California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 9, 1997
Student v. Pleasant Valley School District
SEHO Case No. SN 909-96 · Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson
Pleasant Valley School District must pay $5,400 for an independent assessment and provide handwriting technology; SED eligibility upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A parent filed for due process against Pleasant Valley School District for her 13-year-old son. Over the years he had been served as speech impaired, learning disabled, and then seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). He also has ADHD and serious handwriting delays. The parent disputed the SED label, moved him to a home-study program for 1996-97, and asked to be repaid for that program and for an independent assessment.
Hearing Officer Kathleen Peterson upheld the SED eligibility. The District had moved the student into an SED class in third grade without an IEP meeting. Even so, he had shown a long-standing, pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression and inappropriate behaviors that hurt his learning, both before that move and in 1996-97. She found he needs assistive technology for handwriting. She also found the District denied FAPE for 1996-97. Its offer lacked one-to-one help, transportation to counseling, and handwriting support. The June 1996 IEP meeting went ahead without his teacher or the assessing psychologist, and staff used intimidating tactics. Still, she denied repayment for the home program because it had no special education teacher, no nondisabled peers, and no proof of benefit. The District's 1996 assessment skipped handwriting and let an observer sit in on testing, so the District must pay $5,400 of the independent psychologist's bill. For 1997-98, it must also provide a Talking Pen and a home practice program started by an occupational therapist, plus a keyboard for school.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO kept a finding that FAPE was denied separate from a reimbursement award. Because the parent's home program was not shown to be appropriate, she was not repaid. It also shows a district paying for an independent assessment even though its eligibility conclusion was correct, because its own assessment missed an area of suspected disability.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue I. Did the IEP team correctly assess STUDENT's handicapping condition as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?
The District moved the student to an SED class in third grade without an IEP meeting, which was a procedural violation. However, the student showed a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression and inappropriate behavior or feelings, both before that move and in 1996-97, so the SED eligibility was correct.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue II. Does STUDENT require assistive technology in order to receive a free appropriate public education?
The student's handwriting is markedly delayed, so he needs a Talking Pen for home practice, a keyboard at school, and an OT-initiated home program to receive FAPE.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue III. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for her expenses in placing him in his current academic placement, including tuition, tutoring, and books?
The District denied FAPE for 1996-97. Its offer lacked one-to-one help, transportation to counseling, and handwriting support, and the IEP meeting went ahead without the teacher or the assessing psychologist and used intimidating tactics. Reimbursement was denied because the home program was not shown to be appropriate.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue IV. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for the expenses in obtaining an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Marc Heller?
The District's 1996 assessment was inappropriate because it did not assess handwriting and allowed an observer during testing. The District must reimburse $5,400 in evaluation-related costs but not the costs of testimony or consultation.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to provide or change services. For the 1997-98 school year, the District shall provide a home practice program initiated by an occupational therapist (OTR) that uses a 'Talking Pen' for practice, and a keyboard (with a word processing program of the District's choice) for use in school.
- Reimbursement. The District shall reimburse the mother $5,400 for Dr. Marc Heller's independent assessment within thirty days of the order. This is 27 hours at $200 per hour. Billed time for testimony ($2,800) and consultation ($1,600) was excluded.
Total: $5,400 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Landgraf v. USI Film Products; Letter to Anonymous, 22 IDELR 637 (OSEP 1995); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); 34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); Education Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Cathrine Cartwright, District director of special services, Pleasant Valley School District
- Dr. Marc Heller, independent evaluator; school and clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Honore Kyle-DeCecco, registered occupational therapist; independent handwriting assessor; witness for Student, Columbia Rehab Center
- Myra (Mikki) Heeg, home teacher and day care provider; witness for Student
- Linda Van Dolsen, private tutor; witness for Student
- Matt Borchard, District summer school teacher (1996), Pleasant Valley School District
- Carol Marvin, fifth-grade mainstream teacher, Pleasant Valley School District
- Dr. Paula Cornelius-Lopez, District program specialist, Pleasant Valley School District
- Pat Fitzgerald, principal, Santa Rosa school, Pleasant Valley School District
- Dr. Candra Shiney-Norris, District psychologist; 1993 assessor, Pleasant Valley School District
- Lucy Ableser, school psychologist; 1996 triennial assessor, Pleasant Valley School District
- Christine Welch, school psychologist (1990 evaluation), Pleasant Valley School District
- Dr. Donald Hughes, physician (M.D.), Conejo Counseling Center
- Diane Wamsley, LCSW; AB 3632 mental health counselor, Ventura County Mental Health
- Dr. Nathan Goodlow, independent psychological evaluator (1993), Ventura County Mental Health
- Ms. Rode, first- and second-grade teacher
- Karen Emery, sixth-grade SDC teacher, Pleasant Valley School District
- Mrs. Cooney, classroom aide, Pleasant Valley School District
- Ellen Nilssen, third-grade SED-SDC teacher, Pleasant Valley School District
- Toby Forden, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Pleasant Valley School District
- Jacine Lester, special education teacher (proposed placement), Monte Vista Junior High
- Amy Huff, special education teacher (proposed placement), Monte Vista Junior High
- Carol Springate, physical education teacher (proposed placement), Monte Vista Junior High
- Joan Cherno, speech and language specialist, Monte Vista Junior High
- Ann Harrell, speech and language specialist (1996 assessment), Pleasant Valley School District
- Mark Bucalis, school psychologist who attended the June 1996 IEP meeting in place of the assessor, Pleasant Valley School District
- Mary Emma Wills, supervising teacher, Laurel Springs home-study program
- Laurel Springs, private home-study program
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Kathleen Peterson, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Camarillo, California, on March 11, April 8 and 9, and June 26 and 27, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrew Koenig. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his mother, Ms. PARENT.
Respondent Pleasant Valley School District (hereafter District) was represented by attorney Sharon Watt. Also present on the District's behalf was Cathrine Cartwright, District director of special services.
Testifying on behalf of STUDENT were the following: Ms. PARENT; Dr. Marc Heller, school psychologist; Honore Kyle-DeCecco, Columbia Rehab Center registered occupational therapist (OTR); Myra ("Mikki") Heeg, STUDENT's home teacher and day care provider; Linda Van Dolsen, STUDENT's tutor and mother of a friend of his; Matt Borchard, STUDENT's District summer school teacher (1996); and Carol Marvin, one of STUDENT's District fifth-grade mainstream teachers.
Testifying on behalf of the District were the following: Dr. Paula Cornelius-Lopez, District program specialist; Pat Fitzgerald, District principal of Santa Rosa school; Dr. Candra Shiney-Norris, District psychologist; Lucy Ableser, District school psychologist; and Ms. Cartwright.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. On July 16, 1997, the Hearing Office received the closing arguments, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Petitioner originally submitted eleven issues for hearing. On the first and fourth days of hearing, the parties indicated that they had narrowed the issues for hearing by resolving some of the issues submitted, or parts thereof. The four issues remaining to be resolved by this decision are listed below.
ISSUES
I. Did the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team correctly assess STUDENT's handicapping condition as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?
II. Does STUDENT require assistive technology in order to receive a free appropriate public education?
III. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for her expenses in placing him in his current academic placement, including tuition, tutoring, and books?
IV. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for the expenses in obtaining an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Marc Heller?
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a 13-year-old male who has received special education services from the District under various eligibility labels, including speech impaired, learning disabled, and seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). Speech and language therapy was first provided to STUDENT by the District when he was initially found eligible for special education services in 1990. STUDENT has also been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Additionally, STUDENT has problems with handwriting.
STUDENT began receiving counseling at age four after early years of stress within his family. Beginning in February 1990, STUDENT began seeing Dr. Donald Hughes, M.D., and an attention deficit disorder counselor at Conejo Counseling Center. STUDENT was prescribed Ritalin for his ADHD very early on and continued to take it from March 17, 1990, until his medication was changed to Cylert during first grade (1991).
STUDENT was first found eligible for special education services by the District as speech impaired in kindergarten. For the rest of that school year (1989-90), STUDENT remained in the regular education program at Santa Rosa school and received speech and language therapy.
On June 11, 1990, District school psychologist Christine Welch conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. Ms. Welch concluded that STUDENT was in need of special education services and would benefit highly from a restricted environment due to his ADHD, communication and academic difficulties, and his behavior. On June 13, 1990, the IEP team placed STUDENT in a communicatively handicapped special day class (CH-SDC) at Santa Rosa school for the 1990-91 school year (first grade).
On April 30, 1991, District educational psychologist Dr. Candra Shiney-Norris prepared a referral for an AB3632 mental health assessment of STUDENT. On May 17, 1991, Ms. PARENT signed an AB3632 treatment plan for STUDENT for the 1991-92 school year. The treatment plan states that STUDENT was very concerned about death and violence, that his peer interactions were poor, that he was often withdrawn in the classroom, and that he often appeared dazed. By this time, STUDENT's medication for ADHD had been changed from Ritalin to Cylert. STUDENT was first seen by Diane Wamsley, LCSW, at Ventura County Mental Health that same day, following the referral from Dr. Shiney-Norris, for what Ms. Wamsley described as "withdrawn, bizarre behavior within the classroom." (Pet. Exh. E, p. 54.(Footnote 1)) The admission note states that when corrected in class, STUDENT often curled into a ball or stuck his head under a chair. It also indicates that STUDENT had threatened to kill himself. STUDENT continued to see Ms. Wamsley for AB3632 counseling until sometime during 1993. (Footnote 2) On May 20, 1991, the IEP team decided that STUDENT was eligible for AB3632 Mental Health services and continued his program in a CH-SDC for second grade (the 1991-92 school year), but changed the location to Las Posas school.
On May 18, 1992, Ms. PARENT signed a treatment plan for STUDENT for the 1992-93 school year, and the IEP team indicated agreement to continue STUDENT's placement in the Las Posas CH-SDC for that upcoming school year (third grade). (Dist. Exh. 8 and 32.(Footnote 3)) During third grade, STUDENT attended not only the Las Posas CH-SDC, as indicated in his May 1992 IEP, but also a CH-SDC at Camarillo Heights school and an SED-SDC at Los Nogales school, although there is no IEP documenting those changes. (Dist. Exh. 8, 24, 26, 28, and 30; Pet. Exh. F-8 and J-1; testimony of Ms. PARENT.) An issue arose at the hearing regarding whether, in December 1992, the District had transferred STUDENT to the Los Nogales SED-SDC without involving the IEP team.
On March 18, 1993, Ms. PARENT signed a referral for assessment and assessment plan regarding STUDENT. A psychological report prepared by District psychologist Dr. Candra Shiney-Norris indicates that she conducted testing of STUDENT on April 21 and May 7, 1993. Dr. Shiney-Norris concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services because of a serious emotional disturbance (SED). During third grade, STUDENT continued to take Cylert for his ADHD. The parties also disputed the appropriateness of the SED-SDC for STUDENT while he was in it during the 1992-93 school year. During third grade, STUDENT ran away from this class to the home of his day care provider, Ms. Heeg, but returned before reaching her house because he noticed he left his backpack at school.
An independent psychological evaluation of STUDENT, dated June 2, 1993, was completed by Dr. Nathan Goodlow, of Ventura County Mental Health, at Ms. PARENT's request. Dr. Goodlow's summary states that STUDENT was suffering from "extreme depression," although he noted that his "Axis I" diagnosis included ADHD as well as dysthymia. Dr. Goodlow recommended that STUDENT have his medications reevaluated (he was taking Cylert at the time), that teachers and counselors clarify their communications with STUDENT, and that he receive both individual and "conjoint" therapy (with his mother). Dr. Goodlow's report makes no conclusion regarding special education eligibility.
At the IEP team meeting on August 30, 1993 (Footnote 4), the District portion of the team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services as SED, and recommended the SED program at Los Nogales school for the 1993-94 school year (fourth grade). However, STUDENT's mother did not agree with the SED label or the recommended placement, and the rest of the IEP team agreed to place STUDENT in a regular education program at Santa Rosa school with resource specialist program (RSP) services, noting specifically that this placement was being made at his parent's request. That IEP, dated August 30, 1993, indicates that STUDENT would be "discharged" from the "SDC/SH" and transferred to a regular program. The parties disputed whether, at the IEP meeting in August 1993, the District had informed Ms. PARENT of her rights to contest the SED label, to request an independent assessment, and to request a due process hearing.
On November 22, 1993, the IEP team continued STUDENT's placement in RSP at Santa Rosa school for the 1993-94 school year (fourth grade) pursuant to Ms. PARENT's request, while noting the rest of the IEP team's concerns that STUDENT required placement in an SDC for the 1993-94 school year. STUDENT's eligibility was again marked as SED. On March 10, 1994, the IEP team changed STUDENT's placement from RSP to a "Non-SH SDC" at Santa Rosa school for the remainder of the 1993-94 school year (fourth grade). STUDENT's handicapping condition was still noted as SED, and Ms. PARENT signed her consent to the placement. Ms. PARENT said that she was told STUDENT needed more "resource" and needed to be in the SDC to get it.
On September 22, 1994, the IEP team continued STUDENT's placement in the "Non-SH SDC" at Santa Rosa school for the 1994-95 school year (fifth grade), stating that STUDENT was still eligible as SED, and Ms. PARENT again signed her consent to this IEP. During fifth grade, STUDENT began taking herbal medications for his ADHD instead of Cylert.
On May 25, 1995, the IEP team met to review STUDENT's placement and agreed to continue his placement in the "Non-SH SDC" at Santa Rosa school for the 1995-96 school year (sixth grade). "SED" was still marked as STUDENT's handicapping condition and Ms. PARENT signed the IEP document. On September 14, 1995, the IEP team met again regarding STUDENT's sixth-grade placement and the document states that the team was "continuing" his placement in an SDC at Santa Rosa school, although the SDC was not described as being "Non-SH" on this IEP. STUDENT's handicapping condition was still marked as SED, and STUDENT's mother signed the IEP.
An issue arose at the hearing regarding the appropriateness of the SDC that STUDENT was in during sixth grade. The IEP of September 1995 indicates that STUDENT would be in the "SDC with mainstreaming for science, P.E., lunch, recess & special activities." STUDENT was selected to be a "big buddy" to some of the kindergarten students at the end of his day, from 2:00 p.m. to 2:45 p.m.
From approximately the last week of September or first week of October 1995, until the end of the school year in June 1996, STUDENT also received tutoring from Linda Van Dolsen, a mother of another child in STUDENT's day care. (Testimony of Ms. Van Dolsen.) Her tutoring utilized the "Hooked On Phonics" program. (Id.)
In a psychoeducational report regarding tests given to STUDENT on May 8 and 10, and June 3, 1996, District school psychologist Lucy Ableser found that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between his cognitive ability and his academic functioning, and that he also evidenced "signs of serious emotional disturbance." She concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services as SED.
On June 21, 1996, the IEP team proposed to place STUDENT in an SDC at Monte Vista school for the 1996-97 school year (seventh grade), indicating on the IEP document that it was a "Non-SH" SDC. STUDENT was still noted as being eligible for services as SED, and his mother again signed consent to the IEP. An issue arose at the hearing regarding whether STUDENT was ready to move on to junior high for the 1996-97 school year. The principal at Las Posas stated that STUDENT was beginning to experience teenage issues and to struggle with puberty/sexuality. STUDENT was a little older and taller (although thin) than most of the other sixth graders.
An issue arose at the hearing regarding the attendance of some of the IEP team members at the June 1996 meeting. Although she had recently performed an assessment of STUDENT, Ms. Ableser was not present at this IEP, nor was STUDENT's SDC teacher, Karen Emery.
The parties also disputed whether District director of special services, Cathrine Cartwright, behaved in an intimidating manner at the June 1996 IEP meeting in response to Ms. PARENT's request to allow STUDENT to repeat sixth grade. Ms. PARENT eventually signed the IEP.
On August 22, 1996, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from Ms. PARENT on STUDENT's behalf. In fall 1996, Ms. PARENT put STUDENT in the Laurel Springs home schooling program. Ms. PARENT said that she removed STUDENT from the District at the beginning of the 1996-97 school year because of her dispute with the District over the proposed placement and his eligibility. The District's home schooling program was full at that time and the District had informed Ms. PARENT of laws requiring school attendance.
The Laurel Springs program provides STUDENT with some consulting services once a month to check his progress. Laurel Springs has done no standardized testing on its own, and it is not providing its services pursuant to any of STUDENT's IEPs. STUDENT receives direct instruction at the home of his day care provider, Mikki Heeg, who is a friend of STUDENT's mother. Ms. Heeg is not a credentialed special education teacher although she has a lifetime teaching credential in regular education from New York state. Ms. Heeg is the director of the day care center which STUDENT attends during the hours he is not receiving instruction in the home teaching program.
On December 2 and 3, 1996, and February 10, 18, 21, and March 5, 1997, Dr. Marc Heller conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT pursuant to Ms. PARENT's request. Not including testimony, Dr. Heller's charges (billed at $200.00 per hour) for his evaluation total $7,000.00. Dr. Heller concluded in his report that STUDENT was eligible for special education as communication handicapped, learning disabled, and other health impaired/ADHD, but that STUDENT's behavioral and emotional problems "are not of sufficient frequency or severity to qualify him as Seriously Emotionally Disturbed."
On February 27, 1997, Honore Kyle-DeCecco, registered occupational therapist (OTR), Columbia Rehab Center, performed an assessment of STUDENT regarding his handwriting. Ms. Kyle-DeCecco found that while STUDENT had no delays in strength and had very good bilateral coordination, his printing and cursive handwriting were markedly delayed.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Did the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team correctly assess STUDENT's handicapping condition as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?
One of the biggest concerns Ms. PARENT had with the District's conclusion that STUDENT was SED was her belief that moving STUDENT (without her consent) into the Los Nogales SED-SDC before he was assessed and before the IEP team decided that he was SED, in effect, tainted the results of the assessment done five months later. Ms. PARENT likened this post-placement testing to putting a sane person in Camarillo State Hospital and then testing the person's sanity -- the sane person might begin to "seem" insane after being in that environment, just as STUDENT may have begun to "seem" as though he were SED after being in the SED environment for approximately five months. The District contends that STUDENT was SED before he was moved to the SED-SDC. To address the issue of whether STUDENT was correctly assessed as SED, the Hearing Officer will first consider the issue of whether STUDENT's placement was changed to an SED-SDC without agreement of the IEP team during third grade (the 1992-93 school year).
Ms. PARENT contends that when STUDENT began having more behavioral problems in third grade, she was told that he was eligible for a class for children with low self-esteem, but was not told that it was an SED class. She further contends that she never agreed to the placement change in writing and that no IEP team meeting was convened for such purpose before the change was implemented. The District contends that Ms. PARENT understood that STUDENT was being transferred to an SED-SDC and that she orally agreed to such a move. STUDENT's IEP for the 1992-93 school year indicates that the team agreed to place him in the CH-SDC at Las Posas school. Dr. Shiney-Norris's 1993 assessment indicates that STUDENT had been "transferred" twice during that same year, once from his Las Posas CH-SDC to the Camarillo Heights CH-SDC, and then from that class to the SED-SDC at Los Nogales school in December 1992. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was, in fact, "transferred" to an SED-SDC in third grade before he was found eligible as SED or officially placed there by the IEP team. A CH-SDC and an SED-SDC are sufficiently different enough in basic program components for the Hearing Officer to find further that this "transfer" was a change in STUDENT's placement. (Footnote 5)
An IEP is to be in effect before special education services are provided to a child. (34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1).) The IEP team must meet to revise a child's IEP. (34 C.F.R. § 300.343(a).) The Petitioner contends that the IEP team did not agree to move STUDENT to the SED-SDC in third grade; the District contends that Ms. PARENT's oral agreement to move STUDENT was sufficient agreement of the IEP team. Here, although STUDENT had an IEP in effect for the 1992-93 school year, which placed him in a CH-SDC, the IEP team did not meet and agree to change STUDENT's placement from the CH-SDC to an SED-SDC (or to change his eligibility status from a learning disability to seriously emotionally disturbed). A parent's oral agreement to change a child's special education placement is insufficient to serve as the IEP team's written agreement to do so. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District initiated a change in STUDENT's placement during third grade without the IEP team's input -- a violation of the procedural protections required for children with disabilities.
Although this procedural violation may weigh toward a finding of a denial of FAPE (see Issue III, supra), this violation does not necessarily mean that STUDENT is not SED. Ms. PARENT may be concerned that particular behaviors may be "copied" by students who are placed in an SED environment, but the Hearing Officer has doubts as to whether simply exposing a non-SED student to SED students will cause the non-SED student to "seem" SED, i.e., taking on characteristics of a serious emotional disturbance when one does not exist. The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence presented by the Petitioner to establish that STUDENT could have "become" SED by virtue of being included in an SED class. However, in consideration of the Petitioner's concerns over the validity of the District's assessment finding STUDENT SED after moving him into the SED-SDC, the Hearing Officer will consider whether STUDENT exhibited at least one of the four alleged SED characteristics before the change to the SED-SDC placement in the 1992-93 school year, as well as during the 1996-97 school year, to assist in concluding whether the IEP team correctly assessed him as SED.
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (Footnote 6) (IDEA) and federal regulations, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c); P.L. 105-17, § 601(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.1(a).) "Children with disabilities" includes children with a "serious emotional disturbance" who, because of that disturbance, need special education and related services. (20. U.S.C. § 1401(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(a)(1).)
"Serious emotional disturbance" is defined in the federal regulations as a condition that adversely affects a child's educational performance and that exhibits, over a long period of time and to a marked degree, one of the following characteristics:
(A) An inability to learn that cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors;
(B) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers;
(C) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances(Footnote 7);
(D) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression; or (E) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
(34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i).)
The Hearing Officer notes that it is not necessary to have all five of these characteristics to be SED. Having just one of the characteristics and meeting the requirements regarding severity, duration, and effect on education will result in a finding that the student is eligible for special education services as SED.
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT does not exhibit any of the SED characteristics. The District contends that STUDENT is SED because he has exhibited four of the five characteristics(Footnote 8) -- A through D in the federal regulations -- for a long period of time and to a marked degree, and that they have adversely affected his education.
A. A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression
A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression is an SED characteristic that exists in special education law, and is not automatically proven by a diagnosis of dysthymia from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, fourth edition (DSM-IV). (34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(i)(D).) However, some of the characteristics of dysthymia are relevant to the SED characteristic of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Therefore, the Hearing Officer notes that while a diagnosis of dysthymia, or mild depression, based on the DSM-IV, is not dispositive of a finding of this SED characteristic, it may be helpful to the analysis.
1. Prior to the SED-SDC placement in the 1992-93 school year
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT did not exhibit this characteristic before he was in the SED-SDC, and that any depressive symptoms exhibited were a result of his ADHD medication. The District contends that STUDENT exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression before he was moved to the SED-SDC.
STUDENT began receiving counseling at age four after early years of stress within his family. STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD by June 1990, as noted on his IEP held at the end of kindergarten. On this IEP, the team also noted that STUDENT was temperamental and that he began taking Ritalin for his ADHD on March 17, 1990. In May 1991, the IEP team noted that STUDENT tended to withdraw, and by the end of first grade, the team decided that he required AB3632 Mental Health services. By this time, STUDENT had stopped taking Ritalin and began taking Cylert for his ADHD. STUDENT continued to take Cylert through the first half of fourth grade.
In the AB3632 Mental Health referral filled out by Dr. Shiney-Norris and dated April 30, 1991, she stated that STUDENT "becomes very withdrawn," and noted that he has expressed suicidal ideation. Withdrawal was noted as a problem by STUDENT's first grade teacher, Ms. Rode, in her end-of-year report.
"Withdrawal" has been a theme throughout STUDENT's years in school. Ms. PARENT said that STUDENT reacts to correction by a teacher with complete withdrawal. Ms. Wamsley's notes indicate that STUDENT has been very unhappy for years. Ms. Wamsley stated in her notes that STUDENT's unhappiness stems from unresolved issues to do with his estranged father and his resentment and anger toward both his father and his mother. STUDENT's father is African-American and his mother is Caucasian. Dr. Goodlow noted in his independent evaluation that STUDENT's resentment may partially arise from confusion over racial identity -- he has expressed anger about his parents' separation and the fact that they are not of the same race. Ms. PARENT considers STUDENT to be white.
While acknowledging that STUDENT often withdrew from others and had emotional problems, Ms. PARENT contends that STUDENT's use of Cylert (which he had taken during first through fourth grades for ADHD) had made him "seem" depressed. The District contends that STUDENT's depression was not a result of any of his medications. The Petitioner did not provide any documentary evidence or witness testimony from a qualified professional (e.g., a medical doctor) regarding the side-effects of Cylert or any of the other prescription medications STUDENT took during this time. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is unable to discern what, if any, effect STUDENT's ADHD prescriptions may have had upon the symptoms of depression and unhappiness he displayed before being moved to the SED-SDC. The Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence regarding any medically recognized side effects from Cylert to find a cause and effect relationship between that drug and STUDENT's long-standing emotional problems.
There is ample evidence that STUDENT exhibited severe withdrawal, depression, unhappiness, moodiness, and a lack of energy, and that he walked around with a dazed look for years before he was put in the SED-SDC. STUDENT exhibited the traits described above in school, at home, and at his day care. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's depression was pervasive -- i.e., it was exhibited in all areas of his life.
The parties did not dispute that STUDENT's progress was adversely affected by his emotional and behavioral problems. STUDENT's academic functioning, as tested by the Woodcock Johnson-Revised in 1993, indicate his levels as follows: for broad reading, his standard score was 58 (less than 1st percentile); for broad math, his standard score was 73 (3rd percentile); and for broad written language, his standard score was 62 (1st percentile). Dr. Shiney-Norris noted in her report that this extreme lack of progress could not be explained solely by his non-emotional disabilities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's education was adversely affected by his depression.STUDENT's marked depression and unhappiness existed (even before being moved to the SED-SDC) for a long period of time (several years) and it adversely affected his education. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT exhibited a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression which adversely affected his education and which had existed for a long period of time and to a marked degree before he was moved to the SED-SDC. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was eligible for special education services as SED before he was in the SED-SDC.
2. Currently(Footnote 9)
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT does not presently exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. The District contends that STUDENT currently exhibits a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
The District's 1993 evaluation by Dr. Shiney-Norris notes that STUDENT displayed a "pervasive depressed mood" and met the DSM-III-R criteria for Dysthymia. Dr. Shiney-Norris had STUDENT's teacher complete the Devereux Elementary School Behavior Rating Scale II regarding STUDENT. The scores, according to Dr. Shiney-Norris, indicated that STUDENT did not simply fail to participate in classroom activities, but, instead, actually avoided involvement and communication with his peers. In her report, Dr. Shiney-Norris said that STUDENT's behavior suggested that he was "out of touch" with what was going on around him and that he exhibited "an almost active avoidance of others."
The independent psychological evaluation by Dr. Goodlow from 1993 indicates his diagnosis of dysthymia, and he summarizes his report with the statement that STUDENT suffered from "extreme" depression. Dysthymia in children is defined in the DSM-IV (Footnote 10) as a "chronically depressed mood that occurs for most of the day more days than not for at least 1 year." The Hearing Officer finds that the year-long requirement for a diagnosis of dysthymia in children satisfies the law's requirement of a exhibiting a depression for a "long period of time." Also noteworthy is the fact that "social withdrawal" is one of the features associated with dysthymia, according to the DSM-IV.
Turning to more current evidence, Ms. Ableser includes in her 1996 evaluation her observation that "STUDENT often appears to have limited positive affect, shows signs of depression and has been noted to seem withdrawn." The Petitioner argues that any of STUDENT's depressive traits are caused by side-effects of his prescription medication. The District asserts that STUDENT's depression is not being caused by medication. STUDENT was no longer taking prescribed medication for his ADHD by the fifth grade (a year before the 1996 evaluation), but, instead, was taking herbal medications. The Hearing Officer finds that the fact that STUDENT has continued to exhibit the SED characteristic of depression or unhappiness long after he ceased taking such prescription medication is evidence contrary to the Petitioner's position.
The Petitioner also contends that STUDENT's depression may be the result of a medical (neurological) problem. The District contends that there is no indication of any neurological condition which might explain STUDENT's depression. The Petitioner's independent evaluation conducted in late 1996 and early 1997 by Dr. Heller concludes that STUDENT's depression may be caused by neurological problems. Dr. Heller acknowledges that STUDENT has emotional and behavioral problems; however, he asserts that they may be neurologically based, rather than caused by family issues and other experiences. Dr. Heller states that STUDENT's handwriting problem is a sign of a neurological dysfunction, and that some of his emotional and behavioral problems may be biologically or neurologically based. The District points out that Dr. Heller is not a neurologist. Dr. Heller is a licensed and credentialed school psychologist and a licensed clinical psychologist. However, Dr. Heller is not a neurologist, nor is he a psychiatrist; therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that little weight can be accorded to Dr. Heller's opinion that STUDENT's emotional and behavioral problems may be based solely in a neurological dysfunction. No other professional has indicated any suspicion that neurological dysfunction is at the heart of STUDENT's depression. Considering the upheaval in family life he has suffered early in life, the Hearing Officer finds that it is more likely that his depression is, in fact, emotional in nature.
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's depression is not exhibited in all areas of life, while the District contends that it is pervasive. STUDENT exhibits his depression in school. Although Ms. PARENT asserts that his depression is not pervasive, she acknowledges that she has a difficult time dealing with his withdrawal and behavioral problems at home as well. Ms. Heeg stated that STUDENT does not present a problem she cannot handle in day care, and that he smiles more now than he used to, although she did not dispute that STUDENT is depressed. The Hearing Officer notes that smiling once in a while does not mean that a student does not meet the criteria for the SED characteristic of depression or unhappiness. Both Ms. PARENT's and Ms. Heeg's descriptions of STUDENT as being happy sometimes do not refute the evidence supporting a finding of depression or unhappiness under SED. Although Dr. Heller contends in his report that STUDENT's withdrawal is exhibited "more" at school than elsewhere, this contention does not dispute the evidence showing that his withdrawal, unhappiness, or depression is exhibited in all areas of life. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's unhappiness or depression is pervasive.
No one argued that STUDENT's educational performance was not being adversely affected by his emotional problems. According to Dr. Heller's own testing, STUDENT's most recent scores on the KTEA were as follows: in reading decoding, he had a standard score of 71 (3rd percentile); in reading comprehension, he had a standard score of 74 (4th percentile); in spelling, he had a standard score of 67 (1st percentile); in math computation, he had a standard score of 81 (10th percentile); and in math applications, he had a standard score of 72 (3rd percentile). Therefore, because STUDENT exhibits a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression which has adversely affected his educational performance and which has existed for a long period of time and to a marked degree, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT currently qualifies for special education as SED.
The Hearing Officer will address one more SED characteristic in order to present a fuller picture of STUDENT's educational needs; however, it is not necessary to address all four SED characteristics in dispute between the parties because of the findings made above.
B. Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances
1. Prior to the SED-SDC Placement
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT did not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances before he was placed in the SED-SDC. The District contends that before being moved to the SED-SDC, STUDENT exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances.
In the referral for an AB3632 Mental Health assessment dated April 30, 1991 (at the end of first grade), Dr. Shiney-Norris indicates that STUDENT's teacher had observed that he was attracted to death and wanted to talk about death-oriented and aggressive themes. Significantly, she noted that STUDENT had expressed "much suicidal ideation," saying such things as "I want to kill myself with a knife," or, after giving his mother flowers, "I want to give you these before I kill myself." (Dist. Exh. 35, p. 2.) In a pupil status report by STUDENT's second-grade teacher, Ms. Rode, she wrote that STUDENT was wandering absent-mindedly and exhibiting "bizarre" actions.
STUDENT's counselor, Diane Wamsley, wrote in his AB3632 treatment plan dated May 17, 1991, that STUDENT was fearful of things and that he was very concerned about violence and death. Ms. Wamsley stated in her progress notes of May 23, 1991, that STUDENT was preoccupied with death and destruction. In her notes of May 31, 1991, Ms. Wamsley stated that STUDENT eagerly told her that a boy at school tried to stab him with a knife. Ms. Wamsley noted that this story seemed to be a fabrication. In her notes of June 4, 1991, Ms. Wamsley stated that STUDENT had been having difficulty on the school bus, exhibiting both verbal and physical aggression with adults and peers.
In her notes of October 22, 1991, Ms. Wamsley wrote that STUDENT had shown a "marked improvement" in his school functioning, exhibiting less anger and preoccupation with death. However, Ms. Wamsley noted on November 26, 1991, that STUDENT was making up stories about a make-believe family and that he became angry when the validity of his story was questioned.
Ms. Wamsley's notes indicate that on February 10, 1992, Ms. PARENT called her to say that STUDENT had exposed himself to a girl on his school bus. In discussions with Ms. Wamsley soon thereafter, STUDENT denied that the incident took place. During the summer of 1992, while STUDENT was in summer school, Ms. Wamsley noted that a classmate of his was struck and killed by a car. Ms. Wamsley stated in her progress notes that after this accident, STUDENT began focusing on death and violence again.
Carol Marvin (one of STUDENT's mainstream teachers during summer school after first grade, and during his fifth grade year) said that he was very protective of his personal space, pushing away things left on his desk by other people. She stated that STUDENT was very "aware" of the rules and sought to enforce them whenever anyone "invaded his space."
Ms. PARENT contends that what the District describes as bizarre or inappropriate behavior was just STUDENT's way of playing. Ms. PARENT states that the other students did not like STUDENT and that he, therefore, played alone. She says that he talked to himself because no one was with him, and that he pretended he was a dinosaur, which in her view, has been wrongly interpreted as "bizarre" behavior.
Even before being moved to the SED-SDC, STUDENT had a history of aggression toward both peers and adults, as noted throughout Ms. Wamsley's notes. Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT had problems dealing with his anger. Ms. Wamsley noted these problems and the fact that STUDENT displayed anger toward anyone who did not go along with his ideas. According to his mother, STUDENT was extremely oppositional when he did not get his way. Ms. Wamsley noted that STUDENT exhibited a persistence in believing in things he knows are not true (e.g., that his mother and father will reunite or that he lives with other siblings). STUDENT exhibited suicidal ideation and has had a continuing fascination with death, destruction, and violence over the years, as noted by Ms. Wamsley. Ms. PARENT never refuted the existence of STUDENT's obsession with death and violence or the behavior described as "bizarre." Instead, she maintained simply that STUDENT's actions were misunderstood.
The types of behavior described herein were inappropriate for the settings in which they were exhibited. Occasional unexplainable behavior may be part and parcel of being a child; however, the evidence shows that STUDENT exhibited a pattern of behavior described more than once as "bizarre," behavior which is troubling to the Hearing Officer. Due to the evidence showing behavior at school and home which cannot be explained by the circumstances under which the behavior was exhibited, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT exhibited inappropriate behaviors and feelings under normal circumstances before he was moved to the SED-SDC.
The evidence of this behavior goes back to 1991 in Ms. Rode's notes. Therefore, even before STUDENT was moved to the SED-SDC, he had exhibited these behaviors for a long period of time, and to such a marked degree that his teacher had noted it in her report. Ms. Wamsley's notes also document the long history of STUDENT's inappropriate behavior. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT exhibited these inappropriate behaviors for a long period of time and to a marked degree before he was moved to the SED-SDC.
Again, no argument was made that these behaviors did not adversely affect STUDENT's educational performance. The Hearing Officer notes that behavior which is clearly different from that of other students unfortunately isolates a child from other children, and that isolation and STUDENT's other behaviors became an obstacle to the learning process. The Hearing Officer finds that before STUDENT was moved to the SED-SDC, he exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was eligible for special education services as SED under the characteristic of depression or unhappiness, before being moved to the SED-SDC. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was also eligible for special education services as SED before he was moved to the SED-SDC in the 1992-93 school year because he exhibited inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances.
2. Currently
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. The District contends that currently STUDENT exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances.
In her 1993 evaluation, Dr. Shiney-Norris stated that STUDENT had a significant deficit in perceptual accuracy, which often exists when the student's reality testing is impaired. She explained this as follows:
In other words, STUDENT misinterprets and/or distorts perceptual inputs much more than most people. As a result he displays a higher than usual frequency of behaviors that disregard social demands or expectations. STUDENT will often report events that are not true. He for example, has indicated that he has two older brothers living at home who constantly pour buckets of water on him. He is an only child.
(Dist. Exh. 26, p. 6; Pet. Exh. J-1, p. 6.)
Dr. Nathan Goodlow also evaluated STUDENT in 1993, pursuant to Ms. PARENT's request. Dr. Goodlow summarized his report as follows:
STUDENT is a 9-year-old White/Black child who is suffering from extreme depression and anger, attributed to emotional starvation. STUDENT views interpersonal relationships as rejecting and unnurturing; therefore, he has difficulty trusting others to met [sic] his emotional needs. The test results, however, indicated that STUDENT tries to get his emotional needs satisfied through internal stimulation, such as fantasies and wishes. This mode of coping with emotional frustration, at times, interferes with his ability to see the world in a conventional manner. This causes him to misinterpret information and him to overreact to situations. STUDENT also defends against interpersonal rejection by controlling others, acting out, and showing indifference towards the feelings of others.
(Dist. Exh. 25, p. 4; Pet. Exh. J-2, p. 4.)
Dr. Goodlow ruled out the existence of a thought disorder, even though STUDENT exhibited such a focus on fantasies. (Id.) Dr. Goodlow stated in the report that he came to this conclusion because STUDENT's fantasies seemed to be motivated by his wishes, based on reality, and because STUDENT was willing to be flexible with those fantasies when he was either challenged or given feedback regarding their veracity. Dr. Goodlow also noted that extra care should be taken to clarify communication with STUDENT because of his distorted perceptions.
In Ms. Ableser's 1996 evaluation, she stated that "STUDENT expresses thoughts of violence, anger and aggression and has atypical perceptions of reality."
Mr. Fitzgerald, principal at Santa Rosa school during STUDENT's fifth and sixth grades, described STUDENT as being by himself most of the time, sometimes walking around in circles, often openly talking to himself. He noted that STUDENT openly talked to himself mostly when he was in a large group at recess or lunch. Mr. Fitzgerald, who saw STUDENT at school nearly every day during fifth and sixth grade, said that he would flap his arms "occasionally every week." He also related that STUDENT would walk around one tree for his entire lunch period. Mr. Fitzgerald stated that STUDENT told unusual stories and that the staff would have to find out if the stories were true, before taking action, because there were times when there was no basis in reality for the stories.
In response to the District's allegations, Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT still flaps his arms and talks to himself, but continues to assert that this is part of his play activities. Ms. PARENT described STUDENT as "shy," and stated that his playing (flapping his arms) has been misinterpreted, as have been statements he has made. Ms. PARENT contends that during the District evaluation in 1996, STUDENT was answering a question about whether he wanted to marry one of the girls in his class, and the examiner only heard him say that he "wanted" her. This statement was later used to make the point that STUDENT was too sexually mature to stay in sixth grade, in response to Ms. PARENT's request to retain him. Ms. PARENT contends that STUDENT meant nothing sexual by the comment. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence surrounding this incident does not rise to the level of evidentiary significance.
The Petitioner further points to Dr. Heller's independent evaluation report, in which he stated that STUDENT did not exhibit signs of "overtly psychotic or schizophrenic symptoms such as hallucinations, delusions, incoherence, loosening of associations or other signs of a thought disorder or autism." However, Dr. Heller acknowledged that he did not observe STUDENT in school or at home, where much of his inappropriate behaviors have been exhibited. The theme in Dr. Heller's report is that there are indications of a neurological cause for the behavioral and emotional problems that he agrees STUDENT has. Dr. Heller said that he considered Lucy Ableser's 1996 evaluation, but disagreed with her conclusions. He stated that although STUDENT definitely has emotional and behavioral problems, they do not rise to the level of SED. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to those people who actually observed STUDENT in a formal educational setting. The people who saw STUDENT, day after day at school, provide a more reliable source of information regarding his behavior there than someone who has only seen his behavior in a testing situation.
According to his mother, STUDENT has been in the Laurel Springs home teaching program since the fall of 1996 and, therefore, has not been on a school campus during the 1996-97 school year. Instead, STUDENT has been receiving direct instruction from his day care provider, spending his days at that location with children who are all younger than he. Although Ms. Heeg did not describe STUDENT as exhibiting all of the inappropriate behaviors which have been described by numerous other people, Ms. Heeg is a family friend, not an objective outside observer. She acknowledged, however, that STUDENT still has problems. Additionally, Ms. PARENT acknowledged that STUDENT continues to have tantrumming problems and that he continues to exhibit many inappropriate behaviors with her. This evidence, along with the other evidence of inappropriate behavior, convinces the Hearing Officer that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior and feelings have continued, unchanged, since before he was moved to the SED-SDC. These behaviors and feelings have been exhibited for a long period of time (several years), to a marked degree (meriting counseling), and have continued to adversely affect his educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT currently exhibits inappropriate behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. (Footnote 11)
The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT exhibited two SED characteristics before he was placed in the SED-SDC in third grade. Therefore, the IEP team properly assessed STUDENT as SED in 1993. The Hearing Officer has also found that STUDENT continues to exhibit two SED characteristics. Therefore, the IEP team properly assessed STUDENT as SED in 1996. In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is eligible for special education services as SED because he exhibits one or more SED characteristics under the law. Therefore, it is unnecessary to address whether STUDENT also exhibits other SED characteristics alleged by the District.
II. Does STUDENT require assistive technology in order to receive a free appropriate public education?
Federal and state law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.1; California Education Code § 56000.) Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards and are provided at public expense and in conformity with an appropriate individualized education program (IEP). (34 C.F.R. § 300.8.)
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, whose educational needs cannot be met in a regular education program with modifications. "Related services" (California's term is "designated instruction and services") is defined as transportation and other supportive services that are required to allow a student to benefit from special education. (34 C.F.R. § 300.16(a); California Education Code § 56363.)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982) , the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.)
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's problems with handwriting are severe enough to warrant use of assistive technology, including a "Talking Pen" to practice handwriting at home and a keyboard in class to assist in note-taking. The District contends that STUDENT does not need assistive technology to benefit from his education.
The Petitioner had an independent evaluation done by registered occupational therapist (OTR) Honore Kyle-DeCecco on February 27, 1997. According to her report and her testimony, Ms. Kyle-DeCecco administered several tests, including (1) the Beery Test of Visual-Motor Integration, (2) "portions of" the Quick Neurological Screening Test, (3) the Reflex Integration Test, (4) a 9-hole peg test, (5) the Jarmar Dynamometer Test, (6) the Pinch Gauge Test, (7) Observation of Sensory Motor Integration and (8) behavioral and clinical observations. Ms. Kyle-DeCecco concluded that STUDENT did not have problems with coordination or muscle strength -- he was "extremely coordinated" -- and that he did not need physical therapy.
However, Ms. Kyle-DeCecco found that STUDENT's printing and cursive handwriting were "markedly delayed," taking him one minute and forty-five seconds to print nine words, and three minutes and forty-five seconds to write a nine-word sentence in cursive handwriting. She noted that STUDENT had to concentrate intensely during these tests, and was visibly breathing louder and becoming fatigued as he completed the sentence. In his evaluation, Dr. Heller also noted that STUDENT's "handwriting speed and accuracy were much below average."
In her report, Ms. Kyle-DeCecco recommended the use of a "Talking Pen" for STUDENT, which "provides augmental auditory feedback to reinforce motor pattern of letters and numbers." At the hearing, she explained that a "Talking Pen" or "Electric Pen" (which costs approximately $100 to $125) helps to keep the writer on the line. Although Ms. Kyle-DeCecco did not test STUDENT on a keyboard (she did not have one available), she recommended that he try using a keyboard, due to the length of time it takes him to print or write. Additionally, Ms. Kyle-DeCecco recommended a home program for STUDENT to help him practice his writing. She stated that STUDENT should use the "Talking Pen" and computer exercises in this home program, turning in work once a month. Ms. Kyle-DeCecco also stated that while the home program should be initiated by an OTR, it could be later reduced to quarterly OTR monitoring, allowing the special education teacher and parent to take care of the follow-up on a routine basis. She noted that it was not necessary for a therapist to sit with him while he practices; nor was it necessary to have an OTR come into his class and work with him.
The District argues that STUDENT simply needs more practice on his handwriting. The District asserts that STUDENT's handwriting problems are not severe enough to necessitate a home program, and the use of "Talking Pen" at home and a keyboard at school.
Ms. Ableser noted in her 1996 evaluation for the District under "testing behavior" that STUDENT worked in a slow manner and exerted a great amount of effort. She noted elsewhere in her report that STUDENT's teacher stated that he wrote with an awkward pencil grip. Karen Emery, STUDENT's sixth-grade SDC teacher, stated in a "psychological testing form" that his performance in written language was "poor to labored."
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's handwriting is delayed, based on all the evidence. The District did not provide any reason why Ms. Kyle-DeCecco's recommendations should not be accepted, in light of the problems STUDENT has with handwriting. In junior high (where STUDENT will be for the 1997-98 school year), being able to get assignments down and take notes is critical. STUDENT will not be able to benefit from his education if he is unable to retrieve his assignments or to take notes. The Hearing Officer finds that the use of a "Talking Pen" (to be available at home for practice) and a keyboard at school are necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires these assistive technology devices (and the home program as described by Ms. Kyle-DeCecco) in order to receive a free appropriate public education.
III. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for her expenses in placing him in his current academic placement, including tuition, tutoring, and books?
If the District failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT's mother would be entitled to reimbursement for her expenses in placing STUDENT in his current placement (the Laurel Springs home teaching program), if the latter program is appropriate. (Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al., v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996, 2003 (1985).)In some instances, when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the child's parent has provided an alternate placement which is not the "exact proper placement," courts have balanced the equities in determining whether the parent should be reimbursed. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, et al., 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986).) In Alamo, the parent provided services to her child after the school district refused to provide a summer program, which was necessary to avoid regression during that period of time. The 5th Circuit court added:
The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the interim placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act.
. . . .
Factors that the court may consider in determining whether full or partial reimbursement is in order would include the existence of other, perhaps more suitable, substitute placements, the effort expended by Mrs. G. in securing alternative placements, and the general cooperative or uncooperative position of the School District itself.
(Alamo, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.)
Therefore, the Hearing Officer will analyze whether the District provided STUDENT with an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year and, if it did not, whether STUDENT's mother provided an appropriate placement. If the alternative placement provided by Ms. PARENT is less than appropriate, the Hearing Officer will look to the factors suggested by Alamo for guidance as to the amount, if any, of reimbursement required by law.
A. Did the District provide a FAPE to STUDENT for 1996-97?
The analysis of whether a FAPE has been provided is two-fold. There is a substantive, as well as a procedural, requirement of appropriateness. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.)
1. Substantive Analysis
Taken together, four factors emerge under the IDEA and the Supreme Court's decision in Rowley for analyzing whether a school district has substantively proposed an appropriate placement. Those four factors are as follows:
a. Whether the District's proposed placement was designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs; b. Whether the District's proposed placement was designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; c. Whether the District's proposed placement was designed to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment; and d. Whether the District's proposed placement conformed to STUDENT's IEP.
(20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
Here, in the IEP dated June 21, 1996, the District proposed to place STUDENT in seventh grade at Monte Vista junior high school in an SDC for the 1996-97 school year. The Petitioner contends that the District did not provide an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year because (1) STUDENT was not academically or behaviorally ready for junior high school, (2) the District did not offer assistive technology for his handwriting problems and an appropriate amount of one-to-one assistance, (3) and an SDC would not have provided as much mainstreaming as he needed. The District contends that its offer for 1996-97 was appropriate and that, therefore, STUDENT's mother should not be reimbursed for her expenses in providing the home teaching program.
a. Was the District's proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs?
(1) What were STUDENT's unique needs during 1996-97?
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's unique needs during the 1996-97 school year included a great deal of one-to-one attention and assistance, as was provided by Ms. PARENT in the home teaching program for the 1996-97 school year. At the same time, the Petitioner contends that STUDENT needed more mainstreaming than had been provided by the District during his sixth grade (the 1995-96 school year) and that he needed assistive technology for his handwriting problems. The District contends that STUDENT needed to be mainstreamed with his peers during 1996-97 by being on a school campus to help deal with his peer relationships, and that he needed to move on to junior high school because he was too mature to repeat sixth grade.
No one disputes that STUDENT has ADHD. According to reports from his teachers and evaluators, that disability, combined with his emotional and behavioral problems, creates a need to refocus STUDENT's attention to the task at hand quite often and to provide him with a great deal of one-on-one encouragement and attention in order for him to perform even minimally. Ellen Nilssen, STUDENT's third-grade SED-SDC teacher, wrote on a document entitled "psychological testing form" and dated May 10, 1993, that STUDENT usually needed help from a classroom aide, and that he worked well in a one-on-one situation with a teacher, but not in a group situation. Ms. Nilssen also noted that STUDENT needed prompts because of his problems following the schedule and routine. Toby Forden, the RSP teacher who conducted testing on STUDENT during third grade, noted in an RSP assessment report that STUDENT needed a lot of encouragement in order to perform.
There is reason to believe that STUDENT's need for one-on-one assistance has continued to the present. Karen Emery, one of STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers, stated in her pupil status report of May 1996 that STUDENT worked with the an aide, Mrs. Cooney, who helped him take notes and gave him feedback regarding class expectations. Ms. PARENT stated that STUDENT also needs a supportive teacher who would give positive feedback instead of corrections, because he withdraws whenever he is corrected. Considering STUDENT's ADHD and his emotional and behavioral problems, as well as the reports of his teachers and his mother, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed one-to-one assistance and small group instruction in all his classes in order to benefit from his education during the 1996-97 school year.
STUDENT's emotional and behavioral problems have also created a need for counseling. The IEP team found that STUDENT was eligible for AB3632 services in May 1991, and it has recommended such services every year since then. The Petitioner does not dispute his need for such services. In light of STUDENT's depression and unhappiness, and the fact that even Dr. Heller recommended psychiatric therapy for STUDENT, counseling services were indicated. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's needs for the 1996-97 school year included AB3632 mental health services for his emotional and behavioral problems in order to benefit from his education.
As noted above, STUDENT also has problems with his handwriting, for which the Hearing Officer above found he needs assistive technology. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, according to the findings infra, STUDENT's needs for the 1996-97 school year included assistive technology for his handwriting problems in order to benefit from his education.
Regarding retention, Ms. PARENT believes that STUDENT was not ready, either academically or emotionally/behaviorally, to move on to junior high school, and that he needed to "catch up" in academics before moving on to the more challenging atmosphere of junior high. Mr. Fitzgerald indicated that STUDENT was beginning to experience puberty and that, therefore, he ought to be in a junior high environment, where more of the students are going through the same experience. Mr. Fitzgerald also asserted that it is rarely "right" to retain a child, according to the latest research, because of the self-esteem problems that retention creates. One of STUDENT's fifth-grade teachers, Carol Marvin, stated that STUDENT was very adamant about being a fifth-grader when he was in her class, which she inferred as an attempt to make sure people did not think he had been retained.
Both Ms. PARENT and Santa Rosa principal, Pat Fitzgerald, described STUDENT as quite tall for his age, although he is slim. Certainly, physical size alone is insufficient as an indicator of whether retention is appropriate. STUDENT's achievement scores, clustered in the single-percentile range in both District and independent evaluations, indicate significant delays. Ms. PARENT made a laudable decision to try to get STUDENT "caught up" in his academics by having him taught in a more one-to-one environment. However, considering STUDENT's fragile emotional state, as well as his need to work on peer relations, retention in sixth grade was not needed. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT's isolation could have become even more profound had he stayed in sixth grade at the same school. Younger children would realize quickly that he had been retained. This difference and his emotional and behavioral problems would have made for a difficult time with peers, just when STUDENT needed as few obstacles in that area as possible. What STUDENT needed was more assistance, not retention. The proper remedy for his academic delays was not holding him back, but providing the educational services he needed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need retention in sixth grade for the 1996-97 school year in order to benefit from his education.
Regarding STUDENT's need for mainstreaming, the Petitioner contends that STUDENT needed more mainstreaming than he received in sixth grade. Ms. PARENT asserts that during that year STUDENT was often the only student in his SDC for much of the day. The District contends that STUDENT needed to be on a regular school campus, near his peers during the 1996-97 school year, within the SDC it offered at Monte Vista and taking two regular education classes. At one point, Ms. PARENT suggested that STUDENT should have been in RSP for the 1996-97 school year, apparently arguing that he should be in regular education classes the majority of the day. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties essentially seem to agree that STUDENT needed to be around his peers as much as possible, considering his academic, emotional, and behavioral needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed mainstreaming with his nondisabled peers during the 1996-97 school year.
In summary, STUDENT's unique needs for the 1996-97 school year included: one-to-one assistance and small group instruction in all his classes; AB3632 mental health services (counseling); assistive technology (a "Talking Pen" to practice handwriting at home and a keyboard to use in class); and mainstreaming with nondisabled peers.
(2) What placement did the District offer for 1996-97?
The District's offer for STUDENT's 1996-97 school year, as memorialized in the IEP document dated June 21, 1996, stated that STUDENT would be in seventh grade in an SDC (non-SH, or non-severely handicapped) at Monte Vista Junior High School (Monte Vista) for "4 to 5 periods per day," and that he would be in regular classes "2 to 3 periods per day." This IEP notes that STUDENT would be integrated for 49% of his school day in this placement. Speech and language services were to be provided one to two times per week for "no less" than 40 minutes. Once again, STUDENT was found eligible for AB3632 services. The IEP also notes that STUDENT required transportation to and from school.
Dr. Paula Cornelius-Lopez, District program specialist, spent a total of approximately eight or nine years at Monte Vista junior high as an RSP teacher and the last three or fours years as a District-wide program specialist for both intermediate and elementary schools. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez, who has never met STUDENT, testified regarding the SDC at Monte Vista offered by the District to STUDENT. She stated that STUDENT's schedule at Monte Vista (which has a seven-period day) for the 1996-97 school year was to have been as follows: one period of special education language arts; one period of math; one period of science; one period of social studies; one period of regular physical education; one regular education elective class (which includes one quarter each of speech, shop, art, and conversational Spanish); and one period which would be "Quest" the first semester and literature the second semester. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez described Quest as a life skills program which teaches decision-making and covers sex education, drugs, and nutrition.
Dr. Cornelius-Lopez said that the makeup of the campus was approximately 500 students, split fairly evenly between seventh- and eighth-graders as well as between girls and boys. Of the 500, she said that about 30 were SDC students, about 78 were RSP students, and another 12 students were in the SED-SDC class. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez asserted that SED students at Monte Vista have flexibility and are put where they will be most successful, whether that is the SED-SDC, a non-severely handicapped SDC, RSP, or regular education. She also said that STUDENT's proposed SDC program for the 1996-97 school year was different from the SED-SDC because the latter class was self-contained (i.e., the students stay all day in the same room), it had one teacher and a mental health professional in the class all day long, and it had two instructional assistants. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez asserted that students were mainstreamed out of the SED-SDC when they "earned" that privilege as part of the class management system, whereas in the SDC that STUDENT was to attend, students were mainstreamed from the very beginning.
Dr. Cornelius-Lopez explained the schedule for seventh-graders in the non-SH SDC during the 1996-97 school year as follows: two fifty-minute classes (starting at 8:30 a.m.); a twenty-minute nutrition break; two more classes; a thirty-five minute lunch break; and two more classes (the latter ending at 3:00 p.m). At Monte Vista during the 1996-97 school year, students took seven courses, but only six classes met every day. The schedule would rotate over several days to allow the seven courses to be taught within the six periods. For example, on the first day of school, STUDENT would have had his first six classes during the six periods that day. Since there was no seventh period, his seventh class would have been held during the first period the next day, followed by his first through fifth classes (dropping the sixth class). On the following day, he would have started out with his sixth class during first period, followed by his seventh class, and then his first through fourth classes, and so on. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez stated that the purpose of the rotation was to allow students to have the opportunity to work on each class during their "best" time.
Dr. Cornelius-Lopez described the teachers STUDENT would have had in the 1996-97 school year at Monte Vista. STUDENT would have had two credentialed special education teachers and two regular education teachers, as well as one instructional assistant in all the special education classes. Jacine Lester (one of the special education teachers) would have been STUDENT's teacher for science, history/social science, and Quest/literature. Amy Huff would have been STUDENT's special education teacher for language arts and math. The seventh-graders in the non-SH SDC (total of approximately 18) STUDENT was to attend were divided into two groups of nine each for language arts and for math, so that the teacher who taught language arts and math had two small groups of seventh-graders for math, and two different small groups of seventh-graders for language arts. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez said that the purpose of having the groups was to allow for more individualized attention. In science and social studies, for which larger groups of students were needed for cooperative learning, the teacher had a small group for the more "critical" students. Dr. Cornelius-Lopez asserted that in language arts, spelling was tailored to each student's needs, and that the teacher provided individual assistance with reading so that there was some group work and some individualized work. She also said that in this class, the seventh-graders usually read one of the "core" literature books from the District's list, but the teacher picks a book that is at a lower reading level than the regular seventh-grade students would read.
Dr. Cornelius-Lopez said that Carol Springate would have been STUDENT's teacher for physical education. She stated that Ms. Springate was chosen as his P.E. teacher because she had experience with special education students and allowed them to take tests in their special education teachers' classes.
Dr. Cornelius-Lopez also said that the speech and language specialist at Monte Vista, Joan Cherno, had STUDENT scheduled for two twenty-minute periods in the afternoon on Tuesdays and Fridays for speech and language therapy for the 1996-97 school year. She stated that because the classes rotated, he would have missed a different class for each therapy session, minimizing the amount of time missed in each class.
Regarding extracurricular activities, Dr. Cornelius-Lopez said that Monte Vista offered a competitive speech program as well as many clubs. She also described the availability of computers at the school. The math room has 18 or 19 older Apple IIE computers for drill and practice. The language arts class has older Mac computers which have been refurbished by one of the RSP teachers. Each of the teachers also has at least one state-of-the-art Mac in the classroom, and there is also an IBM lab for use by the students. Two of the special education rooms and the library are on the Internet.
(3) Would the offered placement meet STUDENT's unique needs?
The Petitioner contends that STUDENT's unique needs could not be met in the placement offered by the District because he needed to be retained in sixth grade and he needed more one-to-one assistance and mainstreaming than he had received in sixth grade, i.e., he should have been in RSP. The District contends that placement in the SED-SDC at Monte Vista would have met STUDENT's unique needs because it would have provided more attention than STUDENT would have received in regular education or in RSP, it had mainstreaming built into the placement (unlike the SED-SDC at that school), and he did not need to be retained in sixth grade.
Regarding STUDENT's need for one-to-one assistance, the District's offer for the 1996-97 school year was the non-SH SDC at Monte Vista. According to the testimony given by Dr. Cornelius-Lopez, in this placement STUDENT would have had two special education teachers for five of his seven classes during the 1996-97 school year. She stated that these classes also had one instructional assistant assigned to them. STUDENT's other two classes would have been taught by regular education teachers, and there is no evidence that an aide or assistant would have been assigned to either of those classes.
The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT needed assistance in every class for the 1996-97 school year, due to his academic, emotional, and behavioral problems. The IEP dated June 21, 1996, does not state that STUDENT would separately receive help from an instructional aide, nor does it even guarantee that an assistant would be in the SDC generally. Although Dr. Cornelius-Lopez stated that an assistant was assigned to the SDC proposed by the District, there is no such indication on the IEP. The IEP states that STUDENT's goals and objectives were to be "provided by" the Special Day Class teacher, and does not place any responsibility on, or give any reference to, an instructional assistant assigned to either the SDC or to STUDENT specifically. At any rate, there is no indication that STUDENT would have the one-to-one assistance he needs in his regular education classes. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement for the 1996-97 school year did not meet STUDENT's unique needs for one-to-one assistance.
Another problem with the IEP dated June 21, 1996, concerns the provision of mental health services. STUDENT was being provided transportation to and from school as part of his program. However, there is no notation on the IEP that he was being provided transportation to his counseling sessions. Ms. PARENT stated that she provided transportation for STUDENT to see his counselor, Ms. Wamsley, in Oxnard. During the time that STUDENT was in the Los Nogales SED-SDC, Ms. PARENT said that Ms. Wamsley came to STUDENT's class to provide the counseling, but when he went to Santa Rosa school, it was "too far" for the counselor to travel to see him. Ms. PARENT said that she drove STUDENT to counseling until her car broke down.
It is unclear to the Hearing Officer why STUDENT would be eligible for transportation for school but not for his educationally necessary counseling. It is also unfortunate that STUDENT had to miss out on such counseling because his mother was unable to provide the transportation when her car broke down. Special education students are guaranteed a free appropriate public education. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.) In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that in order to be provided a free appropriate public education, STUDENT should have been provided with transportation to his counseling sessions. STUDENT's IEP does not indicate that transportation to counseling was being offered.
Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement for 1996-97 was deficient because the District offered no assistance (either OTR services or modifications to his program) for STUDENT's handwriting problems. Without assistance in this area, STUDENT could hardly be expected to keep up with the faster pace of junior high school, even with other modifications. Being able to take notes, write down assignments, complete class work, take tests, and finish homework is fundamental to STUDENT's ability to benefit from his education. Because STUDENT's handwriting is seriously delayed, the failure to meet this need doomed the District's offer and foreclosed the possibility that he might benefit from the placement. Although individual teachers may have taken note of the handwriting problem and suggested modifications on their own, the Hearing Officer must look at the offer of the District as memorialized in the IEP of June 21, 1996. No mention of assistive technology or other modifications to help STUDENT with his severe handwriting problems is indicated in that IEP. Including a goal to "complete class and homework assignments in a consistent and timely manner" is meaningless when the District has not provided the tools necessary to meet such a goal. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement for 1996-97 did not meet STUDENT's unique needs because it did not include one-to-one assistance (e.g., a one-to-one aide), did not offer transportation to his counseling, and did not offer assistance for his handwriting problems.
b. Was the District's proposed placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
The Petitioner contends that this placement would not have provided more than minimal benefit. The District contends that its proposed placement in seventh grade in the SED-SDC at Monte Vista junior high school was designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. As stated above, STUDENT required transportation to counseling, help with his handwriting problems, and one-to-one assistance, which were not offered by the District for the 1996-97 school year. Without these essential elements, STUDENT would continue to gain de minimis benefit from his education, as is shown in his several years' lack of progress. (Footnote 12) De minimis benefit is insufficient to meet the Rowley standard of "some" benefit. (M.C. ex rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District 81 F.3d 389 (3d. Cir. 1996); Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171 (3d. Cir. 1988), cert. denied, 488 U.S. 1030 (1989)). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed placement for the 1996-97 school year was not designed to provide some educational benefit to STUDENT.
c. Was the District's proposed placement designed to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment?
The Hearing Officer has found under the substantive analysis that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1996-97 school year; therefore, there is no need to address this factor.
d. Did the District's proposed placement conform to STUDENT's IEP?
In this circumstance, it is not necessary to reach this factor in the analysis because the proposed placement was never implemented.
2. Procedural Analysis
As to the requirement of procedural appropriateness, school districts must make sure that parents are provided an opportunity to participate in the decisions regarding their children's special education program. (34 C.F.R. § 300.345.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205-206.)
The Petitioner alleges that the District committed a procedural violation by intimidating Ms. PARENT into signing the IEP of June 21, 1996. The District denied using intimidating tactics, contending that Ms. PARENT signed the document voluntarily. Ms. PARENT testified that during the IEP team meeting held on June 21, 1996, Ms. Cartwright "slammed" down her fist on the table in response to Ms. PARENT's request to retain STUDENT and stated that he would not be retained in sixth grade, and that if he was, it would not be at Santa Rosa school. Ms. Cartwright denied that she acted in this way. Santa Rosa principal Pat Fitzgerald, who attended at least part of this IEP meeting, stated that he did not recall Ms. Cartwright acting in an intimidating manner, although he acknowledged that she made a "strong" statement about retention. Ms. PARENT said that she finally signed the IEP because she realized she wasn't going to get what she wanted, she felt intimidated, and the other team members "kept shoving the papers at me to sign."
The Petitioner alleges that the District committed another procedural violation by failing to have the necessary personnel at the IEP meeting of June 21, 1996. The District contends that the absence of the personnel was unavoidable and that their replacements were qualified. A public agency "shall ensure" that each IEP team meeting includes the child's teacher. (34 C.F.R. §300.344(a).) It was not contested that STUDENT's teacher at the time, Karen Emery, was not present at this IEP team meeting. STUDENT's mom stated that she was not told why Ms. Emery was not at the IEP team meeting and a teacher named "Nancy," who had never taught STUDENT, attended in Ms. Emery's place.
Also not present at the IEP team meeting on June 21, 1996, was the District evaluator, Lucy Ableser. Ms. PARENT said that she was told Ms. Ableser's car had broken down and that this was why another District psychologist attended this IEP and read Ms. Ableser's report to the team. Ms. PARENT said that she felt "frustrated" because two of the most important team members were not present at the IEP meeting, preventing her from questioning Ms. Emery about STUDENT's performance and the appropriateness of the class, and Ms. Ableser about her evaluation. Ms. Ableser stated at the hearing that the reason she was not able to attend STUDENT's IEP team meeting on June 21 was that she had been involved in an automobile accident the night before the meeting. Ms. Ableser said that the psychologist who attended the IEP meeting in her place, Mark Bucalis, was a credentialed school psychologist.
The policy behind the procedural requirements of having particular people at a special education student's IEP team meeting is to ensure the participation of those persons necessary to decide what is appropriate for the child. Here, STUDENT's teacher and the District psychologist whose report was being discussed were not present at the IEP meeting. STUDENT's teacher, Ms. Emery, would have had valuable information to provide regarding his classroom performance and behavior. The District psychologist, Ms. Ableser, had just completed a triennial evaluation of STUDENT, and his mother disagreed with Ms. Ableser's conclusions. Ms. PARENT stated that she had several questions regarding the evaluation she wanted to ask of Ms. Ableser, but that she was unable to do so because of her absence. Ms. PARENT said that she also had questions for Ms. Emery, but could not have them answered due to her absence as well.
Due to the long-standing parent concerns regarding STUDENT's eligibility status as SED and the District evaluations done of him, the Hearing Officer finds that it was necessary to have Ms. Ableser present to conduct an appropriate IEP team meeting. If anything, Ms. Ableser could have communicated exactly why she felt STUDENT was SED, explaining her basis and trying to help Ms. PARENT understand her view of STUDENT's unique needs. Indeed, rescheduling this meeting (considering that two integral participants were unavailable) would have been preferable to going forward without them. Perhaps Ms. PARENT's frustration with the procedures used over the years would have been somewhat mollified had the meeting been handled in a proper manner.The Hearing Officer also finds that the District took a very aggressive stance with Ms. PARENT at this IEP team meeting, using intimidating tactics and less than "team-like" behavior. The District's intimidation, coupled with the failure to ensure the participation of Ms. Emery and Ms. Ableser, combined to create a situation bound to result in disagreement and escalating hostility.
The Petitioner also alleges that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to explain much of her parent rights to her over the years, including at the IEP team meeting held June 21, 1996. Ms. PARENT said that although she had signed many IEP documents stating that "Parent Rights" had been reviewed with her by District staff, the staff never actually reviewed them with her. She described the IEP team meetings as "rushed" and "intimidating" sessions in which she did not feel she had the right even to take a break and discuss issues with her friend, Ms. Heeg. The District referred to all the IEPs from 1990 through 1996, which include Ms. PARENT's signature and initials indicating her agreement to the placement, the eligibility, and the fact that she had her parental rights reviewed with her. Ms. PARENT contends that she had objected to the IEP team's designation of STUDENT as SED since 1993 when she first learned of it, but that she signed his IEPs designating him as SED under protest after understanding from Ms. Cartwright that she could not contest that eligibility until the next triennial in 1996.
Ms. PARENT acknowledged receiving a copy of the "Parents' Rights" document, but contends that the District's failure to actually review those rights with her is a procedural violation. The District is obligated to provide written notice of procedural safeguards. (34 C.F.R. § 300.504 - 300.505.) Whether the District reviewed the written notice of parents' rights orally with Ms. PARENT (advisable as that might have been) is irrelevant, because it was not required to do so. There was no testimony to the effect that Ms. PARENT could not read or comprehend the written notice. Although the IEP form contains a place for the parent to indicate whether the District had "reviewed" the parents' rights, the law requires only that written notice be given. Written notice was given. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by failing to review Ms. PARENT's parent's rights orally with her.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed procedural violations by adopting an intimidating, "take it or leave it" policy at the IEP team meeting of June 21, 1996, and by failing to have necessary personnel at that meeting to discuss STUDENT's issues (in addition to the earlier violation of moving STUDENT to an SED-SDC in third grade without the IEP team's approval). While not all procedural violations require a conclusion that a FAPE has been denied, procedural violations which result in the loss of educational opportunity (Burke County Board of Education v. Denton, 895 F.2d 973, 982 (4th Cir. 1990)), or seriously infringe upon a parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process (Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990)), are clear instances in which FAPE has been denied. (W.G., 960 F.2d 1479.) In this instance, the District's failure to have STUDENT's teacher and the District psychologist who recently evaluated STUDENT at the IEP meeting infringed upon Ms. PARENT's opportunity to participate in the IEP process because she had relevant questions regarding STUDENT that she was unable to have answered. In fact, that IEP meeting's procedural inadequacies culminated years of poor communication by the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that because of their extent and nature, the District's procedural violations denied STUDENT a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer has found both substantive and procedural failures by the District regarding STUDENT's proposed 1996-97 placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to offer an appropriate placement to STUDENT for the 1996-97 school year. Due to this failure, STUDENT's mother may be entitled to reimbursement for her expenses in providing alternative education for her son. The Petitioner contends that reimbursement is due because the home program was appropriate and it was the best that she could offer. However, the District contends that Ms. PARENT should not be reimbursed for the home program she provided for STUDENT because it was not appropriate.
B. Was the home schooling program provided by STUDENT's mother during 1996-97 appropriate?
Ms. PARENT said that after rejecting the District's inappropriate offer for the 1996-97 school year (withdrawing her consent to the June 1996 IEP entirely) and being told that the District's home teaching program was full, she placed STUDENT in Laurel Springs. She said she did this to avoid legal problems with attendance, an issue highlighted by the District in communications with her. The home teaching program was supposed to be a temporary placement until issues regarding STUDENT's handicapping condition and his placement for the 1996-97 school year were resolved with the IEP team. However, STUDENT was in this home teaching program for the entire school year because of the ongoing dispute.
The Petitioner contends that the home teaching program was appropriate because STUDENT needed one-to-one assistance to help him "catch up" after years of falling behind because of his disabilities. The Petitioner contends that despite any failings of the program, STUDENT's mother should be reimbursed because she did the best that she could when faced with what she felt was an inappropriate placement offered by the District and the legal requirement of having STUDENT in school.
The District contends that the home teaching program that STUDENT received at his mother's expense was inappropriate for several reasons. The District claimed the home teaching program (1) was not provided by a credentialed special education teacher, (2) was not provided in accordance with an IEP, (3) did not include standardized testing, and (4) did not provide speech and language services.
The home teaching program was provided by Laurel Springs school. The direct instruction was provided by Ms. Heeg at her day care site. STUDENT worked in a separate room for approximately four hours a day on academics, either one-on-one with Ms. Heeg or independently. No speech and language services were provided because Ms. PARENT could not afford them; nor did the District offer to continue providing those services after Ms. PARENT withdrew her consent to the IEP of June 1996. Although no standardized tests (as are used in evaluations) are given through Laurel Springs, Ms. Heeg stated that Laurel Springs provided fourth grade curriculum books based on pretests it conducted on STUDENT regarding his reading level. In regard to testing to indicate STUDENT's level of progress, Ms. PARENT stated that she checks in monthly with the supervising teacher at Laurel Springs, Mary Emma Wills, for approximately an hour to an hour and a half.
Ms. Heeg stated that for most of STUDENT's core subjects, he is with her. It should be noted that he is her only student. When he is working on an assignment not requiring Ms. Heeg's assistance, STUDENT is in the room alone, although he may come out to ask questions periodically. Ms. Heeg acknowledged that this lack of socialization was one drawback to home teaching, although she also indicated that the Laurel Springs program was supposed to be a temporary situation. STUDENT has told both his mother and Ms. Heeg that he wants to be back in regular school because he misses the other children.
STUDENT does receive one-to-one instruction (an element missing from the District's offer) from Ms. Heeg, who holds both a bachelor's and a master's degree in education, and a New York state lifetime regular education teaching credential. The Laurel Springs' curriculum covers subjects including reading, mathematics, history, grammar, social studies, art, and science. Ms. Heeg has supplemented the program with her own materials as well, including some science experiments and the California history book her own son uses in fourth grade. Ms. Heeg emphasizes a positive reinforcement approach with STUDENT, who she said responds better when he feels good about himself.
Under Alamo, the existence of other, more suitable, placements is relevant. Here, the District told Ms. PARENT that its home school program was full. Ms. PARENT said that at the beginning of the fall 1996 semester, she was "reminded" by District staff that education was compulsory for students STUDENT's age and that she felt she had to get him into a program immediately to avoid any legal problems. She said that she expected Laurel Springs to be a temporary solution while the parties worked out their dispute. Ms. PARENT also did not have the means to take off substantial amounts of time from work to compare placements, and she had to act quickly to have STUDENT in school. However, this means that she did not expend a lot of time searching for a better placement. The District has shown its general uncooperative position throughout the history of the parties' interaction, including its commission of several substantial procedural violations. Alamo is distinguishable from the instant case because Alamo involved a situation in which the parent provided a less than perfect alternate placement (needed in order to avoid summer regression) when the school district failed to offer any placement during the summer. In the instant case, the District did offer a placement for the 1996-97 school year, with which Ms. PARENT disagreed.
The Hearing Officer notes that this is not a situation in which an affluent family pulls their child out of public school and puts him or her in private school to try to "maximize" the student's potential. In this situation, Ms. PARENT, a dedicated, single parent who worked nights cleaning peoples' houses, was faced with what she believed was an inappropriate offer from the District and her own inability to procure an expensive private school. She made a difficult decision and pulled STUDENT out of public school and attempted to provide an appropriate education. However, Ms. PARENT's own statements show the inadequacies of this home teaching program. STUDENT had no mainstreaming with nondisabled peers -- his interaction was with younger (some much younger) children in the day care facility. Ms. Heeg, although qualified to teach regular education, did not have a special education credential. The Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner did not present evidence showing that STUDENT at least received "some benefit" from his home teaching program, the standard under Rowley. Therefore, for the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer is unable to award reimbursement in this situation.
IV. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for the expenses in obtaining an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Marc Heller?
Parents have the right to have an independent evaluation of their child paid for by public expense if they disagree with the evaluation by the public agency, unless the public agency initiates a special education due process hearing to show that its own evaluation was appropriate. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); California Education Code § 56329(b).) (Footnote 13) Therefore, the burden is on the District to prove that its own evaluation was appropriate; if that burden is not met, it must pay for the independent evaluation. (Footnote 14)
Here, Ms. PARENT contends that she disagreed with the District's evaluations and contends that they were not appropriate because they concluded that STUDENT was SED. The Petitioner asks for the cost of Dr. Heller's evaluation to be reimbursed. (Footnote 15) The District contends that its evaluations were appropriate and that the Petitioner should not be reimbursed for the evaluation by Dr. Heller.
In essence, the Petitioner contends that because the District's evaluation came to the conclusion that STUDENT was SED, the evaluation was inappropriate. The Hearing Officer has already found that STUDENT is eligible for services as SED; therefore, the Petitioner's contention that the District's evaluation was inappropriate because it concluded that STUDENT was SED is not helpful to this analysis. However, because the burden is on the District to prove that its own evaluation is appropriate in order to avoid paying for an independent evaluation, the Hearing Officer will analyze the appropriateness of the District's 1996 evaluation by looking to the legal requirements for such evaluations. (Footnote 16)
Federal regulations require that state and local educational agencies follow certain evaluation procedures with special education students, including ensuring that the child is assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, if appropriate, health, vision, hearing, social and emotional status, general intelligence, academic performance, communicative status, and motor abilities. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(f).) Other procedures require that tests and evaluations be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by their producer. (34 C.F.R. § 300.532(a)(3).)
California's required evaluation procedures essentially mirror those in the federal regulations, although state law also outlines additional areas which might need to be assessed if they are related to the suspected disability, including health and development, and language function, orientation and mobility skills, and career and vocational abilities/interests. (California Education Code § 56320(f).)
In her 1996 evaluation of STUDENT, District school psychologist Lucy Ableser administered (1) the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (K-BIT), (2) the Matrix Analogies Test (MAT), (3) three subtests of the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test-Revised, (4) the Watkins Bender-Gestalt visual motor test, (5) the Burks' Behavior Rating Scale, completed by STUDENT's teacher, (6) the Devereux Behavior Rating Scale-School Form, completed by STUDENT's teacher, (7) the Roberts Apperception Test, (8) two projective drawing tests -- the House-Tree-Person test and the Kinetic Draw-A-Family test, (9) a sentence completion test, (10) My Self-Checklist, and (11) a social and behavioral checklist filled out from STUDENT's background update. A speech and language specialist administered the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Revised (CELF-R).
A. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT's unique needs require assistive technology and a home program for practice to assist with his handwriting problems. The District's 1996 evaluation states that STUDENT's sixth-grade teacher "reports that he writes with an awkward pencil grip." However, the focus of the District's evaluation was on STUDENT's emotional problems. Ms. Ableser, the District psychologist, stated that socio-emotional functioning was STUDENT's area of suspected disability. She did not state that motor ability or handwriting was another area of suspected disability; however, Ms. Ableser administered a visual-motor functioning test (the Watkins Bender-Gestalt) and found that STUDENT's visual-motor abilities were "mildly" delayed.
According to the District, STUDENT's area of suspected disability was a serious emotional disturbance. (Testimony of Ms. Ableser.) However, STUDENT has expressive and receptive communications problems, ADHD, and the above-mentioned handwriting problems. The District acknowledges STUDENT's ADHD, as well as his learning disabilities (for which he was eligible for special education until he was found to have an SED). The District argued that STUDENT's handwriting problems were not serious enough to warrant assistive technology; however, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT's handwriting problems were serious enough to require such technology. After noting that STUDENT's teacher indicated that he had an awkward pencil grip, the District included a visual-motor functioning test as part of its battery of tests given by the psychologist, but the District did not have an OTR carry out any specific tests regarding his handwriting problem. The Hearing Officer finds that handwriting was an area of suspected disability for which the District should have performed more thorough testing by an OTR.
The Petitioner also contends that the District should have referred STUDENT for neurological testing, based on the existence of his handwriting problems and the independent evaluation by Dr. Heller. Dr. Heller stated that STUDENT may have neurological problems which are responsible both for his behavior (which has been attributed to an SED) and his handwriting problems. The District contends that there is no evidence to indicate a neurological dysfunction as an area of suspected disability. Based on the evaluations done up to this point, the Hearing Officer above found insufficient evidence to indicate a neurological basis for STUDENT's emotional and behavioral problems. Based on the information available to the District, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence at the time of the District's 1996 evaluation to indicate that a neurological problem was an area of suspected disability. (Footnote 17)
B. Were the District's tests administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by their producer?
Lucy Ableser administered many of the tests in the District's 1996 evaluation. Ms. Ableser has been a licensed school psychologist for fourteen years. She has conducted approximately fifty assessments a year as a school psychologist. Other personnel who conducted parts of the 1996 evaluation include the speech and language specialist, Ann Harrell (who did not testify). There was no contention by the Petitioner that the District personnel who conducted the evaluation were not trained or otherwise qualified to give the tests. However, the Hearing Officer takes note that the District changed the usual procedure by allowing STUDENT's day care provider, Mikki Heeg, to be in attendance at the testing conducted by Ms. Ableser, at Ms. PARENT's request. The District has an obligation to carry out testing in an appropriate manner. In fact, Ms. Ableser notes in her report the following under "Testing Behavior/Observation":
Assessment occurred during school in an empty classroom. An observer, Mikki Heeg, was present during the testing due to parent request and may have, by her presence, affected the results. Several times, STUDENT did turn to look at the observer and, at one point, he asked her to clarify a statement he made.
(Dist. Exh. 15, p. 2; Pet. Exh. G-1, p. 2.)
The Hearing Officer understands that the District may have been trying to work with Ms. PARENT regarding her concerns over District testing; however, proper testing procedures must be followed. The test producer's instructions regarding whether observers may be present were not introduced into evidence; however, Ms. Ableser apparently felt that the change in procedure was sufficiently important enough to note in her report. The Hearing Officer surmises that if the test producer's instructions did not specifically recommend against outside observers being present, Ms. Ableser would not have felt the necessity to note the presence of Ms. Heeg and the fact that her presence may have affected STUDENT's test results. Therefore, based on the District's own evidence that the test results may have been affected by the presence of an observer, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not administer its tests in conformance with the instructions provided by their producer.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that, although the District's conclusion that STUDENT continues to be eligible for special education as SED was ultimately correct (Footnote 18), its 1996 evaluation suffered from problems, including a failure to assess in all areas of suspected disability and allowing an observer at the testing. The District did not offer much in the way of specific arguments regarding the appropriateness of its own evaluation, although it spent a great deal of time on cross-examination attempting to show how Dr. Heller's independent evaluation was inappropriate. However, the only relevant issue regarding an independent evaluation is whether it is "conducted by a qualified examiner." (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); California Education Code § 56329(b).) The District must prove the appropriateness of its own evaluation to avoid paying for an independent evaluation, but if it fails to make that showing, it cannot prevail by proving that the independent evaluation was also inappropriate. Once the District's evaluation has been found to be inappropriate, and the independent examiner is found to be qualified, the analysis is complete.
Here, the District's evaluation was inappropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer turns to whether Dr. Heller was a qualified examiner. Dr. Marc Heller testified that he is a credentialed and licensed school psychologist and licensed clinical psychologist who worked for Oxnard Union High School District for eight years. Dr. Heller stated that he has done over a thousand assessments in his career, including assessments of 150-200 students whom he found were SED and another 100-125 whom he found were not SED. There is sufficient evidence of Dr. Heller's credentials to find that he was a qualified examiner; therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that because the District failed to conduct an appropriate evaluation, the Petitioner is entitled to have the independent evaluation by Dr. Heller at public expense.
The Hearing Officer does take note, however, of the extremely high amount submitted as the cost for Dr. Heller's independent evaluation. Apparently, Dr. Heller billed his services at $200.00 an hour for testing, consultation, and testimony. The Hearing Officer will not simply grant an award for the total amount submitted. The Hearing Officer will award only those costs that are directly related to the evaluation. The costs of witness testimony are not awardable by a Hearing Officer; therefore, the fourteen hours billed for testimony ($2800.00) are not awarded herein. An evaluation does not include the provision of other services; therefore, the eight hours of consultation ($1600.00) are also not awarded herein.
As to those costs related to the evaluation, according to the bill submitted by the Petitioner, Dr. Heller conducted a "diagnostic interview" for one hour on October 21, 1996 ($200.00). Dr. Heller performed psychological testing on STUDENT on December 2 and 3, 1996, and February 10, 18, and 21, and March 5, 1997, for a total of twelve hours ($2400.00). On February 12 and 19, Dr. Heller evaluated data for a total of five hours ($1000.00). On February 28, and March 5, 1997, Dr. Heller evaluated records for a total of six hours ($1200.00). Lastly, on March 5, 1997, Dr. Heller prepared his report for three hours ($600.00). The total of evaluation-related costs is $5400.00 (27 hours multiplied by $200 an hour). One OSEP letter, dealing with the issue of school district's ability to set maximum allowable charges for independent evaluations, concluded that districts could set such a limit, as long as it gave parents an opportunity to demonstrate that unique circumstances justified going above that limit. (Letter to Anonymous, 22 IDELR 637 (OSEP 1995).)
However, in the instant situation, the District presented no evidence that it has set such a limit on the amount that may be charged for an independent evaluation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders the District to reimburse Ms. PARENT for Dr. Heller's independent evaluation, in the amount of $5400.
ORDER
1. The Individualized Education Program (IEP) team correctly assessed STUDENT's handicapping condition as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED). STUDENT is currently eligible for special education services as SED.
2. STUDENT requires assistive technology in order to receive a free appropriate public education. For the 1997-98 school year, the District shall provide a home practice program initiated by an OTR, which utilizes a "Talking Pen" for practice, and a keyboard (with a word processing program of District choice) for use in school.
3. The District need not reimburse STUDENT's mother for her expenses in placing him in his 1996-97 academic placement.
4. The District shall reimburse STUDENT's mother in the amount of $5400 for her expenses in obtaining an independent assessment by Dr. Marc Heller within thirty days of this order.
5. All of the Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Did the Individualized Education Program (IEP) team correctly assess STUDENT's handicapping condition as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED)?
As to this issue, the District prevailed.
II. Does STUDENT require assistive technology in order to receive a free appropriate public education?
As to this issue, the Petitioner prevailed.
III. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for her expenses in placing him in his current academic placement, including tuition, tutoring, and books?
As to this issue, the District substantially prevailed.
IV. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's mother for the expenses in obtaining an independent assessment of STUDENT by Dr. Marc Heller?
As to this issue, the Petitioner prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: October 9, 1997 _________________________________ Kathleen Peterson Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. "Pet. Exh." refers to the Petitioner's exhibits, lettered A-P, inclusive, admitted into evidence.
2. At that point, Ms. Wamsley could not make the trip to Santa Rosa school because it was too far away, and STUDENT's mother could not take him to Ms. Wamsley's office because her car broke down. (Pet. Exh. E, pp. 52 and 55; testimony of Ms. PARENT.)
3. "Dist. Exh." refers to the District's exhibits, numbered 1-57, admitted into evidence.
4. The parties also disputed whether STUDENT's three-year review IEP was actually held in August 1993 or whether it was in fact held in June 1993. Ms. PARENT stated that there had been an IEP meeting held on June 10, 1993, for STUDENT's triennial review, but that she lost her copy of the IEP document and the District did not have it when she requested STUDENT's records. She also stated that at the June 1993 meeting, Ms. Cartwright told her that she could not challenge STUDENT's SED eligibility until the "next" triennial in 1996.
The IEP document from August 30, 1993, indicates under "Last IEP" a date of "6/10/93." (Dist. Exh. 7; Pet. Exh. F-7.) Additionally, the District's copy of the IEP document from August 1993 contains two marks under "Meeting Information," next to both "review" and "three-year." (Dist. Exh. 7.) The Petitioner's copy of the August 1993 IEP shows only one mark in the "Meeting Information" box, next to "review." (Pet. Exh. F-7.) Dr. Shiney-Norris stated at the hearing that the meeting of June 10, 1993, was held simply to go over the evaluations by her and Dr. Goodlow with Ms. PARENT, who specifically asked that the meeting not be considered a formal IEP meeting to allow her time to "digest" the information. Ms. PARENT said that she did not make such a request.
5. The Hearing Officer makes no ruling regarding whether the "transfer" from one CH-SDC to another CH-SDC might be of sufficient difference in a student's program to be considered a change in placement.
6. The Hearing Officer acknowledges that amendments to the IDEA were signed into law on June 4, 1997. The request for this hearing was received before any of the 1997 Amendments to the IDEA became effective and the parties made no argument that the amendments apply here. Additionally, according to the U.S. Supreme Court's decision in Landgraf v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994), retroactive application of such amendments are not favored; therefore, for all the reasons above, the Hearing Officer will apply the law as it stood at the time of the hearing request.
7. California law adds the requirement that inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be exhibited in "several situations." (California Code of Regulations § 3030(h)(3).)
8. The District does not contend that STUDENT exhibits a "tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems."
9. By "currently," the Hearing Officer refers to the 1996-97 school year.
10. Dr. Shiney-Norris testified that the definition and features for childhood dysthymia in the DSM-IV are not much different from those under the DSM-III-R.
11. The behaviors also seriously concern the Hearing Officer, who suggests that something more than weekly counseling might be in order for STUDENT.
12. In STUDENT's educational evaluations, including the most recent evaluation by Dr. Heller, STUDENT's achievement scores have been clustered in the single-percentile range in most areas.
13. Although this matter was not "initiated" by the District, the Hearing Officer notes that requesting a second hearing, solely on the issue of the appropriateness of the District's assessment, was not necessary because this hearing (regarding issues including reimbursement for the independent evaluation) had already been requested.
14. The Hearing Officer also notes that when a parent disagrees with a school district evaluation and obtains an independent evaluation conducted by a qualified examiner, the school district must pay for the evaluation if no hearing which deals with the issue of the appropriateness of the school district's own evaluation is requested. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503(b); California Education Code § 56329(b).) The only time a school district need not pay for such an independent evaluation is when that district has prevailed in a due process hearing on the appropriateness of its own evaluation. (Id.)
15. Apparently, the Petitioner also requests reimbursement for the time Dr. Heller spent testifying in this hearing. (Testimony of Ms. PARENT.) Hearing Officers are to indicate the prevailing party on each issue, but may not award attorneys' fees or other related costs as a result (parties often go to federal District court for that purpose). (20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(4)(B); California Education Code § 56507(b).) Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider the portion of Dr. Heller's fees for his time spent testifying in the request for reimbursement.
16. Although the Petitioner contends that both the 1993 and 1996 District evaluations were inappropriate because they both erroneously concluded that STUDENT was SED, the Hearing Officer will analyze whether the District's 1996 evaluation was appropriate. The Hearing Officer will not similarly analyze the District's 1993 evaluation because the Petitioner's 1997 independent evaluation was done in response to the 1996 District evaluation, not the District's 1993 evaluation. Ms. PARENT had another independent evaluation done in 1993 in response to the District evaluation done that year.
17. The Hearing Officer notes that the fact that neurological testing was not indicated at the time of the District's 1996 evaluation does not mean that further testing might not be recommended currently, if for no other reason than to rule out any neurological cause for any of STUDENT's disabilities. However, such a test would likely be considered a medical test, for which the District may not have responsibility.
18. The Hearing Officer notes that very little information from the District's 1996 evaluation was utilized in the discussion of STUDENT's SED eligibility. Use of Ms. Ableser's report was confined to her notations of STUDENT's classroom behavior.
