California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 1, 1996

Student v. Mill Valley Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 880-95 · Hearing Officer F. Richard Ruderman

Mill Valley Elementary must provide an autism case manager, 66 compensatory hours, and a special day class; other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 10 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Second hearing decision involving this student; prior decision SN 761-93 (Hearing Officer Cote, August 15, 1994). No remand, vacatur or correction noted.

Summary

The parents of a seven-year-old boy with autism filed for hearing over his 1995-96 program. He attended Kumara School, a private preschool and kindergarten program, with a one-to-one aide paid for by Mill Valley Elementary School District. The District asked the Hearing Officer to decide whether its fall 1995 IEPs were appropriate. The parents raised claims about a case manager, an autism-trained teacher, the behavior plan, mainstreaming, teaching methods, transportation time, assessment timing, and compensatory education.

The Hearing Officer found that the District's early offers were not appropriate. One was a preschool special day class. The others did not yet exist. The District's October 1995 offer of Carol Fitzgerald's special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary was appropriate but came late, and the IEP still needed changes. Because so many providers served the student, case management was a necessary related service. The District must name one case manager with in-depth autism knowledge, for at least five hours a week. The teacher did not need autism training because the Spectrum consultant would support her. The behavior plan and teaching methods were appropriate, and the assessments were timely. The IEP did not say how much time he would spend with nondisabled peers, so it must include at least 105 minutes a week of structured play with them. Counting bus rides to speech therapy as instruction cost him three hours a week, so the Hearing Officer awarded 66 compensatory hours. The parents' other compensatory claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated case management as a related service when a student's many providers needed coordination. It also shows SEHO weighing a late written placement offer for prospective relief, distinguishing Union School District v. Smith. Finally, it treated bus time to outside therapy as lost instructional time.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue Original 2. Is the District required to provide an aide to accompany Student to and from speech therapy due to his unique needs?

    Dismissed after the parties stipulated that Student needs an aide to accompany him to and from speech therapy.

  2. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District offer Student an appropriate IEP for the 1995-96 school year?

    The District's August-September offers (preschool special day class, a not-yet-hired autism teacher, Star Academy with no openings) were not appropriate; its October offer of Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class was appropriate but untimely, and parts of the IEP needed changes, so no appropriate IEP was offered, though the special day class was ordered prospectively.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1a. Should Student's IEP include a designated case manager to oversee implementation of his IEP? If so, what should that person's qualifications, role and authority be?

    Case management is a necessary related service for Student; the IEP must name one case manager with in-depth autism knowledge, providing at least five hours per week of consultation and guidance to providers and parents and overseeing the transition plan.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Does Student need a teacher who is specifically trained in autism?

    With support from the nonpublic agency coordinator and a one-to-one aide, a teacher holding a communicatively handicapped credential without in-depth autism training can appropriately teach Student.

  5. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1c. Does Student's IEP include an appropriate behavior management plan?

    The behavior intervention plan developed by the Spectrum coordinator met Title 5, section 3052 requirements and was appropriate.

  6. Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1d. Does Student's IEP include appropriate mainstreaming opportunities?

    The IEP failed to state the extent of regular education participation or describe integration activities; it must include at least 105 minutes per week of structured play with nondisabled peers (prevailing-party section says neither party prevailed).

  7. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1e. Does Student's IEP include appropriate teaching strategies?

    Methodology is generally within staff discretion; the program included substantial direct instruction and appropriate goals, and small-group structure is for the teacher and coordinator to decide.

  8. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1f. Should Student's six-hour instructional day include transportation time to and from speech therapy?

    Counting about one hour of bus time to speech therapy as instruction was inappropriate; the bus is not an appropriate teaching setting for Student, and transportation must be excluded from the six-hour day.

  9. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 2. Did the District conduct timely assessment of Student's special education needs?

    The functional behavior assessment complied with the settlement agreement, and any delay caused no loss of educational opportunity; the occupational therapy and adapted physical education assessments were completed within the 50-day timeline.

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. If the District denied Student appropriate services in the 1995-96 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education from the District?

    Student was awarded 66 hours for instructional time lost to bus rides (3 hours/week for 22 weeks); the requests for the 1993-94 and 1994-95 years, the Kumara placement, and delayed occupational therapy were denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. Commencing immediately, the District shall designate one case manager with specialized in-depth knowledge of autism to oversee IEP implementation, consult with and guide service providers and parents, and develop and oversee a transition plan from Kumara School to Edna Maguire Elementary School; minimum five hours per week, with specific time set by the IEP team.
  • Order to provide or change services. IEP shall include a minimum of 105 minutes per week of mainstreaming in a structured play group with nondisabled peers, and shall describe activities to integrate Student into the regular school program as part of the transition.
  • Order to provide or change services. Commencing immediately, transportation time to and from speech therapy shall be excluded from the instructional day; the District shall immediately modify the schedule to provide a six-hour instructional day.
  • Compensatory education. 66 hours of compensatory education; allocation to be determined by the IEP team.
  • Placement ordered. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of the decision, Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School shall be Student's placement for the rest of 1995-96; extended school year placement to be equivalent.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of receipt of the decision, convene an IEP team meeting and modify the IEP in accordance with the decision.
  • Order remains in effect for the duration of the 1995-96 school year, including extended school year.

Total: 66 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Lachman v. Illinois State Bd. of Educ.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Hall v. Vance County Bd. of Educ.; Burke County Bd. of Educ. v. Denton; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Murphy v. Timberland Regional School Dist.; Burr v. Ambach; Miener v. Missouri; Robert D. v. Andrews

People named in the decision

  • Barbara Young, District Director of Special Education, Mill Valley Elementary School District
  • Arline Zerkel, Ed.D., Special Education Director; District representative, Marin County Office of Education
  • Kenneth Kammuller, Program Manager, present for District, Not stated
  • Sandra Woliver, Attorney for District
  • Lawrence Siegel, Attorney for Student
  • Stephen Anderson, Ph.D., Witness for Student (testified by telephone from Massachusetts)
  • Susan Campbell, Witness for Student (testified by telephone from Massachusetts)
  • Jude Levine, Special day class teacher, Mill Valley Elementary School District
  • Windy Linden, Kindergarten teacher, Mill Valley Elementary School District
  • Tiphanie Kaufman, Private speech-language therapist (District-funded)
  • Gaynelle Woods, Private occupational therapist
  • Carl Schrader, Ph.D., Psychologist; aide supervisor; conducted functional behavior assessment, Behavioral Counseling and Research Center (BCRC)
  • Behavioral Counseling and Research Center (BCRC), Nonpublic agency providing one-to-one aide
  • Wende Kumara, Witness; private school, Kumara School
  • Kumara School, Private school (interim placement)
  • Star Academy, State-certified nonpublic school (offered placement)
  • May Center for Early Childhood Education, Prior nonpublic preschool in Massachusetts
  • Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer in prior case SN 761-93, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Carol Fitzgerald, Special day class teacher (communicatively handicapped credential), Edna Maguire Elementary School
  • Lisa Fredericks, Special day class teacher, Gallinas Elementary School
  • Heidi Woods, Special day class teacher, Gallinas Elementary School
  • Miriam Gardner, Preschool special day class teacher, Tamalpais Valley Elementary School
  • Christine Stanton, Speech-language pathologist assessor, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute
  • B. J. Freeman, Ph.D., Psychologist assessor; witness, UCLA
  • Rebecca Cox, Ph.D., Psychoeducational assessor, Coordinator Early Childhood Program, UCLA
  • Carrie Risi, Occupational therapist assessor, UCLA
  • Cynthia Ferber, Recreation therapist assessor, UCLA
  • Patricia (Pat) Wagner, ICSS coordinator; behavior intervention plan author, Spectrum In Class Support System (ICSS)
  • Spectrum In Class Support System (ICSS), State-certified nonpublic agency providing aide and coordinator
  • Nancy Henderson, Adapted physical education specialist, Mill Valley Elementary School District
  • Linda Lotspetch, Requested assessor, Stanford University
  • Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., Psychologist (prior evaluation), University of California San Francisco

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before F. Richard Ruderman, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, in Mill Valley, California, on October 17, 24, 25 and 30, November 6, 7, 9 and 27, and December 1, 1995.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his father, PARENT, and his mother, PARENT. On November 6 and December 1, 1995, Lawrence Siegel, attorney, was also present on STUDENT's behalf.

Respondent Mill Valley Elementary School District (hereafter "District") was represented by Arline Zerkel, Ed.D., Special Education Director, Marin County Office of Education. Also present on the District's behalf was Barbara Young, District Director of Special Education. On October 17, 1995, Kenneth Kammuller, Program Manager, was present on the District's behalf. On November 6 and December 1, 1995, Sandra Woliver, attorney, was present on the District's behalf.

Evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. These briefs were received on January 29, 1996, and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Relevant Prehearing Correspondence

At the conclusion of a mediation conference on October 6, 1995, Petitioner identified the issues for hearing as follows:

1(a) Does STUDENT's complicated individualized educational plan and disability necessitate that an administrator or case manager knowledgeable in autism oversee the IEP's implementation?

1(b) If the answer to 1(a) above is yes, what should that person's qualifications, role and authority be?

2. Is the District required to provide an aide to accompany STUDENT to and from speech therapy due to his unique needs?

3. The parties have agreed that STUDENT's instructional day should be six hours. Should these six hours be exclusive of transportation time?

4. Is the District required to provide compensatory education for the instruction and services that the District . . . thus far has failed to provide during the 1995-96 school year?

In a letter dated October 6, 1995, the District identified the issue for hearing as follows:

Are the IEPs developed on August 23, 29, September 5 and 26, 1995, appropriate to meet the needs of STUDENT?

In a letter dated October 6, 1995, Petitioner objected to the District's issue for hearing and asked that it be "handled separately." Petitioner asserted that this was a new issue and asked for additional time to consult with an attorney regarding the issue. Petitioner's letter stated in relevant part:

If the district is concerned about specific and/or necessary issues not yet addressed in STUDENT's IEP meetings, we are committed to fully and cooperatively participating in additional IEP meetings. In fact, another IEP meeting is scheduled for October 23.

In a letter dated October 10, 1995, the District responded to Petitioner's objections to the District's issue. The District asserted that in four recent IEP team meetings STUDENT's parents were not in "total agreement" with any of the IEPs. The District contended that "the four issues that the parents have a requested a Hearing Officer's decision on are a part of the IEPs developed at those meetings." The District asked to postpone the hearing pending completion of the IEP team meeting on October 23, 1995.

District's Motions Regarding Issues and Continuance

On October 17, 1995 (the first day of hearing), prior to any witness testimony, the District contended that Petitioner's second issue was moot because the parties were in agreement on that issue. In addition, the District made a motion to add its issue as an issue for hearing.(Footnote 1) The District also made a motion to continue the hearing pending completion of the IEP team meeting scheduled on October 23. Petitioner objected to the District's motions.

Stipulation

During the discussion regarding the issues for hearing, the parties stipulated that STUDENT needs an aide to accompany him to and from speech therapy. Based on the parties' stipulation, Petitioner's second issue was dismissed.

The District's Proposed Issue for Hearing

During the discussion regarding the issues for hearing, STUDENT's parents contended that they disagreed with many elements of the District's proposed IEP. In all other respects, the parties essentially reiterated the positions that they argued in their correspondence.

Following the discussion regarding the issues, the Hearing Officer ruled that the appropriateness of the District's proposed IEP was a proper issue for hearing. The Hearing Officer concluded that the District's proposed IEP issue was at the heart of the dispute between the parties. Petitioner's issues essentially were sub-issues of the District's proposed issue. Indeed, in order for Petitioner to prevail on one or more of his issues, it would be necessary for the Hearing Officer to conclude that the District did not in fact offer an appropriate IEP for STUDENT. Moreover, the parties had been involved in numerous IEP team meetings and had another IEP team meeting scheduled for the following week. Both parties were asserting that STUDENT's placement at the time was inappropriate.

Continuance

Following the Hearing Officer's ruling, STUDENT's parents reiterated their objection to continuing the hearing pending the scheduled IEP team meeting. STUDENT's parents also asserted that it was necessary to hear the testimony of their first two witnesses (Stephen Anderson, Ph.D., and Susan Campbell) on October 17 because they were testifying by telephone from Massachusetts and, if the hearing was continued, it would be extremely difficult to reschedule their testimony. The District had no objection to having the testimony of Dr. Anderson and Ms. Campbell occur on October 17.

Following the testimony of Dr. Anderson and Ms. Campbell, the Hearing Officer granted the District's motion for a continuance. The Hearing Officer concluded that good cause existed for the continuance because an IEP team meeting was scheduled on October 23, 1995, which both parties wanted to attend and there existed a reasonable possibility that the parties would resolve their dispute in the IEP team meeting. The Hearing Officer urged the parties to continue in mediation and asked that they use October 18 (a date already scheduled as the second day of hearing) as an additional date to meet. The Hearing Officer continued the hearing until October 24 and 25, 1995.

Petitioner's Additional Issues

On October 18 and 23, 1995, the parties met in an IEP team meeting, but were unable to resolve their dispute. When the hearing reconvened on October 24, STUDENT's parents made a motion to add the following issues as issues for hearing:

(a) Did the District conduct timely assessments of STUDENT's special education needs?

(b) Does STUDENT need a teacher specifically trained in autism?

(c) Did the District reasonably exclude from STUDENT's proposed IEP of 10/18 and 10/23/95 expert recommendations for:

(1) teaching social skills, classroom skills, and occupational therapy skills in progressively larger groups, starting with one to five typically developing peers.

(2) a detailed behavioral management plan and/or a consistent behavioral intervention program which stresses frequent, contingent reinforcement of appropriate behaviors.

(3) a classroom setting with typically developing children.

(4) direct teaching of specific skills rather than incidental learning.

The District had no objection to adding Petitioner's additional issues as issues for hearing.

The Hearing Officer concluded that issue (a) constituted a new issue for hearing. Issues (b) and (c) were, in effect, sub-issues of the larger question of whether or not the District offered an appropriate IEP for STUDENT.

ISSUES

(1) Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate individualized education program (IEP) for the 1995-96 school year?

(a) Should STUDENT's IEP include a designated case manager to oversee implementation of his IEP?

If STUDENT's IEP needs to include a case manager, what should that person's qualifications, role and authority be?

(b) Does STUDENT need a teacher who is specifically trained in autism?

(c) Does STUDENT's IEP include an appropriate behavior management plan?

(d) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate mainstreaming opportunities?

(e) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate teaching strategies?

(f) Should STUDENT's six-hour instructional day include transportation time to and from speech therapy?

(2) Did the District conduct timely assessment of STUDENT's special education needs?

(3) If the District denied STUDENT appropriate services in the 1995-96 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education from the District?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is seven years old and is eligible for special education services because he is autistic.

This is the second special education hearing decision involving STUDENT. The first case (Case Number SN 761-93) was heard on June 28 and 29, 1994, by Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote.(Footnote 2) On August 15, 1994, Hearing Officer Cote rendered a written decision in Case Number SN 761-93. Each party submitted Hearing Officer Cote's decision as an exhibit. (Petitioner's Exhibit S; Respondent's Exhibit 14) Neither party disputed the background facts set forth in Hearing Officer Cote's decision. Many of those facts are relevant to this decision and are summarized below.

In August 1993, STUDENT's family moved from Massachusetts to Mill Valley, California. Prior to his family's move to California, STUDENT attended a preschool special education program at the May Center for Early Childhood Education, a nonpublic school in Massachusetts. (Petitioner's Exhibit S; Respondent's Exhibit 14)

On September 8, 1993, STUDENT enrolled in the Respondent District and attended a special day class taught by Jude Levine as an interim placement. There were nine students in the special day class and Ms. Levine was assisted by two instructional assistants. On September 27, 1993, STUDENT's parents withdrew him from the special day class. They asked the District to have STUDENT fully included in a regular kindergarten class. (Petitioner's Exhibit S; Respondent's Exhibit 14)

In October 1993, Tiphanie Kaufman, a private speech therapist, began providing speech and language therapy services for STUDENT. Since December 1993, Ms. Kaufman has provided such services in three sessions per week. Ms. Kaufman's office is in San Francisco. Initially, Ms. Kaufman's services were paid for by STUDENT's parents. Since the 1994-95 school year, the District has paid for her services, including the transportation expenses.

On October 6, 1993, the IEP team agreed to an interim kindergarten placement and, on October 8, 1993, STUDENT entered Windy Linden's kindergarten class. The District provided the services of a full-time one-to-one aide in the classroom. On November 15, 1993, an IEP team developed goals and objectives for STUDENT. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT would continue in the kindergarten class and that he would receive occupational therapy and speech and language services. Ms. PARENT consented to the implementation of the IEP; however, on November 18, 1993, STUDENT's parents sent a letter to the District withdrawing their consent to the "assessment, specific instruction/services, instructional setting." (Petitioner's Exhibit S; Respondent's Exhibit 14)

In IEP team meetings on December 6 and 13, 1993, the District made the following placement offers for STUDENT: Ms. Linden's kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide; a special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School with a one-to-one aide and mainstreaming in a kindergarten class; a county preschool program; or Ms. Levine's special day class. STUDENT's parents opposed all of the District's placement options. (Id.) The parties did agree that STUDENT needed to receive occupational therapy services twice per week. (Respondent's Exhibit 7) Gaynelle Woods, private occupational therapist provided occupational therapy services to STUDENT from January through September 1994. (Respondent's Exhibit 21)

On December 14, 1993, STUDENT's parents submitted a request for a special education hearing, which was assigned Case Number SN 761-93. Immediately following the winter break in early January 1994, STUDENT's parents withdrew him from school. He returned to school for one week in February 1994 and was withdrawn again. (Id.)

From January through June 1994, the parties met in mediation conferences in an effort to resolve their dispute. On March 9, 1994, an IEP team met and developed new goals and objectives for STUDENT. The District made the same placement proposals as before and also offered to fund STUDENT's placement at Star Academy, a local State-certified nonpublic school. STUDENT's parents agreed to the Star Academy placement, but there were no openings at the school. (Id.)

In a mediation conference on March 23, 1994, the parties reached an interim agreement whereby STUDENT was to be placed back in Ms. Linden's kindergarten class. As part of the interim agreement, the District agreed to contract with Behavioral Counseling and Research Center (BCRC) to provide a full-time one-to-one aide for STUDENT; the aide was to be supervised by a credentialed special education teacher. In addition, the District agreed to have BCRC, in consultation with the District, "provide, direct and manage the 1:1 aide and the aide's clinical supervisor." Carl Schrader, Ph.D., a psychologist with BCRC, also supervised the one-to-one aide. On March 28, 1994, STUDENT's parents returned him to school. (Id; Respondent's Exhibit 12). Following STUDENT's return to school, almost all of his services were provided on a pull-out basis with the one-to-one aide. He had very limited contact with the other students. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT and Carl Schrader)

STUDENT's parents did not withdraw their request for hearing. Subsequent mediation efforts did not resolve the dispute and Case Number SN 761-93 proceeded to hearing.

The issues in Case Number SN 761-93 were as follows:

(1) To receive a free appropriate public education, does STUDENT require the following: (a) a total of 228 school days per year?

(b) six hours of instruction per school day?

(c) 2.5 hours per day of instruction in self-help skills?

(d) speech and language therapy when school is not in session? (e) twice weekly cognitive therapy?

(f) participation in an integrated play therapy group in a private neighborhood preschool program to develop socialization skills?

(2) Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of twice weekly cognitive therapy . . . ?

(3) Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of speech and language therapy . . . ?

On August 15, 1994, Hearing Officer Cote issued her decision and order. Hearing Officer Cote ordered the District to provide the following services for STUDENT in the 1994-95 school year:

(1) a six-hour per day instructional program;

(2) three sessions per week of speech and language therapy on a year-round basis;

(3) an integrated play therapy group with kindergarten-age students; and (4) assignments and activities for STUDENT's parents to implement whenever he has a hiatus from school that is two weeks or longer.

Hearing Officer Cote ordered the District to reimburse STUDENT's parents for certain speech and language therapy services. Hearing Officer Cote denied STUDENT's parents remaining requests for relief. (Petitioner's Exhibit S; Respondent's Exhibit 14)

On August 29, 1994, the District convened an IEP team meeting to determine STUDENT's placement for the 1994-95 school year. STUDENT's parents wanted him placed at Kumara School, a nonpublic school which serves pre-school and kindergarten-age children. District staff recommended a "chronologically age-appropriate class" at Tamalpais Valley Elementary School or the special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School taught by Carol Fitzgerald. STUDENT's parents signed the IEP indicating their disagreement with the District's proposed placement. (Respondent's Exhibit 15)

In early September 1994, STUDENT started school at Tamalpais Valley Elementary School. On September 28, 1994, STUDENT's parents removed him from school. (Testimony of Barbara Young) In October 1994, they placed him at Kumara School. (Testimony of Wende Kumara)

On October 5, 1994, the parties met and developed goals and objectives for STUDENT. On October 27, 1994, the parties signed a "settlement and release agreement." Lawrence Siegel (an attorney representing STUDENT's parents) and Sandra Woliver (an attorney representing the District) wrote the settlement agreement. The settlement agreement incorporated by reference the goals and objectives written on October 5, 1994. As part of the settlement agreement, the District agreed to provide the following related services for STUDENT in the 1994-95 school year:

œ a one-to-one BCRC aide for six hours per day;

œ speech therapy three times per week, including transportation costs;

œ play therapy; and

œ occupational therapy consultation one time per month, or more as agreed to by the parties.

In addition, the District agreed to conduct a functional behavioral assessment of STUDENT. The District agreed to schedule an IEP team meeting in April 1995 to review STUDENT's placement for the 1995-96 school year. The parties agreed that Kumara School would not constitute a "stay-put" placement in the event they were unable to reach agreement regarding STUDENT's placement for the 1995-96 school year. (Petitioner's Exhibit BB; Respondent's Exhibit 16)

For the remainder of the 1994-95 school year, including the extended school year, STUDENT attended Kumara School. While attending Kumara School, STUDENT had a one-to-one aide from BCRC. Carl Schrader, Ph.D., a psychologist at BCRC, supervised the aide in consultation with District staff. In addition, STUDENT received three sessions per week of speech therapy services from Ms. Kaufman. The District paid for the speech therapy and transported STUDENT to and from Ms. Kaufman's office in San Francisco. During the 1994-95 school year, Gaynelle Woods, occupational therapist, provided consultation services to staff working with STUDENT. Kumara School serves children in preschool through kindergarten. STUDENT was older than the rest of the children and did not have a specific classroom placement. He participated in a limited amount of group activities with the other children, but primarily received his instruction from a one-to-one aide. (Testimony of Wende Kumara)

On March 30, 1995, the District convened an IEP team meeting. The IEP team reviewed progress reports prepared by Ms. Kaufman, Dr. Schrader, and Ms. Woods. STUDENT's parents presented a list of their concerns regarding his program. They also asked the District to provide for an assessment of STUDENT from Dr. Linda Lotspetch, at Stanford University. The District offered to place STUDENT at the Star Academy "should it become available." Ms. PARENT signed the IEP indicating that she had attended the meeting. (Respondent's Exhibit 20)

In the spring of 1995, STUDENT's parents filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (Compliance Report #S-333-94/95) alleging that the District failed to provide a free and appropriate public education to STUDENT.

On May 11, 1995, the parties met again in an IEP team meeting. The team agreed to have an adapted physical education specialist assess STUDENT. In addition, the team agreed to have the District conduct a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. (Respondent's Exhibit 22)

On June 26, 1995, Dr. Schrader completed a functional analysis report regarding STUDENT. (Respondent's Exhibit 23) On July 5, 1995, the District convened an IEP team meeting. The parties agreed to have STUDENT assessed at the University of California Los Angeles (UCLA) to determine his needs in the following areas: educational, psychological, speech and language, occupational therapy, and recreational. Dr. Schrader presented his functional analysis report to the IEP team. For the 1995-96 school year, the District offered to place STUDENT at "Stars Academy, the Mill Valley special day class, or Jude Levine's special day class." (Respondent's Exhibit 24)

During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT's parents were dissatisfied with the services provided by BCRC. At an IEP team meeting on July 26, 1995, the District agreed to contact a different nonpublic agency for STUDENT's one-to-one aide. (Respondent's Exhibit 25)

By letter dated August 2, 1995, Gaynelle Woods notified the District that she would no longer be available to provide occupational therapy services for STUDENT following the completion of the 1994-95 school year. Ms. Woods' letter stated in relevant part:

During the one and a half year course of providing direct and monitor services for STUDENT, I met obstacles at every turn by his mother, Ms. PARENT, in providing what I viewed as appropriate treatment interventions. . . .

In September of 1994 Ms. PARENT made a decision to discontinue occupational therapy services, giving me little more than an hour's notice before his scheduled therapy session. The parents refused occupational therapy reassessment in September and again in March of 1995. . . .

(Respondent's Exhibit 37)

In a report dated August 7, 1995, the California Department of Education concluded that the District had met its obligation to provide an appropriate education for STUDENT in the 1994-95 school year. (Respondent's Exhibit 29)

On August 7 and 8, 1995, the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute conducted the following assessments of STUDENT: speech and language, psychological, psychoeducational, occupational therapy, and recreational therapy.

Christine Stanton, speech and language pathologist, assessed STUDENT's speech and language skills. Ms. Stanton's assessment report concluded that STUDENT had a "severe communication disorder characterized by delays in receptive and expressive language functioning, poor social communication skills, deficits in auditory language processing, and impaired speech." Ms. Stanton recommended that STUDENT be placed in a "small structured preschool setting." In addition, Ms. Stanton recommended that STUDENT continue to receive individual speech and language therapy three times per week for one hour sessions. Ms. Stanton's report stated in relevant part:

A communicatively handicapped classroom taught by a professional specializing in autism would be ideal in providing STUDENT with the social and language stimulation that he needs.

Peers in the classroom should match or exceed STUDENT's developmental language age and social skills functioning to provide appropriate modelling in the classroom and on the playground.

(Respondent's Exhibit 26)

In an addendum to her report, dated August 22, 1995, Ms. Stanton stated in relevant part:

A speech pathologist who specializes in the evaluation and treatment of autistic children should be assigned as a case coordinator to oversee STUDENT's treatment program in all disciplines (classroom, speech therapy, occupational therapy, after-school programs) to ensure consistency and carry-over across all disciplines and to update and revise STUDENT's treatment goals as needed.

(Id.)

B. J. Freeman, Ph.D., professor of medical psychology at UCLA, conducted the psychological assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Freeman's report stated that STUDENT "obtained a mental age of 50 months" on the Merrill Palmer Preschool Performance Test. On the Stanford Binet Intelligence Scale, STUDENT obtained scores which ranged from 2 years 3 months to 4 years 6 months. Dr. Freeman's report stated in relevant part:

STUDENT's current school program appears to be inappropriate for him. He needs to be enrolled in a highly structured school setting which stresses development of appropriate language, social and self-help skills. He needs to be taught by someone who is specifically trained in autism. In addition, a detailed behavioral management plan needs to be written for him.

(Respondent's Exhibit 27)

Rebecca Cox, Ph.D., Coordinator Early Childhood Program, conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT at UCLA. In her report, Dr. Cox also concluded that STUDENT's overall functioning was at approximately the fifty-month level. Dr. Cox's report stated in relevant part:

STUDENT can best be taught in a small structured classroom (i.e., 10-12 children with a teacher and at least one aide). A functional skills curriculum (rather than an academic curriculum) would be most beneficial for STUDENT at this time. This classroom should provide direct teaching of specific skills rather than a less structured approach which relies on incidental learning. STUDENT will acquire independent learning skills most effectively if the role of the aides in the classroom is to provide assistance for STUDENT within the group rather than removing him from the group for one to one instruction.

(Respondent's Exhibit 28)

Carrie Risi, occupational therapist, conducted an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Risi's report concluded that STUDENT had significantly delayed fine and gross motor skills. Ms. Risi recommended that STUDENT receive occupational therapy services a minimum of two-to-three times per week. (Respondent's Exhibit 30) Cynthia Ferber, recreation therapist, also assessed STUDENT. Ms. Ferber's report recommended that STUDENT receive adapted physical education. (Respondent's Exhibit 31)

On August 23 and 29, 1995, an IEP team met to review the assessment reports from UCLA. Based on the assessment reports, the District offered the following services for STUDENT: individual speech and language therapy three times per week; speech and language consultation services with staff two hours per month; a behavior intervention program; adapted physical education; and occupational therapy services a minimum of two times per week. In addition, the District recommended "a national search for a credentialed teacher trained in autism." On an interim basis, the District agreed to "continue to support placement at Kumara with 1-1 support." The District contracted with Spectrum In Class Support System (ICSS), a State-certified nonpublic agency, to provide STUDENT's one-to-one aide. The District recommended that STUDENT be slowly transitioned from Kumara into a special day class for "preschool communicatively handicapped" students at Tamalpais Valley School. (Respondent's Exhibit 32)

In a two-page memorandum dated August 29, 1995 (and faxed to the District on that date), STUDENT's parents reported their understanding of the IEP team meetings on August 23 and 29, 1995. The memorandum contains many comments that are identical to the IEP notes. In addition, the memorandum states in relevant part:

District will provide a social skills group, as recommended, 2-3 times per week for 45 minute sessions. As recommended, this will employ a structured, therapeutic method. This, and PE and OT groups recommended, will begin with one or two developmental peers and add more peers as STUDENT's skills develop. . . .

The length of STUDENT's school day will remain 6 hours. Therapy (i.e. SPEECH), but not transportation, will be included in the 6 hours. . . .

The District will provide transportation to and from SPEECH and STUDENT will be accompanied by an aide or teacher.

(Petitioner's Exhibit KK, at pp. 43-44)

In approximately late August 1995, Spectrum hired an aide to work with STUDENT. In addition, Patricia Wagner, a consultant with Spectrum, began preparing a behavior intervention program for STUDENT.

On September 5, 1995, an IEP team met and developed goals and objectives for STUDENT. On the IEP form, it was noted that STUDENT's adapted physical education was scheduled to begin on September 11. In addition, the IEP noted that "occupational therapy services will begin as soon as an O.T. can be identified." The IEP also stated in relevant part:

Length of instructional school day is 6 hours. If STUDENT is transported within the school hours to a related service, transportation will be considered part of his school day while accompanied by his aide/teacher.

(Respondent's Exhibit 33)

In a three-page undated memorandum, STUDENT's parents reported their understanding of the IEP team meeting on September 5, 1995. One of the points noted in the memorandum was that there was disagreement regarding whether or not transportation should be included as part of STUDENT's school day. (Petitioner's Exhibit KK, at pp. 32-34)

On September 8, 1995, the Hearing Office received a request for hearing from STUDENT's parents.

In the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT has continued to attend Kumara School. He has not been assigned to a specific classroom and has received most of his instruction from his one-to-one aide. Despite the parties' disagreement regarding STUDENT's IEP, the District has paid for the placement and provided him with a one-to-one aide from I.C.S.S. In addition, the District continued to pay for Ms. Kaufman's speech and language therapy services three times per week and transported STUDENT to and from speech therapy. Since early September, STUDENT has received adapted physical education instruction from Nancy Henderson.

In September, Pat Wagner completed a draft of a behavior intervention plan for STUDENT. On September 26, 1995, an IEP team reviewed Ms. Wagner's proposed plan and discussed placement and services for STUDENT. The District offered to have the one-to-one aide implement STUDENT's language development and independent living goals while he was being transported to and from speech therapy. The District recommended that STUDENT be placed in a preschool special day class at Tamalpais Valley Elementary School. In addition, the IEP stated, "STUDENT will be given regularly scheduled opportunities to integrate with nonhandicapped peers." In all other respects, the District's proposed program was identical to its proposal at the previous IEP. STUDENT's parents did not agree with the IEP. The IEP team scheduled another meeting for October 23, 1995. (Respondent's Exhibit 35)

On October 17, 1995, the case convened for hearing. The hearing was continued until October 24, 1995. On October 18 and 23, 1995, the IEP team met but the parties did not reach agreement regarding STUDENT's placement and services. In general, the District recommended the same related services as it recommended at prior meetings. The District proposed that Barbara Young, the special day class teacher, and the ICSS coordinator be responsible for coordination and oversight of STUDENT's IEP. The District modified its placement recommendation from prior meetings and proposed four possible special day classes as placement options in the following order of preference:

1. a special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School taught by Carol Fitzgerald;

2. a special day class at Gallinas Elementary School taught by Lisa Fredericks;

3. a special day class at Gallinas Elementary School taught by Heidi Woods; or

4. a preschool special day class at Tamalpais Valley Elementary School taught by Miriam Gardner.

(Respondent's Exhibit 42; Petitioner's Exhibit KK)

Following the IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, 1995, in which the parties could not agree on STUDENT's IEP, the case reconvened for hearing on October 24, 1995.

DISCUSSION

(1) Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate individualized education program (IEP) for the 1995-96 school year?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education. (20 U.S.C. ˜ 1400(c); Education Code, ˜ 56000.) A "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that are designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled student in a program that provides educational benefit to the student. Such services must be available to the student at no charge to the parent, must meet state educational standards, and must conform to the student's IEP. (20 U.S.C. ˜ 1401(a)(16-18); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Education Code ˜ 56031.)

In addition, school districts are required to provide special education services in the least restrictive environment. School districts must ensure that, to the maximum extent appropriate, disabled students are educated with nondisabled students and that removal of the student from the regular education environment occurs only when the student's disability is so severe that such a placement is warranted. (20 U.S.C. ˜ 1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. ˜˜ 300.550(b), 300.552(a)(3); Education Code, ˜ 56031.)

STUDENT's Placement Needs

In this case, it is important to start with the areas of STUDENT's program in which the parties agree. STUDENT's need for the following services were not disputed: a one-to-one aide who is trained to work with autistic children; three hours per week of individual speech therapy; two sessions per week of occupational therapy; and one session per week of adapted physical education.

With regard to STUDENT's specific skills, there were areas of agreement and disagreement. It was undisputed that STUDENT generally exhibits good behavior and is cooperative. It was also undisputed that his communication and social skills are very poor. STUDENT was described by witnesses as a "relatively high-functioning" autistic child. He reads at the first-to-second grade level. His math skills are at the kindergarten level. The parties disagreed regarding STUDENT's cognitive ability. Ms. Wagner and Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT is moderately mentally retarded. STUDENT's parents, however, disagreed with this assessment of STUDENT's cognitive ability. They contend that standardized tests are a poor measure of STUDENT's ability and that he is not mentally retarded.

The parties primarily disputed the elements of STUDENT's placement and the extent to which he should be mainstreamed with nondisabled "peers." STUDENT's parents contend that he needs to be in a special day class with a teacher trained to teach autistic children. Alternatively, they assert that STUDENT should be "mainstreamed" in a regular education kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide or remain at Kumara School. STUDENT's parents assert that he functions at the level of a kindergarten student and needs to be placed with his developmental peers. Furthermore, STUDENT's parents contend that he needs to have one case manager who is knowledgeable in autism oversee implementation of his IEP because of the complexity of the IEP. STUDENT's parents contend that the placements proposed by the District are inappropriate for STUDENT.

The District contends that STUDENT needs to be placed in a special day class with a one-to-one aide. The District asserts that STUDENT's aide should be gradually "faded" so that he will function more independently. The District asserts that STUDENT's placement needs to be in a small class where he can receive extensive individual and small group instruction.

The evidence overwhelmingly established that STUDENT needs a highly-structured learning environment with extensive opportunities for individual and small group instruction. Without a highly-structured learning environment, STUDENT is more likely to engage in self-stimulating or other inappropriate behaviors. STUDENT needs extensive individual and small group instruction because his communication and social skills are his greatest areas of weakness. These findings are supported by the testimony of his parents, Ms. Wagner, Dr. Campbell, Dr. Anderson, Dr. Schrader, Dr. Freeman, Ms. Kaufman, and the assessment reports from UCLA.

Because STUDENT needs a highly-structured learning environment, a small class size with a low teacher-to-student ratio is a critical component of his program. Ms. Wagner, the I.C.S.S. coordinator, persuasively testified that STUDENT needs to be placed in a special day class with students his own age and who are at or above his ability level. Ms. Wagner stated that a special day class is appropriate for STUDENT because the class structure, with a small class size and low student-to-teacher ratio, is designed to meet STUDENT's need for individual and small group instruction. In addition, Ms. Wagner testified that STUDENT needs to be placed with students his own age to serve as appropriate peer role models. Ms. Wagner stated that a regular education kindergarten class would be inappropriate for STUDENT because of the large number of students that are typically in such a class and because most of the activities are less structured than a special day class. Ms. Wagner was particularly convincing in this regard because she has extensive knowledge about and experience in working with autistic children and has spent considerable time working directly with STUDENT and his other service providers. Ms. Wagner's special day class recommendation was supported by the testimony of Dr. Freeman and by all of the assessment reports from UCLA. Indeed, her recommendation for a special day class placement was not rebutted by any of the professionals who assessed or worked directly with STUDENT. Moreover, STUDENT's parents would support such a placement provided the teacher has extensive training and experience in autism.

Although Dr. Schrader did not oppose a special day class placement, he recommended that STUDENT be placed in a regular class with chronological peers. Dr. Schrader stated that the parties should give a regular class placement with chronological peers "another try." In this regard, Dr. Schrader's testimony was not convincing. For one thing, both parties opposed placing STUDENT in a regular class with chronological peers. Moreover, STUDENT's past experience in regular education classes was unsuccessful. During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT was placed in a regular education kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide. In that placement, STUDENT received virtually all of his instruction from the one-to-one aide and had little interaction with other students.

STUDENT's parents oppose any special day class placement that is not taught by a teacher with extensive training and experience in autism. If such a program is not provided for STUDENT, they want him "mainstreamed" in a regular education kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide or to remain at Kumara School. They argue that nondisabled kindergarten students are appropriate developmental peer role models for STUDENT.

There was no persuasive evidence that a regular education kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide would be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. As discussed above, in a regular education environment STUDENT tends to become overly reliant on his one-to-one aide and has little interaction with the other students. In this regard, it is more restrictive than a special day class placement where STUDENT will have more opportunities to interact with peers. Indeed, at Kumara School, STUDENT is in a program with nondisabled children, but he receives virtually all of his instruction from the one-to-one aide and has limited interaction with other children. In general, STUDENT's interaction with other children at Kumara occurs in structured play groups but rarely occurs on a spontaneous basis. (Testimony of Pat Wagner and Wende Kumara) In a kindergarten class, STUDENT would be two years older than most of the other students. Thus, he would have no peers his age in the class. Moreover, none of the professionals who worked with STUDENT and/or assessed him recommended that he be placed in a regular education kindergarten class with a one-to-one aide. It is noted that in the prior hearing (Case Number SN 761-93), STUDENT's parents made the same argument and it was rejected by the Hearing Officer. If STUDENT were not disabled, he would be in a second grade regular education class, not a kindergarten class. For the above reasons, the notion that a regular education kindergarten placement constitutes an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment was not persuasive.(Footnote 3)

Autism is a severe and complex disability. (See Education Code, ˜ 56030.5) STUDENT's needs cannot be adequately addressed in a regular education class placement. For the reasons set forth above, an appropriate placement for him is in a special day class that is designed to meet his unique needs. Under the circumstances, such a placement constitutes the least restrictive environment for him.

The District's Initial Proposed Placements

Having concluded that a specifically designed special day class placement is appropriate for STUDENT, it now must be determined whether the District offered such a placement.

At IEP team meetings in August and September 1995, the District offered the following placement options: to "support" Kumara School as an interim placement; to slowly transition STUDENT from Kumara into a preschool special day class for communicatively handicapped students at Tamalpais Valley Elementary School; and to conduct a national search for a teacher trained in autism and place STUDENT in that teacher's special day class once he or she was hired. Alternatively, the District offered to place STUDENT at Star Academy, a State-certified nonpublic school.

The evidence established that the District's proposed placements for STUDENT set forth at the IEP team meetings in August and September were inappropriate for him. There was no persuasive evidence that a preschool special day class would be appropriate for STUDENT. The students in the class are too young and, therefore, would not be appropriate peers for STUDENT. None of the witnesses who assessed or worked directly with STUDENT recommended such a placement. STUDENT's parents also stated that such a placement was inappropriate for him.

The other placements proposed by the District did not actually exist as possible placements. One critical legal element of an IEP is that it set forth "the projected date for initiation and the anticipated duration of the program and services" to be provided. (Education Code, ˜ 56345, subd. (a)(5).) One obvious purpose of this legal requirement is to ensure that the student's program and services are implemented in a timely manner. In this case, the District's other proposed placement options were simply not available and, therefore, cannot be construed as legitimate placement offers because there was no time frame in which the services were to be implemented. The District did not have a special day class taught by a teacher with training and experience in autism; and, the District did not have a specific date in which it proposed to initiate such a placement. Indeed, at the hearing, Ms. Young testified that she had given up hope of finding such a teacher. With regard to Star Academy, the evidence established that the school had no openings and it was uncertain when or if a new opening would occur. In any event, Star Academy would not be an appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time because it lacked appropriate peers. The youngest student at Star Academy is nine years old. Even assuming that Star Academy somehow constituted an appropriate placement, the fact that there was no opening at the school, and no likelihood of an opening in the foreseeable future, meant that it was not available as a placement option and, therefore, was not a legitimate placement offer.

The District's Additional Placement Options

At IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, 1995, the District added three possible placement options for STUDENT in the following order of preference:

1. a special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School taught by Carol Fitzgerald;

2. a special day class at Gallinas Elementary School taught by Lisa Fredericks; or

3. a special day class at Gallinas Elementary School taught by Heidi Woods.

Citing Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, STUDENT's parents argued that the placement proposed by the District at the IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, 1995, should not be considered by the Hearing Officer because the placements were offered after the hearing had commenced. In Union School District, the parents of a disabled child sought retroactive reimbursement for the costs they incurred after rejecting the Union School District's proposed placement at Carlton School and unilaterally placing their child in a private program. At the due process hearing and in court, the Union School District contended that it had an appropriate program for the student at McKinnon School. However, the court concluded that the Union School District never made a formal written offer of a placement at McKinnon School and, therefore, did not consider the possible appropriateness of the placement in resolving the parents' request for retroactive reimbursement.

In this case, STUDENT's parents are not seeking retroactive reimbursement for the costs of a unilateral private placement. The primary focus of the dispute is on STUDENT's prospective placement. The parties held multiple IEP team meetings in an effort to resolve their dispute. The District did not offer an appropriate class for STUDENT prior to the IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, 1995. As discussed more fully below, although the District offered an appropriate class for STUDENT at the IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, other portions of his program were inappropriate and needed modifications. Furthermore, despite the fact that the District eventually offered an appropriate class for STUDENT, that offer was not made in a timely manner. Thus, the District did not offer an appropriate IEP for STUDENT in the 1995-96 school year.

Nevertheless, this case is distinguishable from Union School District because it primarily involves prospective services and does not involve a possible retroactive reimbursement of costs to the parents. Although the District's offer of a special day class at Edna Maguire was not made in a timely manner, it was a formal written offer of a placement. If the Hearing Officer were foreclosed from considering Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class as a possible prospective placement option, STUDENT would, by default, remain at Kumara School, a placement which both parties asserted is inappropriate. Union School District does not bar consideration of a proposed placement for purposes of prospective relief. Under the specific circumstances, it is concluded that the District's placement proposals at the IEP team meeting on October 18 and 23 may be considered in determining an appropriate IEP for STUDENT.

Of the three additional placement options, the District's top preference was Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class. The District presented less specific information regarding the two special day classes at Gallinas Elementary School. Ms. Fitzgerald testified at the hearing; neither Ms. Fredericks nor Ms. Woods testified at the hearing. Edna Maguire Elementary School is closer to STUDENT's home than Gallinas Elementary School and would not present any transportation problems. On the other hand, a placement at Gallinas Elementary School would create some transportation problems with respect to STUDENT's school schedule. Because the evidence established that Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class is appropriate for STUDENT, the two special day classes at Gallinas Elementary School are not considered below.

Ms. Fitzgerald has two teaching credentials: general elementary and communicatively handicapped. She has eleven years of teaching experience. Ms. Fitzgerald's class has twelve students and one full-time adult aide. Ten of the twelve students are close in age to STUDENT. Five of the students are "communicatively handicapped" and seven of the students are learning disabled. Thus, STUDENT would be the only autistic student in the class. When all students are present for school, the class has anywhere from four to twelve students at any given time period because, at varying times, students are mainstreamed in other classes. For two hours during the day, all twelve of the students are scheduled to be in class.

The evidence established that Ms. Fitzgerald's class is an appropriate placement for STUDENT with the support of a one-to-one aide and the I.C.S.S. coordinator. During the hearing, Ms. Wagner, the I.C.S.S. coordinator, convincingly testified that Ms. Fitzgerald's class is designed to meet STUDENT's needs. In this regard, Ms. Wagner's testimony was given considerable weight because of her extensive training and experience in working with autistic children and because she has spent many hours working directly with STUDENT and his other service providers.

Ms. Fitzgerald's class is an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it has a highly-structured program, a small class size with a low student-to-teacher ratio, and frequent opportunities for individual and small group instruction. Moreover, the class contains appropriate peers for STUDENT. STUDENT would continue to have his one-to-one aide; however, one function of the special day class would be to reduce STUDENT's dependence on the aide and encourage spontaneous communication with the other students. The students in the class are appropriate peers for STUDENT because their communication skills are at or above his level and they are at the same chronological age level. Moreover, none of the students exhibit significant behavior problems. In STUDENT's prior special day class with Jude Levine, two of the students exhibited rather extreme behaviors and their behavior had a negative impact on STUDENT. Most importantly, because the underlying structure of Ms. Fitzgerald's class is appropriate for STUDENT, his program in the class can be easily tailored to meet his unique needs.

STUDENT's parents had several specific criticisms of the District's proposed IEP. Some of their criticisms were valid and necessitate modifications to the District's proposed IEP. However, none of the criticisms justify eliminating Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School as STUDENT's underlying placement.

Nevertheless, because modifications are needed in STUDENT's IEP, the District must reconvene an IEP team meeting shortly after receipt of this decision and the parties will need to modify his IEP in accordance with this decision.

(a) Should STUDENT's IEP include a designated case manager to oversee implementation of his IEP?

If STUDENT's IEP needs to include a case manager, what should that person's qualifications, role and authority be?

Case Manager

The District proposed having three individuals responsible for coordination and oversight of STUDENT's IEP. The proposed IEP designates those individuals as follows:

1. Barbara Young will coordinate final financial decisions related to IEP services.

2. The teacher in consultation with the I.C.S.S. coordinator will provide primary coordination of all related services providers, and IEP services.

3. The I.C.S.S. coordinator will in addition to the listed recommendation of the Behavior Plan provide ongoing collaboration and inservicing regarding STUDENT's program.

(Respondent's Exhibit 42, at p. 11)

STUDENT's parents contend that the District's 71-page proposed IEP is so complicated that one person with knowledge in autism should be assigned as case manager to oversee implementation of the IEP. The District contends that case management is not a related service and, therefore, is not a required service under the law.

The list of related services set forth in the Education Code and Federal Regulations is not exclusive. Education Code section 56363, subdivision (a), states in relevant part:

Designated instruction and services as specified in the individualized education program shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. [emphasis added]

In addition, the Code of Federal Regulations defines "related services" and states in relevant part:

As used in this part, the term "related services" means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, . . . [emphasis added]

(34 Code of Fed. Regs. ˜ 300.16(a).)

The "note" to Section 300.16 states in relevant part:

Each related service defined under this part may include appropriate administrative and supervisory activities that are necessary for program planning, management, and evaluation. [emphasis added]

Based on Education Code section 56363 and 34 Code of Federal Regulations section 300.16(a), under certain circumstances, case management is a related service under the IDEA. In this case, the question that must be resolved is whether case management is a necessary service for STUDENT, and whether he should have only one case manager.

Special education law provides for school districts to have program specialists with specialized in-depth knowledge regarding various disabilities to provide support to resource specialists and special day class teachers. (Education Code, ˜ 56368, subd. (a).) One role of a program specialists is to "provide coordination, consultation and program development primarily in one specialized area or areas of his or her expertise." (Education Code, ˜ 56368, subd. (b)(4).) Program specialists often serve as case managers for students' IEPs. (Testimony of Pat Wagner)

One of STUDENT's greatest areas of need is to learn to generalize the skills he learns in one context to other aspects in his life. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT, Tiphanie Kaufman, Pat Wagner) For example, Ms. PARENT testified that STUDENT has made considerable progress in speech therapy, but often does not apply those skills at school or home. Ms. Wagner and Ms. Kaufman persuasively testified that in order for STUDENT to learn to generalize specific skills at school and home, he needs a program in which there is coordination among service providers to ensure that there is consistency and reinforcement in all areas of instruction, particularly with regard to his communication skills. To achieve the coordination in STUDENT's services, case management is a necessary part of his program.

Under the proposed IEP, STUDENT has several services providers: a classroom teacher, a one-to-one aide, a speech therapist, an occupational therapist, an adapted physical education teacher, and the I.C.S.S. coordinator. The speech therapist and I.C.S.S. coordinator have specialized in-depth knowledge in autism. On the other hand, the remaining services providers have limited knowledge and experience working with autistic children. Thus, they need the support of someone with expertise in teaching autistic children.

The evidence established that the District does not have staff with specialized in-depth knowledge regarding STUDENT's disability. There was no evidence that the District has a program specialist with specialized in-depth knowledge regarding autism. Moreover, in the special day classes proposed by the District, none of the teachers have specialized in-depth knowledge regarding autism. Ms. Fitzgerald testified that she has had one autistic child in her eleven years of teaching. Ms. Fitzgerald testified that she would need the support of STUDENT's one-to-one aide and the I.C.S.S. coordinator to implement his IEP.

When a school district does not have appropriate services for a disabled student, one option is to contract with a certified nonpublic agency to provide the service. (See Education Code, ˜ 56365.) That was precisely what the District did in this case. It contracted with I.C.S.S., a state-certified nonpublic agency, to provide a trained one-to-one aide for STUDENT and a coordinator for his program. The District's proposed IEP calls for the I.C.S.S. coordinator to, among other things, provide ongoing consultation with "all instructional personnel" and "staff inservice and training . . . as needed." In addition, the District's proposed IEP calls for the speech therapist to provide two hours per month of consultation services to other service providers.

The District's proposed IEP gave the I.C.S.S. coordinator considerable case management authority. Ms. Wagner, the I.C.S.S. coordinator, testified that she previously served as a program specialist in the Modesto Unified School District and acted as case manager for more than three hundred severely disabled students. Currently, Ms. Wagner has served as behavioral intervention case manager for STUDENT and has been coordinating his other related services. Thus, she has, in effect, been serving in the role as STUDENT's case manager.

The most compelling evidence that case management is needed as part of STUDENT's program is that the parties each identified it as an important element in STUDENT's program. The District proposed it as part of STUDENT's IEP. The District sought to designate three individuals to coordinate and oversee implementation of his IEP. STUDENT's parents also wanted to include case management in STUDENT's IEP, but wanted only one person to serve as the case manager.

For all of the above reasons, it is concluded that case management is a necessary part of STUDENT's IEP. It must now be determined whether he should have only one case manager.

How Many Case Managers Are Needed?

Dr. Schrader convincingly testified that STUDENT needs to have one case manager who is knowledgeable in autism coordinate his program. Dr. Schrader noted that STUDENT has diverse needs and that if there was more than one case manager it would be difficult to implement his IEP. Dr. Schrader's testimony was corroborated by the testimony of Ms. Wagner and Ms. Kaufman, who also favored having one case manager who is knowledgeable in autism coordinate STUDENT's program. The testimony of Dr. Schrader, Ms. Wagner and Ms. Kaufman was given considerable weight because all three have in-depth knowledge regarding autism and have worked extensively with STUDENT.

Based on the above, it is concluded that STUDENT's IEP must identify one individual who has specialized in-depth knowledge in autism to serve as his case manager.

What is the Role of the Case Manager?

An IEP must set forth the "specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil." (Education Code, ˜ 56345, subd. (a)(3).) Under the circumstances, case management is a related service in STUDENT's IEP and, therefore, the IEP must specify the extent to which the service needs to be provided.

Dr. Schrader estimated that case management responsibility would take anywhere from "zero-to-several hours per week." Ms. Wagner testified that she spends up to fourteen hours per week on STUDENT's program. However, she noted that much of that time is spent doing responsibilities that a teacher could perform. Ms. Wagner anticipated that once STUDENT is in a special day class with a teacher, she will need to spend one-to-five hours on his program. However, Ms. Wagner did not anticipate that her role would include case management responsibilities.

Ms. Wagner also testified that it will be necessary to develop and implement a transition plan for STUDENT's transfer from Kumara School into a special day class. STUDENT's proposed IEP provided for a two-week transition period and called for the I.C.S.S. coordinator to coordinate transition services. Ms. Wagner convincingly testified that the transition may need to take up to one month. Thus, STUDENT's IEP will need to be modified to allow for a one-month transition from Kumara School to the special day class. Moreover, the oversight of STUDENT's transition services must be the responsibility of his case manager.

Another important function of the case manager must be to communicate with STUDENT's parents regarding his program at school so that he can receive reinforcement of those skills at home. This will help STUDENT learn to generalize his skills. Parent counseling and training is a related service that must be included as part of an IEP when necessary to enable a student to benefit from his program. (Education Code, ˜56363, subd. (b)(11).)

The main function of STUDENT's case manager needs to be consulting with and providing guidance to other services providers and STUDENT's parents regarding his program. Communication is an essential ingredient in STUDENT's program because of the number of service providers individuals involved in his program and his need to learn to generalize skills from one activity to another. Ms. PARENT testified that she spends six to eighteen hours per week working on STUDENT's program. Much of that time includes communicating with STUDENT's service providers. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that she is "micro-managing" his program, but stated that it is necessary because some of the service providers do not know what they are doing.

The Hearing Officer did not find any evidence of incompetence in STUDENT's service providers. More importantly, Ms. PARENT's acknowledged over-involvement in STUDENT's program appears to be using staff time that should be used to provide direct services for STUDENT. The IEP team needs to specifically define the extent of the case manager's oversight of STUDENT's program, including the amount of time consulting and providing guidance to STUDENT's parents. Regular communication between the case manager and STUDENT's parents regarding the skills that are being addressed by the various service providers is a necessary component of his program. It will help STUDENT generalize the skills he learns from one environment to another. To maintain regular communications, the case manager will need to speak with STUDENT's parents at least once per week. Given that there are several service providers for STUDENT, the communications between STUDENT's parents and the case manager must be for a minimum of thirty minutes per week. The actual amount of time, however, will need to be an IEP team decision.

The District's main objection to having one case manager appeared to be related to their concern about the cost of his program. Spectrum charges $120 per hour for the services of the I.C.S.S. coordinator. The District had a legitimate concern that STUDENT's parents extensive contacts with the services providers could prove extremely costly to the District.

An IEP must state the specific related services needed by the student. (Education Code, ˜ 56345, subd. (a)(3).) In this case, a case manager is a necessary related service for STUDENT and, therefore, his IEP must specifically state the amount of services that are to be provided by the case manager. It is noted that all of the weekly times of the other related services are specifically set forth in the IEP. Moreover, by having the IEP specify the amount of time of the case manager's services, it will provide a limit to the costs of the case manager's services.

Based on the testimony of Dr. Schrader and Ms. Wagner, the case manager will need to spend a minimum of five hours per week to consult with and provide guidance to all services providers and STUDENT's parents. The actual amount of time, however, will need to be defined by the IEP team.

For all of the above reasons, it is concluded that the primary function of the case manager needs to be to consult with and provide guidance to other services providers and STUDENT's parents. In addition, the case manager needs to develop and oversee STUDENT's transition plan for his transfer into public school. The case manager's weekly amount of time must be defined by the IEP team.

(b) Does STUDENT need a teacher who is specifically trained in autism?

STUDENT's parents contend that he needs to have a teacher who is specifically trained to teach autistic children. They contend that the District initially agreed to provide such a teacher and has now reneged on that promise. The District contends that STUDENT needs to be in a classroom with a credentialed teacher and that, ideally, the teacher should have training in autism. The District asserts that it conducted a "national search" for such a teacher, but has been unable to find one. The District contends that its proposed program in a special day class placement with students his own age and support services from I.C.S.S. is appropriate to meet his needs even though the teacher does not have in-depth training in autism.

Under California regulations, there is no specific teaching credential which applies only to autistic children. Teachers with a credential for the severely handicapped are authorized to teach classes in which the primary disability of the students is autism. (5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 80047.4, subd. (a)(1).) However, teachers with a credential for the severely handicapped are also specifically authorized to teach severely mentally retarded, seriously emotionally disturbed, and "multi-handicapped" students. (5 Calif. Code of Reg., ˜˜ 80047.1, 80047.2, and 80047.3.)

A teacher with a "communication handicapped" credential is authorized to teach a class in which the primary disability of the students is autism, provided the teacher has one year of experience since September 1991 teaching such a class, has completed an approved program in autism, and has a favorable evaluation to teach such a class from the local employing agency. (5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 80047.4, subd. (a)(2).)

In this case, Ms. Fitzgerald does not meet either of the above standards for teaching a class in which the primary disability of the students is autism. However, the District is not recommending that STUDENT be placed in a class in which the primary disability of the students is autism. STUDENT will be the only autistic student in a class in which the other students have less severe disabilities. Thus, the above regulations do not apply to this case because the District is not proposing that Ms. Fitzgerald's class consist primarily of autistic students. Moreover, the evidence established that, with the proper support, Ms. Fitzgerald's class is an appropriate placement for STUDENT. Although Ms. Fitzgerald has limited knowledge and experience in autism, she holds a "communications handicapped" credential and has more than ten years of teaching experience. Teachers with a communications handicapped credential are authorized to teach students with speech and language disorders. One of STUDENT's greatest areas of need is his poor speech and language skills.

Most importantly, Ms. Wagner convincingly testified that, with support from the I.C.S.S. coordinator and the one-to-one aide, Ms. Fitzgerald's class will be an appropriate placement for STUDENT. The I.C.S.S. coordinator has the necessary in-depth knowledge and experience in autism to assist the teacher in providing appropriate instruction to STUDENT. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT needs to have both a coordinator and a teacher with in-depth knowledge in autism as part of his program.

For the above reasons, it is concluded that STUDENT's classroom teacher does not need to have in-depth knowledge in autism. With the proper support from the I.C.S.S. coordinator, STUDENT's teacher will be able to provide him with appropriate instruction.

(c) Does STUDENT's IEP include an appropriate behavior intervention plan?

Title 5, section 3052, of the California Code of Regulations sets forth in considerable detail the procedures that must be followed and the type of information that must be included in a behavior intervention plan. Among other things, a behavior intervention plan must include the following: a functional analysis assessment, an intervention plan, acceptable responses to targeted behaviors, and a procedure for evaluating the plan's effectiveness.

The functional analysis assessment must include the following:

œ systematic observation of the targeted behavior;

œ systematic observation of the immediate antecedent events associated with the targeted behavior; œ systematic observation and analysis of the consequences following the display of the targeted behavior; and œ an ecological analysis of the settings in which the behavior occurs most frequently.

(5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 3052, subd. (b).)

The behavior intervention plan must be based on the results of the functional analysis and may include various strategies for preventing the targeted inappropriate behavior. (5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 3052, subd. (d).) The behavior intervention plan must include "positive response options" to be used when the targeted behavior occurs. (5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 3052, subd. (e).) The procedures for evaluating the behavior intervention plan must include baseline and ongoing measurements of the frequency, duration, and intensity of the targeted behaviors. (5 Calif. Code of Regs., ˜ 3052, subd. (f).)

In this case, the evidence overwhelmingly established that Ms. Wagner developed a detailed behavior intervention plan in accordance with Section 3052. Ms. Wagner testified that she spent 24 to 30 hours developing the plan. She systematically observed STUDENT at school and targeted the following behaviors that needed to be addressed: tantrums, inner-directed speech, and requests for a "stim-toy." Ms. Wagner obtained baseline data regarding the frequency of the targeted behaviors. In addition, she identified specific antecedents which occurred before or in the presence of the targeted behaviors.

The behavior intervention plan contained detailed strategies for preventing the targeted behavior and positive response options when the behavior occurs. For example, the behavior intervention plan noted that STUDENT was more likely to engage in a targeted behavior when he lost interest in a task. The behavior intervention plan included a goal for STUDENT to learn to ask for a break during a "less preferred activity." With regard to STUDENT's use of inner speech, the behavior intervention plan recommends specific questions or statements for the teacher to use to stop the behavior and to teach STUDENT to use words, rather than inner-speech, to describe his feelings.

Dr. Freeman reviewed the behavior intervention plan and described it as "one of the best she's ever seen." Indeed, there was no persuasive evidence that the behavior intervention plan was inappropriate for STUDENT.

Based on all of the above, it is concluded that the District developed an appropriate behavior intervention plan for STUDENT.

(d) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate mainstreaming opportunities?

A disabled student's IEP must state the extent to which the student will be able to participate in regular educational programs. (Education Code, ˜ 56345, subd. (a)(4).) When appropriate, the IEP must also provide a description of activities for the transition of the student into a regular class program if the student is to be transferred from a nonpublic school into a regular class program for any portion of the school day. [emphasis added] The description must indicate the nature of each activity, and the time spent on the activity each day or week. (Education Code, ˜ 56345, subd. (b)(6).)

In this case, the District's proposed IEP does not set forth the extent to which STUDENT will be able to participate in regular educational programs. The front page of the IEP contains a section with small boxes to indicate the percentage of time the student will be in regular education. However, none of the boxes are checked. The proposed IEP contains some language that may reference mainstreaming activities. However, the language is so vague that it is virtually meaningless. The IEP states in relevant part:

STUDENT will be given opportunities for age-appropriate instruction.

STUDENT will be given opportunities for developmentally appropriate social interactions.

(Respondent's Exhibit 42, at pp. 22-23)

Neither of the above two sentences sets forth the extent to which STUDENT will participate in regular education program.

Ms. Fitzgerald testified that all of her students are mainstreamed for lunch, recess, music, art, P.E., and library. The fact that Ms. Fitzgerald's other students are mainstreamed in various subjects or activities does not necessarily mean that those would be appropriate subjects in which STUDENT should be mainstreamed.

As discussed above in issue (1), the evidence established that STUDENT needs the structure of a special day class as his underlying placement. That does not mean, however, that he should be totally excluded from the regular education program at his school. It was undisputed that STUDENT can benefit from social interactions with nondisabled peers. Thus, his IEP needs to include mainstreaming activities for at least some portion of his school day. Under Education Code section 56345, his IEP must specify the activities in which he will be mainstreamed. Moreover, because STUDENT will be transferring from a nonpublic school into a regular education program for some portion of the school day, his IEP must describe the activities that will be provided to integrate STUDENT into the regular education program.

For the above reasons, it is concluded that the District's IEP is inappropriate to the extent that it does not specify the extent to which STUDENT will participate in regular education programs and does not describe the activities that will be provided to integrate STUDENT into the regular education program.

The evidence established that STUDENT benefitted from structured play groups at Kumara School. (Testimony of Wende Kumara and Pat Wagner) During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT played with and had opportunities for spontaneous communication with nondisabled children for approximately 105 minutes per week in structured group activities. (Respondent's Exhibit 42, at p. 41)

Based on the above, it is concluded that STUDENT's IEP must include a minimum of 105 minutes per week of mainstreaming in a structured play group with nondisabled peers. The IEP team shall decide what other mainstreaming activities, if any, are necessary for STUDENT.

(e) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate teaching strategies?

STUDENT's parents contend that the District's proposed IEP emphasizes "incidental learning" and that STUDENT needs direct instruction of specific skills. In addition, STUDENT's parents contend that his IEP needs to include instruction in social skills, classroom skills, and occupational therapy skills in progressively larger groups of students.

The District contends that STUDENT's program will include substantial direct instruction of specific skills. The District asserts that STUDENT's IEP includes goals and objectives in social, classroom, and occupational therapy skills.

Teaching methodology is a matter that is generally within the discretion of school staff. (See Lachman v. Illinois State Bd. of Educ. (7th Cir. 1988) 852 F.2d 290.) In this case, the evidence established STUDENT will receive substantial direct instruction as part of the District's proposed program. Ms. Fitzgerald and Ms. Wagner testified that they rely extensively on direct instruction. Moreover, many of the proposed goals and objectives appear to require direct instruction in order to be implemented. The only evidence at the hearing regarding the use of "incidental learning" was a reference to that method by Dr. Schrader. However, Dr. Schrader is no longer involved in STUDENT's program and there was no evidence that the other service providers use incidental learning as a specific mode of instruction.

Furthermore, STUDENT's IEP contains appropriate goals and objectives in the areas of social, classroom, and occupational therapy skills. The evidence established that many hours of effort went into developing STUDENT's IEP and the IEP contains numerous detailed goals and objectives in many areas. Ms. Wagner and Dr. Freeman reviewed STUDENT's IEP and testified that it contains appropriate goals and objectives for him. STUDENT's parents testified that some of the goals and objectives have already been met and, therefore, were inappropriate for him, although they did not dispute that most of the goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT. The fact that some of STUDENT's goals and objectives have been met during the course of the school year is not surprising and, indeed, indicates that he has been making progress.

The structure of STUDENT's small group instruction is a matter that properly belongs to the teacher and the I.C.S.S. coordinator. The entire purpose of the special day class placement is to provide STUDENT with small group instruction in a structured setting. The purpose of hiring an outside expert, the I.C.S.S. coordinator, is to rely on that person's expertise. Whether STUDENT needs to receive one-to-one instruction or instruction in small group of 2, 3, 4 or more students will depend on a variety of circumstances on any given day. Such factors as the subject matter being taught, the skill levels of the different students, and how well certain students work together are all relevant for determining who or how many students should be in STUDENT's small group instruction. However, these are matters which will change on a day-to-day basis and, therefore, should be within the discretion of the teacher and I.C.S.S. coordinator.

Although there may be circumstances which would warrant a specific teaching strategy for a student with severe needs, there was no persuasive evidence that this is such a case. Thus, STUDENT's parents did not establish a factual or legal basis upon which the District should be required to use a specific teaching methodology.

(f) Should STUDENT's six-hour instructional day include transportation time to and from speech therapy?

It is undisputed that STUDENT needs to have a six-hour instructional day. On three days per week, STUDENT is transported to San Francisco for speech and language therapy. The roundtrip takes approximately one hour. During the 1994-95 school year, the transportation time did not interfere with STUDENT's six-hour instructional day. However, in the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT's speech and language schedule was changed such that transportation time is now part of his instructional day.

STUDENT's parents contend that transportation time should not reduce his instructional day. The District contends that STUDENT can receive instruction from his one-to-one aide while he is on the bus and that, therefore, the transportation time will not reduce his instructional time during the school day.

The District's position was not convincing. STUDENT's parents persuasively testified that STUDENT needs the bus ride as a time to relax between school and speech therapy and that a bus ride is an inappropriate teaching environment for STUDENT. Their testimony was supported by almost of all of the professionals who testified at the hearing, including many of the District's own witnesses. The professionals either believed it would be inappropriate to provide STUDENT with instruction on the bus or had significant reservations about such instruction. Dr. Freeman testified that STUDENT would get "turned off to learning" if he received instruction on the bus and that he needed time to "chill out." Dr. Campbell testified that it would be inappropriate for STUDENT to receive instruction on a bus. Dr. Schrader stated that perhaps STUDENT could receive ten minutes of instruction each way, but that the aide would be "rather limited" in what he or she could do. Dr. Schrader also noted that STUDENT needs time to relax between speech therapy and school. Ms. Kaufman testified that it would be more beneficial for STUDENT to receive the instruction in a school setting rather than on a bus. She estimated that the aide might be able to provide five-to-ten minutes of instruction each way.

Ms. Wagner was the only professional who has provided services to STUDENT who favored having him receive instruction on the bus. In this regard, her opinion was not persuasive. Ms. Wagner preferred that STUDENT receive instruction on the bus to his having a longer school day. However, a longer instructional school day is not necessarily required to accommodate STUDENT's need for speech therapy and the transportation time involved. It is undisputed that speech therapy can be provided during the instructional school day. Thus, STUDENT could leave school one hour early on speech therapy days. He would arrive home approximately one hour later on those days due to the transportation time, but his instructional school day would not be longer.

For all of the above reasons, it is concluded that it was inappropriate for the District to include in STUDENT's proposed IEP one hour of instructional time on the bus.

(2) Did the District conduct timely assessment of STUDENT's special education needs?

STUDENT's parents contend that the District failed to conduct the following assessments in a timely manner: functional behavior, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education. The District contends that its assessments were conducted in a timely manner. The District asserts that, as a matter of law, the Hearing Officer must conclude that the functional behavior assessment was conducted in a timely manner because a State Department of Education compliance investigator reached that conclusion in his report.(Footnote 4)

An assessment must be completed and an IEP team meeting convened within fifty (50) days from the date of receipt of the parent's written consent for the assessment. (Education Code, ˜ 56344.)

The Functional Behavior Assessment

On October 27, 1994, the parties signed a settlement agreement which governed STUDENT's placement and services for the 1994-95 school year. The parties agreed to schedule an IEP team meeting in April 1995 to "review STUDENT's IEP, program, and placement for 1995-96." In addition, one provision of the settlement agreement stated as follows:

The District will conduct a functional behavior assessment of STUDENT after he begins attending Kumara. The District will prepare a written report of the assessment as provided by law.

(Petitioner's Exhibit BB)

The District contracted with BCRC to conduct the functional behavior assessment. Dr. Schrader completed his assessment report on June 26, 1995. (Respondent's Exhibit 23)

On its face, the settlement agreement is unclear regarding the timing of the completion of the functional behavior assessment. The settlement agreement states that the District will prepare a "written report of the assessment as provided by law." Assuming Education Code section 56344 governed the timing of the functional behavior assessment report, Dr. Schrader's report should have been completed and another IEP team meeting convened by no later than December 16, 1994, i.e., fifty days after the signing of the settlement agreement. However, it is not clear that Section 56344 necessarily applies to this case. The settlement agreement specifically called for the District to schedule an IEP team meeting in April 1995. Neither party anticipated that an IEP team meeting was going to be scheduled prior to April 1995.

Moreover, it was the understanding of the parties that phrase "as provided by law" meant that the assessment report had to conform to the standards set forth in Title 5, Section 3052 of the California Code of Regulations regarding the substantive content of the report.

One critical purpose of the settlement agreement was for the parties to resolve their dispute regarding STUDENT's services in the 1994-95 school year. It was not clear from the settlement agreement whether the parties intended the functional behavior assessment to be completed immediately, within fifty days, by the end of the school year, or within some other time frame. Dr. Schrader completed the assessment report prior to the end of the 1994-95 school year. Thus, the evidence did not establish that the District failed to complete the functional behavior assessment in a timely manner.

Most importantly, even assuming that the completion of the functional behavior assessment report in June 1995 was untimely and constituted a procedural violation, it did not constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education. Federal circuit courts have found that under certain circumstances procedural violations of the IDEA may constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education. In reaching this conclusion, the courts recognized that not all procedural violations constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479; Hall by Hall v. Vance County Board of Education (4th Cir. 1985) 774 F.2d 629; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton (4th Cir. 1990) 895 F.2d 973; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee (1st Cir. 1990) 910 F.2d 983.)

In W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, the Ninth Circuit held that procedural violations that result in the loss of an educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process constitute a denial of a free appropriate public education. In this case, even assuming that Dr. Schrader's report constituted a procedural violation, there was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT was denied an educational opportunity or that his parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process was infringed as a result of the possible procedural violation. The evidence established that the request for a functional behavior assessment arose because in the summer and fall of 1994 STUDENT exhibited a significant increase in problematic behaviors. However, in October 1994, shortly after STUDENT's placement at Kumara School, his problem behaviors markedly decreased. (Testimony of Dr. Schrader and Ms. PARENT) Thus, there did not appear to be the same need for the functional behavior assessment as at the beginning of the school 1994-95 school year.

Furthermore, STUDENT's parents raised their first concern that the functional behavior assessment had not been completed in late April 1995. The parties actually met in IEP team meetings on March 30 and May 11, 1995. At the IEP team meeting on May 11, 1995, STUDENT's parents raised, for the first time at an IEP team meeting, the fact that Dr. Schrader had not completed the functional behavior assessment. The fact that STUDENT's problem behaviors markedly decreased and that his parents did not raise the issue of the lack of a completed functional behavior assessment for approximately six months indicates that the circumstances that created the need for the assessment no longer existed.

Therefore, even assuming that the District's the timing of the District's functional behavior assessment actually constituted a procedural violation, it did not result in the loss of an educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process.

Occupational Therapy and Adapted Physical Education Assessments

At the IEP team meeting on May 11, 1995, the parties agreed in principle to have professionals outside the District assess STUDENT in a number of areas, but they were still discussing various professionals as possible assessors. (Respondent's Exhibit 21) At the IEP team meeting on July 5, 1995, the parties agreed that the assessments would take place at UCLA. (Respondent's Exhibit 24) On August 7 and 8, 1995, specialists at UCLA, including an occupational therapist and recreational therapist, assessed STUDENT. (Respondent's Exhibits 25 & 26) At IEP team meetings on August 23 and 29, 1995, the parties reviewed the results of the assessments from UCLA.

On September 8, 1995, Ms. PARENT signed a form consenting to an adapted physical education assessment. (Respondent's Exhibit 44) On September 11, Nancy Henderson, adapted physical education specialist, began working with STUDENT. On September 18 and 25, Ms. Henderson conducted an adapted physical education assessment of STUDENT. (Testimony of Nancy Henderson) On October 18, 1995, the District reconvened an IEP team meeting. (Respondent's Exhibit 42)

Based on the above, the evidence established that the District conducted timely occupational therapy and adapted physical education assessments of STUDENT. On July 5, 1995, the parties specifically agreed to the actual assessments. On August 23, 1995, 49 days later, the District reconvened an IEP team meeting to discuss the results of the assessments. With regard to Ms. Henderson's adapted physical education assessment, the District completed the assessment and IEP 40 days after Ms. PARENT signed the form consenting to the assessment.

For all of the above reasons, it is concluded that the District conducted timely assessments of STUDENT.

(3) If the District denied STUDENT appropriate services in the 1995-96 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education from the District?

In their closing brief, STUDENT's parents contend that he is entitled to 3,234 hours of compensatory education because of the District's purported failure to provide an appropriate education in the 1993-94, 1994-95, and 1995-96 school years. The District contends that it has provided STUDENT with an appropriate education in the 1995-96 school year and that, therefore, he is not entitled to compensatory education.

In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 358, the Supreme Court held that school authorities are required to reimburse parents for their expenditures on private special education for a child if it is ultimately determined that such a placement, rather than the placement proposed in the IEP, is appropriate under the IDEA. The Supreme Court also concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA.

Based on the principle in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded if it is determined that a school district failed to provide an appropriate placement for a disabled student. (Lester H. v. Gilhool (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Murphy v. Timberland Regional School District (1st Cir. 1992) 973 F.2d 13, 16; Burr v. Ambach (2nd Cir. 1988) 863 F.2d 1071; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749; Robert D. v. Andrews (11th Cir. 1991) 933 F.2d 1576.)

In this case, STUDENT's request for compensatory education for the 1993-94 school year must be denied because that school year was not at issue in the hearing. The only issue that was relevant to the 1994-95 school year was the allegation that the District failed to conduct a timely functional behavior assessment. However, the evidence established that the District complied with the settlement agreement with respect to the functional behavior assessment. Therefore, STUDENT's request for compensatory education for the 1994-95 school year must be denied.

As discussed above in issue 1 (f), the District denied STUDENT an appropriate education in the 1995-96 school year by including transportation time to and from speech therapy as part of his instructional day. As a result, STUDENT missed three hours of instructional time in each week. As of the date of the decision, there will have been 22 weeks in the 1995-96 school year. Therefore, STUDENT is entitled to 66 hours of compensatory education for the loss of the instructional time. An IEP team will need to determine how the compensatory education time will be allotted.

STUDENT's parents assert that he is also entitled to additional compensatory education because the District did not offer him an appropriate IEP in the 1995-96 school year.

As discussed above in issue (1), the evidence established that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate classroom placement until the IEP team meetings on October 18 and 23, 1995. Even then, some elements of his proposed IEP were inappropriate and needed to be corrected. Despite these discrepancies, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded the STUDENT is entitled to any further award of compensatory education.

STUDENT's parents assert that Kumara School was inappropriate and that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education for his entire time there in the 1995-96 school year. They calculated that he received 606 hours of instruction at Kumara School in the 1995-96 school year and asserted that, therefore, he is entitled to 606 hours of compensatory education.

This hearing primarily focussed on the prospective special education services that are necessary to meet STUDENT's unique needs. At the beginning of the 1995-96 school year, the parties failed to reach agreement regarding STUDENT's IEP and the matter proceeded to hearing. However, the parties essentially agreed on many elements of an interim program for STUDENT pending resolution of the dispute, including his placement at Kumara School. At various times during the hearing, STUDENT's parents changed their position with respect to the appropriateness of Kumara School for STUDENT.

Although the parties never formally agreed on the specific elements of STUDENT's IEP that could be implemented pending resolution of other portions of his IEP, their conduct indicated an agreement regarding the services that were provided. Throughout the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT received the services of a one-to-one aide in a program that was designed by someone with an in-depth knowledge in autism. In addition, he received speech and language therapy and adapted physical education. Thus, STUDENT received a specialized interim program that was, in most respects, designed to meet his unique needs. The entire program was paid for by the District. STUDENT's parents accepted and did not challenge the above elements of his program. It was undisputed that STUDENT made significant progress in that program. (Testimony of Pat Wagner and Ms. PARENT)

Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds no legal or factual basis for an award of additional compensatory education because STUDENT received substantial specialized services that were designed to meet his unique needs and the parties acted as if they were in agreement regarding these interim services.

STUDENT's parents also seek compensatory services because of the delay in the provision of occupational therapy services. In August 1995, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT needed occupational therapy, but the District did not provide occupational therapy for STUDENT until November 1995.

In this regard, equitable considerations weigh against an award of additional compensatory education for the delay in occupational therapy services. The evidence established that the District previously contracted with Gaynelle Woods, a private occupational therapist, to provide occupational therapy for STUDENT. The District demonstrated a willingness to provide whatever occupational therapy services STUDENT needed. However, Ms. PARENT was dissatisfied with Ms. Woods' services and eventually withdrew STUDENT from occupational therapy. Ms. PARENT allowed Ms. Woods to provide consultational services to other staff, but at the end of her contract with the District, Ms. Woods refused to continue providing any services as part of STUDENT's program because of repeated interference from Ms. PARENT. (Respondent's Exhibit 37)

Moreover, Ms. PARENT encountered difficulties with other private service providers. She was dissatisfied with the services provided by Dr. Schrader and with an evaluation conducted by Bryna Siegel, Ph.D., a psychologist at the University of California San Francisco. Barbara Young, District Director of Special Education, credibly testified that she had difficulty contracting with a new private occupational therapist because of the prior problems with the services.

Under the circumstances, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education for the delay in occupational therapy services because the delay was due to Ms. PARENT's withdrawal of STUDENT from such services and there was no persuasive evidence that the services provided by Ms. Woods were inappropriate.

In its closing argument, the District asked the Hearing Officer to make the decision in this case binding on the parties for one year from the date of the decision. A student's IEP must be reviewed at least annually, or more frequently if conditions warrant. (Education Code, ˜˜ 56343 and 56380.) In this case, the primary focus of the hearing was on STUDENT's IEP for the 1995-96 school year. There was no evidence presented regarding the 1996-97 school year. Under the circumstances, it is concluded that the decision shall remain in effect for the duration of the 1995-96 school year, including the extended school year.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

The hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. (Education Code, ˜ 56507, subd. (d).) The following findings are made in accordance with Section 56507(d).

(1) Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate individualized education program (IEP) for the 1995-96 school year?

(a) Should STUDENT's IEP include a designated case manager to oversee implementation of his IEP?

If STUDENT's IEP needs to include a case manager, what should that person's qualifications, role and authority be?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(b) Does STUDENT need a teacher who is specifically trained in autism?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

(c) Does STUDENT's IEP include an appropriate behavior management plan?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

(d) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate mainstreaming opportunities?

Neither party prevailed on this issue.

(e) Does STUDENT's IEP include appropriate teaching strategies?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

(f) Should STUDENT's six-hour instructional day include transportation time to and from speech therapy?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(2) Did the District conduct timely assessment of STUDENT's special education needs?

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

(3) If the District denied STUDENT appropriate services in the 1995-96 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education from the District?

Petitioner prevailed in part and Respondent prevailed in part on this issue.

ORDER

(1) Commencing immediately, STUDENT's IEP shall have one case manager.

(a) The District shall designate one individual who has specialized in-depth knowledge regarding autism to serve as STUDENT's case manager and oversee implementation of his IEP. (b) The primary function of the case manager shall be to consult with and provide guidance to STUDENT's other service providers and his parents regarding his program.

(c) Commencing immediately, the case manager shall develop and oversee implementation of a transition plan to transfer STUDENT from Kumara School to Edna Maguire Elementary School.

(d) The case manager shall provide a minimum of five hours per week of services, including time for consultation with STUDENT's parents and the time needed to develop and oversee implementation of a transition plan. The specific amount of time shall be defined by an IEP team.

(2) STUDENT's IEP shall include a minimum of 105 minutes per week of mainstreaming in a structured play group with nondisabled peers.

(3) STUDENT's IEP shall describe the activities that will be provided to integrate him into the regular school program as part of his transition from Kumara School to Edna Maguire Elementary School.

(4) Commencing immediately, STUDENT's transportation time to and from speech therapy shall be excluded as part of his instructional day. The District shall immediately modify STUDENT's schedule to accommodate his six-hour instructional day.

(5) The District shall provide STUDENT with 66 hours of compensatory education.

(6) Within thirty (30) calendar days of receipt of this decision, Ms. Fitzgerald's special day class at Edna Maguire Elementary School shall be STUDENT's classroom placement for the duration of the 1995-96 school year. STUDENT's extended school year classroom placement shall be an equivalent placement.

(7) Within fifteen (15) calendar days of receipt of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting and modify STUDENT's IEP in accordance with this decision.

(8) This Order shall remain in effect for the duration of the 1995-96 school year, including the extended school year.

(9) Petitioner's requests for relief not addressed in this Order are denied.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Education Code, ˜56505, subd. (i).)

Dated: March 1, 1996 F. Richard Ruderman Hearing Officer California SpecialEducation Hearing Office

1. In general, the petitioner is the party who raises the issues for hearing.

2. The decision in Case Number SN 761-93 contains a typographical error in the heading which identifies the case number as SN 761-94.

3. In Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H. (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, the court of appeal set forth a four-part test for determining whether a placement complies with the mainstreaming requirements of the IDEA. In their closing briefs, the parties in the instant case argued extensively regarding whether or not the placement proposed by STUDENT's parents was consistent with this standard. In Sacramento City Unified School District, the issue was whether a moderately retarded second grade student should be placed full-time in a regular education second grade classroom. Thus, the issue was whether the student should have been placed in a regular education classroom that she would have normally attended if she was not disabled. In this case, STUDENT is a seven year-old student who, under normal circumstances, would be in the second grade. His parents, however, wanted him placed in a regular education kindergarten class. It is questionable that such a proposed placement truly constitutes mainstreaming. In any event, because a regular education kindergarten placement is inappropriate for STUDENT, the standard in Sacramento City Unified School District does not apply in this case.

4. The District's contention that the Hearing Officer must, as a matter of law, adopt the findings by the compliance investigator is without merit. A compliance investigation is a separate process from a due process hearing. In a due process hearing, parties have the right to confront, cross-examine, and compel the attendance of witnesses. (Education Code, ˜ 56505, subd. (e)(3).) Parties do not have these rights in a compliance investigation. Thus, the findings by the compliance investigator do not have a collateral estoppel or res judicata effect on a due process hearing. In any event, it is noted that the Hearing Officer and compliance investigator essentially reached the same conclusion.