California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 30, 1997

Student v. Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 951-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain

Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified denied FAPE in 1995-97, but Lindamood-Bell placement and therapy reimbursement were denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 7 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a 15-year-old ninth grader filed for due process against Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District. The District's assessments described her as developmentally delayed and in the mildly mentally retarded range. The parents argued she was severely dyslexic instead. They claimed she was denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from 1989-90 through 1996-97. They also sought placement at a Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center and repayment for private educational therapy.

Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain found that the evidence showed a developmental delay, not dyslexia. The only report finding dyslexia did not measure her intellectual ability. From 1989-90 through 1994-95, the District provided FAPE: its special day class (SDC) placements followed her IEPs, met her needs, and she made progress. In 1995-96, it denied FAPE. It agreed to the parents' request for general education with resource specialist support, even though its own staff soon saw she was not benefiting. In 1996-97, it also denied FAPE. She attended a general education/resource placement instead of the SDC in her IEP and could not do the work.

Even so, the Hearing Officer denied the Lindamood-Bell placement. The evidence did not show it met her needs, including her need for social skills. Reimbursement was denied because nothing showed the private therapy gave her educational benefit. The District had to hold an IEP meeting by June 6, 1997, to set her 1997-98 placement.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a district that agreed to a parent-requested placement its own staff believed was inappropriate. The district was still found to have denied FAPE. However, that finding alone did not bring relief: the parents had to prove that the program they requested and the private therapy were appropriate and gave educational benefit.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1989-90, 1990-91, 1991-92, and 1992-93 school years?

    The IEP team considered and partly implemented the private assessor's recommendations. The SDC placements were provided as written and met her needs as a developmentally delayed student. The Hearing Officer noted these years were probably time-barred, but the District did not raise that defense.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1993-94 school year?

    The SDC placement was implemented, its goals addressed the needs the private therapist had identified, and her passing grades and promotion showed educational benefit.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1994-95 school year?

    The parent-approved SDC IEP was implemented and met her needs, and she met her goals and made progress.

  4. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year?

    The District went along with the parents' request for a general education/RSP placement even though its own team believed she needed an SDC. That placement did not meet her unique needs, and she got no educational benefit from it, so she was denied FAPE.

  5. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year?

    She was placed in general education with RSP support under a SARB agreement instead of the SDC in her IEP. She could not do the work and got no educational benefit, so she was denied FAPE.

  6. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 6. Is STUDENT entitled to placement in a Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center? (Must the District provide prospective placement in an intensive treatment program at Lindamood-Bell?)

    The limited evidence did not show the Lindamood-Bell program was designed to meet her needs, including her need for social skills. Prospective placement was denied, and an IEP meeting was ordered instead.

  7. Issue 7. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for all previous, current, and future educational therapies and costs?

    Reimbursement was denied for the years in which FAPE was provided. The request for future costs was not specific. For 1995-97, there was no evidence that the private educational therapy gave her educational benefit.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. On or before June 6, 1997, the District must convene an IEP team meeting to determine an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year. All other requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Burger v. Murray County School District; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District; Education Code section 56329(b)

People named in the decision

  • Rhonda Jalali, Educational therapist; witness for Student, Switzer Center (formerly); private
  • Donna Gallagher, School psychologist; witness for District, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
  • Adria Weinstein, Resource specialist program teacher; witness for District, Palos Verdes Intermediate School
  • Susan Abott (Abbott), Resource specialist program teacher; witness for District, Peninsula High School
  • Constance Vendeland, Special education teacher and department chair; witness for District, South High School
  • Susan Wylie (Wyllie), Director of pupil services, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
  • Dr. Jack Schnel, Assessor, 1989 psychoeducational evaluation, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
  • Dr. Robert Colegrove, Private educational psychologist; 1989 evaluation
  • Diagnostic Center for Neurologically Handicapped Children, State diagnostic center; 1991 assessment
  • Scott Kester, Assessor, Loyola Marymount University
  • Ms. Grasinger, Co-teacher of collaborative English class, Peninsula High School
  • R. A. Drew, Former advocate for the parents
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center, Private provider; 1995 learning ability evaluation and proposed program
  • Switzer Center, Nonpublic school/private provider; 1992 assessment

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 951-96 Case Year: 1996 Petitioner: STUDENT Issue: Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 19-64865 District: Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified Disability Type: Mentally Retardation

Case Details This matter was heard on January 7, and February 6, 1997, in Rancho Palos Verdes, California , and by telephone conferences on February 24, March 10 and 24, 1997, (Footnote 1) before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by administrative law consultants George Mason and Francine McDermott-Mason. STUDENT's parents, MR. AND MRS. PARENT, also appeared on behalf of Petitioner.

Respondent Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (the District) was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District was Susan Wylie, director of pupil services.

Petitioner called educational therapist Rhonda Jalali to testify on her behalf.

The following witnesses testified on behalf of the District: Donna Gallagher, school psychologist; Adria Weinstein, resource specialist program teacher (RSP); Susan Abott, RSP teacher; and Constance Vendeland, special education teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received on January 7, and February 6, 1997. The parties prepared written closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision, and the record was closed on April 18, 1997.

ISSUES

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1989-90, 1990-91, 1991-92, and 1992-93 school years?

2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1993094 school year?

3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1994-95 school year?

4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?

5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1996-97 school year?

6. Is STUDENT entitled to placement in a Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center?

7. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for all previous, current, and future educational therapies and costs?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner's Position

In STUDENT's statement of issues, she maintains that the

STATE, District, SELPA, and Board are directly responsible for [her] declining intelligence scores over the past (7) seven years, as they were the responsible Authority who exercised discretion under the Color of authority to reject the parents' request for the District to consider outside professional assessments, and placed [her] contrary to state and federal laws, into curriculum that was for MMR [mildly mentally retarded] rather than dyslexic students. The District's inimical conduct results in denying [her] a free and appropriate education.

STUDENT also rejects the District's offer of placement in a special day class (SDC) at South High School and, instead, requests that she be prospectively placed in a Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center and "that all previous, current, and future educational/ therapeutic costs be paid by the State, District, and SELPA."

Respondent's Position

The District contends that its evaluations have accurately identified STUDENT's disability and led to appropriate educational placement decisions. The District asserts that a repeated evaluations establish that STUDENT is mentally retarded. The District further maintains that STUDENT would receive free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in an SDC at either South High School or Peninsula High School.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old ninth-grader who lives with parents within District boundaries. The FAMILY family speaks both English and Farsi at home. STUDENT established her eligibility for special education when she was three years old, bsaed on "delays in speech and language, motor skills, and other adaptive behaviors." (Footnote 2) STUDENT has also received a diagnosis of attention deficit disorder with hyperactivity (ADHD). STUDENT is currently enrolled in the regular education program with RSP support at Palos Verdes High School.

Until the end of STUDENT's seventh grade year, she had been placed in SDC's in public schools. However, in September 1995, when STUDENT entered the eighth grade, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested that she be enrolled in a general education program with RSP support. Other members of STUDENT's individualized educational program (IEP) team disagreed with the PARENTs' proposed placement, and urged that she continue in an SDC setting. (Footnote 3) Ultimately the District provided STUDENT with the 83.3% regular education and 16.6% RSP placement that the PARENTs requested. (Footnote 4)

Shortly after STUDENT enrolled in the regular education program, RSP teacher Adria Weinstein informed Susan Wyllie, director of pupil services, that "it is apparent that even with the additional modifications listed above, STUDENT's skill level inhibits her ability to benefit from the RSP/General Education program she is now enrolled in." By letter dated October 27, 1995, Ms. Wyllie recommended that the PARENTs "allow STUDENT to return to the special day class placement." Despite the early indication that STUDENT was not appropriately placed, she remained in the regular education/RSP placement throughout the 1995-96 school year.

On June 7, 1996, STUDENT's IEP team met to determine her educational placement for the 1996-97 school year. STUDENT's advocates recommended that she receive twelve weeks of intensive Lindamood- Bell training during the summer months and fall placement at one of the following six sites: Landmark West, Frostic Center, Ayres Center, Ahmanson Center, the Advocate, South High School SDC, or Peninsula High SDC. (Footnote 5)

By letter dated June 20, 1996, the District declined to offer STUDENT twelve weeks of intensive Lindamood-Bell training. Instead, the District offered STUDENT one hour of Lindamood-Bell training a week for a four-week period. The District continued to recommend that STUDENT attend an SDC at either South High or Peninsula High. (Footnote 6)

With a memorandum dated June 20, 1996, STUDENT's advocates submitted the curriculum for the Lindamood-Bell therapy that they sought. STUDENT's advocates also rejected the SDC placement at South High and informed Susan Wyllie that STUDENT's "parents and outside professional experts have throughout the eight year history informed your department that STUDENT is severely dyslexic and not mentally retarded." (Footnote 7)

STUDENT did not attend school for the first months of the 1996-97 school year. Pursuant to an agreement between the PARENTs and the School Attendance Review Board (SARB), STUDENT enrolled in a ninth grade regular education/RSP placement at Peninsula High School in October 1996. (Footnote 8)

STUDENT's IEP team has not met to discuss her current placement. In fact, STUDENT's most recent IEP, that of June 7, 1996, proposes placement options but does not indicate that the team members agreed upon placement.

The District has not offered STUDENT the quantity of Lindamood-Bell therapy that she requested and continues to identify her qualifying disability as a developmental delay. STUDENT still seeks a change in educational placement and services and, for this reason, requested a due process hearing.

SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY and DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE

SUMMARY OF EDUCATIONAL ASSESSMENTS

District psycho-educational evaluation of April 1989

In April 1989, Dr. Jack Schnel reassessed STUDENT's intelligence, achievement, psychological processing, and behavior to "evaluate her rate of growth." According to Dr. Schnel, STUDENT's score on the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC) declined, dropping her from the "borderline to the mildly mentally retarded range." STUDENT's performance on the Sequential, Simultaneous and Mental Processing Composite also placed her "within the mildly retarded range." (Footnote 9)

Dr. Schnel noted that during the 1988-89 school year STUDENT "made modest gains in arithmetic and reading," and learn "in a rote fashion at a limited rate." (Footnote 10) Dr. Schnel concluded that

STUDENT's ability levels in all areas is [sic.] within mildly mentally retarded range. This is true for intelligence, Academics, Psychological Processing, and Social, Emotional, and Adaptive Behavior. Language delay is not the cause of her delays, but reflective of her general level of skill. (Footnote 11)

Psycho-educational evaluation by Dr. Robert Colegrove of October 1989.

After the District conducted its second evaluation of STUDENT, the PARENTs sought a second opinion of her ability and achievement from private educational psychologist Dr. Robert Colegrove.

Dr. Colegrove administered various tests of ability and achievement including the Wechsler Intelligence Tests for Children-Revised (WISC-R), Vineland Scales of Adaptive Behavior, Woodcock Johnson, and Wide Range Achievement Test - Revised for Spelling and mathematics (WRAT-R). (Footnote 12)

According to Dr. Colegrove's report, STUDENT obtained a verbal IQ score of 67, performance IQ score of 73, and a full scale IQ score of 69. STUDENT's scores on the WISC-R fell within the "mildly retarded to borderline range of intellectual functioning." Dr. Colegrove's report states that STUDENT's academic achievement scores "were below grade level in all areas." Dr. Colegrove also noted that STUDENT's "achievement in school seems to be equal to her basic intellectual potential." (Footnote 13)

Notwithstanding STUDENT's low scores on tests of intellectual ability, Dr. Colegrove cautioned against a determination that STUDENT was mentally retarded because of the "discrepancy between STUDENT's WISC-R performance and the results of the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale administered to her parents." Dr. Colegrove pointed out that STUDENT's parents awarded her higher scores on the Vineland than other raters. STUDENT's scores were so high that Dr. Colegrove remarked: "if STUDENT's adaptive functioning outside of school is truly in the average range, she would not qualify for placement in a special day class for the mildly retarded." (Footnote 14)

Evaluation by the Diagnostic Center for Neurologically Handicapped Children of May 1991.

When STUDENT was nine years and one month old, the District referred her to the Diagnostic Center for assessment. Pursuant to this referral, STUDENT underwent one week of assessments that focused, among other things, on intellectual ability, academic achievement, and speech and language skills.

The Diagnostic Center used the WISC-R and the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development to measure STUDENT's intellectual ability. The report states:

The overall finding is that STUDENT clearly scores within the mildly mentally retarded range of intelligence on structured instruments and functions at that level on developmental measures of cognition. (Footnote 15)

The Diagnostic Center's report observed that STUDENT's academic achievement was well below that of her peers, but that "her scholastic profile was not atypical for children with cognitive functioning in the mild rage of retardation." In fact, the Diagnostic Center Assessor found that STUDENT "did not evidence learning patterns associated with a learning disabled child," but, rather, that "STUDENT's academic performance was commensurate with her cognitive abilities." (Footnote 16) The report states that STUDENT continues to require the support and structure of a Special Day Class with an emphasis on functional academics." (Footnote 17)

Switzer Center's assessment of March 3, 1992

After administering the Boder Test to STUDENT, educational therapist Rhonda Jalali determined that STUDENT suffered from "mixed dysphonetic and dyseidetic dyslexia." According to Ms. Jalali, "dysphonetic readers can't use phonics to decode or read a word," and "dyseidetic readers make errors in visual perception, reverse letters and can't use visualization to spell words, but are able to use phonics to decode words." (Footnote 18)

Ms. Jalali noted that she could not gauge "STUDENT's true capabilities" because she did not perform a "full diagnostic evaluation" or administer an intelligence test.

According to ms. Jalali's report, STUDENT's "poor auditory perception and memory skills (severe dyslexia)," bilingualism, and inappropriate education account for her delayed language development. Ms. Jalali's report recommended a multi-sensory approach to reading and spelling and remediation in phonics and mathematics. Ms. Jalali's report also recommended placement in "a classroom that encourages academics rather than daily living skills." (Footnote 19)

District's psycho-educational re-evaluation of March 1995

School psychologist Donna Gallagher administered tests of both intellectual ability and academic achievement. STUDENT's verbal I.Q. score of 56, performance I.Q. score of 59 and full scale I.Q. score of 53 on the WISC-III placed her below the first percentile for her age group. After administering academic achievement testing, Ms. Gallagher wrote that, "poor written language skills indicate inadequate development and integration of her thoughts as expressed in writing at school." (Footnote 20)

Ms. Gallagher recommended many teaching strategies for STUDENT, including maintenance of close physical proximity and eye contact during instruction, use of verbal cues, "repetition of experiences to develop overlearning," and multisensory approaches to learning. (Footnote 21)

Lindamood-Bell Learning Ability Evaluation of September 1995

Thirteen-year-old STUDENT underwent tests of learning aptitude and academic achievement at Lindamood-Bell. STUDENT scored below her mental age or grade level on each of the instruments administered, which included the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Revised (PPVT-R), Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude, Woodcock Reading Master Test, WRAT-R/3, and Gray Oral Reading Test.

From these results, the assessor "identified severe dysfunctions in auditory conceptualized and concept imagery . . . [and] a severe deficit in visual-spatial processing." (Footnote 22) STUDENT's score on the PPVT-R suggested that she had a "severe deficit" in "intellectual potential." (Footnote 23) To address some of these deficits, the assessor advised that STUDENT receive "an estimated initial treatment period of ten to twelve weeks of intensive cognitive therapy." (Footnote 24)

PETITIONER'S WITNESS

Rhonda Jalali

Rhonda Jalali has earned a bachelor's degree in child psychology, a master's degree in education, and a pupil personnel services credential. Nonpublic schools, including the Switzer Center, have employed Ms. Jalali as a special education teacher, educational therapist, coordinator and supervisor. Ms. Jalali currently owns and directs a preschool and kindergarten.

Ms. Jalali has provided educational therapy to STUDENT for the past five years, beginning when STUDENT was a client of the Switzer Center. Ms. Jalali has observed STUDENT at school and, since 1992, has attended several of STUDENT's IEP team meetings.

In 1992 or 1993, when Switzer Center employed Ms. Jalali, she administered assessment instruments including the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT), Boder Test of Reading-Spelling Patterns, and the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery. Ms. Jalali stated that neither she nor anyone else at the Switzer Center administered intelligence testing. However, Ms. Jalali testified that the evaluations of Dr. Colegrove and Diagnostic Center indicate that STUDENT's I.Q. scores have declined.

From her assessments, Ms. Jalali concluded that STUDENT suffered from dyseidetic and dysphonetic dyslexia and ADHD. In Ms. Jalali's view, STUDENT's very short attention span and ADHD, adversely affect her performance on assessments and render a diagnosis of "mild mental retardation" premature. Ms. Jalali commented that medication seemed to lengthen STUDENT's attention span and enable her to better her performance on testing instruments. Ms. Jalali also observed that STUDENT is able to learn if "given a multi-sensory approach and repetition."

Ms. Jalali testified that she shared her findings with STUDENT's IEP team at "three or four" meetings that occurred between approximately 1992 and 1994. On only one occasion did STUDENT's IEP team implement Ms. Jalali's recommendation, namely, enrolling STUDENT in an academic class rather than a daily living skills class. Ms. Jalali also recommended that STUDENT learn phonics, addition, and subtraction, left from right, cursive writing and how to overcome her visual perception problems. Ms. Jalali suggested that, to accomplish this, STUDENT's teachers use a multisensory approach that includes demonstrations of how to complete a task. Ms. Jalali also noted that STUDENT sometimes completed "crossword puzzles, mazes, and word searches" to develop her directional abilities.

Ms. Jalali recalled that she accompanied Ms. PARENT on a visit to the South High School's functional skills SDC in June 1996. Ms. Jalali testified that Constance Vendeland, special educational teacher and coordinator, described the SDC's functional skills curriculum, which emphasizes development of daily living rather than academic skills. For example, Ms. Jalali explained that the students enrolled in the functional skills curriculum learn how to read recipes and newspapers, wash clothes and cook.

Ms. Jalali said that she could only locate third and fourth grade reading books, although ms. Vendeland stated that the South High SDC featured "developmental approach" to teaching reading and "age-appropriate reading material." The SDC students whom Ms. Jalali observed appeared lower functioning, older, and more aggressive than STUDENT. According to Ms. Jalali, another teacher said that a Lindamood-Bell trained speech therapist served South High, but that ms. Vendeland warned that she could not assure Mrs. PARENT that a Lindamood-Bell trained therapist would have the opportunity to serve STUDENT.

Ms. Jalali stated that an SDC with a modified curriculum could be an appropriate placement for STUDENT if the curriculum emphasized acquisition of basic reading and mathematics skills. Ms. Jalali testified that the functional skills curriculum described by Ms. Vendeland is not appropriate for STUDENT because she has already mastered many of the skills taught in the class. Moreover, in Ms. Jalali's opinion, STUDENT wants to learn and is able to grasp academic concepts if they are appropriately modified. However, Ms. Jalali doubted that STUDENT would "come up to speed" unless she were provided with a modified core curriculum and "intensive therapy."

According to testing that Ms. Jalali administered in August of 1996, STUDENT reads at a third grade level. STUDENT's phonics skills are low, but she can understand written words when read to and then shown the written words. Ms. Jalali remarked that STUDENT also does poorly in timed testing situations. Furthermore, in Ms. Jalali's opinion, STUDENT's nervous tics and level of anxiety decreased for a while, but have recently returned.

Ms. Jalali advised that STUDENT receive an individualized academic program that emphasizes basic skills such as syllabification and vocabulary acquisition. Ms. Jalali has read about Lindamood-Bell and spoken with a Lindamood-Bell director and understands that it is a "language approach program that teaches basic skills." In Ms. Jalali's opinion, Lindamood-Bell "seemed like a pretty good program." However, Ms. Jalali acknowledged that she is not very familiar with, and has not visited a Lindamood-Bell Learning Center.

RESPONDENTS' WITNESSES

Donna Gallagher

School psychologist Donna Gallagher has known STUDENT since STUDENT was a second-grader. Ms. Gallagher has assessed STUDENT "two or three times" and attended most of her IEP team meetings.

Ms. Gallagher stated that STUDENT has been assessed seven times by a variety of "competent people," including the Diagnostic Center, Scott Kester of Loyola Marymount University, and District staff.

Ms. Gallagher stated that each of the seven psychological reports reached similar conclusions regarding STUDENT. Ms. Gallagher noted, however, that the Switzer Center's educational evaluation of 1985 reached a different conclusion.

From the psychological evaluations, Ms. Gallagher concluded that STUDENT is "developmentally delayed," i.e., has a borderline to below average I.Q. which enables STUDENT to learn to read, write, and compute, but only to a certain level. Once STUDENT reaches that level she makes no additional progress.

According to Ms. Gallagher, those who assessed STUDENT relied on rating scales, interviews with parents and teachers, home calls, and informal testing instruments. Evidence in the record suggested to Ms. Gallagher that STUDENT is developmentally delayed. Ms. Gallagher was aware, however, that the PARENTs, Ms. Jalali, and another tutor maintained that dyslexia, no developmental delays, accounted for STUDENT's poor performances on measures of intellectual ability and academic achievement. However, Ms. Gallagher testified that she specifically "ruled out" dyslexia when she assessed STUDENT.

Ms. Gallagher explained that a difference in testing instruments, to some extent, accounted for the sixteen-point discrepancy between STUDENT's full scale I.Q. score of 69 on the WISC-R administered in October 1989 and full scale I.Q. score of 53 on the WISC-III that Ms. Gallagher administered in April 1995. (Footnote 25) Ms. Gallagher also stated that notwithstanding the different numerical scores, both tests nettled similar percentile rankings. In Ms. Gallagher's view, STUDENT's intellectual ability and academic achievement are commensurate. Ms. Gallagher noted that STUDENT's short attention span probably had an adverse effect on her testing performance. Ms. Gallagher testified that adherence to the instructions that accompany the testing instrument controls evaluator subjectivity. In response to Petitioner's questions, Ms. Gallagher explained that the WISC-III is normed for all people but not specifically normed for dyslexics. Ms. Gallagher added that the WISC-III does not test a subject's reading ability.

STUDENT's scores on the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale indicate that her relative strengths are in the areas of daily living and social skills. Ms. Gallagher cautioned, however, that Dr. Colegrove considered STUDENT's scores on the 1989 administration of the Vineland "invalid" because primary "raters," Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, reported that STUDENT was able to perform tasks that the assessor found her unable to perform. When Ms. Gallagher administered the Vineland in 1995, the following people rated STUDENT: Mrs. PARENT, Ms. Gallagher, STUDENT's adapted physical education teacher, classroom teacher, and her speech and language therapist. The results suggested relative strengths in the areas of socialization and daily living skills.

Although the Vineland identified STUDENT's social skills as a relative strength, Ms. Gallagher recalled that STUDENT exhibited behavioral problems in the seventh and eighth grades. According to Ms. Gallagher, STUDENT inappropriately touched and hugged her peers, and frequently asked peers and adults questions to which she knew the answers. Ms. Gallagher also reported that STUDENT appeared overly dependent on her mother, because she called her from school on a daily basis. Because of these behaviors, the District provided STUDENT with social skills training. Moreover, when the PARENTs informed the District that STUDENT was unhappy at school, the District provided her with psychological counseling.

In Ms. Gallagher's opinion, the best educational setting for STUDENT would provide structure, an opportunity for interchange with a teacher, language instruction, and lessons that enable her to feel successful and competent. Specifically, the South High SDC would be an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT because it focuses on vocational, daily life, and social kills. Ms. Gallagher offered that the skills STUDENT would learn in this class might help STUDENT gain independence. Moreover, at South High STUDENT would have the opportunity to enroll in appropriate mainstream education classes and attend the school's sporting events.

In Ms. Gallagher's opinion, an RSP class would provide insufficient educational support for STUDENT. However, Ms. Gallagher stated that the IEP of June 6, 1996, indicates that in the eight- month period during which STUDENT was "included in the L Arts/Social Studies collaboration - General Education Class" her reading scores, as measured by the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement (KTEA), improved markedly. (Footnote 26)

Ms. Gallagher has read about the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process but has not observed its techniques. In Ms. Gallagher's opinion, placement at Lindamood-Bell would deprive STUDENT of the chance to learn social and daily living skills, and the opportunity to be mainstreamed. Although STUDENT would receive language training Lindamood-Bell, this alone would not provide an appropriate education for her.

Adria Weinstein

Palos Verdes Intermediate School has employed RSP teacher Adria Weinstein for approximately six and one half years. Ms. Weinstein holds a master's degree in educational psychology, and lifetime credentials in special education and RSP.

STUDENT was enrolled for eighth grade in Ms. Weinstein's RSP class during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Weinstein considered STUDENT amiable, eager to learn, and cooperative. To "maximize" STUDENT's learning, Ms. Weinstein modified her educational program. However, Ms. Weinstein testified that STUDENT could have made more academic progress had she been enrolled in a small setting such as an SDC. Ms. Weinstein recalled that STUDENT occasionally asked to join the smaller special education class rather than remain in the larger, faster-paced regular education class. According to Ms. Weinstein, STUDENT benefitted socially from her 1995-96 placement, but STUDENT found that it challenged her too much and supported her too little.

In Ms. Weinstein's view, STUDENT suffers from educational handicaps that slow her ability to grasp academic concepts and require repetition to address. Ms. Weinstein testified that STUDENT's current academic program should focus on helping her to acquire life skills.

Ms. Weinstein recalled that during the IEP team meeting of June 7, 1996, the members discussed STUDENT's upcoming high school placement. Ms. Weinstein recalled that the members of STUDENT's IEP team considered various placements within the District and SELPA and that many members considered the SDC at South High School an appropriate placement. Ms. Weinstein also remembered that in addition to discussion of placement at South High, the IEP team discussed placement at Peninsula High School or at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center.

Ms. Weinstein presented STUDENT's proposed goals and objectives at the IEP team meeting of June 7, 1996. The ninth-grade goals and objectives focused on improving STUDENT's academic, social/emotional, pre-vocational and vocational skills and were developed in response to STUDENT's class performance and test scores. Ms. Weinstein considered these goals and objectives appropriate for STUDENT and testified that they could be implemented in either the RSP class at Peninsula High or the SDC at South High.

Ms. Weinstein stated that although STUDENT would enter high school as a ninth-grade student, her academic achievement was at approximately the fourth- or fifth-grade level.

Ms. Weinstein visited South High approximately three months ago and has been in telephone contact with its staff. In Ms. Weinstein's opinion, South High would be a good placement for STUDENT because she would be with friends, learn life skills, and have educational opportunities.

Susan Abott

Susan Abott has been an RSP teacher since 1984 and has taught at Peninsula High School since 1990. Ms. Abott holds a master's degree in special education and an RSP certificate.

STUDENT entered the collaborative English Class (Footnote 27) taught by Ms. Abott and Ms. Grasinger in October 1996, pursuant to an agreement between the PARENTs and the SARB. Ms. Abbott understood that the PARENTs disagreed with STUDENT's placement in Ms. Abbott and Ms. Grasinger's class of twenty students.

The members of the collaborative English Class are expected to read novels, write essays, and learn vocabulary. According to ms. Abott, STUDENT "has a very difficult time" with each of these activities. For instance, Ms. Abott recently discovered that STUDENT had not even begun to read the assigned chapters from the novel Farewell to Manzinar. When asked why she had not begun her assignment, STUDENT replied that she did not know. Ms. Abott noted, however, that STUDENT was able to read passages from the novel aloud.

Ms. Abbott testified that STUDENT cannot write paragraphs or essays because she frequently fails to read assignments and cannot express her thoughts. Ms. Abbott recalled that on one occasion, STUDENT wrote three sentences in response to an essay question that required a five paragraph answer. In Ms. Abbotts's view, STUDENT could respond to that question only because she remembered a previous class discussion on the same topic.

Ms. Abott observed that STUDENT struggles socially too. Ms. Abbott described how STUDENT stared at a classmate so long that Ms. Abbott had to intervene. STUDENT has also praised Ms. Abbott's clothing or inquired about vacation days at inappropriate times, such as during a lecture. According to Ms. Abbott, STUDENT's behavior has led other students to avoid her. As a result,

STUDENT has "no social relationships" in Ms. Abbott's class.

According to Ms. Abbott, STUDENT is not appropriately placed in the Peninsula High collaborative English class. Ms. Abbott and other special education teachers agree that she cannot meet the academic demands of the class. Ms. Abbott stated that she does not modify the curriculum for STUDENT, but added that even a modified curriculum would be inappropriate for her. In Ms. Abbott's opinion, an appropriate placement would provide STUDENT with more one-on-one attention, instruction "at her level," and enable her to develop social relationships.

Ms. Abbott stated that she is not familiar with the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center.

Constance Vendeland

South High School Has employed Constance Vendeland as a special education teacher and chair of the special education department since 1981. Ms. Vendeland holds both special and regular educational credentials.

According to Ms. Vendeland, South High School offers an SDC with a "functional approach to basics" that includes academic, social, and vocational components. Forty-one students in grades nine through twelve are currently enrolled in the functional skills program, which consists of three classes that are each taught by one treacher with the help of instructional aides. Enrolled students' disabling conditions include developmental delays, autism, traumatic brain injuries, language disorders, and specific learning disabilities.

Ms. Vendeland stated that each of the teachers of the functional skills SDC uses multiple modalities: the lesson is given orally, in writing and demonstration. Ms. Vendeland testified that the students develop their writing skills by writing in journals, composing letters, and by doing grammar exercises. Members of the class also read aloud and silently on a daily basis. When able to participate, members of the class may enroll in nonacademic regular education elective classes.

Although Ms. Vendeland has not met STUDENT, she reviewed STUDENT's IEP of June 17, 1996. Ms. Vendeland testified that STUDENT's consumer mathematics, socialization, and reading comprehension goals are similar to the goals stated in the IEPs of other students in the functional skills SDC. Ms. Vendeland further testified that she could implement STUDENT's current IEP in the functional skills SDC. According to Ms. Vendeland, if STUDENT entered the functional skills SDC, her academic skills would place her near the middle of the class.

DISCUSSION

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1989-90m 1990-91, 1991-92, and 1992-93 school years? (Footnote 28)

Petitioner contends that the District denied her a FAPE because it rejected "parents' request for the District to consider outside professional assessments, and placed [STUDENT], contrary to state and federal laws into a curriculum that was for MMR rather than dyslexic students." However, the undisputed testimony of Ms. Jalali establishes that STUDENT's IEP team not only considered Ms. Jalali's independent educational assessment, but also implemented her recommendation. The record also reflects that from 1992 through 1996, Ms. Jalali participated in the development of STUDENT's IEPs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with Education Code section 56329(b) which requires a district to consider the results of an independent educational assessment.

Moreover, relevant special education law provides a different method for determining whether a District has offered a student a FAPE. Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(18), "free appropriate public education" mans special education and related services that conform with the student's IEP. "Special education" is defined as "specifically designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child . . . ." (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16).)

In Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982) the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) (20 U.S.C. §1400 et. seq.) The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potentiances from grade to grade. (Rowley, supra, at pp. 203-204.)

Therefore, to determine whether the District has provided a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will consider the following questions: (1) do the special education and related services comply with those stated in STUDENT's IEP, (2) do the special education and related services designed to meet STUDENT's unique educational needs, and (3) did STUDENT derive educational benefit from the placement? Furthermore, as a general rule, the party seeking to change the status quo bears the burden of proof in an administrative hearing. (Burger v. Murray County School District, 612 F. supp. 434 (N.D. Ga. 1984.) In this case, Petitioner is the moving party and is seeking to change STUDENT's placement from public school to non-public placement. Therefore, Petitioner bears the burden of proof.

Moreover, with these standards in mind, the Hearing Officer examines whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the school years at issue. First, Petitioner has not established by competent evidence that the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services listed on her IEP for the 1980-90, 1990-91, 1991-92, and 1992-93 school years. (Footnote 29) Each of these IEPs placed her in an SDC and offered her related services including extended school year, adapted physical education, and speech and language services. The IEPs also indicate that STUDENT was entitled to academic instruction in such areas as reading, spelling, mathematics, and social skills. Because no credible evidence establishes that the District denied STUDENT the services identified in her IEPs, the Hearing Officer cannot find that the District has not satisifed the first requirement of an appropriate placement.

Turning now to the question of whether the District's placements have been designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual educational needs, the weight of the evidence has persuaded the Hearing Officer that STUDENT's primary disabling condition is a developmental delay rather than dyslexia. Even assessments provided by Petitioner, such as those from Dr. Colegrove and Lindamood- Bell, indicate severe deficits in STUDENT's intellectual functioning or potential. Morever, the only assessment finding that dyslexia disabled STUDENT lacked an analysis of her intellectual functioning and could not, therefore, estimate her intellectual ability. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer will examine whether the District's placements were designed to meet the unique needs of STUDENT, as a developmentally delayed student.

Some of the assessments generated during the periods at issue also provide clues as to the nature of STUDENT's educational needs. In 1989, Dr. Colegrove wrote that STUDENT's educational needs. Dr. Colegrove wrote that STUDENT required a "week-long, inpatient evaluation" to discover STUDENT's level of intellectual functioning, assess her short attention span," and examine the interactions among the PARENT family. (Footnote 30) The record reflects that STUDENT received the evaluation that Dr. Colegrove recommended. (Footnote 31)

Other information about STUDENT's educational needs comes from the May 1991 report from the Diagnostic Center. In this report, the Diagnostic Center listed STUDENT's "critical needs" which included "accommodation to intellectual developmental level," "family and individual counseling," "structured and supportive Special Day Class with functional curriculum," and "social skills training." (Footnote 32) STUDENT's IEP for the 1991-92 school year reveals that it addressed each of the critical needs identified in the Diagnostic Center's report. For these school years, Petitioner has failed to establish by competent evidence that the placements the District provided were not designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual educational needs.

2. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education during the 1993-94 school year?

As stated above, to satisfy the first element of an appropriate placement, a district must provide the services stated in the student's IEP. STUDENT's IEP from the 1993-94 school year placed her in an SDC for up to 83% of her school day and provided adapted physical education, speech and language services, and extended school year. Both Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Jalali attended the IEP and consented to its implementation. (Footnote 33) Petitioner did not establish by competent evidence that the District denied STUDENT the services listed in her IEP of 1993-94. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District meets the first element of an appropriate placement.

The District's placement also satisfies the second element of an appropriate placement because the evidence establishes that it was designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Ms. Jalali's report of march 1992, states that STUDENT required remediation in many areas, including phonics, spelling syllabification, addition and subtraction. (Footnote 34) Ms. Jalali testified that she also appeared at STUDENT's IEP meetings to share her results and recommendations. Perhaps in response to Ms. Jalali's input, STUDENT's IEP from the 1993-94 school year contains instructional goals in each of the areas listed above. As Petitioner's evidence did not establish that the District's placement failed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs during the 1993-94 school year, the placement satisfies the second element of an appropriate placement.

During the 1993-94 school year, STUDENT earned passing grades in all of her classes. In fact, 21 of STUDENT's 24 semester grades were either "A's" or "B's" and her lowest grad was a "C." (Footnote 35) Moreover, STUDENT's report card and IEP reflect that she progressed to the seventh grade. Although the Hearing Officer would prefer additional evidence to gauge educational benefit, none was presented. The only evidence available is of progress, not lack of progress. Therefore, as a preponderance of the evidence establishes that STUDENT's 1993-94 program provided her with educational benefit. The placement also satisfies the third element of the Rowley test. Because STUDENT's 1993-94 placement met the standards that Rowley set forth, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received a FAPE during the 1993-94 school year.

3. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1994-95 school year?

With the standards set forth in federal law and Rowley in mind, the Hearing Officer now examines whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 1994-95 school year.

Both Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Jalali approved of STUDENT's seventh-grade IEP from the 1994-95 school year, which placed her in an SDC for up to 83% of her school day and provided adapted physical education, speech and language, and extended school year services. ( footnote 36) Petitioner did not establish by credible evidence that the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services listed on her 1994-95 IEP. Therefore, the IEP for created for the 1994-95 school year satisfies the first element of an appropriate placement.

The District's 1994-95 placement also satisfies the second element of an appropriate placement because the evidence establishes that it was designed to meet STUDENT's unique and individual needs. Charting STUDENT's progress from the 1993-94 school year, the IEP team first noted that she achieved her decoding and phonics goals. The IEP also indicates that STUDENT substantially achieved her reading and mathematics goals not yet achieved. (Footnote 37) As Petitioner presented no credible evidence that established that STUDENT required a different program during the 1994-95 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's IEP team designed a program that met her unique educational needs.

During the 1994-95 school year, STUDENT earned passing grades in all of her classes. Once again, most of STUDENT's grades fell within the "A" or "B" range and her lowest grade was a "C." (Footnote 38) Moreover, STUDENT's report card and IEP reflect that she progressed tot he eighth grade. Petitioner did not establish by credible evidence that STUDENT's 1994-95 program deprived her of educational benefit, therefore, the placement also satisfies the third element of the Rowley test. Because STUDENT's 1994-95 placement met the standards that federal law and Rowley set forth, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT received a FAPE during the 1994-95 school year.

4. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year?

In May of 1995, both Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Jalali approved of STUDENT's seventh-grade IEP for the 1995-96 school year, which placed her in an SDC for up to 83% of her school day and provided adapted physical education, speech and language, and extended school year services. (Footnote 39) In September 1995, however, the PARENTs requested that STUDENT receive her education in a regular education program with RSP support.

In October 1995, STUDENT's IEP team met to discuss instructional goals and objectives. The District agreed to place STUDENT in a regular education program with RSP support. Mrs. PARENT and her then- advocate R. A. Drew consented to the continuation of some of the goals and objectives developed in September 1995, and the omission of others. Petitioner did not establish by credible evidence that the District failed to provide STUDENT with the services listed on her 1995-96 IEP. Therefore, the placement for the 1995-96 school year satisfies the first element of a FAPE.

However, STUDENT's 1995-96 placement fails to satisfy the second requirement of a FAPE because it did not meet her unique and individual needs. The document originally developed as STUDENT's 1995- 96 IEP justifies her proposed placement in an SDC by stating that she requires "the structure/support of small group instruction . . . to progress in the core curriculum." (Footnote 40) While the IEP of September 1995 also acknowledges that she "needs small group instruction" at least half of the day, it relies on the wishes of the PARENTs to justify STUDENT's placement in the regular education program for 83% of the 1995-96 school year.

The Hearing Officer infers that the District consented to the testimony establish that STUDENT did not deprive educational benefit from her 1995-96 placement. The IEP of September 1995 reveals that District members of STUDENT's IEP team doubted that a regular education program with RSP support would meet her educational needs. This IEP recites STUDENT's successes in prior SDC placements and states the team's misgivings about placing her in an RSP class. In fact, the IEP states "the team feels that STUDENT's SDC placement is appropriate and the least restrictive environment." Nevertheless, in apparent acquiescence to the wishes of the PARENTs and their advocate, the IEP team consented to the 83.3% regular education and the 16.6% RSP program that the PARENTs requested. (Footnote 41)

Less than a month after STUDENT enrolled in the general education program with RSP support, Ms. Weinstein informed the District that the placement was no appropriate. On October 5, 1995, Ms. Weinstein wrote, "it is apparent that even with the additional modifications listed above, STUDENT's skill level inhibits her ability to benefit from the RSP/ General Education program she is now enrolled in." (Footnote 42) Ms. Weinstein's records of STUDENT's comments from May and June 1996, also indicate that STUDENT did not belong in regular education classes. Documentary evidence establishes that STUDENT repeatedly asked for instruction in the RSP rather than the regular education class and twice remarked, "I don't like having to do what everyone else does in my regular classes." (Footnote 43) Furthermore, at the hearing, Ms. Weinstein credibly testified that STUDENT did not obtain educational benefit as the year progressed.

Additionally, Ms. Wyllie echoed Ms. Weinstein's opinion in a letter to the PARENTs that, among other things, urged them to return STUDENT to an SDC where she could receive "intensive remediation in reading and writing skills." (Footnote 44)

Although STUDENT progressed to the ninth grade, earning passing markings during the 1995-96 school year, her marks were considerably lower than in previous years. STUDENT earned only one "A" each semester, with the majority of her marks expressed as "credit." (Footnote 45) While marks and grade level advancement are factors to consider, in this case, the observations of STUDENT's teachers and IEP team members are more reliable indicators of whether she derived educational benefit from her placement. For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE during the 1995-96 school year.

5. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year?

STUDENT's proposed IEP for the 1996-97 school year placed in an SDC for 85% of her school day and provided extended school year. Mrs. PARENT and her current advocates George Mason and Francine McDermott-Mason, attended the IEP team meeting of June 7, 1996, and signed the IEP document. (Footnote 46) However, Ms. Abbott testified that, pursuant to an agreement between the SARB and the PARENTs, STUDENT enrolled in a regular education program with RSP support rather than the SDC indicated on her IEP. (Footnote 47) Because STUDENT did not receive the services listed on her 1996-97 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not appropriately placed during the 1996-97 school year.

STUDENT's 1996-97 placement also deprived her of educational benefit. Ms. Abbott, STUDENT's collaborative RSP English teacher, credibly testified that STUDENT's current placement is inappropriate because she cannot complete class assignments or respond to test questions. Undated written reports from STUDENT's other ninth-grade teachers support Ms. Abbott's testimony. For instance, STUDENT's art teacher remarked that STUDENT did not receive "a grade because she is not able to do the work independently." Similarly, STUDENT's mathematics teacher commented that STUDENT has earned an incomplete grade because she "never" completes homework assignments, and "only works if someone sits with her . . . . She will not do any problems on her own." (Footnote 48) Based on the foregoing evidence, th4e Hearing Officer finds that the District's program did not offer STUDENT educational benefit. Therefore, STUDENT has not received a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year.

6. Must the District provide STUDENT with prospective placement in an intensive treatment program at the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process Center?

Federal special education law permits a hearing officer to award "appropriate" relief when a district fails to offer FAPE. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(e)(2).) Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985). Here Petitioner requests placement at the Lindamood- Bell Learning Process Center "to remediate [her] severe dyslexia." Petitioner did not call a Lindamood-Bell representative to testify. Instead, Petitioner submitted two documents from Lindamood-Bell: a "Learning Ability Evaluation" dated September 23, 1995, and a proposed lesson plan dated June 19, 1996. The evaluation describes STUDENT's performance on standardized tests of ability and achievement and the lesson plan outlines STUDENT's proposed remedial program. Interestingly, neither document describes STUDENT as "dyslexic." (Footnote 49)

In fact, STUDENT's most recent performance on a standardized test of achievement in reading suggests that reading is a relative strength for STUDENT, rather than a weakness. In 1995, STUDENT earned a full scale I.Q. score of 53 on the WIC-III and a reading score of 69 on the KTEA. The 13 point difference in these scores weakens Petitioner's contention that STUDENT's ability to read exceeds her achievement in reading.

Moreover, Ms. Jalali admitted to only a passing familiarity with the Lindamood-Bell program and did not specifically recommend it for STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner's limited evidence regarding the Lindamood-Bell program did not establish that it is specifically designed to meet STUDENT's current educational needs or is necessary to allow STUDENT to benefit from her education.

Furthermore, in the letter of June 19, 1996, Lindamood-Bell proposed to provide STUDENT with "four 55 minute sessions wherein STUDENT works with one clinician (a different one each hour using a Socratic methodology." (Footnote 50) However, the testimony of Ms. Abbott and documents from STUDENT's own psychotherapist and art teacher reveal that STUDENT has been socially isolated and requires an educational program that will assist her in the development of both social and academic skills. (Footnote 51) Petitioner did not establish that the program will address her undisputed need for social skills training.

For the above stated reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lindamood-Bell program, is not appropriate and therefore denies Petitioner's request for prospective placement.

Therefore, the parties will convene an IEP team meeting on or before June 6, 1997, to determine an appropriate for the 1997-98 school year.

7. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for "all previous, current and future educational/therapeutic costs?" (Footnote 52)

As noted above, federal special education allows a hearing officer to award "appropriate" relief, when a student is not offered a FAPE. Sometimes appropriate relief includes reimbursement. In Burlington, supra, the United States Supreme court determined that when the public school placement is inappropriate, parents of a student eligible for special education may be entitled to reimbursement for expenses that they incur in educating their child if it is ultimately determined that the services the parents provided were appropriate.

In this case, Petitioner seeks reimbursement for all previous current and future educational/therapeutic costs. As noted above, the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1989-90, 1990-91, 1991-92, 1992-93, 1993-94 and 1994-95 school years; therefore, her request for reimbursement for the educational therapy that Ms. Jalali provided is denied. Petitioner µs request for future educational costs does not indicate what expenses are to be covered or why they are educationally necessary. Accordingly, this request is also denied.

However, Petitioner did not receive a FAPE in either the 1995-96 school year, (including extended school year) or 1996-97 school year (including extended school year). Therefore, the inquiry now centers on the appropriateness of the services for which Petitioner now seeks reimbursement.

Both Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 114 S. Ct. 361 (1993) and Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F. 2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986) relieve parents of the responsibility of providing private educational services that strictly conform to the requirements of the IDEA. The court in Alamo Heights authorized reimbursement to a parent even though the unilateral placement was not the "exact proper placement" required by the IDEA. (Alamo Heights, supra, at p. 1161.) (Footnote 53) But neither of these cases entitles a parent to reimbursement if the parent fails to establish that the services purchased conferred some educational benefit on the student.

In this case, Ms. Jalali credibly testified that she provided STUDENT with educational therapy for five years. Ms. Jalali further testified that STUDENT completed "crossword puzzles, mazes and word searches" during therapy. Aside from those examples, the record does not indicate in which academic area(s) STUDENT received educational therapy, of what the educational therapy consisted, or how long the sessions lasted. Without evidence that Ms. Jalali's educational therapy conferred some educational benefit upon STUDENT, the Hearing Officer cannot grant Petitioner's request for reimbursement.

ORDER

1. All requests for relief are denied.

2. On or before June 6, 1997, Respondents shall convene an IEP team meeting fro STUDENT to determine an appropriate placement for the 1997-98 school year.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finds are made in accordance with this requirement:

Issue No. 1:

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

Issue No 2:

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

Issue No 3:

Respondent prevailed on this issue

Issue No 4:

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No 5:

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No 6:

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

Issue No 7:

Respondent prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 5605(i).

Dated: May 30, 1997 _____________________________ Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes 1. After Petitioner presented her opening statement on January 7, 1997, this matter was continued because Petitioner did not timely evidence to Respondent. No testimony was taken on February 24, 1997. 2. Respondent's Exhibit (Resp. Ex.) 1 at p. 1. 3. Petitioner's Exhibit (Pet. Ex.) 16 at p. 5. 4. Pet. Ex. 15, at p. 1. 5. Pet. Ex. F, at p. 8. 6. Pet. Ex. H, at p. 1. 7. Pet. Ex. G. 8. Pet. Ex. 2. 9. Pet. Ex. 37, at p. 4. 10. Pet. Ex. 37, at p. 4. 11. Pet. Ex. 37, at p. 5. 12. Pet. Ex. 36, at p, 4, 13. Pet. Ex. 36, at pp. 2 and 5. 14. Pet. Ex. 36, at p. 2. 15. Pet. Ex. 35, at p. 4. 16. Pet. Ex. 35, at p. 7. 17. Pet. Ex. 35, at p. 8. 18. Pet. Ex. D, at pp.1-2 19. Pet. Ex. D, at p. 3. 20. Resp. Ex. 26. 21. Resp. Ex. 26, at p. 6. 22. Pet. Ex. E, at p. 5. 23. Pet. Ex. E, at p. 2. 24. Pet. Ex. E, at p. 6. 25. Resp. Ex. 26, at p. 2. 26. Resp. Ex. 17, at p. 6. 27. Ms. Abbott testified that the collaborative English classes combine both regular education and RSP students. In collaborative English classes, the English teacher teaches the material and the RSP teacher assists and modifies the curriculum for the RSP students. 28. Although Petitioner alleged that the District has deprived STUDENT of a FAPE for the past eight years, Petitioner offered no testimony and limited documentary evidence in support of this allegation. With the exception of STUDENT's IEP's the Hearing Officer has little else with which to analyze the 1989-90, 1990-91, 1991-92, and 1992-93 school years. For this reason, the examination of these school years is combined in one discussion section. The Hearing Officer notes that claims for relief for denials of a FAPE during the 1989-90, 1990-91, 1991 -92 and 1992-93 school years are probably barred by the statute of limitations. (Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, 817 F. 2d 551 (9th Cir. 1987.).) However, because Respondent did not raise this argument, he Hearing Officer will examine these school years. 29. Pet. Ex. 26-21. 30. Pet. Ex. 36 31. Pet. Ex. 35, report from the Diagnostic Center. 32. Pet. Ex 35, at p. 8. 33. Pet. Ex. 19. 34. Pet. Ex. D. 35. Resp. Ex. 30. 36. Pet. Ex. 18. 37. Resp. Ex. 30. 38. Resp. Ex. 30. 39. Resp. Ex. 3. 40. Resp. Ex. 2, at p. 8. 41. Resp. Ex. 3. 42. Resp. Ex. 8. 43. Resp. Ex. 13, at p. 1. 44. Resp. Ex. 10, at p.1. 45. Resp. Ex. 30, at pp. 1-2. 46. Pet. Ex. F. 47. Pet. Ex. 2. 48. Resp. Ex. 31, at pp. 1-2. 49. Although admissible in special education due process hearings, 5 C.C.R. section 3082(b) states: Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in civil actions. 50. Pet. Ex. G, at p. 2. 51. Pet. Ex. 1, at p. 2; Resp ex. 31, at p. 2. 52. Petitioner did not define the term "educational/ therapeutic costs." Therefore, the Hearing Officer infers that Petitioner limits consideration for "educational/therapeutic costs" tot he educational therapy that Ms. Jalali provided. 53. The Anna Heights court suggested consideration of the following factors when determining whether to award full or partial reimbursement: "existence of other, perhaps more suitable, substitute placements, the effort expended by (the parent) in securing alternative placements, and the general cooperative or uncooperative position of the School District itself." (Alamo Heights, supra, at p. 1161.)