California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 11, 1999
Student v. Laguna Beach Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 952-98 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Laguna Beach Unified must reimburse $61,801.12 in private school tuition and mileage after denying FAPE for four school years.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student filed this case. He is a 12-year-old seventh grader eligible for special education with a specific learning disability tied to an auditory processing deficit. His parents removed him from El Morro Elementary early in fourth grade (1995) and placed him at Prentice Day School, a nonpublic school. They sought tuition and costs for 1995-96 through 1998-99.
For 1995-96, the Hearing Officer found that Laguna Beach Unified had not fully assessed the student, including his growing school-related emotional distress. His reading had dropped to the 4th percentile. Even so, he received less than an hour a day of isolated resource help and weekly speech, with no written modifications for the general education class where he spent 81% of his day. This gave only minimal benefit and denied FAPE.
For 1996-97 and 1997-98, the District knew the family still lived in the district but never contacted them or made an offer. The Hearing Officer held this violated the District's duty to find and serve students. For 1998-99, the November 1998 IEP team left out the student's current teacher. The team had no current information about him and drafted goals in advance. District witnesses also disagreed about what the offer was, so it failed the clear-offer rule of Union School District v. Smith.
The Hearing Officer found Prentice's multi-sensory Slingerland program appropriate. The District was ordered to pay $38,761.12 for tuition and $23,040 for mileage. Uniform costs were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district's search-and-serve duty toward a student it knew still lived in the district after a private placement. It also applied W.G. v. Target Range to an IEP meeting held without the private school teacher. It rejected an offer that the district's own staff described in conflicting ways.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 1995-96 school year?
The District did not fully assess the student's auditory processing deficit or school-related emotional needs. Under five hours a week of isolated RSP, weekly speech, and no written general education modifications did not meet his needs and gave only minimal benefit, which denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1996-97 school year?
The District knew the student was a special education student who still lived in the district, yet it made no contact, held no IEP meeting, and made no offer. This violated its search-and-serve duty and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
IDEA 1997 required the District to locate children with disabilities, including those in private schools. Its failure to contact the family or offer services denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4a. Did the District commit procedural violations at the IEP meeting of November 23, 1998?
Under W.G. v. Target Range, the District denied FAPE by leaving the student's nonpublic school teacher out of the meeting, having no one present with current knowledge of him, inviting participants with no role, and drafting goals without present-levels information.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4b. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
District witnesses each described the offer differently, and it listed no specific modifications. It did not meet Union v. Smith's clear written offer requirement, which prejudiced the parents and denied FAPE.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and related costs associated with the unilateral placement of STUDENT at Prentice Day School from 1995-96 through the 1998-99 school years?
Prentice's integrated multi-sensory (Slingerland) program and small classes gave educational benefit. Lack of a credentialed special education teacher, LRE, and delay arguments failed, so tuition and mileage were awarded. Uniform costs were denied.
- Dismissed / withdrawnIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue Withdrawn. Reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Lucianne Carlton in 1995
Petitioner withdrew this issue on the third day of hearing, so the Hearing Officer did not address it.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse parents $38,761.12 for Prentice School tuition and costs for 1995-96, 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99, within thirty days of the decision.
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse parents $23,040.00 for transportation (two 50-mile round trips per day, 180 days per year, at $.32 per mile, or $5,760 per year for four years), within thirty days of the decision.
Total: $61,801.12 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School Dist.; M.C. v. Central Regional School Dist.; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit
People named in the decision
- Dr. Robert Patterson, psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Robert White, SELPA director; District representative and witness, South Orange County SELPA
- Dr. Carol Hayes, coordinator/director of special education, Laguna Beach Unified School District (former)
- Wendy Doty, assistant superintendent, Laguna Beach Unified School District
- Leslie Respess, nonpublic school teacher, Prentice School
- Debra Jarvis, executive director, nonpublic school, Prentice School
- Dr. Kay Ostensen, middle school counselor, Thurston Middle School, Laguna Beach Unified
- Lila Samia, school psychologist, Laguna Beach Unified School District
- Karen Hogrebe, special education (RSP) teacher and academic assessor, Laguna Beach Unified School District
- Ms. Vick, fourth grade general education teacher (stipulated testimony), El Morro Elementary School
- Dr. Purrington, principal, El Morro Elementary School
- Lucianne Carlton, independent assessor (1995)
- Prentice Day School, nonpublic school (unilateral placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 952-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: STUDENT
Issue: Assessment Designated Instructionand Services Individual Education Program Non Public School Placement Reimbursementand Funding CDS Code: 30-66555 District: Laguna Beach Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability
Case Details This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Laguna Beach, California, on December 3 and 4, 1998, January 21 and 22, February 2 and 3, February 19, February 25 and 26, and March 11, 1999.
STUDENT (herein after STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Leejanice Toback, of the Law Offices of Joan Honeycutt. Also present were Petitioner's parents, MR. and MRS. PARENT.
Laguna Beach Unified School District (hereinafter Laguna or District) was represented by Robert White, director of the South Orange County Special Education Local Planning Area (SELPA). Also present on Laguna Beach's behalf for the initial two days of hearing was Dr. Carol Hayes, coordinator of special education. (Dr. Hayes was no longer an employee of the District when the Hearing resumed on January 21, 1999.) Wendy Doty, assistant superintendent for Laguna Beach, was present periodically on the first two days of hearing.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Robert Patterson, psychologist; Robert White, SELPA director; MOTHER, mother of STUDENT; FATHER, father of STUDENT; Dr. Carol Hayes, Laguna Beach's director of special education; Leslie Respess, teacher, Prentice School; and Debra Jarvis, executive director of Prentice School.
Laguna Beach called the following witnesses to testify: Dr. Carol Hayes, coordinator of special education; Dr. Kay Ostensen, middle school counselor; Lila Samia, school psychologist; Karen Hogrebe, special education teacher; and Robert White, director of the South Orange County SELPA. Ms. Vick, STUDENT's fourth grade teacher when he left the District, did not testify in person. Instead, the parties stipulated to what the content of her rebuttal testimony would have been had she actually testified.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received, the record was closed, and the issues were submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On January 21, 1999, the third day of the hearing, the Petitioner withdrew the issue of reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Lucianne Carlton in 1995. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not address that issue. On March 11, 1999, the eighth day of hearing, the parties stipulated that had Ms. Vick, STUDENT's fourth grade teacher at El Morro Elementary School, testified, she would have stated that Mrs. PARENT never told her that STUDENT was experiencing insomnia, nightmares, sleepwalking and physical manifestations of stress.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner contends that the District did not identify all of the areas in which he exhibited disabilities, nor did it properly assess him in each of those areas. He also contends that the District committed procedural violations when conducting his IEPs. Petitioner claims that, as a consequence, he did not receive an appropriate education for the school years of 1995-96 through 1998-99, inclusive. Petitioner maintains that these actions by the District necessitated his enrollment in a nonpublic school, for which he seeks reimbursement.
The District contends that it properly identified and assessed STUDENT's suspected disabilities as they arose. It claims that STUDENT initially presented with an articulation problem. As a result of his speech disorder, he was found eligible for special education and the District provided speech and language services. When he appeared to fall behind his classmates in the first grade, he was referred for further evaluation and he received a complete assessment. The District asserts that it promptly responded by providing resource specialist services when the results of these assessments revealed a specific learning disability. It further maintains that STUDENT made educational gains while he attended a District school and that the District is not obligated to retroactively, or prospectively, fund his unilateral placement at a nonpublic school.
ISSUES
1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free, appropriate public education ( FAPE) for the 1995 -96 school year?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1996-97 school year?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year?
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
5. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and related costs associated with the unilateral placement of STUDENT at Prentice Day School from 1995-96 through the 1998-99 school years?
BACKGROUND FACTS
(Footnote 1)STUDENT is twelve years old and currently in the seventh grade. He is eligible for special education as a result of a specific learning disability. STUDENT began attending the Laguna Beach Unified School District at El Morro Elementary School when he entered kindergarten in 1991. Early in kindergarten, STUDENT was provided a routine speech screening which revealed difficulties with articulation and possible language concerns. This screening resulted in a referral for a speech and language assessment. STUDENT was evaluated on October 4, 1991, using the Photo Articulation Test (PAT), the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT) and the Test of Language Development (TOLD). These tests demonstrated receptive and expressive language skills within the normal range except on two tests. The TOLD Sentence Imitation Sub Test evaluated STUDENT's ability to repeat sentences verbatim without grammatical revisions. The results showed a weakness in this area. An articulation delay was evidenced through the PAT and was confirmed by assessor observation. A meeting was convened on October 31, 1991, to discuss the results of the assessments. As a result of his articulation problem, STUDENT was found eligible for special education and in need of speech and language services. An IEP was developed and implemented providing STUDENT with speech therapy one to two times per week for 30-minute sessions. The sole IEP goal was to improve articulation skills.
STUDENT began first grade and continued to receive speech and language services. His annual IEP was held in a timely fashion on October 1, 1992, with his eligibility remaining as a speech and language articulation disorder. Through this IEP, speech services were reduced to one session per month for a maximum of 30 minutes. The prior IEP goal to improve articulation skills continued. On January 28, 1993, when STUDENT was in the middle of first grade, STUDENT's teacher referred him for a special education assessment because his classroom performance was significantly below expectations for grade level and he demonstrated possible language deficiency. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT consented to an assessment and the District conducted multiple evaluations. On the Woodcock- Johnson-R, STUDENT's reading scores were as follows: age equivalence 5.7 years, grade equivalence K.4, standard score 71, and percentage score - 3rd percentile. His math scores were: age equivalence 7.0, grade equivalence 1.5, standard score 102 and percentage score - 56th percentile. Written language scores were: age equivalence 5.9 grade equivalence K.6, standard score 79, and percentage score - 8th percentile. Hearing and vision screenings were normal. Testing of STUDENT's cognitive abilities showed a verbal IQ of 118, a performance IQ of 95 and a full scale IQ of 107. These scores placed him in the 68th percentile for cognitive ability. The Visual Motor Integration (VMI) test revealed age appropriate sensory motor skills. He scored within the average range on the Motor-Free Visual Perception Test. The Behavior Rating Profile measuring social- emotional adjustment was satisfactory with both peer and home relationships. The Woodcock-Johnson, Part 2 was also used to evaluate academic achievement. STUDENT's broad math skills were slightly above age and grade level. The broad reading scores were an area of concern. Letter word recognition scores were at the beginning kindergarten level and in the 2nd percentile. Reading comprehension scores were at the 10th percentile and equivalent to the skills attained by a child at the end of kindergarten. Written language scores revealed that STUDENT could not write all of the letters of the alphabet. As a consequence of the above evaluations, an assessment report was issued concluding that STUDENT exhibited a specific learning disability.
On March 18, 1993, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss the results of the assessments. STUDENT's eligibility condition was changed to a specific learning disability due to a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement with "visual" (Footnote 2)processing deficits. Speech therapy for articulation was continued one time per month pursuant to the prior IEP of October 1, l993. Added to the IEP were resource specialist services (RSP) five days per week for sixty minutes per day. The annual goal was to increase age and grade equivalencies in reading and written language. The resource teacher was to be responsible for this goal.
At the request of STUDENT's parents, an IEP addendum was signed on November 5, 1993, dismissing STUDENT from speech and language services. At this time, the level of service was one thirty- minute period of speech therapy per month for articulation. STUDENT continued to distort the "l" phoneme and substituted "w" for "r" in conversational speech. The operative IEP did not contain a speech and language goal. The District recommended continuation in the speech program.
In preparation for STUDENT's annual IEP during the second grade, the Distict again administered the Woodcock-Johnson-R on March 1, 1994. On the reading portion of the test, STUDENT's age and grade equivalencies were 7.1 and 1.5 respectively. His written language scores showed 7.5 age and 1.8 grade equivalencies. A comparison of this test with the same Woodcock- Johnson-R given a year prior established reading growth in age equivalencies of 1.6 years and grade equivalencies of 1.1 years. Written language growth was 1.8 in age equivalencies and 1.2 in grade equivalencies. The resource teacher wrote that STUDENT had successfully completed 75% of his annual goals and objectives. Although some progress was reported in his RSP class, STUDENT's regular education teacher, in whose class he spent 83% of his school day, described several areas of concern in her annual review. She wrote that STUDENT did not follow group instruction in reading, spelling or language. He did not work independently, nor could he be grouped in the classroom in reading, spelling or language. Areas of concern were reading, creative writing and problem solving.
The IEP meeting held on March 14, 1994, addressed the above evaluations and STUDENT's progress. STUDENT's present levels in reading continued to be below age and grade levels. He knew his beginning and ending sounds but continued to forget the letters and sounds of "h" and "q." He attempted to sound out words but had difficulty with all vowel sounds. He read very slowly and required frequent assistance. His reading comprehension was below his listening comprehension. In written language, STUDENT reversed several of his letters. Letter blends, vowel combinations and irregular vowel sounds were difficult for him. His writing was limited in vocabulary usage and he made extensive spelling errors. Oral vocabulary was age appropriate. Goals were written for the resource teacher and STUDENT to improve reading and written language skills. Services continued at the same level as those of the prior year's IEP, with resource assistance provided five days per week for sixty minutes per day.
In third grade, STUDENT was referred back to the speech pathologist for evaluation by his classroom teacher because of concerns regarding his language skills. The assessment was conducted on October 27, 1994. STUDENT demonstrated a significant delay in his receptive and expressive language skills. His test scores on the C.E.L.F. - R were as follows: receptive language- 5th percentile; oral directions - 2nd percentile; word classes - 25th percentile; semantic relationships- 16th percentile; expressive language - 7th percentile; formulated sentences - 5th percentile; recalling sentences - 2nd percentile; sentence assembly - 16th percentile. The Part IV Token Test for Children was 2.5 standard deviations below the mean with an overall score within average range. It was also found that his auditory processing skills were diminished in following oral directions, classifying and categorizing words, recalling auditory information, and formulating sentences orally using appropriate grammar, syntax and semantic structure. It was recommended that speech and language services resume with the focus on improving STUDENT's receptive and expressive language skills. An IEP addendum was signed on November 15, 1994, implementing these speech and language recommendations through the addition of speech therapy one time per week for thirty minutes. Goals were added to the IEP to increase auditory processing skills and to improve expressive language skills.
The annual IEP meeting for STUDENT was held during his third grade year on March 23, 1995. Results of the Woodcock-Johnson-R test given to STUDENT on March 6, 1995, showed no growth in reading. Age and grade equivalencies remained the same as those of the prior year with scores of 7.1 (age) and 1.5 (grade). However, because STUDENT was one year older, his standard score dropped from 86 to 73 and his percentile ranking declined from the 17th to the 4th percentile. His written language scores increased from 7.5 to 7.9 (age) and 1.8 to 2.1 (grade). Again, due to his increase in age, the standard score decreased from 96 to 88 and the percentile range dropped from the 39th to the 21st percentile. Resource assistance was provided five days per week, sixty minutes per day, excluding "labs." Labs are extra classes such as Spanish, science, etc. Mrs. PARENT testified that she later learned that this effectively reduced STUDENT's resource assistance to four times per week. The District acknowledged that this was a reduction in services. IEP goals to improve reading and written language continued. The resource specialist, classroom teacher, STUDENT and his parents were to be responsible for these goals. A goal for STUDENT and his parents was added to improve study skills at home. The classroom teacher was to monitor STUDENT's completion of his assignments. Speech and language goals from the November 15, 1994 addendum were continued. With the exception of math, an area in which the District was not providing assistance, STUDENT made no progress throughout the third grade.
STUDENT began his fourth grade at El Morro Elementary School with the above-described March 23, 1995 IEP in effect. He continued to receive RSP services five days per week for sixty minutes per session, excluding labs, as well as speech therapy one time per week. His parents removed him from El Morro after the first quarter and unilaterally placed him at Prentice Day School for private education. The District had no further contact with STUDENT until it reassessed him in 1998 following his request for a due process hearing.
DISCUSSION
"Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program. (Footnote 3)
In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district's proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or whether that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court held that "the µbasic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child." An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or "potential-maximizing" education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S.,24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994); Rowley, supra.
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.
Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) meets the student's unique needs through an individually designed program; (2) conforms to the IEP; (3) affords the student some educational benefit; and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.
ISSUE ONE
Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (hereinafter FAPE)?
1. 1995-96 school year.
Did the District's offer of placement meet STUDENT's unique needs through an individually designed program?
STUDENT was in the fourth grade during the 1995-96 school year. He was eligible for special education because of a specific learning disability that caused a significant discrepancy between his abilities and his achievements. The parties generally agree that his disability was the result of an auditory and/or visual processing disorder. This made it difficult for STUDENT to follow verbal directions, classify and catagorize words, recall information received auditorily and formulate and express oral language. Reading and writing were especially difficult for STUDENT.
Dr. Robert Patterson testified on behalf of the Petitioner. Dr. Patterson has a doctorate degree in psychology. He holds masters'degrees in educational psychology, developmental psychology and zoology. He is licenced as a marriage and family counselor. He is credentialed to teach elementary school, middle school and high school. He also has a school psychologist credential and a credential in social work. Dr. Patterson has been a SELPA director, a district coordinator of special education and the director of a career center. He is currently in private practice. In addition, he is retained to provide assessments for Regional Centers and several school districts.
It was Dr. Patterson's opinion that the District did not correctly evaluate or identify all of STUDENT's disabilities. To assist in his explanation of the status of STUDENT's disabilities by the fourth grade, Dr. Patterson provided a history of STUDENT's struggles, as summarized in the background facts. Dr. Patterson testified that the District speech pathologist who evaluated STUDENT in kindergarten diagnosed only an articulation problem and overlooked her own test results that indicated an auditory processing disorder. STUDENT's score in the 5th percentile on the TOLD subtest, which assesses a child's ability to repeat sentences, suggested a processing problem and required further investigation. Dr. Patterson further stated that the evaluator needed to speak with STUDENT's teacher to find out "is he getting it?" The speech pathologist should also have determined whether his articulation problems were caused by his age and would be self-correcting with maturity. Dr. Patterson thought that the speech evaluator focused on the articulation disorder and ignored the more significant language problems indicated by the test results. The assessor was aware that STUDENT wore his shoes on the wrong feet. This should have been recognized as an additional clue that he may have processing difficulties. Moreover, the District did not obtain an IQ score. Thus, the tests that were conducted were "done in a vacuum" because there was no IQ number with which to correlate the speech scores. Speech therapy for articulation was the sole service provided by the District. According to Dr. Patterson, this service was insufficient to meet the needs suggested by the results of STUDENT's assessment.
In the first grade, speech therapy was reduced to one time per month for a maximum of thirty minutes. In Dr. Patterson's opinion, this was inadequate to address STUDENT's articulation problems and did not address his processing difficulties at all. Later in his first grade year, when STUDENT's teacher referred him for a special education assessment, she documented concerns about STUDENT's inability to print and to copy accurately from the blackboard. He had a short attention span, difficulty understanding directions and poor listening skills. In addition, he had trouble remembering material presented verbally and visually. His speech articulation problems continued to cause him to be hard to understand.
Dr. Patterson stated that the District did not test for all of the areas of suspected disability raised by STUDENT's referring teacher. Moreover, the assessments done in response to the teacher's referral revealed low test scores in all areas except math. The District did not follow up with additional tests to specifically investigate the cause of his low test scores. STUDENT read at a kindergarten level. Letter-word recognition was at a beginning kindergarten level and he could not write all of the letters of the alphabet. His full scale IQ was above average at 107, the 68th percentile, yet his performance in the classroom was significantly below average. Dr. Patterson used the Picture Comprehension Test as an example of the District's lack of follow-up testing. He testified that STUDENT's low score on this test should have prompted further testing to determine the type and source of his comprehension problems. In addition, STUDENT had a discrepancy of 23 points between his verbal IQ and his performance IQ. Dr. Patterson explained that while this difference may not have been enough by itself to establish eligibility for special education, it did identify areas that required additional testing. He felt that these results suggested the possibility of an attention deficit disorder, visual distractibility, a processing disorder or comprehension problems. In his opinion, additional testing should have been conducted to identify any actual disabilities that were suggested by the initial test results. Dr. Patterson also referred to the initial Woodcock-Johnson-R (WJR) test that was given to STUDENT by the District. The WJR did not establish either a "basal" or a " ceiling." A basal is a series of test questions that the child correctly answers. When these correct answers are established, the testor may assume for purposes of scoring the test that the child knew the information below the basal. A ceiling is a series of questions that the child answers incorrectly. When the child incorrectly answers seven questions in a row, the assessor may conclude that the child does not possess the information beyond those questions. The failure to establish a basal or a ceiling meant that the evaluator did not know how much information STUDENT was lacking below a basal or where a ceiling confirmed that his knowledge ended.
Dr. Patterson summarized STUDENT's test results in the second grade. Reading and writing abilities were approximately mid-first grade level. His math skills were in the third grade range. Once again, the District administered the WJR without establishing a basal or a ceiling. In addition, STUDENT was not given both the letter-word recognition and the passage comprehension portions of the test. Dr. Patterson testified that without administering both, an accurate score could not be obtained. The scores obtained from the Woodcock-Johnson showed improvement from those of the prior year. However, Dr. Patterson stated that the growth revealed on the WJR did not correlate with other test results or the observations of the general education teacher. In Dr. Patterson's judgement, these discrepancies should have been further investigated.
In the third grade, STUDENT was given the District-wide test administered to all District students. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT's results showed that he was not demonstrating the expected academic skills. STUDENT's scores were one-half to one-third of the average student's scores. When he was in the seventh month of his third grade year, STUDENT was reading at a grade level of 1.5 and writing at a grade level of 2.1. Dr. Patterson pointed out that additional testing of STUDENT during the last quarter of the third grade revealed that he still read symbol by symbol; he was not a fluid reader. He was performing at a mid-first grade level. Dr. Patterson provided examples of ways in which tests were incorrectly administered by the District. These included the assessor providing prompts to assist STUDENT with his answers when the test instructions state that no prompts are to be given. On another test, only STUDENT's language flow was measured. His score was not reduced for spelling, punctuation and grammatical errors, and, as a result, caused his test scores to be skewed.
Dr. Patterson reviewed STUDENT's academic records, including his tests and the test protocols. He prepared charts and graphs evidencing STUDENT's test scores over the years. He conducted an observation of STUDENT at Prentice, and interviewed STUDENT's parents and teacher. Based upon this information, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT had an auditory processing disorder and that he was dyslexic. He was also experiencing emotional difficulties which resulted in a need for him to be in an educational setting where he was the same as other children, not different. In Dr. Patterson's opinion, STUDENT had an unique educational need for a multi-sensory format involving "hear it, see it, say it, touch it" which was consistently applied over a number of years. To provide educational benefit, the multi-sensory program had to be integrated throughout STUDENT's day, not just for one hour per day of RSP service. STUDENT also required modifications to the general education curriculum, such as the use of manipulatives, small group instruction, materials and books consistent with his skills, extra time to complete assignments, reduced assignments, preferential seating, reinforcement of lessons, monitoring to ensure he was "getting it," and appropriate homework. STUDENT's IEPs never called for modifications to his regular education program, where he spent 81% of his day. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT could not participate in most areas of his general education class without such modifications. Specifically, he could not benefit from most of the instruction provided to his fourth grade peers when his reading and writing abilities were at the first and second grade levels, respectively. Dr. Patterson concluded that the District's pattern of incomplete assessments, and the inaccurate scoring and interpretation of the tests the District did perform on STUDENT, resulted in a failure to adequately identify STUDENT's disabilities and respond appropriately. According to Dr. Patterson, although STUDENT's program could have been better, he did receive some educational benefit during his first and second grades. However, by his third grade, his needs had increased and the District's program was no longer conferring any benefit on him. STUDENT's program remained inadequate in the fourth grade, when his parents removed him to a nonpublic school.
Mrs. PARENT testified that her son could not read when he entered the fourth grade. Although he could write letters and attempt to write words, he could not read his own writing, nor could she. Math, at which STUDENT had always done well, became difficult for him. Each night homework was an ordeal for STUDENT and the entire family. She described one evening of homework in the fourth grade when she told him he had to read one of the questions. STUDENT stated that he knew the sentence ended in a question mark, so the first word must be "what" or "why." Mrs. PARENT stated that at that moment she knew with certainty that he really could not read. He was guessing at the words and attempting to learn strategies to compensate for his inability to read. Mrs. PARENT told of STUDENT's distress because he frequently had to miss recess to make up incomplete assignments. When his mother asked him why he did not finish his work, he told her that he did not understand what he was supposed to do. He could not read the assignments or understand the oral directions. Mrs. PARENT also testified that each school year STUDENT's emotional condition became more and more precarious.
STUDENT's parents credibly testified that by fourth grade he was sleepwalking, experiencing night terrors and would only sleep on the floor in his parents' bedroom. STUDENT attempted to avoid school by complaining of stomachaches, and he would force himself to vomit to convince his mother that he was too sick to attend school. His self-esteem had plummeted and he was extremely frustrated. Mrs. PARENT testified that although she told STUDENT's third and fourth grade teachers about the difficulties with homework and her son's frustration, she did not provide all of the details of his emotional problems with school. She worked for the superintendent of the District, as well as on its campuses on a per diem basis, and she was reluctant to share all of the details of her son's psychological problems with co-workers. Mr. PARENT testified that the staff at his son's school was advised that STUDENT was developing serious problems as a result of his academic difficulties and resulting inability to succeed. Additionally, the other students were beginning to tease STUDENT because he did not do well in school. Based on the above, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT believed that STUDENT's unique needs were both academic and emotional.
Dr. Carolyn Hayes, former director of special education for Laguna, and Robert White, SELPA director, both testified that when STUDENT entered the fourth grade in 1995, his reading grade equivalency was a mid-first grade level and in the 4th percentile. His written language grade equivalency was beginning second grade. Since first grade, he had increased his reading skills by one grade level and his writing skills from mid-kindergarten to beginning second grade. STUDENT continued to have difficulty with decoding, spelling, letter and word recognition, and phonics. Dr. Hayes and Mr. White testified that STUDENT needed special education primarily in the areas of reading, writing, study skills and speech articulation.
Dr. Purrington was the principal at El Morro throughout STUDENT's years of attendance. She attended each of his IEPs as the District's administer. Dr. Purrington testified that his teacher reported that, by the end of third grade, STUDENT could still not read, write or work independently. His math scores had always been good, but by the latter part of third grade, math had became much more difficult for him. (The District never provided math assistance for STUDENT.) Dr. Purrington also testified that STUDENT "had not made the expected growth in third grade." She was aware that STUDENT was experiencing frustration with homework and believes the IEP team provided Mrs. PARENT with some suggestions for assisting him with his homework. She did not recall the parents ever discussing emotional or sleep difficulties.
Ms. Leslie Respess was STUDENT's fourth grade teacher after he transferred to Prentice School. She testified that during her year with him his unique needs were in the area of decoding. He "couldn't unlock unknown words." He would look at the first two letters of a word and then guess what the word was. He also had very poor handwriting and low spelling skills.
Based upon a review of the testimony and documentary evidence introduced at the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that in the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT had an auditory processing deficit that created unique needs in the areas of reading, language arts and understanding oral and written instructions. The District did not fully assess STUDENT to determine the extent of his disabilities. Consequently, the services it provided were inadequate to meet his needs. STUDENT required multi- sensory techniques throughout his school day to address his needs. His areas of disability affected all aspects of his education. He read at a mid-first grade, and wrote at a beginning second grade level. He could not read a grade-level text book in any fourth grade subject. He could not participate in grade-appropriate writing, nor could he succeed on a fourth grade test in any subject, including math, when it involved word problems or symbols he did not understand.
Despite these inabilities, regular education classroom modifications were not made for STUDENT. STUDENT was in his general education classroom 81% of the school day. He required modifications for the reading and writing components of all of the fourth grade curriculum to accomodate his skill level. STUDENT needed reduced assignments and/or additional time to complete assignments. It was necessary for the teacher to confirm that STUDENT understood oral and written directions. Collaboration between the special education staff and his regular education teacher was essential to implement the modifications and strategies. Homework assignments needed to be tailored to his abilities by the educational staff. STUDENT also required speech and language therapy for his articulation problems and his processing deficits.
STUDENT also had a particular need for psychological services during this time. He had significant emotional problems as a result of his lack of educational success, with a resulting decrease in self-esteem. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT testified that they informed STUDENT's third and fourth grade teachers of at least some of the emotional problems he was having as a result of his inability to succeed at school. Although there is no evidence that the parents requested a psychological assessment, adequate information was provided to alert the District that this was a suspected area of disability that required an evaluation. Dr. Purrington's and Ms. Vick's stipulated testimony both claim that the District was unaware of the multiple sleep problems STUDENT was experiencing. However, the District was aware that STUDENT was having serious academic difficulties both at school and with homework. Dr. Purrington testified that STUDENT "struggled" with school and he experienced frustration with homework. The District also knew that for 81% of his school day he was participating, without specific assistance, in a class that was several grade levels beyond his capabilities. This knowledge certainly should have alerted them to the need to investigate the extent of STUDENT's emotional difficulties, even if his mother had not elaborated on the severity of his psychological problems.
The District presented testimony through Dr. Purrington that counseling was available for students on the El Morro campus. She said that FEMA (Footnote 4) counselors were present to help children deal with fire and mud-slide disasters experienced by their community. Through a notice sent home in each child's backpack, the parents were notified of these services. However, the notice sent to the parents offered psychological services to victims of the fire disaster. It was not an offer of general psychological services to the students. STUDENT was not a victim of either fire or a mudslide. The District maintained that these counselors would also help with psychological issues unrelated to the disasters. It argued that Mr. and Mrs. PARENT should have known about and requested this service. The District incorrectly attempts to shift the burden of initiating services to STUDENT's parents. The relevant issue is not what the parents should have requested for STUDENT, but what the District should have recognized as his unique need. (California Education Code §56381)
In 1995, California's Education Code §56345 (3) required that an IEP include "the specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil." Because the unique needs of STUDENT were not properly identified, the appropriate services were not provided. As a result, his program was not designed to provide the specific "educational instruction and related services" he required. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District's offer of RSP for less than five hours per week, speech one time per week, and the absence of specific modifications to his general education curriculum did not meet the unique needs of STUDENT during the 1995-96 school year
Did the District provide services in conformance with STUDENT's IEP?
It is undisputed that the District provided the speech and RSP services contained in STUDENT's IEP. However, it has already been determined that these services were insufficient to meet STUDENT's unique needs and provide him with a FAPE.
Did the District's offer of placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
Dr. Hayes, Mr. White and Dr. Purrington each testified that RSP services for sixty minutes each school day and speech and language therapy one time a week for thirty minutes, as contained in his IEP, were the appropriate services to meet STUDENT's needs. They testified that the District's assessments were appropriate and his tests showed that STUDENT was making gains. They point to yearly test results that found the following:
1993 - 1st grade 1994 - 2nd grade 1995 - 3rd grade Reading Grade: K.4 SS:71 3% Grade: 1 SS: 86 17% Grade: l.5 SS: 73 4% Math 1.5 102 56% 3.3 117 87% 4.2 115 84% Written Language K.6 79 8% 1.8 96 39% 2.1 88 21%
These test scores establish that, from the first through the third grades, STUDENT made growth in reading of approximately one grade level, one percentile ranking and two points in his standard score. His written language skills had increased from a grade level of K.6 to 2.1, with his standard score increasing by nine points and his percentile rank by thirteen. The District maintains that these scores establish that STUDENT was receiving educational benefit from his school program. Mr. White, and other District witnesses, testified that standard scores, rather than grade equivalencies, were the more accurate method for interpreting test results. A review of the test results introduced into evidence reveal that, overall, STUDENT increased his standard score in reading by two points from the first through the third grade. However, in the one-year period between the second and third grade, it dropped fourteen points. His written language score from the first through the third grade increased by nine points. However, it decreased by eight points from second to third grade.
The goals contained in the IEP that was in effect when STUDENT began the 1995-96 school year were (1) to improve his skills in reading by learning eighty-five of the top one hundred first grade sight words, and then progressing to the ability to read a passage at his instructional level one year later, (2) to improve written language skills by correctly spelling five out of six of his RSP spelling words and then, by the end of the year, writing a four-sentence paragraph, and, (3) to improve his study skills at home. When comparing the reading and written language goals in the1994 IEP to those in the 1995 IEP, one notes that STUDENT apparently had not made progress on either of his two goals. (The study skills goal was not part of STUDENT's IEP before 1995.) The IEP of March 14, 1994 (second to third grade), contained a one-year goal that, by March 1995, STUDENT would read a second-grade passage with 80% accuracy. The March 23, 1995 IEP one-year goal (third to fourth grade) was that, by March 1996, STUDENT would read a passage "at his instructional level" with 85% accuracy. During the year between these two IEPs, STUDENT's reading percentile rank dropped from the 17th percentile to the 4th percentile. The 1994 IEP (second to third grade) stated that, by March 1995, STUDENT would write a five-sentence paragraph with 75% accuracy. His 1995 IEP's goal (third to fourth grade) was that, in one year, STUDENT would write a four-sentence paragraph with 85% accuracy. Again, his percentile ranking on tests to determine writing ability decreased from 39% to 21%. Despite his apparent failure to progress on the only two IEP goals written, the District did not alter the services provided to STUDENT. Instead, it decreased his RSP services from sixty minutes five times per week to sixty minutes five times per week excluding labs. Mrs. PARENT testified that this resulted in her son receiving RSP services for approximately one hour four times per week. Laguna explained that "labs" were for such subjects as Spanish and science, and it did not dispute that "excluding labs" was a reduction in RSP services.
Dr. Purrington acknowledged that the District did not convene an IEP meeting to address STUDENT's academic decline, nor did it increase his services. It continued to offer one hour per day of RSP; however, this was not one hour of direct service to STUDENT. Instead, the RSP teacher would spend a portion of that hour in the general education classroom assisting all of the children who received RSP support. The remainder of the hour was provided in small groups in the RSP room. An aide would read aloud to STUDENT the novels that his classmates were reading independently. During the RSP pull-out, STUDENT also received reading assistance through a combined phonics and whole-language approach. Dr. Purrington stated that the multi-sensory strategies utilized in the RSP classroom were books with auditory tapes. Dr. Purrington also testified that, in the fourth grade, phonics and other methods to teach students to read were no longer emphasized. The reading program was a literature approach and the students read novels. Although Dr. Purrington confirmed that STUDENT's reading ability was more than two years behind his grade level, she acknowledged that there were no modifications for his regular education class written into his IEP. She believes that the IEP team discussed modifications and shared them with Mrs. PARENT at the IEP meeting. Dr. Patterson testified that a child must learn a year of material each year to keep his standard score consistent from year to year. One goal of remediation is to attempt to obtain more than a year of growth per school year and close the gap between actual and age appropriate skills. STUDENT was not maintaining his own scores and he was falling further behind his peers. The District recognized his declining performance, yet did nothing to respond. Instead, Dr. Purrington testified that although the staff was concerned, it merely agreed to monitor STUDENT in fourth grade. She also said that it was not unusual for a child to have periods without growth.
It has already been determined that STUDENT's unique needs were in the areas of reading, writing and comprehension. His disability required a multi-sensory approach to learning throughout his school day, not one hour of isolated RSP service. Books with accompanying audio tapes, for a portion of an hour each day, is not the multi-sensory technique STUDENT required to benefit from his education. Reading novels aloud to him when he had an auditory processing problem would be of little benefit to him. STUDENT needed to learn by utilizing each of his senses throughout his school day. This type of program could only have been delivered in his classroom through specific and ongoing collaboration between his regular education teacher and his RSP teacher. The District maintains that the RSP teacher communicated frequently with the general education teacher. However, there was no evidence produced to corroborate this assertion. No testimony was provided by either his third or fourth grade teacher , or by yis RSP teacher. More importantly, nothing was documented on his IEP that indicated either collaboration or modifications. His regular education teachers never attended his IEPs, and, therefore, could have had no personal knowledge of any modifications which may have been discussed at these meetings.
Although the District claims that there were generally understood modifications that special education students routinely received, such as more time for test-taking, nothing was specified in STUDENT's IEP. Moreover, the relevant issue is the modifications STUDENT required, not the generic modifications that may be granted to all special education children. STUDENT read, wrote and spelled at the first and second grade level. Four months before the end of third grade, STUDENT's teacher completed an evaluation form. She wrote that in math he had some ability to follow group instruction, work independently and be grouped with his classmates. In reading, he had limited ability to follow group instruction or work independently. He could not be grouped in a reading group. In both spelling and language, he could not follow group instruction, work independently or be grouped in the classroom. This teacher noted that she was "concerned about STUDENT's academic progress in reading, spelling, language as well as other subjects in which these skills are used." It is clear, STUDENT's disabilities made it difficult for him to understand his teacher's instructions and participate in class. He could not understand what was required of him through either written or oral instructions without assistance. Placing him in a regular education classroom with text books and written assignments years beyond his abilities, and no specified modifications to allow him to comprehend the material, inevitably deprived him of educational benefit and adversely affected his self-esteem.
The United States Supreme Court held in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (supra) that a special education student need not be provided with the best education available. However, he or she must receive more than a deminimis gain to satisfy the Rowley (supra) requirement of obtaining "some benefit" from their educational program. M.C. ex.rel. J.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389 (3rd Cir. 1996), Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit, 853 F.2d 171 (3rd Cir. 1988). STUDENT was in his regular education class 81% of his school day, yet his regular education teachers did not attend his IEPs to coordinate strategies. Goals to address his unique needs in his regular education class were not incorporated into his IEP. STUDENT received isolated RSP services that were not incoporated into the remaining 81% of his academic day. Thus, he received very little benefit from the fourth grade classroom where he spent the vast majority of his time. These factors establish that STUDENT's educational placement conferred little benefit upon him academically or emotionally. In fact, in several areas he had regressed.
Did the District provide STUDENT's program in the least restrictive environment?
The District's provision of services in the least restrictive environment was not at issue in this case. However, the District raises this issue as a defense to the Petitioner's request for tuition reimbursement for his nonpublic school placement. Laguna's contention will be addressed below.
As a result of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT evidenced only deminimis growth and that his unique needs were not accommodated by the placement that the District recommended for the 1995-96 school year. These resulted in a denial of a FAPE.
2. 1996-97 school year
At the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT's unique needs remained essentially unchanged from the 1995-96 school year. The District did not convene an IEP meeting to address STUDENT's unique needs for this school year, nor did it make an offer of placement to STUDENT. Ms. Hayes testified that the District did not know what had happened to STUDENT when he left the District's school early in his fourth grade year in 1995. She further testified that Laguna fulfills its responsibility to search for students who attend private schools and reside within the District by contacting the private schools whose addresses are within the District to alert them that special education services are available through Laguna. The District does not attempt to contact families directly. Ms. Hayes stated that the nonpublic school that STUDENT attends is not situated within the District. Therefore, Laguna would not have contacted his school. No attempt was made by the District to contact STUDENT's family.
Pursuant to both the State and federal law in effect during the 1996-97 school year, educational agencies were required to locate, identify and evaluate special education children who resided within their jurisdictional boundaries. California Education Code §56300 et seq., 34 C.F.R. §1412(a)(3). This duty was imposed directly upon the districts and required them to search for all disabled students residing within their boundaries. Laguna's policy was to notify private schools that special education services were available for their students, if the private schools had an address within Laguna's boundaries. Rather than contact the disabled students directly, Laguna relied upon the private schools to locate and notify special education students of available services. This would appear to be an inadequate "search and serve" policy. However, even assuming arguendo that Laguna's "search and serve" endeavors were generally sufficient, they were not enough in this situation. The District knew, or reasonably should have known, that STUDENT continued to reside within the District. STUDENT's older brother was still attending a District school. Mrs. PARENT retained her position as an officeholder with the PTA for the school STUDENT had attended. She, accompanied by STUDENT, chaperoned a school trip after STUDENT changed schools. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT informed their son's substitute teacher that he was leaving and provided the name of the school to which he was transferring. They then returned to STUDENT's prior school when his regular teacher was back to personally inform her of the identity of his new school and the reasons they had moved him. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT stayed in the classroom to answer questions from the other students. They explained that STUDENT "learned in a different way" and that his new school would help him understand his school work. Later, the fourth grade teacher mailed "we miss you cards" from his classmates to the Petitioner's home. Finally, Mrs. PARENT has continued to work for the District on a per diem basis from the time STUDENT changed schools to the present.
At all times during the 1996-97 school year, the District had actual and constructive knowledge that a prior special education student continued to reside within its jurisdictional boundaries. The District also knew, or should have known, that the Petitioner transferred to Prentice because he was dissatisfied with the education he was receiving at the District's school. Furthermore, it was foreseeable that the Petitioner could seek reimbursement for the nonpublic school's tuition. Despite this information, Laguna did not make any attempt to contact Petitioner's parents, schedule an IEP meeting, offer a placement for the 1996-97 school year, or determine what, if any, services STUDENT required. This was contrary to its obligation to search out and provide services to special education students residing within its boundaries. As a result, STUDENT was not offered a FAPE by the District for his fifth grade year.
3. 1997-98 school year
STUDENT's general needs remained unchanged during the 1997-98 school year. He continued to have difficulties with letter-word recognition, phonics, auditory sound discrimination and writing. His dyslexic characteristics remained. The evidence established that STUDENT continued to require a multi-sensory, integrated educational approach throughout his school day.
It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education during the 1997-98 school year. Again, despite Mrs. PARENT' employment with the District and her other son's attendance at a District high school, Laguna made no effort to contact the family or offer STUDENT special education services. The IDEA 97 was in effect for this school year. (Footnote 5)Title 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (1)(B)(3)(A) requires that "all children with disabilities residing in the State, including children with disabilities attending private schools, regardless of the severity of their disabilities, and who are in need of special education and related services, are identified, located and evaluated and a practical method is developed and implemented to determine which children with disabilities are currently receiving needed special education services." (Emphasis added). Laguna had an affirmative duty to seek out all children, even those who may be unknown to it, that require special education services. It had an obligation to contact a child it knew, or should have known, resided in its district, had previously been designated as qualified for special education services, and had left the District dissatisfied with the educational services it provided. Laguna therefore failed in its duty to "search and serve" and, as a result, did not offer STUDENT a FAPE.
4. 1998-99 school year
A. Did the District commit procedural violations at the IEP meeting of November 23, 1998?
In June 1998, the Petitioner filed for a due process hearing seeking reimbursement for the costs associated with his unilateral nonpublic school placement. Later that same month, the District asked the parents to sign an assessment plan. The Petitioner demanded that an IEP meeting be convened to determine the appropriate areas of assessment. The parties could not agree to schedule this meeting. Immediately following unsuccessful mediation of the Petitioner's case, the District filed for a due process hearing requesting the right to assess STUDENT. On September 18, 1998, the Hearing Office issued an order compelling the parties to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the reevaluation of STUDENT. The Petitioner's parents ultimately signed an assessment plan and the evaluations were conducted by Laguna. An IEP meeting was held on November 23, 1998, to review the results of the assessments and discuss placement. The Petitioner contends that the District committed procedural violations during this IEP meeting. The Petitioner alleges that improper District personnel attended the meeting. Education Code §56341(a) and (b) provide that:
(a) each meeting to develop, review or revise the individual education program of an individual with exceptional needs, shall be conducted by an individual education program team.
The IEP team must include all of the following:
(1) A representative other than the pupil's teacher designated by administration who may be an administrator, program specialist, or other specialist who is knowledgeable of program options appropriate for the pupil and who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, special education.
(2) The pupil's present teacher . . .
(3) One or both of the pupil's parents, a representative selected by the parent, or both . . .
Individuals other than those indicated above may be included in the IEP team when appropriate. When developing, reviewing or revising an IEP after an assessment, the person who conducted the assessment or someone knowledgeable about the assessment procedures and the results thereof must be included in the IEP team. Education Code §56341(c). When the IEP involves "pupils with suspected learning disabilities, at least one member of the individualized educational program team, other than the pupil's regular teacher, shall be a person who has observed the pupil's educational performance in an appropriate setting . . . " Education Code §56341(d).
Federal law mandates the inclusion of the following individuals in the IEP team: (1) the parents of the child with the disability; (2) at least one of the child's regular education teachers, if the child has or may have one; (3) at least one special education teacher or, if appropriate, one of the child's special education providers; (4) a representative of the district who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, the DIS services required by the child, is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, knows the availability of the district's resources; (5) an individual who can interpret assessment results (this may be the regular education teacher or the district representative); and (6) other individuals the parents request who have special knowledge of their child. Title 20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(1)(B).
The Petitioner contends that the District brought nine individuals to the November 1998 IEP meeting, many of whom served no purpose other than to attempt to intimidate the parents. The Petitioner further alleges that, despite having so many individuals in attendance, the District did not include those individuals required by the above statutes. The parties agree that the following persons from the District were in attendance at the IEP meeting: the acting principal of El Moro Elementary School, an RSP teacher from El Moro, a regular education teacher from El Moro, the District's coordinator of special education, the SELPA director, the assistant superintendent of instructional services, a counselor from Thurston Middle School, a speech therapist, and a school psychologist. District personnel testified that they did not include anyone from the proposed middle school in the IEP meeting because they thought the meeting might become contentious. They did not want STUDENT's potential teachers to be prejudiced toward STUDENT because of disagreements between the parents and the District.
The District explains that the elementary school principal was there as the District's designated administrator. It wanted the principal present as the site administrator. The coordinator of special education was also present in the capacity of the District administrator. The RSP teacher and the regular education teacher were both from the elementary school STUDENT had attended. They were not from the middle school at which the District proposed to place STUDENT. The District stated that the elementary school's general education teacher was at the IEP meeting in the capacity of the teacher with knowledge of the middle school curriculum. The RSP teacher, speech therapist, and the psychologist from the elementary school had conducted the District's recent assessments of STUDENT. The assistant superintendent was new to special education and she was there to learn about due process matters. The SELPA director had knowledge of the programs available and was involved in the due process case. The counselor had knowledge of the middle school's programs. The District acknowledges that it did not invite anyone from the nonpublic school STUDENT had attended for the past three years. The District refused the parents' request to hold the IEP meeting on the Prentice School site and insisted that it be held at the elementary school which STUDENT had been attending when he left the District.
The speech therapist, resource teacher, and school psychologist were associated with an elementary school, not the middle school which was age appropriate for STUDENT. However, they had conducted the pre-IEP assessments and, therefore, were properly in attendance under California's requirement that those persons who had conducted the evaluations attend the IEP meeting. The SELPA director knew about the resources available within the local educational agency. The special educational coordinator was appropriately designated as the District's administrator and she, in fact, conducted the meeting. The middle school counselor arguably had knowledge of the programs available at that school site. The District stated that although the regular education teacher had taught at the elementary level for the past seven or eight years, she may have had experience at a middle school when she worked at a prior district. This experience does not qualify her, as alleged by the District, to be the designated general education teacher at the IEP meeting, as she clearly would not be one of STUDENT's teachers. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d)(1)(B)(ii). The principal was named as another administrator because the IEP meeting was conducted on his elementary school campus. This was unnecessary, and he did not actually remain throughout the entire meeting. It is questionable that a child's IEP meeting can be used as a training forum for new administrators, especially when so many other administrators are already in attendance and the consent of the parents for such an observer has not been obtained. It is therefore concluded that the general education teacher from the elementary school, the elementary school principal and the assistant superintendent had no actual function at the IEP meeting.
Of greater concern is the District's failure to include STUDENT's current school teacher in the IEP meeting. The District had neither maintained nor reestablished contact with STUDENT for approximately three years. Its assessors generally worked with elementary-age children and they were not familiar with STUDENT. The coordinator of special education may "have seen him" when he was a student in the District. The middle school counselor did not know STUDENT, nor did the SELPA director. Thus, there was no one in attendance as an educator with current knowledge of STUDENT. The District did not comply with the requirement to have the child's current teacher in attendance, nor was anyone present who had observed STUDENT's educational performance in the appropriate setting. (supra §1414). Ms. Jarvis, the director of the nonpublic school, testified that both she and STUDENT's teacher would have attended the IEP meeting had they been invited. They would have been present even if the invitation had come only from the District and not also directly from STUDENT's parents. Ms. Jarvis stated that Prentice School worked with twenty-one different public school districts and they routinely attended IEP meetings for their students, when invited. Typically, the invitation is extended by the district, not the parents.
Ms. Hogrebe, the RSP teacher who evaluated STUDENT and wrote goals for his proposed IEP, testified that she was unable to address his present levels of functioning in writing and spelling because she did not know his current levels of achievement. She therefore could not include them in STUDENT's goals and objectives. Lila Samia, the school psychologist who assessed STUDENT, testified that other than the results of the District's own assessments, the District's team members did not know STUDENT's current abilities. Two District assessors intended to visit his classroom together, and Mrs. PARENT expressed concern that this would make STUDENT feel self-conscious. The classrooms at Prentice do not have windows that would allow observations from the outside, so they would have only been able to watch STUDENT from inside his classroom. STUDENT's mother felt that he, and his classmates, would know he was being observed. However, even had the District's assessors observed STUDENT in his classroom, the observations would have provided little information about his present abilities. The District did not speak with anyone from STUDENT's current school, despite the parents' signed authorization to do so. None of the District's IEP team members exercised the authority granted by the parents to contact STUDENT's teacher to acquire current educational information. "Present levels of educational performance" must be included in the IEP. Title 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(5)(c)(5)(A). This information cannot be obtained without including the student's actual teacher, who possesses the information concerning current educational levels, in the IEP process.
The Petitioner argues that the District committed further procedural errors by completing the IEP goals and deciding upon placement before the IEP meeting. The District maintains that the parents had every opportunity to participate in the development of the IEP and they did not offer any goals. It also claims that STUDENT's IEP was developed at the IEP meeting, not before it was convened. To support its position, the District points to the fact that the proposal for one hour per day of RSP was crossed out and an additional hour of RSP study skills was added. It states that this is evidence that the IEP changed after team discussion. The Hearing Officer agrees that this establishes that the District's proposal was modified during the meeting. However, Ms. Hogrebe, the District's RSP teacher who conducted the academic evaluations, testified that STUDENT had good study skills and did not need the RSP study skills class. Ms. Hogrebe also testified that she had drafted the written language goals and objectives before the IEP meeting. They did not change during the meeting. This goal and one other for speech and language were the sole goals contained in STUDENT's IEP. Goals and objectives are a significant part of an IEP. Based upon the testimony of a District's employee, at least one of the two goals and objectives was written prior to the IEP meeting without the input of anyone with knowledge of STUDENT's current classroom performance. Although it is permissible to draft tentative goals before an IEP meeting, it would seem a difficult task to write proposed goals without knowledge of the student's capabilities in the classroom.
The present case is factually indistinguishable from the case of W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). In W.G. the student had been unilaterally placed in a nonpublic school by his parents after his difficulties in school resulted in the loss of self-esteem, stomach pain and insomnia. The parents then sought reimbursement for tuition costs. The District prepared the IEP prior to the IEP meeting. It also developed the IEP without the participation of the child's teacher or a representative of the private school. The court found that the failure to ensure the participation of all necessary parties at the IEP meeting resulted in an insufficient IEP and constituted a procedural violation that denied the student a
FAPE:
Target Range clearly did not comply with the procedures required by the IDEA. The district court found that Target Range independently developed the IEP that it presented to W.G. and B.G.(parents), without the input and participation of . . . the regular education teacher, or any representative of St. Joseph School in direct violation of 20 U.S.C. §1401 . . . the record supports the findings of the district court . . . Even if the district court's finding that the school prepared the reports were disregarded, other significant procedural errors existed and were admitted by Target Range. The school failed to make efforts to include R.G.'s (student) teacher in the process . . . Because R.G. was enrolled in a parochial school, Target range was required to ensure participation by the private school in the formation of the IEP.
Pursuant to the above Ninth Circuit case, failure to include STUDENT's teacher from his nonpublic school in the IEP process, in itself, would constitute a denial of a FAPE. Here, the District also committed further procedural violations by inviting improper participants and writing proposed goals with placement recommendations without mandated information. As discussed below, the District also failed to provide a comprehensive IEP document and to make STUDENT a clear offer of placement. The United States Supreme Court has held that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard." Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982). Laguna's procedural violations deprived STUDENT and his parents of a meaningful, informed IEP process and resulted in prejudice to the Petitioner. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District violated STUDENT's procedural rights in a substantial and prejudicial way and thereby denied him a FAPE.
B. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
Did the District's offer meet STUDENT's unique needs through an individually designed program?
The District's assessments revealed "subtle deficits in auditory processing resulting in impaired written language skills that adversely affects academic performance." On the evaluation conducted by the resource specialist, Ms. Hogrebe, STUDENT performed within the average range in reading skills and in the below average range in writing skills. STUDENT tested within the lower instructional range in math. This test score within the "lower instructional range of normal" was only obtained by using his "best" score, not his "typical math score." (Dr. Purrington testified that previously math had been STUDENT's area of strength; however, during third grade, math became difficult for him.) Ms. Hogrebe found that STUDENT required cues in math such as "go slower" and "subtraction is different from addition."
The speech therapist found that STUDENT had a delay in the auditory processing of language. She reported that he obtained a reading score within the low average range. His spelling and arithmetic scores were within the impaired range. STUDENT's scores indicated a mild tendency to lose attention to rote presentation and inconsistency in his organizational approach to information. His cognitive ability was within the average range. His ability to sustain his attention and concentrate was within the low average range. His processing speed was average, and he showed improvement in his visual perception since the prior District testing. Subtle auditory processing difficulties were evident. Overall, STUDENT's achievement scores were within a low average to an impaired range.
Based upon the above evaluations, each District assessor provided her opinion of STUDENT's unique needs. Lila Samia, the school psychologist, testified that STUDENT requires additional time to process information, especially on verbal tasks. He has some learning difficulties and has to work a little harder, but he does not have significant deficits. Kay Ostensen, the middle school counselor, testified that STUDENT has a unique need for smaller classes, especially in language arts. He requires a study skills class to help him organize his day and closer contact with school personnel to monitor his work. He also needs speech and language therapy to strengthen his verbal accuracy and to increase his ability to hear and follow directions. Ms. Hogrebe, the District's resource specialist who preformed the academic testing, testified that STUDENT has an unique need in the area of spontaneous writing. He also needs a multi-sensory learning approach, oral information dispensed at a slower pace, repetition, and extra time provided to process information. As a result of these evaluations and the opinions of its assessors, Laguna determined that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of written language and speech and language
Dr. Patterson testified that in his opinion STUDENT continues to need an intensive multi-sensory, hands-on program that must be integrated and consistent throughout his day. Isolated periods of RSP each day are inadequate. STUDENT requires RSP support that is delivered in a multi- sensory manner and provided in collaboration with his general education teachers. He should be allowed to dictate, not write by hand. He needs extra time when taking tests and modified homework assignments in all of his academic classes. STUDENT required speech and language therapy to address his processing deficits. He will also require counseling, especially as he makes the transition from the small-school environment to a large high school.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT currently needs special education services integrated throughout his school day. This need would require specific collaboration to establish a multi- sensory educational approach between the resource specialist and each of STUDENT's general education teachers. STUDENT requires a small class size. He also requires specific classroom modifications included in his IEP. These should address his need to have oral information repeated and additional time to process information. According to the testimony of Dr. Purrington and Ms. Hogrebe, it is likely that STUDENT will also require special education assistance in math. If STUDENT is to succeed, he will need all of the books and materials in his core academic classes presented at his academic level. STUDENT has difficulty writing and should be allowed to dictate as appropriate. He needs increased time to take tests and to have homework adjusted to his capabilities. At least initially, STUDENT will need counseling services to oversee his transition between schools and to monitor his self-esteem.
Would the District's offer of placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
It is impossible to know whether the District's proposed IEP would confer an educational benefit on STUDENT. Each of the District's witnesses who attended the IEP meeting had a different interpretation of the services that were offered in the IEP document. The IEP itself states that STUDENT's placement would be "1 period study skills, 1 period language arts and one period 50 minutes per week of speech and language." Ms. Hogrebe, the RSP teacher, testified that the District offered STUDENT one hour per day in a general education humanity class that had an RSP aide assigned to the class. She further stated that one hour per day of RSP study skills was not specifically offered but it could be included by convening an IEP meeting and adding it if necessary. (As previously indicated, Ms. Hogrebe also testified that STUDENT had good study skills and did not need a study skills class.) The remainder of his classes were to be general education classes with no support and no specified modification. She also testified that if he required more assistance, they could provide it.
Lila Samia, a District school psychologist, testified that the offer of placement to STUDENT was for one hour per day in a special education RSP class for language arts and one period per day in a special education study skills class. Although it was not written in the IEP, she assumed that all of his other core curriculum classes would be in general education with aide support. (Footnote 6) She further assumed, again without its being stated in the IEP, that the modification for STUDENT in his general education classes would be that the aide assigned to the class would notice if he required assistance and respond to his needs. Another unwritten modification was to provide him with extra time to complete his work in the study skills class. Ms. Samia could not explain whose interpretation of the modifications would be conveyed to his general education instructors if the modifications were not written into his IEP and the IEP team members had different understandings of the required modifications. She also testified that had the District IEP meeting participants thought that STUDENT was actually attending the District middle school, they would have been more specific on his IEP. Ms. Samia confirmed that the special education classes at Thurston Middle School use a multi-sensory approach, but that the general education classes do not. Contrary to Ms. Hogrebe, she did not think that STUDENT "had a profile that stood out as a student who needed a multi-sensory program."
Kay Ostensen is the counselor at Thurston and the IEP meeting participant alleged to have the most knowledge of Thurston's programs. She testified that the IEP offered STUDENT placement in two RSP classes (language arts and study skills), three collaborative classes, and physical education in regular education. Ms. Ostensen said that the IEP "goals were not complete because they thought that STUDENT was not coming to Thurston." She acknowledged that the IEP as written could not be fully implemented. The school would need to obtain measurements for meeting the goals and objectives and the benchmarks needed to be clarified. Ms. Ostensen further stated that the IEP did not "specifically state how STUDENT's IEP was to be tied into his regular education classes." She provided information about general modifications that all special education students receive, but could not identify any modifications specifically made to accommodate STUDENT's unique needs in general education classes. Ms. Ostensen explained that the aide assigned to support the regular education classes would be responsible for circulating around the class to determine which students required assistance. If the aide recognized a need for modifications, he or she would tell the special education teacher of the student's need. The special education teacher could then convey the information about any necessary modifications to the regular education teacher. Ms. Ostensen believed that STUDENT required a small class size. She testified that the two RSP classes offered were small and numbered approximately fifteen students. The remainder of the classes offered to STUDENT were not small classes and contained approximately thirty students. One aide was assigned to those classes that were aide-supported, making the ratio one adult to fifteen students. If it were determined that STUDENT required an aide-supported math class, he would have to attend "zero period," which is outside normal school hours.
Dr. Hayes, the District's director of special education at the time of the IEP meeting, also testified about the placement offer made to STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. She said that the District proposed a one-hour RSP class for language arts and a one-hour RSP class for study skills. Social studies and science were to be in aide-supported classes. Math, physical education, and an elective would be in general education without any services. She testified that although the IEP did not specify placement in aide-supported classes, it was understood that placement in the study skills class automatically placed a student in aide-supported general education classes. Dr. Hayes was vague about how such "automatic placement" would enroll STUDENT in aide-supported science and social study classes, but not in an aide-supported math, physical education or an elective class. Dr. Hayes also testified that the IEP provided that STUDENT's "statewide assessment" exam would be administered allowing for "accommodations of flexible time and setting." She maintained that this meant that the same modifications of flexible time and setting would be provided daily in each of STUDENT's classes. This assertion is not a credible interpretation of a box checked on the IEP document under a preprinted item labeled "statewide assessment." Dr. Hayes testimony was also contradicted by other District witnesses, who stated that that portion of the IEP document referred only to the state examination.
Laguna is obligated to make a legally sufficient offer of placement. Union School District v. B. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994) required districts to make a "formal written offer" of placement to the parents. The ninth circuit explained that "this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." The Court then described the "important purpose" of a "formal written offer" as follows: (1) to create a clear factual record for later review; (2) to assist the parents in presenting complaints about the placement; (3) to allow the parents to decide whether to accept or reject the placement offered; and (4) to allow the school district to present relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer regarding the appropriateness of the placement offered.
In this case, each of the District's witnesses was a participant at the IEP meeting where the District made its offer of placement to STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year. Yet, as discussed above, each attendee had a different understanding of the placement offer made. The District also seemed uncertain of the specific services STUDENT required. A study skills class was added to the placement offer during the IEP meeting, apparently to increase the level of RSP services. However, the person who performed the academic assessment for the District testified that STUDENT had good study skills and did not need this class. One District evaluator testified that STUDENT required a multi-sensory methodology to benefit educationally and another testified that he did not.
The District psychologist testified that her impression of STUDENT was that he was below average in spelling and math and he needed extra time to process information, especially for verbal tasks. (Footnote 7) Her overall impression was that STUDENT had some learning disabilities and had to work a little harder, but that he did not have significant deficits. Another District witness stated that STUDENT had moderate to severe reading problems that impacted him in all academic areas that required reading skills. The District offered speech and language services, but did not know whether this was to be provided individually or in a group setting. None of the curriculum modifications required to meet STUDENT's unique needs was expressed on the IEP document and it was unclear how information about necessary modifications would be conveyed to the general education teachers.
This contradictory testimony reflected confusion and uncertainty among the District's IEP team members about the appropriate placement for STUDENT during the 1998-99 school year. When the drafters of a placement offer cannot themselves understand its meaning, the parents certainly cannot be expected to comprehend the placement offer being proposed. In this case, there was no evidence presented that the parents did, in fact, understand the specific offer of placement for their son. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT both testified that they understood the offer to be one period per day of resource assistance and one daily period of study skills, with the remainder of STUDENT's classes in general education. It was their impression that this was the only special education assistance STUDENT would receive. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer was presented with confusing testimony that rendered it impossible to determine the actual placement offer made to the Petitioner. The contradictory testimony regarding the services required by STUDENT and the confusing placement offer resulted in an absence of persuasive evidence that the District fully understood and responded to STUDENT's unique needs. The District also did not address STUDENT's emotional needs when transitioning to a less sheltered school environment or the low self-esteem which may return if he again feels he cannot keep up with his peers.
As a result of the foregoing evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District's failure to make a definite offer of specific classes, support services and modifications violated the mandate of Union School, (supra) for a clear, coherent placement offer. This violation resulted in substantial prejudice to the Petitioner and his parents, as it deprived them of the information necessary to evaluate the District's proposed placement and services. Consequently, the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.
ISSUE TWO
Is the Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for tuition and related costs incurred as a result of his unilateral nonpublic school placement?
In School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358, (1985), the United States Supreme Court held that the parents of disabled children were entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the tuition and related expenses of unilaterally placing their child in a private special education school program. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide the child with a free, appropriate education and the private placement is determined to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. See also Florence County School District Four, et.al. v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).
The Hearing Officer has already determined that STUDENT's placement was not appropriate during the 1995-96 school year and none was offered for the 1996-97 and 1997-98 school years. The proposed placement for the 1998-99 school year was also insufficient. The District argues that Prentice School was an inappropriate placement for STUDENT because it was not the least restrictive environment (LRE) and it did not implement his District IEP. Laguna further contends that STUDENT's teacher did not have a special education credential and that STUDENT's test scores did not improve during that portion of the fourth grade that he attended Prentice. When considering the appropriateness of parents' placement of their child for purposes of reimbursement, parents are not held to the same standard as that of a district. Parents are not required to obtain the best possible private placement to be entitled to reimbursement. Their choice must be designed to meet the student's unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, (supra)
The testimony of Ms. Jarvis, the director of Prentice, established that Prentice is a certified nonpublic school that is designed to meet the needs of children with visual and auditory processing disorders. Although Ms. Respess, STUDENT's fourth grade teacher, was not a credentialed special education teacher, she had received extensive training in the "Slingerland" multi-sensory teaching method. The Slingerland program is intended for use with students who have processing difficulties. It utilizes each of the body's senses and it is integrated throughout the school day at Prentice. According to the testimony of Dr. Patterson and several of the District's witnesses, STUDENT required a multi-sensory method to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT's needs included such an educational approach. The Hearing Officer was impressed with Ms. Respess' explanation and knowledge of a multi-sensory program. Although she was not credentialed as a special education teacher, she was well trained in a teaching method that met STUDENT's needs and provided him with educational benefit.
The testimony of Ms. Jarvis and Ms. Respess also proved that STUDENT's need for a small class was met. Each class at Prentice has approximately fifteen students and the teacher is assisted by an aide. The District's contention that Prentice did not fully implement the IEP as written by the District for STUDENT's fourth grade year is not persuasive and it does not render Prentice an inappropriate placement. The Hearing Officer has previously found that the District's IEP was inadequate to meet STUDENT's unique needs. Thus, implementing the IEP as it was written would not have been beneficial to STUDENT.
The District argues that Prentice was a more restrictive environment. Arguably, Mr. and Mrs.
PARENT placed STUDENT in a more restricted environment by enrolling him in a private school where he is surrounded with children who also have learning disabilities. However, the Hearing Officer accepts the testimony of Dr. Patterson and the parents that STUDENT's psychological status necessitated a placement where he did not see himself as a failure around his peers and where his self-esteem was not further damaged. Dr. Patterson also testified that the nonpublic school was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT because he required the structure and integrated programs imposed by Prentice School. Due to his failure in public school, STUDENT was in a fragile emotional state when he was transferred to Prentice. Dr. Paterson stated that being around children who have the same type of disability was helpful to his self-esteem because he did not feel unsuccessful when he compared himself to all of the other students.
Finally, that each of STUDENT's standardized test scores did not immediately improve does not convince the Hearing Officer that Prentice was an inappropriate placement. STUDENT transferred to Prentice with emotional difficulties. It took time for him to adjust to a new environment and new educational methods. He also needed to improve his low self-esteem and begin to feel capable of learning again. As acknowledged by the District following its 1998 assessments, STUDENT made substantial progress over the course of his time at Prentice. Dr. Patterson and the Prentice personnel testified that Prentice used the Slingerland method, an integrated approach utilizing "hear it, see it, say it, do it," which was beneficial to STUDENT. In June 1996, STUDENT scored the following grade equivalencies: Woodcock Reading Mastery, Word Identification-2.3, Word Attack-1.8; Morrison-McCall Spelling 3.1. One year later, in June 1997, the same tests resulted in grade equivalencies of 3.8 (reading), 2.6 (word identification) and 3.3 (spelling). The same tests were administered in June 1998 with grade equivalencies of 4.2 (reading) , 3.7 (word attack) and 4.2 (spelling). After attending Prentice for two years, STUDENT had made approximately two years of growth in reading and spelling. Moreover, educational benefit is not determined by looking only to standardized test scores. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley, (supra) Certainly the testimony of his parents and teacher that he was learning to read, improving academically and mending emotionally establishes the educational benefit that was conferred upon STUDENT by his placement at Prentice.
Prentice offered STUDENT appropriate instruction to meet his needs during each of the school years. The testimony of Ms. Jarvis, Ms. Respess, Dr. Patterson and Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, as well as STUDENT's classroom performance, test results and report cards, establishes that STUDENT made progress at Prentice during his years of attendance. The District also acknowledged that STUDENT's assessment results improved between the last time it evaluated him in the third grade and its current reevaluation. The testimony of STUDENT's mother regarding his improved emotional condition was particularly compelling. Mrs. PARENT told of STUDENT's improved mood and self-esteem. Each evening was no longer filled with tears and frustration over his inability to understand his homework. He could complete his homework on his own and felt good about his accomplishments. He returned to sleeping in his own bedroom, and the nightmares and sleepwalking ceased. He no longer attempted to avoid school by feigning illness. Mrs. PARENT also testified that he began to read. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program STUDENT received at Prentice was designed to provide him with educational benefit. The parents are entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and transportation costs resulting from STUDENT's placement at Prentice for the 1995-96, 1996-97, and 1997-98 school years. They are entitled to reimbursement for the tuition for the 1998- 99 school year because the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE at the November 1998 IEP meeting, nor did it offer a FAPE thereafter.
The District also argues that reimbursement should not be awarded because the parents delayed too long in filing for due process and it was prejudiced by this delay through the loss of witnesses. This contention is not persuasive. The duty to "search and serve" is imposed upon school districts; parents do not have a duty to seek out services. California Education Code §56300. This is not a case where a child withdrew from school and the District had no practical way of knowing that the family remained residents of the district. Laguna had actual knowledge that STUDENT was a special education student who resided within its boundaries. His brother attended a District school and his mother was a District employee. In addition, its personnel had been advised that STUDENT was leaving the District school because he was not progressing academically. The parents provided uncontroverted testimony that they informed STUDENT's substitute teacher where STUDENT was going and why he was changing schools. That same day they also told STUDENT's RSP teacher and the principal that STUDENT was transferring to Prentice. They later visited STUDENT's class when his assigned teacher returned, and told her and the students that STUDENT was going to another school because he learned in a different way and his new school would help him. The teacher mailed cards from the students to STUDENT's home. Mrs. Purrington, the elementary school principal, testified that Mrs. PARENT continued to participate in school activities and she later saw Mrs. PARENT on the campus. She told Mrs. PARENT that she was sorry that STUDENT had left and that he was welcome to return to the school at any time. The District also responded to a records request from Prentice and forwarded STUDENT's educational records to the nonpublic school. Thus, it was provided with written notice of the actual location of STUDENT's new school. These facts provide substantial evidence that the District knew both STUDENT's home and school addresses. At any time, the District could have limited its exposure for tuition and related costs by convening an IEP meeting and offering STUDENT a FAPE. It did not do so despite its obligation to provide services to all special education students residing within its geographical area. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may also be considered when determining whether parents are entitled to reimbursement following a unilateral placement in a nonpublic school. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 96 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir, 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). The equities in this case weigh in favor of the parents. The District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE. After he was placed in a nonpublic school, Laguna made no effort to convene an IEP or offer special education services despite its actual and constructive knowledge that STUDENT remained a resident of its district. Had it wanted to minimize its financial exposure or avoid losing its witnesses to the passage of time, it could have requested an assessment, initiated an IEP meeting or, if necessary, filed for a due process hearing.
Amount of reimbursement for tuition and transportation
Mrs. PARENT testified that they had paid Prentice $7,061.12 in tuition for the 1995-96 school year. The tuition costs for the 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years were $9,800.00, $10,900.00 and $11,000.00, respectively. They also paid an enrollment fee of $150.00 for each of the above school years. The Petitioner is entitled to tuition and cost reimbursement for the 1995-96 through the 1998-99 school years, inclusive, for a total sum of $38,761.12. The petitioner also claims reimbursement for the cost of school uniforms in the sum of $500.00 per year for a total amount of $2000.00. There was no evidence presented that uniforms were mandatory at Prentice. Moreover, school clothes are necessary for every student. The sum of $500.00 per year is within the anticipated cost of school clothes regardless of the school attended. Thus, reimbursement for uniforms is not awarded to the Petitioner.
The testimony established that it was 50 miles per round trip from the Petitioner's home to Prentice. This round trip to drop off and pick up the Petitioner was made two times each school day for 180 school days per year. The petitioner is therefore entitled to reimbursement for transportation costs at the established District rate of $.32 per mile, in the total sum of $5760.00 per year (180 school days per year x mileage for two round trips per day, 100 miles x $.32 per mile) for a total of $23,040.00.
CONCLUSION
The Hearing Officer has determined that the District did not meet STUDENT's unique needs or offer a FAPE for the school years of 1995-96, 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99. His unilateral placement at Prentice was appropriate and satisfied the duty to provide an appropriate education which is imposed upon parents as a prerequisite to receiving retroactive reimbursement.
ORDER
1. The Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for tuition and costs for the school years of 1995- 96, 1996-97, 1997-98 and 1998-99 in the sum of $38,761.12. The District shall reimburse the parents this sum within thirty days of the date of this decision.
2. The Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for transportation costs in the sum of $23,040.00. The District shall reimburse the parents this sum within thirty days of the date of this decision.
3. The Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of school uniforms.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).
Dated:_________________________ _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Footnotes 1. Both parties presented substantial evidence regarding STUDENT's education in kindergarten, first, second and third grades. The Hearing Officer acknowledges this information for its historical assistance in understanding STUDENT's disability. However, this evidence will be considered only as it relates to determining whether the District provided a FAPE during the years that are within the applicable three-year statute of limitations. Alexopulos v. San Francisco Unified School District, (9th Cir.1987) 2. Although this IEP document indicates a visual processing problem, the above tests, and those conducted thereafter, are more consistent with the later finding of an auditory processing disorder. It therefore appears that STUDENT's auditory processing deficit was erroneously entered as a visual processing deficit. 3. On June 4, 1997, the amended IDEA went into effect (IDEA 1997). The Petitioner's issues relating to the 1995-96 and 1996-97 school years arose prior to the enactment of the IDEA 1997. The Hearing Officer will therefore apply the law that was in effect at the time the disputed events occurred in compliance with the general rules pertaining to the retroactivity of laws. Landgraff v. USI Film Products, 511 U.S. 244 (1994). 4. Although it was not specified at the hearing, FEMA presumably refers to the Federal Emergency Management Agency. 5. The IDEA 97 also authorizes states to adopt provisions reducing or denying tuition reimbursement when parents fail to provide a ten-day notice of their intent to place their child in a nonpublic school. However, California did not impose this notice requirement on parents until January 1, 1999, after the Petitioner's IEP. Therefore, the Petitioner was not required to provide the District with notice of his intent to remain at Prentice. At all relevant times, he had greater procedural rights under the State law. States may provide procedural standards for parents and children that are more protective than federal standards. David D. v. Dartmouth, 775 F.2d 411 (1985); Geis v. Board of Education Parsippany Troy Hills, 77 F.2d 574 (1985). 6. The RSP assessor also testified that STUDENT had difficulty with math. No math assistance was offered by the District. The testimony established that if STUDENT needed math help, it could be added through an aide-supported math class. However, this could only be provided outside regular school hours during a "zero period." 7. The RSP assessor also testified that STUDENT had difficulty with math. No math assistance was offered by the District. The testimony established that if STUDENT needed math help, it could be added through an aide-supported math class. However, this could only be provided outside regular school hours during a "zero period."
