California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 23, 2004
Student v. Greenfield Union School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 971-04 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary
Greenfield Union and Kern County schools' March 2004 offer was a FAPE, but the one-hour home program offered in May was not; 35 compensatory hours ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision notes that the January 13, 2004 settlement of a prior district-filed case limited this hearing to the period after March 2, 2004. No remand, vacatur or correction is noted.
Summary
The Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) filed for due process, and the student's parent filed a separate case; the cases were consolidated. The student was 10½ years old and in fifth grade. His primary eligibility was mental retardation (now called intellectual disability), with established medical condition, hard of hearing, orthopedic impairment and autism also listed. He has a severe seizure disorder and functions at an 8- to 12-month developmental level. His mother removed him from a special day class at Buena Vista Elementary in March 2004. She argued that the March 2, 2004 IEP should have named autism as his primary disability. She also argued that it should have provided five to six hours a day of discrete trial training, plus more occupational therapy (OT). The Hearing Officer found the March offer was a FAPE. The autism-focus class addressed his functional, self-help and communication needs, and staff followed the doctor's seizure protocol once it was clarified. The parent's experts were not persuasive because they had little medical or educational information. The May 7, 2004 offer was different. It provided one hour a day of home instruction and 30 minutes a month of consultative OT. It aimed only to maintain his skills, and he did not medically need home instruction. That offer denied FAPE through the 2004 extended school year. Mileage reimbursement was denied because the private day care provided no education. The Hearing Officer ordered 25 hours of one-to-one instruction, 5 hours of direct OT and 5 hours of consultative OT.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a home instruction offer that cut a student's school day from more than five hours to one hour, with the stated goal of only maintaining skills. It also shows SEHO giving little weight to private experts who had limited medical and educational records.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a FAPE from March 2, 2004, through May 6, 2004?
The March 2, 2004 offer of an autism-focus SDC with speech and 30 minutes a month of consultative OT met the student's functional, self-help and communication needs. The student did not need a full-time ABA/discrete trial program, and staff followed the doctor's seizure protocol once it was clarified.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a FAPE from May 7, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year?
One hour a day of home or day-care instruction, meant only to maintain skills, plus 30 minutes a month of consultative OT with no classroom staff to carry out OT strategies, was not designed to meet the student's needs. No medical documentation showed he needed home instruction, so the offer denied FAPE. The full-time ABA claim was rejected.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is his Mother entitled to reimbursement of travel expenses between Darlyn's Darlings Daycare and Valley Achievement Center or home?
Reimbursement was denied because the March offer was a FAPE, and the private day care the parent chose provides no educational services, so it was not an appropriate placement.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?
For the denial of FAPE from May 7, 2004 through the 2004 extended school year, the student was awarded 25 hours of one-to-one instruction, 5 hours of direct OT and 5 hours of consultative OT. The requested full-time ABA program or private placement was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. 25 hours of direct one-to-one instruction on IEP goals by a credentialed special education teacher. To be provided in an SDC like Ms. Jockinsen's or another location the parties agree on, consistent with the treating medical specialists' opinions and the student's fatigue. Complete by December 31, 2004 unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.
- Compensatory education. 5 hours of direct OT services and 5 hours of consultative OT services, to be completed by December 31, 2004 unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.
Total: 35 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Adams v. State of Oregon; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Todd v. Andrews; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3051.4(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)
People named in the decision
- Steven D. Shapiro, school psychologist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Alexis M. Valos, behavior specialist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Ann Marie Duquette, school nurse, Kern County Superintendent of Schools, Division of Special Education
- Angelina Bertran-Harris, coordinator of special education, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Wilma Poage, director of special education, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Jackie Cooper-Glenn, speech-language pathologist, Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Paul Salmon, director of special education, Greenfield Union School District
- Valinda Kelly Jockinsen, special day class teacher, Buena Vista Elementary School, Greenfield Union School District
- Jana Anderson, special day class teacher (prior teacher), Buena Vista Elementary School
- Sarah Jane Spence, medical director, UCLA Autism Evaluation Clinic; witness, UCLA Department of Psychiatry & Biobehavioral Sciences
- Jay Edward Fisher, clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Jennifer Dowd Furlong, occupational therapist; independent OT assessor for Student, Goodfellow Occupational Therapy Services; Central Unified School District
- Madhu Bhogal, pediatrician
- Susan Koh, pediatric neurologist (treating physician; did not testify)
- Darlyn Baker, registered nurse, owner/director of private pediatric day health care facility, Darlyn's Darlings Daycare
- Rommel Quiton, teacher, Valley Achievement Center (nonpublic school)
- Jolene Billinger, director and co-founder, Valley Achievement Center (nonpublic school)
- Valley Achievement Center, certified nonpublic school / after-school autism program
- Darlyn's Darlings Daycare, private pediatric day health care and respite facility
- Goodfellow Occupational Therapy Services, private OT agency
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on May 18-21 and 25-27, 2004. Student was represented at hearing by attorney Nicole Misner of Anton, Misner, and Associates. Also present on his behalf was his Mother. The Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) and the Greenfield Union School District (Greenfield) were represented at hearing by attorney Stacy L. Inman of School’s Legal Service. Also present on behalf of KCSOS were Dr. Wilma Poage, director of special education, and Angelina Bertran-Harris, coordinator of special education. Also present on Greenfield’s behalf was Paul Salmon, director of special education.
The following witnesses were called to testify: Student’s Mother; Steven D. Shapiro, licensed school psychologist for KCSOS; Alexis M. Valos, behavior specialist at KCSOS; Ann Marie Duquette, school nurse for the Division of Special Education, KCSOS; Angelina Bertran-Harris, coordinator for special education, KCSOS; Sarah Jane Spence, medical director of the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) Autism Evaluation Clinic and assistant professor in residence, UCLA Department of Psychiatry & Biobehavioral Sciences; Deborah Hazel, occupational therapist for KCSOS; Darlyn Baker, registered nurse and owner/director of Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare (DDD), a pediatric day health care and respite facility; Dr. Madhu Bhogal, pediatrician; Jay Edward Fisher, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; Dr. Wilma Poage, director of special education at KCSOS; Rommel Quiton, teacher at Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a certified nonpublic school; Jolene Billinger, director and co-founder of VAC; Valinda Kelly Jockinsen, (Footnote 1) special day class teacher at Buena Vista Elementary School, a public school operated by the Greenfield Union School District; Lynn Davis, personal friend of MOTHER; Sharon Wiley, personal friend of MOTHER; Jennifer Dowd Furlong, occupational therapist for both Goodfellow Occupational Therapy Services, a private agency, and the Central Unified School District; and Paul Salmon, director of special education for the Greenfield Union School District.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Thereafter, the Hearing Office received written closing arguments from both parties, and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING (Footnote 2)
1. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2, 2004, through May 6, 2004?
2. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a FAPE from May 7, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year?
3. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is his MOTHER entitled to reimbursement of travel expenses between Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare and Valley Achievement Center?
4. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?
CONTENTIONS
The Student contends that Greenfield, his school district of residence, and KCSOS, which contracted with Greenfield to provide him with special education services, failed to offer him a FAPE from March 2, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year (ESY). (Footnote 3)
The Student contends he was denied a FAPE because the offer made at the March 2, 2004, individualized educational program (IEP) team meeting was based on inaccurate reporting of his “present levels of performance” so that the IEP did not adequately address his unique needs. The Student contends that the offer was inappropriate because the IEP did not designate his primary disabling condition as autistic, which resulted in the use of teaching methods that did not focus on autism. The Student contends that he should have been provided a program that included three and one-half to five hours of discrete trial training (DTT) per day and a total of five to six hours of instruction per day. The Student also contends that the amount of occupational therapy (OT) offered was insufficient. The Student further contends that placement at the District school (BV) was inappropriate because he did not progress while attending BV previously, and that the staff at BV did not follow his doctor’s orders and protocols in regards to his seizure disorder and thus did not provide him with a safe environment. Lastly, the Student contends that the District did not comport with his IEPs by failing to provide the instruction called for in his IEP.
Regarding the offer of May 7, 2004, the Student contends that it was not an offer of FAPE because it provided only one hour of home or hospital instruction per day, and that the amount of OT offered was insufficient. The Student contends that he should have been provided a home or hospital program that included three and one-half to five hours of DTT per day and a total of five to six hours of instruction per day, with one hour per week of OT.
Because of his contentions that the District failed to provide him a FAPE, the Student contends that his parent is entitled to reimbursement for travel expenses she incurred to transport him from DDD to VAC or to home. (Footnote 4) The Student also contends that he is entitled to compensatory education. (Footnote 5)
The District contends that the program offered on March 2, 2004, constituted an offer of FAPE, as did the offer of May 7, 2004. The District contends that because it did not deny Student a FAPE, his Mother is not entitled to reimbursement nor is Student entitled to compensatory education.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At hearing, Student presented a motion to require the District to allow his expert, Dr. Jay Fisher, to observe the special day class (SDC) at BV. Student was removed from BV by his Mother on March 11, 2004, and has been attending a private day care program since that time. The Student argued that he had the right to have his expert observe the BV program under California Education Code section 56329(b). The District objected to the motion and contended that the Student was no longer placed in the BV program and that, since the current offer was for a home program or services to be delivered at DDD, the Education Code section did not apply and observation was not appropriate. The Hearing Officer ruled that, under the circumstances of this case, Education Code section 56329(b) did not compel the District to allow the Student’s expert to observe the BV program because the BV program was not the current or proposed placement. Section 56329(b) entitles an independent educational assessor to observe only the student’s current education placement and setting and any educational placement and setting “proposed” by the public educational agency. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
On an unrelated note, the District had subpoenaed Student’s pediatric neurologist, Dr. Susan Koh, to testify at the hearing. Dr. Koh contacted the District and refused to testify. She was on medical leave after having an emergency caesarian. The Hearing Officer contacted Dr. Koh and offered to hear her testimony by telephone at her convenience. Dr. Koh would not testify without her chart available to her, and the District offered to have the chart sent to Dr. Koh by overnight mail. Both Mother and her attorney had asked Dr. Koh to testify as well. Dr. Koh was to recontact the Hearing Officer to arrange her testimony. Later, the District was informed via E-mail by the administrator of Dr. Koh’s department that requiring Dr. Koh’s testimony “was asinine” and that Dr. Koh would not testify. After discussion, the parties agreed to forego Dr. Koh’s testimony and the District withdrew its subpoena.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a ten-and-a-half-year-old fifth-grade student who resides in the Greenfield Union School District. His last agreed-upon IEP, dated March 7, 2003, identified his categories of eligibility as mental retardation (primary), established medical condition, hard of hearing (cerebral palsy), orthopedic impairment (cerebral palsy), and autism. Currently, Student spends his mornings (from approximately 9 a.m. to approximately 1:45 p.m.) at a private facility, Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare. (Footnote 6) Student also attends an after-school program at VAC, a certified non-public school, from approximately 2:30 p.m. to 5:00 p.m. (Footnote 7) In addition, pursuant to the parties’ stipulation, Student receives speech and language therapy from the District.
On March 6, 1995, Student began receiving special education services. In November 2000, when he was seven years old, Student began to have seizures. The first seizure was described by Student’s Mother as a “grand mal” seizure. His doctors currently advise that Student suffers from the following multiple types of seizures: “generalized tonic clonic (where he shakes all his limbs), myoclonic (where he has a brief jerk of his limbs or shoulders), absence (where he stares), and atonic (where he falls to the ground).” (Footnote 8) Student’s seizure disorder fluctuates and is considered severe and intractable.
On January 31, 2002, Student began attending an autism-focus program in the Panama-Buena Vista School District. The IEPs in early 2002 contain goals addressing self-help needs such as toilet training, self-feeding, and learning a functional communication system.
On August 22, 2002, a Vagus Nerve Stimulator (VNS) was placed in Student’s chest. The vagus nerve conducts electrical signals to the brain but does not contain pain fibers. The VNS is a pace-maker type unit that creates electrical stimulation to the nerve, which is carried to the brain to interrupt seizures. The VNS can be mechanically triggered by the use of a magnet. The magnet is “swiped” over the implantation site to stimulate the VNS to cycle. Mother testified that Student’s seizure disorder fluctuated between being under control with medication to being out of control, causing Student as many as seventy-five seizures in a day.
Mother agreed to the IEP of March 7, 2003, that placed Student in an SDC at Buena Vista Elementary School for fourth grade and included speech and language services and OT services. Student’s teacher was Jana Anderson. Student attended Jana Anderson’s SDC until August 22, 2003, when the IEP team met to move Student to Valinda Jockinsen’s K-3 classroom (from the 7th-8th grade room). (Footnote 9) Ms. Anderson recommended the move because she was to have a bigger, more aggressive child in her class the next year and she was concerned that placement with such a child might not be good for Student .
Student attended Ms. Jockinsen’s SDC from August 22, 2003, until October 2003. In October 2003, Ms. Jockinsen went on leave because of a medical emergency. The District placed a substitute teacher in the class. Because of her concerns that staff was not properly administering Student’s seizure medication, Mother removed Student from school on October 8, 2003. (Footnote 10) Mother also testified that Student was suffering an increase in seizures and his seizure disorder was poorly controlled at that time. On October 23, 2003, Mother enrolled Student in Valley Achievement Center’s morning academic program.
Student’s annual IEP team meeting was held on October 31, 2003. Mother stated that her concerns were the administration of Student’s medication and the change of teacher. She also felt that Student was not progressing. She requested that the District fund Student’s placement at the VAC morning program. The District told Mother that it believed its offer was an offer of FAPE and refused to fund VAC. Mother declined to consent to continued placement at BV. On November 14, 2003, the District filed a due process hearing request. The matter was settled on January 13, 2004. An IEP team meeting was held on January 15, 2004, with a partial team attending, for the purpose of training the classroom staff on Student’s medicals needs only. KCSOS school nurse Ann Marie Duquette wrote an emergency plan that was to be kept in the classroom. About this time, the District sent a form to Student’s doctor, Dr. Susan Koh, entitled “Parent/Physician’s Authorization for Having Specialized Physical Health Care Service Procedures Administered” requesting that Dr. Koh provide information about Student’s medical needs. On January 16, 2004, Dr. Koh returned the form and addressed the use of the VNS device. Mother signed an amendment to the IEP dated January 20, 2004, agreeing with the updated medication and VNS training. Student returned to Ms. Jockinsen’s class on January 20, 2004. (Footnote 11)
As part of the January 2004 settlement agreement and for the triennial review, the District conducted assessments. Ms. Jockinsen issued an Educational Report regarding her evaluation, which took place on February 10-13, 2004. Ms. Jockinsen had administered the Brigance Inventory of Early Development that measures gross and fine motor skills, self-help skills, general knowledge, and comprehension. She also administered the Southern California Ordinal Scales that measures self-help skills and social/emotional development. Ms. Jockinsen indicated that Student’s medical needs were a priority. She noted that Student ’s seizure activity, medications, and his immune system tended to slow his educational progress. She concluded that he was functioning at the eight- to twelve-month developmental level. She suggested that his IEP focus on areas that could make him feel more independent and that could provide him with functional living skills, community-based skills, and social and vocational skills. Ms. Jockinsen stated that Student benefits from a close staff-to-student ratio and that he needs constant monitoring for seizure activity and assistance with eating and toileting needs. She recommended a program that focuses on language, functional skills, and interaction with others.
KCSOS school nurse Ann Marie Duquette completed a nurse’s health summary dated February 11, 2004, that listed the following medical conditions: intractable epilepsy and autistic disorder, failure to gain weight, cerebral palsy and spastic diplegia, supernumerary pseudodicentric derivative chromosome 15, and mental retardation. Ms. Duquette summarized Student’s condition as medically fragile and set out his medications and other medical interventions.
KCSOS speech-language pathologist Jackie Cooper-Glenn conducted a speech and language evaluation on February 18, 2004. She found that Student suffered from severe developmental delays and that he was non-verbal but had developed some communicative intent using manual signs. She recommended exploring various expressive modalities to develop a functional communication system. She further recommended providing numerous opportunities for communication for Student through his day. She also suggested holding back or “playing dumb” to provoke Student into initiating a request or responding to an offer to motivate him to use his communication skills.
A psychological evaluation was conducted by KCSOS school psychologist Steven Shapiro on February 11, 2004. His report of February 23, 2004, found that Student had become very passive and dependent on adults. On the basis of two days of observations, Mr. Shapiro indicated that he was concerned about Student’s lack of activity. He reported that Student sat for long periods of time if left alone. Mr. Shapiro administered the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale but was unable to obtain any correct responses from Student. He administered the Southern California Ordinal Scales and found Student to be functioning at the eight- to twelve-month level. The administration of the Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised (SIB-R) revealed that Student was functioning at a nine-month level, which was noted to be lower than the eighteen-month level result obtained two and one-half years ago. Mr. Shapiro concluded that Student needed to increase his independence and to generalize his skills. Mr. Shapiro felt that functional goals for self-help and communication needed to be created. He also recommended close communication between the school and the medical specialists.
Mother had reported to the IEP team that Student was slapping himself, taking off other people’s glasses, spitting, and hitting other kids. She requested that a behavior intervention plan be developed. Alexis Valos, behavior specialist, conducted a functional assessment of behavior on February 23, 2004. Ms. Valos concluded that Student did not exhibit behaviors that impeded his education and that a behavior intervention plan was not warranted.
Student’s triennial IEP team meeting was held on March 2, 2004. The IEP contained sixteen goals that addressed functional self-help skills, such as: assisting in his dressing and undressing; traveling to a grocery store and staying with the shopping cart without throwing objects on the floor; pushing and pulling to be able to play a video; matching; learning the steps for hand washing and tooth brushing; learning to feed himself with an adapted spoon; learning some clean-up skills; and learning to pull up and push down his pants to assist in his toileting. A goal was written to assist Student in walking flat-footed instead of on his toes. Goals were written to address communication methods. The District offered continued placement in Ms. Jockinsen’s class at BV, speech and language therapy two times per week for twenty minutes each session on a direct/consult basis, and occupational therapy once a month for thirty minutes on a direct/consult basis. The offer included the same placement and services for the extended school year (ESY). Mother did not consent to the IEP. She insisted that Student needed a behavior plan and was exhibiting excessive behaviors at home.
At the March 2, 2004 IEP team meeting, Mother informed the team that Student had been prescribed Diastat, an anti-convulsive medication given rectally to control seizures. The team agreed that Ms. Duquette was to train staff on the use of Diastat once Mother provided the medication.
On March 4, 2004, Mother called the class and learned that Student had fifteen “head drop” seizures that morning. Mother called Ms. Duquette and voiced her concerns about the staff’s use of the VNS magnet. Mother indicated that she believed the magnet should be swiped over the VNS with every seizure, even if it had passed. Ms. Duquette met Mother at the class on March 9, 2004, to review the doctor’s orders. Based on Dr. Koh’s written order of January 16, 2004, Ms. Duquette amended the emergency plan to require staff to swipe the magnet if Student had three seizures in one hour.
On March 11, 2004, Mother picked Student up from school at 11:45 a.m. Student has not returned to the District school.
Ms. Duquette contacted Dr. Koh by telephone on March 11, 2004, to clarify the use of the VNS magnet and the administration of Diastat. A series of faxes passed between Dr. Koh and Ms. Duquette to clarify the doctor’s orders. Dr. Koh faxed Ms. Duquette a letter dated March 12, 2004, regarding Ms. Duquette’s questions and indicated that Student had been in clinic that morning. Dr. Koh also indicated that Student had a very intractable and brittle seizure disorder. She was increasing his medication and would change the VNS setting since Student was having a significant increase in seizures. Dr. Koh also informed Ms. Duquette that Student was being considered for brain surgery. Dr. Koh provided specific written instructions regarding the use of the VNS device and Diastat.
Dr. Koh’s March 12, 2004, fax to “whom it may concern” notes that Student has severe, intractable seizures and autism. His seizures were reported to be extremely difficult to control with medication and that the doctors had tried everything. Dr. Koh went on to note that Mother was concerned about the confusion over treatment of his seizures. Dr. Koh wrote:
[T]his child is very brittle in terms of his seizure control and therefore, is very sensitive to missed doses or to difficulties with his VNS or Diastat. He may require home schooling until he is evaluated for corpus callosotomy, a type of epilepsy surgery which may help to stop the drop seizures (atonic seizures) that he suffers from…Since Student is having up to 20 seizures a day, I feel that he may benefit from home schooling rather than a classroom where the safety risks are increased. In addition, he may benefit from being in a new school environment such as Valley Achievement where the teachers and staff are used to children with severe seizure disorders.
After Ms. Duquette obtained clarification from Dr. Koh, she contacted Mother to assure her that District staff was trained and able to properly care for Student. Ms. Duquette informed Dr. Koh that she and her staff were very experienced with children with seizures and that Valley Achievement did not have medical staff on site. Ms. Duquette spoke with Dr. Koh on approximately March 24, 2004, by telephone. Ms. Duquette reported that Dr. Koh re-emphasized during the phone conversation that Student should be in a home program. The doctor indicated that the seizures observed were “break through” but that the EEG was recording multiple seizures. The doctor informed Ms. Duquette that Student was too fragile to be in school.
On March 24, 2004, when Mother still had not returned Student to school, the District filed a request for a due process hearing.
On April 5, 2004, Student began attending Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare at his Mother’s expense. On April 15, 2004, Ms. Duquette issued a Nurse’s Update recommending that Student be in a home program until July to allow him sufficient surgical recovery time. An IEP team meeting was scheduled for April 19, 2004, to review the nurses’ update. Mother contacted the school approximately forty-five minutes before the meeting to notify the school that she could not attend because of a family medical emergency. The IEP notes state that an IEP will be scheduled in August following Student ’s surgery to discuss his program.
On April 23, 2004, the Student filed a request for a due process hearing and requested consolidation of the two pending due process hearings.
After several unsuccessful attempts to reschedule an IEP team meeting at a mutually agreeable time, the District set a meeting for April 30, 2004. Mother did not attend. In her absence, the District offered instruction at home for sixty minutes per day, speech and language services twice per week for twenty minutes a session, occupational therapy once per month for thirty minutes (on a direct/consult basis), and ESY services. The one-hour instruction was to be provided after school by Ms. Jockinsen. The proposed IEP was mailed to Mother. The IEP notes indicate that the IEP team meeting would be continued to May 7, 2004, so that Mother could attend. The IEP of April 30, 2004, offers a choice for the location of instruction as either at home or at DDD.
The IEP team met again on May 7, 2004. Mother was in attendance with her attorney. The District offered the same program outlined in the April 30, 2004 IEP. Mother did not consent. She wanted Student’s primary disabling condition to be designated as autism. She wanted him to have a full-time autism program consisting of five to six hours of intensive discrete trial training/applied behavior analysis per day. Mother objected to some of the reported present levels of performance. She stated that Student would not benefit from one hour of instruction per day. She informed the team that surgery had not yet been scheduled.
The cases were ordered consolidated on May 14, 2004, and proceeded to hearing on May 18, 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from March 2, 2004 through May 6, 2004?
Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, that include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) available given the nature and severity of his or her needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 965 (1994). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1997). While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak at 133.
To determine if a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district’s proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8), 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.
Thus, to constitute an offer of FAPE, the IDEA requires that the District’s placement, including related services, (1) be designed to address the student’s unique education needs; (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him or her some educational benefit; and (3) comport with his or her IEP. The offer must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE).
The Student contends he was denied a FAPE because the offer made at the March 2, 2004, IEP team meeting was based on inaccurate reporting of his “present levels of performance” so that the IEP did not adequately address his unique needs. The Student contends that the District failed to provide him a FAPE because the offer made at the March 2, 2004, IEP team meeting did not provide him with teaching methods that focused on autism and that he should have been provided a full-time ABA/DTT program. The Student also contends that the offer did not contain sufficient OT services. The Student further contends that placement at BV was inappropriate because he had not been making progress at BV and the staff at BV did not follow his doctor’s orders regarding his seizure disorder. Lastly, the Student contends that the District did not comport with his IEPs by failing to provide the instruction called for in his IEP.
The District contends that its offer was designed to meet Student ’s unique needs. The District contends that the IEP team developed the program and offer based on current assessments.
Was the March 2, 2004 offer designed to meet Student ’s unique needs?
Before the Hearing Officer can analyze whether the District’s offer of March 2, 2004, addressed Student ’s unique needs, she must determine what those unique needs were as of March 2, 2004.
Student ’s unique needs
The assessments conducted by the District and the earlier assessments conducted by UCLA at the request of Mother all conclude that Student suffers from severe developmental delays. The experts are split as to whether the delays are primarily caused by mental retardation or autism. However, the experts do agree that Student has deficits in communication and self-help skills. The experts all recommend a program that focuses on providing Student with functional living skills and a communication system and on improving his independence.
Student suffers from a number of health problems related to his cerebral palsy and immune deficits and he suffers from severe, intractable seizures. He is reported to have had as many as seventy-five seizures in a day. Most of the seizures are described as very brief (less than thirty seconds) head drop seizures, after which Student recovers quickly. His seizure disorder must be closely monitored for compliance with medication and VNS protocols, to provide data to track the type and frequency of seizures, and to protect Student mechanically from injury due to the seizures.
The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that Student has global deficits and his unique needs are for self-help skills, functional living skills, a functional communication system, and independence. He also has medical needs that require close monitoring and he needs careful administration of medication.
The District’s Offer
The District’s offer of March 2, 2004, consisted of placement in Ms. Jockinsen’s SDC with speech and language therapy of twenty minutes two times per week, OT (on a direct/consult basis) for thirty minutes per month, and ESY services.
Was placement in Ms. Jockinsen’s class designed to meet Student ’s unique needs?
Ms. Jockinsen’s class is an autism-focus class. Ms. Jockinsen has been a special education teacher for severely handicapped (SH) classes since 1993 and has been teaching autistic/SH children since 1997. At hearing she described her class as using teaching techniques suitable for children with developmental delays and autism. She uses methodologies such as DTT, TEACH, applied behavioral analysis (ABA), and other antecedent-behavior-consequence teaching techniques. Her class is small and highly structured with a low student-to-adult ratio.
Ms. Jockinsen credibly testified that she worked on Student’s goals everyday. She used ABA techniques to address Student’s self-help needs, functional needs, and need to form a functional communication system. Two doors down from Ms. Jockinsen’s class is a functional apartment. Ms. Jockinsen testified that her class visited the functional apartment frequently. She worked with Student in the apartment on his hand washing, tooth brushing, and toileting goals, as well as on learning simple clean-up tasks such as mopping, doing dishes, and cleaning counters. Ms. Jockinsen also took her class on “community-based” outings to develop independence and functional skills. During such outings, Ms. Jockinsen worked on Student ’s goal of going to the grocery store and staying with the cart without throwing objects on the floor.
The Student objects to the offered placement for several reasons. The Student contends that there were several inaccurate reports of his present levels of performance in the IEP and therefore the placement did not address his needs. Mother objects to a report in the IEP that Student smiles as a means to communicate that he wants something or that he is pleased with something. Mother asserts that Student smiled but that his smiles did not mean anything in particular. Mother strongly objects to a description of Student as “semi-catatonic.” This language in the IEP was in reference to times when Student’s seizure disorder was poorly controlled and he was heavily medicated. Mother objects to a report that Student can void standing up. She asserts he has never done this at home. The IEP reports that Student has voided standing up for a particular aide who was effusive and loud and was able to obtain responses from Student when others could not. Mother also objects to reports in the IEP that Student has been nodding his head in response to his environment. Mother asserts that Student has been doing this for a couple of years. Mother objects to a report in the IEP that Student showed an interest in emptying trash, picking up books, mopping, and doing chores. Mother asserts that this is not a recent trend.
Although Mother testified that she objected to some of the statements in the IEP as misrepresenting Student’s present levels of performance, she also testified that she agreed with the goals and objectives as written. The Hearing Officer finds that even if Mother’s objections to the foregoing present levels are valid, there is no dispute that the discrepancies did not affect the appropriateness of the goals and objectives of the IEP and did not cause placement in Ms. Jockinsen’s class to be inappropriate.
Additionally, the Student objects to the March 2, 2004, IEP because his primary disabling condition should have been designated as autism and not mental retardation and that he required a full-time ABA/DTT program to achieve educational progress. The Student’s contention that he needed the ABA/DTT program was addressed by his expert, Dr. Jay Fisher, who testified at hearing that Student is “clearly autistic” and needs five to six hours of intensive one-to-one ABA therapy per day. Dr. Fisher did not issue a report of his findings until his testimony on May 21, 2004. The Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Fisher’s report or testimony to be persuasive. Dr. Fisher admitted that he had not been given any of Dr. Koh’s reports or letters nor did he have access to much medical information in general. He also admitted that he had been given very little educational information concerning Student. He knew only, by the report of Mother, that Student was autistic. Dr. Fisher observed Student on three occasions. The first visit was in his office and Dr. Fisher did nothing but watch Student. He reported that Student was non-responsive to him and the environment. On the second visit, also in his office, Dr. Fisher attempted to use compliance-training techniques on Student. He reported that Student demonstrated classic autistic stereotypic movements and that Student cried, tried to pull Dr. Fisher’s glasses off, and tried to escape his office. The last contact that Dr. Fisher had with Student was an observation at VAC. Dr. Fisher testified that VAC used flawed programming on Student because Student was mostly non-responsive there. Dr. Fisher could recall only the amount of time spent at VAC, not the amount of time spent in his office. His report does not indicate the amount of time spent in each visit. Dr. Fisher did not attempt any testing. He did not speak to any of Student’s medical or educational providers except for the program manager of VAC’s after-school program. Dr. Fisher advocated that an autistic child must have a full-time DTT program. Furthermore, Dr. Fisher’s testimony made it evident that he had sparse knowledge about educational requirements. For instance, he was unaware that Diagnostic Statistical Manual-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV) criteria are not used to determine special education eligibility. In addition, he did not know the difference between a functional behavioral assessment and a functional analysis assessment.
The Hearing Officer did not find Dr. Fisher persuasive for several reasons. First, Mother had provided him very limited medical and educational information. Second, he did no testing and did not interview any of Student’s medical or educational providers. Third, he did not demonstrate adequate knowledge of special education requirements. Lastly, the Hearing Officer was disturbed by Dr. Fisher’s level of hostility toward the District. (Footnote 12)
KCSOS school psychologist Steven Shapiro testified that Ms. Jockinsen’s class was an appropriate placement for Student. Mr. Shapiro has evaluated Student several times since Student has been attending District schools and evaluated Student again in February 2004. In February 2004, Mr. Shapiro observed Student on three different occasions in his educational placement at BV and conducted psychological testing. Mr. Shapiro found that Student ’s deficits did not compel a diagnosis of autism nor did Student need a full-time ABA/DTT program. He went on to testify that, even if Student is autistic, his recommendations would not change since they were based on Student’s needs rather than his diagnosis. Mr. Shapiro testified that Ms. Jockinsen’s class was appropriate because it was a small class where Student received individualized attention, had a one-to-one aide, had access to a living skills center, and participated in OT/PT activities. Mr. Shapiro further testified that Ms. Jockinsen was an experienced teacher with an autism background. He testified that Student also had good support from a speech and language specialist and an OT specialist. Mr. Shapiro characterized Ms. Jockinsen’s class as a good mix of spatial individual instruction (in the cubicles) and small-group instruction.
Regarding Student’s needs, the Hearing Officer notes that the experts, whether they believe Student is autistic (Student’s experts) or mentally retarded (District’s experts), determined that he needed a program that provided him with functional skills. The services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive FAPE must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability. 34 C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3)(ii). Student’s IEP goals are focused on providing Student with self-help and functional skills and functional communication skills. Additionally, Ms. Jockinsen’s class is an autism-focus class that uses methodologies determined to be effective with autistic children. She is a veteran special education teacher with specific experience teaching SH/autistic students. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Jockinsen’s class was designed to meet Student ’s unique needs and that he did not require a full-time ABA/DTT program to meet his unique needs.
Was the offer of occupational therapy designed to meet Student’s unique needs?
A “free appropriate public education” is to include special education and any necessary “related services.” The term “related services,” also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.
The Student contends that the District’s offer did not have sufficient OT services and would not have provided him with educational benefit. The Student’s OT assessor, Jennifer Furlong, recommended OT services once per week for thirty to forty-five minutes a session.
The March 2, 2004 offer includes related services of occupational therapy of thirty minutes per month on a “direct/consult” basis. District OT Deborah Hazel credibly testified that she spent the thirty minutes per month updating the training she had already provided for the classroom staff on OT techniques that would support Student’s goals. She testified that she was also available for more time when staff had questions or problems regarding Student and OT support. Ms. Hazel testified that she had worked with Student’s teacher and staff for “quite awhile” so that she did not need more time than thirty minutes per month to update the staff’s training. Ms. Jockinsen testified that she and her staff worked on Student’s OT goals throughout the day so that he received much more time than thirty minutes of OT per month. The IEP contained OT goals in tooth brushing, using an adapted spoon for self-feeding, and pulling his pants up and down to assist in toileting. Ms. Jockinsen credibly testified that she and her staff addressed these goals every day. The IEP contained goals for self-help and functional living skills that the OT supervised.
Ms. Furlong evaluated Student on April 23, 2004. The Hearing Officer does not find Ms. Furlong’s conclusions and recommendations that Student requires thirty to forty-five minutes of OT services per week to be persuasive because they are not supported by medical and educational information. Ms. Furlong testified that she had not been provided with any of Dr. Koh’s letters, was provided with very little medical information in general, and was provided only a part of one IEP as educational records. On cross-examination, Ms. Furlong could not identify the documents she had been provided and could only state that she had been provided very little. Ms. Furlong’s report was based on one afternoon’s contact with Student, which occurred after Student was out of school for the day. The session was cut short due to Student’s fatigue. Additionally, Ms. Furlong did not observe Student in the school setting and did not speak with any educational staff who had been working with Student . Ms. Furlong had also been provided misinformation. Ms. Furlong reported that Mother told her that Student was fidgety in class. However, Student was universally reported as being very passive in class. The witnesses at hearing testified that Student would sit for long periods of time if left alone.
The Hearing Officer finds that the amount of OT services was appropriate to support the foregoing goals and was therefore designed to meet Student’s unique needs.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the program (placement and services) offered by the District on March 2, 2004, was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.
Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to Student?
As will be discussed below, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s program was reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. The program focused on Student’s self-help and functional needs, his need to develop a communication system, and his medical needs.
The Student contends that Ms. Jockinsen’s class would not have benefited him because he had not progressed in that same placement from January 20, 2004 through March 11, 2004, when he was removed from the class.
Ms. Jockinsen testified that she worked with Student on his goals and objectives for one hour per day and that he was making slow steady progress. She testified that she used DTT daily with Student to work on his goals. Ms. Jockinsen credibly testified that Student was “beginning to blossom.” She reported that Student was beginning to express likes and dislikes and beginning to make choices. She felt Student was beginning to interact more. In addition, Ms. Jockinsen testified that Student had slowly progressed in the past in her class. Mr. Shapiro (KCSOS school psychologist) noted that Student was no longer mouthing everything in 2004, which was evidence of developmental progress since 2001. The speech and language report of Jackie Cooper-Glenn notes that by February 2004, Student was beginning to understand and use some manual signs and some picture exchange icons. The report documents some progress in Student’s development of a functional communication system.
The District witnesses testified that Student’s fragile medical condition of intractable seizures, his cerebral palsy, immune system deficiencies, and a chromosomal abnormality all impacted his ability to progress. The District witnesses did not testify that Student was unable to learn but that Student is severely mentally retarded and thus learned very slowly. (Footnote 13) In addition, the District witnesses testified that Student has gone through periods of time when he was over-medicated, which impacted his ability to progress. The District’s assessors all recommended Ms. Jockinsen’s class and testified that the class provided educational benefit in the past to Student. Ms. Bertran-Harris, the coordinator of special education services, testified that Ms. Jockinsen’s class was small and structured with a low student-to-adult ratio and was an autism-focus class. She testified that the class has provided Student with educational benefit in the past and the offer would have provided benefit as well. Dr. Wilma Poage’s testimony corroborated the District’s contention that the offer and program were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to Student.
A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). The testimony and documentary evidence demonstrated that Student has severe cognitive and physical deficits but had been able to progress very slowly. The evidence also demonstrated that Student is severely mentally retarded (or severely autistic) with global developmental delays leaving him with the functioning of an eight- to twelve-month-old child. Based on the testimony of the District’s witnesses (Jockinsen, Bertran-Harris, Poage, and Shapiro) and in consideration of the severe nature of Student ’s disability, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student progressed while attending Ms. Jockinsen’s class at BV prior to March 2, 2004, and would have continued to progress in the class. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the offer of placement and services contained in the District’s offer of March 2, 2004, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
Did the District’s program comport with Student ’s IEP?
The Student contends that the District did not comport with his IEP by failing to follow his doctor’s orders and by failing to provide the instruction set forth in the IEP.
The Student contends that the District did not comport with his IEP because Ms. Jockinsen and her staff did not comply with Dr. Koh’s orders and protocols. Mother testified that Dr. Koh’s protocol required the VNS magnet to be swiped over the VNS device with every seizure that Student had, regardless of whether the seizure had passed.
Dr. Koh wrote on the form dated January 16, 2004, that the VNS magnet should be used “[i]f having prolonged seizure greater than 3 minutes or having increased seizure frequency (3 in a [ ]).” The final word is cut off of the fax and is disputed. Most witnesses at hearing read the phrase to say “3 in a row.” However, at hearing, the witnesses admitted that the phrase could also read “3 in an hour.” KCSOS school nurse Duquette testified that, based on her personal experience and from previous training she had received from the manufacturer of the VNS, she believed that once a seizure had passed, there was no value to swiping the magnet over the VNS site. Ms. Duquette testified that she and Mother had discussed this and that Mother had agreed with her that if staff could not get to Student until after the seizure had passed, it was not necessary to swipe the magnet over his chest. Mother could not recall these conversations at hearing. Student is described as having very brief “head drop” seizures that pass quickly, in less than thirty seconds. Ms. Jockinsen testified that she and her staff could not always reach Student to swipe the magnet before the seizure had passed.
The testimony at hearing established that on March 4, 2004, as soon as the dispute arose regarding the interpretation of Dr. Koh’s order, Ms. Duquette contacted Dr. Koh to obtain clarification of the order. Ms. Duquette then trained the staff to swipe the magnet whenever Student had a cluster of three seizures in an hour, even if the seizure had stopped. Despite this effort, Mother would not return Student to school at BV.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to follow Dr. Koh’s protocol by failing to swipe the VNS magnet on every seizure. The protocol provided to the District prior to March 12, 2004, was unclear, but in any case did not require swiping the magnet after every seizure as contended by Mother. As soon as a dispute came to light regarding the interpretation of Dr. Koh’s order, the District took steps to clarify Dr. Koh’s January 16, 2004, order. Ms. Duquette then retrained staff based on the newly received information from Dr. Koh. (Footnote 14) Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not fail to comport with Student’s IEP regarding Dr. Koh’s orders and protocols.
The Student also contends that the District did not comport with his IEP by failing to provide him with instruction during class. Student’s Mother testified that she observed Ms. Jockinsen’s class many times and that during the times she observed, Student was not receiving instruction. Mother testified that she had transported Student to school between 8:15 a.m. and 8:30 a.m. and the class had not started by that time, the students were running around, the aides were talking to each other, and no instruction was happening. Mother testified that, according to the Buena Vista class schedule, 7:30 a.m. to 8:00 a.m. was class preparation time and the aides should have been preparing, not talking to each other. Mother testified that she has never seen P.E. at 9:00 a.m. as it says on the schedule. Mother did not testify that she had observed the class between 9:00 a.m. and 11:45 a.m. She was at class once at 11:45 a.m. to pick Student up and testified that no instruction was going on at that time. She had gone to the class at 1:45 p.m. on occasion to pick Student up and had observed Student sitting at a table with a toy and not engaged in an activity. Mother could not provide the dates of the above observances. On cross-examination the occasions seemed to be infrequent. She was unable to say that she had observed an entire class period or day.
Sharon Wiley testified on Student’s behalf that she brings her child to Ms. Jockinsen’s class between 9:00 a.m. and 9:15 a.m. because class does not begin until then. She testified that the kids were still running around and that staff was still taking kids to the bathroom at 9:00 a.m. She testified that when she picked up her son, she saw kids on the playground doing nothing. She wanted her son to be involved in an activity at all times. She intended to remove her son from Ms. Jockinsen’s class soon. She was unable to testify as to the dates of these occurrences nor could she testify that she had observed a whole day of class.
Ms. Jockinsen testified that children arrive at different times during the morning depending on the individual bus schedules. Structured activities begin when all the children have arrived. IEP goals are worked on every day and instruction following ABA techniques is provided throughout the day. Ms. Jockinsen testified that on most days Student takes a 1:45 p.m. bus to his after-school program.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the vague testimony offered by Student’s Mother and Ms. Wiley. Neither woman observed Student’s entire school day and neither was able to testify that no instruction was given during the day. At best, their testimony establishes that Ms. Jockinsen does not strictly hold to her published schedule. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Jockinsen’s testimony that the program she implemented comported with Student ’s IEP.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program comported with Student’s IEP.
Did the District’s offered program provide an education in the least restrictive environment?
No issue was raised regarding LRE.
Conclusion
The Hearing Officer finds that the offer contained in the March 2, 2004 IEP and presented at the IEP meeting of that date was designed to meet Student ’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and that the program provided comported with Student’s IEP. There was no dispute that the offer provided placement in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer constituted an offer of FAPE for the period of March 2, 2004 through May 6, 2004.
2. Did the Greenfield Union School District and the Kern County Superintendent of Schools fail to offer Student a FAPE from May 7, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year, including the extended school year?
The Student contends that one hour per day of instruction is insufficient to allow him to progress. The Student contends that the offer did not meet his unique needs because he is autistic and requires a full-time DTT/ABA program. The Student further contends that the offer did not include sufficient OT services.
The District contends that the May 7, 2004, offer was based on Dr. Koh’s instructions and would maintain Student ’s skills until he had recovered from brain surgery.
The District’s offer
The District’s offer consisted of one hour of instruction per day at either Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare or at home provided by Ms. Jockinsen after she had finished her school day. Speech and language therapy and occupational therapy would be provided as well, at DDD or home. The offer included ESY services.
As outlined above, to constitute an offer of FAPE, the IDEA requires that the District’s placement, which includes related services, (1) be designed to address the student’s unique educational needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him or her some educational benefit, and (3) the program implemented comport with his or her IEP. The offer must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE).
Was the May 7, 2004 offer designed to meet Student’s unique needs? (Footnote 15)
First, the Hearing Officer must determine if there had been any change in Student’s unique needs.
Student’s unique needs
Student’s unique needs for self-help, functional living skills, and a communication system did not change between March 2, 2004 and May 7, 2004. However, his medical needs changed. Dr. Koh’s March 11, 2004 fax to Ms. Duquette noted an increase in Student’s seizure activity that included “break through” seizures and EEG evidence of significantly increased seizure activity. Dr. Koh increased Student’s medication and adjusted the VNS. Dr. Koh also informed the District that brain surgery was being considered.
While Student’s seizure disorder might have been fluctuating, there is no clear evidence that Student’s educational needs changed because of this fluctuation. Additionally, when recommending a home or hospital placement, the IEP team is to obtain a medical report from the attending physician stating the diagnosed condition and certifying that the severity of the condition prevents the pupil from attending a less restrictive placement. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, §3051.4(d). The report shall include a projected date for the student’s return to school. Id.
It is unfortunate that Dr. Koh was adamant against testifying in this hearing. However, the relevant inquiry for the Hearing Officer is what the District knew or should have known at the time it made the offer on May 7, 2004. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Board of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993)). Dr. Koh’s letter of March 12, 2004, addressed “[t]o whom it may concern” states that Dr. Koh felt that because Student was having twenty seizures a day and because of increased safety risks at school, Student may benefit from home schooling. Dr. Koh goes on to state that Student should be moved to Valley Achievement where the staff is “used to children with severe seizure disorders.” Dr. Koh stated that her opinion was based on Mother’s concern that the District was not following her treatment protocol. While Dr. Koh’s letter suggested that Student may need to be at home, she also states that he could be educated at another school site (VAC). The District did not have the medical documentation required under section 3051.4(d). Ms. Duquette reported that she spoke with Dr. Koh on or about March 22, 2004, and that the doctor felt Student was too medically fragile to be in school. Dr. Koh felt that Student should be at home until after the brain surgery. Ms. Duquette thought Student would have the surgery in July 2004 and an IEP team meeting should be rescheduled for August to discuss his program.
Dr. Koh based her recommendations on Mother’s reports that the District was not following her medical protocol. The evidence established that the District adjusted its medical plan and was able and willing to follow the protocol. The District had trained staff experienced with caring for children with severe seizure disorders and offered a school nurse on site. Dr. Koh stated in her letter that Student could be at VAC (Mother’s preferred placement) because VAC had staff “used to children with severe seizure disorders.” Ms. Duquette testified that VAC did not have trained medical staff on site. Student began attending DDD on April 5, 2004, and continued in VAC’s after-school program. As of May 7, 2004, Student was able to attend programs that were not provided at home or in the hospital. In light of the evidence provided at hearing, the Hearing Officer does not find that Student needed a home or hospital program.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s unique needs for self-help and functional living skills did not change nor did his need to develop a functional communication system. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no medical evidence that Student’s medical needs changed so as to require a home or hospital program by May 7, 2004. (Footnote 16)
Was the offer of one hour of instruction per day designed to meet Student’s unique needs?
The District’s witnesses testified that one hour of instruction per day would be sufficient to maintain Student’s skills. Ms. Jockinsen testified that one hour per day is appropriate since that is what she provides at school in working on IEP goals. Other witnesses testified that one hour is appropriate because that is what is commonly provided in in-home-schooling programs. However, the witnesses (Ms. Jockinsen and Ms. Bertran-Harris) also testified that ABA instruction goes on the entire school day, even during lunch and recess, so that Student would receive ABA instruction from approximately 8:30 a.m. to 1:45 p.m if participating in the SDC. The District argued that one hour of instruction was sufficient based on Dr. Koh’s reports that Student was medically fragile and was being considered for brain surgery. However, Dr. Koh’s reports did not limit Student’s education to one hour per day. Dr. Bhogal, Student’s pediatrician, testified that Student would be able to participate in two to three hours of instruction per day if he was given frequent breaks.
The District did not provide any authority to support its contention that it must provide services only to maintain Student’s skills. California Education Code section 56363 and Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations sections 3042, 3051.4, and 3051.17 address home or hospital instruction but do not allow such instruction to be limited to maintaining the student’s skills.
Student had been receiving five hours and fifteen minutes of instruction per day at the District. With full-time instruction Student was only able to progress very slowly. Cutting his instruction to only one hour per day was not reasonably calculated to result in progress.
Because the District’s offer was based on “maintaining” Student’s skills only and because Student had been receiving five hours and fifteen minutes of instruction per day, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of one hour of instruction per day was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs.
Did the offer fail to address Student’s unique needs because it did not include a full-time DTT/ABA program?
Because the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Dr. Fisher’s report and testimony that Student requires a full-time ABA/DTT program, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require a full-time ABA/DTT program as part of the May 7, 2004 IEP.
Did the offer fail to address Student’s unique needs because it did not contain sufficient OT services?
The District’s offer was to provide the same level of OT services as offered in the March 2, 2004 IEP (thirty minutes per month on a direct/consult basis) at home or DDD. According to Ms. Hazel’s testimony, the prior offer of thirty minutes per month of OT was sufficient to meet Student’s needs because services were to be provided throughout the day by classroom staff. Therefore, the actual provision of OT services may decrease dramatically depending on the ability or willingness of persons working with Student to use the recommended OT techniques. The testimony at hearing established that Mother is able to implement Student’s OT goals at home. However, a free and appropriate public education does not contemplate that necessary related services are to be provided by the parents. The testimony at hearing also established that DDD does not provide any educational services and would not provide OT support. Therefore, if Student were placed at DDD or at home, the proposed OT services would not have been sufficient.
The Hearing Officer finds that the May 7, 2004 offer was not designed to meet Student’s unique need for OT services because it did not provide for OT to be provided throughout the day.
Is the offer of May 7, 2004, reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit?
As noted above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer to provide Student with one hour of instruction was not sufficient to provide educational benefit. The Hearing Officer also finds that one hour of instruction provided in a home program or at DDD was not reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
Does the offer comport with Student’s IEP?
Because the offer was not accepted or implemented, there is no issue of whether the District’s offer comported with the IEP.
Is the offer in the least restrictive environment?
There was no dispute regarding education in the LRE.
Conclusion
Because the May 7, 2004, offer was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer was not an offer of FAPE.
3. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is his Mother entitled to reimbursement of travel expenses between Darlyn’s Darlings Daycare (DDD) to VAC or to home?
When the district has failed to provide FAPE, the parent may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private school education, if it is determined that the parent’s placement was appropriate. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F. 3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994).
The District’s offer of March 2, 2004, was found to be an offer of FAPE and reimbursement is therefore not warranted. Because the Hearing Officer found that the offer of May 7, 2004, did not constitute an offer of FAPE, the Hearing Officer must determine if the parent’s placement was appropriate for purposes of reimbursement. The Hearing Officer found above that Student did not require a home or hospital placement. The testimony at hearing from Darlyn Baker, owner of DDD, established that DDD does not provide any educational services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that placement at DDD was not an appropriate educational placement and the District is not obligated to reimburse Mother for transportation expenses. The Student did not request reimbursement of any other expenses.
4. If Greenfield and KCSOS did not provide or offer Student a FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?
The authority to award compensatory education is derived from section 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii) of Title 20 of the United States Code, which authorizes the finder of fact to grant “such relief as it determines appropriate.” Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services. Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (D. Minn. 1996). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the student by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief…relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (11th Cir. 1991); see also Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d Cir. 1990); Meiner v. State of Missouri, 800 F.2d 749 (8th Cir. 1986).
The Student requests compensatory education that would consist of receiving three and a half hours of DTT per day with a total of five to six hours of instruction a day, to be delivered at DDD or VAC. The Student also requests direct OT services two times per week for thirty minutes per session, the hours to be adjusted depending on whether he is at home, DDD, or VAC.
As indicated above, the Hearing Officer found that the March 2, 2004, was an offer of FAPE; therefore, Student is not entitled to compensatory education arising out of that offer. However, the Hearing Officer did find that the May 7, 2004, was not an offer of FAPE. Since May 7, 2004, Student has been denied appropriate educational services and is entitled to compensatory education.
The District denied Student a FAPE for a very limited period of time from May 7, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year and ESY, a period that ended on or about July 16, 2004. The failure of the District to offer an appropriate placement resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for Student, but the precise harm that such a deprivation of appropriate educational programming has caused is difficult to measure. It is not disputed that Student functions at a very low cognitive level and that he progresses very slowly. The Student requested additional hours of instruction as compensatory education, but in actuality requested a specific placement in a private facility (DDD) or a non-public school (VAC) or at home where he could receive a full-time ABA/DTT program. As indicated above, the Hearing Officer has found that Ms. Jockinsen’s SDC can meet Student’s unique needs and there is no persuasive evidence that Student needs a full-time ABA/DTT program or a non-public school placement. Further, determining a precise amount of compensatory educational services always involves a difficult appraisal of where the child might have been had he been appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA and what services are required to redress the failure to appropriately educate him. There should be a nexus between the compensatory education award and the specific loss of opportunity suffered by the child.
Given the totality of the circumstances in this case, taking into consideration the length of the deprivation and resulting loss of educational opportunity, the Hearing Officer finds that the following services are reasonably calculated to enable Student to progress to the level of functioning he would have attained had the appropriate services been provided in a timely manner: twenty-five hours of direct one-to-one instruction on his IEP goals provided by a credentialed special education teacher like Ms. Jockinsen. In addition, five hours of direct OT services and five hours of consultative OT services is sufficient to replace lost OTservices. The foregoing services may be provided in an SDC like Ms. Jockinsen’s SDC or another location agreed upon by the parties. The amount of instruction provided per day, the location of the instruction, and the time of day of instruction should be consistent with the medical opinion of Student’s treating medical specialists and should take into account Student’s ability to participate and his potential for fatigue. (Footnote 17) The compensatory education shall be completed by December 31, 2004, unless the parties otherwise agree in writing.
CONCLUSION
The District’s offer of March 2, 2004, is found to have constituted an offer of FAPE. However, the District’s offer of May 7, 2004, was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit and thus did not constitute a FAPE. Student’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for transportation costs per the parties’ stipulation at hearing. Student is entitled to compensatory education as set forth in this Decision.
ORDER
1. The District is ordered to provide Student with compensatory education of twenty-five hours of direct one-to-one instruction on his IEP goals provided by a credentialed special education teacher, along with five hours of direct OT services and five hours of consultative OT services. The foregoing services may be provided in an SDC like Ms. Jockinsen’s SDC or another location agreed upon by the parties. The amount of instruction provided per day, the location of the instruction, and the time of day of instruction should be consistent with the medical opinion of Student’s treating medical specialists and should take into account Student’s ability to participate and his potential for fatigue. The foregoing compensatory education award shall be completed by December 31, 2004, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.
2. All of the Student’s remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: As to issues one and three, the District is the prevailing party; as to issues two and four, the Student is the prevailing party.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: July 23, 2004 ______________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer
Ms. Jockinsen is referred to by her maiden name of Kelly in earlier reports and IEPs. She will be referred to by her married name of Jockinsen throughout the remainder of this Decision.
2 The issues have been restated to reflect the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. Prior to hearing, the Hearing Office issued a ruling limiting the issues of the hearing to the time frame after March 2, 2004, pursuant to the signed settlement agreement entered into by the parties in the previous due process filing.
3 Hereafter, the Hearing Officer will use “District” to refer to KCSOS and Greenfield jointly.
4 The parties stipulated at hearing that, if the Hearing Officer finds that it was appropriate that Student receive one hour per day of instruction at DDD per the District’s offer of May 7, 2004, the District will reimburse Mother for mileage from DDD to either VAC or to home per Mother’s request.
5 The Student raised the following contentions for the first time in his written closing argument. The Student contended that the District committed procedural violations when it allegedly failed to have a regular education teacher properly participate in his IEP team meetings and that the offers of March 2, 2004, and May 7, 2004, allegedly were not presented in a formal, specific, written manner so as to inform his Mother of the details of the proposed educational plans and satisfy the requirements of Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). The Student also contended that substantively the District failed to offer him a FAPE by not offering assistive technology services or a behavior intervention plan and by not ensuring his integration into the regular education population. The Student failed to raise these issues in his issues statement provided prior to hearing or to raise them on the first day of hearing when requested by the Hearing Officer to state his objections to the IEPs in question. In fact, no notice was provided to the District of these issues until receipt of the Student’s closing brief. Consequently, the District did not have notice that the foregoing would be issues for hearing and thus did not have an opportunity to present evidence on these issues at hearing. Given the lack of notice, the Hearing Officer cannot adjudicate the foregoing issues in this Decision.
6 Student was placed there by his Mother. She is not seeking reimbursement for the costs of the program.
7 The VAC program is an after-school program with an autism focus that provides instruction on play skills, socialization, and other deficits. Student has attended the VAC after-school program for approximately two and one-half years. The District has not funded and is not funding Student’s placement at the VAC after-school program and his Mother is not seeking reimbursement for the costs of the program.
8 According to Student’s doctor, grand mal seizures are currently referred to as generalized tonic clonic and atonic seizures.
9 Also located at BV.
10 Mother testified that she spoke to the substitute who did not have any information about Student’s medical needs or the requirements of Student’s IEP. The record did not reflect any other change in classroom personnel other than the replacement of Ms. Jockinsen with a substitute.
11 Ms. Jockinsen had returned from her medical emergency by that time.
12 Additionally, Dr. Fisher testified that the District was “playing games with him” and violating the law by refusing to allow him to observe Ms. Jockinsen’s class in April 2004. Dr. Fisher stated that it was his right under the law to visit the class. During his testimony, Dr. Fisher exhibited significant anger toward Ms. Bertran-Harris who was present during his testimony. As indicated in the Procedural Matters section of this Decision, the District was not required to permit Dr. Fisher to observe Ms. Jockinsen’s class.
13 Mother testified that the District has told her Student is unable to learn. The District witnesses denied ever saying such a thing to Mother .
14 The March 12, 2004, faxed letter from Dr. Koh requested that the District swipe the magnet whenever Student had a cluster of three seizures in an hour, regardless of the length of the seizure and regardless if the seizure had passed. The letter did not require that the District swipe the magnet after every seizure.
15 The offer of April 30, 2004, which was developed at an IEP team meeting of that date that Mother did not attend, was presented again at the May 7, 2004 IEP. This Decision will refer only to the May 7, 2004 offer.
16 This Decision does not preclude reconsideration of a home/hospital program should further medical information be provided to the IEP team that indicates Student’s medical needs require such a program.
17 Mother testified at hearing that she would not place Student back at BV. Should Student be placed back with the District, the hours of compensatory education are to be in addition to instruction received in his educational program to receive a FAPE.
