California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 26, 2002
Student v. ABC Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 977-02 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
ABC Unified denied FAPE by delaying speech-language services; must continue services and revisit math placement, but nonpublic school denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The mother of a 13-year-old seventh-grader filed for due process against ABC Unified School District. He had been home schooled through sixth grade and enrolled at Tetzlaff Middle School in fall 2001. In October 2001, school psychologist Holly Roehl found him eligible as mildly mentally retarded but did not assess speech and language, even though teachers had reported language problems. In February 2002, assessments by speech-language pathologist Ellen Lamberth and psychologist James Morrison found average intelligence and a severe language learning disability. In March 2002, the IEP team changed his eligibility to speech or language impairment, with specific learning disability as secondary, and added speech services.
Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke found the October 2001 assessment improper because it missed an area of suspected disability, which the District conceded. She held that the student was denied a FAPE in speech and language from September 2001 through March 2002 because he had no speech goals or direct services. She rejected his claims of predetermination, poor communication, an inappropriate special day class, math work below his level, and missing progress reports. One missed daily check-in with his teacher did not affect his education. His many absences made it impossible to measure his progress. She denied nonpublic school placement. She ordered the IEP team to decide his math placement, provide at least the March 2002 level of speech services in 2002-2003, and meet again after 30 days to consider more services.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a missed speech-language assessment that led to the wrong eligibility label. The denial of FAPE covered only the months without speech goals or services. The remedy was continued services and IEP review, not compensatory hours, partly because frequent absences made harm hard to measure. A placement first named in a closing brief was not considered.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Did the District fail to properly assess Student in October 2001?
The District knew or had reason to know it needed to assess speech and language but did not, and it wrongly labeled the student mildly mentally retarded; the District conceded the language assessment should have been done.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2 (procedural – parent participation). Whether the parents were denied full participation because the March 26, 2002 IEP was drafted before the meeting, and because the District did not communicate about removal from Spanish class and disciplinary incidents
Draft goals prepared before the meeting did not seriously infringe parent participation; the mother attended, asked questions, and signed; she was informed of the Spanish class change and the discipline incidents.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2(a). Whether the special day class portion of the placement denied FAPE
The language-focused SDC, team-taught with a speech-language pathologist, was designed to meet the student's needs and was reasonably calculated to provide benefit; his lack of progress was tied to the parents keeping him out of school.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 2(b). Whether the level of math work provided in the special day class, and the failure to write new math goals after the second set of assessments, denied FAPE
Easier math homework served legitimate purposes, there was no evidence that the class work was below his level, and the existing multi-step math goal was still appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 2(c). Whether the delay in providing speech and language services denied FAPE
FAPE was denied in speech and language from September 2001 through March 2002 because there were no speech goals or direct services; the March 26, 2002 IEP speech services were appropriate, and no speech homework was needed.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 2 (implementation a). Whether the District failed to implement behavioral intervention methods (daily five-minute discussion with SDC teacher) in the March 26, 2002 IEP
The District failed once to hold the daily discussion, but the principal discussed the incident with the student and his mother the same day, so the lapse did not affect his education.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2 (implementation b). Whether the District failed to provide weekly progress reports to the parents
Weekly progress reports were not part of any IEP; the school prepared them anyway, but the student did not take them home.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2 (implementation c). Whether the District placed the student in physical education contrary to his IEP
There was no evidence that he had to take PE after the March 2002 IEP removed it, and the November 2001 IEP did not restrict PE.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 2 (LRE – math). Whether the SDC math class was the least restrictive environment for math instruction
Because of inconsistent attendance and a lack of persuasive evidence on either side, the Hearing Officer could not decide; the IEP team was ordered to reconvene and decide his math placement.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
Nonpublic school placement was denied because the school was first named in the closing brief, after the record closed; instead, speech services at least at the March 2002 IEP level were ordered, with an IEP review after 30 days.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team must immediately reconvene to decide whether the student should receive math instruction in a regular class with supplemental aids and services or in special education (regular education, RSP, or SDC math). The team must consider information from all of his former math teachers, his ability level, his language disorder, and his limited exposure to the public school math curriculum.
- Order to provide or change services. During the 2002-2003 school year, the District must provide at least the same level of speech and language services as in the March 26, 2002 IEP.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team must reconvene after 30 days of service implementation to decide whether more speech and language services are warranted.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; S.V. v. Sherwood School District
People named in the decision
- Brenda Parks, special education advocate for Student (non-attorney); witness
- Holly Roehl, school psychologist who did the initial October 2001 assessment, ABC Unified School District
- James Morrison, school psychologist who did the second psychoeducational study (February 2002), ABC Unified School District
- Ellen Lamberth, speech and language pathologist; co-teacher in the SDC, ABC Unified School District
- Colin Sprigg, principal, Tetzlaff Middle School, ABC Unified School District
- Peter Morgan, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher, Tetzlaff Middle School
- Earl Stallard, regular education pre-algebra teacher, Tetzlaff Middle School
- Davea Carr, special day class teacher, Tetzlaff Middle School
- Leslie Fagan, program specialist, ABC Unified School District
- Maria Carroll, guidance administrator, Tetzlaff Middle School
- Karen Somosi, special education supervisor, ABC Unified School District
- Kathleen Cronin, District supervisor, ABC Unified School District
- Sheila Levy-Craven, director of pupil support; District representative at hearing, ABC Unified School District
- Ms. Garcia, Spanish teacher, Tetzlaff Middle School
- Sylvan Learning Center, private provider; independent math assessment
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Cerritos, California on June 13, 14, 17, and 18, 2002.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was Brenda Parks, special education advocate, and Shirley Stovall, STUDENT’s grandmother. On the third day of hearing, FATHER, STUDENT’s father, was present part of the day. Petitioner STUDENT was also present for part of one day of the hearing. Respondent ABC Unified School District (hereafter District or ABC) was represented at the hearing by Sheila Levy-Craven, director of pupil support for the District. Also present on behalf of the Respondent was Karen Somosi, special education District supervisor, and Kathleen Cronin, District supervisor.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Brenda Parks; Holly Roehl, District school psychologist who initially assessed STUDENT; MOTHER; and Shirley Stovall.
The following witnesses were called by Respondent to testify: Colin Sprigg, principal at Tetzlaff Middle School (Tetzlaff); Peter Morgan, STUDENT’s resource specialist program (RSP) teacher at Tetzlaff; Earl Stallard, STUDENT’s pre-algebra teacher at Tetzlaff; Leslie Fagan, program specialist for the District; Davea Carr, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Tetzlaff; James Morrison, District school psychologist who also assessed STUDENT; Maria Carroll, guidance administrator at Tetzlaff; Ellen Lamberth, speech and language pathologist for the District; and Karen Somosi.
ISSUES
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in October 2001?
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment during the 2001-2002 school year?
3. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a thirteen year old seventh-grade student eligible for special education services due to his severe speech and language disorder and specific learning disability. At the time of the hearing in this matter and during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was enrolled in a special day class program at Tetzlaff Middle School (Tetzlaff) in the ABC Unified School District (District). Prior to the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was primarily home schooled by his mother, MOTHER, through the sixth grade. He attended public school in the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) for a brief period during sixth grade. His parents removed him from that school before the end of the school year because they believed there was a lack of communication with the school. STUDENT did not return to home schooling after his brief period at LAUSD, and instead enrolled at Tetzlaff in September 2001.
Shortly after his enrollment at Tetzlaff, STUDENT’s performance declined and a student study team meeting was held on September 26, 2001, to discuss his parents’ and teachers’ concerns. STUDENT was subsequently referred for assessment in all academic areas and social areas. The school psychologist Holly Roehl found that STUDENT was performing at a second- to third-grade level. Cognitive testing showed that his estimated ability was in the mild mental retardation range. STUDENT’s mild mental retardation was characterized by sub-average intellectual functioning and concurrent deficits in adaptive behavior.
An initial IEP meeting was held for STUDENT on October 24, 2001, to review testing results. The IEP team noted that STUDENT’s reading and math skills were approximately at the third- to fourth-grade level, that he had strong skills in art, and that he was very detail oriented when copying written material. The IEP team also noted STUDENT’s difficulty in all of his classes, and discussed his social skills and areas in which they believed he was “naive” and needed instruction. Having found STUDENT eligible for special education services under the category of mild mental retardation, the District members of the IEP team believed that a special day class (SDC) would be the best placement for STUDENT. However, the District members deferred to MOTHER’s preference that STUDENT be placed in the resource specialist program (RSP) and thus formally offered him placement in RSP for one to three periods each day. The Hearing Officer notes that although the school psychologist noted in her report that STUDENT was performing well below average on writing tasks that involved spelling and mechanics, that his oral language skills were very poor, and that he had difficulty understanding spoken language, no speech and language assessment was ordered or conducted at that time. However, the IEP team did recommend that the speech and language specialist observe STUDENT to determine if testing was warranted. The IEP team concluded that it would reevaluate STUDENT’s placement and progress at report card periods.
Another IEP meeting was held on October 30, 2001, because of Mr. and MOTHER’s concern about STUDENT’s RSP math class and the level of work that was given in that class. Since math was one of his strengths, STUDENT’s parents wanted him to be in a regular math class. Accordingly, the IEP team changed STUDENT’s schedule to remove him from the RSP math class and place him in a regular education math class. It also was agreed that STUDENT’s parents, his RSP teacher, and the math teacher would work together to help STUDENT progress.
STUDENT’s program was reviewed during an IEP meeting on December 12, 2001. At that time, STUDENT was failing four of his five classes, including math, and it appeared that he needed a higher level of support than placement in the RSP could provide. STUDENT’s RSP teacher recommended that he be placed in an SDC where he could receive intensive academic support. STUDENT’s parent and grandmother indicated their concern about the school psychologist’s earlier diagnosis of mild mental retardation and, therefore, the IEP team decided that further psychoeducational evaluation would be conducted. No change of placement was made at the December 2001 IEP meeting. A follow-up IEP meeting was to be scheduled to further address everyone’s concerns.
On December 27, 2001, STUDENT’s parents took him to the Sylvan Learning Center (Sylvan) for an independent assessment of his basic math skills. According to Sylvan’s assessment report, STUDENT’s target grade equivalent score in math was 8.3. However, his individual grade equivalent scores in computation, concepts & applications, and total math, were 5.2, 1.8, and 3.2, respectively. (Resp.’s Exh. 10.)
At another IEP meeting on January 11, 2002, STUDENT’s RSP teacher, Peter Morgan, indicated that STUDENT continued to have difficulty keeping up with the class. According to Mr. Morgan, STUDENT needed re-teaching, reinforcement, and added practice in all academic areas. It was also noted that STUDENT disliked change and preferred routine. The IEP team, including the parents, all agreed that STUDENT should be moved to Ms. Carr’s special day class, effective January 15, 2002. In addition, MOTHER signed another assessment plan in which she consented to the District’s further assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement and to initial assessment of his language and speech communication development.
In January 2002, STUDENT was suspended twice for a total of four days, once for fighting, and the other time for allegedly initiating a fight.
A speech and language assessment was conducted of STUDENT over a four-day period and concluded in February 2002. Speech and language pathologist, Ellen Lamberth, concluded that STUDENT’s performance was typical of a student with average cognitive skills and a severe language learning disability. Ms. Lamberth recommended speech and language support for STUDENT in order to improve his language skills, which would help him to better understand both written and verbal instruction, and to express his ideas, questions, and responses more clearly.
A second psychoeducational study was completed in February 2002 by a different District school psychologist, James Morrison. Mr. Morrison’s assessment results indicated that STUDENT was functioning within the average range of intelligence. Generalized delays in language, phonological processing, rapid naming, and fine-motor coordination were believed to be associated with a severe discrepancy between measured mental ability and academic achievement in reading and written language skills. Mr. Morrison also noted that STUDENT’s difficulties with social skills were possibly related to pragmatic language difficulties and inexperience in social roles required in the public schools. STUDENT’s adaptive behavioral functioning was generally within the average range. Mr. Morrison recommended STUDENT’s continued placement in the SDC program with speech and language as a designated instructional service (DIS). Additional program and instructional recommendations were also noted in Mr. Morrison’s report.
On March 26, 2002, another IEP meeting was held to discuss the new intelligence testing and the speech and language testing results. During the meeting, the IEP team changed STUDENT’s special education eligibility from mild mental retardation to speech and language, and designated specific learning disability as his secondary eligibility classification. The IEP team also added speech and language services to STUDENT’s IEP and eliminated physical education from his schedule because of his difficulties in that class. Two speech and language goals and related objectives were added to STUDENT’s IEP to help improve his verbal expression and his comprehension. The IEP notes indicate that STUDENT had been absent twenty-three out of thirty-five school days since February 4, 2002, because his mother had kept him home due because of behavior problems he was having. STUDENT’s parent requested that STUDENT be placed on home teaching until the end of the school year and also receive a one-to-one aide; however, both requests were denied since the District believed that STUDENT was appropriately placed in the SDC class and that additional support was unnecessary at that time. The District school psychologist suggested that the SDC teacher take five minutes each day to speak directly with STUDENT about his day, and that the speech and language therapist utilize social stories to assist him in communicating his concerns. MOTHER signed the March 26, 2002 IEP and agreed to the program changes.
The last IEP meeting was held on April 23, 2002, at which time STUDENT’s IEP was changed so that he would have three periods of SDC support, instead of four. That program change resulted in STUDENT’s being moved back into a regular education math class.
MOTHER testified that she kept STUDENT out of school since May 2, 2002, because of her concern for his safety after an incident in which he was accused of inappropriately touching some female students. A school attendance review board meeting was held on May 22, 2002, and it was decided that STUDENT would be placed on home instruction and would not return to school until after this due process hearing. His parents have since picked up his homework and brought it home for him. Documentary evidence also indicates that school administrators have encouraged the parents to return STUDENT to school.
On May 6, 2002, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing and the matter was set for hearing. At the time of hearing, STUDENT had not returned to school and was participating in home instruction.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District improperly assessed him and then failed to provide him a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. With respect to the assessment, Petitioner specifically argues that Ms. Roehl was not competent to have conducted the assessment of STUDENT and that she failed to use appropriate testing tools or take into consideration the fact that languages other than English were spoken in his family home. Furthermore, Petitioner alleges that because the psychoeducational assessment conducted by Holly Roehl failed to assess him in the area of speech and language, the District unfairly and incorrectly labeled his disability eligibility category as mild mental retardation, and this was not corrected until the following year. Procedurally, Petitioner contends that his parents were not given the opportunity to fully participate in the IEP process because the March 26, 2002 IEP was already drafted before they arrived at that IEP meeting. Additionally, Petitioner contends that the District failed to communicate with his parents about his removal from Spanish class and certain disciplinary incidents.
Substantively, Petitioner argues that he was denied a FAPE because the District members of the IEP team failed to identify his present levels of performance, and consequently, developed an educational program with placement in a special day class, which was not the least restrictive environment and which included math curriculum that was below his skill level. Petitioner also argues that after he was reassessed, the District failed to develop new goals and objectives in math. According to Petitioner, the District failed to provide the appropriate speech and language services until after the speech and language assessment was conducted in January and February, 2002. Finally, Petitioner contends that the District failed to implement his IEP with respect to the mandate for daily discussions with his special day class (SDC) teacher, the provision for weekly progress reports to his parents, and the requirement regarding his removal from physical education class.
The District contends that all members of the assessment team that conducted the initial assessment of Petitioner were qualified and competent to assess Petitioner. According to the District, although Petitioner’s language needs should have been assessed in October 2001, he nevertheless received a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and was not harmed by not having speech and language services for the four months between the first and second assessments. The District also contends that it communicated appropriately with the family regarding Petitioner’s Spanish class and the disciplinary incident. It also contends that it provided Petitioner’s parents with weekly progress reports and provided Petitioner a safe environment at Tetzlaff Middle School.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in October 2001?
Petitioner contends that the first psychoeducational study conducted by school psychologist Holly Roehl in October 2001 was improper because Ms. Roehl used outdated testing materials that were racially, culturally, and sexually discriminatory and failed to take into consideration the fact that Swahili and Arabic languages were also spoken in STUDENT’s home. Petitioner also argues that Ms. Roehl failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability because she did not assess his speech and language development.
California Education Code Section 56320(f) requires that a student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. The Hearing Officer finds there is credible evidence that the District failed to assess Petitioner’s speech and language development during its initial assessment and, consequently, incorrectly labeled STUDENT as mildly mentally retarded. Specifically, Ms. Roehl testified that she conducted the first psychoeducational study of STUDENT and conceded that during her assessment, she mistakenly did not explore the language issue or use instruments that would have provided further information about STUDENT’s speech and language development. Ms. Roehl admitted that she should have referred STUDENT for further speech and language assessment.
STUDENT’s speech and language development was later assessed by the District’s speech and language pathologist Ellen Lamberth in January and February 2002, and it was then determined that he had a severe language learning disability. (Resp.’s Exh. 9.) STUDENT’s primary disability was then changed to speech and language impairment and his secondary disability was identified as specific learning disability. Ms. Roehl testified that had she been provided the information derived from the speech and language assessment that was conducted after her assessment, her diagnosis of mild mental retardation would have changed. The Hearing Officer also notes that the District conceded in its closing brief that it should have assessed STUDENT in the area of language in October 2001. Prior to the October 24, 2001 IEP meeting, the District had reports from STUDENT’s teachers indicating that STUDENT took a very long time to read and complete any written work, that his responses often did not correspond to questions asked, that he was easily confused, and that he had poor adaptive skills in language development. By report dated October 23, 2001, the school nurse indicated that STUDENT had problems with processing information and determining how an action could be carried out in a sequential manner. (Resp.’s Exhs. 15-16; Pet.’s Exh. 11.)
In light of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District knew or had reason to know that STUDENT required specific assessment of his speech and language development, and therefore, failed to properly assess him in October 2001 when it neglected to conduct that specific assessment. The District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability when it conducted its initial assessment in October 2001, and instead of identifying his language disorder, it mislabeled him as mildly mentally retarded. Whether the District’s mislabeling of STUDENT ’s handicapping condition harmed STUDENT is discussed in the next section.
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment during the 2001-2002 school year?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), STUDENT s with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the STUDENT at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the STUDENT ’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the STUDENT . (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a STUDENT with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a STUDENT ’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education STUDENT s with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a STUDENT ’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the STUDENT . (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT ’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parent preferred another program and even if the parent’s preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which, in this case, means ensuring that STUDENT ’s education is provided in a manner that promotes his maximum interaction with children or youth who are not disabled, and which is appropriate to the needs of both. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Educ. Code § 56031.)
The analysis of whether a STUDENT has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)
Procedural Appropriateness
The Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al., v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 201 (1982), recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each STUDENT with a disability receives a free appropriate public education and that parents are involved in the formulation of the STUDENT ’s individualized educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483.) Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. However, procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the STUDENT or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of FAPE. (Id. at 1484.)
Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District’s actions infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Specifically, MOTHER testified that she was not allowed to be a full participant in the IEP meeting on March 26, 2002, and that the IEP document was already written before she arrived at the IEP meeting. MOTHER also testified that she has not been able to participate in STUDENT ’s education while he has been maintained in special education because school personnel have not communicated with her about changes in STUDENT ’s class schedule and about disciplinary incidents.
As to the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting, the evidence establishes that MOTHER was present at the meeting, that she was allowed to comment on the information provided by the District, and that she was given an opportunity to ask questions about the intelligence and speech and language assessment reports that were presented. (Testimony of MOTHER; Resp.’s Exh. 3, pgs. 3-5.) MOTHER testified that during that meeting team members reviewed and discussed STUDENT ’s present levels of performance and his goals, but that she did not have an opportunity to actually read the pages of the IEP document that contained this information. Copies of Ms. Lamberth’s speech and language report and Mr. Morrison’s psychoeducational study were given to MOTHER at the March 2002 meeting. Mr. Morrison testified that in addition to presenting his results during the IEP meeting, he spoke on the telephone with MOTHER about the general results of his testing before the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Lamberth testified that she discussed her findings for the first time during the March 2002 IEP meeting. Although MOTHER indicated that she did not specifically review the written portion of the March 26, 2002 IEP that listed STUDENT ’s present levels and the goals and objectives, she testified that she signed the IEP indicating her agreement with it and that she understood at that time what she doing and what she was signing. The evidence also established that there was extensive discussion during the IEP meeting about the substance of the document and that the parents were provided with a copy.
With respect to the allegation that the IEP document was written before the start of the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting, District witnesses testified that it is standard practice to draft proposed goals and objectives prior to a scheduled IEP meeting in order to streamline the process. However, the parents are always informed during the meeting that the drafted goals are not definitive, and the parents are given the opportunity to participate in writing the final version. (Testimonies of Davea Carr, Leslie Fagan, and Peter Morgan.) The District’s preparation of proposed goals and objectives before the IEP meeting did not seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process, but rather streamlined the IEP process and the parents were still given an opportunity to ask questions and participate in formulating the IEP. Accordingly, the evidence demonstrates that STUDENT ’s parents were involved in the IEP process.
As to the District’s communication with the parents regarding STUDENT ’s class schedule, MOTHER testified that STUDENT was removed from his Spanish class and placed in an art class without her knowledge or consent. Guidance administrator Maria Carroll testified that when STUDENT started school at Tetzlaff, he was placed in challenging courses at his mother’s request, including, advanced math, introductory Spanish, and honors Science. A STUDENT study team (SST) meeting was held in September 2001, and MOTHER was in attendance. (Testimony of MOTHER; Resp.’s Exh. 16.) During the SST meeting, Ms. Garcia, STUDENT ’s Spanish class teacher, indicated that STUDENT was not benefitting from the class and would be better served by taking another elective class, such as reading, to increase his skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 15; Testimony of M. Carroll.) According to Ms. Carroll, the elective reading class provided remedial support for STUDENT s with weaknesses in reading, and thus STUDENT was enrolled in that class. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no convincing evidence that MOTHER was not informed of the decision to remove STUDENT from Spanish and into a reading class because MOTHER attended the meeting at which this issue was discussed.
With respect to the disciplinary incidents, MOTHER testified that the District did not communicate with her regarding disciplinary incidents. Moreover, Petitioner contends that because of his inability to verbally defend himself, he was unable to refute allegations made against him. He contends that this created an unsafe environment where he was at risk of being attacked by other STUDENT s and/or being subject to false allegations, which later led to his being disciplined.
In direct contradiction to Petitioner’s contentions, MOTHER testified that Ms. Carroll spoke with her about STUDENT ’s behavior on the quad and his bumping into STUDENT s and falling down. Also, Ms. Carroll testified that she spoke directly with STUDENT about his behavior, asked him what happened on the quad, and told him he could come to her if he had any problems. Ms. Carroll testified that after her discussion with STUDENT , such an incident never happened again. In addition, STUDENT ’s special day class teacher, Davea Carr, testified that when she wrote a referral because of graffiti that STUDENT had written on a desk, she asked STUDENT about the incident and spoke with STUDENT ’s mother about the referral during a sixth period parent conference. Ms. Carr also testified that she asked the STUDENT intervention assistant to counsel STUDENT about his behavior and another disciplinary incident.
Additionally, the principal, Colin Sprigg, testified that although he did not speak with STUDENT immediately after an inappropriate touching incident occurred at lunch, he did speak with STUDENT and MOTHER on the same day of the incident, after sixth period. That same day, after their discussion about the alleged inappropriate touching incident, MOTHER informed Mr. Sprigg that she was taking STUDENT out of school. (Testimony of C. Sprigg.) Mr. Sprigg testified he would have counseled STUDENT about the incident since he believed STUDENT was not being totally forthright when initially questioned about the incident. However, MOTHER removed STUDENT from school and no other action was taken regarding the incident. When STUDENT was involved in two other fighting incidents at school for which he was suspended, the other STUDENT s involved were also suspended. (Pet.’s Exhs. 6-7.) According to Mr. Sprigg, when incidents such as fighting occur at school, they are immediately addressed and therefore, no systemic safety issues exist at Tetzlaff.
The evidence demonstrates that there was direct communication between the school, STUDENT , and STUDENT ’s parents regarding the disciplinary events. And when certain incidents resulted in STUDENT ’s suspension, the parents were notified by phone of the suspension and provided notice of the same. (See Pet.’s Exhs. 6-7.) Moreover, the evidence demonstrates that none of the disciplinary incidents led to an unsafe environment for STUDENT at school. However, Mr. Sprigg testified that there was enough information to conclude that STUDENT requires a behavior plan with goals and objectives to address his poor conflict resolution skills. There was also testimony that STUDENT ’s problems with language were probably associated with his problems with peers, and that had the District assessed STUDENT ’s speech and language development earlier, the occurrence of behavioral/disciplinary incidents might have been reduced. (Testimony of James Morrison.)
While MOTHER’s communication with the District may have been strained given the nature of the incidents that occurred since STUDENT began attending Tetzlaff, communication nevertheless did occur, and the parent was informed about each incident and given anto respond. Additionally, the evidence did not demonstrate that STUDENT was placed in an unsafe environment where he was at risk of being attacked or subject to false allegations. However, he does require additional assistance with addressing his poor conflict resolution skills. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the communication system did not “seriously infringe” on the parents’ participation in the IEP process or result in the loss of educational opportunity to the STUDENT .
Substantive Appropriateness
As previously mentioned, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s program must meet the following four requirements in order to constitute a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP, and (4) be provided in the least restrictive environment.
Identification of STUDENT ’s Unique Needs
As found above, when initially assessed in October 2001, STUDENT was mistakenly diagnosed by school psychologist Holly Roehl as mildly mentally retarded. Neither party disputes that STUDENT ’s diagnosis for the entire 2001-2002 school year should have been a severe speech and language disorder and a specific learning disability. (Testimony of J. Morrison, H. Roehl, and E. Lamberth.) Additionally, the parties do not dispute the findings regarding STUDENT ’s needs as stated in Mr. Morrison’s psychoeducational study dated March 26, 2002, and Ms. Lamberth’s speech and language assessment dated February 21, 2002.
Academically, Mr. Morrison’s psychoeducational study results established that STUDENT functioned within the average range of intelligence. His fluency with academic tasks and his ability to apply academic skills were both within the low range. His level of academic knowledge was very low. His performance was average in math calculation skills; low average in reading and reading comprehension; and low in math reasoning, written language, and written expression, perhaps associated with his generalized speech and language impairment. STUDENT demonstrated a significant weakness in oral language. There was a significant strength in math calculation. There was a severe discrepancy between measured mental ability and academic achievement in reading and written language skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) Consistent with Mr. Morrison’s findings, STUDENT ’s former RSP teacher, Peter Morgan, reported at the January 11, 2002 IEP meeting that STUDENT was having significant difficulty keeping up with the pace of the RSP class and the mainstream. According to Mr. Morgan, STUDENT needed re-teaching, reinforcement, and added practice in all academic areas. (Resp.’s Exh. 4.)
The speech and language pathologist concluded that STUDENT had a severe language learning disability. His auditory discrimination skills were slightly low, which could affect his understanding of spoken instruction in the classroom. His use of vocabulary was relatively stronger than his comprehension of language in context, critical reasoning, and verbal expression. Additionally, STUDENT does not always speak clearly, making it difficult to understand what he says at times. His written language scores showed a failure to address the academic task or question, and demonstrated his problems understanding what was required of him academically. (Resp.’s Exh. 9.) STUDENT required special one-to-one instruction to understand directions, which reflected his deficits in listening comprehension.
Behaviorally, while STUDENT was quiet and did his work in the self-contained SDC, at times he giggled to himself or “stared into space,” and he also had difficulties getting along with peers. He appeared to lack social skills, which was believed to be due to his pragmatic language difficulties and due to the fact that he spent most of his school years isolated and being educated through home schooling. STUDENT tended to work in a reflective manner and required much time to process information.
Mr. Morrison persuasively testified that given STUDENT ’s academic and language needs, he required the following: a small, special day class program that could provide STUDENT assistance with his language processing; paraeducator support in class; social skills training, specifically, the use of adequate language to contact peers and make friends with peers; structured conflict resolution training; a multiple modality instructional approach that utilizes repetition (including having STUDENT repeat or demonstrate the directions), provision of concrete examples, visual aids, and manipulative materials; additional time and repetition for learning new concepts; extra time to complete work; a structured and systemic reading program; and placement in speech and language as a designated instructional service. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) Mr. Morrison based his recommendations on his observations of STUDENT during testing, which included standardized testing, review of records, information from STUDENT ’s classroom teacher and his parents, and discussions with Ellen Lambert, who conducted the speech and language assessment of STUDENT .
Petitioner alleges that the following elements of the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year denied him a FAPE:
(a) special day class portion of placement;
(b) level of math work provided in special day class and math goals after second set of assessments performed; and (c) delay in providing speech and language services.
Petitioner also contends that his program did not comport with his IEP with respect to (a) behavioral intervention methods;
(b) progress reports; and (c) placement in physical education class.
The initial inquiry then becomes whether or not the District’s educational program (specifically with respect to the items listed above) was designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs and otherwise provided a him with a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE).
Designed to Meet STUDENT ’s Unique Needs (a) special day class portion of placement
Considering the unique needs described above, the Hearing Officer first determines whether STUDENT ’s placement in the SDC as of January 2002 was appropriate to address those needs. (Resp.’s Exh. 4.) As discussed above, STUDENT started the 2001-2002 school year placed in the regular education program. After his first IEP meeting on October 24, 2001, STUDENT was placed in the RSP for English and math. Later that same month, however, he was moved back into the regular math class at his mother’s request, but remained in the RSP class for English. As of January 15, 2002, STUDENT was enrolled in Davea Carr’s SDC for English, History/Science, Math, and reading. On April 23, 2002, although STUDENT remained in the SDC for three periods, he was again moved into the regular education math class at his parents’ request.
School psychologist James Morrison testified that Ms. Carr’s SDC was an appropriate placement for STUDENT because the focus of the class is on reading and written language. Also, because it is team taught with speech and language specialist Ellen Lamberth, the class provides STUDENT with more assistance from a credentialed teacher, as opposed to a paraprofessional in a regular education class who may not be as skilled. Ms. Lamberth is able to provide direct assistance in class to STUDENT with his language difficulties and it would be difficult for a teacher to give STUDENT the support that he needs if he were in a regular education class with thirty STUDENT s. (Testimony of J. Morrison.) Mr. Morrison was knowledgeable about social behavior training and educational issues for STUDENT s with needs such as STUDENT ’s. In addition, the Hearing Officer found Mr. Morrison to be a credible and independent witness because although he is employed by the District and was called to testify by the District, he offered independent testimony acknowledging his disagreement with the initial disability label placed on STUDENT by another District psychologist, Holly Roehl.
Mr. Morrison’s recommendations also were consistent with the testimony of STUDENT ’s recent teachers, who said that STUDENT needed a more restrictive environment than the RSP classroom, one where more intensive academic support could be provided. STUDENT ’s RSP teacher, Peter Morgan, testified that STUDENT needed to be in a setting smaller than the regular education or RSP class, with curriculum that was developed to his level, especially in the areas of science, reading, social science, and math. Mr. Morgan also explained that STUDENT would do better socially by becoming successful first in the SDC, and then enrolling in the regular education program, especially since he lacked substantial exposure to the public school system.
Similarly, STUDENT ’s SDC teacher, Davea Carr, testified that she believed her SDC was an appropriate placement to address STUDENT ’s academic needs because there he is provided the additional assistance that he requires, the class has a smaller STUDENT -teacher ratio, and she is able to coordinate his class work with his IEP goals and objectives. According to Ms. Carr, all of STUDENT ’s written language, reading, and math goals from the IEP dated October 24, 2001, are addressed in her class where she is able to monitor his work. (Resp.’s Exh. 7.) In math, two days each week, they work on basic math skills based on his tested level, and they also incorporate those skills into projects dealing with life events, such as planning a trip, determining the price of a hotel, and determining the perimeter of a floor plan. In reading, STUDENT s are given literature to read aloud and are given questions to answer. They work on pronunciation, and play games and read parts in plays to work on comprehension and vocabulary. Finally, in written language, STUDENT s are required to write in their journals and write papers in the social studies and science portions of the class.
In addition, speech and language specialist Ellen Lamberth works with the STUDENT s in Ms. Carr’s class on their written assignments, helping to recap instructions and edit their work. Ms. Lamberth collaborates with Ms. Carr in the area of language arts to team-teach the class. (Testimony of D. Carr.) Ms. Lamberth testified that she works in Ms. Carr’s class for a full class period and that STUDENT ’s specific language issues were incorporated into the class curriculum. During class periods, Ms. Lamberth worked with STUDENT to address his language disorder by rewording information for him, providing direction, and explaining things to him when he had difficulty following the lesson. Although she had already been working with STUDENT on a general basis when he was moved into the SDC in January 2002, once his March 2002 IEP was signed and speech and language services were added, Ms. Lamberth stated that she worked with STUDENT on more of a one-on-one basis, helping him work through the curriculum on a step-by-step basis, teaching him techniques and strategies. There also is an instructional assistant in the SDC who works with the STUDENT s.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Carr’s daily program provided STUDENT with the structure and focus on language processing that he needed to address his academic needs and his language disorder. In light of the small size of the class, the collaboration between the teacher and the speech and language specialist to fashion a language-based curriculum, the additional assistance of the instructional assistant, and the fact that his goals and objectives in reading, written language, and math were all addressed in the SDC, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Carr’s SDC was designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs.
(b) level of math work provided in special day class and math goals after second set of assessments performed
Petitioner argues that the level of math work provided by Ms. Carr in her SDC was too far below his ability level. Petitioner also contends that new math goals should have been written for him at the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting when his primary disability was changed and his ability level was correctly determined. The District contends that Petitioner’s placement in the special education math class was appropriate given his low scores on both the Woodcock Johnson test, administered by Mr. Morrison, and the tests administered by the Sylvan Learning Center. (Resp.’s closing argument.)
MOTHER testified that it was her opinion that STUDENT received poor grades in his math class because he grew tired of doing the work that he believed was too easy. (Pet.’s Exh. 8.) MOTHER also believed that Ms. Carr was not implementing the one math goal stated in STUDENT ’s IEP dated October 24, 2001.
According to Mr. Morrison’s psychoeducational testing, STUDENT was performing at the fifth-grade, three-month level in math overall. However, because of his language difficulties, there was a large difference between his calculation skills, which were at the eighth-grade, one- month level, and his applied skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) Mr. Morrison testified that the math scores obtained through the testing done at the Sylvan Learning Center were similar to scores he obtained in his testing, both showing relatively strong computational math skills and rather weak concepts and applications skills. (Resp.’s Exh. 10.) The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT was of average intelligence, but his learning disability and language disorder kept him from performing at that level. STUDENT has great difficulty understanding directions and receiving verbal instructions. Thus, although STUDENT can complete math calculations, some of the seventh-grade, language-based curriculum in the regular education math class, such as word problems, are difficult for him. (Testimony of J. Morrison.)
When shown some examples of the math homework that STUDENT was given, Mr. Morrison stated that STUDENT was capable of doing higher level work. (Pet.’s Exhs. 2 and 13.) Mr. Morrison qualified this statement, however, by stating that if STUDENT was working on academic fluency, then the math work samples would be good practice for him. However, if the intent of giving that math work was to teach STUDENT new skills or to help him build skills, then it probably would not be appropriate because STUDENT already possessed that level of math skills and could perform at a higher level. (Testimony of J. Morrison; Pet.’s Exh 2 and 13.)
Ms. Carr confirmed that the math homework in Petitioner’s Exhibit 2 was sent home with the STUDENT s for the purpose of teaching responsibility and to give the STUDENT s an opportunity to practice their skills at home. According to Ms. Carr, STUDENT had problems completing his homework and bringing it back to school and putting it in its appropriate place. Ms. Carr also testified that on March 26, 2002, when MOTHER requested additional homework for STUDENT , she supplied MOTHER with that work the next day. Additionally, Mr. Morgan, STUDENT ’s RSP math teacher, testified that he gave STUDENT the work in Petitioner’s Exhibit 13 for the purpose of helping STUDENT become comfortable with his math class.
Mr. Stallard, STUDENT ’s regular education Pre-Algebra teacher, testified that with individual support, STUDENT could be successful and could keep up with the pace of his seventh-grade Pre-Algebra class. However, STUDENT needs to be willing to accept more one-on-one assistance on an extensive basis, and review his work on a nightly basis at home. Mr. Stallard also believed that STUDENT would be more appropriately placed in a math class at the fifth- or sixth-grade level, with monitoring, given the gaps in his education. Although STUDENT has seventh- to eighth-grade ability in math calculations, he would not necessarily be successful in his Pre-Algebra class because the class course work consists of more than just computations. With remediation and outside assistance, such as tutoring, however, Mr. Stallard believed that STUDENT should try his seventh-grade level math class again next school year.
The Hearing Officer concludes that it was appropriate to give STUDENT lower level math homework assignments for the purposes of helping him get accustomed to the math course and teaching him to be responsible in completing and returning his work. Additionally, there was no evidence that the math work performed during class was at a level lower than what STUDENT was capable. Therefore, the math work provided to STUDENT in the SDC was designed to meet his needs.
As to the math goal and objectives, the October 24, 2001 IEP includes one goal and three related objectives designed to help STUDENT solve math problems that involve two or more steps. (Resp.’s Exh. 7.) Both Ms. Carr and Mr. Morrison testified that neither a new math goal nor objectives were drafted at the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting because none were needed since the District members of the IEP team believed the existing ones were appropriate. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT required any new goals or objectives with respect to math. Although STUDENT ’s primary disability was changed to speech and language at the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting, the existing math goal and objectives were not grade-level specific and could have been applied to whatever level STUDENT needed. According to documentary evidence, STUDENT continued to have difficulty with multi-step math problems, and the math goal and objectives focused on helping STUDENT incorporate his basic math skills to solve problems with two or more steps. (Resp.’s Exhs. 7, 8, and 10.) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the math goal and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT ’s needs.
(c) delay in providing speech and language services
It is undisputed that STUDENT should have been identified as eligible to receive speech and language services when he first entered the District in September 2001. The District acknowledged that it should have assessed STUDENT ’s speech and language needs when it conducted its initial assessment in October 2001. (Resp.’s closing argument.) Thus, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the program STUDENT received during the entire 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet his speech and language needs, notwithstanding the fact that direct speech and language services were not initiated until April 2002. (Resp.’s Exh. 3.)
From September 2001, through March 2002, STUDENT did not receive any direct speech and language services. However, as mentioned previously, Ms. Lamberth team-taught the SDC class with Ms. Carr, and when STUDENT was enrolled in Ms. Carr’s SDC in January 2002, he began receiving some general speech and language services in class during the lessons that involved classroom participation. (Testimony of E. Lamberth.) However, Because STUDENT ’s language disability impacted his performance in class, the lack of direct services affected his ability to organize information well and his ability to understand instructions correctly. (Testimony of E. Lamberth.) Ms. Lamberth testified that had STUDENT ’s speech and language been assessed earlier, they could have helped him to better handle the curriculum language. Additionally, Mr. Morrison testified that he believed that STUDENT ’s language difficulties probably were associated with the problems he had with his peers, and had the District assessed his speech and language needs sooner, STUDENT might have had fewer behavioral problems.
The Hearing Officer finds that the delay in providing the speech and language services negatively impacted STUDENT ’s education because specific goals and objectives that would have addressed STUDENT ’s language processing difficulties were not implemented until April 2002. (Resp.’s Exh. 3.)
Speech and language goals and objectives were added to STUDENT ’s IEP on March 26, 2002. According to Ms. Lamberth, those speech and language goals were designed to help STUDENT understand the teacher and the text, and to help him be successful in the classroom and in the community. In addition, once the District identified STUDENT ’s speech and language disorder and revised his IEP, STUDENT began receiving speech and language therapy in class as a designated instructional service. (Testimony of E. Lamberth; Resp.’s Exh. 3.) Specifically, Ms. Lamberth’s lessons with STUDENT included rewording information for him, giving him directions on a one-to-one basis, and explaining things to him, step by step, when he had difficulty following a lesson.
The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District’s program from September 2001 through March 2002, was not designed to address STUDENT ’s speech and language needs. Although STUDENT received some general speech and language services through his enrollment in Ms. Carr’s SDC, which was team-taught with the speech and language specialist, there were no goals and objectives drafted that could address his specific needs. The Hearing Officer does find, however, that when speech and language goals and objectives were drafted and implemented pursuant to the IEP dated March 26, 2002, and one-on-one speech and language services provided to STUDENT by the speech and language specialist during his SDC starting in April 2002, the educational program met his speech and language needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit (a) special day class portion of placement, and (b) level of math work provided in special day class and math goals after second set of assessments performed
While the SDC and the math work, goals, and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT ’s unique needs, a more difficult question is whether those elements of his program were reasonably calculated to allow STUDENT to receive educational benefit. STUDENT was placed in Ms. Carr’s SDC program as of January 15, 2002, and his math goal and objectives from the October 24, 2001 IEP were implemented in that classroom. The primary goal of improving STUDENT ’s academic skills was addressed in the SDC, by direct instruction from the teacher and the speech and language pathologist, and through the group experiences. An appropriate curriculum at STUDENT ’s developmental level, provided in a well-structured environment, allowed him the opportunity to further develop his reading, written language, and math skills. STUDENT ’s program and services were provided in a coordinated and collaborative manner by key District personnel. Mechanisms and support systems were also offered to ensure STUDENT ’s successful integration into the new SDC placement.
Given that the SDC contained the basic necessary components for STUDENT to learn, and the math goal and objectives were consistently addressed throughout the school year in each math class, as discussed above, it appears that STUDENT would have been able to make educational progress in the SDC and specifically with respect to math. Notably, however, there is little evidence of any actual educational benefit STUDENT received over the course of the 2001-2002 school year.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight...an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).) However, the “snapshot” rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a STUDENT ’s educational program if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the STUDENT is not receiving any educational benefit.
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received all Ds, except for one F and one C-. (Resp.’s Exh. 13.) Notes from the October 24, 2001, December 12, 2001, and January 11, 2002 IEP meetings, and STUDENT progress reports from May 2002, indicate that STUDENT continued to have difficulty in all of his classes, that he was in danger of failing, and that his achievement was affected by absences and tardies. (Resp.’s Exhs. 7, 5, 4, and 13.)
However, the Hearing Officer also considers the fact that STUDENT ’s parents kept him out of school for a considerable amount of time from January 2002, to May 2, 2002, at which time they removed him from the school altogether. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through May 22, 2002, the record established that STUDENT had fifty-five unexcused absences, twenty-three of which occurred between February 4, 2002, and March 26, 2002. MOTHER was aware of all of them. (Resp.’s Exhs. 3 and 13; Testimony of MOTHER.) According to MOTHER, by the time of the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT had started to have behavioral problems at school and she grew afraid that STUDENT would not know how to solve peer problems because of his inexperience. MOTHER removed STUDENT from school on May 2, 2002, after an incident on campus allegedly involving STUDENT and some other STUDENT s where alleged inappropriate touching occurred. According to MOTHER, during the STUDENT attendance review board (SARB) conference held in May 2002, an arrangement was made whereby STUDENT would stay home from school until such time as this due process hearing was completed. However, Karen Somosi, District supervisor, testified that after MOTHER removed STUDENT from school, she attempted to arrange a meeting with his parents to discuss his removal. According to Ms. Somosi, she tried on three occasions to contact the parents and inform them of an IEP meeting. There also was a mediation scheduled after the SARB meeting in May 2002, however, the parents did not attend. (Testimony of K. Somosi.) In addition, by letter dated June 4, 2002, the District encouraged STUDENT ’s parents to have him return to school for four periods, three periods in the SDC for English/Language Arts, history, and science, and one period of an elective. Five hours of home instruction per week was offered for math. (Resp.’s Exh. 26.) There was no evidence whether the parents responded to this letter. However, MOTHER testified that STUDENT had not returned to school as of the date of the hearing in this matter.
The Hearing Officer finds that it is nearly impossible to determine whether the District’s program, with respect to his placement in the SDC and the math work and goals implemented therein, actually provided educational benefit because STUDENT was not in school often enough to evaluate any impact the program may have had on his educational progress. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive, however, the District witnesses’ testimony regarding STUDENT ’s potential success had he consistently been present in the SDC with the goals and objectives outlined in the October 24, 2001 IEP. For instance, Ms. Carr testified that she believed that STUDENT could have done better in her class had he not been absent so often and had he made up some of his work and turned in his homework. While in her class, STUDENT missed three and one-half consecutive weeks of school sometime around the end of February and end of March 2002. (Testimony of D. Carr.) In addition, he regularly missed one to two days of school each week, and had many missing assignments. (Id.; Pet.’s Exh. 10.) Ms. Carr explained that she contacted MOTHER during STUDENT ’s extended absence to see if someone would pick up his homework for him. Ms. Carr provided MOTHER with the missing homework assignments; however, not all of it was returned completed. In addition, Ms. Lamberth indicated that she would have liked to, and that it would have been helpful to share information with STUDENT ’s parents regarding his language disorder and things they could work on at home; however, because STUDENT was absent so often from school, it was difficult to determine how to help him with assignments.
Taking into account what was objectively reasonable when the IEPs were drafted, the District’s program, with respect to STUDENT ’s placement in the SDC and the math instruction, was reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Moreover, the District attempted to persuade the parents to return STUDENT to school and it also gave STUDENT an opportunity to make up the school work that he had missed during his absence. The parents’ decision to keep STUDENT out of school had a causal link to STUDENT ’s failure to make progress. Had the District been permitted to consistently provide STUDENT with general instruction in the SDC and work on his math goal and objectives in the SDC, the District would have had the opportunity to gain better insight as to STUDENT ’s performance levels and otherwise amend STUDENT ’s program to ensure he received educational benefit in the 2001-2002 school year.
(c) delay in providing speech and language services
With respect to speech and language services, the Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to design a program to meet STUDENT ’s speech and language needs until the IEP meeting held on March 26, 2002. One-on-one speech and language services did not begin until April 2002; however, the District argues that the lack of speech and language services did not deny STUDENT educational benefit since the SDC classroom was “language rich” and was an appropriate placement to address STUDENT ’s language disability. According to Ms. Lamberth, Ms. Carr’s class was a language-rich environment in which she worked collaboratively with Ms. Carr and the instructional assistant in language arts, and STUDENT received language services on a general basis when he enrolled in that class in January 2002.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT received educational benefit in speech and language beginning in January 2002, when he was placed in Ms. Carr’s SDC because there were no goals and objectives in place to address his specific needs. Although STUDENT ’s presence in the SDC (although sporadic) may have provided him some minimal benefit given the language-rich environment and the general assistance of the speech and language specialist in the classroom one day each week, there was no convincing evidence that any benefit that he may have received was more than minimal. Although the IDEA is not a maximizing statute and special education law only requires a school district to provide a STUDENT with a “basic floor of opportunity,” de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Bd. of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley; 458 U.S. 176, 208 (1982); Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998).
Therefore, because there were no speech and language goals in place until April 2002, no direct speech and language services provided to STUDENT until then, and no convincing evidence of any progress made by STUDENT with respect to his speech and language development, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit in speech and language until the IEP dated March 26, 2002, was implemented in April 2002. The evidence does demonstrate, however, that the offer contained in the March 26, 2002 IEP with respect to speech and language services was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. MOTHER testified that she agreed with the findings made in Ms. Lamberth’s speech and language evaluation, and there was no dispute that the speech and language goals were appropriate. However, MOTHER did contend that STUDENT ’s speech and language needs were not being met because no material was sent home with STUDENT . Ms. Lamberth testified that she did not give language homework because she assisted STUDENT in class and most of the assignments were language-based and oral. Ms. Lamberth worked in connection with the core SDC curriculum and taught STUDENT techniques and strategies within the curriculum for him to be successful in class. The March 26, 2002 IEP included speech and language goals that were geared towards helping STUDENT understand the teacher and texts, and helping him be successful in the classroom and community. (Testimony of E. Lamberth.) In light of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language services provided at school were appropriate and that STUDENT did not require homework to address his speech and language development. Accordingly, the speech and language portion of the March 26, 2002 IEP that was implemented in April 2002, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit.
Comported with his IEP
Petitioner alleges that the District’s program failed to comport with his IEP in the following respects: (a) the District failed to implement behavioral intervention methods as stated in his IEP; (b) the District failed to provide his parents with weekly progress reports as specified in his IEP; and (c) the District placed him in a physical education class despite his parents’ notification to the school that he could not participate in physical education class due to his asthma condition.
(a) behavioral intervention methods
The IEP dated March 26, 2002, indicates that the psychologist recommended that a five-minute time be set aside each day for the SDC teacher to speak directly with STUDENT about his day. (Resp.’s Exh. 3.) Ms. Carr testified that the IEP team agreed that she would talk with STUDENT each day about how his day went and about his homework. According to Ms. Carr, this provision in the IEP was not a behavior intervention program, but simply a strategy that could be used with STUDENT . This strategy was suggested given the many social/behavioral problems that STUDENT was having on campus and with his peers. According to MOTHER, although Petitioner did talk with his SDC teacher at the end of each school day, they did not discuss his behaviors. Specifically, MOTHER testified that Ms. Carr did not discuss the incident involving the alleged inappropriate touching with STUDENT at the end of the day on which it happened, even though she was aware that the incident had occurred. Rather, principal Sprigg brought the matter up with STUDENT and MOTHER at the end of the school day when MOTHER came to the school.
Based on the limited evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not implement the March 26, 2002 IEP on one occasion with respect to the discussions that were to take place between Ms. Carr and STUDENT . There was no other evidence that this aspect of the IEP was not implemented on other occasions.
(b) progress reports
Once STUDENT was placed in Ms. Carr’s SDC on January 15, 2002, MOTHER requested that progress reports be sent home every Friday during the third quarter of the school year. (Pet.’s Exh. 1.) MOTHER testified that she received only one progress report on January 18, 2002, and then communication between her and the school ceased. According to guidance administrator Maria Carroll, the progress report system at Tetzlaff functions as follows: the school office provides the progress form to the STUDENT during first period every Friday; the STUDENT takes the form to each of his/her teachers for their respective signatures; and then the STUDENT takes the form home for his parent’s signature. The STUDENT must bring the form back to school the following school day, signed by his/her parent. If the STUDENT does not return the form on the following Monday, he may not receive the progress form again the next Friday.
The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the provision of progress reports was not a part of any of STUDENT ’s IEPs. Rather, it was a service provided by the school upon parent request. Therefore, the District was not obligated, pursuant to any law, to provide a STUDENT with weekly progress reports. Nevertheless, the evidence showed that, in accordance with the District’s general procedures for all STUDENT s, the District did in fact prepare the requested progress reports and forward them to the parent through the STUDENT . However, STUDENT had neglected to take the progress reports home and the IEP team found a stack of the reports under his desk at school. (Testimony of D. Carr.)
(c) placement in physical education class
The March 26, 2002 IEP indicates that STUDENT ’s participation in physical education would be discontinued from March 27, 2002, until June 22, 2002. (Resp.’s Exh. 3.) According to MOTHER, however, STUDENT ’s fourth quarter class schedule indicated he was enrolled in physical education. MOTHER went to the school on May 2, 2002, to alert the school of the mis-scheduling; however, she was approached by the principal who wanted to discuss another incident. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
Notwithstanding the fact that physical education may have shown up on STUDENT ’s fourth quarter class schedule, there was no evidence that STUDENT was required to participate in that class after it was removed from his schedule at the March 26, 2002 IEP meeting. Petitioner also alleged that in November 2001, his parent provided the school with a doctor’s note, stating that he was not to participate in physical education due to his asthma condition. According to MOTHER, although STUDENT tried to explain to his instructor that he was not to participate in physical education, he was forced to wear someone else’s gym clothes and participate in the class.
Petitioner did not provide evidence of the note submitted to the school, and at the time of the November 2001 incident, his IEP did not restrict his participation in physical education class. Therefore, the school did not violate any provision of his IEP when he was required to participate in the physical education class in November 2001.
Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner argues that Ms. Carr’s SDC math class was not the least restrictive environment (LRE) in which to provide him educational services because of his higher level of skills in math calculation. The District argues that STUDENT ’s placement in the special education math class was the least restrictive environment for him.
Because of STUDENT ’s extensive absences, the evidence did not clearly demonstrate which class would be the least restrictive environment in which STUDENT should receive math instruction. Over the course of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT received math instruction in the regular education, RSP, and SDC classrooms. However, each of his math teachers indicated that his inconsistent attendance at school negatively impacted his performance in their respective classes because he was not receiving the instruction he required. (Testimonies of E. Stallard, P. Morgan, and D. Carr.) Because STUDENT ’s attendance at school was inconsistent and therefore his instruction in math not continuous with any one teacher, the Hearing Officer cannot make a determination as to whether the SDC was the LRE for STUDENT ’s math instruction. Nor was there persuasive evidence to support either party’s contentions with respect to the appropriate math class for STUDENT .
Therefore, the Hearing Officer orders the IEP team to reconvene and determine whether STUDENT should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, or in special education for his math instruction. Information from all of STUDENT ’s former math teachers must be considered when making a placement determination for his math class. Moreover, the IEP team must also consider STUDENT ’s ability level, his language disorder, and his limited exposure to the public school math curriculum when determining whether he would be more appropriately placed in RSP, SDC, or regular education math class.
Conclusion
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received a FAPE with respect to his placement in the SDC and the math work, goals and objectives because those provisions of his IEP were designed to meet his unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. The parent’s removal of STUDENT from school, however, caused him to miss an extensive amount of instruction, which resulted in his failure to make progress. Because the effect of the parents’ removal was not the District’s fault, the absence of any substantial evidence of educational progress did not constitute a legal violation by the District.
With respect to speech and language services, the District’s program from September 2001 through March 2002, was not designed to address STUDENT ’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was denied a FAPE with respect to speech and language services from September 2001 through March 2002.
With respect to implementation of STUDENT ’s IEP, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed, on one occasion, to implement his March 26, 2002 IEP with respect to the five-minute discussion that was supposed to take place between Ms. Carr and STUDENT . However, the Hearing Officer concludes that because the particular disciplinary incident that Petitioner believed should have been discussed with his teacher was ultimately discussed between STUDENT , his mother, and the principal on the same day that it occurred, there was no evidence that this failure to implement the IEP in any way affected STUDENT ’s education.
In addition, the Hearing Officer found that the District properly implemented STUDENT ’s IEPs with respect to the provision of progress reports and his participation in physical education class.
Finally, the Hearing Officer was not able to make a determination as to whether the SDC math class was the least restrictive environment for STUDENT , given his inconsistent attendance and the lack of any persuasive testimony from the witnesses in support of either party’s contentions. The IEP team is ordered to reconvene and make a determination, using the criteria stated by the Hearing Officer in the section above, as to the appropriate math placement for STUDENT .
3. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
During the course of the hearing, Petitioner did not provide the Hearing Officer or the District with notice of any nonpublic school in which he desired placement. However, when Petitioner submitted his closing argument, he also submitted the name of a school that he wanted the Hearing Officer to consider. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that the record was closed for any additional evidence on the last day of hearing. Closing arguments are not considered evidence and are merely a summary of a party’s argument. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider Petitioner’s request for placement in the school that was submitted with his closing brief. Although Petitioner’s request for placement at a particular school will not be considered in this Decision due to its untimeliness, the Hearing Officer has full authority to award an appropriate remedy in this matter since it was determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from September 2001 through March 2002, with respect to speech and language services. With this in mind, the Hearing Officer considers awarding relief in the form of compensatory education.
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the STUDENT with appropriate, special education services. (STUDENT W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the STUDENT is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.) In determining an appropriate award of compensatory education, the Hearing Officer must examine what services would be necessary to compensate for the District’s failure to provide appropriate services from September 2001 through March 2002.
When questioned by the Hearing Officer as to whether STUDENT required additional services to make up for the time he was not provided speech and language services, speech and language pathologist Ellen Lamberth did not have a definitive response. Rather, Ms. Lamberth indicated that it would be difficult to determine if STUDENT suffered any harm from not receiving speech and language services since his situation was so uncommon. Ms. Lamberth indicated that she did not have experience with STUDENT s who had been out of the public school system for such an extensive period of time, and that STUDENT probably needed speech and language services all of his life. Moreover, she indicated that she did not know if it would make a significant difference if STUDENT had make-up sessions because as of January 2002, he had received some speech and language services, although at a reduced level, just from being in Ms. Carr’s SDC. Nevertheless, Ms. Lamberth also testified that the assumption is that some services are always beneficial to a STUDENT . However, STUDENT had not been in class regularly enough for her to give an opinion as to whether an increased amount of services was necessary.
The Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that STUDENT requires more speech and language services than what he previously required. Therefore, the District shall provide STUDENT with the same level of speech and language services as indicated in his March 26, 2002 IEP. However, the IEP team shall reconvene after thirty days to determine whether an increase in services is warranted at that time.
ORDER
1. The IEP team shall immediately reconvene and determine whether STUDENT should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, or in special education for his math instruction. Information from all of STUDENT ’s former math teachers must be considered when making a placement determination for his math class. The IEP team must also consider STUDENT ’s ability level, his language disorder, and his limited exposure to the public school math curriculum when determining whether he would be more appropriately placed in a regular education, RSP, or SDC math class.
2. During the 2002-2003 school year, the District shall provide STUDENT with, at a minimum, the same level of speech and language services as indicated in his March 26, 2002 IEP. The IEP team shall reconvene after thirty days of implementation of services to determine whether an increase in services is warranted at that time.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in October 2001?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment during the 2001-2002 school year?
Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue with respect to speech and language services. The District prevailed in part with respect to STUDENT ’s placement in the SDC, the math work, goal, and objectives, and implementation of his IEP.
3. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school?
Petitioner partially prevailed on this issue in that he is entitled to receive speech and language services. The District prevailed in part in that Petitioner is not entitled to prospective placement at a nonpublic school.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: August 26, 2002 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis.
2. The Sylvan diagnostic assessment report indicates that the results that it reports as grade equivalent are not expected to equal the classroom grade level since Sylvan administers standardized tests on an individual basis for placement within a Sylvan program. (Resp.’s Exh. 10.)
3. The Hearing Officer need not address Petitioner’s additional arguments regarding Ms. Roehl’s competency because the Hearing Officer was able to conclude that the assessment was improper based on the fact that STUDENT ’s speech and language development was not assessed at the time of the initial assessment and his disability was misdiagnosed.
4. Mr. Morrison’s experience includes working as a school psychologist for the District for the past twenty-two years. He is licensed as a marriage and family therapist and education psychologist and possesses administration and school psychologist credentials. He has worked as a teacher in an RSP program and has served as a school counselor. Mr. Morrison testified that he has a bachelor’s degree in English, a master’s degree in education, and both an advanced master’s degree and Ph.D. in education psychology.
5. Mr. Morgan testified that he conducted the achievement testing of STUDENT in October 2001, and met with STUDENT ’s classroom teacher to determine where he needed help. According to Mr. Morgan, he is trained and qualified to administer the Woodcock Johnson Test of Achievement that he used with STUDENT . (Pet.’s Exh. 4.)
6. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT did not enroll in Ms. Carr’s SDC until January 15, 2002, and therefore, the analysis regarding the educational benefit of the SDC and the math work and goals implemented in that class is confined to the time frame from January 15, 2002, to the end of the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner does not allege that he should have been placed in the SDC sooner than January 2002, or that his math work was inappropriate in any class other than Ms. Carr’s SDC.
7. STUDENT began receiving speech and language therapy as a direct instructional service as of April 2002, and Petitioner contends that he should have received those services as of the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year.
