California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 3, 2004

Student v. Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 963-04 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Fairfield-Suisun Unified denied FAPE to a student with Asperger's across two school years and must provide 151 compensatory hours.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision includes a footnote noting an amendment that struck the words "and approved by his current IEP team" from the Order. It also notes that a Solano County Superior Court temporary order (January 14, 2002) allowed the student's transfer and assessment, and that the court petition was later settled by the parent's March 1, 2002 agreement to an interim ED-SDC placement.

Summary

The mother of a student eligible for special education under an autistic disorder (Asperger's Disorder) filed for due process on his behalf against Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District. She represented him herself. In third and fourth grade the student attended general education classes at Nelda Mundy School with a behavior plan and an aide. In March 2002 he moved to a special day class for students with emotional disturbance at Anna Kyle School. Because the mother refused a continuance, the Hearing Officer dismissed reimbursement claims she raised late. For spring 2001, the Hearing Officer found no barrier to the parent's participation. However, the IEP lacked a behavior intervention plan, daily home-school communication and regular team meetings. The District also never replaced the trained one-to-one aide after the aide died. For fall 2001, the principal barred the student from recess and lunch with peers. He then held a meeting without the parent to approve that change. The Hearing Officer held both were procedural denials of FAPE. The aides were also untrained and were openly identified as the student's aide, contrary to the IEP. From March 2002 through extended school year, the parent had consented to the special day class. Still, applying the Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer found it was not the least restrictive environment. The District must provide 44 hours of one-to-one tutoring and 107 hours of social skills training with typically developing peers.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled several common problems. A district had to supply a trained aide even after an unexpected staff death. Barring a student from recess was treated as a change of placement that required the parent's involvement. Behavior problems did not justify an emotional disturbance class when the district had never fully provided the supports the IEP promised.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue Procedural (reimbursement claims). Whether the parents were entitled to reimbursement for services by Michelle Winner ($325) and Advance Education, Inc. ($1,400), and for an independent assessment by Sally Osonoff, Ph.D. ($700). These claims were first raised at the July 23, 2004 prehearing conference.

    The reimbursement claims were dismissed because the District did not get the 10 days' notice required by Education Code section 56505(e)(6) and the parent refused a brief continuance. A District motion to dismiss the compensatory education claim was denied.

  2. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 regular school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001?

    The parent was not denied meaningful participation. However, the IEP lacked a BIP, daily home-school communication and regular team meetings, and the District did not replace the trained one-to-one aide (22.5 hours a week) after the aide died. This denied FAPE.

  3. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from September 4, 2001, to on or about December 14, 2001?

    The principal unilaterally barred the student from recess and lunch with nondisabled peers and held an October 18, 2001 placement meeting without the parent. Both were procedural denials of FAPE. The aides were untrained and were openly identified as the student's aide, contrary to the IEP, which was a substantive denial.

  4. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 3. Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from on or about March 1, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year?

    The procedural claim failed because the parent consented to the ED-SDC through a court settlement. Applying the Rachel H. factors, however, the Hearing Officer held the ED-SDC was not the least restrictive environment, which denied FAPE.

  5. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. If the District failed to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during any of the time at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?

    The Hearing Officer awarded 44 hours of one-to-one tutoring and 107 hours of small-group social skills training with typically developing peers. The request for about 969 hours from Advance Education, Inc. was not granted.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Compensatory education. Forty-four hours of one-to-one academic tutoring from a credentialed teacher (2 hours for each of 22 weeks of lost instruction time).
  • Compensatory education. One hundred seven hours of social skills training in a small group of typically developing same-aged peers, from a person with documented experience providing that service to children with Asperger's disorder.
  • The District must arrange the services within 30 calendar days of the decision. They must be provided by District personnel or by another public agency or NPA under contract with the District, at times and locations convenient to the parent. The order says the services must be completed by the beginning of the 2005-2006 school year; the findings say by the end of that year.

Total: 151 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Educ. v. Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Honig v. Doe; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education

People named in the decision

  • Karen Hanson, director of special education, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • William Stockman, principal, Nelda Mundy School
  • Barbara Taylor, consulting speech and language pathologist, provider to the District
  • Nancy Lamp, general education teacher, Nelda Mundy School
  • Debra Back, fourth-grade general education teacher, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Kathleen England, ED-SDC teacher, Anna Kyle School
  • Ms. Hodges, general education teacher, Nelda Mundy School
  • Vickie Wells, District behavior specialist, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Katie Thrift, RSP provider and case manager, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Patti Thrift, teacher providing lunch and recess supervision, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Mr. Patton, teacher providing lunch and recess supervision, Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Jill Ryan, RSP provider and case manager (2001-2002), Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District
  • Monique Bekeschus, behaviorist, nonpublic agency, Behavioral Intervention Association
  • Hilary Baldi, Director, nonpublic agency, Behavioral Intervention Association
  • Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA), nonpublic agency providing behavior services
  • Linda Lotspeich, M.D., M.Ed., private diagnostician, Lucile Packard Children's Health Services, Stanford University
  • Saritha Vermeer, Ph.D., private diagnostician, Lucile Packard Children's Health Services, Stanford University
  • Mary Steinfeld, M.D., developmental pediatrician, U.C. Davis Medical Center
  • Sally Osonoff, Ph.D., independent assessor, M.I.N.D. Institute, U.C. Davis
  • Michelle Winner, private speech and language therapist
  • Advance Education, Inc., private provider proposed for compensatory education
  • Carl Corbin, law clerk to District counsel

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Fairfield, California, on July 27, 28, 29, and 30, and August 3, 2004.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, Mrs. PARENT.

Respondent Fairfield-Suisun Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Joseph Kinkade. Karen Hanson, the District’s director of special education, was also present. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Barbara Taylor, a speech and language pathologist who provided services to STUDENT during the time at issue; Karen Hanson; William Stockman, the principal of the school STUDENT attended during some of the time at issue; and Nancy Lamp, one of STUDENT’s teachers during his third-grade, regular education placement.

The District called the following witnesses: Debra Back, one of STUDENT’s fourth-grade, regular education teachers, and Kathleen England, another of STUDENT’s fourth-grade teachers during his final District placement in a special day class for students with severe emotional disturbances (ED-SDC). The District also recalled Ms. Hanson for further testimony.

Oral and documentary evidence was presented at the hearing. The parties’ closing arguments were heard and the record was closed on August 3, 2004.

ISSUES (Footnote2)

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 regular school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001?

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from September 4, 2001, to on or about December 14, 2001?

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from on or about March 1, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year?

Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide a free appropriate public education to Petitioner during any of the time at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the time of the prehearing conference on July 23, 2004, Petitioner for the first time made a claim for reimbursement by the District of expenses paid by his parents. The Prehearing Conference Order issued on July 26, 2004, listed as issue number three Petitioner’s claim that his parents were entitled to reimbursement for the cost of educational and related services provided by Michelle Winner and Advance Education, Inc., in the amounts of $325.00 and $1,400.00, respectively. The Order listed as issue number four Petitioner’s claim that his parents were entitled to reimbursement for the cost of an independent assessment conducted by Sally Osonoff, Ph.D., in the amount of $700.00.

On the first day of hearing, the District made a motion to dismiss both of Petitioner’s claims to reimbursement on the ground that the District did not have adequate notice of the issues as required by California Education Code section 56505(e)(6), which states that the parties to a due process hearing have the right to be informed by the other parties at least ten days before the hearing regarding the issues to be adjudicated and the proposed resolution of those issues.

The District also made a motion to dismiss Petitioner’s claim that he was entitled to an award of compensatory education consisting of 969 hours of educational services through Advance Education, Inc. This motion was made on the ground that the District had not received timely notice of the role of Advance Education, Inc. and had not seen any evidence upon which Petitioner might rely to show the type or amount of services allegedly due.

Petitioner opposed all of the District’s motions to dismiss. He asserted that the District was aware that he had been evaluated by Dr. Osonoff at the M.I.N.D. Institute at the University of California, Davis (U.C. Davis) in March 2002 and that a copy of the report had been provided to the District. He also argued that he stated in his initial request for due process on April 26, 2004, that he would be seeking an award of compensatory education and that the District had timely notice of this claim.

Reimbursement Issues

There was nothing in the Hearing Office file to show that Petitioner had informed the District at any time before the July 23, 2004 prehearing conference that he would be making a claim at this hearing for reimbursement of educational or related expenses incurred. The Hearing Officer explained to the parties that he was inclined to take action to ensure that the District had the required ten days notice of the claim to reimbursement. The Hearing Officer asked STUDENT’s mother if she would be willing to agree to a continuance of the hearing for a time adequate to provide the District with the notice to which it was entitled. Mrs. PARENT stated that she opposed any continuance and would rather the claim be dismissed than the hearing be continued for even a few days. The Hearing Officer therefore concluded that Petitioner’s failure to give timely notice regarding the reimbursement issues and his refusal to agree to a brief continuance to allow the notice mandated by California Education Code section 56505(e)(6) required dismissal of those issues. The reimbursement issues were dismissed.

Compensatory Education Issue

The District cited no authority to support its argument that it was entitled to ten-days notice of the specifics of the compensatory education claim, including its factual bases and the identity of the proposed service providers. The law requires only that the party identify the issues to be decided at the hearing and their proposed resolutions. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6). There is no requirement that the party identify the specific facts upon which it will rely to establish entitlement to a remedy.

The law does require that a party provide copies of documents it intends to offer into evidence at least five business days before the hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(7). However, a failure to provide those copies alone is typically not adequate ground to dismiss an issue that may or may not depend upon the admission of such documents into evidence.

The Hearing Officer was satisfied that the District had received the required notice regarding the compensatory education issue. Therefore, the District’s motion to dismiss this issue was denied.

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is the twelve-year-old son of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, with whom he currently resides in Elk Grove, California. STUDENT carries a diagnosis of Asperger’s Disorder, one of the milder autistic spectrum disorders. He has been eligible for special education and related services since first entering public school for second grade in 1999. During the school years at issue here, 2000-2001 (third grade) and 2001-2002 (fourth grade), STUDENT attended school within the District, first at Nelda Mundy School (Nelda Mundy), STUDENT’s home school, then at Anna Kyle School (Anna Kyle) for the last six months of fourth grade. STUDENT moved with his family to Elk Grove, California and has attended a regular education program with various services and supports in the Elk Grove Unified School District since the beginning of fifth grade in the 2002-2003 school year.

By the time STUDENT began to attend school within the District for second grade during the 1999-2000 school year, he had already been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and Asperger’s disorder. When the District first assessed him in November 1999, parent and teacher concerns included dysfluent speech, unusual intonation, poor social skills, lack of focus, and shouting out at peers. STUDENT’s mother reported that he fought with others often, appeared lonely, had anxiety about being in a group of children, acted impulsively, got angry easily, and had tantrums. His teacher added that he threatened others, argued, and was distracted easily. He also would pick at and chew on his fingers, at times causing them to bleed. The individualized education program (IEP) team found him eligible for special education and related services on the basis of severe language impairments. STUDENT was placed in a regular education second-grade class and provided resource specialist program (RSP) services and speech and language therapy. A behavior support plan also was developed for STUDENT to address the threatening, distracting, and disruptive behaviors.

A diagnosis of Asperger’s disorder was confirmed in March 2000 by Linda Lotspeich, M.D., M.Ed., and Saritha Vermeer, Ph.D., of the Lucile Packard Children’s Health Services at Stanford University. Their report recommended that STUDENT be placed in a regular education setting with behavior support. It also recommended that the District consult with Michelle Winner, a speech and language therapist who had developed a variety of behavioral strategies for children with Asperger’s disorder. The report also suggested the use of “quiet time” to calm STUDENT, social skills training, and speech and language therapy to address pragmatic issues. If significant behavioral problems persisted, the doctors recommended a one-to-one aide.

On the basis of this assessment, Mrs. PARENT requested an IEP review. An IEP meeting was convened on May 1, 2000. Eligibility was confirmed on the basis of an autistic disorder with principal areas of need being social/emotional and communication. District team members reported that STUDENT was making good progress controlling his behaviors, with mostly good days, though he continued to struggle with social interaction and transitions. A new behavior support plan was developed to address disruptive behaviors that were said to be occurring three times per week. Mrs. PARENT requested the services of a behavior specialist if STUDENT’s behaviors were not soon brought under control. Among other things, she was concerned about recent violent incidents at home. Mrs. PARENT did not sign the IEP until May 16, 2000. On May 22, 2000, she revoked her consent and requested another meeting to address what she believed to have been misrepresentations regarding STUDENT’s behavior and progress.

On June 2, 2000, another IEP meeting was convened. The team agreed to add behavior consultation for five to ten hours per month. However, in spite of the consensus that STUDENT’s disabilities were the root cause of his unacceptable behaviors, some District representatives already were complaining that STUDENT needed to learn that if he misbehaved, he would face the same consequences that his typically developing peers would face.

According to a September 2000 report by Mary Steinfeld, M.D., a pediatrician specializing in developmental issues at the U.C. Davis Medical Center, Mrs. PARENT believed that STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors had improved somewhat over the summer months with the institution of a behavior chart at home. However, Mrs. PARENT remained concerned about his angry outbursts when his own agenda was thwarted, his obsession with Pokemon (a fantasy card collection), a new habit of facial grimacing, and picking at his fingernails and skin. Doctor Steinfeld recommended increased speech and language therapy and a one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT in less structured, larger group settings and situations requiring social participation.

In early November 2000, District behavior specialist Vickie Wells observed STUDENT in various environments at his school, including his regular classroom and outside on the play yard. She observed disruptions by STUDENT in both of those environments and made a number of suggestions in a written report to the District, including the assignment of a trained, one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT during unstructured free time at recess and lunch and allowing STUDENT to spend some of the day in the fourth-grade class taught by Ms. Lamp. Ms. Wells also recommended a mental health referral under Chapter 26.5 of the California Government Code. (Footnote 3)

STUDENT began the fourth grade (2000-2001) in Ms. Hodges’ general education class at Nelda Mundy School. He continued to have difficulties with aggressive behavior. According to documents, on November 7, 2000, several District staff members who worked with STUDENT informally met to discuss the situation. This was not convened as an IEP meeting. Among the agreed-upon strategies/supports were a teacher assigned to “spot check” STUDENT during recess and lunch, initiation of the mental health referral, and daily reports home. Threats and physical violence were to be dealt with according to the usual District policy, but there was no explanation of what that policy was.

A memorandum outlining the recommendations made at this meeting was sent to Mrs. PARENT, who did not agree with many of them. She communicated her concerns to the District in an e-mail on November 16, 2000. Mrs. PARENT did not believe that the spot-checking by a teacher would be effective. She requested that a trained aide be assigned and that an appropriate behavior intervention plan (BIP) be designed to address the behaviors that were interfering with STUDENT’s and the other student’s learning. Her e-mail said nothing about the mental health referral.

Ms. Wells’ report was presented to the IEP team at a meeting on December 4, 2000. The IEP team, including Mrs. PARENT, agreed that STUDENT would continue in a regular education placement with RSP and speech and language services. The IEP team also agreed to provide a behavior specialist for four to eight hours per month to support and train the people who worked with STUDENT. A behavior support plan also was developed at the December 2000 IEP meeting to address aggressive behaviors that were said to be occurring approximately once per week, usually when STUDENT was teased by other children and during transitions to and from recess. Nothing was recorded in the December 2000 IEP documents regarding the recommended referral to mental health.

Mrs. PARENT consented to a functional analysis assessment (FAA) on January 3, 2001. A lengthy report of that assessment by the District refers to acts of aggression one to four times per day, low intensity but high frequency incidents of non-compliance, and high frequency disruptive behaviors during structured activities, occurring across all environments. Among the conclusions contained in the report was that the District’s response to the behaviors to date, which generally consisted of ignoring them or verbally redirecting STUDENT while focusing on the negative behavior, had not been effective. The assessing behaviorists suggested that structured and adult-supervised play activities, scripts for requesting assistance, and a token system of rewards would be more effective. (Footnote 4) They also recommended that a trained one-to-one aide be assigned to STUDENT, that behavioral training and consultation be provided to the family to assist with interventions at home, that appropriate interventions be implemented across all environments with the support of a behavior specialist, and that mental health services be provided.

The first IEP at issue was developed at a meeting on January 30, 2001. The FAA report was presented. The District offered STUDENT continued placement in a regular education third-grade classroom during seventy-five percent of his school day. STUDENT also was offered the following services: an instructional assistant for twenty-two and one-half hours per week; two to three hours per week of RSP services; fifty minutes per week of direct speech and language services and fifteen to ninety minutes per week of speech and language consultation with the parents, teacher, aide, and RSP provider; thirty to sixty minutes per week of case management and consultation through the RSP provider, and; four to eight hours per month of behavioral specialist consultation until March 1, 2001, then fifteen to twenty hours in March to work with the aide and develop the BIP, and three to five hours consultation per week thereafter.

Mrs. PARENT did not agree to the program as offered. Initially, she believed that STUDENT should not be out of his regular classroom for twenty-five percent of the day. As recommended by developmental pediatrician Mary Steinfeld in her report that was provided to the District in February 2001, Mrs. PARENT did not want the assigned aide identified to STUDENT or his peers as STUDENT’s aide. (Footnote 5) She also wanted the BIP to be designed by a private behavior specialist and she offered to pay for that service.

Sometime after the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents and the District reached an agreement regarding a behavior specialist. The District agreed to fund fifteen to twenty hours of service by Behavioral Intervention Association (BIA), a certified nonpublic agency (NPA), to develop STUDENT’s BIP and additional time, up to five and one-half hours per week, for training and consultation regarding implementation of the BIP.

Mrs. PARENT agreed to the January 30, 2001 IEP, but only after the District agreed to modify the “Review Summary” portion to include the language: “No instructional assistant services will start for STUDENT until recommended by the NPA behavior specialist. The NPA behavior specialist will determine how the instructional assistant is introduced to STUDENT.”

By March 2001, one particular male peer had begun to tease and harass STUDENT. Mrs. PARENT complained about this on several occasions and kept STUDENT home from school for a time to protect him. While Monique Bekeschus, the BIA behaviorist, was conducting her observations at the school, she also observed STUDENT being teased. During one documented observation while the second-grade teacher was supposed to be aiding STUDENT, Ms. Bekeschus saw a particular boy try to pick a fight with STUDENT three times. At no time did this teacher attempt to intervene to stop the teasing or facilitate appropriate social interaction. Even after Ms. Bekeschus warned this teacher about the importance of vigilance in supervising STUDENT, Ms. Bekeschus saw the same child teasing STUDENT and encouraging other boys to join in. In spite of the fact that the District recognized the need to closely observe STUDENT’s social interactions and intervene when appropriate, Ms. Bekeschus observed no adults doing it. According to her report of her observations, Ms. Bekeschus also saw other instances of inappropriate social interaction involving STUDENT that went unnoticed or uncorrected by an adult.

Monique Bekeschus completed her report on March 30, 2001. (Footnote 6) The report, which included the BIP that was to become part of STUDENT’s IEP, summarized her behavioral observations and made a number of recommendations. Those included the recommendations that the aide be thoroughly trained, that the aide be assigned to be an integral part of the classroom when not implementing STUDENT’s BIP, that STUDENT be moved to Ms. Lamp’s fourth-grade class due to conflicts with peers in Ms. Hodges’ class, and that a communication log be used to record strategies and outcomes and to function as a means of communication among those responsible for implementation of the BIP and STUDENT’s parents. The report also suggested that a case manager be assigned to oversee implementation, expedite communications among participants, organize and schedule meetings, and document specific behaviors addressed and that consideration be given to placing STUDENT at a different school, with the focus on finding the best teacher and an opportunity for STUDENT to develop good relationships with peers not previously exposed to his aggressive, disruptive, and other negative behaviors. According to the BIA report, the BIP implementation team, consisting of teacher Nancy Lamp, RSP provider and case manager Katie Thrift, speech and language provider Barbara Taylor, principal William Stockman, the aide, and the behavior specialist Ms. Bekeschus, should have met twice monthly. The report also recommended that the case manager meet with STUDENT’s parents, the aide, and another District representative three times monthly.

The District did not convene an IEP meeting to present the BIA report and recommendations and to consider adoption of the BIA recommendations and BIP as parts of STUDENT’s IEP. However, as more fully explained below, District staff and NPA providers, including Ms. Bekeschus and Ms. Taylor, proceeded to implement both as if they were part of the IEP.

The aide was not started until on or about Wednesday, April 11, 2001. According to the April 14, 2001 BIA progress report, the aide training went well the first three days. (Footnote 7) In that report, Monique Bekeschus recommended that the aide work from 9:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m. daily. She also stated that STUDENT should go to the RSP room or stay home on days when there was a substitute teacher and no aide was available.

During the spring break in or about the third week of April, the aide passed away unexpectedly. The District did not hire a replacement during the 2000-2001 school year. Other staff persons provided supervision during lunch and recess for the remainder of the year.

The relationship between Mrs. PARENT and District personnel became increasingly strained over the course of the 2000-2001 school year. Mrs. PARENT became more distrustful of the District’s intentions and ability. She believed that the District was consistently failing to fulfill its responsibilities to STUDENT by not following the recommendations of the behaviorists and physicians, particularly those relating to the assignment of a properly trained aide to, among other things, avoid or diffuse situations that might otherwise lead to aggressive, destructive, or disruptive behavior.

On the other hand, the District came to see Mrs. PARENT’s participation as more of a hindrance than a help to her son’s education. Mr. Stockman, the principal at Nelda Mundy School, saw Mrs. PARENT as a threat of sorts. In an e-mail to Karen Hanson on March 7, 2001, he said, “We are all feeling the emotional effects of [Mrs. PARENT’s] constant harassment, criticism, disruption, lies, rudeness, and undermining behaviors.” Mr. Stockman goes on to say that he “was reluctant to deal with matters pertaining to STUDENT because Mrs. PARENT is not prepared to focus on the concern at hand. Rather, she wants to place blame on staff for any inappropriate behaviors on STUDENT’s part.” Some of the other staff who worked with STUDENT shared this opinion of Mrs. PARENT.

STUDENT was assigned a new aide for the 2001-2002 school year. The aide did not testify so it is not known where she was when STUDENT was involved in several episodes of unacceptable behavior on the first day of school on September 4, 2001. According to a September 19, 2001 report of BIA, STUDENT became disruptive in the classroom when he was not made a lunch monitor. He became sad, then angry to the point that he cursed at the teacher and the other students. As the incident began to escalate, he was removed from the classroom. However, his anger continued. Without any obvious provocation, STUDENT later kicked two students while standing in the lunch line. Mr. Stockman reported that STUDENT also kicked Ms. Bekeschus. Later, he punched a student in the face on the playground, possibly in the course of a mutual combat.

The relationship between STUDENT’s parents and the District did not improve during the 2001-2002 school year. According to various documents and the testimony of several witnesses, Mrs. PARENT was openly critical of the District’s handling of STUDENT, at times criticizing staff in front of STUDENT. On September 14, 2001, Mr. Stockman wrote to Mrs. PARENT to ask that she limit her visits to the campus. He explained his view that STUDENT was at greater risk of an act of aggression when he knew that she was or would be nearby. The principal also asked Mrs. PARENT to refrain from criticizing staff in STUDENT’s presence. He suggested that she communicate only with the RSP provider, Ms. Ryan, and that she do so only by e-mail.

In spite of the presence of the aide, STUDENT continued to exhibit disruptive, threatening, and aggressive behaviors. Mrs. PARENT blamed the District, attributing the behavior to STUDENT’s disability and the District’s failure to provide properly trained staff, particularly an aide, to carefully observe STUDENT and his interactions with others, correctly identify precursors to the behaviors, anticipate escalation, and diffuse the situation before the unacceptable behaviors occurred.

A serious incident occurred on September 25, 2001. According to Mr. Stockman’s report of the incident, STUDENT exploded with rage after losing all of his tokens. He screamed profanities at the teacher and his classmates. The matter continued and escalated at recess when STUDENT chased two male classmates into the boy’s restroom, where he proceeded to repeatedly attack them. Even after the boys were removed to the principal’s office, STUDENT continued to scream profanities and he tried to kick one of the boys. As a result of the episode on September 25, 2001, the District unilaterally restricted STUDENT from morning, lunchtime, and afternoon recess. He was required to stay in the classroom with his teacher or go to the RSP room with his aide. The District imposed this change without the knowledge or consent of the parents or the behavior consultant and outside of the IEP process.

Many of the people who were attempting to provide an education to STUDENT became increasingly frustrated during the first four months of the 2001-2002 school year. Barbara Taylor believed that the aide and other school staff had not been adequately prepared to meet the significant challenge that STUDENT’s behavior presented. Some District staff, particularly Mr. Stockman and Ms. Hanson, believed that Monique Bekeschus had failed in her effort to develop a workable BIP and train District staff to implement it. Many believed that Mrs. PARENT made matters worse with her relentless criticism and constant distrust of the District and its recommendations. Mrs. PARENT continued to be frustrated with what she viewed as the refusal of District administrators and staff to follow the recommendations of the behavior specialist. Documents authored by Ms. Bekeschus show that she also was critical of the District’s failure to implement her BIP. Parents of other students at the school also were frustrated and complained that their children were at risk because the District was not taking appropriate steps to control STUDENT’s behavior.

On October 5, 2001, the District convened an IEP meeting to address STUDENT’s behaviors. At least one of the purposes of the meeting was to obtain IEP team approval of Mr. Stockman’s decision to restrict STUDENT’s access to the play yard during recess, which had been implemented shortly after the incident on September 25, 2001. Mrs. PARENT disagreed with and did not consent to the change. Ms. Bekeschus, who had not been consulted about the change earlier, also disagreed with it. Nevertheless, the District continued the restriction.

By later in October, the team that was responsible for developing and implementing an IEP for STUDENT had become hopelessly polarized. Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Bekeschus blamed the District for its failing to implement the plan to address STUDENT’s counterproductive behaviors, and the District blamed Ms. Bekeschus’ for the development of an unworkable plan and Mrs. PARENT for her destructive involvement. By October 18, 2001, District staff were meeting without Ms. Bekeschus and Mrs. PARENT to condemn the participation of both. Mr. Stockman, Jill Ryan, and Barbara Taylor were critical of the BIP created by Ms. Bekeschus as “unworkable,” while they blamed the lack of an effective behavior program in the home and complained about the frequent tardies and absences that made schedules impractical. (Footnote 8) At the same time, Ms. Bekeschus and Mrs. PARENT were writing memoranda and letters condemning the failures of District staff. On November 9, 2001, Mrs. PARENT filed formal charges with the District against Mr. Stockman, alleging dishonesty, discrimination, and retaliation. (Footnote 9)

Another IEP meeting was convened on November 16, 2001, to address the persistent difficulties with STUDENT’s behavior. According to the IEP documents, the team agreed that an SDC would not be the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, as required by law. Instead, the District offered STUDENT and his mother a fresh start that would include placement at Suisun Valley School, a smaller campus with fewer students. It was hoped that this change would allow STUDENT and his mother to be free of the adversarial relationships that had developed between them and the staff, students, and parents at Nelda Mundy School. There would be fewer students in STUDENT’s class, fewer students in the play yard with STUDENT, and a smaller play yard, allowing for more personal attention to STUDENT’s needs while minimizing the risk of conflict. The District also planned to change STUDENT’s aide, speech and language therapist, and behavior specialist. It was not until December 4, 2001, that Mrs. PARENT finally consented to the IEP, with the exception of the changes of STUDENT’s placement and the consulting behaviorist.

The final incident that led to STUDENT’s suspension and, ultimately, to the change of placement to the ED-SDC occurred on December 14, 2001. According to Mr. Stockman, STUDENT defied his new aide when she refused permission for him to go to a classroom to retrieve a toy that belonged to him. (Footnote 10) In the dispute that followed, STUDENT punched the aide, screamed at her, and kicked her. STUDENT was suspended from school for five days. That suspension was extended for another five days. The District then went forward with the expulsion process. Mr. Stockman and Ms. Hanson testified that they realized that the behavior was probably a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability and that he would not be expelled, but they believed the process was necessary to compel a change of placement.

In January 2002, the District conducted a partial assessment of STUDENT’s social/emotional functioning. (Footnote 11) The District psychologist concluded that STUDENT would do best with structure and predictability and with expectations, rules, and consequences that were clear and consistent. She also believed that his underlying resentment and anger toward the world led him to be negative and to engage in oppositional behavior. The psychologist recommended placement in a structured, predictable environment, direct social skills training, and anger management counseling under Chapter 26.5 or through private providers. The psychologist did not find that STUDENT was emotionally disturbed (ED).

The pre-expulsion IEP was convened on January 8, 2002. The IEP team concluded that the offending behavior was a manifestation of STUDENT’s disability. The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in Ms. England’s ED-SDC at the Anna Kyle campus. Mrs. PARENT did not then consent to the change.

The District subsequently filed a petition for injunctive relief in the Solano County Superior Court, seeking court orders compelling Mrs. PARENT to consent to proposed assessments and to allow it to transfer STUDENT to an appropriate, alternative interim placement pending the outcome of due process proceedings. Mrs. PARENT did not respond to the superior court petition. The court issued a temporary order allowing STUDENT’s transfer and assessment as requested. Eventually, the superior court petition was settled by Mrs. PARENT’s agreement on March 1, 2002, that STUDENT would attend the ED-SDC at Anna Kyle as an alternative interim placement. In that settlement, Petitioner did not waive his right to assert that the ED-SDC placement did not provide a FAPE.

STUDENT completed the 2001-2002 school year in Ms. England’s ED-SDC. He then matriculated to the fifth grade. However, after the 2001-2002 school year and ESY ended, STUDENT moved with his family to Elk Grove, California where, according to Mrs. PARENT, he has been successful in a general education placement.

Mrs. PARENT filed a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT on April 26, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 regular school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001?

The Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq., and State special education law provide that a disabled student is entitled to a FAPE. A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions.

Procedurally, the law requires that the process for the development of the IEP allow the student and parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Substantively, a FAPE is special education and related services that are available to a student at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). It includes special education and related services that are designed to meet the child’s unique needs when those needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. It must enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).

The term “related services,” which in California also is referred to as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. DIS may include language and speech development and remediation services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(1); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.1. It also may include psychological counseling services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(10); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3051.10.

The United States Supreme Court stated that the local educational agency (LEA) is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 198-200. The Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997). Moreover, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).

In summary, to have provided a child with a FAPE, an IEP must have been the result of a process that adequately protected the procedural rights of the parents and student. In addition, the student’s educational placement must (1) have been designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) have conformed to the student’s IEP. A disabled child also must have been provided an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). This means that the student must have been educated and allowed to participate in school activities with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. (Footnote 12) 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). The LEA has the burden of proof on all of these issues. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).

Procedural FAPE

Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide a FAPE during the time at issue by preventing his parents from meaningfully participating in the IEP process. (Footnote 13) He alleges that Mrs. PARENT was (1) intimidated by Mr. Stockman, who was hostile and overbearing, (2) denied reasonable access to observe STUDENT’s program and communicate with the education professionals who shared responsibility for the development and implementation of his IEP, and (3) excluded from staff meetings (not IEP meetings). (Footnote 14) Petitioner proposes that the Hearing Officer find that the District procedurally failed to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the time at issue for the foregoing reasons.

The District contends that it did everything that could reasonably be expected of it to procedurally provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the time at issue and that if Petitioner did not receive a FAPE during that time, that was due solely to circumstances beyond its control, including the unexpected death of a District employee and matters within the exclusive control of Petitioner’s parents. The District proposes that the Hearing Officer find that it fulfilled its obligations to Petitioner and that it did not procedurally deny a FAPE to STUDENT during the time at issue.

The overall scheme of special education law envisions a cooperative, team-based effort by parents, LEAs, and other agencies to properly educate individuals with exceptional needs. See 20 U.S.C. § 1414; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56340-56347. In its appendix to regulation promulgated under the IDEA, the U.S. Department of Education describes the role of the disabled student’s parents, in part, as follows:

The parents of a child with a disability are expected to be equal participants along with school personnel, in developing, reviewing, and revising the IEP for their child. This is an active role in which the parents (1) provide critical information regarding the strengths of their child and express their concerns for enhancing the education of their child; (2) participate in discussions about the child's need for special education and related services and supplementary aids and services; and (3) join with the other participants in deciding how the child will be involved and progress in the general curriculum and participate in State and district-wide assessments, and what services the agency will provide to the child and in what setting.

34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A.

The parents’ right to participate is described more specifically in the regulations. They have the right: (1) to participate at meetings to discuss the identification, evaluation, and educational placement of their child, and the provision of a FAPE to the child ( 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.501(b) and 300.344(a)(1), (2) to be part of the groups that determine what additional data are needed as part of an evaluation of their child to determine their child's eligibility and/or educational placement (34 C.F.R. §§300.533(a)(1), 300.534(a)(1), and 300.501(c), (3) to have their concerns and the information that they provide regarding their child considered in developing and reviewing their child's IEPs (34 C.F.R. §§ 300.343(c)(iii) and 300.346(a)(1)(i) and (b)), and (4) to be regularly informed of their child's progress toward the annual goals in the IEP and the extent to which that progress is sufficient to enable the child to achieve the goals by the end of the year, as specified in their child's IEP and at least as often as parents are informed of their nondisabled children's progress, (34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(7)).

California law specifically provides that IEP meetings should be “nonadversarial and convened solely for the purpose of making educational decisions for the good of the individual with exceptional needs.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(g). However, Congress and State legislators also understood that the cooperative process could break down. To address that risk, the respective rights of students, parents, LEAs, and others are set forth in the law with some particularity and procedures were established to resolve disputes through mediation and due process hearings. 20 U.S.C. § 1415; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56500-56508.

Special education law does not control the personalities of District staff or parents. The subjective reaction of a parent to the demeanor or personality of an LEA employee, or visa versa, is not the issue. It would be unproductive for the Hearing Officer to engage in a comparative analysis of the personalities in this case. It is clear from the evidence that the relationship between Mrs. PARENT and Mr. Stockman was not one of mutual respect. However, to the extent that either believed that STUDENT’s needs required it, a dispute resolution process was available. Furthermore, there is no evidence that Mrs. PARENT was prevented from meaningfully participating in the IEP process by Mr. Stockman’s intimidation.

Federal law provides that parents are entitled to an independent educational assessment if they disagree with the District’s assessment. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502. Under certain circumstances, the right to an independent assessment in California includes the right to observe the student’s educational placement and setting. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The law does not expressly grant parents the right to “observe” the student under any other circumstances. It clearly does not allow the parents unfettered access to a school site or educational staff. At most, a parent would be entitled to reasonable access as necessary to enable them to meaningfully participate in the IEP process. That determination should be made on a case-by-case basis.

In this case, the evidence did not show that Mrs. PARENT was denied reasonable access to observe STUDENT’s program and communicate with the education professionals who shared responsibility for the development and implementation of his IEP. There was testimony from Barbara Taylor that she believed that the Nelda Mundy campus was locked on one occasion, possibly to control what Mr. Stockman believed was the disruptive presence of Mrs. PARENT. There was also evidence that Mr. Stockman may have limited Mrs. PARENT’s access to school staff by insisting that she communicate through STUDENT’s case manager by e-mail. There was no claim that Mrs. PARENT was not allowed a reasonable opportunity to observe STUDENT’s program. There was no evidence that she was ever prevented from communicating necessary information to the IEP team. The Hearing Officer finds that the access restrictions imposed on Mrs. PARENT did not significantly impair her ability to meaningfully participate in the IEP process.

There were two kinds of meetings involving STUDENT that are pertinent to this discussion: IEP meetings and staff meetings convened to discuss implementation of behavioral supports (staff meetings). (Footnote 15) Parents have the right to participate in meetings relating to the identification, evaluation, and educational placement of, or the provision of a FAPE to, their child. 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(a)(2). California’s statute requires that District’s take steps to ensure that parents are allowed to participate at IEP meetings. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s parents were wrongfully excluded from an IEP meeting. The staff meetings were meetings of staff persons involved in implementing STUDENT’s behavioral supports. Ms. Bekeschus prescribed these meetings and she did not specify that the parents should attend. According to her recommendations, the staff were supposed to discuss STUDENT’s progress, current concerns, and strategies. They were not for any of purpose that required the presence of Mrs. PARENT. The Hearing Officer finds that Mrs. PARENT’s ability to meaningfully participate in the IEP process was not significantly impaired by her absence from staff meetings.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not procedurally deny a FAPE to STUDENT during the during the 2000-2001 regular school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001. Substantive FAPE

STUDENT’s Needs

STUDENT clearly had many needs during the time at issue. Only those needs placed in issue by STUDENT need to be addressed here. The focus of the parties’ dispute is on STUDENT’s behavioral needs. Specifically, the Petitioner contends that the District failed to meet his unique need for an appropriate behavioral plan and an aide to assist with the proper implemention of that plan during the 2000-2001 school year from April 26, 2001 to the end of the regular school year on or about June 10, 2001.

There is no real dispute regarding STUDENT’s need for an appropriate behavior plan to address noncompliant, disruptive, and at times dangerous behaviors that were occurring both at school and at home. A behavior support plan was part of a May 2000 IEP. In part due to the limited effectiveness of that plan, behavioral consultation was added to STUDENT’s IEP in June 2000. In September 2000, Dr. Steinfeld at U.C. Davis recommended behavioral supports that included the use of a behavior chart at home. On January 3, 2001, the District began the process for an FAA, which was conducted later that month. Vickie Wells, who participated in that FAA, recommended a behavior plan that included behavior training and consultation for STUDENT’s family and the implementation of various interventions across all environments. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needed a behavior plan to address his noncompliant, disruptive, and violent behaviors that were occurring both at school and home. He also finds that to ensure consistency of the behavioral program across environments, it was necessary that the plan include daily communication between the school and home regarding behaviors exhibited, strategies employed, success of the strategies, and other information. Additionally, STUDENT needed information-sharing and strategy meetings several times monthly to include Mrs. PARENT, the aide, the case manager and other persons.

There also is no significant disagreement about STUDENT’s need for an aide to assist with the implementation of behavioral supports. As early as March 3, 2000, Dr. Lotspeich and Dr. Vermeer from Stanford University diagnosed Asperger’s and recommended a one-to-one aide, if necessary, to control STUDENT’s behavior. In September 2000, Dr. Steinfeld recommended a one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT with social interaction. After Vickie Wells, one of the District’s own behavior specialists, observed STUDENT in November 2000, she also recommended a one-to-one aide “trained in appropriate strategies” to assist STUDENT at recess and lunch. The District’s FAA prescribed a trained one-to-one aide. Finally, the NPA behavior specialist, BIA, recommended a trained one-to-one aide to handle the day-to-day implementation of STUDENT’s BIP. No qualified professional suggested that a one-to-one aide was not one of STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT also needed an aide to assist with the proper implementation of his behavior plan.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

The testimony was in conflict regarding whether the recommendations contained in Ms. Bekeschus’ March 30, 2001 report and BIP were ever actually part of STUDENT’s IEP and enforceable as such. In the report, among other things, Ms. Beckeschus provided a detailed BIP. Additionally, she recommended that a daily communication log between home and school be utilized and that the staff and STUDENT’s parents meet three times a month to discuss, review, and possibly revise the behavioral components of STUDENT’s program. It is undisputed that no IEP meeting was held after Ms. Bekeschus issued her report. It is also undisputed that from March 30, 2001, through the end of the school year, on or about June 10, 2001, that the IEP did not contain those specific recommendations of Ms. Bekeschus, including the BIP.

The District witnesses were inconsistent in their testimony regarding Ms. Bekeschus’ report and whether or not it was part of STUDENT’s IEP. Barbara Taylor testified that she and District staff were implementing the recommendations and BIP during the last few months of the 2000-2001 school year. However, Ms. Hanson, the director of special education, testified that the District was not required to comply with Ms. Bekeschus’ recommendations and BIP because they were just recommendations and were not part of STUDENT’s IEP. (Footnote 16)

Regardless of the inconsistent testimony, the Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT’s unique needs required an effective behavior plan, daily communication between home and school, and routine meetings with the District staff and his parents. The IEP team was required to address STUDENT’s behaviors that were impeding his and his classmates’ learning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(b)(1). STUDENT’s IEP for the 2000-2001 school year did not include a BIP, a communication system between home and school, or a provision for monthly meetings. As noted, these were necessary components of an IEP to meet STUDENT’s needs. In light of this failure, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. (Footnote 17)

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Education Benefit

The Hearing Officer determined above that the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs. It is undisputed that during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT’s negative behavior significantly interfered with his ability to access and benefit from his education. The IEP did not include necessary components such as a BIP, daily home and school communication, and routine meetings with the staff and his family to address those needs. Accordingly, the IEP was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

Conform to the IEP

A school district is required to provide special education and related services to an eligible student in accordance with the student’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350(a)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(c). It can provide the services through its own personnel or by contracting with another public or private agency. However, the school district remains responsible for ensuring that the all services required by the IEP meet the student's needs as specified in the IEP. The school district may not allow another agency’s failure to deny or delay the provision of FAPE to the child. 64 Fed. Reg. 48 at 12478. (See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(12)(B)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.142(b)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56344.

STUDENT contended that the program actually provided did not conform to his IEP. More specifically, the promised aide was not provided during the period of time at issue.

It is undisputed that an aide was hired by the District and began work on or about April 11, 2001, just a few days before the spring break. Monique Bekeschus notes in her April 14, 2001 report that her training of the aide and work with the class was going well. Unfortunately, the aide passed away the following week over the spring break. A new aide was not hired during that school year. Instead, according to Mr. Stockman and Ms. Hanson, the District increased STUDENT’s behavioral support services and enlisted other school employees, specifically Mr. Stockman and teachers Patti Thrift and Mr. Patton, to supervise STUDENT during lunch and recess for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. However, the evidence demonstrated that the aide services contemplated by the January IEP were not provided.

The IEP provided an aide for twenty-two and one-half hours per week. Covering recess and lunch amounted only to approximately six to seven hours per week. There was no one providing aide services for the remaining sixteen hours per week.

Additionally, there was no evidence that Mr. Stockman or the teachers provided the kind of services contemplated by the IEP. The record makes clear that it was not the intent of the IEP team that the aide simply watch STUDENT to keep him from striking out against staff or students. The intent was to provide a trained aide who would share responsibility, and in some cases have primary responsibility, for the implementation of the BIP, including helping STUDENT with compliance issues, emotional control, remaining on task, and social interaction. The District made no effort to show that Mr. Stockman or the teachers did this or were trained to be able to do this appropriately. (Footnote 18)

The Hearing Officer is aware that the death of STUDENT’s aide during spring break was unexpected and that it takes time to hire a qualified aide. He is also aware that, as stated by Ms. Taylor, there is a learning curve for a new aide. However, neither excuses the District from its obligation to provide a FAPE for the period of time in question. The evidence did not persuade the Hearing Officer that the District exercised appropriate diligence in its effort to meet STUDENT’s need for a qualified and trained aide from approximately April 26 through the end of the regular 2000-2001 school year.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to substantively provide a FAPE to STUDENT during the time at issue by failing to provide a qualified and trained one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT in conformance with his IEP.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 regular school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001.

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from September 4, 2001, to on or about December 14, 2001?

Procedural FAPE

Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year on September 4, 2001, until his suspension on or about December 14, 2002, by preventing Petitioner’s parents from meaningfully participating in the IEP process. More specifically, he claims, as he did for the prior year, that Mr. Stockman continued to intimidate his mother and that the District continued to deny her reasonable access to observe STUDENT’s program and communicate with the education professionals who shared responsibility for the development and implementation of his IEP. STUDENT also alleges that his mother was excluded from staff meetings and that his BIP was changed without his parents’ knowledge and/or consent. Petitioner proposes that the Hearing Officer find that the District failed to procedurally provide a FAPE to him, as alleged, during this time period.

The District contends that it procedurally provided a FAPE to Petitioner during this time period and proposes that the Hearing Officer so find.

The deterioration of the working relationship between Mrs. PARENT and District staff accelerated during the first half of the 2001-2002 school year. Barbara Taylor testified that the intensity of the dislike between Mrs. PARENT and the District was such that nothing was being done to improve the situation. Ms. Taylor was so frustrated that by December 2001 she did not want to work with STUDENT anymore. It is the Hearing Officer’s view that responsibility for that deterioration belongs to both parties. If Mr. Stockman was overbearing, rigid, or restrictive, the evidence shows that the approach was a response to what he viewed as unreasonable demands and criticisms by Mrs. PARENT that were, in his opinion, having an adverse effect on school staff and on STUDENT. However, what is important is that there is no evidence that Mr. Stockman’s personal approach to Mrs. PARENT, including any limitations that were placed on her ability to visit her son’s program or to communicate with teachers, administrators, and service providers, prevented her from meaningfully participating in the IEP process or resulted in the loss of any educational opportunity by STUDENT.

STUDENT does not claim that his mother was excluded from any IEP meetings. He claims that she was wrongfully excluded from staff meetings, as he alleged for the prior year. As with the prior year, however, the evidence showed that the most of those meetings about which STUDENT complains were staff meetings which were solely for the purpose of allowing the educational staff to discuss STUDENT’s behavioral program as it was being implemented at school. With the exception of one meeting, discussed below, these were not the kind of meetings that required the participation of STUDENT’s parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5.

There was one meeting on October 18, 2001, that should have included STUDENT’s parents, as well as the consulting behaviorist, and other members of the IEP team. That meeting was convened by Mr. Stockman and included only him, STUDENT’s case manager Jill Ryan, consulting speech and language provider Barbara Taylor, and the District’s speech and language therapist. It is apparent from the notes from this meeting that are in evidence that it was Mr. Stockman’s intent to exclude Mrs. PARENT and Ms. Bekeschus, most likely because he knew that they would disagree with what he intended to do at that meeting: formally change STUDENT’s placement by denying him the opportunity to participate in play activities with nondisabled students during lunch and recess times. (Footnote 19) Because this meeting was related to STUDENT’s educational placement, his parents had the right to attend.

The District’s failure to include Mrs. PARENT at this meeting was a procedural denial of a FAPE.

The parents of a disabled student have the right to be included in any decision to change the placement of their child. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.344(a)(1) and 300.501(b); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56304, 56341.1(e), and 56342.

The same evidence about the meeting on October 18, 2001, also showed that significant changes were made to STUDENT’s program without the knowledge and consent of his parents or other IEP team members who should have been part of that decision process. (Footnote 20) As a result of an incident on September 25, 2001, when STUDENT lost emotional control and verbally and physically attacked at least two of his classmates, Mr. Stockman unilaterally changed STUDENT’s educational program by denying him access to the play yard when other children were present during recess and lunch. STUDENT’s operative IEP dated January 30, 2001 states that he would spend seventy-five percent of his school time in regular education settings. Denying STUDENT the opportunity to engage in activities with nondisabled children at recess and lunch times reduced his time in regular education settings by six to seven hours per week. There is no question that this action was taken without the knowledge or consent of STUDENT’s parents. The evidence also showed that it was taken without the knowledge and consent of any behaviorist from BIA, which at that time was supposed to be the entity primarily responsible for BIP development, training, and behavior consultation. This was a significant lapse by the District that cannot be explained or justified on the basis of a difficult parent.

The Hearing Officer finds that the unilateral change to STUDENT’s program also resulted in a procedural denial of a FAPE. Substantive FAPE

STUDENT contends that the District failed to substantively provide him a FAPE from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year on September 4, 2001, to the date of his suspension on or about December 15, 2002, by failing to provide a qualified and properly trained or experienced aide and failing to properly implement his IEP by following the recommendation of the behavioral consultant regarding the identification of the aide as STUDENT’s aide, the use of a communication log and meetings with Mrs. PARENT. (Footnote 21)

The District contends that it substantively provided a FAPE to STUDENT during the time period at issue.

STUDENT’s Needs

It has already been determined on the basis of virtually undisputed evidence that STUDENT required an appropriate plan to control the noncompliant, disruptive, and aggressive behaviors that were occurring in both the home and school environments and the services of an aide who was qualified and adequately experienced and/or trained to implement an appropriate behavior plan. As a result of the severity of STUDENT’s behaviors at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, he continued to need daily communication between home and school and routine meetings with District staff and the parents to help stabilize behavior.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs

The extent to which this element was contested is unclear. Petitioner did not dispute that the January 30, 2001 IEP and resulting BIP offered a FAPE. However, the District offered evidence to suggest that the BIP and the services of the behavior consultants at BIA were inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs. Several witnesses, including Mr. Stockman, Ms. Hanson, and Ms. Taylor, were critical of Ms. Bekeschus and questioned her competence to create a workable BIP. These criticisms suggested that the District believed as early as the close of the 2000-2001 school year that Monique Bekeschus was not able to develop a workable BIP to enable the District to provide a FAPE to STUDENT in a regular education classroom. The purpose of this evidence was not explained in closing argument. If the District’s position was that it was not responsible for the BIP created by an NPA that had been purportedly selected by STUDENT’s parents, BIA, it is laboring under a misconception. (Footnote 22) The District had the obligation to provide a FAPE and that obligation was not dependent on the providers selected or who selected them.

Rather than simply accepting the District’s offer of this evidence as tantamount to a stipulation that it denied a FAPE to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will also examine the possibility that the District intended its criticism to support an argument that Ms. Bekeschus’ inability to design a workable BIP for use in a regular education classroom showed that STUDENT required a more restrictive placement in an ED-SDC.

The evidence did not demonstrate that the BIP was unworkable. Since neither party chose to call a behavioral expert to testify, the Hearing Officer resorted to documentary evidence, particularly the reports of the District’s behavior specialists (including BIA), who were directly involved in assessing and providing services to STUDENT.

In November 2000, after District behavioral specialist Vickie Wells observed disruptions by STUDENT inside the classroom and on the play yard, she recommended that STUDENT receive one-to-one support during recess and lunch and that this adult “receive training in the use of preventive behavior management strategies and in the facilitation of appropriate social/play skills prior to working with him.” She also made other recommendations, including two hours per week of behavior consultation/support services to the staff that worked with STUDENT. (Footnote 23)

Ms. Wells’ observations were confirmed a few months later when she and her colleagues conducted the FAA in January 2001. Targeting STUDENT’s aggressive, noncompliant, and disruptive behaviors, the District’s behavior specialists concluded that the function of STUDENT’s behavior was primarily to get something, such as preferred activities or attention from adults or peers, to provide self-stimulatory feedback as an attempt to self-regulate, or to avoid or escape something. Among those behavioral interventions was the identification of alternative behaviors that would serve the same function. Recommendations for adult intervention or assistance included teaching STUDENT a verbal script or specific gesture to request adult attention, assistance with transitions by providing STUDENT with a schedule of the day’s activities, the use of a “token” system of rewards at school and home, accommodations (e.g. a foot rest, seat cushion and squeeze object) to facilitate required self-stimulation, and structured social/play activities facilitated and supervised by an adult. The report recommends assignment of a trained one-to-one aide “within the school environment,” behavioral training and consultation for STUDENT’s family, mental health services, and that the specific behavioral interventions be implemented across all environments with behavior specialist support.

Monique Bekeschus agreed that a one-to-one aide should be assigned. She recommended that the aide be “an integral part of the classroom” while she was not implementing the BIP. Ms. Bekeschus recommended that the aide undergo hands-on training, including at least nineteen days of training by the end of the 2000-2001 school year. (Footnote 24)

The parties did not dispute the qualifications of the various behavioral specialists. The various documents prepared by those specialists show that their recommendations were the result of a thoughtful and detailed analysis of STUDENT’s needs. This is some evidence that the pertinent portions of the program, essentially those related to controlling STUDENT’s behavior, were reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and, therefore, workable. STUDENT accepts the BIP as appropriate. The District does not. However, as discussed in more detail below, the District did not show that it implemented the recommendations of the behavior specialists. Without that proof, the argument fails.

Despite the inclusion of the BIP in STUDENT’s IEP in October 2002, the IEP failed to include all of the necessary components to meet STUDENT’s needs. Even with STUDENT’s behaviors continuing to escalate and Ms. Bekeschus’ report the IEP was not amended to include a daily communication log or routine meetings with school staff and parents. Therefore, the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the challenged portions of the IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

STUDENT did not challenge this element of FAPE, essentially accepting the pertinent IEP/BIP as offering a FAPE while arguing that the District did not deliver the promised program.

Conform to the IEP

The evidence shows that the District did not properly implement STUDENT’s IEP/BIP. The District offered no evidence to show that any of STUDENT’s aides were adequately trained or experienced to meet his needs. (Footnote 25) On the contrary, testimony of several witnesses, including Barbara Taylor, demonstrated that the aide who was supposed to be assisting STUDENT during the first few months of the 2001-2002 school year had not been adequately trained to effectively implement STUDENT’s BIP. Ms. Taylor testfied that she observed the aide’s interaction with STUDENT and documented her concerns about the apparent lack of training. (Footnote 26) At least one parent of another child in STUDENT’s class complained that the aide stood by and did nothing to stop STUDENT’s aggressive or disruptive behavior. In addition, the minutes from the October 18, 2001 meeting of Mr. Stockman, Ms. Ryan, Ms. Taylor, and the speech and language therapist refers to their conclusion that the aide was not capable of carrying out the responsibilities of the position.

The behavioral specialist retained by the District specifically recommended that the aide not be identified as STUDENT’s. He or she was to be introduced as an integral part of the teaching team in the class and was to function as such when not specifically implementing STUDENT’s BIP. The District was also advised by Mrs. PARENT that STUDENT would not readily accept the assistance of an aide assigned specifically to him. This was sufficiently important to Mrs. PARENT that she declined to consent to the January 2001 IEP until the review summary was amended to include that protection. In spite of the assurance in the IEP document and the risk that STUDENT would be embarrassed, self-conscious, and angry, and refuse to accept support from his aide if the aide was specifically identified as his, the District did what it was advised not to do.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program as delivered did not conform to STUDENT’s IEP.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to substantively provide a FAPE to STUDENT from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year on or about September 4, 2001 to the date of his suspension on or about December 14, 2001. (Footnote 27)

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did fail to provide a FAPE, both procedurally and substantively, to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from September 4, 2001 to on or about December 14, 2001.

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from on or about March 1, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year?

Procedural FAPE

The Petitioner’s sole procedural claim for the period of time at issue is that his placement was changed to the ED-SDC without his parents’ consent. The District claims that the change of placement was initially allowed by a valid court order and later consented to by Mrs. PARENT.

Generally, an IEP cannot be implemented without parental consent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). If the parent refuses consent to any part of an IEP and the LEA determines that the part to which the parent does not consent is necessary to provide a FAPE, it is required to initiate a due process hearing unless a prehearing mediation conference is held. Cal. Educ Code § 56346(b). However, there are special procedures available when the LEA believes that the subject student is truly dangerous. In such cases, the LEA can seek a court order allowing the LEA to change the student’s placement without parental consent. Honig v. Doe, 484 U.S. 305, 327-328 (1988).

On January 14, 2002, the Superior Court in Solano County issued a temporary order that prevented STUDENT from returning to his placement at Nelda Mundy. The Hearing Officer has no jurisdiction to review that order. However, the superior court case was dismissed and STUDENT was placed in the ED-SDC on or about March 1, 2002 pursuant to a settlement agreement. Mrs. PARENT consented to the placement. Therefore, her procedural challenge must fail.

The Hearing Officer finds that the placement of STUDENT in the ED-SDC on or about March 1, 2002, was not without parental consent.

Substantive FAPE

STUDENT makes two related substantive claims for the last part of the 2001-2002 school year and ESY. He claims that the ED-SDC was not the LRE in which to educate him and that an appropriate placement would have been comparable to that prescribed by his IEP, a regular education placement with an appropriate behavior plan, an experienced or trained one-to-one aide, and maximum opportunities to participate in school and related activities with nondisabled peers for at least seventy-five percent of his school day. These will be addressed together as an LRE claim.

The District contends that its reasonable efforts to educate STUDENT in a regular classroom with typically developing peers failed through no fault of its own and that the ED-SDC was the LRE in which to deliver a FAPE to STUDENT during the time in question.

Federal and State special education laws require that an eligible student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student's disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. The preference in the law for educating disabled students with those who are not disabled is so strong that it rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989). Futhermore, it is not an all-or-nothing proposition. Even when it is determined that some of the student’s needs cannot be satisfactorily met in regular education classes, removal to a special education environment should occur only as necessary to meet those needs. Id at 1050.

Initially, the Hearing officer notes that the District argued that the Petitioner’s placement in the ED-SDC at Anna Kyle was less restrictive than his prior placement at Nelda Mundy, his home school. Ms. Hanson, the District’s director of special education, testified to her opinion that STUDENT’s regular education placement with an assigned aide was more restrictive than the ED-SDC placement. Her opinion is at odds with the law, which requires that the student be educated and allowed to participate in other school activities with nondisabled students to the maximum extent possible. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). In his regular education placement, STUDENT’s IEP allowed him to be with his nondisabled peers throughout the day except during speech and language and RSP pull-out, which according to the January 2001 IEP constituted no more than twenty-five percent of his day. According to the testimony of Ms. England, the teacher of the ED-SDC in which STUDENT spent his entire class day, all of her students, with the exception of STUDENT, were identified as special needs children under the category emotionally disturbed. It is clear that his regular education placement at his home school with an aide and other supports was a less restrictive environment than the ED-SDC. (See 34 C.F.R. § 300.552.)

The determination of whether a particular placement is in the least restrictive environment involves an analysis of four factors: (1) the educational benefits available to the child in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared to the educational benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the nonacademic benefits to the disabled child of interaction with nondisabled children, (3) the effect of the presence of the disabled child on the teacher and other children in the regular classroom, and (4) the costs of supplemental aids and services necessary to mainstream the disabled child in a regular classroom setting. Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994, cert. denied 1994).

Comparative Educational Benefit

Prior to March 1, 2002, STUDENT received sufficient educational benefit from his regular classroom placement in the District to move from grade to grade in spite of the behaviors that interfered with his education. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the benefit received would have been even greater if the District had implemented an appropriate IEP/BIP that included a trained and properly supervised, full-time aide, adequate training and support for school staff and STUDENT’s family, and an effective program for educating other students about STUDENT’s disability and for eliminating teasing.

The parties agree that STUDENT also received educational benefit from his ED-SDC placement. Ms. England testified that STUDENT did fairly well and that he benefited from the placement in her class. Mrs. PARENT testified that as far as she knew, STUDENT’s placement in the ED-SDC was relatively smooth.

The Hearing Officer finds that there is no evidence to demonstrate that STUDENT received a greater educational benefit in the ED-SDC than he did in any of his regular education placements.

Nonacademic Benefits

The parties spent little time offering evidence or argument on the non-academic benefits of a regular education placement. However, some are obvious.

Everyone agrees that STUDENT is a bright child. He is able to learn. There is general agreement that he has learned much about appropriate social interaction but has had some persistent difficulty applying that knowledge and generalizing it across environments. The experts who have considered the matter have been in agreement that part of STUDENT’s education must include teaching him to apply and generalize this knowledge in social situations through facilitated and supervised social situations.

The only witness to testify regarding the type of student that should participate in social skills training with STUDENT was Barbara Taylor, who would occasionally supervise that training. She testified that it would not be beneficial to include any other student with behavior problems in that training for STUDENT. It is also logical that STUDENT would have been more likely to learn appropriate social skills from interaction with children who were not seriously emotionally disturbed or otherwise prone to negative behaviors.

Ms. England testified that STUDENT was allowed to take recess and lunch with the upper grades four through six at her school. She supervised her class, but there was no evidence that there was any facilitated play or social interaction between STUDENT and his nondisabled peers. Although all of the other children in the ED-SDC were in regular education for some of their day, the efforts to “mainstream” STUDENT were unsuccessful. It is not clear from the evidence why they were unsuccessful, but a reasonable inference to be drawn from Ms. England’s testimony is that STUDENT was teased and there was no trained aide with him to intervene. The only social skills training evident from Ms. England’s testimony would have been that provided in her classroom to her ED students and STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that the nonacademic benefit to STUDENT was and would have been greater in an appropriate general education placement with supports than in the ED-SDC.

STUDENT’s Impact On Teacher and Other Students

There is no question that STUDENT was at times disruptive. In support of its position that STUDENT’s disruptive and violent behavior justified his placement in the ED-SDC, the District offered letters from STUDENT’s teachers, Ms. Hodges, Ms. Lamp, and Ms. Back, as well as other documents and testimony. The letters from the three teachers were all dated January 8, 2002. (Footnote 28) All describe various disruptive and violent behaviors of STUDENT, and all appear to have been drafted for the sole purpose of supporting the school’s decision to force a change of placement.

Ms. Lamp wrote that “STUDENT’s angry outbursts were a real concern for the safety of everyone around him. Without any warning he would hurt other students and yell out inappropriate and verbally abusive things. He continued this behavior with very little improvement. Due to this above mentioned (sic) behavior, the learning process was greatly disrupted.” However, at the hearing, she testified that she believed that STUDENT’s behavior plan was working and that he was making progress both academically and behaviorally. She said that he even did fine in her class without the assistance of an aide. In her view, it was on the playground that STUDENT had difficulty.

In her letter, Ms. Back describes sudden and unprovoked outbursts that, in her opinion, threatened her safety and that of her students. She also listed physical attacks against her, the aide, the behavior specialist, and other students. She did not state which of the incidents occurred in the classroom, the precipitating factors or surrounding circumstances, or that she was unable to teach her class as a result of these incidents. (Footnote 29) In her testimony, she stated that the presence of STUDENT and his aide in the classroom did not prevent her from teaching the class.

The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the District’s argument that it had tried less restrictive placements such as that still proposed by STUDENT but had been unsuccessful. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District had not provided STUDENT with the supports that he needed in his earlier regular education placement.

The Hearing Officer finds that there is inadequate evidence to support a finding that STUDENT’s behavior that was merely disruptive was sufficient to justify a finding that he required placement in the ED-SDC. The Hearing Officer is mindful of the District’s responsibility for the safety of students and staff on campus and that threatening or violent behavior must be addressed. However, at least from the District’s perspective, placing STUDENT in the ED-SDC did not eliminate the behavior. It merely changed the available targets. Ms. England’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s behavior in her class and her ability to manage it, and the documents describing STUDENT’s experience in his current placement persuade the Hearing Officer that STUDENT did not need a more restrictive placement to receive a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer finds that the impact that STUDENT’s behavior had on his teachers and other students did not require placement in the ED-SDC, or in any comparably restrictive environment, for him to receive a FAPE.

The Cost of Supportive Services

The cost of services required to support STUDENT in an LRE was not put in issue and no evidence was presented as to the cost of either placement at issue.

Weighing all of the factors, the Hearing Officer finds that the ED-SDC in which STUDENT was placed from March 2002 through the end of the ESY was not the LRE in which the District could have delivered a FAPE to him.

On the basis of the above, the Hearing officer finds that the District failed to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from on or about March 1, 2002 to the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year.

Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide a free appropriate public education to Petitioner during any of the time at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?

Petitioner proposes that the Hearing Officer find that Petitioner is entitled to an award of compensatory education and that he should receive, at public expense, approximately 969 hours of services from Advance Education, Inc. The District proposes that the Hearing Officer find that Petitioner is not entitled to the requested compensatory education or to any compensatory education award whatsoever and that all of Petitioner’s claims for relief be denied.

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, supra, 31 F.3d at 497.

There is no doubt in the Hearing Officer’s mind that STUDENT suffered a loss of educational opportunity as a result of the denials of a FAPE. For approximately eight weeks during the 2000-2001 school year, he was without a trained aide. For the same period of time, STUDENT’s parents were not being provided with information that should have ensured consistency of the behavior program at the school and at home and might have enabled them to be more informed and effective advocates for STUDENT in the IEP process. For approximately fourteen weeks during the first part of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was without an aide that was properly trained to assist him with his behavior and he was denied social time at lunch and recess for approximately eleven of those fourteen weeks. In addition, STUDENT’s parents were still was not receiving information through communication logs and parent meetings. Throughout all of these weeks during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, STUDENT was missing significant periods of instruction time because he was being removed from his classroom. He was also denied the benefit that should have come from the efforts of a properly trained aide to facilitate social interaction and to teach STUDENT how to generalize those skills across environments.

The evidence showed that STUDENT probably did not lose instruction time during his twenty-five week placement in the ED-SDC. (Footnote 30) However, he did lose opportunities to participate in instruction and other school activities with nondiasbled peers. To that extent, he was denied the opportunity to further develop social skills.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education. On the basis of several witnesses’ estimates of the time that STUDENT was out of class due to behavioral problems, the Hearing Officer finds that a reasonable award of compensatory education will include one-to-one tutoring from a credentialed teacher for two hours for each of the twenty-two weeks that he was missing substantial instruction time due, in part, to not having a trained aide. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that a compensatory education award will include social skills training in a small group of typically developing and same-aged peers from a person with documented experience providing that kind of service to children with Asperger’s disorder. This component of the award will include two hours for each of the eight weeks that STUDENT was without his trained aide during the 2000-2001 school year, and two hours for each of the first three weeks of the 2001-2002 school year before STUDENT was denied opportunities to be with the regular students during lunch and recess, and three hours for each of the eleven weeks while STUDENT was not allowed to play with the other children at recess and lunch, and two hours for each of the twenty-six weeks that STUDENT was in the ED-SDC and allowed to play with the other children at lunch and recess but without a trained aide to facilitate play. (Footnote 31) In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is entitled to an award of compensatory education and that the award will consist of forty-four hours of one-on-one academic tutoring from a credentialed teacher and one hundred and seven hours of social skills training in a small group of typically developing same-aged peers from a person with documented experience providing that kind of service to children with Asperger’s disorder. All of these services shall be provided by District personnel or by another public agency or NPA under contract with the District and shall be delivered at a time and location convenient to STUDENT’s parent’s. The compensatory education services shall be completed by the end of the 2005-2006 school year.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall arrange for the Petitioner to receive the following compensatory education to be completed by the beginning of the 2005-2006 school year:

(a) Forty-four hours of one-to-one academic tutoring from a credentialed teacher; and, (b) One hundred and seven hours of social skills training in a small group of typically developing same-aged peers from a person with documented experience providing that kind of service to children with Asperger’s disorder; (c) The ordered services shall be provided by District personnel or by another public agency or NPA under contract with the District and shall be delivered at a time and location convenient to STUDENT’s parent’s.

2. All other requests by Petitioner are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

Issue No. 1: Did the District fail to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner during the 2000-2001 school year from on or about April 26, 2001, to the end of the school year on or about June 10, 2001?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 2: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from September 4, 2001, to on or about December 14, 2001?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 3: Did the District fail to provide a FAPE to Petitioner during the 2001-2002 school year from on or about March 1, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 extended school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide a free appropriate public education to Petitioner during any of the time at issue, is he entitled to an award of compensatory education and, if so, what should that award be?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: Date: September 3, 2004 _________________________________ Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

* The sole amendment strikes the words, “and approved by his current IEP team” from the Order on page 30. On the first day of hearing only, Mr. Kinkade was assisted by his law clerk, Carl Corbin.

2 The issues were identified by Petitioner during a telephonic prehearing conference on July 23, 2004, and clarified on the first day of hearing.

3 Ms. Wells recommended a referral under AB 3632. Chapter 26.5 governs interagency responsibilities for the delivery of related services, including mental health services, to individuals entitled to them under the IDEA and related State laws. Such related services are frequently referred to by the number designations of the many assembly bills that have gone into making up the statutes in Chapter 26.5 over the years since AB 3632 was first passed in 1984.

4 According to the testimony of several District employees, under the token system STUDENT would receive four tokens in the morning. These would be taken away to punish misconduct.

5 Mrs. PARENT was aware that STUDENT was embarrassed by the prospect of having an adult watch him. On November 9, 2000, after his teacher told him that he would be watched at lunch and recess to make sure he behaved, STUDENT wrote in a story explaining that this would embarrass him.

6 The report was also reviewed and approved by Bs. Bekeschus’ supervisor, Hilary Baldi, the Director of BIA.

7 There was no testimony showing to whom the report was directed.

8 The reference to “schedules,” contained in the notes of the October meeting of Mr. Stockman, Ms. Ryan, Ms. Taylor, and the District’s speech and language therapist do not explain how schedules were affected.

9 District administrative regulations establish a procedure for the filing of formal charges against a school employee.

10 The IA that who been assigned to STUDENT at the beginning of the year had quit recently.

11 According to the testimony, the assessment was never completed.

12 A FAPE should enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). This element is not at issue in this case.

13 The parties agree that Mrs. PARENT was the parent who dealt with STUDENT’s educational issues.

14 STUDENT also claimed that his mother was denied access to information that should have been provided to her through a communication log and in parent meetings. This claim is more appropriately addressed, below, as an alleged substantive denial of a FAPE.

15 Recommended meetings with Mrs. PARENT will be discussed below.

16 The District’s counsel argued the position taken by Ms. Hanson.

17 Some District witnesses testified that they acted upon Ms. Bekeschus’ report and attempted to implement the BIP and additional recommendations. However, there is no provision in special education law that provides for the inclusion of additional necessary supports and services outside of the IEP process. Even assuming that the recommendations and BIP were incorporated into the IEP by the conduct of the parties, they were not implemented or only implemented to a limited degree. For example, according to the evidence presented at hearing, the communication log was utilized by an instructional aide on one occasion and the monthly meetings were never held. Therefore, if the Hearing Officer had determined that the components were somehow incorporated into the IEP, the District still would have substantively denied STUDENT a FAPE because of the failure to implement a program that comported with his IEP.

18 According to Mr. Stockman’s summary of significant aggressive incidents, five of them occurred during May 2001 when Mr. Stockman and two teachers were providing “aide” services to STUDENT. This was more than recorded in any other month for which a record had been made.

19 The actual change had been instituted approximately three weeks earlier on Mr. Stockman’s orders.

20 The District did not argue that the change of placement was an in-school suspension and an allowed method of disciplining STUDENT. In any event, because the change exceeded ten days in length and there was no manifestation determination in connection with it, such a argument would not have been persuasive. (See: 20 U.S.C. §1415(k); 34 C.F.R. § 300.519; Cal. Educ. Code § 48915.5.

21 In October 2001 Mrs. PARENT learned that the BIP was not part of STUDENT’s IEP. She went to the school and signed the BIP in October, making it part of the IEP. However, the other recommendations of Ms. Bekeschus’ report remained unaddressed in the IEP.

22 It was not established that STUDENT’s parents required the retention of BIA. However, whether they did or not is immaterial to the District’s obligation to provide a FAPE, including an appropriate BIP if required. Parents’ insistence on a particular provider may or may not be material to equitable issues, such as compensatory education.

23 Another of her recommendation was that STUDENT be referred for mental health assessment. Others made this same recommendation, but there was no evidence that the District diligently pursued it.

24 Considering the date of the recommendation and the number of school weeks remaining, this would have amounted to approximately half of the school days left in the year.

25 STUDENT had two aides between the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year and his suspension in December 2001.

26 Although her criticisms seemed somewhat dulled at the hearing, the Hearing Officer gave greater weight to the impressions recorded at the time the observations of the aide occurred.

27 LRE was not an issue for this first segment of the 2001-2002 school year.

28 Circumstances demonstrate that the “2001” date on Ms. Hodges’ letter is a mistake and should have been “2002”.

29 Even in his ED-SDC placement, STUDENT was allowed to be on the playground with nondisabled students. The focus here should be on his behavior in the classroom.

30 There was no specific information offered by either party regarding the exact period of time. The Petitioner framed the issue to include the period up to August 31, 2002 and the District did not suggest a different date.

31 The parent requested an award of services through a specific provider, but there was no evidence upon which the Hearing Officer could base such a requirement.