California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 26, 1999
Student v. Walnut Creek Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 927-98 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Walnut Creek Elementary must reimburse $10,173.16 for Raskob placement and provide speech and OT sessions; tutoring claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Parents of a 12-year-old with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Walnut Creek Elementary School District. He attended general education classes at Parkmead Elementary with resource and speech-language services, and his parents paid for private tutoring. For sixth grade they rejected the District's offer at Walnut Creek Intermediate and enrolled him at Raskob Learning Institute, a nonpublic school. The Hearing Officer first held that a three-year statute of limitations barred claims arising on or before June 23, 1995, including claims for compensatory education. On the merits, the District's resource and speech services produced real academic progress, and he did not qualify for extended school year services in any summer. From 1995-96 through 1998-99, however, the District never adequately addressed social skills deficits its staff knew about. Its 1998-99 counseling offer was vague and did not include the group social skills training that the parents' neuropsychologist, Dr. Richard Pollack, said he needed. The District also failed to address his motor needs and took six months to issue an occupational therapy assessment plan. Reimbursement for private tutoring was denied because the tutoring did not target the unmet social or motor needs. The District must reimburse $10,173.16 for Raskob tuition, transportation, and social skills group therapy, plus later costs on proof. It must also provide 46 speech sessions and 30 occupational therapy sessions.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated unaddressed social skills deficits as a FAPE denial even when a student made solid academic progress. It also shows that reimbursement was tied to the specific unmet needs: tutoring for needs the District already met was not reimbursed. A three-year limitations period applied to compensatory education claims.
Issues and holdings
Issue Procedural matter. Whether Petitioner may litigate FAPE for the 1994-95 school year (for compensatory education) and reimbursement for Alice Rector tutoring during 1994-95, given the three-year statute of limitations.
Under Alexopulos, a three-year limitations period applies whether the remedy sought is reimbursement or compensatory education; claims accruing on or before June 23, 1995 are barred.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1a. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE for the 1995 extended school year session (starting June 24, 1995)?
No evidence of regression with limited recoupment capacity under 5 C.C.R. § 3043; the District's suggestion of summer tutoring was not a finding that ESY was needed.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1b(i). 1995-96 school year, procedural appropriateness: failure to hold an IEP meeting within 30 days of the parent's October 23, 1995 request; no administrator at the March 14, 1996 IEP meeting; goals developed without parental input.
The late meeting and missing administrator were procedural violations, but they did not cause lost educational opportunity or seriously infringe on parent participation; parents meaningfully participated in developing goals.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1b(ii). 1995-96 school year (including 1996 ESY), substantive appropriateness: sufficiency of academic services, social skills deficits, motor difficulties, and ESY.
Resource and speech services were sufficient and gave more than de minimis benefit, and no ESY was required, but the program denied FAPE by failing to address known social and motor needs.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 1c(i). 1996-97 school year, procedural appropriateness: no regular education teacher at May 27, 1997 IEP meeting; goals adopted without parental input; untimely OT assessment plan and assessment.
Before IDEA '97 took effect, no regular education teacher was required and parents participated in setting goals, but the six-month delay in issuing an OT assessment plan after the September 1996 referral denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1c(ii). 1996-97 school year (including 1997 ESY), substantive appropriateness: sufficiency of academic services, social skills deficits, motor difficulties, and ESY.
Academic and speech services were sufficient and no ESY was required, but the District denied FAPE by failing to address social skills deficits and by not providing OT.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1d. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year, including the 1998 extended school year session?
Academic, speech and OT services gave meaningful benefit and no ESY was required, but mainstreaming, pragmatic goals and late individual counseling by an intern did not address social skills deficits.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for private tutoring with Alice Rector from June 24, 1995 through the 1997-98 school year?
Reimbursement was denied because the tutoring targeted academic needs the District met, not the social and motor needs it failed to address.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for Raskob's six-week intensive remedial program during the 1998 extended school year session?
The student was not eligible for ESY in summer 1998, and the summer program did not address the areas the District failed to address.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE to meet the student's needs for the 1998-99 school year?
The Walnut Creek Intermediate offer gave enough academic support, PE alternatives and LRE, and no ESY was needed, but it did not address social deficits: the District's assessment was inadequate and its counseling offer was vague and lacked group social skills training.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Are the program, placement and services at Raskob appropriate, and should the Raskob program (with added speech and language services) be ordered prospectively to implement the 1998-99 IEP?
Raskob met the student's unique needs, including social skills, and gave significant academic and social benefit; missing OT and speech, which the parents could not afford, did not make it inappropriate.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Should the District be ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob to implement the 1998-99 IEP and provide a consistent and coordinated program?
The student still needed speech-language therapy, so the District must provide 46 forty-minute sessions to make up for therapy missed in 1998-99.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for the Raskob program for 1998-99, including tuition, transportation, and Dr. Antoniadis' services?
Full reimbursement was ordered with no equitable reduction, given four years of unaddressed social deficits and the appropriateness of Raskob.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of the order, reimburse parents $10,173.16: $8,961.00 Raskob tuition for 1998-99, $602.16 transportation by Kid's Coach through December 1998, and $610.00 for Dr. Antoniadis' social skills training through December 16, 1998.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof, reimburse parents for Dr. Antoniadis' social skills training between December 16, 1998 and the end of the 1998-99 school year.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 days of receiving proof, reimburse parents for transportation provided between December 1998 and the end of the 1998-99 school year.
- Compensatory education. Absent written parental agreement otherwise, 46 forty-minute speech and language sessions (two per week) on the March 10, 1998 IEP goals, plus other goals the IEP team adopts. They must not cost the student school time and must be completed within one year, with transportation provided. If he returns to public school in 1999-2000, these are in addition to IEP services.
- Compensatory education. Absent written parental agreement otherwise, 30 sixty-minute occupational therapy sessions (one per week) on the March 27, 1998 OT goals prepared by Nan Arkwright, plus other goals the IEP team adopts. They must not cost the student school time and must be completed within one year, with transportation provided. If he returns to public school in 1999-2000, these are in addition to IEP services.
Total: 60.67 hours of compensatory services; $10,173.16 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; W.G. v. Target Range; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified Sch. Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg; Alamo Heights Indep. Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist.
People named in the decision
- Lorraine Ryor, director of special services, Walnut Creek Elementary School District
- Richard Pollack, Ph.D., clinical and neuropsychologist; expert witness for Student
- Brad Berman, M.D., developmental pediatrician; witness for Student
- Jack Davis, Ph.D., director / clinical director and psychologist, nonpublic school, Raskob Learning Institute
- Maria Antoniadis, Ph.D., clinical psychologist providing social skills group therapy, Raskob Learning Institute
- Sarah Harris, nonpublic school teacher, Raskob Learning Institute
- Karen Parkhurst, speech therapist, Parkmead Elementary School
- Lisa Callagy, fifth grade general education teacher, Parkmead Elementary School
- Janet Kirkpatrick, resource specialist, Parkmead Elementary School
- Joanne Rossi, Ed.D., director, Foster City Reading and Learning Institute; witness for District, Foster City Reading and Learning Institute
- Nancy Rivera, principal, Parkmead Elementary School
- Toby Hopstone, resource specialist (later Contra Costa County SELPA program specialist), Walnut Creek Intermediate School
- Kathryn DeRusso, learning center teacher, Walnut Creek Intermediate School
- Robert Goyer, school psychologist, Walnut Creek Intermediate School
- Robin Reeves, former program specialist; witness for District, Contra Costa County SELPA
- Alice Rector, private tutor, Learning Dynamics
- Martha Kentfield, school psychologist (1995 assessment), Walnut Creek Elementary School District
- Claudia Young, third grade general education teacher, Parkmead Elementary School
- Marianne Powell, registered occupational therapist (1997 assessment), Walnut Creek Elementary School District
- Lynne Childers, school psychologist (1998 triennial assessment), Walnut Creek Elementary School District
- Michael Cohen, Ph.D., school psychologist who wrote proposed social-emotional goals, Walnut Creek Intermediate School
- Mary Lovell, academic counselor, Walnut Creek Intermediate School
- Nan Arkwright, registered occupational therapist (March 27, 1998 OT goals)
- Kid's Coach, private transportation carrier
- Raskob Learning Institute, certified nonpublic school
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Pleasant Hill and Concord, California, on February 2-5, 17-18, and 22, 1999.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn Dobel from the Law Office of Kathryn E. Dobel. Also present on STUDENT's behalf were his father and mother, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Walnut Creek Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Elizabeth Estes from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District's behalf was Lorraine Ryor, the District's director of special services.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Lorraine Ryor, the District's director of special services; MOTHER; Richard Pollack, Ph.D., a clinical and neuropsychologist; Brad Berman, M.D., a developmental pediatrician; Jack Davis, the director of the Raskob Learning Institute (Raskob), the nonpublic school STUDENT currently attends; Maria Antoniadis, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist who provides social skills training at Raskob; and Sarah Harris, one of STUDENT's teachers at Raskob.
The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Karen Parkhurst, the speech therapist at Parkmead Elementary School (Parkmead); Lisa Callagy, STUDENT's fifth grade teacher at Parkmead; Janet Kirkpatrick, the resource specialist at Parkmead; Joanne Rossi, Ed.D., the director of the Foster City Reading and Learning Institute; Nancy Rivera, the principal at Parkmead; Toby Hopstone, the resource specialist at Walnut Creek Intermediate School (WCI); Kathryn DeRusso, the learning center teacher at WCI.; Robert Goyer, the school psychologist assigned to WCI.; Robin Reeves, a former program specialist for the Contra Costa County SELPA; and Lorraine Ryor, the District's director of special services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES (footnote 1)
1. Did the District offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to meet STUDENT's needs for the following school terms:
a. the 1995 extended school year session (starting June 24, 1995)? b. the 1995-96 school year, including the 1996 extended school year session? c. the 1996-97 school year, including the 1997 extended school year session? d. the 1997-98 school year, including the 1998 extended school year session?
2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring with Alice Rector which they provided to implement STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) during the summer of 1995 (starting from June 24, 1995) and for the 1995-96, 1996-97, and 1997-98 school years?
3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by the Raskob Learning Institute (Raskob) which they provided to implement STUDENT's IEP for the 1998 extended school year session?
4. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE to meet STUDENT's needs for the 1998-99 school year?
5. Are STUDENT's program, placement and services at Raskob appropriate to meet his needs, and should the Raskob program, placement and services (with the addition of speech and language services) be ordered prospectively to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP?
6. Should the District also be ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP and to provide him a consistent and coordinated program?
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with providing the Raskob program to STUDENT, including tuition, transportation, and Dr. Antoniadis' services, during the 1998-99 school year?
PROCEDURAL MATTER
In his statement of issues for hearing, Petitioner included the following two issues: (1) whether the District provided STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1994-95 school year and (2) whether the parents are entitled to reimbursement for tutoring privately provided by Alice Rector during the 1994-95 school year. On February 2, 1999, the first day of hearing, the District moved to strike these issues on the ground that Petitioner was barred from raising them by the three-year statute of limitations. Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing on June 23, 1998. Petitioner agreed that a three-year statute of limitations applies to claims brought under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) in California with respect to claims for reimbursement, and that consequently he was precluded from raising the issue of whether the parents are entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services provided prior to June 24, 1995. Petitioner argued, however, that no similar statute of limitations applies to claims seeking compensatory education and that, therefore, Petitioner was entitled to raise the issue of whether a FAPE was provided during the 1994-95 school year for compensatory education purposes.
The Hearing Officer ruled that evidence could be introduced with regard to whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 1994-95 school year, subject to a later determination of whether Petitioner was entitled to litigate this issue. (Footnote 2) The parties were ordered to include in their final briefs any further arguments or authorities they wished the Hearing Officer to consider, which they did. Having considered the parties' arguments, the Hearing Officer concludes that a three-year statute of limitations applies to Petitioner's claims irrespective of whether the remedy sought is reimbursement or compensatory education.
A three-year statute of limitations governs the filing of claims brought under the IDEA in California pursuant to Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified Sch. Dist., 817 F.2d 551, 555 (9th Cir. 1987), and the recently enacted California Education Code § 56043(p). In Alexopulos, the student alleged that the school district violated the IDEA in 1979 by not timely providing him with an appropriate education, and requested compensatory education. 817 F.2d at 553. The Ninth Circuit found that the California cause of action most analogous to the student's IDEA (footnote 3) claim was contained in Code of Civil Procedure § 338(a)(footnote 4) , which imposed a three-year statute of limitations on actions based upon a liability created by statute. Id. at 555. The Court concluded that any cause of action the student may have had accrued in 1979 when the parent knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying it and, therefore, the student was barred from bringing the claim in 1985, when the parent finally requested a due process hearing. Id.
Thus, the question of which statute of limitations governs the filing of IDEA claims seeking compensatory education in California has been conclusively answered by the Ninth Circuit. Neither of the authorities Petitioner cited mandates a contrary conclusion. (Footnote 5) Therefore, because a three-year statute of limitations applies to Petitioner's claims, including those seeking compensatory education, Petitioner is barred from raising any claims that accrued on or before June 23, 1995.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student who qualifies for special education on the basis of a specific learning disability (SLD). STUDENT has attended public schools in the District since kindergarten.
From the 1992-93 school year (STUDENT's second year in kindergarten (footnote 6)) to the 1996-97 school year (when he was in the fourth grade), STUDENT attended Parkmead. Except for the 1997-98 school year, he was enrolled in the Parkmead Active Learning School (PALS) during his years at Parkmead. The PALS program requires sixty hours of parent participation in the classroom per year.
STUDENT was first identified as a student eligible for special education and related services on February 28, 1994, when he was a first-grade student at Parkmead. The individualized education program (IEP) team concluded that he required speech and language (S/L) remediation because of difficulties he was having with expressive language. The team agreed that STUDENT needed S/L therapy to develop his expressive language skills. Since that time and until the end of the 1997-98 school year, he received S/L services from Karen Parkhurst, the District's speech therapist. Beginning February 1995 and until the end of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT also received resource specialist (RS) services from Janet Kirkpatrick to support him in reading, mathematics, and written expression. At an IEP team meeting held on May 27, 1997, occupational therapy (OT) services were added to STUDENT's program to address demonstrated fine and gross motor difficulties.
Starting with the summer of 1994 and continuing until the end of the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT's parents paid Alice Rector from Learning Dynamics to tutor STUDENT in reading, reading comprehension, and written expression. Ms. Rector tutored STUDENT for about one hour every week after school during the regular school year and for about two hours per week during the summer months.
In anticipation of the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT's IEP team held four meetings in the spring of 1998 to discuss placement options. In June 1998, the District offered STUDENT a program for the 1998-99 school year at Walnut Creek Intermediate School (WCI) in either the resource specialist program (RSP) or the learning center (LC) with two forty-minute sessions of direct S/L therapy per week, one forty-minute session of direct OT per week, and one forty-minute session of counseling by a school psychologist per week. The parents rejected this offer and enrolled STUDENT in Raskob, a certified nonpublic school that serves learning disabled children.
STUDENT attended Raskob during the summer of 1998 in its six-week intensive remedial program, and was thereafter enrolled in Raskob's day school program for the 1998-99 school year.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (footnote 7) 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c) (1991)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000 (1993). The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18) (1991)).
"Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25) (1997) (formerly 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16) (1991)). The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1991)). Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of possible related services are language and speech development and remediation, psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, parent counseling and training, health and nursing services, specially designed vocational education and career development, and counseling and guidance. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22) (1997) (former version at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(17) (1991)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b) (1983).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student's IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student's abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a "basic floor of opportunity" that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child's IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(1991)). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent's opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the hearing officer to determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been violated and to determine whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.
1. Did the District offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to meet STUDENT's needs for the following school terms:
a. the 1995 extended school year session (starting June 24, 1995)?
Petitioner contended that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by not providing him with extended school year (ESY) services during the summer of 1995. The District argued that STUDENT has never been eligible for ESY services.
ESY programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the conventional school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY services when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1988). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil's educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. The lack of clear evidence of such factors may not be used to deny an individual an extended school year program if the individualized program team determines the need for such a program and includes extended school year in the individualized education program ... .
(Italics added.)
At no time has STUDENT's IEP team determined that he needed ESY services or included the provision of ESY in his IEP. The question here is whether STUDENT needed ESY programming in the summer of 1995 because interruption of his educational programming during the summer months caused regression which, coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendered it impossible or unlikely that he could attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that otherwise could have been expected in view of his handicapping condition.
Ms. Kirkpatrick, the RS who worked with STUDENT from February 1995 to the end of the 1997-98 school year, testified that STUDENT lost a good deal of information over the summer of 1995 but was able to regain the knowledge, including knowledge of math, after reviewing the information at the beginning of the year. She testified that she had not been concerned about STUDENT losing information that summer. Ms. Parkhurst, the speech therapist who worked with STUDENT from February 1994 to the end of the 1997-98 school year, testified that she did not recommend ESY programming for the summer of 1995 because she did not think that STUDENT needed it.
MOTHER testified that, while the IEP team did not discuss STUDENT's need for ESY services during IEP meetings held on February 1, 1995, and March 14, 1995, the team was aware of and supported the fact that the family planned to provide tutoring in the summer to maintain STUDENT's progress in reading, reading comprehension and writing. According to MOTHER, District personnel had originally suggested that the family seek tutoring services to maintain STUDENT's achievement levels during the summer at a student study team (SST) meeting held in April 1994. Ms. Parkhurst, who was present at that SST meeting, testified that she suggested tutoring only in response to the parents' request for ideas for summer enrichment activities.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY services during the summer of 1995. Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst, both of whom worked with STUDENT in his areas of difficulty, testified that STUDENT did not require ESY services that summer. Further, as will be discussed later, STUDENT made significant progress during the 1995-96 school year in all areas including math, an area in which STUDENT did not receive tutoring during the summer. In short, there was no evidence that STUDENT had "limited recoupment capacity" as required by section 3043. The District's suggestion that the parents look into tutoring services for the summer did not amount to a finding or admission by the District that STUDENT required educational services during the summer. Therefore, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE in the summer of 1995 by not offering ESY services.
b. the 1995-96 school year, including the 1996 extended school year session?
i. procedural appropriateness
As noted above, one of the steps in a FAPE analysis is to determine whether the District violated any of the procedural safeguards guaranteed to students and parents by the IDEA and state special education law and, if so, whether the violations constituted a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. Petitioner alleged that the District committed three procedural errors during the 1995-96 school year: (1) the District failed to hold an IEP meeting in a timely manner following the parents' request for a meeting in a letter dated October 23, 1995, (2) the District failed to have an administrator present at the annual IEP meeting held on March 14, 1996, and (3) STUDENT's goals and objectives were developed and adopted without parental input.
With regard to Petitioner's first contention, Education Code § 56343(c) requires that an IEP meeting take place whenever the parent of a special education student requests a meeting to develop, review or revise the student's IEP. When a parent requests an IEP meeting to review an IEP, the meeting is to be held within 30 days (not counting days in July and August) from the date the school district receives the parent's written request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5 (1985). Here, through a letter to Janet Kirkpatrick dated October 23, 1995, STUDENT's mother requested that the IEP team meet to review STUDENT's IEP to ensure that the staff working with him knew the IEP goals (the letter indicated that she was concerned because STUDENT had a new teacher that year). Ms. Kirkpatrick acknowledged that she received the letter and testified that she promptly responded to other concerns MOTHER raised in the letter. The District offered no explanation as to why an IEP meeting was not convened during the 1995-96 school year until March 14, 1996. Thus, the evidence established that the District failed to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days of receipt of the parents' request for a meeting pursuant to Education Code § 56343.5. However, there was no evidence that the District's inaction in this case seriously infringed the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process or otherwise led to a denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484 ("Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. However, procedural inadequacies that ... seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE."). The parents were not seeking to develop or revise an IEP, or to review the adequacy of STUDENT's existing IEP. They simply wanted an opportunity to meet with staff to ensure that STUDENT's new teacher was aware of his goals and objectives. Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst testified that they frequently collaborated with STUDENT's classroom teacher to make sure that she was aware of the goals and objectives.
As for Petitioner's second allegation (i.e., that the District failed to have an administrator present at STUDENT's annual IEP meeting), Education Code § 56341(a) requires that a child's IEP team conduct meetings during which the child's IEP will be developed, reviewed, or revised. Subsection (b)(1) of the same section defines the IEP team as including "[a] representative other than the pupil's teacher designated by administration who may be an administrator, program specialist, or other specialist who is knowledgeable of program options appropriate for the pupil and who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, special education." There is no dispute that the IEP team intended to review STUDENT's IEP at the meeting held on March 14, 1996. In attendance at the meeting were STUDENT's RS teacher, S/L teacher, regular education classroom teacher, and mother. The signature line for the administrator was left blank on the IEP developed on March 14, 1996, and there was no evidence that any other persons attended the meeting. Furthermore, there was no evidence that any of the persons who attended the meeting represented the District's administrator for the IEP team. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to have an administrator present at the IEP meeting held on March 14, 1996, in violation of Education Code § 56341. The evidence did not establish, however, that this procedural lapse resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringed the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484. No issues arose during the meeting held on March 14, 1996, that required the special expertise of an administrator, and the District's program recommendations made at the meeting held on March 14, 1996, were the same as those made at the subsequent meeting held on May 30, 1996, at which an administrator was present.Finally, with regard to Petitioner's third contention, that the District developed and adopted goals and objectives without parental input, the IDEA and State special education law clearly envision that parents will be active and involved members of an IEP team in developing and adopting goals and objectives. See, e.g., Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(f) (1982) ("The parent shall have the right ... to participate in meetings relating to ... recommendations, and program planning."). MOTHER testified that Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst developed goals and objectives without the parents' input and presented them at the IEP meetings, and that the parents did not know that they could be involved in fashioning the goals and objectives. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she drafted goals and objectives prior to IEP meetings, but she always reviewed her proposed goals and objectives with the parents at the meetings and asked the parents whether they believed the goals and objectives were appropriate and whether they had any concerns that had not been addressed. According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, she modified a math objective reviewed at the IEP meeting held on May 30, 1996, to reflect one of the parents' suggestions. Ms. Parkhurst testified that MOTHER was a very involved mother who kept in frequent contact with school personnel and participated in making decisions about STUDENT's program and teachers. Ms. Parkhurst also testified that, like Ms. Kirkpatrick, she drafted goals and objectives prior to IEP meetings, but she always presented her proposed goals and objectives at the meetings and asked the parents whether they wished to add to or modify the proposed goals and objectives.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided the parents an equal opportunity to participate in the formulation and adoption of STUDENT's goals and objectives in compliance with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. While it is not permissible for District personnel to present a completed IEP to the parents before there has been a full discussion with the parents about the child's needs, it is entirely proper for personnel to come prepared with proposed goals and objectives if the parents are told that the proposed goals and objectives are only recommendations for review and discussion with the parents. 34 C.F.R., App. C to Part 300, Q. 55 (1993) (current version at 34 C.F.R., App. A to Part 300, Q. 32 (1999)). The uncontroverted testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst established that the parents were informed that the goals and objectives they presented at the IEP meetings were only recommendations subject to change and modification after a discussion with the parents. Further, the evidence clearly showed that the parents were full and active participants in the IEP process who contributed to the IEP formulation process. They did not argue that they would have disagreed with the proposed goals and recommendations had they been more fully informed of their right to participate in the process.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed two procedural errors during the 1995-96 school year (i.e., failed to hold an IEP meeting within thirty days of the receipt of the parents' request for a meeting and failed to have an administrator present at an IEP meeting), but that the errors did not seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the formulation of the IEP or otherwise result in a denial of a FAPE.
ii. substantive appropriateness
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District's program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's program reflected STUDENT's needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents' preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(5)(B) (1991) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) (1997)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031 (1992) (current version at Cal. Educ. Code § 56031 (1998)).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District's program for the 1995-96 school year, including the 1996 ESY, must have met the following four requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program: designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comported with his IEP, and provided in the least restrictive environment.
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The first step in the analysis, then, is to determine what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1995-96 school year, when he was in the third grade. STUDENT is a child of low average intelligence who has a number of deficits that affect his ability to learn. Martha Kentfield, a school psychologist, administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III) to STUDENT in February 1995, the semester before STUDENT's third grade year. STUDENT received a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) score of 80, a performance IQ score of 100, and a full scale IQ score of 88. Ms. Kentfield's evaluation report noted that the test results should be considered minimum estimates of STUDENT's ability because of the high level of anxiety and variable efforts STUDENT displayed during the test's administration.
During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT qualified for special education because of a documented language disability, which resulted in delays in expressive and receptive language development. He was a literal and concrete thinker who had difficulty with figurative language and abstract concepts. In the third grade, he had problems with short-term memory, and required frequent repetition and review to retain information. According to Ms. Parkhurst, STUDENT also had problems understanding and following directions, staying on topic, focusing (although he was easily redirected), giving and understanding instructions, reasoning analytically, and retaining and utilizing expressive vocabulary. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT had problems with visual-motor integration, auditory processing, and fine motor activities (i.e., it was difficult for STUDENT to write in cursive form). These deficits resulted in slow academic progress, especially in mathematics. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT's significant difficulty with mathematics was due to his weaknesses in conceptual understanding, and inability to remember new processes and to understand the abstract process of numerical computation. Achievement testing conducted in March 1995 by Ms. Kirkpatrick indicated that STUDENT was functioning academically at or slightly below grade level (second grade), but significantly below the level normally seen for his age (he was eight years and ten months old at the time). (Footnote 8) STUDENT attained the following results on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) (footnote 9) in February 1995:
Subtest By Age By Grade S.S. %ile Age Equiv. S.S %ile Grade Equiv.
Basic Reading 84 14 7-9 95 37 2.0 Reading Comprehension 80 9 7-3 88 21 1.9 Listening Comprehension 91 27 7-6 97 42 2.2 Written Expression 89 23 7-3 n/a n/a 1.2 Spelling 86 18 7-9 95 37 2.3 Mathematics Reasoning 84 14 7-3 92 30 1.9 Numerical Operations 81 10 7-6 90 25 2.0
Ms. Kirkpatrick also testified that STUDENT appeared to become less socially connected and more withdrawn from his peers over the course of his third grade year, but that he remained cooperative and did not appear unhappy. Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT did not play with his peers as much as other students and tended to isolate himself socially, but that he never acted out or misbehaved. By all accounts, he was more comfortable interacting with adults than with his peers, and was more comfortable in one-on-one situations than in large-group situations. The observations of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst were corroborated by the results of the psychological evaluation performed by Ms. Kentfield in February 1995. In her evaluation report, Ms. Kentfield stated that a screening of STUDENT's social-emotional development suggested concerns in this area but that specific issues would be addressed at the IEP meeting. Ms. Kentfield noted that STUDENT performed in the low average range on tasks which measured practical knowledge and judgment in social situations.
Having determined what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1995-96 school year, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District provided STUDENT a program that addressed those needs. During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT was placed in a regular education third grade classroom in the PALS program at Parkmead, which consisted of approximately twenty-seven students, and received RS and S/L services. From the beginning of the year to March 17, 1996, STUDENT's IEP stated that he was to receive one to two fifteen- to thirty-minute S/L therapy sessions per week for language development, and two to four twenty- to forty-minute RS sessions per week for collaborative work and small-group instruction. Beginning March 18, 1996, the IEP team agreed to increase the provision of RS services to three to five thirty- to forty-minute sessions per week; the provision of S/L services remained the same. STUDENT's goals and objectives for the 1995-96 school year were aimed at improving his skills in mathematics, reading, reading comprehension, written expression, receptive and expressive language and auditory processing, and increasing his vocabulary, semantics and ability to produce speech sounds correctly in spontaneous speech. Ms. Parkhurst and Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that they developed STUDENT's goals and objectives based on the areas of difficulty that he exhibited during testing and during their work with him.
Petitioner contended that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1995-96 school year because it (1) did not provide him with sufficient services to support him in his academic work, (2) did not address his social skills deficits, (3) did not address his motor difficulties, and (4) failed to provide him with ESY services. Each of these arguments will be addressed in turn.
To support his first argument, Petitioner argued that the District recognized its inability to provide STUDENT with sufficient services to support him in his academic work when it began including his parents and tutor as implementers on his IEPs. The Hearing Officer does not find this argument persuasive. District personnel began including the parents as implementers on STUDENT's IEPs as early as his first IEP, which was developed on February 28, 1994, and began listing the tutor (in addition to the parents and STUDENT) as an implementer on his IEP dated May 30, 1996. Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst credibly testified that the parents and tutor were listed as implementers because the IEP team sought to endorse the parents' wish that all providers work as a cohesive team in furtherance of the same goals, not because the District found that a FAPE could not be provided without the parents' and tutor's services. Further, there is no indication that the tutor was considered part of the IEP team or that the District expected any persons other than District personnel to be responsible for implementing the goals and objectives listed on STUDENT's IEP. There was little to no communication between the District's service providers and the tutor, and the tutor did not attend any IEP meetings.
Furthermore, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she believed the amount of RS services provided to STUDENT was appropriate to meet his academic needs. Ms. Kirkpatrick is a fully qualified and credentialed RS teacher who has provided services on behalf of the District since October 1992. She received a bachelor of arts degree in education in 1979 and a master's degree in education with a learning handicap specialty. She obtained a multiple subject credential in 1979, a learning handicapped credential in approximately 1983, and an RS certificate in 1993. She worked with communicatively handicapped and learning handicapped students in Stockton for eight years prior to coming to the District. Petitioner failed to present any persuasive evidence to rebut Ms. Kirkpatrick's testimony that the amount of services provided was appropriate to meet STUDENT's academic needs. Ms. Kirkpatrick (or her aide) worked with STUDENT in the areas of reading comprehension, written expression, and mathematics during his RS time. As will be discussed in detail later, STUDENT made progress in all these academic areas by the end of his third grade year. "Academic success is a helpful guidepost in determining the appropriateness of an educational setting in meeting a student's unique needs." Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 896 (9th Cir. 1995). Additionally, Ms. Parkhurst testified that the amount of S/L services provided to STUDENT was appropriate to meet his language needs. Ms. Parkhurst is a fully qualified and credentialed speech therapist who has provided services on behalf of the District for seven years. She has a bachelor of arts degree in speech and hearing and a special education credential in speech, hearing and language. Petitioner failed to present any persuasive evidence to rebut Ms. Parkhurst's testimony that the amount of services provided was appropriate to meet STUDENT's language needs. As will be discussed in detail later, STUDENT made significant progress in his language skills while working with Ms. Parkhurst. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with sufficient services to support him in his academic work.
With regard to Petitioner's second argument, that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's social skills deficits, the Hearing Officer notes that an IEP is an educational package that must target all of a student's unique educational needs, whether academic or nonacademic. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm., 998 F.2d 1083, 1089 (1st Cir. 1993). The term "unique educational needs" is to be broadly construed and includes the student's academic, social, emotional, communicative, physical, and vocational needs. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996) (citing H.R. Rep. No. 410, 1983 U.S.C.C.A.N. 2088, 2106). Thus, this requirement is not limited to deficits that directly affect a child's ability to progress academically, and academic success is not the sine qua non of "educational benefit." Id. Moreover, as noted by Joanne Rossi, Ed.D., an inability to participate in class discussions and interact normally with peers certainly does affect a child's ability to obtain educational benefit from classroom activities. Ms. Rossi noted in her report on STUDENT, which was commissioned by the District, that "STUDENT needs the practice of discussion and involvement to better test his own thinking."
The evidence established that STUDENT's ability to interact comfortably with his peers was the source of some concern for District staff during the third grade. As mentioned earlier, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT appeared to become less socially connected and more withdrawn from his peers over the course of the year, but that he remained cooperative and did not appear unhappy. Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT did not play with his peers as much as other students and that he tended to isolate himself socially, but that he never acted out or misbehaved. By all accounts, he was more comfortable interacting with adults than with his peers, and was more comfortable in one-on-one situations than in large-group situations. The psychological evaluation performed by Ms. Kentfield in February 1995 suggested concerns in the social-emotional area, although the nature and extent of any concerns were not documented in her report. Additionally, a review of documents contained in STUDENT's school file reveals that the social deficits he exhibited during his third grade year were merely part of a slow decline in social interaction that he began experiencing as early as the first grade. For example, his first grade teacher noted on a form entitled a "Concerns Checklist" that STUDENT had difficulty with peer relationships and tended to isolate himself during group activities in the classroom. Finally, even Nancy Rivera, the principal at Parkmead who attended a number of STUDENT's IEP meetings and spoke with the parents about two to three times per year, testified that she had concerns about STUDENT's social-emotional development and believed he needed the support of counseling.
The evidence also established that STUDENT's IEP did not specifically address any social issues, except to the extent that the IEP provided for mainstreaming in the regular education third grade classroom. The import of the mainstream placement for a child who has difficulty interacting with his peers cannot be ignored when judging the program's overall adequacy and appropriateness. Lenn, 998 F.2d at 1090 n7. A child may obtain unique benefits from integration in a regular classroom, such as the development of social and communication skills from interaction with nondisabled peers, which cannot be achieved in a segregated environment. Oberti v. Bd. of Educ. of the Borough of Clementon Sch. Dist., 995 F.2d 1204, 1216 (3d Cir. 1993). However, there was no evidence that STUDENT's social and communication skills were improved by mainstreaming alone. No other formal attempts were made to address STUDENT's social difficulties, although there was evidence that Ms. Kirkpatrick and Claudia Young, STUDENT's third grade classroom teacher, made informal attempts to help STUDENT overcome some of his social problems. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she attempted to initiate or have STUDENT initiate interactions with his peers on occasion during the year. Ms. Kirkpatrick also testified that she knew from conversations with Claudia Young, STUDENT's third grade teacher, that Ms. Young was aware of and sensitive to STUDENT's social-emotional needs and that she observed Ms. Young counsel STUDENT on the appropriateness or inappropriateness of his behavior with others on a number of occasions. For example, STUDENT once shaped his hand to simulate a gun and pointed it at some fellow classmates in a playful manner. Ms. Young pulled STUDENT aside and informed him that his classmates might not see his gesture as friendly. Additionally, during the year, Ms. Young forwarded to the parents a permission slip for counseling that was available to all students, including regular education students. The parents did not return the permission slip and STUDENT did not receive any counseling that year.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to fashion an IEP that adequately addressed STUDENT's social needs during the 1995-96 school year. The staff working with STUDENT were fully aware that he had social deficits that affected his ability to interact with peers and participate in group discussions. Further, a psychological evaluation by the District's school psychologist performed in February 1995, which was available to the IEP team when it developed STUDENT's IEP for the 1995-96 school year, found that there were deficits in STUDENT's social-emotional development. Although there was evidence that the IEP team discussed the report at the following IEP meeting and specifically discussed Ms. Kentfield's social-emotional concerns, the District took no action to address those concerns in the IEP it developed for the 1995-96 school year. No services were offered and no goals and objectives were formulated to address STUDENT's social needs. While STUDENT was placed in a mainstream environment, mainstreaming alone was not sufficient to address the social skills deficits that STUDENT displayed during the 1995-96 school year. Further, all of the school staff working closely with STUDENT realized that he had difficulty interacting with his peers and yet nothing was done to address the problem, apart from some informal attempts by Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Young. While it is encouraging to note that school personnel acted on their own initiative to help STUDENT in this regard, there was no evidence that either Ms. Kirkpatrick or Ms. Young was qualified to appropriately remediate social skills deficits in children such as STUDENT, or that the techniques they utilized with STUDENT were appropriate.
The District's attempt to portray STUDENT as merely shy and reserved in nature was undermined by the testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick, who noticed a decline in STUDENT's ability to interact with his peers through the years she worked with him. Additionally, MOTHER testified that STUDENT interacted normally with his peers in the community and that concerns about his social development were raised only in relation to school. MOTHER also testified that STUDENT was quite anxious about school and his ability to perform in class, an observation that was corroborated by Richard Pollack, Ph.D. Dr. Pollack is a licensed clinical and neuropsychologist who assessed STUDENT in January 1997 at the parents' request. Dr. Pollack testified that the nature and extent of STUDENT's learning deficits created undue pressure on him to perform in the classroom like other students and contributed to his social-emotional problems, making him more anxious and socially withdrawn as the curriculum became more difficult.
The District's argument that it met its obligation by offering general education counseling (which was rejected by the parents) is not persuasive. There was no evidence that an appropriate social skills group was available in which STUDENT could have participated and, as discussed below, there was no persuasive evidence that individual counseling would have been appropriate to address STUDENT's social skills deficits. Additionally, general education counseling was not included as part of STUDENT's IEP, nor was it provided during the 1995-96 school year. District personnel, as educational professionals trained and experienced in providing educational services, are entrusted to use their expertise and judgment to fashion an appropriate education for a disabled child. While parental input is an indispensable factor in determining the appropriate services to provide to a child, a school district cannot use the parents' refusal to excuse it from providing a service that is necessary to the provision of a FAPE. Education Code § 56346(b) requires school districts to seek administrative resolution if parents do not agree with a proposed service where the service is necessary to provide a child a FAPE. Section 56346(b) states:
If the district ... determines that the part of the proposed special education program to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a free and appropriate public education to the pupil, a due process hearing shall be initiated ..., unless a prehearing mediation conference is held.
Therefore, the District's informal offer of counseling services cannot wholly excuse its failure to provide any services to address STUDENT's social needs during the 1995-96 school year.
Petitioner's third argument, that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE because it did not provide him with occupational therapy, is subject to the same principles that applied to his social needs. As mentioned earlier, an IEP must target all of a student's unique educational needs, both academic and nonacademic, including the student's academic, social, emotional, communicative, physical, and vocational needs. Seattle Sch. Dist., 82 F.3d at 1500; Lenn, 998 F.2d at 1089. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that during the 1995-96 school year STUDENT had difficulty with fine motor activities, especially cursive writing. The IEP team discussed STUDENT's possible occupational therapy (OT) needs during the IEP meetings held in the spring of 1996, but the team took no further actions to explore STUDENT's needs in this area. Additionally, Ms. Kentfield's testing in February 1995 suggested that STUDENT had delays in fine-motor coordination. Despite these indications, the IEP failed to address the problem with fine motor coordination either through accommodations and modifications, goals and objectives, or the provision of services. It is difficult to determine, however, the extent of STUDENT's fine-motor delays during the 1995-96 school year, since a formal and thorough evaluation was not conducted to gauge the nature and extent of his motor delays during that year. Ms. Kentfield's evaluation provided very little useful information in this regard. Moreover, no further testing was performed by any District personnel until Ms. Kirkpatrick filled out an OT screening form on September 20, 1996, and an evaluation was conducted by an occupational therapist in April 1997. Marianne Powell, a registered occupational therapist, evaluated STUDENT on behalf of the District on four separate dates in April 1997. She concluded that STUDENT seemed to be experiencing delays in the foundations of motor development, including reflex development, postural and ocular mechanisms, balance, muscle strength and coordination, and motor planning. She found that he was delayed in gross and fine motor skills, including visual-motor control, and that writing was difficult for him. Based on the foregoing, it is clear that the District should have assessed STUDENT earlier to determine the nature and extent of his fine and gross motor difficulties, and that the IEP should have addressed his motor difficulties.
Finally, with regard to Petitioner's fourth argument, that the District erred when it failed to provide STUDENT with ESY services during the summer of 1996, the Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team did not determine that STUDENT needed ESY services during the summer of 1996, nor was ESY included in his IEP. The question is whether STUDENT needed ESY programming in the summer of 1996 pursuant to the standard set forth in Section 3043, Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she realized at the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, when she was reviewing concepts with STUDENT, that he had been able to retain a significant amount of information over the summer of 1996. According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, STUDENT had difficulty recalling some math processes, but remembered the touch math strategy she had taught him and was able to recall the rest after a brief review at the beginning of the year. According to MOTHER, the parents paid Ms. Rector to tutor STUDENT two times per week during the summer of 1996 because they wanted to prevent him from losing any of the progress he had made thus far. MOTHER testified that the IEP team did not recommend that the parents provide tutoring to STUDENT during the summer, but they supported the parents' decision to do so and provided the parents with materials to use during the tutoring. The tutor focused on reading, writing and reading comprehension, but did not work on mathematics. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY services during the summer of 1996. There was no evidence that STUDENT had "limited recoupment capacity" as required by section 3043. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT was able to remember lessons that he had forgotten during the summer after a brief review at the beginning of the year and that this was true even with mathematics, an area that the tutor did not work on with him during the summer. Therefore, the District was not obligated to offer or provide STUDENT with ESY services during the summer of 1996.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program for the 1995-96 school year was not designed to meet all STUDENT's unique educational needs because it failed to address his social and motor needs. The evidence established, however, that the District provided STUDENT with sufficient RS and S/L services to support him academically and was not obligated to provide ESY services.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District's proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of "some" benefit. Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional Sch. Dist., 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996). Of course, a child's academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child's potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).
There is little question that STUDENT gained some educational benefit from his program during the 1995-96 school year. Even MOTHER acknowledged during her testimony that STUDENT made some growth and progress as a result of the RS and S/L services provided by Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst. The question, then, is whether STUDENT obtained more than de minimis benefit or made more than trivial advancement during the 1995-96 school year. Progress may be measured in a number of ways. Reference to standardized test scores, grades, progress on goals and objectives, and teacher observation may all be used to determine progress.
During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT received passing marks from his classroom teacher and met the majority of his goals and objectives. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that he had made substantial progress by the end of the year: he had learned how to use touch math (a strategy for addition and subtraction), could identify some specific math language, was able to regroup with manipulatives, had progressed in his ability to decode, and had advanced his writing skills (could consistently write sentences to convey a complete thought). The evidence established that STUDENT passed almost all of the math, reading, and writing goals and objectives contained in his IEP dated March 14, 1995. By the end of the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT had met the following goals and objectives in these areas: read/decode independently at the mid-third grade level with ninety percent accuracy (he did not pass the portion of the objective that called for independently comprehending at the mid-third grade level); read the Dolch sight words through the third grade level with eighty percent accuracy (he was able to do this with ninety-eight percent accuracy); using an ending-second grade reading text, be able to use context cues, put details in sequence, locate information, determine the main idea, and draw conclusions with eighty percent accuracy; add and subtract two digit numbers with regrouping with eighty percent accuracy; identify the language for addition, subtraction, and multiplication in word problems at a third grade level at eighty percent accuracy; develop and use a strategy for computing addition and subtraction (e.g., touch math) at eighty percent accuracy (he was not able to do this with multiplication); write one symbol or combination of symbols for each sound presented orally with ninety-five percent accuracy; and spell Dolch words through the second grade level with eighty percent accuracy.
During most of the 1995-96 school year, Ms. Parkhurst worked with STUDENT on goals and objectives listed in his IEP dated February 1, 1995. Ms. Parkhurst testified that by March 1996 STUDENT met all four of his objectives to improve speech sounds in spontaneous speech (produce the /th/ sound in the initial, middle & final position of words with ninety percent accuracy; produce the /th/ sound in phrases and short sentences with ninety percent accuracy; produce the /th/ sound in speaking situations with ninety percent accuracy; and produce the /th/ sound in spontaneous speech with ninety percent accuracy); met five of his objectives to increase vocabulary and semantics (name the group to which two or more words belong with eighty percent accuracy; name words associated with a given topic with eighty percent accuracy; state the opposite of a given word with eighty percent accuracy; use a synonym for a given word with eighty percent accuracy; and explain the meaning of some popular idioms with eighty percent accuracy); and partially met two other objectives to increase vocabulary and semantics (give two meanings for multiple meaning words with eighty percent accuracy; and retell a story read by the teacher, state the main idea, and answer questions with seventy percent accuracy). Ms. Parkhurst further testified that by May 1996 STUDENT had passed most of his goals and objectives: his vocabulary was increased; he could identify words and phrases in response to who, what, why and where questions; he could put words into the correct categories; and he was able to give two meanings for words that have multiple meanings.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT obtained educational benefit from his educational program during the 1995-96 school year, and that the progress constituted more than de minimis benefit or trivial advancement. The level of progress was established by teacher observations and progress on goals and objectives. Although it is difficult to determine the extent to which the private tutoring STUDENT's parents provided him through Ms. Rector contributed to the progress he made during the year, there was progress in areas in which Ms. Rector did not provide any instruction. Thus, there was evidence of educational benefit due solely to the efforts of District personnel.
Comport With the IEP
Petitioner contended that the RS services listed on STUDENT's IEP were not provided near the beginning of the year. MOTHER testified that, near the beginning of the year, STUDENT told her that he had not been receiving RS services and that she called Ms. Kirkpatrick to inquire. According to MOTHER, Ms. Kirkpatrick told her that she was at Parkmead only four days per week and that STUDENT was not a priority because she knew he had a tutor. During her testimony, Ms. Kirkpatrick denied making the statement and testified that STUDENT received the RS services listed on his IEP throughout the year. She testified that the RS services were provided exclusively in the regular education classroom during the first part of the year (Ms. Kirkpatrick either worked with STUDENT during classroom activities or pulled him to a table by himself for one-on-one instruction), but thereafter STUDENT was sometimes pulled out of his classroom and taken to the RS room for services. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she worked with STUDENT during the following times during the 1995-96 school year: from 9:30 a.m. to 10:00 a.m. on Mondays for the writer's workshop; half an hour between 8:30 a.m. and 9:30 a.m. on Wednesdays for writing instruction; from 8:30 a.m. to 9:30 a.m. on Thursdays for reading instruction; and from 11:00 a.m. to 11:30 a.m. for mathematics instruction.
In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's provision of services during the 1995-96 school year complied with the IEP. Ms. Kirkpatrick credibly testified that she provided STUDENT with the amount of services listed on his IEP during all times of the school year. STUDENT's comment to his mother that he was not receiving RS services may have simply been confusion on his part because he was not being pulled out of the classroom and instructed in the RS room. However, nothing in STUDENT's IEP mandates that the RS services must be provided in the RS room. Further, the fixed schedule Ms. Kirkpatrick had for working with STUDENT satisfied the mandates of the IEP.
Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment
The District's provision of services in the least restrictive environment was not at issue in this case. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT was mainstreamed in a regular education third grade classroom with services to support his academic and language needs. There is no question that this was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT given his unique needs.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed two procedural errors during the course of the 1995-96 school year, but that the errors did not result in the denial of a FAPE. Additionally, the evidence established that the program the District provided to STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year provided him with educational benefit, comported with the IEP, and occurred in the least restrictive environment, and that STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summer of 1996. The program was not, however, designed to address all STUDENT's unique educational needs because it failed to address his social and motor needs. Thus, the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year to the extent that its program was not designed to address his social and motor needs.
c. the 1996-97 school year, including the 1997 extended school year session?
i. procedural appropriateness
Petitioner contended that the District committed procedural errors during the 1996-97 school year by (1) failing to have STUDENT's regular education classroom teacher present at the IEP meeting held on May 27, 1997, (2) adopting goals and objectives without parental input, and (3) not developing an OT assessment plan or conducting an OT assessment in a timely manner.
With regard to Petitioner's first argument, as noted earlier, Education Code § 56341(a) requires that a child's IEP team conduct meetings during which the child's IEP will be developed, reviewed, or revised. The IEP team must include the following person:
The pupil's present teacher. If the pupil does not presently have a teacher, this representative shall be the teacher with the most recent and complete knowledge of the pupil who has also observed the pupil's educational performance in an appropriate setting. If no teacher is available, this representative shall be a regular classroom teacher referring the pupil, or a special education teacher qualified to teach a pupil of his or her age.
Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2) (1982).
The following persons were present at the IEP meeting held on May 27, 1997: STUDENT's parents, Ms. Rivera (principal), Ms. Kirkpatrick (RS teacher), Ms. Parkhurst (speech therapist), and Marianne Powell (occupational therapist). Either Ms. Kirkpatrick or Ms. Parkhurst qualified as the "teacher" required to be present at the IEP meeting since they both taught him. Education Code § 56341 does not require that a regular education classroom teacher be present at the meeting. Further, this interpretation is supported by the federal regulations implementing the IDEA. Note 1 to former Section 300.344 of the Code of Federal Regulation, which was effective in May 1997, stated that the teacher required to be part of the IEP team could be the child's special education teacher if the child is receiving special education, or the child's speech-language pathologist if the child's disability is a speech impairment. Petitioner did not present any authority in effect on May 27, 1997, and the Hearing Officer is not aware of any, that required that the IEP team include a regular education classroom teacher. (Footnote 10) In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate Petitioner's procedural rights by not having STUDENT's regular education classroom teacher present at the IEP meeting held on May 27, 1997.
Petitioner's second argument, that the District developed and adopted goals and objectives without parental input, is not persuasive for the same reasons that were detailed during the discussion of the 1995-96 school year. No evidence unique to the 1996-97 school year was presented on this issue. For the same reasons noted earlier, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided the parents an adequate opportunity to participate in the formulation and adoption of STUDENT's goals and objectives during the 1996-97 school year.
With regard to Petitioner's third argument, that the District did not timely develop an OT assessment plan or conduct the OT assessment, the Hearing Officer notes that state special education law sets forth strict requirements about when these events are supposed to occur. Education Code § 56321(a) states that a proposed assessment plan must be given to parents within fifteen days of receipt of a referral for assessment (not counting days between the student's regular school sessions or terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays) whenever an assessment is to be conducted for development or revision of the IEP, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. Here, Ms. Kirkpatrick referred STUDENT for an OT assessment on September 20, 1996, by filling out a form entitled "Screening for Occupational Therapy Referral." An assessment plan was not developed until March 20, 1997, a full six months after the referral. This was clearly beyond the fifteen-day interval required by Section 56321. No explanation was offered by the District as to why there was such an unusually long delay between the time of the referral and the date of the assessment plan. The assessment that was eventually conducted by the District in April 1997 resulted in a recommendation of sixty minutes of OT services per week, which was adopted by the IEP team on May 27, 1997, for implementation at the beginning of the 1997-98 school year. Thus, this procedural violation clearly resulted in the loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT in accordance with W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484, because it resulted in about a six-month delay in receiving OT services.
As for the assessment itself, Education Code § 56344 requires that an assessment be completed and an IEP be developed (which requires a meeting of the IEP team) within fifty days of the school district's receipt of the parent's consent for assessment (not counting days between the student's regular school sessions or terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays), unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. Here, MOTHER signed the assessment plan for the OT assessment on March 20, 1997. The assessment was conducted on April 2, 14, and 16, 1997, and the assessment report was dated May 12, 1997. The IEP team met to review the results of the assessment and revise STUDENT's IEP in accordance with the occupational therapist's recommendation on May 27, 1997. Thus, approximately sixty-eight days passed between MOTHER giving consent for the assessment and revision of the IEP. There was no evidence presented as to when the District received MOTHER's consent to conduct the assessment or if there were any intervening days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays. Regardless, this was a de minimis violation.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE with regard to his OT needs because it failed to timely develop an assessment plan in response to the referral for an OT assessment, which resulted in an approximately six-month loss of services.
ii. substantive appropriateness
As noted earlier, the District's program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs, reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comported with his IEP, and provided in the least restrictive environment.
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The first step in the analysis is to determine what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1996-97 school year, when he was in the fourth grade. While some of the needs discussed in relation to the 1995-96 school year continued to be needs for STUDENT in the 1996-97 school year, there were some new developments, such as increased difficulty with social situations. For example, STUDENT had one friend in his class at the beginning of the 1996-97 school year. MOTHER testified that this friendship did not last throughout the year, however, and that social situations became increasingly more difficult for STUDENT as the year progressed. Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT became more reserved during this year (i.e., he spent more time by himself in the halls). According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, STUDENT did participate in classroom activities during the 1996-97 school year, although overall he was more reserved and socially isolated than he had been during the previous year. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that the following description of STUDENT's emotional functioning presented an adequate picture of STUDENT at the time:
It appears that STUDENT is concerned about issues of adequacy and probably feels best in situations where [he] has an internal sense of mastery. He wants to feel proud of himself and is working hard to achieve this feeling. However, he seems to be experiencing some anxiety about his performance. ... There is some evidence that the anxiety is becoming increasingly pervasive. Some of his responses suggest that his difficulty with short term memory may be involved. That is, he becomes anxious because he knows he should be able to remember things he cannot: Unfortunately, this seems to be contributing to an increasing fear that there is something inadequate about him. As a result he feels vulnerable and afraid of each new situation. ... Interpersonal situations appear to be difficult for him. For reasons which aren't clear, he seems to have some difficulty understanding how others think, feel and behave. The testing suggests that this is a part of his characterological functioning. ... He needs some prompt in this area, without it he is likely to have increasing problems in the future.
(This description was contained in Dr. Pollack assessment report dated January 20, 1997.)
As noted earlier, Ms. Kirkpatrick filled out an OT referral for STUDENT near the beginning of the year. She testified that it was because STUDENT exhibited some awkwardness while running and was not able to manipulate a ball very well. The OT assessment that was finally performed in April 1997 found that STUDENT had significant fine and gross motor delays. The assessor found that STUDENT had difficulty with all the gross motor tasks such as running, balancing, jumping, and throwing and catching balls. STUDENT scored at the tenth percentile for fine motor skills on the Bruininks Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency, and at an age equivalent of seven years five months on the Beery Visual Motor Integration Test (STUDENT was eleven years old at the time). The assessor concluded that STUDENT had delays in such areas as reflex development, postural and ocular mechanisms, balance, muscle strength, coordination, and motor planning.
Having determined what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1996-97 school year, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District provided STUDENT a program that addressed those needs. During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was placed in a regular education mixed fourth and fifth grade classroom in the PALS program (Level 3) at Parkmead and received RS and S/L services. (Footnote 11) STUDENT's IEP dated May 30, 1996, stated that he was to receive three to five fifteen- to forty-five-minute RS sessions per week (a minimum of one hundred thirty-five minutes per week) to work on the core curriculum, with remedial materials as needed, and one to two fifteen- to thirty-minute S/L sessions per week to work on expressive and receptive language skills. However, the amount of services was increased at the beginning of the school year (through an IEP dated October 3, 1996) to three individual RS sessions per week for a total of one hundred thirty-five minutes, and two thirty-minute S/L sessions per week. STUDENT's goals and objectives for the 1996-97 school year were aimed at improving his skills in mathematics, reading comprehension, written expression, receptive and expressive language, semantics, and syntax. Ms. Parkhurst and Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that they developed STUDENT's goals and objectives based on the areas of difficulty he exhibited during testing and during their work with him.
Petitioner contended that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1996-97 school year because it (1) did not provide him with sufficient services to support him in his academic work, (2) failed to address his social skills deficits, (3) failed to address his motor difficulties, and (4) did not provide him with ESY services.
Some of the discussion in the section dealing with the 1995-96 school year applies equally to Petitioner's first contention for the 1996-97 school year, especially with regard to the argument involving the parents and the tutor being listed as implementers on STUDENT's IEPs. Further, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she believed the amount of RS services provided to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year was appropriate to meet his academic needs, and Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut Ms. Kirkpatrick's testimony. Ms. Kirkpatrick's work with STUDENT focused on written expression and mathematics. As will be discussed in detail later, STUDENT made progress in both of these areas by the end of his fourth grade year. Additionally, Ms. Parkhurst testified that she believed the amount of S/L services provided to STUDENT was appropriate to meet his language needs, and Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut this testimony. As will be discussed in detail later, STUDENT made significant progress in his language skills during the 1996-97 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with sufficient services to support him in his academic work.
With regard to Petitioner's second argument, that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's social skills deficits, the evidence clearly established that the school staff was fully aware that STUDENT had problems socializing with his peers during the 1996-97 school year. MOTHER testified that school staff reported that STUDENT was not participating in class at the IEP meeting held on October 3, 1996. As a result, the IEP team briefly discussed STUDENT's social skills and the possibility of counseling at the meeting, but no goals and objectives were formulated to address any social concerns and no specific information was provided as to how counseling might be provided. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she told the IEP team at that meeting that she was concerned because STUDENT was not engaging in play with other children on the playground. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she agreed with MOTHER that the 1996-97 school year was more difficult for STUDENT socially. There were more group activities during class, and STUDENT became more reserved and socially withdrawn during the year. According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, at least one of STUDENT's teachers was also aware that group activities were difficult for STUDENT. Moreover, there is no dispute that STUDENT's IEP did not specifically address any social issues. STUDENT was mainstreamed in a regular education fourth grade classroom, but, as with the 1995-96 school year, there was no evidence that the mainstreaming was sufficient by itself to address STUDENT's social skills deficits or that it provided any tangible benefit in this area.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to fashion an IEP that adequately addressed STUDENT's social needs during the 1996-97 school year. While STUDENT was placed in a mainstream environment, mainstreaming was not sufficient to address the social skills deficits that STUDENT experienced during the 1996-97 school year. As with the 1995-96 school year, general education counseling was not included as part of his IEP, nor was it provided during the 1996-97 school year. An informal offer of counseling may not serve to remedy the District's failure to address STUDENT's social needs through his IEP or to provide services to address his social needs during the 1996-97 school year. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b) (1994). Moreover, there was no evidence that an appropriate social skills group existed at the time in which STUDENT could have participated, and, as will be discussed later, there was no persuasive evidence that individual counseling would have been appropriate to address STUDENT's social delays.
Petitioner's third argument (i.e., that the District failed to address STUDENT's motor difficulties during the 1996-97 school year) was clearly supported by the evidence. As noted earlier, Ms. Kirkpatrick made an OT referral in September 1996 because of demonstrated gross motor difficulties. The OT assessment performed in April 1997 found significant gross and fine motor delays that qualified STUDENT for OT services. OT services, however, were not provided until the 1997-98 school year because of a lengthy unexplained lapse of time between the time of the referral and the assessment. Although the District was aware of STUDENT's motor difficulties, these needs were not addressed through his IEP by way of OT services, the formulation of goals and objectives, or accommodations and modifications until the 1997-98 school year. Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's motor needs during the 1996-97 school year.
Finally, with regard to Petitioner's fourth argument, that the District erred when it failed to provide STUDENT with ESY services during the summer of 1997, the Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team did not determine that STUDENT needed ESY services during the summer of 1997, nor was ESY included in his IEP. The question is whether STUDENT needed ESY programming in the summer of 1997 because interruption of his educational programming during the summer months caused regression which, coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendered it impossible or unlikely that he could attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that otherwise could have been expected in view of his handicapping condition. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1988). Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that, as with the previous summers, STUDENT forgot some lessons over the summer of 1997 but he was able to remember the lessons after a review at the beginning of the year, even in math. Ms. Parkhurst testified that, although STUDENT did forget some vocabulary over the summer of 1997, she did not think STUDENT lost a significant amount of information over the summer (no more than any of the other students forgot) and that he was able to regain the lost information shortly after the beginning of the school year. According to MOTHER, the parents provided two one-hour tutoring sessions per week by Ms. Rector so that STUDENT could maintain his level of progress in reading, reading comprehension, and written expression. MOTHER testified that the IEP team did not recommend that the parents provide tutoring to STUDENT during the summer, but they supported the parents' decision to do so and provided the parents with materials to use during the tutoring.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY services during the summer of 1997. There was no evidence that STUDENT had "limited recoupment capacity" as required by section 3043. Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT was able to remember lessons that he had forgotten during the summer after a brief review at the beginning of the year and that this was true even with mathematics, an area that the tutor did not work on during the summer. Therefore, the District was not obligated to offer or provide STUDENT with ESY services during the summer of 1997.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program the District provided STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year was not designed to address all his unique educational needs because it failed to address his social and motor needs. The evidence established, however, that the District provided STUDENT with sufficient RS and S/L services to support him academically and was not obligated to provide him with ESY services.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The evidence established that STUDENT gained some educational benefit from his program during the 1996-97 school year and that the benefit was more than de minimis. This was established by teachers' observations, his progress on goals and objectives, and the results of standardized testing.
During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT met most of his goals and objectives. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that he had made significant progress by the end of the year: he had a good grasp of base ten concepts (he could demonstrate it with the use of manipulatives and could explain it in words); he knew the multiplication facts through sevens and eights, and was able to perform well on timed tests with the rest of the class; he could identify the language for addition, subtraction, and multiplication in word problems; he participated in classroom activities with some success; and he could correct subtract (with trading) numbers containing up to three digits. STUDENT passed some of the goals and objectives for RS contained in his IEP dated May 30, 1996. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that by March 1997 STUDENT had passed his reading comprehension goal (answer comprehension questions about a fourth grade passage read orally or silently with eighty-five percent accuracy), except with regard to inferential-thinking questions. STUDENT had also passed his written expression objective to write three to five connected sentences with complete ideas, main ideas, and appropriate supporting details. STUDENT had not, however, wholly passed his math objective to produce multiplication, addition, and subtraction facts zero to ten with eighty-five percent accuracy. According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, he could produce multiplication facts zero to ten with eighty-five percent accuracy and do addition and subtraction (with trading) with eighty-five percent accuracy.
Formal testing by Ms. Parkhurst in March 1998, which was part of STUDENT's triennial assessment, showed that STUDENT's language skills had improved in virtually all areas since 1996 to the extent that he no longer qualified as a speech impaired student. (Footnote 12)Ms. Parkhurst testified that the results showed that STUDENT had made very good progress in all areas; all scores were in the normal range for expressive and receptive language, and semantics (results which STUDENT had never before been able to achieve); and his linguistic knowledge had increased. For example, STUDENT's scores on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamental - III (CELF-3), a measure that tests receptive and expressive language (including semantics, morphology, syntax, and memory), were in the mildly delayed to normal range. A comparison of STUDENT's scores on the CELF-3 in 1998 with his scores on the CELF-Revised (CELF-R) in February 1996 shows significant improvement in both receptive and expressive language:
S.S. 1996 %ile Rank S.S. 1998 %ile Rank Total Language Score 72 3 87 19 Receptive Language Score 76 5 86 18 Expressive Language Score 72 3 90 25
On the Test of Problem Solving (TOPS), STUDENT scored in the normal range, a substantial improvement from the scores he achieved in March 1996, as the following comparison illustrates:
Subtests S.S. 1996 %ile Rank S.S. 1998 %ile Rank Explaining Inferences 38 1 51 51 Determining Causes 51 55 54 75 Negative Why Questions 32 1 50 46 Determining Solutions 42 9 55 81 Avoiding Problems 55 82 53 72 Total Test Score 42 6 53 71
His 1998 scores on the SCAN (a screening test for central auditory processing) were appropriate for his age, a dramatic improvement from the scores he obtained in about May 1996:
Subtests S.S. 1996 %ile Rank S.S. 1998 %ile Rank Filtered Words 7 16 14 91 Auditory Figure Ground 5 5 12 75 Competing Words 4 2 8 25 SCAN Composite 69 2 101 53
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT obtained educational benefit from his educational program during the 1996-97 school year and that the progress constituted more than de minimis benefit or trivial advancement. As with the 1995-96 school year, it is difficult to determine the extent to which the private tutoring STUDENT's parents provided him through Ms. Rector contributed to the progress he made during the year. However, there was demonstrated progress in areas in which Ms. Rector did not provide any instruction, which evidenced that STUDENT obtained at least some educational benefit due solely to the efforts of District personnel.
Comport With the IEP
The testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst established that they provided services to STUDENT as they were required to under his IEP. For example, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she worked with STUDENT on an individual basis three times per week for forty-five minutes (for a total of one hundred thirty-five minutes). She worked with STUDENT one time per week on Mondays during his writing period and twice per week on math, as well as collaborated with his classroom teacher. According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, STUDENT also received some assistance while in the regular education classroom from either her or her aide. Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut the testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst that the IEP was properly implemented. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a program during the 1996-97 school year that comported with his IEP.
Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment
The District's provision of services in the least restrictive environment was not at issue in this case. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT was mainstreamed in a regular education fourth grade classroom with services to support his academic and language needs. There is no question that this was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT given his unique needs.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural error during the course of the 1996-97 school year that denied STUDENT a FAPE with regard to his OT needs. The District failed to timely develop an assessment plan in response to a referral for an OT assessment, which resulted in an approximate six-month delay in the provision of OT services. The evidence established that the program that the District provided to STUDENT during the 1996-97 school year provided him with educational benefit, comported with the IEP, and occurred in the least restrictive environment, and that STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summer of 1997. The program was not, however, designed to meet all STUDENT's unique educational needs because it failed to address his social and motor needs. Thus, the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year to the extent that its program failed to address his social skills deficits and did not provide him with occupational therapy.
d. the 1997-98 school year, including the 1998 extended school year session?
i. procedural appropriateness
Petitioner did not allege that the District committed any procedural errors during the 1997-98 school year. Because this is not an issue in dispute between the parties, the Hearing Officer will not explore this issue further.
ii. substantive appropriateness
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The needs discussed in relation to the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school year continued to be needs for STUDENT in the 1997-98 school year, especially in the social domain. Lisa Callagy, STUDENT's fifth grade regular education teacher, testified that he was friendly with a few other boys in her class at the beginning of the year. The boys played with legos together, fifty percent of which was collaborative play and fifty percent of which was parallel play. Although STUDENT maintained the friendships throughout the year, they were limited because STUDENT withdrew slightly when the boys began playing chasing games and telling jokes. According to Ms. Callagy, STUDENT successfully participated in a week-long outdoor education camp that the fifth grade class attended in Pescadero where the children stayed in cabins and the activities were performed in groups. However, she noticed that he had some difficulties with peers: he did not often initiate conversations with peers, was frequently alone in the playground and did not join in games, was not as interactive in group work as the other students, and was less comfortable interacting with peers than with adults. According to Ms. Callagy, STUDENT found it difficult to follow fast-paced conversations or understand jokes. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT developed relationships with a few other students at the beginning of the year, but that he became unsure how to respond to overtures made by the students later in the school year. Ms. Kirkpatrick also testified that she was aware that STUDENT had difficulty working in particular group activities. A progress report for the 1997-98 school year, which was filled out jointly by Ms. Callagy and Ms. Kirkpatrick, indicated that STUDENT preferred not to interact with peers and stated that preference; never initiated dialogues with peers (even if instructed to do so), although he did initiate conversations with adults; never participated in class discussions or in class activities, preferring to stand to the side and be "forgotten."
Having determined what STUDENT's unique needs were during the 1997-98 school year, the Hearing Officer now turns to the question of whether the District provided STUDENT a program that addressed those needs. During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT was placed in a regular education fifth grade classroom at Parkmead that consisted of twenty-seven students, and he received RS, S/L, and OT services. STUDENT's IEP dated May 27, 1997, stated that he was to receive one hundred thirty-five minutes of RS services per week to work on the core curriculum, with remedial materials as needed, S/L two times per week for a total of sixty minutes on an individual or small-group basis, and OT sixty minutes per week. However, the amount of RS and OT services was modified slightly at an IEP meeting held on March 31, 1998. The IEP dated March 31, 1998, indicated that STUDENT was to receive RS services four times per week (thirty to forty-five minutes each session) and OT one time per week (forty-five to sixty minutes each session). STUDENT's goals and objectives for the 1997-98 school year were aimed at improving his skills in the following areas: comprehension, inferential thinking, written expression, computation, study skills, postural control and stability, gross and fine motor, eye tracking, semantic language, syntax, pragmatics, and problem solving. Ms. Parkhurst and Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that they developed STUDENT's goals and objectives based on the areas of difficulty he exhibited during testing and during their work with him. Beginning approximately February 1998, STUDENT started receiving about an hour per week of individual counseling with an M.F.C.C. (marriage, family, and child counselor) intern who was supervised by the school psychologist. (Footnote 13)
Petitioner contended that the District's program failed to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1997-98 school year because it (1) did not provide him with sufficient services to support him academically, (2) did not address his social skills deficits, and (3) did not provide him with ESY services.
The Hearing Officer notes that some of the discussion with regard to the previous school years, especially with respect to the argument involving the parents and the tutor being listed as implementers on STUDENT's IEPs, is equally applicable with regard Petitioner's first contention for the 1997-98 school year. Further, Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst testified that the amount of RS and S/L services provided to STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year was appropriate to meet his academic needs. Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut this testimony. Petitioner presented the testimony of Dr. Pollack and Brad Berman, M.D., a developmental pediatrician who conducted a neurodevelopmental consultation in late 1996 at the request of STUDENT's parents, but neither testified that the services at Parkmead were insufficient to support STUDENT's academic work. Both Dr. Berman and Dr. Pollack testified that their assessments were not educational assessments. Dr. Pollack testified that his assessment was more concerned with STUDENT's social-emotional functioning than his academic progress. Dr. Pollack testified that he only did a cursory analysis (from a review of records) of how STUDENT had been progressing academically and that he did not specifically assess what learning strategies would be most useful for STUDENT. Further, neither assessor spoke with Ms. Kirkpatrick or Ms. Parkhurst to determine what services they were providing to support STUDENT in his academic work. Moreover, Dr. Berman testified that the amount of RS services provided during the 1997-98 school year complied with his recommendations at the time and that STUDENT was able to make academic progress that year. Finally, as will be discussed in detail later, STUDENT made significant progress in academic areas and his language skills during the 1997-98 school year.
With regard to Petitioner's second contention, that STUDENT had social skills deficits which the District failed to address, the evidence established that, as in previous years, the school staff was fully aware that STUDENT had difficulty interacting with his peers and participating in group discussions. For example, Lynne Childers, the school psychologist who evaluated STUDENT for his triennial assessment in March 1998, noted the following:
Previous history suggests that there have been ongoing concerns for STUDENT's social-emotional development. STUDENT has had difficulty working in a group; he also does not make friends easily. His teacher also reports that he has shown a decrease in his productivity in the classroom during the course of the school year.
No suggestions were made, however, about how the concerns for STUDENT's social-emotional development should be addressed in the school setting. Furthermore, even Dr. Rossi and Robin Reeves (a former program specialist for the Contra Costa County SELPA), both of whom testified on the District's behalf, found from a review of STUDENT's records that he had delays in social skills development. He was not comfortable participating in class discussions and was not at expected levels for peer interaction. They testified that he needed extra support with social issues. The District's program failed to adequately address those needs.
There is no dispute that STUDENT's IEP did not specifically address any social issues. STUDENT was mainstreamed in a regular education fifth grade classroom and had a number of pragmatic language objectives. Ms. Parkhurst testified that during the year she ran a pragmatic language group in which STUDENT participated. STUDENT was required to teach two fellow students how to make something. Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT, although apprehensive at first, quickly became more comfortable with the task and was ultimately successful. The pragmatic language group did not, however, address STUDENT's ability to interact normally with peers or his ability to participate in classroom discussions. Informal attempts were also made to address STUDENT's social needs. At the beginning of the school year, school staff orally suggested general education counseling through group social skills training to the parents. While there was conflicting testimony about the events leading up to the provision of counseling, there is no dispute that no appropriate social skills group was available by the time the parents' permission slip was returned and that STUDENT did not receive any counseling services until approximately March 1998. What STUDENT finally did receive was approximately an hour per week of individual counseling with an M.F.C.C. (marriage, family, and child counselor) intern who was supervised by the school psychologist. MOTHER testified that STUDENT reported to her that little was discussed about peer interactions or relationships at the counseling sessions. The District did not provide any evidence to contradict this. Finally, Ms. Callagy testified that she tried to address STUDENT's social needs in the classroom by encouraging him to discuss his problems with others. She also had weekly class meetings in which the class discussed issues they were having with peers; classmates offered suggestions on how to deal with the issues. STUDENT, however, never offered an issue for discussion or suggested a possible resolution to another student's problem.
In light of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to fashion an IEP that adequately addressed STUDENT's social needs during the 1997-98 school year. While STUDENT was placed in a mainstream environment, there was no evidence that mainstreaming, in conjunction with a few pragmatic goals and approximately three months of individual counseling provided by an M.F.C.C. intern, was sufficient to address the social skills deficits that STUDENT experienced during the 1997-98 school year. Dr. Pollack testified that STUDENT required social skills training in a group setting to address his difficulties with peer interaction and that individual counseling would not be appropriate because of the nature and severity of his social skills deficits. Dr. Pollack conducted a comprehensive neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT in January 1997 and observed STUDENT for one and a half hours at Parkmead in June 1998. The 1997 assessment consisted of a review of records; interviews with STUDENT, his parents, and his tutor; and administration of a number of measures that test cognitive ability, academic functioning, and memory functioning. The District did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut Dr. Pollack's testimony. Additionally, there was no evidence that the intern worked with STUDENT on the social difficulties identified herein; in fact, there was no evidence whatsoever provided about the nature of the counseling, except STUDENT's statement to his mother that the counselor did not address issues involving peer interaction. Further, the informal attempts by Ms. Callagy to address STUDENT's social needs, while commendable, were of dubious benefit. There was no evidence that she was qualified to appropriately remediate social skills deficits in children such as STUDENT, or that the techniques she utilized with STUDENT were appropriate or beneficial.
Finally, with regard to Petitioner's third argument, that the District erred when it failed to provide STUDENT with ESY services during the summer of 1998, the Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team did not determine that STUDENT needed ESY services during the summer of 1998, nor was ESY included in his IEP. The question is whether STUDENT needed ESY programming in the summer of 1998 because interruption of his educational programming during the summer months caused regression which, coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendered it impossible or unlikely that he could attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that otherwise could have been expected in view of his handicapping condition. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1988). MOTHER testified that STUDENT attended Raskob's six-week intensive remedial program during the summer of 1998. However, as with the previous summers, there was no evidence that STUDENT had "limited recoupment capacity" as required by section 3043. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY services during the summer of 1998.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program the District provided STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year was not designed to address all his unique educational needs, because it failed to address his social needs. The evidence established, however, that the District provided STUDENT with sufficient RS and S/L services to support him academically and it was not required to provide him with ESY services.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The evidence established that STUDENT gained some educational benefit from his program during the 1997-98 school year, and that the benefit was more than de minimis. This was established by teachers' observations, his progress on goals and objectives, and the results of standardized testing.
During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT met a number of his goals and objectives. STUDENT passed at least half of the goals and objectives for RS contained in his IEP dated May 27, 1997. Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that by March 1998 STUDENT had either wholly or partially passed a number of his mathematics goals, an area in which his tutor did not assist him. For example, according to Ms. Kirkpatrick, STUDENT was able to multiply three to four digits by two to three digits with eighty percent accuracy, and could perform with eighty to eighty-five percent accuracy on a basic math operations test in addition, subtraction, and multiplication. STUDENT had also learned how to use the "SQ3R" strategy in the content areas to remember main ideas and details in expository texts. STUDENT had also met his comprehension goal, which was to respond to fifth grade comprehension questions by recalling information (without choices being given) with eighty-five percent accuracy, with regard to literal questions; he had more difficulty with inferential questions.
STUDENT's progress in academic areas was also apparent through the results of achievement testing. A comparison of the scores STUDENT achieved on the Wide Range Achievement Test - Revision 3 (WRAT-3) administered in January 1997 by Dr. Pollack and in February 1998 by Ms. Kirkpatrick suggests that STUDENT made substantial progress in one year:
Jan. 1997 Feb. 1998 R.S. (Footnote 14) S.S. %ile Rank G.E. (Footnote 15) R.S.S.S.%ile RankG.E. Reading 33 93 40 4 37 99 47 6 Spelling 26 90 36 4 32 98 45 5 Arithmetic 23 72 31 2 30 88 21 4
STUDENT's results on the WIAT administered in March 1995 and February/March 1998 by Ms. Kirkpatrick also show improvement in all areas, except written expression:
Subtest March 1995 Feb./March 1998 S.S. %ile Age Equiv. S.S %ile Age Equiv.
Basic Reading 84 14 7-9 100 50 11-3 Reading Comprehension 80 9 7-3 84 14 9-0 Written Expression 89 23 7-3 88 21 8-9 Spelling 86 18 7-9 90 25 10-0 Mathematics Reasoning 84 14 7-3 93 32 10-6 Numerical Operations 81 10 7-6 83 13 10-0
As previously noted, formal testing by Ms. Parkhurst in March 1998 showed that STUDENT's language skills had improved in virtually all areas since 1996 to the extent that he no longer would have qualified as a speech impaired student. Ms. Parkhurst testified that STUDENT passed virtually all of his speech and language goals during the 1997-98 school year. By the end of the year, STUDENT met the following objectives from his IEP dated May 27, 1997, among others: identify words or phrases in terms of who, what, where, why, and how with seventy-five percent accuracy; use the words "however" and "whenever" in sentences with eighty-eight percent accuracy; formulate the questions that prompted a given answer with eighty percent accuracy; describe a series of actions directed toward a result in response to "how" questions with eighty percent accuracy; answer negative "why" questions with seventy-five percent accuracy; and explain causes, inferences and predictions (for example, by providing answers to situational "what" questions based on context clues) with eighty percent accuracy,
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT obtained educational benefit from the District's program during the 1997-98 school year and that the progress constituted more than de minimis benefit or trivial advancement.
Comport With the IEP
The testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst established that they provided services to STUDENT as they were required to under his IEP. For example, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that STUDENT received RS services from 1:30 p.m. to 2:15 p.m. on Mondays, Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Fridays in her RS room, which constituted more than the one hundred thirty-five minutes he was required to receive under his IEP. She testified that approximately seventy-five percent of this time was spent in one-on-one instruction with STUDENT and that occasionally there was parallel instruction (i.e., there were one or two other students in the room working on a different task). According to Ms. Kirkpatrick, STUDENT also received some assistance while in the regular education classroom from either her or her aide. Ms. Parkhurst testified that she provided S/L services to STUDENT two times per week for thirty minutes per session, in accordance with the IEP. Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut the testimony of Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst that the IEP was properly implemented. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT a program during the 1997-98 school year that comported with his IEP.
Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment
The District's provision of services in the least restrictive environment was not at issue in this case. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT was mainstreamed in a regular education fifth grade classroom with services to support his academic, language, and motor needs. There is no question that this was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT given his unique needs.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program the District provided to STUDENT during the 1997-98 school year provided him with educational benefit, comported with the IEP, and occurred in the least restrictive environment, and that STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summer of 1998. However, the District's program was not designed to meet all his unique educational needs because it failed to appropriately address his social needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year to the extent that its program failed to address his social needs.
2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring with Alice Rector which they provided to implement STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) during the summer of 1995 (starting from June 24, 1995) and for the 1995-96, 1996-97, and 1997-98 school years?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997) (amending 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(2) (1991)). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. Petitioner contends that he is entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services that the parents funded for STUDENT from the summer of 1995 (beginning June 24, 1995) to the end of the 1997-98 school year through Ms. Rector.
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years because its program failed to address his social and motor needs, and denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-98 school year because its program failed to address his social needs. Ms. Rector's tutoring addressed neither social nor motor needs. Instead, Ms. Rector addressed needs which the Hearing Officer found were appropriately met by the District during those years. Thus, relief in the form of reimbursement for Ms. Rector's tutoring services would not serve the purposes of the IDEA. Appropriate relief should seek to redress the harm flowing from the District's failure to fulfill its FAPE obligation to STUDENT. Because the evidence established that the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT's social and motor needs and the tutoring addressed neither of these areas, the Hearing Officer denies the parents' request for reimbursement of the tutoring services by Ms. Rector.
3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by the Raskob Learning Institute (Raskob) which they provided to implement STUDENT's IEP for the 1998 extended school year session?
Petitioner contends that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the tutoring provided by Raskob through its six-week intensive remedial program during the summer of 1998. Sarah Harris, the teacher at Raskob who provided the tutoring, testified that the instruction focused on reading, writing, and mathematics. The parents' request for reimbursement is denied. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summer of 1998. Additionally, as with the tutoring provided by Ms. Rector, the summer tutoring at Raskob did not address the areas which the District's program failed to address during the previous school years.
4. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE to meet STUDENT's needs for the 1998-99 school year?
a. procedural appropriateness
Petitioner did not allege that the District committed any procedural errors during the 1998-99 school year. Because this is not an issue in dispute between the parties and no persuasive evidence was introduced to establish that the District committed any procedural errors that denied STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will not explore this issue further.
b. substantive appropriateness
Designed To Meet STUDENT's Unique Needs
The needs discussed in relation to the previous school years continued to be needs for STUDENT in the 1998-99 school year. The question is whether the District offered STUDENT a program that addressed those needs. For the 1998-99 school year, the District offered STUDENT placement at Walnut Creek Intermediate School (WCI) with either two periods in the resource specialist program (RSP) or up to four periods in the learning center (footnote 16) (LC), with the remainder of the time spent in regular education sixth grade core classes and the designated related services of S/L therapy, OT, and psychological counseling. Regardless of whether the parents chose the RSP or LC, the following related services were to be provided: two forty-minute S/L sessions per week; OT one time per week for forty minutes; and counseling to address social-emotional issues one time per week for forty minutes. STUDENT's goals and objectives were aimed at improving his skills in the areas of reading comprehension, written expression, mathematics, in-class communication, vocabulary, language flexibility, figurative language, syntax, fine motor and gross motor (including postural strength and control, bilateral coordination, and perceptual and visual-motor skills), peer interaction, participation in group activities, and his ability to understand social situations. Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst testified that they developed the goals and objectives based on the areas of difficulty STUDENT exhibited during testing and during their work with him. (Ms. Parkhurst would have continued to be STUDENT's S/L therapy provider at WCI during the 1998-99 school year.)The following modifications were also made a part of STUDENT's IEP: modification of assignments as needed (i.e., length and due date adjustments); test-taking in the RS room with extended time when appropriate; modification of tests as needed (i.e., length adjustments, offer of an alternative means of assessment); use of the computer for written projects when appropriate; and use of a calculator for math assignments and tests.
By the conclusion of the four IEP meetings held during the 1997-98 school year, this offer had been made in writing and fully discussed with the parents by staff from Parkmead and WCI. The following WCI personnel attended one or more of STUDENT's IEP meetings during the 1998 spring semester to discuss the WCI program with the team and answer the parents' questions: Toby Hopstone, RS; Mary Lovell, academic counselor; and Michael Cohen, Ph.D., school psychologist. MOTHER was also given an opportunity to observe an RS class at WCI. District personnel informed the parents during the meetings that they recommended a mainstream placement with two RS periods but, to relieve the parents' concerns that STUDENT would not receive sufficient support for his academic work, also offered placement with up to four periods in the LC instead of the two RS periods.
Petitioner contended that the District's proposed program for the 1998-99 school year failed to address STUDENT's unique needs because it (1) did not provide him with sufficient services to support him in his academic work, (2) did not provide modifications for physical education (PE), (3) failed to offer ESY services, and (4) did not adequately address his social skills deficits. Each argument will be addressed in turn.
With regard to Petitioner's first contention that insufficient services were offered to support STUDENT in his academic work, Ms. Kirkpatrick and Ms. Parkhurst testified that the amount of RS and S/L services offered to STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year was more than appropriate to meet his academic needs, especially since even two periods of RS per day would have provided him with substantially more support than he received at Parkmead and he had been able to obtain significant educational benefit at Parkmead. Toby Hopstone was the RS at WCI until January 1999. (Footnote 17) Ms. Hopstone has a bachelor's degree in elementary education, a master's degree in teaching emotionally handicapped children, a multiple subject credential, a severely handicapped credential, and an RS certificate of competence. She was an RS at WCI for three and a half years before leaving the position in 1999. She testified that the student-teacher ratio in the RS classes was two adults to three to seven students, and that students were often able to receive individual instruction. After reviewing the proposed modifications and goals and objectives, Ms. Hopstone testified that she could have implemented them in her RS class during the year. While Ms. Hopstone was replaced in January 1999 by another teacher, there is no evidence that the personnel change resulted in a difference in the RSP's ability to support students academically.
Kathryn DeRusso, the LC teacher at WCI, has a bachelor's degree in English, a master's degree in psychology, a single subject credential in English, and an emergency credential in special education, (footnote 18) and is a licensed family and child counselor. She has taught in the public schools for twenty years. According to Ms. DeRusso, she works collaboratively with the regular education teachers to support the LC students in their mainstream classes by frequently meeting with the regular education teachers. Ms. DeRusso testified that she familiarizes herself with the regular education curriculum and discusses with the teachers the appropriate accommodations and modifications that should be made in the regular education classes for LC students. She also testified that her assistant is present in some of the regular education classes to assist LC students with activities such as note taking and keeping track of assignments, as well as making sure that the students understand what is expected of them. After reviewing the proposed modifications and goals and objectives, Ms. DeRusso testified that she could have implemented them for STUDENT.
Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut the testimony of District personnel. As noted earlier, Dr. Berman and Dr. Pollack testified that their assessments were not educational assessments. Further, while Dr. Pollack observed the classes at WCI and found that it was not appropriate for STUDENT, his opinion was clearly based on concerns about STUDENT's social-emotional issues. Dr. Pollack did not find that the program at WCI could not support STUDENT academically. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed program offered STUDENT sufficient support academically. The program at WCI would have provided STUDENT with more academic support than he received during any of his years at Parkmead and, as previously determined, STUDENT was able to obtain substantial educational benefit from his Parkmead placement.
With regard to Petitioner's second argument, that the District's proposed program failed to provide necessary modifications with regard to PE, MOTHER testified that she had concerns that STUDENT would not feel comfortable changing clothes in front of other children and would not be able to physically perform the activities required in a regular education PE class. Ms. DeRusso and Ms. Hopstone both testified that alternatives to the regular education PE class were available to STUDENT at WCI. A program at WCI called "Lifetime PE" modifies the PE curriculum based on the students' needs. Ms. Hopstone testified that she informed the parents that STUDENT could participate in this modified PE program and that there were other alternatives to PE, such as folk dancing. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed program adequately addressed any changes to the regular education PE program that STUDENT might have required. (Footnote 19)
The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Petitioner's third argument, that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by not offering ESY services for the summer of 1999. The Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team did not determine that STUDENT needed ESY services during the summer of 1999, nor was ESY included in his IEP. The question is whether STUDENT needed ESY programming in the summer of 1999 because interruption of his educational programming during the summer months would cause regression which, coupled with limited recoupment capacity, would render it impossible or unlikely that he could attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that otherwise could have been expected in view of his handicapping condition. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043 (1988). It was determined above that STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summers of 1995, 1996, 1997 and 1998. There was no evidence that STUDENT's needs had changed to the extent that he needed ESY services during the summer of 1999. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for ESY services during the summer of 1999.
However, the record does clearly support Petitioner's fourth argument, that the District's proposed program failed to adequately address STUDENT's social skills deficits. The program the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year contained a number of new elements including counseling, social-emotional goals and objectives, and a speech goal to improve participation in class discussions. However, as in previous years, the District failed to understand the scope and nature of STUDENT's deficits in this regard and, as a result, failed to offer appropriate services to address the problem. First, the District's triennial assessment in March 1998 noted that STUDENT had a history of social-emotional concerns and had difficulty working in a group, but contained no psychometric testing (apart from the Kinetic Family Drawing, the results of which were not reported) or other similar measures to determine the scope and nature of STUDENT's social-emotional difficulties. There is no evidence that Ms. Childers, the school psychologist who assessed STUDENT, made any findings or recommendations with regard to STUDENT's social-emotional difficulties. Additionally, the social-emotional goals and objectives that were proposed for the 1998-99 school year were written by Michael Cohen, the school psychologist assigned to WCI at the time, who had never worked with STUDENT or assessed him. No evidence was presented at hearing as to Mr. Cohen's understanding of STUDENT's needs or how Mr. Cohen acquired that understanding. In short, apart from informal observations of STUDENT's increasing social isolation and inability to productively engage in group activities, District personnel had (at best) a limited understanding of the nature and scope of STUDENT's social-emotional needs and no basis upon which to be able to recommend the appropriate services to address those needs.
Second, the District gave the parents only a vague description of the services being offered to address STUDENT's social-emotional difficulties. While "counseling" was included as a part of STUDENT's proposed program, the District failed to explain whether this would be on an individual or group basis. This was no doubt due to the fact that District personnel were still unsure even by the time of the hearing whether the offer was for individual or group counseling. For example, Ms. Kirkpatrick testified that she believed the offer was for individual or small-group counseling; Ms. Ryor testified that she thought that the offer was for individual counseling but that ultimately the decision would be left to the school psychologist. Robert Goyer, the school psychologist who was assigned to WCI for the 1998-99 school year and who would have been the school psychologist assigned to STUDENT, testified that STUDENT's first few sessions would have been on a one-on-one basis for diagnostic purposes. Mr. Goyer testified that during those initial sessions he would have determined the type of service that would be most beneficial for STUDENT. Mr. Goyer testified he likely would have recommended that STUDENT receive group counseling (which is conducted by a licensed M.F.C.C.) in conjunction with individual counseling. However, according to Mr. Goyer, the M.F.C.C. would have made the ultimate decision about whether STUDENT would be allowed to participate in group counseling in light of the make-up of the rest of the group. Thus, not only was the offer of counseling insufficiently specific to allow the parents to make a reasoned decision but it left critical decisions about how the services would be implemented to the discretion of the school psychologist and an M.F.C.C., rather than the IEP team. Further, the District's offer did not constitute an offer for group counseling, which Dr. Pollack found was required to address STUDENT's social-emotional problems. As mentioned earlier, the District did not present any persuasive evidence to rebut Dr. Pollack's finding. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed program for the 1998-99 school year failed to appropriately address STUDENT's social skills deficits. (Footnote 20)
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program the District offered STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year was not designed to address all his unique educational needs, because it failed to include appropriate services to address his social-emotional problems.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Petitioner contended that the program the District proposed for the 1998-99 school year would not have provided STUDENT with educational benefit, because it was similar to the program provided at Parkmead during the past three years. Thus, it is appropriate to review STUDENT's progress during the previous years at Parkmead to provide insight into whether the District's proposed program for the 1998-99 school year was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT obtained significant educational benefit from each of the years he attended Parkmead. It is reasonable to conclude that he would have also obtained educational benefit from the program at WCI, especially since he would have received more academic support at WCI than he had at Parkmead. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's proposed program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit.
Comport With the IEP
The District did not have an opportunity to provide STUDENT with the program proposed for the 1998-99 school year. STUDENT's parents unilaterally removed him from the District's public schools and placed him in Raskob, a nonpublic school. The District presented evidence that it was willing and able to provide STUDENT with an educational program as set out in the IEP during the 1998-99 school year, and Petitioner did not present any evidence to rebut this showing. The Hearing Officer finds that the District's provision of instruction and services would have comported with the IEP.
Occur In the Least Restrictive Environment
The District's provision of services in the least restrictive environment was not at issue in this case. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that STUDENT would have been mainstreamed in regular education sixth grade classrooms with services to support his academic, language, motor, and social-emotional needs. There is no dispute that the District recommended RS placement for STUDENT (rather than the LC placement), because it would have been the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. However, the team also offered STUDENT placement with up to four LC periods, because it was difficult to determine how well STUDENT would handle the sixth grade core curriculum and his parents were concerned that two periods of RS would not provide sufficient academic support. Ms. Ryor, Ms. Hopstone, and Ms. DeRusso testified that, as with all students, the amount of assistance STUDENT received could have been modified by the IEP team during the year depending on his ability to deal with the rigors of the sixth grade core curriculum. Thus, it is clear that the District took into account the requirement that instruction be provided in the least restrictive environment possible given the student's unique needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that instruction would have been occurred in the least restrictive environment possible given STUDENT's unique educational needs.
*****
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program the District offered STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year would have provided him with educational benefit, comported with the IEP, and occurred in the least restrictive environment. Additionally, STUDENT was not entitled to ESY services during the summer of 1999. However, the District's proposed program failed to address all his unique educational needs to the extent that it failed to appropriately address his social needs.
5. Are STUDENT's program, placement and services at Raskob appropriate to meet his needs, and should the Raskob program, placement and services (with the addition of speech and language services) be ordered prospectively to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP?
6. Should the District be ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP and to provide him a consistent and coordinated program?
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with providing the Raskob program to STUDENT, including tuition, transportation, and Dr. Antoniadis' services, during the 1998-99 school year?
The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year to the extent that its proposed program failed to adequately address his social needs. Therefore, if the parents' unilateral placement at Raskob is appropriate under the IDEA, STUDENT is entitled to prospective placement at Raskob and/or the parents are entitled to reimbursement for expenses related to the Raskob placement. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii) (1997).
As noted previously, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the placement they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement, and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C) (1997). However, the Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement chosen by the parent is found to be the exact proper placement required under the Act. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The Alamo court stated the following about the rationale behind the Court's decision in Burlington:
The rationale behind Burlington's holding is that parents who elect to risk shouldering the costs of what they perceive to be a more appropriate placement, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an ‘empty victory.' [Footnote omitted.] As stated by the Court, if ‘appropriate relief' in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, ‘the child's right to a free appropriate public education, the parent's right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.' [Footnote omitted.]
Id.
The Supreme Court in Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student's IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court has recognized that the parents' placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district's must meet, the parents' placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student's needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id. Here, there is no question that the parents' unilateral placement at Raskob for the 1998-99 school year was appropriate under the IDEA.
There is little dispute that the Raskob placement met STUDENT's unique educational needs, particularly STUDENT's primary deficits in short-term memory, auditory processing, peer interaction, and class participation. Raskob is a certified nonpublic school located in Oakland that serves learning disabled children with a variety of learning issues. The day program, which STUDENT currently attends, consists of forty-two students (grades three through eight). The classes at Raskob generally consist of approximately twelve students, a teacher and an aide. All of Raskob's teachers have (at a minimum) a learning handicap teaching credential, except one teacher who instead has an RS certificate.
Sarah Harris, who teaches STUDENT in reading, math, and science, testified that he often receives instruction in groups of two to three students. The teachers accommodate STUDENT's documented and observed deficits. For example, because of his auditory processing deficit, the teachers seat STUDENT in the front of the classroom, give him oral and visual prompts, and check in with him periodically to make sure he is understanding the teacher's instructions. To address his short-term memory deficit, the teachers present lessons with frequent review and repetition to aid STUDENT's ability to retain the lessons. The curriculum is individualized for STUDENT to reflect his present levels of functioning. Jack Davis, Ph.D., has been the clinical director and psychologist at Raskob for the past seven years. He has a Ph.D. in school and educational psychology from the University of California at Berkeley and prior experience working as a school psychologist in the public schools. Dr. Davis testified that the staff at Raskob frequently meet to discuss the social needs of the students. The staff target specific aspects of a student's behavior and discuss how they should deal with the student in order to address the targeted behavior. For example, with STUDENT, the staff were aware that he was socially withdrawn, anxious, and unlikely to interact with his peers or in class discussions. The staff decided to use a softer and slower tone of voice with STUDENT, and to engage him in activities by addressing specific questions to him, checking in with him to make sure he felt comfortable and informed about what was expected of him, and asking some of his classmates to engage him in play (offering adult assistance when necessary). Further, the staff speak at least weekly with Dr. Antoniadis about the students' social progress to inform her of how the students are functioning in the classroom and to consult with her on how to deal with social-emotional issues.
STUDENT also attends the weekly social skills group therapy sessions provided at Raskob by Dr. Antoniadis, a licensed clinical psychologist. These sessions deal with subjects such as the students' ability to interact with peers and participate in group discussions. Before working with STUDENT, Dr. Antoniadis interviewed STUDENT's parents, Dr. Davis, and the teachers and aides at Raskob about STUDENT. She also met with STUDENT individually and reviewed his records. STUDENT's group sessions, which last forty-five minutes and consist of six male Raskob classmates, start with a check-in period during which time everybody has to say something and then proceeds to a lesson, such as talking one at a time or staying on topic.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the Raskob placement was designed to meet STUDENT's unique educational needs. The evidence also clearly established that STUDENT obtained significant educational benefit from the Raskob placement.
STUDENT made gains in both his academic and social development at Raskob during the 1998-99 school year. Ms. Harris testified that STUDENT has made good progress in all academic areas and has met a number of the goals and objectives set forth in the District's proposed IEP. He received passing marks in all of his classes. Dr. Antoniadis testified that STUDENT has made dramatic social improvements since entering her program. By the beginning of the 1999 spring semester, he had become good friends with two boys in the group session (to the extent that they interact even outside of school) and now is often the first person to speak during the group sessions. Dr. Antoniadis reported that STUDENT's communication skills are also greatly improved: he remains on topic, is cooperative, and functions appropriately as part of the group (e.g., takes turns speaking). By all accounts, STUDENT now participates more regularly in class discussions, has friends at school whom he also sees outside of school, interacts with other students even in unstructured situations, and is better able to handle group situations.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents' unilateral placement was appropriate under the IDEA. While STUDENT has not been receiving OT or S/L services at Raskob, the overall program remained appropriate because it addressed his primary educational needs, including social-emotional development. (Footnote 21) Having determined that the District failed to provide a FAPE during the 1995-96, 1996-97, 1997-98, and 1998-99 school years because its programs failed to adequately address STUDENT's social needs, and that the parents' placement was proper under the IDEA, the next inquiry is the appropriate amount of reimbursement. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 96 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992). Here, there was no evidence that the parents' conduct warranted a reduction in the amount of reimbursement to be awarded. Further, there was no evidence that the amount of reimbursement should be reduced for any of the reasons stated in 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii). Looking at the record as a whole, given the nature and extent of STUDENT's social deficits, the four years during which the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT's social deficits, and the finding that STUDENT nevertheless obtained significant educational benefit, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the full amount of the expenses related to the Raskob placement for the 1998-99 school year, including tuition, transportation, and the social skills training provided by Dr. Antoniadis.
The evidence established that STUDENT's annual tuition at Raskob is $8,961.00 and that the parents paid Kid's Coach, a private carrier, $602.16 to transport STUDENT to and from Raskob through the end of December 1998. The evidence also established that the parents paid $610.00 to Dr. Antoniadis for services she provided through December 16, 1998. Thus, the District must reimburse the parents $10,173.16 in addition to the cost of the weekly social skills training and transportation services provided after December 1998 and before the end of the 1998-99 school year. To be reimbursed for social skills training and transportation services provided after December 1998, the parents must submit proof of their expenses (e.g., receipts) to the District to establish the amounts paid.
Finally, when Petitioner submitted an issue statement in January 1999, one of the issues for hearing was whether the District should be ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob prospectively. STUDENT's IEP team determined that he required two forty-minute S/L sessions per week during the 1998-99 school year but, as mentioned earlier, no S/L sessions were provided at Raskob because of the parents' financial situation. There was no dispute that STUDENT continued to need S/L therapy to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer found above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-99 school year, and that the parents were entitled to reimbursement for their unilateral placement. Now, near the end of the 1998-99 school year, the issue becomes whether the District should be ordered to provide speech and language therapy despite the fact that the school year is nearing its end.
Because the District would have been ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob had the due process proceedings been concluded earlier, the Hearing Officer finds that is appropriate to award STUDENT a roughly approximate amount of S/L therapy sessions. Looking at the record as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of forty-six forty-minute S/L therapy sessions (to be delivered two times per week) is reasonably calculated to approximate the S/L therapy that STUDENT missed and to provide sufficient services to enable STUDENT to progress to the level of S/L development he would have attained had the services been provided during the 1998-99 school year. Therefore, absent written agreement by the parents otherwise, the District shall provide STUDENT two forty-minute S/L sessions per week (for a total of forty-six sessions) to work on the S/L goals and objectives listed in his IEP, which were developed by Ms. Parkhurst and dated March 10, 1998, and any other goals and objectives that the IEP team determines to be appropriate. These sessions shall be provided in a manner that does not cause STUDENT to lose any time from school and shall be completed within a year of the date of this order. The District shall also provide, at no cost to the parents, any necessary transportation to and from the sessions. Should STUDENT re-enter the public school system for the 1999-2000 school year, the District must provide the aforementioned forty-six S/L sessions in addition to any S/L services that the IEP team finds are necessary to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
*****
The decision has not thus far dealt with the appropriate remedy for the District's failure to address STUDENT's motor needs during the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years. As previously noted, when a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(e) (1991) (current version at 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997)). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). However, compensatory education does not necessarily involve an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity or time missed. Id. at 1497. The purpose of compensatory education is to "ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA." Id.
The Hearing Officer finds that an award of compensatory education in the form of OT is necessary to help STUDENT overcome lost educational opportunity. During the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT received sixty minutes of OT services per week. Although the record is otherwise limited with regard to this issue, looking at the record as a whole, the Hearing Officer finds that an award of thirty sixty-minute OT sessions (to be delivered one time per week) is reasonably calculated to provide sufficient services to enable STUDENT to progress to the level of motor development he would have attained had the appropriate services been provided in a timely manner. Absent written agreement by the parents otherwise, the District shall provide STUDENT one sixty-minute OT session per week (for a total of thirty sessions) to work on the OT goals and objectives set forth in his IEP, which were prepared by Nan Arkwright, registered occupational therapist, and dated March 27, 1998, as well as any other goals and objectives which the IEP team agrees to implement. These sessions shall be provided in a manner that does not cause STUDENT to lose any time from school and shall be completed within a year of the date of this order. The District shall also provide, at no cost to the parents, any necessary transportation to and from the sessions. Should STUDENT re-enter the public school system for the 1999-2000 school year, the District must provide the aforementioned thirty OT sessions in addition to any OT services that the IEP team finds are necessary to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
ORDER
1. Within twenty days of the date of this order, the District must reimburse the parents the amount of $10,173.16. This amount represents reimbursement for the annual tuition at Raskob for the 1998-99 school year, the social skills training provided by Dr. Antoniadis through December 16, 1998, and the cost of transportation services provided through December 1998.
2. Within twenty days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the parents the amount they paid for social skills training by Dr. Antoniadis between December 16, 1998, and the end of the 1998-99 school year.
3. Within twenty days of receipt of proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the parents the cost of transportation services provided between December 1998 and the end of the 1998-99 school year.
4. Absent written agreement by the parents otherwise, the District shall provide STUDENT two forty-minute speech and language therapy sessions per week (for a total of forty-six sessions) to work on the speech and language goals and objectives set forth in his IEP, which were prepared by Karen Parkhurst and dated March 10, 1998, as well as any other goals and objectives the IEP team agrees to implement. These sessions shall be provided in a manner that does not cause STUDENT to lose any time from school and shall be completed within a year of the date of this order. The District shall also provide, at no cost to the parents, any necessary transportation to and from the sessions. Should STUDENT re-enter the public school system for the 1999-2000 school year, the District shall provide the aforementioned forty-six speech and language sessions in addition to any speech and language services that the IEP team finds are necessary to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
5. Absent written agreement by the parents otherwise, the District shall provide STUDENT one sixty-minute occupational therapy session per week (for a total of thirty sessions) to work on the occupational therapy goals and objectives set forth in his IEP, which were prepared by Nan Arkwright, registered occupational therapist, and dated March 27, 1998, as well as any other goals and objectives the IEP team agrees to implement. These sessions shall be provided in a manner that does not cause STUDENT to lose any time from school and shall be completed within a year of the date of this order. The District shall also provide, at no cost to the parents, any necessary transportation to and from the sessions. Should STUDENT re-enter the public school system for the 1999-2000 school year, the District shall provide the aforementioned thirty occupational therapy sessions in addition to any occupational therapy services the IEP team finds are necessary to address STUDENT's unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
6. All of Petitioner's other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: (footnote 22)
1. Did the District offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to meet STUDENT's needs for the following school terms: a. the 1995 extended school year session (starting June 24, 1995)? b. the 1995-96 school year, including the 1996 extended school year session? c. the 1996-97 school year, including the 1997 extended school year session? d. the 1997-98 school year, including the 1998 extended school year session? Petitioner substantially prevailed with respect to the regular school terms, and the District prevailed with respect to the extended school year sessions.
2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring with Alice Rector which they provided to implement STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) during the summer of 1995 (starting from June 24, 1995) and for the 1995-96, 1996-97, and 1997-98 school years? The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private tutoring by the Raskob Learning Institute (Raskob) which they provided to implement STUDENT's IEP for the 1998 extended school year session? The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Did the District offer and provide a FAPE to meet STUDENT's needs for the 1998-99 school year? Petitioner substantially prevailed on this issue.
5. Are STUDENT's program, placement and services at Raskob appropriate to meet his needs, and should the Raskob program, placement and services (with the addition of speech and language services) be ordered prospectively to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
6. Should the District be ordered to provide speech and language therapy at Raskob to implement STUDENT's 1998-99 IEP and to provide him a consistent and coordinated program? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
7. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with providing the Raskob program to STUDENT, including tuition, transportation, and Dr. Antoniadis' services, during the 1998-99 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i) (1998).
Date: May 26, 1999 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ slightly in numbering and content from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis, to reflect the discussion held on the first day of hearing between the parties and the Hearing Officer with regard to the issues for hearing, and to comport with the Hearing Officer's finding that Petitioner was barred from raising any claims that accrued on or before June 23, 1995 (an explanation of which may be found in the section dealing with procedural matters).
2. The Hearing Officer was reluctant to dismiss issues without allowing the parties an opportunity to brief the matter. Additionally, Petitioner indicated that allowing such evidence would not unduly lengthen the hearing.
3. At the time, the IDEA was known as the Education of the Handicapped Act.
4. Formerly known as California Code of Civil Procedure § 338(1).
5. Petitioner cited Choctaw County Bd. of Educ., 25 IDELR 485 (SEA AL 1997), and Leake v. Berkeley County Bd. of Educ., 26 IDELR 401 (N.D. W.Va. 1997), in support of his position. These opinions are neither persuasive nor binding on a hearing officer sitting in California.
6. STUDENT repeated kindergarten upon the recommendation of his kindergarten teacher, who felt that he was not yet ready for first grade.
7. In 1997, the IDEA was amended (IDEA ‘97). Most of the provisions of IDEA ‘97 became effective on June 4, 1997; others became effective January 1, 1998, or July 1, 1998. Thereafter, changes were made to a number of State code provisions, and new federal regulations were issued to reflect the mandates of IDEA ‘97. Senate Bill No. 1686, which became effective January 1, 1999, amended various State statutes relating to special education. The Department of Education issued new regulations to accompany IDEA ‘97 on March 12, 1999. Petitioner's claims relating to the 1995 ESY, the 1995-96 school year, the 1996 ESY, and the 1996-97 school year arose prior to the enactment of IDEA ‘97. While IDEA ‘97 did not alter the general standards reflected in the IDEA, the Hearing Officer will apply the law and regulations that were in effect at the time the disputed events occurred in compliance with the general rules against the retroactive application of laws. Landgraff v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994).
8. As noted previously, STUDENT was retained in kindergarten and was thus a year older than most other children in his grade.
9. "S.S." refers to the standard score. "%ile" refers to the percentile rank. "Equiv." means equivalent.
10. IDEA ‘97 now requires that at least one regular education teacher attend a child's IEP meeting if the child is or may be participating in the regular education environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B)(ii) (1997). However, this particular provision of IDEA ‘97 did not become effective until July 1, 1998.
11. There was evidence that the IEP team also offered STUDENT placement in a special day class at Indian Valley Elementary School for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years. The parents declined the offer and, instead, chose to keep STUDENT at Parkmead. Because the District provided continued placement at Parkmead and STUDENT did not receive any services at Indian Valley, this decision will not deal with the appropriateness of the Indian Valley placement.
12. Ability and academic achievement testing conducted at about the same time showed that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement. However, the IEP team agreed at an IEP meeting held on March 31, 1998, when the results of the triennial assessment were reviewed, that STUDENT continued to need special education and related services, especially in light of his upcoming transition to middle school. STUDENT thus continued to remain eligible for special education at least through the end of the 1998-99 school year.
13. The counseling was provided for the purpose of addressing STUDENT's difficulties with peer interaction, but there was no direct evidence regarding the issues discussed in counseling.
14. "R.S." refers to the raw score
15. "G.E." refers to the grade equivalent.
16. The learning center was described as a type of special day class program designed for students who need the core curriculum modified to such an extent that it makes it difficult for them to keep up with the curriculum (i.e., those experiencing severe academic difficulties), making remedial instruction more appropriate.
17. Ms. Hopstone became a program specialist for the Contra Costa County Special Education Local Planning Area on February 1, 1999.
18. She was in the process of completing the final coursework required to receive her special education credential. She expected to complete the required coursework by March 1999.
19. The District was not required to offer STUDENT adapted physical education (APE), because STUDENT did not require APE in order to benefit from his education. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.5(a) (1988).
20. Moreover, assuming arguendo that the District's proposed program would have sufficiently addressed STUDENT's social skills deficits during the 1998-99 school year, the marginal amount of services being offered was not enough to fulfill the District's separate obligation to provide compensatory education to remediate its failure to address STUDENT's social skills deficits during the previous three years.
21. The evidence disclosed that OT and S/L services were not provided at Raskob because the parents were unable to afford the additional expense of these services. As the remainder of the Raskob program was appropriate, the absence of OT and S/L due to the parents' inability to financially afford the additional services does not render the placement inappropriate.
22. It should be noted that the District prevailed on two issues raised by Petitioner that were subsequently dismissed by the Hearing Officer in light of the three-year statute of limitations. (See the section entitled "Procedural Matter.")
