California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 30, 1998
Student v. Petaluma City School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 923-98 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Petaluma City School District must place 11-year-old in a regular fifth grade class with a full-time aide, not a special day class.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The Petaluma City School District filed for due process in December 1997. An 11-year-old boy's father had removed him from a special day class (SDC) and asked for a regular class with support. The father cross-filed in June 1998, and the cases were consolidated. The student has significant cognitive and adaptive delays, is largely nonverbal, and has cerebral palsy. He spent second and third grade in regular classes with a full inclusion case manager and a one-to-one aide. The parties agreed on the goals and services in the June 1998 IEP but not on placement for 1998-99. The District proposed an SDC. The father wanted a regular fifth grade class.
Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait applied the four-factor Rachel H. test. He found that the student could make progress on his mostly academic IEP goals in a regular class with support. Even the District's inclusion specialist wrote that his goals could be met in either setting. The Hearing Officer rejected the District's arguments about living skills, the student's age, teasing, and the gap between the student and his classmates. He said that even dramatic curriculum changes do not by themselves justify removal. The student would gain social benefits and had not disrupted past classes. The District offered no evidence on cost. The District was ordered to place him in a regular fifth grade class at his neighborhood school within 30 days, with a special education case manager and a full-time one-to-one aide.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rachel H. least restrictive environment factors to a student with cognitive delays. The Hearing Officer held that a large skill gap, heavy curriculum modification, or a view that an SDC is academically better did not alone justify removal from a regular class. Because the district offered no cost evidence, cost could not weigh against inclusion.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate program in the least restrictive environment for the 1998-99 school year?
Under all four Rachel H. factors, the student could be educated satisfactorily in a regular fifth grade class with supplementary aids and services, so the District's offer of a special day class was not the least restrictive environment.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Placement ordered. Within 30 days of the decision, the District shall place the student in a regular fifth grade class at his neighborhood school with appropriate supplemental services, including a special education case manager and a full-time one-to-one aide.
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City U.S.D. v. Rachel H. (Holland); Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Roland v. Concord School Committee
People named in the decision
- Gerry Klor, Director of Student Services, Petaluma City School District
- Barbara Ramirez, regular third grade teacher, McNear Elementary School, Petaluma City School District
- Pam Ferrara, special education teacher and full inclusion case manager (third grade), Petaluma City School District
- Christie Lovejoy, special day class teacher, Petaluma City School District
- Heather Rooney, home instruction teacher, Petaluma City School District
- Erich Brocker, school psychologist, Petaluma City School District
- Kathie Flanagan, speech and language specialist (assessor), Petaluma City School District
- Mimi Carrol (also spelled Carroll), full inclusion case manager (second grade), Mewok School, Old Adobe School District
- Lisa Laborte, 1:1 instructional aide, Petaluma City School District
- Susan Mark-Raymond, District inclusion specialist, Petaluma City School District
- Dr. Paula Gardener, expert witness for Student; Associate Professor, California State University, Sacramento
- Dona Meinders, expert witness for Student; regional consultant, California for Inclusive Education
- Northern California Diagnostic Center, comprehensive assessment provider, State Diagnostic Center
- Easter Seal Society Infant Development Program, early intervention provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Officer, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, on August 13 and 14, and September 3, and 4, 1998, in Petaluma, California.
Petaluma City School District (District) and the Sonoma County Office of Education (SCOE) were represented by attorney Lawrence M. Schoenke. Also present on behalf of the District was Gerry Klor, Director of Student Services.
STUDENT was represented by attorney Dale Mentink. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his father, FATHER.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the matter was continued so that the parties could submit written closing briefs. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision on October 2, l998.
ISSUE
Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate program in the least restrictive environment for the l998-99 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eleven-year-old boy who has significant delays in cognitive abilities and adaptive behaviors that adversely affect his educational performance in all areas. STUDENT attended special day classes during kindergarten and first grade. During the second grade, STUDENT was enrolled in a regular second grade class at the Mewok School in the Old Adobe School District. He had the assistance of a full inclusion case manager and a one-to-one aide.
Prior to the l996-97 school year, STUDENT moved with his father into the Petaluma City School District. During that year, STUDENT attended a regular third grade class taught by Barbara Ramirez at the McNear Elementary School. His special education program was overseen by Pam Ferrara, a special education teacher who acted as his full inclusion case manager. He was assisted by one-to-one aides for five and one-half hours of the six and one-half hour school day. STUDENT was also provided speech, language and occupational therapy services. During the l996-97 school year, STUDENT’s father expressed dissatisfaction concerning the amount of services that STUDENT was receiving in these areas of speech and language and occupational therapy.
In late Spring of l997, STUDENT began to exhibit some resistive behaviors such as falling on the floor and laughing loudly. The collaborative team, made up of STUDENT’s teachers, aides, the full inclusion case manager and STUDENT’s father, designed a behavior management plan to address STUDENT’s inappropriate conduct. On May 20, l997, the team concluded that the behavior management plan was working.
During the Spring and Summer of l997, the District recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class (SDC) to address his needs more effectively. In August l997, STUDENT’s father agreed to place STUDENT in an SDC during the l997-98 school year. STUDENT enrolled in the SDC taught by Christie Lovejoy at the beginning of the l997-98 school year. He attended the class for about five weeks in September and October l997, after which his father pulled him out of the class. On December 1, 1997, an advocate for STUDENT requested that STUDENT be placed in a regular class with special education support. On December 4, l997, the District filed a request for hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office stating that the issue for hearing was “appropriate placement.”
In February l998, the District agreed to have Heather Rooney provide home instruction for STUDENT for one hour per day. The parties agreed that STUDENT would return to Ms. Lovejoy’s SDC for the month of March so that both parties could have their full inclusion specialists observe STUDENT. On the fourth of March, STUDENT was injured while playing at recess and STUDENT’s father removed him from the class. STUDENT returned to home teaching for one hour per week, where he has remained. The full inclusion specialists were not able to observe STUDENT in the special day class setting, but were able to observe him while he received his home instruction.
During the spring of l998, STUDENT underwent his triennial assessment. The speech and language assessment dated May 18, l998, concluded:
[STUDENT’s] receptive language abilities [are] in the 3-4 year range, while his expressive language skills are at about the 2 year-old level. STUDENT is nonverbal, but smiles, laughs, makes eye contact, and uses a number of gestures and signs to communicate his wants and needs. Signs include names of objects, animals, adjectives, and some verbs. He vocalizes to say ‘yeah’ appropriately, but uses few other sounds. His oral motor skills are weak, with poor lip and tongue mobility; some drooling noted. He has successfully used a Macaw speech output device programmed with 32 message areas while in full inclusion program.
An occupational therapy assessment was performed on May 13, l998, which recommended continued occupational therapy. The report concluded:
It seems that STUDENT has poorly integrated reflexes which affect his patterns of movement. STUDENT seems to have a difference in the way he processes and responds to sensory information. This is noted in his ‘overflow’ patterns when writing, or doing fine motor activities. This is also of note in his difficulty with motor planning.
The school psychologist, Erich Brocker, performed an assessment of STUDENT in March and April l998. He attempted to use two tests of cognitive ability which were designed for children ages five to twelve (The Motor Free Visual Perceptual Test - revised and the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence - 2). He was not able to obtain reliable scores because STUDENT was not able to comprehend the concepts and instructions of the tests. Mr.Brocker also assessed STUDENT’s visual motor integration and concluded:
STUDENT was able to correctly draw two items. He was able to imitate the horizontal line, but not copy it, and imitated the circle, but did not copy it in the proper place. STUDENT drew his circle inside of the stimulus circle. He seemed to need some sort of prompt, be it direct drawing, or visual. STUDENT is struggling with his visual motor skills. Some trouble comes from his low muscle tone in his hands, and hand tremors that have been present for some time. He is currently working with his Home Study teacher on writing the letters of his name.
Mr. Brocker assessed STUDENT’s social emotional status using the Behavior Assessment System for Children, Parent Rating. He concluded that while STUDENT’s profile falls mostly within average ranges, he was rated “with extreme caution” in relation to leadership. Mr. Brocker stated that “STUDENT is a shy type student, who takes time to warm up to new people. He was rated as sometimes avoiding other children, sometimes clinging to parents in strange surroundings, and is often shy with other children.”
The Brigance Inventory of Early Development was utilized to determine STUDENT’s developmental level in a number of different domains. Within the gross motor domain, “STUDENT was reported to stand on one foot for five seconds, walk backwards for six steps, and walk up stairs carrying objects in one hand. He was reported to run smoothly with changes in speed, takes steps and kicks a ball, and has learned to walk a balance beam in his gymnastics class. He was reported to catch, bounce, and throw playground balls.”
In the Self-Help skills domain, the report concludes:
STUDENT was reported to be able to make sandwiches, can remove pull over garments, and can dress himself without using difficult fasteners. Lowered muscle tone make fasteners difficult for STUDENT; i.e., zippers, buttons, etc. STUDENT is recently able to sign his desire to use the bathroom, and was reported to be able to care for his toileting needs other than for some help in wiping. He was reported to have the ability to bath and brush his teeth with assistance. STUDENT’s father reported that STUDENT enjoys helping around the house, and cleans up his own clutter.
Within the General Knowledge and Comprehension domain it was reported that:
STUDENT has difficulty with receptive and expressive skills. He currently understands and uses approximately 15 C signs. He can match red, blue, green, and yellow, but continues to have some difficulty with color identification. He requires verbal prompts, and at this time, appears to be somewhat prompt dependent. Design and Time concepts are not areas that have been worked directly with STUDENT, but it was reported that these may be areas of difficulty for him. Directional and Positional concepts were limited, and STUDENT understood, up/down, bottom/top, and go/stop. STUDENT’s father indicated that STUDENT understands the directional arrows on the computer, but his use of the directions is sporadic.
In the Basic Reading Skills domain, “STUDENT was reported to be able to use his auditory discrimination skills for all the letters of the alphabet.”
In the Math domain, STUDENT was reported to “understand ‘one more,’ ‘just one’, and can count up to three items. He was observed to read numerals up to twenty, and was reported to count by rote up to 13.”
Mr. Brocker’s report concludes with the following summary and recommendations:
STUDENT is an 11 year old male student who continues to demonstrate significant deficits in cognitive ability and adaptive behavior. He has made some growth in the adaptive area since his previous assessment. The most appropriate educational setting for STUDENT is a small, structured, learning environment that gives him the opportunity to work on functional, academic, and life skills. STUDENT is an active child who seems to benefit from interactions with peers and adults, and needs continued social skills practice. Learning self help and functional life skills should continue to be an important focus of this academic program.
After completion of the assessments, the IEP team met on June 4, l998, to develop a program for STUDENT. The team developed goals to increase STUDENT’s skills in the areas of writing, reading, communication, math and social skills. There are also goals and objectives for speech and language and occupational therapy. Three short-term objectives are included for writing skills, which includes writing his name, writing letters of the alphabet and writing his phone number. Objectives for increasing his reading skills include identification of words from the Edmark Reading Program and answering questions after reading words in a sentence. Objectives for increasing communication skills include learning an additional 25 functional signs and independently initiating communication with staff and peers. STUDENT’s objective in math is to count using counting manipulatives and stopping when he gets to the requested amount. In the area of increasing social skills, the objective is to have STUDENT independently participate with at least one peer in a P.E., Recreation or Leisure time activity. Speech and language goals include increasing STUDENT’s ability to communicate using a voice output devise and the development of oral motor skills. The occupational therapy goals include improvement of perceptual motor skills and manual dexterity. The manual dexterity goal and objectives include increasing his ability to use snaps, zippers, and buttons.
The IEP provides for the related services of speech and language therapy for thirty minutes two times a week and occupational therapy, using the collaborative model, for a total of 12 hours during the year. The IEP also provides that a toileting goal will be developed 30 days after STUDENT’s placement in a classroom.
The District and STUDENT’s father agreed to the IEP in all respects except for the appropriate placement. The District favored placing STUDENT in an SDC, and STUDENT’s father favored placement in a regular class with special education support.
On June 12, l998, the Northern California Diagnostic Center completed a comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. Following are some of the key findings from the report:
STUDENT is a pleasant, compliant boy who has developmental delays, cerebral palsy and speech impairment. He is predominately nonverbal with some gestural and sign language used linguistically. He is at the readiness level academically. STUDENT’s social awareness is a relative strength as is his motivation to interact, learn new information and use his pleasing personality with others. Weaknesses are most apparent in his scant verbal language, poor oral motor skills and fine-motor control.
STUDENT’s small size, motoric difficulties and cognitive and speech difficulties put him at risk for accidents and potential teasing on the school grounds. The possible role of ongoing seizures is unclear....
Although STUDENT experiences considerable academic delays commensurate with his overall functioning, he demonstrates the ability to associate symbols with meaning. He is able to understand and make use of cause and effect relationships in order to complete tasks. STUDENT performed best when the task was presented with a few visual distractors, organized in two to three items at a time. He was able to process a sequence of three steps, but had difficulty integrating more than three. During the assessment, STUDENT was able to learn six new Signed Exact English signs, match words to objects, words to pictures and point to written words following a verbal prompt. In the course of two hours of instruction, STUDENT was able to learn the signs and read four new vocabulary words. He was able to read these words in order to follow a sequence of directions that lead to the completion of a cooking project. Success with this activity indicates a positive future, growth in vocabulary and reading skills....
Although STUDENT did not initiate any verbal communication, he responded well to social interaction and exchanges with adults. He moved easily between test settings. There is positive indication for STUDENT to strengthen his functioning within a structured setting which builds on appropriate peer relations and positive social interaction.
Among the recommendations set out in the report are the following:
STUDENT will benefit from consistent, daily classroom experiences with peers, in which he can receive instruction that is directed toward improving his daily living skills with a focus on effective communication strategies. He needs to develop his social skills with age level peers. Safety issues need to be strongly considered when making his class placement.
The report goes on to recommend assistive technology, speech and language therapy, voice output communication devices, occupational therapy, continued use of the Edmark program and the training of staff.
On June 23, l998, STUDENT cross-filed a request for hearing. The two hearing requests were later consolidated.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) with special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8) (A-D) & 1401 (25). A FAPE must be provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (8) (D).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
United States Code § 1412(a)(5) provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or educating them in the “least restrictive environment.” The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45.
In the case of STUDENT, the District contends that the least restrictive environment for an appropriate program would be in a special day class with other children who have disabilities similar to STUDENT’s. STUDENT’s father believes that STUDENT should be placed in a regular fifth grade class with specially designed support services.
In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental services, the courts have considered four factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the educational benefits of a special education classroom; (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with children who are not disabled; (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom; and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. Sacramento City U.S.D. v. Rachel H. (Holland) (1994) 14 F.3d 1398.
1. What educational benefits would be available to STUDENT in a regular fifth grade classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with those he would receive in a special day class?
During the hearing, there were two principal sources of evidence upon which to base this analysis: (1) evidence concerning STUDENT’s prior experience in regular classes in the second and third grade and his experience for a short time in a fourth grade special day class, and (2) opinions concerning his likely success in such placements in the fifth grade.
The only witness to testify who was directly involved with STUDENT’s regular second grade class at Mewok School was Mimi Carrol, STUDENT’s full inclusion case manager. She testified that the 95-96 school year was a learning year for STUDENT. She said that at the beginning of year STUDENT had little idea of how to get along in a large group but that, by the end of the year, he was doing well at recess with his nondisabled classmates. Ms. Carrol testified that STUDENT’s regular second grade teacher was helpful in modifying the class for him and that the other children in the classroom were supportive and helpful to him. Ms. Carrol concluded that STUDENT made both social and academic progress in his second grade year.
The IEP dated January 10, l996, states that STUDENT “enjoys second grade classroom” and “peers supply support and encouragement.” The IEP also concludes that STUDENT had met his speech goal to point to pictures, but had not met the goal relating to vocalization. He had partially met his domestic goals relating to spreading peanut butter and putting on his shoes and socks and had met his toileting goal. He had also “practically” met his two PE goals.
Pam Ferrara was STUDENT’s full inclusion case manager while he was in the third grade (96-97 school year). She testified that she worked with STUDENT several hours each week and that he did well in meeting his IEP objectives. Lisa Laborte was STUDENT’s one-to-one instructional aide during the later part of the 96-97 year. She testified that STUDENT met the majority of his IEP goals and objectives and was making progress on the rest of them. Barbara Ramirez, STUDENT’s regular third grade teacher, testified that she had not instructed a severely disabled child before STUDENT came to her class and was given no special preparation for instructing STUDENT. She worked individually with STUDENT for some period of time each day. She said that STUDENT did make social progress during the year but that she didn’t think he made any academic progress. She did not express her views regarding his progress in meeting his IEP goals and objectives. She testified that she felt the best placement for STUDENT during the 97-98 school year would have been in a full inclusion third grade class.
Testing done in January 1995, January 1997, and May 1998 are difficult to interpret in as much as they are based on different instruments. It is clear that testing is difficult with STUDENT because of the severity of his disability and its effect on his receptive and expressive language. In January l995, he was determined to have a receptive language level of two years and eight months. The January l997 testing, based on a different assessment tool, found him to have a two-year-old level of receptive language. The assessment performed by Speech and Language Specialist Kathie Flanagan, dated May 18, l998, concluded that STUDENT was at the three-year level for receptive language and the two-year level for expressive language. These assessments reflect some growth over the three-year period from January l995 to May 1998. During that three-year period, STUDENT was in a full inclusion class for two years, a special day class for approximately seven months, and in home teaching for almost four months.
The assessment done by Erich Brocker, the school psychologist in April 1998, was based to a great extent on the opinions of STUDENT’s father and his home teacher, Heather Rooney. Mr. Brocker concluded that STUDENT “has made some growth in the adaptive area since his previous assessment.”
Although it is clear that progress with STUDENT must be measured in very small steps, those who worked closest with him during his two-year experience in a full inclusion setting believed that he made progress toward meeting his goals and objectives. The evidence concerning his progress in the SDC during the fall of l997 is sketchy. He was only in the class for about five weeks. His teacher, Christie Lovejoy, described his program, but said little about any progress during that period.
District witnesses consistently testified that they believed the best placement for STUDENT during the 98-99 school year would be an SDC made up of students with disabilities similar to STUDENT’s. Erich Brocker, the school psychologist, concluded that the most appropriate placement for STUDENT would be in “a small, structured, learning environment that gives him the opportunity to work on functional, academic, and life skills.”
The law, however, does not require that STUDENT be placed in the best program. In Board of Education of the Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874 (1992), (aff’d, 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994), the court concluded that "the Act’s requirement of integration, based on recognition of the non-academic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom.” (See also Roland v. Concord School Comm., 910 F. 2d 983,993 (1990).)
The issue is whether STUDENT’s education can be achieved satisfactorily in a regular class with the use of supplementary aids and services. U.S.C § 1412(a)(5)(A). The District’s own inclusion specialist, Susan Mark-Raymond, in her report dated April 8, l998, stated that “after a record review of STUDENT’s IEP, it appears that his instructional objectives can be met in either a special day class or in an inclusive classroom.” Although Mimi Carroll, STUDENT’s full inclusion case manager at Mewok school, recommended his placement in an SDC, she did testify that he could make progress in a full inclusion program. Pamela Ferrara, STUDENT’s full inclusion case manager in the third grade, also recommended that STUDENT be placed in an SDC, and also stated that a program could be designed that would work for STUDENT in a full inclusion environment.
Dr. Paula Gardener, an Associate Professor at California State University, Sacramento, observed STUDENT during his home schooling and reviewed his IEP. She stated that “an inclusive 5th or 6th grade general education classroom would provide appropriate opportunities for STUDENT to develop both academic skills, friendships and other relationships with students without disabilities.” She said that it would be necessary to develop an inclusion support plan that is supported by all of the members of the team responsible for STUDENT’s education. A special education teacher would need to oversee the modifications to the curriculum necessary for STUDENT to benefit from the class. He would also need an aide to assist him. Dr. Gardener set forth a proposed comprehensive plan for how STUDENT’s goals and objectives could be attained through appropriate modification of the regular class curriculum.
Dona Meinders, a regional consultant for California for Inclusive Education, testified that she observed STUDENT during his home study and reviewed his educational records and his IEP. She knew the fifth grade curriculum and believed that with appropriate support and materials STUDENT could meet his goals and objectives in a full inclusion classroom. She said that such a program would require a special education case manager who would work closely with the classroom teacher and one-to-one aide. They would adapt the materials and would work collaboratively toward meeting STUDENT’s goals and objectives.
The weight of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT could make educational progress in a regular classroom with appropriate supplementary aids and services.
The District mentioned a number of reasons relating to living skills as to why they believed that placement of STUDENT in a full inclusion program would not be appropriate.
Several District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s program should emphasize the living skills he will need to develop in order to function as an adult. They contended that such living skills cannot be appropriately addressed in a full inclusion setting, but could be addressed in an SDC. The problem with this argument is that the goals and objectives contained in STUDENT’s June 4, l998 IEP are, for the most part, academic goals and objectives. The only objective related to his living skills is under his occupational therapy goals and involves learning to use snaps, zippers and buttons. Dr. Gardener suggested that such manual dexterity objectives could be accomplished in a regular classroom when he is required to remove clothes when arriving and leaving school or going to recess or P.E. There was no evidence that this objective could not be accomplished in a regular classroom. It is also interesting to note that STUDENT’s regular third grade teacher, Ms. Ramirez, testified that she felt that there should have been more work on living skills goals while STUDENT was in her third grade class and that such goals could have been accomplished in that class. It is true that the IEP of June 4, l998, anticipated the formulation of a toileting goal after he had been in his program for 30 days. If such a goal were considered necessary, it was probably related to his difficulty in wiping. The suggested approach to helping him with such a goal was to have an aide accompany him to the bathroom to provide guidance. District witnesses stated that they believed that such an approach would be difficult in a regular classroom because it would necessitate the aide’s going into the bathroom with STUDENT while other children might be using the bathroom. But, nonetheless, the evidence seems to indicate that the goal might be better addressed in the full inclusion setting. In the SDC, there was no separate bathroom and there may not have been enough aides available to accompany STUDENT to the regular bathroom. If placed in the regular fifth grade class at the McNair School, he would have a full-time aide who would be available to accompany him whenever necessary and, additionally, there is a separate nurse’s bathroom that could be used.
Therefore, it is concluded that most of STUDENT’s goals and objectives relate to academics and can be successfully addressed in a full inclusion setting. Those few living skills goals that are in his IEP can also be addressed adequately in such a setting.
A number of District witnesses contended that a full inclusion program would not be appropriate for STUDENT because full inclusion does not work as well with older children as it does with younger children. Among the reasons stated were the increased class size in the higher grades, the danger of teasing by older students, and the increasing gap between the performance levels of the nondisabled children and the disabled child, the latter of which requires radical modifications of the curriculum.
Dr. Gardener testified that in her experience she has not found older students in full inclusion programs to have more difficulty than younger ones. She said there are different challenges but not necessarily greater difficulty.
It is true that the class size is larger in the fifth grade than in the second and third grades, and that a larger class may create more distraction for STUDENT, who has been shown to be distractible. But, on the other hand, witnesses for STUDENT and the District agreed that it is easy to refocus STUDENT and, therefore, his full-time aide would be able to lessen the impact of such distractions.
As to the increased danger of teasing, the evidence does not support that conclusion. District witnesses suggested that while STUDENT is in an SDC he should be integrated with nondisabled students in nonacademic classes and at recess and lunch. If teasing is a problem, it appears that it would be just as much a problem, if not more of a problem, when he is sporadically integrated with nondisabled students. In a full inclusion program, nondisabled students in his class would receive orientation concerning STUDENT and he would be with those nondisabled peers most of the time. In STUDENT’s former full inclusion classes, nondisabled students were recruited to assist STUDENT. Similar assistance could be given STUDENT by fellow classmates, thereby minimizing the danger of teasing.
There is no doubt that there would be a large gap between the functioning level of STUDENT and the nondisabled students in his class. While they are writing short essays, he will be learning to write his name. While they are learning multiplication and division, he will be learning his telephone number. But the size of the gap between the nondisabled students and STUDENT should not disqualify him from being educated with his nondisabled peers. If such a gap justified denying a child the less restrictive environment, it would mean that all severely disabled children would never be given the opportunity to be educated with nondisabled children. In the district court decision in the Holland case, Judge Levi stated: “The decision as to whether any particular child should be educated in a regular classroom setting, all of the time, part of the time, or none of the time, is necessarily an inquiry into the needs and abilities of one child, and does not extend to a group or category of children, as the District suggests.” 786 Fed. Supp. 874, 878.
The gap between STUDENT’s performance level and that of his nondisabled classmates will require significant modification of the curriculum for STUDENT. A number of District witnesses stated that the full inclusion program would not be appropriate for STUDENT because of the extent of the curriculum modification that would be necessary. The same argument was raised by school authorities in the Holland case. The court concluded that “modification of the curriculum for a handicapped child, even dramatic modification, has no significance in and of itself.” 786 Fed. Supp. 874, 880.
The evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT’s progress will be very slow in either a full inclusion setting or a special day class, but it also supports the conclusion that significant progress can be made in a full inclusion classroom toward meeting the goals and objectives contained in his June 4, l998 IEP.
2. Would there be nonacademic benefits to STUDENT from placement in a regular fifth grade class?
Another factor used by the courts in determining whether to place a child in a full inclusion setting is whether such a placement would provide nonacademic benefits.
Mimi Carroll testified that while STUDENT attended the full inclusion second grade class he advanced socially and benefitted from the models provided by his nondisabled peers. The District’s full inclusion specialist stated that the strengths of full inclusion would be that “ the student is a member of a class with peer role models.” The District’s psychologist, Erich Brocker, testified that a benefit to STUDENT from placement in a full inclusion setting would be the opportunity to develop social skills through having nondisabled peer models. Lisa Laborte, STUDENT’s aide in his third grade class, testified that STUDENT “did great” getting along with other kids and that the other kids helped him. Ms. Ramirez, STUDENT’s regular third grade teacher, testified that STUDENT received social benefits from being in her class and that he got a lot of love and attention from the other students. An example of how his interaction with nondisabled students helped him occurred when he was having trouble remembering the names of his classmates in the third grade. His collaborative team decided to have STUDENT hand out the papers to the other members of his class. This resulted in his learning to recognize his classmates and going to them by name.
Some District witnesses stated that STUDENT would be isolated in the class and would spend much of his time with his aide. But, as pointed out by Dr. Gardener, that would only occur if those responsible for STUDENT allowed it to occur. The strategy used in having STUDENT pass out papers to his classmates is an example of a strategy that could be used to ensure that STUDENT is not isolated.
Some District witnesses stated that in the fifth grade the nondisabled students will stop being STUDENT’s friends, that they will still help him, but will not view him as a friend. In any case, there was no persuasive evidence that all nondisabled students will reject STUDENT as a friend.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT will receive nonacademic benefits from a full inclusion setting.
3. How will STUDENT’s placement in a regular classroom affect the teacher and other children in the classroom?
The best, most succinct answer to this question was provided by STUDENT’s regular third grade teacher, Ms. Ramirez, when she said that the people who benefitted most from STUDENT’s presence in her classroom were her and her class. When STUDENT was almost three years old, a summary of his progress at the Easter Seal Society Infant Development Program described him as follows:
STUDENT is a petite thirty-five month old boy with charming brown eyes and a wonderful disposition. He has a dynamite social smile and enjoys attention. STUDENT’s strengths continue to be his relatively low frustration level, curious nature, desire to socially interact, and overall good nature.
This general assessment of STUDENT’s disposition has been consistent throughout his life. The assessment report by the Diagnostic Center dated June 12, l998, states:
STUDENT is a pleasant, compliant boy who has developmental delays, cerebral palsy and speech impairment.... STUDENT’s social awareness is a relative strength as is his motivation to interact, learn new information and use his pleasing personality with others.
The only evidence of behavior problems by STUDENT occurred in the Spring of l998, when STUDENT began to engage in misbehavior such as pressing his face to the window of the class, laughing loudly, lying on the floor, and setting the computer to a high volume so that when someone turned it on it would cause a commotion. While such conduct was not serious, the collaborative team designed a behavior plan to address the problem. A few weeks later, the team noted that the behavior plan was working successfully. The majority of the responsibility of adapting STUDENT’s curriculum was carried out by his special education case manager and his one-to-one aide. Ms. Ramirez also testified that although she did do something with STUDENT each day, she did not spend a lot of time with him. In conclusion, there is no persuasive evidence that STUDENT would cause an undue burden for the teachers or would detrimentally affect his nondisabled classmates. On the contrary, the evidence supports the conclusion the STUDENT will add an important new dimension to the regular fifth grade classroom that will benefit all concerned.
4. What is the cost of placing STUDENT in a full inclusion classroom?
The District presented no evidence concerning the financial impact of STUDENT’s placement in a full inclusion setting. Therefore, this factor cannot weight against such a placement.
The hearing officer concludes that STUDENT will receive significant educational benefit from placement in a full inclusion fifth grade class, will receive significant nonacademic benefits from such a placement, and will not negatively affect his teacher or his nondisabled classmates. It is further concluded that the cost of such a placement should not be considered as a factor because the District provided no evidence concerning cost.
ORDER
Within 30 days of the date of this decision, the District shall place STUDENT in a regular fifth grade class at his neighborhood school with appropriate supplemental services including a special education case manager and a full time one-to-one aide.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
STUDENT prevailed on the only issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 30, 1998 Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer
