California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 8, 2000
Student v. Baldwin Park Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 931-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Baldwin Park Unified must treat student as emotionally disturbed from 1997-1998, provide counseling and tutoring, and repay one assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a separate pending case against Monrovia Unified (off calendar) and an earlier filing that did not reach hearing.
Summary
The parents of a 12-year-old seventh grader filed against Baldwin Park Unified School District in 1997. The District had repeatedly found him ineligible for special education. During the dispute he received home instruction, then attended Arcadia and Monrovia schools on interdistrict permits. Baldwin Park remained responsible for his education. The parents argued he qualified as emotionally disturbed, learning disabled, other health impaired, or speech-language impaired. They also sought repayment for three private assessments.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found he met the criteria for serious emotional disturbance starting in 1997-1998, but not in 1996-1997. Testimony from treating therapists showed long-lasting depression, inappropriate feelings in several settings, and physical symptoms tied to school problems. His grades also fell, and he needed counseling beyond regular education. He did not meet the relationship criterion, because it requires problems with both peers and teachers. The other eligibility claims failed. Test results were inconsistent, teachers saw no significant attention problems, and no language scores met the cutoffs. The District's 1997 and 1998 assessments were appropriate. However, it wrongly refused the parents' 1997 request for a speech-language assessment. It therefore had to repay the Erin Hyer and Associates assessment, but not those by Dr. Ponton or Dr. Hoagland. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days that included individual and group counseling, among other services. It also had to provide compensatory tutoring through 2000-2001.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO reviewed each emotional disturbance criterion separately, gave weight to treating therapists over a records-only reviewer, and dated eligibility from when the conditions became long-lasting and marked. It also shows that refusing a parent's request for an assessment after new information can lead to reimbursement of a private assessment.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partEligibility
Issue 1. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Student met ED criteria from the 1997-1998 school year on. He showed inappropriate feelings or behavior, pervasive depression, and physical symptoms over a long period and to a marked degree, and these adversely affected his education. He did not meet the criteria in 1996-1997, and he did not meet the relationship criterion, which requires an inability to relate to both peers and teachers.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
No processing disorder or consistent severe discrepancy was shown across assessments. Relative weaknesses could be addressed in regular education, so the student was not eligible as SLD.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as other health impaired (OHI) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Teachers consistently saw no significant attention problems. Claimed tics were not shown to limit strength, vitality, or alertness or to affect his education. He was not eligible as OHI based on attention deficit disorder or Tourette syndrome.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 4. Was STUDENT eligible for special education as speech and language impaired (S/L) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Test scores did not meet the regulatory cutoffs for a language disorder (1.5 standard deviations below the mean or below the 7th percentile), and the testifying speech-language pathologist found him not eligible. He did not qualify as speech or language impaired.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments they procured from Marcel Ponton, Ph.D., Erin Hyer and Associates, and Donald Hoagland, Ph.D.?
The District's 1997 and 1998 assessments were appropriate, so the Ponton and Hoagland assessments are not reimbursed. The District wrongly denied the parents' 1997 request for a speech-language assessment, so it must reimburse the Erin Hyer and Associates assessment.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what constitutes appropriate remedy(ies) for the District's failure to identify him for special education?
The District must convene an IEP meeting and include at least the components Dr. Totten recommended, including individual and group counseling. It must also provide compensatory tutoring in auditory processing and written language through the 2000-2001 school year. Parent training and a positive behavior intervention plan were not shown to be necessary.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the decision, Baldwin Park must convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and to determine placement and services. The team must include at least one Monrovia School District administrator (while the student attends Monrovia), one current teacher, and Dr. Totten.
- Order to provide or change services. At a minimum, the IEP must include: (a) placement to the fullest extent in regular education; (b) instruction in self-management strategies; (c) individual counseling; (d) group counseling to improve socialization and peer relationships; and (e) behavioral intervention strategies and instructional methods using positive reinforcement.
- Order to provide or change services. Within 25 days, Baldwin Park must arrange FAPE, including the instruction and services the IEP team determines, for as long as the student remains at Monrovia. It must stand ready to serve him if he returns to Baldwin Park.
- Compensatory education. Tutoring to remediate auditory processing delays and to develop strategies to improve written language, through the 2000-2001 school year. The IEP team sets the amount, considering the student's schedule and his tolerance for additional services.
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse the parents for the cost of the Erin Hyer and Associates speech and language assessment. No amount is stated.
Key authorities
School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Lester H. v. Gilhool (3d Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749; Landgraf v. USI Film Products (1994) 511 U.S. 244; 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320, 56329, 56333, 56337, 56381
People named in the decision
- Carolyn Coffey, director of pupil services, Baldwin Park Unified School District
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District (non-attorney), Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Norma Lopez-Reid, principal, Kenmore Elementary School, Baldwin Park USD
- Sahar Barsoum, school psychologist (initial assessment), Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Dorothy Burstein, supervising school psychologist, Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Delia Jaurequi-Rivera, fourth-grade teacher, Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Arturo Ortega, fourth-grade teacher, Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Ms. Clark, home instruction teacher, Baldwin Park Unified School District
- Christina M. Gershon, Ph.D. student assessor (supervised), LAC-USC Department of Mental Health
- Louise Macbeth, Ph.D., supervising psychologist, LAC-USC
- Bruce Spring, M.D., treating physician, LAC-USC
- Shawn T. Crombie, M.D., treating psychiatrist/therapist, LAC-USC
- Marcel O. Ponton, Ph.D., independent clinical neuropsychologist, private practice
- Joan M. Ybarra, Psy.D., treating clinical psychologist, witness for Student, Enki Youth and Family Services
- Dr. Basrai, psychiatrist (medication evaluation)
- Dr. Malon, treating provider
- Erin Hyer and Associates, private speech-language assessors, private provider
- Carl Totten, Psy.D., school psychologist (District-arranged assessment), witness for District, Alhambra School District
- Roberta Eckel, language and speech specialist (assessor), Los Angeles County Office of Education
- Donald Hoagland, Ph.D., independent assessor, expert witness for Student, private
- Terri Tibbets, Ph.D., expert witness for District (records review), Jurupa School District
- Ms. Luster-Carpenter, speech-language pathologist, witness for District
- Ophelia C. Barajas, after-school child care program director, YMCA
- Gloria Patterson, PAWS teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Amber Cole, language arts teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Ms. Griangregoria, math and science teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Tony Ellis, band teacher, Monrovia Unified School District
- Dedra Lutz, principal, Monrovia Unified School District
- Maria Calzada, child care provider and family advocate
- Carmen Guzman, certified Spanish interpreter
- Sophia Stutz, certified Spanish interpreter
- Cristina Bravo Diaz, certified Spanish interpreter
- Arther Lopez, Jr., Spanish interpreter
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Baldwin Park, California, on April 20 - 23, June 3, 4, and 21, August 23, and September 21, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Jane F. Reid. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his parents. Respondent Baldwin Park Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of the District was Carolyn Coffey, director of pupil services. Spanish language translation was provided on April 20, 1999, by Carmen Guzman, certified interpreter; On April 21 - 23, June 21, and August 23, 1999, by Sophia Stutz, certified interpreter; on June 3, 1999, by Cristina Bravo Diaz, certified interpreter; and on September 21, 1999, by Arther Lopez, Jr.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
(2) Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
(3) Was STUDENT eligible for special education as other health impaired (OHI) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
(4) Was STUDENT eligible for special education as speech and language impaired (S/L)during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
(5) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments they procured from Marcel Ponton, Ph.D., Erin Hyer and Associates, and Donald Hoagland, Ph.D.?
(6) If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what constitutes appropriate remedies for the District's failure to identify him for special education?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner STUDENT filed this case in July 1997 while receiving home instruction from the Baldwin Park Unified School District. During the second semester of the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT attended school in the Arcadia Unified School District on an interdistrict transfer permit. Arcadia revoked the interdistrict permit in June 1998. STUDENT has attended school in the Monrovia Unified School District pursuant to an interdistrict transfer permit since the 1998-1999 school year. It should be noted that at all times STUDENT's family has continued to reside within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Baldwin Park District and that the basis for STUDENT's attending school outside of the District was the ongoing dispute between STUDENT's parents and the District. Moreover, throughout the course of this lengthy dispute, the Baldwin Park District has continued to act as the district responsible for STUDENT's education. It has convened meetings of the individualized educational program (IEP) team and has arranged for STUDENT to be assessed. The Baldwin Park District never requested that either the Arcadia School District or the Monrovia School District be joined as a Respondent in this matter. The Baldwin Park District also did not request that this case be joined with a separate matter pending between Petitioner and the Monrovia School District. (Footnote 1) Thus, since neither the Arcadia District nor the Monrovia District has ever been a party to this matter, the Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction over them. In reliance on Baldwin Park's assumption of responsibility for STUDENT's education, the decision below addresses Baldwin Park's obligations to STUDENT.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner is a 12-year-old student in the seventh grade. STUDENT presently attends Santa Fe Middle School in the Monrovia Unified School District pursuant to an interdistrict transfer permit. STUDENT has never been found eligible for special education.
STUDENT entered kindergarten in the fall of 1992 and attended Kenmore Elementary School in the Baldwin Park District. STUDENT's parents noted concerns related to STUDENT's school performance during kindergarten, first, and second grades. According to STUDENT's parents, several incidents occurring just prior to and at the beginning of STUDENT's fourth-grade year (1996-1997) caused him to act out and exhibit signs of stress and depression. One of the incidents involved STUDENT's dispute with a neighborhood child. STUDENT believed that the neighbor had threatened him with a knife. The neighbor's younger brother then ran his bicycle over STUDENT's finger. STUDENT engaged a third child to "beat up" the first child; however, STUDENT's parents intervened. When STUDENT did not pay the student who had offered to beat up the neighbor, STUDENT and the child had an altercation at school that resulted in STUDENT's suspension. In early September 1996, a dog bit STUDENT. STUDENT continued to ruminate about his suspension, which he believed was a "grave injustice" against him. On at least two occasions during the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT attempted to strangle himself with his shoe laces. The school principal, Norma Lopez-Reid, suspended STUDENT a second time when he would not desist from circulating a petition at school calling for her removal as principal. STUDENT also claimed that Ms. Lopez-Reid had physically hurt him. The parents completed a Claim for Damages against the school.
On November 19, 1996, STUDENT's parents requested in writing that the District assess STUDENT for special education. On that same day, the District developed an assessment plan and the parents consented to the assessment; however, they requested that the school psychologist assigned to Kenmore not assess STUDENT. The District assigned Sahar Barsoum, a school psychologist from another school, to assess STUDENT. The assessment took numerous days to complete because of the parents' request that testing not occurred during the regular school hours, STUDENT's resistence to testing and missed appointments. Dorothy Burstein, supervising school psychologist for the District, completed the assessment when STUDENT refused to work further with Ms. Barsoum. The parents then filed their first request for a special education due process hearing. (Footnote 2) On February 5, 1997, the Individualized Educational Program (IEP) team met to review the results of the assessment. The meeting ended before the review was completed and the IEP was to be reconvened at a later date.
On February 6, 1997, STUDENT made a "citizen's arrest" of Ms. Lopez-Reid. Several weeks later, Ms. Lopez-Reid claimed that STUDENT struck her, filed a crime report, and suspended him. The parents declined to accept the District's offer to move STUDENT to any other elementary school in the District. On February 24, 1997, the District authorized home instruction of STUDENT because of "special circumstances." STUDENT's sister also received home instruction. The events occurring between STUDENT and the principal were part of the reason for STUDENT's receiving home teaching. During testimony, District personnel also cited conflicts with the family's advocate.
On March 6, 1997, the IEP team reconvened. The District members of the IEP team found STUDENT not eligible for special education. They concluded that the results of STUDENT's assessment revealed a discrepancy between STUDENT's cognitive potential and achievement in written language; however, the team did not find that STUDENT had a processing disorder. The District members of the IEP team also concluded that STUDENT had been doing well in school, was receiving grades of "B's" or above, was not exhibiting any behavioral problems in the classroom, and that his needs could be met through regular education instruction. In March 1997, STUDENT's parents took him to the Los Angeles County-University of Southern California (LAC-USC) Department of Mental Health because of ongoing concerns related to STUDENT's emotional functioning. STUDENT received therapy for symptoms of depression and anxiety. Trazondone, an antidepressant, was prescribed for STUDENT. In the report of an assessment completed on April 1, 1997, Christina M. Gershon, Ph.D. student under the supervision of Louise Macbeth, Ph.D., diagnosed a chronic adjustment disorder with anxious and depressed mood.
On July 7, 1997, the Hearing Office received a second request for a due process hearing from STUDENT's parents. On July 28, 1997, Marcel O. Ponton, Ph.D., licensed clinical neuropsychologist in private practice, completed a report of his neuropsychological evaluation of STUDENT that had been requested by his parents. Dr. Ponton concluded that STUDENT's receptive language skills in English were significantly discrepant with his expressive abilities. Dr. Ponton also found STUDENT to have spelling difficulties. Finally, Dr. Ponton concluded that STUDENT was experiencing "moderate to significant clinical depression and anxiety." Dr. Ponton recommended psychological treatment, reading and spelling remediation, and speech/language therapy.
STUDENT continued to receive home instruction at the beginning of his fifth-grade year in the fall of 1997. The parents obtained private counseling services for STUDENT from Joan M. Ybarra, Psy.D., of the Enki Youth and Family Services (Enki). Enki is a contract agency with Los Angeles County Mental Health. In November 1997, the IEP team convened to discuss Dr. Ponton's assessment. Dr. Ybarra participated in the IEP meeting. The District members of the IEP team again concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education. They concluded that STUDENT did not have a condition that affected his learning.
In December 1997, the parents sought a speech and language assessment from the District. An assessment plan was drafted; however, no assessment took place at that time. Following an incident in December 1997 at Dr. Ybarra's office which involved STUDENT's attempting to choke himself with a shoe lace in the rest room, Dr. Ybarra referred STUDENT to Dr. Basrai, a psychiatrist, for a medication assessment. Dr. Basrai diagnosed STUDENT with depression and recommended a trail of Paxil, an antidepressant medication. In January 1998, STUDENT entered the Arcadia Unified School District on an interdistrict transfer permit. STUDENT continued to see Dr. Ybarra until March 1998. During therapy with Dr. Ybarra, STUDENT reported leaving home one day with a baseball bat with the intent to harm Ms. Lopez-Reid after which he planned to kill himself by walking on the freeway. At the end of the school year, the Arcadia District canceled STUDENT's interdistrict permit citing unsatisfactory scholastic achievement as the reason.
During mediation on July 13, 1998, the District agreed to reassess STUDENT and to refer him to Mental Health. The assessment plan was developed and approved by the parents on that date. The District made two attempts to assess STUDENT; however, he refused to allow anyone from the District to assess him. In August 1998, STUDENT began seeing Shawn T. Crombie, M.D., of LAC-USC, for weekly therapy. Dr. Crombie prescribed Zoloft for STUDENT to treat an obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD). On August 28, 1998, the parents consented to the District's proposal to have STUDENT assessed by Carl Totten, Psy.D., school psychologist for the Alhambra School District, and Roberta Eckel, a language and speech specialist with the Los Angeles County Office of Education. It was also agreed that the District would make a referral to Mental Health.
During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT attended the sixth grade in the Monrovia Unified School District on an interdistrict transfer. Dr. Totten completed his assessment on October 21, 1998. His report of the assessment is dated January 9, 1999. Dr. Totten concluded that STUDENT exhibited a "moderate psychological processing disorder characterized by deficits in auditory memory and expressed in written language" and a "moderate social maladjustment characterized by chronic peer conflicts and feelings of moderate depression, suspiciousness, feelings of victimization and somatic concerns." Dr. Totten also concluded that the feelings did not rise to the level of pervasiveness, duration, or intensity required for a diagnosis of ED and did not have a severe adverse effect on STUDENT's educational performance. Dr. Totten recommended regular education with accommodations and counseling. The report of Ms. Eckel's speech and language assessment is dated December 7, 1998. Ms. Eckel concluded that STUDENT's overall receptive and expressive skills fell well within expectancy level for his age and that speech and language services were not warranted. The Mental Health report of its assessment is dated January 26, 1999. The assessment concluded that, because STUDENT did not qualify for special education services, he did not meet eligibility requirements for mental health services. Mental Health did not make any "formal" recommendations; however, the report does suggest that STUDENT continue with services provided by LAC-USC. On January 27, 1999, the IEP team met to discuss the results of the assessments. The District members of the IEP team again concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education.
STUDENT stopped seeing Dr. Crombie at the beginning of March 1999. As of April 4, 1999, STUDENT has received treatment from Dr. Malon. Also in April 1999, the Monrovia District suspended STUDENT and recommended his expulsion for possession of a pyrotechnic device. According to a Monrovia police report, the pyrotechnic device is more dangerous than either a firecracker or an M80. The parents filed a request for a special education due process hearing regarding the recommendation for expulsion. STUDENT continued to attend school in the Monrovia District pursuant to stay put. The parents obtained an independent assessment from Donald Hoagland, Ph.D. in March 1999. Dr. Hoagland concluded that STUDENT has learning disabilities, an attention deficit disorder, and speech and language impairments, and that he suffers from a serious emotional disturbance. Dr. Hoagland expressed the opinion that STUDENT satisfies special education eligibility criteria as a result of these conditions. STUDENT attended summer school in Monrovia and entered the seventh grade in the fall of 1999 at Santa Fe Middle School in the Monrovia District.
Petitioner contends that he meets special education eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED), specific learning disabilities (SLD) in written language and reading comprehension, and speech and language disorders (S/L). Petitioner also contends that he suffers from an attention deficit disorder (ADD) and Tourette Syndrome (TS), which qualify him for special education and services as other health impaired (OHI). Petitioner asserts that the IEP team should have found him eligible for special education and services following the District's initial assessment in 1997. The Baldwin Park District contends that Petitioner has never qualified for special education and services. The District asserts that its conclusion is based on multiple assessments of Petitioner and the fact that he has done well in regular education.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (Footnote 3) 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d)1997 (formerly found at 20 U.S.C. §1400(c)); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A "child with a disability" is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(3)(A)(1997)( formerly found at 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(a)(1)(A). A student is eligible for special education and services when, as a result of the student's disability, the student requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 565026(a) and (b).
Serious Emotional Disturbance (ED) Eligibility Criteria(Footnote 4)
A student meets eligibility criteria as ED when he/she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. tit.5 § 3030(i).
The student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as ED if the student is socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that the student has a serious emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(ii).
Petitioner contends that he is eligible for special education as ED under all of the categories above except the first category. The District asserts that Petitioner has always done well in school and does not have social/emotional problems that rise to the level of an ED.
Does STUDENT exhibit an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers?
As to STUDENT's relationship with peers generally, MOTHER testified that she is not familiar with STUDENT's friends, if he has any. She stated that no children invite STUDENT to their homes. MOTHER testified that her attempts to have children to their home and to facilitate interactions between STUDENT and other children have failed. Dr. Hoagland described STUDENT's relationships with peers as "transient."
In the fall of 1996, STUDENT's difficulties with peers escalated when he had a dispute with a neighbor child, which then carried over to school and ultimately resulted in his well-documented dispute with the principal. STUDENT's fourth-grade teachers at Baldwin Park testified that STUDENT's only problems at school were with the principal; however, they also stated that after incidents with the principal, other students did not want to work with STUDENT. Their recollections of STUDENT's behavior contrasts with their appraisal of his behavior in the during the 1996-1997 school year as a part of the District's initial assessment of STUDENT. On the Burks Behavior Rating Scale, Delia Jaurequi-Rivera, one of STUDENT's fourth-grade teachers, rated the following as "significant": excessive dependency, poor sense of identity, excessive suffering, poor anger control, and poor social conformity. She rated the following as "very significant": poor impulse control, excessive sense of persecution, excessive aggressiveness, and excessive resistance. The report of the assessment includes the following additional comments related to STUDENT's peer relationships:
Socially, he usually works well with others although he can and has become verbally and physically aggressive with peers when things do not go his way. Use of profanity was also noted by both teachers. His teachers also report that STUDENT seems to get along better with adults than peers and that he is not particularly well liked by classmates. Although he works with others in class and joins group games during breaks, he does not seem to have many friends.
(Petitioner's Exhibit 65, page 269)
Because STUDENT's teachers from Arcadia did not testify, there is limited evidence regarding STUDENT's social skills at school during the spring of 1998. Reports from the school indicate that STUDENT was disciplined on at least three occasions because of difficulties with other students and/or adults. He kicked another student, scratched someone's glasses, and brought a toy knife to school. (Petitioner's Exhibit 84)
During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT's teachers at Monrovia described disputes he had with one or more specific students. Dr. Totten, who assessed STUDENT in the fall of 1998 at the request of the District following a mediated agreement, stated that STUDENT experiences some social problems with peers. Dr. Totten testified that STUDENT has a "moderate social malady: characterized by peer conflicts." In his opinion, STUDENT's poor social adjustment interfered with his ability to attend and organize his thoughts. In his report, Dr. Totten stated the following:
Many of STUDENT's attitudes and behaviors are characteristic of an incipient personality disorder: affective instability, suicidal and homicidal ideation, unstable relationships with peers, feelings of being victimized, difficulty controlling anger, preoccupations with somatic concerns, and chronic feelings of boredom and suspiciousness. STUDENT seems to perceive himself as suffering but appears to lack the interpersonal skills to adequately resolve many of his interpersonal conflicts with peers.
(Petitioner's Exhibit 5, page. 45)
As part of his assessment, Dr. Totten gathered information from STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers at Monrovia. They all stated that STUDENT had adequate relations with his peers although he had some specific conflicts with specific students. On Ms. Cole's response, she noted that "STUDENT has had a series of social conflicts that have included teasing." She also indicated that STUDENT had some classroom friends but no close friends. Other teachers noted minor problems only with peers. STUDENT's teachers at Monrovia generally characterized their relationships with STUDENT as "good." (See Petitioner's Exhibit 77.)
Ophelia C. Barajas, director of the YMCA child care program STUDENT participated in during the 1998-1999 school year, described STUDENT as a "loner." She stated that he provoked other children and that his only contact with other children in the afternoon program was to pick on them or engage in fights with them.
Terri Tibbets, Ph.D., administrator of educational support services for the Jurupa School District, testified on behalf of the District. Dr. Tibbets testified that his review of STUDENT's records does not reveal an inability to build relationships. Dr. Tibbits testimony is unpersuasive. Dr. Tibbets reviewed STUDENT's educational records; however, he has not met STUDENT. Moreover, there is abundant evidence from the fourth grade to the present of STUDENT's conflicts with peers at school, in his neighborhood, and at an after-school program. This evidence was provided by STUDENT's treating therapists, his parents, and an administrator of an after school program, and is supported by treating notes and educational records. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT's ability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal peer relations is significantly impaired and has been since the 1996-1997 school year.
As to STUDENT's relationships with teachers, Dr. Hoagland, MOTHER, Dr. Ybarra, and Dr. Totten testified that STUDENT's ongoing sense of injustice at the hands of the principal, which began when he was in the fourth grade in Baldwin Park, has continued to distress STUDENT some three years later. STUDENT's distrust of adults was described by each of the persons who have assessed him. In 1997, he refused to complete testing with Ms. Barsoum and, in 1998, refused all testing by anyone from the District. When meeting independent assessors and mental health therapists for the first time, STUDENT demanded their credentials and needed a great deal of assurance related to the appropriateness of their qualifications prior to submitting to their assessing him. (Testimony of Ms. Ybarra, Dr. Hoagland, Ms. Burstein, and Dr. Totten.)
Ms. Clark, STUDENT's home teacher in the fall of 1997, described strained relationships with STUDENT, and Dr. Ybarra testified that two days after starting school in Arcadia in January 1998, STUDENT thought the teacher was "out to get him." In fact, STUDENT ended up being moved to a different class after accusing his first teacher of abusing him. Ms. Barajas testified that STUDENT also has had difficulty with counselors at his after-school program and does not accept authority well.
The evidence establishes that STUDENT has had many conflicts with teachers, principals, and others in authority; however, there also have been reports of satisfactory relations with teachers at Baldwin Park and with his teachers at Monrovia. The criterion discussed above appears to call for an inability to build or maintain relationships with peers and adults. (Emphasis added.) This is a very high standard. Taking the standard as it reads, to satisfy this criterion, STUDENT's difficulties with relationships must be both with peers and teachers. Because STUDENT has had some satisfactory relations with teachers, he does not meet the above criteria for ED.
Does STUDENT exhibit inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations?
MOTHER testified that since at least the1997-1998 school year, STUDENT has had difficulty controlling himself when he is angry. She described incidents of STUDENT's wetting himself, throwing glasses, and pounding on tables at home. MOTHER stated that STUDENT has nightmares, difficulty sleeping, and sleepwalks. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is fearful that people are following him and are listening to his conversations. She described STUDENT's checking doors multiple times at home. MOTHER testified that all of STUDENT's behaviors have escalated over time and she described several suicidal attempts that STUDENT has made at home. One involved taking broken glass from a picture to cut himself and another involved attempting to strangle himself with shoelaces.
Joan M. Ybarra, Psy.D., clinical psychologist, testified on behalf of STUDENT. Dr. Ybarra is the clinic manager for Enki Youth and Family Services, a contract agency for Los Angeles County Mental Health. Dr. Ybarra served as STUDENT's therapist from September 1997 to April 1998. She met individually with STUDENT and held additional sessions with his family. Dr. Ybarra described in detail many of the same concerns expressed above by MOTHER. Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT suffered from nightmares and headaches, and that he exhibited fear, sadness, and anger related to his perceived abusive treatment by the principal. She stated that STUDENT expressed to her that he wanted to die and, at times, also expressed an overwhelming desire to get revenge for perceived injustices he had suffered. Dr. Ybarra described STUDENT as "paranoid." As a result of his paranoia, he tape-recorded phone conversations and followed people. STUDENT locked himself in his room with a baseball bat for fear someone was coming to get him. Dr. Ybarra related an incident of STUDENT's misinterpreting her. She had suggested that STUDENT use a tape recorder to help him memorize the state capitals. STUDENT thought that she would use his recordings as a means to obtain information to use against him. Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT had delusions of grandiosity. He told her that "God had put him in his mother's womb and, therefore, he had special powers and was on earth to do something special." Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT perceives things that are said to him differently than others do. At one therapy session, Dr. Ybarra engaged in a "benign" discussion with STUDENT about a television program he had found offensive. He reported that this discussion led to his inability to do his homework because he had "sex on his mind." STUDENT also related how a halter and short outfit a nine-year-old neighbor child was wearing so offended him that he told the neighbor's father that it was "bad to allow her to dress like that."Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT has unreasonable fears, has nightmares, and is sad. He has an overwhelming desire to get revenge and has an unreasonable fear that teachers will hurt him. Dr. Ybarra testified that themes related to feelings of victimization, injustices, and preoccupation with revenge are seen throughout STUDENT's responses on the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) and the Sentence Completion Test. STUDENT also expressed thoughts of administering justice by harming the principal with a baseball bat and then killing himself. Dr. Ybarra took the threat so seriously that she informed authorities. Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT ruminates excessively about the injustices he has suffered. Dr. Ybarra's observations were supported by Dr. Basrais' notes of his sessions with STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibit 18) Finally, Dr. Ybarra testified that it is highly unusual for a child to be consumed two years later by the incident such as the one related to the principal at Baldwin Park.
There are additional incidents of unusual behavior throughout the record in this case. STUDENT believed that his first fifth-grade teacher at Arcadia abused him. In providing Dr. Totten input for his assessment of STUDENT, Ms. Cole, one of STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers, indicated that STUDENT had engaged in "bizarre or ‘crazy' behaviors." She explained that STUDENT started talking about "taking matters into my own hands . . . " (Petitioner's Exhibit 77, page 485) STUDENT has expressed suicidal ideation and made suicidal gestures several times since 1997. The most recent occurred during the spring of 1999 following the proposal to expel STUDENT because of his having the pyrotechnic device at school. STUDENT told Dr. Hoagland that he had suffered a great injustice because of the proposed discipline. Dr. Hoagland testified that STUDENT misinterprets his environment, distorts reality, and has psychosomatic complaints. Dr. Hoagland testified that STUDENT has "transient breaks from reality."
Dr. Totten and Dr. Tibbets, who testified on behalf of the Baldwin Park District, concluded that STUDENT's behavior did not rise to the level of an emotional disturbance. Dr. Tibbets has never met STUDENT. However, Dr. Totten has assessed STUDENT and, therefore, has some personal knowledge of him. Dr. Totten's report includes information that, to other assessors, was considered highly inappropriate under the circumstances. For example, Dr. Totten testified that STUDENT's three wishes--to "get rid of these problems; get even by putting the principal behind bars; and to get the owner of the dog that bit him"–illustrate STUDENT's continued obsession with incidents occurring two years earlier. (Petitioner's Exhibit 5, page 35)
As stated above, Dr. Ybarra testified that it is highly unusual for a child of STUDENT's age to ruminate excessively about something for several years. Dr. Hoagland, who also assessed STUDENT, concurs that STUDENT's ruminations are highly unusual. Dr. Hoagland's testimony establishes that STUDENT continued to experience the same feelings in 1999. Dr. Hoagland, Dr. Ybarra, and other witnesses also considered STUDENT's suicidal ideations and multiple suicidal gestures highly unusual. Dr. Ybarra provided therapy to STUDENT and his family and, thus, is very familiar with his behaviors and expressions of his feelings. She also observed firsthand some of STUDENT's more unusual responses to ordinary circumstances, such as his wanting to punish the principal and to remedy all perceived injustices. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Ybarra's testimony persuasive and concludes that STUDENT suffers from inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations, including home, school, and therapy sessions.
As to when STUDENT met the above criteria, the District's initial assessment indicated some concerns related to STUDENT's behavior; however, at that time STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors and feelings had not been exhibited to a marked degree or for a long period of time. By the fall of 1997, Dr. Ponton and Dr. Gershon had completed their assessments of STUDENT and therapy with Dr. Ybarra had been initiated. For example, STUDENT had continued to ruminate over incidents with the principal and the dog bites, had expressed suicidal ideation, had been diagnosed with depression, and continued to be placed on home instruction, where his grades were falling. It is noted that both Dr. Ponton and Dr. Ybarra attended the IEP meeting. Thus, there was substantial evidence that STUDENT met criteria of an emotional disturbance at the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year.
Does STUDENT exhibit a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression?
STUDENT's records are replete with comments related to depression. Treatment records from LAC-USC made in March 1997 indicate that STUDENT was being treated for depression and anxiety and that he was prescribed an antidepressant. Bruce Spring, M.D., stated in treatment notes in April 1997 that STUDENT expressed suicidal ideation to him. STUDENT's scores on the Children's Depression Inventory (CDI) administered by Ms. Gershon in April 1997 placed him in the mildly elevated range for depressive symptoms. Ms. Gershon reported that STUDENT "endorsed" suicidal ideation but reported that he did not intend to act on these thoughts. Her diagnosis was "Adjustment Disorder with Anxious and Depressed Mood, chronic." She also noted diagnosis of post traumatic stress disorder and major depression should be ruled out. (Petitioner's Exhibit 37) Dr. Ponton's report, which was completed July 1997, diagnosed STUDENT with severe childhood depression. He noted suicidal ideation as well. (Petitioner's Exhibit 35) (See also discharge summary dated June 30, 1997.) Dr. Ybarra diagnosed STUDENT with a chronic adjustment disorder accompanied by depression and anxiety. Dr. Hoagland testified that he diagnosed STUDENT with severe depression. On Dr. Hoagland's administration of the CDI, STUDENT's scores were indicative of severe depression. Dr. Hoagland also related a conversation he had with Dr. Crombie, who treated STUDENT in 1999. Dr. Crombie stated to him that he too had diagnosed STUDENT with depression. In summary, multiple psychologists and psychiatrists who have treated STUDENT over the past three years have given him a diagnosis of depression.
Dr. Totten, who testified on behalf of the District that STUDENT is not eligible for special education, nonetheless concluded that STUDENT experiences depression. Dr. Tibbets, who also testified on behalf of the District, concluded that if STUDENT were clinically depressed, it would be "unlike any case he has ever seen." For example, he would not expect STUDENT to be able to conceal his depression from his teachers at school. Dr. Tibbets also testified that depression is in response to internal stimulation that cannot be turned off and on at will. At least one teacher at Monrovia, Ms. Cole, observed "some" sadness in STUDENT lasting about 15 minutes at the beginning of her class. (Petitioner's Exhibit 77) Two teachers from Monrovia also identified characteristics of significant to very significant degrees of depression on the Devereux administered as part of Dr. Hoagland's assessment. (Petitioner's Exhibit 65) There also were reports of STUDENT's crying by the home teacher. Thus, the testimony of Dr. Tibbets, who has neither met nor assessed STUDENT, stands alone in conflict with the testimony by mental health specialists who have treated STUDENT and whose diagnosis of depression is supported by other mental health professionals who did not testify but who have treated STUDENT. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT suffers from depression.
There are notes of depression and suicidal ideation beginning in March 1997. (See Petitioner's Exhibits 35 and 37) At that time, STUDENT was receiving therapy from LAC-USC and an antidepressant had been prescribed. It was not then determined whether STUDENT was suffering from a single episode of depression related to his experiences with the principal and the dog bites; however, Dr. Ybarra's testimony establishes that by the time she began working with STUDENT in the fall of 1997, STUDENT's condition had existed for a long period of time.
Does STUDENT exhibit a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems?
A number of witnesses described STUDENT's physical symptoms associated with personal or school problems. MOTHER testified that she took STUDENT to doctors many times during 1997 in response to his complaints related to pain. She also described calls she received from school because of STUDENT's complaints related to illnesses. Ms. Clark stated that during her home teaching visits during the fall of 1997, STUDENT complained of stomachaches; however, in her opinion, the complaints were attempts to avoid having to do work. Ms Gershon noted "multiple vegetative symptoms such as difficulty sleeping, loss of appetite . . . " Dr. Ponton also described somatic complaints. (Petitioner's Exhibit 37) Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT voids his bladder in his clothes in stressful situations. She also described his fears associated with going to school. STUDENT told her that he believes that someone may hurt him at school. Dr. Hoagland testified that STUDENT's depression is revealed through psychosomatic complaints, and Dr. Totten concluded that STUDENT expressed somatic complaints related to being overweight, difficulty sleeping, and having headaches and stomachaches. Multiple assessors indicated that appointments were missed due to headaches or stomachaches and that STUDENT made similar complaints during testing.
The testimony related to STUDENT's somatic complaints was essentially undisputed by the District; however, Ms. Burstein testified that STUDENT is not ED for reasons that include the following. First, STUDENT's complaints are perpetuated by his parents, whom she described as "unduly involved" with STUDENT. Second, STUDENT has the same physical complaints as his sister. Dr. Hoagland described this condition known as "Folie a Deux" as a "shared delusion." Dr. Hoagland testified persuasively that neither STUDENT's mimicking of his sister's condition nor his parents paying too much attention to his problems changes or minimizes the fact that STUDENT has somatic complaints. Therefore, based on the testimony by the parents and assessors, it is concluded that STUDENT exhibits a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems. As discussed earlier, the reports of Dr. Ponton and Dr. Ybarra establish that STUDENT's physical symptoms and fears have been present since at least the beginning of the 1997 school year.
Has STUDENT exhibited characteristics of an ED over a long period of time?
As to whether STUDENT's conditions described above have existed for a long period of time, it has been concluded above that STUDENT began exhibiting difficulty with peers, depression, inappropriate feelings and behavior, and physical symptoms during the 1996-1997 school year. Thus, by the fall of 1997, these conditions had existed for a long period of time. It is also concluded that, based on the testimony of Dr. Totten and Dr. Hoagland, in particular, that STUDENT continued to exhibit the same characteristics at the time of the hearing.
Has STUDENT exhibited these characteristics of an ED to a marked degree?
Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT's ruminations about the dog bite and the perceived injustices he suffered at the hand of the principal were significant. She stated that STUDENT's anger permeated all aspects of his life and he failed to enjoy anything. Additionally, Dr. Ybarra determined that STUDENT's global assessment of functioning (GAF) was 40, which is an indication of a severe impairment in functioning. Dr. Ybarra concluded that STUDENT required a higher level of care than she was able to provide. She believed that he would be a candidate for medication and placement in a day treatment program. Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT's condition was manifested in several environments, including home, school, and her office. Ms. Barajas' testimony establishes that STUDENT's problematic behavior extended to his after-school program. MOTHER described STUDENT's problems at home and in the neighborhood. The testimony discussed above establishes that STUDENT's depression has resulted in suicidal ideation and suicidal gestures. Mental health professionals have treated STUDENT with therapy and medication. For these reasons, it is concluded that STUDENT exhibits conditions of an emotional disturbance to a marked degree.
Has STUDENT's condition adversely affected his educational performance?
To qualify for special education as ED, STUDENT's inappropriate types of behavior and feelings under normal circumstances, depression, and physical symptoms must adversely affect his educational performance. 34 C.F.R.§ 300.7(b)(9)(i); Cal. Code Reg. tit.5 § 3030(i).
Dr. Ybarra testified that STUDENT's emotional difficulties had an impact on his ability to function at school. He did not want to go to school because he was afraid of being hurt. At school, STUDENT was so anxious that he could not do tasks that he was capable of doing. Additionally, STUDENT's ruminations kept him from assimilating new information. In fact, STUDENT's obsession with obtaining justice led to his being removed from school and placed on home teaching.
Dr. Hoagland described STUDENT's conflict with the principal and the resulting emotional conditions as the "single most impacting force on STUDENT's life." Dr. Hoagland cited the following as examples. For two years in a row, STUDENT's fourth and fifth grade years, STUDENT was removed from school and placed on home teaching. Despite warnings that the interdistrict transfer would be canceled if his academic performance did not improve, STUDENT could not "pull it together" and improve his performance. By February of his sixth grade, STUDENT was receiving notices of failing grades and had an incident with a substitute teacher.
Dr. Totten also described ways in which STUDENT's depression has manifest itself in an educational environment. He stated that depression, along with feelings of victimization and somatic concerns, has resulted in STUDENT's experiencing difficulties with social adjustment, attending, and organizing his thoughts.
The effect on STUDENT's educational performance is also reflected in his declining grades. STUDENT's received all "A" and "B" grades in the fourth grade (1996-1997 school year). STUDENT's fourth-grade teachers, Arturo Ortega and Delia Jaurequi-Rivera, found no reason to refer STUDENT for special education. They described STUDENT as an "average" or "normal" student with slightly higher than average academic skills. Ms. Burstein testified that, at the time of testing, STUDENT was an average student doing primarily average work. He was at the top of his class in math, in the middle of the top of the class in reading, and in the middle of the class in written language. (Petitioner's Exhibits 71 and 75) In the report of the District's initial assessment, Ms. Jaurequi-Rivera noted that "his grades have been slipping in most subjects in her class since the November report card. She reported that this was primarily due to incomplete, missing, or messy work. (Petitioner's Exhibit 65, page 272)
Ms. Clark, STUDENT's home teacher at the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year, testified that STUDENT made progress while receiving home instruction and was functioning at grade level in reading and language; however, STUDENT's grades decreased significantly during the 1997-1998 school year. During the fall of 1997 while receiving home teaching, STUDENT received one "D," three "C-" grades, and one "A" in speaking. (Petitioner's Exhibit 26) In the fall of 1997, STUDENT received marks of "needs improvement" and "unsatisfactory" in social skills and work habits, whereas all previous school years STUDENT had received marks of "outstanding" or "satisfactory." (Respondent's Exhibit 33). STUDENT's grades slipped further when he entered Arcadia in 1998. Arcadia uses a grading scheme of from one to five. "One" indicates that the student has exhibited limited effort and progress. "Two" indicates the student shows effort but needs more time to meet curricular expectations. "Three" indicates the student is progressing and meets curricular expectations. While attending Arcadia for the last two quarters of the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT received only four "threes" out of a possible 33. Two-thirds of his other grades were "Ones." (Petitioner's Exhibits 13) STUDENT's interdistrict transfer to Arcadia was not renewed at the end of the 1997-1998 school year because of poor academic achievement.
The following teachers from Monrovia testified: Gloria Patterson, Personal Advancement with Support (PAWS) teacher; Amber Cole, language arts teacher; Ms. Griangregoria, math and science teacher; and Tony Ellis, band teacher. The principal, Dedra Lutz, also testified. They all had generally the same things to say about STUDENT. While at Monrovia, he initially had a number of tardies, engaged in a dispute with a specific student, and was suspended once; however, STUDENT's teachers otherwise described him as a regular sixth-grade student. STUDENT did show some improvement at Monrovia; however, he continued to receive some poor grades, including a "D" in social studies.
MOTHER contradicted the teachers' testimony. She stated that Ms. Cole, the vice principal, and Ms. Griangregoria have spoken to her regarding STUDENT's social problems with other students, including fighting both verbally and physically. Dr. Hoagland testified that the testimony of Ms. Cole and Mr. Ellis also was not consistent with their responses on the Devereaux, a measure of STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. According to Dr. Hoagland, one teacher's responses indicated STUDENT experiences a significant degree of interpersonal problems and very significant degrees of depression, physical symptoms, and fears. Mr. Ellis' scored the Devereaux similarly. (Petitioner's Exhibit 83) Dr. Hoagland testified that Ms. Cole told him that STUDENT is overly concerned about fairness.
Based on STUDENT's declining grades and poor social functioning at school, and primarily on the testimony of Dr. Hoagland and Dr. Ybarra that was discussed above, it is concluded that STUDENT's educational performance has been adversely affected by his emotional conditions since the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year.
Does STUDENT require instruction and/or services because of his ED which cannot be provided with modification to his regular program?
A student is eligible for special education and services when, as a result of the student's disability, the student requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 565026(a) and (b).
Since 1997, STUDENT has received individual and family therapy, and medications have been prescribed to alleviate the symptoms of his ED. One of the reasons Dr. Ybarra stopped treating STUDENT was that he needed a higher level of care than she was able to provide. Dr. Totten recommended that STUDENT continue receiving counseling to decrease depression, obsessive-compulsive thinking, tendencies toward somatization, sleep disorders, anger, suspiciousness, hypersensitivity and similar symptoms. Dr. Totten also recommended group counseling to improve socialization skills and peer relationships. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 5, page 47.) Dr. Hoagland's recommendations included psychological services that consist of school counseling, individual and family therapy, parent counseling, and parent training. He also recommended a psychiatric medication evaluation. Additionally, Dr. Hoagland stated that placement in a special day class or a nonpublic school for ED children could not be ruled out. (See also Petitioner's Exhibit 83, page 611.)
Individual and group mental health services are generally provided by psychologists, psychiatrists, marriage, family and child counselors, or other appropriately qualified mental health professionals. Therefore, the recommendations set forth above call for services that are above and beyond the services that are available in a regular education program. Based on this finding, STUDENT requires specialized services because of an ED which cannot be provided with modification to his regular program.
In summary, it has been concluded that STUDENT is eligible for special education instruction and services as a student with an ED based on the determination that has exhibited ED characteristics for a long period of time and to a marked degree that adversely affect his educational performance and for which he requires services that cannot be provided with modification to the regular education program. The evidence discussed earlier establishes that STUDENT met eligibility criteria beginning in the 1997-1998 school year and continuing.
ISSUE NO. 2: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
SLD Eligibility Criteria
The IDEA defines "specific learning disability" as a "disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which disorder may manifest itself in an imperfect ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations." 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(26). (Second Footnote 2) California Education Code § 56337 provides that a student has a SLD which makes the student eligible for special education and related services when it is determined that a severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in oral expression, listening comprehension, written expression, basic reading skills, reading comprehension, mathematics calculation, and/or mathematics reasoning. The discrepancy must be due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. Finally, the discrepancy cannot be corrected through services offered within the regular instructional program.
Basic psychological processes include "attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, conceptualization and expressive." Intellectual ability includes "both acquired learning and learning potential and shall be determined by a systematic assessment of intellectual functioning." Neither the District nor Ms. Gershon identified a psychological processing disorder. Dr. Ponton concluded that STUDENT's verbal and nonverbal memory, visual spatial skills, and psychomotor function were "intact." The only area of concern noted by Dr. Ponton was in the area of attention. In his report, Dr. Ponton stated that STUDENT had "diminished functioning in attentional tasks." (Petitioner's Exhibit 35)
No concerns were expressed by STUDENT's parents or teachers prior to or during his initial assessment related to STUDENT's attentional skills. The District's initial assessment of STUDENT also did not identify difficulties with psychological processing. Therefore, it is concluded that the information available to the IEP team in 1997 did not establish that STUDENT has a disorder in psychological processing. Moreover, given STUDENT's good grades and the comments from his teachers, and the testimony of Ms. Burstein, it is concluded that any areas of relative weakness could be and were being addressed in the regular instructional program. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not eligible for special education during the 1996-1997 school year because of an SLD.
Additional testing of STUDENT occurred in the fall of 1998 (Dr. Totten's assessment; Petitioner's Exhibit 5) and in March 1999 (Dr. Hoagland's assessment; Petitioner's Exhibit 83). Dr. Totten's assessment did identify some relative weaknesses in psychological processes and Dr. Hoagland testified that STUDENT has an attention disorder that would qualify STUDENT for special education. Dr. Hoagland based his conclusion on information obtained from STUDENT and his mother, on the results of the TOVA and the Hawthorne Attention Deficit Disorder Evaluation Scale-Second Edition (ADDES-2), and STUDENT's self rating on the criteria in the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of the American Psychiatric Association. On the ADDES-2, the scores resulting from MOTHER' ratings placed STUDENT within the deficient range of attention. (Petitioner's Exhibit 83)
Other assessors noted that STUDENT exhibited some inattention; however, other than Dr. Hoagland, none diagnosed STUDENT as having an ADD. Dr. Totten observed some fluctuation in STUDENT's ability to concentrate; however, Dr. Totten testified that there were no indications that any attentional problems STUDENT may exhibit affect his ability to function in school. Dr. Ponton commented that STUDENT was well behaved and paid attention to all instruction; however, Dr. Ponton also described STUDENT's attention as "variable." Significantly, Dr. Ponton did not diagnose an attention disorder. (Petitioner's Exhibit 35) Dr. Ybarra testified that any difficulties STUDENT exhibited concentrating likely were related to his ruminations and other emotional problems.
In summary, of the many persons who have assessed STUDENT, only Dr. Hoagland reached the conclusion that STUDENT has an attention disorder that would impact his eligibility for special education. Also of importance is the fact that none of STUDENT's teachers found STUDENT to exhibit attentional or concentration problems of any significance. STUDENT's teachers in the District, including his home teacher, Ms. Clark, did not express concerns regarding STUDENT's ability to attend or to concentrate. STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers from Monrovia also testified that they did not observe STUDENT to have attentional problems. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the consistent testimony of STUDENT's teachers, including his fourth- and sixth-grade and home teachers, the testimony of Dr. Totten and Ms. Burstein, who have assessed STUDENT, and the testimony of Dr. Ybarra, who treated STUDENT, that STUDENT does not have an attention disorder that is so significant as to adversely affect his education.
Moreover, comparisons of ability to achievement, as measured by tests administered by Dr. Totten, do not result in a severe discrepancy in any area of achievement. Therefore, testing by Dr. Totten does not corroborate Dr. Hoagland's finding of a severe discrepancy in written language. It should be noted that earlier testing by Dr. Goshen and Dr. Ponton also had inconsistent results as related to whether STUDENT exhibited a severe discrepancy in written language or reading. One assessment found a discrepancy in written language while the other did not. Conversely, one assessment found a discrepancy in reading while the other did not. Moreover, when discrepancies have been established, it has been on the basis of one test and on a discrepancy barely meeting the 1.5 standard deviation requirement.
In summary, some assessments show a discrepancy between reading and measures of abilities, others show a discrepancy between written language and ability, and others do not show any discrepancy between achievement and ability. It is anticipated that a learning disability would be consistently manifested across a number of instruments to constitute a learning disability under California special education law. Additionally, teachers testified consistently that STUDENT's relative academic weaknesses can be addressed by regular education instruction. For these reasons, it is concluded that testing after the 1997-1998 school year fails to establish learning disabilities which satisfy eligibility criteria for special education as SLD.
ISSUE NO. 3: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as other health impaired (OHI) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
OHI Eligibility Criteria
A student meets eligibility criteria for special education as OHI when the pupil has:
Limited strength, vitality, or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, severe asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil's educational performance . . . such physical disabilities shall not be temporary in nature. . . .
Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, 3030(f).
Petitioner contends that he has an attention deficit disorder and Tourette's Syndrome, which satisfy the criteria for special education eligibility as OHI.
Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD)
Dr. Hoagland testified that STUDENT's attention deficit disorder establishes eligibility criteria for special education as OHI. It has been concluded above that STUDENT does not have attentional problems that adversely affect his education. Similarly, the evidence does not establish that any variability in attention that STUDENT exhibits is either chronic or due to a chronic or acute health problem.The testimony of STUDENT's teachers as to his attentional skills was consistent and compelling, since they have had ongoing observations of him in their classrooms. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT as not met special education eligibility as OHI based on an attentional disorder.
Tourette's Syndrome (TS)
Dr. Hoagland concluded that STUDENT suffers from Tourette's Syndrome (TS). TS is characterized by involuntary motor and vocal tics. MOTHER testified that STUDENT makes noises, opens and closes his eyes, and twitches his mouth and nose. Other witnesses described limited observations of STUDENT's ticking and/or twitching. Ms. Cole, one of STUDENT's sixth-grade teachers, observed mouth and nose ticking. Ms. Clark, one of STUDENT's home teachers, observed that STUDENT twitched only in the presence of his parents or Maria Calzada. (Ms. Calzada provided child care for STUDENT and also served as his advocate.) Dr. Ybarra, who provided numerous therapy sessions to STUDENT, testified that she had not observed STUDENT to tic.
None of the witnesses described ticking or twitching that resulted in STUDENT's having limited strength, vitality or alertness. Additionally, none of the witnesses testified that any tics or twitching that STUDENT may exhibit have adversely affected his education. For these reasons, it is concluded that STUDENT has not met eligibility criteria for OHI on the basis of TS.
ISSUE NO. 4: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as speech and language impaired (S/L) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Speech and Language Eligibility Criteria
A student meets special education eligibility as speech and language impaired if the student has a speech or language disorder that makes it difficult to understand or use spoken language to the extent that it adversely affects the student's educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education or related services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56333.
A language disorder is established when the student scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean, or below the 7th percentile, for the student's chronological age or developmental level on two or more standardized tests in morphology, syntax, semantics, or pragmatics. A disorder may also be established when the pupil scores at least 1.5 standard deviations below the mean or the score is below the 7th percentile for the student's chronological age or developmental level on one or more standardized tests listed above and displays inappropriate or inadequate expressive or receptive language as measured by a language sample of at least 50 utterances. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(c)(4)(A) & (B).
During the 1996-1997 school year, no one expressed concerns regarding STUDENT's speech and language skills. The District's initial assessment of STUDENT did not evaluate STUDENT's speech and language skills, nor was it necessary to do so because neither speech nor language was a suspected area of disability. (See discussion below in regard to the District's assessments.) Thus, there is no basis for identifying a speech and language disorder during the 1996-1997 school year.
The first recommendation for speech and language services is contained in the report of Dr. Ponton's assessment of STUDENT. The report is dated July 28, 1997. Dr. Ponton recommended speech and language therapy to address a receptive language "problem" in English that he found discrepant with STUDENT's expressive language abilities. First, Dr. Ponton's conclusion that STUDENT has a language deficiency was not reached using the same standard used to establish special education eligibility. Moreover, none of STUDENT's scores on standardized tests administered by Dr. Ponton fell below the 7th percentile.
The next speech and language assessment was completed by Erin Hyer and Associates in November 1997. Their report assessment does not make a determination of STUDENT's eligibility for special education. For the most part, the scores are reported as age scores. The report also includes a note that "STUDENT's age is one year beyond norms. Therefore, unable to report Standard Score and Percentile Rank." It is unclear whether this comment applies to the Woodcock Language Proficiency Test as well as the Phonological Awareness Test. In any case, neither standard nor percentile scores are reported for either test. Thus, absent testimony from the assessors to the contrary, the results on these two measures cannot be relied upon in making a determination as to special education eligibility. STUDENT's score on the CELF is reported at the 10th percentile and his score on the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude Primary is reported at the 16th percentile. Both of these scores are higher than the percentile scores needed to establish eligibility for a speech or language disability.
The Arcadia District provided STUDENT with support services in English language development. These services are available to students whose home language is other than English and who do no pass fluency tests. None of STUDENT's teachers from Arcadia testified and there was no evidence that eligibility for the Arcadia program is related to special education eligibility.
As to the 1998-1999 school year, Ms. Eckel, who assessed STUDENT in November 1998, found STUDENT's performance on language testing indicatives receptive and expressive skills "well within expectancy level for his age." Ms. Eckel concluded that language therapy was unwarranted. The lowest score STUDENT obtained was on a subtest of the Test of Problem Solving; however, his score fell in the 13th percentile. On the Clinical Evaluation of Language Functions, STUDENT performed below age expected criteria in Oral Directions and Spoken Paragraphs; however, he fell below his grade level by only one point in each area. His total processing on the battery fell in the 45th percentile. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6)
Dr. Hoagland testified that, based on assessments by Dr. Totten and Ms. Eckel, and on his own administration of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-Third Edition (CELF-3), he concluded that STUDENT has oral language deficits that would qualify him for special education. In his report, Dr. Hoagland stated that "One of the language measures of the current evaluation fell below a standard score of 78, as did one during the district's speech and language assessment and two during its psycho-educational evaluation." As to the test results upon which Dr. Hoagland relied, the only score more than one standard deviation from the mean on Ms. Eckel's testing was on the dictation subtest of the Elementary Word-R Test. In the body of his report, Dr. Hoagland discounts the use of the Elementary Word-R Test. He states on page 58 of Exhibit 83 that "the fact that this measure is not listed in the 809-page Tests: A Comprehensive Reference for Assessment in Psychology, Education, and Business Fourth Edition, 1997, nor in any of the current catalogs of major test publishers raises concern that may also be obsolete." On Dr. Hoagland's administration of the CELF-3, STUDENT's sole score below the 7th percentile was in an optional subtest entitled "Listening to Paragraphs." STUDENT's standard score was 75, which is three points below 1.5 standard deviations from the mean. (Page 81 of Petitioner's Exhibit 83)
Witnesses testifying on behalf of the District did not concur with Dr. Hoagland's conclusions. Dr. Totten, who also conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT, testified that he did not find any evidence of a language deficit, given that STUDENT's overall scores were in the average range and any slight deficits did not interfere with his ability to communicate. The only speech and language therapist to testify, Ms. Luster-Carpenter, concluded that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria. Ms. Luster-Carpenter did not assess STUDENT; however, she reviewed the results of testing and was the only witness holding the appropriate credentials to reliably comment in the area of speech and language. Therefore, based on her testimony, the findings of Ms. Eckel, who also is a speech and language pathologist, and the fact that testing fails to establish that STUDENT satisfies the definition of a language disability under the Education Code, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT is not eligible for special education because of a speech and/or language disability.
ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments they procured from Marcel Ponton, Ph.D., Erin Hyer and Associates, and Donald Hoagland, Ph.D.?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency's assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Additionally, individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. Assessments must include tests and other test materials that assess specific areas of educational need and that do not just provide a single general intelligence quotient. Assessment and testing materials also must not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.
Subsection 56320(e) states that no single procedure shall be used as the "sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs." Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324(a) and (b). Section 56322 additionally states that assessments shall be conducted by "persons competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area."
The primary concern expressed by Petitioner is whether the District adequately assessed him in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, Petitioner asserts that the District's assessments did not assess his attentional and psychological processing skills. Petitioner also asserts that the District's assessment of his social/emotional skills was inadequate. Finally, Petitioner asserts that the District's assessments should have included measures of his speech and language skills. The disputed assessments of Petitioner occurred in 1997 and in 1998.
A. Did the District conduct appropriate assessments of STUDENT?
The District's Initial Assessment Completed in January 1997
The results of the District's initial assessment of STUDENT are contained in a report dated February 4, 1997. (Petitioner's Exhibit 65) The initial testing was administered by credentialed school psychologists Ms. Barsoum and Ms. Burstein. (Second Footnote 3) Ms. Barsoum obtained developmental, medical, and educational histories through interviews with STUDENT's family and teachers. The assessment included a health screening completed by the nurse and an observation of STUDENT in the classroom. Testing consisted of measures of STUDENT's cognitive abilities, his academic achievement, visual-motor functioning, and social/emotional functioning. To assess cognitive abilities, the District administered the Stanford Binet Intelligence Scale-Fourth Edition (SB-4). To assess academic achievement, the District administered the Woodcock-Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery-Revised (WJ-R). To assess visual-motor functioning, the District administered the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration-3 Revision (VMI-3R). The District administered a number of measures to assess STUDENT's social/emotional functioning including the Goodenough Draw-A-Person (DAP), the Burks' Behavior Rating Scale, the Student Self-Esteem Scale, and the Forer Structured Sentence Completion Test. STUDENT's father, mother, and teacher completed the Burks.
The District's assessment of STUDENT was not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Thus, the requirements of Education Code § 56320(a) were satisfied. Spanish is the family's predominant language; however, as observed during the hearing, STUDENT's mother converses competently in English and, according to multiple teachers and assessors, STUDENT is fluent in both Spanish and English. Since entering school, STUDENT has received instruction in English. A Pre-language Assessment indicated that STUDENT had higher English than Spanish language skills, with proficiency demonstrated in both. (See Petitioner's Exhibit 65) For these reasons, it is concluded that testing STUDENT in English satisfied the requirements of Education Code § 56320(b)(1). Both Ms. Barsoum and Ms. Burstein are credentialed school psychologist and are knowledgeable of students with learning disabilities and social/emotion difficulties. Therefore, the requirements related to the qualifications of the assessors have been satisfied. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3) and (g), 56322, and 56324(a) and (b).
No one challenged the way in which the assessment was administered to STUDENT. As to the instruments used, the evidence establishes that the assessment included test instruments that are frequently employed by educators and psychologists to assess students who may exhibit learning and/or social/emotional difficulties. The instruments employed several measures to assess STUDENT's cognitive abilities, academic achievement, and social/emotional functioning. Additionally, STUDENT's parents and teacher completed rating scales regarding STUDENT's behavior and the assessment included observations of STUDENT in school and in test environments. Thus, no single procedure was used in making decisions regarding STUDENT, satisfying the requirement of Education Code § 56320(e).
Dr. Hoagland testified in support of Petitioner's assertion that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Dr. Hoagland testified that the Stanford-Binet standing alone was insufficient to assess STUDENT's processing skills and, in fact, STUDENT's scatter scores on the Stanford-Binet suggested the need to for further assessment of his processing skills. Dr. Hoagland also testified that STUDENT's attentional problems should have been identified by the District. Ms. Burstein, who provided most of the testimony related to STUDENT's initial assessment by the District, concluded that the District assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Ms. Burstein also testified that all of STUDENT's scores on all measures of testing fell within in the average range and that, therefore, there were no indications that further assessments were warranted. STUDENT earned standard scores of 113 on verbal reasoning, 92 on abstract/visual reasoning, 103 on quantitative reasoning, 95 on short-term memory, and a composite abilities score of 101. On measures of academic achievement, STUDENT earned standard scores of 100 in reading, 111 in mathematics, and 91 in written language. (Petitioner's Exhibit 65)
As to whether the initial assessment evaluated STUDENT's attentional skills, Ms. Burstein's testimony establishes that information regarding STUDENT's attentional skills was obtained through observations of STUDENT during testing and in the classroom, and through responses on the Burks completed by STUDENT's parents and Ms. Rivera, one of STUDENT's regular education teachers. The assessment did not reveal any deficiencies related to his attentional skills. The observations of the assessors during testing was that STUDENT was focused and attentive. Their observations during class were generally the same. Neither the responses on the Burks by STUDENT's parents nor those by Ms. Rivera identified attention as an area of concern. A subsequent assessment by LAC-USC shortly after the District's assessment includes Ms. Calzada's responses to the Attention Deficit Hyperactive Disability Rating Scale IV. Ms. Calzada identified some concerns related to attention; however, the assessor noted that her ratings fell below criteria for an attention disorder. (Petitioner's Exhibit 37) Moreover, attention was not an area of suspected disability. The initial referral for assessment was not made because of concerns related to attention and there is no credible evidence that either STUDENT's parents or his teachers during the 1996-1997 school year had expressed concerns related to these areas. In summary, the District's initial assessment did evaluate STUDENT's attentional skills and there was no evidence that attention was an area of suspected disability.
As to whether the initial assessment evaluated other psychological processes, Ms. Burstein's testimony establishes that the District's administration of the Stanford-Binet provided information regarding STUDENT's abstract visual processing, verbal reasoning, and memory. The District's assessment also included the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration-3 Revision (VMI-3R), which assessed his visual-motor functioning. STUDENT's skills fell within the average range on all measures. A subsequent administration of the VMI placed STUDENT in the 68th percentile, which also placed him within the average range. (Second Footnote 4) (Petitioner's Exhibit 37) The assessment did not specifically measure STUDENT's auditory skills or sensory-motor skills, except in the area of visual-motor; however, the evidence did not establish that the District was required to assess all areas of psychological processes given that STUDENT's scores in measures of ability and achievement all fell within average ranges.
The initial referral for special education did not indicate concerns related to STUDENT's speech and language skills and no concerns in these areas were expressed by STUDENT's parents and/or teachers during the assessment process. As a matter of fact, STUDENT's expressive language skills were viewed by assessors and teachers alike as an area of strength. Moreover, STUDENT's scores on testing in academic and cognitive areas fell within the average or above-average range. Thus, at this point, there was no indication that speech and language testing was necessary or that speech and language were areas of suspected disability. Therefore, it is concluded that at the time of STUDENT's initial assessment, the District was not required to undertake a speech and language assessment. (Footnote 5)
As to the District's assessment of STUDENT's social/emotional functioning, the evidence establishes that the District employed four measures to assess STUDENT's social and emotional functioning. Both of STUDENT's parents and one of his teachers completed the Burks. Petitioner asserts that the responses by STUDENT's parents and his teacher should have alerted the District to the need to further assess STUDENT's social/emotional functioning. The responses by STUDENT's parents resulted in significant scores indicating excessive self-blame, anxiety, and suffering, and poor anger control. STUDENT's teacher indicated six areas as significant and poor impulse control, excessive sense of persecution, excessive aggressiveness, and excessive resistance as very significant. Despite these concerns, other measures of social/emotional functioning were not indicative of poor social/emotional functioning. Moreover, STUDENT scored high on measures of self-esteem, obtained average scores on academic achievement, and was receiving good grades in school. Given the number of measures employed by the District to assess STUDENT's social/emotional functioning and in light of the evidence that STUDENT was learning and achieving at school, as measured by standardized tests and grades, it is concluded that the District adequately assessed STUDENT's social/emotional functioning.
Because the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320, 56322, and 56324 have been satisfied, it is concluded that the District completed an appropriate assessment of STUDENT
Subsequent Referral for Speech and Language Assessment
An assessment must be completed every three years or when conditions warrant or "if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed." (Emphasis added.) Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). Petitioner asserts that the District had an obligation to undertake a speech and language assessment when, following Dr. Ponton's recommendation for speech and language therapy in July 1997, the PARENTS requested a speech and language assessment.
The evidence establishes that the parents disagreed with the District's assessment of STUDENT and with the conclusion by the District members of the IEP team that STUDENT did not meet eligibility criteria for special education. The evidence further establishes that the parents sought an independent psychoeducational assessment from Dr. Ponton in July 1997 because of their ongoing concerns related to STUDENT's social/emotional functioning and learning difficulties they believed he was experiencing. Based on his assessment of STUDENT in April and June 1997, Dr. Ponton concluded the following:
. . .cognitively the child [STUDENT] has a receptive language problem in English, which is significantly discrepant with his expressive abilities. This most likely represents a communication disorder not otherwise specified (DSM IV 307.9).
Dr. Ponton went on to state that "the child will require speech therapy for his receptive language skills in English by a bilingual therapist." (Petitioner's Exhibit 35.) MOTHER testified that she provided a copy of Dr. Ponton's report to the District.
Whenever an assessment is to be conducted, the District is required to provide the parent in writing a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56321(a) and 56344. Accordingly, the District should have developed an assessment plan to the parents in response to their request for a speech and language assessment. Instead, on September 19, 1997, the District denied the parents' request for a speech and language assessment. In a letter to the parents, Ms. Coffey explained the District's position as follows:
. . .STUDENT was thoroughly evaluated last school year and there was no indication of any need for such an assessment. Additionally, during the extensive communications from you, the mediation, and the lengthy IEP meeting, neither you nor your advocate, Mrs. Calzada, requested such an assessment nor did you indicate any concern regarding this area.
Petitioner's Exhibit 32.
The District also informed the parents of their right to obtain an independent assessment and to challenge the District's decision at a due process hearing.
Given the new information provided by Dr. Ponton's report, his recommendation for speech and language therapy, and because a speech and language assessment of STUDENT by a speech and language pathologist had not been completed, it is concluded that the parents' request for a speech and language assessment obligated the District to conduct such an assessment following the parents' request.
The District's Second Assessment Completed in 1998
At the request of the District, a second assessment of STUDENT was conducted in September and October 1998 by Dr. Totten, a school psychologist with the Alhambra School District. The report of Dr. Totten's assessment dated January 9, 1999, is contained in Petitioner's Exhibit 5. The assessment included measures of cognitive, language, academic, adaptive, and social/emotional functioning. Dr. Totten also assessed STUDENT's psychological processing skills.
Dr. Totten conducted clinical interviews with STUDENT and his mother, reviewed educational records and prior assessments, consulted with Ms. Coffee and Ms. Burstein, and administered a comprehensive battery of psychoeducational measures. To assess STUDENT's cognitive skills, Dr. Totten administered the WISC-III. To assess psychological processes, Dr. Totten administered the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt Test (Bender), the developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI), and the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills-Revised (TAPS-R). To assess STUDENT's language skills, Dr. Totten administered Dos Amigos Verbal Language Scales. To assess academic achievement, Dr. Totten administered the Woodcock Mini-Battery of Achievement (MBA) and the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Essential Skills. To assess adaptive and social/emotional functioning, which were areas of particular concern to STUDENT's parents, Dr. Totten administered the Personality Inventory for Youth (PIY), the Conner's Parent Rating Scale-Revised, the Childrens Depression Inventory (CDI), the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT), the Draw A Person Test (DAP), the Kinetic Family Drawing Test (KDF), and the House-Tree-Person Test (H-T-P). STUDENT also completed a self-portrait and was asked to describe his three wishes.
Dr. Totten's assessment of STUDENT was not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Dr. Totten is a credentialed school psychologist, a licensed educational psychologist, and holds a doctoral degree in psychology. No one challenged the way in which the assessment was administered or the instruments that Dr. Totten used. The list of test instruments utilized by Dr. Totten to assess STUDENT is extensive and included observations, interviews and rating scales completed by MOTHER, and thus, no single procedure was used to make decisions regarding STUDENT. For these reasons, Dr. Totten's assessment satisfied the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320(a) - (e), 56322, and 56324(a) & (b).
Petitioner raised few concerns related to the adequacy of Dr. Totten's assessment. Dr. Hoagland testified that Dr. Totten did not conduct a "full assessment," in part, because he failed to administer two subtests of the WISC that would have provided additional information regarding STUDENT. Despite this testimony, Dr. Hoagland stated that, according to the test manual, the two subtests of the WISC Dr. Totten did not administer are optional.
The evidence establishes that Dr. Totten conducted a thorough and comprehensive assessment of STUDENT. As to concerns related to assessment of STUDENT's psychological processes, the evidence establishes that Dr. Totten utilized several measures to evaluate STUDENT's psychological processing skills. These measures were described above. As to concerns related to assessing STUDENT's attention, Dr. Totten testified that the WISC digit span subtest, the Bender, the Connors, and his personal observations assessed STUDENT's attention. A separate evaluation of STUDENT's speech and language was completed by Ms. Eckel, a language and speech specialist with the Los Angeles County Office of Education. (Petitioner's Exhibit 6.) The speech and language assessment included the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised, the Elementary Word-R Test, the Test of Problem Solving, and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Functions, Diagnostic Battery.
Petitioner did not present any credible evidence to support his contentions that the District's assessments, particularly when taken together, were deficient. Because the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320, 56322, and 56324 have been satisfied, it is concluded that the District has completed a second appropriate assessment of STUDENT, except as concluded above in relation to its failure to timely complete a speech and language assessment.B. Parents' entitlement to reimbursement.
Dr. Ponton's Assessment
The parents seek reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Ponton's assessment completed in June 1997. (Petitioner's Exhibit 35) It has been concluded above that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT in January 1997. Therefore, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of Dr. Ponton's assessment.
Speech and Language Assessment by Erin Hyer and Associates
The parents seek reimbursement for the costs of the speech and language assessment conducted by Erin Hyer and Associates in October 1997. (Petitioner's Exhibit 23.) STUDENT's parents requested that the District assess STUDENT's speech and language in response to Dr. Ponton's recommendation for speech and language therapy. Dr. Ponton is a psychologist. When the District declined to have a speech and language pathologist assess STUDENT, the evidence establishes that the parents procured an independent speech and language assessment from licensed speech and language pathologists. The assessment by Erin Hyer and Associates included administration of the Woodcock Language Proficiency Battery-Revised, the Phonological Awareness Test, the Lindamood Test of Auditory Conceptualization, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Functions, and the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude. The District did not undertake a speech and language assessment of STUDENT until November 1998. Therefore, in light of the District's failure to assess, the parents are entitled to relief in the form or reimbursement for the costs of the assessment by Erin Hyer and Associates.
Dr. Hoagland's Assessment
There are no grounds for awarding reimbursement for Dr. Hoagland's assessment. As discussed above, the District's assessments in 1997 and 1998 were appropriate. Therefore, the request for reimbursement is denied.
ISSUE NO. 6: If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what constitutes appropriate remedy(ies) for the District's failure to identify him for special education?
The Hearing Officer now turns to the task of determining appropriate remedies that both will address STUDENT's significant needs and redress the District's failure to properly identify STUDENT as a student with an emotional disturbance that meets special education eligibility criteria. The Hearing Officer has authority to order appropriate relief for the failure to provide FAPE. School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369. In Burlington, the Supreme Court concluded that equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. See also Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
Petitioner's proposed resolution for the District's failure to find him eligible for special education, which has resulted in the denial to him of a free appropriate public education (FAPE), is to order the District to develop an IEP containing an appropriate program and placement for him. Petitioner asserts that an appropriate educational program contains at least the following components: individual, group, and family counseling, social skills training, parent training, direct instruction to address his areas of learning disability, and a positive behavior intervention plan. Petitioner also seeks compensatory education that, at a minimum, includes the above components.
Given the finding that STUDENT has met special education eligibility because of an emotional disturbance, a necessary first step is for the IEP team to convene to develop goals and objectives and to identify appropriate services and placement to meet STUDENT's needs. As to whether certain components should be included in STUDENT's initial IEP, Dr. Totten, who completed a thorough assessment of STUDENT in 1998, made the following recommendations: placement to the fullest extent in the regular education environment; instruction in self-management strategies to minimize anxiety and to improve his ability to remain focused and better organized; counseling to exhibit more trust in his environment, and to decrease feelings of depression, obsessive-compulsive thinking, tendencies towards somatization, sleep disorders, anger, suspiciousness, hypersensitivity, and similar symptoms; group counseling to improve socialization skills and optimize peer relationships; behavioral intervention strategies and instructional methods which provide positive reinforcement for appropriate behaviors and learning. Dr. Totten also recommended "approaching STUDENT in a mature, respectful manner to enhance thrust and continued cooperation will prove useful. Both educators and family members are encouraged to provide him with consistent, firm, yet fair expectations at home and at school." (Petitioner's Exhibit 6, page 47) Dr. Totten's recommendations were generally consistent with recommendations of other assessors, including Dr. Hoagland, and with STUDENT's needs discussed at the hearing. There was no persuasive evidence that parent training is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education of that a positive behavior intervention plan is currently necessary. Therefore, based on Dr. Totten's testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that, at a minimum, STUDENT's IEP must include the components listed above.
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) (Footnote 8) The District has never found STUDENT eligible for special education. It has been concluded above that STUDENT has an emotional disturbance for which he met special education eligibility criteria as of the fall of 1997. During the fall of 1997, STUDENT received one hour daily of home teaching. He received minimal educational instruction and did not receive any special education services. The parents had to arrange for mental health services on their own to address STUDENT's social and emotional difficulties. (Footnote 9) The services they provided have not ameliorated STUDENT's problems. He has shown some improvement of late as a result of a newly prescribed medication. STUDENT's grades deteriorated, particularly during the 1997-1998 school year. Therefore, it is also concluded that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory remedies for the period the District had failed to determine him eligible for special education.
As to the appropriate form of compensatory services, there was no persuasive evidence that services to supplement those determined above as necessary components of an appropriate placement for STUDENT would be beneficial to STUDENT. STUDENT has identified relative weaknesses in auditory processing and written language. These relative weaknesses were not sufficiently addressed in the fall of 1997 and thereafter. It is anticipated that STUDENT would have shown growth in academics, given his average or better cognitive skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that appropriate compensatory remedies include tutoring to remediate auditory processing delays and to develop accommodating strategies to improve written language. These remedies are consistent with Dr. Totten's recommendations and the evidence related to STUDENT's education skills. These services shall be provided through the end of the 2000-2001 school year at a rate to be determined by the IEP team. The IEP team shall take into consideration, STUDENT's schedule and his tolerance for additional services.
ORDER
(1) Petitioner met eligibility criteria for special education instruction and services as a student with a serious emotional disturbance beginning as of the 1997-1998 school year.
(2) Within 15 days of the date of this decision, the Baldwin Park District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and to determine appropriate placement and services for STUDENT. The IEP team shall include at least one administrator from the Monrovia School District, so long as he continues to attend school in Monrovia, one of STUDENT's current teachers, and Dr. Totten. At a minimum, the services shall include the following components contained in Dr. Totten's report:
(a) placement to the fullest extent in the regular education environment; (b) instruction in self-management strategies to minimize anxiety and to improve his ability to remain focused and better organized; (c) individual counseling to exhibit more trust in his environment, and to decrease feelings of depression, obsessive-compulsive thinking, tendencies towards somatization, sleep disorders, anger, suspiciousness, hypersensitivity, and similar symptoms; (d) group counseling to improve socialization skills and optimize peer relationships; and (e) behavioral intervention strategies and instructional methods which provide positive reinforcement for appropriate behaviors and learning.
(3) Within 25 days of the date of this decision, the Baldwin Park District shall arrange for provision of a free appropriate public education for STUDENT, including instruction and services determined by the IEP team, for as long as he remains at Monrovia, and shall stand ready to provide instruction and services to STUDENT upon his return to Baldwin Park.
(4) As compensatory remedies, the Baldwin Park School District shall provide tutoring to STUDENT to remediate auditory processing delays and to develop accommodating strategies to improve written language through the 2000-2001 school year. The specific amount of services shall be determined by the IEP team, which shall consider STUDENT's schedule and his ability to tolerate additional services.
(5) Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT's parents for the costs of the speech and language assessment conducted by Erin Hyer and Associates.
(6) All of Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
ISSUE NO.1: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance (ED) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
Petitioner prevailed as of the 1997-1998 school year to the present. ISSUE NO. 2: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as a student with a specific learning disability (SLD) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
The District prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 3: Was STUDENT eligible for special education as other health impaired (OHI) during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
The District prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 4 Was STUDENT eligible for special education as speech and language impaired (S/L)during the 1996-1997, 1997-1998, 1998-1999, and 1999-2000 school years?
The District prevailed on this issue.
ISSUE NO. 5: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of independent assessments they procured from Marcel Ponton, Ph.D., Erin Hyer and Associates, and Donald Hoagland, Ph.D.?
Petitioner prevailed with respect to the assessment by Erin Hyer and Associates. The District prevailed with respect to assessments by Dr. Ponton and Dr. Hoagland.
ISSUE NO. 6: If STUDENT is eligible for special education, what constitutes appropriate remedy(ies) for the District's failure to identify him for special education?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
DATED: February 8, 2000 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
*The footnotes in this decision were inadvertantly miss numbered. There will be no footnotes for numbers 6 and 7.
1. The Baldwin Park District failed to submit a brief in response to the Hearing Office's request on the issue of whether the interdistrict transfers had any effect on the outcome of this case.
2. The present case is the parents' second filing on behalf of STUDENT. The first case did not result in a hearing. A third case pending against the Monrovia Unified School District is currently off calendar.
3. In 1997, the IDEA was amended (IDEA 1997). Most of the provisions of the IDEA 1997 became effective on June 4, 1997. Other provisions became effective January 1, 1998, or July 1, 1998. Petitioner's claims related to the 1996-1997 school year arose prior to the enactment of IDEA 1997. While IDEA 1997 did not alter the general standards reflected in the IDEA, the Hearing Officer will apply the law in effect at the time the disputed issues occurred, in compliance with general rules disfavoring the retroactive application of laws. Landgraff v. USI Film Products 511 U.S. 244 (1994).
4. Under IDEA 1997, this disability category is known as "emotionally disturbed (ED)." 20 U.S.C.§ 1401(4)(i). The criteria that must be satisfied to meet special education eligibility as either ED, serious emotionally disturbed, or SED are similar.
Second Footnotes 2-4
2. IDEA and IDEA 1997 contain similar definitions of SLD.
3. After several testing sessions with Ms. Barsoum, STUDENT refused to allow her to conduct further testing. Ms. Burstein then completed two testing sessions with STUDENT.
4. The report by LAC-USC does not indicate which edition of the VMI was administered.
5. The parents later requested a speech and language assessment. See below for discussion of the District's obligation to assess STUDENT as a result of that request.
No footnotes for number 6 and 7
8.. The right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. Parents of Student W. ex rel. Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. D. No. 3 (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489.
9.The parents have not requested reimbursement for the costs of mental health services they have procured by STUDENT since 1997. It is the understanding of the Hearing Officer that these services have been provided at no cost to the parents through LAC-USC.
