California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 5, 1997
Student v. Ross Valley School District
SEHO Case No. SN 927-97 · Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan
Ross Valley School District's offer lacked counseling and structure, but parents denied Sterne School funding; new IEP meeting ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 12-year-old boy with a specific learning disability asked Ross Valley School District to pay for his private placement at Sterne School in San Francisco for 1997-1998. His disability involved visual processing and visual-motor delays. He had never attended public school. After three IEP meetings, the District offered a special day class (SDC) at White Hill middle school, with 30 to 39 percent of the day in general education. The parents rejected the offer and enrolled him at Sterne.
The Hearing Officer found that he needed a small, structured class, teachers trained in learning disabilities, and counseling. The White Hill SDC was small, and its teacher was well qualified. But all three assessments recommended counseling, and the written offer did not include it. Spreading the offer across three IEP documents also went against Union School District v. Smith, which requires one clear written offer. The class was also too distracting for him because students changed every period and worked at very different levels. No witness said he was ready to spend 30 to 39 percent of his day in general education. For these reasons, the offer was not appropriate. However, the parents gave almost no evidence about Sterne's program, staff, or services, so reimbursement was denied. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days and offer a small structured class, qualified teachers, and counseling.
Why it matters
This decision shows that finding a district's offer inadequate was not enough to win private school reimbursement at SEHO. Parents also had to prove the private school was appropriate with specific evidence. It also shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith to an offer spread across several IEP documents that left out a service everyone agreed was needed.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1A. Did the District offer Student an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year? (sub-question of: Is the District required to fund Student's placement at Sterne School for the 1997-1998 school year?)
The District's offer did not provide FAPE: it left out the counseling all assessments recommended, was split across three IEP documents contrary to Union v. Smith, and placed him in an SDC too unstructured and distracting, with more mainstreaming (30-39%) than any witness supported.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 1B. Is the Sterne School an appropriate placement for Student during the 1997-1998 school year?
Parents offered almost no specific evidence on Sterne School's program, staff credentials, or services, so they did not prove it was appropriate, and reimbursement was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within fifteen days of the order, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop an offer of appropriate placement that includes a small structured class, teachers knowledgeable in educating students with learning disabilities, and counseling.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Eugene Rich, special education program manager, Ross Valley School District
- Gail Benvenuta, RSP teacher; conducted initial educational assessment, Ross Valley School District
- Vivian Sherman, RSP teacher (District witness), Marin Horizons
- Yvonne Nolan, RSP teacher, serving as assistant principal at White Hill; Summer Shorts computer teacher, Ross Valley School District
- Carolyn Taormina, school psychologist; conducted psychoeducational assessment, Ross Valley School District
- Barbara Gaman, SDC teacher, White Hill, Ross Valley School District
- Judy Frankel, SDC classroom aide, White Hill, Ross Valley School District
- Pat Cook, school counselor, White Hill, Ross Valley School District
- Dr. Carl Baum, behavioral pediatrician; expert witness for Student, Private
- Vivian Snyder, educational therapist; conducted diagnostic educational evaluation, Private
- Ms. Jones, contacted by Dr. Baum during clinical evaluation (role not stated), Not stated
- Marin Horizons, private Montessori-based school Student previously attended, Private school
- Sterne School, private school where parents unilaterally placed Student, Private school, San Francisco
- Summer Shorts program, summer recreation program on White Hill campus, San Anselmo Recreation Department
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in San Anselmo, California, on September 30 and October 1, 1997, and, in San Rafael, California, on October 14, 1997.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his parents, FATHER and MOTHER.
Respondent Ross Valley School District (District) was represented by attorney Nancy Klein of Lozano Smith Smith Wolliver and Beherns. Also present on behalf of the District was Eugene Rich, District special education program manager.
STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify: FATHER, STUDENT’s father; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; and Dr. Carl Baum.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: Gail Benvenuta, District RSP teacher; Vivian Sherman, Marin Horizons RSP teacher; Yvonne Nolan, District RSP teacher;(footnote 1) Carolyn Taormina, District school psychologist; Eugene Rich, District special education program manager; and Barbara Gaman, District SDC teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties presented oral closing arguments at the hearing, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Is the District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at Sterne School for the 1997-1998 school year?
STIPULATIONS
At the hearing, the parties stipulated to the following: there is no disagreement as to (1) the assessments performed and (2) the goals and objectives set forth in STUDENT’s IEP.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student who qualifies for special education services because he has a specific learning disability (SLD) with a visual processing disorder and visual motor delay.
STUDENT’s educational experience has been marked by frustration and low self-esteem because of his academic struggles. Although STUDENT’s family has lived within the District boundaries since 1979, STUDENT has never been enrolled in a public school. Prior to the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT attended Marin Horizons, a private school for students in kindergarten through sixth grade which is based on the Montessori philosophy.
In December 1996 Vivian Snyder, an educational therapist, conducted a diagnostic educational evaluation of STUDENT. STUDENT was referred for this evaluation by his parents and the staff at Marin Horizons. (Dist. Exh. 12.)
In January 1997 STUDENT began seeing Dr. Baum, a behavioral pediatrician. From February 1997 to present, Dr. Baum has met with STUDENT on a weekly basis. Dr. Baum indicated that STUDENT has difficulty in visual, motor, and auditory processing. STUDENT also has social and emotional issues stemming from his learning difficulties. It is Dr. Baum’s opinion that if STUDENT is comfortable in his educational setting he will be better able to deal with his academic weaknesses.
In early 1997, Ms. Benvenuta, District RSP teacher, conducted an initial educational assessment of STUDENT. She concluded that STUDENT has a significant learning disability in written language and math computation based on visual perception and processing delays with visual-motor output. (Dist. Exh. 10.)
Ms. Taormina, District psychologist, assessed STUDENT in March 1997 and concluded that STUDENT is qualified for special education as SLD due to math and written language discrepancies with processing deficits. (Dist. Exh. 11; testimony of Ms. Taormina.)
On March 17, 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team held its first meeting, at which the reports of Ms. Benvenuta and Ms. Taormina were presented. The IEP team recommended an SDC placement at White Hill for STUDENT, and Ms. Benvenuta summarized counseling services that are available on the White Hill campus. FATHER and MOTHER submitted in writing what they believed to be STUDENT’s needs. Goals and objectives in the areas of written language, basic math, fractions, and risk taking were drafted at this meeting. FATHER and MOTHER were encouraged to visit the SDC class at White Hill. The IEP Pupil Placement Summary concludes by stating that pending placement in a Special Day Class, another meeting will take place to formalize and finalize goals and objectives. FATHER and MOTHER did not consent to this IEP. (Dist. Exh. 9.)
STUDENT’s parents observed the SDC at White Hill and were told this was the only placement the District had to offer. (Testimony of FATHER.) They observed the class for approximately one hour and were concerned by what they characterized at the hearing as a distracting environment. Their observations included multiple level tasks, multiple instructions on the board, different students doing different tasks, and some students walking around. It is their concern that the environment is too distracting for STUDENT to function well. Additionally, they are concerned that the SDC may not be stimulating enough for STUDENT. (Testimony of FATHER and MOTHER.) Neither FATHER nor MOTHER discussed these concerns with the teacher or the aide. Dr. Baum also observed the SDC at White Hill and at the hearing expressed several concerns with placing STUDENT at White Hill.
On May 14, 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team reconvened for the purpose of discussing special education services and determining an appropriate program to meet STUDENT’s needs. FATHER and MOTHER shared their concerns, including STUDENT’s distractibility, self-esteem, and physical education. Mr. Rich informed STUDENT’s parents that there were counseling opportunities at White Hill and that mental health services were available. At the conclusion of the meeting, it was decided that the team would reconvene at a later date. (Dist. Exh. 8.)
On June 27, 1997, STUDENT’s IEP team met again. This meeting culminated in the District’s final offer of placement for STUDENT for the 1997-1998 school year - placement in the SDC at White Hill with 30-39% of the day in regular education. The June IEP indicates that prevocational/vocational education and physical education would be in the regular program. This IEP document does not contain any goals and objectives. (Dist. Exh. 7.) Mr. Rich testified that this IEP was the District’s final offer of placement and is to be read in conjunction with the two previous IEP documents including the March IEP at which goals and objectives were drafted. FATHER and MOTHER did not consent to the IEP.
During the summer of 1997 STUDENT attended the Summer Shorts program run by the San Anselmo Recreation Department. The program is held on the White Hill campus and was recommended by Mr. Rich as a means for STUDENT to gain familiarity with the White Hill campus, become acquainted with other kids who would be attending White Hill in the fall, and meet some teachers from White Hill.(footnote 2) Additionally, Mr. Rich suggested “tracking” by which the parents would inform the IEP team about how the Summer Shorts program worked for STUDENT. FATHER testified that STUDENT did not want to go to summer school and that he was afraid of the Summer Shorts staff and of moving from class to class. FATHER stated that the campus was too big, there were too many students, STUDENT was scared to find his way around, and he did not feel welcome. None of these concerns were expressed to Summer Shorts staff. FATHER stated that he did not share these concerns with District staff or the IEP team, but that he did express some of these concerns at the mediation. He did not recall if he specifically stated that STUDENT was afraid of the staff and of getting lost.
STUDENT’s parents did not agree with the IEP team’s recommended placement and placed STUDENT at the Sterne School, a private school in San Francisco. Tuition for the Sterne School was not due until the first day of school. (Testimony of MOTHER.) One factor in the decision not to place STUDENT in a District school was the recommendation of STUDENT’s preschool teacher, who indicated that he would benefit from a small-class size. Based on conversations with people who had students in District schools, FATHER and MOTHER believed the District student-to-teacher ratio to be approximately 1:30. FATHER does not recall contacting the District to determine the exact student-to-teacher ratio.
STUDENT currently attends the Sterne School in San Francisco.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Is the District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at Sterne School for the 1997-1998 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(A)-(D), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that (A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; (B) meet the standards of the State educational agency; (C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the state involved; and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under § 614(d).(Footnote 3) “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child....” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).)
The term “related services” includes transportation and other services (including counseling services) that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility instruction, adapted physical education, counseling and guidance, psychological services, parent counseling and training, and social worker services. (California Education Code § 56363(b).)
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit” to the student. (458 U.S. 176, 200.)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. § 300.550; California Education Code § 56031.)
In the present case, if the District failed to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT’s parents would be entitled to reimbursement for their expense in placing STUDENT in his current placement at the Sterne School, if the latter program is appropriate. (Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts et. al. v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et. al., 471 U.S. 359, 105 S.Ct. 1996, 2003 (1985).) The Hearing Officer will analyze whether the District provided STUDENT with an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year and, if not, whether STUDENT’s parents provided an appropriate placement.
A. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year?
Taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley provide four factors for analyzing whether a local school district has substantively proposed an appropriate placement:
1. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; 2. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; 3. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment; and 4. Whether the District’s proposed placement conformed to STUDENT’s IEP.
(20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)
1. Was the District’s proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
(a) What are STUDENT’s unique needs for the 1997-1998 school year?
No one disputes that STUDENT is learning disabled with visual processing and visual motor delays. At the beginning of the hearing, the parties stipulated to the fact that they are in agreement with the results of STUDENT’s assessments. Ms. Benvenuta’s written assessment recommends that STUDENT be placed in a small group setting that is a more restrictive environment than the regular class setting and that STUDENT have counseling. (Dist. Exh. 10.) Ms. Taormina’s written assessment concludes that STUDENT would benefit from a small, supportive, structured class placement with a teacher who has specialized training and experience with students with learning disabilities.(Footnote 5) She also concludes that STUDENT would benefit from counseling to address anxiety, low self-esteem, and his tendency to turn problems inward. (Dist. Exh. 11.) Ms. Snyder’s assessment recommends that STUDENT continue with individual therapy. Ms. Snyder’s report indicates that, academically, STUDENT needs almost continual remedial help and a great deal of either one-to-one or very small group help in the class room.(Footnote 6) (Dist. Exh. 12.) Dr. Baum, a behavior pediatrician who began working with STUDENT in January 1997, testified that he agreed with the results of the assessments.(Footnote 7)
At the hearing, testimony emerged to reinforce the conclusion in Ms. Taormina’s written assessment that STUDENT’s needs include not only a small class but also a structured class. Each of the Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT is highly distracted and needs to be in a structured environment that is as free from distraction as possible. MOTHER and FATHER testified that it is hard to keep STUDENT on track. FATHER stated that STUDENT starts a lot of things but has difficulty finishing the task. MOTHER stated that he has trouble making the transition from one task to another. Additionally, Ms. Sherman, a District witness, testified about the program and class structure at Marin Horizons.(Footnote 8) She indicated that STUDENT did not function well at Marin Horizons where the students are given control over structuring their academic schedule; he becomes “overwhelmed” when he has to determine how to accomplish work on his own. Additionally, Ms. Sherman testified that STUDENT needs tasks broken down and put into steps and that he requires a lot of one-on-one attention to keep on task. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Sherman’s testimony credible, because unlike the other District witnesses Ms. Sherman worked with STUDENT for several years and has observed him in an academic setting.(Footnote 9) No evidence was produced that would contradict the contention that STUDENT needs to be in a structured environment.
To summarize, based on the testimony presented, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs for the 1997-1998 school year require that he be placed in a small, structured class with teachers knowledgeable about learning disabilities and that he has counseling.
The parties dispute whether or not the SDC at White Hill can meet these needs.
(b) What placement did the District offer for 1997-1998?
The District’s offer for STUDENT’s 1997-1998 school year placement, as memorialized in the IEP document dated June 27, 1997, stated that STUDENT would be in sixth grade in an SDC at White Hill and would be in regular classes, including prevocational/vocational education and physical education, for a total of 30-39% of the day spent in the mainstream. (Dist. Exh. 7.) This IEP does not contain any goals or objectives, indication of STUDENT’s current level of performance, or the specific special education instruction and related services required by STUDENT. Mr. Rich testified that the June IEP is to be read in conjunction with the March and May IEPs. (Dist. Exh. 8 and 9.) The March IEP contains goals and objectives along with STUDENT’s current level of performance. (Dist. Exh. 9.) However, none of the IEPs specifies what special education instruction and related services STUDENT requires. The District regards its IEP of June 27, 1997, as the final written offer of placement for STUDENT. (Testimony of Mr. Rich; Dist. Exh. 7.)
White Hill is a middle school campus with approximately 535 students enrolled. (Testimony of Ms. Nolan.) The SDC is designed for students with learning disabilities and related emotional problems; it is not for students who have needs beyond those of students with learning disabilities or who have serious conduct issues. (Testimony of Ms. Taormina.)
Overall the SDC curriculum is parallel to that of the general curriculum, which meets the state guidelines, but it contains the appropriate modifications. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman, Ms. Benvenuta, and Ms. Nolan.) The class focuses on the practical aspects of life including cooking and daily life skills as well as academics. (Testimony of Ms. Benvenuta.)
Barbara Gaman, the SDC teacher at White Hill, testified regarding her SDC for the 1997-1998 school year, the class STUDENT would be in if he were enrolled at White Hill. Currently, there are sixteen students and one aide in the class at White Hill. Ms. Gaman and the aide, Judy Frankel, have worked as a team for four years. The students in the SDC are all middle-school age ranging from approximately eleven to thirteen years of age. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman and Ms. Taormina.) However, the students’ functional levels generally range from second to eighth grade level, with one student functioning at a kindergarten level. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman.) Most of the students are functioning below grade level in two areas. (Testimony of Ms. Taormina.)
The White Hill School day consists of six periods, a morning break, and lunch.(Footnote 10) Currently, all of the SDC students are mainstreamed for some portion of the day. All of the students are mainstreamed for Homeroom, a twelve-minute period at the beginning of each day. (Dist. Exh. 16; Testimony of Ms. Gaman and Ms. Benvenuta.) Homeroom is a time when the entire student body gets school-wide announcements. Both Ms. Gaman and Ms. Benvenuta testified that if an SDC student has a day when he or she does not feel comfortable attending their regular Homeroom, he or she can go to Ms. Gaman’s room and spend the time with her. At the beginning of the year, Ms. Gaman informs her students that they can come to her room if they have had an incident in the morning they would like to talk about, if they are not feeling well, or if there is another reason they do not feel able to attend their regular Homeroom. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman and Ms. Benvenuta.) Ms. Gaman does not have Homeroom students assigned to her so that she can be available for the SDC students. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman and Ms. Benvenuta.)
All of the SDC students spend first period in Ms. Gaman’s class; none of the students are mainstreamed during first period. This period is an organizational period for Ms. Gaman’s class. She assigns the student’s homework, makes announcements, holds class meetings as needed, and talks with students about situations that may have arisen. Although homework assignments are given at the beginning of the day and the students are expected to write them down at that time, the assignments remain on the board for the entire day. Also during this period, the class participates in an oral language activity. This activity lasts approximately five minutes and is performed by the class as a whole.(Footnote 11)
After completion of the organizational portion of first period, the students move onto other work. Some students will be involved in a group activity while others will work from their individual work folders.(Footnote 12) Those in the group activities work on reading activities, including oral reading and discussion.(Footnote 13)
First period is not always spent on reading activities. Because this is the only period during which all of the SDC students are together, Ms. Gaman may schedule other activities for this time. For example, generally on the first Friday of the month, the class cooks. Other first-period activities may include having an artist or guest speaker come to the class.
For second through sixth period, there are approximately ten to twelve of the sixteen students in the SDC but not the same students at any one time; the other students are participating in the mainstream. In the SDC, the reading groups and individual folder work that started during the first period continues.
Between second and third period, there is a thirteen-minute morning break. The students can go out on the playground or go to designated areas of the school such as the library or computer room.
During third period, Ms. Gaman focuses on oral language. Generally, the whole class participates in the same activity. The lessons focus on areas such as high-level vocabulary, dictionary skills, syntax, opposites, and synonyms. During this time, the students may be asked to do some writing as a part of some lessons. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman.)
Fourth period in the SDC is spent focusing on individual work. Currently, only about four or five students remain in the class during fourth period; the rest are mainstreamed. Ms. Gaman and Ms. Frankel utilize this time for working with students on remedial skills. Additionally, the students can work on their mainstream assignments and get help from Ms. Gaman or Ms. Frankel. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman.)
Math is generally the focus of the SDC fifth period. The lessons include small group and individualized work. Ms. Gaman also may teach social studies or geography during the fifth period. If the class is involved in a large unit, the afternoon is a time it can be worked on.
Sixth period may contain lessons in the areas of history, geography, math, social studies, or remedial work. Ms. Gaman testified that fifth and sixth period assignments often are combined and that, in sixth period, students will continue what was started during fifth period.
As previously stated, STUDENT’s IEP states that he would participate in the mainstream for 30-39% of the school day. The District witnesses testified that STUDENT would be able to participate in the mainstream at a level he is comfortable with and the amount could increase or decrease as needed. (Testimony of Ms. Benvenuta, Ms. Nolan, and Ms. Taormina.) In Ms. Taormina’s opinion, STUDENT is currently ready for low-level mainstreaming such as Homeroom.
The District witnesses also testified about transition services and modifications that could be utilized. Possible transition services would include, but would not be limited to, assigning an escort or monitor to STUDENT during the beginning of his time at White Hill, reducing or limiting his homework, modifying his class tasks, or assigning STUDENT a “buddy” to assist in making sure he copied the assignments correctly.
Several District witnesses testified about the counseling services that would be available to STUDENT at White Hill. The school has a counselor, Pat Cook, who conducts both one-on-one and group counseling sessions. Students in the SDC have priority over the other students in scheduling counseling appointments. (Testimony of Ms. Taormina.) Additionally, a referral to community mental health could be made for STUDENT.(Footnote 14)
(c) Would the offered placement meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
It is the Petitioner’s position that the SDC at White Hill is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Petitioner contends that the SDC is a chaotic environment and does not have enough structure for STUDENT. Additionally, the Petitioner believes that the 30-39% mainstreaming, as called for in his IEP, is an amount too great for STUDENT to currently succeed.
All of the District’s witnesses stated that the SDC at White Hill could meet STUDENT’s needs. Several of the District witnesses testified that the goals contained in STUDENT’s IEP are common goal areas that are shared by other student’s in the SDC. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman, Ms. Nolan, and Ms. Benvenuta.)
Turning first to STUDENT’s need for a small class size, the testimony presented established that the White Hill SDC is currently a small class, with no more than sixteen students in the class at any given time. The Hearing Officer concludes that, based on the testimony, the SDC would provide STUDENT with the small class size he needs.
Next, STUDENT needs to be instructed by teachers knowledgeable in instructing students with learning disabilities. Ms. Gaman, the SDC teacher at White Hill, has been an SDC teacher for fifteen years, with an additional five years as an aide in an SDC. She has a master’s degree in education, a multi-subject credential, and a severely handicapped credential. In addition to Ms. Gaman, the SDC has an aide, Ms. Frankel, who has been working in Ms. Gaman’s class for the past four years. Based on the testimony and other evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the offered placement meets STUDENT’s need of having a teacher knowledgeable in learning disabilities.
Each of the three assessments conducted concluded that STUDENT needs counseling. Additionally, STUDENT’s parents and Dr. Baum testified about STUDENT’s low self-esteem and anxiety with school. At the hearing many District witnesses testified about the counseling services available at White Hill. However, the District’s last offer of placement does not contain any counseling services. The testimony established that the District had suggested a mental health referral to STUDENT’s parents on at least two occasions but that they had continually expressed their lack of interest in using mental health. A school district cannot escape its obligation to make a formal, written offer of placement because the student’s parents have expressed unwillingness to accept the district’s proposed placement. (Union School District v. Smith, (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F3d 1519, 1526) The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes a change of placement. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A-B).) In Smith the court stated, “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” The court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parent of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer for the appropriateness of the placement. (Smith, at 1526.) Absent counseling, the District’s written offer did not satisfy Smith and was not sufficient for STUDENT’s parents to determine whether the District was offering a placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. In this case, there is no single coherent document constituting an offer of placement. Referencing more than one document defeats the purpose of Smith, which is to provide a central focus and to make completely clear what placement is being offered.
Whether or not the District’s offer was procedurally sufficient under Smith, the District’s offer of placement does not meet STUDENT’s unique needs with regard to counseling. Therefore, the District failed to offer an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year. Finally, STUDENT needs to be educated in a structured environment for the 1997-1998 school year. The SDC consists of sixteen students who are functioning academically at varying levels from kindergarten to eighth grade. Ms. Sherman and STUDENT’s parents testified that he has trouble staying focused and that he requires a great amount of one-to-one attention to complete his work. Ms. Gaman testified about the modifications she makes to adapt the curriculum to benefit each child and about the schedule of the SDC students. On an individual level, each student has their own work folder and participates in group activities based on their functioning level. As a class, Ms. Gaman will tailor the lessons in an attempt to have it benefit each student. Ms. Gaman gave the example of silent reading where she will choose a book to read to the class. Throughout the year Ms. Gaman picks books from different reading levels to appeal to the different comprehension levels of the students. Although Ms. Gaman testified that she could modify activities and lessons to meet STUDENT’s needs, the testimony established that in effect the modifications create a distracting environment. Throughout the school day the SDC is composed of different students depending on who is participating in the mainstream at any given time. Students are frequently required to complete work from individual folders and to participate in group work during which time they may or may not be directly supervised by Ms. Gaman or Ms. Frankel. The Hearing Officer finds that the varying class schedule and activities within the SDC and the change in the students in the class each period are too distracting for STUDENT to successfully function.
Additionally, the District’s proposed placement indicates that STUDENT is to participate in the mainstream 30-39% of the school day. The Petitioner’s witnesses testified persuasively that STUDENT should not be mainstreamed at this time. A majority of the District witnesses testified that at this time STUDENT should be mainstreamed at a low level and should gradually work up to higher levels of mainstreaming. Although there is disagreement among the parties about the level of mainstreaming STUDENT should currently have, no witness testified that he is ready to spend 30-39% of his day in the mainstream as indicated in his IEP. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement lacks the structure STUDENT needs both because of the class structure and because of the percent of the day the IEP states he is to be mainstreamed.
2. Was the District’s proposed placement designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?
The evidence does not establish that the District’s proposed placement is reasonably likely to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. The SDC is a distracting environment that serves an enormous range of student needs. The SDC does not provide the structure STUDENT requires. The students in the class change each period depending on which students are mainstreaming and the SDC class schedule varies from day to day based on what lessons the students are working on. Additionally, the District’s proposed placement does not provide for counseling services which STUDENT needs. Based on the above, it is highly unlikely that STUDENT would benefit from the SDC at White Hill.
3. Was the District’s proposed placement designed to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment?
As stated above, the proposed placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs nor is there a reasonable likelihood of educational benefit. Therefore, it is not necessary to determine whether the proposed placement was in the least restrictive environment.
4. Did the District’s proposed placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
It was determined above that STUDENT’s IEP is deficient. Therefore, the inquiry into whether the proposed placement conforms to STUDENT’s IEP is not relevant here.
B. Is the Sterne School an appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year?
As a prospective placement for the 1997-1998 school year, Sterne School must satisfy the four factors outlined above. In some instances, when a school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the child’s parent has provided an alternative placement which is not the “exact proper placement,” courts have balanced the equities in determining whether the parent should be reimbursed. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, et. al., 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986).) In Alamo, the parent provided services to her child after the school district refused to provide a summer program, which was necessary to avoid regression during that period of time. The 5th Circuit court added:
The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the interim placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act.
(Alamo, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) Even giving the parents this benefit, the Petitioner has not established the legal requirements necessary for reimbursement.
Very little specific evidence was presented regarding the educational program at Sterne School. MOTHER gave some general testimony about the class size at Sterne School and about the courses STUDENT is enrolled in. Dr. Baum testified that he has observed Sterne School and has worked with some students who were placed at Sterne School and, based on those experiences, he believed the program at Sterne School would be appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Baum testified that Sterne School would be appropriate because it serves students with learning disabilities. However, there was no evidence presented regarding the specific learning disabilities served by Sterne School, the credentials of the staff, or the types of services available. No Sterne School employees were called to testify regarding the program at Sterne School.
Because there was little evidence presented regarding Sterne School, the Petitioner has failed to establish that Sterne School is an appropriate placement for STUDENT pursuant to the IDEA and Rowley.
This case leaves the parties in a position where neither the District’s proposed placement nor the parents placement is appropriate. Therefore, the District must hold an IEP meeting to produce a comprehensive placement offer that addresses all of STUDENT’s needs including a small, structured class, teachers knowledgeable in learning disabilities, and counseling.
ORDER
1. Petitioner’s claim for relief is denied.
2. Within fifteen days of the date of this order, the District will convene an IEP meeting to develop an offer of appropriate placement to meet STUDENT’s needs. The placement is to include a small structured class, teachers knowedgeable in educating students with learning disabilites, and counseling.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Is the District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at Sterne School for the 1997-1998 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: November 5, 1997 ______________________________ Jennifer Nolan Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1.Ms. Nolan is currently serving as the assistant principal at White Hill but will return to her position as an RSP teacher next semester. 2. Although Summer Shorts is not a District program, some District teachers participate in the Summer Shorts program. For example, Ms. Nolan taught STUDENT’s computer class during the Summer Shorts program. 3. Except for subsection (6), which addresses children with disabilities in adult prisons, § 614(d) of IDEA does not go into effect until July 1, 1998. 4.Ms. Benvenuta administered reading, spelling, and math computation sub-tests of the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement, and the General Information subtest of the Peabody Individual Achievement Test. 5. Ms. Taormina assessed STUDENT in early 1997 and administered the following tests: Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III); Visual Aural Digit Scan (VADS); Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test; Roberts’ Apperception Test For Children (RAT-C); Draw A Person. (Dist. Exh. 11; testimony of Ms. Taormina.) 6. Ms. Snyder’s report indicates that in addition to informal diagnostic procedures, the following tests were used: Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude, Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Cognitive Ability, Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration, Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests Revised, Slingerland Screening Tests for Identifying Children with Specific Language Disability, Key Math Diagnostic Arithmetic Test, Wide Range Achievement Test, and Test of Written Language - 2. (Dist. Exh. 12. 7. Dr. Baum conducted a clinical evaluation of STUDENT. The evaluation included approximately six to eight visits by STUDENT to Dr. Baum, STUDENT’s history as given by his parents, child interviews, a family interview, a review of Ms. Snyder’s report, and telephone conversations with Ms. Jones and STUDENT’s teacher. No formal testing instruments were used. Additionally, Dr. Baum has administered two childhood depression inventories, first in March 1997 and again in June 1997. The test consisted of a 27-item questionnaire from which STUDENT was asked to pick the responses he thought best described him. Based on the results of the test, Dr. Baum did not think STUDENT was clinically depressed. 8. Ms. Sherman described Marin Horizons. The class structure is such that there are several activities going on at any one time, small groups meet throughout the room, the rooms are generally not silent, there are generally no desks, there are tables but no assigned seats, and the students are given choices throughout the day. Each student is given a work plan that he or she fills in with lessons and follow-up assignments. The student-to-teacher ratio is approximately 12:1 in the classroom. 9.As previously stated, Ms. Nolan has also observed STUDENT in an academic setting. She was his computer teacher during the Summer Shorts program. 10.The District submitted the 1997-1998 Bell Schedule as exhibit 16. On Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday, the school day begins with Homeroom at 8:50 a.m. and ends at 3:15 with sixth grade dismissal at 3:10. On Wednesdays, the schedule indicates that the day begins with Homeroom at 8:50 and ends at 2:15 with sixth grade dismissal at 2:10. On Wednesdays, the classes are shortened to allow for dismissal an hour earlier than the rest of the week. 11.These lessons focus on skills such as punctuation and grammar. 12. The work contained in the folder is individualized based on each student’s IEP. Weekly and daily assignments are in the folder. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman.) 13. The students are grouped based on their functioning level in reading. Each group generally consists of two to four students. (Testimony of Ms. Gaman.) 14. At the IEP meeting on May 14, 1997, mental health services were discussed. FATHER and MOTHER opted not to pursue mental health services and stated that they would continue to provide their own counseling. (Dist. Exh. 8; Testimony of MOTHER.) On July 25, 1997, Mr. Rich sent a letter to FATHER and MOTHER again stating that mental health services were available. (Testimony of Mr. Rich; Dist. Exh. 2.)
