California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 2, 1996

Student v. San Gabriel Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 89-95 · Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel

San Gabriel district must place boy in regular kindergarten with a signing aide and inclusion specialist; home-schooling reimbursement denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 5 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. Footnote 1 records that the matter was taken off calendar after a tentative settlement in June 1995 and returned to calendar when the settlement was not finalized.

Summary

The parents of a seven-and-a-half-year-old boy filed for hearing in February 1995 against their San Gabriel school district. The student has Angelman syndrome, with mild to moderate mental retardation and a severe expressive language delay. He communicates through speech, sign language, gestures, and an Alpha Talker voice-output device. In 1994-95 he spent mornings in a special day class (SDC) and afternoons in a regular education Two Year Kindergarten Experience (TYKE) class at Wilson Elementary School, with a one-to-one aide. For 1995-96 the district offered only the SDC, and the parents home-schooled him.

The Hearing Officer applied the Ninth Circuit's four-factor Rachel H. test and found that every factor favored mainstreaming. The TYKE teacher never taught the student academics or modified the curriculum, so the district could not show he would not benefit in a regular class. TYKE peers were better language and behavior models. His behavior did not harm other students' learning. Neither side offered evidence on cost. The SDC-only offer therefore denied FAPE. The Hearing Officer ordered placement in regular kindergarten with a full-time aide who knows enough American Sign Language to interpret the student's signs and teach him new ones. The request for a fluent signer was denied. A full inclusion specialist must help the teacher modify the curriculum, and the IEP had to be updated within 15 days. About $1,900 in home-schooling costs was not reimbursed because there was no evidence of that program's quality.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. mainstreaming factors and put the burden on the district. A district that never modified the regular curriculum could not show that a regular class would fail. It also shows that home-schooling reimbursement could be denied when parents offered no evidence of the program's quality or benefit.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. What is the least restrictive appropriate environment (LRE) for STUDENT?

    Applying the four Rachel H. factors, each of which favored mainstreaming, the Hearing Officer held that the LRE is a regular education kindergarten class.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Does STUDENT require the full-time assistance of an aide fluent in American Sign Language in order to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE)?

    The aide need not be fluent, but the aide must know enough American Sign Language to interpret the student's signs and teach him new signs suited to his developmental level; neither party substantially prevailed.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Does STUDENT require the intermittent services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

    The student requires a full inclusion specialist trained in special education, as an IEP team member, to help the regular education teacher modify the curriculum.

  4. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?

    The district's offer of a special day class with only incidental contact with nondisabled peers did not provide mainstreaming to the maximum extent appropriate, so it denied FAPE for 1995-96.

  5. Issue 5. If not, must the District reimburse the parents for expenditures made on their home schooling of STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year?

    Reimbursement for home-schooling supplies, the Excellence in Education Academy fee, and private sign language interpreter fees was denied because there was no evidence of the quality or benefit of those services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. The appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment is a regular education kindergarten class.
  • Order to provide or change services. The full-time 1:1 aide must have enough knowledge of American Sign Language to interpret the student's signs for others and to teach him new signs that are appropriate to his developmental level and necessary for successful communication.
  • Order to provide or change services. The student must receive the services of a full inclusion specialist, trained in special education, as a member of his IEP team to help the regular education teacher with curriculum modification.
  • The IEP must be conformed to the decision within 15 days of the decision date.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland; Rowley; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Poolaw v. Bishop; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Judith Jacobs, pupil personnel services coordinator; IEP administrator, District
  • Regina Robinson, school psychologist, District (Wilson Elementary School)
  • Dr. Maurice Cayem, psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Lynn Smithey, full inclusion specialist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Nanette Meldrum, behavior specialist; witness for Student, East Los Angeles Regional Center
  • Matthew Pope, clients' rights advocate; witness for Student, East Los Angeles Regional Center
  • Dr. Eugene Couture, neuropsychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Kristine Swanson, speech therapist, District
  • Nina Perret, speech therapist, District
  • Charlene Birgy, augmentative communication specialist, Los Angeles County Office of Education
  • Richard Tauer, principal, Wilson Elementary School
  • Jill Soto, resource specialist, Wilson Elementary School
  • Kris (Kristen) Carbonell, special day class teacher (1995-96), Wilson Elementary School
  • Gloria Duvardo, special day class aide, Wilson Elementary School
  • Francois Polifroni, TYKE (regular education) teacher, Wilson Elementary School
  • Karen Westphaln, regular education kindergarten teacher, Wilson Elementary School
  • Mrs. Nielsen, special day class teacher (1994-95), Wilson Elementary School
  • Debra Blackburn, 1:1 aide (1994-95), District
  • Cynthia Gareeb, private sign language interpreter for home program
  • Excellence in Education Academy, home-schooling support organization

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Leonard Garfinkel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Gabriel, California, on June 6 and 7 and October 3, 1995, and January 29 and 30 and March 4, 1996.(Footnote 1)

Petitioner was represented by attorney Joseph Rhine. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents, PARENTS.

Respondent was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on behalf of the District were Judith Jacobs, pupil personnel services coordinator, and Regina Robinson, school psychologist.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of Petitioner:

PARENTS; Dr. Maurice Cayem, psychologist; Lynn Smithey, full inclusion specialist; Nanette Meldrum, behavior specialist; Matthew Pope, clients' rights advocate, East Los Angeles Regional Center; and Dr. Eugene Couture, neuropsychologist.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of Respondent: Ms. Jacobs; Ms. Robinson; Kristine Swanson, speech therapist; Nina Perret, speech therapist; Charlene Birgy, augmentative communication specialist, Los Angeles County Office of Education; and the following staff members of Wilson Elementary School: Richard Tauer, principal; Jill Soto, resource specialist; Kris Carbonell, special day class teacher; Gloria Duvardo, special day class aide; Francois Polifroni, Two Year Kindergarten Experience (TYPE) teacher; and Karen Westphaln, kindergarten teacher.

Oral, documentary, and video evidence was received. The record was left open until March 20, 1996, for the receipt of closing briefs. At that time the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. What is the least restrictive appropriate environment (LRE) for STUDENT?

2. Does STUDENT require the full-time assistance of an aide fluent in American Sign Language in order to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE)?

3. Does STUDENT require the intermittent services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

4. Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?

5. If not, must the District reimburse the parents for expenditures made on their home schooling of STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner asserts that the least restrictive appropriate environment (LRE) for STUDENT is in a regular education class. Petitioner also asserts that in order to receive a free, appropriate education, STUDENT requires the assistance of both a full-time, one-to-one aide proficient in American Sign Language and a full inclusion specialist.

Respondent District asserts that the least restrictive environment for STUDENT is in a special day class (SDC) on a campus which allows some opportunity for interaction with nondisabled peers.(Footnote 2) The District agrees that sign language is one appropriate method of communication for STUDENT -- along with verbalization, gestures, and augmentative communication devices. However, the District believes that staff who work with STUDENT need only have some rudimentary knowledge of sign language, rather than proficiency.(Footnote 3) Finally, the District asserts that because the LRE for STUDENT in an SDC, he does not require the assistance of a full inclusion specialist.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT EVIDENCE

A. Chronological Summary

STUDENT is seven and one-half years old and lives with his parents in San Gabriel within the District. STUDENT has been diagnosed with Angelman's Syndrome, and exhibits several of its common characteristics, most notably mild to moderate mental retardation, severe expressive language delay, gross and fine motor skill deficits, and behavior problems. The most recent formal assessment data shows that he functions at about age 1.5 in expressive language and at about age three in most other areas. (R 16)

STUDENT attempts to communicate in a variety of ways, including verbalization, sign language, gestures, and augmentative communication devices. (While STUDENT has normal hearing, he uses some sign language as one mode of expressive communication to compensate for his difficulty with verbalization.) Because his expressive communication skills are limited, at times he makes physical contact with others in order to get their attention. The contact most commonly involves hugging, grabbing, and/or touching. At times, it has included hitting, kicking, and/or biting.

STUDENT began receiving special education services from the District in the fall of 1991, when he turned three years old. For several years, he attended preschool programs for disabled students. He also received individualized speech and language therapy, adapted physical education (APE), and occupational therapy (OT). In April 1994, when STUDENT was five years old, his parents requested that he be mainstreamed with nondisabled students. From April through June 1994, STUDENT was placed in the Two Year Kindergarten Experience (TYKE) program at Wilson Elementary School, with PARENT serving as his one-to-one aide. (R 5)

The TYKE program is for students with normal abilities who are not developmentally ready for traditional kindergarten. It is a regular education program and has no special education component. In the first year of the TYKE program, the students attend a developmental, regular education kindergarten. In the second year, they attend the more traditional, academic regular education kindergarten. The program provides these students with an extra year of opportunity to mature, both physically and mentally, before entering traditional kindergarten. The TYKE curriculum places less emphasis on pre-academic skills than does the traditional kindergarten curriculum. The TYKE curriculum is an "experiential" one, focusing on physical and social activities and transitions between activities.

During the fall of 1994 STUDENT attended an SDC for mildly to moderately retarded students in the morning, and the TYKE class (for 80 minutes) in the afternoon (R 4). The SDC included eleven special education students in grades 1-3, the teacher, and three adult aides. The TYKE class included twenty-five regular education students, two teachers, and a part-time aide. In both classes, STUDENT was assisted by a one-to-one aide, Debra Blackburn. As the year progressed, Ms. Blackburn received some instruction in rudimentary sign language from District staff, and developed some knowledge of STUDENT's signs.

The PARENTS were unhappy with the SDC. They believed that the class was unstructured, lacked an appropriate behavior management program, and did not offer appropriate peer social and language role models for STUDENT. They also believed that the SDC staff had insufficient ability in sign language to assist STUDENT with communication. In February 1995, the PARENTS filed a request for a due process hearing, in which they sought full-time, regular education placement in the TYKE class and a full-time sign language interpreter for STUDENT.

Pursuant to a mediation agreement in March 1995, STUDENT's time in the afternoon TYKE class was nearly doubled -- from 80 minutes to 150 minutes. By the latter part of the school year, the parents remained convinced that the TYKE class was an appropriate placement and that the SDC was not. On June 9, 1995, the parents advised the District that they were removing STUDENT from the SDC, but that he would continue to attend the TYKE class and his related services such as speech and language therapy, APE and OT. They advised that STUDENT would receive home schooling pending resolution of due process. (R 39)

On August 28, 1995, the District notified the parents that STUDENT's placement for 1995-96 would be in the SDC he previously attended, with a new teacher, Kristen Carbonel. (P 15) The written placement notice did not mention any mainstreaming of STUDENT into regular education classes. On September 13, the parents informed the District that STUDENT would not attend Ms. Carbonel's SDC, but rather would continue to receive home schooling. They stated that STUDENT would continue to attend his related services and that they would hire a sign language interpreter for his home schooling. (R 38)

On September 19, 1995, the District advised PARENT that because she did not have a teaching credential, her home schooling of STUDENT did not meet state compulsory education requirements. The District directed PARENT to contact the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE). (R 37) LACOE told PARENT that it did not provide a home teaching program for students of STUDENT's age and with his special needs. The District then advised that it could provide both educational materials and curriculum supervision by a credentialed teacher for STUDENT's home schooling program if the PARENTS would allow the District to place STUDENT's name on the SDC class roster. The parents refused.

In late October, the parents paid an enrollment fee to the Excellence in Education Academy, an organization which provided nominal supervision of PARENT's home teaching of STUDENT. (P 16) The parents also continued to use the services of a privately obtained sign language interpreter, Cynthia Gareeb, for assistance with STUDENT's home program. (P 13, 16)

In February 1996, the District sought the parents' permission to conduct an assessment of STUDENT's sign language ability. The parents declined on the grounds that they believed the proposed assessment would measure receptive sign language ability, but not expressive.

B. Testimony of Petitioner's Witnesses

1. PARENT

PARENT has always sought to be very involved in STUDENT's classroom and curriculum during his school career. She is a very assertive parent and at times may, in her words, "come on too strong" when advising staff how she thinks they should work with STUDENT.

PARENT believes that the SDC taught by Mrs. Nielsen which STUDENT attended during 1994-95 was inappropriate. The class lacked structure and an effective, positive behavior management program. Staff often told students "no" and recorded negative behavior, but they failed to use appropriate positive reinforcers such as stickers for good behavior. Mrs. Nielsen was not able to control STUDENT's behavior effectively. In early 1995, the parents obtained through East Los Angeles Regional Center the services of an in-home behavior specialist, Nanette Meldrum.

PARENT testified that the TYKE class, on the other hand, was appropriate for STUDENT. STUDENT imitates peer behavior, and in the TYKE class he was able to model behavior more appropriate than she observed in the SDC class. For example, in the SDC class photo, STUDENT appears to be waving his arms and is not looking at the camera. A number of other students are not sitting up straight. In the TYKE class photo, on the other hand, STUDENT, like his classmates, is standing up straight, looking directly at the camera, and smiling. (P 11)

PARENT, who has some sign language ability, believes STUDENT has a vocabulary of about 300 words, most of which he signs. At times, he signs spontaneously, such as when he developed his own sign for "Nutcracker" after seeing the Christmas show. Some of his signs are gross approximations of proper signs. In some cases, he vocalizes along with the sign. He also uses gestures and his Alpha talker. (The Alpha talker is an augmentative communication device that contains a number of picture symbols representing messages. When STUDENT selects a picture symbol, a pre-recorded voice presents the corresponding message out loud.) While Ms.Blackburn, STUDENT's one-to-one aide during 1994-95, learned some signs that year, PARENT believes the aide did not have sufficient signing ability to assist STUDENT in the classroom.

2. Maurice Cayem

Dr. Cayem, a psychologist, was retained by Petitioner to conduct an independent assessment of STUDENT. He observed STUDENT in both the SDC and the TYKE class at Wilson School in May 1995. (P 1)

Dr. Cayem testified that in the SDC, STUDENT did not interact much with the other children. He pushed one student away and sought adult attention with his behavior. He paid attention to the task at hand briefly, but was often distracted by the level of activity in the room. For example, one student was rolling around, bumping into people, playing with his feet, pushing and kicking.

The TYKE class was quieter and more structured. The other students exhibited few behavior problems. STUDENT was attentive the whole time and interacted somewhat with his peers. He did not use the Alpha talker or sign very much; he used some gestures.

Dr. Cayem stated that, in his opinion, the TYKE class was better for STUDENT than the SDC. He noted that STUDENT's major problem is expressive language, and asserted that, therefore, STUDENT should be placed with peers who speak better than he does. He believes STUDENT's aggressive behavior is a manifestation of frustrated communication. He also believes that STUDENT must make extensive use of sign language in order to participate successfully in regular education. He believes the Alpha talker is too cumbersome to be used in everyday life.

3. Nanette Meldrum

Ms. Meldrum, a behavior specialist, provided behavioral training to STUDENT in his home on behalf of East Los Angeles Regional Center during the spring of 1995. She also observed STUDENT in both the SDC and the TYKE class that spring. (P 7)

In the SDC class, Ms. Meldrum did not observe STUDENT exhibiting behavior problems. However, staff reported to her that (1) STUDENT often showed frustration when his peers did not understand him, (2) he showed some frustration when his one-to-one aide did not understand his signs, and (3) he had some compliance problems with the teacher, Ms. Nielsen. Ms. Nielsen told Ms. Meldrum that there were students in the class who modeled each other's poor behavior; however, Ms. Nielsen felt that there were no major behavior problems in the class and that her current behavior strategies were working sufficiently well. She told Ms. Meldrum that a formal behavior intervention plan was not necessary for STUDENT.

In the TYKE class, Ms. Meldrum did not observe STUDENT to exhibit behavior problems. In that class, he was more animated, and appeared to enjoy interacting with peers. The other students seemed receptive to his use of sign language. PARENT facilitated and mediated his communication with his peers. STUDENT was more motivated to use his Alpha talker, did not show frustration, and was more compliant with the teacher.

Ms. Meldrum testified that, in her opinion, the TYKE class was a better placement for STUDENT than the SDC. She stated that the TYKE class contained appropriate peer social and language role models. Additionally, in that class, STUDENT's peers could understand him better and showed interest in learning his signs. Ms. Meldrum believes that in order to participate successfully in regular education and avoid frustration, STUDENT requires the support of someone with good sign language ability who can facilitate and mediate his communication with the teacher and his peers. Because he has an extensive repertoire of signs, the use of sign language is critical to his ability to participate successfully in regular education.

4. Lynn Smithey

Ms. Smithey, a special educator and full inclusion specialist, was retained by Petitioner to conduct an independent assessment of STUDENT. She observed him for one full class period in both the SDC and the TYKE class in May 1995. (P 3) Ms. Smithey observed that, in both classes, STUDENT was assisted by an aide who monitored his behavior, gave him prompts, and helped him with instructions.

In the SDC, STUDENT engaged in 18 incidents of aggressive behavior -- five of them on the way back from recess.(Footnote 3) Eleven of the incidents involved adults and seven involved peers. STUDENT's aggressive behavior was at times fairly intense -- hitting, kicking and throwing objects. STUDENT appeared to engage in the behavior for the purpose of getting adult attention, which he did receive. One other student besides STUDENT was kicking other students. The teacher, Ms. Nielsen, told Ms. Smithey that she believed her behavioral strategies were working sufficiently and that there was no need for a formal behavior intervention plan for STUDENT.

In the TYKE class, STUDENT engaged in only three incidents of aggressive behavior, all involving peers. These incidents involved less intense behavior -- for example, pushing -- than was observed in the SDC. The teacher, Mr. Polifroni, was able to manage STUDENT's behavior with physical proximity and touches on the arm. The other students seemed interested in playing with STUDENT.

Ms. Smithey stated that, in her opinion, a regular education placement is appropriate for STUDENT because it will allow him to learn from nondisabled social and language peer role models. She believes he requires the assistance of an aide with good sign language ability to monitor his behavior and assist the teacher. She believes that, with such support, STUDENT could acquire academic skills, albeit at a slower rate than his classmates. She recommended that the District provide STUDENT's teacher with access to a special education teacher for assistance with curriculum modification. She stated that such a "full inclusion expert" would be a member of STUDENT's IEP team who would provide intermittent services. The full inclusion expert would be more heavily involved at the outset of the mainstreaming experience, and would fade out as time passed.

5. Eugene Couture

Dr. Couture is a neuropsychologist who was retained by Petitioner to perform an independent assessment of STUDENT in May 1995. (P 5) He found that STUDENT had an IQ of 39, placing him in the mildly to moderately retarded range. He determined that STUDENT was functioning, cognitively, at about age 3 and that his receptive language skills were far ahead of his expressive language skills. Dr. Couture, who demonstrated some sign language proficiency while illustrating a point during a portion of his testimony, also assessed STUDENT's sign language ability. He found that STUDENT's signing ability is what one would expect in a three-year-old signer. He noted that while STUDENT is not developing speech well, he is spontaneously and naturally using signs and sometimes uses vocalization along with a sign.

Dr. Couture testified that, in his opinion, STUDENT's school program should employ a total communication approach involving signs, gestures, and words.(Footnote 5) He noted that the purpose of sign language for a hearing child such as STUDENT is to help him to learn to speak, not to make him a good signer. Dr. Couture stated that STUDENT requires the assistance of an aide with fairly good signing ability. The aide could (1) interpret for STUDENT what the teacher is saying, (2) teach him new signs, (3) give him prompts to communicate with peers, and (4) facilitate his communication with peers and the teacher. Because the main focus of STUDENT's IEP is developing language, the aide should assist STUDENT on a full-time basis.

6. PARENT

PARENT testified that he and PARENT have made a number of expenditures on STUDENT's home schooling program during the 1995-96 school year. These include educational materials such as books and supplies ($511.10); sign language interpreter fees ($1,120.00); mileage for sign language interpreter sessions ($65.00); mileage for local supply trips ($54.00); and an enrollment fee for the Excellence in Education (EIE) Academy ($150.00). (P 16)

PARENT stated that the interpreter, Ms. Gareeb, is pursuing a degree in sign language interpreting at a local community college. (P 13) He described the EIE Academy as an organization which provides support to parents who are home schooling their children. He noted that EIE provides the PARENTS with access to a credentialed teacher for support. He did not provide details as to what specific support, if any, EIE and/or its credentialed teachers have provided to the PARENTS.

C. Testimony of District's Witnesses

1. Francois Polifroni

Mr. Polifroni was STUDENT's TYKE teacher from April-June 1994 and during the 1994-95 school year. The daily schedule in TYKE included rug time and circle time (large group activities such as stories and songs), small group academics, free choice time and play time. The program emphasized socialization with other children, fine motor skills such as cutting, following directions, transitioning from one activity to another, visual discrimination skills, and hands-on activities with colors, shapes, patterns, puzzles and blocks.

STUDENT's TYKE class lasted from 11:40 a.m. to 2:20 p.m. There were twenty-six students age 4 and 5, one teacher, and one classroom aide. STUDENT, the only special education student in the class, was assisted by a one-to-one aide, Ms. Blackburn.

During large group activities in rug and circle time, STUDENT did well. He sat quietly, was receptive to and able to focus on and follow the stories and songs, and participated in discussions. STUDENT learned how to interact with a group of children and was able to model appropriate social skills. Mr. Polifroni believed that acquiring social skills was the major purpose of STUDENT's attendance in the TYKE class.

During small-group academics, STUDENT had a more difficult time. He was not as able as the other students. He functioned at about age 2 or 3 in most areas, slightly higher in receptive language. He was able to follow some one-step commands, but not two-step commands. He needed a lot of assistance and prompting from his aide to stay on task and follow the activity. STUDENT would get frustrated and exhibit a short attention span. He was able to stay on task for only 10-30 seconds before he had to be directed back by the aide. The curriculum appeared to be beyond his ability, even with the help of the aide, and he did not appear to gain much academic benefit.

Mr. Polifroni did not attempt to teach STUDENT academics. He believed that STUDENT was learning his academics in the SDC and that he was attending the TYKE class for social reasons. Therefore, he did not make modifications to the academic curriculum for STUDENT. The TYKE class did not have a special education component, and Mr. Polifroni did not have much experience in making curriculum modifications for special education students. He acknowledged that it might have been helpful to have the assistance of a full inclusion specialist, trained in special education, to make modifications to the academic curriculum for STUDENT. Mr. Polifroni believed that while STUDENT may have received an opportunity to practice his academic skills in the TYKE class -- recognition of colors and shapes, for example -- he was actually learning these skills in the SDC, not the TYKE class.

STUDENT communicated with other TYKE students using verbalization, his Alpha talker, and sign language, in that order of priority. At times, he attempted to get other childrens' attention in a physical way, such as by touching, grabbing or hugging them, or even kicking them. His interactions with other children were sometimes good, sometimes not. STUDENT at times became frustrated with communication problems, and other children at times became frustrated with him when he was physical with them. (Other children in the class also exhibited physical behavior during the year, but the other children had, for the most part, ceased such behavior by the end of the year.) STUDENT's one-to-one aide, Ms. Blackburn, was helpful in letting the other children know that STUDENT's physical behavior was simply an effort to communicate with them. Mr. Polifroni agreed that STUDENT's education would be greatly enhanced if his expressive language could be improved.

Mr. Polifroni believes that STUDENT benefitted from the TYKE program because he was able to model appropriate social skills, and also gain access to materials such as manipulatives and a rich playground environment which might not have been available in other settings. His expressive communication improved somewhat. He believes that an SDC is more appropriate than regular education for teaching STUDENT academic skills. He did not have an opinion as to whether an SDC or regular education was a better setting for learning social skills. 2. Gloria Duvardo

Ms. Duvardo was an aide in Mrs. Nielsen's SDC during the 1994-95 school year. She observed that STUDENT had a very low attention span -- he could attend for only 5-10 seconds at a time. He was very distractible and had a hard time focusing. He worked on such skills as cutting, coloring, and identifying objects, letters and numbers. He made some limited progress on skills but still had a long way to go. By the end of the year, STUDENT could do some matching with assistance, name some letters and numbers, and follow instructions somewhat better.

STUDENT was encouraged by the SDC staff to use his voice. He used vocalization more than sign. Ms. Duvardo recalls STUDENT saying "cookie." He signed very little; she recalls him signing "bathroom" and "candy." He used his Alpha talker only when prompted. By the end of the year STUDENT, was trying to verbalize more than he had at the beginning of the year.

During the last few months of the school year, STUDENT's behavior in the SDC became significantly worse. Perhaps two or three times each day STUDENT would hit, kick, or attempt to bite staff and/or peers, or knock over furniture. On those occasions, staff would physically remove him from the situation to calm him down. Although STUDENT was considered the student with the most significant behavior problem in the class, no special behavioral interventions -- such as a Hughes Bill assessment -- were undertaken.

When PARENT was present in the SDC room that year, it was often harder to get STUDENT to calm down. However, during the latter part of the year, when his behavior became worse, PARENT was in the room less than she had been at the beginning of the year. Therefore, Ms. Duvardo testified, the increase in STUDENT's behavior problems at the end of the year was not attributable to PARENT's presence in the room.

3. Judith Jacobs

Ms. Jacobs has been the administrator at most of STUDENT's IEP meetings during his tenure in the District, including the October 1994 meeting. At that time STUDENT was attending both Ms. Nielsen's SDC and Mr. Polifroni's TYKE class. The IEP prepared then included goals and objectives in numerous areas. The skill areas, with examples of corresponding goals and objectives in parentheses, were: (1) social/emotional (following instructions, exhibiting appropriate social skills, staying on task); (2) pre-academic (coloring, cutting, identifying objects, colors and letters, counting); (3) gross and fine motor skills (matching, running, jumping, catching and throwing); (4) self-care (snapping pants); and (5) speech and language (improving vocalization). (R 3)

Based on discussions with both of STUDENT's teachers at the end of the 1994-95 school year, Ms. Jacobs concluded that STUDENT met some goals (following instructions, recognizing his name, matching, snapping his pants), partially met some others (identifying colors) and did not meet some others (exhibiting appropriate social skills, staying on task, coloring, counting, grouping, identifying letters, distinguishing right and left). There were some goals which STUDENT could not meet independently but which he was able to meet with the assistance of his aide -- for example, sitting in a circle with his hands to himself for ten minutes, and cutting.

In the summer of 1995, Ms. Jacobs determined that the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year was in the SDC for mildly to moderately retarded students in grades 1-3, which is now taught by Kris Carbonell. (P 15) STUDENT required more support than was available in the regular education classroom, even with curriculum modification and an aide. He was very distractible and he engaged in aggressive, disruptive behavior in order to get other students' attention. The SDC offered a small class setting with individualized attention, a specialized curriculum geared to providing instruction at his level, behavior modification, and some opportunities for mainstreaming.

4. Regina Robinson

Ms. Robinson is the school psychologist assigned to Wilson Elementary School. During the 1994-95 school year, she observed STUDENT in both the SDC and the TYKE class two or three times each month for an average of fifteen minutes per observation.

Ms. Robinson testified that, in the SDC, STUDENT appeared to be a comfortable, enthusiastic participant. He functioned in the lower range of the class, but was able to work at approximately the same level as his peers without constant assistance from an aide. He used several modes of communication. Ms. Nielsen had some difficulty controlling the class; however, STUDENT's behavior was sufficiently controlled such that he did not require a formal behavior intervention plan.

In the TYKE class, the curriculum was way over STUDENT's head. His aide had to be right with him in order for him to perform any skill, and, in some cases, the aide had to perform the skill for him. He was not able to be as independent as he could be in the SDC. The one-to-one aide stigmatized STUDENT as being different from the other students. He had great difficulty staying on task and exhibited more inappropriate behavior than he did in the SDC. The behavior was the result of frustrated attempts to communicate with peers. He would attempt to get their attention physically -- for example, by hugging them. It was difficult to control STUDENT's behavior in such a large class.

STUDENT's presence in the TYKE class did not impair the learning or safety of the other students. He never injured another student. However, by the Spring of 1995, the potential for safety problems was developing. STUDENT was older and physically larger than the other TYKE students. He could potentially injure another child if he attempted to hug or hit them. Some students seemed to cringe when STUDENT came near. At times at recess, he attempted to hit or bite other children, and on one occasion he knocked an aide's glasses off.

Ms. Robinson stated that, in her opinion, the appropriate placement for STUDENT is Ms. Carbonell's SDC for mildly-to-moderately retarded students in grades 1-3. Because of Angelman's Syndrome, the highest academic level STUDENT will achieve in his lifetime will be 4th-6th grade, and he will never engage in abstract reasoning. He is too old for the TYKE program, and is not able to independently do things required in regular education kindergarten, such as performing skills, handling free choice time, and following multistep directions. If he were placed in regular education kindergarten, he would frequently be off-task and would become frustrated.

Even in Ms. Carbonell's SDC, Ms. Robinson stated, STUDENT would be one of the lowest functioning students. However, in the SDC, he would benefit from behavior modification, individualized instruction geared to his cognitive level, a slower pace, plenty of reinforcement, self-help skills, a functional skills curriculum, some opportunities for mainstreaming, and the opportunity to work on his IEP goals in pre-academics, communication and behavior.

5. Charlene Birgy

Ms. Birgy is an augmentative communication specialist for the Los Angeles County Office of Education. She testified regarding STUDENT's use of the Alpha talker device.

In October 1994, STUDENT began using an Alpha talker furnished by Regional Center in the TYKE class. In November 1994 Ms. Birgy began a one-month assessment of STUDENT's use of the Alpha Talker in the SDC at circle time and story time. (R 11) Her assessment report, prepared in January 1995, noted that both the SDC and TYKE teachers felt the device was benefiting STUDENT. Mr. Polifroni, the TYKE teacher, told Ms. Birgy that the device "increased [STUDENT's] participation in communication-based activities and his classmates respond to him with interest and pay better attention to him when he uses the Alpha Talker than when he signs or speaks." (R 11) Based on Ms. Birgy's recommendation, in January 1995 the use of the Alpha talker was incorporated into STUDENT's school program.

During the spring of 1995, Ms. Birgy observed STUDENT on a monthly basis in both the SDC and the TYKE class. She determined that the Alpha Talker helped him to communicate, most particularly in the TYKE class. There, STUDENT often successfully used the Alpha Talker in a group to answer questions about a story. While his TYKE peers often did not notice or understand STUDENT's signs, they noticed and understood him more when he used the Alpha talker. 6. Jill Soto

Ms. Soto is a resource specialist at Wilson Elementary School. She holds a credential which entitles her to teach hearing-impaired students, and has some proficiency in sign language. Ms. Soto observed STUDENT in both the SDC (approximately once per week) and the TYKE class (approximately once every two weeks) during the 1994-95 school year.

In the SDC, STUDENT never worked independently, but rather was always accompanied by a one-to-one aide. He was easily distractible. He tried to communicate using sign, gestures, vocalization, and the Alpha talker. In the spring of 1995, he seemed somewhat more aggressive and/or upset than he had earlier in the year. She observed him to chew his nails more and to kick an aide on the playground.

In the TYKE class, STUDENT was distractible and constantly monitored by his aide to keep him on task. He had difficulty cutting, and could not complete academic projects the way the other students could. He had no behavior problems in class -- his one-to-one aide was effective in monitoring his behavior -- but he engaged in some pushing and shoving when lining up to go to recess. On the playground he liked to go on the swings and play catch with other children. On one occasion he hit a child on the swingset.

In Ms. Soto's opinion, Ms. Carbonell's SDC is presently the appropriate placement for STUDENT. She believes the class is geared to his functioning level. In the SDC, he would rank in about the middle of the class in terms of functioning level. In a regular education class, on the other hand, he would be the lowest-functioning student. STUDENT is too old for the TYKE program and not able to independently perform tasks required in regular education kindergarten. In kindergarten, children perform such tasks as cutting, letter recognition, sequencing, beginning phonics, handwriting, and beginning number concepts.

With respect to communication, Ms. Soto observed STUDENT using all four of his modes of communication -- Alpha talker, verbalization, sign language and gestures -- in both classes. She believes the Alpha talker is STUDENT's most effective mode of communication. His speech is difficult to understand. While he signs better than he verbalizes, many people don't know sign, and STUDENT's lack of fine motor dexterity makes signing difficult for him.

When she screened STUDENT's signing ability in October 1995, Ms. Soto observed him to perform about ten signs accurately. He was also able to "approximate" about 20-30 signs. In order to understand the approximations, the viewer would need to know the context of the communication. Ms. Soto stated that signing is not STUDENT's first choice of communication modes, except when persons such as herself who have some proficiency in sign language are present. Then sign does become his preferred mode.

Ms. Soto agreed that sign language must play a role in STUDENT's education. There must be a staff member available to teach him some new signs and to interpret what he is signing for others. However, a fluent signer would have more skill than is necessary. During 1994-95, she taught STUDENT's SDC teacher, Ms. Nielsen, and his one-to-one aide, Ms. Blackburn, enough signs to "stay one step ahead of STUDENT".

7. Kristine Swanson

Ms. Swanson is a District speech therapist who worked with STUDENT during the summer of 1995. She knows some sign language. During their sessions, STUDENT communicated using the following modes, in decreasing order of frequency: (1) gestures, (2) signs, (3) Alpha Talker, and (4) vocalization. He used some signs without prompting, but did not use the Alpha Talker without prompting. At times during their sessions, STUDENT hit or kicked Ms. Swanson. When PARENT was present, STUDENT became very excited and had trouble focusing.

Ms. Swanson believes STUDENT should be encouraged to continue to use all four of his modes of communication. The Alpha Talker is valuable because its output is understandable to everyone. Sign language must also play a role in STUDENT's education. He must be accompanied by someone who knows some sign language in order to help him understand and be understood.

8. Nina Perret

Ms. Perret is a District speech therapist who has worked with STUDENT since January 1995. Ms. Perret does not know sign language. In her January 1995 assessment report, Ms. Perret found that STUDENT's expressive language was at about 20 months. (R 10) Ms. Perret wrote "[STUDENT] continues to exhibit a severe articulation delay characterized primarily by unintelligible single words/vocalizations." Id.

During the Spring of 1995, Ms. Perret worked with STUDENT in both the SDC and the TYKE class twice weekly. For purposes of communication, the TYKE class was superior to the SDC for STUDENT. The TYKE class had more students who were good language role models, and the TYKE students' utterances were lengthier than those of the SDC students.

Since January 1995 STUDENT has made slow, inconsistent, limited progress on the speech and language goals and objectives contained in his IEP. He has used four modes of communication. When a person who signs is present, STUDENT uses sign language more. He needs prompting to use the Alpha Talker. She believes the Alpha Talker and gestures are his most effective modes of communication.

Ms. Perret has continued to work with STUDENT on an individual basis during the 1995-96 school year, during which time he has been schooled at home. His progress on speech goals and objectives has been slower since he began home schooling because he lacks needed interaction with peer role models.

9. Richard Tauer

Mr. Tauer is the principal of Wilson Elementary School. During the 1994-95 school year, both of STUDENT's teachers, Mrs. Nielsen in the SDC and Mr. Polifroni in the TYKE class, reported to him that PARENT was interfering with the performance of their duties. More specifically, the teachers reported that on several occasions PARENT entered the classroom unannounced and attempted to alter the class activity in a way that she believed was best for STUDENT. On February 15, 1995, Mr. Tauer wrote PARENT a letter requesting that she gain approval at the front office before entering the school and refrain from volunteering in any classroom unless it was specifically scheduled with the teacher. (R 33)

10. Karen Westphaln

Ms. Westphaln teaches the regular education kindergarten class at Wilson Elementary School. There are currently 33 students in the class, none of whom are served by special education. Class activities include pre-academics, socialization, free choice time, physical education, and transitioning between activities. Students work on all of the following: counting, manipulatives, telling time, measurement, names, letters, sounds, stories, literature, making choices, and appropriate social interaction with peers. (R 40)

Ms. Westphaln observed STUDENT on campus at Wilson Elementary School during the 1994-95 school year. She saw him play with others, and at times observed him to touch or grab other children in a friendly, happy way, surprising them. On one occasion, she saw STUDENT bite another child at lunch.

Ms. Westphaln testified that, in her opinion, it would be difficult for STUDENT to receive any academic benefit from her class because it is not geared to his needs. She does not favor one-to-one aides because she believes they foster dependence rather than independence.

11. Kristen Carbonell

Ms. Carbonnel is presently the teacher of the SDC for mildly-to-moderately retarded students at Wilson School. The class includes twelve students in grades 1-3 and three aides. The students' functioning level ranges from preschool to first grade in various skill areas. Ms. Carbonell uses a wide variety of class activities including matching, manipulatives, stories, computers, and art projects.

None of Ms. Carbonell's students is mainstreamed into a regular education classroom for any portion of the day, with the exception of one student who attends the TYKE class for part of the morning. The students have the opportunity to interact with nondisabled students at lunch and recess, and her class is planning to take a field trip with a regular education class. At times, regular education students come to her class to help out -- a concept referred to as "reverse mainstreaming."

Ms. Carbonell stated that the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's most recent IEP (R 3) are similar to those contained in the IEPs of her other students. She believes she could successfully implement STUDENT's IEP in her class.

DISCUSSION

1. What is the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT?

Although educators frequently use the terms "mainstreaming" and "full inclusion," neither term is defined by federal or state special education law. Both federal and state law require, however, that in order to receive a free, appropriate education (FAPE), disabled students must be educated in the "least restrictive environment (LRE)." 34 C.F.R. §300.550 et seq.; Education Code §56031. The federal LRE mandate provides:

. . . to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities . . . [should be] educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B). The federal regulations note that the term "supplementary aids and services" is synonymous with "modifications," and describes what is done to the regular education program to ensure a disabled student's satisfactory participation in that program. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix Part C, q. 48. Common examples of supplementary aids and services include a one-to-one aide, curriculum adaptations, and assistive technology.(Footnote 6)

California's Education Code notes that the LRE requirement "promotes maximum interaction [of disabled children] with the general school population in a manner which is appropriate to the needs of both." Education Code §56001(g); §56031. The Code provides that disabled students shall attend special classes only when "the nature or severity of the disability precludes their participation in the regular school program for a majority of a school day." Education Code §56364. The relevant section of the Code, which mirrors the federal provision, continues:

Special classes and centers and other removal of individuals with exceptional needs from the regular education environment shall occur only when education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily due to the nature and severity of the exceptional need." Education Code §56364.

The IDEA's LRE provision reflects Congress's preference for educating disabled students in regular classrooms with their nondisabled peers. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1403 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994) (hereafter referred to as "Rachel H."). Because of this statutory presumption in favor of mainstreaming, the District bears the burden to show that its proposed placement provides mainstreaming "to the maximum extent appropriate" for STUDENT. Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874, 880 and n.7 (E.D. Cal. 1992) (hereafter "Board v. Holland"), aff'd sub nom. Rachel H., supra. The Ninth Circuit has adopted a four-factor test to consider in determining whether the presumption in favor of mainstreaming has been overcome in a particular case:

a. the educational benefits available in the regular class with the use of supplementary aids and services;

b. the nonacademic benefits of interacting with nondisabled students;

c. any negative effects that the child's presence in the regular class has on the teacher and other students;

d. the cost of mainstreaming.

Rachel H., supra, at 1404; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 (9th Cir. 1994); Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 836 (9th Cir. 1995). Each of these factors is applied to the facts of this case below.

a. Educational benefits available in the regular class

The issue here is not whether STUDENT can keep pace academically with students of far greater cognitive ability, but, rather, whether he can make progress on his IEP goals and objectives in the regular classroom with the use of supplementary aids and services such as curriculum modification and a one-to-one aide. Rachel H., supra, 14 F.3d at 1401.(Footnote 7) As the federal district court stated in Board v. Holland:

[I]f the child's disabilities are so severe that he or she will receive little or no benefit from placement in a regular education class, then mainstreaming may not be appropriate . . . However, the Act's requirement of integration, based on recognition of the non-academic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom . . . The Act's presumption in favor of mainstreaming requires that a handicapped child be educated in a regular classroom if the child can receive a satisfactory education there, even if it is not the best academic setting for that child. Further, in considering the relative educational benefits available in integrated and non-integrated settings, the school district must demonstrate that it has considered whether supplemental aids and services will permit satisfactory education in the regular classroom . . . Only if the child cannot receive a satisfactory education in the regular education class, even if the appropriate support services are offered, should the child be placed in a special education class.

Board v. Holland, supra, 786 F. Supp. at 878-879.

The District asserts that the regular education academic curriculum is too difficult for STUDENT, even with an aide, and that he would receive no academic benefit from mainstreaming. The District asserts that the SDC is a better setting for STUDENT to learn academics because its curriculum is geared to his cognitive level. To evaluate the correctness of these assertions, one must examine STUDENT's experience in the regular education TYKE program during 1994-95.

The evidence showed that STUDENT made some progress on academic goals and objectives that year when he attended both the SDC and the TYKE program. Because of his cognitive difficulties, the progress was limited in both settings. The evidence was inconclusive as to how much of STUDENT's academic progress was attributable to each class. The evidence did show that, in the TYKE class, STUDENT had some success in answering questions about stories and songs and was able to perform certain tasks with the assistance of his aide. Therefore, the evidence does not support the District's assertion that the SDC would be a superior setting for the learning of academic skills.

In any event, the District has not sustained its burden to show that STUDENT cannot receive academic benefit from regular education with the use of supplementary aids and services. Mr. Polifroni, STUDENT's TYKE teacher, testified that he did not attempt to teach STUDENT academics -- he assumed STUDENT was learning academics in the SDC, and believed STUDENT was attending the TYKE program only for social reasons. Mr. Polifroni testified that he did not attempt to modify the academic curriculum for STUDENT. He also testified that he was not provided with the services of a special educator and/or inclusion specialist to assist with curriculum modification.

Because the District has not made a sufficient attempt to teach STUDENT academics in regular education with a modified curriculum -- and because it appears that STUDENT has, nevertheless, received some academic benefit from his experience in regular education -- the District has not sustained its burden to show that STUDENT cannot receive academic benefit from mainstreaming with appropriate supplementary aids or services. See, e.g., Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 882 and n.9 ("a placement in other than a regular class is a fall-back choice only after it is determined that placement in regular classes would be unsuccessful").(Footnote 8) Accordingly, this factor weighs in favor of mainstreaming.

b. Nonacademic benefits of interacting with nondisabled students

Significant nonacademic benefits of mainstreaming may include having appropriate peer language and behavior role models. Board v. Holland, supra, 786 F. Supp. at 879. This factor reflects the "fundamental purpose" of IDEA's mainstreaming requirement. Id. Appropriate peer language role models are particularly important for STUDENT, given his great difficulty with expressive language. Ms. Perret, the District speech therapist who served STUDENT in both the SDC and the TYKE class, testified that the TYKE class provided superior peer language role models. The TYKE class had more students who were good language role models, and the TYKE students' utterances were lengthier than those of the SDC students. No witness contradicted Ms. Perret on this point. There was also evidence that the TYKE students showed interest in STUDENT's Alpha Talker and signs and were better able to understand his attempts at communication than were the cognitively impaired students in the SDC.

With respect to behavior, the weight of evidence showed that STUDENT's behavior was somewhat better in the TYKE class than it was in the SDC, which had more students with behavior problems. Mr. Polifroni, the TYKE teacher, testified that STUDENT benefitted from modeling appropriate social skills in the TYKE class. In large group activities in rug and circle time, STUDENT did well. He sat quietly, was receptive to and able to focus on and follow the stories and songs, and participated in discussions.Mr. Polifroni's testimony corroborated the observations of Petitioner's expert witnesses, Dr. Cayem, Ms. Meldrum, and Ms. Smithey, all of whom testified that STUDENT appeared to benefit from exposure to appropriate social peer role models in the TYKE class. Another example which illustrates this point is the TYKE class photo, in which STUDENT exhibits appropriate social skills. (P 11)

The evidence shows that STUDENT gains significant nonacademic benefits from participation in regular education classes, including the opportunity to model appropriate peer communication and behavior. Therefore, this factor weighs in favor of mainstreaming.

c. Negative effects that the child's presence in the regular class has on the teacher and other students

Such negative effects may include (a) disruptiveness and/or (b) taking up so much of the teacher's time that other children suffer from lack of attention. Rachel H., supra, 14 F.3d at 1401. This factor is derived in part from the federal regulations, which state in relevant part:

[W]here a [disabled child] is so disruptive in a regular classroom that the education of other students is significantly impaired, the needs of the [disabled] child cannot be met in that environment. Therefore regular placement would not be appropriate to his or needs.

34 C.F.R. §300.552, Note.

None of the witnesses who observed STUDENT in the TYKE class testified that his presence impaired the learning of the other students. Ms. Robinson, the school psychologist, specifically acknowledged that his presence did not do so. Mr. Polifroni, the TYKE teacher, did not testify that STUDENT's presence placed any particular burden on him or his time.

Mr. Polifroni, the TYKE teacher, has more knowledge than any other witness as to STUDENT's experience in regular education. Although various witnesses testified to having observed STUDENT hit, kick or bite at times in various school settings, Mr. Polifroni stated that STUDENT's physical behavior in TYKE consisted primarily of hugs, touches, and grabs of other children. These incidents often surprised, but never injured, the other children, and STUDENT's aide explained to them that these were attempts at communication. The evidence showed that STUDENT's behavior was, for the most part, effectively controlled by his aide. District witnesses testified that they believed STUDENT's behavior was sufficiently under control such that no extraordinary behavioral interventions were required.

It is concluded that STUDENT's presence in regular education classes does not have a negative impact on the teacher and other students. Even assuming that his presence did have some negative impact, before determining that a child is too disruptive to be mainstreamed, a school district must ensure that consideration has been given to the full range of supplementary aids and services that could be provided to the student in the regular education environment to accommodate his unique needs. U.S. Department of Education, Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP), Memorandum 95-9, 21 IDELR 1152, 1155 (1994); see also Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 n.7 (9th Cir. 1994); Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 879. One such supplementary aid or service is a behavioral intervention plan (BIP).

Under California's so-called Hughes Bill, if a child is exhibiting serious behavior problems that significantly interfere with implementation of his IEP, the District should conduct a functional analysis of his behavior for the purpose of developing a BIP. Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Sections 3001(f), 3052(b).(Footnote 9) California law notes that behavioral interventions are to be utilized "to assure the pupil's placement in the least restrictive environment." Education Code §56523(b)(2)(D); Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(d).

The District never sought to implement a BIP for STUDENT. This is susceptible of one of two interpretations. Either (1) STUDENT did not exhibit a "serious behavior problem" and therefore did not require such a plan -- as District witnesses testified at the hearing, or (2) STUDENT did require such a plan as a supplementary aid or service to ensure his success in regular education, but the District failed to provide one. Under either interpretation, the evidence does not show that, with appropriate supplementary aids or services, STUDENT's presence in a regular education class has a negative impact. Therefore, this factor favors mainstreaming.

d. Cost of mainstreaming

Only where the cost of mainstreaming a disabled child will significantly affect other children in the district will this factor weigh against placing a disabled child in a regular classroom. Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 880. Neither party presented any evidence on this factor. (The District asserted in its closing brief that it is in fact more expensive to educate STUDENT in an SDC than in regular education.) Therefore, there is no evidence that cost factors militate against mainstreaming STUDENT.

In conclusion, each of the four factors in the Ninth Circuit's test weighs in favor of mainstreaming STUDENT. Therefore, it is concluded that, presently, the least restrictive appropriate environment for STUDENT is in a regular education class.(Footnote 10)

With respect to the appropriate grade level, the parents have requested kindergarten. The Hearing Officer concludes that, presently, this is the most appropriate grade level for STUDENT's regular education placement. A traditional academic kindergarten, such as Ms. Westphaln's class at Wilson Elementary School, is the next logical step for STUDENT after his attendance in the developmental portion of the TYKE program. Although STUDENT will be as much as two years older than some of his fellow students, there was no evidence that the age difference is so pronounced that he will be modeling inappropriate behaviors or that he will not be perceived as part of the class. Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 883 n.10. Nor was there evidence that STUDENT's presence will impair the safety of the other students simply because he is physically larger than they are.

2. Does STUDENT require the full-time assistance of an aide fluent in American Sign Language in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

A free, appropriate education (FAPE) includes special education and related services that are individually designed to meet a disabled student's unique needs and that are reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. 20 U.S.C. §1400(c); §§1401(a)(16-18); Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982). The school district is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits to the child, but rather to provide a "basic floor of opportunity." Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200.(Footnote 11)

In determining whether the district has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program is adequate, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program, and even if the parents' preferred program is better (that is, would likely result in greater educational benefit to the child than the District's program). Id. In Rowley, the Supreme Court stated that so long as the school district's choice of educational methodology is reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, that choice is entitled to deference. 458 U.S. at 207-208.(Footnote 12)

This case, however, does not involve a dispute regarding educational methodology. The parties agree as to the communication methods which should be used in educating STUDENT. That is, both parties agree that STUDENT should be encouraged to use all four of his modes of communication -- signs, gestures, verbalization and the Alpha Talker. The parties also agree that STUDENT requires an aide with enough knowledge of American Sign Language to interpret what STUDENT is signing for others and to teach him some new signs. The testimony of District witnesses Ms. Soto and Ms. Swanson was in agreement with the testimony of Petitioner's expert witnesses Dr. Cayem, Ms. Smithey and Dr. Couture on this point.

The parties' disagreement concerns the degree of sign language proficiency that the aide must have. The dispute thus involves, generally, the nature and extent of the supplementary aids and services (or modifications) that STUDENT requires in order to successfully participate in regular education. See 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48. It also involves, more specifically, the necessary qualifications of the full-time, one-to-one aide assigned to STUDENT.

The parties have not cited any laws specifically relating to the qualifications of classroom aides assigned to disabled students.(Footnote 13) The determination must necessarily be made on a case-by-case basis. In this case, it must be based on STUDENT's individual needs. Petitioner asserts that the aide must possess "fluency" in American Sign Language. Petitioner defines fluency as having comparable experience and qualifications to the aides employed within Los Angeles County to work with deaf and hard-of-hearing students. Petitioner submitted a recent job announcement for such a position in a neighboring school district. (P 12) That position required (1) six months of full-time experience or its equivalent, including paid, volunteer or family-related experience, as an interpreter for the deaf using oral and manual forms of communication; and (2) the ability to communicate effectively using American Sign Language as measured by the "Instructional Interpreter Rating Scale."

The evidence from STUDENT's experience in the TYKE class showed that STUDENT can receive educational benefit in a regular education class, and make progress on his IEP goals and objectives, by employing all four of his modes of communication and receiving the assistance of an aide who has sign language ability equivalent to that possessed by his former aide, Ms. Blackburn. According to testimony, Ms. Blackburn received some instruction in sign language from Ms. Soto and became acquainted with STUDENT's signs. Neither party characterized her sign language ability as "fluent" as defined by Petitioner.

Accordingly, Petitioner's request for an order that STUDENT must be accompanied by an aide who is fluent in American Sign Language is denied. Rather, STUDENT's IEP must be amended to provide that one supplementary aid or service (or modification) that he requires in order to successfully participate in regular education is an aide with sufficient knowledge of American Sign Language to interpret what STUDENT is signing for others and to teach him those new signs that are both appropriate to his developmental level and necessary to his successful communication. See 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B); 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48.

3. Does STUDENT require the intermittent services of an inclusion specialist in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

Petitioner's inclusion expert, Ms. Smithey, testified that STUDENT requires the services of an inclusion expert in order to ensure his success in a regular education class. She testified that such a person would be a credentialed special education teacher who would provide support and assistance to the regular education teacher with respect to such matters as curriculum modification. The inclusion expert would be a member of STUDENT's IEP team who would provide intermittent services, being more heavily involved at the outset of the mainstreaming experience, and fading out as time passed. Mr. Polifroni, the TYKE teacher, testified that the services of an inclusion expert would have been helpful in assisting him with curriculum modification for STUDENT.

Accordingly, the evidence shows that STUDENT requires the services of an inclusion expert as a supplementary aid or service (or modification) in order to ensure his successful participation in regular education. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix C, q. 48.

4. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?

The District's placement offer for the 1995-96 school year --to educate STUDENT in a special day class on a campus providing some opportunities for interaction with nondisabled students -- did not provide for mainstreaming "to the maximum extent appropriate." 20 U.S.C. §1412(5)(B). Therefore, because an element of a free, appropriate education is that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment, it is concluded that the District failed to offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education for the 1995-96 school year.

5. If not, must the District reimburse the parents for expenses associated with their home schooling of STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year?

Under IDEA, decision makers have the authority to award "appropriate" relief for violations of FAPE. 20 U.S.C. §1415(e)(2). Appropriate relief may, under certain circumstances, include reimbursement for expenditures made on privately obtained educational services. For example, parents are entitled to be reimbursed for private school expenditures if it is determined that the school district failed to offer a FAPE and the private school placement was proper. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). Reimbursement can be awarded even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 114 S.Ct. 361, 365-366 (1993).

Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, supra, at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Therefore, in determining whether a reimbursement award should be limited, one appropriate consideration is the quality of the privately obtained educational services. See, e.g., Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986).

Petitioner seeks reimbursement for three categories of expenses incurred to support STUDENT's home schooling program during the 1995-96 school year: (1) supplies; (2) the enrollment fee for the Excellence in Education Academy; and (3) fees for home sign language interpreter Cynthia Gareeb. (P 16) On the one hand, the PARENTS incurred all of these expenses in an attempt to educate STUDENT during a time period when the District failed to offer him an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment. On the other hand, the appropriateness of the home schooling services STUDENT has received cannot be determined from the evidence presented at the hearing.(Footnote 14) It is not known whether STUDENT has made any progress on his IEP goals and objectives during this time period and/or whether he has received benefit from these services.

As for (1), PARENT did submit a detailed, daily schedule of activities that she pursues with STUDENT. (P 14) However, there is no basis upon which to determine the quality of the services provided by PARENT with the independently purchased supplies. Similarly, as for (2), no evidence was presented as to the specific support, or the quality of such support, provided by the Excellence in Education Academy to STUDENT's home schooling program. Finally, as for (3), Ms. Gareeb did not testify, and no evidence was presented as to the specific content or quality of the interpreter services she provided to STUDENT.

Accordingly, Petitioner's requests for reimbursement are denied.

ORDER

1. The appropriate placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment is in a regular education kindergarten class.

2. The full-time, one-to-one aide assigned to STUDENT must have sufficient knowledge of American Sign Language to interpret what STUDENT is signing for others and to teach him those new signs that are both appropriate to his developmental level and necessary to his successful communication.

3. STUDENT requires the services of a full inclusion specialist, trained in special education, as a member of his IEP team in order to assist his regular education teacher with curriculum modification.

4. Within fifteen (15) days of the date of this Decision, STUDENT's Individualized Education Plan shall be conformed to the contents of the Decision.

All of Petitioner's remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Issue #1: What is the least restrictive appropriate environment for STUDENT?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue #2: Does STUDENT require the full-time assistance of an aide fluent in American Sign Language in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

Neither party substantially prevailed on this issue.

Issue #3: Does STUDENT require the services of a full inclusion specialist in order to receive a free, appropriate education?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue #4: Did the District offer STUDENT a free, appropriate education in the least restrictive environment for the 1995-96 school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue #5: If not, must the District reimburse the parents for expenditures made on their home schooling of STUDENT for the 1995-96 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: April 2, 1996 ___________________ Leonard Garfinkel Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES:

1. The Hearing Office received Petitioner's request for hearing on February 2, 1995. The parties mutually agreed to several continuances, and the hearing began on June 6 and 7. On June 7, the parties indicated that they had reached a tentative settlement and requested that the matter be taken off calendar until late August. In late August, Mr. Rhine, attorney for Petitioner, informed the Hearing Office that the parties had been unable to reach a final settlement and requested that the hearing be placed back on calendar. He stated that Petitioner was "waiving time" and requested an additional day of hearing on any of several dates including October 3.

2. This matter has been pending since February 1995, and the District's position on LRE changed somewhat during the course of the litigation. When the hearing began in June 1995, the District indicated that it believed the appropriate placement for STUDENT was half-day in a special day class and half-day in a regular education kindergarten class. By the conclusion of the hearing in March 1996, the District's position was that the appropriate placement for STUDENT was full-time in a special day class with opportunities for interaction with disabled peers at lunch and recess, on field trips, and possibly at other times.

3. The District agrees that STUDENT requires the services of a full-time, one-to-one aide for assistance with behavior, academics and communication. The dispute concerns the degree of sign language proficiency that the aide must have.

4. Ms. Smithey acknowledged that in instances where STUDENT engaged in multiple acts of aggression within a brief, continuous period, she counted each instance of physical contact as a separate incident.

5. STUDENT did not bring his Alpha talker to his session with Dr. Couture. Therefore, Dr. Couture did not assess STUDENT's ability to use the augmentative communication device.

6. Assistive technology devices and services are defined at 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)25) and (26).

7. See also Mavis v. Sobol, 839 F. Supp. 968 (N.D.N.Y. 1994), in which the federal district court stated:

8. The Ninth Circuit's decision in Poolaw v. Bishop is not to the contrary. There, it was held that, in determining whether a child should be mainstreamed, a school district may rely on evidence of a student's recent mainstreaming experience in another school district, as long as the information relied upon is still relevant. 67 F.3d 830, 835 (9th Cir. 1995).

9. The term "serious behavior problems" includes those behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive or cause property damage, and other behaviors that are pervasive, maladaptive and require a systematic and frequent application of behavioral interventions. Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(y).

10. The law requires that a disabled student's IEP be updated at least annually. This Decision makes no determination as to the LRE for STUDENT one year from now.

11. Although Title 5, California Code of Regulations Section 3001(b) states that educational programs for disabled students must allow them the opportunity to "achieve [their] full potential", the Education Code provides that nothing in state special education law is intended to set a higher standard of educating disabled students than is required by the IDEA. Education Code Section 56000; see Bertolucci v. San Carlos Elementary School District, 721 F. Supp. 1150, 1156 (N.D. Cal. 1989).

12. The federal courts have consistently so held, in a line of cases involving -- as did Rowley -- hearing-impaired students. Lachman v. Illinois State Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290, 296 (7th Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 925 (1988); Bonnie Ann F. v. Calallen Independent School District, 835 F. Supp. 340, 347 (S.D. Tex. 1993), aff'd, 22 IDELR 615 (5th Cir. 1995), cert. denied, ___ U.S. ___ (1995); Peterson v. Hastings Public Schools, 31 F.3d 705, 707-708 (8th Cir. 1994); Brougham v. Town of Yarmouth, 823 F. Supp. 9, 15-16 (D. Me. 1993); Dreher v. Amphitheater Unified School District, 797 F. Supp. 753, 760-761 (D. Ariz. 1992), aff'd, 22 F.3d 228 (9th Cir. 1994).

13. The federal regulations implementing the IDEA indicate that qualifications of persons providing special education and related services are to be determined by the individual states. 34 C.F.R. 300.15; 34 C.F.R. 300.153. In California, "qualified" is defined as follows:

. . . a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services, or, in the absence of such requirements, the state-education-agency-approved or recognized requirements, and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation . . .

Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(x). There are no federal or state certification, licensing, or registration requirements for classroom aides, nor was there any evidence that there are any state department of education approved or recognized requirements.

14. STUDENT has continued to receive individualized speech and language therapy, occupational therapy and adapted physical education from the District during the 1995-96 school year. Those services are not at issue here.