California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 13, 1996
Student v. Victor Valley Union High School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 876-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Victor Valley Union High School District prevails: student with an ADHD diagnosis and a discipline history found ineligible for special education.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 16-year-old eleventh grader filed for due process against Victor Valley Union High School District and the Desert/Mountain SELPA. The student had never qualified for special education. He had a long discipline history, including two expulsions, and his grades had fallen. IEP teams in September 1995 and July 1996 found him ineligible. A private evaluator, Dr. Douglas Harrington, diagnosed attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), mainly from parent behavior ratings. But the student scored normally on Dr. Harrington's attention tests, and his report found no educationally handicapping condition.
Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain explained that an ADHD diagnosis alone does not make a student eligible. Under Education Code section 56339, the student must also meet the criteria for other health impairment, serious emotional disturbance, or specific learning disability. No health problem limited his strength, vitality or alertness. He met none of the criteria for serious emotional disturbance. He achieved at grade level, had peer relationships and workable relationships with teachers, and discipline alone was not enough. District psychologists Diane Hannett and April Johnson agreed, as did both outside evaluators. On learning disability, the largest gap between his ability and achievement scores was 18 points. That fell short of the 22.5-point severe discrepancy, and the evidence did not justify overturning the IEP team's decision. Because he was ineligible, the home study question was not decided. All relief was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Education Code section 56339. A student with ADHD had to meet the criteria for other health impairment, serious emotional disturbance, or specific learning disability. Normal attention testing, grade-level achievement, and serious misconduct without an emotional basis did not establish eligibility.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)?
An ADHD diagnosis alone does not make a student eligible. The student did not meet the criteria for other health impairment, serious emotional disturbance, or specific learning disability. His largest ability-achievement gap was 18 points, below the 22.5-point severe discrepancy.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2. Should STUDENT participate in a regular education home study program?
Not reached because the student was found ineligible for special education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's requests for relief denied.
Key authorities
34 C.F.R. section 300.7; Education Code section 56339(a); Education Code section 56337; 5 C.C.R. section 3030(f), (i), (j); U.S. Department of Education Policy Letter of September 16, 1991 (18 IDELR 118)
People named in the decision
- Robert Parker, program manager, Desert/Mountain SELPA
- Susan Wells, superintendent of student services; District witness, Victor Valley Union High School District
- Diane Hannett, school psychologist; 1995 psychoeducational assessor; District witness, Victor Valley Union High School District
- April Johnson, school psychologist; 1994 psychological assessor; District witness, Victor Valley Union High School District
- Dr. Linda Nelson, clinical neuropsychologist; jointly selected assessor (1996), University of California, Irvine
- Dr. Douglas Harrington, private neuropsychological evaluator for Student
- Barry Nelson, teacher providing weekly individual instruction, Excelsior Charter School
- Lane Cole, paralegal for Student; witness
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on October 8, 1996 before Carin N.
Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Officer, McGeorge School of Law, in Victorville, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Herbert H.
Williams. FATHER and paralegal Lane Cole also appeared on behalf of Petitioner.
Respondents Desert/Mountain SELPA and Victor Valley Union High School District (the District) were represented by attorney Sharon A. Watt. Also present on behalf of the District were Robert Parker, program manager, Desert/Mountain SELPA, and Susan Wells, superintendent of student services, Victor Valley Union High School District.
FATHER and Lane Cole testified on behalf of Petitioner. The following witnesses testified on behalf of the District: Diane Hannett, psychologist; April Johnson, psychologist; and Susan Wells, superintendent of student services, Victor Valley Union High School District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received on October 8, 1996. The matter was submitted for decision and the record was closed on October 22, 1996.
ISSUES
1. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA)?
2. Should STUDENT participate in a regular education home study program?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Sixteen-year-old STUDENT resides within and receives regular education services from the Victor Valley Union High School District. STUDENT's primary language is English, but he speaks Spanish at home. He is currently an eleventh grader and has never qualified for special education.
STUDENT attended kindergarten in the Bell School District.
From grades one through four, STUDENT attended school within the Paramount Unified School District. Noting STUDENT's inattentiveness during the 1987-88 school year, his second-grade teacher commented that he "has great potential to do better in his academic work when he listens or reads directions." (Petitioner's Exhibit 3a.) STUDENT's teachers observed that he was bright and referred him to the Gifted and Talented Education Program (GATE). He qualified for and remained in the GATE program until he left the Paramount Unified School District.
STUDENT's family moved to Victorville, California, when he was in the fourth grade. As there was no GATE program at Park View Elementary School, STUDENT enrolled in regular education classes for the 1989-90 school year. While in the regular education program, STUDENT received many disciplinary referrals and suspensions for misbehavior. His fourth grade teacher commented that he was "irresponsible about completing his work" and was "constantly trying for the classes [sic] attention." (Petitioner's Exhibit 3b.)
For the 1990-91 school year STUDENT transferred into a fifth-grade GATE program at Lomitas Elementary School in the Victor Elementary School District. There his teacher observed that he "continues to do well academically, despite his problems with following directions." (Petitioner's Exhibit 3c.) STUDENT attended Mojave Vista Elementary School during the 1991-92 school year. There, STUDENT's sixth grade teacher remarked that "[o]nce STUDENT settles down & gets to work, he will do very well."
(Petitioner's Exhibit 3d.)
During the 1992-93 school year, STUDENT's seventh-grade progress reports and report cards reflected uneven behavior and academic performance. On his first semester grade report, six of seven teachers commented that STUDENT engages in "misconduct and/or poor attitude disruptive behavior in class." Despite this, STUDENT's lowest grade was the "C-" that he earned in physical education. He earned an "A-" in Social Studies, a "C+" in English, a "B+" in Math 7, and an "A-" in Science. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3e.) STUDENT's second semester grade report has only one comment about disruptive behavior and one comment urging greater class participation and readiness. However, his grades in academic classes dropped slightly. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3e.)
STUDENT's eighth-grade progress reports cite in-class disruptions and low test scores for his increasingly poor grades. His 1993 first quarter grade report shows that he was in the "D" range in English, Social Studies, and Math 8. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3f.) By the second quarter of eighth grade STUDENT received a "D-" in Math 8, an "F" in English, and an "F-" in Social Studies.
(Petitioner's Exhibit 3f.)
On February 9, 1994, during the eighth grade STUDENT, was expelled from Victor Valley Junior High School because he accumulated twenty-two disciplinary referrals in the seventh grade and eight during the first four months of the eighth grade.
STUDENT's offenses included using profanity and committing "obscene acts."(Respondents' Exhibit 37.) His parents then referred STUDENT for a psychological assessment "to better understand STUDENT's personality and his motivation for his actions."
During the expulsion, STUDENT attended the Desert Educational Clinic, where his accumulation of units "far exceed[ed] the requirements." On July 27, 1994, the District readmitted STUDENT to its schools. (Respondents' Exhibit 36.)
STUDENT floundered academically in the tenth grade. He failed English in fall 1994 and spring 1995. (Respondents' Exhibit 11.) STUDENT's behavior suffered a similar decline. A discipline report reflects twelve separate occasions of tardiness, truancy, disruptive behavior, vandalism, and suspensions for causing physical injury to other students from January through June 1995. (Respondents' Exhibit 71.) In June 1995, the District proposed to expel STUDENT. (Respondents' Exhibit 69.)
In September 1995, an IEP team met to discuss whether STUDENT qualified for special education. The team, which included FATHER, determined that he would "attend regular class" because he "does not meet eligibility requirements for Special Education Placement." (Respondents' Exhibit 3.) The IEP team also referred STUDENT to the California Department of Education Diagnostic Center but the Center declined to assess STUDENT.
In October 1995, the District expelled STUDENT for the remainder of the 1994-95 school year and the first semester of the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT was readmitted to the District in March 1996. (Respondent's Exhibits 30, 32 and 70.)
On July 17, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team convened and concluded that he did not meet special education eligibility requirements and would therefore attend regular education classes. FATHER neither attended the meeting nor signed the IEP. (Respondents' Exhibit 1.)
STUDENT currently attends the Excelsior Charter School within the District for one hour each week. While at school, he turns in completed assignments, receives new ones, and discusses school- related problems with his teacher, Barry Nelson. STUDENT also spends one hour per week in individual instruction with Mr. Nelson.
SUMMARY OF WRITTEN ASSESSMENTS
When STUDENT was expelled, his parents requested a psychological assessment "to better understand STUDENT's personality and motivation." In March 1994, April Johnson, a credentialed school psychologist who works for the District, administered the following tests: Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised (WRAT-R), Bender Gestalt Test, the Comprehension and Picture Arrangement portions of the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition (WISC-III), the Adolescent Self-Report Projective Inventory, Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI) and the Personality Inventory for Children (PIC).
(Respondents' Exhibit 10.)
STUDENT scored within the 91st and 84th percentiles on the Comprehension and Picture Arrangement portions of the WISC-III. His scores led Ms. Johnson to observe that "STUDENT appears to have above average intellectual potential." According to the WRAT-R, STUDENT's reading recognition was at ending eighth grade level, spelling recall at beginning ninth grade level and arithmetic at ending eleventh grade level. From these scores, Ms. Johnson concluded that "STUDENT certainly has the academic ability necessary to succeed in his classes." (Respondents' Exhibit 10.)
After a lengthy discussion of STUDENT's responses to the personality assessments, Ms. Johnson concluded:
STUDENT seems to have a high energy level which is contributing to his unpredictable impulsive, non-conforming behaviors. STUDENT also seems to have an egocentric orientation towards life, a low tolerance for frustration, and difficulty forming long standing, stable relationships. He tends to externalize problems -- feeling that others are to blame for his misbehavior and misfortunes.
Ms. Johnson also noted that "STUDENT wrote his words using the style of writing commonly utilized by gangs and taggers."
(Respondents' Exhibit 10.)
In August 1995, with another expulsion pending, Diane Hannett, a District-employed credentialed school psychologist, conducted another psychological assessment. STUDENT obtained the following scores on the WISC-III: verbal 100, performance 110, and full scale 105. According to Ms. Hannett, "STUDENT's Full Scale score of 105 is an average score." (Respondents' Exhibit 9.)
STUDENT's index scores from the WISC-III of 99 for Verbal Comprehension, 114 for Perceptual Organization, and 112 for Freedom from Distractibility indicate to Ms. Hannett that he prefers non-verbal over language tasks and "is easily able to concentrate on a given task." (Respondents' Exhibit 9.)
On the WISC-III Verbal Scale Subtests, STUDENT scored as follows: Information 13, Similarities 9, Arithmetic 11, Vocabulary 8, Comprehension 9, and Digit Span 13. Regarding STUDENT's scores, Ms. Hannett remarked that "all fell within the average range and none differed significantly from the other." On the WISC Performance Scale Subtests, STUDENT obtained the following scores: Picture Comprehension 13, Coding 8, Picture Arrangement 12, Block Design 11, and Object Assembly 13.
Ms. Hannett also administered the Bender Gestalt Test, Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Adolescent Self-Report Projective Inventory (ASRPI), Normative Adaptive Behavior Checklist (NABC), Behavior Evaluation Scale-2 (BES) Home Version, COPS Interest Inventory and Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement - Revised (WJ-R). On the Woodcock-Johnson, STUDENT's standard scale scores were: 104 broad reading, 103 broad math, 92 broad written language, and 99 skills.
Summarizing the personality tests that STUDENT took, Ms.
Hannett concluded that "[e]motionally he appears to be maturing and better able to cope with stressors than previously indicated." He continues to demonstrate significant behavior problems both at home and at school."
Concluding that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services, Ms. Hannett stated:
STUDENT does not display a significant discrepancy between his cognitive ability and current academic achievement. No processing deficits were suggested by his pattern of test scores. He does not demonstrate a specific learning disability. Although STUDENT displays significant behavior problems, they do not appear to be emotionally based. He does not demonstrate a severe emotional disturbance.
In April 1996, STUDENT's parents and the District selected Dr. Linda Nelson, clinical neuropsychologist/associate professor of neurology and psychiatry from the University of California, Irvine to conduct STUDENT's next assessment. (Respondents' Exhibits 1 and 27.) Dr. Nelson administered a variety of academic and psychological tests; her conclusions were similar Ms. Johnson's and Ms. Hannett's. Dr. Nelson observed that STUDENT's full scale IQ score of 103 on the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale-Revised fell within the average range of general intellectual ability. Dr.
Nelson commented:
He is currently functioning within the average range of intellectual ability and has performed fairly consistently across and within domains. Surprisingly, STUDENT is achieving at age- and grade- matched test standards -- despite lack of involvement in ongoing, regular classes over the past two years. This means STUDENT is demonstrating grade-level achievement and is thus learning and acquiring necessary academic skills....
Results of attention tests showed attention to be intact and, at times, well-above normative standards.
In short, there was little, if any, objective support for specific cognitive defects, a learning disability, or an attentional disturbance as factors for impeding learning.
(Respondents' Exhibit 4.)
In light of these findings, Dr. Nelson attributed STUDENT's "presenting problems" to his admitted gang affiliation and drug use. Dr. Nelson noted:
STUDENT is a self-described 'gangster' [who] prefers a thrill-seeking, dangerous lifestyle [which] includes regular marijuana use, an attraction to so-called negative influences (fellow gang members), a disregard for authority figures, and a lack of concern for behavioral consequences.
Results of parent and patient interview, review of educational records, and personality test results suggest symptoms of Oppositional Defiant Disorder. Also strongly manifested are symptoms of sociopathy.
Ultimately, Dr. Nelson's diagnosis was Oppositional Defiant Disorder. To address STUDENT's Oppositional Defiant Disorder, Dr. Nelson recommended that STUDENT's parents enroll in the Victorville probation department's "tough love program" (which is designed to intervene with parents of gang members), that STUDENT participate in a drug rehabilitation program, and engage in a "home/school conference to plan for the 1996-97 school year." Dr. Nelson also encouraged STUDENT's parents to increase their "quality time" as a couple. (Respondents' Exhibit 4.) Dissatisfied with Dr. Nelson's assessment, STUDENT's parents had Dr. Douglas Harrington (FOOTNOTE 1) conduct a neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT in August 1996. In the course of the evaluation, Dr. Harrington administered the following tests: Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence - 2 (TONI-2), Gordon Diagnostic Assessment System, California Verbal Learning Test - Children's Version, Children's Category Test, Test of Memory and Learning, and the Attention Deficit Disorders Evaluation Scale (parents respondent). (Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.)
Dr. Harrington found that STUDENT's "results of current neuropsychological testing focusing on intellectual performance and attention/concentration abilities were within normal limits." For example, "on the TONI-II his standard quotient score places him at the 55th percentile on measured non-verbal intellectual performance." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.)
With regard to STUDENT's ability to attend and concentrate, Dr. Harrington observed:
he performed normally on ... the Gordon Diagnostic Assessment System, a measure of attentional vigilance and susceptibility to visual distractions, and on the Attention/Concentration Index from the TOMAL, a cognitive measure of auditory and visual-motoric sequencing.
Nevertheless, Dr. Harrington found that STUDENT's history indicates that he suffers from Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). Dr. Harrington so concludes because the "self-report behavioral inventory" that PARENTS completed shows that STUDENT's "behavioral pattern was clearly in the clinically significant range on the behaviors associated with impulsiveness, hyperactivity, and in the borderline range on behaviors associated with inattentiveness." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.)
Dr. Harrington's other diagnoses include conduct disorder and cannabis dependence. However, his report contains:
No special education diagnosis in that there is no clearly identified educationally handicapping condition (i.e. specific learning disability, other health impairment, serious emotional disturbance).
Dr. Harrington's report concludes by recommending Section 504 accommodations for STUDENT's ADHD, drug rehabilitation with individual and family counselling, and an anti-gang intervention program. (Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.)
SUMMARY OF RELEVANT WITNESS TESTIMONY
FATHER
FATHER testified that his son has been hyperactive since birth. According to FATHER, STUDENT was placed in the GATE program because he was too bright and active for regular education classes. FATHER asserted that a doctor diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD when he was enrolled in the Paramount Unified School District. The doctor prescribed medication to "calm STUDENT down," but wary of medication, the PARENTS refused to administer it. To FATHER, his son's behavior indicates that he suffers from ADHD.
FATHER stated that STUDENT's academic performance improved when he was in either the independent or home study program. In contrast to his performance in regular classes, STUDENT passed all classes when he participated in home study.
FATHER testified that he believes that STUDENT still smokes marijuana and belongs to a gang. Neither he nor STUDENT has enrolled in any of the parenting, drug abuse, or anti-gang programs that both Dr. Nelson and Dr. Harrington recommended.
Diane Hannett
Educational psychologist Diane Hannett assessed STUDENT in August 1995 and concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services because he did not meet the criteria for learning disabled, severely emotionally disturbed, or other health impaired. (FOOTNOTE 2) Specifically, Ms. Hannett testified that according to the Education Code, STUDENT was not learning disabled because she did not discover a twenty-point discrepancy between his academic potential and achievement when she compared his IQ scores from the WISC to his achievement scores from the Woodcock Johnson.
Similarly, Ms. Hannett found no evidence that STUDENT suffered from serious emotional disturbance. She observed that STUDENT was not depressed, could maintain relationships, learned at expected levels, and had no bizarre behavior or thought patterns. Ms.
Hannett also ruled out other health impairment as the cause of STUDENT's educational problems because she found no indication of a medical disorder that affected his vitality and awareness.
Ms. Hannett stated that her review of STUDENT's cumulative educational file revealed no evidence of ADHD. After reviewing Dr. Harrington's report, Ms. Hannett still maintains that STUDENT does not suffer from ADHD. Ms. Hannett opined that Dr. Harrington's test data do not indicate hyperactivity or inattention. STUDENT scored within the normal range on two of the tests that Dr.
Harrington administered to detect ADHD. According to Ms. Hannett, Dr. Harrington based his ADHD diagnosis on behavioral reports and anecdotal records rather than on tests. In Ms. Hannett's view, behaviors that Dr. Harrington construed as ADHD are, in reality, oppositional behaviors.
Ms. Hannett also concluded that STUDENT does not have ADHD because he scored 112 on the Freedom From Distractibility Subtest. She considered STUDENT's score above average, and asserted that "STUDENT has at least average ability to focus and concentrate, he's not more distractible than any other student his age."
Ms. Hannett also asserted that STUDENT's performance on certain of the WISC subtests indicates that he is able to attend and concentrate. Ms. Hannett noted that STUDENT's scores of 11 and 13 on the arithmetic and digit span verbal scale subtests suggest that he does not have a problem with distractibility.
Ms. Hannett stated that STUDENT's score of 105 on the WISC would not qualify him for gifted classes, which require a score of 130 or higher. Likewise, his scores on the verbal and performance scale subtests fell within the average range.
April Johnson
Educational psychologist April Johnson assessed STUDENT in March 1994. Based on her assessment, she did not think that STUDENT was easily distracted or that he suffered from ADHD.
However, she recommended a "quiet place for him to work" so that he would not "get into trouble" with his peers.
DISCUSSION
Notwithstanding Petitioner's assertion, under both federal and state special education law, a diagnosis of ADHD alone is insufficient to qualify a student for special education services. (34 Code of Federal Regulations [C.F.R] section 300.7; United States Department of Education Policy Letter of September 16, 1991 18 IDLER 118; Education Code section 56339 (a)). Education Code section 56339 (a) states:
A pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in subdivision (f) or (i) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations or Section 56337 and subdivision (j) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations for the federal Individuals with Disabilities Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 and following) categories of "other health impairments,"
"serious emotional disturbance," or "specific learning disabilities," is entitled to special education and related services.
According to this section, to qualify for special education and related services, a student affected by a suspected or diagnosed ADHD, must establish that he suffers from other health impairments, serious emotional disturbance, or specific learning disabilities. Taking each category singly, the Hearing Officer will determine whether STUDENT qualifies for special education under this section.
Other Health Impairments
In relevant part, section 3030 (f) of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations (C.C.R.) states that a student suffers from other health impairments if he has:(FOOTNOTE 3)
limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis, and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil's educational performance.
The record contains no evidence that STUDENT suffers any health impairments that limit his strength, vitality or alertness and adversely affect his educational performance. According to Dr. Harrington's report and the credible testimony of Ms. Hannett and Ms. Johnson, STUDENT lacks any health impairments; therefore the Hearing Officer concludes that he does not qualify for special education under 5 C.C.R. section 3030 (f).
Serious Emotional Disturbance
5 C.C.R. section 3030 (i) states that a student qualifies for special education services under the serious emotionally disturbed category if he:
exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors.
(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
(3) Inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.
(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
The record does not support a finding of eligibility for special education based on serious emotional disturbance. First, neither test data nor testimony suggests that over a long period of time and to a marked degree, STUDENT has an inability to learn that has adversely affected his educational performance. According to Dr. Nelson, STUDENT's scores on achievement tests show that his achievement "was at age- and grade-matched standards."
(Respondents' Exhibit 4.) STUDENT's 1995 scores on the Woodcock-Johnson also indicate that STUDENT is able to learn. On the broad reading, broad math, broad written language and skills portions of this test, he scored grade equivalents of 10 years 9 months, 10 years 7 months, 7 years 4 months, and 9 years 9 months.
(Respondents' Exhibit 9.) It was Ms. Hannett's uncontradicted testimony that all of these scores fell within the average range of achievement for a student at STUDENT's grade level. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that he does not demonstrate an inability to learn.
Second, Petitioner did not establish either by witness testimony or documentary evidence that over a long period of time, to a marked degree, STUDENT has been unable to build satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers. Neither STUDENT's father nor the psychologists who assessed him stated that he has ever lacked relationships with peers. When pressed, STUDENT told Dr. Nelson that he has a close friend. (Respondents' Exhibit 4.)
STUDENT also told Dr. Harrington that he "hangs around people who use [marijuana]" and reported "that he is involved with a gang." (Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.) In fact, according to Ms. Johnson, FATHER' ratings of STUDENT suggest that he "is quite socially competent." (Respondents' Exhibit 10.) Dr. Nelson's report reveals that STUDENT's parents expressed concerns about the negative influence of STUDENT's peer group, but the record contains no persuasive evidence that he is or has been unable to build satisfactory relationships with peers.
Petitioners provided little evidence regarding STUDENT's relationships with his teachers. Dr. Nelson's report states that STUDENT's ninth-grade shop teacher observed that STUDENT had "a quiet disdain for adults." (Respondents' Exhibit 4.)(FOOTNOTE 4). Notwithstanding this, there is no evidence that over a long period and to a marked degree, STUDENT had an inability to build satisfactory relationships with teachers which adversely affected his educational performance.
On the contrary, FATHER testified that each week STUDENT successfully receives an hour of individual instruction from teacher Barry Nelson. Petitioner's attorney points out that STUDENT did "exceptionally well" during his "semester of home study with 10 hours of faculty interaction." (Petitioner's closing argument.) Furthermore, STUDENT's May 20, 1994 progress report suggests that he had a satisfactory relationship with his teacher as he attended 119 and 3/4 of 120 days of school and "earned 55.7 units of credit, far exceeding the requirements." (Respondents' Exhibits 18 and 37.)
Third, Petitioner did not assert that STUDENT exhibits "inappropriate types behavior or feelings under normal circumstances ... in several situations." On this point, Ms.
Hannett credibly testified that STUDENT's emotional functioning seemed adequate and that he did not have bizarre behavior or thought patterns, and could cope with his environment. By itself, the fact that STUDENT was expelled, suspended, and referred for discipline does not satisfy the requirements of this criterion.
Fourth, Petitioner neither advanced arguments nor presented evidence to support a finding that STUDENT suffers from an ongoing pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression that harms his educational performance. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that Petitioner does not satisfy this eligibility criterion.
Fifth, Petitioner neither advanced arguments nor presented evidence to support a finding that STUDENT tends to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. In fact, Ms. Johnson's report states that STUDENT's "father does not feel that STUDENT develops somatic complaints in response to his problems. (Respondents' Exhibit 10.)
Finally, when considering whether STUDENT suffers from a serious emotional disturbance, the Hearing Officer notes that both Ms. Hannett and Petitioner's own assessor, Dr. Harrington, concluded that STUDENT "does not demonstrate a serious emotional disturbance." (Respondents' Exhibit 9; Petitioner's Exhibit 1d.) In light of the above analysis of the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not qualify for special education on the basis of serious emotional disturbance.
Specific Learning Disability
California Education Code section 56337(FOOTNOTE 3) states that to qualify for special education services on the basis of specific learning disability, a student must meet the following three requirements:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following areas: (1) Oral expression; (2) Listening comprehension; (3)
Written expression; (4) Basic reading skills;
(5) Reading comprehension; (6) Mathematics calculation; (7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
An IEP team decides whether a severe discrepancy exists. The IEP team can establish the existence of a severe discrepancy through a formula using standardized tests (5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j) (4) (A)), by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid (5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j) (4) (B)), or by the team's own determination (5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j) (4) (C)).
Petitioner did not persuasively argue that the use of standardized tests would not be a valid way to assess STUDENT's ability or achievement. Therefore, for purposes of establishing a severe discrepancy pursuant to 5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j) (4) (A), STUDENT's Woodcock-Johnson scores may be compared with his ability scores as measured by the WISC. A severe discrepancy exists when the difference between ability and achievement scores results in a 1.5 standard deviation or a 22.5 discrepancy. STUDENT obtained the following scores of intellectual ability on Ms. Hannett's 1995 administration of the WISC: verbal 100, performance 110, full scale 105. (Respondents' Exhibit 9.) On the Woodcock-Johnson, also administered in 1995, STUDENT obtained the following standard scores: broad reading 104, broad math 103, broad written language 92, and skills 99.
A severe discrepancy is not obtained by subtracting any of STUDENT's achievement scores from the highest of STUDENT's ability scores. For example, subtraction of STUDENT's standard score of 92 in broad written language (the lowest score STUDENT obtained on the Woodcock-Johnson) from his performance score of 110 (the highest measure of cognitive ability he obtained on the WISC), results in a discrepancy of 18. This discrepancy is fewer than 22.5 points, and, therefore, is not sufficient to establish a severe discrepancy.
The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT obtained the following scores when Dr. Nelson administered the WAIS in 1996: verbal 98, performance 108, and full scale 103. (Respondents' Exhibit 4.) Subtraction of his standard score of 92 in written language (his lowest score on the Woodcock-Johnson) from his performance score of 108 (his highest score on the 1996 WAIS), results in a discrepancy of 16, and still does not indicate a severe discrepancy.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has not established that he is eligible for special education services pursuant to 5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j)(4)(A).
A severe discrepancy may be established by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid. (5 C.C.R. section 3030 (j)(4)(B).) As stated above, there was no credible testimony or other evidence that standardized testing is invalid for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is not necessary to use other means to determine whether STUDENT's ability and achievement are severely discrepant.
When a discrepancy is not found as defined in subsections (A)
or (B) of section 3030 (j) (4), subsection (C) provides that an IEP team may determine the existence of a severe discrepancy between achievement and ability. The IEP team must base this determination on a number of factors, including: data from standardized assessment instruments, information from parents and child's present teacher, classroom performance, and any additional relevant information. On September 5, 1995, and July 17, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met and concluded that his educational needs could be meet through a regular education program. On both occasions, the IEP team found him ineligible for special education. The Hearing Officer must, therefore, determine whether the IEP team was correct in determining that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.
Looking at the evidence as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that the sum of evidence is not sufficient to overturn the conclusion of the IEP team and finds that Petitioner has not established that there is a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not find that STUDENT meets special education criteria as a student with a learning disability pursuant to Education Code section 56337.
As the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not qualify for special education services, she will not reach the issue of whether STUDENT should participate in a regular education home study program.
ORDER
All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondents prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).
Dated: November 13, 1996 Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. According to Dr. Harrington's curriculum vitae, he earned a doctorate in educational psychology from the University of Southern California in 1981.
2. Ms. Hannett testified that she is fluent in Spanish and offered to conduct the assessment in either English or Spanish. STUDENT elected to be assessed in English.
3. See also 34 C.F.R. section 300.7 (a) (8).
4. The teacher comments on STUDENT's seventh- and eighth-grade report cards may imply that he could not build satisfactory relationships with teachers, but Petitioner's evidence was not sufficient to support a finding of serious emotional disturbance under this subsection.
