California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 4, 2000
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 973-99 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Capistrano Unified prevails: a gifted tenth grader who failed classes was found ineligible under all three claimed categories.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader's parent filed for due process against Capistrano Unified School District, claiming he qualified for special education. The student has very superior intelligence (full-scale IQ of 143) and scored at or above grade level on achievement tests. He still failed many high school classes, mostly because he did not turn in work. District IEP teams found him ineligible in April 1999 and again in June 2000. The student argued he qualified under emotional disturbance, specific learning disability, or other health impairment based on attention deficit disorder.
Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait denied every claim. On emotional disturbance, psychologists Loren O'Connor and Walter Ernsdorf both found that the student met none of the five criteria. The student's own private psychologist, Dr. Jacqueline Shohet, testified that she could not conclude he met them. One spitting incident did not show inappropriate behavior over a long period and to a marked degree. On learning disability, the experts agreed there was a severe gap between ability and achievement in written expression. However, the Hearing Officer found no disorder in a basic psychological process. He gave little weight to Dr. Shohet's auditory and visual processing scores because of signs of poor effort and contrary district test results. On other health impairment, no professional had diagnosed attention deficit disorder, and teachers saw no attention problems. No remedy was ordered.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied California's learning-disability test. A severe gap between ability and achievement was not enough without proof of a processing disorder. It also shows a Hearing Officer weighing whether test results were valid and discounting private scores when the record suggested the student had not tried.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services because he is emotionally disturbed?
Both psychologists who assessed social-emotional status found none of the five serious emotional disturbance criteria met over a long period and to a marked degree, and Student's own expert could not conclude otherwise; one spitting incident did not establish a pattern.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability?
A severe discrepancy existed in written expression, but the preponderance of evidence showed no disorder in a basic psychological process; the private assessor's auditory and visual processing scores were given little weight because of poor effort and contrary district test results.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 3. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services because he is other health impaired?
No professional who examined Student diagnosed ADD or ADHD, and teachers saw no attention problems, so he did not qualify as other health impaired.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of Petitioner's claims denied.
Key authorities
34 CFR 300.7; Education Code section 56026; Education Code section 56339(a); 5 CCR 3030(f), (i), (j)
People named in the decision
- Dennis Robertson, Director of Special Education, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robert White, SELPA director, South Orange County SELPA
- Robert G. Roice, educational consultant representing District (non-attorney), Capistrano Unified School District
- Brenda Dahlgren, sixth-grade teacher, Capistrano Unified School District
- Mr. Butera, English teacher, San Clemente High School
- Loren O'Connor, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robin Veit, resource specialist (academic assessor), Capistrano Unified School District
- Lori Steiner, speech-language pathologist (assessor), Capistrano Unified School District
- Jacqueline Shohet, private psychologist/assessor; expert witness for Student, Private
- Sandy Flockton, resource specialist (academic assessor), Capistrano Unified School District
- Walter S. Ernsdorf, psychologist (social-emotional assessor), Assessor under agreed assessment plan
- Yasuko Ozawa, Japanese teacher, San Clemente High School
- Sally J. Okumura-Clain, counselor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Mr. Scherbart, biology teacher, San Clemente High School
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The hearing in this case was conducted on August 31 and September 1, 2000, in San Juan Capistrano by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by attorney Kathleen Loyer. Also present on behalf of Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER.
Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented by Robert G. Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of the District was Dennis Robertson, director of Special Education, and Robert White, director of the South Orange County SELPA.
Evidence was received and the matter was continued to receive written closing briefs from the parties. The record was closed on October 4, 2000, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Is STUDENT eligible for special education services?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 16-year-old young man who was in the tenth grade during the 1999-2000 school year. He is highly intelligent, but has a recent history of academic difficulties.
During the fourth grade, STUDENT received satisfactory or outstanding grades in all subjects. During the fifth grade he received A’s and B’s in reading, language, mathematics, social studies, spelling, physical education, art, health and science. He received C’s in handwriting and music.
During the sixth grade, STUDENT’s parents divorced. His grades began to fall. By the end of the year, he was receiving grades of “unsatisfactory” or “needs improvement” in reading, writing, spelling, social studies, and science. His grades in math were mixed. He received an A- in math facts and a C- in math concepts, but received “needs improvement” in applications and problem solving, and mathematical communication. He received grades of “satisfactory” in art, music, physical education, penmanship, and technology. His behavior was becoming a problem. He was rated as unsatisfactory in 14 of the 15 categories relating to work habits, study skills and behavior. His teacher, Brenda Dahlgren, stated:
STUDENT completed only a few in-class and homework assignments this school year. He seldom read assigned or independent novels. He also did not do any assigned novel projects, math activities, science or social studies projects despite the fact that he is an extremely capable student. STUDENT’s behavior inside and outside the classroom was very disrespectful and disruptive to both the teacher and other students. He was suspended 4 days outside of school and had numerous in-house suspensions for his conduct in the classroom and playground. STUDENT is a smart boy who has chosen not to use his academic abilities at school.
STUDENT’s parents enrolled him in a private military academy in Missouri during his seventh and eighth grade years. He did well academically during these years, but continued to exhibit behavior problems.
STUDENT was enrolled in ninth grade at San Clemente High School during the l998-99 school year. During the fall semester, STUDENT received grades of “F” in Spanish, English, and world history. He received a “D” in geometry, a “C” in biology, a “B” in concert band, and an “A” in marching band. His failing grades were caused primarily by his failure to turn in homework. In the report of his performance during the first month of the fall semester, each of his teachers noted that he had “late/incomplete/missing work.”
In STUDENT’s English class, he received his fall grade based upon the points he received for 73 different assignments and tests. Of the 73 assignments and tests, STUDENT received thirty-three A’s, five B’s, one C, one D, and thirty-three F’s. STUDENT’s English teacher, Mr. Butera, testified that STUDENT’s F’s resulted from his failure to do assigned work. When he did the work, he received excellent grades. Mr. Butera also testified that STUDENT told him at the end of the semester that he would have the best grade in the class during the spring semester. Mr. Butera said that at the sixth week reporting period for the spring semester, STUDENT had an A+ and was at the top of his class. At that point, STUDENT slowly stopped working. Mr. Butera testified that if STUDENT chose to do the work, he would consistently achieve high grades, but he chose not to do the work. On December 9, 1999, a student study team was convened to review STUDENT’s academic difficulties. It is not clear from the evidence whether STUDENT’s mother requested an assessment for special education at this meeting. One form (Petitioner’s exhibit 5) indicates that the parent had requested an evaluation, and another form (Petitioner’s exhibit 6) indicates that there would not be a referral to special education. STUDENT’s mother testified that the District advised her against pursuing a special education assessment and she agreed to accept the District’s recommendation.
STUDENT continued to fail in his academic endeavors during the spring semester and, on February 10, 1999, STUDENT’s mother approved an assessment plan that had been prepared by the District. The assessment plan called for evaluation in the areas of academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, communication development, intellectual/cognitive development, and health.
On March 11, 23, and 24, 1999, STUDENT was assessed by school psychologist Loren O’Connor. Dr. O’Conner spent over 15 hours with STUDENT during the assessment and administered a variety of testing instruments. They included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children (WISC-III), the Beery-Buktencia Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), the Kinetic Family Drawing, the Beck Depression Inventory, a Written Language Sample, the Bender Gestalt Test, Beck Anxiety Inventory, the Sentence Completion Test, the Adolescent Symptom Inventory - IV, the SNAP IV - Teacher Rating Scale, the SNAP IV - Parent Rating Scale, the Attention Deficit Disorder Evaluation Scale (ADDES) School Version and Home Version, the Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory (MACI), the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory - Adolescent (MMPI-A), and the Emotional and Behavior Problem Scale. Dr. O’Conner also spoke to STUDENT’s teachers and interviewed both STUDENT and his mother. STUDENT demonstrated a full score I.Q. of 143, which is in the very superior range of intellectual functioning.
Dr. O’Conner concluded in his report dated April 20, 1999:
It is this examiner’s opinion that STUDENT does not have a learning disability in the area of attention which would impact his educational performance and academic achievement. STUDENT is a bright young man with much potential who has exhibited a turbulent family history. He is an extremely gifted student who is not highly motivated.
Dr. O’Conner set forth in his report the statutory criteria for determining whether a student is emotionally disturbed and concluded that “STUDENT does not exhibit any of the above criteria as an emotionally disturbed adolescent.”
Dr. O’Conner further concluded that “Test results do not indicate the existence of a Specific Learning Disability....”
At the conclusion of his report, Dr. O’Conner states:
STUDENT is a talented, bright young man who has many capabilities. It is the examiner’s opinion that STUDENT is not emotionally disturbed nor does he exhibit any learning disabilities. STUDENT is generally well-behaved in the school environment and has the capability to be extremely successful both academically and socially.
On March 12, 1999, Resource Specialist Robin Veit administered the Woodcock Johnson Psychoeducational Battery, which measures cognitive ability, achievement and interest. STUDENT scored at or significantly above grade level in all portions of the test. His grade equivalence for the various portions of the test was 16.9 for broad reading, 16.9 for broad math, 9.4 for broad written language and 14.3 for broad knowledge. Ms. Veit concluded that “STUDENT appears to be an extremely bright and capable student. His test scores reflect no areas of concern and [he] would not benefit from Special Education services at this time.”
On March 16, 1999, a speech and language assessment was performed on STUDENT by speech and language pathologist Lori Steiner. STUDENT ranked between the sixty-first and ninety-fifth percentile on all tests in relation to his peers. Ms. Steiner concluded that “assessment results indicate that STUDENT demonstrated exceptional skills in the areas of expressive and receptive language, auditory memory and auditory processing.”
On April 2, 1999, an IEP meeting was held to review the results of the assessments. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services. STUDENT’s mother, signed the IEP.
STUDENT’s final spring semester grades were lower than those of the fall semester. He received F’s in Spanish, English, geometry, aviation science, and reading improvement. His only passing grade was a C in biology. He had been disqualified from participation in concert and marching band because of his low grades during the fall semester.
On June 21, 1999, STUDENT’s mother requested a due process hearing. After the request for hearing, the parties engaged in mediation in an attempt to resolve the dispute. As a result of the mediation, the student study team met on September 8, 1999, to review STUDENT’s class schedule. The team recommended that STUDENT participate in group counseling.
During the fall semester of the l999-2000 school year STUDENT’s grades were slightly better than in the previous semester, but it was clear that he was not working up to his potential. He received an “F” in English, “D’s” in world history, Japanese, and chemistry, and a “C” in geometry. STUDENT regularly participated in group counseling during this time.
In December 1999, the parties agreed to have a different team assess STUDENT in the areas of social emotional and academics. The assessment plan was signed by STUDENT’s mother in January 2000. Prior to the assessment that was envisioned in the assessment plan, STUDENT’s mother arranged for him to be assessed by Dr. Jacqueline Shohet during January 2000.
In her report dated January 23, 2000, Dr. Shohet analyzed the results of tests that she administered, which included the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT), Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills (TAPS), Test of Visual-Perceptual Skills(TVPS), and the Test of Visual-Motor Skills (TVMS). She also reviewed the assessment done by Dr. O’Connor in March 1999. Dr. Shohet concluded:
STUDENT is a 16-year-old young man who completed the WIAT. STUDENT demonstrated personal strength in Reading Comprehension on the WIAT. He demonstrated relatively weak skills in Written Expression on the WIAT. Considering his level of intellectual functioning, STUDENT demonstrates a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement in written language skills. The previous assessment by Dr. O’Connor also identified written language as a problem for STUDENT but did not cite it as a disability.
There appears to be some auditory processing problems that involve memory for words, numbers and interpretation of directions as well as visual processing problems in sequential memory. Both of these areas may require further diagnosis.
In addition, judging from Dr. O’Connor’s report, STUDENT presents as having emotional problems that meet the criteria of DSM IV Adjustment Disorder 309.28 With Mixed Anxiety and Depressed Mood. “By definition, an Adjustment Disorder...may persist for a prolonged period (longer than 6 month) if they occur in response to a chronic stressor...that has enduring consequences (e.g...emotional difficulties resulting from a divorce).”
On February 17, 2000, STUDENT’s academic performance was assessed by Resource Specialist Sandy Flockton, who administered the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised. STUDENT’s standard scores on the test ranged from 108 in written expression to 117 in reading comprehension. His percentile ranking ranged from 70 in written expression to 87 in reading comprehension. His total test score resulted in a standard score of 123, which gave him a percentile rank of 94.
On March 23, 2000, STUDENT was assessed by psychologist Walter S. Ernsdorf in the area of social-emotional status pursuant to the assessment plan agreed to by the parties. Dr. Ernsdorf based his conclusions on a number of factors including an interview of STUDENT and his mother, a review of previous testing done by Dr. O’Connor, and additional testing performed by him. The assessment tools that Dr. Ernsdorf administered included the SnapIV Rating Scale completed by his parent and five of his teachers, the ADHD Rating Scale - Self Report, the Multidimensional Self Concept Scale (MSCS), the Multi Dimensional Depression Inventory (MDI), the Differential Test of Conduct and Emotional Problems (DT/CEP), the Child Behavior Checklist(CBCL), and the Rorschach.
Dr. Ernsdorf concluded:
STUDENT is a boy with superior intelligence who also has above average academic skills. Current testing reveals narcissistic traits which appear to explain his disruptive behaviors and anger at home. STUDENT’s self-focus also interferes with his social judgment and ability to empathize with others. He would be expected to be both unrealistic about his expectations and easily frustrated when his needs aren’t met. During these periods STUDENT would be quick to anger and to become defiant.
STUDENT does not exhibit a learning disability or meet the Emotionally Disturbed criteria. Although he is manifesting some ADHD behaviors, they would be better accounted for by other dynamics.
During the first part of the spring semester, STUDENT’s grades continued to suffer. On March 15, 2000, he transferred to the Fresh Start Program, which consisted of home-based instruction. His final grades for the spring semester were greatly improved over his previous grades. He received A’s in world history, English I, English II, and reading improvement. He received an “F” in his ROP course.
An IEP team meeting was convened on June 19, 2000, to review the assessments, including the assessment by Dr. Shohet. The District’s IEP members again concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with this conclusion.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
An individual with exceptional needs in entitled to a free appropriate public education under both federal and State law. 34 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Section 300.1 and California Education Code (EC) Section 56000. An individual with exceptional needs is defined as a child who has been identified by an IEP team as a child with a disability whose impairment “requires instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program.” EC Section 56026
A child has exceptional needs if that child is evaluated as having mental retardation, a hearing impairment including deafness, a speech or language impairment, a visual impairment including blindness, emotional disturbance, an orthopedic impairment, autism, traumatic brain injury, and other health impairment, a specific learning disability, deaf-blindness, or multiple disabilities, and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services 34 CFR 300.7.
In this case, STUDENT is claiming to be eligible for special education services on the basis of emotional disturbance, learning disability, and an other health impairment. Each of these alleged claims of eligibility will be examined separately below.
1. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services because he is emotionally disturbed?
Federal and State laws set forth the criteria for determining whether a pupil qualifies for special education services on the basis of serious emotional disturbance. 34 CFR 300.7(c)(4) and California Code of Regulations (CCR) 3030(i). The law provides that a pupil is considered to be seriously emotionally disturbed if:
Because of a serious emotional disturbance, a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
None of the psychologists that examined STUDENT concluded that STUDENT met the criteria for emotional disturbance.
Dr. O’Connor and Dr. Ernsdorf both concluded that testing and school records were indicative of the ability to learn and perform academically.
Dr. O’Connor concluded that the mental status exam, Sentence Completion Test, MMPI-A, MACI, and observations do not indicate a pervasive problem over a long period of time relating to the ability to maintain satisfactory inter-personal relationships which has affected education performance. Dr. Ernsdorf stated that “although STUDENT has some peer problems, he can interact when he desires. Based on both school and self report his lack of social activities outside of school appears to be by choice.” Yasuko Ozawa, the teacher of STUDENT’s Japanese class, testified that STUDENT had good times and difficult times with relationships. She said that STUDENT was good friends with two girls in her class. She tried to separate them because they talked too much. She said he did not associate much with ninth-grade boys, but got along well with the tenth-grade boys. Mr. Butera, STUDENT’s English teacher, said he would be surprised if told that STUDENT did not have friends. A number of the adult witnesses, including counselor Sally J. Okumura-Clain, STUDENT’s English teacher, Mr. Butera, his biology teacher, Mr. Scherbart, and school psychologist Dr. O’Connor, said that they had good relationships with STUDENT. There is no evidence to support the conclusion that STUDENT is unable to maintain satisfactory inter-personal relationships when he desires to do so.
With respect to whether STUDENT has inappropriate feelings or behaviors under normal circumstances, Dr. O’Connor concluded that “STUDENT’s mental status exam, and MACI were not indicative of a thought disorder. STUDENT does not exhibit any unusual or bizarre behavior. None has been observed or reported.” Dr. Ernsdorf reached the same conclusion. Counsel for STUDENT asserted that an incident in which STUDENT spit on a teacher, after the teacher had accidentally spit on STUDENT, constituted inappropriate behavior. While such conduct would appear to be inappropriate, one isolated incident does not constitute behavior over a long period of time and to a marked degree. It is concluded that there is no evidence to support the conclusion that STUDENT would be eligible as emotionally disturbed because of inappropriate feelings or behaviors under normal circumstances.
Relating to whether STUDENT had a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression, Dr. O’Connor concluded:
Test results, including the Mental Status Exam, BDI, MMPI-A, MACI, and STUDENT’s own statements do not indicate a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. Furthermore, STUDENT’s current mood has not significantly affected his education and/or academic achievement. Further there are no non-verbal signs of depression such as a somatic complaints, withdrawal, antisocial behavior, clinging behaviors, nightmares, slowing down, or lack of interests.
Dr. Ernsdorf stated:
STUDENT does not exhibit the depressed mood or loss of interest or pleasure necessary to meet the criteria for major depression. He reported average or above self-concept in all areas except for within his family. Although he reported a high level of irritability, this may be better accounted for by his narcissistic anger and oppositional behaviors when things don’t go his way.
STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT had been hospitalized while in the third grade for suicidal ideas. However, his mental status in the third grade does not support the conclusion that such problems currently exist. While STUDENT’s mother testified that he had made recent references to suicide, the weight of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT does not currently have an emotional disturbance because of a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
Both Dr. O’Connor and Dr. Ernsdorf concluded that there was no evidence of STUDENT having a tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with school or personal problems.
It is important to note the Dr. Shohet did not assess STUDENT in the field of social emotional status. While she rendered some opinions concerning his emotional problems, she testified that she could not conclude that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria for emotional disturbance. Because the two school psychologists who examined STUDENT in the area of social/emotional status concluded that he did not meet the criteria for emotional disturbance, and because these conclusions were not contradicted by STUDENT’s own psychologist, and because the other evidence supports the conclusions of Drs. O’Connor and Ernsdorf, it is concluded that STUDENT is not eligible for special education service as an emotionally disturbed adolescent.
2. Is STUDENT eligible for special education services because of a specific learning disability?
California law sets forth three requirements necessary to establish the existence of a specific learning disability:
(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievements in one or more of the following academic areas:
(1) Oral expression.
(2) Listening comprehension.
(3) Written expression.
(4) Basic reading skills.
(5) Mathematics calculation.
(7) Mathematics reasoning.
(b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not a result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages.
(c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.
Both Dr. O’Connor and Dr. Shohet concluded that there was a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and achievement in the area of written expression. He had a full scale I.Q. of 143 but had a standard score of 98 in Broad Written Language on the Woodcock Johnson Psychoeducation Battery. Dr. Shohet’s testing resulted in STUDENT’s achieving a writing composite standard score of 99. Dr. O’Connor testified that he would have been very surprised if STUDENT had not shown a severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and achievement in some area because his I.Q. is so high. But even though there was a discrepancy, STUDENT still tested at or above grade level in all areas.
For a student to be eligible for special education services as learning disabled, it is necessary to not only show a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, but it is also necessary to demonstrate that the discrepancy is caused by a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes. Basic psychological processes include attention, visual processing, auditory processing, sensory-motor skills, cognitive abilities including association, and conceptualization and expression. 5 CCR (j)(1)
In her report dated January 23, 2000, Dr. Shohet suggests that:
There appears to be some auditory processing problems that involve memory for words, numbers and interpretation of directions as well as visual processing problems in sequential memory. Both of these areas may require further diagnosis.
In her report and in her testimony, Dr. Shohet hinted at a possible problem in the area of auditory and visual processing, but failed to provide significant evidence of such a disorder. Her opinion concerning his auditory-perceptual skills was based on the results from her administration of the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills. STUDENT received low scores on two subtests. He received a scaled score of 8 on the Auditory Number Memory Forward subtest which resulted in a percentile rank of 25. Dr. O’Connor testified that this test is to evaluate short-term auditory memory by giving the pupil numbers to memorize. He said that another test which tested short- term auditory memory was the diget span subtest on the WISC-III. STUDENT received a scaled score of 17 on that test which put him at the ninety ninth percentile as compared to other adolescents his age. Dr. O’Connor did not believe that STUDENT put forth his best effort during Dr. Shohet’s testing.
Dr. Shohet also referred to STUDENT’s scaled score of 7 on the Auditory Interpretation of Directions subtest on the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills. She concluded that such a scaled score would put him in the thirteenth percentile of similarly placed students. Dr. O’Connor testified that this subtest related to the capacity of a student to understand auditory directions. Dr. O’Connor referred to the speech and language assessment done during 1999, including the Concepts and Directions subtest of the CELF-3. He testified that this subtest also tests a student’s ability to understand auditory directions. STUDENT scored 12 on that test, which put him a the seventy fifth percentile in relation to his peers.
Dr. Shohet expressed concern about STUDENT’s results on the Test of Visual-Motor Skills and concluded that there appeared to be “visual processing problems in sequential memory.” STUDENT received a standard score of 111 which put him at the seventy-seventh percentile compared to his peers. Her concern appeared to be soley based on his difficulty with copying one design. Dr. O’Connor testified that the Bender Gestalt Test is another test for visual motor skills. STUDENT received a perfect score on this test during Dr. O’Connor’s testing. The VMI test also tests for a student’s ability to copy geometric figures. STUDENT received a perfect score on this test when he took it in March 1999. Dr. O’Connor also testified that the perceptual organization composite on the WISC-3 is a measure of all performance subtests, which includes an evaluation of visual perceptual skills. STUDENT’s score was 144 which was at the ninety ninth percentile compared to his peers.
Dr. Shohet’s test results in relation to auditory and visual processing are greatly at odds with the testing results of Dr. O’Connor. One explanation for STUDENT’s lower performance on the tests administered by Dr. Shohet may be that STUDENT was not trying to demonstrate his full potential. Dr. Shohet’s notes indicate that STUDENT had a difficult time staying on task and that he “gives up and says anything without working.” In relation to a task that involved drawing, Dr. Shohet notes that STUDENT “quickly lost interest, and... just did the drawing ‘any old way.’” STUDENT’s level of effort in the testing performed by Dr. Shohet is further called into question by the fact that he scored a zero on the Visual Sequential Memory subtest of the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills. It appears that he just did not attempt this subtest.(Footnote 1)
The Hearing Officer has a difficult time taking seriously the test scores provided by Dr. Shohet. Her hesitancy to give a firm diagnosis of a disorder in auditory or visual processing is perhaps a reflection of her own doubt about the testing results. The testing done by Dr. O’Connor shows no sign of a disorder in auditory or visual processing. His testing was thorough and he testified that STUDENT used his best efforts during the testing. It should also be mentioned that none of the testimony by STUDENT’s teachers supported the conclusion that STUDENT has an auditory or visual processing disorder. In fact, Ms. Oxawa, the teacher of STUDENT’s Japanese class, testified that STUDENT quickly picked up spoken Japanese.
The preponderance of the evidence, including the testing done by Dr. O’Connor and the speech and language therapist, Ms. Steiner, and the opinions of STUDENT’s teachers, supports the conclusion that STUDENT does not have a disorder in auditory or visual perception.(Footnote 2) For this reason, it is concluded that STUDENT does not qualify for special education services because of a learning disability.
3. Does STUDENT qualify for special education services because he is other health impaired?
STUDENT’s counsel argues that STUDENT qualifies for special education services because he has attention deficit disorder (ADD) or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), which qualifies as an other health impairment.
California law provides:
A pupil whose educational performance is adversely affected by a suspected or diagnosed attention deficit disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and demonstrates a need for special education and related services by meeting eligibility criteria specified in subdivision (f) or (i) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations or Section 56337 and subdivision (j) of Section 3030 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations for the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 and following) categories of “other health impairments,” “serious emotional disturbance,” or “specific learning disabilities,” is entitled to special education and related services.” EC 56339(a).
Other health impairment is defined by CCR 3030(f), which provides:
A pupil has limited strength, vitality or alertness, due to chronic or acute health problems, including but not limited to a heart condition, cancer, leukemia, rheumatic fever, chronic kidney disease, cystic fibrosis, sever asthma, epilepsy, lead poisoning, diabetes, tuberculosis and other communicable infectious diseases, and hematological disorders such as sickle cell anemia and hemophilia which adversely affects a pupil’s educational performance.
STUDENT argues that he suffers from ADD or ADHD, which limits his alertness and therefore qualifies him as other health impaired. The problem with this argument is that no expert who has examined STUDENT has concluded that he suffers from ADD or ADHD. Dr. O’Connor asked two of STUDENT’s teachers to complete the Attention Deficit Disorder Evaluation Scale (ADDES) School Version. Dr. O’Connor concluded that “according to teacher input, STUDENT experiences no significant areas of concern.” The ADDES Home Version was competed by STUDENT’s parents. Dr. O’Connor concluded that, according to this form, STUDENT “has mild Hyperactive-Impulsive behavior in the home setting.” Dr. O’Connor’s summary includes the conclusion the STUDENT “does not have a learning disability in the area of attention which would impact his educational performance and academic achievement.”
Dr. Erfsdorf concluded that “although he is manifesting some ADHD behaviors, they would be better accounted for by other dynamics.” As with the testing by Dr. O’Connor, the ADHD behaviors were not reflected in the forms filled out by teachers, but were moderately reflected in the self- report and the report completed by STUDENT’s parents. Dr. Erfsdorf concluded that this inconsistency may be related to STUDENT’s “inability to meet his egocentric needs and an underlying personality disorder.” Dr. Shohet did no testing concerning ADD/ADHD and did not render an opinion concerning the existence of this disorder. STUDENT’s teachers testified that when he wanted to he could concentrate on his work for extended periods of time. None was of the opinion that he had ADD or ADHD.
Based upon the lack of any evidence from professionals that STUDENT has ADD or ADHD, it is concluded that he does not qualify for special education services on the basis of other health impairment.
ORDER
All of Petitioner’s claims are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).
Dated:
Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: It is interesting to note that even though STUDENT received a zero on this subtest, his total of all of the subtests was 81, which put him at the eighty third percentile in comparison to his peers.
Footnote 2: Attention is another one of the basic processes, a disorder of which may provide the basis for establishing eligibility as learning disabled. Whether there is a disorder in the area of attention is discussed below under “other health impaired.”
