California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 24, 1997
Beverly Hills Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 936-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Beverly Hills Unified's triennial assessment found appropriate; parents denied $1,500 reimbursement for private psychological assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1 says there were clerical errors on page 8 of the previous Decision sent to the parties. This version appears to be the corrected decision. The decision also mentions an earlier due process case (SN 473-97) about placement, which the parties resolved through mediation.
Summary
Beverly Hills Unified School District filed for a hearing after the parents of an 11-year-old fifth grader asked it to pay for a private psychological assessment. The student was eligible for special education because of significant delays in receptive and expressive language. She also had gross motor deficits. She attended a special day class, spent about 25% of the day in general education, and received speech-language therapy and adaptive physical education. The District's 1996 triennial assessment produced lower cognitive and achievement scores than earlier testing. The parents questioned those results and obtained a $1,500 assessment from clinical psychologist David Brendel, Ph.D. The District argued that its own assessment met all legal requirements.
Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote found the District's assessment appropriate under Education Code section 56320. Credentialed, qualified staff conducted it. They used several valid, standardized tests and observations and covered all areas of suspected disability: language, motor skills, academics, cognition, and social-emotional status. English was the student's primary language for testing. School psychologist Helaina Taylor credibly explained that scores on the newer WISC-III are expected to be lower than on the older WISC-R, and Dr. Brendel did not rebut her. No evidence supported the parents' claim of a testing irregularity. Because the District's assessment was appropriate, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement under Education Code section 56329(b). The District prevailed on both issues, and the reimbursement request was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district-filed hearing to defend an assessment against a claim for reimbursement of an independent assessment. Lower scores than on earlier testing did not by themselves make the assessment inappropriate. A witness tied the drop to a test revision (WISC-R to WISC-III), and the parents' expert did not rebut that explanation.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Did the Beverly Hills Unified School District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?
The District's 1996 triennial assessment met Education Code section 56320. Qualified staff used multiple valid instruments and covered all areas of suspected disability, and the drop in scores was credibly explained by the WISC-III revision.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 2. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment completed by David Brendel, Ph.D., on May 21, 1997?
Because the District's assessment was appropriate, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement of $1,500 for the independent assessment under Education Code section 56329(b).
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Parents' request for reimbursement of the cost of Dr. Brendel's independent assessment denied.
Key authorities
Education Code § 56320; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56322; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b) (IDEA Amendments of 1997); Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1st Cir. 1984); David D. v. Dartmouth School Committee (1st Cir. 1985); Geis v. Board of Education of Parsippany-Troy Hills (3rd Cir. 1985)
People named in the decision
- DeeDee Graves, program specialist; testified about the academic achievement testing, Beverly Hills Unified School District
- Nancy E. Wolf, Ed.D., director of special pupil services and SELPA director; filed the hearing request, Beverly Hills Unified School District
- Wendy O. Bergman, speech and language specialist; assessor and treating therapist, Beverly Hills Unified School District
- Helaina Taylor, school psychologist; testified about the 1996 psychological assessment, Beverly Hills Unified School District
- Ida Guillermo, Ph.D., school psychologist who conducted the 1996 psychological assessment (did not testify), Beverly Hills Unified School District
- David Brendel, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist; independent assessor and witness for Student, Private practice
- Bobbie Albanese, attorney for District
- Kathy Finn, attorney for Student
- Warren Finn, advocate for Student
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 936-97 Case Year: 1997 Petitioner: BEVERLY HILLS UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-64311 District: Beverly Hills Unified Disability Type: Speech or Language Impairment
Case Details This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Beverly Hills, California, on October 14, 1997. Petitioner Beverly Hills Unified School District was represented at the hearing by attorney Bobbie Albanese. Also present on behalf of the District was DeeDee Graves, program specialist. Respondent STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathy Finn and advocate Warren Finn. STUDENT's father was present for a portion of the hearing.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the Beverly Hills Unified School District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT?
(2) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment completed by David Brendel, Ph.D., on May 21, 1997?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Respondent STUDENT is an 11-year-old-student in the fifth grade. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills. She also has deficits in gross motor skills. STUDENT attends a special day class and is mainstreamed for approximately 25% of the school day. She receives speech and language therapy three times per week. Two of the one-half hour sessions are with a small group of other students. The other one-half- hour session is one-to-one. STUDENT also receives two thirty-minute sessions of adaptive physical education (APE) per week.
In March 1993, when STUDENT was in the first grade, the Individualized Educational Program (IEP) team initially determined that she met eligibility criteria for special education because of language and gross motor deficits. STUDENT was placed in an SDC and provided speech and language therapy and APE. (Footnote 2) (Respondent's Exhibit O)
On January 1, 1996, STUDENT's parents consented to the District's triennial assessment plan. The assessment took place from January 5, 1996 to April 22, 1996.(Footnote 3) The District assessed STUDENT in the following areas: academic achievement; social, emotional, and adaptive behavior; psycho-motor development; speech, language, and communications skills; and intellectual development. The assessment also included an update of STUDENT's medical history. (District's Exhibits 1-4, 6, and 7) The results of the assessment and recommendations are summarized in a report dated May 15, 1996. (District's Exhibit 8)
Because of a dispute regarding a disciplinary incident, STUDENT's parents removed her from school in the spring of 1997 and, on April 21, 1997, requested a special education due process hearing regarding the issue of placement (SN 473-97). The parties resolved the placement dispute through mediation.
On May 21, 1997, David Brendel, Ph.D., clinical psychologist in private practice, completed an independent psychological assessment of STUDENT. Dr. Brendel's assessment included reviewing educational records, administering tests, and observing STUDENT during testing and in her classroom. (Respondent's Exhibit B)
On July 8, 1997, the Hearing Office received a request for a special education due process hearing from Nancy E. Wolf, Ed.D., District director of special pupil services, on the issue of whether the District is required to reimburse the parents for Dr. Brendel's independent assessment. Dr. Wolf requested that the matter be scheduled after September 24, 1997, when school staff would have returned to their duties. By agreement of the parties, the hearing was continued to October 14, 1997.
The District contends that it conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT and that she was assessed in all areas of suspected disability. The District asserts that Dr. Brendel's independent assessment resulted in findings similar to the District's; however, his assessment did not include a measure of STUDENT's language skills. The District also asserts that Dr. Brendel used outdated assessment instruments.
STUDENT's parents assert that they obtained an independent assessment because they questioned the validity of the District's assessment, on which STUDENT's scores on measures of academic achievement and cognitive potential fell much lower than on previous testing by the District. The parents seek reimbursement for Dr. Brendel's assessment in the amount of $1,500.00.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the Beverly Hills Unified School District conduct an appropriate assessment of
STUDENT?
In order for the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states in relevant part that testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory; provided and administered in the student's primary language or other mode of communication; administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Assessment and testing materials must also not measure the student's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless that is what the test purports to measure.
Subsection 56320(e) states that "no single procedure is used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs." Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status. Pursuant to subsection (g), the assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists, and health assessments must be conducted by a credentialed school nurse or physician. These assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Education Code § 56324(a) and (b).
Federal special education law includes similar provisions. See Individuals with Disabilities Education Act Amendments of 1997 § 1414 (b). Federal law also provides that the district will "use a variety of assessment tools and strategies to gather relevant functional and developmental information, including information provided by the parent . . . [and] including information related to enabling the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. . . ." Section 1414(b)(2)(A). (Footnote 4)
Assessments must be conducted by "competent" persons. It is the District's responsibility to determine who is competent. Education Code § 56322. "Competent" is not further defined. Education Code § 56520 states that assessments will be conducted by "qualified" persons. A "qualified" person is defined as one who
. . . has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services, or, in the absence of such requirements, the state-education-agency-approved or recognized requirements, and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation. . . .
Title 5 California Code of Regulations § 3001(x).
STUDENT's father, testified that he had concerns about STUDENT's self-esteem and lack of progress and requested an independent assessment to see if there were "different ways of looking at STUDENT." He also wanted to focus on her strengths rather than her weaknesses to help her move into a regular education program. (Footnote 5)
The District's triennial assessment of STUDENT in 1996 evaluated her academic functioning, language, speech, and hearing, motor skills, cognitive skills, visual-motor skills, and social and emotional functioning. The assessment also included an updating of STUDENT's medical history and behavioral observations.
Wendy O. Bergman, speech and language specialist, conducted the speech and language portion of the District's assessments in 1993 and 1996. She currently provides speech and language therapy to STUDENT three times per week and consults with her SDC and regular education teachers. Ms. Bergman has been employed by the District for 15 years, has been in private practice since 1989, and has been published in three books. Ms. Bergman has received the "Best Teacher" and "Best Practices" awards and was selected as a mentor teacher.
Ms. Bergman testified that she assessed STUDENT's receptive and expressive language skills through formal testing and behavioral observations. In her report, she summarized the findings from the assessment and made recommendations for services. Ms. Bergman also presented her report to the IEP team. Ms. Bergman administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised, the WORD-R Test, the Clinical Evaluation of Language Functions, and the Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities. She also took a language sample. Ms. Bergman concluded that STUDENT continues to have severe receptive and expressive language deficits in the areas of semantics, syntax, pragmatics, and morphology. Ms. Bergman testified that "semantics" is the understanding of words and their meanings, "syntax" is the structure and order of sentences, "pragmatics" is the use of language in social context, and "morphology" is the grammatical and linguistic structure of language.
Helaina Taylor, school psychologist, testified regarding the psychological portion of the District's assessment. Ms. Taylor holds a master's degree in counseling and is a credentialed school psychologist. She assessed STUDENT in 1993. Ms. Taylor testified that she has been trained in the use of test instruments and interpreting results of testing on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC), which is a measure of global intelligence; the Draw-A-Person Test; and the Beery Visual Motor Inventory. Ida Guillermo, Ph.D., administered the WISC-III, the Bender Gestalt Visual Motor Test, the Berry Visual Motor Integration Test, the Draw-A-Person, Draw-A-Family, and Rorschach projective tests. Ms. Taylor testified about the 1996 assessment because Dr. Guillermo, who completed this portion of the assessment of STUDENT in 1996, has relocated out of state and was unavailable to testify at the hearing. Ms. Taylor testified that Dr. Guillermo is a credentialed school psychologist and holds a doctorate in psychology.
Ms. Taylor testified that the tests employed by Dr. Guillermo are standardized and valid instruments. Ms. Taylor testified that the current version of the WISC is the WISC-III, which has superseded the WISC-R. Ms. Taylor testified that students' performance scores on the WISC-III have been 5 to 10 points lower on the WISC-III than on the WISC-R, which, according to the test manual, is expected. In regard to Dr. Brendel's use of the WISC-R to assess STUDENT in 1997, Ms. Taylor testified that it is not professionally appropriate to use the WISC-R and that the WISC-III is considered a more accurate measure for the current population. Ms. Taylor testified that, in general, the results of testing by Dr. Guillermo and Dr. Brendel are similar to the results of her testing in 1993. Dr. Brendel, who testified on behalf of STUDENT, stated that the differences in performance scores could also be explained by a number of factors, including STUDENT's level of fatigue on the day of testing and other test conditions.
DeeDee Graves, District program specialist, has taught regular, SDC, and resource classes. Ms. Graves testified that she received training in college to administer measures of academic achievement and assessed many students as a teacher. The District's 1996 assessment of STUDENT's academic achievement included administration of the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) and the Woodcock Johnson Psychoeducational Battery (WJ). Ms. Graves testified that the WRAT is a "quick" measure of academic achievement and is used to determine a student's growth from year to year, whereas the WJ provides more "diagnostic" information. Ms. Graves testified that STUDENT's standard scores on tests of achievement, which were lower than scores obtained on earlier testing, can be explained by the fact that as students get older they are required to know more and STUDENT's language deficits affect her ability to respond to questions that require her to make more difficult inferences.
Nancy E. Wolf, Ed.D., District director of special pupil services and SELPA director, did not recall that anyone expressed concern about the District's assessment when it was completed or discussed at the IEP meeting. When she received a letter written on behalf of STUDENT requesting an independent assessment, she reviewed the assessment with Dr. Guillermo. Dr. Guillermo told Dr. Wolf that the assessment accurately reflected STUDENT at the time of the testing. Dr. Wolf concluded that the District's assessment was appropriate and denied the request for an independent assessment.
Turning to the requirements of an appropriate assessment as set forth in Education Code § 56320, there was no evidence that testing and assessment materials or procedures were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. As to whether the testing and assessment materials and procedures were provided and administered in STUDENT's primary language, the testimony establishes that STUDENT speaks both English and Hebrew. In 1993, Ms. Bergman did some informal testing of STUDENT using a Hebrew interpreter. Ms. Bergman's testimony that STUDENT did not require an interpreter during testing was not disputed and there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that for testing purposes English is STUDENT's primary language. All of the persons who administered portions of STUDENT's assessment were appropriately credentialed and competent. Ms. Bergman is a credentialed speech and language specialist, and Dr. Guillermo is a credentialed school psychologist and holds a doctorate in psychology. Respondent did not challenge the credentials of either the RSP teacher or the APE teacher who also completed portions of STUDENT's assessment. Respondent also did not challenge the training of the various District personnel who conducted the assessment to use the test instruments administered to STUDENT. There was no evidence that any of the assessors were unqualified to assess STUDENT. As to the requirement that the assessment be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the student's disability, STUDENT is eligible for special education because of significant expressive and receptive language deficits. The District's assessment included an assessment by Ms. Bergman, a speech and language pathologist. STUDENT also has gross motor deficits. The assessment included an assessment by an APE specialist. Additionally, the psychological assessment was conducted by a credentialed school psychologist and the health history was updated by a school nurse. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District personnel who assessed STUDENT satisfied the requirements set forth above in the California Education Code and Code of Regulations.
The District's assessment of STUDENT included a number of measures, including formal testing and observation. Thus, the District's assessment did not rely on one single assessment procedure. The assessment included measures of STUDENT's speech and language strengths and weaknesses and motor skills, which are primary areas of concern. The parent expressed concern about STUDENT's self- esteem and academic achievement. The assessment included measures of academic achievement. Projective measures of STUDENT's social and emotional status were also included in the District's assessment. Respondents did not raise any additional areas of suspected disability. Therefore, the District assessed all areas of suspected disability. No one raised any questions regarding the validity of the assessment instruments employed by the District. Moreover, the unrebutted testimony of Ms. Bergman establishes that all of the tests she employed in assessing STUDENT's speech and language are standardized and normed, and are recognized by speech and language pathologists as valid. The instruments used by Dr. Guillermo are regularly used by school psychologists to assess students with disabilities. The Hearing Officer finds that the District employed test instruments and procedures that complied with the requirements set out above.
The primary concern expressed on behalf of STUDENT was related to the results of Dr. Guillermo's testing on which STUDENT's standard scores on the performance test of the WISC-III were lower than her performance test scores on the WISC-R administered three years earlier. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Taylor's explanation of the discrepant scores to be credible. Moreover, her explanation that the decrease in scores was anticipated and is a factor related to the revision of the WISC-R was not rebutted by the only other psychologist to testify, namely, Dr. Brendel. Respondent also made some vague assertion that some unspecified irregularity may have occurred during Dr. Guillermo's portion of the testing. There was no evidence to substantiate this claim. The Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent did not provide any testimony substantiating that the District's assessment was inappropriate. The Hearing Officer also finds that the evidence discussed above establishes that the District's assessment satisfied the requirements of Education Code § 56320 and, therefore, was appropriate.
ISSUE NO. 2: Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an assessment completed by David Brendel, Ph.D., on May 21, 1997?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student. When the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent also has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency's assessment was appropriate. Education Code § 56329(b).
It was determined above in Issue No. 1 that the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT. Because the District conducted an appropriate assessment of STUDENT, the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for an independent assessment.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) Did the Beverly Hills Unified School District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT? The District prevailed on this issue.
(2) Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment completed by David Brendel, Ph.D., on May 21, 1997?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
ORDER
Respondent's request for reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Dr. Brendel is denied.
DATED: November 24, 1997 _____________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes
1. Please note that there were some clerical errors on page 8 of the previous Decision that was sent to the parties. 2. District members of the IEP team had recommended that STUDENT be placed in an SDC for students with communication disabilities (SDC-CH). STUDENT's parents consented to an SDC placement but not to the SDC-CH. The team then agreed to place STUDENT in an SDC and to provide her with additional speech and language therapy. 3. The parents agreed to extend the time line for the completion of the assessment to allow for additional testing. (District's Exhibit 5) 4. Section 1414 (c)(1)(A) and (B) provide that as part of any reevaluation, the IEP team and other qualified professionals shall review existing evaluation data and "identify what additional data, if any, are needed to determine whether the student continues to meet eligibility criteria, the present levels of performance, the educational needs of the student, whether the student continues to need special education and related services, and whether modifications or additions are needed for the student to meet goals and objectives and to participate in the general curriculum." Subsection (2) of Section 1414(c)(1)(B) provides that the district shall administer tests and other evaluation materials as needed to obtain the above information or, if it is determined that no additional data are needed to determine whether the student continues to be a child with a disability, the school district shall notify the child's parents of that determination, the reasons for it, and inform the parents of the right to request an assessment. The district is not required to conduct an assessment unless requested to by the student's parents. Section 1414(4). Federal law apparently has fewer requirements than California law in conducting triennial assessments. California has not adopted a provision allowing a district to determine whether additional data are needed for a triennial evaluation. Because current California law requiring a full assessment every three years affords more protection to the student, the Hearing Officer concludes that California law applies. See Town of Burlington v. Department of Education for the Commonwealth of Massachusetts (1st Cir. 1984) 736 F. 2d 773; David D. v. Dartmouth School Committee (1st Cir. 1985) 775 F. 2d 411; Geis v. Board of Education of Parsippany-Troyhills (3rd Cir. 1985) 774 F. 2d 575. 5. Dr. Brendel also testified on behalf of STUDENT. The majority of his testimony addressed his assessment of STUDENT.
