California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 12, 1996

Student v. Ocean View Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 905-96, SN 814-96 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Ocean View Elementary need not add an outside behavior supervisor or expanded optometric services, but must reassess and hold an overdue IEP meeting.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 4 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision refers to prior case SN 810-94, decided after an October–November hearing; the order was amended on February 23, 1995 by Hearing Officer Garfinkel. It also refers to a September 18, 1995 U.S. District Court order (Judge Gadbois) compelling a functional analysis assessment by Dr. Mesaros. The decision itself records no remand, vacatur, or correction.

Summary

A parent filed for hearing for an eight-year-old third grader. The student first qualified for special education based on a speech and language disorder. He was placed in a regular class with speech therapy, an inclusion specialist, adapted PE, occupational therapy and an agreed behavioral intervention plan. The parent asked for four things: an outside expert, Dr. Richard Mesaros, to supervise the plan and the District's behavior case manager, Janet Halliday; 74 hours a year of optometric consultation recommended by Dr. Beth Ballinger; speech services from a speech pathologist the parent chose; and audiological services recommended by Rosemarie Davis. The Hearing Officer denied the District's motions to dismiss based on an earlier hearing and on state compliance findings.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found that Ms. Halliday was qualified and unbiased, that staff had been trained, and that conflict between the parent and the District did not deny a free appropriate public education. No outside supervisor was required. The optometric recommendations were nearly two years old, and other staff could carry out the goals. The 74-hour request was denied, and the District's offer of two hours a month continued. The District did not have to hire the parent's chosen speech pathologist, but the student's communication skills had to be reassessed. The hearing-retest and FM auditory trainer objectives had not been met, so the District had to keep working on them. Because the IEP had not been updated since June 1995, the District had to hold an IEP meeting within 10 days to plan speech, language and hearing assessments and write a new IEP.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a parent's request for particular outside providers. Under Rowley, the Hearing Officer looked at whether the student needed the services. She did not ask whether the parent trusted District staff. She also used an outdated IEP and outdated assessments as grounds to order reassessment and a prompt IEP meeting.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. To receive a FAPE, does the student require the appointment of a qualified and experienced behavior specialist, such as Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., to supervise and monitor the District's behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), Janet Halliday, and the implementation of the student's behavioral intervention plan?

    The BICM was qualified and unbiased, staff were trained, and parent–district hostility did not deny FAPE, so outside supervision of the plan was not required.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations of Beth Ballinger, O.D., contained in the report of her assessment of the student, dated February 7, 1995?

    The request for 74 hours a year of optometric consultation was denied because the assessment was outdated and other staff could carry out the goals; the District must continue the visual-motor goals and 2 hours a month of consultation, and must hold an overdue IEP meeting.

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is the District obligated to have WITNESS, C.C.C., implement the recommendations for speech and language services contained in the report of her January 1995 assessment of the student?

    The District need not contract with the parent's chosen speech pathologist as long as a qualified provider serves the student, but it must reassess communication skills (a baseline and a classroom observation) and continue the June 20, 1995 goals.

  4. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 4. Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations for audiological services made by Rosemarie Davis, C.C.C., contained in the report of her March 1995 assessment of the student?

    The audiological objectives (hearing reevaluation and an FM auditory trainer) had not been met or tried, so the District must keep implementing them and assess audiological needs; no other audiological services were warranted.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 calendar days of receipt of the decision, the IEP team must meet to develop goals and objectives for the 1996-1997 school year and write an IEP reflecting agreement on placement and services.
  • Order to assess. At that IEP meeting, the team must prepare an assessment plan to evaluate the student's speech, language and audiological needs. The findings require the communication assessment to include at least a baseline of current communication skills and a classroom observation.
  • Order to provide or change services. Until a new IEP is developed, Respondents must implement the goals and objectives in the June 20, 1995 IEP and provide the services the parent authorized in the attorney's October 1995 letter.
  • Order to provide or change services. Until a new IEP is developed, Respondents must provide two hours per month of optometric consultation to staff.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Board of Education of Community Consolidated School Dist. No. 21 v. Illinois State Board of Education (7th Cir. 1991) 938 F.2d 712; Letter to Breecher (1990) 16 IDELR 1404; Education Code § 56363(a); 34 C.F.R. § 300.16; 5 CCR § 3052; 5 CCR § 3001(x)

People named in the decision

  • Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., Behavior specialist who led the functional analysis assessment; expert witness for Student, California State University, Northridge
  • Janet Halliday, School psychologist and behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Marilou Lundberg, Coordinator of special education, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • John Thomas, Director of student services, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Jim Hemsley, Director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education
  • Beth Ballinger, O.D., Developmental optometrist; SELPA consultant assessor; witness for Student, Private practice
  • Rosemarie Davis, C.C.C., Audiological assessor
  • Roger Titgemeyer, Ph.D., Administrator, pupil personnel and special schools; witness for Respondents, Orange County Office of Education
  • Ann Carr, Inclusion facilitator/specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Connie McCandless, Second grade teacher, Circle View Elementary School
  • Dan Moss, Principal, Circle View Elementary School
  • Maria Shickler, Adapted physical education specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Jane Vogel, Teacher of the visually impaired; witness for Respondents, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education
  • Cecile (Sissy) Sandeen, Ed.D., Home teacher (1994-95) and RSP-trained teacher, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Cynthia Cottier, Augmentative and alternative communication consultant; speech pathologist; witness for Respondents, Private practice, consultant to WOCCSE
  • Charlotte Gibbs, Speech and language specialist, Ocean View Elementary School District
  • Howard Plass, Ph.D., School psychologist who observed the student and made behavior recommendations, Orange County Office of Education
  • Ted Schoneberger, Independent behavioral consultant originally designated to lead the functional analysis assessment
  • Jocelyn Mayer, M.S., Proposed independent behavioral assessor, California State University, Los Angeles
  • Dave Hagen, Former superintendent subpoenaed by Petitioner; did not appear, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Leonard Garfinkel, SEHO Hearing Officer in prior case SN 810-94 and subpoena ruling, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Joan Honeycutt, Student's attorney in prior case SN 810-94
  • Richard A. Gadbois, Jr., U.S. District Judge who ordered the behavioral assessment, U.S. District Court, Central District of California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Huntington Beach, California, on September 9, 10, 11, and 30, and October 1 and 2, 1996. On October 3, 1996, the parties made closing arguments by telephone.

STUDENT was represented by his PARENT on September 9, and October 1, 2, and 3, 1996. Attorney Peter D. Collisson represented STUDENT at the hearing on September 10 and 30, 1996. Attorney Diane Lipton represented STUDENT at the hearing on September 11, 1996.(FOOTNOTE 1) Attorney Ronald D. Wenkart represented Respondents Ocean View Elementary School District (District) and the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE). Also present at the hearing on behalf of the District were Marilou Lundberg, coordinator of special education, and John Thomas, director of student services. Present on behalf of WOCCSE was Jim Hemsley, director.

Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require the appointment of a qualified and experienced behavior specialist, such as Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., to supervise and monitor the District's behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), Janet Halliday, and the implementation of STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan?

(2) Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations of Beth Ballinger, O.D., contained in the report of her assessment of STUDENT, dated February 7, 1995?

(3) Is the District obligated to have WITNESS, C.C.C., implement the recommendations for speech and language services which are contained in the report of her January 1995 assessment of

STUDENT?

(4) Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations for audiological services made by Rosemarie Davis, C.C.C., which are contained in the report of her March 1995 assessment of

STUDENT?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the beginning of the hearing, the District made a motion to dismiss Issue No. 1, based on the doctrine of res judicata and/or collateral estoppel. The District asserted that Ms. Halliday's qualifications to be STUDENT's BICM were determined in a decision rendered in January 1995, following a hearing in Case No. SN 810-94. Petitioner contended that the issue of whether someone of Dr. Mesaros' qualifications should supervise implementation of Petitioner's behavioral intervention plan was not previously litigated. Petitioner stated that he was not now disputing Ms. Halliday's participation in the behavioral intervention plan.

Parents may request a due process hearing regarding the identification, assessment, educational placement, or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to their child. Education Code § 56501(a). A decision rendered in a due process hearing constitutes a final administrative determination and is binding on the parties. Education Code § 56505(g). Parties have the right to appeal the decision to a court of competent jurisdiction within 90 days of receipt of the hearing decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

The doctrine of res judicata gives "conclusive effect to a former judgment in subsequent litigation involving the same controversy. It seeks to curtail multiple litigation causing vexation and expense to the parties and wasted effort and expense in judicial administration." 7 Witkin, California Procedure (3rd ed., 1985), Judgment, § 188, pp. 621-622. Res judicata does not preclude a second action between the parties based on a different cause of action. The doctrine of collateral estoppel precludes relitigation of issues that were actually decided in a prior action between the parties. 7 Witkin, California Procedure (3rd ed., 1985), Judgment, § 253, pp. 691-692. In special education matters, whether there is a res judicata effect depends on a number of factors including whether "the circumstances may have changed from the original complaint." Letter to Breecher (1990) 16 IDELR 1404.

By requiring annual IEPs, special education law has recognized that the needs of students with disabilities are fluid and changing. Thus, a party is not automatically precluded from re-addressing certain issues, such as the provision of a free, appropriate public education, in a subsequent due process hearing. In this case (SN 814-96/905-96), Petitioner has raised an issue that was not specifically addressed in the prior case (SN 810-94). In the first case, the parties agreed that Ted Schoneberger, a private consultant, would lead the assessment of STUDENT's behavior.(FOOTNOTE 1) At issue, however, was whether the District was "entitled to have school psychologist Janet Halliday assist in STUDENT's behavioral assessment." In the present case, Petitioner is not challenging Ms. Halliday's participation in the assessment. The assessment of STUDENT's behavior, in fact, has been completed. Thus, the circumstances have changed since the prior hearing. The assessment, which took place during the course of the 1995-96 school year, was conducted by Dr. Mesaros, Ms. Halliday, and others. Following the assessment, Dr. Mesaros and Ms. Halliday drafted a behavioral intervention plan, which was modified by the IEP team and to which the parties ultimately agreed. The issue in this case is whether Dr. Mesaros, or someone with his qualifications and experience, should supervise and monitor the implementation of the behavioral intervention plan. The Hearing Officer concluded that the issue raised in this case is not the same issue that was decided in Case No. SN 810-94 and, for this reason, denied the District's motion to dismiss Issue No. 1.

Respondents also made a motion to dismiss issues regarding whether the District is obligated to implement the recommendations of Dr. Ballinger for vision services, the recommendations of WITNESS for speech and language services, and the recommendations of Ms. Davis for audiological services. The motion was made on the ground that the recommendations of all three had been incorporated into Petitioner's IEP dated June 20, 1995. The District asserted that several State compliance/complaint investigations had found the District in compliance with regard to providing speech and language and vision services to Petitioner.

Compliance complaints may be made to allege violations of federal or state law governing educational programs. Education Code § 56500.2; Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 4610(a). Due process hearing procedures may be initiated regarding the identification, assessment, educational placement, or the provision of a free, appropriate public education. Education Code § 56505(a). Special education law does not indicate that the two procedures are mutually exclusive. Compliance complaints filed by PARENT alleged that the District had failed to provide certain services to Petitioner during school years preceding the 1996-1997 school year. Reports of the findings made as a result of the complaints were rendered in October of 1995, and in April and June of 1996. The issues in this case are in regard to Petitioner's need for speech, language, audiological, and vision services for the 1996-1997 school year. The Hearing Officer concluded, therefore, that issues regarding Petitioner's current need for services has not previously been addressed. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer denied Respondents' motion to dismiss.

During preliminary discussions at the hearing, Petitioner withdrew from consideration an issue regarding whether the District is obligated "to provide additional security and educational therapy for STUDENT based on the history, attitude, and overall position of the district." Petitioner also requested that the Hearing Officer order Dave Hagen to appear as a witness at the hearing. Petitioner identified Mr. Hagen as the former superintendent of the Huntington Beach Union High School District and asserted that Mr. Hagen had failed to appear at the hearing in response to a subpoena served on him on August 29, 1996.

Petitioner stated that Mr. Hagen was subpoenaed to testify about security issues related to Petitioner's school attendance in the District. Petitioner stated that he would also ask Mr. Hagen to testify regarding visits made to Petitioner's house by uniformed officers at the request of the District during a residency dispute.

Respondents did not dispute the adequacy of the service of the subpoena. Respondents informed the Hearing Officer that Mr. Hagen was unavailable to appear at the hearing because, on August 29, 1996, Mr. Hagen had retired from the Huntington Beach District and had relocated to Pennsylvania. Respondents asserted that, in advance of the hearing, they had informed Petitioner of Mr. Hagen's status. Respondents also asserted that they had requested that the Hearing Office quash the subpoena for Mr. Hagen based on his unavailability and on the lack of relevancy of his testimony.

Respondents also asserted that the Hearing Office did not rule on this motion prior to the hearing.(FOOTNOTE 1) Respondents agreed to make Mr. Hagen available for telephone testimony on the next day of hearing. Petitioner declined to call Mr. Hagen by telephone and indicated that he would pursue enforcement of the subpoena in a court of competent jurisdiction to have Mr. Hagen appear at the hearing in person.

Because the hearing was not completed during the first three days for which it had originally been set, the matter was continued. On September 18, 1996, the Hearing Office received a second motion to quash the subpoena served on Mr. Hagen from Mr. Wenkart on behalf of Respondents. Respondents contend that because Petitioner voluntarily dismissed the issue regarding security, which Petitioner identified as the area about which Mr. Hagen would testify, Mr. Hagen's testimony was not necessary or relevant to the issues in this case. On September 27, 1996, Petitioner objected to quashing the subpoena and again stated that he intended to seek enforcement of the subpoena in a court. He also asserted that Mr. Hagen's testimony was relevant with regard to the issue of his residency.

Mr. Hagen did not appear at the hearing when it reconvened on September 30, 1996. The Hearing Officer does not have authority to enforce the subpoena. Petitioner did not present a court order requiring Mr. Hagen to appear, nor did he request that the hearing remain open for Mr. Hagen's testimony. The case was closed on October 3, 1996. The motion to quash is moot and, therefore, the Hearing Officer declines to rule on the motion.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eight-year-old student in the third grade.

STUDENT was first found eligible for special education when he was three years old. Eligibility at that time was based on a speech and language disorder. Subsequent IEPs have indicated that STUDENT has auditory processing and expressive language disorders. His most recent IEP states that "STUDENT's multiple needs necessitate specialized instruction as provided by special education."

(Respondents' Exhibit 3-13) STUDENT's last agreed upon placement is in a regular education classroom with the following: speech and language therapy for one hour daily; the services of an inclusion specialist for one hour daily; adapted physical education (APE) for 45-minute sessions, two times per week; occupational therapy (OT) for one-hour sessions two times per week; and transportation.(FOOTNOTE 4) STUDENT also has a behavioral intervention plan which was developed and agreed to in May 1996. The most recent goals and objectives that were agreed upon are contained in an IEP dated June 20, 1995. The goals and objectives address the following areas: attention and on-task behavior;

postural and ocular-motor control; motor skills and strength;

computer skills; reading; auditory memory; math; written language; vocabulary; and communication skills. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT had not attended school during the 1996-97 school year.

STUDENT attended preschool in the District. During the 1993-1994 school year, STUDENT entered a regular education kindergarten class at Circle View Elementary School. To address what the District perceived as escalating behavioral problems, the District proposed to conduct a functional analysis of STUDENT's behavior. Between January and March 1994, the District presented assessment plans to PARENT on approximately five different occasions.

(Respondents' Exhibits 2-1, 2-2, 2-3, 2-4, and 2-5) On March 25, 1996, PARENT consented to a functional analysis of STUDENT's behavior by an employee of the Orange County Office of Education (COE). In April 1994, Howard Plass, Ph.D., a COE school psychologist, observed STUDENT and made preliminary recommendations regarding managing STUDENT's behavior in the classroom. In May 1994, Dr. Plass recommended that STUDENT be transferred from his regular education class to a special day class (SDC), with mainstreaming as appropriate. Because PARENT did not consent to STUDENT's placement in the SDC, Mr. Plass developed a second proposal whereby STUDENT would remain in the regular kindergarten class and spend portions of the day in the SDC.

According to the District, STUDENT's behavior was so disruptive and violent that, on May 26, 1994, the District sought and was granted a temporary restraining order authorizing the District to temporarily remove STUDENT from the regular education class and place him in an SDC. The District then sought a preliminary injunction to maintain STUDENT in the SDC. Dr. Plass, among others, prepared a declaration in support of the District's request. The District's request was denied and the District was ordered to return STUDENT to the regular kindergarten class.

On June 2, 1994, PARENT consented to the Respondents' proposed triennial assessment plan. (Respondents' Exhibit 2-7) PARENT revoked his consent, however, to a functional analysis assessment by Dr. Plass. (Respondents' Exhibit 2-8) On June 9, 1994, STUDENT returned to his regular kindergarten class at Circle View. He attended school for only a few days prior to the end of the school year. On June 17, 1994, the IEP team met to discuss STUDENT's program for the summer. At that time, PARENT consented to home teaching and to the services of speech and language, APE, and OT. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-1)

On August 25, 1994, PARENT agreed to allow Ted Schoneberger, an independent consultant, to conduct the functional analysis assessment of STUDENT. (Respondents Exhibit 2-11) Mr.

Schoneberger was originally scheduled to begin his assessment of STUDENT on September 1, 1994. At one point, PARENT withdrew consent for Mr. Schoneberger to conduct the assessment and at another point, Mr. Schoneberger withdrew from the assessment process, reconsidered, and then agreed to do the assessment.

PARENT, however, continued to object to school psychologist Janet Halliday's participation in the assessment. The District then requested a special education due process hearing on the issue of whether it was allowed to assess STUDENT (SN 810-94).(FOOTNOTE 5) Following a due process hearing in October and November 1995, the Hearing Officer determined that Ms. Halliday was qualified to assist in STUDENT's functional analysis assessment. (Respondents' Exhibit 1-2)(FOOTNOTE 6)

Meanwhile, the IEP team met on September 6, 1994, and at a second meeting on September 9, 1994, PARENT consented to STUDENT's continuation in home teaching. Following the triennial assessment, the IEP team met on January 20, 1995, to review reports by the school nurse, APE specialist, and resource specialist. On February 7, 1995, the IEP team reconvened to review reports by the school psychologists who had assessed STUDENT. The IEP team also reviewed reports of assessments conducted by consultants to the SELPA (WOCCSE), Beth Ballinger, O.D., and speech and language pathologist WITNESS. Dr. Ballinger and WITNESS also presented their proposed goals and objectives for vision, speech, language, and audiological services. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would begin to phase back into the regular school program at Circle View and that he was entitled to the following services: five one-hour sessions per week of speech, language, and augmentative communication services; two one-hour sessions per week of OT; five one-hour sessions per week of RSP; transportation; and optometric consultation, the amount of which was "to be determined." (Respondents' Exhibit 3-5) On February 15, 1995, the IEP team reconvened to further discuss STUDENT's placement and services. The team recommended that STUDENT be transitioned from home teaching to Circle View for two hours daily and that optometric consultation be for two hours per month. PARENT did not consent to the IEP. His disagreement is included in the IEP document. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-6)

The District requested that the Hearing Office order Petitioner to comply with the decision in SN 810-94 to allow the District to go forward with its assessment of STUDENT's behavior. On February 23, 1995, Hearing Officer Leonard Garfinkel denied the request, indicating that he had no power to enforce the original order. The Hearing Officer did, however, amend the order to read as follows:

The District is entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT's behavior pursuant to Title 5 California Code of Regulations section 3052, led by private consultant Ted Schoneberger, with the assistance of school psychologist Janet Halliday. PARENT shall make STUDENT reasonable available to the District for the purpose of conducting the behavioral assessment.

(Respondents' Exhibit 1-4)

On approximately March 25, 1995, Mr. Schoneberger advised the District that he no longer wanted to be involved in the assessment of STUDENT. In a letter dated April 21, 1995, the District proposed two alternative independent assessors to conduct the functional analysis assessment of STUDENT's behavior: Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., a professor at California State University, Northridge; and Jocelyn Mayer, M.S., an assistant professor at California State University, Los Angeles. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-7) At an IEP meeting on June 20, 1995, PARENT agreed to proposed goals and objectives. On June 22, 1995, the IEP team again met to discuss STUDENT's summer placement. No agreement was reached on placement.

PARENT also did not consent, at that time, to either Dr.

Mesaros' or Ms. Mayer's assessing STUDENT. The District applied to the United States District Court, Central District of California, for an order to compel PARENT to make STUDENT available for a behavioral assessment. (Respondents' Exhibit 1-10) On September 18, 1995, Judge Richard A. Gadbois, Jr. found Dr. Mesaros qualified to assess STUDENT. Judge Gadbois ordered PARENT to make STUDENT available for a functional analysis assessment to be conducted in a classroom setting by Dr. Mesaros with the assistance of Ms.

Halliday. (Respondents' Exhibit 1-8) The District contracted with Dr. Mesaros to provide a maximum of 30 hours of service toward completing a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT's behavior. (Respondents' Exhibit 4-9)

The IEP team reconvened on September 22, 1995. The IEP team members agreed that STUDENT would enter a regular education class; however, the IEP was not signed by PARENT. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-10) In a letter dated October 9, 1995, Petitioner's attorney Ms. Lipton stated that PARENT "agrees with the provision of a 1:1 aide, full inclusion specialist, speech and language therapy and adapted physical education instruction as specified on the September 22, IEP." She also indicated that PARENT consented to placing STUDENT in a regular second grade class at Circle View School; however, he did not agree that the placement should be for 30 days only, as indicated on the IEP. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-11) The District then provided STUDENT with the above services at Circle View Elementary School.(FOOTNOTE 7) STUDENT attended summer school briefly before he was withdrawn from the program by his father.

On October 30, 1995, the IEP team convened to discuss and develop an interim behavioral intervention plan to address STUDENT's "eloping" behavior. (On October 26, 1995, STUDENT had attempted several times to leave the school building and go to the parking lot.) (Respondents' Exhibits 3-11 and 3-12) Another IEP meeting took place on November 17, 1995, to discuss Dr. Mesaros' preliminary behavioral assessment data. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-13) At that time, PARENT consented to implementation of the interim behavioral intervention plan and to extend the functional analysis assessment through January 8, 1996. (Respondents' Exhibits 3-14 and 3-15) On March 27, April 17, and May 8, 1996, the IEP team met to discuss the behavioral intervention report and plan, and to make modifications to the plan. The final behavioral plan was agreed to on May 8, 1996. The plan states that the following persons are responsible for its implementation:

STUDENT's regular education teacher; the speech and language specialist; the BICM; STUDENT's APE teacher; the instructional assistant; the school site administrator; and the school psychologist. The plan calls for weekly consultation to the staff and the parent by the BICM. It also states that the plan will be reviewed no later than September 30, 1996. Ms. Halliday continues to be designated as the BICM. (Respondents' Exhibit 4-7)

On July 25, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from PARENT, on behalf of STUDENT. In his request for hearing, PARENT asserted that the District and WOCCSE were failing to provide STUDENT with a free and appropriate education. PARENT waived mediation and the matter proceeded to hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NO. 1: To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require the appointment of a qualified and experienced behavior specialist, such as Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., to supervise and monitor the District's behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), Janet Halliday, and the implementation of STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that because of the negativity and hostility that have existed between the parent and the District, his behavioral intervention plan must be overseen by an independent person. Petitioner asserts that for the plan to be successful, the person responsible for the plan must have the trust of Petitioner's family. Petitioner questions Ms. Halliday's ability to communicate with the family and to be objective. Petitioner also has concerns about the level of Ms. Halliday's competence to implement and modify his behavioral intervention plan.

Respondents contend that the services of Dr. Mesaros or someone with similar qualifications and experience are not necessary to implement STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan. Respondents assert that in the District's employ are persons qualified to implement the plan. Respondents also assert that the school staff working with STUDENT have "lost faith" in Dr. Mesaros and question his ability to provide them with unbiased and direct input regarding implementing the behavioral intervention plan. They also assert that Dr. Mesaros' schedule and the distance of his place of employ from STUDENT's school make it difficult for him to be available when needed.(FOOTNOTE 8) Finally, Respondents assert that by participating in the assessment of STUDENT's behavior and the development of a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT, Dr. Mesaros completed the services called for in his contract.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner called Dr. Mesaros as a witness. Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., is a professor in the special education department at California State University, Northridge. Dr. Mesaros teaches courses and supervises graduate-level students in the special education teacher credential program. He also is in private practice and provides training and consultation to individuals and school districts. Dr. Mesaros testified that he has provided training for BICMs in approximately 11 states, has published a number of articles related to positive behavioral support, and has reviewed several hundred behavioral intervention plans. Dr.

Mesaros testified that STUDENT presents as a learner with moderate to significant disabilities, delayed speech and language, and social and cognitive "difficulties." Dr. Mesaros testified that STUDENT is at a pre-academic stage in some areas of development with strengths in motor skills and visual-motor processing. Dr. Mesaros also found STUDENT "likeable and social."

Dr. Mesaros became involved with STUDENT in September 1995, when he was asked by Respondents to participate in a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT's behavior, toward the end of developing a behavioral intervention plan for him. His responsibilities were to provide guidance, support, and leadership to the IEP team, and to train the team on assessment tools, analyze data, and develop a behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT. He also stated that Janet Halliday, the BICM, was to assist him in the process. Dr. Mesaros testified that the procedures entailed data collection, generation of a hypothesis regarding STUDENT's behavior, and development of the support plan. Dr. Mesaros stated that he was asked to look at specific behaviors including hitting, kicking, spiting, biting, and eloping from the class and school grounds.

Dr. Mesaros testified that he developed a large portion of the support plan and that Ms. Halliday contributed only minimally to the plan. Dr. Mesaros was not familiar with Ms. Halliday's educational background; however, he testified that she has foundational skills on the subject of behavior management. He expressed concerns regarding Ms. Halliday's ability to develop a comprehensive hypothesis regarding the nature of STUDENT's behaviors and to develop a comprehensive behavioral support program. Dr. Mesaros testified that Ms. Halliday generally deferred to him and solicited ideas from him, which he felt demonstrated her apparent lack of ideas regarding specific or appropriate strategies to address STUDENT's behavior. Dr. Mesaros also testified that Ms. Halliday demonstrated her bias against STUDENT's family when she made a declaration in support of Respondents' motion for contempt against PARENT.

Dr. Mesaros testified that STUDENT's behavioral plan requires ongoing monitoring and modification. He also stated that additional data may need to be collected in STUDENT's new educational environment. Dr. Mesaros testified that someone with his expertise is required to do the following: provide leadership; support and guide the gathering of additional data in STUDENT's new educational environment; train new staff; synthesize the data; and make recommendations to modify the existing plan. Dr. Mesaros testified that the team developed a good plan for STUDENT and that he wants to ensure that it is implemented and appropriately revised. Dr. Mesaros testified that it is integral to the implementation of STUDENT's behavioral program that the family supports the plan and that, because STUDENT's father exhibits confidence in him, he would be able to bridge controversies that have existed in the past between PARENT and the District.

Testifying on behalf of Respondents on this issue was Roger Titgemeyer, Ph.D. Dr. Titgemeyer is an administrator for the Orange County Office of Education (COE) pupil personnel and special schools programs. Dr. Titgemeyer expressed concerns regarding Dr. Mesaros having supervisory responsibility for STUDENT's behavioral program. He testified that Dr. Mesaros is not qualified to be a BICM, is not a licensed school or educational psychologist, and does not possess an administrative credential, which is necessary to supervise public school personnel. Dr. Titgemeyer testified that the primary role of the BICM is to develop the behavioral plan to be implemented in an educational environment. He stated that it is desirable to have communication and support from the child's home. Dr. Titgemeyer testified that Ms. Halliday is "absolutely" qualified to supervise STUDENT's program. Ms. Halliday completed BICM training sponsored by the COE which, according to Dr.

Titgemeyer, is the most comprehensive BICM training in the state. He stated also that if Ms. Halliday needs help, there are staff members within the county who are available for consultation. Dr. Titgemeyer testified that Ms. Halliday's preparation of a declaration in support of the District does not affect her ability to continue to reach out to the family and to work with STUDENT. Dr. Titgemeyer testified that from what he knows about Ms.

Halliday, she was expressing her concern about STUDENT's failure to attend school and unavailability for the functional analysis assessment.

Janet Halliday, school psychologist, is STUDENT's BICM. Ms.

Halliday holds a master's degree in educational psychology. She has teaching and pupil personnel credentials. Ms. Halliday testified that she received approximately 75 hours of training on the Hughes Bill from the COE and has received several additional days of training at conferences.(FOOTNOTE 9) Ms. Halliday testified that she has taken the following actions regarding STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan: she collected data on STUDENT's behavior; she prepared a draft of the findings from the data collection; she collaborated with Dr. Mesaros to integrate their findings and make recommendations for behavioral intervention strategies; she led staff training on the plan itself and how to implement the plan; she provided the same training in June to the summer staff; she participated in training regarding emergency procedures to employ with STUDENT; she developed an observational schedule with STUDENT's regular education teacher; she gathered data for two weeks; she scheduled weekly consultations with PARENT; and she met with STUDENT's new teacher for the 1996-97 school year to go over the plan with him.

Ms. Halliday responded to the assertion that her declaration in support of the District's motion to compel STUDENT's participation in a functional analysis assessment indicates that she is biased against STUDENT. Ms. Halliday testified that she prepared the declaration because of her belief that STUDENT needs to attend school, arrive at school on time, and to have an appropriate behavioral intervention plan developed and implemented so that he can benefit from his educational program. She testified that STUDENT's absence from school prevented him from participating in the functional analysis assessment and his educational program, and was significantly detrimental to his being successfully included in his regular education classroom. Ms. Halliday testified that she has continued to communicate with PARENT and to work with the family, and promised to continue to do so.

Ms. Halliday testified that she is fully qualified to implement the behavioral intervention plan and that there is no need for an outside consultant to supervise her. As to Dr.

Mesaros' involvement, Ms. Halliday testified that she found it difficult to reach Dr. Mesaros, he frequently was not available to discuss their work, and, on at least two occasions, he was not prepared for team meetings. At the IEP meeting on November 17, 1995, Dr. Mesaros wrote his notes while the meeting was in progress. Dr. Mesaros also was not prepared for a meeting on February 16, 1996.

Ms. Halliday testified that rather than working for consensus at meetings, Dr. Mesaros would "pull rank." Ms. Halliday testified that when she met Dr. Mesaros in September 1995, he informed her that he did not write reports and that he objected to the format utilized by the SELPA. He ultimately agreed to use the form. Ms. Halliday testified that Dr. Mesaros' ideas were good; however, his suggestions were of a global nature and were not necessarily based on data collected regarding STUDENT, nor were they specific enough to help staff deal with STUDENT's behaviors. Ms. Halliday testified that Dr. Mesaros adopted many of her findings in developing strategies for the behavioral intervention plan. Ms. Halliday also testified that she does not believe that Dr. Mesaros is impartial. She indicated that Dr. Mesaros had extensive conversations with PARENT but did not share the contents of conversations with District personnel.

Jim Hemsley, director of WOCCSE, testified that Dr. Mesaros has completed the function for which he was retained. Mr. Hemsley expressed several concerns regarding Dr. Mesaros, including his unavailability on several occasions for meetings and the distance from Dr. Mesaros' place of work to STUDENT's school. Mr. Hemsley also testified that Dr. Mesaros did not work collaboratively with the IEP team, was not impartial and always took the parent's side, and expanded the original role for which he was hired by taking charge of the development of STUDENT's behavioral plan. Mr.

Hemsley testified that Dr. Mesaros spoke of his need to "pull rank" when there was disagreement among the IEP team members.

Marilou Lundberg, District coordinator of special education, concurred with Mr. Hemsley's testimony that District members of the IEP team did not have any confidence in Dr. Mesaros because he did not work collaboratively with them. Ms. Lundberg expressed the following additional concerns regarding Dr. Mesaros' performance: Dr. Mesaros met with PARENT at an unknown location rather than with the IEP team as had previously been scheduled; he did not observe STUDENT on that date or at the next date set by the District; he never modeled for the staff techniques that he recommended be used with STUDENT; he observed staff members but did not communicate or work with them; and he did not work directly with STUDENT. Ms. Lundberg testified that based on her observations of Ms. Halliday working with students, parents, and staff, she concluded that Ms. Halliday is fully qualified to implement STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan. Ann Carr is an inclusion facilitator for the District. She holds a master's degree in education and several special education credentials. Ms. Carr provided direct services to STUDENT, provided training to PARENT, and collected data on STUDENT's behavior as part of the functional analysis assessment. Ms. Carr testified that Dr. Mesaros did not work collaboratively with the team and was rarely available to them. She testified that she saw Dr. Mesaros on campus only three times in the fall of 1995.

Connie McCandless, STUDENT's second grade teacher, participated in development of the behavioral intervention plan. Ms. McCandless testified that Dr. Mesaros' recommendations were more theoretical than practical and, on those few occasions when Dr. Mesaros visited her class, he did not offer any suggestions to her regarding STUDENT. Ms. McCandless testified that many things in STUDENT's program were working well and that it appeared Dr. Mesaros wanted to change some of those elements that were working. Ms. McCandless testified that she has worked with Ms. Halliday during the past three years. Ms. McCandless described Ms. Halliday as very competent and found that her ideas had practical application.

Dan Moss was principal of Circle View Elementary School. Mr.

Moss testified that during his tenure as principal, Ms. Halliday performed her job well. He also testified that Ms. Halliday has excellent communication skills and is an excellent choice to lead STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan. Mr. Moss testified that Dr. Mesaros has good credentials; however, he was rarely available to the staff. Mr. Moss noted also that Dr. Mesaros did not demonstrate how to implement behavioral intervention techniques. In his opinion, Dr. Mesaros "aligned" very quickly with PARENT.

Maria Shickler, adapted physical education (APE) specialist, provides STUDENT with APE. She testified that Ms. Halliday observed STUDENT a number of times during the school year and was available to answer questions regarding techniques to employ with STUDENT. On the other hand, on the two occasions she saw Dr.

Mesaros, he did not appear to have much familiarity with STUDENT. Ms. Shickler testified that Dr. Mesaros appeared to rely on other team members for information regarding STUDENT. On one occasion, Ms. Shickler was called on to demonstrate emergency procedures to employ with STUDENT because Dr. Mesaros was unfamiliar with the appropriate technique.

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child...." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

California Education Code § 56363(a) states in relevant part:

Designated instruction and services...shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.(FOOTNOTE 10)

In addition, the Code of Federal Regulations defines related services as:

...transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as are required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education,.... [emphasis added]

34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a)

The note to Section 300.16 states:

Each related service defined under this part may include appropriate administrative and supervisory activities that are necessary for program planning, management, and evaluation. [emphasis added]

Based on the code sections above, the Hearing Officer concludes that, under certain circumstances, supervision is a related service.

The regulatory scheme implementing Hughes Bill behavioral intervention plans states that plans "shall only be implemented by, or be under the supervision of, staff with documented training in behavior analysis, including the use of positive behavioral interventions." (Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3052(2)) Ms. Halliday has been selected as the BICM for STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan. The BICM is a part of the IEP team and, among other responsibilities, supervises and consults with staff and parents who are implementing the behavioral intervention plan. The regulations do not call for someone in addition to the BICM to supervise or oversee implementation of the plan. (See generally 5 CCR §§ 3001 and 3052) In this case, Petitioner contends, however, that Dr. Mesaros, or someone with similar qualifications and experience, is necessary to supervise implementation of his behavioral intervention plan.

It has been established in an earlier hearing that Ms.

Halliday is qualified to serve as BICM for STUDENT and meets the requirements set forth in 5 CCR § 3052(2). Ms. Halliday is a credentialed school psychologist and has received comprehensive training in Hughes Bill functional analysis assessments and behavioral intervention plans. She participated in STUDENT's functional analysis assessment and the development of his behavioral intervention plan. The Hearing Officer found that Ms. Halliday was "well-qualified and can participate in STUDENT's assessment in a professional and fair manner." The Hearing Officer also found that Ms. Halliday did not have any bias against either PARENT or STUDENT. (Decision, Case No. SN 810-94, p. 30) Ms. Halliday presented herself in the same manner in this hearing, and there is no persuasive evidence to reach a different finding in this hearing regarding Ms. Halliday's qualifications or her ability to perform the duties of a BICM in a professional and unbiased manner.

STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan was developed by the IEP team. PARENT was a part of the IEP team, as were Dr. Mesaros and Ms. Halliday. At the time the plan was agreed to, no one suggested that it was necessary to have additional supervisory services from Dr. Mesaros or anyone else. Thus, the behavioral intervention plan does not call for a person to supervise the BICM and other persons who are implementing the plan. None of the persons with responsibility for implementing STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan supported Petitioner's contention that an additional person is necessary, beyond the BICM, to supervise implementation of the plan. The plan is specific and the staff responsible for its implementation receivied training from Dr. Mesaros and Ms. Halliday to implement the plan. None of Respondents' witnesses who work with STUDENT testified regarding the need for more training or supervision regarding the plan or its implementation. Ms. Halliday is available, as are other resources within the District and County, to offer assistance with implementing and/or modifying the plan. School staff who have worked with Ms. Halliday, the District's BICM, testified that she works well with them, is available to provide them with assistance, and has constructive suggestions regarding methods to employ with

STUDENT.

As to whether PARENT' distrust of Respondents' personnel justifies the need for Dr. Mesaros' services, the Hearing Officer notes that one circuit court has addressed parental hostility as a factor in determining whether a district has proposed an appropriate placement. In Board of Education of Community Consolidated School District No. 21 v. Illinois State Board of Education (7th Cir. 1991) 938 F.2d 712, the Seventh Circuit found that the District Court had appropriately considered the parents' hostility to a proposed placement in determining whether the proposed placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit for the child. California falls within the jurisdiction of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals and, therefore, this case merely constitutes persuasive authority. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds the reasoning of the dissent in the above case more persuasive that the majority's reasoning. The dissent concluded that the school district should have been allowed to implement the placement once it had been determined that the proposed placement was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. The majority, however, allowed the parents to have an "absolute veto" over the proposed placement. Illinois State Board, supra, 938 F.2d at 718-719.

Even if parental hostility is considered in this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the dispute between the parties does not result in the denial of a free appropriate public education for STUDENT. The ongoing dispute between the parties is well documented; however, in relation to the development of STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan, there has been a great deal of collaboration between the parties. The parent participated in data collection and the drafting of the plan and has consented to its implementation. With the exception of the services disputed at this hearing, the parties have also agreed to STUDENT's placement in a regular education program and to a number of other related services.

For all of the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mesaros' services to "bridge" controversies between the parent and the District are not necessary to successfully implement the behavioral intervention plan or to provide STUDENT with an appropriate education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes as a matter of law that the District is not required to provide the services of Dr. Mesaros or someone with similar qualifications and experience, to supervise STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations of Beth Ballinger, O.D., contained in the report of her assessment of STUDENT, dated February 7, 1995?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that an appropriate education includes optometric services at the level recommended by Dr. Ballinger. Dr. Ballinger recommended that she provide approximately 74 hours annually of consultative services to the District in regard to STUDENT. Petitioner asserts that Dr. Ballinger is familiar with his needs and is qualified to make recommendations regarding his vision needs. Respondents generally concur with Dr. Ballinger's recommendations; however, they do not agree with the number of hours she has recommended. The District has offered to provide optometric consultations to the staff working with STUDENT at the rate of two hours per month.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioner called Dr. Ballinger as a witness. Beth Ballinger, O.D., is a developmental optometrist in private practice. She has assessed between 12 and 24 students for the District. Dr.

Ballinger first assessed STUDENT at the request of WOCCSE in March 1993. (Petitioner's Exhibit 1) She testified that at that time she recommended that STUDENT be considered for occupational therapy (OT) that would incorporate a vision enhancement program. In February 1995, Dr. Ballinger again assessed STUDENT at the request of WOCCSE. The results of her assessment are contained in a report dated February 7, 1995. (Petitioner's Exhibit 2) Dr. Ballinger recommended that STUDENT participate in a multi-disciplinary, multi-sensory approach learning program. She also recommended 74 hours of consultative services to the staff working with STUDENT. Dr. Ballinger's report sets forth the rationale for the amount of time she recommended for optometric services:

A program for visual enhancement for visual-motor integration development...is necessary to prepare STUDENT for success with increasing visual demands needed for accessing language and reading. This program needs to be ongoing over the year and have flexibility of design.

Staff and parent inservicing will be needed. Program development, monitoring ever changing academic and classroom demands, modification and evaluation of effectiveness will require approximately 74 hours of on-sight optometric consultation time for the school year.

(Petitioner's Exhibit 2)

Dr. Ballinger testified that she has recently seen STUDENT in a home environment. She continues to recommend the same level of services for him. Dr. Ballinger proposed that at the initiation of the program, she would spend an entire day with STUDENT each week. She would then provide 15 to 20 hours of training for the staff working with STUDENT and, thereafter, would visit the site monthly to evaluate and modify STUDENT's program and to meet with staff. Dr. Ballinger testified that she would also evaluate STUDENT in his classroom utilizing a retinoscope. According to Dr. Ballinger, a retinoscope measures the body's response to a light source coming from the back of the retina.(FOOTNOTE 11) Dr. Ballinger stated that a retinoscope is an unobtrusive means to objectively gather information, including when and for how long STUDENT is focusing and whether "the cognitive link is open." Dr. Ballinger testified that some of her recommendations for STUDENT are incorporated in goals and objectives regarding OT and fine-motor development.

Testifying on behalf of Respondents was Jane Vogel, WOCCSE teacher of the visually impaired. Ms. Vogel holds a master's degree in education and a number of regular and special education credentials. She belongs to several professional organizations and has published in professional journals. Ms. Vogel testified that Dr. Ballinger's recommendations generally are not related to optometry or vision. Ms. Vogel testified that Dr. Ballinger's recommendations can be carried out by someone other than an optometrist. Ms. Vogel testified that she is not aware of any therapeutic use for the retinoscope and that, to her knowledge, a retinoscope cannot be used to determine on-task behavior. Ms. Vogel testified that a retinoscope is used to diagnose pathology of the eye. Ms. Vogel testified that a student's on-task behavior can be determined by staff observation of the student's body language, eye contact with the materials or the instructor, verbal responses, and completion of tasks.

Mr. Hemsley testified that prior to the hearing, Dr. Ballinger had not before recommended the use of a retinoscope. Mr. Hemsley testified that District and WOCCSE personnel can implement Dr. Ballinger's recommendations.

Cecile (Sissy) Sandeen, Ed.D., was STUDENT's home teacher during the 1994-1995 school year. Dr. Sandeen testified that Dr. Ballinger is competent, but that her services are not necessary to implement STUDENT's IEP. Dr. Sandeen testified that her own training for RSP certification included visual-motor integration and that she is qualified and able to implement Dr. Ballinger's recommendations.

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

A district is required to provide related services when the services are necessary to meet a student's unique and individual needs and to allow the student to benefit from his education. The IEP team has not deemed STUDENT eligible for special education because of a visual impairment; however, according to Dr.

Ballinger, STUDENT does exhibit deficits in visual-motor integration. In 1993, Dr. Ballinger identified deficits in his ability to control visual motor tracking and focusing. STUDENT continued to exhibit deficits in visual-motor integration during Dr. Ballinger's assessment of him in February 1995. (Petitioner's Exhibit 1)

Dr. Ballinger presented her findings and recommended goals and objectives to the IEP team in 1995. The last agreed-upon goals and objectives, which are contained in STUDENT's IEP dated June 20, 1995, incorporated many of Dr. Ballinger's suggestions as well. For example, goals and objectives for which the occupational therapist has responsibility include "to improve functional ocular motor control and greater success for writing, copying, eye hand coordination tasks, and eventually reading." There also is a goal designed to increase STUDENT's sustained attention and focus. The speech and language specialist is deemed responsible for implementing this goal. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-7) No one disputed Dr. Ballinger's assessment of STUDENT's deficits in visual-motor integration or that STUDENT continues to require goals and objectives to address these deficits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP shall continue to include goals and objectives to address his deficits in this area.

The IEP team also concluded that STUDENT would benefit from optometric consultation to assist in the implementation of the above goals and objectives. Respondents proposed that his needs could be met through two hours per month of such services, whereas Petitioner contends that he requires 74 hours of consultative services, delivered over the course of the school year. At the hearing, Dr. Ballinger acknowledged that many of her suggestions are related to general education practices for students with disabilities. For example, a multisensory approach and signing are methods employed in many regular and special education environments. Dr. Ballinger also acknowledged that the goals and objectives described above can be carried out by other staff members, such as the speech and language therapist and/or the occupational therapist. Dr. Sandeen, who worked directly with STUDENT for an entire school year, testified that as an RSP teacher, she has appropriate training and would also be able to implement many of Dr. Ballinger's recommendations.

Dr. Ballinger's assessment of STUDENT is nearly two years old. When Dr. Ballinger last assessed STUDENT, he was receiving home instruction while in the first grade, which followed a difficult kindergarten year. At that time, the IEP team was in the process of developing plans to transition STUDENT back into a school environment. Since Dr. Ballinger's assessment in 1995, STUDENT has spent one year in a regular education second-grade class. The evidence establishes that STUDENT's needs in an educational environment have changed, as have his behavior and attention span. Thus, Dr. Ballinger's recommendations were based on circumstances that have now changed. Dr. Ballinger has seen STUDENT recently in a home environment; however, she has not recently observed STUDENT in an educational environment or with the level of support that is currently available to him. The Hearing Officer also is not persuaded that Dr. Ballinger's current recommendation regarding the use of retinoscope, a diagnostic tool, justifies the need for the amount of time Dr. Ballinger has recommended for consultation services regarding STUDENT.

For the reasons discussed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner has not substantiated that 74 hours annually of consultation by Dr. Ballinger are necessary to implement the agreed-upon goals and objectives, to meet his unique and individual needs, or to allow him to benefit from his education. Therefore, Petitioner's request for optometric consultations at this level is denied.

The Hearing Officer has great concern that STUDENT's IEP has not been revised since June 1995, other than to add the behavioral intervention plan.(FOOTNOTE 12) The IEP team must meet at least annually to review the student's progress, review and revise as appropriate the IEP goals and objectives, and determine an appropriate placement. California Education Code § 56343(d). In this case, the IEP has remained in force pursuant to stay-put. Because there is no current IEP, the Hearing Officer determines that the District is required to continue implementing the last agreed-upon goals and objectives and to provide two hours per month of optometric consultations to the staff working with STUDENT until a new IEP has been developed. Given that STUDENT's IEP is over one year old, the Hearing Officer orders the District to convene an IEP meeting within 10 calendar days of receipt of this decision.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is the District obligated to have WITNESS, C.C.C., implement the recommendations for speech and language services which are contained in the report of her January 1995 assessment of STUDENT?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that an appropriate education includes the speech and language services recommended by WITNESS. Petitioner asserts that WITNESS assessed him at the behest of the District but that the District is not now implementing the services she recommended because of "politics or in retaliation." Petitioner asserts that WITNESS knows him well and is qualified to assess him and to make recommendations regarding his educational needs.

Petitioner requests that either WITNESS or someone with similar qualifications provide the services she has recommended.

Respondents contend that because of WITNESS's personal relationship with Petitioner's father, it is not appropriate for her to make recommendations or provide services for STUDENT.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

WITNESS holds a master's degree in speech pathology and audiology and is a licensed speech pathologist. WITNESS is an independent consultant regarding augmentative and alternative communication. She was employed for 10 years by the Huntington Beach Union High School District and WOCCSE. WITNESS stated that Respondents viewed her as "unconventional." WITNESS testified that she sees STUDENT regularly because of her relationship with STUDENT's father.

During the summer of 1994, the District employed WITNESS as STUDENT's home teacher. In January 1995, WITNESS assessed STUDENT's speech and language skills. (Petitioner's Exhibit 3) She testified that STUDENT's nonconventional ways of communicating includes jargon, vocalizations, movement, pulling people toward what he wanted, and other "out of focus" behavior. WITNESS's original recommendations included training for STUDENT's parent, teacher, and aide regarding how to recognize his communications and how to get him from nonsymbolic to symbolic communication. She recommended that key words be signed to STUDENT and that he receive therapy to address production of speech. WITNESS testified that many of her recommendations were implemented by the District;

however, she asserted that certain components of the program she recommended are not being utilized and other components of the program need revision. WITNESS testified that STUDENT's computer is not being utilized appropriately, the aide needs more formal training in sign language, and STUDENT's sign/symbol system that represents the sequence of activities in his school day needs to be expanded. WITNESS testified that follow-up is very important to ensure that the agreed-upon language program is being implemented and is appropriately modified.

During her testimony, WITNESS made the following recommendations: incorporate signing and verbal language into STUDENT's activities; use a pictograph for activities and objections; use computers appropriately; and monitor and modify STUDENT's program regularly to ensure that it is meeting his needs.(FOOTNOTE 13) WITNESS testified that her recommendations regarding STUDENT have not been affected by the relationship she has with PARENT. WITNESS testified that her recommendations were made long before she had a personal relationship with PARENT and were based on her experiences working with STUDENT.

Cynthia Cottier, who was called to testify on behalf of Respondents, holds master's degrees in speech pathology and education administration. Ms. Cottier is in private practice and consults with WOCCSE regarding augmentative and alternative communication. She has authored a publication regarding how to provide augmentative and assistive communication via the consultative model. Ms. Cottier testified that if she were requested to provide services to STUDENT, she would first evaluate him because she has not met STUDENT and because WITNESS's evaluation is over one year old. Included in the information she would obtain is a baseline of STUDENT's current communication skills. She would also observe him in his classroom to evaluate what is working and what is not. Ms. Cottier testified that to develop STUDENT's ability to communicate independently, she would utilize pantomime, gestures, picture systems, communication boards, technology with voice output, and signing. Ms. Cottier testified that the consultative model is an appropriate way to meet STUDENT's needs. She testified that initially she would meet weekly with the staff providing services to STUDENT to train them on the varying communication systems so that they could meet STUDENT's needs with consistency. She would then gradually reduce the number of visits to every other week or less frequent.

Charlotte Gibbs, District speech and language specialist, worked with STUDENT during the summer of 1995, and provided him with one hour daily of speech and language therapy during the 1995-1996 school year. Ms. Gibbs testified that when STUDENT was willing, she worked with him at the computer on language-based activities. She also planned activities to get STUDENT used to wearing headsets, taught him some words to sign, and engaged with him in cutting, pasting, and tracing words. Ms. Gibbs testified that she assembled a communication book and provided a picture exchange system for STUDENT. Although she requested information and materials from WITNESS, she did not obtain either from her.

Ms. Carr, the District's inclusion specialist, testified that STUDENT's greatest area of need is communication. He needs to increase his language development and sight vocabulary and to improve his interactions with peers. Ms. Carr testified that information from over one year ago does not necessarily reflect STUDENT's current needs. She testified that STUDENT has made changes in communication skills within the last 10 months.

Mr. Hemsley testified that at the IEP meeting on June 20, 1995, WITNESS discussed her assessment of STUDENT. Based on WITNESS recommendations, the IEP team developed goals and objectives, which were implemented with the approval of PARENT.

Dr. Sandeen, STUDENT's home teacher, testified that WITNESS's recommendations were incorporated into the goals and objectives in STUDENT's IEP dated June 20, 1995. (Respondents' Exhibit 3-7)

Mr. Moss, principal, described WITNESS as "talented." He also testified that she found it hard to stick to a fixed schedule and was not punctual, according to his time table.

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Petitioner's and Respondents' witnesses with training and experience in the area of speech and language testified regarding the need to re-evaluate STUDENT's communication skills to determine what services are currently needed and in what way the existing program needs to be modified. Therefore, based on their testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that an assessment of STUDENT's communication skills is warranted. Ms. Cottier discussed the basic information that is needed to provide a program to meet STUDENT's needs. No one disputed her recommendations. Therefore, based on Ms. Cottier's testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment must minimally include a determination of the baseline of STUDENT's current communication skills and an observation of STUDENT in his classroom.

The Hearing Officer also concludes that until such time as an assessment is completed and an IEP developed, the goals and objectives set forth in STUDENT's IEP dated June 20, 1995, must be continue to be implemented. (See Respondents' Exhibit 3-5, p. 5 and Exhibit 3-7 pp. 2 and 12.) These are the last agreed-upon goals and objectives and were based on the recommendations of

WITNESS.

As to who should provide speech and language services to STUDENT, personnel matters are generally at the discretion of the school district. The California Code of Regulations specifies that the person providing services must be "qualified." Under 5 CCR § 3001(x), "qualified" means "a person who has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services...."

Respondents stated that Ms. Cottier or someone with similar qualifications is available to provide services for STUDENT. Ms. Cottier holds master's degrees in speech pathology and education administration and, therefore, would appear to be "qualified" to provide services to STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner did not elicit persuasive evidence that Respondents are required to re-employ or to contract with WITNESS to provide services to STUDENT, so long as they available to provide someone who is qualified under Section 3001(x) of the CCR to provide STUDENT's speech and language services.

ISSUE NO. 4: Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations for audiological services made by Rosemarie Davis, C.C.C., which are contained in the report of her March 1995 assessment of STUDENT?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that he continues to require the audiological services recommended by Ms. Davis in her report of March 1995, and that the District is responsible for implementing her recommendations. The District contends that Ms. Davis' recommendations have been addressed in the last agreed-upon goals and objectives.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

WITNESS testified that at the IEP team meeting in April 1995, she discussed Ms. Davis' suggestions that an FM auditory trainer be used with STUDENT and that STUDENT should be provided activities to get him used to wearing headsets so that an accurate measure of his hearing could be obtained. WITNESS also recommended that STUDENT use an FM amplifier to help him focus on one speaker and to reduce auditory distractions. WITNESS testified that the IEP team drafted objectives regarding STUDENT's use of headsets and the amplification system but that to her knowledge, the objectives have not been implemented.

Ms. Gibbs, who provided speech and language therapy to STUDENT during the 1995-1996 school year, testified that she planned activities for STUDENT to help him sustain the period during which he was willing to wear headsets.(FOOTNOTE 14) She also testified that in her opinion, an amplification system would not work well with STUDENT because the amplifier would pick up background noise, which would be distracting to him.

FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Ms. Davis' report includes the following recommendations:

1. ...This change in behavior [STUDENT's willingness to wear earphones] should be utilized to:

A. provide play audiometric training through earphones so that more comprehensive information can be obtained regarding STUDENT's hearing status and auditory processing skills.

B. conduct language lessons while providing a more optimal auditory signal using an Fm type auditory training device.

C. facilitate auditory focusing during "free time"

at home while using earphones to listen to music, video and story books.

2. Middle ear status should be monitored regularly....

3. STUDENT's family was requested to monitor STUDENT's hypersensitivity responses....

4. STUDENT should be seen for more comprehensive audiological assessment....

(Petitioner's Exhibit 4)

Based on Ms. Davis' recommendations, the IEP team included the following objective in an IEP developed for STUDENT in April 1995: "By October 1995, STUDENT will be able to tolerate wearing earphones for reevaluation of hearing status and auditory processing skills...." (Respondents' Exhibit 3-7) Updates made to the objective in November 1995 and February 1996 state that STUDENT was able to wear headsets for up to three minutes. Based on Ms. Gibbs' testimony that she implemented the objectives and on the information contained in the IEP, WITNESS's claim that the objective regarding STUDENT's use of headsets was not implemented is unfounded. There was no evidence, however, that STUDENT has been seen for a re-evaluation of his hearing status and auditory processing skills called for by Ms. Davis and set forth in the IEP. STUDENT's IEP also includes an objective regarding use of an FM auditory training device:

By June 1995, STUDENT will participate in language lessons for up to 10 minute intervals using an FM-type auditory training device in a one-to-one condition in home and/or school setting....

Ms. Davis did not favor use of an amplification system with STUDENT; however, there is no evidence that an amplification system has ever been attempted or utilized with STUDENT.

As discussed above, there is no current IEP for STUDENT. For this reason and because the evidence establishes that the goals and objectives discussed above have not been met, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District must continue to implement the last agreed-upon goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no other evidence presented at the hearing to warrant any additional audiological services.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

ISSUE NO. 1: To receive a free, appropriate public education, does STUDENT require the appointment of a qualified and experienced behavior specialist, such as Richard Mesaros, Ph.D., to supervise and monitor the District's behavioral intervention case manager (BICM), Janet Halliday, and the implementation of STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan?

Respondents prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 2: Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations of Beth Ballinger, O.D., contained in the report of her assessment of STUDENT dated, February 7, 1995?

Respondents substantially prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 3: Is the District obligated to have WITNESS, C.C.C., implement the recommendations for speech and language services which are contained in the report of her January 1995 assessment of STUDENT?

Respondents substantially prevailed on this issue.

ISSUE NO. 4: Is the District obligated to implement the recommendations for audiological services made by Rosemarie Davis, C.C.C., which are contained in the report of her March 1995 assessment of STUDENT?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

ORDER

(1) Within 10 calendar days of receipt of this decision, the IEP team shall meet to do the following:

(a) prepare an assessment plan to evaluate STUDENT's speech, language, and audiological needs;

(b) develop goals and objectives for the 1996-1997 school year; and (c) write an IEP that reflects the agreement regarding placement and services.

(2) Until an IEP is developed, Respondents shall continue to do the following:

(a) implement the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT's IEP dated June 20, 1995 (Respondents' Exhibit 3-7);

(b) provide the services authorized by PARENT in the letter dated October 3, 1995, from Petitioner's attorney Diane Lipton; and (c) provide two hours per month of optometric consultation.

(3) All other requests for relief are denied.

DATED: November 12, 1996 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. During the first three days of hearing, PARENT participated in the hearing by telephone. PARENT was present at the hearing for the last three days and participated in oral closing arguments by telephone.

2. Ultimately, Mr. Schoneberger was not involved in either the assessment or the development of the behavioral intervention plan.

3. In a letter dated August 20, 1996, Mr. Wenkart requested, among other things, that the Hearing Office quash Petitioner's request for subpoenas for some 41 individuals, including Mr. Hagen. The Hearing Office did, in fact, rule on Respondents' motion. In an order issued on August 22, 1996, Hearing Officer Garfinkel made the following determination:

Petitioner's request for seventy-three (73) subpoenas is granted in part and denied in part. Ten (10) subpoenas will be issued at this time. At the hearing, the assigned Hearing Officer may issue such additional subpoenas as appear necessary.

Petitioner elected to use one of the subpoenas for Mr. Hagen. Respondents did not then take any further action in advance of the hearing to quash Mr. Hagen's subpoena.

4. Consent for the District to implement the placement and services is expressed in a letter dated October 9, 1995, from Petitioner's attorney, Ms. Lipton.

5. At this time, PARENT and STUDENT were represented by attorney Joan Honeycutt.

6. The parties stipulated that Mr. Schoneberger would conduct the functional analysis assessment.

7. In April 1996, the District concluded that STUDENT no longer resided within the District and required that PARENT submit proof of residency. STUDENT was precluded from attending school in the District for 14 days. He was allowed to return to school after the District accepted documents by PARENT substantiating his residency within the boundaries of the District. (Petitioner's Exhibit 8-H) 8. Dr. Mesaros teaches at California State University, Northridge, which is approximately 60 miles from STUDENT's school.

9. California Education Code § 56520, which is commonly referred to as the "Hughes Bill," addresses the use of behavioral interventions with special education students. Implementing regulations are contained within Title 5, California Code of Regulations, §§ 3052, 3001.

10. Designated instruction and services (DIS) is California's term for related services.

11. Dorland's Illustrated Medical Dictionary (28th Ed., 1994) p. 1455, describes a retinoscope as an instrument for performing retinoscopy, which is "an objective method for investigating, diagnosing, and evaluating refractive errors of the eye, by projection of a beam of light into the eye and observation of the movement of the illuminated area on the retina surface and of the refraction by the eye of the emergent rays."

12. Respondents advised the Hearing Officer that several dates have been set for an IEP meeting; however, an IEP meeting had not been convened prior to the close of the hearing.

13. WITNESS also recommended use of an FM auditory trainer with STUDENT. This recommendation is addressed below in Issue No. 4.

14. In her recommendations, Ms. Davis refers to the use of "headphones" with STUDENT. The IEP indicates that "earphones" would be used and Ms. Gibbs testified that she used "headsets" with STUDENT. It appears that the terminology--headphones, earphones, and headsets--has been used interchangeably.