California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 28, 1997
Student v. Apple Valley Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 967-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain
Apple Valley Unified must reimburse a parent-obtained vision assessment; vision therapy denied, limited print and retest accommodations ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted in the decision. It mentions a California Department of Education compliance report finding District noncompliance, which the District intended to appeal.
Summary
A 13-year-old eighth grader at Vista Campana Middle School in Apple Valley Unified School District was eligible for special education based on a learning disability. She spent most of her day in general education, with resource specialist program (RSP) support on a "watch and consult" basis. In May 1996 her father asked the IEP team for a visual assessment. The District tried to schedule a regional IEP meeting but never gave the family an assessment plan. Before the August 29, 1996 meeting, the parents had optometrist Dr. Charles McQuarrie assess her. He recommended 60 hours of vision therapy and classroom accommodations. The District refused to pay for the assessment or provide therapy.
The Hearing Officer found the father's request reasonable. Once school resumed, the District had 15 days to provide an assessment plan, and it never did. It must reimburse the assessment and mileage. The Hearing Officer denied vision therapy under Rowley. The student was earning passing or better grades and meeting her IEP goal, even though she failed some tests on the first try. The Hearing Officer found no separate visual disability and denied enlarged textbooks, books on tape, tape recording of classes, and extended time. However, her IEP must allow a magnifying device, enlarged print when the device is not feasible, and retakes of failed tests. The request for legal costs and witness fees was denied for lack of authority.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district that never issued an assessment plan within the 15-day timeline. The parent was reimbursed for a private assessment, even though she got it before the plan was overdue. It also shows the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard being used to deny a related service to a student who was passing her general education classes.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Must the District reimburse STUDENT for the cost of Dr. Charles McQuarrie's visual developmental assessment report and the cost of transportation to and from Dr. McQuarrie's office?
The father's reassessment request was reasonable and the District never produced an assessment plan within 15 days after school resumed, so it must reimburse the private vision assessment and mileage, even though the parent obtained it before the plan was overdue.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Must the District provide STUDENT with vision therapy with Dr. McQuarrie?
Under Rowley, the student was earning passing or better grades and meeting her IEP goal without vision therapy, so the therapy was not necessary for educational benefit.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 3. Must the District modify STUDENT's IEP to accommodate a visual disability?
No separate visual-disability eligibility and no enlarged textbooks, books on tape, tape recording, or extended time were ordered, but the IEP must allow use of a magnifier, enlarged print when the magnifier is not feasible, and retakes of failed tests; the team must consider the private report.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 4. Must the District reimburse the PARENT for legal costs and witness fees?
Under Education Code section 56507(b), the Hearing Office is not a court and has no authority to award legal costs or witness fees.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days, District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of Dr. McQuarrie's developmental vision assessment report dated August 26, 1996, plus round-trip mileage to his office at the rate the District reimburses employees who travel by automobile (dollar amount not stated).
- Order to provide or change services. IEP shall reflect that the student may use her magnifying device whenever necessary and feasible; when the device is necessary but not feasible, the District shall enlarge the print of documents she must read.
- Order to provide or change services. IEP shall reflect that the student may retake tests that she does not pass.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Education Code section 56381; Education Code section 56321(a); Education Code section 56329(b); Education Code section 56363; Education Code section 56507(b)
People named in the decision
- Dr. Charles McQuarrie, private developmental optometrist; assessor and expert witness for Student
- Valerie Rincon, social science and language arts teacher, Vista Campana Middle School
- Chris Perkins, science teacher, Vista Campana Middle School
- Rita Burleson, RSP teacher / case worker, Vista Campana Middle School
- Linda Plaas, private music teacher
- Toni Lynn Robinette, language arts teacher (1995-96), Apple Valley Unified School District
- Diane Reynolds, science teacher (1995-96), Apple Valley Unified School District
- Tom Reynolds, vice principal, Vista Campana Middle School
- Robert Parker, program manager, Desert/Mountain SELPA
- Jane Pace, interim director of student services, Apple Valley Unified School District
- Elizabeth Monticue, school nurse, Apple Valley Unified School District
- Wanda Liggins, school counselor, Vista Campana Middle School
- Douglas Snider, school psychologist, Apple Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Lynn Bouffard, director of personnel services, Apple Valley Unified School District
- Dr. Jan Horn, licensed educational psychologist; expert witness for Student, University of California, Riverside (learning disabilities specialist)
- Armalyn DeLao, instrumental music and choir director, Vista Campana Middle School
- Joy Ast, math teacher, Vista Campana Middle School
- Mary Welamin, language arts teacher, Vista Campana Middle School
- Laurel Arnold, school psychologist; witness for District, Newport Mesa Unified School District
- Dr. Beth Ballinger, vision assessor and vision therapy provider (prior district), Newport Mesa Unified School District referral
- Bobbie Cummins, District staff assisting visually handicapped students, Apple Valley Unified School District
- G. Robert Roice, educational consultant representing District (non-attorney)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on October 29 and 30, and December 10 and 11, 1996 and January 21 and 22, 1997 before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Apple Valley, California.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by her father, FATHER.
STUDENT's mother, MOTHER, and friend, FRIEND also appeared on behalf of Petitioner.
Respondent Apple Valley Unified School District (the District) was represented by educational consultant G. Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District were Robert Parker, program manager, Desert/Mountain SELPA, and Jane Pace, interim director of student services for the District.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify on her behalf: Dr. Charles McQuarrie, Valerie Rincon, social science and language arts teacher; Chris Perkins, science teacher; Rita Burleson, RSP teacher; FATHER, STUDENT's father; STUDENT; Linda Plaas, private music teacher; Toni Lynn Robinette, language arts teacher; Diane Reynolds, science teacher; Tom Reynolds, vice principal; Robert Parker, program manager, Desert/Mountain SELPA; Jane Pace, interim director of student services for the District; Elizabeth Monticue, school nurse; Wanda Liggins, school counsellor; Douglas Snider, school psychologist; Dr. Lynn Bouffard, District director of personnel services; and Dr. Jan Horn, licensed educational psychologist.
The following witnesses testified on behalf of the District:
Armalyn DeLao, music teacher; Joy Ast, math teacher; Mary Welamin, language arts teacher; and Laurel Arnold, school psychologist, Newport Mesa Unified School District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received on October 29 and 30, and December 10 and 11, 1996, and January 21 and 22, 1997. The parties prepared written closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision and the record was closed on February 5, 1997.
ISSUES
1. Must the District reimburse STUDENT for the cost of Dr.
Charles McQuarrie's visual developmental assessment report and the cost of transportation to and from Dr.
McQuarrie's office?
2. Must the District provide STUDENT with vision therapy with Dr. McQuarrie?
3. Must the District modify STUDENT's IEP to accommodate a visual disability?
4. Must the District reimburse the PARENT for legal costs and witness fees?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is thirteen years old and resides with her parents and brother within the District. STUDENT's history of visual problems began at age two. The last IEP to address STUDENT's eligibility for special education states, "STUDENT was placed in special ed., qualified in her previous district." (Resp. Ex. 11, at p. 1.) The last IEP from NMUSD to address STUDENT's eligibility for special education states that she qualifies because she has learning disabilities. (Resp. Ex. 6.)
In 1986, one ophthalmologist recommended eye surgery, and another recommended bifocals and a vision training program.
STUDENT and her parents opted for corrective lenses and completed a regimen of vision therapy with Dr. Charles McQuarrie that was "directed toward allowing her to learn to use her two eyes simultaneously." (Petitioner's Exhibit "Pet. Ex." 3, page 1 and Pet Ex. 54 at p. 1.)
In 1987, STUDENT began school in the Newport Mesa Unified School District (NMUSD). In 1991, NMUSD requested that Dr. Beth Ballinger conduct a visual assessment of STUDENT and recommended more vision training. NMUSD provided two forty-five-minute vision therapy sessions to STUDENT each week until 1993, when her IEP team decided to "transfer [her] out of vision therapy [because her] objectives [were] met." (Pet. Ex. 4, page 1.)
In 1993, STUDENT's parents enrolled her in a nonpublic special education school where she remained until November 1994. STUDENT returned to NMUSD, and completed the sixth grade with resource specialist program (RSP) support. (Respondents' Exhibit "Resp. Ex." 6 and 7.)
STUDENT began seventh grade at Vista Campana Middle School in the District. STUDENT received RSP support, and was placed in the regular education program for eighty-five to ninety per cent of the school day. Eventually STUDENT was placed in RSP on a "watch and consult" basis. (Resp. Ex. 8-11.)
STUDENT earned either "A's" or "B's" throughout the seventh grade. (Resp. Ex. 1, at pp. 2 and 3.) In the spring of STUDENT's seventh-grade year, her older sister was killed in an automobile accident. In May 1996, toward the end of STUDENT's seventh grade year, FATHER asked her IEP team to have a nonpublic agency "conduct a visual perceptual examination" of STUDENT. (Resp. Ex. 11, at p. 1.) The District scheduled a regional IEP meeting for August 1996 to determine whether to conduct the visual examination. Before the regional IEP meeting occurred, the PARENT had Dr. McQuarrie conduct a visual assessment. (Pet. Ex. 17.)
FATHER presented copies of Dr. McQuarrie's report at the regional IEP that took place on August 29, 1996. FATHER requested that the District reimburse him for Dr. McQuarrie's assessment and provide vision therapy at District expense. Noting that "vision therapy is not ... a necessary service in order for STUDENT to benefit from her special education program," the District refused both of FATHER's requests. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would continue to participate in RSP on a watch and consult basis.
(Resp. Ex. 12.) STUDENT earned four "A's," one "B," and one "C" on her first eighth-grade progress report. (Resp. Ex. 1, at p. 1.)
Because the District did not provide the services FATHER requested, he filed for a due process hearing to challenge the District's position.
SUMMARY OF WITNESS TESTIMONY and DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE
PETITIONER'S EVIDENCE
Dr. Charles McQuarrie
Charles McQuarrie is a doctor of optometry whose practice emphasizes developmental optometry and the treatment and diagnosis of visual problems of very young children, older children with learning disabilities and adults with traumatic brain injuries.
Dr. McQuarrie has not spoken to any of STUDENT's teachers regarding her vision or academic performance. Aside from Dr.
McQuarrie's own clinical observations and STUDENT's remarks, the primary source of Dr. McQuarrie's observations regarding STUDENT's vision or reading problems was STUDENT's parents. (Pet. Ex. 17, at pp 1-2.)
According to Dr. McQuarrie, STUDENT has worn corrective lenses since she was two years old. Dr. McQuarrie first assessed STUDENT in 1987 when she was four years old. As result of that assessment, Dr. McQuarrie prescribed bifocal lenses for STUDENT, who is hyperopic (farsighted) and has an astigmatism. Dr. McQuarrie performed a developmental visual assessment on STUDENT in 1991 when she was eight years old. (Pet. Ex. 54.)
Dr. McQuarrie recalled that in 1987, STUDENT had good sight in either eye with corrective lenses, but that she had severe eye tracking problems even with glasses. According to Dr. McQuarrie, STUDENT's eyes were not always in the same place at the same time when she was looking to the left, or right up or down.
Comparing STUDENT's developmental-perceptual profile of May 1992 to that of December 1993, Dr. McQuarrie stated that STUDENT's visual motor integration (VMI) improved "significantly" from the 37th to the 90th percentile. Dr. McQuarrie explained that VMI involves the eye-hand coordination task of looking at and then reproducing a geometric form. STUDENT's improved score indicates an increased ability to fixate on and reproduce a geometric form. Between May 1992 and December 1993, STUDENT demonstrated approximately five years' growth in visual motor speed and precision. (Pet. Ex. 53-A and 53-B.) Based on these scores, Dr. McQuarrie concluded that STUDENT responded to the vision therapy that she received.
Dr. McQuarrie explained that in May 1996 he performed a "brief screening" that included "visual-performance tests" and found that STUDENT was experiencing eye teaming and visual suppression dysfunction. Dr. McQuarrie described eye teaming dysfunction as the failure of the eyes to track at the same place at the same time. Dr. McQuarrie noted that STUDENT manifests visual suppression dysfunction because her right eye turns in toward her nose, which prevents "reading from coming through in that eye." STUDENT is left-eye dominant and right-handed. Dr. McQuarrie's clinical practice experience led him to conclude that children with "mixed dominance" tend to reverse or transpose letters and have trouble directing their hands while writing. Dr. McQuarrie suggested to the District that a school psychologist test STUDENT's VMI. Dr. McQuarrie did not recommend or conduct an "in depth test" of STUDENT's vision because, in May 1996, her grades were satisfactory. (Pet. Ex. 14.)
STUDENT's parents informed Dr. McQuarrie that STUDENT was still complaining about her vision; therefore in August 1996 he conducted a vision assessment. Dr. McQuarrie explained that STUDENT's vision assessment results revealed that she has "a great deal of difficulty bringing both eyes together at the same place at the same time." Dr. McQuarrie also found that STUDENT's ability to focus is inadequate. For example, when looking from near to far, STUDENT's focusing was "sluggish." According to Dr. McQuarrie, this sluggishness tends to cause visual fatigue following sustained reading or writing.
Dr. McQuarrie also administered Nonmotor Subtests of Visual Perceptual Skills (TVPS). STUDENT achieved low scores in two of the seven areas, visual discrimination and visual sequential memory. STUDENT's sixteenth percentile score in visual discrimination indicates difficulty in discriminating shapes and forms. STUDENT's twenty-first percentile score in visual sequential memory suggests that she would have difficulty remembering a sequence of geometric objects. Dr. McQuarrie asserted that skill in visual sequential memory tends to correlate to one's reading comprehension ability. Dr. McQuarrie explained that if a student has visual sequential memory problems, that student would "take smaller bites" of written material. That student might also be slower at taking tests, and might experience difficulty with timed tests.
Dr. McQuarrie commented that STUDENT's scores on the August 1996 VMI test were "very low," i.e., she cannot look at and then reproduce geometric figures. Dr. McQuarrie explained that STUDENT "gets lost somewhere between seeing the figure and reproducing it on paper." Because of this, STUDENT might have trouble copying from a board or overhead projection quickly and accurately or writing and thinking at the same time. Dr. McQuarrie also observed that STUDENT moves her head "excessively" to bring her eyes in line with the printed page.
Dr. McQuarrie offered that STUDENT's visual deficits "play a role" in her inability to achieve passing grades on tests and quizzes. Based on STUDENT's visual assessment results, Dr.
McQuarrie recommended sixty hours of visual therapy to help her cope with the visual deficits. (See Pet. Ex. 17, at p. 6.) Dr. McQuarrie stated that vision therapy would help STUDENT develop two-eyed vision, improve information sequencing, and generally increase her ability to see and respond to stimuli. Dr. McQuarrie expects that STUDENT's vision will deteriorate without visual therapy. Dr. McQuarrie stated that the decline in STUDENT's visual ability is not unusual, especially since such a decline is common in patients who are in the growth years.
Dr. McQuarrie recommended that STUDENT's school seat her in the front and center of her classrooms, offer her extended time to complete tests (as a temporary measure), provide her with documents with enlarged print (unless there is good contrast between the words and the page and ample space between words), allow her to tape-record classes and have tests read aloud if necessary, offer her an aide if she has extensive copying, supply her with an angled desk, and light her classrooms well. Dr. McQuarrie stated that STUDENT's visual deficit would not necessarily affect her performance in all classes. For example, classes that require reading comprehension, sustained concentration and copying would be more challenging than those that do not. Dr. McQuarrie added that students like STUDENT, who suppress one eye, will not rub their eyes.
Although Dr. McQuarrie expressed concern about STUDENT's ability to participate in team sports, he did not recommend that STUDENT restrict her participation to individual physical education activities.
Valerie Rincon
Each day, STUDENT spends two consecutive periods of language arts and one period of social studies with Valerie Rincon. At the beginning of the 1996-97 school year, Rita Burleson, STUDENT's RSP teacher, informed Ms. Rincon that STUDENT received RSP "watch and consult" services. Ms. Rincon understands that Ms. Burleson assists STUDENT when STUDENT needs academic help. Ms. Rincon testified that FATHER informed her that STUDENT had a visual disability.
Ms. Rincon estimates that she and Ms. Burleson speak about STUDENT on a weekly basis. When Ms. Rincon and Ms. Burleson last spoke about STUDENT, Ms. Rincon reported that STUDENT was doing well in social studies. Once Ms. Rincon mentioned that STUDENT occasionally had trouble taking notes in social studies. To address this problem, Ms. Rincon provides Ms. Burleson with copies of her notes. Ms. Rincon conceded that STUDENT's notes are not accurate "word for word", but, overall, in Ms. Rincon's opinion, STUDENT's social studies class notes are comparable in quality to those of her classmates. (Pet. Ex. 78.)
Ms. Rincon stated that her social studies students very often work in groups of two or four. Ms. Rincon intends that all of the members of the group contribute in arriving at an answer. Ms. Rincon testified that STUDENT does not volunteer to read aloud in class. Because eighth graders may be self-conscious, Ms. Rincon does not insist that they read aloud if they do not wish to.
Ms. Rincon stated that she had not enlarged the print on STUDENT's work or made other accommodations for STUDENT's visual deficits. Ms. Rincon has never noticed that STUDENT has trouble reading in class. Ms. Rincon observed that in December 1996, STUDENT used a magnifying device a "couple of times in class" but has not used it recently. It appeared to Ms. Rincon that the magnifier "caused her problems." Ms. Rincon stated that in her opinion, STUDENT does not need extra time for tests or enlarged print. STUDENT has been allowed to retake tests, but Ms. Rincon stated that she permits retesting when she thinks that a student can improve his or her test grade.
Ms. Rincon testified that as of September 26, 1996, STUDENT had earned an "A-" in social studies, notwithstanding the fact that she had a failing average on the only two quizzes then taken. (FOOTNOTE 1) (Pet. Ex. 34.) Ms. Rincon noted that STUDENT's test grades were not always in the "A" or "B" range but that her strong performances on other assignments elevated her overall average. Ms. Rincon suggested that stress may account for STUDENT's relatively poor test scores.
The December 3, 1996, social studies printout reflects that she had a failing average. (Pet. Ex. 51.) Ms. Rincon explained that this printout covered a different grading period. Ms. Rincon testified that when STUDENT had this average the class had taken no tests. Ms. Rincon stated that STUDENT was missing a current event and a "summary page." Furthermore, the two current events that STUDENT completed were "very poorly written." (Pet. Ex. 51.)
However, by January 21, 1996, STUDENT had raised her grade to a "C" because she started working harder on current events.
Ms. Rincon testified that from August through October 31, 1996, STUDENT achieved an "A" average in both social studies and language arts and never once complained that she could not read an assignment. However, during an October 31, 1996 language arts unit test on The Witch of Blackbird Pond, STUDENT orally complained that she could not read the test even before she read it. Ms. Rincon advised STUDENT to try to complete the test. According to Ms. Rincon, STUDENT responded randomly to the multiple choice questions and replied to some of the short answer questions with the sentence "I can't read question." STUDENT failed this test. (Resp. Ex. 22.)
Ms. Rincon asserted that the October 31, 1996 test on The Witch of Blackbird Pond was in the same format and printed in the same size as all of the other tests that she administered previously. Upon receiving STUDENT's responses, Ms. Rincon gave her the same test and asked her to read questions one and two aloud to her. When Ms. Rincon was satisfied that STUDENT could read the test, she instructed STUDENT to "go next door [to Ms. Welamin's language arts class] and take the test again." Ms. Rincon estimated that STUDENT was in Ms. Welamin's class for a class period "and then some."
On the retest, STUDENT earned a "B." On the retest, STUDENT wrote:
Mrs. Rincon,
It was a little fuzzy but question number 4 was really blurry and on the questions I had to hold the paper up to my nose.
(Resp. Ex. 22, at p. 3.) STUDENT also orally reported to Ms.
Rincon that to read the retest, she had to hold it inches from her face. It was Ms. Rincon's belief that STUDENT did not know the answer to question four. Moreover, Ms. Welamin told Ms. Rincon that she never observed STUDENT lift the test from her desk.
STUDENT never complained to Ms. Rincon that she was unable to read The Witch of Blackbird Pond, which contained "small print." Based on STUDENT's performance on the test, Ms. Rincon believes that STUDENT read the book. Ms. Rincon reported that she read the novel aloud in class while the students followed silently.
STUDENT also responded "can't read question" to approximately thirty questions on a November 15, 1996 social studies test.
(Resp. Ex. 20, at pp. 6-7.) The next day, Ms. Rincon allowed her to retake the "exact same test" and STUDENT earned a "C." STUDENT explained that on the previous day, she could not read the test.
Ms. Rincon recalled that one time STUDENT complained to her that the words on the printed page were moving. In response to this complaint, that Ms. Rincon believed came sometime after October 31, 1996, she suggested that STUDENT use a bookmark to help her steady the words on the page. According to Ms. Rincon, STUDENT reported that using the bookmark helped her to read. Ms. Rincon stated that she was not aware that five years ago, Dr. Ballinger suggested that STUDENT use her finger rather than a bookmark to assist her in visual tracking.
According to Ms. Rincon, STUDENT had an "A-"average in language arts at the end of the first semester. This semester, STUDENT currently has a "B+" average. Ms. Rincon stated that STUDENT is "near the upper end" of the class in both language arts and social studies. Ms. Rincon reported that on January 17, 1997, STUDENT earned a "B" on a forty-word spelling test in language arts.
Chris Perkins (footnote 2)
STUDENT is currently enrolled in Chris Perkins' sixth-period science class, which meets from 12:56 p.m. to 1:43 p.m. Mr.
Perkins testified that he has not modified his curriculum or grading policies to accommodate her visual disability. Mr. Perkins has observed that STUDENT copied her notes from the overhead projector, read aloud in class and located information in "extremely small print mass numbers on a periodic table" without difficulty or need for accommodation. (Resp. Ex. 4.)
Generally, Mr. Perkins finds that STUDENT performs her class and homework well, but noted that STUDENT has not earned passing grades on tests and quizzes. For example, on the first test, STUDENT earned 17 of 30 points; on the second, she earned 24 of 50 points; and on the quiz she earned 6 of 10 points. On class and homework, however, STUDENT earns significantly higher grades. Mr. Perkins stated that the nature of class and homework assignments varies: they may require reading or drawing or may be assigned to individual students or to pairs. Buoyed by excellent scores on class and home work assignments, STUDENT's overall average of 83.5% placed her in the top quarter of her thirty-four-student science class on September 29, 1996. (Pet. Ex. 36.) By October 22, 1996, STUDENT's average had risen to 90% when, at the request of Ms. Burleson, and FATHER, Mr. Perkins allowed STUDENT to retake a test that she had failed. She earned an "A" on the retest. (Resp. Ex. 4.) STUDENT's current average in science is 81.95, which converts to a grade of "B-."
Mr. Perkins testified that STUDENT is a "diligent" student.
According to Mr. Perkins, until October 31, 1996, STUDENT neither behaved nor performed like a student with a visual disability. For example, STUDENT did not accept his offer to seat her in the front of the class, did not ask for help more frequently than other students or complain of eye strain, and was able to read aloud without apparent difficulty. Mr. Perkins did not attribute STUDENT's poor performance on tests and quizzes to a visual problem. When asked why STUDENT performs worse on tests than on class and homework, Mr. Perkins responded, "some kids don't test well." Mr. Perkins believes that STUDENT could improve her test scores if she participated in the "kennel club," which is an after school tutoring program.
However, Mr. Perkins stated that the day after he first testified in this proceeding, STUDENT began to rub her eyes in class and complain that she could not see the printed material clearly. Mr. Perkins specifically recalled that on November 14, 1996, he gave his students a worksheet on which his students had to fill in answers and find words arranged vertically, horizontally, and diagonally in a word search. Without a partner or her magnifier, STUDENT completed ten of the fourteen worksheet questions before class ended. Mr. Perkins testified that when STUDENT had trouble on a couple of questions, he referred her to the relevant section of her notes and she found the answers.
(Resp. Ex. 20, at p. 3.)
The next day, STUDENT encountered the same questions in the same size print on her test. Instead of responding with the answers, STUDENT wrote "can't read question." (Resp. Ex. 20 at pp. 6-7.) Once during the November 15, 1996 test, STUDENT told Mr. Perkins that the words were moving around, but she has not complained since then. Mr. Perkins observed that during this test, STUDENT held the paper close to her face and that she finished twice as fast as her classmates. STUDENT had the opportunity to retake the November 15, 1996 test but opted not to. (Footnote 3)
Nevertheless, Mr. Perkins stated that "last week," STUDENT volunteered to read aloud with her magnifier and demonstrated good understanding of the material. Furthermore, in Mr. Perkins' opinion, STUDENT's class notes accurately reflect the content of his lectures. (Pet. Ex. 76.) STUDENT is also able to complete her classwork at the same rate as her classmates.
STUDENT currently has a "B-" average in science. Mr. Perkins last tested STUDENT "about two weeks before Christmas." STUDENT scored five of forty on the first administration of the test and thirty-two of forty, a "B-," the second time. Mr. Perkins reported that he provided his notes to STUDENT before she retook the test and was told that she would study for it.
Rita Burleson
RSP teacher Ms. Burleson is STUDENT's case worker. Of the thirty three children that Ms. Burleson teaches, she estimates that STUDENT is one of the least needy. Ms. Burleson stated, "She is what I hope all students will come to. She works hard." Ms.
Burleson does not think that reading is difficult for STUDENT, because she never complained of eye strain or other visual problems.
With regard to her low scores on tests and quizzes, Ms.
Burleson remarked: "I know she can do the work. She can achieve higher scores on tests." But Ms. Burleson also commented: "some people don't take tests well." When STUDENT retook the science test, Ms. Burleson asked her to read the test aloud to ensure that she understood the questions. Without relying upon notes or modifications, STUDENT earned an "A" on the exact same science test that she had taken earlier.
Ms. Burleson described the academic services and modifications that she provides. Ms. Burleson monitors STUDENT's academic progress by consulting with her classroom teachers. When appropriate, Ms. Burleson gives STUDENT tips on how to take tests and study. If any of her students think that they could improve a test grade by retaking the test, she asks the classroom teacher to schedule a retest. Like Mr. Perkins, Ms. Burleson stated that STUDENT would benefit from participation in after-school tutoring.
Ms. Burleson testified that she did not think that providing STUDENT with materials in enlarged print would address STUDENT's difficulty taking tests. She likewise rejected the idea of having a teacher read tests to STUDENT. In Ms. Burleson's opinion, STUDENT does not have a visual problem that adversely affects her academic progress.
FATHER
STUDENT's father, FATHER, testified that in March or April 1996, he observed that STUDENT occasionally missed words or lost her tracking when she read. FATHER recalled that STUDENT started complaining that her eyes were bothering her in school, i.e., sometimes blurring up "predominantly in the latter part of the day."
FATHER stated that at about this same time, STUDENT's music teacher, Linda Plaas, advised him to have STUDENT's vision checked because she "skipped" notes. Thinking that STUDENT just needed a new prescription for eyeglasses, the PARENT took her to Dr.
McQuarrie in May 1996.
FATHER stated that he presented a letter from Dr. McQuarrie at the IEP team meeting of May 23, 1996, and asked that the team authorize a visual assessment of STUDENT. According to FATHER, none of the team members was able to authorize the requested assessment. Members of the team informed FATHER that they would convene a regional IEP with the SELPA in attendance. FATHER understood that his request for a visual assessment would be discussed at the regional IEP meeting.
District representative, Dr. Lynn Bouffard, proposed having the regional IEP before the end of the school year and telephoned FATHER with a date. FATHER could not meet on the proposed date because his son had a previously scheduled IEP. The District could not schedule other dates, so FATHER and Dr. Bouffard concluded that the regional IEP would occur after school resumed.
Prior to the regional IEP, no one from the District told FATHER that it would not assess STUDENT. Nevertheless, FATHER had Dr. McQuarrie assess STUDENT before the regional IEP meeting took place on August 29, 1996. FATHER did not await the decision of the IEP team because he was concerned that STUDENT's vision was deteriorating and did not want to wait through the potentially lengthy assessment and evaluation process.
FATHER stated that he provided copies of Dr. McQuarrie's assessment to every team member present at STUDENT's August 29, 1996 IEP team meeting. According to FATHER, no one at the meeting read or discussed Dr. McQuarrie's report or asked for a second opinion. Instead, the discussion centered on STUDENT's grades as reflected in her teachers' computer grade printout. While FATHER acknowledged that STUDENT's overall grades were good, he felt that her grades were "sugar-coated" because her test and quiz grades were generally in the "D" or "F" range.
FATHER disputed team members' assertions that STUDENT does not excel in test situations, because STUDENT tested well until the beginning of this school year. FATHER also asserted that STUDENT does well in her first-period math class but that her academic performance declines as the day progresses. In FATHER's opinion, STUDENT's deteriorating eyesight accounts for her declining performance.
FATHER asserted that the quality of STUDENT's handwriting and notetaking has declined since last year. (See, e.g., Pet. Ex. 75 and Resp. Ex. 20.) FATHER also stated that during the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT seldom earned less than an "A" or "B" on a test or quiz. This school year, STUDENT routinely fails tests and quizzes the first time she takes them.
In FATHER's opinion, STUDENT's performance on tests gives the most accurate information regarding her knowledge and ability. FATHER is concerned that if STUDENT continues to perform poorly on tests and quizzes, she will not have a "fighting chance" in college.
FATHER stated that STUDENT's social science homework grades have fallen because he and his wife have stopped assisting her at home. FATHER maintained that STUDENT's social science homework grades as of January 22, 1996, reflect her actual ability. FATHER testified that during the seventh grade, he spent about an hour each night helping her with her homework, but now he spends from one and one half to two hours a night assisting her.
FATHER recalled when STUDENT wrote "can't read question" in the space provided for answers on one of Ms. Rincon's tests. When FATHER learned of the incident, he asked Ms. Rincon if she would read the test aloud to STUDENT. According to FATHER, Ms. Rincon did not respond to his request.
FATHER recalled that Ms. Rincon later telephoned him to discuss STUDENT's declining performance in social science. FATHER testified that Ms. Rincon once offered to enlarge print for STUDENT, but the enlargements were never provided. (Pet. Ex. 62.) FATHER also testified that the seating arrangement and lighting in Ms. Rincon's class contributes to her visual difficulties. FATHER reported that on another occasion, Mr. Perkins refused to respond to STUDENT's request for help on a science test.
STUDENT
Thirteen-year-old STUDENT stated that she began having trouble seeing "at the end of last [school] year." STUDENT complained to her parents but did not immediately tell her teachers because she "did not want kids making fun" of her. STUDENT stated that when she started having visual problems, she held papers close to her face. STUDENT explained that her sight gradually deteriorated, worsening after third period (mid-morning). She stated that when her vision is affected, words "get really fuzzy" and lines move "all over the place."
STUDENT recalled that she complained to Ms. Rincon that she could not read a social studies test. Ms. Rincon instructed STUDENT to "go next door" to retake the test. STUDENT stated that she failed both the first and second social studies tests. (Resp. Ex. 20, at pp. 6-7.) STUDENT testified that no teacher has ever checked her class notes, and that her own social studies class notes make no sense to her. (Pet. Ex. 78 and 79.)
STUDENT also stated that she could not read the homework handouts from Ms. Rincon's classes. According to STUDENT, her mother read the homework questions to her and she wrote the answers. STUDENT stated that her test grades suffered because her mother was not there to read the test questions to her.
STUDENT asserted that she was unable to read The Witch of Blackbird Pond. According to STUDENT, she listened while either Ms. Rincon or one of her classmates read aloud and turned pages when the rest of the class did so. STUDENT once told Ms. Rincon that the words were fuzzy and lines were moving. Ms. Rincon's response was to give her a bookmark, which kept the lines from moving but did not sharpen her focus.
When STUDENT received the language arts unit test on The Witch of Blackbird Pond, in October 1996, "it was blurry, fuzzy, and the words were moving everywhere." (Resp. Ex. 22.) STUDENT testified that after she complained that she could not read the test, Ms. Rincon sent her to Ms. Welamin's class to retake it. STUDENT stated that when she held the test close to her face, she could read it. By holding the test close to her face, STUDENT was able to read the questions and complete the test on the second try.
STUDENT acknowledged that she could see the test questions about as well on first test as on the second. However, STUDENT stated that she "had no idea" whether she could have completed the first test if she had held it close to her face. STUDENT did not use her magnifying device to retake the test. While STUDENT retook the test, Ms. Welamin was either lecturing or reading aloud to her class.
According to STUDENT, science class is also difficult for her. STUDENT stated that she has a problem understanding in class and reading the tests. STUDENT explained that she alerted Mr. Perkins that she was having trouble reading a science "pre-test." Mr. Perkins first encouraged her to "give it a try." When STUDENT renewed her complaint, Mr. Perkins either supplied her with the answer or directed her to review her notes.
STUDENT testified that when she receives new sheet music to play, she takes it home, enlarges it, memorizes it, and plays it from memory at school. If Ms. DeLao were to ask her to play new music before she had a chance to memorize it, STUDENT stated that she would "fake it," i.e., play "any notes in [her] fingers."
STUDENT stated that she loved school last year and sometimes volunteered to read aloud. This year, however, STUDENT sometimes feels that she "never wants to go back" because cannot see the words and is not getting the help she needs. She suggested that if her teachers enlarged print, thoroughly explained what she did not understand, read unclear words aloud, and "had the courtesy" to check her notes, they would be providing her with the help that she needs. STUDENT also stated that the magnifier helped her "a lot" but that she no longer uses it because her peers commented about it.
Linda Plaas
Since September 1995, STUDENT has received individual flute lessons from music teacher Linda Plaas. Ms. Plaas observed that STUDENT skips both lines of music and notes more frequently than her other students. Ms. Plaas also noticed that STUDENT skipped more notes when they were crowded onto the page and could not read the abbreviation "cresc." that was printed on her sheet of music.
As a result, in early 1996, Ms. Plaas suggested that the PARENT have STUDENT's eyes tested. In October 1996, Ms. Plaas began enlarging the print on STUDENT's music from 8 and 1/2 by 11 to 11 by 17. (Pet. Ex. 48.) Ms. Plaas stated that since she started enlarging STUDENT's sheet music, STUDENT skips fewer notes and lines.
Ms. Plaas considers STUDENT one of her hardest working students. While most of Ms. Plaas' students practice for half an hour each day, FATHER reported that STUDENT practices for two to three hours. Ms. Plaas accepts FATHER's estimation of STUDENT's practice time because STUDENT has improved markedly since she first began taking lessons. Ms. Plaas testified that she believes that STUDENT avoids skipping lines and notes when she plays at school because she memorizes the music at home.
Toni Lynn Robinette
During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT earned "B's" on tests and quizzes in Toni Robinette's language arts classes and earned "B" grades overall. Ms. Robinette remembered that STUDENT volunteered to read aloud in class, and did so without complaint or apparent difficulty. According to Ms. Robinette, like the other students in her class, STUDENT was able to copy class notes daily. Ms. Robinette stated that STUDENT's copying mistakes were typical of those of the other students in the class.
During the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT asked Ms. Robinette to move her seat from the back of the class so that she could see better. Ms. Robinette complied and after being moved to the middle of the room, STUDENT no longer complained that she was unable to see. Aside from STUDENT's request for a different seat, Ms.
Robinette could not recall any indication that STUDENT's vision adversely affected her academic performance.
Toward the end of the 1995-96 school year, the District notified Ms. Robinette about STUDENT's sister's accident. (Pet. Ex. 81.) Ms. Robinette did not notice a "dramatic" change in STUDENT's behavior after the accident.
Diane Reynolds
Diane Reynolds was STUDENT's science teacher during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Reynolds recalled that STUDENT's test and quiz grades improved during the school year, eventually netting her "A's" and "B's" in science class. Based on STUDENT's past performance, Ms. Reynolds would expect that she would succeed in science class this year.
Ms. Reynolds considered STUDENT's notetaking ability within the average range and remembered that STUDENT did not volunteer to read aloud in class. At no time during the school year did STUDENT's behavior suggest to Ms. Reynolds that she needed vision therapy. For example, STUDENT did not ask for enlarged print or a seat in the front of the class. Ms. Reynolds recalled that STUDENT became "very quiet" after her sister's accident.
Tom Reynolds
Tom Reynolds is currently the vice principal of Vista Campana Middle School. Facilitating IEP team meeting was one of Mr.
Reynolds' duties as vice principal.
Mr. Reynolds recalled that, at the IEP team meeting of May 23, 1996, FATHER requested that the District conduct a visual assessment of STUDENT. Mr. Reynolds also attended the August 1996 IEP team meeting at which the members received copies of Dr.
McQuarrie's visual assessment of STUDENT. Mr. Reynolds testified that neither he nor any other District employee is an expert in the area of visual disabilities, and after reading Dr. McQuarrie's assessment, he understood "as much as a layman could."
Mr. Reynolds recalled that FATHER was the only IEP team member who proposed seeking a second opinion regarding STUDENT's asserted need for vision therapy. According to Mr. Reynolds, the IEP team members rejected FATHER's proposal without either disagreeing with Dr. McQuarrie's findings or discussing them at length. Instead, the IEP team members focused on whether STUDENT's visual problems prevented her from being a successful student.
Mr. Reynolds stated that the IEP team did not act on Dr.
McQuarrie's report because STUDENT was succeeding in her educational program. Mr. Reynolds also stated that he was aware that Dr. Ballinger recommended that STUDENT resume vision therapy.
According to Mr. Reynolds, during that IEP team meeting, FATHER requested that STUDENT be enrolled in an RSP science class. Mr. Reynolds denied this request because STUDENT was succeeding her regular education science class and Mr. Reynolds wished to keep STUDENT in the least restrictive environment. Mr. Reynolds stated that even considering the recommendations of Dr. McQuarrie and Dr. Ballinger, he would not alter STUDENT's IEP because she is succeeding in her current educational program.
Robert Parker
Desert/Mountain SELPA director Robert Parker recalled that FATHER first requested a visual assessment for STUDENT during the May 1996 IEP meeting. Mr. Parker testified that he tried to set a regional IEP before the semester ended on June 6, 1996, but he and FATHER could not arrange a mutually convenient date. (Footnote 4)
According to Mr. Parker, the 1996-97 school year began on August 6. Mr. Parker attempted to set the regional IEP in early August, but scheduling conflicts prevented the regional IEP from taking place until August 29, 1996. In mid August, FATHER informed Mr. Parker that Dr. McQuarrie had conducted the visual assessment.
Mr. Parker chaired the regional IEP team meeting during which the members discussed Dr. McQuarrie's report and whether STUDENT required vision therapy services. At the regional IEP meeting, the IEP team denied FATHER's request for vision therapy because STUDENT had been benefitting from her education program without it. Mr. Parker stated that the IEP team did not seek a second opinion because the team thought that STUDENT's program was appropriate.
Mr. Parker noted that according to a February 1995 psychological assessment, STUDENT obtained a full scale I.Q. score of 90 on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children-III (WISC-III). From this score, Mr. Parker stated he would expect STUDENT to earn average grades. However, STUDENT is functioning at a higher level than Mr. Parker would expect.
Jane Pace
Jane Pace has served as the District's interim director of student services since August 1996. Ms. Pace testified that STUDENT's ability, as measured in the 1994 administration of the WISC-III, falls within the average range. (See, Resp. Ex. 14, at p. 2.) Based on STUDENT's average I.Q., Ms. Pace would predict that STUDENT would earn average grades.
Ms. Pace testified that STUDENT should earn higher than a 51.9% average in social studies. Ms. Pace attributed STUDENT's low average to "test anxiety" rather than a visual problem. Ms. Pace also noted that STUDENT's standardized test scores revealed no discrepancy between academic ability and achievement.
Ms. Pace recalled that she attended the August 1996 IEP meeting at which FATHER presented Dr. McQuarrie's visual assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Pace stated that she read and kept a copy of Dr. McQuarrie's report. Ms. Pace is not an expert in visual disabilities. She asserted that if she had questions about Dr. McQuarrie's report she would have referred them to Bobbie Cummins, a District employee who provides assistance to visually handicapped students. Notwithstanding Ms. Cummins' availability, no District employee at the IEP meeting suggested that the IEP team seek a second opinion regarding STUDENT's asserted need for vision therapy.
Ms. Pace acknowledged that the California Department of Education's Compliance Report concluded the District did not comply with some sections of the Education Code regarding such issues as the duty of the District to consider Dr. McQuarrie's vision assessment, the right of parents to tape record IEP team meetings, and the District's duty to provide. (Pet. Ex. 49.) Ms. Pace stated the District intends to appeal the report but has developed a visual assessment plan pursuant to the requirements of the report. According to Ms. Pace, STUDENT's parents have refused to sign the assessment plan.
According to Ms. Pace, STUDENT's IEP team met on December 12, 1996. During that meeting, FATHER requested that that STUDENT receive RSP science. Ms. Pace stated that STUDENT's science teacher objected to this proposed placement because STUDENT was doing well in her regular education science class.
The IEP team also discussed STUDENT's use of a magnifying overlay called a "magna page," which would increase the size of print. Ms. Pace reported that none of the team members objected to STUDENT using the magna page, so she instructed Ms. Burleson to alert STUDENT's teachers that she would use the device in class.
At the IEP meeting, the team recalled that STUDENT was doing well in all aspects of school, including tests and quizzes, until May 1996. Ms. Pace suggested that the death of STUDENT's sister in spring 1996 might possibly have caused STUDENT to experience difficulty with tests and quizzes. Ms. Pace stated that the District provides grief counselling and recommended that it might be appropriate for STUDENT to avail herself of the counselling. Ms. Pace also stated that STUDENT might perform better on tests if they were called quizzes.
Elizabeth Monticue
Elizabeth Monticue, nurse for the District, serves the students of Vista Campana Middle School. Ms. Monticue has neither met nor been asked to evaluate STUDENT. Ms. Monticue has not read Dr. McQuarrie's report.
Wanda Liggins
Vista Campana Middle School counsellor Wanda Liggins monitors STUDENT's academic progress. STUDENT is one of the approximately seven hundred students in Ms. Liggins' case load, and Ms. Liggins estimates that she briefly speaks to STUDENT once a month.
Ms. Liggins testified that STUDENT impresses her as a good student. Ms. Liggins does not know precisely what grades STUDENT earns on tests and quizzes but expects that her grades should be higher than "D's" and "F's." Ms. Liggins was not aware that STUDENT received RSP monitoring and support. No teacher has expressed complaints or concerns about STUDENT to Ms. Liggins.
Both FATHER and Ms. Burleson informed Ms. Liggins that STUDENT has a visual disability, but Ms. Liggins has never seen Dr.
McQuarrie's visual assessment. Ms. Liggins testified that she has not seen any indication that STUDENT suffers from a visual disability. Moreover, neither STUDENT nor her teachers have suggested that a visual disability affects STUDENT's performance at school. Ms. Liggins stated that she did not know that STUDENT was failing a class until FATHER showed her STUDENT's December 3, 1996 social studies printout. (Pet. Ex. 51.) Upon reviewing the printout, Ms. Liggins offered that STUDENT's social studies grade may be low because she is not completing her homework.
Douglas Snider
School psychologist Douglas Snider has neither met nor assessed STUDENT since she enrolled at Vista Campana in August 1995. Although Mr. Snider attended several of STUDENT's IEP team meetings during the 1995-96 school year, he has not spoken to any of STUDENT's teachers for the 1996-97 school year.
Mr. Snider stated that he was not aware of STUDENT's current grades. Mr. Snider suggested that test anxiety might account for a student's poor performance on tests and quizzes when that same student did well on other assignments.
Dr. Lynn Bouffard
Dr. Lynn Bouffard is the District's director of personnel services. Dr. Bouffard recalls that when she spoke with Dr.
Ballinger regarding STUDENT's progress in vision therapy, Dr.
Ballinger stated that STUDENT had achieved her therapeutic objectives and had been fitted with new glasses.
Dr. Bouffard was not present at the August 1996 IEP team meeting.
Dr. Jan Horn
Dr. Jan Horn is a licensed educational psychologist who works primarily with children. Dr. Horn is also the "learning disabilities specialist" at the University of California, Riverside. Dr. Horn stated that he has reviewed developmental visual assessment reports and suggested modifications to children's IEPs based on his review. Dr. Horn testified that he lacks formal training in developmental optometry.
In March 1991, at the request of NMUSD, Dr. Horn conducted a psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT. (Pet. Ex. 2.) (Footnote 5) During the 1991 evaluation process, Dr. Horn reviewed a report from Dr. McQuarrie that recommended vision therapy for STUDENT. Dr. Horn endorsed Dr. McQuarrie's recommendation and also advised that NMUSD provide vision therapy at public expense. (Pet. Ex. 2, at p. 7.) Dr. Horn supports Dr. McQuarrie's current recommendation that STUDENT receive vision therapy. (Pet. Ex. 17.)
Dr. Horn attended STUDENT's September 1995 IEP team meeting.
(Pet. Ex. 11.) Dr. Horn remembered that Dr. Bouffard stated she suspected that STUDENT qualified for special education because she suffered from a visual processing disability. Dr. Horn did not recommend vision therapy during this IEP meeting.
According to Dr. Horn, Dr. Bouffard asked the school psychologist, Douglas Snider, to obtain additional information regarding STUDENT's eligibility for special education from NMUSD. After reviewing STUDENT's subsequent IEPs, Dr. Horn concluded that Mr. Snider did not secure the requested information or so inform the IEP team.
Dr. Horn remarked that STUDENT performs significantly better on science, social science and language arts homework or classwork than she does on tests. (Pet. Ex. 34, 35, and 36.) Dr. Horn concluded that STUDENT is a bright, motivated student who does poorly on structured tests that require reading and reading comprehension. Dr. Horn suggested that STUDENT's high grades are misleading.
Dr. Horn rejects the theory that "test anxiety" or "bad days"
are responsible for STUDENT's poor showing on science, social science, and language arts tests. Dr. Horn added that if STUDENT suffered from "test anxiety," she would also be anxious during and do poorly on math tests. However, STUDENT has maintained an "A" average in math. (Resp. Ex. 3, at p. 3.)
Dr. Horn stated that STUDENT suffers from a visual disability and urged the District to provide vision therapy to STUDENT because her vision is adversely affecting her performance at school. Dr. Horn also stated that STUDENT suffers from a learning disability.
Dr. Horn advised the following modifications to STUDENT's program: enlarged print, front and center class seating, extended time to complete tests and quizzes, having tests read to her, and the use of a tape recorder in class. Dr. Horn offered that STUDENT's performance on tests and quizzes is more important than her performance on class and homework. In Dr. Horn's opinion, STUDENT is college bound and therefore must be prepared to succeed on the tests that she will encounter in college.
RESPONDENT'S EVIDENCE
Armalyn De Lao
Armalyn De Lao is Vista Campana's instrumental music and choir director. STUDENT currently plays first chair flute in Vista Campana's marching band and wind ensemble, and second alto saxophone in the jazz band. STUDENT has consistently received "A's" or "A+'s" in Ms. De Lao's classes. Ms. De Lao reported that of the ten or eleven flutists, STUDENT has become the best. Ms. De Lao attributes STUDENT's musical success to hard work, noting that in approximately one year she advanced from fifth to first chair in wind ensemble.
In the past, STUDENT failed to win a place in one of the very competitive music festivals. Ms. De Lao remarked that STUDENT performed well on her pieces and scales, but not on the sight reading. Nevertheless, Ms. De Lao describes STUDENT as a "highly motivated" student, commenting, "the music she knows, she plays well."
With fifty students in her class, Ms. De Lao does not work with individual students except during scales and testing. Ms. De Lao stated that during daily practices, she stands approximately three feet away from STUDENT. According to Ms. De Lao, STUDENT places her music stand approximately one foot away from herself and can sight read music printed on the 8 and 1/2 by 11 sheet as well as anyone. Occasionally, STUDENT shares a music stand with the performer next to her. Ms. De Lao testified that STUDENT has never asked for sheet music with enlarged print. STUDENT is also able to watch Ms. De Lao as STUDENT plays the flute.
STUDENT has never complained of eye strain or other visual problems. Moreover, Ms. De Lao has not observed that visual problems inhibit STUDENT's ability to perform. For example, Ms. De Lao has not noticed that STUDENT loses her place while playing. Ms. De Lao has noticed that STUDENT makes the other "typical"
mistakes of beginning to play too early or too late. Ms. De Lao reported that STUDENT plays as well in the morning as she does later in the day.
Ms. De Lao stated that a document placed in her mailbox in 1995 informed her that STUDENT had a visual disability. Until Ms. De Lao received the document, she did not suspect that STUDENT suffered from a visual disability.
Ms. De Lao testified that FATHER requested the name of a private music teacher for STUDENT so she recommended Linda Plaas. Ms. De Lao knew that STUDENT is currently taking individual lessons from Ms. Plaas. Ms. De Lao did not know how many hours STUDENT practices each day, but estimated that most of her students practice from twenty to twenty-five minutes.
Joy Ast
Of the thirty-four students in Joy Ast's second period pre-algebra class, STUDENT has the highest average. Ms. Ast testified that she has not altered her curriculum to accommodate STUDENT's visual disability. For example, STUDENT sits in the middle of the class and works from charts, graphs, overhead projections, the chalk board and her text book. (Footnote 6) STUDENT is able to work on pre-algebra problems arranged either vertically or horizontally on the page.
Ms. Ast asserted that STUDENT has neither asked for enlarged print nor complained that she could not read the course material. Ms. Ast recalled that STUDENT read aloud in class approximately six times. According to Ms. Ast, STUDENT reads aloud well and does not rub or appear to rest her eyes during class.
Ms. Ast acknowledged that she is not an expert in visual disabilities. Ms. Ast stated that she was not aware of and had not read Dr. McQuarrie's visual assessment. In Ms. Ast's opinion, however, STUDENT does not require additional time to complete tests, enlarged print, or other accommodations to succeed in pre-algebra.
Mary Welamin
On October 31, 1996, STUDENT retook Ms. Rincon's unit test on The Witch of Blackbird Pond in Mary Welamin's language arts class. Ms. Welamin stated that she seated STUDENT at the front of the room, and was able to see STUDENT as she completed the test.
According to Ms. Welamin, STUDENT completed the test in approximately fifteen minutes. Ms. Welamin did not observe that STUDENT lifted the test or in any other way demonstrated that she had trouble reading the test.
When STUDENT retook the test, there were between twenty-eight and thirty-five other students in Ms. Welamin's class. Ms. Welamin acknowledged that because she was teaching her class while STUDENT was taking the test, she could not observe STUDENT for the entire class.
Laurel Arnold
NMUSD has employed Laurel Arnold as a school psychologist for the past twelve years. Ms. Arnold recalled that she assessed STUDENT when she was in the first grade. According to Ms. Arnold, STUDENT was qualified for special education because she had "sensory and visual motor problems and met the discrepancy model." STUDENT was therefore enrolled in a special day class within NMUSD.
STUDENT remained in NMUSD's special education program until the second semester of second grade, when her parents enrolled her in a nonpublic school. Ms. Arnold recalled that in 1991, NMUSD provided STUDENT with vision therapy with Dr. Ballinger because Drs. Horn and Ballinger recommended that she receive it. In 1993, Dr. Ballinger released STUDENT from vision therapy.
STUDENT returned to NMUSD in 1994 when she was a sixth grader. About the time of STUDENT's return to NMUSD, Ms. Arnold conducted an educational assessment that revealed that STUDENT no longer "met the discrepancy model." According to Ms. Arnold, STUDENT no longer displayed visual problems. (Resp. Ex. 13.) Nevertheless, Ms.
Arnold testified that NMUSD continued to offer STUDENT RSP services for the following reasons: she had just returned from a nonpublic school, her siblings had a history of learning disabilities, and NMUSD had experienced "problems" dealing with the PARENTS' family. In 1995, STUDENT left NMUSD.
Ms. Arnold stated that she has reviewed the reports of Drs.
Horn, Ballinger and McQuarrie, and based on her review, concluded that STUDENT does not have a visual disability. When asked what might account for STUDENT's poor test scores, Ms. Arnold suggested that test anxiety may be a factor.
DISCUSSION
1. Must the District reimburse STUDENT for the cost of Dr.
Charles McQuarrie's visual assessment, report, and round-trip milage to his office?
Petitioner contends that the District must reimburse her for the cost of the visual assessment that Dr. McQuarrie performed in August 1996. The District maintains that it is not financially responsible for Dr. McQuarrie's assessment, which was conducted without the District's consent or knowledge.
Education Code section 56381 states the circumstances under which a District must reassess a student:
The reassessment of a pupil, based on procedures specified in Article 2 (commencing with Section 56320)
shall be conducted every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment and a new individualized education program to be developed.
If the reassessment so indicates, a new individualized education program shall be developed.
(Emphasis added.)
In this case, it is undisputed that FATHER requested that the District reassess STUDENT for a visual disability at the May 1996 IEP team meeting. The Hearing Officer finds that FATHER's request was reasonable because it was supported by both Dr. McQuarrie's letter and STUDENT's complaints as conveyed to the IEP team by FATHER. (Pet. Ex. 14.) As the request for assessment was both reasonable and received by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that, under Education Code section 56381, the District was legally obligated to conduct it. (Footnote 7)
It is also undisputed that within days of FATHER's request, the District attempted to schedule a regional IEP team meeting to determine whether to conduct the assessment. FATHER, Mr. Parker, and Dr. Bouffard each testified that the District proposed to convene an IEP meeting before the second semester of the 1995-96 school year ended on June 6, 1996, but the parties' conflicting schedules prevented the meeting from taking place until school resumed in August.
Moreover, neither party disputes that the District attempted to schedule the regional IEP team meeting within days of the beginning of the 1996-97 school year. However, it is clear from the evidence that the regional IEP team meeting did not occur until August 29, 1996.
Education Code section 56321(a) sets forth some of the timelines to which the District must adhere when it is to conduct an assessment. In relevant part, this section states:
Whenever an assessment for the development or revision of the individualized education program is to be conducted, the parent of the pupil shall be given, in writing, a proposed assessment plan within 15 days of the referral for assessment not counting days between the pupil's regular school sessions or terms of days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays from the date of the receipt of the referral, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension. In the case of pupil school vacations, the 15-day time shall recommence on the date that the pupil's regular schooldays reconvene.
Under the section cited above, the District had fifteen days "from the date of receipt of referral" to provide the PARENT with a proposed assessment plan. Even assuming that the District received the PARENT' request at 9:00 a.m. on May 23, 1996, the District had fifteen twenty-four hour days, or until 9:00 a.m. on June 7, 1996, to give the PARENT its proposed assessment plan. But, according to the undisputed testimony of Mr. Parker, the semester ended on June 6, 1996. Therefore, the District did not violate this timeline because only fourteen twenty-four hour days elapsed between the date of receipt and the last day of the semester.
When the 1996-97 school year began on August 6, 1996, "the 15-day time...recommence[d] on the date that the pupil's regular schooldays reconvene." Therefore, the District had from August 6, 1996 until 9:00 am on August 22, 1996, to give the PARENT a proposed assessment plan.
It is clear from the record that the District did not provide the parents with a proposed assessment plan. (Resp. Ex. 12.) Mr. Parker's credible testimony establishes that since May 1996, the District repeatedly attempted to convene and ultimately scheduled an IEP meeting at which the requested assessment was to be discussed. But the District's efforts to convene an IEP to discuss an assessment plan does not relieve it of its clear statutory obligation to produce a plan within the legal time frame.
Similarly, nothing in the Education Code states that a parent's unilateral action to secure an assessment excuses a District from conducting an assessment plan. (Education Code section 56321(a).) As no assessment plan was created, the District did not meet its statutory duty.
According to Education Code section 56329(b), a parent is entitled to receive at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists,..., if the parent disagrees with the assessment obtained by the public education agency.
In this case, FATHER obtained an independent visual assessment before the District's assessment plan was overdue. But FATHER's quick action does not divest him of the right to seek reimbursement, because the section does not require a parent to forego assessing his child until the District has completed its own assessment. If the District had conformed to the statutory time lines, the adequacy of its assessment would be at issue. But, because the District neither produced an assessment plan nor conducted the requested assessment, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. McQuarrie's assessment and reasonable round-trip mileage to and from Dr. McQuarrie's office.
2. Must the District provide STUDENT with vision therapy with Dr. McQuarrie?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), the federal government provides monetary grants to participating states for assistance in educating disabled students. Under federal law, participating states must assure all disabled students the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) which is defined as:
special education and related services that (A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge, (B) meet the standards of the state educational agency, (C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved, and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under section 614(a)(5) [20 U.S.C. section 1414(a)(5)].
(20 U.S.C. (United States Code) section 1400(c); section 1401(a)(16-18); section 1412(1) and (2)(B); see also Education Code section 56031.) "The 'free appropriate education' required by the Act is tailored to the unique needs of the handicapped child by means of an 'individualized education program' (IEP) section 1401(18)." (Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207 (1982).) The IEP identifies the special education and related services necessary to meet that child's unique educational needs, and the district must then offer to provide those services at full public expense.
(Footnote 8) (20 U.S.C. sections 1412(4) and 1414(a)(5); Education Code section 56040.)
In the above cited case, Amy Rowley, a deaf first-grader, challenged her IEP which included a wireless hearing aide, one hour of tutoring each day, and three hours of tutoring each week. Amy's IEP, however, did not provide her with the services of a qualified sign language interpreter in each of her academic classes.
Amy has "minimal residual hearing and is an excellent lipreader." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 184.) Relying on her lipreading skills and a hearing aid, she successfully completed kindergarten. The District refused to provide Amy with an interpreter for first grade because she was "achieving educationally, academically, and socially without such assistance." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 185.)
Ultimately, the United States Supreme Court concluded that Amy was receiving a FAPE without the services of an interpreter because the "'evidence firmly establishes that Amy is receiving an 'adequate' education, since she performs better than the average child in her class and is advancing easily from grade to grade." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 210.) In making this determination a divided Court recognized, however, that relying on the hearing aid an lip-reading, Amy often understands "less than half of what is said in the classroom." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 215.)
Nevertheless, the Court held that Amy was not prospectively entitled to the services of a sign language interpreter.
To determine whether a FAPE has been offered, one must decide whether the student's IEP is reasonably calculated to enable her to receive educational benefit. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 176.) If the District's proposed IEP is adequate, then the District has offered a FAPE, even when the parents prefer another program.
(Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) The school district is not required to provide the best possible education or to maximize educational benefits to the child, but rather offer special education program that provides a "'basic floor of opportunity'... which consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are designed to provide educational benefit to the handicapped child" (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 200.)
In Rowley, the Court recognized that it could not establish "any one test for determining the adequacy of educational benefits conferred upon all children covered by the [IDEA]," given the varying degrees and types of disabilities among these children. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 202.) However, "if the child is being educated in the regular classrooms of the public education system, [the IEP] should be reasonably calculated to enable the child to achieve passing marks and advance from grade to grade."(Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 204.)
In this case, both the IDEA and Rowley standard requires that STUDENT receive sufficient support services that are designed to her unique educational needs and enable her to achieve passing marks and advance from grade to grade. (Footnote 9) The evidence establishes that STUDENT's current IEP, which provides RSP services but does not include vision therapy (footnote 10), satisfies the Rowley standard. STUDENT's grades reveal that, like Amy Rowley, she "performs better than the average child in her class and is advancing easily from grade to grade."
Additionally, without vision therapy, STUDENT is meeting the goal and objectives stated in her current IEP. The IEP of May 23, 1996 defines STUDENT's educational goal as follows (footnote 11):
STUDENT will maintain passing grades in all regular education classes.
This IEP also lists the following short term objectives:
(a) STUDENT will complete assignments [in] a regular classroom with minimal adaptations and maintain passing grades.
(b) STUDENT will complete homework and classwork for regular classes with minimal parent support (no more than would be normally given to a student at middle school level.)
(Resp. Ex. 11 at p. 2.)
Each of STUDENT's eighth-grade teachers testified that she is currently achieving better than passing grades and none of them expressed any concern that she would not advance to the ninth grade. In fact, Ms. Ast testified that STUDENT has earned the highest average in her regular education mathematics class and Ms. DeLao testified that STUDENT has an "A" average in wind ensemble. (See, e.g. Resp. Ex. 3.)
The record also reflects that STUDENT has failed tests in both Ms. Rincon and Mr. Perkins' classes. (Pet. Ex. 34, 35, and 36.) But STUDENT's current overall grades in these classes are at or above average because her performances on other assignments have been strong. STUDENT's current overall averages are as follows: social studies "C," language arts "B+," and science "B."
Furthermore, the record contains no evidence that STUDENT received failing grades at the semester grading period. Moreover, STUDENT's teachers have credibly testified that they were not aware that STUDENT's vision adversely affected her academic performance. For instance, Mr. Perkins stated that STUDENT successfully read aloud in class and even read from the periodic table of the elements. (Resp. Ex. 16.) Therefore, the evidence establishes that the services that STUDENT currently receives allow her to meet the educational goal and objective that her IEP team agreed upon.
The evidence is less clear regarding whether STUDENT is satisfying the second objective, i.e., completion of homework with no more support than would be "normally" given to a student in middle school. FATHER estimated that he and his wife assist STUDENT from one and one-half to two hours each night. By itself, this estimation does not establish that STUDENT is not achieving the second objective. The record contains no evidence as to how much time the IEP team imagined parents "normally" spend assisting their children with homework. Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot find that the STUDENT is not meeting this objective.
Petitioner urges the Hearing Officer to focus on STUDENT's scores on tests and quizzes, rather than her overall average, but cites no authority to support this approach. Clearly, adherence to the Rowley standard requires that STUDENT derive some educational benefit from her educational placement. Here, as was the case with Amy Rowley, STUDENT's academic performance supports the conclusion that she is deriving some educational benefit from her educational placement.
STUDENT's testimony that she has had to rely heavily on listening comprehension and memorization to succeed is troubling. But, just as Amy Rowley lipread and relied on her hearing aid, STUDENT listens and relies on her memory. In cases such as these, the law does not require a District to provide more services when a child is deriving educational benefit from her program.
In conclusion, although vision therapy may enable STUDENT to improve her academic performance, there is no evidence in the record that STUDENT requires vision therapy to derive educational benefit from her current educational program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not order the District to provide it.
(Footnote 12)
3. Must the District modify STUDENT's IEP to accommodate a visual disability?
Petitioner requests that STUDENT's IEP team modify her current IEP to reflect that: (1) the IEP team accepts and acknowledges the existence of Dr. McQuarrie's developmental assessment report, (2) the IEP team recognizes that STUDENT suffers from a visual disability, (3) the print on all of STUDENT's reading material will be enlarged, (4) the textbooks that STUDENT uses will either be audio-taped or in enlarged print, (5) STUDENT may tape record her classes, and (6) STUDENT will receive extended time to complete all tests and assignments. (Pet. Closing Argument at p. 33.)
The District maintains that STUDENT does not need the requested modifications and that, if provided, they will "foster dependence and helplessness."
The Hearing Officer cannot determine precisely what Petitioner seeks in her first request. Credible testimony from those present at the August 29, 1996 IEP team meeting establishes that each team member received and read a copy of Dr. McQuarrie's report. While no one questioned the existence of the report, not all IEP team members understood the technical language of the report or agreed with its recommendations. The Hearing Officer will not order individual members of STUDENT's IEP team to "accept" a report that they may not understand or agree with. However, the IEP team members must consider Dr. McQuarrie's report when developing STUDENT's educational program.
The Hearing Officer also cannot determine precisely what Petitioner seeks in her second request. Is Petitioner seeking an order stating that STUDENT qualifies for special education because she suffers from a visual disability or does Petitioner want STUDENT's IEP to reflect that Dr. McQuarrie determined that she has visual deficits? Petitioner has failed to establish that in addition to a learning disability, STUDENT also has a separate qualifying disability in the area of vision. Therefore the IEP need not be modified to contain a separate basis of eligibility. However, to the extent that Petitioner is requesting that STUDENT's IEP contain accommodations for visual deficits, that will be addressed below.
Regarding the third request, both FATHER and Ms. Pace credibly testified that during the December 1996 IEP team meeting, the team agreed that STUDENT may use her portable magnifying device in class. (Pet. Ex. 82, tape recording of December 12, 1996 IEP team meeting.) Because there was no evidence establishing that both a magnifying device and enlarged print are necessary, the Hearing Officer finds that the use of the magnifying device obviates the need for enlarged print text books, tests, quizzes, handouts, and other documents. However, if circumstances arise in which use of the magnifying device is impracticable, in music class, for example, the District is ordered to enlarge the print of the document.
As the parties agreed that STUDENT may use the magnifying device, the District is not ordered to supply books on tape. The Hearing Officer also notes that Petitioner's own witness, Dr.
McQuarrie, generally discouraged reliance upon books on tape.
Therefore, Petitioner's fourth request is denied.
Neither STUDENT, members of her IEP team, nor any of the District witnesses testified that tape-recording classes, Petitioner's fifth request, would improve her academic performance. Even Dr. McQuarrie pointed out that tape-recording classes is quite time-consuming, and recommended that STUDENT be permitted to use a tape recorder in class only if necessary. Because no evidence establishes that STUDENT needs to use a tape recorder in class or that use of a tape recorder would improve her academic performance, the Hearing Officer denies this request.
In her sixth request, Petitioner seeks extended time to complete all assignments, including tests, quizzes, homework and classwork. The record does not establish that this accommodation is necessary. For example, Ms. Ast stated that STUDENT does not require this type of modification because STUDENT is earning an "A" in her class without having more time to complete her work. Ms. Burleson's comments at the December 12, 1996 IEP team meeting support Ms. Ast's observation. Ms. Burleson, who has proctored STUDENT's tests, stated that whether STUDENT does well or poorly on a test, she completes it quickly. According to Ms. Burleson, she has advised STUDENT to work more slowly, but STUDENT continues to work at her own rapid pace. (Pet. Ex. 82, tape recording of December 12, 1996 IEP team meeting.)
Furthermore, Mr. Perkins has not observed that STUDENT needs more time to complete her assignments. For example, Mr. Perkins credibly testified that on November 14, 1996, STUDENT completed ten of fourteen questions on her science pre-test before the period ended. (Resp. Ex. 20, at p. 3.) Mr. Perkins also stated that STUDENT completed the test that she failed on November 15, 1996, twice as fast as her classmates.
Finally, neither Ms. Rincon nor STUDENT testified that she needed extra time to complete her assignments. Dr. McQuarrie suggested that STUDENT's teachers, on a temporary basis, give her more time for test-taking. But Dr. McQuarrie did not testify that he has observed STUDENT in an academic testing situation. The first-hand observations of STUDENT's teachers and testimony of STUDENT herself is entitled to more weight; therefore, the request for additional time to complete tests and assignments is denied.
However, the record establishes that both Ms. Rincon and Mr.
Perkins currently extend the time that STUDENT has to complete tests by allowing her to retake tests when she does poorly. The evidence reflects that this accommodation is tailored to meet her educational needs because during retesting, STUDENT's performance tends to improve. Therefore, this accommodation should be reflected in STUDENT's IEP and, in this respect, the request for additional time to complete tests is granted.
4. Must the District reimburse the PARENT for legal costs and witness fees?
Petitioner maintains that the District must reimburse her for legal costs and fees, while the District contends that Petitioner seeks relief that the Hearing Officer lacks the legal authority to grant.
The Education Code does not authorize the Hearing Officer to award either party legal costs or witness fees. Education Code section 56507 (b) states:
An award of reasonable attorneys' fees to the prevailing parent, guardian, or pupil, as the case may be, may only be made either with the agreement of the parties following the conclusion of the administrative hearing process or by a court of competent jurisdiction pursuant to paragraph (4) of subsection (e) of Section 1415 of Title 20 of the United States Code.
The Special Education Hearing Office is not a court of law, and therefore has no authority to award legal fees under Education Code section 56507(b). Therefore, Petitioner's request for reimbursement for these fees and costs is denied.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen days of the date of this order, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of Dr.
McQuarrie's developmental vision assessment report dated August 26, 1996, and reimburse Petitioner for round-trip mileage to Dr. McQuarrie's office at the rate which the District reimburses its employees who travel by automobile.
2. The District is not required to provide STUDENT with vision therapy with Dr. McQuarrie.
3. Petitioner's IEP shall reflect that she may use her magnifying device whenever necessary and feasible. When use of the magnifying device is necessary but not feasible, the District shall enlarge the print of the documents that Petitioner must read. Petitioner's IEP shall also reflect that she may retake tests that she does not pass.
4. The District is not required to reimburse Petitioner for legal costs or witness fees.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. 1:
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2:
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3:
Respondent substantially prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4:
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).
Dated: February 28, 1997 Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnotes 1. Petitioner's Exhibit 34 reflects that STUDENT earned "perfect scores" on the other fifteen assignments.
2. Petitioner called Mr. Perkins to testify in October 1996. Respondent recalled Mr. Perkins in January 1997.
3. Mr. Perkins noted that STUDENT retook a previous test without her magnifier and scored a ninety 4. According to Mr. Parker, regional IEPs are appropriate when, as here, the services requested are beyond what is available within the District.
5. Dr. Horn has not assessed STUDENT since 1991 or seen her since September 1995. Dr. Horn has not spoken to any of STUDENT's current teachers or her current school psychologist.
6. Ms. Ast commented that the text book print is "on the small side."
7. The Special Education Hearing Office does not conclude that this section entitles a parent to an assessment unless the request for assessment is reasonable. To conclude otherwise, might obligate districts to perform serial assessments.
8. Special education means specially designed instruction to meet the needs of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. §1401(a)(16).) Related services are those required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C.
§1401(a)(17).)
9. STUDENT's last IEP places her in a regular education program with an RSP teacher monitoring and providing support if necessary. (Resp. Ex. 12, at p. 2.)
10. Under California law, the designated service of vision therapy must be necessary for STUDENT "to benefit educationally from...her instructional program." (Education Code section 56363.)
11. STUDENT's August 29, 1996 IEP states that it will "continue all goals, objectives & services" listed in the May 23, 1996 IEP. 12. At present, STUDENT is not legally entitled to vision therapy. But the evidence suggests STUDENT's vision may warrant regular monitoring.
