayan’s assertion regarding the need for a placement specifically serving children with autism. The parents raised an additional concern regarding Ms. Aguilar’s class. They testified that STUDENT’s desk was located in the back of the room, which they asserted resulted in his being isolated from the other students. STEPMOTHER testified that she observed Ms. Aguilar’s class prior to STUDENT’s entering the class. However, she visited only briefly while STUDENT was attending Ms. Aguilar’s class. None of the other witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT had observed Ms. Aguilar’s class.

All of the District’s witnesses testified that Ms. Aguilar’s class constituted an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Ms. Aguilar’s testimony provided information regarding her class. Her testimony establishes that she teaches a primary learning handicapped SDC for students in grades one through three. During the 2001-2002 school year, there were approximately 13 students in her class with disabilities ranging from mental retardation, specific learning disability, to autism. Ms. Aguilar was assisted by an instructional assistant and an additional aide was assigned to work with STUDENT.

Ms. Aguilar testified regarding her classroom and some of the activities she does with the students on a daily basis. She stated that the class has a calendar area with a large calendar on the wall. The students spend 20 to 30 minutes daily in this area engaged in math, typical calendar, and prereading activities. For example, the students count by twos, fives, and tens and identify the days of the week by odd and even numbers. The students also engage in patterning activities, which helps the students to develop prereading skills. For example, a bug may be printed on each day’s placard. If there is one ant on three days in a row and bees on the next three days, the students say “ant, ant, ant, bee, bee, bee.” Ms. Aguilar testified that the class has a library containing grade-level literature books. There is a listening center that has four headphones so that the students can listen to a story as it is read on tape and follow the printed words on the pages of the book. Ms. Aguilar testified that the class has two computers that are used to teach the students computer skills and academics, including reading, arithmetic, and science. The class has two kidney-shaped tables where the students work in small groups. Ms. Aguilar testified that the students’ work is displayed in the classroom. There also are alphabet, number, and writing charts on the bulletin boards in the classroom.

Ms. Aguilar described her daily schedule as “structured.” The school day begins with a daily oral language lesson with all of the students in the class. Spelling and phonics are examples of the topics Ms. Aguilar may cover during oral language. Reading follows oral language. Ms. Aguilar testified that reading is taught in small groups of three or four students. Following reading is recess, which is followed by arithmetic. Arithmetic is taught in small groups. Ms. Aguilar and the aides alternate working with the groups in both reading and arithmetic. Ms. Aguilar testified that she uses the touch math system and the District’s core curriculum for mathematics. (footnote 18) Lunch follows arithmetic. Ms. Aguilar testified that after lunch, many of the students are mainstreamed or have OT or LAS. The afternoon schedule includes science, social studies, and physical education. The students also participate in a weekly computer lab. Ms. Aguilar testified that because the afternoon schedule may vary, she writes the schedule on the board each day.

Ms. Aguilar testified that she addressed STUDENT’s needs to improve social skills in multiple ways. For example, she engaged STUDENT and several other peers in roll modeling. She covered topics including appropriate ways to manage anger. Ms. Aguilar testified that the students also participated in a weekly social skills curriculum.

Ms. Aguilar testified that to address STUDENT’s behavioral problems, she implemented the behavior support plan contained in District’s Exhibit 7 at page 15. Ms. Aguilar described some of the strategies she employed as “reactive.” For example, to replace inappropriate behaviors, she would redirect STUDENT to an appropriate behavior or activity, and reinforce him for engaging in appropriate behavior by providing him with stickers, tokens, class money, time on the computer, a trip to the class “treasure box,” verbal compliments, or a choice of activities. Additional strategies to address STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior that Ms. Aguilar employed included working one-to-one with STUDENT, pulling him aside and talking with him, changing tasks, and redirecting him before his frustration escalated. Ms. Aguilar also testified that if STUDENT had a temper tantrum, she may move him away from other students and speak to him in a calm manner. The behavioral plan called for weekly communication with the parents regarding STUDENT’s behavior.

The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the PARENTS’ assertion that Ms. Aguilar’s class was not appropriate because it was designed for ED students rather than for students with autism. Contrary to the assertion by STUDENT’s parents, Ms. Aguilar’s class was not designated ED. The evidence establishes that the class served students with varying special education eligibility designations. Additionally, it has been concluded that STUDENT does not meet eligibility criteria as a student with autism or autistic-like characteristics nor does he require a class specifically designed for students with autism. In response to the PARENTS’ concern about the location of STUDENT’s desk, Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT has desks both near the other students’ desks and in the back of the room. Ms. Aguilar described STUDENT’s desk at the back of the room as a “carrel” with three high sides. She stated that STUDENT uses the desk at the back of the room to minimize distractions to the other students and STUDENT’s being distracted by other students. Ms. Hazel testified that given STUDENT’s propensity to suddenly reach out and grab or hit other students, having him sit in the back of the room at times is a matter of safety for STUDENT and other students.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Aguilar’s class addressed STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Aguilar’s testimony establishes that the class offered STUDENT academic instruction in a small-group setting and provided him one-to-one attention from both herself and the aide to address STUDENT’s off-task behavior. Ms. Aguilar’s testimony also establishes that she provided instruction and practical experiences for the purpose of teaching STUDENT appropriate social skills. Ms. Aguilar also implemented positive behavioral strategies to improve STUDENT’s behavior. Because neither Dr. Bayan nor Dr. Szeftel had direct knowledge of Ms. Aguilar’s class, the Hearing Officer gave less weight to their testimony regarding the inability of Ms. Aguilar’s class to address STUDENT’s needs. Additionally, STEPMOTHER’s observations of Ms. Aguilar’s class were limited. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of the District’s witnesses who have direct knowledge of Ms. Aguilar’s class and of appropriate teaching strategies for students with behavioral and social skills deficits such as STUDENT and concludes that Ms. Aguilar’s class was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs related to academics and social and behavioral skills.

Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?

Ms. Aguilar testified that she provided STUDENT academic instruction at an appropriate level that also followed California standards for arithmetic, reading and writing, which allowed STUDENT to progress in the curriculum that also is followed in general education classes. The placement also allowed STUDENT to receive instruction in a general education first-grade class, thereby providing him opportunities to engage with his general education peers. Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT is able to learn in small groups. She testified that STUDENT is learning to take turns and engage in social interaction. She described these skills as positive steps toward increasing mainstreaming.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the placement was designed to provide STUDENT with benefit. Moreover, Ms. Aguilar’s testimony was persuasive that STUDENT did benefit from his education. She testified that daily communication with STUDENT’s mainstream teacher led her to conclude STUDENT did very well in his mainstream class. It also was her impression that STUDENT enjoyed the class.

Did the District provide STUDENT with a program and services that conformed to his IEP?

There is no dispute regarding the provision of a program and services that conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.

Summary

The Hearing Officer has concluded that the change of placement to Ms. Aguilar’s SDC pursuant to the IEP developed in October 2001 was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Therefore, the District offered a program and placement that satisfied the requirements of a FAPE.

IEP dated November 29, 2001

Following STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Aguilar’s class, another IEP meeting was convened on November 29, 2001. (District’s Exhibit 22) Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT continued to be both verbally and physically aggressive and mean to other children in the class. Ms. Aguilar stated that STUDENT’s interactions with other students began appropriately but after a few minutes, STUDENT would get angry over some minute detail and would push his desk away or engage in some other inappropriate behavior. Ms. Aguilar testified that as she became more familiar with STUDENT, she determined that his IEP goals and objectives should be revised in some areas. STUDENT also was refusing to do work and was loud and defiant.

Ms. Aguilar testified that at the IEP meeting in November, the team drafted prevocational goals and objectives related to STUDENT’s attending to task, following directions, and initiating and completing tasks. Ms. Aguilar testified that she also developed goals and objectives in academic areas to ensure STUDENT was developing skills commensurate with District expectancies for his grade level. Additional supplemental supports were added including additional aide support, a visual schedule, frequent breaks and changing activities on frequent basis, and use of an “office” area to work. The IEP team agreed to explore other possible placements for STUDENT. (footnote 19) The team also concluded that an assessment was warranted in the areas of communication, academics, cognitive, adaptive, health, motor, behavioral, social, emotional, and OT areas. (footnote 20) Ms. Aguilar’s testimony and the revisions to STUDENT’s IEP establish that as his needs changed, the District responded appropriately by convening an IEP meeting and amending his IEP to address STUDENT’s changing needs.

IEP dated January 24, 2002

As noted above, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be assessed. Following the assessments, another IEP was convened on January 24, 2002, to discuss the results of the assessments. (District’s Exhibit 7) It is necessary to next discuss whether there were any changed needs identified as the result of the assessment. STUDENT’s parents assert that he required OT and LAS. The District asserted that he did not.

The PARENTS described STUDENT’s sensory seeking including wearing a vest. (See discussion in Issues No. 2.) There were several additional indicators of STUDENT’s sensory seeking. Dr. Daggett noted that STUDENT sucked on beads during her administration of the Robert’s. Ms. Aguilar testified that she had not observed STUDENT seeking sensory stimulation. However, she also testified that STUDENT will ask her to “gently scratch” his arm or leg when he is getting agitated. Ms. Hazel conducted the OT assessment. (District’s Exhibit 10) Ms. Hazel testified that she assessed STUDENT by observing him on multiple occasions in the classroom, on the playground, and going and coming to the bathroom. She also reviewed records, interviewed Ms. Aguilar, and administered the Visual Motor Integration test to STUDENT and engaged him in functional activities such as cutting and coloring. Ms. Hazel testified that STUDENT has a short attention span and his visual-perceptual skills fall on the low side of normal. He did not demonstrate any deficits in fine-motor or functional mobility skills. Ms. Hazel concluded that her assessment did not identify deficits for which she recommended OT for STUDENT. Ms. Hazel testified that at the time she wrote her report, she did not have the parents’ responses on the sensory survey. (footnote 21) After reviewing the survey, she testified that the parents’ responses did not change her opinion regarding STUDENT’s need for OT. STUDENT did not call an OT or similarly qualified person to rebut the testimony of Ms. Hazel. Ms. Hazel is appropriately qualified and conducted an extensive assessment of STUDENT prior to reaching her conclusions. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive that STUDENT did not have sensory or motor needs for which he required OT.

STUDENT also asserts that he required LAS therapy. In January 2001, Shannon Howry, District LAS pathologist, assessed STUDENT. (District’s Exhibit 17) Ms. Howry testified that on the basis of the results of multiple assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language, she concluded that STUDENT demonstrated age-appropriate language skills and did not meet eligibility criteria for LAS services. Ms. Howry is an appropriately qualified LAS therapist. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony credible. Moreover, STUDENT did not call an LAS therapist to testify. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have speech and language needs for which he required LAS therapy.

The IEP indicates that STUDENT was more compliant with teacher/aide directions. However, he still had room to grow in that area. The parties agree that STUDENT continued to exhibit inappropriate behavior and deficits in social skills.

Turning to the new IEP to determine whether it was designed to meet STUDENT’s identified needs, the Hearing Officer notes that the goals and objectives from the November 2001 IEP remained in place. There was no evidence that the prior goals and objectives previously determined appropriate were no longer appropriate. A review of the IEP and testimony of Ms. Aguilar establishes that additional goals and objectives were developed in the behavior and social areas. A goal and objectives were developed to address compliance with aide/teacher direction. Another goal with multiple objectives was developed to address STUDENT’s difficulty expressing anger and frustration and to help him identify feelings in an appropriate manner. A third and a fourth new goal were developed to increase social skills with peers and adults. Another goal and related objectives were developed to improve listening, turn taking, and following instruction in group activities. Ms. Aguilar testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate to address STUDENT needs because they addressed STUDENT’s poor social skills, anger, and academic. There is no persuasive evidence to the contrary.

As to supplemental aides and services called for by the IEP of January 2002, the evidence establishes that STUDENT continued to receive individual aide assistance, small-group instruction, preferential seating, and grade-level literature on tape. Additionally, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for Mental Health services and that he would participate in a monthly social skills group and receive case management services. Ms. Kaul provided STUDENT’s social skills therapy for Mental Health. She testified that the purpose of group therapy in which STUDENT participated was to improve his self-awareness and to promote social skills development. Additionally, the group address how to play cooperatively and take turns. The group consisted of four to five students. (See District’s Exhibit 32.)

STUDENT’s IEP also included the behavioral support plan developed in 2001. To address noncompliant behavior resulting in STUDENT’s failing to participate in school activities, the plan calls for replacement behaviors to improve STUDENT’s ability to identify emotions and to stay on task. The Hearing Officer finds that the supplemental aides and services as described above were designed to provide STUDENT additional support in his identified areas of need, namely, social skills and behavior.

Continued placement in Ms. Aguilar’s class was recommended. It has been concluded above that Ms. Aguilar’s class was appropriate for STUDENT. There was no persuasive evidence that her class failed to continue to be appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that the District continued to fulfill its obligation to provide a FAPE to STUDENT by developing additional goals and objectives, and providing additional supplemental aides and services as the year progressed to adjust its program to meet the needs of STUDENT.

Ms. Aguilar also taught the ESY program. The class was located at a different school site. However, Ms. Aguilar testified that she provided the students with reading, arithmetic, calendar, and center activities that were similar to the activities that took place in her class during the regular school year. She also provided “fun” activities. The ESY program was four hours daily for 20 days. Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT did well during the ESY program. The PARENTS did not raise any specific objections nor did anyone testify on behalf of STUDENT that the ESY was other than appropriate for STUDENT.

Summary

In summary, the Hearing Officer concluded above that the District made an appropriate offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The evidence also established that when STUDENT experienced difficulty with behavior and social skills, the District took active steps by convening multiple IEPs to address STUDENT’s changing needs, including drafting additional goals and objectives and changing placements. Therefore, in taking all of the findings above into consideration, The Hearing Officer determines that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

ISSUE NO. (5): Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

STUDENT remained in Ms. Aguilar’s class for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT continues to assert that he did not receive a FAPE for the same reasons set forth above related to the 2001-2002 school year. Additionally, STUDENT asserts that the District failed to provide FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year because it provided inappropriate behavioral interventions, including the use of improper restraint, failed to communicate with the parents regarding STUDENT’s progress, and failed to provide consistent aide services.

What were STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT had met some of his goals and objectives and was beginning to have some successful interactions with peers. However, the witnesses generally concurred that STUDENT’s primary areas of need remained the same for the 2002-2003 school year, namely, to address social and behavioral deficits as described above in Issue No. 4.

The PARENTS again asserted that STUDENT required LAS therapy. STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT was slurring his speech and speaking quickly. She also asserts that STUDENT was not initiating conversations. The District contends that STUDENT did not require LAS therapy. Ms. Aguilar testified that STUDENT did not exhibit speech or language deficits. The District undertook another LAS assessment of STUDENT in January 2003. LAS therapist Mr. Tickle testified that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for LAS therapy. Mr. Tickle’s assessment results were similar to those obtained by Ms. Howry approximately one year earlier. Mr. Tickle reached this conclusion that STUDENT did not require LAS therapy as the result of a thorough speech and language assessment of STUDENT’s expressive and receptive language, fluency, articulation, and pragmatic language skills. Mr. Tickle observed STUDENT in class, at recess, and during lunch. He also obtained a language sample. In response to assertions that STUDENT was spitting while speaking, Mr. Tickle testified that the school nurse advised him that excessive saliva was a side effect of the medication STUDENT then was taking. STUDENT did not call a speech and language therapist to testify. Thus, Mr. Tickle’s testimony was not rebutted. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds Mr. Tickle to be a credible witness. He is appropriately credentialed to administer an LAS assessment and described his assessment in great detail. The Hearing Officer relies on Mr. Tickle’s testimony in concluding that STUDENT did not require speech and language therapy.

The PARENTS asserted that the District failed to properly plan a program to address STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs. Both Ms. and STEPMOTHER testified that improper behavioral techniques were employed with STUDENT. At this point in the discussion, the focus is on the adequacy of the program offered by the District. For this reason, the concerns regarding implementation of the behavioral interventions will be addressed below in the section addressing whether the program provided by the District conformed with STUDENT’s IEP. Several of STUDENT’s witnesses made specific recommendations regarding how STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs should be addressed. Dr. Bayan continued to recommend that STUDENT be placed in and receive services from a program specifically designed for children with autism. As to social skills in particular, Dr. Bayan disputed the appropriateness of teaching STUDENT social skills in a therapeutic group setting, as had been done by Mental Health. She testified that the only time she had noted STUDENT’s behavior improve was following his enrolling in the VAC after school program in June 2002. Dr. Bayan appeared to contradict her testimony when she later stated that she had not seen social improvement in STUDENT over the past year. In support of Dr. Bayan’s testimony, STEPMOTHER commented that she has not been called to pick up STUDENT from VAC because of inappropriate behavior. She also described him as “calm” when he arrives home from VAC.

Dr. Szeftel’s recommendations were more general that Dr. Bayan’s recommendations. Dr. Szeftel recommended that a combination of behavioral interventions and psychotropic medications be employed to impede STUDENT’s aggressive behavior and to address depression. Dr. Szeftel testified that an appropriate behavioral program would identify the root of the behavior and address the behavior itself. Additionally, in response to STUDENT’s parents reporting to her that the bus driver was locking STUDENT’s seat belt in place to ensure that STUDENT would remain in his seat, Dr. Szeftel testified that STUDENT’s difficulty may stem from sensory problems that need to be addressed.

In response to Dr. Bayan’s assertion that STUDENT could not benefit from a Mental Health social skills group, Ms. Kaul testified that while attending the group she facilitated, STUDENT improved his interactions with the other students in the group. She stated he acted appropriately and played with other children in the group. Ms. Kaul’s testimony establishes that STUDENT was able to benefit from his participation in the group.

There was no persuasive testimony establishing that VAC, a program that serves students with autism, was solely responsible for any improvement to STUDENT’s social skills or behavior or, alternatively, that all inappropriate behavior is attributable to school. For example, both Dr. Bayan and STEPMOTHER testified that STUDENT’s behavior escalated at home during the spring of 2003. They acknowledge that contributing to STUDENT’s hospitalization in June were STUDENT’s throwing an ice chest at a caretaker and fighting with his siblings. Thus, STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior is not limited to the school environment. For reasons set out in the findings above in previous issues, including lack of familiarity with the educational components of STUDENT’s program and placement, and because of contradictory testimony the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Bayan’s testimony unpersuasive as to STUDENT’s need for a program, services, or placement specifically designed for children with autism.

To summarize, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s needs for the 2002-2003 school year required goals, objectives, a program, and placement to improve social and behavioral skills.

Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

Turning first to the goals and objectives in place at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT began the 2002-2003 school year with the same goals, objectives, and supports as the prior school year, which previously were determined to have been designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and, thus, do not need to be reevaluated. The IEP team convened on November 19, 2002. The IEP included new goals and objectives, including academic goals and objectives following the District’s grade-level expectancies for written language, arithmetic, and reading. Other goals and objectives related to STUDENT’s appropriately interacting with peers and being compliant. The parents did not consent to the IEP until January 14, 2003, at which time the parents continued to dispute STUDENT’s eligibility designation. (District’s Exhibit 41)

The testimony of Ms. Lemes-Jones supported Ms. Aguilar’s testimony regarding the appropriateness of the goals and objectives. There was no persuasive testimony to the contrary. Therefore, because the goals and objectives addressed social and behavioral areas, and also were designed to maintain STUDENT at academic par with his general education peers, the Hearing Officer concludes that the goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

All of the District witnesses, including Dr. Daggett, Ms. Lemes-Jones, Ms. Aguilar, and Mr. Rhoten testified that the program and services offered to STUDENT were designed to address his needs and that he did not require a program or services designed specifically for students with autism. The program offered by the November 2002 IEP called for small-group instruction, preferential seating, extended time to complete class assignments, and additional classroom aide support throughout the school day. Additionally, STUDENT remained entitled to Mental Health Services. Mental Health offered a weekly social skills group for STUDENT. The IEP also contained a revised behavior support plan. The behavior support plan identifies inappropriate behaviors, hypothesizes why the behavior occurs, and defines replacement behaviors. Teaching strategies on the behavior plan include teaching STUDENT about emotions and skills for accessing teacher attention. The plan calls for modeling, role playing, positive feedback given immediately, and presenting STUDENT an option of selecting a preferred activity. The plan also sets forth reinforcement procedures that include verbal praise, special rewards, and reactive strategies. The plan also calls for a parent/teacher communication system.

The District’s witnesses testified that the above modifications, behavior plan, and services were designed to address STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. For example, Mr. Rhoten, who has observed Ms. Aguilar’s class on multiple occasions, testified that the behavior plan addresses STUDENT’s aggressive and noncompliant behaviors. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified similarly. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT offered specific testimony about the plan. Therefore, in reliance on the testimony of the District’s witnesses, it is concluded that the IEP modifications and services were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in the areas of behavior and social skills.

The District convened an IEP meeting on January 14, 2003, to discuss mainstreaming. (District’s Exhibit 2) The team concluded that STUDENT would begin mainstreaming in a general education second-grade class for 30 minutes daily for science, social studies, literature, or art, and for an additional 30 minutes weekly for music. Ms. Aguilar testified that mainstreaming was appropriate for STUDENT because he “basically” was at grade level academically. Ms. Aguilar additionally testified that mainstreaming offered STUDENT an opportunity to interact with general education peers and to participate in the core curriculum. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony compelling given that she has had STUDENT in her class for over one year and is in a better position than other witnesses to comment on STUDENT’s academics and readiness for mainstream experiences.

As to whether Ms. Aguilar’s class offered an appropriate placement, Ms. Aguilar, Dr. Daggett, Ms. Lemes-Jones, and Mr. Rhoten testified that it did. To summarize, they testified that Ms. Aguilar’s class allows STUDENT to receive small-group and individualized instruction that addresses his behavior and social needs and provides him with appropriate instruction in the District’s core curriculum. Ms. Aguilar’s testimony establishes that the class was relatively the same during the 2002-2003 school year as the class the prior school year. There were a total of 11 students and as many as five or six aides during the course of the school year. Ms. Lemes-Jones’s testimony confirmed Ms. Aguilar’s testimony regarding the composition of her class. In particular, she noted that the students have a variety of disabilities and all of the students have the ability to work on academic goals and objectives. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that STUDENT has grown academically, behaviorally, and socially while in Ms. Aguilar’s class.

Regarding Ms. Aguilar’s addressing STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties, Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that the reinforcement system set up by Ms. Aguilar is an intrinsic component of the class. Ms. Lemes-Jones described a chart in the class that identifies positive replacement behaviors such as raising one’s hand rather than shouting out when feeling angry. The system has been adjusted to meet STUDENT’s needs. For example, Ms. Lemes-Jones observed STUDENT working on his own individual strategies. Ms. Lemes-Jones also testified that because STUDENT needs more frequent reinforcement than other students in the class, the amount of time that STUDENT must sustain good behavior before his receives reinforcement is shorter than the time for other students in the class. Ms. Lemes-Jones based her testimony on observations of the class and information obtained during the IEP meeting in November. Ms. Lemes-Jones stated that STUDENT appears to enjoy Ms. Aguilar’s class and has a good relationship with his teacher.

Mr. Rhoten testified that he also has observed Ms. Aguilar implementing the behavior plan and, in his opinion, the plan is “working.” In support of his opinion that the plan was working to improve STUDENT’ s behavior, Mr. Rhoten testified that STUDENT was responding well to redirection. Mr. Rhoten had recently observed STUDENT during the ESY. He stated that STUDENT showed him the money he had earned by behaving appropriately in class, which was more than the other two students in his group.

Both Ms. Lemes-Jones and Mr. Rhoten testified that they trained the classroom aides to implement STUDENT’s behavioral plan including proper prompting and redirecting strategies.

Ms. Aguilar testified that she continued to provide social skills training to STUDENT in the same manner as the prior school year. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that she observed a social skills curriculum being implemented in Ms. Aguilar’s class.

In summary, the testimony of the District’s witnesses establishes that Ms. Aguilar’s class with mainstreaming and services was designed to meet STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs. They also testified that Ms. Aguilar’s class would provide STUDENT with appropriate academic instruction. None of the witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT had observed Ms. Aguilar’s class to any extent and, therefore, did not specifically comment on the social, behavioral, and academic components of the class. STEPMOTHER testified that her observations were limited. Therefore, the Hearing Officer accords greater weight to the testimony of the District’s witnesses and finds that the IEP proposed in November was reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Petitioner with educational benefit?

The IEP offered by the District provided goals, objectives, modifications and services to address STUDENT’s poor social and behavior management skills. The witnesses testified that poor social and behavior management skills were interfering with STUDENT’s participating in general education and his getting along with peers. It is undisputed that STUDENT possesses average cognitive skills and is at or near grade-level proficiency in academic subjects. Ms. Aguilar testified that during the course of the year, STUDENT had been learning to better get along with his peers. Ms. Aguilar also stated that STUDENT continued to experience some episodes of anger, but not as frequently. She stated that STUDENT has been learning to de-escalate before having a tantrum. Ms. Aguilar testified that tantrums have occurred less frequently during the current school year than during the prior school year. Further evidence that STUDENT’s program was designed to meet his needs is that during the course of the year, STUDENT was able to be mainstreamed successfully. The Hearing Officer concludes that the testimony of Ms. Aguilar establishes that STUDENT, in fact, was benefitting from the program.

Did the District provide STUDENT with a program and services that conformed to his IEP?

STUDENT’s parents contend that the District failed to implement STUDENT’s IEP properly. They assert that the District employed behavioral interventions that were inconsistent with his behavioral intervention plan by using a lock on his seatbelt, seating STUDENT in the back of the class, removing STUDENT from recess, and using physical force. STUDENT’s parents assert that Ms. Aguilar failed to properly communicate with them. Lastly, the parents assert that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide.

The first assertion related to the District’s alleged failure to follow the IEP is related to the use of a lock to maintain STUDENT in his seatbelt on the bus. The PARENTS testified that STUDENT’s seat belt was secured with a lock so that he would not open it on the bus. The District did not dispute Dr. Szeftel’s testimony that locking the seat belt is not a good strategy to use with STUDENT and is not safe. Additionally, the use of a lock is not called for in STUDENT’s behavior plan. The Hearing Officer finds that the securing of STUDENT’s seat belt on the bus is not appropriate.

As to STUDENT’s seat in the classroom, STUDENT’s parents testified that STUDENT is improperly isolated from the other students in the class because he is seated in the back of the classroom. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that the desks in Ms. Aguilar’s class are arranged in a horseshoe. STUDENT has a desk within the horseshoe and also has a study carrel approximately three feet behind the horseshoe. Ms. Lemes-Jones testified that STUDENT uses the carrel when doing independent work or when his behavior is inappropriate. Mr. Rhoten testified that he has observed STUDENT seated in the front of the room, in the back of the room and elsewhere. STUDENT’s IEP calls for preferential seating. As discussed in the issue above, placing STUDENT away from other students helps him to focus on his work and keeps him from bothering other students. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District improperly removes STUDENT to a location to the rear of the classroom.

STUDENT’s parents assert that Ms. Aguilar improperly removes STUDENT from recess. Ms. Aguilar testified that sometimes she does not allow STUDENT to go to recess because he has had difficulty getting along with peers or has refused to do work. Ms. Aguilar testified that when recess is withheld from STUDENT, he has several activities to choose from and is in the company of his aide. Ms. Aguilar also testified that removing recess is an option that she utilizes for all of her students. A review of the behavior plan reveals that one of the strategies called for by the plan is to remove recess. (District’s Exhibit 41, page 9) Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the removal of STUDENT from recess is not contrary to his IEP.

STUDENT’s parents testified that the District improperly physically restrained STUDENT. The parents and Ms. Barrus recounted STUDENT’s telling them that physical restraint was used to hold his head down on a table on the school’s playground. STEPMOTHER testified that this use of restraint occurred in April 2003 and, according to STUDENT, lasted for 45 minutes. STEPMOTHER testified that on another occasion, an aide pulled the hood on STUDENT’s jacket and then fell on him. As to the incident described above, Ms. Aguilar testified that in April 2003, STUDENT had an outburst. He pushed classroom desks around and an aide took STUDENT outside to try to calm him down. STUDENT ran away, began ripping up bushes near his classroom, and was described as “flailing.” Ms. Aguilar testified that the aide, with her assistance, put STUDENT in a crisis prevention intervention (CPI) baskethold for a period up to 45 minutes while STUDENT calmed down. Ms. Aguilar, Ms. Lemes-Jones, and Mr. Rhoten testified regarding the use of CPI restraint. Their testimony establishes that the individual must be trained when to use CPI restraint and how to administer CPI restraint prior to employing CPI techniques. They testified that CPI restraint would only be used to protect a student who is out of control and who is not responding to other behavioral interventions.

The Hearing Officer makes no finding as to the specific incident described by the parties. However, in reviewing STUDENT’s behavioral support plan, it is noted that the plan calls for use of “as little physical assistance as possible.” The behavioral support plan does not contain any references to the use of physical restraint with STUDENT, nor is there any other reference on the IEP to the use of physical restraint. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the use of physical restraint with STUDENT for an extended period of time was inconsistent with his IEP. (footnote 22)

STUDENT’s parents assert that they are not properly informed of STUDENT’s behavior or of his progress in school. The behavior plan calls for a “parent communication system to be developed to facilitate communication between home and school.” (District’s Exhibit 41) STUDENT’s parents testified that a satisfactory communication system had been in place but that the District thwarted the system by implementing a different system. The parents also testified that they wanted to be better informed of STUDENT’s progress in school. Apparently the parents preferred the older system wherein the aide completed a narrative log, which was passed to VAC and then home to the parents.

Ms. Aguilar and Mr. Rhoten testified regarding the development of the present communication system. Mr. Rhoten testified that the communication system was revised so that it would provide more objective data that could be analyzed to identify STUDENT’s problem behaviors and when they were occurring with the most frequency. The communication system called for the teacher to rate STUDENT’s behavior at various intervals during the course of the school day. Information from the daily logs is compiled and analyzed to obtain a picture of STUDENT’s behavior. (See District’s Exhibit 64) Ms. Aguilar testified persuasively that she completes a daily behavior sheet, which allows her to see a pattern of STUDENT’s behavior. If certain problems occur with regularity, she can make modifications to the schedule. For example, Ms. Aguilar testified STUDENT was having problems waiting in line for lunch. Once the problem was identified, Ms. Aguilar had the aide accompany STUDENT to the cafeteria a few minutes before the other students to avoid the problem. Ms. Aguilar testified that in addition to the daily logs, she provides information to STUDENT’s parents at IEP meetings and through quarterly progress reports that coincide with reports to the parents of general education students.

The testimony of Ms. Aguilar and Mr. Rhoten establish that a daily communication log was maintained and information was transmitted to the parents via the log, IEP meetings, and quarterly reports. The evidence establishes that a communication system was developed consistent with the requirement set forth in STUDENT’s behavior plan.

STUDENT’s parents next assert that the District did not provide STUDENT with an individual aide as called for by the IEP. Ms. Aguilar, Ms. Lemes-Jones, and Mr. Rhoten testified regarding the aide. Their testimony establishes that STUDENT had an aide, Fred, who was with him for an extended period of time and with whom STUDENT and his parents were familiar. Unfortunately, Fred left the position and, in the spring of 2003, from three to four aides were assigned to STUDENT. At least one left the position and several were substitute aides while the District secured full-time aide services for STUDENT. It is unfortunate that several different persons filled in as STUDENT’s aide during the spring of 2003. However, there is no evidence that STUDENT was without an aide at any time. Additionally, Ms. Aguilar, Ms. Lemes-Jones, and Mr. Rhoten testified that each time a new aide was assigned to STUDENT, they trained the aide to work with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the requirements of the IEP as far as providing an individual aide for STUDENT.

Summary

It has been concluded above that the District failed to provide a program to STUDENT that comported with the IEP to the limited extent that its employees used a lock on STUDENT’s seatbelt and employed physical restraint on one occasion. The question becomes whether the failure to adhere to the behavior support plan related to these two incidents rendered an otherwise appropriate placement inappropriate. The Hearing Officer concludes that while somewhat disturbing, the use of CPI physical restraint does not appear to have recurred routinely. The problem related to STUDENT’s remaining in his seat during bus transportation, again, while not called for by STUDENT’s IEP and potentially dangerous, also does not render inappropriate what has been deemed an appropriate placement in all other aspects.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that the IEP team shall be consulted to amend STUDENT’s behavior support plan to include appropriate measures to be taken should he become out-of-control and nonresponsive to adult intervention, and to determine what steps to take to ensure STUDENT’s safety on the bus. As to all other aspects of the IEP, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year was appropriate.

ISSUE NO. (6) If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech services (LAS)?

A special education student may be entitled to relief when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.)

STUDENT contends that he is entitled to compensatory education in the form of OT and LAS for the District’s failure to provide him with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. As to OT, STUDENT requests that for the period of one year, the District be compelled to provide him with (1) individual, direct OT for 30 minutes weekly at a location that has available appropriate equipment to address sensory deficits, and (2) consultative OT services for 30 minutes weekly. As to LAS, STUDENT requests that for the period of one year, the District be compelled to provide him (1) direct LAS therapy for 30 minutes weekly and (2) consultative LAS services for 15 minutes weekly.

The Hearing Officer determined above that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE. Therefore, requests for reimbursement for OT and LAS on behalf of STUDENT are denied.

ORDER

(1) Within 15 calendar days of the receipt of the Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to amend STUDENT’s behavioral support plan to include appropriate means to address STUDENT’s safely riding the bus to and from school and, if determined necessary by the IEP team, to determine the circumstances, if any, under which the use of physical restraint is necessary.

(2) All of STUDENT’s additional requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) Was the District’s assessment by Julie Daggett, Ph.D., appropriate?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(2) If the District’s assessment was not appropriate, is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained by his parents from Ruby Bayan, M.D., and Roxy Szeftel, Ph.D.?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(3) Is STUDENT eligible for special education as a child with autism or autistic-like behavior or does he continue to be eligible as a child with an emotional disturbance?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(4) Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

(5) Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

The District substantially prevailed on this issue.

(6) If the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy (OT) and language and speech services (LAS)?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: September 8, 2003 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. The parties identified issues and their proposed resolution during a prehearing telephone conference on June 2, 2003. In the Prehearing Conference Order dated June 6, 2003, the hearing officer who convened the conference noted that “the parties recognize that the eligibility criteria for special education is not the determinative factor for determining whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE. However, the parties agreed that for purposes of analysis, it is useful to determine whether STUDENT is impaired with ‘high functioning’ autism or is emotionally disturbed, since the disagreement over the nature of his impairment plays a central role in the parties’ dispute over what constitutes an appropriate educational program for STUDENT.” During the hearing, although Dr. Bayan had diagnosed STUDENT with Asperger’s Disorder, the parties interchangeably used “high functioning autism” and “Asperger’s” to describe STUDENT’s condition. Neither “high functioning autism” nor “Asperger’s” is an eligibility designation in federal or State law. As set forth below in issue No. 3, the special education eligibility criteria under federal law are “autistic” and, under State law, is “autistic-like.” For these reasons, the undersigned Hearing Officer has modified the issue from how it was framed initially, namely, “Is STUDENT eligible for special education as an emotionally disturbed child or as a child with high functioning autism (emphasis added)?” to the legally proper special education designation of “autism” or “autistic-like behavior.”

2. The essential features of Asperger’s are “severe and sustained impairment in social interaction and the development of restricted, repetitive patterns of behavior, interests, and activities. . . . In contrast to Autistic Disorder, there are no clinically significant delays in language. . . . In addition, there are no clinically significant delays in cognitive development or in the development of age-appropriate self-help skills, adaptive behavior (other than in social interaction), and curiosity about the environment in childhood.” Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. (DSM-IV), (1994) American Psychiatric Association, p. 75.

3. STUDENT was hospitalized in a psychiatric facility during the first few days of hearing. Prior to the end of the hearing, STUDENT had returned home and was attending the extended school year (ESY) program taught by Ms. Aguilar.

4. VAC is a nonpublic school serving children with autism.

5. For the past four years, STUDENT’s regimen of medications has changed multiple times. Initially, Ritalin was prescribed for attentional problems. Dr. Bayan stated that STUDENT’s current medications are “to stabilize his emotional and behavioral state.”

6 STUDENT does not have any contact with his biological mother.

7. STUDENT then resided with his family in a different school district.

8. By report, the following medications had previously been prescribed for STUDENT: Resperidal, Trazadone, Prozac, Lithium, and Tofranil.

9. Dr. Daggett testified that she was asked to conduct a psychological evaluation to answer (a) whether STUDENT has Asperger’s and (b) what behavioral supports are necessary to address STUDENT’s challenging behaviors to allow STUDENT to access his education.

10. In January 2002, Deborah Hazel, registered occupational therapist (OTR) employed by the Kern County Superintendent of Schools, completed the OT assessment, Debra Ragsdale, District school nurse, completed the health assessment, and District school psychologist Richard Roy undertook a review of STUDENT’s special education file and assessed STUDENT’s cognitive, processing, and achievement skills. (District’s Exhibits 10, 11, and 13)

11. No concerns were raised, nor is there evidence that the tests and procedures employed by Dr. Daggett were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Additionally, the tests were administered in English, which is STUDENT’s primary language.

12. Dr. Daggett is presently in private practice as a clinical psychologist with the Family Institute of the Central Coast. She also is a consultant and in service trainer to school districts in San Luis Obispo and Kern Counties. Dr. Daggett was employed as a program specialist for the Kern County Superintendent of Schools during the 2000-2001 school year. Dr. Daggett also is a credentialed school psychologist. (See Dr. Daggett’s curriculum vitae, District’s Exhibit 19.)

13. In September 2001, Dr. Bayan sent the District a letter stating STUDENT’s diagnosis as “Asperger’s Syndrome, Bipolar Affective Disorder, and Learning Disability non-specified.” (District’s Exhibit 15) There is no evidence of STUDENT’s having a learning disability nor did either party raise learning disability as an appropriate special education eligibility for STUDENT.

14. It is also noted that although the District did not assert STUDENT meets ED eligibility because of a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, Dr. Daggett diagnosed STUDENT with a mood disorder - not otherwise specified. She testified that results from her administration of the Roberts Apperception Test for Children revealed significant levels of concern on the depression subscale, suggesting that STUDENT is experiencing feelings of depression. Elevated scores also were obtained in the areas of anxiety, aggression, and rejection. On the Behavior Assessment Scale for Children (BASC), STUDENT’s teachers and STEPMOTHER scored him high in several areas including depression. 15. The 1997 reauthorization of the IDEA also calls for school districts to provide special education students with access to the general education curriculum and instruction and related services designed to prepare the students for employment and independent living.

16. Although the Hearing Officer has determined above that STUDENT does not meet special education eligibility criteria as a student with autism or autistic-like behaviors, STUDENT remains entitled to an educational program that addresses all of his unique needs and not just those specifically related to the ED eligibility designation. Capistrano Unified School District v. Wartenberg (9th Cir. 1995) 59 F.3d 884.

17. Because STUDENT had been mainstreamed successfully for one hour daily in a general education kindergarten, the IEP team determined in May that he should be mainstreamed for 75 percent of his school day for the remainder of the school year.

18. Each number in the touch math system has touch points. For example, the number one has a single dot at the top of the number one and the number three has three dots located on each end of the number.

19. STEPMOTHER made visits to several classes. She testified that neither of the other classes under consideration were appropriate.

20. The assessment resulting from the referral to Mental Health was pending.

21. The parents failed to return the survey until the assessment had been completed and the report discussed at the IEP meeting.

22. There is no evidence of a pattern of use of physical restraint although Ms. Lemes-Jones found several behavioral incident reports during the course of the hearing which had not previously been made available to the parents.