California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 17, 1998

Student v. Sunnyvale Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 92-98 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

Sunnyvale Elementary owes no private school reimbursement; eighth grader with low writing score found not eligible as learning disabled.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 15-year-old who had never qualified for special education filed for due process against Sunnyvale Elementary School District. In fall 1996, while he was in eighth grade at Columbia Middle School, he was suspended and not allowed to return. A student study team proposed a smaller alternative class instead. His father turned down that class, asked for a special education assessment, and enrolled him at Palo Alto Prepatory School, a private school. In December 1996 the IEP team found him not eligible. The student claimed he qualified as having a specific learning disability and attention deficit disorder. He asked for reimbursement of private school costs from November 1996 to June 1997.

The Hearing Officer found him not eligible. His test scores showed a severe gap between ability and achievement in written expression. However, California regulations required other evidence to back up that gap. Resource specialist Karen Bautista doubted the low writing score because he rushed through the subtest. His seventh-grade writing samples, his teacher's observations, and group standardized test scores showed work at or near grade level. The student's experts did not show that his writing weakness could not be addressed in regular education. He also earned average grades at the private school without special education. Because he was not eligible, the reimbursement claim failed. The Hearing Officer added that it would have failed anyway, because there was little evidence the private school was appropriate. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied California's former severe-discrepancy test for learning disabilities. A large gap between ability and achievement scores was not enough when work samples, teacher observations, and group tests did not back it up. It also shows that a reimbursement claim needed evidence that the private school met the student's needs.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 1. Was Student eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability and attention deficit disorder on or about December 1996?

    Student was not eligible as SLD. The severe discrepancy in written expression test scores was not backed up by work samples, teacher observations, or group test scores, and any weakness could be addressed in regular education. ADD alone is not an eligibility category.

  2. Issue 2. If Student was eligible for special education on or about December 1996, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with Student's attendance at the Palo Alto Prepatory School from November 1996 to June 1997?

    No reimbursement because Student was not eligible. In the alternative, Petitioner offered too little evidence that the private school was appropriate under Rowley.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982); Education Code § 56337; Education Code § 56339(a); Education Code § 56026; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j); U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum (1991) 18 IDELR 116

People named in the decision

  • Don Jolly, Director of special education and pupil personnel services, Sunnyvale Elementary School District
  • Karen Bautista, Resource specialist; academic achievement assessor (WIAT), Sunnyvale Elementary School District, Columbia Middle School
  • Naomi Lyall, Former science teacher, Columbia Middle School
  • Sheila Coonerty, Ph.D., School psychologist; psychoeducational assessor, Sunnyvale Elementary School District
  • Annabelle Markoff, Ph.D., Educational consultant; expert witness for Student
  • Betty Spicher, School psychologist; expert witness for Student, Oak Grove Unified School District
  • Palo Alto Prepatory School, Private school (parent's unilateral placement)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office in Sunnyvale, California on May 28 and 29, 1998.

Petitioner STUDENT was present for most of the hearing and was represented by attorney Robert J. Douglas. Also present on STUDENT's behalf was his father. Present for a portion of the second day was STUDENT's mother.

Respondent Sunnyvale Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds from the firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District's behalf was Don Jolly, the District's director of special education and pupil personnel services.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: STUDENT's father; STUDENT; Annabelle Markoff, Ph.D., educational consultant; Betty Spicher, school psychologist for the Oak Grove Unified School District; and STUDENT'S GRANDMOTHER, Ed.D., a retired school psychologist.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Karen Bautista, resource specialist for the District; Naomi Lyall, STUDENT's former science teacher at Columbia Middle School; and Sheila Coonerty, Ph.D., the District's school psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

(1) Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability and attention deficit disorder on or about December 1996?

(2) If STUDENT was eligible for special education on or about December 1996, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Palo Alto Prepatory School from November 1996 to June 1997?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who has never been found eligible for special education services. He lives with his father within the District. STUDENT attended regular education classes in the District from the third grade to the beginning of the eighth grade, where he had been receiving passing grades since at least the sixth grade. (District's Exh. 2.) From all accounts, STUDENT had been an average student academically, although his father testified that he had noticed that STUDENT had some difficulties with written work in spelling and punctuation, and with certain types of math problems. (Lyall and FATHER Testimony.)

At the beginning of the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT was in the eighth grade at Columbia Middle School in the District. In October of that school year, the school received a complaint that STUDENT had been carrying a gun on campus and/or that he had been involved in altercations with other students. STUDENT was searched by school personnel a number of times, but no gun was ever found. The school suspended STUDENT for three days.

After the suspension, STUDENT was not allowed to return to Columbia. Instead, on October 9, 1996, a student study team (SST) meeting was held. The SST Summary cites STUDENT's strengths as "academic," "grade improvement" in the eighth grade, and "no behavior problems in class," among other things. (District's Exh. 3.) Areas of concern were listed as "inability to follow school rules - not threaten physical harm to other kids"; "not accepting the school/classroom rules, particularly pertaining to handling problems with other students"; and "[STUDENT], according to his father, doesn't feel safe at school and so is unable to follow the rules." (District's Exh. 3.) The SST determined that STUDENT should be placed in an alternative class at Sunnyvale Middle School for a month. (District's Exh. 3.) The alternative class was to be a regular education class, but smaller in size than STUDENT'S class at Columbia, with someone to take charge of STUDENT's educational goals. (GRANDMOTHER Testimony.) STUDENT's father disagreed with the SST's recommendation and asked for an assessment for special education eligibility. On October 10, 1996, STUDENT's father signed his consent to an assessment plan that was to be performed by the resource specialist and school psychologist. (District's Exh. 4.)

In late October and November 1996, the District's school psychologist, Sheila Coonerty, Ph.D., performed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT using the following tests and methods: interviews; assessment observations; Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III); Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt (Bender); Beery Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (Beery); Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills - Upper Level (TVPS); Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills - Upper Level (TAPS); Human Figure Drawing; Roberts Apperception Test; portions of the Thematic Apperception Test; Child Behavior Inventory; and Differential Problem Inventory. (Coonerty Testimony; District's Exh. 5.)

On the WISC-III, STUDENT achieved a full scale score of 92 (average range) which consisted of a verbal score of 87 (low average) and a performance score of 100 (average). (District's Exh. 5.) The lower verbal score was the result of a score of 3 on the arithmetic subtest and 7 on the comprehension subtest. (District's Exh. 5.) Dr. Coonerty believes that the WISC-III scores are valid with the exception of the arithmetic score. (Coonerty Testimony.) She doesn't believe that STUDENT took the arithmetic subtest in a valid manner since he arrived at answers in the span of a second or refuse to take any time to think about the problems. (Coonerty Testimony.) In her report, she noted the following:

[STUDENT]'s very short term memory of simple material is very good. If he can attend and does not have to process much of what he hears, he can do very well. However, keeping information in his head while trying to solve problems is more problematic for [STUDENT], particularly when numerical operations are involved. He becomes impatient and quickly gives up or loses concentration. To "rid" himself of a problem that is difficult for him, [STUDENT] just gives the first possible answer and gives up. It is possible that, although his capacity to attend and concentrate are good, [STUDENT] has trouble due to cognitive impulsivity. This, coupled with anger and resentment, leads to severe problems staying with a difficult task. However, [STUDENT]'s ability to perform well in school suggests that the major factor in these difficulties is his lack of internal motivation to stay on task when it involves sustained concentration.

(District's Exh. 5.)

On November 26, 1996, the District's resource specialist, Karen Bautista, administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) to STUDENT. (District's Exh. 5.) She did not administer the listening comprehension, oral expression and spelling subtests of the WIAT. (Bautista Testimony.) STUDENT's WIAT scores showed that he was performing in the average range in the area of reading despite some inattention during testing (at a grade level of 7.9; standard score of 97); in the low-average range in the area of math (at a grade level of 6.2; standard score of 86); and at the 1.2 grade level in the area of written expression (standard score of 73). Ms. Bautista noted STUDENT's weaknesses were in extension of details, sentence structure, capitalization and punctuation. (District's Exh. 5.)

Ms. Bautista was suspicious of the accuracy of the written expression score because of the quickness by which STUDENT completed the subtest, his unhappiness at being tested, and the fact that the written expression subtest was administered last. (Bautista Testimony.) She talked with STUDENT's eighth and seventh grade English teachers about his writing in class. (Bautista Testimony.) STUDENT was not in the eighth grade English class long enough to produce any adequate writing samples, but the seventh grade English teacher was able to produce some samples of STUDENT's written work during the seventh grade and said that she felt he had been on grade level that year. (Bautista Testimony.) Ms. Bautista reviewed the writing samples and found that they were much different from what STUDENT wrote during the WIAT testing. (Bautista Testimony; District's Exh. 9.) On these writing samples, STUDENT received Bs and Cs for the quality of his work, and Cs and Ds for punctuation and grammar. (District's Exh. 9.) These writing samples were admitted into evidence and discussed at the hearing by numerous witnesses, including Ms. Bautista. (See District's Exh. 9.)

Ms. Bautista concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because (1) the one low score for written expression was inconsistent with the level of achievement reflected in his classwork and in his teacher's observations; and (2) his scores on group standardized tests, such as the Individual Tests of Academic Skills (ITAS), showed that he was on or above grade level in all areas tested, including written language. (Bautista Testimony; District's Exh. 1.) Based on these factors, she determined that he did not need special education and that his needs could be met in the regular education classroom. (Bautista Testimony.)

Dr. Coonerty also concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services under the designation of SLD. (District's Exh. 5.) Dr. Coonerty testified that the assessment did reveal a significant discrepancy between the ability and achievement scores in the area of written expression but that, based on Ms. Bautista's observations, there was considerable doubt as to the validity of the written expression score on the WIAT. (Coonerty Testimony.) Dr. Coonerty testified that she looked over the rest of STUDENT's profile and found that there was not a significant discrepancy in any area. (Coonerty Testimony.) Dr. Coonerty also testified that, even assuming there was a valid significant discrepancy between ability and achievement, (1) STUDENT's needs could be met in the regular education classroom and (2) she did not find any processing disorder that could be causing a discrepancy in the area of written expression. (Coonerty Testimony.) She testified that records indicate that many downs in his performance were clearly affected by emotional issues. (Coonerty Testimony.)

On December 18, 1996, an IEP meeting was held in which Ms. Bautista's and Dr. Coonerty's findings were presented. (District's Exh. 6; Bautista Testimony.) From these, the IEP team determined that STUDENT did not qualify for special education because his "achievement is commensurate with his ability, except for the area of written language." (District's Exh. 6.) The team found that "[a]t this time, . . . written language needs can be addressed in the classroom." (District's Exh. 6.)

During this time, Columbia Middle School had continued to refuse to allow STUDENT to return to classes at Columbia and STUDENT's father had continued to refuse the alternative placement at Sunnyvale Middle School. (FATHER Testimony.) After STUDENT stayed home for approximately 3 weeks following the 3-day suspension, STUDENT's father placed him at Palo Alto Prepatory School, which FATHER testified was a small private school listed as handling children with special needs. (FATHER Testimony.) STUDENT attended Palo Alto Prepatory that year from early November 1996 to early June 1997, with his father providing daily transportation to and from the school. (FATHER Testimony.) STUDENT did not receive special education services at Palo Alto Prepatory. (GRANDMOTHER Testimony.)

SUMMARY OF OTHER RELEVANT EXPERT TESTIMONY

Petitioner's Witnesses:

ANNABELLE MARKOFF, Ph.D.

Annabelle Markoff, an educational consultant, was asked by GRANDMOTHER to review the documents submitted by Petitioner to determine if she thought STUDENT had any learning disabilities. Dr. Markoff has a bachelor of arts degree in psychology and elementary education, two masters of arts in mental retardation and visually handicapped, and a Ph.D. in special education. Among other things, she has been a teacher from the elementary to university levels, has written three books, has a remedial reading background, and was education director for a school for children with severe behavior and learning problems. She is currently teaching a four-session class for the ADHD Parenting Skills Program on behalf of Kaiser Permanente.

Dr. Markoff did not assess STUDENT or speak to anyone at the District regarding STUDENT, but she did review the materials given to her by GRANDMOTHER. From these, Dr. Markoff concluded that STUDENT had a "learning disability" in four areas: auditory processing, reading, attention and behavior. She testified that STUDENT would not make progress without resource specialist help because of his need for direct, intense intervention. She based this on his achievement results, which she states were below average. Dr. Markoff pointed out that there was a thirteen point discrepancy between the verbal and performance scores on the WISC-III, which she characterized as a significant discrepancy in intelligence and performance.

Dr. Markoff defined a "learning disability" as an undeveloped skill needed to succeed in school, a definition which covers social, emotional, physical and cognitive skills. Dr. Markoff admitted that, although she has read the legal definition of a "specific learning disability," she tries to "stay away from that." She testified that her expertise is in interpreting diagnostic information and helping teachers apply it, not in applying the legal definition of a "specific learning disability."

BETTY SPICHER

Betty Spicher has been a school psychologist with the Oak Grove Unified School District for the past twenty-three years. Ms. Spicher has a bachelor's degree in child development and a master's degree in school psychology, and is a licensed educational psychologist.

Ms. Spicher reviewed materials given to her by GRANDMOTHER concerning STUDENT, but did not assess STUDENT or speak to anyone at the District. Based on materials she reviewed, Ms. Spicher testified that the District's 1996 assessment did find a discrepancy between ability and achievement in written language and that, as past records indicate attention problems, attention could have been STUDENT's qualifying condition for special education services. Although she admitted that she thought STUDENT could make progress without special education, she testified that it seems his written language ability is pretty delayed compared to his potential and that he needed some support. She had reviewed some of his 1996 writing samples and found that they were nowhere near what would be expected of a boy of his age, ability and grade level with respect to the quality, grammar, punctuation, spelling, vocabulary and content.

STUDENT'S GRANDMOTHER, Ed.D.

GRANDMOTHER is a retired school psychologist and STUDENT's paternal grandmother. She has a bachelor's degree in liberal arts and a doctorate in education from Stanford in counseling and guidance, and school psychology. She is also a certified psychologist and a credentialed school psychologist. She was a school psychologist for approximately thirty years in various school districts, most recently for Oak Grove Unified School District, before she retired in 1993.

GRANDMOTHER testified that she has reviewed STUDENT's school records and thinks that STUDENT is qualified for special education based on a specific learning disability. She disagreed with the District's discounting of STUDENT's low written expression score on the WIAT based on his writing samples from his seventh grade English class. GRANDMOTHER'S disagreement was based on (1) her belief that the teacher could not have compared STUDENT's performance with children in other classes or according to national standards, especially when, according to the school, its population is composed of 15.6% limited or non-English speaking students (Pet.'s Exh. C); (2) there is no formal standard for scoring the writing samples; (3) some samples didn't have dates to show when they were completed; and (4) it could not be determined whether there had been any correction by the teacher. Additionally, she found that the work samples revealed problems "not typical" of a boy of STUDENT's age and intelligence. She also disagrees with the District's reliance on STUDENT's scores on standardized group tests, such as the ITAS, because they do not involve the same sort of writing task as the WIAT.

GRANDMOTHER testified that, of the basic psychological processes listed in the legislation, the testing done by the District and past records show that STUDENT has disabilities in the areas of attention, auditory reception, visual reception and sensory-motor skills. She testified that his disabilities in visual reception and auditory reception affect his written language and written composition skills.

She concluded that "some special education help would be very worth the effort." She reports that Palo Alto Prepatory has been helpful for STUDENT, but that he has not had the benefit of special education services or consultation. She thought that more focused services would be more helpful. STUDENT's grades at Palo Alto Prepatory have been mostly average, although some declined within the last year.

GRANDMOTHER provided some general testimony that she had asked that a language assessment be performed by a specialist. However, she did not provide any testimony with regard to whom she made the request or when she made the request. Based on the lack of information provided at hearing, this testimony will be given little weight.

District's Witnesses:

KAREN BAUTISTA(Footnote 1)

Karen Bautista is the District's resource specialist at Columbia Middle School who assessed STUDENT in the area of academic achievement. Ms. Bautista has a bachelor's degree in psychology, a lifetime elementary credential, a lifetime learning handicapped credential, and a resource specialist certificate. She taught special day classes for grades kindergarten through sixth for approximately eight years and has been the District's resource specialist for the past five years.

Ms. Bautista testified that she is trained to administer the WIAT and has administered it at least a hundred times. In assessing STUDENT, Ms. Bautista administered the WIAT, reviewed notes from the SST meeting, spoke with STUDENT's English and math teachers, and reviewed writing samples from his English classes. She testified that she didn't administer the listening comprehension, oral expression and spelling subtests of the WIAT to STUDENT because there did not appear to be any specific area of academic need. She had been informed that the major concern was STUDENT's behavior outside the classroom.

She testified that she found that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because, based on her discussion with his seventh grade English teacher and the writing samples she reviewed from that teacher, his one low score in written expression was mitigated by his classwork. She knew that at least one of the writing samples did not allow for correction by the teacher because it was a pretest taken by both schools in the District. On the whole, she found that the samples were average examples of a middle school student's writing. She also reviewed STUDENT's scores on standardized tests that the whole school took, which were normed across the country, and found that he was on or above grade level on these tests. (District's Exh. 1.)

SHEILA COONERTY, Ph.D. (Footnote 2)

Sheila Coonerty works part-time for the District as a school psychologist and is a clinical psychologist in private practice. She has a bachelor of arts degree in psychology; a master's degree in school and clinical psychology; a Ph.D. in clinical psychology; and credentials in elementary and secondary teaching, and pupil personnel services with a school psychology specialty. She is also a licensed psychologist. She has seven years of experience as a teacher, five years as a school psychologist, and fourteen years as a clinical psychologist.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

ISSUE NO. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability and attention deficit disorder on or about December 1996?

The threshold issue is whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). Under the IDEA and California special education law, only individuals with certain disabilities, including specific learning disabilities, are eligible for special education services. Moreover, the individual's disability must require instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. California Education Code § 56026(a)-(b).

Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD)

Petitioner contends that STUDENT shows signs of attention deficit disorder. ADD is not listed in federal or state law as one of the disabilities that establishes eligibility for special education. The United States Department of Education has stated in a policy memorandum that a student with ADD or ADD with hyperactivity (ADHD) is eligible for special education only if by reason thereof (1) the student meets that eligibility criteria for a listed disability such as SLD, other health impairment (OHI) or serious emotional disturbance (SED); and (2) the student needs special education. U.S. Department of Education Joint Policy Memorandum, (1991) 18 IDELR116. Similarly, California law states that a student whose educational performance is "adversely affected" by a suspected or diagnosed ADD is eligible for special education if the student meets eligibility criteria in the category of SLD, OHI or SED, which would demonstrate a need for special education and related services. Education Code § 56339(a).

Since there was no allegation or evidence that STUDENT should have qualified for special education services under the category of SED or OHI, this decision will focus only on whether STUDENT should have qualified under the category of SLD.

Specific Learning Disability (SLD)

California Education Code § 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met in order to satisfy eligibility criteria for a specific learning disability:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) oral expression; (2) listening comprehension; (3) written expression; (4) basic reading skills; (5) reading comprehension; (6) mathematics calculation; (7) mathematics reasoning. (b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. © The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

1. severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement

The IEP team, including assessment personnel, is to determine whether or not a "severe discrepancy" exists between intellectual ability and achievement by taking into account all relevant material which is available on the student. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4). "No single score or product of scores, test or procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for the decisions of the [IEP] team as to the pupil's eligibility for special education." 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4). In this context, "intellectual ability" includes both "acquired learning" and "learning potential" and is to be determined by a systematic assessment of intellectual functioning. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(2). The level of "achievement" includes the student's "level of competence in materials and subject matter explicitly taught in school" and is to be measured by standardized achievement tests. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(3).

A "severe discrepancy" can be established in one of three ways: through a formula using standardized tests; by alternative means when standardized tests are considered invalid; or through a determination by an IEP team that such a discrepancy exists. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A)-(C). California Code of Regulations § 3030(j)(4)(A) sets forth the method by which to establish a severe discrepancy for students for whom standardized tests are considered to be valid. There was no testimony that the use of standardized tests is invalid for assessing STUDENT's ability or achievement. Therefore, to determine if a severe discrepancy exists, STUDENT's scores on standardized intellectual testing can be compared with his scores on achievement testing.

When standardized tests are considered valid for a student, a severe discrepancy is established by the following:

[F]irst, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. A computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, the adjustment not to exceed 4 common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.

5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).

In this case, there was no real dispute that, when STUDENT's scores on the WISC-III and WIAT are compared, a severe discrepancy between the achievement and ability scores occurred in one area, namely written expression. (Bautista and Coonerty Testimony.) However, the District contends that this severe discrepancy in the test scores was "mitigated," or not corroborated, by STUDENT's work samples, the observations of his seventh grade English teacher, and his performance on standardized group tests. (Bautista and Coonerty Testimony.)

Under 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A), "[a] computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion . . . indicates a severe discrepancy when such discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include . . . observations and work samples, as appropriate." (Emphasis added.) Here, Ms. Bautista found STUDENT's significantly lower written expression score to be suspect because of her observations during testing. She followed up on her concerns by collecting other assessment data in the form of teacher observations and work samples from STUDENT's seventh grade English class. She found that a severe discrepancy was not indicated by all the assessment data, as the teacher's observations and the work samples indicated that STUDENT was performing at or about grade level. Moreover, she found that STUDENT's performance on the written expression subtest was inconsistent with his performance in class, which indicated to her that STUDENT did not give his best effort in completing the subtest.

Petitioner offered the testimony of Dr. Markoff, Ms. Spicher and GRANDMOTHER to show that a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement was shown by the District's testing. Dr. Markoff's testimony does not carry much weight with respect to this issue because, as she freely admitted during the hearing, she lacks expertise in applying the legal definition of SLD. Ms. Spicher's testimony, e.g., that she had reviewed "some" of STUDENT's 1996 writing samples and found them well what would be expected for STUDENT, carries less weight than does Ms. Bautista's. It was never made clear how many of the writing samples Ms. Spicher actually did review, although it was clearly not as many as Ms. Bautista reviewed, and she never spoke with STUDENT's teacher, the one who had the opportunity to observe his performance all year.

GRANDMOTHER's testimony on this issue is also not persuasive. According to 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(3), a student's level of achievement is to include the "level of competence in materials and subject matter explicitly taught in school." (Emphasis added.) Additionally, even though achievement is to be "measured by standardized achievement tests," 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(3), a severe discrepancy must be "corroborated by other assessment data" such as "observations and work samples." 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A). In this case, the discrepancy in achievement and ability test scores was not corroborated. The Hearing Officer does not find convincing GRANDMOTHER's testimony that STUDENT's achievement in written expression cannot be gauged by writing samples that (1) STUDENT himself produced, (2) were offered by his seventh grade English teacher as examples of work STUDENT performed while in the seventh grade, and (3) were the result of assignments in school. Moreover, there was testimony by Ms. Bautista that at least one of the writing samples was the result of a pretest which all students in Columbia Middle School and Sunnyvale Middle School took, which allowed no correction by the teacher and was scored by two teachers according to a preset standard. STUDENT received an average score on that test from both teachers.

2. discrepancy is due to a disorder in a basic psychological process

For purposes of this section, "basic psychological processes" include "attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expression." 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(1).

Dr. Coonerty testified that she did not find any processing disorder that could be causing a discrepancy in the area of written expression. On the other hand, GRANDMOTHER testified that STUDENT had disabilities in visual processing and auditory reception that were affecting his written language and written composition skills. The testimony of these experts need not be reconciled with each other as Petitioner clearly did not establish that he met the other requirements for special education eligibility based on a specific learning disability.

3. discrepancy cannot be corrected within regular instructional program

Ms. Bautista and Dr. Coonerty firmly stated that they believed that any weakness in written expression could be corrected within the regular education program. They based this opinion on STUDENT's past academic progress within the regular education program, writing samples from class, his teacher's observation that he was performing at or near grade level in written expression, and his average to above average performance on group standardized tests.

Petitioner, on the other hand, did not offer any convincing testimony that discrepancy in STUDENT's written expression skills could not be corrected within the regular instructional program. Ms. Spicher admitted that STUDENT could progress without special education, although she felt some support was needed. GRANDMOTHER testified only that "some special education help would be very worth the effort."

Further, the evidence shows that STUDENT received passing or better grades while in regular education classes within the two years prior to eighth grade, he consistently performed at or above grade level since the third grade on the ITAS, and he received average grades in the eighth grade at Palo Alto Prepatory without the benefit of any special education services. Therefore, there is no convincing evidence that STUDENT required instruction or services that could not be provided with modifications to the regular school program on or around December 1996.

***

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not qualify for special education services for a specific learning disability on or about December 1996.

(2) If STUDENT was eligible for special education on or about December 1996, must the District reimburse Petitioner for costs associated with STUDENT's attendance at the Palo Alto Prepatory School from November 1996 to June 1997?

Based on the evidence presented at hearing, STUDENT was not eligible for special education services on or about December 1996. Therefore, the issue of whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for his unilateral placement at Palo Alto Prepatory need not be considered.

In addition, it should be noted that, even had STUDENT been eligible for special education services on or about December 1996, Petitioner would still not be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the expenses associated with Palo Alto Prepatory. Without the submission of evidence demonstrating the appropriateness of Palo Alto Prepatory to meet STUDENT's educational needs, retroactive reimbursement cannot be awarded. Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 207 (1982). Petitioner's evidence demonstrated only that the classes at Palo Alto Prepatory were smaller than STUDENT's class at Columbia, that Palo Alto Prepatory describes itself as a school for special needs children, and that STUDENT did not receive any special education or related services while there for the 1996-1997 school year, yet he maintained average grades. Based on the scantness of the evidence regarding the educational services STUDENT received at Palo Alto Prepatory, Petitioner did not meet his burden of proof under Rowley.

ORDER

All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(I).

Date: July 17, 1998 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. This supplements the testimony of Ms. Bautista that is recounted in the Background Facts section. 2. This supplements the testimony of Dr. Coonerty that is recounted in the Background Facts section.