California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 17, 1997

Student v. Oceanside Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 904-96 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Oceanside Unified's assessments and special day class offer upheld; Hearing Officer orders a split day with kindergarten for the rest of the year.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The mother of a six-year-old boy with receptive and expressive language delays requested a hearing against Oceanside Unified School District. She had withdrawn him from kindergarten in November 1995, and he missed the rest of that school year. After mediation, he returned to Miriam Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten at Del Rio Elementary, and the District reassessed him. A December 17, 1996 IEP offered a special day class with speech and language therapy, extended school year services, and 10% to 25% of the day with general education students. The mother refused consent. The Hearing Officer first explained that the hearing office could not award the punitive damages the family sought, so he limited the hearing to IDEA issues. On assessment, he found psychologist Dr. Ursula Sack's evaluation thorough. The mother stopped two other assessments before they were finished, but the assessors testified they had enough information. Every assessment, including those the family obtained privately, reached similar conclusions. Dr. Sack found no basis for further autism testing. On placement, the parents offered almost no evidence against the IEP. Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer held the offer appropriate. For the rest of 1996-97, he ordered mornings in Cathy Ahinger's special day class and afternoons in the student's current kindergarten class. Otherwise, the December 1996 IEP applies, including during extended school year. The District prevailed on all issues.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO treated assessments that a parent cut short. They were upheld where the assessors testified they had enough information and their results matched other evaluations. It also shows a Hearing Officer upholding an IEP while ordering a split special day class and kindergarten schedule that both sides partly supported. Finally, it shows SEHO declining to hear damages claims.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Preliminary. Petitioner's request for hearing sought punitive damages for a violation of civil rights under 20 USCS 1706 (and damages for negligence, discrimination, pain and suffering, and slander).

    The Hearing Officer explained that the Special Education Hearing Office had no jurisdiction over a civil damages action and limited the hearing to IDEA issues.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Has the District adequately assessed STUDENT?

    The District's assessments were appropriate. The psychologist's evaluation was thorough, the interrupted assessments still gave enough information, all assessments agreed, and further autism testing was not warranted.

  3. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Has the District offered an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT?

    Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer held that the December 17, 1996 IEP (special day class with speech therapy, ESY and 10–25% general education time) was appropriate. He ordered a half-day special day class and half-day kindergarten split for the rest of 1996-97.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. For the remainder of the 1996-97 regular school year, the student is placed in Ms. Ahinger's special day class at Del Rio Elementary School for the first half of the school day and continues in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten for the second half.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. In all other respects, the student's program must conform to the December 17, 1996 IEP. During extended school year, the program must comply with the provisions of the December 17, 1996 IEP.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982); Education Code Section 56320; Education Code Section 56000 et seq.; 20 U.S.C. 1401(16), (18); Education Code Section 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office
  • Robert Roice, District representative, Oceanside Unified School District
  • Art Gamble, Director of Special Education, Oceanside Unified School District
  • Ursula Sack, school psychologist (assessor), Oceanside Unified School District
  • Gayle Hamilton, resource specialist (assessor), Oceanside Unified School District
  • Kathy Smith, speech-language pathologist (assessor), Oceanside Unified School District
  • Deborah Llewellyn, private speech-language assessor obtained by parent, Childrens (organization name as stated)
  • Miriam Shipp-Tolliver-El, regular kindergarten teacher, Del Rio Elementary School
  • Cathy Ahinger, special day class teacher, Del Rio Elementary School
  • Mr. Hazelton, principal, Del Rio Elementary School
  • C. Valette, psychologist who evaluated student for Department of Social Services, Department of Social Services evaluation
  • Honore M. Fila, Director of Education (private assessor), American Center for Learning
  • Country School, private school requested by parents, private school

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 904-96 Case Year: 1996 Petitioner: Student Issue: Assessment Placement CDS Code: 37-73569 District: Oceanside Unified Disability Type: Speech or Language Impairment

Case Details CASE NO. SN 904-96 STUDENT V. OCEANSIDE UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT ISSUES 1. Has the District adequately assessed STUDENT? 2. Has the District offered an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT? ORDER For the remainder of the 1996-97 regular school year, STUDENT shall be placed in Ms. Ahinger's special day class at Del Rio Elementary School during the first half of the school day and will continue in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten during the second half of the school day. In all other respects, STUDENT's program shall conform to the IEP of December 17, l996. During the extended school year STUDENT's program shall comply with the provisions of the December 17, l996 IEP. This matter was heard before Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Oceanside, California, on February 20 & 21, l997. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his mother and stepfather. Respondent Oceanside Unified School District (hereinafter District) was represented by Robert Roice. Also appearing on behalf of the District was Art Gamble, Director of Special Education. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed on February 21, l997, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES 1. Has the District adequately assessed STUDENT? 2. Has the District offered an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT? PROCEDURAL MATTERS Petitioner's request for hearing indicated that he was seeking punitive damages for a violation of civil rights. Petitioner cited 20 USCS Section 1706 as the basis for her claim for damages. That section reads: An individual denied an equal educational opportunity, as defined by this part, may institute a civil action in an appropriate district court of the United States against such parties, and for such relief, as may be appropriate. The Attorney General of the United States ... for or in the name of the United States, may also institute such a civil action on behalf of such individual. The Hearing Officer explained to Petitioner that the California Special Education Hearing Office did not have jurisdiction to hear such a civil action. The Hearing Officer explained that the Special Education Hearing Office did have the jurisdiction to determine whether Petitioner had received a free appropriate public education under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and would limit the hearing to issues relating to his rights under that act. FINDINGS OF FACT Background Facts STUDENT is a six-year-old boy with a history of receptive and expressive language delays. When STUDENT was four, his mother referred him to the District for consideration for special education services because of her concern about his speech delays. The District's assessment concluded that he had delays in auditory processing and verbal expression. STUDENT was found to be eligible for special education services, and an IEP meeting was held in November l994. The IEP provided that STUDENT receive speech and language services four times per week. Transportation was to be provided by STUDENT's mother; however, she was not able to obtain transportation. The District offered to have STUDENT transported to his program by taxi, but STUDENT's mother did not avail herself of that service. The District then referred STUDENT's mother to the Head Start program and agreed to provide transportation to the District site after class for speech and language services. STUDENT's mother did not enroll him in the Head Start program or take advantage of the offered speech and language services. In September l995, when STUDENT was five years old, his mother enrolled him in kindergarten at Del Rio school, where he also began receiving speech and language services. STUDENT's mother complained about the services he was receiving in the class and requested more one-to-one instruction. STUDENT's mother said that STUDENT either should be transferred to another school or taken out of regular school and placed in a home teaching program. The District immediately suggested that a meeting be held to arrange for additional assessments of STUDENT. STUDENT's mother did not attend the meeting scheduled on November 16, l995, did not respond to follow-up communications, and did not agree to an assessment plan. In mid- November l995, STUDENT's mother removed him from kindergarten class and obtained a packet of information concerning home schooling from the District. The District notified STUDENT's mother that STUDENT could continue to receive speech and language services while he was in a home education program. STUDENT's mother did not respond to that offer. In December l995 STUDENT's mother requested the District to give her the money that it would normally receive for STUDENT's education so that she could use it to provide a home education program. The District informed STUDENT's mother that the law would not permit such funding. STUDENT's mother then requested the district to provide her with a list of educational supplies needed for STUDENT's home-based program. The District refused to provide the requested items, but did recommend that STUDENT's mother enroll him in the District's Home Education program which would supply certain materials to assist with the home teaching. STUDENT's mother did not do so. STUDENT was out of school for the remainder of the 1995-96 school year. On August 21, l996, STUDENT's mother filed a request for hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office seeking damages for "negligence, discrimination, pain and suffering, and slander." She also sought punitive damages under 20 USCS 1681, et seq. Mediation was held on September 25, l996, during which she agreed to enroll STUDENT in the regular kindergarten class of Ms. Miriam Shipp-Tolliver-El at the Del Rio Elementary School, where he was still enrolled at the time of this hearing. STUDENT's mother and the District agreed to a further assessment of STUDENT and, thereafter, an IEP meeting to design an appropriate program. Assessments were performed by psychologist Dr. Ursula Sack; Resource Specialist Gayle Hamilton; and Speech and Language Pathologist Kathy Smith. Ms. Hamilton's and Ms. Smith's assessment sessions with STUDENT were not completed because STUDENT's mother refused to let them continue without her being present. Both Ms. Hamilton and Ms. Smith testified that they believed they had obtained sufficient information for their assessments. During October and November l996, while the District was completing it's assessments, STUDENT's mother obtained a speech and language assessment from Deborah Llewellyn of Childrens. (Apparently the name of the organization that employed her.) An IEP meeting was held on December 17, l996. The IEP developed by the team provided for STUDENT to be placed in a Special Day Class with speech and language services to be provided 1 to 2 times per week for from 30 to 60 minutes. The IEP provided for extended school year services and required that STUDENT be integrated with regular school students for 10% to 25% of each day. Goals and objectives were developed. STUDENT's mother refused to consent to the IEP and asked that a hearing be scheduled. Summary of Assessments Dr. Sack's assessment concluded that STUDENT had a history of receptive and expressive language delays, and that his language impairments were currently impacting his ability to learn in a large classroom environment. She recommended that STUDENT be placed in a small-group special education setting with curriculum modifications to help him develop receptive and expressive language skills. She said that STUDENT's academic skills should be addressed in the small classroom, but that he should participate with regular education students in nonacademic, socialization, and play activities for the remainder of his school day. Dr. Sack also recommended speech and language therapy to supplement STUDENT's program. Ms. Hamilton, the resource specialist, concluded in her assessment that STUDENT should be placed in small group instruction with speech and language support. Ms. Smith, a speech and language therapist, recommended in her assessment that STUDENT be placed in a special day class with speech and language therapy provided to support him with his communication needs. In her assessment, Ms. Llewellyn recommended the STUDENT be placed in a speech and language handicapped classroom with speech and language therapy to supplement the classroom instruction. In an earlier assessment dated April 10, l996, and May 17, l996, Honore M. Fila, the Director of Education of the American Center for Learning, stated that "STUDENT needs a specialized program that will help him in both his visual and auditory areas. His skills are such that he would have difficulty functioning in a regular kindergarten class at this time." Placement Options The District has offered as placements for STUDENT Special Day Classes at his local school, Del Rio Elementary, or special day classes at four other elementary schools in the District. The special day class at Del Rio Elementary is taught by Cathy Ahinger. The class is in session from 8:15 a.m. to 2:55 p.m., and has 11 students, some of whom spend a portion of their day in regular education classes. Ms. Ahinger has an instructional aide to assist her during most of the day, but from 1:30 p.m to 2:55 p.m. she does not have the assistance of the aide. When the instructional aide is present, the class is broken into two groups with 5 or 6 children in each group. On Monday and Thursday mornings, there are speech and language therapy sessions after recess that last 30 minutes. Ms. Ahinger testified in the hearing that she could implement STUDENT's goals and objectives in her class. Currently, STUDENT is in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten class at Del Rio Elementary School. Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's class lasts only a half day, from 11:35 a.m. to 2:55 p.m. In addition to Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El, the class is supported by an aide for 45 minutes per day and a full-time parent volunteer. There are 32 students in the class. Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El testified that STUDENT has improved since he first entered her class. He has good rapport with the other students and is happy to come to school. She said that STUDENT works better in small groups. He gets frustrated when in large- group sessions. She said he appears to be a little delayed, but she is not sure whether that is caused by a disability or by his lack of attendance for much of last year. She testified that STUDENT would do better in a small classroom where he could get more individual instruction. Psychologist Ursula Sack testified that placing STUDENT in the special day class in the morning and in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's class in the afternoon would provide him the best of both worlds and would be appropriate for him. This view was indorsed by Mr. Hazelton, the principal at Del Rio; Mr. Gamble, the special education director; Ms. Hamilton, the Resource Specialist; and Ms. Ahinger, the special day class teacher. They all agreed that a six year old like STUDENT could handle a full day of classes. STUDENT's parents requested that STUDENT be placed in a private school and specifically mentioned the Country School. Other than a one-page advertisement from the school, no evidence was provided during the hearing concerning the ability of the Country School to provide an appropriate program for STUDENT. DISCUSSION 1. Has the District adequately assessed STUDENT? California Education Code Section 56320 provides that disabled students must be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability and that assessments must be performed by trained personnel. The assessment done by psychologist Ursula Sack was thorough and set out its findings in detail. The assessment included interviews with STUDENT and his mother, observing STUDENT in his classroom and a review of STUDENT's educational records. Dr. Sack administered the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development, the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning, the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt Test, the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration, the Conners Teacher's Rating Scale, and the Draw A Person test. (Her conclusions were consistent with the findings of all the other assessments including those obtained by STUDENT's mother.) Although the assessments by Ms. Hamilton and Ms. Smith were interrupted by STUDENT's mother prior to completion, the assessors both testified that they had enough information to support their conclusions. (Their conclusions were consistent with the other assessments including those obtained by STUDENT's mother.) STUDENT's mother claimed that there should have been a more complete assessment of STUDENT to determine whether he was autistic. She based this claim on the fact that C. Valette, a psychologist who had done an evaluation of STUDENT for Department of Social Services in relation to an application for SSI benefits, had stated that STUDENT "shows signs of autism whereby he exhibits echolalia." However, the report by Dr. Valette did not conclude that STUDENT was autistic. The report also stated that there were signs of mental retardation, severe problems in the verbal areas, organic mental disorder, and attention deficit disorder. Dr. Sack testified that her examination of STUDENT did not support a diagnosis of autism, nor did it justify the need for further assessment. In addition to all of her testing and observation of STUDENT, Dr. Sack discussed his case with Dr. Valette and based upon all this information concluded that the signs of other disabilities including autism were caused by STUDENT's sever receptive and expressive language disorder. For the reasons stated above, it is concluded that the District performed appropriate assessments of STUDENT. 2. Did the District offer an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT? Disabled students have a right under both state and federal law to a free appropriate public education. (California Education Code Section 56000 et seq., and 20 U.S.C. 1400 et seq.) Pursuant to 20 USC section 1401(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that, among other things, must conform with the students individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined in subsection 16 as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to parent or guardians, to meet the unique needs of the handicapped child, including classroom instruction, instruction in physical education, home instruction, and instruction in hospitals and institution." The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) was interpreted by the Supreme Court in the case of Board of Education., etc, v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 175. The Court concluded that the law did not require that the services provided be the best available or that they be sufficient to maximize each child's potential commensurate with the opportunity provided other children. The Court held that "the basic floor of opportunity" provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the handicapped child." 458 U.S. 175, 200. STUDENT's parents did not raise any significant objections to the IEP prepared in December l996; nor did they provide any evidence to demonstrate that the proposed placement in the special day class at De Rio was inappropriate. The greatest part of their testimony related to perceived slights or insults to them by the District. The IEP team met and produced a number of goals and objectives. All of the witnesses in the hearing who had attended the IEP testified that STUDENT's parents did not object to those goals and objectives during the meeting. District witnesses testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT. The IEP team agreed that, based upon all of the assessments, the best educational setting for STUDENT would be in the special day class at Del Rio Elementary School. The also agreed that it was important for STUDENT to spend from 10% to 25% of his time with regular education students. The team further agreed that STUDENT should receive speech and language therapy. The program was individually designed for STUDENT's needs and consisted of specialized instruction in the special day class and related services, including speech and language therapy. It was the consensus of the team that these services would provide educational benefit to STUDENT. During the hearing, most of the District's witnesses stated that for the rest of the 96-97 school year it would be appropriate for STUDENT to spend the first half of the school day in the special day class and the second half in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten class, where he is currently enrolled. Continuation in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's class is one of the only points of agreement between STUDENT's parents and the District. Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El is a dedicated, talented and compassionate teacher who has helped STUDENT make progress, even though in a larger than optimum class. STUDENT has made friends in this class, and those friendships should not be interrupted. STUDENT's mother testified that she wanted STUDENT to graduate from Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's kindergarten class at the end of the regular school year. It is concluded that the District has offered an appropriate program and placement for STUDENT. For the rest of the regular 96-97 school year, STUDENT should be placed in the special day class at Del Rio for the first half of the day and continue in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's class for the second half of the day. During the extended school year, STUDENT's program should comply with all of the provisions of the December l996 IEP. ORDER For the remainder of the 1996-97 regular school year, STUDENT shall be placed in Ms. Ahinger's special day class at Del Rio Elementary School during the first half of the school day and will continue in Ms. Shipp-Tolliver-El's regular kindergarten during the second half of the school day. In all other respects, STUDENT's program shall conform to the IEP of December 17, l996. During the extended school year STUDENT's program shall comply with the provisions of the December 17, l996 IEP. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extend to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: Respondent District prevailed on all issues. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code Section 56505(i). Dated: March 17, l997 Glenn A. Fait Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes