California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 4, 2004
Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 934-03 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
San Dieguito Union High must reimburse tutoring and fund 120 remediation hours and transition services for graduate denied FAPE.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Before this hearing, the Hearing Office granted the District's motion to dismiss in September 2003. On the Petitioner's motion for reconsideration, the dismissal was vacated and the case was reset for hearing. In July 2003, the diploma was rescinded to enforce stay put, then returned after the student declined the stay put placement. This decision carries an amendment changing the prevailing party on Issue 2 from Petitioner to Respondent.
Summary
A 20-year-old former La Costa Canyon High School student filed for due process in May 2003, shortly before he graduated with a regular diploma. He was eligible for special education as speech and language impaired. He challenged San Dieguito Union High School District's assessments, IEPs, and transition planning from his enrollment in April 2000 until graduation. The Hearing Officer found the District did not assess phonological processing, visual processing, or reading fluency until December 2002, even though his records pointed to those needs. The District's auditory processing assessment was adequate. The claim of a late assessment plan failed because the parent had not asked for an assessment in May 2002. For each school year, the IEP goals could not be measured, progress was not reported, and the IEPs did not address reading, spelling, writing, or vision needs until March 2003. The District never provided the promised note-taking help or the 2001 summer services. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to standardized test scores than to passing grades. Transition planning was missing or came too late. The diploma was not rescinded because the student wanted to keep it. The District must reimburse $5,030 in tutoring costs and up to $250 for writing software. It must also fund 12 vision therapy sessions, 120 hours of reading and writing remediation, and 30 hours of transition services.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO awarded compensatory education and reimbursement to a student who had already graduated with a regular diploma. When IEP goals were too vague to measure progress, the Hearing Officer relied on standardized test scores rather than passing grades to decide whether the student received educational benefit.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 1. Did the Respondent fail to properly assess the Petitioner from the date of his first enrollment at La Costa High School on or about April 1, 2000 to on or about December 19, 2002?
District failed to assess phonological processing, visual functioning/processing, and reading fluency from 2000 until about December 16, 2002; auditory processing was properly assessed and an audiologist's assessment was not required.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. Did the Respondent fail to timely provide the Petitioner's parent with a written assessment plan following her request to assess in 2002?
The parent did not request an assessment in May 2002; the District timely provided an assessment plan after the September 19, 2002 IEP team agreement.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year (and extended school year)?
FAPE denied: no method in the IEP for reporting progress, no progress reports, no notice that transition would be discussed, vague unmeasurable goals, no services for reading, writing, spelling, or vision needs, and promised note-taking help and summer 2001 ESY were not provided.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year (and extended school year)?
FAPE denied: no progress reports, no notice of transition discussion, unmeasurable goals, services reduced without evidence of progress, no reading, spelling, or vision services, and note-taking help dropped; passing grades did not show the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide benefit.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year (and extended school year)?
FAPE denied: the May 2002 offer was not specific, notice of the November 2002 meeting was inadequate, progress was not reported, and IEPs did not meet reading, writing, spelling, or vision needs until March 12, 2003; the March 2003 IEP was appropriate, but its note-taking help was never provided.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue 6. Did the Respondent fail to provide appropriate transition assistance to the Petitioner?
The District never assessed transition needs, developed no transition plan in 2000, did not make the Workability referral, and offered transition plans in 2001-2003 that were inadequate or too late to help.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 7. Should the high school diploma issued to the Petitioner in June 2003 be rescinded on the ground that the Respondent failed to provide appropriate transition services or on the ground that rescission is required to allow the Hearing Officer to award full and appropriate relief?
No rescission: the student wanted to keep his diploma, graduation had no transition requirement, and rescission was not needed to give full relief.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 8. If the Respondent failed to provide a FAPE during any of the years at issue, should he and/or his parent be reimbursed for the cost of privately obtained educational and related services?
The District must reimburse $1,980 for private tutoring by Jodie Schuller before graduation; post-graduation tutoring costs were handled as compensatory education.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 9. If the Respondent failed to provide a FAPE during any of the years at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
Compensatory education awarded to a student who had already graduated: post-graduation tutoring reimbursement, 12 vision therapy sessions, 120 hours of remediation, up to $250 for writing software, and 30 hours of transition services; no remedy for the procedural violations, note-taking, or ESY.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days, reimburse $1,980.00 for tutoring services rendered by Jodie Schuller before graduation.
- Compensatory education. Within 30 days, make available 12 additional visual therapy sessions with Susan Daniels or another specialist of Petitioner's choosing from the District's approved list, to be used within two years of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 days, reimburse $3,050.00 for tutoring by Jodie Schuller ($2,000) and Patricia Padgett ($1,050) after graduation, awarded as compensatory education.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receipt of proof of purchase, reimburse the cost of a linear writing program of the type recommended by Dr. Patterson, not to exceed $250.00, excluding sales tax.
- Compensatory education. Within 30 days, begin making available 120 hours of remediation in basic reading and written expression skills, including spelling, through a state-certified nonpublic agency, to be used within two years of the decision.
- Compensatory education. Within 30 days, begin making available 30 hours of transition services from a certified nonpublic agency for assessment or services in college and/or career guidance and counseling, to be used within two years of the decision.
Total: 150 hours of compensatory services; $5,280 ordered
Key authorities
Board of Educ. v. Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Union School District v. Smith; Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S.; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Educ.; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Bd. of Educ.; Student v. Temecula Valley USD, SN01-02415
People named in the decision
- Torrie Norton, Director of pupil services, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Mary Ellen Nest, Co-director of special education; District witness, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Susan Daniels, O.D., Optometrist providing vision therapy; witness for Student, Private provider (District approved list)
- Patricia Padgett, Educational consultant/tutor (former Lindamood-Bell clinician); witness for Student, Private provider
- Julie Bloomfield, District special education teacher, summer 2002 reading class; witness for Student, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Robert Patterson, Psychologist and educational consultant; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Jodie Schuller, Private speech-language pathologist and tutor; witness for Student, Private provider
- Carol Atkins, Audiologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
- Gary Clark, Transition expert witness for Student, University of Kansas, Department of Special Education
- Lauranne Howard, District speech and language therapist; District witness, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Nicole Housen, English teacher (senior year); District witness, La Costa Canyon High School
- Dawn Dully, Former director of student services; District witness, La Costa Canyon High School
- Paula Furgerson, Resource specialist and Career 2 reading teacher; District witness, La Costa Canyon High School
- Jeffrey Owen, Psychologist; record-review witness for District
- Mr. Ahrens, Learning center class instructor providing one-on-one reading instruction, La Costa Canyon High School
- Judi-Anne Perez, O.D., Optometrist; private vision assessment (November 2002), Private
- Carl Hillier, O.D., Optometrist; visual functioning/processing assessment (March 2003), Private (District approved list)
- Richard Skay, Practitioner reported to have provided visual therapy in 2002, Private (District approved list)
- Mary Ann Carpenter, Ph.D., School psychologist; 1997 psychoeducational assessment, Encinitas Union School District
- NCCSE, Speech and language assessor (2000 and 2002 assessments)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), the University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Marcos, California, on February 17, 18, 19, and 20, 2004, and in Encinitas, California on February 24 and 25, 2004.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Margaret Adams and Eric Freedus. PARENT, the Petitioner’s aunt and the person to whom his educational rights have been delegated, was also present. (Footnote 1)
Respondent San Dieguito Union High School District (District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jonathan Read. Torrie Norton, the director of pupil services for the District, was also present on all except the fourth day of hearing. Mary Ellen Nest, the co-director of special education for the District, was present on day four of the hearing.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Susan Daniels, a doctor of optometry who provided visual therapy to the Petitioner; Patricia Padgett, an educational consultant who has provided remedial educational services to the Petitioner; Julie Bloomfield, a District teacher who provided special education services to the Petitioner during the summer of 2002; Robert Patterson, a psychologist and educational consultant who conducted an independent assessment of the Petitioner; Jodie Schuller, a speech pathologist who provided services to the Petitioner; Carol Atkins, an audiologist who conducted an independent assessment of the Petitioner; Gary Clark, a faculty member at the University of Kansas, department of Special Education, who specialized in transition issues; PARENT; and STUDENT.
The Respondent called the following witnesses: Lauranne Howard, a District speech and language therapist; Nicole Housen, a District teacher who taught the Petitioner English during his senior year at La Costa Canyon High School (La Costa); Dawn Dully, former director of student services at La Costa; Paula Furgerson, a District resource specialist who provided services to the Petitioner during his senior year at La Costa; Jeffrey Owen, a psychologist who reviewed some of the Petitioner’s records and the District’s evidence; and Mary Ellen Nest.
The oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing argument were heard, and the record was closed upon receipt of the parties’ closing briefs on March 4, 2004.
ISSUES PRESENTED (Footnote 2)
Issue No 1: Did the Respondent fail to properly assess the Petitioner from the date of his first enrollment La Costa High School on or about April 1, 2000 to on or about December 19, 2002? (Footnote 3)
Issue No. 2: Did the Respondent fail to timely provide the Petitioner’s parent with a written assessment plan following her request to assess in 2002?
Issue No. 3: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year?
Issue No. 4: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year?
Issue No. 5: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year?
Issue No. 6: Did the Respondent fail to provide appropriate transition assistance to the Petitioner?
Issue No. 7: Should the high school diploma issued to the Petitioner in June 2003 be rescinded on the ground that the Respondent failed to provide appropriate transition services or on the ground that rescission is required to allow the Hearing Officer to award full and appropriate relief?
Issue No. 8: If the Respondent failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, should he and/or his parent be reimbursed by the Respondent for the cost of the privately obtained educational and related services?
Issue No. 9: If the Respondent failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
There were a number of procedural issues presented at or near the outset of the hearing. Those of significance will be discussed separately, below.
REQUIRED SPECIFICITY FOR ISSUES AND CONTENTIONS
In the various statements of issues prepared by Ms. Adams on the Petitioner’s behalf, she described the issues to be addressed with substantial detail. Nevertheless, in the course of the Hearing Officer’s efforts to clarify the issues for hearing, Petitioner’s other attorney, Mr. Freedus, objected to the Hearing Officer’s requirement that the Petitioner state the issues to be addressed, and his contentions with respect to those issues, with substantial specificity. Mr. Freedus argued that a student should only be required to assert that there had been a denial of a free, appropriate public education and that the Hearing Officer should be allowed to make any finding and reach any conclusion regarding that broad claim that the evidence supported.
Requiring that the challenges to the educational program be stated with reasonable certainty allows the parties to efficiently marshal their evidence in a way that will minimize an unnecessary drain on resources. Additionally, the presiding hearing officer, whose responsibility itis to efficiently conduct the hearing, will thus know the scope of the issues presented in order to correctly make relevancy determinations in an effort to conserve limited resources. Therefore, on the basis of long-standing practice, the Hearing Officer found the objection of Mr. Freedus to be without merit, and it was overruled.
PETITIONER’S AMENDMENT OF ISSUES
The Respondent made a motion to limit the issues to those disclosed months ago by the Petitioner and identified by the hearing officer who convened the hearing on September 23, 2003. It also made a motion to deem the Petitioner’s claim to reimbursement to be resolved and therefore not at issue, at least to the extent the District has previously tendered payment of the amount claimed on September 23, 2003.
In June 2003, approximately one month after this case was filed, the Petitioner graduated from high school with a regular diploma. The Hearing Office rescinded the diploma as part of its enforcement of “stay put.” Subsequently, the Petitioner declined the offered stay put placement back in his former high school, and his diploma was returned to him.
On September 18, 2003, the Hearing Office conducted a prehearing conference by telephone in preparation for the hearing that had been previously scheduled for September 23, 2003. Issues and the parties’ proposed resolutions were clarified at that conference. The Petitioner, through his attorney Margaret Adams, stated that he wanted to keep his diploma and that no further issues remained regarding the District’s award of the diploma or the Petitioner’s entitlement to that diploma. The Petitioner confirmed that he was seeking reimbursement and an award of compensatory education.
Just as the hearing of the due process claims was about to begin on September 23, 2003, the District made a motion to dismiss the case on the ground that there was no actual controversy. The District offered to pay the requested reimbursement. It argued that no other relief was available to a student who had graduated with a regular diploma. Therefore, there was no controversy that required a hearing. The hearing was continued to allow the parties an opportunity to file written briefs. Those were filed, and the motion to dismiss was granted.
The Petitioner made a motion for reconsideration. That motion was granted, and on reconsideration the dismissal order was vacated, and the case was put back on the hearing calendar with a February 17, 2004 start date. Prior to the rescheduled hearing, the Petitioner served a new statement of issues more than ten days prior to the hearing as required by law. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6). Although this issue statement for the most part tracked the prehearing conference order from the September 18, 2003 conference, it also added an issue that challenged the Respondent’s award of a regular diploma (Issue No. 6), which claim had previously been withdrawn by the Petitioner. In addition, on the first day of the instant hearing the Hearing Officer and the parties discussed issues, contentions, and proposed resolutions in detail. In addition to the new challenge to the issuance of the diploma to the Petitioner, the Petitioner increased his claim to reimbursement, purportedly to include expenses incurred since September 2003.
The Respondent objected to the amendment of the issues, arguing that the issues should be limited to those properly raised at the time the hearing convened on September 23, 2003. In addition, the Respondent explained that on September 23, 2003, the Petitioner claimed a stated sum certain as reimbursement and that the Respondent had in fact tendered that amount in satisfaction of that claim, although the tender was not accepted. The Respondent argued that the parties’ agreements about the diploma and the reimbursement were tantamount to binding stipulations that should prevent Petitioner from raising new claims or seeking additional amounts at this hearing. The Respondent also asserted that to the extent it has offered to reimburse the Petitioner for the sum claimed on September 23, 2003, that part of the claim, at least, should be deemed resolved.
The Petitioner countered that there was no agreement. He argued that there was only the Respondent’s unilateral effort to pay a disputed claim in the hope of preventing a determination that the Petitioner was a prevailing party. (Footnote 4) The Petitioner stated that the circumstances relied upon by the Respondent could no more be deemed a binding stipulation to limit the issues or the reimbursement claim than they can be deemed an admission by the Respondent that it denied a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Petitioner during all of the years at issue.
The Hearing Officer denied the Respondent’s motion to limit the issues to those properly disclosed at the time of the September 2003 hearing. No binding stipulation resulted from the earlier discussion of issues. There was no legal impediment to the Petitioner timely disclosing new or different issues. The Respondent had the right to know what the Petitioner believed were the issues ten days before the hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(e)(6). The required notice was given to the Respondent.
The Hearing Officer also denied the Respondent’s motion to limit the Petitioner’s claim to reimbursement. The law does not require that a student identify the specific dollar amount sought in the statement of issues. Id. It is not uncommon in practice for a student to disclose the amount of reimbursement claimed for the first time at the hearing. The previous tender was not negotiated and the check was returned to the Respondent. There was nothing to prevent the Petitioner from claiming that additional amounts were now due, some five months after the amount of the claim had first been announced at the September 2003 hearing. The Respondent could have offered to pay the entire amount claimed, but it chose not to do so. The Hearing Officer found that the Petitioner’s claim to reimbursement was not limited to the amount claimed in September 2003. (Footnote 5)
RESPONDENT’S MOTION TO PROTECT A DOCUMENT FROM DISCLOSURE
The Respondent sought to strike from the Hearing Office’s file, to seal, or to otherwise protect from further disclosure a letter prepared by the Respondent’s attorney and claimed to be privileged and therefore protected from disclosure by the attorney-client and work product privileges. The supporting declarations explained that the letter was intended for dissemination to clients of Mr. Read’s firm and to other attorneys who shared a like interest in the litigation that was the subject of the letter. The letter had been inadvertently sent to Margaret Adams, who attached a copy to her letter opposing an earlier request by the Respondent to remove this case from the hearing calendar.
The Respondent’s counsel sought an order compelling Petitioner’s counsel to return or destroy all copies of the letter. The Respondent argued that the inadvertent disclosure of the document did not waive the privileges. It was clear that the document had been sent to Ms. Adams by mistake and that she was or should have been aware that she was not an intended recipient. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer lacked the authority to compel Petitioner’s counsel to return or destroy all copies of the letter. That request would have to be addressed to some other proper authority or court. The Hearing Officer concluded that, although there was an inadequate foundation for a finding that the document was privileged, it was clear that it had no relevance to the earlier motion or the pending proceedings. On that basis, the Hearing Officer sealed the copy of the letter attached to the Petitioner’s opposition and contained in the Hearing Office file.
PETITIONER’S MOTION RE: OFFICIAL RECORDS EXCEPTION TO HEARSAY RULE
Generally, technical rules of evidence do not apply to a special education due process hearing. The Hearing Officer may admit any relevant evidence, including hearsay evidence “if it is the sort of evidence on which responsible persons are accustomed to rely in the conduct of serious affairs. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3082(b). However, hearsay evidence alone cannot be considered sufficient to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in a civil action. Id.
Mr. Freedus requested that the Hearing Officer recognize Petitioner’s school records as qualified under the “official record” exception to the hearsay rule. He stated his concern that the Hearing Officer might decline to base a finding on facts evidenced only in individualized education program (IEP) documents and assessment plans and reports because they were hearsay. No ruling on the motion was required because the parties stipulated that the admitted IEP documents and assessment plans and reports qualified under the official record exception to the hearsay rule. Cal. Evid. Code § 1280. (Footnote 6)
PETITIONER’S MOTION TO STRIKE PORTIONS OF RESPONDENT’S BRIEF
On March 8, 2004, the Hearing Office received the Petitioner’s motion to strike portions of the Respondent’s closing brief. The motion was made on the ground that the Respondent included points and authorities on matters that were outside the scope of the issues on which briefing was allowed by the Hearing Office’s order. The Hearing Officer determined that the motion did not require notice or response. By the time the motion was filed, he had already read the District’s closing brief and considered only those points and authorities on which briefing had been requested. The motion is denied.
OVERVIEW OF CONTENTIONS
STUDENT alleges that the District’s claim that it complied with required procedures to provide him with a FAPE is not supported by the weight of the evidence. He asserts that the greater weight of evidence shows that he has at least average cognitive abilities and that the District failed to design an educational program to meet his needs and provide educational benefit. STUDENT submits that the District’s reliance on evidence that he received passing grades and a regular high school diploma is misplaced because those do not prove its compliance with the law. He states that to the extent that evidence is entitled to some weight, it is far outweighed by evidence of years of assessment data that shows the District’s failures. The assessment scores are summarized in the following charts.
COGNITIVE TESTING CHART (Footnote 7)
DATE GRADE AT TESTING TEST VERBAL OR SEQEN. NONVERBAL OR SIMULT. FULL SCALE OR COMP
May-97 6.9 WISC-3 79 104 90 May-97 6.9 KABC 83 101 92 May-00 9.9 WAIS-3 89 98 91 Apr-01 10.8 TONI 112 Oct-02 12.2 KBIT 99 110 105 Jun-03 Graduated CTONI 94
The above chart describes the results of STUDENT’s cognitive ability assessments from 1997 when he was last assessed by his prior school district to 2003 when the most recent assessment occurred.
ACHIEVEMENT TESTING CHART (Footnote 8)
DATE GRADE AT TIME TEST READING RECOG. READING COMP BROAD READING DICTATION SPELLING WRITING SAMPLE BROAD WRITING May-97 6-9 WJ-R 4.1 (83) 3.6 (82) 3.9 (81) 2.6 (65) 5.6 (93) 3.4 (75) May-00 9-9 WJ-R 8.9 (100) 6.2 (91) 7.7 (95) 4.1 (74) 5.6 (89) 4.5 (76) Jun-02 11 KTEA 7.5 (81) 7.3 (80) 7.4 (80) 5.3 (72)
Oct-02 12-2 WJ-3 11.6 (99) 11.3 (98) 5.0 (76) 7.6 (87)
Nov-02 12-3 GORT 6.4 4.4 Jun-03 Graduated PIAT-R 6.6 (74) (58)
Jun-03 Graduated WRAT 5.0 (80) 4.0 (71)
Jun-03 Graduated NEL-DEN 7.4 4.1 4.1
This chart summarizes STUDENT’s scores on assessments of achievement that were conducted during the same period. The scores are first stated in terms of grade level equivalent to provide a ready comparison with STUDENT’s grade at the time the tests were administered. The scores in parentheses are standard scores. Empty boxes mean that no comparable test was administered. The absence of a grade level equivalent or standard score means that these were not available.
The Hearing Officer will address the specific contentions of the parties in the context of his analysis of the various issues. However, a general overview of their respective contentions should help as a guide through the three years that are at issue.
The District asserts that STUDENT was a young man of low-average abilities who performed at a level commensurate with those abilities. It contends that STUDENT’s passing grades and the award of a regular diploma in June 2003 establish the adequacy of its program to meet his needs and provide benefit. The District asserts reliance on assessment scores to show a lack of progress is unwarranted, arguing that an educational program cannot be judged in retrospect but must be viewed in the context of facts and circumstances objectively known at the time it was created. It specifically contends that charts similar to those set out above are misleading.
BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a twenty-year-old high school graduate who is currently living with his mother outside of the District and attending classes at Palomar Community College, where he studies diesel mechanics. During the time at issue, the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, and 2002-2003 school years, STUDENT attended La Costa High School (La Costa) within the District. STUDENT’s language abilities, particularly his ability to read and write, are the focus of this dispute. (Footnote 9)
The evidence that pertains to the eight school years prior to STUDENT’s enrollment in the District, show that STUDENT had long-standing educational challenges, particularly in connection with language. (Footnote 10) Some of the areas of concern in those early years were the core academic areas of reading (including phonics and word attack) and writing (including spelling, capitalization, and punctuation). There were also concerns about possible problems with vision (including perception, visual-motor functioning, and visual-sequential memory), hearing (including auditory perception and processing), attention (including difficulties with attention to task and organizational skills), hyperactivity, and social-emotional functioning (emotional immaturity and control). However, only a few of these areas of need were placed in issue by the Petitioner, principally visual functioning/processing, reading, written language, and task completion.
STUDENT’s former school district, Encinitas Union School District (EUSD) assessed his cognitive abilities in 1994 and 1997. (Footnote 11) Two test instruments were used in each year, the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III) and the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC). The KABC was chosen to minimize the potential impact of language and long-term memory problems. The assessments produced cognitive ability scores mostly in the low-average to average range in 1994, with the highest score being a 91 in simultaneous processing on the KABC. (Footnote 12) STUDENT’s verbal and sequential scores from the 1997 testing were a few points lower than they were in 1994, but his performance and simultaneous processing scores showed significant increases, with a prorated performance score of 104 on the WISC-III. (Footnote 13) This indicated that he may have been losing ground in language ability as compared with his normed group and that the nonverbal scores may have been a better measure of his actual cognitive ability.
Achievement test scores from the Woodcock Johnson, Revised (WJ-R) administered during those same years suggest that STUDENT also was losing ground in the area of language skills (reading and written language). Although the 1994 scores of 84 in broad reading and 77 in written language were close to his low-average ability scores from that year, his even lower achievement scores in 1997 were significantly discrepant (14 to 29 points) from his performance scores. In addition, STUDENT was approximately two to two and one-half grade levels behind in broad reading and broad written language in 1994, with spelling being his weakest skill. Three years later in 1997, he was even further behind, three grade levels in broad reading and three and one-half grade levels in broad written language.
In her May 1997 report, the EUSD psychologist appeared to recognize the potential significance of these results. She identified visual processing, visual-motor speed, and visual-sequential memory as areas of weakness. She indicated that STUDENT’s problems with short-term auditory memory and auditory sequential memory suggested a verbal learning disability consisting of a phonetic coding deficit. The assessor opined that STUDENT’s problems with symbolic language were adversely affecting his education, resulting in gaps in his fund of information and difficulties with skill development. She recommended eligibility for special education under the category of specific learning disability (SLD) and a program to include small group instruction in reading, written language, and math using a multi-sensory approach. She also recommended accommodations and modifications to include the use of a keyboard, books on tape, modified assignments, and extra time to complete work.
STUDENT’s family did not accept the program that was offered by EUSD. Instead, they removed him from that district and placed him in private schools for his seventh, eighth and most of his ninth grades. He apparently had no IEP during these years, and only limited information was provided to the Hearing Officer concerning STUDENT’s time at these private schools.
Report cards from STUDENT’s seventh- and eighth-grade years at Escondido Adventist Academy showed inconsistent and generally poor achievement. His performance was worse during the first semester of ninth grade at Calvary Christian. In six academic classes, he received five Fs and one D-. His grade point average for that first semester was .80. There was nothing in the testimony or documents to shed light on why STUDENT’s grades dropped so precipitously that semester. His report card indicates that STUDENT remained there for at least part of the second semester. His third quarter grades were all Fs in the five academic subjects for which he received a grade.
STUDENT enrolled in the District on March 23, 2000 and began taking ninth-grade regular education classes at La Costa by early April. He was sixteen years old at the time. The District’s IEP process began shortly after his enrollment with an assessment plan dated April 3, 2000. (Footnote 14)
2000-2001 School Year
Planning for STUDENT’s 2000-2001 school year began with the District’s initial health assessment on which the parent noted that STUDENT had problems tracking when reading, required prompting for homework, and needed directions repeated. His ninth grade teacher administered the WJ-R. The broad reading score was higher than the 1997 score and suggested that STUDENT had made slightly more than year-for-year progress in this area during the time he was failing his courses at the private schools. On the other hand, STUDENT’s scores showed that he had fallen further behind in broad writing and was now about five and one-half grade levels behind. The report suggests that the scores may have been lower than stated because the assessor miscalculated STUDENT’s date of birth.
On May 19, 2000, the District psychologist conducted a psychoeducational assessment. The assessor administered the Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale, Third Edition (WAIS-III), which produced verbal, performance, and full scale ability scores of 89, 98, and 91, respectively. STUDENT’s verbal ability score continued to show improvement. The assessor noted slow processing of auditory information by observation. Test results suggested weak short-term auditory memory with auditory processing, visual-motor coordination, and speed of operation in the deficit range. The assessor concluded that STUDENT was qualified for special education under the category speech and language impaired (SLI) due to deficits in the areas of auditory processing and memory. (Footnote 15) She recommended accommodations, including seating near the teacher, visual aids, and extra time for written work.
The May 2000 NCCSE speech and language assessment revealed that STUDENT had a weakness in receptive language skills. His skills in the areas of short-term auditory memory and processing auditory information at paragraph level were found to be well below average. The assessor recommended speech and language services once weekly for thirty minutes to work on these deficits.
The meeting to develop STUDENT’s IEP for the 2000-2001 school year was convened on May 31, 2000. The team agreed upon eligibility under the category SLI and drafted goals in the areas of reading, written expression, and auditory comprehension and memory, but these goals had no useful baselines or way to measure progress. The team developed a program that placed STUDENT in special education for about half the day, including his English class and speech and language services once weekly for thirty minutes. There was no transition plan developed at the meeting. The IEP documents stated that an individualized transition plan (ITP) would be mailed to the parent.
There was no evidence to show whether or not STUDENT made any progress in his areas of need during his tenth-grade year (2000-2001). He was not enrolled in a special education English class, which was contrary to his IEP. He did poorly in his regular English class, receiving “D” grades for both semesters.
On April 12, 2001, a private assessor administered the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence, Third Edition (TONI-3) and the Test of Variables of Attention (TOVA) to STUDENT. The evidence did not demonstrate who initiated this assessment, but it appears to have been done to explore the possibility of an attention deficit. The results as interpreted by the assessor, who did not testify, suggested an attentional disorder and very slow processing. On May 1, 2001, the District assessed STUDENT’s visual and hearing acuity. Both were within normal limits. These were the only formal assessments of STUDENT prior to the IEP meeting on May 9, 2001.
The first annual review of STUDENT’s program for the 2000-2001 school year was on May 9, 2001. There had been no standardized reassessments to measure STUDENT’s growth. The review of his present levels of performance and his progress toward his annual goals and objectives consisted entirely of anecdotal reports. The IEP document reports the same present levels of performance that had been reported a year earlier, suggesting no progress or, at least, nothing upon which to base a measurement of progress. There was no attempt to actually use the goals to measure progress. They were essentially ignored, then abandoned, a critical flaw that was repeated in other IEPs.
2001-2002 School Year
STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year was planned at the May 2001 IEP meeting. Without any documented justification for its decision, the IEP team decided on a regular education placement for the 2001-2002 school year that provided no special education instruction to address reading and written language skills. It did provide speech and language services for thirty minutes once weekly and general academic assistance in the learning center class (LCC) for thirty minutes once weekly. (Footnote 16) The IEP also provided an extended school year (ESY) program during that summer of 2001. The sole agreed-upon accommodation was extra time to complete his work, but only as agreed upon by his teachers.
The IEP team drafted three new goals: one to improve study skills, one to address auditory comprehension/memory, and one to improve oral and written expressive language skills by fifty percent. There was nothing to indicate how the fifty percent increase in expressive language skills was to be measured or that it was even achievable, particularly without specific services to address that need. The goal was essentially meaningless. There was no goal to address basic reading skills.
A transition plan is attached to the May 2001 IEP, but there was no assessment data reflecting STUDENT’s academic and vocational strengths and weaknesses. The plan notes STUDENT’s interests in computers and his desire to attend a community college part-time while working full-time. It states that STUDENT would work with a career counselor and receive a referral for the Workability vocational program, but no other transition needs or services are identified or addressed.
The IEP team reviewed STUDENT’s achievement during the 2001-2002 school year at an IEP meeting on May 8, 2002. The parent reported that STUDENT felt overwhelmed with all of his work and that it took him two to three times as long as the other students to read. She requested placement in a summer remediation program. According to the stated present levels of performance, STUDENT was two to three grade levels behind in reading and six to seven grade levels behind in written language. These levels again suggested either that there had been no progress since May 2000 or that the District had no more current and reliable data than its two-year-old standardized assessment data. STUDENT’s teachers had awarded passing grades in the first semester, which included a D in English, but there was no standardized reassessment data, and, again, there were only anecdotal reports of progress in his areas of need. (Footnote 17) There was no suggestion that anyone had actually measured STUDENT’s progress toward the prior year’s goals or that it was measurable. Even when the parent requested more specific information about STUDENT’s progress, none was given.
STUDENT did attend a summer reading program taught by Julie Bloomfield. The course provided individual and small-group instruction in decoding, spelling, reading comprehension, and written language. It met five times weekly for approximately two hours for six weeks. Seven to eight special education students attended the class.
At about the same time that STUDENT was attending Ms. Bloomfield’s class, private speech and language therapist Jodie Schuller was assessing and providing services to him. Ms. Schuller administered several reading and writing assessments and provided one-on-one services once weekly for ninety minutes using the Wilson Reading System and Lindamood-Bell’s LiPS program to work on phonological awareness, decoding, spelling, syllabication (knowing how to break words into syllables), reading fluency, and reading comprehension. The assessments indicated that STUDENT had lost substantial ground in both his reading and writing skills.
2002-2003 School Year
At the May 2002 meeting, the IEP team agreed upon a placement in regular education classes with an unspecified type and amount of services in the resource specialist program and thirty minutes weekly of speech and language services. The District agreed to provide books-on-tape and note-taking assistance. STUDENT would also be allowed additional time to complete his work, but only by prior arrangement with his teachers. Three of the five goals for the 2002-2003 school year were simply restatements, sometimes with minor changes, of the goals contained in the IEP for the prior school year. For the first time, there was a specific writing goal requiring STUDENT to write an expository essay and increase his use of a word processor.
The 2002-2003 school year was a busy one for STUDENT’s IEP team. The parties’ disputes regarding STUDENT’s education became more specific and pronounced. There were five IEP meetings, several proposals to change STUDENT’s program, and some agreements.
Around the time that the 2002-2003 school year began, Ms. PARENT revoked her consent to the May 2002 IEP and asked the District to convene an IEP meeting. The meeting was held on September 19, 2002. At the meeting, parent expressed her concerns about STUDENT’s progress. She confirmed the rescission of her consent to the May 2002 IEP. Jodie Schuller, who attended the meeting with the parent, proposed several specific goals that she described as more specific and measurable. The District representatives believed that STUDENT was doing well in his classes. Nevertheless, they proposed the addition of a reading class, taught by Paula Furgerson, where he was to receive direct instruction in reading, including Earobics, a program designed to help students who are struggling with phonological awareness, auditory processing and phonics skills. (Footnote 18) STUDENT and Ms. PARENT agreed to add the reading class, but no reading goal was established.
A District reassessment that began in early October 2002 indicated that STUDENT continued to show gains in cognitive ability. The Kaufman Brief Intelligence Scale (KBIT) produced verbal (vocabulary), performance (matrices) and composite ability scores of 99, 110, and 105, respectively. His verbal score, now just one point below the mean, still lagged significantly behind his performance score, which was now just two points below the “high average” range.
Paula Furgerson administered the WJ-III about the same time. On this occasion, the District did not do the broad reading and broad writing clusters of the test, both of which required administration of the fluency subtests. The assessment produced reading scores at least four grade levels higher than the scores obtained by Ms. Schuller a few months earlier. Although the District’s scores indicated that there had been dramatic improvement in reading skills, they showed that he was falling even further behind in written expression. (Footnote19) His results on the Bender Gestalt assessment of visual-motor integration suggested a lack of interest in school and/or impulsivity related to anxiety associated with assignments requiring written work.
The District’s speech and language pathologist, Lauranne Howard, conducted a speech and language assessment that showed continuing deficits in auditory processing, auditory comprehension, auditory memory, and the processing of semantic relationships and complex language. She concluded that STUDENT continued to need speech and language services “at least through his senior year of high school” to help improve or compensate for auditory skills deficits.
There was a visual assessment by Judi-Anne Perez, O.D. on November 18, 2002, apparently at the request of Ms. PARENT, to whom the report is addressed. The diagnosis by this assessor is not clear from her report, and she did not testify. She recommended ten visual therapy sessions followed by a reevaluation.
Ms. Schuller reassessed STUDENT in November 2002. She administered the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), the Oral and Written Language Scales (OWLS), and the Writing Process Test (WPT). STUDENT was reading six to eight grade levels behind according to the GORT. He scored in the sixteenth percentile on the OWLS and in the first percentile on the WPT. (Footnote 20)
An IEP meeting was convened on November 25, 2002. STUDENT was pulled from class to attend. (Footnote 21) The District recommended that STUDENT add Ms. Furgerson’s Career 2 class, which would provide some assistance with career planning and provide other support. Goals were written to address written language and organizational skills, and the District offered a “support class” said to account for eighteen percent of STUDENT’s instructional day, but the specifics of that instruction were not given. STUDENT was also to receive thirty minutes weekly of speech and language services. An ITP was attached to the IEP. It showed that STUDENT would take the placement test for Palomar community college and explore careers in his new career class. He was also going to update his résumé and explore part-time work through Workability. STUDENT did not consent to this IEP.
The next IEP meeting was convened on December 16, 2002. Ms. Schuller presented her most recent assessments. The parent asked the District to (1) triple STUDENT’s speech and language services, (2) provide one-on-one instruction in decoding, vocabulary, spelling, and written language for two hours five times weekly, (3) provide vision therapy as recommended in the report by Judi-Anne Perez, O.D., (4) adopt reading/written language goals written by Ms. Schuller, and (5) reimburse for privately obtained educational services and provide compensatory education. Ms. PARENT also expressed some concerns about whether STUDENT should be graduating at the end of that school year. Finally, she asked for key math and occupational therapy (OT) assessments, as well as an assessment of STUDENT’s auditory processing abilities conducted by an audiologist. The team agreed that STUDENT would enroll in Ms. Furgerson’s Career 2 class, where he would receive reading instruction and other support, and in one period of LCC and that it would reconvene after the holiday break to further address the parent’s requests.
On December 18, 2002, the District sent the parent an assessment plan to authorize the key math assessment, the word attack, reading fluency, and sound awareness subtests of the WJ-R, an OT assessment, a developmental vision assessment, and an audiological assessment. Ultimately, in early February, Ms. PARENT refused to authorize the assessments that had been requested by her with the exception of the key math and OT assessments.
Before the next scheduled IEP meeting, audiologist Carol Atkins conducted an independent assessment of STUDENT on December 30, 2003. Among her findings was a reduced ability to hear and understanding the words spoken in the left ear with a competing background of white noise. Other testing demonstrated difficulties with auditory processing, memory, and attention. Ms. Atkins concluded that STUDENT presented a “varied profile.” There was some indication of an associative auditory processing deficit, which causes difficulty applying the underlying rules of language to what is heard. She also concluded that the findings were suggestive of an integration deficit, which makes it difficult for the person to perform tasks that require intersensory or interhemispheric communication (between the right and left sides of brain). Ms. Atkins’ recommenations included the use of a rule-based approach to language and learning like those offered by Lindamood-Bell Learning Centers and a number of other organizations, instruction to increase auditory memory and interhemispheric communication, classroom accommodations, and assistance with self-advocacy. (Footnote 22)
STUDENT was given passing grades for the first semester of the 2002-2003 school year. He received a “D” in English.
The key math assessment conducted by the District on February 7, 2003 provided a mixed picture of STUDENT. It showed that he had weak basic math knowledge, such as basic units of measurement, but strengths in geometry, simple addition, and missing elements. Contrary to earlier testing, this one also indicated that STUDENT had strength in word problems.
The next IEP meeting was held on February 10, 2003. The District agreed to the parent’s request for a developmental vision assessment to be done by a private practitioner, as long as the assessor was on the District’s approved list and a different assessor on the list provided any required services. It also offered to provide a general education placement with one period of reading (Ms. Furgerson’s Career 2 class), one period of LCC, and speech and language services for thirty minutes twice weekly. (Footnote 23) The team, including Ms. PARENT and her representatives, agreed to a thirty-day interim placement in the District’s offered program. It is not clear what STUDENT’s goals were to have been for that placement.
Carl Hillier, O.D., conducted a visual functioning/processing assessment on STUDENT on March 10, 2003. He did not testify, but in his report he concluded that STUDENT had functional and perceptual difficulties relating to eye movement control, eye teaming, visual closure, visual memory, visual sequential memory, and perceptual speed that were significantly contributing to his problems with written language. He recommended twenty-five to thirty weekly visual therapy sessions with reassessments after each ten visits. (Footnote 24) He also suggested accommodations, such as placing STUDENT close to the teacher and directly in front of the marker board
An informal reading inventory was conducted on March 12, 2003. (Footnote 25) Ms. Furgerson administered the reading inventory. STUDENT had difficulty decoding ninth-grade level words but was independent for comprehension at tenth-grade level. Ms. Furgerson testified that the results probably underestimated STUDENT’s reading ability because he hurried unnecessarily through the test.
On March 12, 2003, the IEP team met for the last time. STUDENT was now just three months short of graduation. Recent assessments, including Dr. Hillier’s vision assessment, were shared. The District agreed to fund ten visual therapy sessions. The occupational therapist shared her findings and informed the team that services were not required because the noted OT deficits were not significantly impacting STUDENT’s education. The District offered to provide an Alphasmart keyboard for a two-month trial to assist STUDENT with written work.
The District offered a continuation of the interim placement last-agreed upon: a regular education placement for with one “support class” (Ms. Furgerson’s Career class) where STUDENT would receive forty minutes of individual or small group reading instruction in addition to other instruction, and one period of LCC where STUDENT would “be taught the money skills of making change and percentiles as related to daily living skills.” (Footnote 26) He would also receive speech and language services for thirty minutes once a week. An ITP was attached. There were several goals attached to this IEP, some showing a date on or about the date of this meeting and some showing the earlier dates. (Footnote 27) These addressed the areas of self-advocacy skills, positive life choices, anxiety/stress reduction, auditory perception and memory, reading, writing, and task completion.
There was no formal agreement to this offered IEP. However, some of the changes proposed in the February and March 2003 IEP meetings were implemented. STUDENT dropped his American Government and sculpture classes to add Ms. Furgerson’s Carreer 2 class and one period of LCC.
STUDENT received passing grades in his final semester. He graduated from La Costa and received his regular diploma on June 19, 2003. A “regular high school diploma” is one that is conferred on a student who has completed the prescribed course of study and has met the standards of proficiency in basic skills prescribed by the governing board of the school district. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026.1(b). According to statements made at the February 2003 IEP meeting by co-director of special education services Mary Ellen Nest, there were no proficiency exams at the time. If STUDENT took and passed the required courses, he was entitled to his diploma.
Shortly after graduation, psychologist Robert Patterson evaluated him. Dr. Patterson, who testified at the hearing, reviewed STUDENT’s records, compared the results of the many prior assessments, interviewed STUDENT and his family, and administered numerous tests. Once again, STUDENT’s test scores were significantly lower than the District’s scores from 2000 or 2002, with reading recognition five and one-half to eight grade levels behind, reading comprehension eight to nine grade levels behind and written expression, including spelling, six to nine grade levels behind. Dr. Patterson is of the opinion that STUDENT has a reading disorder and a disorder of written expression for which he recommends, among other things, services to remediate what he believes to be a significant decoding deficit.
STUDENT received ten sessions of vision therapy with Dr. Susan Daniels beginning on April 29, 2003, and concluding in July. According to her report and testimony, STUDENT made progress as a result of the therapy given. However, she is of the opinion that more therapy is necessary. She recommended to the District that an additional twelve sessions be provided to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. No additional sessions have been authorized.
On July 18, 2003, the Hearing Office granted the Petitioner’s motion to rescind his diploma and enforce his right to “stay put.” The order required that STUDENT be maintained in his last agreed-upon and implemented placement at La Costa. STUDENT chose not to return to high school. He declined the available stay put placement and instead continued with his plan to enroll at Palomar College (Palomar), a two-year community college in the area. The District returned the diploma to STUDENT, who testified that he wants to keep it.
On the basis of test scores, the counselor at Palomar recommended that STUDENT enroll in English 10, Reading 50 and Math 15. These are credit courses but do not qualify for transfer credit. STUDENT has opted to study diesel mechanics. He likes the program. He is able to read schematics and expects to be awarded a certificate upon completion of the course of study.
In spite of his satisfaction with his present vocational pursuit, STUDENT has continued to receive tutoring, during the 2003 summer from Ms. Schuller and most recently in October 2003 from Patricia Padgett, a former Lindamood-Bell clinician.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to properly assess the Petitioner from the date of his first enrollment in a District school on or about April 1, 2000 to on or about December 19, 2002?
The Petitioner alleges that during the time stated the District’s IEP process was procedurally flawed in that it failed to include assessments in the areas of phonological processing, visual functioning/processing, auditory processing, and reading fluency. (Footnote 28) The District asserts that it properly assessed STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disabilities as required by law.
The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district “in all areas related to the suspected disability,” including, where appropriate, vision, language function, general intelligence, academic performance, communicative status, [and] career and vocational abilities and interests. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b). (Footnote 29)
After the initial assessment and IEP, a reassessment of the student must take place at least every three years or more often if conditions warrant or if the parent requests a reassessment and the development of a new IEP and changed circumstances makes an earlier reassessment necessary. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a); Student v. Fresno Unified School District, SN96-00235. The reassessment planning must include a review of the existing assessment data, including classroom-based assessments and teachers’ and service providers’ observations, by the IEP team and other qualified professionals. On the basis of that review and after considering input from the student’s parents, the IEP team is to determine what additional data, if any, is needed. The reassessment is calculated to obtain that additional data. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b).
2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR
Phonological Processing Assessment (Footnote 30)
According to Ms. PARENT, the District decided to assess STUDENT for special education almost immediately upon his enrollment in the District. The April 3, 2000 assessment plan showed that the assessment would be in all areas except “prevocational/vocational.” (Footnote 31) The District’s assessment consisted, in pertinent part, of standard batteries to assess cognitive ability and achievement. It also included language function tests, including the CREVT and the CELF-III. Based principally on the results of these tests, the assessors concluded that STUDENT was qualified for special education on the basis of his deficits in auditory processing and memory.
It does not appear from the evidence that adequate attention was given to information that indicated that STUDENT’s educational difficulties were not adequately explained by reference to auditory processing and memory only. An examination of past school records would have revealed the earlier psychoeducational assessment in 1997 by EUSD psychologist Mary Ann Carpenter, Ph.D., who concluded as follows:
STUDENT exhibits auditory and visual processing deficits which impact his academic performance in all areas, particularly written language. STUDENT continues to have difficulty with language skills, in part due to his bilingual background, but also due to auditory processing difficulties, word retrieval difficulties and expressive and receptive language deficits in both languages.
Dr. Carpenter was of the opinion that STUDENT probably had a verbal learning disability consisting principally of a phonetic decoding deficit.
STUDENT’s dictation (spelling) subtest score that placed him almost six grade levels behind and his writing sample that placed him over four grade levels behind should have raised a suspicion that STUDENT’s disability involved more than just auditory processing and memory. It does not appear from the evidence that the District followed up on that earlier assessment and the interpretation of the results by Dr. Carpenter. If the District was not prepared to accept the opinions of Dr. Carpenter, it should at least have conducted a more focused assessment, including the area of phonological processing, to rule that out as a cause of STUDENT’s reading, writing, and spelling difficulties.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct a required phonological processing assessment as part of its initial assessment in violation of law. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Visual Functioning/Processing Assessment
According to Susan Daniels, O.D., vision has three components. The sensory component requires that the eye structure function correctly as an optical instrument. The motor component requires that the eyes function efficiently and in proper coordination. This includes tracking (the ability to follow a moving object), pursuit (required for following words smoothly and not losing one’s place when reading), saccadic movement (required to efficiently shift focus between a book or notepad on one’s desk and a teacher writing on a board), and eye teaming (the ability to fuse the input for the eyes into one percept). There is also the information processing component to vision. Dr. Daniels describes this as the software of the visual system that determines how the brain processes the visual input.
Visual processing is one of the basic psychological processes involved in using or understanding language. A student may be entitled to special education or related services to address deficits in this area that impair a student’s ability to think, read, write, spell, or do math calculations. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).
STUDENT’s records contain numerous indications regarding his difficulties with vision. In 1993, school staff observed that he would skip lines when reading and read letters out of order. The first referral for special education assessment in April 1994 listed visual perception as a suspected area of disability. The 1997 IEP documents justifies the recommended placement in part on visual processing deficits. The District should have known about these earlier concerns and determinations. In addition to the information contained in earlier records, the information supplied by STUDENT’s mother and aunt in the health questionnaire completed by them on May 2, 2000 included their concerns about his vision and specifically noted that he had been complaining about not being able to focus or track well even with his reading glasses. On the basis of this information, the District should have considered visual functioning, including visual processing, as a potential area of need related to STUDENT’s suspected disabilities. It should have assessed him in this area, but it did not.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct a required assessment of STUDENT in the area of visual functioning, including visual processing, as part of its initial assessment in violation of law. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Auditory Processing Assessment
According to Carol Atkins, the only audiologist to testify at the hearing, auditory processing is to hearing what visual processing is to seeing. It is one component of a complex system that requires properly operating auditory instruments, the ears, to perceive the sound and efficient software to accurately process it. Auditory processing is another one of the basic psychological processes involved in using or understanding language. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(j).
There were indications in STUDENT’s school records that he had difficulty processing auditory information. Auditory perception was identified as a suspected area of disability in his first referral for assessment in the fourth grade (1994). During his annual review by the former district in 1996, a team member reported that STUDENT had continuing difficulty listening to and following directions. The EUSD psychologist opined in 1997 that STUDENT’s short-term auditory memory and auditory sequential memory deficits were characteristic of a verbal learning disability. The NCCSE speech and language assessment that same year produced scores consistent with an auditory processing disorder.
The District was undoubtedly aware from STUDENT’s history and from its own initial assessment that auditory processing was a suspected area of special education need. The assessing psychologist observed what she characterized as a slow processing of auditory information. The speech and language assessment conducted by NCCSE included administration of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals, Third Edition (CELF-III) and the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills, Upper Level (TAPS-UL), which produced scores that indicated a deficit in this area. On the basis of the assessment data and other information, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services on the basis of his deficits in auditory processing and auditory memory.
The District did assess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing. The IEP team found that he was eligible for special education in large part on the basis of deficits in this area. No other assessment in this area was required.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to properly assess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing as part of its initial assessment for the 2000-2001 school year.
Reading Fluency Assessment
It is generally accepted that one who reads accurately, at a reasonable rate, and with ease or automaticity is considered fluent. Visual deficits and problems with decoding can hinder fluency. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT should have been assessed in the area of reading fluency. However, it is apparent from his testimony and the testimony of the other education professionals that the value to STUDENT of a reading fluency assessment was to alert the District to the underlying deficits that were interfering with STUDENT’s reading, principally the visual and coding deficits. Had the District conducted assessments in the areas of phonological processing and visual functioning/processing, a reading fluency assessment might have been unnecessary. The District did not conduct those other assessments. A fluency assessment would probably have pointed the District in the right direction. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to conduct a required assessment of STUDENT in the area of reading fluency in connection with STUDENT’s IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. (Footnote 32)
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of phonological processing, visual functioning/processing, and reading fluency as part of its initial assessment for the 2000-2001 school year.
2001-2002 SCHOOL YEAR
Phonological Processing Assessment
There was no evidence of changed circumstances during the intervening year that would have caused the District to eliminate phonological processing as a suspected cause of STUDENT’s continuing written language deficits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of phonological processing in connection with his IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Visual Functioning/Processing Assessment
There is nothing in the record to suggest that the District either ruled out visual functioning/processing deficits as a cause of STUDENT’s continuing difficulties with reading and writing or that it assessed its role at all during the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of visual functioning/processing in connection with his IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Auditory Processing Assessment
In May 2001, when the IEP team was planning STUDENT’s program for the 2001-2002 school year, the team was aware that auditory processing continued to be an area of weakness. A goal was developed to continue to address that deficit during the year. There was no request at the time for an auditory processing assessment. There were no other circumstances that should have led the District to reassess in that area. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to reassess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing in connection with his IEP for the 2001-2002 school year.
Reading Fluency Assessment
Assessments by Ms. Schuller and Dr. Patterson in 2002 and 2003 showed that STUDENT had a significant deficit in reading fluency. That deficit did not materialize just prior to those assessments. It existed all along. STUDENT’s poor fluency should have been apparent to teachers whose job it was to make sure that he had appropriate reading skills. Something should have been done by this time to more carefully focus on STUDENT’s problems with written language. If the District had conducted appropriate assessments of STUDENT’s phonological and visual functioning/processing skills, an assessment of reading fluency might have been redundant. In part because the District persistently failed to conduct those assessments, it should have assessed STUDENT’s reading fluency.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of reading fluency in connection with his IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of phonological processing, visual functioning/processing, and reading fluency in connection with his IEP for the 2001-2002 school year.
2002-2003 SCHOOL YEAR
Phonological Processing Assessment
More information came to the attention of the District that should have caused it to conduct more focused assessments in the area of reading, including an assessment of phonological processing, to determine the cause of STUDENT’s difficulties with written language. In an email dated May 2, 2002 to STUDENT’s English teacher, Ms. PARENT complained that her nephew was struggling in classes that required reading and written expression. At the IEP meeting on May 8, 2002, the parent explained to the team that STUDENT took two or three times as long as other students to read the same material. STUDENT was receiving consistently poor grades in his English class. There was no report of any improvement in STUDENT’s written language skills at the meeting. Ms. PARENT requested that STUDENT be given reading remediation services over the summer. The District referred STUDENT to Ms. Bloomfield’s summer 2002 reading class, but still it did not conduct an assessment in this area.
During the summer of 2002, STUDENT attended Julie Bloomfield’s special education reading class, where STUDENT received one-on-one and small-group instruction in decoding, spelling, comprehension and written language. Ms. Bloomfield testified that she believed that STUDENT would benefit from more instruction, and she so informed the District. She recommended that he focus on comprehension and fluency skills.
Even Ms. PARENT’s revocation of her consent to the May 2002 IEP and the information provided by Ms. Schuller at the September 19, 2003 IEP meeting did not stir the District into action. The District did not take steps to do its own assessment of STUDENT’s phonological processing skills until it included them and related assessments on the December 16, 2002 assessment plan.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of phonological processing in connection with his IEP for the 2002-2003 school year prior to its request to do so on or about December 16, 2002. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Visual Functioning/Processing Assessment
In addition to the information that it already had about his problems with tracking, in May 2002 Ms. PARENT complained to the IEP team that STUDENT was taking two to three times longer than most other students to read the required material. Still, the District did not conduct visual functioning/processing assessment in preparation for the meeting to develop STUDENT’s IEP for the 2002-2003 school year.
There was a vision assessment and a recommendation of therapy by Dr. Perez in November 2002, apparently at the request of Ms. PARENT to whom the report was addressed. (Footnote 33)Although the District offered this document into evidence, the Hearing Officer does not know when the District first became aware of the report. It was almost a month later on or about December 16, 2002, that the District for the first time sought permission to conduct its own visual assessment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of visual functioning/processing in connection with his IEP for the 2002-2003 school year prior to its request to do so on or about December 16, 2002. 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).
Auditory Processing Assessment
In May 2002, the IEP team agreed that short-term memory and auditory processing deficits continued to impact STUDENT’s learning and a goal to address that area of weakness was again included in his IEP. The NCCSE assessment summary dated October 10, 2002 acknowledges the need to continue to address deficits in auditory processing.
The Petitioner asserts that an assessment of auditory processing skills by a licensed audiologist was required. His expert, Carol Atkins, is a qualified audiologist with many years of experience conducting assessments and consulting with special education litigants, usually parents and their attorneys. She conducted a thorough evaluation of STUDENT on December 30, 2002. Prior to her testimony, Ms. Atkins obtained a history from STUDENT and his family, reviewed records, including the lengthy report of Dr. Patterson, and conducted a thorough audiometric assessment, looking at everything from hearing acuity to the temporal processing of auditory input.
Ms. Atkins concluded that STUDENT had a deficit “most like” an inability to apply the underlying rules of language to what he hears (associative defect) and an inability to perform tasks that require intersensory or interhemispheric (requiring both sides of the brain) communication (integration defect). She recommended a systematic, rule-based approach to language and learning as well as a number of specific methodologies to increase linguistic familiarity and auditory memory. She also recommended OT exercises to improve interhemispheric communication, the improvement of self-advocacy skills, and various classroom accommodations.
District speech and language therapist Lauranne Howard provided services to STUDENT during his three years at La Costa and assumed principal responsibility for addressing his auditory processing and memory deficits. She disagreed with Ms. Atkins. Ms. Howard testified that an assessment by an audiologist was not necessary because the District had no need for information more detailed than what it already knew. The IEP team knew that there were auditory processing deficits. Ms. Howard assessed those in her administration of the CELF and attempted to address them in her therapy by focusing on the listening and receptive language goals. In her opinion, Ms. Atkin’s report added little of value. Ms. Howard testified that, other than the recommendation regarding OT to increase interhemispheric communication, Ms. Atkins’ recommendations were things that the IEP team had already considered.
The Hearing Officer is satisfied that the District properly assessed STUDENT’s auditory processing skills. Although the IEP team did not have the opinion of an audiologist before Carol Atkins’ report was shared sometime after mid-January 2003, the evidence shows that the IEP team recognized that STUDENT had deficits in auditory processing and auditory memory. An assessment by an audiologist was not required. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Atkins’ opinions to the contrary unpersuasive. She did not explain why or how her findings were necessary to either identify or address an area of need for special education or related services. On the contrary, her stated expectation that STUDENT would be graduating and moving on to community college with supports available there is a good indication that she realized that STUDENT had been benefiting and would continue to benefit from his speech and language services at La Costa.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to reassess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing in connection with his IEP for the 2002-2003 school year.
Reading Fluency Assessment
The Hearing Officer has found that the District should have assessed STUDENT in the areas of visual and phonological processing. In the absence of those assessments, an assessment of reading fluency would have helped to point the way toward the goal of identifying the causes if STUDENT’s difficulties with reading and written expression. The District did not take steps to assess in this area until its proposed assessment plan dated December 16, 2002. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of reading fluency in connection with his IEP for the 2002-2003 school year until December 16, 2002.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year until on or about December 16, 2002, the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of phonological processing, visual functioning/processing and reading fluency. There was no failure to assess STUDENT in the area of auditory processing.
Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to timely provide the Petitioner’s parent with a written assessment plan following her request to assess in 2002?
The Petitioner alleges that she requested an assessment at the IEP meeting on May 8, 2002, and that the District failed to timely deliver an assessment plan to her following that request. The District contends that the request was made in September 2002 and that it timely provided an assessment plan pursuant to that request.
A proposed assessment plan must be prepared in writing and delivered to the student’s parent within fifteen days of the request or referral. Excluded for the allowed fifteen days are days between the student’s regular school sessions or terms, days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays, and such other time as agreed upon between the District and the parents. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(a).
Ms. PARENT’s claim that she requested an assessment at the IEP meeting on May 8, 2002 is not supported by the evidence. The notes from the May 2002 IEP indicate only that the parent was informed about the triennial assessment and review that would occur the following year and that she could request that specific assessments be incorporated into and made a part of that process. (Footnote 34) Ms. PARENT’s testimony is contradicted by the testimony of Ms. Howard who stated that the assessment was requested at the September 2002 meeting. There is no written request for an assessment. (Footnote 35) Ms. PARENT’s testimony is also inconsistent with her letter to Ms. Nest dated more than two weeks before the September IEP meeting that specifically requests an IEP meeting to revise STUDENT’s IEP but mentions nothing about an assessment plan being overdue or about assessment at all. Likewise, the partial transcript of the September IEP meeting reveals that Ms. PARENT did not mention a prior request for an assessment or an overdue assessment plan, even when discussing the May 2002 IEP meeting. When the District suggested starting the assessment process immediately and meeting again within fifty days, Ms. PARENT asked if it the process could be completed more quickly, but said nothing about an earlier request.
The evidence establishes that the Petitioner’s parent did not request an assessment in May 2002 and that the District timely provided an assessment plan following the IEP team’s agreement on September 19, 2002, that an assessment should be conducted. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to timely provide the Petitioner’s parent with a written assessment plan following her request to assess in 2002.
Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student in a public school is entitled to a FAPE. A FAPE issue can present both procedural and substantive questions.
Procedurally, the law requires that the IEP process be designed and conducted to allow the student and parents to effectively participate in the IEP process. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may in and of itself constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).
Substantively, a FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State LEA, and are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs that cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. It must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).
An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the student. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Moreover, the focus of the inquiry is not on whether the student may obtain greater benefit in the program that is preferred by the parents but, rather, whether the school district’s proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982); Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).
In summary, to be found to provide a FAPE, an IEP must be the result of a process that adequately protected the rights of the parents and student. In addition, the IEP itself must (1) be designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) conform to the student’s IEP. (Footnote 36) The local educational agency (LEA) has the burden of proof on all of these issues. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
PROCEDURAL CLAIMS
Procedurally, the Petitioner alleges that the District violated its procedural obligations to him and his parent in three respects. He claims that the District:
(1) failed to provide in the IEP for a method to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress; (2) failed to inform the parent regarding progress; and, (3) failed to notify him that transition services would be considered at the May 2000 IEP meeting.
The District asserts that it complied with the procedural requirements and that it’s failure to do so in particular respects, if any, caused no harm.
IEP Provision for Reports of Progress
The IEP process should be not only a collaborative process, it should be a continuous process, one that is closely monitored by teachers, parents, and others to ensure that the purposes of the IDEA are being met. Measurable goals, including benchmarks or benchmarks/short-term objectives, are critical elements of an IEP. They are the foundation for the development of strategies that that will effectively meet the student’s unique needs. They enable the parents, students and educators to monitor progress during the year and to revise the IEP, if necessary to meet the student’s needs. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A. It is the responsibility of the IEP team to review and consider revision of the IEP when there is a lack of expected progress toward goals and objectives and when information or assessment data provided by the parents warrant such review. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(d).
Parents have always had an important role in the education of their disabled children under the IDEA. That role was further strengthened as part of the 1997 reauthorization. An IEP must now contain a statement of how the student’s progress toward annual goals will be measured and how the parents will be regularly informed regarding that progress. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, 34.300-60A; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(10).
It is therefore clear that the effective participation of parents in the IEP process requires that they be informed regarding the student’s progress toward annual goals. There is no provision in the IEP for the 2000-2001 school year for such notification. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was deficient in this respect.
Reports of Progress
Ms. PARENT testified that she received report cards, but no reports regarding STUDENT’s progress toward the two goals contained in this IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. The District offered no evidence to show that it fulfilled its obligation to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress, or lack thereof. The evidence showed that the District was not adhering to proper IEP procedures. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s advancement toward his goals was measured or that the goals themselves were measurable at all. The goals were essentially abandoned at the first annual review with only anecdotal references to STUDENT’s progress. Critical information that should have guided the parents, student, and educators was simply not available. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his goals.
Notice Regarding Consideration of Transition Services at IEP Meeting
Parents are entitled to receive reasonable notice of an IEP meeting. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(b). When the student is age 14 or older, as STUDENT was when this meeting was convened, the notice must indicate that a purpose of the meeting will be the development of a statement of transition service needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(d). There is no evidence that STUDENT’s parent received the appropriate notice. Ms. PARENT testified that she never received the required notice of the meeting. There is a copy of a notice in evidence, but it is dated the day of the meeting, and it does not contain the notice regarding a planned discussion of transition. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to notify the parent that transition services would be considered at the May 2001 IEP meeting.
SUBSTANTIVE CLAIMS
The Petitioner also contends that the District denied him a substantive FAPE. He alleges that the District:
(1) failed to identify STUDENT’s need in the area of task completion; (2) failed to design an IEP to meet his needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency), written language, spelling, task completion, and visual functioning/processing; (3) It failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum; and, (4) failed to provide ESY services as specified in his May 9, 2001 IEP.
The District contends that it provided a FAPE to STUDENT.
The placement and services are not determined by the eligibility classification. If a student is qualified for special education under any category, the IEP must be designed to meet the student’s educational needs that result from the disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345 (a)(2). The FAPE analysis initially requires a determination of what STUDENT’s needs were during the time in question.
STUDENT’s Needs
STUDENT contends that during the 2000-2001 school year he had specific needs in the following areas: reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and reading fluency), spelling, written expression, task completion, and visual functioning and processing. STUDENT also claims that he needed extended year services (ESY) to prevent regression from which he could not timely recover. (Footnote 37)
As evidenced by the goals in the IEP for that school year, the parties agreed that STUDENT had needs then in the areas of reading and oral and written expressive language. However, because the District failed to identify through assessment or otherwise the particular deficiencies that were causing STUDENT’s problems, and because the IEP goals for that year do not adequately specify the area of need being addressed, this apparent agreement is of little assistance in the determination of STUDENT’s specific and unique needs. The parties agree that he had needs in the areas of auditory processing and memory, which needs are not at issue here.
STUDENT came to the District after two and one-half years in private schools. He did not have an IEP when he arrived, but an IEP had been developed for him by EUSD in June 1997 based upon assessments done around that time. STUDENT’s school records contain information about those assessments and about his earlier problems with reading and written language. (Footnote 38)
The District’s initial assessment and other evidence available at the time indicated that STUDENT had average cognitive ability, with visual-motor deficits, and slow processing speed. Although the assessment suggested that STUDENT was able to perform at a level commensurate with his ability in most academic areas, it demonstrated significant deficits in written language, including spelling.
In the opinion of Jodie Schuller, a licensed speech and language pathologist who holds a master’s degree in communicative disabilities, STUDENT’s phonological awareness was probably inadequate for mastering the phonics system. She relied on the CELF-III that had been administered by NCCSE in May 2000 to conclude that STUDENT also had a moderate delay in “grammatic” [sic] development. Although he had adequate conversational and narrative skills to tell and write grade-level literature, the writing Process Test revealed significant deficiencies in his ability to execute the process of writing. Ms. Schuller concluded that STUDENT had needs in the areas of phonological awareness, decoding, spelling, syllabication, reading comprehension, reading fluency and writing skills. (Footnote 39)
Patricia Padgett is a former employee of Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, who worked as a clinician and in other capacities from 1990 until she started her own business as an educational consultant in 1997. She did not assess STUDENT but was paid to provide services to him beginning on October 27, 2003, more than four months after STUDENT received his diploma. Ms. Padgett testified that in her opinion, STUDENT has needs in the areas of phonoogical awareness and decoding.
Dr. Robert Patterson is a licensed and qualified psychologist who was retained to assess STUDENT. The doctor testified that STUDENT has average cognitive abilities but processes things slowly and has poor fluency, probably as a result of a language processing deficit. (Footnote 40) STUDENT also has poor sound blending skills and difficulty seeing or hearing sound-symbol relationships. These adversely affect his ability to spell and read. He also exhibits a pattern of decreasing performance on a given task over time that is typical of student with attention and processing disorders. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT has needs in various areas. The ones that are pertinent here are reading, particularly phonetic decoding, reading comprehension, reading fluency, spelling (phonetic encoding), and written expression. He opines that, although STUDENT is not technically dysgraphic, he has many characteristics of that disorder.
Julie Bloomfield taught STUDENT in his special reading and written language class during the summer of 2002. She and her staff provided small group instruction. Most of the time was spent on basic reading skills, including decoding and comprehension, but they also covered spelling and written language. Ms. Bloomfield testified that STUDENT benefited from the instruction, and she recommended additional one-on-one or small group instruction in reading and written language.
Although Ms. Schuller, Ms. Padgett, Ms. Bloomfield, and Dr. Patterson all assessed or worked with STUDENT in 2002 and later, their opinions were consistent with the District’s initial assessment and those from prior years. The Hearing Officer finds that the areas of need identified by them were also present during the District’s assessment for the 2000-2001 school year.
Lauranne Howard, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist throughout high school is of the opinion that STUDENT’s needs have always been in the area of listening comprehension and expressive language. She does not believe that he had a need in the area of phonological awareness or processing, and she disagrees with the opinions of Jodie Schuller to the contrary. In support of view, Ms. Howard points to the lack of any prior test result suggesting that there was a deficit of sufficient severity to require special education or related services.
STUDENT has a long and well-documented history of difficulties with reading and written language. Dr. Carpenter, EUSD psychologist, diagnosed a phonetic decoding deficit in 1997. The Hearing Officer found her report to be thorough and well reasoned. She explained in her report that persons with this deficit have difficulty with the decoding and encoding of written language, precisely the difficulty that STUDENT consistently exhibited before the 2000-2001 school year. The opinions of Ms. Schuller, Ms. Padgett, and Dr. Patterson all essentially agreed with Dr. Carpenter’s view of STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading and written language. Even Ms. Bloomfield, the teacher who provided intense instruction to STUDENT in these areas during the summer of 2002 was of the opinion that STUDENT required the service and would benefit from even more assistance with reading and written language after she completed her work with him.
STUDENT had consistently performed at least two to three grades below grade level in broad reading on standardized tests. (Footnote 41) He was tested at more than three grade levels behind in reading comprehension in 1997 and 2000. The gap between his performance and grade level in written language grew from two to three grade levels in 1994 to five grade levels in 2000 based on the District’s initial assessment. In that same WJ-R battery, STUDENT’s score on the applied problems subtest that uses word problems was two grade equivalents worse than his score on the math calculation subtest that does not use word problems.
The weight of the evidence convinces the Hearing Officer that STUDENT did have specific and unique needs during the 2000-2001 school years in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and reading fluency), spelling, and written expression.
The Petitioner called Susan Daniels, O.D. to testify regarding his visual functioning/processing deficit. Dr. Daniels is a certified optometrist who also holds a therapeutic license to prescribe medication. Ms. PARENT hired her from the District’s approved list of providers to perform the visual therapy that had been recommended by Dr. Hillier. She started the therapy in April 2003 and concluded her approved ten visits in July 2003. Dr. Daniels testified that STUDENT has visual difficulties with visual functioning that adversely impacted the learning process. These included moderate difficulty with pursuit (necessary for keeping one’s place and following smoothly), saccades (the ability to rapidly switch one’s gaze between objects, such as the teacher at the front of the class and a book on one’s desk), accommodation (switching focus between near and far), binocular alignment (eyes working in alignment to produce a single, stable image), and visual processing skills, including visual memory, visual sequential memory, and visual closure. She also testified that it is likely that STUDENT had these problems throughout the school years at issue. Dr. Daniels testified that STUDENT showed marked improvement as a result of the ten therapy sessions provided by her.
The testimony of Dr. Daniels stood alone on the question of STUDENT’s needs in the areas of visual functioning and processing. The District called no witness to refute her testimony. Dr. Daniels’ opinions were consistent with those expressed in writing by Dr. Hillier, who, along with Dr. Daniels, is on the District’s approved list of providers. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had a unique need in the area of visual functioning and processing during the 2000-2001 school year.
The evidence showed that there was some concern about an attention deficit and organizational problems three or four years before STUDENT entered the District. As part of the initial assessment, Ms. PARENT told the District that STUDENT required lots of prompting to do homework. The Hearing Officer finds little else in the record to support a finding that STUDENT had a unique need in the area of task completion during the 2000-2001 school year, and finds that task completion was not an area of need at that time.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 2000-2001 school year STUDENT had needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and reading fluency), spelling, written expression, and visual functioning and processing. The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT’s difficulties with written language required not only that they be addressed directly, but also that he be provided with access to equipment and/or services that would better enable him to keep up with class notes and written assignments. He did not have a need in the area of task completion. (Footnote 42)
Designed to Meet Needs
The Hearing Officer has already referred to the importance of the IEP document. It is the blueprint that guides educators, service providers, students, and parents in their efforts to provide a FAPE. In order to meet a student’s unique special education needs, an IEP must contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, that relate to meeting those needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). The IEP must also contain appropriate and objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for measuring progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(7). Without appropriate measurable goals, the measurement of progress is problematic.
The IEP must also provide the special educational instruction and related services, the supplementary aids and services, and the program modifications or supports that are reasonably designed to assist the student to make appropriate progress toward his or her goals. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT had needs in the areas of reading and writing. The IEP for the 2000-2001 school year contained a goal to address those needs. However, the goal was critically defective and indicative of the District’s disregard for what an IEP should be.
The goal required STUDENT to “improve writing and reading skills.” The goal itself is vague and without any reference to determine when the goal would be met. The first benchmark/short-term objective for this goal was for STUDENT to write a three-paragraph essay with correct punctuation and grammar. The second was for STUDENT to be able to read seventh-grade level material with 80% comprehension. (Footnote 43) There were no due dates for either benchmark/short-term objective and STUDENT was designated as the person responsible for implementing the goal and measuring progress. Baselines were apparently references to the May 2000 WJ-R broad reading and broad written language grade equivalent scores, 7.7 for reading and 4.5 for written language, but there was no appropriate and objective criteria, evaluation procedures or schedules for measuring progress. None of the specific deficits that made reading and writing difficult for STUDENT were addressed at all. Spelling instruction is also not part of the goals. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal and benchmarks/short-term objectives were inadequate and not designed to meet STUDENT’s special education needs in the areas of reading and written expression.
According to the IEP, STUDENT was to be placed in special education classes for English, history, and math. The testimony and other evidence revealed that he was not put in a special education English class where he might have had an opportunity to work on his basic language skills. He was also to receive speech and language services once weekly for thirty minutes. However, no specialized instruction in STUDENT’s basic written language deficits was included. The several professionals who testified for STUDENT on the matter agreed that he needed this instruction. The Hearing Officer found their testimony to be credible and finds that the IEP services were not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading and written expression.
No visual therapy or other service was offered or provided to meet STUDENT’s visual functioning and processing needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the related services to be provided to STUDENT were not adequate to meet his needs in this area.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s special education needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Benefit
The Hearing Officer has already found that the goals and objectives of the IEP were inadequate because they did not properly address STUDENT’s specific areas of need, and they provided no reliable data, methods, or scheduling to measure his progress. Furthermore, the IEP contained inadequate instruction or services to enable STUDENT to make meaningful progress toward his special education goals. The District argues that STUDENT’s passing grades show that he received benefit, but this was STUDENT’s first program at La Costa, so the District could not look back at past years’ grades to argue that an IEP so lacking in the necessary components could still confer the required benefit. (Footnote 44)
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide a meaningful educational benefit to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year.
Conformance to the IEP
The Offer of Note-taking Assistance
STUDENT’s written language skills were five grade levels behind his then current grade when the IEP was developed. The IEP team recognized that STUDENT would have difficulty with written work in class and at home. It offered to provide assistance with note-taking “as agreed upon by instructors.” (Footnote 45) However, there was no evidence that the District took any steps to ensure that STUDENT’s instructors were informed regarding this offer or that they were instructed to take reasonable steps to implement this component of the IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District should have made an Alphasmart keyboard, a note-taker or some other assistance available to STUDENT to compensate for his writing difficulties while the remediation process was underway. Because the District took no action to provide that assistance, the Hearing Officer finds that the program as provided did not conform to the IEP in this respect.
The Offer of ESY Services
ESY services extend educational programming beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months in order to provide the student with a FAPE. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY services when the student has unique needs that require special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year. Generally, a student is entitled to ESY services if he or she has handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. A student would also be entitled to ESY services if, for any reason, the IEP team included those services on the IEP.
The May 31, 2000 IEP for the 2000-2001 school year was intended to run from September 2000 to September 2001, including the 2001 summer break when ESY services would have been provided to students. That IEP did not provide for ESY services. However, a new annual IEP was agreed upon on May 9, 2001, and was to remain in effect for one year from that date. It did provide for ESY services for thirty days at four hours per day. (Footnote 46) The evidence established that STUDENT was not provided with ESY services during the summer of 2001 as specified by his IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program did not conform to his IEP in this respect.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide a FAPE to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year by:
1. failing to provide in the IEP for a method to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress; 2. failing to inform the parent regarding his progress toward his goals; 3. failing to notify the parent that transition services would be considered at the May 2001 IEP meeting; 4. failing to design an IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs and provide a meaningful educational benefit in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing; 5. failing to provide note-taking assistance in conformance to the IEP; and, 6. failing to provide ESY services in conformance to the IEP.
Issue No. 4: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year and extended school year?
The IEP team developed the educational plan for the 2001-2002 school year at a meeting on May 9, 2001.
PROCEDURAL CLAIMS
Procedurally, the Petitioner alleges that the District violated its procedural obligations to him and his parent in three respects. He claims that the District:
(1) failed to inform the parent regarding progress; and, (2) failed to notify the parent that transition services would be considered at the May 2001 IEP meeting.
The District asserts that it complied with the procedural requirements and that it’s failure to do so in particular respects, if any, caused no harm.
Reports of Progress
Ms. PARENT testified that she was not informed regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his IEP goals and objectives. The District made no attempt to prove otherwise. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to inform the parents regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his IEP goals.
Notice Regarding Consideration of Transition Services at IEP Meeting
The District offered no evidence to establish that the notice of the IEP meeting contained the required reference to transition services. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to give the appropriate notice.
SUBSTANTIVE CLAIMS
The Petitioner also contends that the District denied him a substantive FAPE. He alleges that the District:
(1) failed to design an IEP to meet his needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency), written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing; and, (2) It failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum. (Footnote 47)
The District contends that it provided a FAPE to STUDENT.
STUDENT’s Needs
The Hearing Officer must first determine whether or not STUDENT’s needs changed.
There is nothing in the record to suggest that the District had adequately addressed STUDENT’s reading and written language needs, or that the specific causes of his deficits had been addressed at all. There was also no new assessment data to suggest that the general or special education provided by the District during the 2000-2001 school year had ameliorated the problem. (Footnote 48) Likewise, the evidence demonstrated that the District neither identified nor addressed STUDENT’s visual functioning/processing needs during the year.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing.
Designed to Meet Needs
The IEP contained an annual expressive language goal that stated that STUDENT would continue to improve his expressive language skills by fifty percent. That goal on its face was inadequate. There is no baseline and nothing against which it could be measured. There was no evidence to suggest that such a dramatic improvement was a reasonable expectation.
The goal contained, under the guise of benchmarks/short-term objectives, what are really two other annual goals. One stated that STUDENT would continue to practice the production of complete, complex and grammatically correct oral sentences of increasing length. The other stated that he would continue to produce complete, complex and grammatically correct written sentences and paragraphs of increased length. Again, there were no practical baselines, and the goals were not really measurable. There were no goals or benchmarks/short-term objectives to address reading, spelling, or any of the specific deficits that were causing the problems with reading and writing, including visual functioning/processing.
These goals ignored the deficits that were at the root of many of STUDENT’s problems with written language and were so general and lacking required detail that they would have been useless in measuring STUDENT’s progress. The goals and objectives did not meet the requirements of the law. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2). The Hearing Officer finds that on this basis alone the District failed to design the IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency), written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing.
According to the IEP document, the special education component of STUDENT’s instructional day was reduced by this IEP from fifty percent to twenty percent. His only special education class was to support his general education math class. Although STUDENT was to continue to receive thirty minutes of speech and language services from Ms. Howard weekly, her services were to be guided by the goals and objectives. She did not believe that STUDENT needed services to address needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency) or spelling. No special education instruction or services were to be provided to address a need in these areas.
This IEP did not indicate that STUDENT was to be provided with any form of note-taking assistance to compensate for his difficulties with written language. Part of meeting STUDENT’s needs in the area of written language was the obligation to provide assistive technology or services, such as an Alphasmart keyboard, a note-taker, or other device or assistance to help STUDENT to make up for his writing deficits and thereby access the curriculum. The assistance was included in the prior year’s IEP. (Footnote 49) There was no explanation as to why it was omitted from this IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to design the IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs in this respect.
STUDENT’s needs in the area of visual functioning/processing continued, but the IEP does not address those needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to design the IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs in the area of visual functioning/processing.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s special education needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Benefit
It appears from the evidence that the District was satisfied that STUDENT was passing his classes and matriculating from year to year and that his apparent success justified a reduction in services. It is possible that his passing grades might have a different significance if the question were eligibility. Rowley, supra, at 203, n. 25.; Student v. Encinitas Union School District, (2003) SEHO Case No. SN02-00363. However, the question here is whether the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide the required benefit to STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer has held that the IEP for the 2000-2001 school year was not reasonably calculated to provide the required benefit to STUDENT. There was no adequate evidence to show that STUDENT had made progress in reading or written language during the 2000-2001 school year. The 2000-2001 goals and objectives, which should have provided a basis for that determination, were of no use. There were no new standardized assessment scores. There were only grades; but these were not an adequate measure of STUDENT’s progress in his areas of need because there was no evidence to establish how the grades correlated with actual progress toward IEP goals or even that they were fairly indicative of STUDENT’s progress in the general curriculum. (Footnote 50) This IEP for the 2001-2002 school year was not better than the one for the previous year. The goals and objectives were inadequate, which would once again prevent the IEP team, including the parent and the student, from knowing whether or not STUDENT was making any progress at all. (Footnote 51) In addition, although there was no reliable indication that STUDENT had made progress under the 2000-2001 IEP, services were reduced.
The Hearing Officer finds that the IEP for the 2001-2002 school year was not reasonably calculated to provide the required educational benefit on STUDENT.
Conformance to the IEP
There is no issue regarding the conformance of the IEP to the provided program during the 2001-2002 school year.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide a FAPE to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year in the following respects:
1. It failed to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his goals; 2. It failed to provide notice that transition would be addressed at the May 9, 2001 IEP meeting; 3. It failed to design an IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs and provide a meaningful educational benefit in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing; and, 4. It failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum.
Issue No. 5: Did the District fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year?
There were several IEP meetings that dealt with STUDENT’s educational program for the 2002-2003 school year. The first was the annual review that took place on May 8, 2002. An agreed-upon IEP resulted from that meeting. There were also meetings on September 16, November 25, and December 16, 2002, and on February 10 and March 12, 2003.
PROCEDURAL CLAIMS
The Petitioner makes three procedural allegations for this school year. He alleges that the District:
(1) failed to make an appropriately specific offer in the May 2002 IEP; (2) failed to notify him that transition services would be considered at the November 2002 IEP meeting; and, (3) failed to inform his parent regarding progress toward his goals and objectives following the March 12, 2003 IEP.
The District asserts that it complied with the procedural requirements and that its failure to do so in particular respects, if any, caused no harm.
Specificity of May 2002 Offer
Districts are required to give written prior notice to the parents of the child whenever they propose to initiate or change, or refuse to initiate or change, the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child, or the provision of a free appropriate public education to the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Such notice provides the parents with information that can help them to make informed decisions about their child’s education. The notice is also important in that it helps ensure that there is a clear record of what placement, services and assistance were offered to the student and when they were offered. This information might be required years after the fact if there is a dispute about compliance with the special education laws. The same reasoning supports the rule that when an offer of a FAPE is required at all, it must be a formal and specific offer. Union School Dist. v. B. Smith 15 F. 3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994).
The Hearing Officer agrees that the May 2002 IEP does not contain the kind of specific written information that the Petitioner needed to make an informed decision. It states that the team recommended primary service though the resource specialist in LCC, but it provides no information regarding the frequency, duration, or type of service to be provided, or the percentage of time that would be spent in special education. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make an appropriately specific offer in the May 2002 IEP.
Adequacy of Notice of IEP Meeting
Neither party offered into evidence a copy of the notice of the November 2002 IEP meeting. Since the District has failed to carry its burden of proof that its notice complied with the law, the Hearing Officer finds that it did not comply and that the notice was inadequate to inform the parent and student that transition would be addressed at the November 2002 IEP meeting.
Notice of Progress
When the Petitioner revoked consent to the May 2002 IEP, the last agreed-upon IEP became operable. He should have been working on the goals contained in that IEP. Those were designated for study skills, auditory processing, and written and oral expressive language. (Footnote 52) According to the IEP, the parent should have been informed of progress toward goals and objectives through progress summaries at the end of each semester. Although there were several IEP meetings over the next few months, there was no agreement on a new IEP before the end of the first semester. The team agreed to a thirty-day interim placement at the February 10, 2003 IEP meeting, but there was no change to the requirement of progress reports proposed or agreed upon. While the March 12, 2003 proposed IEP would have required quarterly reports through annotated goals and objectives, there was no agreement to this IEP. However, there was also no evidence that the parent was provided with a report of semester progress at the end of the school year as required by law. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his goals and objectives following the March 12, 2003 IEP.
SUBSTANTIVE CLAIMS
Substantively, the Petitioner claims that the District (1) failed to design an IEP to meet his needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency) for the entire year, and in the areas of written language/spelling and visual functioning/processing until the March 12, 2003 IEP; (Footnote 53) and, (2) failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum.
The District contends that it offered and provided a FAPE to the Petitioner.
May 8, 2002 IEP
STUDENT’s Needs
There was no evidence to suggest that the Petitioner’s needs changed substantially during the year preceding the May 2002 IEP meeting. According to the IEP documents generated that date, the “latest test results” showed his performance lagged two to three grade levels behind in math and reading and six to seven grade levels behind in writing ability. Although it appears that this reference is to the District’s initial assessment in May 2000, the reference to that data strongly suggests that the District had no reliable information upon which to base a more hopeful view of STUDENT’s performance. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s needs that have been placed at issue in this case continued to be the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing. These specific deficits were, in turn, adversely affecting STUDENT’s ability to keep up with class lectures (note-taking) and written assignments.
Designed to Meet Needs
STUDENT’s May 2002 IEP goal and objectives for written language, including spelling, were essentially identical to those from the prior year. Therefore, they shared the same deficiencies. There was no adequate report of progress made during the preceding year, even when more detailed information was requested by Ms. PARENT. There were no specific goals in the May 2002 IEP to address the phonological awareness, decoding, or any of the other specific deficits that were impacting STUDENT’s reading and writing skills. There was no reliable evidence to show that STUDENT had made any progress in his deficit areas, but the IEP again reduces the amount of special education for STUDENT. Other than the continuation of the thirty-minute weekly speech and language session, STUDENT was to have received an unspecified amount of RSP services of an unspecified nature. In addition, the District did not agree to address STUDENT’s visual functioning and processing needs in the May 2002 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that the May 2002 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Benefit
The May 2002 IEP contained inadequate goals and objectives and no clear promise of services to address STUDENT’s areas of need in reading and written language other than thirty minutes weekly of speech and language. The District’s position is that STUDENT’s passing grades and his receipt of a regular diploma is all the benefit that the law requires. The Hearing Officer disagrees. The District was obligated to provide special education and related services designed to meet the STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide an educational benefit. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Rowley, supra, at 200. There is nothing in the IDEA or State law to suggest that grades or matriculation alone are acceptable barometers of educational benefit. They can be some evidence of benefit, but they are not the only measure. Rowley, supra, at 207, n. 28. Standardized test scores, teacher observation, and progress toward goals and objectives are also relevant.
The importance of the last-stated measure is apparent from the legal requirements regarding objectively measurable goals and objectives, but the District’s actions have prevented the Hearing Officer from relying on that important measure. There was no adequate evidence from teacher testimony. Although there were some general statements suggesting that STUDENT made progress, there was no way for the Hearing officer to determine from that testimony that STUDENT received the requisite benefit. In essence, the only evidence upon which a finding of benefit can rest is the evidence regarding his grades and the various assessments that have taken place over the last several years. For reasons discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment scores are a more reliable measure.
STUDENT’s grades did not show progress in the specific areas that should have been targeted by special education and related services. There was nothing to show how STUDENT earned those grades. The minimal testimony from the District’s witnesses regarding STUDENT’s progress was mostly the same kind of anecdotal information that was shared at the various IEP meetings. What little information that was provided indicated that STUDENT’s grades were largely based upon subjective evaluation. There was nothing in that testimony or in the grades that were awarded to STUDENT that can be relied upon to satisfy the requirement that there be objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for measuring progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(7) [Emphasis added].
The determination of whether or not an IEP was reasonably calculated to confer an educational benefit is generally based upon matters objectively known at he time it was drafted. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir.1999), citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993). However, under the circumstance presented here, with no measurable goals and objectives and no annual standardized testing, an examination of assessment data from before and after the May 2002 IEP meeting provides the only counterpoint to STUDENT’s grades and matriculation for this analysis of benefit.
COGNITIVE TESTING CHART
DATE CURRENT GRADE TEST VERBAL SEQENT. NONVERBAL SIMULT FULL SCALE COMP
May-97 6.9 WISC-3 79 104 90 May-97 6.9 KABC 83 101 92 May-00 9.9 WAIS-3 89 98 91 Apr-01 10.8 TONI 112 Oct-02 12.2 KBIT 99 110 105 Jun-03 Graduated CTONI 94
The above chart describes the results of STUDENT’s cognitive ability assessments from 1997 when he was last assessed by his prior school district to 2003 when he was last assessed at all by Dr. Patterson. Patterns emerge. One shows that STUDENT’s verbal skills were consistently improved, from 79 (now considered “borderline”) in 1997 to 99 (average) in 2002. Whether a result of STUDENT’s increasing familiarity with English or some other cause or causes, STUDENT never was a young man with less than average cognitive ability. He had average verbal ability at least average nonverbal ability and should have been able to make more than de minimus progress.
ACHIEVEMENT TESTING CHART
DATE GRADE AT TIME TEST READING RECOG. READING COMP BROAD READING DICTATION SPELLING WRITING SAMPLE BROAD WRITING May-97 6.9 WJ-R 4.1 (83) 3.6 (82) 3.9 (81) 2.6 (65) 5.6 (93) 3.4 (75) May-00 9.9 WJ-R 8.9 (100) 6.2 (91) 7.7 (95) 4.1 (74) 5.6 (89) 4.5 (76) Jun-02 11 KTEA 7.5 (81) 7.3 (80) 7.4 (80) 5.3 (72)
Oct-02 12.2 WJ-3 11.6 (99) 11.3 (98) 5.0 (76) 7.6 (87)
Nov-02 12.3 GORT 6.4 4.4 Jun-03 Graduated PIAT-R 6.6 (74) (58)
Jun-03 Graduated WRAT 5.0 (80) 4.0 (71)
Jun-03 Graduated NEL-DEN 7.4 4.1 4.1
The “Achievement Testing Chart,” above, summarizes STUDENT’s scores in reading and written language on achievement testing during the same period. STUDENT’s grades were poor during the three years between the 1997 and 2000 testing. Yet, the scores show almost three years of growth in broad reading during that period. There was substantially less growth in broad writing. The next testing by Ms. Schuller in June 2002 indicates that STUDENT had made just over one year of growth in reading comprehension and spelling, but had actually lost some recognition skills in the intervening two years.
The next assessment administered by Ms. Furgerson in October 2002 shows approximate year-for-year growth in reading recognition. In reading comprehension, STUDENT went from being 3.7 years behind grade level in 2000 to .9 years behind grade level in 2002, an effective gain of 5.1 grade levels in less than two and one-half years, a rather dramatic gain under the circumstances. The test materials that are in evidence include a notation that STUDENT was allowed to reread the passages. Ms. Furgerson did not explain the notation, but it is clear that allowing STUDENT to reread the materials, perhaps repeatedly, would have made it easier for him to comprehend. Ms. Furgerson’s assessment shows that STUDENT lost substantial ground in spelling and some ground in writing.
Later assessments by Ms. Schuller and Dr. Patterson do not show the gains that were suggested by Ms. Furgerson’s testing. Taken as a whole they show essentially no gain. In most areas they evidence a loss of skills. The testing by Dr. Patterson show that STUDENT was five to seven grade levels behind in reading recognition, more than eight grade levels behind in reading comprehension and broad reading, and six to nine grade levels behind in spelling. According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT’s writing sample was in the “retarded” range.
Because of the test selection and administration procedures and the wide variation in scores, the Hearing Officer cannot point to any particular assessment as indisputably indicative of STUDENT’s skill level at any given point in time. Nevertheless, certain truths can be gleaned from the data, and the Hearing Officer finds those truths to be more reliable indicators of STUDENT’s progress in the areas of reading and written language than his grades are. One such truth is that if STUDENT made any progress in the area of written expression, it was insignificant and certainly not sufficient to constitute a benefit from his educational program. Another truth is that the weight of the evidence indicates that STUDENT made insufficient progress in the area of reading. Although the 2002 administration of the WJ-III suggests that there was better than year-for-year progress in reading, the omission of subtests in significant areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability and the way that the tests were administered caused the Hearing Officer to give less weight to those scores as a measure of STUDENT’s reading skills than he gave to the tests administered by Dr. Patterson.
The Hearing Officer finds that, with the exception of the WJ-III scores, the results of the standardized assessments provide more convincing proof than STUDENT’s grades and that the scores from those assessments show that the May 2002 IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide the required educational benefit to STUDENT.
Conformance to the IEP
The May 2002 IEP states that “NCR note-taking” was to be provided to STUDENT. (Footnote 55) Along with books-on-tape, it is listed as a “supplemental aid or service.” (Footnote 56) This reference is reasonably construed as an expression of the District’s intent to appoint a competent classmate to provide a duplicate set of notes to STUDENT. That would have been one way to assist STUDENT with his class notes. However, the District did not show that there was any actual provision of the note-taking assistance. Under the circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the program that was provided failed to conform to the IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the May 2002 IEP did not provide a FAPE to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year in the following respects:
1. It failed to make an appropriately specific offer in the May 2002 IEP. 2. It failed to notify the Petitioner that transition services would be considered at the November 2002 IEP meeting. 3. It failed to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his goals. 4. It failed to design an IEP to meet his needs in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing; and, 5. failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum.
September 19, 2002 IEP Meeting
The May 2002 IEP was only in effect for the last month or so of the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. PARENT revoked her consent to the IEP around the time that the 2002-2003 school year began. There was another IEP meeting on September 19, 2002, but there is no evidence that this meeting resulted in a new IEP. Absent some agreement otherwise, the IEP last agreed upon before May 2002 became the operable IEP. That would have been the May 2001 IEP that has already been discussed above.
There was no evidence that STUDENT’s needs had changed appreciably since the prior May. He had had intensive instruction over the summer of 2002, both from Ms. Bloomfield and Ms. Schuller, but they testified that STUDENT continued to need additional individual or small group instruction in basic written language skills. The parties also agreed to add a class in which STUDENT was to receive direct instruction in reading basics, including the Earobics program to specifically address phonics skills. Although this instruction might have been sufficient to meet some of STUDENT’s needs and to provide a benefit with respect to those needs, there were no goals and objectives or other required components of an adequate IEP. The District continued to deny a substantive FAPE on the bases set forth above.
November 25, 2002 Meeting
STUDENT was reassessed by the District beginning in October 2002. The Kaufman Brief Intelligence Scale produced ability scores at the mid to high end of the average range (99 to 110) with a composite score of 105. The Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement, Third Edition (WJ-III) was used on this occasion. STUDENT’s lowest subtest scores were in spelling, which was at the fifth percentile and a 5.0 grade equivalent, the writing sample, which was at the twentieth percentile and a 7.6 grade equivalent, and applied problems, which was at the twenty-sixth percentile and a 7.6 grade equivalent. According to the testimony of Paula Furgerson, she did not administer the sound awareness, word attack, or any of the fluency subtests. There was no explanation given for omitting those tests. When Dr. Patterson administered the academic fluency subtests of the WJ-III, he found that STUDENT scored at or below the first percentile in reading fluency and at the seventh percentile in writing fluency.
Ms. Schuller also reassessed STUDENT in November 2002. She administered the GORT-4. According to this test, STUDENT’s rate, fluency, and comprehension scores all fell below the fifth percentile, with grade equivalents of 6.0 or lower. She also administered the OWLS and WPT to assess STUDENT’s writing skills. His score on the OWLS was at the sixteenth percentile. He scored at the first percentile in development and fluency on the WPT.
The evidence demonstrates that, in spite of the fact that STUDENT had received many hours of instruction in basic language skills over the summer of 2002, he still had needs in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning and processing. The testing conducted by the District showed apparent achievement in limited areas only. Subtests that could have been used to measure STUDENT’s skills in the areas that have been at the root of his difficulties, such as phonological awareness, decoding, and fluency, were not administered. The testing done by Ms. Schuller and Dr. Patterson shows that STUDENT’s basic skill deficits were still having a significant impact during the 2002-2003 school year and later. (Footnote 57) A fair reading of the District’s assessment results indicates that, while STUDENT showed some improvement in reading comprehension, he was just barely able to maintain year-for-year growth in spelling, writing, and solving word problems (applied problems) during the two and one-half years at La Costa. When a student arrives at the end of ninth grade as far behind his classmates as STUDENT was in his written language skills, year-for-year growth is de minimus.
Only STUDENT attended the November 25, 2002 IEP meeting. The two new goals that were proposed by the District, one to improve written language and the other to improve task completion and organizational skills, suffered from many of the same infirmities that affected earlier goals. The offer of special education instruction was likewise deficient. No new agreements were reached, and no further discussion of what transpired is required here.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District continued to deny a substantive FAPE on the bases set forth above.
December 16, 2002 Meeting
No new agreement was reached at the December 16, 2002 IEP meeting. The parties were becoming more polarized in their respective positions. Among other things, the parent demanded a developmental vision assessment, and two days later the District provided an assessment plan that included that assessment, as well as other assessments including the sound awareness, word attack, and reading fluency subtests of the WJ-III. With the exception of taking that step toward better identifying and meeting STUDENT’s needs, there were no other changed circumstances worthy of note here. The Hearing Officer finds that the District continued to deny a substantive FAPE on the bases set forth above.
February 10, 2003 Meeting
On February 3, 2003, Ms. PARENT consented to allow the District to assess STUDENT only in the areas of visual functioning and processing needs and occupational therapy needs. She refused to allow the District to perform the tests of STUDENT’s basic reading skills and fluency. Then, at the meeting of February 10, 2003, the District offered a new placement in general education with speech and language services for thirty minutes twice weekly and one period daily each of direct reading instruction in Ms. Furgerson’s class and LCC. The parties agreed to the District’s placement on an interim basis. Goals were proposed. Those addressed auditory memory and comprehension, decision making, and stress reduction. None addressed basic written language skills or visual functioning and processing.
The fact that Ms. PARENT refused to allow the District to conduct reading assessments that she herself had requested just a short time earlier may suggest a tactical maneuver orchestrated by counsel. However, her refusal did not relieve the District of its obligation to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of phonetic decoding, language construction, and visual functioning and processing. Although the District did offer a substantial increase in special instruction and related services, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the services were adequate and that the interim placement was designed to met STUDENT’s needs. Furthermore, the goals remained deficient.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District continued to deny a substantive FAPE on the bases set forth above.
March 12, 2003 Meeting
The Petitioner agrees that as of the date of the IEP meeting on March 12, 2003, the District offered and provided a substantive FAPE except in the areas of reading and note-taking assistance. The evidence does not demonstrate any changed circumstances, either with respect to STUDENT’s needs or any other pertinent matter since the last meeting on February 10, 2003.
The District offered a regular education placement for math, English, science, and electives (82%) with one period daily of reading instruction from Ms. Furgerson, one period of LCC, thirty minutes weekly of speech and language services, and various accommodations, including a note-taker and course outline.
The IEP included reading and spelling goals. The absence of benchmarks/short-term objectives is understandable since there were only three months remaining of STUDENT’s high school education. The spelling goal had a baseline, reference to STUDENT’s WJ-III score, and appears to have been designed to address his needs in the area of phonetic decoding. The reading goal was to increase STUDENT’s reading rate by one and one-half grade levels as measured by the GORT. An earlier score provides the baseline. This goal also appears to have been designed to meet STUDENT’s need to improve his reading rate.
The Hearing Officer finds that the March 12, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of phonetic decoding and note-taking.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Some Benefit
For the same reasons that the Hearing Officer’s finding that the March 12, 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of phonetic decoding and note-taking, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was reasonably calculated to provide the required educational benefit.
Conformance to the IEP
Although there was some dispute regarding the District’s actual provision of the reading and related introduction promised by the IEP, STUDENT agreed that he ultimately received at least forty minutes per class-day of reading instruction from Ms. Furgerson and additional one-on-one reading instruction from Mr. Ahrens in the LCC. However, there was no evidence that the District actually provided the note-taker or class outline that had been offered to help STUDENT to keep up with class work. The Hearing Officer finds that the program did not conform to the IEP with respect to the note-taking assistance only.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide a FAPE to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year in the following respects:
1. It failed to make an appropriately specific offer in the May 2002 IEP. 2. It failed to notify the Petitioner that transition services would be considered at the November 2002 IEP meeting. 3. It failed to inform the parent regarding STUDENT’s progress toward his goals. 4. It failed to design an IEP to meet his needs in the areas of reading, written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing until March 12, 2003; and, 5. failed to provide note-taking assistance that was required to help STUDENT to overcome his writing and processing deficits and thereby access the curriculum through the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue No. 6: Did the District fail to provide appropriate transition assistance to the Petitioner?
The Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide appropriate transition services during the years at issue until the IEP date March 12, 2003. The District claims that it met STUDENT’s need for such services.
An important purpose of special education law is to prepare an individual with disabilities for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. This purpose has become more prominent since the reauthorization of the IDEA in 1997. There are now specific provisions that require school districts to provide special education students with services to facilitate their transition from the protected environment of a special education program to the more advanced education, employment opportunities, and independent living available to adults. The purpose of transition under the IDEA is to provide planning, instruction, and support to allow the successful transition of disabled individuals into the community as adults. As stated in California Education Code Section 56460(e), “The goal of transition services is planned movement from secondary education to adult life that provides opportunities which maximize economic and social independence in the least restrictive environment for individuals with exceptional needs.”
Beginning at age fourteen, every special education student shall have included in his or her IEP, and updated annually, a “statement of transition service needs.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(a). The purpose of this information is to focus on the planning of a student’s course of study. For example, the IEP team might consider whether the student should participate in advanced placement or vocational education courses. 64 Fed. Reg. 12595.
No later than at age sixteen, every special education student shall have included in his or her IEP, and updated annually, a “statement of needed transition services, including, when appropriate, a statement of the interagency responsibilities or any needed linkages; . . .” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii)(II); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(b). This information should focus on the student’s need for transition services as he or she moves from school to post-school activities. 64 Fed. Reg. 12595.
Transition services consist of a coordinated effort, sometimes involving multiple agencies, to promote movement from school to post-school activities, including vocational training, integrated employment (e.g., supported employment), independent living, or community participation. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c)(1). They must be based on the student’s needs, taking into account his or her preferences and interests. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c)(2). Transition services include instruction, related services, community experiences, the development of employment and other post-school adult living objectives, and, when appropriate, the acquisition of daily living skills and a functional vocational evaluation. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(30)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(c)(3).
Dr. Clark testified for the Petitioner. He holds a master’s degree in guidance and counseling from the University of Michigan and a doctorate degree in special education from Vanderbilt University. He has been a teacher, a high school counselor, a vocational rehabilitation counselor, and a college professor. Dr Clark is currently a professor in the department of special education at the University of Kansas. He has substantial experience with transition issues, which have been the focus of his professional pursuits for over thirty years. Dr. Clark has provided consulting services in at least nine states and assisted with the creation of transition guidelines in Kansas and Utah. He was a principal investigator in a national study of high school programs for handicapped youth and a co-principal investigator in a study of transition personnel preparation in Kansas, both funded by the U.S. Department of Education’s Office of Special Education and Rehabilitative Services.
Dr. Clark explained that an appropriate transition process should begin with the identification of the student’s strengths, weaknesses, needs, interests and post-secondary-education goals. The witness testified that the student determines the ultimate post-secondary-education goal. (Footnote 58) Then it becomes the responsibility of the IEP team, including the student, to use this information to establish goals and objectives for the knowledge and skills that that the student must acquire to reach his or her goals. In Dr. Clark’s opinion, the educational agency’s obligation is to provide the information to enable the student and parents to make informed decisions about transition goals. The educational agency is not responsible for the student’s failures that are attributable to his or her poor judgement in the selection of unrealistic post-secondary-education goals.
Dr. Clark reviewed STUDENT’s IEPs for compliance with the IDEA requirements regarding transition. He found them to be lacking in several respects. His testimony, which was essentially unopposed and persuasive, will be discussed in connection with each year’s program below.
2000-2001 School Year
Because STUDENT was already sixteen years old by the time he enrolled in the District, the IEP team should have addressed both aspects of transition in the initial IEP process. It should have considered STUDENT’s transition needs for the purposes of planning his course of study, and it should have considered it for the purpose of determining the services and agency referrals STUDENT would need during his actual transition to post-high school activities. (Footnote 59)
In Dr. Clark’s opinion, there was no adequate assessment of STUDENT’s strengths, weaknesses, needs, interests and post-secondary-education goals by the District. The administration of the Career Occupational Preference System, Second Edition (COPS-II) that took place only about three months before graduation was too little assessment at too late a time to be of real value to the student. According to Dr. Clark, there should have been a systematic screening, perhaps beginning with the COPS-II as part of STUDENT’s initial assessment, followed by more in-depth probes as circumstances warranted. The District did no assessment at that time. In addition, none of the required information was contained in this first IEP. The evidence establishes that the IEP team did not discuss transition at the IEP meeting in May 2000, except to indicate that a transition plan would be developed and mailed to the parent. Ms. PARENT testified that no ITP was ever mailed. The District did not dispute this fact. Dr. Clark explained that even if it had been mailed, that process would have shown a disregard for the requirement that the transition plan be developed as part of the IEP process.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide appropriate transition assistance to the petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year.
2001-2002 School Year
There is no evidence that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT’s transition needs in connection with planning his program for the 2001-2002 school year. Although there was more information about STUDENT’s plans, full-time employment involving computers and part-time community college, in the May 2001 IEP, Dr. Clark testified that too little attention was given to those stated goals. As an example, he believes the IEP team should have explored the student’s interest in computers, determined what knowledge and skills would be required to help STUDENT reach that goal, and used that information as a basis for IEP goals related to transition. He explained that the same applies to a goal of attending college. For example, if a student has that goal but does not possess the necessary reading skills to be successful in college, the IEP team should set a goal for reading. Dr. Clark testified that the transition needs should also have included improving STUDENT’s self-advocacy, note-taking, test-taking, and time-management skills. None of this was done in the context of transition for STUDENT. (Footnote 60)
There was a separate document entitled Individualized Transition Plan (ITP) attached to the May 2001 IEP. (Footnote 61) STUDENT’s plans are identified, but there is no indication in the document that his plans were considered for the purpose of planning his course of study. Although STUDENT did take computer courses, there was no evidence that those were anything other than his preferred electives. There is nothing to suggest that the IEP team actually considered how STUDENT did in those courses or any other information that would suggest that those choices were actually part of the transition planning.
The ITP does recommend a referral to the Project Workability, but there was no evidence that this referral actually occurred. (Footnote 62) There was no evidence to support the suggestion by the District that STUDENT’s sporadic work in the school cafeteria during the tenth and eleventh grade was the result of his referral to Project Workability. The Hearing Officer finds that it did not occur.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide appropriate transition services to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year.
2002-2003 School Year
May 8, 2002 ITP
There was no assessment of STUDENT to determine his transition needs in preparation for the May 2002 IEP meeting. There was an ITP attached to the IEP that was drafted at that meeting. STUDENT’s goals were the same as they had been the prior year. There was no reference to a referral to Project Workability. The part of the ITP that deals with instructional needs simply states that STUDENT would continue to work toward graduation. In fact, the ITP appears to put all of the responsibility for STUDENT’s transition needs on STUDENT. He was designated the one to explore community service possibilities and career options. He was the one who was to “develop independent living skills through practice at home and exploration.” The only clear designation of responsibility appears in a reference in the section on interagency responsibilities or linkages to a referral to a local community college through “DSS.” There was no such referral shown by the evidence.
The District failed to provide appropriate transition services to the Petitioner in the May 8, 2002 ITP.
November 25, 2002
A new ITP was drafted at the November 25, 2002 meeting, the one that was not attended by the parent. This one indicates STUDENT’s goals of full-time employment and full-time community college. There is no reference to computer work. Other than a reference to the plan to take the test for admission to Palomar College, there is nothing in the document that can be fairly characterized as complying with the law regarding transitions services and transition service needs.
The District failed to provide appropriate transition services to the Petitioner in the November 25, 2002 ITP.
March 12, 2003 ITP
There was a different ITP attached to STUDENT’s final IEP in March 2003. Page one was a copy of the ITP drafted in November 2002. Page two refers to specific areas of instruction, such as the practical math skills of making change and finding percentages, with an attempt at a measurable goal for that instruction. There was a plan for STUDENT to produce a resume and to take an interest survey, the COPS-II.
This March 12, 2003 ITP contained some of the elements required by law. However, it was not supported by appropriate assessment data. It did not adequately address either STUDENT’s need for instruction to assist with his post-high school goals or his need for services that would be required for his transition to community college and full-time employment. Perhaps most importantly, the District’s efforts to meet STUDENT’s transition needs just three months before he was expected to graduate was too late to be deemed of any substantial value to him and certainly not in substantial compliance with the law.
The District failed to provide appropriate transition services to the Petitioner in the March 12, 2003 ITP.
To conclude, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide appropriate transition services to the Petitioner at any time during the 2000-2001, 2001-2002, or 2003-2003 school years.
Issue No. 7: Should the high school diploma issued to the Petitioner in June 2003 be rescinded on the ground that the District failed to provide appropriate transition services or on that ground that rescission is required to allow the Hearing Officer to award full and appropriate relief?
The Petitioner contended that the diploma should be rescinded only if the Hearing Officer found that rescission was required because STUDENT failed to fulfill a transition requirement for graduation or that it was necessary to provide complete relief. The District asserted that there was rescission was not warranted because STUDENT fulfilled all graduation requirements.
The parties agree that the Hearing Office has the authority to rescind the diploma. It has exercised that authority in the past when it has determined that a diploma was not properly awarded and that continued high school placement was required to provide a FAPE to a student. STUDENT v. Temecula Valley, USD SN01-02415 (2002).
In this case it is clear from the evidence that STUDENT does not want the diploma to be rescinded. The District stated that there was no transition requirement for graduation. Therefore, in view of the limited scope of inquiry invited by the Petitioner, the Hearing Officer concludes that rescission of STUDENT’s high school diploma is neither compelled by the finding that the District did not meet his transition needs nor necessary in order to provide complete relief to him. There being no legitimate basis for the rescission of STUDENT’s regular high school diploma, no rescission will be ordered.
Issue No. 8: If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, should he and/or his parent be reimbursed by the District for the cost of the privately-obtained educational and related services?
The Petitioner asks the Hearing Officer to order the District to reimburse him or his aunt for the cost of reading, spelling, and written language tutoring. He claims reimbursement for the services and in the amounts indicated below:
Provider Dates of Service Amount Claimed
J. Schuller (Footnote 64) 7/2/02 to 9/4/02 $ 1,980.00 6/23/03 to 8/27/03 $ 2,000.00 P.Padgett 10/27/03 to 2/11/04 $ 1,050.00
TOTAL $ 5,030.00
The District contends that no reimbursement is due. It also asserts that, if any reimbursement is awarded, it should only be for services rendered before STUDENT’s graduation.
The school District had an ongoing duty to provide a FAPE to the Petitioner. It began as soon as he was deemed eligible for special education and related services and continued to the date of his receipt of a regular diploma on June 19, 2003. The District would argue that receipt of a regular high school diploma is the ultimate goal of special education and that once that goal was achieved through the program provided by the District, nothing more was required of it under the IDEA or State law. The Petitioner would contend that his claims to remedies for the District’s failures to provide a FAPE became ripe at the moment of each transgression and that STUDENT’s acceptance of the diploma did not render his claims moot.
Special education law provides that the obligation to make a FAPE available to all children with disabilities does not apply to students who have graduated from high school with a regular diploma. 34 C.F.R. § 300.122(a)(3)(i); Cal. Educ. Code § 56026.1(a). It has previously been held in this case, on the Petitioner’s motion for reconsideration of the dismissal, that this law does not expressly limit the equitable power of the Hearing Officer to award appropriate relief, including compensatory education, to a student who has been awarded a regular diploma if it is determined that a FAPE has been denied. As mandated by the Ninth Circuit decision in Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, No.3, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994), the Hearing Officer must now conduct a “fact-specific analysis,” taking all relevant matters into consideration, to determine whether or not the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496. The placement or services chosen by the parents is not required to be the “exact proper placement required under the Act.” Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the placement and services selected by the parents must address the student’s needs and provide the student with educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
The Hearing Officer found that the District did not meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency), written language, spelling, and visual functioning/processing. (Footnote 65) Ms. Schuller testified that her work with STUDENT focused on phonemic awareness, decoding, spelling, syllabication, and reading comprehension and fluency. She also assessed STUDENT and worked with him to some degree on his writing skills. The Hearing Officer is satisfied that her efforts generally addressed basic language skills that would have been required for STUDENT to make meaningful progress in his areas of need. The Hearing Officer also believes that the services rendered by Ms. Schuller before STUDENT’s graduation contributed to his ability to achieve his diploma. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the cost of the tutoring services rendered by Ms. Schuller to STUDENT before his graduation in the amount of $1,980.00 must be reimbursed by the District.
The Hearing Officer finds that the claims to reimbursement for the cost of tutoring or related educational services rendered by Ms. Schuller and Ms. Padgett after STUDENT’s graduation are more appropriately addressed below in the context of compensatory education.
Issue No. 9: If the District failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington, supra, have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.
The District failed to take certain required steps to ensure that STUDENT’s IEP process was fair. It also failed for years to meet STUDENT’s needs in the various areas, including visual functioning/processing, written language, including spelling, transition and ESY services. There was no evidence that the District recognized the deficiencies in its process or program or did anything to rectify its errors or to compensate STUDENT for any resulting educational losses. On the contrary, there were at least times that the District seemed content that STUDENT would eventually graduate and no longer be their responsibility.
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a procedural FAPE to STUDENT during all of the years at issue on various bases. It is almost certain that the Petitioner lost educational opportunities and that his parent was denied an opportunity to fully participate in the IEP process as a result of procedural errors committed by the District during every year at issue. However, the Petitioner has not offered any persuasive evidence or argument that any particular remedy is due, and there is no evidence upon which the Hearing Officer can fashion an appropriate remedy for these procedural denials of a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer also found that District denied a substantive FAPE to STUDENT during every year at issue. It failed to design an IEP to meet the Petitioner’s needs in the areas of reading (including phonological awareness, phonological processing, reading decoding, comprehension, and fluency), written language (including note-taking and writing aids), spelling, visual functioning/processing, and transition. Those will be addressed below.
Visual functioning/processing
The several specialists who assessed STUDENT all agreed that he needed visual therapy to address this need. Dr. Hillier recommended twenty-five to thirty sessions. Dr. Daniels recommended twelve additional sessions after she completed ten. The District offered opposing expert opinion. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education to include up to twelve additional visual therapy sessions with Dr. Daniels or another specialist of the Petitioner’s choosing from the District’s approved list.
Reading/Written Language/Spelling
The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to meet STUDENT’s needs in these areas. Some of those needs were met by the services provided by Jodie Schuller before STUDENT’s graduation. Ms. Schuller testified that STUDENT should receive services four hours per week (approximately 144 hours per school year) to achieve a gain of one and one-half to two grade equivalents per year in reading. Patricia Padgett recommended two hundred and fifty to three hundred hours of instruction for STUDENT to achieve accurate reading and comprehension at an adult level. However, she testified that she was able to bring STUDENT from a “need for instruction” at one reading level (level five) to mastery at the next level (level six) in nine ninety-minute sessions (13.5 hours). (Footnote 66) Neither witness specifically addressed what would be required to address the loss that resulted from the District’s failure to meet the Petitioner’s needs in the area of reading. Writing and spelling were not addressed at all, except that Dr. Patterson stated that there is software available to address deficits in writing.
The Hearing Officer finds that the award of compensatory education shall include reimbursement for the services rendered by Jodie Schuller and Patricia Padgett to STUDENT after his graduation in the amounts of $2,000.00 and $1,050.00, respectively. He also finds that an amount of remediation instruction reasonably designed to further compensate for the District’s failures to meet STUDENT’s reading, writing, and spelling needs is one hundred and twenty hours of remediation in basic reading and written expression skills, including spelling, through a nonpublic agency certified by the State of California. (Footnote 67) The District shall make those hours available by direct agreement with a provider of the Petitioner’s choice. It shall also reimburse the Petitioner for the cost of transportation for these services. Any time remaining unused two years after the date of this Decision will be forfeited. In addition, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner or his parent for the cost of a linear writing program of the type recommended by Dr. Patterson at a cost not to exceed $250.00, excluding sale tax.
The Hearing Officer will order that these services be provided by a certified nonpublic agency because he finds that it would not be appropriate to require the Petitioner to return to a District facility for the service and because there was inadequate evidence to show that the District is willing or able to provide the service.
Note-Taking Assistance
The Petitioner offered neither evidence nor argument that would provide a reasonable basis for a determination that STUDENT suffered a compensable educational loss as a result of this denial of a FAPE. Therefore, no remedy is given.
ESY
The Hearing Officer was not required to find that STUDENT required ESY to receive a FAPE. The finding that there was a denial was based solely on the unexplained inclusion of the service in the May 2001 IEP and the District’s failure to deliver the service pursuant to that IEP. The Petitioner has not demonstrated a loss from this denial. In addition, the District provided summer programs to STUDENT in 2000 and 2002. The Hearing Office finds that no remedy is due for this failure.
Transition
The District provided little transition assistance to STUDENT. Fortunately, according to his own testimony, he is pursuing a career that interests him and one for which he appears to be well suited. Nevertheless, it is impossible to know whether or not adequate transition services would have led to a different pursuit. STUDENT is entitled to know what paths might be opened to him even now.
Dr. Clark testified that STUDENT may need a comprehensive assessment of transition needs and the services of a specialist to provide college and/or career guidance and counseling. The doctor recommends four to six hours per month for nine to twelve months, or thirty-six to seventy-two hours be allowed for these services. The Hearing Officer finds that these estimates are likely in excess of the amount of transition assistance STUDENT would have been entitled to receive during his three years at La Costa. STUDENT is twenty years old. He has no desire to return to high school to obtain at least some of what he should have received long ago. The compensatory damage award will include an order that the District fund up to thirty hours of the kind of services described by Dr. Clark from a professional agreed upon by the parties. The District shall also reimburse the Petitioner for the cost of transportation for these services. Any time remaining unused two years after the date of this Decision will be forfeited.
The Hearing Officer will order that these services be provided by a certified nonpublic agency because he finds that it would not be appropriate to require the Petitioner to return to a District facility for the service and because there was no evidence to show that the District is willing or able to provide the service.
ORDER
1. Within thirty days of the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner and Ms. PARENT the amount of $1,980.00 for the cost of tutoring services rendered by Jodie Schuller to Petitioner prior to his graduation.
2. Within thirty days of the date of this Decision, the District shall make available to the Petitioner twelve additional visual therapy sessions with Susan Daniels or another specialist of Petitioner’s choosing from the District’s approved list, to be used within two years of the date of this Decision.
3. Within thirty days of the date of this Decision, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner and Ms. PARENT the amount of $3,050.00 for the cost of tutoring services rendered by Jodie Schuller and Patricia Padgett to STUDENT after his graduation.
4. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof of purchase, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner for the cost of a linear writing program of the type recommended by Dr. Patterson at a cost not to exceed $250.00, excluding sale tax.
5. Within thirty days of the date of this Decision, the District shall begin to make available to the Petitioner one hundred and twenty hours of remediation in basic reading and written expression skills, including spelling, through a nonpublic agency certified by the State of California, to be used within two years of the date of this Decision.
6. Within thirty days of the date of this Decision, the District shall begin to make available to the Petitioner thirty hours of transition services from a certified nonpublic agency that may be used by the petitioner for assessment or services in the area of college and/or career guidance and counseling to be used within two years of the date of this Decision.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue No 1: Did the Respondent fail to properly assess the Petitioner from the date of his first enrollment La Costa High School on or about April 1, 2000 to on or about December 19, 2002?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Did the Respondent fail to timely provide the Petitioner’s parent with a written assessment plan following her request to assess in 2002?
The Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 5: Did the Respondent fail to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during the 2002-2003 school year?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 6: Did the Respondent fail to provide appropriate transition assistance to the Petitioner?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 7: Should the high school diploma issued to the Petitioner in June 2003 be rescinded on the ground that the Respondent failed to provide appropriate transition services or on that ground that rescission is required to allow the Hearing Officer to award full and appropriate relief?
The Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 8: If the Respondent failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, should he and/or his parent be reimbursed by the Respondent for the cost of the privately-obtained educational and related services?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 9: If the Respondent failed to provide a free, appropriate public education to the Petitioner during any of the years at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?
The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: May 4, 2004 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
* The sole amendment changes the identification of the prevailing party on Issue No. 2, page 56, from the Petitioner to the Respondent. STUDENT lived with Ms. PARENT during the time he attended La Costa Canyon High School, the years at issue here. References to his “mother” refer to his biological mother. References to his “parent” during the time at issue are to Ms. PARENT unless otherwise noted.
2 Because the Hearing Officer has organized the issues for the purpose of adjudication, the wording may not be identical to that stated on the first day of hearing. The substance is unchanged. Although the issues were specifically stated by the Petitioner in his statement of issues and discussed at the hearing in much greater detail than indicated above, that detail is revealed in later discussions relating to the respective contentions of the parties as to each issue. The Hearing Officer’s intention here is to describe the broad scope of the issues to be addressed.
3 The Petitioner filed the request for due process on May 9, 2003. Although a claim based upon acts or omissions occurring before May 9, 2000 would potentially be barred by the three-year statute of limitations set forth in California Education Code Section 56505(j), this partial defense was not raised as an issue at the hearing. Since the District’s initial assessment had not been completed by May 9, 2000, the impact of the statute of limitations, if any, would be de minimus.
4 Prevailing party status is a condition precedent to an award of attorneys’ fees
5 There was also nothing to prevent the Respondent from arguing that no reimbursement was due.
6 It is not clear to the Hearing Officer that the stipulation accomplished anything. In any event, it was not a factor in this Decision.
7 The scores are generally based upon a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. Under the labeling system commonly used during the earlier years, the “average” range was generally considered to be within one standard deviation of the mean, or 85-115. In more recent years, 80-89 is considered low-average, 90-110 is considered average, and 111-120 is considered high-average.
8 The scores are reported as grade-level equivalents and standard scores. The grade at testing is reported by grade year and month, with September being month 1 and May being month 9. For example 6-9 refers to May of the sixth-grade year.
9 It is undisputed that reading and writing are complex processes. As described by Dr. Daniels, a reader must be able to accurately perceive and effectively process the written word. The parties agreed that effective receptive processing of written language requires the ability to translate perceived letters and combinations of letters into sounds and to recognize the identity, number, and sound of syllables in words (reading decoding). Likewise, effective expression of the written word (writing) requires that the writer organize thoughts, plan the writing process, and execute the plan, including the accurate translation of sounds into their corresponding letters and combinations of letters.
10 STUDENT’s first language was Tagolog. The evidence suggests that some of his early difficulties with language may have been due to the fact that English was his second language; however, there is no contention that this was a factor during the time at issue.
11 In the interim, he had repeated fourth grade.
13 The scores are based upon a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15. Under the labeling system commonly used during those years, the “average” range was generally considered to be within one standard deviation of the mean, or 85-115. Under the current classification system, 80-89 is considered low-average and 90-110 is considered average.
14 The performance and full scale scores of 95, and 85 were “prorated” to 104 and 90, respectively, because the assessor concluded that the low scores in the symbol search and coding subtests had to be factored out of the analysis to more accurately reflect STUDENT’s strong visual-spatial abilities.
15 There is no foundation for this eligibility classification apparent in the psychologist’s report, but it was not an issue at the hearing. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030.
16 According to Mary Ellen nest, the LCC was a special education class that covered study skills, organization, assignment completion and other, more specific needs of the students. It was not an RSP class.
17 Although STUDENT’s Standardized Testing and Reporting (STAR) Performance Report for the test administered in April 2002 is in evidence, no witness was called to testify regarding its validity or meaning. It appears from the report that STUDENT did not attempt many of the tests.
18 The class was designated a “Career 2” class where student’s explored career options and worked on basic functional career skills, including reading basics. 19 STUDENT had reversed the regression suggested by the KTEA in June 2002 and made more than two and one-half years of progress in reading recognition, and more than five years of progress in reading comprehension.
20 Grade equivalents for the OWLS or the WPT were not in evidence.
21 Ms. PARENT did not attend the meeting. She testified that she was told the meeting would be rescheduled, but learned later that it had taken place with STUDENT in attendance
22 It was not clear how this last recommendation related to the witness’s area of expertise.
23 Other services that are not at issue were also offered.
24 In his “Case History” portion of his report, Dr. Hillier mentions that STUDENT completed eighteen visual therapy sessions with Dr. Richard Skay, another practitioner on the Districts approved list, in August 2002. Neither party offered any more specific information about this therapy.
25 An occupational therapy assessment also was conducted at that time, but it is not at issue here.
26 According to STUDENT’s testimony, he also received one-on-one reading instruction in the LCC.
27 As with most of the IEP documents from the November 2002 meeting forward, the exhibits offered by the parties as documents relating to specific IEP meetings appeared to be collections of documents bearing different dates. There was no testimony to explain how or why the documents came together, and it was often difficult for the
28 The evidence suggested that the District might have failed to properly assess STUDENT in other areas, including attention and social-emotional functioning. The Hearing Officer addresses only those assessment areas identified by the parties as being at issue.
29 Eligibility was not an issue here.
30 It is generally accepted that the term “phonological processing” refers to the ability to identify the sound components of words (phonemes) and the words those components combine to make.
31 It is unclear why the District omitted this area, particularly since STUDENT was sixteen years old and entitled to transition services.
32 Dr. Patterson concedes that the fluency tests were not part of the WJ-R that was used by the District during the May 2000 testing. Those were added later to the WJ-III. The Hearing Officer does not find fault with the District’s decision to use the WJ-R tests of achievement. It could have used some other fluency measure.
33 There is a single reference in a later report by Carl Hillier, O.D., stating that STUDENT received eighteen sessions of visual therapy concluding on August 11, 2002, from Dr. Richard Skay, but there is no evidence from either party to corroborate this or to explain what information, if any, the District had about it at the time.
34 The specific reference in the notes is to an assistive technology assessment to see if STUDENT qualified for use of a hand-held word processor.
35 It would have been the District’s obligation to help the parent put an oral request for an assessment into written form. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3025.
36 A FAPE must also provide the student an opportunity to be educated and to participate with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. The requirement is often referred to as “least restrictive environment.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). This is not an issue here.
37 STUDENT also alleges that he had unique needs in the area of transition, but this issue is addressed under Issue No. 6, below.
38 The records also contain information about needs in other areas that are not at issue in this case.
39 Phonological awareness involves the recognition that words are composed of constituent sounds and the ability to decompose and manipulate those sounds.
40 STUDENT’s scores on the reading and writing fluency subtests of the WJ-III administered by Dr. Patterson were first percentile and seventh percentile, respectively.
41 The one notable exception was the District’s administration of the WJ-III in October 2002. The Hearing Officer gave less weight to that testing because it omitted the fluency subtest.
42 As a matter of law, STUDENT also needed the transition services that every sixteen-year-old special education student is entitled to receive in this State. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1. This need is addressed separately under Issue No. 6, below.
43 The objective actually states that STUDENT was to answer four out of five comprehension questions with 80% accuracy, which would literally require that he need only answer with approximately 64 % accuracy. This was clearly not what was intended.
44 The Hearing Officer does not suggest that the District can rely upon grades not yet earned to prove that an IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. However, as is more fully discussed in the context of the 2002-2003 school year, even grades earned in past years might be of little value to prove compliance with the IDEA.
45 It would be unreasonable to construe this as an offer of assistance only if the various teachers allowed it. The need for the accommodation or service is decided by the IEP team. The qualification is reasonably construed only to allow the teachers some discretion regarding how the assistance was provided so as to minimize disruption to the class.
46 Because the May 2001 IEP would expire before the summer break in 2002, the offer must have been to provide ESY services during the summer of 2001.
47 STUDENT also claimed that the District failed to provide him with required ESY services. The Hearing Officer addresses that claim in connection with the 2000-2001 school year, above. Because the May 2001 IEP expired in May 2002, before ESY services would be delivered to students in the summer of 2002, a similar claim regarding services during that summer will be addressed below.
48 There was evidence regarding STUDENT’s ADD. That condition might have had some impact on his reading or writing skills, but the question was not presented for determination here.
49 The note-taking assistance was to have been provided as an “accommodation” pursuant to the May 2000 IEP for the 2000-2001 school year. As indicated above, there was no evidence that it was provided.
50 As discussed later in this decision, STUDENT’s course grades may have been indicative of nothing more than the District’s desire to move him through the grade levels and, eventually, out of high school.
51 That failure also made it impossible for the Hearing Officer to rely on goals as a measure of progress.
52 The actual areas addressed by these goals may have been more or less broad than the designation suggest
53 The September 19, 2002 prehearing conference order states that the issues for this school year include the allegation that the District failed to draft an appropriate written language goal. The issue statement filed just prior to the hearing contains no such reference. On the first day of the hearing, the Petitioner indicated that the written language goal remained an issue for this school year. The Hearing Officer determined that the issue should be addressed.
54 There was no grade level equivalent provided by Dr. Patterson. He characterized the standard score as being in the “retarded” range.
55 The Hearing Officer interpreted this as a reference to NCR’s carbonless notepads that are often used to create duplicate sets of lecture notes.
56 The significance of the characterization of service as a “supplemental aid or service” was not explained by the District. It presumably refers to aids or services provided to students with disabilities to help them to make progress in a regular education environment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).
57 The parent may be the one to do this or may participate in the process.
58 The parent may be the one to do this or may participate in the process.
59 The District’s failure to provide appropriate transition assistance began with its failure to inform STUDENT and his parent that the matter would be discussed at the first IEP meeting in May 2000. The Hearing Officer addressed that failure above.
60 STUDENT did enroll in computer classes at La Costa, but there was no evidence that his performance in these classes as it related to his transition goals was even discussed by the IEP team.
61 The Hearing Officer could find no specific legal requirement in federal or State law for an individualized transition plan that, in effect, stands on its own as a document distinct from the IEP. What is required is that the IEP team identifies and addresses the transition needs of all special education students.
62 Project Workability is a transition service developed and supported by the State Department of Education that provides instruction and experience that reinforce core curriculum concepts and skills leading to gainful employment.
63 The Petitioner does not seek reimbursement for the cost of assessments.
64 Ms. Schuller’s charges are broken down to services rendered before graduation and those rendered after graduation. Ms. Padgett’s services were all rendered after graduation
65 No reimbursement is sought for the District’s failure to meet STUDENT’s needs in the areas of transition and visual processing.
66 The witness referred to STUDENT’s ability at the higher grade level as “comfortable.” The Hearing Officer interprets this as mastery or near mastery of that grade level.
67 The Hearing Officer does not require that particular outcome from the instruction. It requires only the provision of the amount of instruction awarded.
