California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 20, 2001

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 944-01 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Los Angeles Unified's middle school special day class offer upheld; parents' request for nonpublic school funding denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 12-year-old girl filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. She was eligible for special education under speech and language and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability). A structural palate defect made her speech largely unintelligible to unfamiliar listeners. She had been fully included in general education classes at Warner Elementary with a one-to-one assistant. Everyone agreed that full inclusion was no longer working. For sixth grade, the District offered a small special day class (SDC) taught by Linda Hoffman at Palms Middle School. The offer included a one-to-one assistant for the first month, a review IEP meeting after that month, general education electives, speech services, and transportation. The parents argued that Palms, a large campus, was unsafe for a vulnerable child who tended to wander. They also said the class had too few girls and too few peers who would challenge her. They asked the District to fund the Kayne-Eras nonpublic school. The Hearing Officer found the offer met her academic, social-emotional, and safety needs. The small class, specialized teaching, peers at similar levels, the aide, and campus programs that pair students with and without disabilities supported that finding. The offer was also the least restrictive environment, because the nonpublic school offered no contact with nondisabled peers. The funding request was moot, and all relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO weighed parents' safety and social concerns about a large comprehensive campus against least-restrictive-environment rules. Access to nondisabled peers at lunch, in electives, and in clubs counted in favor of a district SDC over an all-disability nonpublic school, even where that school might have removed the need for an aide.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

    The offered mental retardation SDC at Palms Middle School, with a one-to-one assistant for the first month, a follow-up IEP meeting, general education electives, and speech services, met the student's academic, social-emotional, and safety needs, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and was the least restrictive environment.

  2. Issue 2. If the District did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to funding by the District for STUDENT's future attendance at the certified nonpublic school proposed by her parents?

    Moot because the District offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment; funding for the Kayne-Eras nonpublic school was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of the Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f)

People named in the decision

  • Janice Woolsey, therapy supervisor; witness for Student, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center
  • Paula Pearlman, parent of a Palms Middle School student; witness for Student, Palms Middle School parent
  • Steven Toda, assistant principal, Palms Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Ann Pruitt Shough, speech and language teacher and pathologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Janice Greenberg, resource specialist teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Brick Baker, program specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Hoffman, special day class teacher, Palms Middle School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Sheila Williams, assessor (educational achievement and perceptual skills, March 2000), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Kayne-Eras, certified nonpublic school proposed by parents, Nonpublic school
  • Warner Elementary School, student's prior school, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Palms Middle School, proposed placement site, Los Angeles Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on July 5, 6, and 13, 2001, in Encino, California.

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER, and by her father, FATHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District or Respondent) was represented by attorney Christopher J. Fernandes from the law office of Lozano Smith.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Janice Woolsey, therapy supervisor at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center; Paula Pearlman, mother of a child at Palms Middle School (Palms); Steven Toda, assistant principal at Palms; and MOTHER. The District called the following witnesses: Ann Pruitt Shough, speech and language teacher and pathologist at the District; Janice Greenberg, resource specialist teacher at the District; Brick Baker, program specialist at the District; Linda Hoffman, special day class teacher at Palms.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until July 23, 2001, for the submission of written closing arguments, which were received from each party on that date.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

Issue No. 2: If the District did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year, is STUDENT entitled to funding by the District for STUDENT’s future attendance at the certified nonpublic school proposed by her parents?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner claims that the placement offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year in a special day class (SDC) at Palms is not designed to meet her unique academic, social, emotional, and safety needs.

The Petitioner also claims that her safety needs in a placement at Palms would require confinement in the proposed SDC, which would not be the least restrictive environment.

The District claims it has offered the Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, age 12 years and 11 months, is eligible for special education and related services under the categories of speech and language and mental retardation.(Footnote 3) She has attended Warner Elementary School since kindergarten. Her placement has always been in regular education classes with an assigned one-to-one assistant, speech and language services, and transportation services. Under the District’s current offer, she would enter the sixth grade at Palms Middle School for the 2001-2002 school year.

STUDENT, born on [date redacted], has a genetic condition known as “chromosome 9p monosomy.” This condition is manifested in STUDENT by craniofacial structural defects, other physiological anomalies, and mental retardation. STUDENT has a structural defect in her palate that prevents closure between her oral and nasal cavities. The palate deformity is not visually apparent upon her external appearance, but it severely impairs her speech intelligibility.

As STUDENT has grown, proportional changes in her craniofacial anatomy have caused the impairment of her speech to increase. In her earlier school years, she was approximately fifty-percent intelligible to an unfamiliar listener. She has currently reached a level of ninety-percent unintelligible as estimated by her mother. At least one physician specializing in pediatric genetics at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center has characterized her current speech as unintelligible (Pet. Ex. 1).

Prosthetic devices and additional reconstructive surgery to improve STUDENT’s speech are under consideration. It is hoped that successful placement of an artificial device may improve her speech during the next year to about fifty-percent intelligibility (testimony of Ms. Woolsey).

STUDENT’s educational setting beginning with kindergarten has always been in a regular education class at Warner Elementary School (Warner) with modifications and supportive services including a one-to-one assistant.

In the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT repeated third grade as a “fully included” student at Warner Elementary. An “individualized educational program” (IEP) meeting in preparation for the 1999-2000 fourth-grade school year was held on June 15, 1999 (District Ex. 8). The IEP lists STUDENT’s eligibility criteria as ER (educable retarded) and LAS (language and speech). She was performing at the equivalent of first- and second-grade work levels. The inclusion report states STUDENT had demonstrated progress socially and academically, although overall the 1998 IEP goals and objectives in language arts and math had not been met. She was continuing to benefit from the services of a full-time one-to-one assistant. STUDENT’s parents expressed that she would greatly benefit from a consistent, structured classroom environment that would also allow for her need for flexibility. She had friends in class and had classmates come to her home. The IEP team consensus was that the least restrictive environment and most advantageous program for STUDENT was full inclusion in a regular education class.

The District had Petitioner assessed on March 28, 2000, by Sheila Williams, LRE. Educational achievement, visual perceptual skills, and auditory perceptual skills were evaluated. The report (District Ex. 5) shows first-grade equivalent math scores and second-grade equivalent reading scores, with spelling at third-grade level. Visual perceptual non-motor skills and auditory perceptual skills were in the one-percentile ranking. According to the classroom teacher’s comments, STUDENT was usually able to cope with frustration. She related positively to peers in the classroom and to adults. She was not able to independently make acceptable or appropriate decisions. She played appropriately in the schoolyard and appeared to have a positive self-image. Her assistant provided the reinforcement and encouragement needed for her to begin work on time, stay on task, and work independently. She was able to participate in small-group activities but would lose focus in large-group activities. The inclusion specialist commented that STUDENT responded well to rules and limits with minimal attempts at manipulation, and that she was an affectionate and likable young girl. She was observed to play in the school yard with hula hoops and to play handball with other students. The parents’ concerns were to keep their daughter interested and on task at the appropriate level, to have her make and keep a best friend, and to worry less about her being “left-out” socially. The parents were also concerned that STUDENT’s speech was not improving as quickly as they had hoped. Ms. William’s recommendations were to use behavior modification techniques to increase attention and compliance, refer to the IEP team for placement and services, encourage independence and responsibility through fading the need for an assistant, and provide opportunity for socializing with appropriate peers.

An IEP meeting was held on June 14, 2000, as part of a three-year reassessment (District Ex. 9). The IEP team determined that STUDENT met eligibility criteria of MR (mental retardation) and LAS. She was continuing to function within the significantly below-average range of estimated general cognitive ability. Deficits also existed in adaptive behavior, academic performance, language, visual-motor integration, and psycho-social development. These deficits, existing concurrently with STUDENT’s developmental period, were adversely affecting her educational performance.

The psychologist’s summary presented at the June 14, 2000 IEP meeting stated that STUDENT was reported to relate positively to peers in the classroom and to adults, to participate in small group activities, to play appropriately in the schoolyard, and to have a positive self-image. She did not assume responsibility for actions. She did not make acceptable or appropriate decisions independently. She would begin her work on time only with assistance, and she would complete her work only with assistance. She had a short attention span and easily lost focus. The psychologist reported that STUDENT’s mother wanted her daughter to be interested and on task, and to establish a close friendship. STUDENT was beginning to feel left out, socially. Although friendly, she had no close friends at school. She still liked school and her teachers, but she was losing her enthusiasm for learning. The psychologist concluded that STUDENT’s emergent needs in the area of social competence, including her expressed desire to make a close friend, might best be afforded in a situation where she could socialize more frequently with students with like interests and psychological development, in an appropriate setting.

Placement discussion at the June 14, 2000 IEP meeting included alternatives of an SDC or fifth-grade general education class with 1:1 support. The speech and language specialist, Ms. Shough, offered that over the past five years STUDENT had shown a two-year increase in her language development but only minimal improvement in phonology. Ms. Shough testified that the increase in language development made STUDENT’s language more complex, but without an increase in phonetic ability this situation had caused greater frustration in STUDENT, as she was unable to express herself as she intended. At the IEP meeting, Ms. Shough recommended a possible change in educational placement to promote greater opportunities for oral communication within a small group and consistently familiar listener environment. The parents expressed concern that STUDENT had reached a plateau academically and had not progressed as much as they had hoped she would progress. She no longer had a special friend and was not included in play dates. She was aware of her social isolation and had “shut down” in some areas and regressed to imaginative play. The parents wanted an educational environment that was highly structured, repetitive, and would teach to STUDENT’s strengths, such as music and visual memory. The parents were concerned that in an SDC STUDENT would mimic negative behaviors.

The District’s members of the June 14, 2000 IEP team recommended that the most appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENT was an SDC on a regular education campus. She continued to require additional support due to safety concerns. She had a tendency to wander off from the group or the location where she should be. She also had a tendency not to pay attention to where she should be or to her surroundings. Those safety concerns qualified her for home transportation services. The District’s members of the IEP team also recommended support for the transition into the new SDC placement. STUDENT’s parents withheld their consent to the June 14, 2000 IEP team recommendation. The parents wanted to first observe SDC placements that were proposed at various schools.

The next IEP, dated October 13, 2000 (District Ex. 3), states that although the District’s recommendation at the June 14, 2000 IEP team had been to place STUDENT in a small SDC, when the parent observed the SDCs she did not feel those classes were appropriate for the 2000-2001 school year. At the October 13, 2000 IEP meeting STUDENT’s mother expressed concerns that homework was not consistently coming home and that STUDENT was often trying to hide or throw away her homework. She wanted STUDENT to participate in a small group of peers who were at her level in language expression. She was concerned that her daughter was withdrawing because of peer rejection, and the mother was looking at other placements such as smaller schools. The mother was eager to find a suitable middle school for the 2001-2002 school year. The classroom teacher reported that STUDENT was cooperative and that she would occasionally vocalize inappropriately, but she was not disruptive. The resource specialist reported that STUDENT often displayed stubborn behavior and needed very firm and consistent rules and consequences. She could be easily distracted by others but rarely would interact. She was exhibiting juvenile behaviors such as putting her fingers in her mouth. The inclusion teacher reported that STUDENT had few opportunities to interact successfully with peers, as her level of maturity and her ability to initiate and sustain conversation were limited. The inclusion teacher also reported that STUDENT was socially somewhat isolated, and that her stubbornness was impeding her progress. The decision of the IEP team was to continue STUDENT for the remainder of 2000-2001 school year as a fully-included student in a fifth-grade general education class with supportive services including speech and language, a one-on-one assistant, and home transportation.

The most recent IEP is dated April 19, 2001 (District Ex. 2). The IEP states that STUDENT had met the goals and objectives of being able to socialize with peers appropriately, but she would often wander off on her own or do things that peers would encourage her to do. One of those things, according to the mother’s testimony, was having STUDENT pull down her pants. The parents were concerned she did not have peers and seemed to be withdrawing. The teacher commented that several students would “look out” for STUDENT, but she did not have any real friends. Her performance and behavior were very inconsistent even when she was given material at her ability level. She had taken the identity of a particular television character during the year, and at times would write that character’s name on all of her papers. In the teacher’s opinion, it had been very difficult to get STUDENT to resume her own identity. STUDENT was observed to have tantrums when upset or having something of value taken from her. She was able to interact with adults and peers but was not able to sustain conversation or attention. She worked cooperatively in groups. Academically, she was continuing to perform at first- and second-grade levels in most areas.

The parties agreed at the April 19, 2000 IEP meeting that the past programs of inclusion were no longer effective for STUDENT as the disparity widened between STUDENT and her typical peers. Accordingly, the District recommended and offered an SDC in STUDENT’s District school of residence. Assistance in the form of peer/classroom support was recommended. It was also recommended that she participate in a regular education elective and physical education with assistance. The SDC curriculum would be at her ability level, maintaining content areas as appropriate. Assistive technology devices were specified. Transportation would be provided from home to school.

On June 19, 2001, the District sent a letter to STUDENT’s parents confirming that the placement offer was the self-contained MR special day class at Palms taught by Ms. Hoffman (Respondent’s Ex. 18).(Footnote 4)

STUDENT’s parents did not and have not consented to the placement portion of the District’s program offer for the 2001-2002 school year. The parents assert that the placement on the Palms campus would not meet their daughters’ academic, social, emotional, and safety needs.

Regarding academic needs, the parents assert that STUDENT requires a method of teaching focused on her strengths. They state that STUDENT is particularly gifted in music, dance, and drama. She learns best through direct experience as opposed to theoretical learning. They claim her education should stress exposure to the arts, because these are her areas of strength. They claim the proposed placement would be inconsistent with the need to teach to STUDENT’s strengths, because courses in the arts are only available at Palms in regular education classes. The parents also claim that STUDENT would not be sufficiently challenged academically, by her disabled peers at Palms, and that she needs a placement with a larger pool of disabled peers.

Regarding social and emotional needs, the parents assert that the placement at Palms would have insufficient boy-to-girl ratios in the particular SDC proposed for STUDENT, and the Palms campus would have an insufficient number of peers at similar cognitive levels to meet STUDENT’s needs for friendship and not being socially isolated.

Regarding safety needs, the parents assert the Palms campus is too large and the students are potentially too tough for STUDENT to be safe, especially given her vulnerability and her tendency to wander off. The parents claim that for STUDENT to be safe on the Palms campus she would need to be confined to the SDC, which would allegedly violate legal requirements for education in the least restrictive environment.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year?

Under State and federal law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8).

The term “special education” means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services,” at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.

The parameters for adequacy of a student’s IEP are set forth in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982). The United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-208.

To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's proposed program would have addressed the Petitioner’s unique needs, provided her some educational benefit, and comported with her IEP, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.

In summary, under the IDEA , State law, and Rowley, the program the District has proposed for the 2001-2002 school year must have met the following four requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for the Petitioner: (I) designed to meet her unique needs, (II) reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, (III) comport with her IEP, and (IV) provide her an education in the least restrictive environment. I. Is the District’s Proposed Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?

STUDENT has disabilities arising from craniofacial structural defects that render her speech essentially unintelligible to an unfamiliar listener. She also has mental retardation, which impairs both her ability to learn and her ability to cope with her speech deficits. Her learning and speech deficits, separately and in combination, cause STUDENT to have unique needs, including academic, social, emotional, and safety needs.

The parties agree that the past strategy of inclusion programs would no longer be effective for STUDENT as the developmental disparity has continued to widen between STUDENT and her typical peers. The parties acknowledge that effective communication between the teacher and STUDENT is essential. The parties agree that STUDENT needs a more structured school environment. They agree that STUDENT needs to be taught predominantly by teachers who specialize in teaching children with special needs, and that she needs to be surrounded by a small group consisting of children at similar cognitive and communicative levels.

The parties also agree that STUDENT would communicate better in a smaller and more consistently familiar listener environment. STUDENT is more intelligible to familiar listeners. STUDENT’s phonetics are extremely poor due to structural defects, but as Ms. Shough testified, STUDENT does have the strength of excellent intonation patterns, where a familiar listener can better understand her by listening to the patterns or rhythm of her speech.

The District has submitted an educational program offer for the 2001-2002 school year. The District asserts that its offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The offer includes placement in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms for students designated as MR, with a one-to-one assistant for the transition during the first month of school. At the conclusion of the first month, the District would convene an IEP meeting to address the need to continue the one-to-one assistant and to add appropriate mainstream experiences with inclusion support (Respondent’s Ex. 18).

The April 19, 2001 IEP lists and discusses STUDENT’s present levels of performance in language arts, math, behavior, and articulation. Recommendations were made by the District for assistive technology (AT) pursuant to an AT assessment reviewed at the IEP meeting. Goals and objectives in reading, written language, math, behavior, vocational education/transition, and articulation are included in the IEP. The appropriateness of the goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s unique needs is not in dispute. The special education teacher (Ms. Hoffman) would be responsible for goals and objectives in reading, written language, math, behavior, and vocational/educational transition. A speech and language pathologist would be responsible for goals and objectives in articulation. The goals and objectives have methods listed for reporting and evaluation. AT services have been specified.

The above-stated facts show the District has offered a program which includes agreed-upon goals and objectives and other services to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The District has offered a placement in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms for MR students as the place where that program would be implemented.

The parents object to certain aspects of the placement at Palms, which they claim would prevent the program from meeting STUDENT’s unique academic, social, emotional, and safety needs.

A. Academic Needs

Regarding academic needs, STUDENT’s parents claim there are two unacceptable deficiencies with the placement at Palms. They claim that the placement would be inconsistent with the need to teach to STUDENT’s strengths, and that she would not be sufficiently challenged by her disabled peers.

Teaching to STUDENT’s Strengths. The parents assert that STUDENT needs a method of teaching that focuses on her strengths. This means teaching with a “hands-on,” direct-experience approach to learning. The parents believe STUDENT learns best by direct experience as opposed to absorbing through lectures or abstract reading.

The evidence confirms that STUDENT’s academic needs do include a method of teaching that focuses on her strength for learning by direct experience. As Ms. Shough expressed, “this relates to STUDENT’s exceptionality.” Ms. Shough testified that children within STUDENT’s eligibility classification of MR generally learn better with practical teaching than with theoretical teaching.

Ms. Hoffman testified that her approach with STUDENT in the SDC would be to teach to STUDENT’s strengths, using those strengths to overcome STUDENT’s weaknesses and to help build self-esteem. Ms. Shough testified that teaching through hands-on activity in regular education classes begins to diminish after kindergarten, and by the third grade an SDC would embrace that type of hands-on activity more than a regular education class.

The testimony of Ms. Hoffman and Ms. Shough establishes that hands-on, direct-experience learning is one of the distinguishing characteristics of an SDC, and more specifically, of the SDC proposed by the District.

Although the proposed SDC would embrace a method of teaching that focuses on STUDENT’s strength for learning by direct experience, the parents believe that more is required. The parents assert that a method that teaches to STUDENT’s strength for learning by direct experience should also stress exposure to the arts such as music, dance, and drama, because these are areas of strength for STUDENT. They claim the placement at Palms would fail to meet the need to teach to STUDENT’s strengths, because such courses in the arts are only available at Palms in regular education classes.

Regarding music, for example, STUDENT has recently enjoyed learning to play the cello. Employees of the District testified that STUDENT could take music as an elective at Palms. The parents believe it would be highly problematic to place STUDENT in Palms’ regular education music class, which consists of 50 to 70 orchestra students. The parents assert that STUDENT needs a setting where subjects such as music, dance, drama, and art are taught in smaller classes by teachers who are specifically trained in teaching children with disabilities.

The proposed placement at Palms may or may not provide the more favorable setting to STUDENT for classes in the arts. There are definite advantages to specialized teaching of the arts to children with disabilities, but there also would be advantages to having STUDENT see, hear, and participate with her nondisabled peers. A regular education elective in a subject in which STUDENT excels would seem to be a propitious setting for STUDENT to interact positively with her nondisabled peers. In either event, a resolution of these questions would not be determinate of the issue of teaching to STUDENT’s strengths.

The pertinent inquiry is whether the proposed program and placement at Palms, considered as a whole, is designed to meet STUDENT’s academic need for a method of teaching that focuses on her strengths. STUDENT has a strength for learning by direct experience. That strength provides the pathway for her academic progress. The arts may be a particular area of strength for STUDENT, but the analysis of meeting her academic needs must not be so narrow as to only include consideration of the offerings at Palms in classes focused on the arts. If STUDENT is capable of academic progress in areas other than the arts, evaluating her academic needs only from the perspective the arts would be a disservice to her overall academic development. It would also be a disservice to relegate STUDENT to a program focused on the arts, at the expense of her opportunity for learning other subjects.

The evidence shows that although STUDENT has plateaued academically under the mainstreaming approach at first- and second-grade levels, she can still receive academic benefit from being taught core subjects such as math, reading, and writing in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT’s recent use of the computer for writing had demonstrated STUDENT’s thoughts to be well beyond what had previously been revealed to the mother by oral communication. Ms. Hoffman was especially enthusiastic about proper use of the computer as a tool for communication and learning by STUDENT.

Ms. Hoffman testified she was “hopeful” STUDENT would show academic progress. Ms. Shough was more emphatic. Ms. Shough testified that the SDC would “absolutely” allow STUDENT to progress academically, given the more suitable skills of an SDC teacher, the smaller class size, and the communication advantages of the SDC. Ms. Shough testified that the SDC setting would be very positive for STUDENT’s communication and academic needs. She testified that in an SDC, the teacher is trained to educate children with special needs. She stated that an SDC teacher typically has more compassion and feelings for special needs students. She also stated that an SDC class is usually small, with typically between eight to twelve communication patterns among the students. In this type of environment, according to Ms. Shough, a level of understanding usually occurs quite readily between the teacher and the students.

The Hearing Officer agrees with Ms. Shough. The reasons she states for expecting academic progress by STUDENT in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC are all consistent with the undisputed needs of STUDENT for learning in a structured environment, where the teacher and STUDENT can orally communicate with each other and where the teacher specializes in teaching students with STUDENT’s type of disabilities.

In summary, the SDC proposed by the District would utilize a method of teaching that focuses on STUDENT’s strength for learning by direct experience. There is a strong likelihood that STUDENT will receive significant academic benefit from being taught core academic subjects such as math, reading, and writing in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. It is certainly appropriate for STUDENT to have her SDC curriculum concentrated on the core subjects specified in her agreed-upon goals and objectives, and then pursue the arts as electives. Furthermore, although it is debatable whether Palms’ electives in the arts provide a better opportunity for learning the arts than the program proposed by the Petitioner, the electives at Palms would still provide benefit to STUDENT by having her participate with her nondisabled peers.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique academic need for a method of teaching that focuses on her strengths.

Sufficiently Challenged by Her Peers. STUDENT’s parents also assert that STUDENT needs to be challenged academically by her peers. Her parents state that STUDENT would not be sufficiently challenged by the students in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms. The parents believe STUDENT needs exposure to a larger number of disabled peers, to disabled peers at higher cognitive levels, and to disabled peers who may be gifted in certain areas, such as children with autism. The mother testified that she has observed Ms. Hoffman’s prior class and the two “feeder classes” from which new students would be placed. In the mother’s opinion, those children, who are classified as MR, would not present a challenge to the academic level of STUDENT. Other than the mother’s testimony at the hearing, there was no evidence presented regarding whether STUDENT’s academic needs included a need to be challenged academically by her peers. The mother believes that through STUDENT being challenged by and mimicking the example of her twin brother, who is in a magnet program for gifted students, STUDENT has progressed far beyond the prognosis that doctors made when she was an infant. The mother had been told that STUDENT would never walk, talk, or even be potty-trained. On the basis of the mother’s knowledge of what motivates STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will accept the premise that being challenged is a motivating factor for STUDENT.

The question to be resolved is whether the placement and program at Palms is designed to meet STUDENT’s need to be challenged and therefore motivated by her peers.

Palms is a campus with over 1800 students. STUDENT would be included with nondisabled peers at lunch, recess, and in electives. Some of those nondisabled students would be participating in special programs administered by Ms. Hoffman through her “Optimists Club,” which is founded upon the concept of regular and positive interaction between disabled and nondisabled peers at lunch, at special events such as the Special Olympics, on field trips, in regular education electives, and in adaptive physical education. This positive interaction will provide STUDENT with plentiful and diverse challenges and competition from her peers.

With regard to her peers in her classroom, the evidence shows that STUDENT has an academic need to be with other disabled peers at similar cognitive levels. STUDENT needs a small-class setting where she is surrounded by a group of children at similar cognitive levels, forming a consistently familiar listener environment.

There are several SDCs on the Palms campus, and each SDC is designed to accommodate children within a certain eligibility category. STUDENT would be placed in Ms. Hoffman’s class for students under the MR eligibility category, where peers are at similar cognitive levels.

Academically, STUDENT may be above or below the levels of other children in the MR eligibility category of Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. STUDENT’s specific position or level within the continuum of that category is not fundamental to STUDENT’s academic needs. STUDENT’s peers in Ms. Hoffman’s class would meet STUDENT’s needs because those peers have similar cognitive levels.

Accordingly, STUDENT’s academic needs within her classroom do not require her to be challenged academically by exposure to larger numbers of disabled peers or to disabled peers who may be highly gifted in certain areas. Instead, STUDENT needs peers in her classroom who are at cognitive levels similar to hers. Outside of her classroom, her interactions with peers through the activities and special programs available at Palms would provide her with challenge and motivation.

Summary. The characteristics of Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms for MR students are consistent with STUDENT’s unique academic needs, providing a structured environment, specialized teaching, and peers at similar cognitive levels, all of which will facilitate communication between STUDENT and her teacher and classmates. Agreed-upon goals and objectives have been drafted to meet STUDENT’s academic needs. The evidence shows that Ms. Hoffman’s SDC for MR students is an appropriate placement for accomplishing those academic goals and objectives, and there is a strong likelihood that STUDENT will receive significant academic benefit from being taught core academic subjects such as math, reading, and writing in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. Additionally, the placement at Palms will provide STUDENT with plentiful and diverse challenges and competition from her peers.

The Hearing Officer finds that the placement and program offered by the District at Palms is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique academic needs.

B. Social and Emotional Needs

California special education law provides that before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an assessment shall be conducted in all areas related to the suspected disability, including the “social and emotional status” of the pupil. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320(f). Therefore, special education law envisions that development of a program designed to meet a student’s unique needs will include consideration of the student’s social and emotional status as related to her disability.

STUDENT’s IEPs and testimony of the witnesses for both parties have shown that STUDENT has unique social and emotional needs related to her disability, and that those needs are adversely affecting her education.

The question to be decided is whether the District’s placement offer at Palms is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique social and emotional needs related to her disability.

STUDENT’s Unique Social and Emotional Needs. Before determining whether the District’s program offer addresses STUDENT’s social and emotional needs, it is necessary to more clearly identify those needs.

The parents expressed concern at the June 14, 2000 IEP that STUDENT no longer had a special friend, was not included in play dates, was aware of her social isolation, and had “shut down” in some areas and regressed to imaginative play (District Ex. 9). STUDENT’s mother testified that as STUDENT’s communication difficulties have increased to 90-percent unintelligibility, STUDENT has become increasingly frustrated. The mother observed that

STUDENT has begun having long conversations with herself and exhibiting tic-like behaviors. The parents stated that during a psychiatric consult, they were told much of that behavior was due to STUDENT’s isolation and lack of appropriate peers.(Footnote 5)

Ms. Greenberg testified that one of the purposes of the October 13, 2000 IEP meeting was to address the widening academic and social gap between STUDENT and her peers. Ms. Greenberg testified that in the fifth grade STUDENT was functioning at the second-grade level with a modified curriculum. She was paired with students to help her with socialization, but on the playground she was by herself most of the time. She would start with a group, then leave. Ms. Greenberg believed one impact of this form of social isolation was that STUDENT had less desire to focus on academics.

Ms. Shough testified that over the past five years STUDENT had shown a two-year increase in her language development but only minimal improvement in phonology. The increase in language development has made STUDENT’s language more complex. However, with only minimal improvement in phonetic ability, the increase in language development has caused greater frustration in STUDENT because she is increasingly unable to express herself as she intends. The source of frustration is perhaps even more profound than indicated by Ms. Shough, since there was testimony that proportional changes in STUDENT’s craniofacial anatomy as she grows have caused the impairment of her speech to worsen from about fifty-percent unintelligible to “unintelligible” as characterized by the pediatric genetic specialist at Cedars-Sinai Medical Center.

Ms. Woolsey testified that according to research on the subject, disorders of the type suffered by STUDENT have extremely detrimental consequences, with the child’s emotional suffering leading to academic problems, such as losing motivation to go to school. In her observations, STUDENT appeared to still be highly motivated, but when her speech was not understood her entire affect would change, and she would not want to talk. STUDENT knows that her speech is unintelligible, and this has caused secondary behaviors such as facial grimacing in an effort to make her speech understood, which, in Ms. Woolsey’s words, make STUDENT look more abnormal.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s severe communication impairments have caused her to experience frustration, anxiety, and social isolation. These conditions are compounded by her intellectual and cognitive deficits, and are negatively impacting her education. A program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs must address that frustration, anxiety, and social isolation.

The District’s Offer. The core component of the District’s offer in response to STUDENT’s unique social and emotional needs is Ms. Hoffman’s SDC for MR students at Palms.

The Petitioner’s Objections. The Petitioner’s parents are not opposed to a class composed of children with disabilities, but they are opposed to the placement at Palms. They object to the disparate boy-to-girl ratio in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. They also object to the overall scarcity of female peers on the Palms campus who are at developmental levels similar to STUDENT. They claim that because of these factors, it is unlikely that STUDENT would find and keep a close friend at Palms. Therefore, according to the parents, the placement at Palms is not designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs.

In support of her contentions regarding disparate boy-to-girl ratios in the proposed SDC, STUDENT’s mother testified that she observed only one girl in the applicable SDC at Palms for the 2000-2001 school year. Mr. Baker acknowledged in his testimony that the District generally has an overpopulation of boys compared to girls in its SDCs, and parents often express concern. Ms. Hoffman affirmed that when STUDENT’s mother visited Ms. Hoffman’s SDC, there was only one girl in the class at that time. Ms. Hoffman testified that although the gender ratios vary, there are always more boys in her class than girls. She stated there are usually 3 or 4 girls in her classroom, but last year there were only two girls in a class of eight. For the 2001-2001 school year, she currently has six students. Ms. Greenberg testified she had confirmed the class as currently planned would have three girls out of eight students.

Discussion. The question to be decided is whether the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs, and more specifically whether that offer appropriately addresses STUDENT’s frustration, anxiety, and social isolation.

Ms. Woolsey stated STUDENT needs a very supportive school environment instead of an environment where people make fun of her. The school psychologist reported at the June 14, 2000 IEP meeting that STUDENT’s emergent needs in the area of social competence and the expressed desire to make a close friend might best be addressed in a situation where she could socialize more frequently with students having like interests and psychological development, in an appropriate setting. Ms. Shough’s testified that STUDENT should have a change in placement to promote greater opportunities for oral communication within a small and consistently familiar environment, where the listeners would be familiar with STUDENT’s speech.

Ms. Shough also testified that she believes STUDENT would be comfortable in an SDC, adapting to it and finding her own comfort level within that setting. Ms. Shough stated that having children with STUDENT who are at STUDENT’s developmental level in an SDC would improve STUDENT’s communication. She testified that communication is best when peers surrounding a child with communication difficulties are developmentally appropriate, and Ms. Hoffman’s SDC would give STUDENT more opportunities to communicate with peers who are at her developmental level. According to Ms. Shough, children in an SDC tend to get to a point where they understand each other. In Ms. Hoffman’s SDC, STUDENT would be protected from peer rejection, would benefit from being with other children who would solicit her input, and would be less exposed to peers who ignore her by neither soliciting nor valuing her input.

STUDENT’s communication deficits, in combination with her intellectual and cognitive deficits, are the underlying cause of her social and emotional needs, including her frustration, anxiety, and social isolation. The evidence has established that the SDC at Palms would be composed of children at similar developmental levels, in a small and structured setting, with an appropriately skilled teacher. The class would have Ms. Hoffman as the teacher, plus one teaching assistant and a one-to-one assistant assigned to another student. The size of the class, the skills of the special education teacher, and the developmental level of the children will address STUDENT’s communication problems and academic needs, regardless of the boy-to-girl ratios and regardless of whether there are other disabled students on the campus outside of the SDC. The SDC is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some academic benefit, which would increase STUDENT’s self-esteem. By addressing STUDENT’s communication deficits, the SDC at Palms would give her the opportunity to interact with peers who would be interested in her, despite her disabilities. These components of the SDC would address STUDENT’s frustration, anxiety, and social isolation, and they would give STUDENT the opportunity to develop multiple friendships.

Furthermore, regarding boy-to-girl ratios, although STUDENT’s parents would prefer a setting with more girls in the class, it does not necessarily follow that more girls would increase the likelihood of STUDENT’s making a close friend. Although there is no placement that can guarantee a friend for STUDENT, Ms. Hoffman testified that the children in her SDC interact with each other, and they love each other. This is the type of setting that can meet STUDENT’s need for a friend.

Summary. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms for ER students is designed to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs. The SDC offered at Palms would address STUDENT’s frustration, anxiety, and social isolation through the size of the class, the special skills of the teacher, the interaction with peers at a similar developmental level, and through the likelihood of improved self-esteem as STUDENT progresses academically, communicates more effectively, and has her input solicited by her peers.

C. Safety Needs

To determine whether the District’s program offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique safety needs, it is necessary to identify those needs and to have an understanding of the setting at the Palms campus.

STUDENT’s Unique Safety Needs. STUDENT has a history of wandering off. This has been acknowledged in her IEPs and has been addressed in the past by use of a one-to-one assistant and provision of home transportation services. STUDENT’s parents are greatly concerned by her history of wandering off. The mother testified that during STUDENT’s attendance at Warner, there were many occasions when she would disappear from the place where she or her class was expected to be. There were two occasions during STUDENT’s six or seven years of attendance at Warner when the school actually called the mother because they could not find STUDENT. On the remaining occasions, STUDENT disappeared but was eventually located without the parents being called. The mother was aware of those incidents because she would be so informed by the school at the end of the day. All of this occurred despite STUDENT’s having a one-to-one assistant.

Ms. Shough testified that she believes STUDENT’s wandering is actually a navigation problem, where she gets confused by the sequence of turns necessary to get from one area to another. The mother disagrees that the wandering is due to navigation problems. She believes STUDENT knows exactly where she is, where she wants to go, and how to get there. If she becomes bored and thinks she can get to a better location or activity, she will disappear to that place. As proof to support her assertion, the mother noted that when STUDENT would disappear at Warner she usually would be found in either of her two favorite places, the cafeteria or the computer room.

In addition to STUDENT’s wandering off, her parents are very concerned about what they characterize as STUDENT’s vulnerability. STUDENT’s parents characterize her as especially vulnerable to abuse because she is cute, petite, extremely friendly, and trusting. The worsening of her communication abilities has overlapped with her increasing need to feel loved. She is gullible and easily manipulated. Her inability to have her speech understood increases her vulnerability. Puberty issues are emerging, which compounds the parents’ concern about STUDENT’s vulnerability.

Having observed STUDENT at the hearing and listened to the testimony of the witnesses, the Hearing Officer considers the parents’ characterization of their daughter to be accurate. A program that is designed to meet STUDENT’s safety needs must address her physical and emotional vulnerability and her tendency to wander off.

The Palms Campus. Mr. Toda testified that Palms has 1849 students on a 20-acre campus which is divided essentially in half by a 4-lane major highway. A tunnel under the highway connects the divided campus. There are 22 gates, four main entrances, and 179 staff members on campus during the school day. By comparison, the mother testified that the Warner campus, which the Student has attended since kindergarten, has about 600 students.

STUDENT’s mother described Palms as a tough inner-city school with tough kids. Mr. Toda described the policies and procedures used for the goal of providing a safe and secure school that children want to attend where they can learn. Students are not allowed off the campus. The codes of conduct are distributed to all students and reviewed periodically in the classrooms. Discipline is used. Strangers are not allowed on the campus. There are daily random metal detector searches in classes. There is a dress code. There is sexual harassment training.

Palms has been referred to by the witnesses as a “school that works.” Mr. Toda testified that Palms has 94.8 percent in-seat attendance of its students. He testified that compared to other schools in its area, there are fewer suspensions and fewer drugs. He has no knowledge of a special needs student ever being sexually harassed at Palms. Regarding harassment or teasing of special needs students in general, he testified that typically there is more teasing at the beginning of the year, such as when the special education students are arriving on buses. Mr. Toda or the staff then counsel the regular education students, and as the year progresses the regular education students reportedly co-mingle well and sometimes even become friends with the students who have disabilities.

The mother is familiar with Palms because her son attends Palms in a magnet program for gifted students. She testified that Palms has been very swift, responsive, and effective in matters that require disciplinary measures. However, her son has told her his perception of incidents in which regular education students were teasing SDC students and causing them to engage in inappropriate behaviors. When Mr. Toda testified about the same or similar incidents, his perspective was quite different. Mr. Toda acknowledged that harassment does occur, but it was the Hearing Officer’s impression that in defining harassment, Mr. Toda believes a determining factor is how the SDC student views the particular event. For example, in an incident involving regular education students bringing a skateboard to school (against school rules) and having an MR student ride the skateboard, Mr. Toda thought that was the regular education students’ method of showing friendship. The particular MR student, when interviewed by Mr. Toda, thought the experience was fun.

If she attended Palms, STUDENT would be outside her SDC during recess, lunch, elective periods, and the early-morning home room. Recess and lunch are at the same time for everyone on campus. (Testimony of Mr. Toda, Ms. Hoffman.) During those times, the SDC students are essentially on their own unless they have a one-to-one assistant, or students from the on-campus “Optimists Club” join them.

The Optimists Club is administered by Ms. Hoffman. In that club, students from all groups can volunteer to go one time per week to lunch with the SDC students, or go to events such as the Special Olympics. Regardless of their volunteer schedule, typical peers from the Optimists Club tend to gravitate toward their disabled peers at lunchtime. (Testimony of Ms. Hoffman.)

Ms. Hoffman believes that Palms provides a safe environment for her SDC children during the times they interact with their nondisabled peers. Ms. Hoffman testified that throughout her 18 years at Palms, she has been amazed by the positive interaction between the regular education students and her SDC students. She sees little or no harassment, and is impressed by how well the SDC children are treated. She testified there is abundant security on campus, especially with teachers helping.

Discussion. The question to be decided is whether the District’s program offer on the Palms campus is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique safety needs arising from her physical and emotional vulnerability and her tendency to wander off.

The District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year includes a one-to-one assistant for the transition during the first month of school. At the conclusion of the first month, the District would convene an IEP to address the need to continue the one-to-one assistant and to add appropriate mainstream experiences with inclusion support. (Respondent’s Ex. 18.)

STUDENT has a history of wandering off at Warner despite having always been assigned a one-to-one assistant. Her mother testified that STUDENT’s wandering is usually the result of boredom or lack of interest. When STUDENT thinks there is a better place for her to be, she will depart for that place. Although a one-to-one assistant did not solve STUDENT’s wandering problem at Warner, there are circumstances that distinguish the past situation at Warner from the prospective situation at Palms.

At Warner, STUDENT was fully included, meaning that she attended regular education classes with an aide. She never had the protection inherent to an SDC. In contrast to an entire day in and moving between regular education classes at Warner, during most of her school day at Palms, STUDENT would be in her relatively small SDC class. The proposed SDC class would have a ratio of about three adults to six or eight children, making the class easier for the adults to observe. The SDC would also tend to keep STUDENT more interested and engaged than a regular education class by virtue of the specialized teaching and an environment that promotes meaningful oral communication. These factors yield a much lower probability that STUDENT would be able to wander off or even choose to wander off from the SDC at Palms.

STUDENT’s parents assert that outside the confines of her SDC class, STUDENT would especially be at risk for her safety. At Palms, STUDENT would be outside the confines of her SDC and exposed to nondisabled peers during lunch, recess, the early morning home room, and in regular education electives.

The testimony of Ms. Hoffman and Mr. Toda has shown that the SDC students in Ms. Hoffman’s MR class, while experiencing some problems, have not experienced major problems with the regular education students at Palms during Ms. Hoffman’s 18-year tenure. Ms. Hoffman’s SDC students have unsupervised excursions on the main campus during lunch and recess, simultaneously with their nondisabled peers. Relationships between the SDC pupils and the regular education pupils are promoted by the Optimists Club program and the school administration’s attitude toward discipline and teaching the regular education students to respect their peers with disabilities. Ms. Hoffman was a credible witness and very devoted to the well-being of the children in her SDC class. She testified that she tends to be overprotective of her children and that they always know where to find her. Her opinion that STUDENT would be safe at Palms carries substantial weight. In addition to the considerations mentioned above, another factor that would assist in STUDENT’s safety needs is the offer of a one-to-one assistant for the first month. Although the one-to-one assistant approach was apparently ineffective at Warner, STUDENT’s opportunities to wander off would be greatly reduced at Palms because STUDENT would be attending the SDC for the majority of her time. Furthermore, if STUDENT did elude her aide, testimony has shown that other programs in place at Palms are effective for protecting the safety of children with special needs. Finally, wandering off should not occur if the aide is competent, and it is presumed the District will assign a competent aide.

After the first month, the District would convene an IEP to address the need to continue the one-to-one assistant and to add appropriate mainstream experiences with inclusion support. At that time, STUDENT’s parents and the District would have had an opportunity to observe STUDENT’s status at Palms and rate the effectiveness and necessity of a one-to-one assistant for STUDENT in the Palms environment. They would then be in a better position to determine whether it was appropriate to have STUDENT continue with an aide and/or attend regular education electives.

The evidence shows that the proposed SDC class at Palms addresses STUDENT’s unique safety needs arising from her vulnerability and her tendency to wander off. The small class size and favorable ratio of SDC students to adults will make it easier for the adults to observe STUDENT. The specialized teaching and an environment that promotes meaningful verbal communication are designed to keep STUDENT engaged in the class. These factors yield a much lower probability that STUDENT would be able to wander off or even choose to wander off from the SDC at Palms.

The evidence further shows that the offer of a one-to-one assistant at Palms, in combination with the other programs already existing at Palms to facilitate appropriate interaction between SDC students and regular education students, is designed to meet STUDENT’s safety needs while she is outside the SDC. The evidence also shows that the District’s offer to reconvene an IEP after one month of school to review the need to continue the one-to-one assistant and to add mainstream experiences with inclusion support is appropriate.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer at Palms is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique safety needs.

II Is the District’s Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit?

The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, including her academic, social, emotional, and safety needs. Designated instruction and services in speech and language have been agreed upon. Agreed-upon goals and objectives have been drafted to meet STUDENT’s academic needs. The evidence shows that Ms. Hoffman’s SDC for MR students is an appropriate placement for accomplishing those academic goals and objectives, and there is a strong likelihood that STUDENT will receive significant academic benefit from being taught core academic subjects such as math, reading, and writing in Ms. Hoffman’s SDC. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

III. Does the District’s Proposed Program Comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

There is no dispute that the District’s program offer comports with STUDENT’s IEP.

IV. Does the District’s Proposed Program Offer STUDENT an Education in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The issue to be decided is whether the District’s proposed program offers STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment.

As stated above, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U. S.C. § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.

STUDENT was placed in regular education classes with supportive services in all of her prior educational programs. The District is now offering placement in an SDC at Palms with a one-to-one assistant for at least the first month and opportunity for electives in regular education classes. The SDC component of the District’s offer constitutes a more restrictive environment than STUDENT’s prior programs.

The more restrictive environment of an SDC is appropriate to STUDENT’s needs. It is undisputed that the nature and severity of STUDENT’s disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. The mainstreaming approach has brought STUDENT to first- and second-grade levels in most subjects, where she has plateaued over the past several school years. The increasing disparity between the developmental levels of STUDENT and those of her nondisabled peers has led to frustration, anxiety, and social isolation as discussed above. Academically, socially, and emotionally, STUDENT needs to be in a more structured school environment, in a small group taught predominately by teachers who specialize in teaching children with special needs, and surrounded by children with similar psychological development. A small and consistently familiar environment would promote greater opportunities for oral communication where the listeners could become familiar with STUDENT’s speech.

The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s program offer is designed to meet the needs stated above. However, the Petitioner claims that because of the setting at Palms, her safety needs would dictate that she be confined to the SDC. The Petitioner claims this would violate the requirement of least restrictive environment. The Petitioner claims that a less restrictive environment would be at Kayne-Eras, the certified nonpublic school proposed by her parents. According to STUDENT’s parents, Kayne-Eras has high number of teachers and aides trained in special education, and the student body would consist entirely of children with disabilities. The parents assert that Kayne-Eras is a place where STUDENT could safely have access to virtually the entire campus, and this could all be accomplished without the use of a one-to-one assistant.

Regarding the Petitioner’s contention that her safety needs would require confinement in the SDC at Palms, the Hearing Officer has previously determined that the District’s offer is designed to meet the Petitioner’s unique safety needs. That finding was not contingent upon STUDENT’s being confined to an SDC.

Regarding the matter of a one-to-one assistant, the characteristics of Kayne-Eras, as they are described by STUDENT’s parents, could present a distinct advantage over the District’s offer. With a small and self-contained campus, plentiful support staff trained in teaching children with special needs, and a student population consisting entirely of special needs children, such a school would likely obviate STUDENT’s need for a one-to-one assistant. For STUDENT, this would mean greater independence. She would be reasonably challenged to find her own way around the campus, and an aide would not be interfering with her social interactions. Notwithstanding its advantages regarding the likely elimination of a one-to-one assistant, placement at the nonpublic school proposed by STUDENT’s parents would exact an unacceptable toll by eliminating STUDENT’s ability to interact with nondisabled peers. STUDENT would have no opportunity to participate in a regular education environment.

The importance of access to a regular education environment, even if that access may only be partial, is emphasized in Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031. That section envisions “. . . maximum interaction between children or youth with disabilities and children or youth who are not disabled, in a manner that is appropriate to the needs of both.”

Although STUDENT may not presently be able to benefit academically from certain large, regular education classes, she could still potentially benefit from inclusion opportunities with nondisabled peers at lunch, recess, in clubs or other school activities at Palms, and in certain appropriate electives. Testimony has shown that SDC students at Palms have been able to successfully interact with their nondisabled peers, without the use of one-to-one assistants. STUDENT would initially need a one-to-one assistant during her transition to a new campus, and that need may continue. With the structure of the SDC, such an aide will likely become unnecessary in the future for the majority of STUDENT’s school day.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s offer is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique safety needs. That finding was not contingent upon STUDENT’s being confined to Ms. Hoffman’s SDC at Palms. STUDENT will have opportunities at Palms to interact with nondisabled peers and to participate to some extent in a regular education environment. A placement at the nonpublic school proposed by STUDENT’s parents would provide no opportunity for STUDENT to interact with nondisabled peers on the campus or in the classrooms. Conversely, the use of a one-to-one assistant in the District’s proposed placement is appropriate. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer satisfies the requirements of least restrictive environment.

Issue No. 2: If the District did not offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year, then is STUDENT entitled to funding by the District for STUDENT’s future attendance at the certified nonpublic school proposed by her parents?

Since the Hearing Officer has found that the District offered the Petitioner a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2001-2002 school year, Issue No. 2 is moot.

ORDER

All of the Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).

Dated: August 20, 2001 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.The Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2.The issues listed here differ in wording from the issues as stated by the Petitioner. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis. 3.The District’s witnesses and exhibits appear to use interchangeably the terms mental retardation (MR), mental retardation mild (MRM), and educable retarded (ER). For purposes of this Decision, the terms ER, MR, or MRM are all considered to have substantially the same meaning. In the interest of consistency, the Hearing Officer uses the term MR in this Decision. 4.STUDENT’s “school of residence” referenced in the April 19, 2001 IEP was Webster Middle School. As an accommodation to the parent’s concerns about Webster Middle School, the District confirmed by a letter to STUDENT’s parents dated June 19, 2001 that the District was offering placement on the Palms campus. The June 19 letter also confirmed the District was offering the services of a one-to-one assistant. (Respondent’s Ex. 18.) 5. The report from Cedars-Sinai Medical Center (Pet. Ex. 1) recommends consideration of neuropsychiatric evaluation to determine whether the tics, phrase repetition, and other unusual behaviors seen recently in new or different situations or environments are the product of a tic disorder vs. an anxiety disorder.