California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 18, 2003
Student v. Redlands Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 953-03 · Hearing Officer Joy Redmon
Redlands Unified must rescind an eighth grader's expulsion, find her eligible as other health impaired, and reimburse one private assessment.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Child find and FAPE claims for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years were bifurcated and taken off calendar pending this decision; either party could ask the Hearing Office to place them back on calendar.
Summary
A mother filed for an expedited hearing after Redlands Unified expelled her 13-year-old eighth grader from Cope Middle School. The student had never been found eligible for special education. She had failing grades and about 45 office referrals. Her mother had told school staff about a depression diagnosis and had given the school a form asking it to give her medication. After the January 2003 suspension, the mother asked for an assessment. The District school psychologist found the student not eligible, and the IEP team agreed. A private psychiatrist then diagnosed attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Claims about earlier school years were split off for later.
The Hearing Officer found the student eligible as other health impaired. Credible private experts showed that her ADHD limited her alertness and vitality in class and caused her failing grades, even though her test scores were average. Informal classroom changes, which her counselor called an "unofficial 504 plan," had not worked, so she needed special education. She was eligible when suspended, and the District had a "basis of knowledge" of a possible disability, so the expulsion was rescinded. The psychiatrist's evaluation was done before the mother disagreed with the District's assessment, so it was not reimbursed. The District's assessment was inappropriate because it used no ADHD screening tool despite high attention and hyperactivity ratings. The District must pay for the private psychologist's evaluation and hold an IEP meeting within 20 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied the 1997 IDEA "basis of knowledge" rule to a student who was never identified as eligible. Years of failing grades, many discipline referrals, and written notice of a diagnosis supported rescinding the expulsion. It also shows that skipping an ADHD screening tool despite red-flag rating scores made an assessment inappropriate.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is Student eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired as a student with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder?
Student's ADHD caused limited alertness and vitality that adversely affected her grades, and failed informal modifications showed she needed special education; she is eligible as other health impaired.
- Student prevailedDiscipline
Issue 2. Must the District rescind Student's expulsion because she was a child with a disability at the time she was suspended and ultimately expelled from school?
Student was eligible when suspended on January 30, 2003, and the District had a basis of knowledge of a possible disability, so the expulsion imposed without IDEA protections must be rescinded.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg?
The District assessment was inappropriate because it did not screen for ADHD, so Dr. Greenberg's assessment is reimbursed; Dr. Corman's evaluation was obtained before the parent disagreed with the District assessment and is not reimbursed.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Student's expulsion by Redlands Unified School District is rescinded.
- Declaration that Student was eligible for special education and related services as other health impaired on January 30, 2003, when she was suspended for the conduct that led to her March 27, 2003 expulsion.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop and implement an IEP that addresses all of Student's needs, including her depression and behavior needs.
- Reimbursement. Mother must submit proof of payment for Dr. Greenberg's independent assessment within 20 calendar days of the decision; the District must reimburse within 20 calendar days of receiving proof of payment. Amount not stated.
- Student may file a written request with the District superintendent under Education Code section 49070 to remove any reference to the expulsion from her school records.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1415(k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527; Cal. Educ. Code § 56339; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5
People named in the decision
- Cheryl Sjostrom, director of special education, Redlands Unified School District
- Gail Lindberg, SELPA program manager; District representative at hearing, Special education local plan area
- Phillip Simpson, math teacher, Cope Middle School
- Scott Reynolds, science teacher, Cope Middle School
- Diana Cilmi, intervention/math skills review teacher, Cope Middle School
- John Swift, English teacher, Cope Middle School
- Frank Spaeth, school counselor, Cope Middle School
- Mike Munoz, assistant principal, Cope Middle School
- Mr. Snellings, director of student welfare and attendance, Redlands Unified School District
- Catharine Siglow, school psychologist, Redlands Unified School District
- Ms. Pietrzak, sixth grade teacher (BASC rater), Redlands Unified School District
- Darielle Greenberg, PsyD, private psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student
- Clifford Corman, M.D., child psychiatrist; private evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Robert Gordon, M.D., treating psychiatrist
- Carol Eyster, private psychologist/therapist
- Loma Linda Behavioral Medical Center, private outpatient treatment program
- Ellen Keller, R.N., nurse, Loma Linda Behavioral Medical Center
- Mr. Silva, treatment provider, Loma Linda Behavioral Medical Center
- Don Gonzales, attorney for Student
- My Huynn, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
- Terry Ohler, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. The matter proceeded to hearing in Redlands, California, on May 29-30 and June 3-4, 2003.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Don Gonzales. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER. Respondent Redlands Unified School District (District) was represented by Gail Lindberg, program manager for the special education local plan area. Also present on the District’s behalf was Cheryl Sjostrom, director of special education. Hearing Officers My Huynn and Terry Ohler were present to observe at different times throughout the hearing.
The following witnesses were called to testify: Cheryl Sjostrom, director of special education; Phillip Simpson, math teacher; Scott Reynolds, science teacher; Diana Cilmi, intervention math teacher; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Darielle Greenberg, private psychologist; Clifford Corman M.D., child psychiatrist; Frank Spaeth, school counselor; John Swift, English teacher; Mike Munoz, assistant principal; and Catharine Siglow, school psychologist.
The parties made oral closing arguments on the last day of hearing. Thereafter, the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
Issue 1 Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired as a student with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder?
Issue 2 Must the District rescind STUDENT’s expulsion because she was a child with a disability at the time she was suspended and ultimately expelled from school?
Issue 3 Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg?
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
At the time of the hearing, STUDENT had been expelled from school for two months, but had been suspended from school pending expulsion since January of 2003. Because Petitioner raised issues regarding a basis of knowledge prior to disciplinary action being taken by the District, the matter was deemed expedited. In addition to the issues identified above, Petitioner also asserted that the District failed in its search and serve obligations and denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years.
After a discussion with the parties regarding the issues, the Hearing Officer bifurcated the issues relating to the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years from the expedited case. The parties agreed to proceed to hearing on the expedited issues and to take the bifurcated issues off calendar pending a decision on the issues herein. The Hearing Officer informed the parties that after a decision is rendered, if either party desires to place the remaining issues back on calendar, they will have to contact the Special Education Hearing Office. If either party does choose to place the matter back on calendar, the Hearing Officer strongly encourages the parties to participate in mediation prior to holding a second hearing.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen-year-old eighth grade student who has never been found eligible for special education services. STUDENT was enrolled in the District in 2000 as a sixth grade student. STUDENT attended Cope Middle School from the time she entered the District until her expulsion. STUDENT was expelled on March 27, 2003, at the end of her eighth grade year, for an incident that occurred on January 30, 2003. During the incident, STUDENT confronted another student in a loud and threatening manner, shouted obscenities and made threats against the other girl, and caused a disturbance during the lunch period.
Immediately following the incident, STUDENT was suspended for five days and a pre-expulsion meeting was scheduled. Michael Munoz, assistant principal at Cope, explained that the reason he elected to pursue expulsion was that STUDENT had a history of failing to comply with school rules. According to Mr. Munoz, STUDENT had previously proven that she was capable of following directions, but chose not to follow them. Mr. Munoz explained that several attempts were made to assist STUDENT with her behavior, including the implementation of a behavior contract in October of 2002.
A pre-expulsion meeting was held on February 6, 2003. Present at the meeting were STUDENT, MOTHER, Mr. Munoz, and Mr. Snellings, District director of student welfare and attendance. Mr. Munoz explained that there are two possible outcomes of a pre-expulsion meeting: the student will either be referred to a panel for expulsion or returned to school on a stricter behavior contract. According to Mr. Munoz, it is common for students to receive a stricter behavior contract at their first pre-expulsion meeting. Prior to the meeting, STUDENT had written Mr. Munoz a letter apologizing for the incident and requesting to return to school. Mr. Munoz testified that before the meeting he and Mr. Snellings agreed that STUDENT would likely receive a stricter behavior contract and return to school. However, during the meeting STUDENT became defensive and did not express regret over the incident. MOTHER, who was asked to sit behind STUDENT and out of her line of vision, explained that she saw STUDENT “unravel” in front of her eyes. During the meeting, Mr. Snellings told STUDENT that because of her attitude he was recommending that STUDENT be expelled. Mr. Munoz testified that STUDENT was not disrespectful, but that her attitude during the meeting changed his mind and that he agreed with Mr. Snellings’s recommendation. STUDENT was then referred to a panel for an expulsion hearing.
On February 14, 2003, MOTHER sent three letters to the District. MOTHER sent a letter to Mr. Spaeth, STUDENT’s counselor, requesting a referral for mental health counseling for STUDENT and requesting that STUDENT’s teachers send home school work for STUDENT during her suspension. MOTHER did not receive a response. MOTHER also sent a letter to Ms. Sjostrom, director of special education, requesting a full educational evaluation for eligibility for special education. MOTHER attached a document from STUDENT’s treating psychiatrist, Robert Gordon M.D., that stated STUDENT suffers from anxiety and major depression and possibly ADHD. The letter also informed Ms. Sjostrom that STUDENT had been treated once a week for three years by private psychologist Carol Eyster. Finally, the letter indicated that STUDENT and MOTHER were participating in an intensive outpatient program at Loma Linda Behavioral Medical Center. Attached to the letter was a note from Ellen Keller, R.N., that stated Loma Linda was working with STUDENT on her psychiatric issues that lead to her possible expulsion from school. The third letter from MOTHER was to Mr. Snellings. MOTHER requested that the expulsion hearing be postponed pending an IEP eligibility determination. The expulsion hearing was postponed. From the time STUDENT was suspended up through her expulsion hearing, the District did not provide any educational services to STUDENT, who remained at home.
The District prepared an assessment plan on February 20, 2003, and MOTHER signed it giving consent on March 4, 2003 for STUDENT to be assessed by the District. The District intended to assess STUDENT’s eligibility for special education under the categories of emotionally disturbed, specific learning disabled, and other health impaired. Prior to conducting its assessments of STUDENT, the District held a student study team (SST) meeting on March 7, 2003. Present at the SST meeting were STUDENT, MOTHER, Mr. Reynolds (science teacher), Mr. Simpson (math teacher), Mr. Swift (English teacher), Ms. Cilmi (math skills review teacher), Mr. Spaeth, and school psychologist, Catharine Siglow. The SST members reviewed STUDENT’s first semester grades. STUDENT had an “F” in English, social studies, algebra, and science. She earned a “D-” in physical education and a “C” in math skills review. STUDENT’s grade point average for the semester was a 0.50 with an overall middle school grade point average of 0.87.
According to Ms. Siglow, STUDENT’s teachers reported that STUDENT is intelligent, that she understands and retains ideas well, that she has excellent writing skills, and that she is capable of higher-order thinking. Ms. Siglow explained that of major concern to her teachers was STUDENT’s defiant behavior in class. Additionally, they stated that at times, STUDENT could be extremely rude and hurtful to others, that she was very impulsive, and that she blurted out both positive and negative comments in class. Unanimously, STUDENT’s teachers reported that she frequently spent class time writing notes to friends and that she rarely turned in homework assignments. The team developed strategies for STUDENT to help her if she returned to school after the expulsion hearing.
After the SST meeting, the District conducted its assessments of STUDENT. She was seen by school psychologist Catharine Siglow on March 19, 20, and 21. MOTHER signed a release of information for Ms. Siglow to speak with STUDENT’s health care providers. Ms. Siglow spoke with STUDENT’s private therapist, Ms. Eyster, and Mr. Silva, who was working with STUDENT at Loma Linda. Ms. Siglow also communicated with Dr. Gordon via letter. According to Ms. Siglow, Ms. Eyster revealed that she had been counseling STUDENT and her mom for three years regarding family issues but that progress was very slow. Mr. Silva told Ms. Siglow that STUDENT was considered to be at risk for developing drug and alcohol problems. Dr. Gordon completed a form requested by Ms. Siglow. On that form, Dr. Gordon indicated that STUDENT was diagnosed with major depression and possible ADHD.
Ms. Siglow administered several assessments and rating scales to STUDENT.(Footnote 1) After Ms. Siglow met with STUDENT but before she prepared her report, and before an IEP meeting was held, the District conducted STUDENT’s expulsion hearing. An administrative panel voted to expel STUDENT on March 27, 2003. After STUDENT was expelled, the District began to send a home instructor to work with STUDENT one hour per day, five days per week.
On April 3, 2003, Ms. Siglow prepared a written report containing her findings. Regarding a specific learning disability, Ms. Siglow determined that STUDENT did not have a severe discrepancy between her cognitive ability and academic achievement. Both STUDENT’s cognitive ability and achievement scores were in the average range. Additionally, Ms. Siglow completed a lengthy analysis of STUDENT’s eligibility as emotionally disturbed resulting from her diagnosis of depression. Regarding depression specifically, Ms. Siglow concluded that, “medication in combination with the therapeutic process at Behavioral Medicine are felt by this examiner to probably be appropriate interventions for STUDENT’s feelings of depression at this point in time. It is certainly felt by the school staff and this examiner that placement in the special education program would probably not help STUDENT feel more positively about herself or her life situation.” Moreover, Ms. Siglow determined that STUDENT was capable of learning in a regular education environment as evidenced by her average scores on standardized tests. Ms. Siglow concluded that, in her opinion, STUDENT was not eligible for special education as a student with an emotional disturbance. Ms. Siglow’s report does not contain an analysis of whether or not STUDENT was eligible as other health impaired. Additionally, there is no specific analysis regarding STUDENT’s possible ADHD. Ms. Siglow’s report does indicate that STUDENT would be eligible for modifications and accommodations to her program under a section 504 plan. No 504 plan was ever developed.
STUDENT’s IEP meeting was held on April 9, 2003. The notes from the meeting indicate that the IEP team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education under any category. MOTHER testified that she discussed her concerns regarding STUDENT’s possible diagnosis of ADHD with the team. According to Ms. Siglow, while STUDENT did exhibit some behaviors consistent with ADHD, Ms. Siglow’s overall conclusion was that STUDENT more likely was socially maladjusted rather than a child with ADHD. MOTHER signed the IEP indicating her participation but dissenting with the IEP team’s decision.
MOTHER obtained two independent evaluations to determine if STUDENT had ADHD and whether or not she qualified for special education as other health impaired. On April 8, 2003, STUDENT was seen by child psychiatrist Clifford Corman M.D.. The purpose of Dr. Corman’s evaluation was to determine if STUDENT had ADHD. Dr. Corman explained that he conducted an initial interview with structured questions. He then administered a questionnaire based on diagnostic criteria for ADHD as outlined in the DSM-IV. STUDENT’s results on the questionnaire revealed that STUDENT likely had ADHD, combined type. However, according to Dr. Corman, oppositional defiant disorder (ODD) and ADHD may manifest in similar ways. To determine if STUDENT had ADHD, Dr. Corman administered, over multiple sittings, the Test of Variable Attention (TOVA). According to Dr. Corman, the test is used to titrate stimulants for the purpose of determining attention issues and proper medication levels in children. The TOVA is administered once to determine a baseline of brain functioning. Then the subject is given different doses of generic adderall to determine if his or her brain functioning can be brought within a normal range. According to Dr. Corman, if a person responds to medication, he or she has ADD or ADHD rather than ODD, because a person with ODD will not vary from his or her baseline TOVA scores even with medication. STUDENT responded to the medication and Dr. Corman diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD, combined type.
Once STUDENT was diagnosed with ADHD, MOTHER decided to have a private psychological evaluation done to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. On April 12, 2003, STUDENT was seen by Darielle Greenberg, PsyD.. Dr. Greenberg reviewed Ms. Siglow’s report, reviewed Dr. Corman’s medical records regarding STUDENT, and administered several assessments.(Footnote 2) Dr. Greenberg completed an analysis regarding eligibility for other health impaired. Dr. Greenberg determined that STUDENT meets the criteria for other health impaired and should be found eligible for special education and related services.
After these independent assessments were completed, MOTHER filed a request for a due process hearing seeking a determination that STUDENT is eligible for special education as other health impaired and an order rescinding STUDENT’s expulsion.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue 1 Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired as a student with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder?
Under both State law and the federal IDEA, children with disabilities have the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A). A student is eligible for special education and related services when, as a result of the student’s disability, the student requires instruction, services, or both, which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56502(a) and (b).
STUDENT argues that she is eligible as other health impaired because of her diagnosis of ADHD. The law clearly provides that a student with ADHD is eligible for special education only if the student with ADHD also meets the eligibility criteria for other health impaired, emotionally disturbed, or specific learning disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56339. A student meets the eligibility criteria for OHI when the student has a condition that is not temporary, that causes limited strength, vitality, or alertness, and that adversely affects the student’s educational performance. Cal. Code of Regs. title 5 § 3030(f).
To summarize, the Hearing Officer must determine whether or not STUDENT meets the criteria for OHI. If she does, Education Code section 56339 also requires that the Hearing Officer determine if STUDENT demonstrates a need for special education and related services.
The District does not dispute Dr. Corman’s diagnosis that STUDENT has ADHD. The District argues that her ADHD does not result in limited strength, vitality, or alertness, and that any adverse affects to STUDENT’s educational performance are within her control to change.
Does STUDENT’s ADHD cause her limited strength, vitality, or alertness?
As noted above, the parties do not dispute that STUDENT has ADHD and that the condition is chronic. The Hearing Officer must then determine whether or not this chronic condition results in STUDENT’s having limited strength, vitality, or alertness. According to STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. Cilmi, Mr. Reynolds, and Mr. Simpson, STUDENT does not appear to have limited vitality or alertness in class. On the contrary, Mr. Reynolds and Mr. Simpson both testified that STUDENT is constantly focused on writing notes to her friends and attempting to socialize in class.
Private psychologist Dr. Greenberg explained that the behaviors reported by STUDENT’s teachers are very common with ADHD children. According to Dr. Greenberg, the term “limited alertness” for STUDENT means that her heightened alertness to environmental stimuli causes distractibility which results in limited alertness to the educational environment. Dr. Corman testified that, consistent with most untreated ADHD children, STUDENT is able to sustain alertness on tasks of high interest, including socializing, writing notes, and certain academic assignments. However, STUDENT is unable to sustain alertness or to attend to work that does not strongly appeal to her. Dr. Corman also testified that when STUDENT was properly medicated during an administration of the TOVA, she was more alert and able to attend to academic tasks.(Footnote 3)
Dr. Greenberg is a psychologist in private practice who assessed STUDENT after she was diagnosed with ADHD. Dr. Greenberg explained that having the proper diagnosis was important in determining how STUDENT’s symptoms were manifesting. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Greenberg a credible witness who is knowledgeable about ADHD generally and about STUDENT in particular. Dr. Corman is a psychiatrist specializing in the treatment of children with attention issues. Dr. Corman has worked with the FAMILY family previously, having seen STUDENT’s older brother for attention issues. Dr. Corman spent a significant amount of time with STUDENT over several sessions. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Corman a credible witness who is knowledgeable about STUDENT’s ADHD and about the manifestation of attention issues in children.
No District witness testified that STUDENT was alert to the educational environment, only that she was very alert to environmental stimuli. In light of the credible testimony of Dr. Greenberg and Dr. Corman regarding STUDENT’s limited alertness to the educational environment, and no credible evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD causes her to have limited alertness in the educational environment.
In addition to limited alertness, Dr. Corman testified that STUDENT has limited vitality. Prior to becoming a patient of Dr. Corman’s, STUDENT was seen by child psychiatrist Dr. Gordon. Dr. Gordon had diagnosed STUDENT with Axis 1 major depression and began treating her for depression. Dr. Gordon’s medical records reveal that during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years, STUDENT was on a variety of medications including paxil, xanex, prozac, and effexor. According to MOTHER, these medications did not improve STUDENT’s depression or reduce her undesirable behaviors. Dr. Corman testified that Dr. Gordon was treating one of STUDENT’s symptoms, but not treating her problem.
Dr. Corman testified that STUDENT’s untreated ADHD manifested in external negative behaviors. STUDENT received negative attention as a result of her behaviors. This situation repeated itself over and over again, which ultimately lead to STUDENT developing major depression. According to Dr. Corman, the likely reason STUDENT did not respond to the depression medication is that depression, in STUDENT, was merely another manifestation of her ADHD as opposed to an independent illness. Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg both testified that STUDENT’s depression caused her to have limited vitality. The testimony of STUDENT’s English teacher Mr. Swift was consistent with that of Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg. Mr. Swift testified that STUDENT frequently attempted to and actually did fall asleep in class. Mr. Swift said he had to wake STUDENT up and require that she keep her head up.
In light of the testimony of Dr. Greenberg, Dr. Corman, and Mr. Swift, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s chronic medical condition of ADHD caused her to have limited vitality at school.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD caused her limited vitality and alertness.
Does STUDENT’s ADHD adversely affect her educational performance?
It is undisputed that for the first semester of the current school year, STUDENT had a grade point average of .50, earning an “F” in science, English, algebra, and social studies. It is also undisputed that STUDENT’s overall grade point average during her three years at Cope is .87. The District’s position is that STUDENT’s refusal to complete her assignments is willful and that if she put forth effort, she would have all passing grades. In support of its position, the District argues that STUDENT’s ADHD does not adversely affect her educational performance as evidenced by her standardized test score on the WJ-III.(Footnote 4) Ms. Siglow testified that STUDENT’s academic scores on the WJ-III put her solidly within the average range and revealed that virtually no discrepancy existed between her cognitive ability and achievement level. Ms. Siglow testified that this evidenced STUDENT’s potential to perform academically and supported the teachers’ conclusions that STUDENT chose not to work to her potential at school.
Dr. Corman testified that it is not uncommon for STUDENT, a student with untreated ADHD, to have failing grades. It is also not uncommon, according to Dr. Corman, for educators to believe that poor academic performance is willful. Each of STUDENT’s teachers testified that she is very intelligent, but rarely turns in homework and other out-of-class assignments. Dr. Corman explained that the failure to turn in assignments is a hallmark of ADHD. According to Dr. Corman, ADHD impairs a person’s ability to plan and organize thoughts. It is consistent, therefore, that STUDENT had difficulty turning in assignments. According to MOTHER, many assignments that STUDENT failed to turn in she had actually completed. There is no logical reason, according to Dr. Corman, for STUDENT not to have turned in completed assignments but for her ADHD. Dr. Corman explained that STUDENT’s WJ-III scores establish that she has the potential to perform well academically, while her grades demonstrate that her ADHD has prevented her from translating her ability into consistent academic achievement in the classroom.
In light of the persuasive testimony of Dr. Corman and STUDENT’s consistent history of failing grades, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s ADHD adversely affects her educational performance.
In summary, as found above, STUDENT is a student with ADHD, a chronic illness, that has caused her to have limited vitality and alertness which adversely affects her educational performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT meets the criteria of other health impaired.
Does STUDENT demonstrate a need for special education and related services?
As noted above, a pupil with ADHD who meets the criteria for OHI must also demonstrate a need for special education and related services. Cal. Educ. Code §§56026 and 56339.
The District argues that even if STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for OHI, she is still not eligible for special education because her needs can be met with modifications to the regular education program with a section 504 plan. The evidence does not support this conclusion.
Mr. Spaeth was STUDENT’s middle school counselor. He has worked with STUDENT in an effort to improve her academic performance and classroom behavior for the last three years. Mr. Spaeth testified that he probably knows STUDENT better than anyone else at school. Mr. Spaeth testified that in an effort to assist STUDENT, he worked with her teachers to develop modifications to her program. Mr. Spaeth even described these modifications as an “unofficial 504 plan.” These modifications or interventions included STUDENT’s being seated in the middle or front of the classroom, sitting in close proximity to the teacher, verbal prompts to return to task, a modified math curriculum, a review class to assist with homework completion, weekly progress reports, and frequent contacts with MOTHER. Each of STUDENT’s teachers testified that they implemented these modifications in their respective classes, but with only minimal and temporary or no success.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District has attempted modifications to STUDENT’s general education program with no improvement in her grades or behavior. The Hearing Officer further finds that in light of STUDENT’s academic performance and the failure of the implemented modifications to improve her academics or behavior, STUDENT has demonstrated a need for special education and related services. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services as a student who is other health impaired as a result of ADHD.
Issue 2 Must the District rescind STUDENT’s expulsion because she was a child with a disability at the time she was suspended and ultimately expelled from school?
Under federal and State special education law, students found eligible for special education are accorded certain rights in disciplinary matters. Among those rights is the right to a determination of whether the student’s misconduct arose from either a disability or an improper educational placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(4); Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5(a). The Hearing Officer determined above at the time STUDENT was suspended from school in January of 2003, she was eligible for special education and related services. In light of the determination regarding STUDENT’s eligibility, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s expulsion must be rescinded because the District expelled STUDENT without providing her the various protections she was entitled to under the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer notes that even though STUDENT had not yet been assessed for special education eligibility, at the time the District took disciplinary action against STUDENT it was on notice that she was potentially a student with a disability. In 1997, Congress amended the IDEA to extend the protections afforded to eligible students to some students not previously identified as eligible for special education and related services. 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(8); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527. These protections are extended to students not previously identified as eligible for special education services if the following factors are met: (1) the student has engaged in behavior that violated a rule or code of conduct of the school district, and (2) the school district had knowledge, or is deemed to have had knowledge, that the student was a child with a disability “before the behavior that precipitated the disciplinary action occurred.” 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(8)(A).
The foregoing “basis of knowledge” or “deemed” knowledge exists when (1) the parent of the child expresses concern in writing to personnel of the appropriate educational agency that the child may be in need of special education; (2) the behavior or the performance of the child demonstrates a possible need for such services; (3) the parent of the child has requested an evaluation; or (4) the teacher of the child or other personnel expressed concern about the behavior of the child to the director of special education or other personnel of the local educational agency. 20 U.S.C. § 1415 (k)(8)(B); 34 C.F.R. § 300.527(b).
In this case, the District had a “basis of knowledge” that STUDENT was a child with a disability prior to her expulsion because MOTHER expressed concern in writing to Mr. Spaeth regarding STUDENT’s medical diagnosis of depression and possible ADHD and because her behavior and academic performance demonstrated a possible need for special education services.
MOTHER testified that she had several conversations with Mr. Spaeth regarding STUDENT’s behavior at school. According to both MOTHER and Mr. Spaeth, MOTHER told him that STUDENT had been diagnosed with depression. In May of 2002, eight months prior to the incident that caused STUDENT’s expulsion, MOTHER submitted a health services form to the District giving permission for the school to give STUDENT xanax for depression each day at noon. The Hearing Officer finds that in light of the conversations between MOTHER and Mr. Spaeth regarding STUDENT’s diagnosed depression, coupled with the letter requesting that the school dispense medication to treat STUDENT for depression, MOTHER expressed concern in writing to personnel of the appropriate educational agency that STUDENT was in need of special education services.
Additionally, Petitioner argues that the District had knowledge that she was a child with a disability prior to her expulsion because her behavior and academic performance demonstrated a need for special education services. At all times throughout STUDENT’s attendance at Cope, she never had a passing grade point average. STUDENT’s dismal academic performance continued during the first semester of eighth grade with a grade point average of .50. As discussed above, all of STUDENT’s teachers implemented modifications and accommodations to assist STUDENT with her academics, with no benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s academic performance demonstrated a possible need for special education services. A review of STUDENT’s behavior record is replete with incidents establishing the need to investigate whether or not STUDENT was a child with a disability. During her attendance at Cope, STUDENT was referred to the office approximately forty-five times for disciplinary reasons. Multiple parent teacher conferences were held and several behavior contracts signed. MOTHER testified that Mr. Spaeth even suggested STUDENT receive counseling and he gave MOTHER the name of a private psychologist in town.
Despite STUDENT’s history of failing grades and behavior problems in school, no one ever referred STUDENT for a special education assessment. When asked why, the District witnesses continually stated that they believed STUDENT’s behavior and poor academic performance were willful. However, the weight of the evidence does not support their conclusion. STUDENT in fact is a child with a disability. The Hearing Officer finds that, at a minimum, STUDENT’s behavior and academic performance demonstrated a possible need for special education services.
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District knew of STUDENT’s disruptive and inattentive behaviors, her poor academic performance, and her diagnosis of depression and possible ADHD prior to her suspension and eventual expulsion. Therefore, the District had a basis of knowledge at the time STUDENT was suspended that she was possibly a child with a disability. As such, STUDENT was entitled to the protections extended under the IDEA, including the right to remain in her then current placement pending a determination regarding her eligibility for special education.
In summary, the District must rescind STUDENT’s expulsion because she was eligible for special education and related services at least as far back as January 30, 2003, the day she was suspended from school. Additionally, the District had a basis of knowledge that she was possibly a student with a disability when it initiated disciplinary action against her without providing her the various protections she was entitled to under the IDEA.
Issue 3 Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg?
Petitioner contends that she is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments conducted by Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg that MOTHER obtained in April of 2002. Petitioner argues that she is entitled to reimbursement because MOTHER disagreed with the educational assessment conducted by Ms. Siglow and because the assessment was not appropriate in that it failed to adequately screen for ADHD. The District argues that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement because the independent assessment by Dr. Corman was obtained prior to MOTHER’s receiving Ms. Siglow’s assessment report and because the District’s assessment was appropriate.
State special education law states that a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a public agency and the agency’s assessment is determined to be inappropriate. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).) Thus, the Hearing Officer must determine whether MOTHER disagreed with the District’s assessment and, if so, whether the District’s assessment was appropriate.
The District asserts that the independent assessment by Dr. Corman was obtained before MOTHER had received Ms. Siglow’s report, and that therefore, MOTHER could not have disagreed with the assessment prior to obtaining an independent assessment. The IEP meeting at which Ms. Siglow presented her report was held on April 9, 2003. STUDENT was seen by Dr. Corman for the first time on April 8, 2003, prior to the IEP meeting where MOTHER received Ms. Siglow’s report. Dr. Corman testified that it was at the initial meeting that he diagnosed STUDENT with ADHD. During subsequent appointments, he readministered the TOVA to titrate her medication, not for the purpose of diagnosis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER did not object to Ms. Siglow’s assessment prior to the time she sought the independent evaluation by Dr. Corman. The Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER is not entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Corman’s assessment.(Footnote 5)
Dr. Greenberg did not evaluate STUDENT until April 12, 2003, after MOTHER received Ms. Siglow’s report. It is undisputed that MOTHER disagreed with Ms. Siglow’s evaluation and that STUDENT was not evaluated by Dr. Greenberg until after the IEP meeting. Therefore, for the purpose of reimbursement, the Hearing Officer must determine only if the District’s evaluation was appropriate.
Petitioner contends that prior to conducting her assessment, Ms. Siglow received Dr. Gordon’s diagnosis that STUDENT suffered from major depression with possible ADHD. Ms. Siglow testified that ADHD is a medical diagnosis that she is not capable of rendering. However, Ms. Siglow did explain that there are certain evaluation instruments that identify attention and impulsive issues consistent with ADHD. Ms. Siglow also testified that there are rating scales that she is able to administer that directly screen for ADHD. Petitioner argues that Ms. Siglow received inconsistent data on certain instruments that required her to investigate further the presence of ADHD.
Ms. Siglow testified that she administered the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale to MOTHER and STUDENT’s English teacher. MOTHER’s report rated as significant poor attention and poor impulse control. STUDENT’s English teacher’s report rated as very significant poor impulse control. Ms. Siglow also administered the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) to MOTHER, STUDENT, and Ms. Cilmi, STUDENT’s math skills teacher. Ms. Siglow administered the BASC to one of STUDENT’s sixth grade teachers, Ms. Pietrzak. Ms. Siglow testified that a T-Score above seventy is a significant area of concern. On MOTHER’s BASC, STUDENT received a T-Score of 98 for hyperactivity and 82 for attention problems. STUDENT’s BASC identified a significant area of concern for sensation seeking. Ms. Cilmi’s BASC identified as significant areas of concern hyperactivity, aggression, and conduct problems. Ms. Pietrzak’s BASC identified only conduct problems as an area of concern.
Ms. Siglow testified that the Burks’ and the BASC, while not diagnostic tools, can be used to identify attention and impulse issues. Additionally, Ms. Siglow explained that the WISC-III has a sub-test called freedom from distractibility. STUDENT obtained a score of 109, within the average range. According to Ms. Siglow, despite the scores on the BASC and Burks’, she felt that no additional assessments were necessary in the area of ADHD. Ms. Siglow testified that in the past she has administered instruments that specifically screen for ADHD, but that she did not with STUDENT. Ms. Siglow found that STUDENT’s scores were consistent with a finding of social maladjustment rather than ADHD.
Dr. Greenberg testified that with the scores showing significant and very significant for poor attention and poor impulse control on the Burks’ and significant T-Scores on the BASC for attention problems, and hyperactivity, further testing was necessary. Dr. Greenberg conducted further assessments and administered the ADHD Symptom Checklist-4. Dr. Greenberg agreed with Ms. Siglow that as psychologists they were prohibited from making a medical diagnosis; however, an instrument like the Symptom Checklist-4 will screen directly for ADHD. Dr. Greenberg administered it to both MOTHER and Ms. Cilmi. Both identified symptoms of ADHD, combined type.
The Hearing Officer finds that in light of STUDENT’s possible diagnosis of ADHD from Dr. Gordon and the scores received on both the Burks’ and the BASC, Ms. Siglow should have administered an instrument that specifically screened for ADHD. The Hearing Officer finds that the failure to administer to STUDENT an ADHD screening instrument was a significant omission that resulted in an inappropriate assessment.
MOTHER disagreed with the District’s assessment because it failed to adequately screen for ADHD. MOTHER obtained an independent educational assessment for STUDENT by Dr. Greenberg. Dr. Greenberg’s assessment screened for ADHD and concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of OHI. The Hearing Officer found above that the District’s assessment was not appropriate. For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Greenberg’s independent assessment.
ORDER
1. STUDENT’s expulsion by the Redlands Unified School District is rescinded.
2. STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as other health impaired on January 30, 2003, when she was suspended for the conduct that led to her expulsion on March 27, 2003.
3. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop and implement an IEP for STUDENT that addresses all of her needs, including her depression, and behavior needs.
4. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, MOTHER must submit proof of payment to the District for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Greenberg.
5. Within twenty calendar days of receiving proof of payment from MOTHER, the District shall reimburse MOTHER for Dr. Greenberg’s assessment.
6. Petitioner may file a written request with the District superintendent pursuant to California Education Code section 49070 if she desires to remove any reference to the expulsion from her school records.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute.
Issue 1 Is STUDENT eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired as a student with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder? - Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2 Must the District rescind STUDENT’s expulsion because she was a child with a disability at the time she was suspended and ultimately expelled from school? -Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3 Is STUDENTR entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments by Dr. Corman and Dr. Greenberg?
-Petitioner and Respondent equally prevailed on this issue because reimbursement was ordered for one assessment.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: June 18, 2003 ____________________________________ Joy Redmon, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Ms. Siglow administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III), the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-III (WJ-III), the Test of Written Language-2 (TOWL-2), the Burks’ Behavior Rating Scale, the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) parent report, self-report, and teacher rating scales, the Differential Test of Conduct and Emotional Problems (DT/CEP), the Roberts Appreciation Test for Children, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III (PPVT-IIIA), the Learning Efficiency Test-II (LET-II), the Bender-Gestalt, and the Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration (VMI).
2. Dr. Greenberg administered the ADHD symptom checklist-4, the Alcohol and Drug Checklist, the Children’s Depression Index, the Family Assessment Measure-III, the House-Tree-Person Drawing, the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory-Adolescent, the Revised Children’s Manifest Anxiety Scales, the Rorschach Inkblot Test, the Sentence Completion Series, and the Thematic Apperception Test.
3. According to MOTHER, STUDENT is currently taking 2.5mg of generic adderall several times a day. This dose seems to be appropriate and MOTHER has noticed an overall improvement in STUDENT’s mood at home. However, the Hearing Office makes no determination regarding how the new medication impacts STUDENT’s ability to function at school. STUDENT was expelled prior to receiving this medication. There is no evidence of what, if any, impact the medication will have on STUDENT if she returns to school.
4. It should be noted that the administration of a single academic instrument given in a one-on-one setting is very different from a classroom and, therefore, not necessarily indicative of a child’s ability to perform in a traditional school setting.
5. A parent may, in some circumstances, receive reimbursement for a private assessment without disagreeing with the District’s assessment. For example, if the District either fails to or refuses to assess a child, the parents may be entitled to reimbursement. That is not the case here. After receiving MOTHER’s request to assess STUDENT for special education eligibility, the District conducted a timely assessment of STUDENT.
