California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 3, 2003
Student v. Santa Cruz City Elementary School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 968-01 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Santa Cruz City Elementary must fund a behavior assessment, parent training, and 232 compensatory hours after years of FAPE denials.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1 states the decision was amended to add Order 3.C (30 hours of consultation with Dr. Paula Gardner), which had been inadvertently omitted; in all other respects the decision is unchanged.
Summary
The parents of a seven-year-old girl filed for due process, and Santa Cruz City Elementary School District filed its own case. The two cases were consolidated. She was eligible as learning handicapped with developmental delay and attended District special day classes (SDCs) from January 1999. The parents said the District ignored her behavior and expressive language needs. They asked for Pivotal Response Training (PRT) with a trained aide.
After a 15-day hearing, Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard ruled on each year. In 1998-1999, the District denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) only by not assessing for or providing occupational therapy (OT) and adapted physical education. It denied FAPE in 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 because it wrote no behavior or social communication goals and did no functional analysis assessment, even though her behavior problems were serious. It also gave the parents no training and did not target her expressive language. The District could not prove it offered appropriate summer (ESY) programs for 1999 through 2002. The 2001-2002 kindergarten SDC was appropriate, but the agreed assistant for general education time never arrived. For 2002-2003, the District made no specific written offer and held no IEP meeting.
PRT itself was not required. The SDC was the least restrictive environment through 2000-2001, and no neurological assessment was owed. The District must reimburse the parents' UC Santa Barbara training costs and conduct the assessment. It must also provide 52 OT hours, 150 behavior specialist hours, and 30 hours of consultation with Dr. Paula Gardner, and hold an IEP meeting.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied California's Hughes Bill. Hitting, choking, and avoidant behavior counted as serious behavior problems even without injury or intent to harm. Parent training was treated as a related service the District owed. A vague placement plan, later "clarified" by letter, was not a legally sufficient written offer under Union v. Smith.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue I. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 1998-1999 school year? (unique needs, goals, measurability, fine and gross motor assessment and services)
The SDC program generally met her needs and the goals were measurable, but the District failed to assess for and provide OT and APE for about 15–18 months, denying FAPE to that limited extent.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue I-LRE. Was the SDC placement the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during 1998-1999?
The preschool SDC was the least restrictive environment; no general education teacher or inclusion goals were required.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue I-ESY. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999 extended school year?
The District failed to carry its burden of proving an appropriate ESY 1999 program, including speech and OT services needed to prevent regression.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 1999-2000 school year?
The program was not designed to meet her needs: no IEP meeting was held to add behavior and social communication goals, no Hughes Bill functional analysis assessment was done despite serious behavior problems, and no parent training was provided.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue II-LRE. Was the SDC placement the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during 1999-2000?
The SDC remained the least restrictive environment, as the IEP team, including the parents, determined.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue II-ESY. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000 extended school year?
The District failed to prove an appropriate ESY 2000 program, and there was no justification for delaying OT services until September 2000.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including whether she required Pivotal Response Training (PRT) methodology and a functional analysis assessment?
PRT methodology was not required, but the program did not target expressive language, no FAA was done, and the behavior plan and goals addressed only aggression, not resistant and avoidant behaviors.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue III-LRE. Was the SDC placement the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during 2000-2001?
The SDC was the least restrictive environment, though the unaddressed behavior and language needs likely limited her mainstream opportunities and bathroom use was not a real mainstream opportunity.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue III-ESY. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001 extended school year?
The District failed to carry its burden of proving an appropriate ESY 2001 program.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue IV-A. Did the District fail to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability by failing to assess her neurological needs or refer her for neurological assessment (2001-2002 to present)?
Staff did not observe symptoms that would raise a suspicion of neurological disability, and prior neurological testing was normal, so no assessment or referral was required.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue IV-B. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2001-2002 school year, including the mainstream component with an assistant?
The kindergarten SDC was appropriate, but the District failed to provide the agreed trained, dedicated assistant for the general education kindergarten after the March 2002 IEP, denying an LRE opportunity.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue IV-ESY. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002 extended school year?
The parents were denied participation in developing ESY 2002 because no follow-up IEP meeting was held, and the District offered no evidence of the ESY program's content.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue V. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
The District made no legally sufficient written offer of a specific placement and held no IEP meeting for 2002-2003, which seriously infringed parent participation. The Hearing Officer made no finding on ESY 2003.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue VI-a. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the costs of attending parent training at the Autism Research and Training Center at UC Santa Barbara, including transportation and lodging?
Because the District failed to provide needed parent training, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the PRT training and related travel and lodging costs.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue VI-b. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations?
The parents did not challenge the District's assessments, and the IEE findings did not differ significantly from them, so the Hearing Officer denied reimbursement.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue VII. If the District denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory education?
The Hearing Officer awarded 150 hours of behavior specialist services, 52 hours of OT, and 30 hours of consultation with Dr. Gardner. She denied gross motor compensatory services and did not award the requested PRT-trained aide bank.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 10 business days, reimburse the parents for the costs of the PRT training at UC Santa Barbara (October 30–November 3, 2000) and related transportation and lodging, according to proof.
- Order to assess. Within 10 business days, begin a functional analysis assessment under Education Code § 56520 et seq. and 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001, 3052; then immediately develop and implement any behavior intervention plan the assessment indicates, in the current placement.
- Compensatory education. 52 hours of compensatory occupational therapy for fine motor skills; the IEP team decides the manner of delivery.
- Compensatory education. A bank of 150 hours of one-to-one services by a behavior specialist trained in behavioral methods for facilitating expressive language and social communication. The specialist joins the IEP team and consults with the parents, teacher, speech therapist, school psychologist, and any behavioral intervention case manager.
- Compensatory education. 30 hours of compensatory consultation with Dr. Paula Gardner to ensure the IEP team prepares measurable annual goals designed to facilitate inclusion in regular education.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 business days, convene an IEP meeting to address placement for 2002-2003 and ESY 2003.
- Order to provide or change services. The 2002-2003 placement must include at least 2 hours a day in an appropriate regular education program with a dedicated assistant trained in facilitating expressive language and social communication.
Total: 232 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Adams v. Oregon; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education; Student v. Laguna Beach Unified School District (SEHO); Newark Unified School District (SEHO)
People named in the decision
- Phyllis Stagnaro, preschool SDC teacher and speech pathologist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Paula Fuller, speech pathologist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Dr. Sheila Coonerty, clinical psychologist and school psychologist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Cumba Siegler, occupational therapist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Clare Choate, adapted physical education specialist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Nancy Boehm, kindergarten SDC teacher, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Cynthia Paulsen, school psychologist (behavior support plan author), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Marsha Isaacson, SDC teacher (1st-3rd grade, De La Viega), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Dr. Gary Rezowalli, clinical psychologist and school psychologist, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Dr. Wilma Poage, former director of special education, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Cece Burgoon, director of special education, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Alan Pagano, assistant superintendent of instruction, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Ms. Torp, former special education director, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Ms. Baker, speech pathologist (initial assessment), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Ms. Bennett, school psychologist (initial assessment), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Ms. Bouett, SDC teacher (IEP team member), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Rosalie, classroom aide (assistant offered for general education kindergarten), Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Kim, classroom aide, Santa Cruz City Elementary School District
- Linda Fleming, speech pathologist (independent contractor providing District speech services), Independent contractor to District
- Caryl Hogan, case manager, Santa Cruz County Office of Education
- Dr. Paula Gardner, expert witness for Student; special education professor; ordered consultant, California State University, Sacramento
- Dr. Lyn Kern Koegel, expert witness for Student; clinical director, PRT program, Autism Research and Training Center, UC Santa Barbara
- Jenny Symon, PRT trainer (doctoral graduate student), UC Santa Barbara
- Dr. Jacknow, independent developmental pediatrician (IEE), Private
- Dr. Goldman, independent psychologist (IEE), Private
- Ms. Gault (also spelled Galt), independent speech therapist (IEE), Private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Santa Cruz, California, on August 13, 14, 27, 28, 29, September 12, 13, 18, 19, 24, 25, and October 1, 2, 3, and 8, 2002.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorneys Roberta Savage and Eileen Matteucci. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf were her parents, PARENT and PARENT. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner Santa Cruz City Elementary School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen M. Rezendes on all hearing days except August 13 and 14, when it was represented by attorneys Sarah Tigerman and Charmaine Huntting. Also present on the District=s behalf was its director of special education, Cece Burgoon, on all hearing days except August 13, 2002, when assistant superintendent of instruction, Alan Pagano, was present on the District’s behalf.(Footnote 2)
The Student called the following District employees as witnesses: speech pathologist Paula Fuller, special day class (SDC) teacher and speech pathologist Phyllis Stagnaro, clinical psychologist and school psychologist Dr. Sheila Coonerty, occupational therapist Cumba Siegler, adapted physical education specialist Clare Choate, SDC teacher Nancy Boehm, and school psychologist Cynthia Paulsen. The Student also called the following witnesses: speech pathologist Linda Fleming, California State Sacramento special education professor Dr. Paula Gardner, STUDENT’s mother PARENT, and Dr. Lyn Kern Koegel, clinical director of the Autism Research and Training Center of the University of California, Santa Barbara.
The District called the following witnesses: County Office of Education case manager Caryl Hogan, STUDENT’s parent PARENT, former director of special education Dr. Wilma Poage, SDC teachers Phyllis Stagnaro, Nancy Boehm, and Marsha Isaacson, clinical psychologist and school psychologist, Dr. Gary Rezowalli, and occupational therapist Cumba Siegler.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. On October 31, 2002, the Hearing Officer received closing briefs from the Student and the District. The record was then closed and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES(Footnote 3)
I. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment during the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year?
II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 1999-2000 school year, including the extended school year?
III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2000-2001 school year, including the extended school year?
IV. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment, during the 2001-2002 school year, including the extended school year?
V. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment during the 2002-2003 school year, including the extended school year?
VI. If the District denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for any of the years outlined above, is she entitled to reimbursement for independent educational evaluations or for the costs of attending a parent training at the Autism Research and Training Center at the University of California Santa Barbara, including reasonable costs for transportation and lodging?
VII. If the District denied or failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for any of the years outlined above, is she entitled to compensatory education?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Student contends that she has lost substantial educational opportunities from January 1999 to the present as a result of the District’s procedural and substantive failures to appropriately address her unique needs. In her view, these failures are most clearly manifested in her limited educational progress in social communication and expressive language: from speaking in one-word utterances in January 1999, to speaking in one- to three-word utterances at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT alleges that the District failed to address her expressive language and behavior needs and that she has been treated as a child with mental retardation from whom only slight achievements can be expected. She contends that she requires an intensive behavior and language program, like the Pivotal Response Training (PRT) program, to address these needs. In her view, implementation of a PRT program would require the District (1) to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of her negative behaviors and replace those behaviors with effective social communication skills, and (2) to provide her with an appropriate mainstream program with the support of a one-to-one aide trained in PRT.
The District contends that it has fully assessed STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and provided her with an appropriately designed program in which she received some educational benefit relative to her disabilities from January 1999 to the present. In its view, PRT is not required under the Rowley standard for STUDENT to receive some educational benefit. The District asserts that STUDENT does not require a one-to-one aide because she has not required one in the past and her own experts testified that she did not require a “velcro aide.” The District also asserts that STUDENT does not have a “serious behavior problem” that significantly interferes with the implementation of her goals and objectives which would require an FAA assessment pursuant to the Hughes Bill. Accordingly, the District contends that neither compensatory education nor reimbursement is appropriate.
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a seven-year-old developmentally delayed student currently attending a combined first through third grade learning handicap (mild-to-moderate) special day class (SDC) at the District’s De La Viega Elementary School. Pursuant to a stay put order issued by the Hearing Office on June 17, 2002, STUDENT is also receiving two thirty-minute sessions a week each of speech therapy and adapted physical education (APE), and one hour a month each of direct and consultative occupational therapy services (OT).(Footnote 4)
STUDENT was referred to the District for a special education assessment in October 1998, two months after her third birthday, due to concerns that she used single words, communicated primarily with gestures and noises, and had difficulties in gross and fine motor skills. In November and December of 1998, STUDENT was assessed in the area of health by the school nurse, in communication by the speech pathologist, in pre-academics and perceptual motor ability by the preschool specialist, and in cognition and social-emotional status by the school psychologist. Significant findings from her initial assessment were as follows: At a chronological age of three years and four months, STUDENT’s overall language skills were between the eighteen-month to two-year-old level. Her receptive language was delayed approximately one year (2.3 age equivalent) and her expressive language was seriously delayed, at a 1.6 year-old age equivalent. STUDENT had significant delays in all areas of her pre-academic and perceptual motor development and functioned between one year six months and two year-old age equivalent on most developmental tasks. On the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of IntelligenceBRevised (WPPSI-R), STUDENT received a verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) of 77, a performance IQ of 70, and a full scale IQ of 70. Each of these scores was in the borderline range of intellectual functioning. STUDENT’s full scale IQ score of 70 was consistent with her Vineland Adaptive Behavior Composite score of 74, and both scores were in the borderline range of cognitive functioning.(Footnote 5)
On December 18, 1998, the IEP team met for the first time. The team determined that STUDENT had significant delays in language, motor, and readiness skills with borderline intellectual functioning and was eligible for special education as a learning handicapped student with a disabling condition of developmental delay. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a prekindergarten special day class (SDC) for a minimum of three days a week, up to five days a week, for small group and individual instruction to implement her goals. STUDENT would participate with nondisabled peers five percent of her school day. In addition, the team recommended speech and language for “oral motor skills evaluation and... services” and screening for adapted physical education (APE). Annual goals were written for STUDENT to improve her fine motor skills, to increase her skills for academic readiness, and to improve her verbal and nonverbal communication skills. The parents consented to this IEP. Extended school year (ESY) services 3-5 times a week to “implement goals” were added by the IEP team on February 21, 1999. The parents also consented to this IEP.
Placement in Ms. Stagnaro’s Preschool SDC: January 1999 through June 2001
In January 1999, STUDENT entered Bay View Elementary School’s prekindergarten SDC class taught by District speech pathologist and SDC teacher Phyllis Stagnaro. With the exception of summers, STUDENT remained in this class for two and a half years, until June of 2001. Throughout this period, STUDENT also received speech and language services in the area of oral motor skills from District speech pathologist Paula Fuller. During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT attended the SDC three hours a day, three mornings a week. Beginning in the fall of 1999, STUDENT attended the SDC five days a week with the same services.
During STUDENT’s first year and a half in this class, the SDC staff were concerned about the appropriateness of her placement. Both Ms. Stagnaro and Ms. Fuller observed STUDENT to be at a lower instructional and developmental level than the other students in this class. Although STUDENT had received cognitive scores in the borderline range, Ms. Stagnaro was concerned that she had been unable to complete many of the WPPSI-R subtests and her performance in class was low.(Footnote 6) In late May or June 1999, Ms. Stagnaro informally requested permission for additional cognitive testing of STUDENT. Concerned that new testing would negatively impact STUDENT’s placement, the parents denied consent to test. The request for additional testing was renewed in the fall of 1999 and again denied.
At the March 2, 2000 IEP annual review, the IEP team discussed whether Ms. Stagnaro’s SDC was an appropriate placement for STUDENT. At Ms. Stagnaro’s invitation, County Office of Education (COE) case manager Ms. Hogan attended the meeting to provide the IEP team with information about COE placements. At the conclusion of the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s placement remained unchanged, with continuing speech therapy and a new service of adapted physical education (APE). The parents agreed to visit several COE placements with Ms. Hogan. They also requested independent educational evaluations in various areas, including psychological testing for IQ and development and comprehensive neuropsychological testing, that they believed essential before a reasoned placement decision could be made for STUDENT. The parents consented to a psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT by a District school psychologist; however, to avoid prejudgment of STUDENT’s capabilities, the parents insisted that the psychologist not review any prior testing or discuss STUDENT with staff.
Dr. Sheila Coonerty conducted this assessment and administered several subtests of the Differential Abilities Scale, Preschool Level [DAS], a test that is less dependent upon language. STUDENT received borderline range scores in verbal comprehension, visual-spatial reasoning, and recognition vocabulary. Her expressive language score was in the mildly mentally retarded range, at the first percentile. Her overall nonverbal composite score was in the borderline range of functioning. Dr. Coonerty determined that STUDENT was clinically in the 68 to 72 IQ range of functioning. Dr. Coonerty made several key observations and recommendations for STUDENT. First, she observed that STUDENT had a very high degree of resistance to learning and a behavioral habit of walking away from challenging tasks. When Dr. Coonerty pursued her, STUDENT was able to complete tasks. Second, she observed the parents to be overwhelmed with STUDENT’s successful oppositional behaviors at home. Given STUDENT’s young age and her solidly borderline scores, Dr. Coonerty recommended that STUDENT be exposed to a year of intensive language services to determine if her expressive speech would increase. This “planned flooding” of language was recommended to occur both at school and at home. Due to STUDENT’s attentional issues, she required brief exposure to services throughout the day. Dr. Coonerty recommended that the best way to implement this planned flooding would be to train STUDENT’s parents to respond to her behavior so that they would be able to help STUDENT in her efforts to increase expressive language.
On May 31, 2000, the IEP team again met and reviewed Dr. Coonerty’s report and recommendations. The team determined that STUDENT should remain placed in Ms. Stagnaro’s class for the 2000-2001 school year unless the parents decided otherwise. The parents later advised Ms. Stagnaro that they did not want a County placement. The IEP team increased STUDENT’s DIS speech services from two to three times a week and specified that this was for “instruction in expressive language.” OT services to address STUDENT’s fine motor deficits were offered for the first time and were to commence in September 2000. Following the IEP meeting, the parents had STUDENT assessed by three independent assessors: by Dr. Jacknow, a develop-mental pediatrician, by Dr. Goldman, a psychologist, and by Ms. Gault, a speech therapist.
In September 2000, STUDENT returned to Ms. Stagnaro’s class for her final year. Her placement remained substantially the same except that she began attending Nancy Boehm’s SDC kindergarten movement education class for thirty to forty minutes each morning during her free play time. She also began to receive OT services from Ms. Siegler. The parents requested an IEP meeting and asked the District to authorize ten hours a week of behavioral therapy services focused on motivating STUDENT’s language use and decreasing her aggressive behaviors. In response to this request, District school psychologist Ms. Paulsen began conducting observations of STUDENT in her placement.
On October 2, 2000, the IEP team met in response to the parent’s request. At Ms. PARENT’s suggestion, the District agreed to refer STUDENT for an evaluation at home and school by the California Diagnostic Center. The IEP team also authorized the development of a short-term behavioral program, consistent between home and school, by Ms. Paulsen. The behavior plan was to be reviewed at the December IEP meeting. The IEP team decreased STUDENT’s speech and language services to twice a week. The parents did not sign this IEP addendum and ultimately declined the assessment by the Diagnostic Center.
From October 30 to November 3, 2000, the parents and STUDENT attended an intensive parent education program they discovered independently and that was not sponsored by the District. The program was at the Autism Research and Training Center (ARTC) at the University of California, Santa Barbara campus. Although STUDENT is not autistic, the program was reported to be effective for students with developmental and language delays. The purpose of the training was to teach the parents procedures to work with STUDENT throughout the day to improve her social communication with others with a goal of increasing her “use of spontaneous (unprompted) expressive words and to expand her use of word combinations.” A report prepared after the training by clinical director Dr. Lynn Kern Koegel recommended that Pivotal Response Training (PRT) motivational techniques continue to be used with STUDENT across home, school and community settings and that they be implemented by a one-to-one aide trained in applied behavioral analysis/PRT to provide STUDENT with “opportunities to use expressive language several times per minute.” Dr. Koegel also recommended that a “functional assessment” be conducted to determine the function of STUDENT’s problem behaviors in her social interactions with peers and that appropriate replacement behaviors be taught to her.
At STUDENT’s December 18, 2000 IEP annual review meeting, the parents brought the team information about their PRT training and requested an intensive behavior therapy program for STUDENT using PRT with a one-to-one aide for ten hours a week. For the first time, the IEP document acknowledged that STUDENT’s behavior was a special factor that impeded her learning and/or the learning of others. The IEP team adopted the Behavior Support Plan (BSP) prepared by Ms. Paulsen which addressed STUDENT’s behavior of “hitting, pushing, flailing of arms,” as well as new goals for STUDENT to address her attention to task and her use of picture icons to support verbalization. The BSP used icons to teach STUDENT “no hitting” and employed verbal praise of “STUDENT, you are a good friend.” The IEP document provided that, in addition to her current services, STUDENT was to receive “individual instruction - playground from an instructional technician” and “behavior specialist - followup and training.” An additional aide was to be hired as soon as possible to supervise STUDENT during unstructured time and various class activities. Ms. Paulsen’s notes from the IEP meeting indicated that Dr. Wilma Poage, the District’s then-director of special education, “will go over report and recommendations by [U.C.]S.B.... An addendum will be signed after consultation from Santa Barbara.” Believing that the District agreed to provide a PRT program for STUDENT, the parents consented to this IEP. This was the last IEP signed by the parents.
On May 8, 2001, the Hearing Office received STUDENT’s request for a due process hearing, in which she requested an intensive 30-40 hour program using applied behavioral analysis/PRT techniques, across home and school environments, to meet her needs. On May 22, 2001, the case was taken off calendar by agreement of the parties while the parties engaged in mediation.
On June 6, 2001, the IEP team met at the parents’ request to address concerns about STUDENT’s delay in expressive language and slow rate of progress. The parents requested more “home-school strategies for increasing spontaneous language, appropriate summer school program, summer activity ideas.” The IEP team again acknowledged that STUDENT’s behavior impeded her learning and/or that of others and indicated that “parent/teacher collaboration will occur one time per week. Staff training for teacher and staff provided by district.” STUDENT was offered placement in a prekindergarten SDC class for the 2001-2002 school year with sixty minutes a week of speech therapy, twice weekly APE services, and weekly and monthly direct and consultative OT services. STUDENT was also offered sixty minutes of individualized activities after school; however, the parents never consented to this additional service.
Placement in Ms. Boehm’s Kindergarten SDC: 2001-2002 School Year
In September 2001, STUDENT began kindergarten in Nancy Boehm’s SDC class at Bay View Elementary. Her services remained the same except that speech services began in October and were provided by speech pathologist Linda Fleming, an independent contractor. Although the parents did not sign the IEP, they verbally agreed to the placement and DIS services. In late November 2001, the parents were provided with two assessment plans by Ms. Boehm in preparation for STUDENT’s triennial review. PARENT initially declined consent; however, the following day, Ms. PARENT consented to an assessment of STUDENT by the school nurse, the OT specialist, and in the areas of pre-academic achievement. She “waived testing” for STUDENT in the areas of personal and social adjustment (Vineland), cognitive/intellectual development, and language, speech and communication development.
From November 26 through November 29, 2001, the District provided an intensive training in PRT methods to its special education staff, including Ms. Boehm, her two teaching aides Rosalie and Kim, and STUDENT’s parents. The training was provided by U.C.S.B. doctoral level graduate student Jenny Symon, who lectured about PRT and provided hands-on modeling of of specific techniques with STUDENT. On December 10, 2001, a report prepared by Dr. Koegel and Ms. Symon regarding the PRT training reiterated their recommendation that STUDENT be provided PRT techniques to increase her language and decrease her behavior problems.
On January 28, 2002, STUDENT’s triennial review IEP meeting was held without STUDENT’s parents in attendance. Present at the meeting were Dr. Poage, Ms. Boehm, Ms. Siegler, Ms. Fleming, Ms. Paulsen, and another SDC teacher, Ms. Bouett. The IEP was annotated as follows: “Parents indicated by phone 1-28-02 that they would not attend an IEP meeting until the issue of PRT is resolved.” The IEP team increased STUDENT’s time for participation in the mainstream to fifteen percent. The team also determined that STUDENT’s behavior was not a special factor because it did not impede her learning or that of others and that she had “met all goals and her behavior plan of last year.” STUDENT’s special education program and services continued, except that occupational therapy was decreased to direct and consultative service once a week for 30 minutes. The IEP team indicated that, while STUDENT would remain in the SDC kindergarten until the end of the school year, she was six years old and eligible for a first grade school day. As a result, the team indicated that there would be a transition plan to a first grade SDC to start February 2002, four days a week for two hours (12:20 p.m. to 2:20 p.m.) for communication and social skills. Several new goals were written for STUDENT at this IEP meeting, including academic goals in math, reading, and language pursuant to kindergarten curriculum performance standards.
After the triennial IEP meeting, the parties again participated in mediation and agreed to convene another IEP meeting. On March 20, 2002, the IEP team was convened with the parents and Dr. Koegel in attendance. Parental concerns discussed were improving STUDENT’s expressive language, especially her social communication with regular education peers. The IEP team adopted ten parent-drafted goals for STUDENT in expressive language, social communication and toileting. The IEP team indicated that a positive behavioral intervention plan was to be developed and that STUDENT “will have a behavior support plan developed for parent goals and objectives #9 & #10.” The IEP documented that STUDENT’s program would expand by adding an afternoon general education kindergarten from 11:45 a.m. to 2:20 p.m. “with an assistant” four days a week and that Ms. Boehm would arrange a transition time to prepare STUDENT for the regular education kindergarten. Goals and objectives from the January 28, 2002 IEP meeting would continue. The IEP document also indicated “planning for 2002-2003 placement: SDC-primary grade with mainstream time into 1st grade gen. ed. class.”
STUDENT and the District subsequently disputed what was offered at this IEP meeting. On March 29, 2002, the parents provided the District with an addendum to the IEP, in which they consented to some services, including the offer of a one-to-one assistant/aide during regular kindergarten, and requested clarification of services they believed had been offered. They agreed to the implementation of “a functional behavior assessment and behavior intervention plan [BIP], as identified on the IEP dated March 20, 2002.” The District replied to this addendum with two letters, in April and May 2002, outlining its offer for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year, for the extended school year 2002, and for the 2002-2003 school year. The District indicated that it offered an additional aide to the classroom, not a one-to-one aide for STUDENT, and that it offered to prepare a behavior support plan, not to conduct a functional behavior assessment.
On June 3, 2002, Student requested that the case be placed back on calendar for a due process hearing. In addition, the Student submitted a motion for stay put and specifically requested that the stay put order include the disputed services. The stay put motion was opposed by the District as seeking an order for services it had never offered STUDENT.
On June 17, 2002, the Hearing Office issued an order granting STUDENT’s motion for stay put in part and denying it in part. The Hearing Office determined that STUDENT had conceded that the parties had not agreed to or implemented terms relating to a proposed transition plan, transition services, a behavior management plan, a functional analysis assessment, goals and objectives, and one-to-one assistant. The following placement outlined in the March 20, 2002 IEP document was ordered as the stay put placement: STUDENT was to remain placed in a kindergarten special day class, with speech and language services and APE services two times per week each for thirty minutes a session, and OT therapy consultation and direct services for once a month each, for 60 minute sessions.
On June 10, 2002, the District filed an independent request for a due process hearing, seeking a determination that it had offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment from 1998 through the 2002-2003 school and extended school year.
On June 18, 2002, the Hearing Office ordered the cases consolidated. The 2002-2003 school year began during the due process hearing. STUDENT was placed in a combined first through third grade SDC at the District’s De La Viega Elementary School.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). The term includes parent counseling and training. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22), 34 C.F.R. § 300.24 (a), Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(11). Education Code § 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. De minimus benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2nd Cir. 1997). The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.
The IDEA also provides that “to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A), 34 C.F.R. § 300.550. See also Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit; (3) have comported with her IEP; and (4) have been provided in the least restrictive environment. Because there is no contentionn in this case that the program did not comport with STUDENT’s IEPs, it is not necessary to address this element.
I. DID THE DISTRICT DENY STUDENT A FAPE DURING THE 1998-1999
SCHOOL YEAR?
1. Was the District’s Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
a. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
To determine whether the program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1998-1999 year, the Hearing Officer must first determine what those needs were. The evidence was undisputed regarding STUDENT’s strengths. STUDENT was and is a very social child, who was described by Ms. Stagnaro as being receptively “enthralled” with her peers. She had good eye contact and attempted to initiate contact with peers by touch. She was keenly attuned to the presence of others. According to Ms. Fuller, STUDENT was generally the student in class who acknowledged Ms. Fuller’s presence and tried to show others that she was there. She was generally happy, affectionate, and loved physical movement.
STUDENT’s unique needs upon her entry into the District in January 1999 were detailed in her initial assessments, conducted in late 1998 in preparation for her initial IEP meeting, and were described in the testimony of various witnesses. The parties agree that STUDENT’s skills for academic readiness were significantly delayed and that she had unique needs in pre-academic skills as demonstrated by her borderline range of cognition on both the WPPSI-R and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Composite. For example, she was interested in books but not able to listen to a complete story, did not turn an upside-down book right-side-up, did not respond to questions about the story, did not match colors or shapes, had no number concepts, and had delayed short-term auditory skills. There was also no dispute that STUDENT’s needs in this area included needs to improve her school readiness and attention to task. According to Ms. Fuller, STUDENT had a very limited attention span of two to three minutes. She could not transition from one activity to another by herself but needed to be escorted by an adult. Ms. Stagnaro testified that during this school year, STUDENT seemed “very young” to her. She frequently called for “mommy,” cried and sucked her thumb, and wanted to be held and rocked, often by one of the aides. STUDENT was continually tired and often lay down or curled up in an adult’s arms.
The parties also agree that STUDENT had unique needs in both expressive and receptive language skills. In a language development survey completed for STUDENT’s initial assessment, the parents indicated that STUDENT had a receptive vocabulary of approximately 210 words and an expressive vocabulary of approximately 46 words, which she did not combine into phrases. She spoke in one-word utterances. The Preschool Language Scale (PLS-3) revealed a one-year delay in receptive communication skills and a delay of nearly two years in expressive communication. While the parties agree on STUDENT’s unique needs in pre-academics as well as in expressive and receptive language, STUDENT contends that she had additional unique needs identified in her initial assessments that the District failed to address. Specifically, she contends she had unique needs in oral-motor skills, behavior, social communication (peer interaction), fine and gross motor skills, and self-help skills. In its closing brief, the District did not address any of these areas of asserted need but argued that STUDENT’s fundamental area of need was/is in “developmental delays in cognitive skills.”
Unique Needs in Oral-Motor and Articulation Skills
The evidence established that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of oral-motor and articulation skills. In December 1998, District speech pathologist Ms. Baker reported that she was not able to fully explore STUDENT’s full oral-motor capabilities due to her resistance. Ms. Baker recommended that further oral-motor assessment be completed when STUDENT “becomes comfortable in the learning environment.” District speech therapist Paula Fuller, who worked with STUDENT from January 1999 to June 2001, reported that when STUDENT first began in the class, she was in a sensory exploration period consistent with an 18- to 20-month-old developmental level. During this period, a child defines her mouth and becomes familiar with what it feels like to move her lips, teeth and tongue, a familiarity that is necessary to the production of intelligible words. In addition to mouthing objects, STUDENT habitually sucked her thumb, which can create a dysfunctional tongue pattern and inappropriate lip closure. Ms. Fuller testified that these factors indicated that STUDENT had oral-motor needs that should be addressed. STUDENT also had articulation needs. Many of STUDENT’s 46 expressive words were “approximations” or words that had one or two accurate phonemes, did not match the targeted word, but could be functionally understood by familiar peers or adults.
Unique Behavioral Needs
The evidence persuasively established that STUDENT had unique behavioral needs during the 1998-1999 school year that were manifested by resistant and aggressive acts, and inappropriate touching behaviors. STUDENT’s resistant behaviors were noted by school psychologist Ms. Bennett during her initial assessment. STUDENT was alert and curious, but lost focus on tasks that were difficult or not intrinsically interesting to her. “STUDENT appeared to have difficulty tolerating frustration, wanting to get away, quickly, from the frustrating situation or wanting to change the activity.” From her observation, Ms. Bennett advised that “impulsivity and frustration tolerance may be areas of behavior to be addressed.” STUDENT’s aggressive behavior was noted by Ms.Stagnaro in her March 2000 report, in which she indicated that, from January to June 1999, STUDENT “became aggressive with peers (hitting, pushing, grabbing, choking) when seemingly over aroused by an activity level or the number of peers.” STUDENT’s inappropriate touching behavior stemmed from her desire for social contact with her peers. She frequently hugged and kissed peers who came in close proximity to her. According to Ms. Stagnaro, STUDENT did not understand that this was inappropriate, or that students did not generally like this behavior.
Unique Needs in Social Communication/Peer Interaction
The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT had unique needs in social communication and peer interactions that were intertwined with her expressive language deficits and her aggressive or inappropriate behavior. When Ms. Baker assessed STUDENT’s communicative skills, she noted that STUDENT was very social and enjoyed watching and imitating the play of other children. She also observed that STUDENT’s “lack of expressive language presents a barrier to full inclusion in their play, however.”
While STUDENT’s expressive language delays were apparent to the IEP team at the December 1998 IEP meeting, her social communication needs did not become apparent until the last months of the 1998-1999 school year. Both Ms. Stagnaro and Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT was not able to spontaneously initiate peer interactions or play but needed to be facilitated. On her own, STUDENT engaged in parallel play. Ms. Fuller testified that STUDENT was not using a functional approach to her environment and that her play skills were commensurate with her language skills, in the 18- to 20-month range. Ms. Stagnaro testified that she eventually became concerned about STUDENT’s behavior because she “spent a lot of time not interacting with peers” in the SDC class. In June 1999, she discussed these concerns with STUDENT’s parents as a factor in her overall concern about the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in her class.
Unique Needs in Fine and Gross Motor Skills
The weight of the evidence also established that STUDENT had unique needs in fine and gross motor skills, that were first recognized in her initial referral for assessment. The referral indicated that an occupational therapy and/or an adapted physical education evaluation “may be warranted.” In her assessment, Ms. Baker also noted that STUDENT may have some delays in fine and gross motor areas. STUDENT’s fine motor skills as measured on the December 1998 Brigance were at the two-year-old age equivalent in pre-handwriting and cutting with scissors skills. STUDENT was reported to have no scissor skills, held a pencil incorrectly in her left hand and was unable to copy any of the lines or shapes. According to the Vineland, STUDENT’s fine motor skills were at the 2.8 age equivalent. These scores indicated a fine motor delay of from eight months to 1.4 years. STUDENT’s gross motor skills were also delayed nine months, according to the Vineland completed by the parents. While STUDENT was observed to have little fear of undertaking physical activities such as climbing, her gait when running was reported to “appear immature.”
Unique Self-Help Needs
The evidence established that STUDENT had unique self-help needs in the area of toilet training. STUDENT wore diapers to school from January 1999 when she began Ms. Stagnaro’s class until late 2000, and did not initiate toileting. Evidence also indicates that STUDENT had needs in the area of feeding skills. Due to her extreme oral sensory seeking behavior, STUDENT would stuff food into her mouth beyond its capacity. Ms. PARENT testified that this raised a concern about possible choking.
* * * In summary, the parties agreed that STUDENT had unique needs in pre-academic skills and expressive and receptive language. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony and/or assessments of District staff supports The Student’s contention that she had additional unique needs. From the evidence outlined above, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT had unique needs in pre-academic skills (including school readiness and attention), in expressive and receptive language, in oral-motor and articulation skills, behavior, social communication/peer interaction, fine and gross motor skills, and self-help skills.
b. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
The Hearing Officer must now determine whether the program offered to STUDENT was designed to meet her unique needs identified above. The December 18, 2000 IEP offered STUDENT a placement in an SDC class with twice weekly speech therapy services. As previously discussed, STUDENT attended Ms. Stagnaro’s preschool special day class from January 1999 through June 2001. The evidence was undisputed that, in addition to her credential and experience as a special day class teacher, Ms. Stagnaro is a speech pathologist. Speech therapist Paula Fuller, who provided STUDENT with her DIS speech and language therapy twice a week for twenty minutes a session, is also a speech pathologist with experience in public schools and private practice. The SDC class was described as a “language rich environment.” During the 1998-1999 school year, two aides were in the SDC class, for an adult-to-student ratio of 1:5. Ms. Stagnaro described her preschool class as similar to, but more structured than, other preschool classrooms. Activities included circle time, table jobs involving multiple materials to maintain interest (calendar, weather, grocery store), and free time. During adult-directed activities, the staff would address receptive language with real items and use natural or intrinsic rewards (e.g., teach sweet and sour with real food items). Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT’s five percent participation with non- disabled peers (‘mainstreaming’) involved using the school bathrooms with other children and attending assemblies if she determined they were appropriate.
STUDENT attended the SDC for a total of nine instructional hours three mornings a weekduring the 1998-1999 school year. At the hearing, Ms. Stagnaro explained her language development strategy for STUDENT during this school year. Because receptive language is a foundational skill for expressive language, Ms. Stagnaro focused on developing STUDENT’s expressive language by developing her receptive language. Ms. Stagnaro testified that she did not have high expectations for STUDENT’s verbal language during this school year as a result of her separation issues and her need to become accustomed to class routines. Ms. Stagnaro testified that the SDC program included methods to reinforce expressive language. For example, staff always responded positively when STUDENT used expressive language. If she used an approximation that could not be understood, the classroom staff would try to find an adult who understood what she was saying in order to build trust and to naturally reinforce the use of language.
The evidence established that STUDENT’s parents believed Ms. Stagnaro’s SDC to be the appropriate placement for her during the 1998-1999 school year and that they were alarmed when the potential of a more restrictive placement was discussed. The Student argues that the program during the 1998-1999 school year was not designed to meet her unique needs for two reasons. First, she asserts that the goals and objectives contained in the December 1998 IEP did not address all of her unique needs and that those that were written were not measurable. Second,she asserts that the program failed to meet her unique fine and gross motor needs because assessments recommended in the areas of occupational therapy and adapted physical education were not conducted and those related services were not offered.
Goals and Objectives
Pursuant to the IDEA and federal regulations, the IEP for each child with a disability must include a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance. For preschool children like STUDENT, the present levels must include, “as appropriate, how the disability affects the child’s participation in appropriate activities....” The IEP must also include a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to “meeting the child’s needs that result from the child’s disability to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum; and meeting each of the child’s other educational needs that result from the child’s disability.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i),(ii). The student’s program must be designed to help him to “advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals” and to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with other disabled and typically developing peers. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).
1. Did the goals address all of STUDENT’s unique needs?
STUDENT’s annual goals from her initial IEP were “to improve her fine motor skills,” “to increase skills for academic readiness,” and “to improve her verbal and non-verbal communication skills.” The IEP team did not prepare goals and objectives for STUDENT in all her areas of unique need as enumerated above. There was no specific goal for oral-motor,articulation, behavior, social communication (peer interaction), gross motor skills, or self-help skills. Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT’s initial assessments indicated she had many needs. In her opinion, the initial IEP team picked STUDENT’s top priority needs and wrote annual goals to address those needs. Associate professor of special education Dr. Paula Gardner agreed that goals can be developed to address areas of high priority and that an IEP team may decide to concentrate on specific areas before addressing other areas.
The Hearing Officer finds that, during the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT did not require a distinct goal to address her unique needs in the areas of oral-motor, articulation and self-help for feeding skills. In this regard, the Hearing Officer relies on Ms. Fuller’s testimony that STUDENT’s communication goal, and specifically the short-term objective to “produce spontaneous vocalization /verbalization w/accompanying gesture to indicate wants and needs,” encompassed foundational skills such as oral-motor skills, articulation, and self-help feeding skills and that Ms.Fuller addressed these areas of need with STUDENT. Ms. Fuller’s testimony is supported by her March 2000 report, which detailed STUDENT’s needs and progress in these three areas, from January 1999 through March 2000.
The Hearing Officer also finds that at the time the IEP was developed, it was not necessary to prepare a goal to address STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s behavioral needs were not apparent to the IEP team at the time of the initial IEP meeting, but became apparent to the SDC staff over time after she entered the class. Ms. Stagnaro’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s overall demeanor in the SDC class during this time period persuasively established that her needs in the area of behavior were overshadowed by her intense separation issues and ongoing need to be comforted while in the classroom. In addition, as recognized by Dr. Gardner, the fact that a goal is not written in a particular area does not mean that it is not being addressed. Ms. Stagnaro testified that her SDC class has a behavior management component and that behavior management is integrated into the entire day. The primary focus of this component is to address individual student behavior and modify it using natural and logical consequences and reinforcement. Because this was STUDENT’s first entry to the District’s SDC, it was reasonable for Ms. Stagnaro to attempt to address STUDENT’s negative behaviors within the existing class behavior management component. Accordingly, the failure to convene an IEP meeting to develop a behavior goal for STUDENT does not mean that the program was not designed to address her unique needs. Whether it was reasonable to continue in this manner the following year is addressed below.
Similarly, the Hearing Officer finds that lack of a specific goal in social communication does not result in a finding that the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. During her initial assessments, one of STUDENT’s consistently noted strengths was her social nature. STUDENT’s primary need was to increase her expressive language, a skill that could reasonably be expected to increase her ability to communicate with her peers. This need was being addressed in her communication goal. STUDENT’s specific needs in this area were not apparent to Ms. Stagnaro until late in the year, when she discussed the issue with the parents. The failure to convene an IEP meeting to develop a specific goal for STUDENT in social communication/peer interaction does not mean that the program was not designed to address her unique needs. Particularly in the case of a preschooler who is initially entering the District’s program, District staff must be provided with a reasonable opportunity to work with the student and to reassess if more specific needs should be addressed in an annual goal.
Accordingly, for the reasons set forth above, the lack of specific goals in the areas of oral motor, articulation, feeding skills, behavior and social communication does not mandate a finding that the program during the 1998-1999 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
2. Were the goals and objectives measurable?
As previously discussed, STUDENT’s three annual goals from the December 1998 IEP were “to improve her fine motor skills,” “to increase skills for academic readiness,” and “to improve her verbal and non-verbal communication skills.” STUDENT’s present levels of performance in these areas were described in her initial assessments. Dr. Gardner testified that STUDENT’s general goals “to improve” or “to increase” skills were not measurable because they did not specify with any degree of clarity the behavior required of STUDENT, the conditions for observing her performance, or the criteria for acceptable performance.
In determining the degree of measurability required, the Hearing Officer considers the fact that the annual goals were written for a student entering preschool, which does not have a prescribed general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i),(ii). In addition, while the annual goals are general, STUDENT’s short-term objectives for each of these annual goals provided a context within which to measure STUDENT’s progress. In fine motor skills, STUDENT’s short-term objectives were to copy vertical and horizontal lines, to draw “somewhat recognizable pictures,” and to hold scissors correctly and cut a five inch piece of paper in two. In pre-academic readiness, STUDENT’s short-term objectives were to “describe actions depicted in pictures,” to answer yes or no questions about books read to her, to “match like pictures with 80% accuracy,” and to “count out 1-3 objects from a group of 6 objects in random order as directed.” In communication skills, STUDENT’s short-term objectives were to “produce spontaneous vocalization/verbalization w/accompanying gesture to indicate wants/needs,” to “have significant adult and children in her life on request,” to “use words (and signs, if appropriate) to indicate possession, attributes (hot, dirty) and movement/location (up, all gone),” to “match like objects and pictures w/ 90% accuracy,” to “increase receptive vocabulary by at least 150 words,” and to increase expressive vocabulary by at least 100 words.”
The Hearing Officer finds that the short-term objectives provide a reasonable basis for measuring whether STUDENT was progressing in appropriate preschool activities as described by her annual goals. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s annual goals in the December 1998 IEP were measurable. As a consequence, there is no basis for finding that the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs on this ground.
Fine and Gross Motor Needs
The District must assess students “in all areas related to the suspected disability...” Cal. Educ. § 56320(f). The Student contends that the program was not designed to meet her fine or gross motor needs because the District failed to conduct full assessments in these areas and to offer appropriate DIS related services in the areas of occupational therapy and adapted physical education. The undisputed evidence established that OT and/or APE assessments were recommended in October 1998 during STUDENT’s referral for special education assessment due to her delays in fine and gross motor skills, and that an APE screening was again recommended at the December 18, 1998 IEP. Nonetheless, STUDENT was not assessed by the APE specialist, Ms. Choate, until March 2000, or by the OT specialist, Ms. Siegler, until May 2000. Both Ms. Choate and Ms. Siegler testified that they had never seen STUDENT’s initial referral for assessment and that, in their opinion, STUDENT would have been eligible for APE and OT services to address her gross and fine motor needs duringg the 1998-1999 school year. In addition, Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT would have benefitted from occupational therapy to improve her fine motor skills during the 1998-1999 school year. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s gross motor/APE needs for approximately fifteen months and her fine motor/OT needs for approximately eighteen months and failed to provide her with necessary services to benefit from her educational program. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1998-1999 school year, the SDC program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique fine and gross motor needs.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1998-1999 school year, except for her fine and gross motor needs.
2. Was the Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit?
The Ninth Circuit has rejected a hindsight analysis to determine whether a program was reasonably calculated to provide a student with some educational benefit. Adams v. Oregon (Ninth Cir. 1999) 195 F.3d 1141. In Adams, the court determined that the appropriate inquiry is whether the IEP’s goals and goal achieving methods were reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit at the time the IEP was written. STUDENT’s placement in a language rich SDC class with an experienced SDC teacher and speech pathologist was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit in her areas of need, particularly in the area of communication and pre-academic skills. Her speech services with an experienced speech pathologist were reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit in oral motor, articulation, and self-help feeding skills. The evidence also established that during STUDENT’s first six months in the SDC class, one of her primary needs was in pre-academic school readiness due to her intense separation issues from her mother. The staff observed STUDENT spend a significant amount of time mournfully calling for her mother, crying, and needing to be held. Ms. Stagnaro testified that this separation phase was lengthy; however, by June 1999, STUDENT was able to go into the playhouse and functionally participate. It is apparent that STUDENT received educational benefit in this important pre-academic/school readiness skill. From the totality of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC placement with DIS speech services was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit during the 1998-1999 school year.
3. Was the SDC Placement the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT?
Special education law requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which means ensuring that her education is provided in a manner that promotes her maximum interaction with children who are not disabled, and that is appropriate to the needs of both. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III), Calif. Educ. Code § 56031. The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45. The Student argues that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to discuss mainstreaming opportunities with the parents, failing to place her in the least restrictive environment, by failing to have a general education instructor at the IEP meeting, and by failing to draft goals and objectives to facilitate inclusion in a regular education setting. These arguments are not persuasive.
The Hearing Officer finds that placement in Ms. Stagnaro’s preschool SDC class was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year. The weight of the evidence established that STUDENT was at a lower instructional range than other students in the class, that she experienced intense separation issues relating to being away from her mother, that she was very resistant to direct instruction, and had difficulty attending for any length of time. As indicated above, the requirements for placement in the least restrictive environment and for the participation of a regular education teacher at an IEP meeting are each tempered by the notion of appropriateness. In light of Ms. Stagnaro’s years of experience and personal experience with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds her testimony persuasive that the SDC was the least restrictive placement for STUDENT. The great weight of the evidence established that STUDENT would not have been appropriately placed in a regular education classroom. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District successfully rebutted the presumption that STUDENT be placed in a regular education setting. Furthermore, while both Dr. Koegel and Dr. Gardner testified that STUDENT was a good candidate for full inclusion during preschool, neither had any personal or professional knowledge of STUDENT’s needs and behavior during this time period. Finally, because the SDC was the least restrictive environment, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District was not obligated to have a regular education teacher present at the IEP meeting or to draft goals and objectives to facilitate inclusion in a regular education environment. * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that during the 1998-1999 school year, the SDC was substantially designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. Accordingly, except to the limited extent that it did not address her unique fine and gross motor needs by providing her with OT or APE services, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the SDC was the least restrictive placement for STUDENT.
4. Did the District Deny STUDENT a Fape During the 1999 Extended School Year?
ESY programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F. 3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R.§ 300.309(b). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner: Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil's educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii).
STUDENT was determined to be eligible for extended school year services at the February 21, 1999 IEP with the notation that it was “to implement her goals.” There was no indication on the IEP document, however, that DIS speech services would be provided. None of the District’s staff who testified at the hearing was involved in the provision of ESY services to STUDENT or had any knowledge of the ESY teaching staff, including whether the ESY was taught by a speech pathologist or whether DIS speech and language services were provided to STUDENT during the 1999 ESY. In addition, STUDENT required OT services to address her fine motor deficits and APE services to address her gross motor deficits. Given STUDENT’s severe language, articulation and fine motor delays, speech therapy and OT services during this period were necessary to avoid regression. At the administrative hearing, the school district has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered an appropriate educational placement for the child. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). The Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to carry its burden of proof regarding the provision of ESY services to STUDENT for the 1998-1999 extended school year. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for ESY 1999.
II. DID THE DISTRICT DENY STUDENT A FAPE DURING THE 1999-2000
SCHOOL YEAR?
STUDENT returned to Ms. Stagnaro’s class in the fall of 1999, one month after her fourth birthday. She began attending four mornings a week, and quickly increased her participation to five days a week. STUDENT continued to receive twice weekly speech services from Ms. Fuller. Her program remained unchanged until the annual review IEP meeting on March 1, 2000, that focused on the appropriateness of her placement. At its conclusion, STUDENT’s placement in the SDC, her mainstream component, her speech services, and her eligibility for ESY services remained unchanged. APE services twice a week for twenty minute sessions were offered. The IEP indicated that STUDENT’s behavior did not impede her learning or the learning of others. New goals were developed for STUDENT in the areas of gross motor skills, articulation, self-help, pre-academics, fine motor, and communication. The parents consented to the IEP. Following Dr. Coonerty’s psycho-educational evaluation, on May 31, 2000, the IEP team resolved the placement issue in favor of continuing STUDENT in Ms. Stagnaro’s class. The IEP team added occupational therapy (OT) services to address STUDENT’s fine motor needs beginning in September 2000.
1. Was the District’s Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
a. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs remained substantially similar during the 1999-2000 year to those of the 1998-1999 school year. For example, in the area of expressive language, STUDENT remained primarily a nonverbal child, who had begun to use a Picture Exchange Communication System (PECs) program during a limited portion of her school day (snack time) to visually support her expressive language. STUDENT’s needs in the area of social communication and peer interactions continued to manifest themselves. STUDENT frequently seemed unsure of how to play with peers. Ms. Stagnaro reported continuing concerns regarding STUDENT’s frequent withdrawing from self selected play when she lays down and sucks her thumb. STUDENT’s needs in the area of fine motor skills were reinforced when she was evaluated and found eligible in May 2000 for occupational therapy services. As discussed below, however, STUDENT’s behavioral needs intensified and a unique need for consistency across home and school environments to address her behavior and language needs emerged.
Unique Behavioral Needs
STUDENT’s aggressive behavior increased in intensity during the 1999-2000 school year. In March 2000, Ms. Stagnaro described STUDENT’s aggressive behavior as follows: “Present aggressive behavior occurs primarily when she is outside where activity level increases...or inside on occasion when an adult is not close to monitor her interaction (grabs, pokes, squeezes, chokes, hits). Recently, it was documented that an adult needed to intervene eight times during a 90 minute period in order to stop such behavior. She has been observed to grab for a desired object a peer has and then to poke or choke that child.” STUDENT’s initial efforts to obtain or maintain possession of a desired object were always aggressive and she could not take turns without adult assistance.
STUDENT’s resistant and avoidant behavior became more obviously an obstacle to her learning. Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT had made progress in separation from her mother during the 1999-2000 school year; however, she continued to withdraw from activities and suck her thumb. STUDENT’s withdrawal occurred off and on throughout the day, for longer periods of time than Ms. Stagnaro had experienced with other children and added to her concern that the class was too challenging for STUDENT. Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT’s withdrawal would begin by her saying “stop” and generally occurred during adult-directed activities. It also occurred when too many children were in the area and she seemed overwhelmed. When COE’s Ms. Hogan observed STUDENT in class in preparation for the March 2000 IEP, she noted that STUDENT frequently said “no” in response to requests. During her OT evaluation of STUDENT in May of 2000, Ms. Siegler reported that STUDENT consistently refused to perform tasks by saying “no” and walking away. Dr. Coonerty observed the same behavior during her May 2000 observation: STUDENT was willing to be involved with classroom activities, but had a very limited attention span, was quick to use avoidant behavior in situations that placed any demands on her, and appeared anxious during this behavior. Ms. Stagnaro advised Dr. Coonerty that STUDENT was often unwilling to attempt tasks that she felt were difficult and refused when effort to task was required. STUDENT was also extremely resistant to being challenged at home.
Unique Need for Consistency Across Home and School Environments
Dr. Coonerty’s evaluation, as well as the testimony of Ms. Stagnaro and Ms. Fuller, established that STUDENT required language instruction woven throughout her day with brief doses of direct language therapy due to her attentional issues. Dr. Coonerty’s evaluation and testimony also persuasively established that STUDENT had a unique need for consistency in addressing her behavior across home and school environments in order to reach her for expressive language development. In Dr. Coonerty’s opinion, the parents were overwhelmed by STUDENT’s successful oppositional behaviors and needed training and behavioral support in how to work with her. Assistance to the parents was necessary in order for them to help STUDENT address her expressive language needs at home.
STUDENT’s need for assistance with her expressive language development at this time was particularly crucial. As noted by Dr. Coonerty, the year following STUDENT’s evaluation was an important window for “planned [language] flooding” as the brain continues to develop. While STUDENT’s expressive language was scored in the mildly mentally retarded range, she had other skills, including receptive language, solidly in the borderline cognitive range. The brain’s early development of language centers was acknowledged by Ms. Fuller in her testimony that, for typically developing children, the brain has incorporated knowledge of all necessary language patterns and structure by age five. In addition, due to her special needs, STUDENT was simply not amenable to treatment by lengthy individual sessions with the speech therapist. As a consequence, parent training was critical to ensure that she was consistently exposed to language stimulation after her three daily hours at school to develop expressive language. The Hearing Officer gives great weight to Dr. Coonerty’s recommendations and testimony in light of her extensive experience in clinical, academic, and public school settings as well as her knowledge, testing, and observation of STUDENT at home and at school. In addition, Dr. Coonerty’s recommendation was corroborated by Dr. Jacknow and Ms. Gault. 5 C.C.R. § 3082(b).(Footnote 7) For example, Dr. Jacknow concluded that daily one-to-one behavioral therapy was “critical” to help STUDENT “overcome her resistance to functioning in a structured learning environment so that she can benefit from the therapies necessary to help her developmental progress.” Speech pathologist Ms. Galt recommended that the parents receive training in language facilitation strategy to reinforce with STUDENT in the home. From Dr. Coonerty’s evaluation, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had a unique need for consistency across home and school environments that encompassed a need for parental training in how to address behaviors that prevented her from learning. Training for STUDENT’s parents was also consistent with the Legislative findings regarding early education programs--specifically, that special education and related services programs for children with disabilities between the ages of three and five years, in typical environments appropriate for young children, and with active parental involvement, may “significantly reduce the potential impact of any disabling conditions” and “produce substantial gains,” including in the areas of speech and language and psycho-social development. Cal. Educ. Code § 56441.
b. Designed to Meet Unique Needs?
STUDENT’s program during the 1999-2000 school year was substantially the same as that described for the previous year. Ms. Stagnaro testified that she used a narrative language development strategy to motivate STUDENT’s work on her expressive and receptive speech. When STUDENT demonstrated an interest in an activity, an adult would sit next to her and narrate or give words to her activities. Ms. Stagnaro testified that attempts were not made to elicit speech from STUDENT during these times; rather, the focus was on receptive language exposure. She considered narrating as an indirect language stimulation. She also testified that eventually she would require more utterances from STUDENT. For example, she would remove a toy and STUDENT would have to say “want turn” to get it back. A PECs system to visually support expressive language was established in a limited area during class (snack). In addition, Ms. Stagnaro addressed STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors by trying to replace them with expressive language. The “carrier phrase” taught to STUDENT for use in a variety of settings to convey her intent was “my turn.” This phrase was at the core of developing turn-taking skills. In March 2000, Ms. Stagnaro reported that, throughout the 1999-2000 school year, “steps in ‘turn taking’ have been presented, modeled, prompted, and supported throughout the day.” STUDENT would continue to grab or possess a toy or attempt “to poke at a peer’s eyes or ears if ‘me turn’ does not illicit the toy immediately.”
One of the Student’s primary contentions was that the District program failed to appropriately address her behavior problems and that this resulted in a failure to appropriately meet her expressive language needs. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that the program for the 1999-2000 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the IEP did not contain annual goals in social communication and behavior, because the District failed to conduct a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors, and because the District failed to provide parent training necessary to address STUDENT’s need for consistency across home and school environments.
1. Annual Goals
Until March 2000, STUDENT’s annual goals for the 1999-2000 school year were those contained in the December 1998 IEP. As previously discussed, annual goals in the areas of social communication and behavior were not required because STUDENT’s needs in these areas were not apparent to the IEP team at the time of the initial IEP and because it was appropriate for the District to attempt to address these needs within its existing language goals and behavior management component of the SDC program. However, beginning in the fall of 2000, the District had six months of experience with STUDENT and an indication of her responsiveness to the existing program. While it was reasonable in light of all the circumstances for the District to attempt to address STUDENT’s behaviors within the context of the SDC’s behavior management program during her initial six months in the program, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have brought STUDENT’s behavior issues to the attention of the IEP team for discussion and possible revisions of the IEP in the fall of 1999. As indicated in 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(4), the IEP team must revise the IEP “as appropriate” between annual reviews. This was clearly such a case. Given the observations of the SDC staff and their concerns regarding STUDENT’s behaviors and her ability to relate to peers, the Hearing Officer finds that an IEP team meeting should have been convened in the fall of 1999 to address those needs and to prepare annual goals in these areas.
2. Behavioral Goal and Functional Analysis Assessment
Pursuant to the IDEA and implementing federal regulations, a child’s behavior is among the special factors an IEP team must consider in developing the IEP. Specifically, “in the case of a child whose behavior impedes his or her learning or that of others, [the IEP team must] consider, when appropriate, strategies, including positive behavioral interventions, strategies, and supports to address that behavior....” 20 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(1). If, in considering these special factors, “the IEP team determines that a child needs a particular device or service (including an intervention, accommodation, or other program modification), in order for the child to receive FAPE, the IEP team must include a statement to that effect in the child’s IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(c).
In 1990, California passed Education Code § 56520, et seq., which is commonly known as the Hughes Bill. Regulations implementing the Hughes Bill are contained in Title 5, California Code of Regulations §§ 3001 and 3052. Pursuant to the Hughes Bill, a functional analysis assessment (FAA) forms the basis for a “behavior intervention plan,” which is defined as “a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” C.C.R. §§ 3052(a)(3), 3001, (h). The regulations define serious behavior problems as “behaviors which are self-injurious, assaultive, or cause serious property damage and other severe behavior problems that are pervasive and maladaptive for which instructional/behavioral approaches specified in the student’s IEP are found to be ineffective.” 5 C.C.R. §§ 3001(ah) and 3052(b). When members of the student’s IEP team find that the instructional or behavioral approaches specified in the IEP have been ineffective, an FAA must be conducted. 5 C.C.R. § 3052(a)(6)(b). One of the consequences of failing to convene an IEP meeting in the fall of 1999 to address STUDENT’s behavior problems was that the IEP team did not have an opportunity to review and consider appropriate instructional or behavioral approaches for STUDENT, such as by the development of a specific behavior goal.
The Student argues that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to conduct an FAA of her behavior during any of the years at issue despite her history of aggressive behaviors toward her peers. The District contends that STUDENT’s behaviors were not “serious behavior problems” that would require it to conduct an FAA within the meaning of the Hughes Bill. In addition, District staff testified that STUDENT’s behaviors were never maliciously intended and did not result in injury to anyone. For example, Ms. Stagnaro testified that during the choking incident, STUDENT did not appear enraged and an adult quickly intervened to prevent harm. Ms. Stagnaro testified that STUDENT was more likely to kick than to choke a peer. Ms. Siegler observed that STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors occurred a number of times, but were brief. She also testified that STUDENT frequently “crashed” into her by way of greeting, not in an assaultive manner. All staff testified that STUDENT was not malicious during these behaviors but, instead, was trying to communicate her needs nonverbally. Ms. Stagnaro testified that she did not count the number of STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors, but that it was a problem in her class as well as on the playground and that it was a problem for the other child involved.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s behavior fell within the definition of “serious behavior problems” under the Hughes Bill. First, while the majority of STUDENT’s behavior was directed outward, she also engaged in the self-injurious behavior of excessive hair-pulling that resulted in some thinning on one spot on her head. Second, while STUDENT’s assaultive behavior may not have actually resulted in physical injury to a peer, unlike the case with property damage, there is no legal requirement that bodily harm be accomplished before the provisions of the Hughes Bill come into play. As acknowledged by Dr. Koegel and Dr. Gardner, choking, kicking and poking others in the eyes are serious behaviors that are likely to cause harm. That no one was actually harmed is not relevant to the inquiry. Third, there is no legal requirement that a student with a disability actually intend to cause harm to invoke the provisions of the Hughes Bill. Disabling conditions encompassed by special education law may include behaviors that unintentionally or involuntarily cause injury. Fourth, although the parties focused primarily on STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors, as indicated in Dr. Coonerty’s evaluation, STUDENT’s avoidant and resistant behaviors continually interfered with her ability to access instruction in the area of expressive speech. The Hearing Officer finds that these avoidant and resistant behaviors are severe behavior problems that were pervasive and maladaptive to STUDENT’s potential for learning.
The Hearing Officer finds that the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the District failed to conduct a functional analysis assessment of her behaviors and to prepare a positive behavior intervention plan designed to replace these behaviors and to assist her in her primary unique need of expressive language development.
3. Parent Training to Address Need for Consistency Across Home and School
The IDEA and implementing regulations include “parent counseling and training” within the “related services” that can be provided to a child with a disability where required to assist that child to benefit from special education. See 20 U.S.C. §1401(22), 34 C.F.R. § 300.24 (a). “Parent counseling and training” is defined as:
(i) Assisting parents in understanding the special needs of their child; (ii) Providing parents with information about child development; and (iii) Helping parents to acquire the necessary skills that will allow them to support the implementation of their child’s IEP or IFSP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.24 (b)(7).
In this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that parental training was necessary to allow STUDENT’s parents to support her language development at home and that such training addressed STUDENT’s unique need for consistency across home and school environments. The evidence was undisputed that the District took no action to incorporate Dr. Coonerty’s recommendation to enlist the parents in working with STUDENT on her expressive language development at home by helping them to address her behavior. In fact, Dr. Coonerty testified that she was told by then-special education director Ms. Torp that Dr. Coonerty could not authorize any behavioral services for the parents. In addition, although the parents occasionally met with Ms. Stagnaro and Ms. Fuller, and Ms. Stagnaro had a videotape of her techniques available for parental checkout and review, the Hearing Officer finds there was no training provided to the parents during this school year to adequately address STUDENT’s unique needs for consistency across home school environments or her expressive language needs.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
2. Was the Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit?
Because the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
3. Was the SDC Placement the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer finds that the District again met its burden of establishing that the SDC was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. The weight of the evidence established that Ms. Stagnaro appropriately used the IEP process to raise her concerns about STUDENT’s placement with the IEP team and that she sought information and resources for the IEP team regarding other potentially appropriate programs for STUDENT. The IEP team, including the parents, determined that Ms. Stagnaro’s class was the appropriate and least restrictive environment for STUDENT. Because it was the least restrictive environment, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District was not obligated to have a regular education teacher in attendance at the IEP meeting or to draft goals and objectives to facilitate inclusion in a regular education environment.
4. Did the District Deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000 Extended School Year?
The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for extended school year services at the March 2000 IEP. At the IEP of May 31, 2000, STUDENT was determined eligible for OT services but the date for the initiation of OT services was September 2000. None of the District’s staff who testified at the hearing was involved in the provision of ESY services to STUDENT, had any knowledge of the ESY teaching staff, or whether DIS speech and language services were provided to STUDENT during the 2000 ESY. Given STUDENT’s continuing fine motor needs, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no reasonable justification for the delay in beginning occupational therapy services to STUDENT. In light of Dr. Coonerty’s recent recommendation for a planned language flooding to determine STUDENT’s expressive language potential, the development of a clear ESY 2000 program was essential. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to carry its burden of proof regarding STUDENT’s ESY program for the 1999-2000 extended school year. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for ESY 2000. * * * In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school or extended school year.
III. DID THE DISTRICT DENY STUDENT A FAPE DURING THE
2000-2001 SCHOOL OR EXTENDED SCHOOL YEAR?
1. Was the District’s Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
a.. Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs remained the same. Her communication skills remained generally nonverbal with some one-word responses in class and occasionally two-word utterances with adult prompting. STUDENT was generally quiet and would nonverbally communicate by pulling SDC staff over. Ms. Stagnaro reported that since September 1999, STUDENT had trained in using simple signs in sign language to reinforce her receptive skills and used communication boards with pictures/icons at specific times such as snack and certain areas in room to augment verbal retrieval, for example, to say “I read book.” Due to her fine motor deficits, however, STUDENT was not able motorically to make many of the signs. While STUDENT’s behavior remained substantially the same, she made several important accomplishments. First, in the fall of 2000 she spontaneously said “I like you” to a friend in class instead of inappropriately hugging him, following ongoing efforts by Ms. Stagnaro to have her use this replacement behavior phrase. Second, for the first time, STUDENT waited for her turn while an adult negotiated a turn for her. This occurred after ongoing efforts to decrease grabbing and ask for a turn with adult assistance. Third, following her participation at the PRT training, STUDENT came to school for the first time not wearing diapers, after using a PRT behavior modification program for toileting.
b. Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT returned to Ms. Stagnaro’s SDC preschool class in the fall of 2000. Her placement remained the same except that she began to participate in a half hour movement education SDC kindergarten class taught by Nancy Boehm during her morning ‘free time.’ Several significant changes to STUDENT’s program were made at the December 18, 2000 IEP team meeting. First, the IEP team adopted a behavior support plan and new goals for STUDENT in social-emotional/functional language development, receptive language, language sequencing, communication using icons, pre-academic skills, self-help skills, and behavior (to decrease distractability). Second, the IEP team determined that STUDENT required additional supervision and the District hired an extra aide to work with STUDENT beginning in January 2001.
The Student’s principal contentions for this year were that she required Pivotal Response Training (PRT) methodology to receive a FAPE, and that the District should have conducted an FAA to address her behaviors.
1. Did STUDENT require PRT Methodology?
PRT motivational techniques were described as follows: STUDENT’s interests and preferences should be followed to determine items and activities that are highly motivating for her and these interests should be incorporated into naturalistic teaching sessions (child choice). Tasks should be varied and her interest maintained in this manner rather than repeating the same activities or items in a drill type format. All of STUDENT’s verbal responses and initiations, even single word usage, should be rewarded in order to maintain her motivation to use language and to expand unprompted speech. Natural and direct consequences should be used to ensure that STUDENT understands the positive consequences of using language and to increase the likelihood of expanding her communication skills. By “repeatedly providing natural rewards and immediate consequences for expressive language, the connection between spontaneous expressive language and the reinforcement that follow should be strengthened for STUDENT.”
The Student contends that she requires the use of PRT methodology to meet her unique behavioral and language needs. As previously discussed, the parents and STUDENT attended the Pivotal Response Training (PRT) program at the University of California, Santa Barbara, at their own expense, from October 30 to November 3, 2000. From STUDENT’s progress in this program, at the December 18, 2000 IEP meeting the parent requested that the District implement a PRT program for her. The parents believed that the District had agreed to implement whatever Dr. Koegel recommended at this IEP meeting, then misled the parents by not including the agreement to provide a PRT program in the IEP document.
The Hearing Officer finds that the December 2000 IEP document, viewed in light of the testimony and the contemporaneously taken notes, provided only that the District agreed to explore PRT services on behalf of STUDENT. The weight of the evidence established that the District acted reasonably in response to the parents’ request for PRT services by obtaining information from U.C.S.B. and Dr. Koegel, educating their staff, discussing how or if PRT could assist STUDENT, paying for staff PRT training, and paying for bringing both Ms. Symon and Dr. Koegel to the school for training and consultation.(Footnote 8) The Hearing Officer further gives great weight to the testimony of Ms. Stagnaro, Ms. Fuller, Ms. Siegler and Ms. Boehm that they read and seriously considered the PRT information in light of their knowledge of STUDENT. Ms. Stagnaro testified persuasively that, after the parents’ PRT training, the District tried to support them due to their enthusiasm about it. She reviewed the PRT pamphlets but did not see anything new STUDENT needed. She agreed to make and did make a videotape of her program for critiquing by Dr. Koegel, but did not find her feedback to be helpful. She agreed to do priming (pre-teaching) activities with STUDENT twice a week for several months in April and May 2001 and observed that STUDENT seemed “slightly more attentive” during this time period. While there was delay in the overall process of investigating and scheduling the PRT training, the evidence revealed multiple reasons for that delay, many of which were out of the District’s control.
The District argues that STUDENT did not require PRT to receive a FAPE because PRT is a methodology designed for autistic children and STUDENT is not autistic, and because it has provided an appropriate multi-sensory methodology to support STUDENT’s needs that incorporated established educational techniques also used by PRT. The District also asserted that Dr. Koegel had no knowledge of STUDENT’s educational program with the District and that the PRT data of significant increase in STUDENT’s language usage is based only on a comparison two ten-minute videotape language samples.(Footnote 9)
It is generally recognized that the choice of methodology is within the discretion of the school district. While parents may prefer a particular methodology for their child and believe it would confer more educational benefit on her than would the program offered by a school district, the law requires the district “to provide an appropriate placement, not the best possible placement. Moreover when a district is providing an appropriate placement, the parents do not have a right to compel the district to provide a particular educational program or methodology.” Student v. Laguna Beach Unified School District (1997) 26 IDELR 903, citing Lachman v. Illinois Board of Education (7th Cir.) 1988-89 EHLR 441:156. The narrow exception embodied in this rule arises where the placement is not appropriate because it is not meeting a student’s unique needs.
In this case, both of STUDENT’s parents testified that they were not seeking PRT methodology per se. Rather, because the District completely failed to respond to the recommendation of Dr. Coonerty and their independent evaluators for a behaviorally based expressive language program, they sought out a program on their own and this is what they found. After taking STUDENT to the PRT training, they were impressed by her responsiveness to PRT methods and the increase in her expressive language demonstrated by its use. They requested this methodology because it was what they had found and it seemed to be successful. PARENT testified that, regardless of the name of a particular methodology, she believed STUDENT required an intensive program for nine months to a year that would involve more one-to-one attention than a classroom teacher could provide to increase STUDENT’s use of expressive language by anticipating her needs and actively eliciting language from her. PARENT contrasted this approach to a program in which STUDENT is at a table identifying objects or being a passive container filled with receptive language. Both parents believed that the methods employed by Ms. Stagnaro were too focused on receptive language development and were premised on a belief that STUDENT’s language could not improve or that expressive language would eventually emerge. At the PRT training, the parents observed a significant difference in STUDENT’s willingness to use expressive language when it was expected of her.
Data regarding effectiveness
Dr. Koegel testified that it was not ‘just her opinion’ that PRT was effective with STUDENT but that the data demonstrated an increase in STUDENT’s expressive language following the family’s participation in the PRT training. Data were collected by having the family provide a videotape of one to two hours of STUDENT in her home environment prior to the training. A videotape language sample was also taken at the end of the training. A ten-minute segment of STUDENT’s language usage during the pretraining videotape was then compared to a ten-minute segment of her language usage after the training. During the pretraining sample, STUDENT used a total of 39 spontaneous single-word or word-combination utterances in ten minutes. In a post-training video sample, STUDENT used a total of 93 utterances (including fifty spontaneous utterances) in ten minutes. In addition, the post-training videotape evidenced a decrease in STUDENT’s use of protests (uses of “No” decreased from 11 to 0) and of problem behaviors (decreased from 5 to 0). After the training, STUDENT also demonstrated an improvement in the number of spontaneous words used, from 16 different words during the pretraining segment to 25 different words “when motivational procedures were applied.”
The only comparative data available from the District were language samples taken by Ms. Stagnaro in March 2000 and in December 2000. During the March 2000 language sample, STUDENT used 27 single words, four two-word utterances and six sound effects over a three-week 45-hour period at school, or a total of 35 single word or word-combination utterances. In December 2000, during a four-day, 12-hour period, STUDENT used a total of nineteen single words with six two-word utterances. STUDENT also demonstrated the use of new syntactic features: addition of “ing” to 2 words, use of one preposition (off), two adjectives (big, little) and two pronouns (me, you). In her December 2000 present levels of performance report, Ms. Stagnaro concluded that “STUDENT’s expressive language has increased in frequency (three weeks/four days) and in quality (verbs, adjectives, pronouns, prepositions).” Her parents reported her longest utterance to be a four-word utterance [“come mommy push me”]. She also noted that STUDENT had more readily imitated one- and two-word utterances during the 2000-2001 school year and that two- and three-word utterances “have been elicited only with accompanying visual icons.” Ms. Stagnaro testified that she did not observe a change in STUDENT’s verbalization after PRT.
The Hearing Officer finds that PRT methodology is not required to provide STUDENT with a FAPE. While PRT methodology can be effective with children with language and developmental delays like STUDENT, the weight of the evidence established that the motivational techniques recommended were based upon educational principles already integrated into STUDENT’s program. Speech therapist Ms. Fleming likened the PRT training to “a beginning language development course” that reiterated established principles such as constantly requiring verbal responses from the child and ensuring that the child is engaged in the activity. Ms. Stagnaro testified that the PRT techniques such as following a child’s lead, using natural and logical rewards, varying concepts to maintain interest are part of basic learning theory necessary for obtaining a teaching credential or becoming a speech pathologist. She also testified that the preschool SDC class was based on naturalistic teaching environment and that STUDENT’s favorite time in class was child-directed activities. In addition, the Hearing Officer is strongly persuaded by the testimony of both Ms. Stagnaro and Ms. Boehm that a purely auditory system for teaching language was not effective for STUDENT. Rather, she required multiple stimuli and paired associations (such a icons, pictures, movements) to assist her in the development and retrieval of language. Because Dr. Koegel had little knowledge of STUDENT’s educational program or history, the Hearing Officer finds that her opinion regarding STUDENT’s need for PRT is entitled to less weight.(Footnote 10)
In addition, Dr. Koegel conceded that there are many appropriate methodologies and that PRT is not the only method for intensive language and behavioral instruction for STUDENT. Rather, she asserted that PRT was effective in comparison to what the District was providing. While the raw data provided in PRT’s comparative language samples is impressive, the Hearing Officer finds it to be of limited value for purposes of comparison with District language samples. For example, STUDENT’s pre-PRT training expressive language sample data bear no reasonable relationship to the language sample data provided by the District (e.g., 35 single word or word-combination utterances at school over 45 hours in March 2000 versus 39 single-word or word-combination utterances at home in 10 minutes sometime before October 2000). At best, this comparison suggests STUDENT made remarkable progress in expressive language before attending the PRT training. While the evidence was undisputed that STUDENT is highly motivated by the presence of her parents and their presence appears to affect her verbal production, the Hearing Office finds this variable alone unlikely to account for the huge disparity in expressive language samples. In addition, there is no factual basis for comparing the language sampling method used by the District and PRT to collect STUDENT’s utterances. The method used by Ms. Stagnaro apparently involved passively recording whatever STUDENT said, whereas the PRT method appeared to involve actively evoking utterances, as indicated by the fact that nearly half of her post-training utterances were not spontaneous. While the Student would undoubtedly argue that this is the point, it nonetheless undercuts the validity of the asserted comparison.(Footnote 11)
While PRT methodology is not required for STUDENT, it nonetheless may be an appropriate one. Ms. Stagnaro’s testimony indicates that during at least STUDENT’s first year and a half in the SDC, her methodology for STUDENT’s expressive language development was largely narrative, or indirect language stimulation that did not actively elicit expressive language. The Hearing Officer finds that while Ms. Stagnaro’s methodology with STUDENT was clearly designed to meet her receptive language needs, it was not designed to meet her expressive language needs. Rather, the evidence–including the PRT data–established that STUDENT requires and responds to a method of expressive language development that actively encourages and elicits the use of expressive language.
2. FAA and BSP
The Student contends that the District denied her a FAPE by its continued failure to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) of her behaviors, that the behavior support plan (BSP) developed was insufficient and not implemented.
District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s behavior improved during the 2000-2001 school year, and that she seemed to have matured. For example, in her written observations of STUDENT in late September 2000, school psychologist Ms. Paulson reported that “last school year, STUDENT was observed to engage in aggressive behaviors requiring adult intervention (hitting, biting, squeezing, poking, grabbing) 8 times in a 90 minute period. This school year, adult intervention is required approximately three times a day.” In October 2000, Ms. Stagnaro described STUDENT’s behavior as inappropriate and reported that STUDENT “will occasionally hit, kick, try to bite a peer during nonstructured times, outside time and that the parents have reported the same behaviors at the park.” She also indicated that STUDENT was resistant to direct requests from adults and less so when with peers. In her December 2000 present levels of performance, Ms. Stagnaro reported that she maintained a daily log of STUDENT’s behaviors from September 7 through November 30, 2000. According to the BSP, STUDENT’s behavior of hitting, pushing and flailing her arms was documented “14 times on 9 different days this school year from 9/7 -11/30. The intensity is moderate.” Ms. Stagnaro indicated that aggressive behavior “occurs predominantly at Outside Time which is a time when the numbers of children increase, the activity level increases, and the activity is unstructured. At times, it appears that STUDENT becomes overwhelmed with peers coming quickly into close proximity and strikes out at them; at other times she seems unable to join into the ‘play’....”
While District personnel testified that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior decreased during the 2000-2001 school year, the evidence also persuasively established that STUDENT’s resistant and avoidant behavior continued. STUDENT continued to withdraw by lying on the floor with her thumb in her mouth or sitting and watching in both the SDC and in her movement class with Ms. Boehm. Ms. Siegler testified that, in her opinion, STUDENT’s withdrawal indicated she was mentally or physically fatigued or at the saturation point. STUDENT was observed at the end of the 2000-2001 school year to be largely unengaged for most of the time during circle time. This behavior continued through the year and was observed in November 2001 during the PRT training. Dr. Koegel later reported that “observations at home and school indicated that STUDENT did not initiate social interactions with peers. She engaged in disruptive behaviors of hitting, flopping on the floor, crying, running away, as well as avoidance behaviors of walking away, ignoring, and lying on the floor, both at home and at school.” These behaviors occurred “when demands were placed on her and when she was told ‘no.’” Additional behaviors reported by the parents were refusing to get dressed, hitting and walking away at home and in the community.
As previously discussed, during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT exhibited serious behavior problems that required the District to conduct a functional analysis assessment and to prepare a positive behavior intervention plan to address her aggressive, resistant and avoidant behaviors. This was not done and the effects of this failure continued on into the 2000-2001 school year.
Assuming arguendo that STUDENT did not require an FAA/BIP during the 2000-2001 school year, she did require comprehensive behavioral goals and a behavior support plan in the same behavioral areas for the reasons previously articulated. The evidence established, however, that the only behavioral goal was to “decrease distractability (looking away) in large (8:1) and small group activities, structured activities” and that the BSP focused only on STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors, but it did not address her resistant or avoidant behaviors. These behaviors appear to have been viewed as symptomatic of STUDENT’s asserted global developmental delay, despite the fact that STUDENT remained within the borderline range in many areas.(Footnote 12) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require a PRT methodology in order for the program to be designed to meet her unique needs during the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer also finds, however, that the SDC program was not designed to address STUDENT’s unique expressive language needs and that it was not designed to meet her behavior and social communication needs because an FAA was not conducted, and the BSP and IEP goals only addressed a limited portion of her behavior needs.
2. Was the Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit?
Because the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer concludes that it was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
3. Was the SDC Placement the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer again finds that the SDC placement was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during this school year and that the District was not obligated to have a regular education teacher attend the IEP meetings or to prepare goals and objectives to facilitate her inclusion into regular education program. However, because the District continued not to satisfactorily address STUDENT’s behavioral, expressive language and social communication needs, it is likely that STUDENT’s opportunity to participate in the mainstream was negatively impacted. This is particularly true in light of the testimony of Dr. Gardner and Dr. Koegel that STUDENT was a good candidate for full inclusion due to her social nature. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony persuasive that the use of the bathroom is not an appropriate mainstream opportunity, despite Ms. Stagnaro’s testimony that bathroom time was part of STUDENT’s five percent mainstream experience. If and how this negative impact should be remedied will be addressed in section VII, below.
4. Did the District Deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001 Extended School Year?
STUDENT remained eligible for extended school year services during the 2000-2001 school year. As previously discussed, none of the District’s staff who testified at the hearing was involved in the provision of ESY services to STUDENT, or had any knowledge of the ESY teaching staff or whether DIS speech and language services were provided to STUDENT during the 1999 extended school year. At the administrative hearing, the school district has the burden of proving that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it has offered an appropriate educational placement for the child. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). The Hearing Officer finds that the District has failed to carry its burden of proof regarding the provision of ESY services to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 extended school year. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for ESY 2001.
IV. DID THE DISTRICT DENY STUDENT A FAPE DURING THE 2001-2002 SCHOOL OR EXTENDED SCHOOL YEAR?
A. Procedural Appropriateness
The Student argues that the District failed to assess her in all areas of suspected disability because it failed to assess her neurological needs or to refer her for an assessment in this area of suspected disability. Cal. Educ. § 56320(f). The Hearing Officer granted the Student’s request to add this issue after the commencement of the hearing following the testimony of speech pathologist Linda Fleming that she noticed STUDENT’s unusual gait while working with her during the 2001-2002 school year, that this was a possible characteristic of autism that would need to be addressed by a neurologist, and that she had discussed her observation with OT Ms. Siegler, but had not mentioned her observation or a neurological evaluation to STUDENT’s parents. See: Order of September 23, 2002. STUDENT is not alleging that she is within the autistic spectrum; rather, her contention is that immature gait was one of a collection of symptoms she exhibited, such as squinting or hand tremors, that would raise concern of possible neurological problems that should have been assessed.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Siegler, Ms. Boehm, Ms. Isaacson and Dr. Rezowalli persuasive that the District had no reasonable basis to suspect a need to assess STUDENT or to refer her for a neurological assessment during this or the following year. Specifically, the Hearing Officer finds that the collection of symptoms on which Student relies were not observed by any District staff working regularly with STUDENT to any qualitative or quantitative degree, either singly or in combination, that would cause the District to suspect a disability in this area. In addition, the record clearly establishes than the parents had previously had STUDENT assessed by pediatric neurologists and that her EEG and MRIs were normal. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no reasonable basis for the District to suspect a need for a neurological assessment and it was under no obligation to assess STUDENT or to refer her for an assessment in this area.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
1. Was the District’s Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
a. STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs remained substantially the same during the 2001-2002 school year. District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s behavior in kindergarten was very different from that in preschool in that she seemed to have matured and to be more able to make her needs known. STUDENT continued to lay down, curl up and suck her thumb when she was tired but did so less frequently than the previous year. According to APE specialist Ms. Choate, STUDENT did have aggressive behaviors toward others but was “mostly a huggy kid.”
Nonetheless, as previously indicated, during the PRT staff training, STUDENT was observed to engage in disruptive behaviors of hitting, flopping on the floor, crying, running away, as well as avoidance behaviors of walking away, ignoring, and lying on the floor, both at home and at school. Most of STUDENT’s language was observed to function as requests and she demonstrated a limited social interaction repertoire of saying “boo” or calling out someone’s name, but did not initiate social interactions with peers.
b. Designed to Meet Unique Needs
SDC Class
In September 2001, STUDENT began kindergarten in Nancy Boehm’s SDC class at Bay View Elementary. Although the parents did not sign the June 2001 IEP, they verbally agreed to this placement and DIS services. Throughout the year, Ms. PARENT worked in Ms. Boehm’s class one day a week for the entire 3.5 hour program. The parents did not contest the academic program provided by Ms. Boehm. In sharp contrast, both parents testified that, in their opinion, this was the first time since entering the District that STUDENT was challenged in the classroom and expected to perform. They also testified that Ms. Boehm provided them with training, especially in methods to overcome STUDENT’s behavioral resistance to doing homework. Ms. PARENT testified that the parents “were totally impressed in STUDENT’s demonstrated abilities to move toward goals with the tremendous teaching skills of Nancy Boehm.”
As previously indicated, the parents do not dispute the appropriateness of Ms. Boehm’s academic program for STUDENT. Rather, they contend that the SDC class lacked a behavioral and language component, due to the District’s ongoing failure to address these issues. The Hearing Officer finds this argument unpersuasive. While the evidence revealed that STUDENT continued to act out and remove herself from the learning situation when demands were placed on her, the weight of the evidence in this matter persuasively established that Ms. Boehm’s class was well designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The class was highly structured. STUDENT was required to use her whole body in movements designed to teach her pre-academic skills, such as writing and counting, as well as social skills, in group, partner, and leader games. STUDENT responded well to the highly structured nature of Ms. Boehm’s class, and was seen to imitate the movements of her peers when she was unsure of her actions. Ms. Boehm testified that she was able to address STUDENT’s behavior in class and that STUDENT did not stand out as a problem child. In addition, the testimony of Ms. PARENTs established that STUDENT had very resistant behavior regarding homework completion, including throwing her pencils across the room when asked to comply. Nonetheless, Ms. Boehm was able to train Ms. PARENT in techniques to engage STUDENT effectively in completing her homework. Ms. Boehm also welcomed the parents’ participation in the classroom and modeled techniques in this context. Thus, the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique need for consistency across home and school environments. There was no dispute that the DIS APE, and OT services addressed her unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique expressive language needs were also addressed within the SDC class as well as in DIS speech therapy services with Ms. Fleming. In this regard, the Hearing Officer gives great weight to Ms. Fleming’s testimony that she was specifically instructed by Ms. Boehm to teach STUDENT that “her job was to talk” and that Ms. Fleming should push STUDENT in expressive language even when she appeared tired or to need a break. Accordingly, while some effects of the previous denials of FAPE were still felt during this school year, from the evidence outlined above, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC program was substantially designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 2001-2002 school year.
Mainstream Component
The evidence established that the parties agreed to substantially expand STUDENT’s participation in regular education at the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting. Specifically, the IEP team offered to provide STUDENT with a 2.5 hour regular education afternoon placement four days a week “with an assistant” for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year. The parties dispute the nature of “assistant” services STUDENT required in this placement.
The Student argued that the District denied her a FAPE because it offered her a specific PRT-trained one-to-one aide (Rosalie) to support her in the regular education program at this IEP meeting and then failed to implement this component. The District contended that it never offered STUDENT a one-to-one aide and that it would not write a specific name into the IEP. In its view, STUDENT had never had or required a one-to-one aide in the past, and its offer was to add an instructional aide to the regular education classroom to help STUDENT along with other students.
The question is whether STUDENT required a specific one-to-one aide trained in PRT techniques to meet her unique needs in the mainstream classroom. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of Ms. PARENT, PARENT, Dr. Koegel, and Ms. Boehm persuasively established that the District in fact offered to place a specific aide, Rosalie, in the regular education classroom to assist STUDENT in her first mainstream experience at the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting. The evidence demonstrated that Rosalie was familiar with STUDENT and with her language and behavioral needs. Although the Hearing Officer has determined that PRT is not a required methodology, the Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT needed the assistance of a person trained and familiar with her unique needs in order to benefit from her placement in the regular education classroom. While STUDENT required a specific trained assistant, the Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT required a “dedicated” aide, but not necessarily a one-to-one aide. Ms. Boehm’s testimony persuasively established that the intention was for Rosalie to work with other students as well as STUDENT.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that, following the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting, the mainstream component of the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs because the agreed-upon assistant/aide was not provided.
2. Was the Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Some Educational Benefit?
The parents did not contest the adequacy of Ms. Boehm’s academic program or that it provided STUDENT with educational benefit. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Boehm’s testimony and her substantial records of STUDENT’s work clearly demonstrate that the SDC program was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
As previously indicated, the denials of FAPE outlined for previous years continued to impact STUDENT’s program. The Hearing Officer finds that these effects were ameliorated by the extensive training and communication between Ms. Boehm and the parents, and particularly Ms. PARENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the SDC program was substantially calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
3. Was the SDC Placement the Least Restrictive Environment for STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer again finds that the SDC placement was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT during this school year and that the District was not obligated to prepare goals and objectives in to facilitate her inclusion into regular education program.
However, as previously indicated, at the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed to expand’s STUDENT’s participation in the regular education environment to a 2.5 hour afternoon placement four days a week “with an assistant” for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that it was unreasonable for the District not to implement the mainstream program with the agreed-upon aide. This failure deprived STUDENT of an opportunity to begin functioning in a learning environment with typically developing peers. As a consequence, the District denied STUDENT an educational opportunity in the least restrictive environment following the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting. * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that, with the limited exception that it did not provide the trained assistant STUDENT needed to participate in the regular education program after the March 2, 2002 IEP meeting, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year in the least restrictive environment.
4. Did the District Deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002 Extended School Year?
STUDENT remained eligible for extended school year services during the 2001-2002 school year. She argues that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to ensure her parents the opportunity to participate in the development of her ESY 2002 program. The District argues that its offer for the ESY 2002 was contained in its letters written after the March 2002 IEP meeting in April and May 2002. As discussed more fully below, the Hearing Officer finds that the March 2002 IEP meeting contemplated that another IEP meeting would occur after STUDENT had an opportunity to participate in the afternoon mainstream component with a dedicated aide. As a consequence, the failure to convene an IEP meeting deprived the parents of an opportunity to participate in the development of the ESY program. In addition, as previously discussed, there was no evidence presented at the hearing regarding the nature and substance of STUDENT’s ESY 2002 program. Accordingly, the District did not meet its burden of proof regarding the provision of ESY services to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 extended school year. As a consequence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for ESY 2002.
V. HAS THE DISTRICT OFFERED STUDENT A FAPE DURING THE
2002-2003 SCHOOL OR EXTENDED SCHOOL YEAR?
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(b)(3). In Union, the Ninth Circuit stated that “this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” Union, 15 F.3d at 1526. According to the Ninth Circuit, the purpose of imposing the requirement is (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the school district’s proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so that the school district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. Id.
A review of the March 2, 2002 IEP indicates that STUDENT’s special education placement is described as “SDC-special ed teacher-public school.”(Footnote 13) No date for the beginning or end of services was indicated. Under additional comments, the IEP provided that “STUDENT’s program will expand by adding K, p.m. gen ed. from 11:45 to 2:20 with an assistant, 4 days a week. Nancy Boehm will develop a transition time to prepare student for K. Goals and objectives continue from the 1-28-02 IEP. Planning for 02-03 placement: SDC-primary grade with mainstream time into first grade gen. ed class.”
The Student asserts that the District failed to provide her with a specific offer of placement for the 2002-2003 school year and that the IEP team did not address her placement for the 2002-2003 school year at the IEP meeting of March 2, 2002. The Student contends that the testimony of her parents, as well as that of Dr. Koegel and Ms. Boehm, established that the IEP team only discussed Dr. Koegel’s recommendation for a trained aide and regular education for the end of 2001-2002 school year, and not the 2002-2003 school year. Ms. PARENT testified that the reference in the March 2002 IEP to “planning for 02-03 placement” meant that another IEP meeting would be held to plan STUDENT’s 2002-2003 placement after there was information about how well she did in the afternoon kindergarten class. In addition, the Student contends that the District’s offer contained in its two ‘clarifying’ letters of April and May 2002 was an offer of a generic placement that failed to provide the parents with any meaningful information about STUDENT’s proposed placement and denied them the right to participate in the development of her program for this year.
The District contends that its offer for the 2002-2003 school year is contained in the March 2, 2002 IEP document and is further clarified in two letters sent to the Student through her attorney on April 4, and May 9, 2002. Pursuant to these letters, the placement offer for the 2002-2003 school year is for “public school, primary special day class (SDC) Program with special education teacher five days per week.” A specific offer of mainstream participation was also included. STUDENT was to be placed for thirty minutes a day in a first grade general education class, four days a week for free choice math and social environment. In addition, she would be mainstreamed for schoolwide activities, recess, breaks and lunch.
The weight of the evidence established that, at the March 2, 2002 IEP team meeting, the IEP team did not go beyond a very preliminary sketch of what STUDENT’s placement might look like in the 2002-2003 school year. This conclusion is buttressed by testimony of Dr. Koegel, Ms. PARENT and PARENT, and Ms. Boehm that the majority of the two- to three-hour IEP meeting was spent discussing Dr. Koegel’s recommendations for a mainstream component for the balance of the 2001-2002 school year. This testimony adds weight to Ms. PARENTs’ interpretation that further planning of STUDENT’s placement for the following year was contemplated and would be necessary after the IEP team had an opportunity to determine how STUDENT adjusted to the newly offered regular education kindergarten component. As members of the IEP team, STUDENT’s parents had the right to participate in the decision regarding her placement for the 2002-2003 school year. Local educational agencies are required to “ensure that the parents of each child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of their child.” 20 U.S.C.§ 1414(f), 20 U.S.C.§ 1414(d)(1)(B)(i). The Hearing Officer finds that the failure to convene another IEP meeting to discuss a specific placement for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year deprived her parents of an opportunity to participate as IEP team members in decisions regarding her educational placement.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the District failed to make a legally sufficient written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year. A specific educational placement “means that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs....” tit.5 C.C.R. § 3042 (a). A specific primary SDC placement was not identified in writing for the parents’ consideration at the IEP team meeting of March 2002 or at any time subsequent to that meeting. The District’s letters of April and May 2002 did not provide any specific information for the parents to seriously consider. The District argues that the Hearing Office has upheld the use of post-IEP documents to clarify placement offers, citing Newark Unified School District, 34 IDELR 23 (Nov. 1, 2000). In that case, however, the clarifying documents actually provided information about a specific classroom, with information about the number of students in the class, the adult-to-student ratio, the types of disabilities as well as the developmental and chronological ages of those students. There is clearly no comparison between the documents that constituted the offer in Newark and the IEP and subsequent letters from this District in this case. The uncontroverted evidence at the hearing was that the parents were not advised of a specific placement until the day before the first day of school.
Not all procedural violations constitute a denial of FAPE. However, “procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity,... or seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process,...clearly result in the denial of FAPE.” W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479. In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents were deprived of their right to participate in the development of STUDENT’s IEP placement for the 2002-2003 school year, a right underscored in 20 U.S.C.§ 1414(f). While the parents verbally agreed to STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Isaccson’s class when it was thrust upon them the day before the school year began, such an agreement does not cure the prejudice occasioned by the loss of opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process, particularly in light of the ongoing dispute between the parties of the appropriate components of STUDENT’s placement. For example, the failure to convene an IEP meeting specifically deprived the parents an opportunity to address their concerns regarding STUDENT’s participation in the mainstream and the support necessary for her in that setting.
For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year because it failed to make a legally sufficient offer at a properly constituted IEP team meeting. The Hearing Officer also concludes that it is not appropriate to make a finding regarding the ESY 2003 at this time.
VI. IS STUDENT ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR THE COST OF HER PARENTS’ TRAINING PROGRAM AT UCSB OR FOR INDEPENDENT EDUCATIONAL EVALUATIONS?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. Equitable considerations are relevant in determining relief under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 374.
The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT has a unique need for consistency across home and school environments that required parental involvement in the implementation of her IEP and that the District denied her a FAPE by failing to provide her parents with appropriate behavioral training that would enable them to assist STUDENT’s language development. The evidence established that in an effort to address these needs, the parents sought out and attended a four-day training program in PRT techniques at the Autism Research and Training Center, University of California, Santa Barbara, and incurred costs for transportation and lodging in that endeavor. The evidence also supports a finding that the parents and STUDENT benefitted from this training. For example, both parents testified that the program demonstrated STUDENT was capable of greater language production if she was expected to speak. The parents learned to work more effectively with STUDENT’s oppositional behavior, to insist on verbalization, and to successfully modulate her behavior, including her self-help toileting needs. Testimony of District staff members also indicated that, while PRT techniques were familiar to educators, they would be of great benefit to the parents. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the PRT parent training program in Santa Barbara in October and November 2000, as well as for related costs for transportation and lodging incurred during the training.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the independent educational evaluations (IEE) of Dr. Jacknow, Dr. Goldman, and Ms. Galt, none of whom testified at the hearing. A student is entitled to reimbursement for an IEE if the District’s assessments were not appropriate. Calif. Educ. Code § 56329. In this case, however, STUDENT clarified that she was not directly challenging the manner in which the District’s assessments were conducted or their findings, but rather the District’s failure to address her unique needs identified in the District’s own assessments. While these IEE reports were admitted into evidence and provided some corroboration for Dr. Coonerty’s recommendations, none of the findings of the assessments were significantly different from those contained in the District’s assessments. Accordingly, reimbursement is not appropriate.
VII. IS STUDENT ENTITLED TO COMPENSATORY EDUCATION DUE TO THE DISTRICT’S FAILURE TO PROVIDE FAPE?
The Hearing Officer has concluded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the limited extent that it failed to provide APE and OT services during the 1998-1999 school year, that it denied her a FAPE during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, and that it failed to make a legally sufficient offer of a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. In addition, the Hearing Officer had concluded that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for all extended school years from 1999 through 2002. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See: Parents of Petitioner W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. At 1497.
The Student requests a wide range of compensatory education services. First, she asserts that she is entitled to a “bank of hours” for services by a one-to-one aide trained in PRT and applied behavioral analysis techniques to be supervised by a qualified nonpublic agency, to work on developing her social communication skills with typical peers. Second, the Student requests compensatory education hours in a setting with typical peers to remedy the District’s failure to address mainstream settings. Third, the Student requests that the Hearing Officer order the District to hire a qualified consultant to the IEP team, like Dr. Gardner, to assist in the development of appropriate and measurable goals and objectives in regular and special education settings, and to facilitate discussions on how to conduct IEP team meetings with meaningful parental participation. Fourth, the Student requests compensatory services for all related services not provided due to the failure to appropriately assess her or timely provide her with services.
As indicated in the testimony of Dr. Koegel and Dr. Gardner, it is difficult to determine how to compensate STUDENT for the time she has missed as a result of the District’s denials of FAPE. To the extent that there was a window in time during which intensive expressive language facilitation in a behavioral format would have improved STUDENT’s expressive and social communication skills, she may never be adequately compensated for the delay. The Hearing Officer reiterates the very realistic assessments of Dr. Coonerty and STUDENT’s parents: that the goal is not to “cure” STUDENT but to bring her up to her solidly borderline potential and to integrate her into a mainstream setting with typically developing peers.(FOOTNOTE 14)
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires compensatory education services in a one-to-one format provided by a behavioral specialist trained in behavioral methodologies relating to the facilitation of expressive language and social communication. The Hearing Officer also concludes that three hours a day for one year is appropriate for the denials of FAPE described above. However, because these hours must be integrated with STUDENT’s SDC and mainstream placement, the Hearing Officer finds it more appropriate to award STUDENT a bank of 150 hours of one-to-one instruction by a behavior specialist. The behavioral specialist must be part of STUDENT’s IEP team, and must work in consultation with STUDENT’s parents, classroom teacher, speech therapist, school psychologist and, if appropriate, behavioral intervention case manager. In providing compensatory services, the behavioral specialist shall work directly with STUDENT and with typically developing peers in a social context determined appropriate by the IEP team.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT is entitled to a total of 52 hours of compensatory services for lost occupational therapy services to address her fine motor needs. The evidence established that STUDENT continues to have fine motor deficits that affect her ability to write and to sign. The IEP team may determine whether such services are more appropriately provided in a direct (individual or small group) or consultative fashion. While the District failed to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs during the 1998-1999 and much of the 1999-2000 school year, there is insufficient evidence that this is a current area of need in which STUDENT requires compensatory services.
Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory consultation services with Dr. Gardner to ensure that measurable annual goals designed to facilitate her inclusion in a regular education setting as appropriate are prepared by the IEP team. Given Dr. Gardner’s extensive experience in special education and in providing consultation services to school districts and parents, the Hearing Officer concludes that both the parents and the District will benefit from her participation at this important juncture in STUDENT’s education.
ORDER
1. Within 10 business days of the date of this order, the District shall reimburse the the Student’s parents for the costs of the PRT training at U.C.S.B., and for related costs of transportation and lodging necessary for attendance at this training, according to proof.
2. Within 10 business days of the date of this order, the District shall begin a functional analysis assessment of STUDENT’s behaviors described in this Decision as required by California Education Code § 56520, et seq., and its implementing regulations, 5 C.C.R. § 3001, 3052. Thereafter, the District is required to immediately develop and implement any behavior intervention plan indicated by the assessment in STUDENT’s current placement.
3. The District shall provide STUDENT with the following related services to compensate her for the loss of services during the 1998-1999, 1999-2000, 2000-2001 school years and extended school years from 1999 through 2002:
A. A total of 52 hours of compensatory occupational therapy services to address fine motor skills. The IEP team shall determine the manner of delivery of these services.
B. A bank of 150 hours of one-to-one services to be provided by a behavior specialist trained in behavioral methodologies relating the facilitation of expressive language and social communication. The behavior specialist shall be part of the IEP team, and shall work in consultation with STUDENT’s parents, classroom teacher, speech therapist, school psychologist, and, if appropriate, her behavioral intervention case manager.
C. A total of 30 hours of compensatory consultation services with Dr. Paula Gardner to ensure that measurable annual goals designed to facilitate STUDENT’s inclusion in a regular education setting are prepared by the IEP team. Consultation services may include, but are not limited to, participation in IEP team meetings, independent review of proposed goals and objectives, and/or development of proposed goals and objectives in special education and regular education environments.
4. Within 10 business days of the date of this order, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to address STUDENT’s placement during the 2002-2003 year and the ESY 2003. For the 2002-2003 school year, the placement shall include a minimum of 2 hours a day in an appropriate regular education program with a dedicated assistant who is trained in the facilitation of expressive language and social communication skills.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The Student prevailed on the following issues:
The Student prevailed on the FAPE issues relating to the 1998-1999 school year to the limited extent that she was denied OT and APE services. The Student prevailed on the FAPE issues relating to the 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2002-2003 school years and the extended school years from 1999 through 2002. The Student also prevailed in part on her reimbursement claim and substantially prevailed in her compensatory education claim.
The District prevailed on the following issues:
The District prevailed on the least restrictive environment issue for the 1998-1999 through 2000-2001 school years, and on the alleged failure to refer or assess issue for the 2001-2002 school year to the present.
The District substantially prevailed on the FAPE issues for the 1998-1999 and the 2001-2002 school year, and prevailed in part on the reimbursement claim.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: January 3, 2003 ____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Decision is amended to add Order 3.C., that was previously inadvertently omitted. In all other respects, the Decision remains the same. 2. Ms. Rezendes also represented the Santa Cruz County Office of Education until the Hearing Officer dismissed it as a party on September 27, 2002. See Memorandum of Orders at Hearing dated September 4, 2002. 3. The Student’s original statement of issues generally asserted a denial of FAPE as outlined above. On the first day of hearing, at the Hearing Officer’s request, the Student clarified her specific contentions for each of these years in great detail. Student’s contentions were then summarized in a memorandum of issues dated August 22, 2002. On September 23, 2002, the Hearing Officer granted the Student’s motion to add a new issue based on newly discovered evidence relating to the alleged failure to refer or assess her in neurological areas. Due to the multiplicity of contentions raised, the Hearing Officer has consolidated the issues for clarity of analysis. Specific procedural and substantive contentions will be addressed as relevant to each of the years at issue. 4. The stay put order also provided that STUDENT remain in a kindergarten special day class; however, the day before the school year began, the parents learned of and verbally agreed to STUDENT’s placement in Ms. Isaacson’s class at De La Viega 5. The Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders- Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) provides that individuals with IQ levels ranging from 50-55 to approximately 70 are in the mild mental retardation range. Individuals with an IQ in the 71-84 range are within the borderline intellectual functioning range. Mental retardation is described as ‘significantly subaverage general intellectual functioning’--defined as an IQ of 70 or below or approximately 2 standard deviations below the mean-- that is accompanied by significant limitations in adaptive functioning in at least two of the following skill areas: communication, self-care, home living social/interpersonal skills, use of community resources, self-direction, functional academic skills, work, leisure, health, and safety. When there is significant scatter in the subtest scores, the profile of strengths and weaknesses, rather than the mathematically derived full-scale IQ, will more accurately reflect the person’s learning abilities. DSM-IV at pp. 39-40. 6. STUDENT did not receive any credit on some of the WPPSI-R subtests; however, the school psychologist who administered the test reported that she received scaled score values on these as the result of test standardization. 7. “Hearsay evidence may be used for the purpose of supplementing or explaining other evidence but shall not be sufficient in itself to support a finding unless it would be admissible over objection in a civil action.” 5 C.C.R 3082(b) 8. In early 2001, Dr. Poage requested PRT manuals for the staff to review, including manuals on how to teach pivotal behaviors to children with autism, how to teach self-management to people with severe disabilities, a parent guide on assessing causes of behavior and designing treatment plans, a guide on how to increase school success through priming, a model for parent professional collaboration and a toilet training manual for students with severe handicaps. 9. The District also argued that the PRT program was part of Dr. Koegel’s private practice rather than UCSB’s autism clinic and that all payments had been made to her personally. Dr. Koegel testified that because STUDENT’s case was a “demonstration” case graduate students could observe, the association with UCSB was appropriate. She also testified that she charged the parents her standard fee of $4,000 a day for testifying. The District agreed to allow her to testify telephonically. 10. In addition, many of the recommendation made by the PRT program had already been implemented in the SDC. For example, following the PRT staff training in November 2001, it was recommended that STUDENT be taught turn-taking with peers “since this skill should improve STUDENT’s interactions with peers.” Ms. Stagnaro had instituted turn-taking instruction with STUDENT in September 1999. Other recommendations included teaching STUDENT questions and phrases to increase her social repertoire. Ms. Stagnaro had worked with STUDENT receptively to respond to the question “What are you doing” in December 2000 and reported in June 2001 that STUDENT had spontaneously asked a peer “What doing?” She had also begun work on goals to produce two- to three-word utterances in a functional setting with peers such as “Come look” and “I want turn.” 11. Ms. Stagnaro testified that the March and December 2000 language samples discussed above were the only data taken of STUDENT’s expressive language usage during her 2.5 years in the preschool SDC program. The Hearing Officer notes that the lack of systematic data or reports on STUDENT’s language usage made it extremely difficult for the parents to monitor, understand or appreciate the District’s efforts to address her most serious area of need.
12. The Hearing Officer notes that the question about STUDENT’s ultimate cognitive potential remains unanswered due to the District’s failure to follow through with Dr. Coonerty’s recommendations and the parents’ refusal to authorize any cognitive or language testing since her evaluation. Unfortunately, that question appeared to have been resolved in favor of mental retardation by some members of the staff. For example, Dr. Poage testified that PRT was not appropriate for a mentally retarded child like STUDENT.
13. The Student is not disputing the offer of DIS services which were the same in the IEP as in the District’s clarifying letters: twice weekly speech and APE services for 30 minutes a session and 1 hour each a month of direct and consultative OT services. 14. The Hearing Officer also notes that, in order to adequately document STUDENT’s progress in this and future years, both the District and the parents need to ensure that proper data are collected and preserved regarding STUDENT’s program, and in particular regarding her expressive language development. District staff must understand the importance of taking and maintaining data logs and STUDENT’s parents must cooperate in providing consent to assess STUDENT’s areas of need. See Cal. Educ. Code 56506(e).
