California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 20, 2004

Student v. San Francisco Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 972-03 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke

San Francisco Unified provided a FAPE to a fifth grader with a learning disability; request for Lindamood-Bell tutoring denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision says the student's continued eligibility, after the District proposed exiting him in November 2003, was the subject of a separate due process hearing. A residency dispute was resolved by settlement in another due process matter.

Summary

An 11-year-old student, represented by his mother, filed for due process against San Francisco Unified School District over the 2002-2003 school year. He is eligible for special education with a specific learning disability. After transferring from the Jefferson School District, he attended general education fifth grade at Caesar Chavez Elementary with resource specialist program (RSP) support. In October 2002 the District proposed cutting RSP from 200 to 135 minutes a week. The parents agreed only to the new goals, so the District kept providing the prior 200 minutes. The parents argued that he needed reading comprehension goals and 60 minutes of daily one-to-one help. They also said the District did not deliver the RSP minutes and that about a month in a Spanish-language afternoon class blocked his progress. They asked for compensatory Lindamood-Bell tutoring.

Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found the District's teachers and test results more persuasive than private psychologist Dr. Tina Guterman. Dr. Guterman had not reviewed school records, gathered teacher input, or observed the student. Reading comprehension was not an area of need. The writing and math goals were appropriate, small-group RSP met his needs, and he made substantial progress on his goals. Teacher testimony and the RSP teacher's plan book showed the services were delivered. About 12 hours in the Spanish-language class did not deny him benefit. Because the District provided a FAPE, the compensatory education request was not reached, and all relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the Rowley "some educational benefit" standard and the snapshot rule. A private evaluation carried less weight because the evaluator had not reviewed school records, gathered teacher input, or observed the student. Teacher testimony and service logs outweighed the student's own account of how much RSP service he received.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year? (Including whether the IEP needed reading comprehension goals, whether STUDENT needed 60 minutes of daily one-to-one instruction instead of RSP three times a week, whether the District delivered the RSP minutes in the February 2002 IEP, and whether a temporary move to a Spanish-language afternoon class denied benefit.)

    The Hearing Officer found reading comprehension was not an area of need, that small-group RSP with appropriate writing and math goals met the student's needs and gave him educational benefit, and that RSP services were delivered as required by the February 2002 IEP. The District offered and provided a FAPE.

  2. Issue 2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education services in the form of a multi-sensory tutoring program at Lindamood-Bell or an equal multi-sensory teaching program during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, together with related services, including transportation?

    Not reached because the District provided a FAPE.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; M.C. v. Central Regional School District; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16

People named in the decision

  • Lenore Silverman, District counsel (deputy general counsel), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Ralph Scott, special education local plan area director, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Micky Dantine, program administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Pamela Mills, District administrator; District witness, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Aruna Subramanian, RSP teacher (fifth grade); District witness, Caesar Chavez Elementary School, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Liz Kimball, fifth-grade general education (bilingual) teacher; District witness, Caesar Chavez Elementary School, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Richard Costello, fifth-grade general education teacher; District witness, Caesar Chavez Elementary School, San Francisco Unified School District
  • Matthew Kulis, sixth-grade RSP teacher; District witness, James Denman Middle School, San Francisco Unified School District
  • DeAna Soto, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessment, fall 2003), San Francisco Unified School District
  • Dr. Tina Guterman, licensed clinical psychologist and child neuropsychologist; private assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Lindamood-Bell, private multisensory tutoring provider requested as compensatory education, Private provider
  • Manti Henriquez, interpreter
  • Pilar Myers, interpreter
  • Victor Fridman, interpreter

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Francisco, California, on January 15, 16, and 20, 2004.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was present at the hearing and was represented by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on his behalf was his father, FATHER. The San Francisco Unified School District (hereafter Respondent or District) was represented by Lenore Silverman, deputy general counsel for the District. Also present on behalf of the District on different days were Ralph Scott, special education local plan area director for the District, and Micky Dantine, program administrator for the District. Present on different days of the hearing were the following interpreters: Manti Henriquez, Pilar Myers, and Victor Fridman.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: STUDENT, FATHER, MOTHER, and Dr. Tina Guterman, licensed clinical psychologist.

The following witnesses were called by the District: Pamela Mills, District administrator; Aruna Subramanian, STUDENT’s former resource specialist program (RSP) teacher; Liz Kimball, STUDENT’s former fifth-grade general education teacher; Matthew Kulis, STUDENT’s current sixth-grade RSP teacher; and Richard Costello, STUDENT’s former fifth-grade general education teacher.

Oral and documentary evidenced was received. Following receipt of the parties’ closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year? 2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education services in the form of a multi-sensory tutoring program at Lindamood-Bell or an equal multi-sensory teaching program during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, together with related services, including but not limited to transportation to and from school and between schools?

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is an eleven-year-old sixth-grade student who currently attends James Denman Middle School in the San Francisco Unified School District. STUDENT was previously enrolled in the Jefferson School District; however, in September 2002, he enrolled in the San Francisco Unified School District and attended Caesar Chavez Elementary School (Caesar Chavez) for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT qualifies for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disability and has received services through the resource specialist program (RSP).

Upon STUDENT’s enrollment in the District, STUDENT was placed in Liz Kimball’s general education fifth-grade classroom for language arts and math during the morning hours. Because Ms. Kimball’s classroom was taught in Spanish in the afternoon, after lunch, STUDENT then attended Rick Costello’s English-speaking general education class for social studies, science, art, and music. (Footnote 1)

After STUDENT had begun attending classes in the District in September 2002, MOTHER informed RSP teacher Aruna Subramanian that STUDENT had an IEP from his previous school district. Ms. Subramanian then contacted the Jefferson Unified School District and requested that STUDENT’s educational records, along with a copy of his individualized education program (IEP), be sent to the District. According to Ms. Subramanian, upon her receipt of the special education documents, she reviewed STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP to determine the level at which STUDENT had been functioning. The IEP dated February 1 and 7, 2002, contained STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented placement, and called for STUDENT to receive 200 minutes each week of RSP services to address his written expression needs. The February 2002 IEP did not indicate whether the RSP services must be provided on a “push-in” (in the general education classroom) or “pull-out” (in the RSP classroom) basis.

Ms. Subramanian then conducted individual achievement testing of STUDENT to determine the amount of progress he had made. She also asked STUDENT’s teachers to complete questionnaires about STUDENT’s academic, behavior, communication, and social skills in order to get an idea about his strengths and needs.

The District convened an IEP meeting on October 24, 2002. On the basis of Ms. Subramanian’s achievement tests, the District recommended that STUDENT’s RSP services be reduced to one hundred thirty-five (135) minutes each week, three times a week for forty-five minutes each session, on a push-in, pull-out basis. The IEP dated October 24, 2002, also contains one revised writing/editing (spelling & grammar) goal and related objectives from the previous IEP, and one goal and related objectives in the area of math. The District offered extended school year (ESY) services, along with various supports and modifications. MOTHER did not agree with the placement and services offered at the October 24, 2002 IEP meeting because she believed STUDENT required one-to-one instruction for sixty minutes each day in all academic areas, including reading comprehension. The District, therefore, continued to provide STUDENT RSP services at the prior level according to his February 2002 IEP. MOTHER did, however, sign the IEP indicating her agreement with the goals and objectives and requesting that they be implemented.

According to testimony from MOTHER, she had concerns regarding STUDENT’s progress in school, so she decided to obtain a private educational assessment to verify her instincts. Dr. Tina Guterman, licensed clinical psychologist, conducted educational testing of STUDENT on November 5 and 14, 2002, and prepared a written report. On or about February 5, 2003, Dr. Guterman participated by telephone in a conference with MOTHER and some of STUDENT’s teachers, during which Dr. Guterman indicated she believed that in addition to written expression, STUDENT required daily individual or small-group support in the areas of reading comprehension, spelling, and math. No changes were made to STUDENT’s IEP at that time; however, it was decided that Dr. Guterman would conduct some additional testing of STUDENT in the social/emotional area because, on occasion, he was “tuning out” and resisting being pulled out of class for RSP assistance. The District also decided to refer STUDENT for an AB 3632 mental health assessment; however, the parents never signed the consent for referral. Although Dr. Guterman conducted the additional social/emotional testing, she did not produce a report with the results. The meeting was left unfinished and rescheduled for February 26, 2003. No IEP meeting occurred in February 2003, and the record is unclear as to why no meeting was held.

In early spring of 2003, STUDENT’s continued resistance to being pulled out for RSP led to some behavioral problems in class. According to one of his general education teachers, Richard Costello, STUDENT started becoming defiant, would resist RSP support, and would shut down and refuse to work in class. As a result, a behavior checklist was created to address STUDENT’s unwillingness to attend RSP class and to help STUDENT keep distractions down to a minimum. On or about March 27, 2003, FATHER and STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Costello, had a telephone discussion about implementation of STUDENT’s behavior plan and the fact that STUDENT had to forego recess because he did not bring his behavior plan checklist to school. As a result of the telephone conversation, both FATHER and Mr. Costello became upset and FATHER went to the school that same day. MOTHER also came to the school on March 27, 2003, at which time the parents requested that STUDENT be removed from Mr. Costello’s afternoon general education class due to their concerns with STUDENT’s reports that Mr. Costello yelled at and embarrassed him in class and in front of other students. (Footnote 2) Due to the parents’ request that STUDENT be removed from Mr. Costello’s class, when STUDENT returned to school after spring break, he began attending Liz Kimball’s fifth-grade general education class in the afternoons, where the instruction was given in Spanish. Therefore, from the end of April 2003 to the end of May 2003, STUDENT remained in Ms. Kimball’s class for both the morning session and the afternoon session that was taught in Spanish.

On May 6, 2003, the Hearing Office received the parents’ request for this due process hearing, but the matter was taken off calendar at the request of the parties in order to participate in mediation.

Another IEP meeting was noticed for May 14, 2003, and MOTHER wrote the District on May 13, 2003, asking it to cancel that meeting and reschedule it to a different date. When the 2003-2004 school year began, an assessment plan was developed and signed by MOTHER on September 23, 2003. During September and October 2003, District psychologist DeAna Soto conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT and prepared a report of her findings dated October 23, 2003. The next IEP meeting occurred on November 3, 2003, at which time the District recommended that STUDENT be removed from the special education program. (Footnote 3) MOTHER attended the IEP meeting, but did not agree with the IEP and refused to sign the IEP document.

By letter dated November 26, 2003, MOTHER requested that this matter be placed back on the hearing calendar and scheduled for a hearing.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer and provide him with a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that the District failed to write any goals and objectives in reading comprehension. Petitioner also contends that the District should have offered to provide him one-to-one assistance for sixty minutes each day rather than RSP assistance only three times a week. Petitioner contends that because he was moved to a Spanish-speaking classroom and had difficulty understanding much of the class work, he did not make any academic progress. Petitioner also argues that the District did not address his math and written expression needs because the District failed to provide the amount of RSP services required by his February 1 and 7, 2002 IEP. As a remedy, Petitioner is seeking compensatory education services in a multisensory tutoring program at Lindamood Bell or an equal multisensory teaching program during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, together with related services, including, but not limited to, transportation to and from school and between schools.

The District argues that STUDENT met his IEP goals and is performing within the average range in all academic areas. The District also argues that STUDENT received RSP services as set forth in the IEP and requests that Petitioner’s request for relief be denied.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student=s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a FAPE, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, provide some benefit, and comport with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which means ensuring that STUDENT=s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comported with his IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 4)

What are STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine the appropriateness of the District’s offered program and placement, the Hearing Officer must first identify STUDENT’s needs during the 2002-2003 school year. The parents agree with clinical psychologist and child neuropsychologist Dr. Tina Guterman’s assessment of STUDENT that was conducted in November 2002. According to Dr. Guterman’s testing, STUDENT had broadly average range cognitive abilities, but his sight reading, reading comprehension, and written expression skills were significantly below his cognitive ability and two years below his then-current grade level. (Dist.’s Exh. 44.) Dr. Guterman also diagnosed STUDENT with a reading disorder and a disorder of written expression as defined by the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-IV and believed STUDENT needed support with reading comprehension. Based on the information obtained from her assessment, Dr. Guterman believed that STUDENT needed increased one-to-one assistance, on a daily basis, for reading, spelling, written language, and math. Dr. Guterman also opined that material should be presented to STUDENT through multisensory and experientially based formats so that complex and abstract tasks could be broken down into small, concrete steps, and symbolic material linked by supplemental contextual cues and prompts. (Footnote 5)

The District agreed that STUDENT had difficulty with basic math operations, spelling, and writing, including structure and detail. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) Thus, all parties agreed that STUDENT needed assistance in the areas of writing/editing and math. A significant area of disagreement between the parties as to STUDENT’s needs, however, was with respect to whether he required any support for reading comprehension. The parents believed STUDENT required assistance with reading comprehension. The District disagreed, believing STUDENT’s reading comprehension skills were at grade level.

STUDENT’s general education fifth-grade teachers, Richard Costello and Liz Kimball, and RSP teacher, Aruna Subramanian, all either testified or reported that STUDENT showed good comprehension skills, had strong vocabulary, used context clues for meaning, shared ideas, and enjoyed explaining things to others. (Footnote 6) (Dist.’s Exhs. 30, 32, & 59.) District witnesses also credibly testified that although STUDENT had some problems with sight words, his reading comprehension skills, as demonstrated by class tests and discussions and his input in conversations, were at grade level. (Testimonies of L. Kimball and R. Costello.)

The testimony of District witnesses was supported by the results of testing. Ms. Subramanian administered the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R) to STUDENT in October 2002, and STUDENT performed in the average range for all subtests, including reading comprehension, showing only relative weaknesses in reading recognition and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 59.) As of the October 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT was performing at the high fourth-grade instructional level in reading comprehension and in class, he was capable of reading at the fifth-grade level. (Testimonies of A. Subramanian and L. Kimball.) Moreover, STUDENT’s last agreed upon and implemented IEP dated February 1 and 7, 2002, from the Jefferson School District listed reading comprehension as an area of strength for STUDENT. (Dist.’s Exh. 34.) Jefferson School District’s administration of the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test G on January 31, 2002, indicated that STUDENT was then reading at the overall standard score of 99, which is average, and had improved his standard score of 87 in 2001 on the passage comprehension subtest to 99 in 2002. (Dist.’s Exh. 34.)

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s evidence regarding STUDENT’s reading comprehension needs more persuasive than Dr. Guterman’s. Dr. Guterman did not obtain any input from STUDENT’s teachers, and she acknowledged that it would have been helpful to have such information before conducting her testing. Additionally, Dr. Guterman did not observe STUDENT in school and did not have the benefit of having reviewed any previous testing done by the District or STUDENT’s previous school district. Dr. Guterman testified that she typically reviews a student’s background information before she conducts her testing, but she was unable to review any of STUDENT’s educational records beforehand because the parents wanted her to test STUDENT without having any information that was produced by a school district. (Testimonies of MOTHER and T. Guterman.). Dr. Guterman also testified that she was not familiar with the State standards for fifth-grade curriculum. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Dr. Guterman had extremely limited information on which to conclude that STUDENT required support in reading comprehension.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT did not have needs in the area of reading comprehension that should have been addressed in his IEP. However, the evidence did demonstrate that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of written expression and math that needed to be addressed through more intensive instruction than he would receive in a general education class. The dispute, as discussed below, is whether STUDENT required daily one-to-one instruction or whether his needs could be met through small-group instruction in an RSP environment, three days a week.

Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs

As indicated above, when STUDENT enrolled in the District, his parents did not inform the District that he had previously received special education services while at the Jefferson School District. However, when MOTHER informed the school that STUDENT was a special education student, the District requested his IEP from Jefferson, and upon receipt of his educational records, it began providing services. On October 24, 2002, the IEP team reviewed and determined STUDENT’s current levels of performance based on assessment, observation, work samples, and his progress on previous objectives, and then drafted goals and objectives to address his identified areas of need. (Testimony of A. Subramanian; see also Dist.’s Exhs. 30, 32, 34 & 59.) In analyzing the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated October 24, 2002, the Hearing Officer first addresses whether the goals and objectives were appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s needs as identified above.

The IEP included goals and objectives that addressed STUDENT’s identified areas of deficit in writing/editing and math. For example, the IEP included one writing/editing goal and three related objectives designed to help STUDENT learn to check his work in order to correct the spelling, grammar, and structural errors and to ultimately produce written work with less than three errors per paragraph. In the area of math, the IEP included a math goal and three objectives that would help STUDENT identify operations and solve equations for word problems, demonstrate the steps for long division problems, and demonstrate knowledge of multiplication tables from zero to ten. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) The parties did not dispute the appropriateness of the goals and objectives that were developed to address STUDENT’s identified deficits in writing/editing and math. However, Petitioner argued that the IEP should have included goals and objectives in the area of reading comprehension. However, as discussed by the Hearing Officer above, neither the assessments, class work, nor input from STUDENT’s teachers indicated that STUDENT had deficits in the area of reading comprehension that needed to be addressed in his IEP.

The Hearing Officer now turns her attention to the placement offered by the District to address the goals and objectives included in the IEP. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight…an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).) However, the “snapshot” rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a student’s educational program if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the student is not receiving any educational benefit.

To address STUDENT’s writing/editing and math needs, the District recommended STUDENT be placed in the general education fifth-grade classroom and receive RSP services (up to 135 minutes/week - 3 sessions each week for 45 minutes), during which his writing/editing and math goals would be addressed. The IEP also included extended school year services (ESY), visual aides to support instruction, peer and individual assistance, and extra time for completion of assignments. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) Based on STUDENT’s teachers’ comments, his progress on the goals from his Jefferson School District (Jefferson) IEP, and District testing, the District recommended a decrease in RSP services from the 200 minutes each week that was allotted in his February 2002 IEP, to 135 minutes each week. (Testimony of A. Subramanian.)

Since the parents only agreed with the goals and objectives in the October 24, 2002 IEP, during the 2002-2003 school year, the District continued to provide the same amount of RSP services identified in STUDENT’s February 1 and 7, 2002 IEP from Jefferson. (Dist.’s Exh. 34.) (Footnote 7) Petitioner argued that he required one-to-one assistance for sixty minutes each day of the week rather than RSP services only three times each week, as proposed by the District. Although the District continued to provide STUDENT 200 minutes of RSP services pursuant to the February 2002 IEP, the District argued that the decreased RSP services offered in the October 2002 IEP were appropriate, and witnesses provided an abundance of evidence indicating that STUDENT required only minimal assistance in order to progress in the general education curriculum.

For example, Ms. Subramanian testified that at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s academic achievement scores were all in the average range, he worked hard, was very cooperative and engaged, and showed more success in the general education class compared to other students in the class. Ms. Subramanian also stated that she pulled STUDENT out for RSP services twice a week for 120 minutes (Tues. – 1 hour; Wed. – 1 hour) to assist him with reading, writing, and oral language. According to Ms. Subramanian, there were usually eight to ten other students in the RSP room and there were three different centers for the reading, writing, and oral language sessions. Students were placed into small groups of three to receive instruction and all three groups were linked together by the content of the materials. Ms. Subramanian testified that during STUDENT’s RSP sessions, they worked on his October 2002 goals, using a variety of techniques, including using the spelling/grammar check on computers, using graphic writing organizers such as the Kidspiration program and writing prompts, and reading aloud and circling words to help STUDENT identify and edit his mistakes.

Ms. Subramanian also pulled STUDENT out for RSP services once each week for 45 minutes to work on math, and she “pushed-in” to the class 30 to 40 minutes each week to provide STUDENT additional RSP assistance with math. When STUDENT was pulled out for RSP math instruction, there was only one other student in the group with him, and that student also was in the fifth grade. (Testimony of A. Subramanian.) Ms. Subramanian testified that during RSP math instruction, they worked on multiplication, division, fractions, word problems and problems involving money. During push-in math sessions, Ms. Subramanian would check STUDENT’s class work and support him during the class when necessary. According to Ms. Subramanian, STUDENT often reported that the work in class was too easy and nothing indicated to Ms. Subramanian that STUDENT needed one-to-one daily assistance.

Liz Kimball was one of STUDENT’s general education fifth grade teachers and her testimony corroborated other witnesses’ testimony regarding the appropriateness of STUDENT’s placement in general education with the support of the RSP program three times each week. Ms. Kimball testified that she was able to work on STUDENT’s IEP goals because writing and multiplication/division were a large part of her curriculum. Ms. Kimball’s class instruction included teaching students how to use a dictionary and thesaurus, learning new grammar rules, peer editing with a partner in class, and various writing modeling techniques. In math, Ms. Kimball testified that they worked on word problems each week and students used flash cards to practice and memorize their multiplication and division tables. Ms. Kimball testified that STUDENT possessed the skills necessary to progress in the general education curriculum and although he was not always accurate, he demonstrated that he could do the work.

Psychologist Tina Guterman contended that because STUDENT had difficulty dealing with more abstract language, he required daily one-to-one and small group support in order to help him “break down” tasks and provide links in the material so he could understand. However, Dr. Guterman offered very limited support for the position that STUDENT required one-to-one or small group support on a daily basis. Moreover, as indicated above, the witness testimony confirmed that fully including STUDENT in the general education classroom with the support of the RSP three times each week met his needs. Providing RSP support to STUDENT once a week in the classroom and three times a week in the RSP room to explain information to STUDENT, work on his writing/editing and math goals, and to facilitate his learning, allowed STUDENT to still be a part of the general classroom and have the opportunity to receive additional support on a small group basis.

In summary, the evidence establishes that during the 2002-2003 school year, appropriate goals and objectives were drafted to address STUDENT=s specific needs. Additionally, interventions in writing/editing and math were carried out weekly in his general education fifth-grade class and through RSP instruction each week.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a program that met his unique needs during the 2002-2003 school year. In addition, although the proposed placement, program, and services offered in the IEP dated October 24, 2002, included 65 minutes less of RSP services than the prior IEP, there was no persuasive evidence that the difference of 65 minutes is significant enough to change the Hearing Officer’s determination that RSP small-group instruction was sufficient to meet STUDENT’s needs in writing/editing and math. Moreover, the fact that STUDENT participated in an after-school homework tutoring lab with some success at the end of the school year does not affect the appropriateness of the October 24, 2002 IEP. (Footnote 8) (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999).) Therefore, the District’s October 24, 2002 IEP offer was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit

The next determination is whether the District=s offer and provision of services during the 2002-2003 school year were calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District=s proposed program must have been reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of Asome@ benefit. (Id., 142 F.3d at 130; M.C. v. Central Regional School District, 81 F.3d 389, 393 (3d Cir. 1996).) Of course, a child=s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his/her disability and must be gaged in relation to the child=s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 185 (3d Cir. 1988).)

The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s IEP during the 2002-2003 school year was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit and, in fact, did provide him with benefit. All of the District personnel working with STUDENT essentially testified that STUDENT made more than minimal progress after he began receiving RSP services at the end of September 2002. (See Pet.’s Exh. 2; Dist.=s Exhs. 28 & 49.) Ms. Kimball stated that by the end of the 2002-2003 school year, despite occasional problems, STUDENT was an average student doing sufficiently well in general education and capable of doing the work. Ms. Kimball also testified that STUDENT learned various writing strategies, which allowed him to improve his grammar and writing mechanics, and by January 2003, STUDENT was taking more risks by trying different learning strategies, especially in math. Ms. Kimball stated that although STUDENT made careless errors and would sometimes forget to check his work, by the end of the school year, he made more of an effort in math and understood the concepts. In addition, on his May 2003 report card, Ms. Kimball reported that STUDENT achieved “competent performance” in almost all academic areas. His limitations were in his ability to communicate mathematical thinking and compute accurately, and he needed to improve in certain areas involving personal responsibility. (Dist.’s Exh. 49.)

Ms. Subramanian testified that STUDENT made progress on his writing goals and when he was being cooperative, he could do most of the tasks listed in his writing/editing objectives. In math, Ms. Subramanian stated that by June 2003, although he still made mistakes, STUDENT had the skills that were addressed in his goals and objectives.

STUDENT’s final progress report dated June 6, 2003, indicates that he met the first objective of his writing goal and made “substantial progress” on the second and third writing objectives. In math, he made “substantial progress” on all three objectives. (Dist.’s Exh. 28.) STUDENT’s current sixth-grade RSP teacher, Matthew Kulis, testified that at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT was performing within the sixth-grade instructional level in writing, meeting or moving towards mastery of areas in math that he needed to learn, doing complex algebraic equations in his head without needing to write down his steps, and performing in the average range in both reading fluency and comprehension.

Petitioner argued that because he was moved to a Spanish-speaking classroom where he had difficulty understanding much of the class work, he did not make academic progress during the 2002-2003 school year. According to MOTHER, although STUDENT speaks Spanish, he does not read or write in Spanish. At the parents’ request, from the end of April 2003 to the end of May 2003, STUDENT was removed from Mr. Costello’s afternoon English-speaking class and placed in Ms. Kimball’s afternoon Spanish-speaking. According to both Ms. Kimball and Ms. Subramanian, due to MOTHER’s pulling STUDENT out of school early each day, his late start back to school after spring break, his attending RSP two days a week during the afternoon, and his attending art class every Friday afternoon, STUDENT only spent a total of approximately twelve hours in Ms. Kimball’s Spanish speaking afternoon class. (Footnote 9) Petitioner did not dispute the District’s calculation of time he spent in Ms. Kimball’s class. Moreover, Ms. Kimball’s afternoon class focused on social studies and science, neither of which is an identified area of need for STUDENT. Although STUDENT was placed in what may have been a less than ideal class for twelve hours of instruction, the Hearing Officer finds that the temporary class change did not prevent STUDENT from receiving academic benefit because he continued to receive RSP services and make progress on his goals and objectives. (Testimonies of L. Kimball and A. Subramanian.)

Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the placement, program, and services provided during the 2002-2003 school year were designed to and did provide STUDENT with educational benefit. In addition, given that the placement, program, and services outlined in the IEP dated October 24, 2002, are substantially similar to those actually provided during the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer contained in the IEP dated October 24, 2002, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

Conform to the IEP

Petitioner contends that during the 2002-2003 school year, the District did not provide the program and services pursuant to his last agreed upon and implemented IEP dated February 1 and 7, 2002, from the Jefferson School District. Specifically, Petitioner contends that the District did not provide him the two hundred minutes of RSP each week, but instead, only provided him RSP services one time each week for thirty minutes. The District contends that STUDENT received RSP services as set forth in his February 2002 IEP.

STUDENT’s February 2002 IEP states that he is to receive two hundred minutes each week of RSP services that focus on written expression skills. (Dist.’s Exh. 34.) However, since the parents agreed to the goals and objectives outlined in the October 24, 2002 IEP, STUDENT was to receive RSP services in both writing/editing and in math. (Dist.’s Exh. 30.) STUDENT testified that during the entire 2002-2003 school year, Ms. Subramanian only pulled him out of class for RSP services one time each week for thirty minutes. According to STUDENT, Ms. Subramanian helped him with math, reading, and writing during their sessions. STUDENT also stated that Ms. Subramanian never came into his general education class to help him.

Ms. Subramanian testified that she maintained a record in her plan book of the times she provided RSP services to STUDENT last year. According to Ms. Subramanian, she consistently provided RSP services to STUDENT at the rate required by the February 2002 IEP, unless a special event was occurring in class or the class took a field trip. As discussed earlier, Ms. Subramanian testified that during the RSP sessions, she worked on STUDENT’s writing/editing and math goals and objectives from his October 2002 IEP. Ms. Subramanian also stated that when she “pushed-in” and provided RSP services in the general education classroom, she would support STUDENT during the math lesson and when he worked with a partner, as he often did, she would work with both of them, checking to see how they were doing and providing assistance when necessary.

Both of STUDENT’s general education teachers, Ms. Kimball and Mr. Costello, confirmed that during the 2002-2003 school year, Ms. Subramanian pulled STUDENT from class during the afternoons two times each week for RSP services. Moreover, Ms. Kimball testified that Ms. Subramanian consistently “pushed-in” to her class and made herself available to assist STUDENT. Ms. Kimball also stated that she witnessed Ms. Subramanian using a variety of instructional approaches with STUDENT to be sure he received the support that he needed.

The Hearing Officer finds that the teachers provided credible testimony about the amount of RSP services that STUDENT was provided. Although STUDENT testified that he was only pulled out one time each week for RSP, the Hearing Officer gives STUDENT’s testimony little weight because he appeared to have no memory of other events that occurred that all of his teachers testified about. For instance, all of STUDENT’s teachers testified about the meeting at school with STUDENT and his mother regarding STUDENT’s behavior and how STUDENT was defiant, rude to his mother, and stated that he would tear up the behavior plan. But STUDENT testified that he had no recollection of that meeting. Moreover, MOTHER did not dispute testimony about what occurred at that meeting and the fact that STUDENT attended that meeting. The Hearing Officer finds it unpersuasive that STUDENT could recall nothing about that meeting but could recall that for the entire school year he was allegedly only pulled out once each week and never received any push-in RSP services. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that based on the credible testimony of District witnesses, STUDENT was provided RSP services during the 2002-2003 school year in conformity with his IEP dated February 1 and 7, 2002.

Conclusion

On the basis of the findings above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program, placement and services provided by the District during the 2002-2003 school year and offered in the IEP dated October 24, 2002, were designed to meet STUDENT=s needs, were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP. Accordingly, the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.

2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, is he entitled to compensatory education services in the form of a multi-sensory tutoring program at Lindamood-Bell or an equal multi-sensory teaching program during the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year, together with related services, including but not limited to transportation to and from school and between schools?

The Hearing Officer does not reach this issue given the decision regarding issue one above.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: February 20, 2004 ____________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

According to MOTHER, STUDENT speaks Spanish, but he does not read or write in Spanish

2 During the course of the school year, the parties were in dispute regarding whether the PARENTS resided within the District’s attendance boundaries and at one point in time, the District withdrew STUDENT from Caesar Chavez Elementary School. However, in another due process matter involving both STUDENT and the District, the parties reached a settlement that resolved the residency issue and allowed STUDENT to remain a student in the District and enrolled at Caesar Chavez.

3 The issue of STUDENT’s eligibility to continue to receive special education services is currently the subject of a separate due process hearing and is not considered in this Decision.

4 The Hearing Officer notes that the parties do not dispute whether the District’s offered program was provided in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, requirement four noted above will not be discussed in this Decision.

5 Dr. Guterman testified that she has a Ph.D. in clinical psychology and has been a licensed clinical psychologist since 1996. She has been a trained child neuropsychologist for eleven years and is a member of the National Academy of Neuropsychologists.

6 Mr. Costello testified that he obtained a bachelor’s degree from University of California, Los Angeles, and a cross cultural language and academic development certificate and multiple subject teaching credential from the University of San Francisco. This is his fifth year teaching and he spent four years teaching at Caesar Chavez Elementary School (Caesar Chavez). He currently teaches all subjects of a fourth/fifth grade class at E.R. Taylor Elementary School Ms. Kimball testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in psychology and obtained a bilingual teaching credential from San Francisco State University and a clear credential from University of California, Santa Cruz. Ms. Kimball has been teaching for seven years, four of which she has spent with the District. Ms. Subramanian testified that she recently completed her master’s degree in special education and she has a credential as an educational specialist in moderate to severe disabilities. This is her eighth year teaching as a credentialed teacher and she has taught at Caesar Chavez for the last three years.

7 The February 2002 IEP did not specify whether the RSP services should be provided on a “pull-out” or “push-in” basis.

8 Starting around the middle of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT started participating in an after-school homework lab at Caesar Chavez, which was available to all students. Four days each week, from 4-5 p.m., STUDENT received assistance with his homework and STUDENT even helped the younger students with their homework. (Testimony of A Subramanian.) Both Ms. Subramanian and STUDENT reported that his participation in the homework lab helped him understand class material and do better with his homework.

9 From the end of April 2003 to the end of May 2003, STUDENT only spent Monday and Thursday afternoons in Ms. Kimball’s Spanish-speaking afternoon class. According to Ms. Subramanian, this amounted to eight days, or twelve hours.