California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 15, 2000
Student v. Whittier City School District
SEHO Case No. SN 964-00 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Whittier City School District need not provide an Apple iBook laptop; school desktops and an AlphaSmart were found sufficient.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A nine-year-old fourth grader eligible for special education as other health impaired filed for due process against Whittier City School District. Her medical conditions caused long absences. She had fine motor deficits that made handwriting hard, and weak auditory memory and language skills. Both sides agreed she needed assistive technology for writing. They also agreed that a computer with voice output, which reads typed text aloud, would help her. The parent agreed to the rest of the May 2000 IEP but asked for an Apple iBook laptop for use at school and at home. Independent assessor Dr. Laura Meyers had recommended it. The District offered an AlphaSmart word processor for her exclusive use, which she could take home. It also offered access to voice-output desktop computers in the classroom, resource room, and computer lab.
The Hearing Officer split the dispute into two questions and ruled for the District on both. First, the laptop and the school desktops worked the same way, so the desktops could carry out her IEP goals. Concerns about files spread across machines and screens blocking her view were efficiency issues. A floppy disk and moving the computer could fix them. Second, she did not need voice output at home to receive FAPE. Her teachers said direct instruction in strategies drove her progress, and Dr. Meyers' own plan relied on limited instructional sessions. The laptop request was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied the "benefit from education" standard to assistive technology. A device that would help a student, or make her work more efficient, was not required when equivalent school equipment could carry out the IEP. Home use was required only when the IEP team found the student needed home access to receive FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(1). Does STUDENT require assistive technology in the form of an Apple ibook laptop computer to benefit from her education during 2000-2001; subissue (1): whether STUDENT requires a laptop computer for personal use rather than access to various equivalent desktop computers at school.
The school's voice-output desktop computers work the same way as the laptop and can carry out her IEP; concerns about file storage and blocked views were efficiency issues that could be easily fixed.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1(2). Subissue (2): whether STUDENT requires a computer (either a laptop or a desktop model) with voice output capabilities for use at home rather than the AlphaSmart word processor (without voice output technology) offered by the District.
Voice output at home might help, but she did not need it to receive FAPE. Direct strategy instruction, voice-output computers at school, and speech services met her needs, and the expert's own plan relied on limited instructional sessions.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's request for an Apple ibook laptop computer for the 2000-2001 school year denied.
Key authorities
20 U.S.C. § 1401; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(3)(B)(v); 34 C.F.R. § 300.308(b); Education Code § 56363; Education Code § 56363.1
People named in the decision
- Matthew Pope, attorney for Student
- Darin Barber, attorney for District
- Eugenia Rubalcaba, Regional Center services coordinator, Regional Center
- Dr. Laura (Dollie) Meyers, language development specialist; independent assistive technology assessor; expert witness for Student
- Nelle Paegel, intern, Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP)
- Karen Herbst, director of educational support services, Whittier City School District
- Diana Zelezny, school psychologist, Whittier City School District
- Christina Riserbato, speech and language specialist, Whittier City School District
- Alondra Cortez, third grade general education teacher, Phelan Elementary School
- Colette Kanengiser, resource specialist, Whittier City School District
- Trudie Efstratios, principal, Washington Elementary School
- Will Gagner, special education coordinator; conducted District assistive technology assessment, Whittier City School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Whittier, California, on July 18, 2000.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at hearing by attorney Matthew Pope. Also present on her behalf were her mother, MOTHER, and her Regional Center services coordinator, Eugenia Rubalcaba. STUDENT and her older sister, SISTER, were also present for part of the hearing.
Respondent Whittier City School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Darin Barber. Also present on the District's behalf were Nelle Paegel, intern with the Whittier Area Cooperative Special Education Program (WACSEP), and Karen Herbst, director of educational support services.
Petitioner called her mother and Dr. Laura Meyers, Ph.D., language development specialist, to testify at hearing. STUDENT also testified on her own behalf.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Diana Zelezny, school psychologist; Christina Riserbato, speech and language specialist; Alondra Cortez, teacher at Phelan Elementary School; Colette Kanengiser, resource specialist; and Trudie Efstratios, principal at Washington Elementary School.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Does STUDENT require assistive technology in the form of an Apple ibook laptop computer to benefit from her education during the 2000-2001 school year?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old fourth-grade student who has been eligible for special education and related services within the District since September 1996 under the category of "other health impaired." STUDENT, who was born three months premature, suffers from petit mal seizures, asthma-like symptoms, and chronic pneumonia. As a result of her medical conditions, she is frequently absent from school for extended periods of time. Upon her return to school, she has been noted to exhibit "significant regression" in her academic skills. While STUDENT's cognitive ability is in the low average range, she has difficulty with the concept of sequence and has significant deficits in auditory memory and visual memory. Additionally, STUDENT has fine motor deficits that affect her ability to write with a pen or pencil. STUDENT's educational needs are in the areas of reading comprehension, written language, math computation, "practical math," and receptive and expressive language.
For the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was mainstreamed in Ms. Alondra Cortez's third grade regular education class at Phelan Elementary School and was assisted by a full time one-to-one resource specialist aide. For thirty percent of her school day, STUDENT received resource specialist services from Colette Kanengiser. Additionally, STUDENT received pull-out speech and language services from Christina Riserbato.
Pursuant to a request for assessment from MOTHER, District special education coordinator, Will Gagner, conducted an assistive technology assessment of STUDENT in September of 1999. Mr. Gagner noted that STUDENT had auditory and visual processing and memory problems, had difficulty generalizing previously learned materials, and had difficulty writing words down on paper. Mr. Gagner also noted that the District staff working with STUDENT had implemented both "non-technology strategies and accommodations" and assistive technology devices to assist in STUDENT's learning. The non-technology strategies and accommodations included "tactile-kinesthetic approach, sign-language for phonetic cues, tapping out and blending words, [and] visual pictorial clues for grapho-phonics." The assistive technology devices used with STUDENT included a "pencil grip to correct pincer grasp, computers for word processing, step boards to improve tactile-kinesthetic learning, a white board to improve letter formation, a reading window to improve on visual awareness and a language master to ameliorate sound symbol relationship using a multi-modality approach." Based on his assessment, Mr. Gagner recommended that STUDENT continue to have access to a computer to assist in word processing and enhance reading skills, that she "be given instruction in the use of a hand portable word processor (such as an Alpha Smart) to assist in word processing and eventually increase writing speed and output," that the "hand portable computer" be accessible at her desktop, and that her educational staff continue to use a multisensory approach to teaching STUDENT.
On October 7, 1999, STUDENT's individualized education program (IEP) team convened. At the meeting, the team agreed that STUDENT required assistive technology services and that she should be provided assistive technology in the form of "access to writing equipment such as an AlphaSmart, computer, [and] spell check device." Although it was noted in the IEP that STUDENT's parents were seeking an independent assistive technology assessment, her parents consented to the IEP placement and services. At hearing, Petitioner clarified that she had no issues with regard to the appropriateness of the placement and services she received pursuant to the October 1999 IEP.
At the end of October 1999, MOTHER obtained the independent assistive technology assessment from Dr. Laura ("Dollie") Meyers, a language development specialist. For STUDENT's assessment, Dr. Meyers administered the Illinois Test of Psycholinguistic Abilities Assessment, the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, and the Berry Developmental Test of Visual-Motor Integration. From these assessments, Dr. Meyers made the following findings: STUDENT was close to age level on tests of visual processing, she was "more delayed" on tests of auditory processing, and she was "most seriously delayed" on the tests that required the use of expressive language. Furthermore, Dr. Meyers found that STUDENT had "severe problems with visual-motor integration, which is required for handwriting." Also as part of the assessment, Dr. Meyers instructed STUDENT on the use of a computer with voice output technology to aide in her writing composition and reading comprehension. Based on her assessment and findings, Dr. Meyers concluded that STUDENT would benefit from the use of a computer with voice output technology because it enabled her "to produce highly legible text, bypassing her problems with eye-hand coordination… [and] it linked her writing (visual feedback) with speech output (auditory feedback)," which allowed her to use her stronger visual skills to enhance her auditory processing and expressive language use.(Footnote 1) Accordingly, Dr. Meyers developed a number of language goals for STUDENT, and recommended that STUDENT be provided "research-based teaching methods" using a computer with speech output to assist her with her written and spoken language. Dr. Meyers recommended that the language services be provided for two one-hour sessions per week for six months. Subsequent to the assessment, Dr. Meyers began to provide STUDENT with the services recommended in her report. Such services were funded by the local Regional Center.
On April 21, 2000, the District conducted a triennial evaluation of STUDENT to determine her continued eligibility and need for special education services. STUDENT was assessed in the areas of sensory-motor/perceptual skills, social emotional development and adaptive behavior, cognitive functioning, and speech and language development. According to her triennial evaluation, STUDENT has age-appropriate social communication skills, but only limited language comprehension skills. Additionally, STUDENT's ability to formulate ideas and sentences, understand word-relationships, and recall information is in the below-average range. Furthermore, it was found in the triennial evaluation that STUDENT's fine motor skills are limited and that tasks involving eye-hand coordination using the small muscles of her fingers, hand and arm would be very difficult for her. The District assessors also found that, when STUDENT is required to perform a motor task such as handwriting, her visual memory ability "deteriorates."
On April 27, 2000, approximately six months after Dr. Meyers began providing STUDENT with language services, Dr. Meyers wrote a letter (apparently to the District) recommending that STUDENT be provided with an Apple ibook laptop computer with voice output capabilities. In her letter, Dr. Meyers indicated that her work with STUDENT had enabled STUDENT to "write more, at a more age-appropriate level, in a shorter time, than she [was] able to accomplish in other settings." She also stated that, for STUDENT to be able to write at that level in the classroom, she needs to be provided a computer for use with all writing assignments. Dr. Meyers recommended that the language goals from her October 1999 assessment report be incorporated into STUDENT's IEP and that she be provided with the Apple ibook laptop computer for use at home and at school.
STUDENT's IEP meeting convened again on May 3 and May 9, 2000, to discuss the assessments of the District and of Dr. Meyers, and to develop an educational program for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year. At the meeting, the team developed goals and objectives for STUDENT to address her deficits in math computation, reading comprehension, reading decoding, written language, expressive language, and auditory comprehension. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT a placement in a general education fourth grade class at her home school with resource specialist program support, speech and language services, and supplemental assistance from an instructional aide. Furthermore, the District offered to provide STUDENT with an AlphaSmart word processor for her exclusive use and access to the "iMac" computers and "PowerMacs" in the classroom, resource specialist room, and computer lab. MOTHER consented to the IEP goals and objectives, and the District's offered placement and programs, with the exception of the offered assistive technology. Instead of the use of the AlphaSmart and access to various computers at school, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be provided with the Apple ibook laptop computer recommended by Dr. Meyers.
Unable to agree as to the appropriate assistive technology device for STUDENT, MOTHER requested a special education due process hearing on May 30, 2000.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18). "Special education" is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term "related services" includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program."
Additionally, Districts are responsible for providing certain types of specialized equipment, including assistive technology devices, for use at school when the equipment is needed to implement the individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(1), 1414(d)(3)(B)(v); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.1. According to Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, Section 300.308(b), the use of school-purchased assistive technology devices in a child's home or in other non-school settings is required if the child's IEP team determines that the child needs access to those devices in order to receive a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.308(b).
The sole issue in this case relates to what type of assistive technology STUDENT requires as part of her educational program. The parties generally agree that STUDENT requires assistive technology in the form of a computer or word processor to aid in her writing composition and reading skills. Additionally, the parties agree that STUDENT would benefit from a computer with voice output capabilities because she is a multi-sensory learner and such a computer would enable her to both see and hear what she is writing. The dispute centers on whether STUDENT requires an Apple ibook laptop computer with voice output technology. Petitioner argues that she requires an Apple ibook laptop computer with voice output capabilities for her own personal use at school and at home. The District, on the other hand, argues that STUDENT's needs can be met through the use of the desktop computers (with voice output) at school and through her exclusive use of an AlphaSmart word processor that she can take home. In light of the parties' contentions, two subissues arise: (1) whether STUDENT requires a laptop computer for personal use rather than access to various equivalent desktop computers at school, and (2) whether STUDENT requires a computer (either a laptop or a desktop model) with voice output capabilities for use at home rather than the AlphaSmart word processor (without voice output technology) offered by the District.
With regard to the first subissue, the evidence established that STUDENT does not require the use of a laptop computer rather than the use of the equivalent desktop computers offered by the District to implement her IEP. In her IEP, STUDENT has goals and objectives in written language that require her to write, type, and edit sentences. Her IEP also provides for accommodations and modifications in the form of "multisensory instruction." Dr. Meyers, Ms. Kanengiser, and Ms. Riserbato all agree that a computer with voice output would benefit STUDENT because it would enable her to write while receiving both visual and auditory feedback from her writing. Trudie Efstratios, the principal of Washington Elementary School through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, testified that STUDENT's prospective fourth-grade classroom and resource specialist program room have desktop computers with voice output technology similar to the kind found on the Apple ibook laptop computer. The parties do not dispute that both the Apple ibook laptop computer and the desktop version of the computer function in much the same way. As both the desktop computer and the laptop computer have voice output technology and word processing programs, STUDENT's written language and reading needs can be met through the use of either type of computer. Because STUDENT's goals and objectives can be implemented and multisensory instructional needs can be met with a voice output computer, and because there is no dispute that the desktop and laptop computers function in the same way, it is concluded that STUDENT's goals and objectives can be implemented through use of the District's desktop computers.
While Petitioner does not dispute that the desktop computer and the laptop computer functions similarly, she argues that she requires the laptop computer for other reasons. According to Dr. Meyers, Petitioner's expert witness, STUDENT requires a laptop for her personal use so that she will have the same computer to use throughout the day and so that all of her compositions will be stored on one hard drive for her ready access. In her July 5, 2000 letter, Dr. Meyers wrote that STUDENT's having her own laptop would eliminate the need for her to "find what she wrote on several different machines, amid other students' files, or transfer [files] from the AlphaSmart to the computer." Dr. Meyers also testified that having a desktop computer on STUDENT's desk would block her view of the teacher and would interfere with her classroom instruction. Dr. Meyers appears to be making an efficiency argument rather than identifying STUDENT's educational need. Although STUDENT would be using a number of different computers that are accessible to other children, she could organize and maintain her own compositions on her own individual floppy disk rather than on the shared hard drive. Moreover, the desktop computers at school could be moved or positioned in the classroom in such a way that would not block STUDENT's view of her teacher during classroom instruction. Because Dr. Meyer's concerns are easily and readily remedied and do not relate specifically to any of STUDENT's educational needs, her arguments for the use of a laptop computer rather than the use of various desktop computers are unpersuasive.
With regard to the second subissue, the evidence established that STUDENT does not require a computer with voice output capabilities for use at home in order to obtain a FAPE. While both the AlphaSmart and a computer can be used by STUDENT for word processing in order to bypass her deficits in fine motor functioning and eye-hand coordination, the main difference between the two devices is that one does not have voice output technology. According to the testimony and reports of Dr. Meyers, STUDENT requires voice output technology to improve her spoken language. Through the use of a computer with voice output technology, STUDENT's written language could be "linked" to her spoken language because the computer would enable her to type and hear the words at the same time. In her July 2000 report, Dr. Meyers wrote that voice output technology "lets STUDENT use her higher visual skills to improve her severely delayed spoken language."
Although there seems to be no dispute that STUDENT would benefit from the use of computers with voice output technology, the evidence does not indicate that STUDENT's language difficulties can be addressed only through the use of a computer with voice output capabilities. Ms. Riserbato and Ms. Kanengiser testified that STUDENT has difficulty comprehending what she reads and has difficulty answering questions about the information she read. Accordingly, both specialists testified that STUDENT requires specific instruction on strategies for comprehending what she reads. For example, she should be taught to visualize what she reads so that she uses her stronger visual memory and to compare and contrast information that she reads to develop her auditory comprehension and spoken language. Although Ms. Riserbato and Ms. Kanengiser acknowledged that a computer with voice output would provide multisensory feedback that would assist in STUDENT's learning, they both indicated that it is through the direct instruction that STUDENT is able to best improve her language skills.
Furthermore, nothing in the evidence indicates that STUDENT requires the voice output technology while outside of school. As was noted above, there are computers with voice output technology available to STUDENT throughout the school day, and STUDENT's IEP provides for multisensory instruction as part of her accommodations and modifications. STUDENT's IEP also provides for pull-out speech and language services for one hour per week. Thus, while at school, STUDENT would be provided many opportunities to improve her spoken language through access to the computers and through mulitmodality teaching. Moreover, according to Ms. Cortez and Ms. Kanengiser, the two people who worked with STUDENT most during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT should have no problems meeting her goals and objectives for the 2000-2001 school year if she is provided direct instruction and taught specific strategies to address her learning deficits. Neither Ms. Cortez nor Ms. Kanengiser was of the opinion that STUDENT requires an Apple ibook in order to benefit from her education.
Finally, Dr. Meyers' own reports indicate that it is possible for STUDENT to meet her language goals without the Apple ibook for home use. In her October 1999 report, Dr. Meyers developed a number of language goals to improve, among other things, STUDENT's spoken language. Many of those goals were later incorporated into STUDENT's 2000-2001 IEP. According to Dr. Meyers' recommendations in her October assessment, to meet those goals, STUDENT requires language instruction and the use of the computer with voice-output technology during her instructional sessions for two hours per week for a period of six months. Based on Dr. Meyer's own recommendations, STUDENT can meet such language goals through limited instructional sessions. It appears, then, that STUDENT's use of a computer with voice output technology for writing would simply reinforce what she learned through Dr. Meyers' "teaching methods." Based on the above, while access to such a computer at home may benefit STUDENT, the evidence does not establish that she requires it to benefit from her instruction or to obtain a FAPE.
In summary, the evidence established that the computers and AlphaSmart word processor provided by the District are sufficient to meet STUDENT's educational needs and can be used to implement her IEP. Moreover, the weight of the evidence supports that STUDENT does not need an Apple ibook laptop computer for home use to benefit from her educational program or to receive a FAPE. Therefore, she is not entitled to such a computer as part of her assistive technology program.
ORDER
Petitioner's request for assistive technology in the form of an Apple ibook laptop computer for the 2000-2001 school year is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on the issue decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: September 15, 2000 ____________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1: Dr. Meyers testified that "voice output technology" is a computer program that generates a computerized voice that reads text that is typed into the computer.
