California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 9, 1998

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 954-97 · Hearing Officer Jennifer Nolan

Los Angeles Unified must provide a permanent aide for toileting and lunch and bathroom key access; private school request denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 16-year-old tenth grader eligible for special education under orthopedic handicap due to cerebral palsy filed against Los Angeles Unified School District, with her father representing her. She took mostly honors classes at Birmingham High School and had a full-time one-to-one aide, adapted physical education (APE), a least restrictive environment counselor, and transportation. She asked the District to pay for New Roads School, a private school. She said her aides kept changing and the campus was hostile. The District moved to dismiss because New Roads was not a certified nonpublic school. The Hearing Officer denied the motion and noted she could grant other appropriate relief.

The Hearing Officer found the student was clearly benefiting academically. She also held that the law does not require a "better" aide to produce better grades. APE, counseling, and access to activities met the student's needs. The evidence did not show a hostile environment, and regular classes with APE were the least restrictive environment. However, the District was not meeting her needs for help with toileting and lunch. She had about six aides that year, mostly substitutes, and not all of them would help her. Finding the bathroom key could take up to an hour. The District called no aide to testify. The Hearing Officer ordered a permanent aide within 30 days who is able and willing to help with toileting and lunch. She also ordered the District to give a bathroom key right away to every aide, including substitutes. The private school request was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a student who was succeeding academically but whose physical-care needs went unmet. Academic benefit did not excuse unreliable toileting help and bathroom access. The remedy was a targeted fix inside the public school, not a private school placement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?

    Student was benefiting academically, and APE, counseling, IEP conformity and LRE were adequate, but the District was not meeting her needs for a reliable aide to help with toileting and lunch or for consistent bathroom access; Petitioner prevailed.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Is the Los Angeles Unified School District required to fund STUDENT's placement at a private school, specifically New Roads School, for the 1997-98 school year?

    No evidence was presented about New Roads School, which must be certified under Ed. Code 56505.2, and the District's placement with modifications could meet Student's needs, so a nonpublic placement was not warranted.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. Within 30 days of the order, District shall provide a permanent one-to-one aide who can effectively assist Student in class and is physically capable and willing to assist her with toileting and obtaining lunch.
  • Order to provide or change services. District shall immediately provide a bathroom key to any aide assigned to Student, including substitute aides assigned before a permanent aide is hired.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education; Ivan P. v. Westport Bd. of Educ.; Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education; Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2; Cal. Educ. Code § 56365

People named in the decision

  • Alex Morena, Regional Center service coordinator, Regional Center
  • Erica Rodrigues, former one-to-one aide, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Charlene Zhe, one-to-one aide, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Gerald Kleinman, principal, Birmingham High School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Claudia Oviedo, special education counselor and coordinator, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Stacy Palmer Henderson, adapted physical education teacher and drill team coach, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Sandra Odom, personnel officer, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Volly Aronson, school administrative assistant, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Paula Moore-Diggs, least restrictive environment counselor, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • David Joseph, math teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Steven Kofahl, math teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Zita Evensen, science teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Elizabeth Majeski, assistant principal, Birmingham High School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Linda Michel, west valley coordinator of special education, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Victoria McKendall, District representative, due process unit coordinator, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Howard Fulfrost, District attorney (observer), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • New Roads School, private school requested by Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jennifer Nolan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Reseda, California, on December 2 and 3, 1997.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by her father, FATHER. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her mother, MOTHER, her sisters SISTER 1 and SISTER 2, and Alex Morena, Regional Center service coordinator. STUDENT was also present at the hearing.(Footnote 1)

Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by Victoria McKendall, District coordinator for the due process unit. Also present on behalf of the District was Linda Michel, west valley coordinator of special education. Howard Fulfrost, District attorney, was present as an observer for approximately fifteen minutes on the first day of hearing.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: SISTER 1, Petitioner’s sister; Erica Rodrigues, STUDENT’s former one-to-one aide; Gerald Kleinman, Birmingham High School principal; Claudia Oviedo, District special education counselor and coordinator; STUDENT, Petitioner; Stacy Palmer Henderson, District adapted physical education teacher; and MOTHER, Petitioner’s mother.

The District called the following witnesses: Sandra Odom, District personnel officer; Volly Aronson, District school administrative assistant; Paula Moore-Diggs, District least restrictive environment counselor; David Joseph, District math teacher; Steven Kofahl, District math teacher; Zita Evensen, District science teacher; and Elizabeth Majeski, District assistant principal at Birmingham High School.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments on December 17, 1997, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

(1) Did the Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?

(2) Is the Los Angeles Unified School District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at a private school, specifically New Roads School, for the 1997-98 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old student who is currently in the tenth grade at Birmingham High School within the District. The basis of STUDENT’s special education eligibility is an orthopedic handicap caused by Cerebral Palsy. Her special education consists entirely of accommodations and related services that address her physical limitations. She needs assistance in toileting, note taking, and getting lunch. Her services include a full-time one-to-one aide, a least restrictive environment counselor, adapted physical education, and transportation.

Birmingham has a population of approximately 3,000 students. Approximately 285 students in the school are special education students. The special education programs at Birmingham include resource specialist programs, special day classes, a deaf program, a learning handicapped program, a community-based instruction program, and a visually handicapped class. Sixteen special education classes exist at Birmingham. At least twenty-five students are disabled, mainstreamed and college bound.

During the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT was a ninth-grade student at Birmingham. For her ninth-grade year, STUDENT’s grades were as follows:

Fall Semester Spring Semester

Honors English B Honors English C Honors Biology B Honors Biology B Geometry A Geometry D French A French B

APE A APE C

Health A Drivers Ed. B Ed C Plan I A

Currently, STUDENT attends Birmingham as a tenth-grade student. She is enrolled in honors courses, except for math and adapted physical education (APE). STUDENT’s ten-week progress report indicates her performance in the beginning of the 1997-98 year as follows:

Honors World History B Adapted Physical Education A Honors English A Honors Advanced Physical Science B Honors French C Algebra C

STUDENT plans to continue her studies at the university level after graduating from high school and indicated a desire to pursue a career as an attorney.

On July 11, 1997, the Petitioner filed for hearing to determine whether she should be placed in a private school in order to benefit from her education in a least restrictive, “nonhostile” environment.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On December 2, 1997, when this hearing convened, the District made a motion to dismiss the case. It was the District’s contention that the case should be dismissed because the remedy the Petitioner was seeking, placement at New Roads School, could not be ordered by the Hearing Officer. The District stated that the California Department of Education has not certified New Roads School to provide services as a nonpublic school. This Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion and informed the parties that the evidence would be heard.

At the conclusion of the Petitioner’s case, the District again moved to have the case dismissed. This Hearing Officer informed the parties that the District’s case would be heard before making a ruling on the motion.

At the close of the District’s case, the District renewed its motion to have the case dismissed. This Hearing Officer requested that the District put the motion in writing so that the Petitioner could have adequate time to respond to the motion.

On December 8, 1997, the Hearing Office received the District’s written motion. The District requested that the case be dismissed on the ground that the Hearing Officer is precluded from ordering the Petitioner’s proposed resolution. The District cited California Education Code section 56505.2, which provides that a Hearing Officer may not render a decision that results in the placement of a student in a nonpublic school if the school is not certified pursuant to California Education Code section 56366.1.

On December 17, 1997, the Hearing Office received the Petitioner’s opposition to the motion. The Petitioner contends that the case should not be dismissed because the Hearing Officer is to make a determination as to whether the District provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The Petitioner cited California Education Code section 56101(a) for the proposition that a waiver may be given if that is what is necessary to provide a FAPE.

On December 17, 1997, the parties were read an oral ruling stating that the District’s motion to dismiss the case had been denied.

Appropriate issues for a special education due process hearing include a proposal or refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment or educational placement of a child or the provision of a free appropriate education to the child. (California Education Code § 56501.) To determine whether STUDENT should be placed at New Roads School as requested, the Hearing Officer must first determine whether the placement offered by the District is appropriate. The issues set forth in both the Petitioner’s and District’s statement of issues and the issues identified at the hearing are proper for a due process hearing.

Although the Hearing Officer may be precluded as a matter of law from ordering the remedy the Petitioner is seeking, the Hearing Officer is not confined to granting remedies specifically requested. The Hearing Officer may grant relief as determined to be appropriate. (See, Ivan P. v. Westport Bd. of Educ., 865 F.Supp. 74, 80 (Dist. Ct. Conn. 1994), citing OSERS policy letter (June 17, 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(I)(2)(B)(iii); Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington Massachusetts, et al., v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et al., 471 U.S. 359.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

(1) Did the Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(A)-(D), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that (A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; (B) meet the standards of the State educational agency; (C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the state involved; and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under § 614(d).(Footnote 2) “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a disabled child....” (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).)

The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). According to the Court, an IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The school district is not required to provide the best possible education, to maximize educational benefits, or to provide each disabled child with an equal educational opportunity “commensurate with the opportunities provided other children.” The school district must only provide a “basic floor of opportunity.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200-201.)

In determining whether the District has offered a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflects the child’s needs, provides some benefit, and comports with the IEP, the District has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 at 207-208.)

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); California Education Code § 56031.) This means that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children without disabilities. (34 C.F.R. 300.500.) Removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment is to occur only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (34 C.F.R. 300.550(b)(2).)

Taken together, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley provide four factors for analyzing whether the Los Angeles Unified School District has substantively proposed an appropriate placement:

1. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to provide educational benefit to STUDENT; 2. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; 3. Whether the District’s proposed placement conformed to STUDENT’s IEP; and 4. Whether the District’s proposed placement was designed to provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment.

(20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S. 176.)

1. Some Educational Benefit

At the hearing, STUDENT testified that she does not feel she is reaching her full potential at Birmingham but that she is generally making academic progress. As stated above, the law does not require a school district to provide the best possible education. Only a “basic floor of opportunity” is required. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200-201.) Last year STUDENT was enrolled in two honors courses. This year that number has increased to four. STUDENT’s grades from last year and the first ten weeks of this year show that fourteen were As or Bs and that only five were Cs or Ds.(Footnote 3) (Dist. Exh. 1.)

The Petitioner contends that some grades she received were not fair because the one-to-one aides would challenge her answers and change them to an incorrect answer. (Testimony of STUDENT.) STUDENT stated that Charlene Zhe, who has served as her one-to-one aide on several occasions, would not always correctly write answers on tests because she is dyslexic. No evidence was presented to substantiate the claim that Ms. Zhe has dyslexia. STUDENT also stated that the aides talked during class, did not understand the subject matter, did not take adequate notes, and were not fluent in English.(Footnote 4) Despite these allegations of problems with the aides, STUDENT clearly benefited from her ninth-grade education and moved with her peers to the tenth grade, where she continues to benefit from her education. The law does not require that a “better” aide be provided so that the student may get “better” grades.

STUDENT is in many respects like Amy Rowley, who was found to be a “‘remarkably well adjusted child’.... ‘(S)he performs better than the average child in the classes and is advancing easily from grade to grade.’” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 185.) Unlike Amy, who was partially deaf, STUDENT has the capacity to understand everything that occurs in her classes without assistance and has proven her ability to achieve honors grades. STUDENT has benefitted and continues to benefit from her education at Birmingham.

2. STUDENT’s Unique Needs

STUDENT’s unique needs arise solely from her physical limitations. STUDENT is a wheelchair-bound student with Cerebral Palsy. During the hearing the following emerged as STUDENT’s unique needs: a one-to-one aide to assist in note-taking, toileting, clothing, and getting lunch; adapted physical education; access to a bathroom; and a least restrictive environment counselor. The parties did not dispute that these are STUDENT’s needs. The dispute is over whether or not the District is meeting these needs.

a. One-to-one aide(Footnote 5)

Because of her Cerebral Palsy, STUDENT is not always able to write or take notes at a pace that would allow her to keep up with the class. The parties agree that STUDENT needs an aide who can copy notes from the board and who can take notes on what is happening in the class, as directed by STUDENT. Additionally, STUDENT needs the assistance of an aide in writing for tests. STUDENT can read the test questions on her own and formulate an answer. What she needs is assistance transmitting the answer to paper. STUDENT currently dictates her answer to an aide, who then writes it down. (Testimony of STUDENT.)

No argument was presented that the District has failed to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one aide. The testimony established that STUDENT has had several aides assigned to her. (Testimony of STUDENT and Mr. Kleinman.) The Petitioner contends that the quality of the aides has not been satisfactory with regard to note-taking and assisting in test-taking. Ms. Odom testified that all of the aides assigned to STUDENT are classified by the District as special education trainee assistants and are qualified to take notes, regardless of the subject matter. As indicated earlier, although STUDENT may not be satisfied with the quality of the aides, the law does not require a “better” aide. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is meeting STUDENT’s unique need to have an aide assist in note-taking and test-taking.

STUDENT also requires the assistance of a one-to-one aide when using the restroom. STUDENT is not able to maneuver herself out of her wheelchair and onto the toilet by herself. To use the bathroom, she needs someone to help her. Depending on the size and strength of the people involved, it may take more than one person to assist in this process. (Testimony of STUDENT.) According to STUDENT, not all of the aides provided by the District have been willing or able to assist her with her toileting needs. STUDENT testified that she has a kidney condition and has been told by her doctor that she needs to drink as much water as possible and use the restroom frequently. She stated that she does not do so because it is to much of a “hassle” to use the restroom at school. Moreover, STUDENT testified that she does not eat breakfast so that she will not have to use the restroom during the school day. As of the date of the hearing, STUDENT testified that she had only used the bathroom twice at school during the current year, and there was no evidence to the contrary presented. When she used the restroom, two aides were present. One aide helped her onto the toilet and the other aide stood outside the restroom to make sure no one else entered. When STUDENT used the toilet, the stall door remained open because there was not room to close the door due to her wheelchair. (Testimony of STUDENT.) The District’s assertion that STUDENT’s toileting needs were being met is unsupported. None of the District employees who testified were able to provide testimony other than conjecture. Ms. Odom, District personnel officer, testified that all of the aides hired by the District should be able to handle the duties that come with any assignment. However, Ms. Odom works at the District offices downtown and no testimony was received to indicate that she has knowledge of what duties the aides perform daily at the school site. Likewise, Ms. Oviedo stated that at times she would see STUDENT and ask her if she needed to use the restroom and STUDENT would reply negatively; therefore, Ms. Oviedo assumed STUDENT’s needs with regard to the restroom were being met. The District did not call anyone who served as an aide to STUDENT to testify. Based on the testimony presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not meeting STUDENT’s unique need to have assistance in using the restroom.

Lunch is also a time when STUDENT needs the assistance of an aide. STUDENT usually requires assistance to get food for lunch. (Testimony of STUDENT.) Specifically, if she wants to have more than one item, such as a slice of pizza and a soda, she cannot get them by herself because she would need both hands to carry the items, leaving her unable to maneuver her wheelchair. (Testimony of STUDENT.) STUDENT testified that many of her aides do not assist her in getting lunch, even if she asks. Ms. Majeski testified that it is part of the aides’ duties to help STUDENT get her food. According to Ms. Moore-Diggs, students who need assistance in getting lunch are to be released from class five minutes early with their aides so they can get food. Although Ms. Moore-Diggs testified that this is the policy, she does not know whether this was being done with STUDENT. The District employees testified that they assumed STUDENT was getting food because they had no contrary information. (Testimony of Ms. Oviedo and Ms. Moore-Diggs.) None of the evidence presented by the District contradicts STUDENT’s testimony that not all of the aides assist her in obtaining lunch. Based on the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is not meeting STUDENT’s unique need to have assistance in obtaining lunch.

At the hearing, testimony was received regarding the lack of consistency of STUDENT’s aides. In the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT had at least three aides.(Footnote 6) To date in the 1997-98 school year, STUDENT has had approximately six aides. (Testimony of STUDENT.) Ms. Aronson testified that all of the aides assigned to STUDENT have been substitute aides except Charlene Zhe. Two of STUDENT’s teachers, Mr. Joseph and Ms. Evensen, testified that having a continual change in aides may have had some effect on STUDENT’s academic performance. STUDENT testified that she has to give each new aide instructions of what her duties are. In her opinion, constantly spending time giving each aide instruction distracts her from her course work and takes away from the time she should be listening to the teacher or participating in class. As set forth above, the lack in consistency of the aides is of little consequence as it relates to STUDENT’s academics. She is benefiting from her education. However, as to STUDENT’s physical needs, primarily toileting and lunch, the lack of consistency in aides is troubling.

It is necessary that STUDENT have an aide she can rely on to help her use the bathroom and to get lunch. Especially in regard to toileting, which is extremely personal in nature, STUDENT needs to be able to use the restroom in a dignified way and have the knowledge that if she needs to use the restroom a capable person is ready and able to assist her. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is not meeting STUDENT’s need to have an aide who can and will help her with toileting and lunch.

b. Access to a bathroom

STUDENT’s needs include access to the bathroom. The parties are not in agreement about the accessability of a bathroom. District employees testified about keys that are available to STUDENT so she may use the bathroom when necessary. Ms. Oviedo testified that a key was made available to STUDENT’s aide last year and the aide declined to take the key. She stated that the school administrators also all have keys to the bathroom and STUDENT could track one of them down and gain entrance to the bathroom from them. This year a key has not been given to the aides because of the constant turnover in aides. A key can only be given to aides who are permanent; it cannot be given to every aide who comes on campus. A key was placed in a room and STUDENT was told where it is located. STUDENT stated the key is not always in the room when she attempts to find it, and that currently, it can take up to one hour for her to go to the bathroom at school. Of the hour, approximately fifteen minutes is actually spent using the bathroom. The remaining time is spent finding a key. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is not meeting STUDENT’s unique need to have consistent access to the bathroom.

c. Adapted physical education (APE)

Due to her physical restrictions, STUDENT requires adapted physical education (APE). The Petitioner contends that the APE goal contained in the IEP dated February 7, 1997, is not being properly implemented. The goal states that STUDENT will increase her overall strength. The goal was written to cover the period of February 1997 to February 1998. Two short-term objectives are contained in the IEP. First, STUDENT will be able to sit in her wheelchair maintaining correct posture for a minimum of five minutes. Second, STUDENT will stand independently while holding a bar for five minutes without assistance. (Dist. Exh. 3 and Pet. Exh. A.)

STUDENT’s APE class meets second period in a studio room. The class lasts fifty-five minutes and takes place five times a week. (Testimony of Ms. Palmer Henderson; Pet. Exh. A; Dist. Exh. 3.) There are eighteen students in the class with differing disabilities. STUDENT’s goals are worked on every day with direct activity two to three times a week. (Testimony of Ms. Palmer Henderson.) The Petitioner contends that the goals are not being properly implemented because at this time STUDENT cannot stand on her own for five minutes. In general, a school district may select the method by which it performs its special education obligations. (See, Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 207-208; Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education, 852 F.2d 290 (7th Cir. 1988); Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) Ms. Palmer Henderson testified that all of the work STUDENT does in APE is done to enable her to meet the goal by February. A multi-discipline model is used, and strength, stretching, standing, and posture are all worked on in an effort to attain the goal. At the time of the hearing, Ms. Palmer Henderson testified STUDENT was able to stand at the bar unassisted for three-and-a-half to four minutes at a time. Based on STUDENT’s current performance, the APE goal should be met by February. The Hearing Officer finds that the District is meeting STUDENT’s adapted physical education needs.

d. Least restrictive environment counselor

STUDENT’s IEP includes the services of a least restrictive environment counselor in order to help her continue her academic success. The short-term objectives include that STUDENT will discuss problems and concerns with her least restrictive environment counselor and other appropriate personnel and that STUDENT will explore appropriate extracurricular activities. (Pet. Exh. A; Dist. Exh. 3.) The Petitioner contends that her needs are not being met because her LRE counselor, Ms. Moore-Diggs, is frequently not on campus, and when on campus, is busy or unapproachable. The Petitioner also contends that her needs are not being met because she is not involved in extracurricular activities, particularly drill team. However, the evidence presented does not support the Petitioner’s contentions.

Ms. Moore-Diggs is a District least restrictive environment counselor assigned to several high schools, including Birmingham. Her duties include facilitating academic services for physically disabled students, working with nurses to ensure that there are appropriate facilities, conducting graduation checks and generally making sure the students are on track, and bringing in outside resources when necessary. Ms. Moore-Diggs stated that she is on the Birmingham campus at least weekly and sometimes daily. Support services that Ms. Moore-Diggs has provided to STUDENT include transportation, making sure she has appropriate academic courses, and helping acquire desks. Ms. Moore-Diggs explained to STUDENT that if she had concerns, she could talk to her about them. Ms. Moore-Diggs sees STUDENT on campus approximately once a week and STUDENT has not indicated any problems, with the exception of the one-to-one aide. (Testimony of Ms. Moore-Diggs.) STUDENT testified that she attended a group counseling session once run by Ms. Moore-Diggs. In addition to Ms. Moore-Diggs, Ms. Oviedo plays a role in meeting STUDENT’s counseling needs. STUDENT has expressed concerns to Ms. Oviedo regarding one-to-one aides, desks, and extracurricular activities. (Testimony of Ms. Oviedo.) Ms. Oviedo testified that she has served as a counselor to STUDENT and has made program changes. Ms. Moore-Diggs and Ms. Oviedo both worked with STUDENT to acquire special desks and suggested methods of obtaining notes from classmates. (Testimony of Ms. Moore-Diggs and Ms. Oviedo.) STUDENT acknowledged bringing some of her concerns to Ms. Oviedo and Ms. Moore-Diggs but stated that she is not always satisfied with their responses. STUDENT testified that she has not approached her teachers with her concerns because she does not think she will get a good response. It appears that the problem is not with the availability of school personnel, but with STUDENT’s willingness to approach them with her concerns and her lack of satisfaction with their proposed resolutions.

As for extracurricular activities, the Petitioner contends that this portion of the goal is not being met because she is not involved in extracurricular activities with other students. Ms. Moore-Diggs stated that she would like to see STUDENT in a leadership role and suggested this to STUDENT. All special education students at Birmingham have access to the extracurricular activities and are encouraged to participate; however, it is up to each student to choose what activities to participate in. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman, Ms. Majeski, and Ms. Oviedo.) Birmingham has between seventeen and twenty-two clubs, and the meetings are announced in the school bulletin and over the public address system. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman and Ms. Oviedo.) Ms. Oviedo testified that in September 1997, she met with STUDENT to discuss clubs and extracurricular activities. At the meeting, she gave STUDENT a list of the activities, and they discussed participation in the French and Renaissance clubs. Ms. Oviedo testified that she volunteered to accompany STUDENT to any of the club meetings but STUDENT stated that she could go on her own. Apparently, STUDENT did not attend the Renaissance Club meeting because she did not think it was “cool.” (Testimony of MOTHER.)

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District is meeting STUDENT’s needs with respect to her having access to a least restrictive environment counselor and other school personnel and that STUDENT has had an opportunity to explore extracurricular activities.(Footnote 7) STUDENT is sixteen years old and capable of taking responsibility for becoming involved in activities. While the school can ensure that counselors and extracurricular activities are available, it cannot force STUDENT to seek the counselors out or to become involved in any activities if she is not willing to do so.(Footnote 8)

e. Nonhostile Atmosphere

The evidence presented fails to establish that Birmingham is a hostile environment. STUDENT testified that she is not happy at Birmingham and feels the administration does not like her. Several situations were testified to on behalf of the Petitioner which lead to the contention that the District is antagonistic and hostile. The testimony included an allegation that Ms. Oviedo called STUDENT a “brat,” that District administrators are not responsive to STUDENT’s concerns, and that some teacher’s treat her differently because of her handicap. (Testimony of STUDENT and MOTHER.) MOTHER stated that STUDENT is very self-conscious about being different. Each of the District employees testified that they do not believe Birmingham is a hostile environment and that they have not noticed any students acting improperly toward STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that there is no evidence to establish that Birmingham is a hostile atmosphere such that it denies STUDENT a FAPE.

3. STUDENT’s IEP

On February 7, 1997, an IEP meeting was convened and the parties, including STUDENT and her parents, signed the resulting IEP indicating their consent. The District’s proposed placement for STUDENT of regular education classes with APE at Birmingham High School is the placement indicated on the IEP. The Petitioner does not dispute the IEP itself, but disputes the implementation of the provisions contained in the IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement conforms to the IEP.

4. Least Restrictive Environment

As stated above, special education law provides that to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities must be educated with children without disabilities. (34 C.F.R. 300.500.) STUDENT is enrolled in regular education classes, with the exception of APE, on a regular District campus. Due to the nature of her disability, STUDENT requires APE to meet her physical education needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that for STUDENT regular education classes with APE is the least restrictive environment.

(2) Is the Los Angeles Unified School District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at a private school, specifically New Roads School, for the 1997-98 school year?

The Petitioner has requested a nonpublic school placement at District expense. A nonpublic school placement can be provided when no appropriate public education is available. (California Education Code § 56365.)

According to California Education Code section 56505.2(a)

a hearing officer may not render a decision that results in the placement of an individual with exceptional needs in a nonpublic, nonsectarian school...if the school ...has not been certified pursuant to Section 56366.1.

As a prospective placement for the 1997-98 school year, not only must New Roads School be certified but it also must satisfy the four factors outlined above. No evidence was presented at the hearing regarding New Roads School. As discussed above, with some modifications, the District’s placement can appropriately meet STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, it cannot be said that no appropriate education is available within the meaning of Education Code section 56365.

ORDER

1. Within 30 days of the date of this order the District shall provide STUDENT with a permanent one-to-one aide. In addition to being able to effectively assist STUDENT in class, the aide shall be physically capable and willing to assist STUDENT in toileting and obtaining lunch.

2. The District shall immediately provide a key to the bathroom to any aide assigned to STUDENT, including substitute aides that may be assigned prior to the District’s hiring a permanent aide.

3. Petitioner’s request for private school placement at New Roads is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

(1) Did the Los Angeles Unified School District offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1997-98 school year?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

(2) Is the Los Angeles Unified School District required to fund STUDENT’s placement at a private school, specifically New Roads School, for the 1997-98 school year?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: January 9, 1998 ___________________________ Jennifer Nolan Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Mr. Morena was only present for the morning of December 2. STUDENT and SISTER 2 were present on December 2, and for a portion of the morning on December 3. 2.Except for subsection (6), which addresses children with disabilities in adult prisons, § 614(d) of IDEA does not go into effect until July 1, 1998. 3.Of these five grades, only one was a D and it was in geometry during her ninth-grade year. 4.Sandra Odom, District personnel officer, is in charge of all assistants in the District. She testified that, to be hired, all of the aides had to pass both a written examination and oral interview that are given in English. 5. The Petitioner brought up many concerns regarding the release of Erica Rodrigues as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, including the fact that the Petitioner did not have any input into the decision to remove Erica and that the Petitioner and her family were not told why the District released Erica from her assignment with STUDENT. Generally, personnel matters are within the school district’s discretion. STUDENT’s IEP does not specify that Erica Rodrigues is to serve as the one-to-one aide. 6. During the first semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT had one aide. (Testimony of Mr. Kofahl.) During the second semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT had at least two aides. One aide, Erica Rodrigues, was STUDENT’s aide from March until May 1997. Erica was released from her duties as STUDENT’s aide for several reasons, including signing in late, disrupting classes, disobeying teachers’ instructions, and engaging in inappropriate conversations with other aides and students. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman, Ms. Palmer Henderson, Ms. Aronson, and Ms. Oviedo.) After Erica was released, STUDENT had other aides until Erica was temporarily reassigned to STUDENT to complete the remaining three weeks of the 1996-97 school year. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman.) 7. STUDENT is particularly interested in joining the drill team and contends that not being allowed to join the drill team this year is a violation of her IEP. (Testimony of STUDENT and MOTHER.) Ms. Palmer-Henderson, the APE teacher and drill team coach, testified regarding the tryout process and time line for joining the drill team. STUDENT did not go through the tryout process necessary to become a member of the drill team. (Testimony of STUDENT and Ms. Palmer Henderson.) Generally, a student has a right to participate in an activity only if it is specifically written into the IEP. Here, the IEP does not provide that STUDENT will participate in the drill team but only that she will explore extra-curricular activities. In the present case, no authority has been cited to warrant an order requiring the District to allow STUDENT to participate in drill team without going through the tryout process 8. For example, STUDENT’s parents contend that because STUDENT did not take the PSAT the District failed to meet her counseling needs. However, STUDENT testified that she was aware of the PSAT, which is a voluntary practice exam, but chose not to take it because she though the aide might change her test answersFootnotes:

1. Mr. Morena was only present for the morning of December 2. STUDENT and SISTER 2 were present on December 2, and for a portion of the morning on December 3. 2.Except for subsection (6), which addresses children with disabilities in adult prisons, § 614(d) of IDEA does not go into effect until July 1, 1998. 3.Of these five grades, only one was a D and it was in geometry during her ninth-grade year. 4.Sandra Odom, District personnel officer, is in charge of all assistants in the District. She testified that, to be hired, all of the aides had to pass both a written examination and oral interview that are given in English. 5. The Petitioner brought up many concerns regarding the release of Erica Rodrigues as STUDENT’s one-to-one aide, including the fact that the Petitioner did not have any input into the decision to remove Erica and that the Petitioner and her family were not told why the District released Erica from her assignment with STUDENT. Generally, personnel matters are within the school district’s discretion. STUDENT’s IEP does not specify that Erica Rodrigues is to serve as the one-to-one aide. 6. During the first semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT had one aide. (Testimony of Mr. Kofahl.) During the second semester of the 1996-97 school year, STUDENT had at least two aides. One aide, Erica Rodrigues, was STUDENT’s aide from March until May 1997. Erica was released from her duties as STUDENT’s aide for several reasons, including signing in late, disrupting classes, disobeying teachers’ instructions, and engaging in inappropriate conversations with other aides and students. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman, Ms. Palmer Henderson, Ms. Aronson, and Ms. Oviedo.) After Erica was released, STUDENT had other aides until Erica was temporarily reassigned to STUDENT to complete the remaining three weeks of the 1996-97 school year. (Testimony of Mr. Kleinman.) 7. STUDENT is particularly interested in joining the drill team and contends that not being allowed to join the drill team this year is a violation of her IEP. (Testimony of STUDENT and MOTHER.) Ms. Palmer-Henderson, the APE teacher and drill team coach, testified regarding the tryout process and time line for joining the drill team. STUDENT did not go through the tryout process necessary to become a member of the drill team. (Testimony of STUDENT and Ms. Palmer Henderson.) Generally, a student has a right to participate in an activity only if it is specifically written into the IEP. Here, the IEP does not provide that STUDENT will participate in the drill team but only that she will explore extra-curricular activities. In the present case, no authority has been cited to warrant an order requiring the District to allow STUDENT to participate in drill team without going through the tryout process 8. For example, STUDENT’s parents contend that because STUDENT did not take the PSAT the District failed to meet her counseling needs. However, STUDENT testified that she was aware of the PSAT, which is a voluntary practice exam, but chose not to take it because she though the aide might change her test answers