California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 9, 2001

Student v. Huntington Beach Union High School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 98-01, SN-98-01 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

Huntington Beach Union High must fund Summit View School, counseling, and software after years of unimplemented accommodations.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Before the decision, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner's post-hearing motion (received October 1, 2001) to reopen the record to admit a civil complaint filed by a District witness. The parties also agreed before hearing that the student would get an additional year of high school eligibility and a driver's education class.

Summary

An 18-year-old student with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Huntington Beach Union High School District and the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education. At Edison High School he took mostly general education classes plus one resource specialist program (RSP) class. Because of slow processing speed and working-memory deficits, he read at an elementary level. The hearing covered January 11, 1998, through the 2000-2001 school year.

The Hearing Officer found that the district denied him a FAPE every year. His IEPs left out accommodations he needed. The ones they did list, such as a peer note-taker and computer access, were seldom provided. His RSP case carrier knew he was failing tests and losing work but did not act. Teachers gave him passing "D" grades because he tried. Exempting him from group testing did not deny FAPE. Holding IEP meetings without a general education teacher was a procedural violation, but it did not deny FAPE either.

In February 2001 the parents moved him to Summit View School, a nonpublic school. Testimony showed he benefited there, so the district must repay tuition and mileage. As compensatory education, the district must pay for Summit in 2001-2002, provide weekly counseling with a different district counselor, and supply writing software with parent training. It must also assess him for occupational therapy and provide recommended services. The Hearing Officer denied repayment for private assessments, 360 hours of LMB reading therapy, and speech therapy, which the parents had declined.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO found that passing grades and being on track to graduate did not prove educational benefit when IEP accommodations went unimplemented. It also shows SEHO denying payment for private evaluations because the parents never disagreed with a district assessment first. Parents' and student's own testimony could establish that a private placement was appropriate.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 1A. Did the District substantively deny a FAPE from January 11, 1998, through 2000-2001 by failing to provide appropriate classroom accommodations and modifications and/or implement those in the IEP; inadequately responding to unique needs in reading, math, social skills, counseling, and organizational skills; refusing to refer to county mental health from January 2001; and declining to provide OT, speech and language, and assistive technology services?

    Needed accommodations were missing from the IEPs and listed ones were not consistently implemented, so the District denied a substantive FAPE each year; speech therapy was not shown to be a need, and the county mental health referral claim was not separately decided.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1B(i). Did the District procedurally deny a FAPE by excusing the student from participation in the yearly national testing?

    The IEP team's January 2000 decision to measure progress with an individual Woodcock-Johnson test instead of group testing was not shown to cause any loss of benefit and was not made without parental knowledge; no violation.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 1B(ii). Did the District procedurally deny a FAPE by failing to include a general education teacher as a member of each IEP meeting?

    General education teachers were absent from many IEP meetings, which was of significant concern, but this alone did not deny FAPE because communicating with teachers was the case carrier's duty.

  4. Issue 2. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for tuition and transportation for that portion of 2000-2001 during which the student was unilaterally placed at Summit, a nonpublic school?

    Although Summit gave no credit and enrollment was part-time, testimony showed it met his needs and gave educational benefit; tuition and mileage reimbursement ordered.

  5. Issue 3. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments?

    Parents obtained private evaluations without first disagreeing with a District assessment and before the District could finish the assessments they had requested, so no reimbursement.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Is the student entitled to compensatory education in the form of Summit tuition and transportation for 2001-2002; 360 hours of LMB therapy; weekly counseling through 2001-2002; weekly speech and language therapy through 2001-2002; and a computer and appropriate software?

    Awarded Summit tuition and transportation for 2001-2002, weekly counseling with a different District counselor, and writing software with parent training; LMB therapy and compensatory speech therapy denied.

  7. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 5. Is the student entitled to an occupational therapy (OT) assessment with the implementation of any recommended services?

    Records repeatedly noted hand tremors and slow, laborious handwriting, which put the District on notice; OT assessment and recommended services ordered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of payment, reimburse parents for Summit tuition for the relevant portion of 2000-2001, plus transportation at the District's regular mileage rate for two home-to-school round trips per school day attended.
  • Prospective funding of private placement. Within 10 calendar days of the decision, arrange to pay Summit tuition and transportation for the 2001-2002 school year (as compensatory education).
  • Order to assess. Conduct an OT assessment.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Convene an IEP meeting within the legal timeline to discuss the OT assessment and arrange appropriate OT services.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 10 calendar days, provide the computer writing software described in the assistive technology assessment (order says dated April 11, 2001) and arrange monthly computer training for parents as recommended.
  • Compensatory education. Schedule weekly counseling sessions with a District counselor other than the prior counselor (order says 'Mr. Creighton'; discussion says Mr. Kaplan).

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School District v. B.S.; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup; Moubry v. Independent School District 696; Todd v. Andrews

People named in the decision

  • James Keating, director of special education, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Jim Hemsley, SELPA/consortium director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education
  • James Kilroy, reading teacher, head of reading department, Edison High School
  • Carol Hayes, Ph.D., school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Robert Stolte, assistant principal, Edison High School
  • Wayne Jorgenson, general education government teacher, Edison High School
  • Dennis Creighton, resource specialist teacher and case carrier, Edison High School
  • Teresa Etchepare, speech-language pathologist and assistive technology specialist, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Steve Kaplan, school psychologist/counselor, Edison High School
  • Pat Goldman, administrative designee and inclusion specialist, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Leah Ellenberg, Ph.D., private neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student, Private
  • Dr. Corman, private neurological testing for dyslexia, Private
  • LMB, private reading provider (diagnostic testing), Private
  • Mr. Chaplin, counselor (as named in decision), Not stated
  • Summit View School, nonpublic school, Private
  • Loren Grossman, non-attorney advocate for Student, A to Z Educational Advocates

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Huntington Beach, California, on May 17 and 18, June 21, July 5, 6, 12, 13, 26, and 27, 2001.

Petitioner STUDENT (hereinafter Petitioner or STUDENT ) was represented by attorney Jane Dubovy and advocate Loren Grossman with A to Z Educational Advocates. The Petitioner and his parents, FATHER and MOTHER, were present throughout the hearing. FAMILY FRIEND, a friend of the family, was present for a portion of the hearing.

Respondents, Huntington Beach Union High School District (hereinafter Huntington or District) and West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE), were represented by attorney Laurie Reynolds with the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District=s behalf was James Keating, the District=s director of special education, and Jim Hemsley, director of West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE).

Many of the witnesses who appeared at the hearing were listed as witnesses by both the Petitioner and the Respondent. The parties therefore stipulated that each would conduct its direct and cross-examination during the same appearance of the following witnesses: James Kilroy, teacher at Edison High School (hereinafter Edison); Carol Hayes, Ph.D., school psychologist; Robert Stolte, assistant principal at Edison; Wayne Jorgenson, teacher at Edison; Dennis Creighton, resource specialist teacher at Edison; Teresa Etchepare, speech and language pathologist; Steve Kaplan, school psychologist at Edison; and Pat Goldman, District administrative designee and inclusion specialist.

The Petitioner called the following additional witnesses: Leah Ellenberg, Ph.D., neuropsychologist; STUDENT, Petitioner; and MOTHER, Petitioner=s mother. The Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: James Keating, District=s director of special education, and Jim Hemsley, director of WOCCSE. As rebuttal witnesses, the Respondent called, or recalled Steve Kaplan, school psychologist; Carol Hayes, Ph.D., school psychologist; and James Keating, director of special education.

Oral and documentary evidence was received during the hearing, and written closing arguments were submitted thereafter. The record was then closed and the issues were submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

A. During the Course of the Hearing

The Petitioner submitted a lengthy statement of issues, several of which the Respondent contested. The Hearing Officer and the parties devoted substantial time to ascertaining the issues to be determined at the hearing. Thereafter, with the agreement of both parties, the Hearing Officer defined the issues as set forth below.

The Respondent also maintained that many of the issues set forth by the Petitioner were limited by the statute of limitations and requested a determination of the school years to be adjudicated during the hearing. The Hearing Officer determined that none of the exceptions that would extend the statute of limitations applied to this case and, that the time period to be addressed at the hearing would be three years prior to the date that the Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office. California Education Code '56505.

Before the hearing began, the parties agreed that the Petitioner would remain eligible for a additional year of high school, rather than graduate at the end of the 2000-2001 school year as scheduled, and that the District would provide a driver=s education class.

The Petitioner initially asserted a claim to college tuition and expenses at a college specifically designed for students with learning disabilities. The Hearing Officer ruled that this was not an appropriate issue for a due process hearing. However, the Petitioner was given an opportunity to provide legal support for his contention that a high school district could be held responsible for college expenses after the graduation of a special education student. No legal authority was provided, thus this claim was removed as an issue for the hearing.

B. After the Hearing Concluded and the Record was Closed

On October l, 2001, the Special Education Hearing Office received a motion from the Petitioner to reopen the due process hearing to admit a civil complaint filed by a District witness as additional evidence in this case. The motion is based upon the assertion that school psychologist, Carol Hayes, Ph.D, a District employee who provided expert testimony at the hearing, had filed a lawsuit before she testified at the hearing alleging defamation and seeking money damages against the Petitioner=s parents, his attorney, and his advocate. The Petitioner asserts that the basis of the lawsuit by Dr. Hayes is that the Petitioner attacked her status as an appropriately licensed psychologist by the State of California. The Petitioner maintains that Dr. Hayes should have disclosed that she had filed this lawsuit before she provided testimony at the hearing. He states that the civil complaint should be admitted to establish that Dr. Hayes had a motive to give biased testimony, which, if accepted by the Hearing Officer, could substantially prejudice the outcome of the hearing.

The District=s response to the Petitioner=s motion to admit additional evidence was submitted to the Special Education Hearing Office on October 5, 2001. The District argues that there is no legal requirement that a witness disclose a conflict of interest. The District points out that Dr. Hayes was subjected to lengthy cross-examination by the Petitioner, which afforded him an opportunity to fully explore Dr. Hayes=s credibility, biases, and any conflicts that would affect the believability of the testimony she provided. Additionally, the District contends that Dr. Hayes=s testimony related to an assessment she conducted on the Petitioner months before any civil lawsuit was contemplated or filed. Thus, her testimony was based upon facts, information, and opinions that existed prior to any events that later gave rise to a civil suit by Dr. Hayes.

DISCUSSION

The Hearing Officer initially notes that the Petitioner has not provided any legal support for his contention that a witness in any type of judicial proceeding has an affirmative duty to disclose potential conflicts of interests, biases, or other information that could render the witness=s testimony less credible. To establish bias or impeach a witness=s credibility, an opposing party is entitled to cross-examine and introduce relevant evidence that tends to prove that a witness=s testimony should be doubted, or disregarded. California Evidence Code ' 406.

The trier of fact is then specifically authorized by statute to consider any evidence brought forth regarding a witness=s credibility. California Evidence Code ' 780 states in relevant part: AThe court or jury may consider in determining the credibility of a witness any matter that has any tendency in reason to prove or disprove the truthfulness of his testimony at the hearing, including but not limited to any of the following: . . (f) the existence or nonexistence of a bias, interest, or other motive . . . .@

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that there is a valid reason to reopen the record to admit the civil lawsuit itself. The actual contents of a separate civil suit is not the relevant issue. Instead, the Petitioner=s underlying argument is that the fact that such a lawsuit existed at the time the testimony was provided is relevant to a determination of whether of Dr. Hayes=s testimony was biased in this case.

The Petitioner was allowed to introduce the evidence of Dr. Hayes=s licensing difficulties, and fully cross-examined her on this issue during the hearing. The Hearing Officer was therefore informed of the matter, and understood that the Petitioner presented this information to question Dr. Hayes=s competence and credibility. Thus, for purposes of this hearing, the information that apparently forms the basis of Dr. Hayes=s civil lawsuit was presented to the Hearing Officer, and introducing the actual lawsuit containing these allegations would not add additional information relevant to the due process hearing.

More importantly, the Petitioner has substantially prevailed in the decision rendered herein, and a civil filing by Dr. Hayes does not impact that determination. Furthermore, the psychological evidence relied upon by the Hearing Officer was agreed upon by both the Petitioner=s expert psychologist and Dr. Hayes. Thus, there was no area in which the decision was impacted solely by the testimony of Dr. Hayes.

For the above reasons, the Petitioner=s motion to reopen the record to admit the civil lawsuit filed by Dr. Hayes is denied.

ISSUES

1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE), from January 11, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year, and during the 1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years by:

A. SubstantivelyBfailing to provide appropriate classroom accommodations and modifications, and/or implement those specified in STUDENT=s IEP; inadequately responding to STUDENT=s unique needs in the areas of reading, math, social skills, counseling, and organizational skills; refusing to refer STUDENT to the appropriate county mental health (CMH) agency from January 2001 through the present; and declining to provide services in the areas of occupational therapy, speech and language, and assistive technology; and

B. ProcedurallyBExcusing STUDENT from participation in the yearly national testing and failing to include a general education teacher as a member of each Individual Education Plan (IEP) meeting during each of the above school years?

2. Are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for tuition and transportation for that portion of the 2000-2001 during which he was unilaterally placed at Summit, a nonpublic school (NPS)?

3. Are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments?

4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of: tuition and transportation costs for Summit NPS for the 2001-2002 school year; 360 hours of LMB therapy; counseling one hour per week until the end of the 2001-2002 school year; one hour a week of speech and language therapy until the end of the 2001-2002 school year; and a computer and appropriate software?

5. Is the Petitioner entitled to an occupational therapy (OT) assessment with the implementation of any recommended services?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

It is the Petitioner=s position that the District did not provide adequate support, modifications, and accommodations to meet his needs as a special education student with an identified specific learning disability. He also claims that many of the modifications and accommodations that were identified in his IEP were not implemented. The Petitioner maintains that the District did not recognize, assess, or service all areas of his disability. Specifically, he claims that his needs in the areas of OT, speech, mental health, and assistive technology were ignored by the District. As a result of the District=s alleged failure to meet his educational needs, the Petitioner contends that he did not make meaningful academic progress during his ninth, tenth, eleventh, and twelfth grades of high school.

The District disputes the Petitioner=s assertions. It maintains that it consistently offered and/or provided an appropriate educational program for STUDENT that included general education courses, classes from the resource specialist program (RSP), general education remedial reading classes, speech therapy, and counseling services. The District also claims that it provided the Petitioner with all necessary accommodations, modifications, and assistive technology. The District argues that its program was beneficial to the Petitioner and he was Aon-tract@ to graduate from high school at the end of the 2000-2001 school year, until his parents terminated his school attendance and Athwarted@ his scheduled graduation. On the basis of its position that it provided the Petitioner with a FAPE, the District denies that the Petitioner is entitled to any of the remedies he seeks.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is an eighteen-year-old student eligible to attend a fifth year of high school during the 2001-2002 school year. He has a medical diagnoses of neurofibromatosis (a congenital condition involving the tissues), and attention deficit disorder (ADD). His educational designation is a specific learning disability. STUDENT=s disability is primarily evidenced by decreased processing speed and difficulties with his Aworking@ memory. Thus, he cannot readily retrieve information, and he is unable to successfully access what he has learned. STUDENT also has ADD with organizational problems, diminished social skills, hand tremors of an undetermined source, and handwriting that is slow and laborious. His cognitive ability scores have remained relatively consistent over the years. The recent standardized intelligence score obtained by his private psychologist on the Weschsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III) was a full-scale score of 91.

Historically, STUDENT was identified as a special education student by the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) soon after beginning elementary school. He was initially placed in a special day class (SDC) by LAUSD, but was removed at his parents= request. In the fourth grade, STUDENT began attending the Huntington Beach Elementary School District. He continued in this school district for the remainder of his elementary and middle school years, when he transitioned to high school. STUDENT entered Edison High School (Edison), within the Huntington Beach High School District, as a ninth-grader and remained at that school until he was removed by his parents and placed in a nonpublic school (NPS) during the latter portion of his senior year.

In elementary and middle school, STUDENT was placed in general education classes with accommodations, modifications and RSP support. At various times, he received DIS services that included adaptive physical education (APE), counseling, and speech therapy. Woodcock-Johnson (WJ) standardized test scores were relatively consistent for the fifth, sixth, seventh and eighth grades, and did not significantly change throughout four years of high school.

At the annual IEP meeting held in April 1997 during STUDENT=s eighth grade year, the team agreed that an appropriate program for STUDENT=s first year of high school would be five general education classes with accommodations and RSP support, one period of RSP English, and weekly counseling. A transition plan also was developed containing goals for education, employment, recreation, independent living, and financial skills.

STUDENT matriculated to high school and began ninth grade in September 1997. The District implemented the April 1997 IEP drafted at the end of eighth grade. It added a reading skills class. At the District high schools, an RSP teacher is appointed as a special education case carrier/manager. The duties of a case carrier are to ensure that the special education student=s IEP is implemented to monitor the student=s progress, and to respond to any problems that may arise. During the middle of STUDENT=s ninth grade, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT requested that STUDENT=s case carrier be changed from the individual initially assigned to another teacher. The District agreed to assign Mr. Creighton, STUDENT=s RSP English teacher, in place of the initial case carrier. Mr. Creighton continued as STUDENT=s case carrier until STUDENT left Edison during his senior year.

In the ninth grade, a few students made racially offensive remarks to STUDENT, then physically attacked him on his way home from school. An IEP meeting was convened to address STUDENT=s consequent fears and discuss ways to maximize his safety on campus. A plan was agreed upon by the IEP team under which STUDENT would be observed at all times by a staff member during breaks between classes and at lunchtime. A school psychologist was to explain the situation to STUDENT=s general education teachers. Sometime thereafter, the student who was the Aring leader@ of the verbal harassment and assault on STUDENT, left Edison.

During STUDENT=s senior year, the student who had assaulted him when he was a freshmen returned to Edison and was placed in STUDENT=s ceramics class. STUDENT stated that he felt apprehensive and anxious because this student was back at Edison and in one of his classes. The PARENTS did not advise the District that the student with whom STUDENT had an altercation as a freshman was enrolled in his ceramics class. The District personnel who arranged the schedule for the offending student were unaware, or did not recall, that there had been a conflict between STUDENT and the other student three years prior.

STUDENT struggled academically throughout high school, but completed his all of classes with final grades of AD@ or above. He had problems each year with interactive skills and had few, if any, friends at school. Based upon the District=s requirements, STUDENT was Aon-track@ to graduate from high school at the end of the 2000-2001 school year.

Mr. and Mrs. PARENT did not agree that STUDENT was prepared to exit high school, maintaining that his entire high school education had been inadequate. They obtained an educational assessment from Leah Ellenberg, Ph.D., a private neuropsychologist, in mid-December 2001 (report dated January 7, 2001). At the IEP meeting of January 11, 2001, the Petitioner=s parents requested reimbursement for the evaluation by Dr Ellenberg, private placement at Summit View School (hereinafter Summit), an NPS, an additional year of high school at Summit, and District assessments. At the same meeting, the PARENTS and their advocate, acting in conjunction with an their attorney, demanded that the District pay for STUDENT=s college education at Landmark College in Vermont as remuneration for his alleged lack of progress in high school. The Petitioner represented that Landmank specializes in teaching students with learning disabilities. When the District did not agree with the Petitioner=s position at the January 11, 2001 IEP meeting, his parents unilaterally transferred him to Summit, and filed for this due process hearing.

Pursuant to the parents= request for District assessments, the District provided them with an assessment plan dated January 18, 2001. On February 10, 2001, Mr and Mrs PARENT returned the signed assessment plan to the District. The agreed-upon assessment plan provided for the school nurse to review any significant medical information. In addition to an evaluation of social and emotional status, a school psychologist was to assess STUDENT=s general cognitive, academic and motor abilities. A speech therapist was designated to assess the Petitioner=s language and to conduct an assistive technology screening.

Portions of the assessments were completed before STUDENT was unilaterally removed from Edison and placed at Summit on February 20, 2001. The psychoeducational assessment was conducted by the District=s school psychologist on February 7 and 14, 2001. When the District was attempting to complete the assessments after STUDENT left Edison, MOTHER initially stated that because of her son=s schedule, the evaluations must be arranged for a Sunday. School personnel are not available on weekends, so compliance within her parameters was impossible. Instead, the District offered four dates in late March to complete the remaining assessments. Ultimately, MOTHER relented and authorized one session to complete the two assessments. After rescheduling, the IEP meeting to discuss the results and recommendations of the District=s assessors was convened on May 7, 2001. Dr. Hayes began the presentation of her psychoeducational report. Before she completed the review of her test results and conclusions, MOTHER became upset and terminated the meeting. The District completed a draft IEP and sent it to the Petitioner=s parents with its placement offer.

The PARENTS rejected the District=s offer. Instead, STUDENT transferred to Summit on a part-time basis. Summit agreed only that STUDENT could retake classes for which he had already received credits at Edison, the equivalent of Aauditing@ a course.

FINDINGS OF FACTS AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE ONE

Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE), from January 11, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year, and during the 1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?

ASpecial education@ is defined as Aspecially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . @ 20 U.S.C. '1401(25). Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8), Afree and appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student=s individualized education program.

In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district=s proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or if that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child=s potential. The Court held that Athe >basic floor of opportunity= provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.@ An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or Apotential-maximizing@ education for the individual child. See also, Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994).

As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. Pursuant to federal law, the term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22). California Education Code ' 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@ Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.

Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment can occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes, with the use of supplementary aids and services, cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code ' 56031.

Pursuant to the above law, a district has complied with its statutory obligations to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services: (1) identifies and addresses the student=s unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, (3) conforms to the IEP, and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. ' 1400 et seq. placement offer.

The Hearing Officer will discuss the above requirements when determining the appropriateness of the District=s placement offers and services rendered during STUDENT=s high school years. Although the Petitioner=s claim encompasses multiple years, each year involves allegations regarding the same facts. Therefore, the school years will be discussed collectively when determining the appropriateness of the District=s placement and services.

A. Substantive Appropriateness B January 11, 1998, through June 1998,1998-99, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years.

1. Did the District identify and address STUDENT=s unique needs during the years at issue?

To determine whether the District=s offer of placement and services addressed STUDENT=s needs, it is first necessary to identify his unique needs. STUDENT suffers from a rare congenital disorder called neurofibromatosis. There was no medical evidence presented regarding it effects. However, the parties agreed that a general description of neurofibromatosis is that it is a condition involving abnormalities of the body=s tissues and that learning disabilities are typically a consequence. The parties state that STUDENT has auditory processing limitations with a reduced processing speed that interferes with his ability to hold and retrieve information. He takes medication for ADD, lacks organizational skills, has difficulties with handwriting, mild hand tremors, and limited social skills.

The Petitioner claims that the District repeated its failure to respond to his unique needs each year of high school in essentially the same manner: it failed to provide him with appropriate classroom accommodations and modifications, and to implement those specified in his IEP, and thereby inadequately responded to his unique needs in the areas of reading, math, social skills and organizational skills; it refused to refer him to the appropriate county mental health (CMH) agency from January 2001 through the present; and it declined to implement services in the areas of occupational therapy, speech, and assistive technology. The District maintains that it consistently provided a program that met the Petitioner=s unique needs.

Teresa Etchepare, the District=s speech pathologist and assistive technology specialist, assessed the Petitioner in April 2001. Ms. Etchepare testified that STUDENT=s disability significantly interferes with his ability to process incoming information; he misses and misunderstands details. This combination of disabilities results in STUDENT receiving information that is both superficial and erroneous. According to Ms. Etchepare, not only does STUDENT have problems with incoming information, he also has difficulties expressing information due to his deficiencies in written expression. She stated that to address these duel disabilities, he required modifications such as tape-recorded lectures, a peer note-taker, and assistive computer technology.

During the Petitioner=s first two-and-a-half years of high school, the District provided a program that consisted of five general education classes and RSP English. In the tenth grade, he was enrolled in a general education reading skills class, which combined phonics, decoding, sight words, and contextual reading methodologies. Additionally, note-taking and organizational skills were taught in the reading class. STUDENT was invited to attend his reading instructor=s tutorial twice a week. He continued to receive thirty minutes a week of both speech and counseling services. Tests were read to STUDENT in the RSP room. Other accommodations itemized in STUDENT=s IEP were the use of a calculator when necessary, extended time for tests, access to a computer in the RSP classroom, and peer note-takers as needed.

In the eleventh grade (1999-2000), STUDENT was a teacher=s aide, rather than a student, in his reading skills class. Counseling with the school psychologist continued for half an hour each week. In November 1999, STUDENT was removed from speech by his parents. STUDENT and his parents stated that he was upset by his speech teacher=s death during the semester, and that they thought that the therapy was not beneficial. Speech therapy was not reauthorized by his parents. In March 2000, the IEP team decided that he should be changed to RSP math due to his difficulties with general education math. He completed the RSP math course during the 1999-2000 school year, and its completion fulfilled his graduation requirement for math. At the IEP meeting of January 27, 2000, the IEP team decided that STUDENT would no longer take the group standardized tests. Instead, his progress would be evaluated yearly using an individually administered Woodcock-Johnston Achievement Test (WJ-R). The District offered STUDENT a summer school program called ABreaking the Code,@ a reading program that emphasizes phonics. STUDENT=s parents declined the reading program because it was taught in an SDC for students with learning disabilities.

Since STUDENT=s math requirements were complete, his senior class schedule during the 2000-2001 school year reverted to the program that he had had throughout high schoolCone RSP class (RSP English) and the general education classes he needed to graduate. He remained in counseling.

Dr. Carol Hayes, a District school psychologist, and Dr. Leah Ellenberg, the Petitioner=s private assessor, confirmed that STUDENT=s reading level was that of an elementary student. They also determined that he had auditory processing deficits and could not readily retrieve information stored in his memory. Dr. Hayes testified that these disabilities Aseverely impacted@ STUDENT=s ability to perform in his general education classroom without modifications and accommodations. As early as 1997, the IEP team acknowledged the necessity of implementing appropriate modifications and accommodations in STUDENT=s regular education classes. At an IEP meeting held on March 19, 1998, the team reiterated the need to explore appropriate accommodations and modifications. Although an intent to devise a support plan for general education was expressed, few modifications were actually incorporated into his IEP, or implemented with regularity.

The IEP team determined that STUDENT would have a peer note-taker. However, the note-taker was only provided for one history class, not for his academic classes each school year. STUDENT was removed to an area separate from his classroom so that his tests could be read to him, yet this often occurred in a common, outside corridor by the classrooms. The District provided STUDENT with a regular education reading skills class taught by James Kilroy for the later half of ninth and all of tenth grade. Mr. Kilroy was clearly a committed instructor, who cared about STUDENT and made great efforts to help him learn to read. Unfortunately, his Aeclectic@ reading approach was not effective with STUDENT and did not provide him with truly meaningful benefit. A few computers were located in the RSP room to be shared by all of the RSP students. Although STUDENT was to be allowed access them, since there were more RSP students than computers, his access was limited. Furthermore, the software responsive to STUDENT=s specific needs was not made available to him.

STUDENT read at the level of an elementary student. Even had he been given class notes by a teacher or a peer, his ability to read and understand them was limited. Mr. Creighton testified that STUDENT was never given a tape recorder so that he could record class lectures, nor was he provided with an opportunity to dictate his homework or tests to compensate for his decreased writing skills. He was not supplied computer software that would have assisted him with his difficulties with the mechanics of writing. He did not receive assistance at the end of the school day with compiling his homework assignments. There was no evidence that he was allowed to complete reduced tests or homework assignments. In fact, Mr. Creighton stated that the District will make accommodations, but will not modify general education curriculum for special education students. If the student requires modifications, he will be removed for regular education and placed in RSP pull-out classes.

Each special education student in the District is assigned a RSP teacher as a case carrier. The case carrier is responsible for implementing the student=s IEP placement, program and services. He/she also is to coordinate with the student=s other teachers, ensure that all modifications and accommodations are carried out, evaluate their effectiveness, and make any necessary adjustments. Dennis Creighton testified that he was STUDENT=s case carrier from STUDENT=s freshman year until his exit during his senior year. The testimony of the District witnesses was replete with evidence that STUDENT was not provided with appropriate assistance in his regular education classes. General education teachers testified to various instances where they informed Mr. Creighton that STUDENT was failing tests and/or experiencing difficulties in their classes. Each District witness either stated, or clearly implied, that many of STUDENT=s final grades were finessed to reflect at least a AD,@ which was adequate for him to graduate as scheduled. Wayne Jorgenson, STUDENT=s government teacher, testified to the attitude conveyed by several general education teachers: that the regular educational staff believed that they were successful if the special education students merely obtained some information from their classes.

A concise illustration that establishes that the District did not meet STUDENT=s unique needs each year was provided by Mr. Creighton. As the individual responsible for enforcing STUDENT=s program and ensuring its effectiveness, his testimony alone establishes that STUDENT=s needs were not met. Mr. Creighton relayed instances in which STUDENT=s regular education teachers advised him that STUDENT was failing tests and not completing homework, yet he did not act on this information by providing assistance for STUDENT. Mr. Creighton testified to examples of his personal experience with STUDENT=s need for additional accommodations. He therefore had knowledge that the IEP was inadequate. In his own RSP English class, he observed STUDENT do all of his classwork, understood that STUDENT had ADD which caused difficulty with attention to responsibilities, but did not react when STUDENT turned in less than half of the classwork he had completed. Mr. Creighton did not implement strategies to collect STUDENT=s work at the end of the class. STUDENT often forgot his homework, but he was not given assistance with gaining organizational skills. When the special education staff entrusted with providing the services necessary to meet a student=s needs fails, that student cannot receive a FAPE.

With minor changes, the District provided the same program for STUDENT throughout high school. He was given one RSP course, with the remainder of his classes in general education. Some modifications were included in his IEP, but most were seldom implemented and other needed modifications were never addressed. The Hearing Officer concludes that each school year the modifications and accommodations specified in STUDENT=s IEP were not consistently implemented. The Hearing Officer is further persuaded that necessary modifications and accommodations were absent from his IEP. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs from January 11, 1998, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.

Did the District=s placement provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

Mr. Creighton=s testimony clearly conveyed that STUDENT did not receive the classroom modifications he needed during any of his high school years. The testimony of Wayne Jorgenson, a teacher who has taught general education classes at Edison for thirty-one years, expressed the philosophy that was applied to STUDENT=s educational performance throughout high school. He stated that Aif the student is trying and getting everything he can@ from the class, the student will receive a AD@ grade and not be allowed to fail the course. The Hearing Officer has already concluded that the Petitioner was not given the modifications he needed to accommodate his disability and benefit educationally from his high school classes. Instead, because he appeared to Atry,@ he was promoted year after year, regardless of his poor classroom performance.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District=s failure to consistently implement the modifications and accommodation both identified and needed by the Petitioner deprived him of educational benefit during his four years of high school.

Did the District=s services conform to STUDENT=s IEP?

In the Aunique needs@ section above, the Hearing Officer has already determined that the District did not provide the accommodations and modifications specified in STUDENT=s IEPs.

Was STUDENT=s placement in the least restrictive environment (LRE)?

This was not an issue between the parties while STUDENT attended Edison. Neither party claimed that his program at Edison, which consisted primarily of general education classes, was not in the LRE. For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Petitioner was denied a substantive FAPE during each of the years he attended Edison High School, and he is entitled to a determination of available remedies.

B. Procedural Violations

The United States Supreme Court has held that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of their child’s educational program. Procedural defects do not automatically result in a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a “loss of educational opportunity,” or that “seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992); Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983 (1st Cir. 1990). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. §1415(b). This Petitioner alleges that the following procedural violations deprived him of a FAPE.

1. Excusing STUDENT from participation in the yearly national testing

The Petitioner contends that he should have participated in each year=s District-wide group testing. He alleges that the District did not want him to take the tests because his scores would diminish those of the entire school. Pursuant to his IEP, the Petitioner took the national/group tests without modifications during his first years of high school. Thus, those school years are not at issue. In his IEP dated January 27, 2000, the second semester of his junior year, STUDENT=s participation in group assessments was changed to exempt him from such testing. Instead, his IEP team determined that it would be more beneficial to measure his progress through yearly administration of the WJ.

The Petitioner=s argument is ineffective. The Hearing Officer does not accept the allegation that the decision by the IEP team to evaluate STUDENT=s progress with the WJ rather than the group test constitutes a denial of a FAPE. In particular, a nexus was not established between nonparticipation in yearly group testing and a failure to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. No one testified that the IEP was changed to eliminate STUDENT=s participation in group testing without the knowledge, understanding, and consent of the parents. Other than MOTHER=s testimony of her opinion, there was no evidence introduced that the District encouraged or wanted STUDENT removed from the group testing to enhance the District=s performance scores. To the contrary, District witnesses testified that the scores of a single student would not alter those of the entire district. Jim Keating, director of special education, also explained that at the relevant time, the law allowed a special education student to opt out of the group test. However, that has now changed and all students must take the test with necessary modifications provided for special education students.

2. Failure to include a general education teacher as a member of the IEP team

This Petitioner alleges noncompliance with the law that mandates the presence of a general education teacher at every IEP meeting. In recent years, the law has required a general education teacher=s attendance at all IEP meetings for special education students. Education Code '56341(c). Additionally, when the IEP involves Apupils with suspected learning disabilities, at least one member of the individualized educational program team, other than the pupil=s regular teacher, shall be a person who has observed the pupil=s educational performance in an appropriate setting . . . . @ Education Code '56341(d).

Federal law mandates the inclusion of the following individuals in the IEP team: (1) the parents of the child with the disability; (2) at least one of the child=s regular education teachers, if the child has, or may have, one; (3) at least one special education teacher, or if appropriate one of the child=s special education providers; (4) a representative of the district who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, the DIS services required by the child, is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, and knows the availability of the district=s resources; (5) an individual who can interpret assessment results (this may be the regular education teacher or the district representative); and (6) other individuals the parents request who have special knowledge of their child. Title 20 U.S.C. '1414(d)(1)(B).

Except for one RSP English class each year, and one semester of RSP math, STUDENT attended all general education classes throughout high school. Despite STUDENT=s primary affiliation with the regular education system, District witnesses acknowledged that during his high school years, a general education teacher was rarely in attendance at his IEP meetings.

The District realized the necessity of involving a regular education teacher in STUDENT=s IEP decisions, as well as implementing modifications in his classes. At an IEP meeting held on December 11, 1997, the IEP members specified that a general education teacher should participate in the next IEP meeting. Unfortunately, the IEP team did not follow through. Examples are the absence of general education teachers at IEP meetings on the following dates during STUDENT=s high school years: December 11, 1997, March 19, 1998, April 8, 1998, November 4, 1999, May 6, 2000, and January 11, 2001.

The Hearing Officer is troubled by the frequent absence of a member from the general education staff at the Petitioner=s IEP meetings in a case where the majority of the student=s classes were general education. The Hearing Officer trusts that the District will remedy this defect, and understand that the input of a member from the regular education department would be beneficial when determining STUDENT=s needs. However, every procedural defect does not automatically constitute a denial of a FAPE. As previously stated, the statutory violation must result in deprivation of educational opportunity or substantially interfere with a parent=s participation in their child=s education. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, (supra).

Although of significant concern, the absence of a general education teacher in the IEP process does not form the basis of the denial of a FAPE in this case. It was not the obligation of a single general education teacher to participate in the IEP meeting to communicate with each of STUDENT=s other regular education teachers. This was the duty of STUDENT=s case carrier. Thus, the involvement of a regular education instructor would have greatly assisted in producing an appropriate program for STUDENT, but such a lack of attendance, alone, did not prevent STUDENT from receiving a FAPE.

ISSUE TWO

Are STUDENT=s parents entitled to reimbursement for tuition transportation, and related costs for that portion of the 2000-2001 during which he was unilaterally placed at Summit, a nonpublic school (NPS)?

The parents of disabled children can be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for expenses they incur for private services they obtain to meet their child=s special education needs. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide their child with a free, appropriate education and the private services are found to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358, (1985), See also Florence County School District Four, et.al. v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).

The Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during each of the years that he attended Edison. When considering the appropriateness of the private services provided for their child for reimbursement purposes, parents are not held to the same standard as that of school districts knowledgeable in education, nor must they obtain the best possible private service to be entitled to reimbursement. Their choice must, however, be designed to meet their child=s unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, (supra).

Reimbursement for tuition for the Petitioner=s unilateral placement at Summit for the latter portion of the 2000-2001 school year could initially seem an inappropriate remedy in this case. Documentary evidence and the testimony of MOTHER established that the Petitioner=s parents placed STUDENT at Summit pursuant to an agreement with the NPS that his attendance would not result in credits toward his high school graduation requirements. The agreement also included a disclaimer stating that Summit would not warrant that STUDENT would benefit from Summit=s classes. It further specified that STUDENT would only attend part-time, taking classes for which he had already received credit at Edison. This arrangement did not advance STUDENT=s educational goal of earning a high school diploma, and it raises questions about Summit=s initial belief that it was an appropriate school for STUDENT.

The wisdom of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT=s original decision to place their son at Summit was debatable. Although Summit agreed to allow STUDENT to audit its classes, it placed conditions upon his attendance. STUDENT=s initial placement at the NPS was for a partial day and Summit specified that STUDENT could only retake classes he had already completed at the District=s high school, and that his participation at Summit would not result in credits toward his high school graduation requirements. However, the Petitioner=s inability to establish the appropriateness of his initial placement at Summit was remedied by his consequent ability to establish the educational benefit resulting from his attendance.

Although the Petitioner did not present testimony from anyone affiliated with Summit, the testimony of STUDENT and his mother established the educational, social, and emotional benefits that were conveyed by the NPS. STUDENT testified that the teaching methods employed by Summit allowed him to acquire information that he had not understood when he took the same classes at Edison. He mentioned that class notes are routinely provided by the teachers, that he has access whenever necessary to a computer with software, which helps circumvent his reading and writing difficulties, that homework assignments are clearly defined, and that he be given assistance with organizational and study skills. Socially, STUDENT testified that for the first time he felt accepted by his peer, that the other students were friendly toward him, and that he did not feel different and rejected.

MOTHER reiterated STUDENT=s remarks that he had never had friends at Edison but that he does not feel different from the other students at Summit, which has allowed him to establish friendships with like-peers. She testified that the teachers used a multi-modality method of teaching that worked well for STUDENT. For example, the math teacher used a different colored pencil to depict each step for math calculations. Computers, software appropriate to the individual student=s needs, and Alpha Smart word processors were readily available to the students who require this assistance. STUDENT=s writing projects are edited by the teachers and discussed with him so that he understands ways to improve his writing skills. MOTHER stated that STUDENT=s mood has improved dramatically and he no longer appears depressed, nor does he express feelings of depression and hopelessness. She believes that his self-confidence has improved because he feels successful at Summit.

Dr. Ellenberg testified that she was aware of Summits=s methods, and that many of the modifications necessary to meet STUDENT=s needs are contained within the design of its program. These standard program components include small classes exclusively for students with learning disabilities that utilize multi-modality teaching methods intended to Abypass@ the learning disabilities, the provision of study notes, assistance with organizational skills, test modifications, a modified curriculum, and assistive technology that is immediately accessible to each student in need of such support.

The Hearing Officer has found that the District=s offer for the 2000-2001 school year was inadequate. Accommodations and modifications necessary to provide educational benefit to STUDENT either were not provided in his IEP, or if specified, were not regularly implemented. Computers were few in number, access was available only in the RSP room, and the computers had to be shared by all of the RSP students. This severely limited any individual RSP student=s ability to use a computer. Necessary software to address the Petitioner disabilities was not provided. Even though STUDENT cannot read near grade level, neither a note-taker nor a tape-recorder was routinely provided. He was not assisted with organizational difficulties. The failure to include and/or implement necessary support and accommodations for STUDENT=s classes was a significant defect in his IEP and constituted a primary reason for the denial of a FAPE.

The above testimony provides adequate information to conclude that Summit met the Petitioner=s unique needs and provided educational benefit. The Hearing Officer therefore determines the parents have met the legal requirements necessary to receive reimbursement for STUDENT=s attendance at Summit for the relevant portion of the 2000-2001 school year. Additionally, both Mr. Keating and Mr. Hemsley testified that there are no local nonpublic schools with an appropriate program for STUDENT. Consequently, his enrollment at Summit, even though it is located a significant distance from the District, is reasonable, and the District will also be responsible for reimbursing the Petitioner=s parents for the cost of transporting STUDENT to and from school on the days he attended Summit during the 2000-2001 school year.

ISSUE THREE

Are the Petitioner=s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments?

California Education Code '56329(b) provides:

A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists . . . if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, the public education agency may initiate a due process hearing . . . to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.

Mr. and MOTHER are seeking reimbursement for the following evaluations: a neuropsychological evaluation conducted by Dr. Ellenberg on January 7, 2001, neurological testing for dyslexia done by Dr. Corman on April 4, 2001, and diagnostic testing by LMB on February 27, 2001. The last assessment conducted by the District prior to the independent evaluations obtained by Mr. and MOTHER was a multidisciplinary triennial report prepared for, and presented at, STUDENT=s three-year IEP meeting on January 27, 2000. The Petitioner did not express disagreement with this District assessment. Instead, without prior communication with the District, he secured an independent evaluation by Dr. Ellenberg, and presented her bill for payment at the IEP meeting of January 11, 2001. Likewise, the Petitioner never requested a medical assessment for dyslexia or an LMB evaluation, nor did he allege that the District failed to assess him in these areas.

At the January 11, 2001 IEP meeting, the Petitioner asked for a District psychoeducational assessment to include the areas of social skills, and an assistive technology evaluation. In compliance with the parents= request for a psychoeducational assessment, the District provided an assessment plan to Mr. and Mrs. PARENT for their consent on January 18, 2001, which they returned to the District on February 10, 2001. The assessment plan responded to the parents= requirement that the District=s assessment contain a social skills component, and an assistive technology evaluation. Pursuant to Education Code '56344, the District had fifty days to complete its assessments and convene an IEP meeting following receipt of an executed consent to assess. This time line can be extended through an agreement by the parties.

To be entitled to reimbursement for an independent evaluation, the parents must disagree with a district=s assessment. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT obtained independent opinions, conducted the evaluations, and presented the results without conveying disagreement with any District assessment and before the District could comply with their request to assess. Thus, there were no District assessments with which the parents disagreed. Furthermore, the Petitioner did not focus on producing evidence that the District=s assessment was inadequate. This is a further precondition to reimbursement for independent evaluations.

On the basis of this information, the Hearing Officer determines that the District=s assessments cannot be deemed inadequate, and that the private evaluations obtained by the Petitioner were not sought as a result of a disagreement with District assessments. Consequently, the Petitioner=s request for reimbursement for the three above-mentioned assessments is denied.

ISSUE FOUR

Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education in the form of:

tuition and transportation costs at Summit for the 2001-2002 school year; 360 hours of LMB therapy; counseling one hour per week until the end of the 2001-2002 school year; one hour a week of speech and language therapy until the end of the 2001-2002 school year; an occupational therapy (OT) assessment with the implementation of all recommended services; and a computer and appropriate software?

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such Arelief as it determines is appropriate.@ AThe purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.@ Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991).

There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. ACompensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court=s resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.@ Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child=s lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law. It has already determined that the District=s substantive violations deprived STUDENT of a FAPE. Thus, consideration of compensatory services is appropriate.

The Hearing Officer was not presented with the issue of whether the District had offered the Petitioner a FAPE for the 2001-2001 school year. However, the parties did agree that one of the issues to be resolved in this hearing was whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the form of NPS placement at Summit and transportation costs for the 2001- 2002 school year. In addition to tuition and costs for Summit for the 2001-2002 school year, the Petitioner asks for compensation consisting of 360 hours of LMB therapy to be provided over the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year. The Petitioner also seeks private counseling services for post-traumatic stress syndrome, speech therapy, and computer technology as recompense for the District=s denial of a FAPE during his high school years.

The District=s May 2001 placement offer continued to be one period of RSP language arts, with the remainder of his classes in general education. Speech therapy as previously offered and counseling to address social and self-esteem issues remained available. The District also offered transition services as developed through an individual transition plan (ITP), to include coordination with a community college and access to the District=s Ajob bank.@ In accordance with the assistive technology assessment, for the first time the use of computer software to respond to STUDENT=s writing difficulties was offered daily in the RSP room, as was one hour per month of parent training and consultation with the RSP teacher from the assistive technology specialist. An extended school year was offered to make up the government class that STUDENT needed to complete his requirements for high school graduation. As compensatory education, the District offered 160 hours of LMB, and four hours of home instruction per week to address the Petitioner=s reading and written language deficits.

The Hearing Officer does not agree that the District=s above offer addresses STUDENT=s continued need for accommodation and modifications that respond to his decreased ability to acquire and express information adequately, or that it adequately compensates STUDENT for four years without a FAPE.

The manner in which Summit addressed STUDENT=s needs was discussed in Issue Two, and the Hearing Officer concluded that Summit appropriately responds to his disability and confers some educational benefit. In light of the District=s failure to provide a FAPE for several years or extend an offer in its May 2001 IEP that compensates STUDENT for depriving him of an appropriate education, compensatory education in the form of education at Summit for the 2001-2002 school year is an appropriate remedy.

The District offered 160 hours of compensatory LMB. An offer of LMB is contrary to the recommendations of its witnesses who were identified as knowledgeable in the area of reading disabilities. These witnesses stated that LMB emphasized a phonetic approach, which was not a beneficial remediation methodology for STUDENT. This opinion was illustrated by the testimony of James Kilroy, STUDENT=s reading instructor and head of the reading department at Edison for twenty-two years. Mr. Kilroy testified that LMB focuses on sequentially introducing phonics, which primarily benefits young students. He stated that STUDENT is an older student who has not responded to a phonetic reading approach. It was his opinion that STUDENT needs an eclectic approach that includes word attack, comprehension, vocabulary, study skills, encouraging a positive attitude toward reading, and some phonics. In Mr. Kilroy=s experience, STUDENT is Ahighly resistant@ and Areally turned off@ by efforts to teach him phonics. This forms a further basis for his belief that STUDENT would not be well served with a LMB phonics-based program.

The Petitioner did not call a witness from LMB, or any other reading expert, to testify about STUDENT=s reading needs, explain why LMB was an appropriate program to meet his needs, or justify the conclusion that he required 360 hours of LMB therapy to remediate his deficiencies. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by Dr. Ellenberg=s testimony that LMB was the only effective reading therapy for STUDENT. Dr. Ellenberg is not a reading expert and she acknowledged that she recommended LMB, essentially by default, because it was the only program that emphasized phonics with which she was familiar.

The Petitioner provided insufficient evidence to establish that LMB therapy would compensate the Petitioner for a denial of a FAPE, and the District offered testimony that LMB was an inappropriate methodology to meet his needs. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that there was no convincing justification for awarding STUDENT compensatory education in the form of LMB therapy.

The Petitioner also requests one hour per week of private counseling. It is his contention that he suffered post-traumatic stress syndrom (PTSD) as a result of the off-campus attack by another student when he was a freshman. STUDENT further contends that his PTSD was reactivated by the return of that student during his senior year and that he needs consequent therapy for the disorder. The Hearing Officer does not find this contention credible, nor was it supported by the evidence presented.

Although the Hearing Officer does not accept that compensatory private weekly counseling for PTSD is warranted, the IEP team consistently determined that STUDENT had ongoing social and emotional difficulties that required DIS counseling services. No objective evidence was presented to establish that there had been demonstrative gains in this area. To the contrary, despite four years of counseling services, the IEP team consistently found that STUDENT had the same needs, and each IEP contained virtually the same counseling goalS to improve his peer relationships. The last IEP offered by the District recommended continued counseling for the same difficulties, which denotes persistent unmet problems in this area. This convinces the Hearing Officer that STUDENT received limited benefit from his sessions with Mr. Chaplin.

Dr. Ellenberg and STUDENT=s mother provided further evidence that his emotional and social difficulties remained. Each testified that although STUDENT=s confidence was improving at Summit, he still suffers from diminished self-esteem, he does not have friends outside of school hours, and, other than scuba diving, he is not involved in typical age-appropriate social activities. STUDENT=s admissions were particularly compelling regarding his continuing difficulties with social situations and the development of friendships. He testified that he did not receive social telephone calls, he had never been on a date, and that he never participated in any activities with friends away from his school environment.

The facts described above cause the Hearing Officer to determine that STUDENT’s progress in the areas of confidence, peer relationships, and social skills has been de minimus and he requires compensatory counseling services. The Hearing Officer also finds that the Petitioner’s primary emotional and social issues are intertwined with school/peer relationships and can best be addressed by a school counselor. There was no dispute that trust is mandatory between a counselor and a student for effective treatment. Steve Kaplan, STUDENT’s high school counselor for several years, testified that he believed that he and STUDENT always had a good and productive relationship. The Hearing Officer believes that this is Mr. Kaplan’s sincere perception of his working relationship with STUDENT. However, STUDENT and his mother testified that he was not comfortable disclosing personal information to Mr. Kaplan, so he did not convey his true feelings to his counselor.

A therapeutic relationship, by definition, is confidential and involves only the participants. Thus, the Hearing Officer cannot discern the actual relationship between STUDENT and Mr. Kaplan. However, the nature of a therapist-patient connection is so personal, that when one party makes a claim that rapport and confidence is absent in an affiliation that demands trust and openness, the mere allegation is enough to interfere with the effectiveness of the relationship. Consequently, without an attempt to judge the credibility of the participants, it is reasonable to eliminate any possible concerns about the effectiveness of the counseling by creating a different counselor/patient dynamic.

As previously stated, the Petitioner=s difficulties predominately flow from his diminished ability to interact with his school environment and his age-similar peers. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that if the Petitioner decides to avail himself of District counseling, his compensatory sessions should be provided by a school counselor other than Mr. Kaplan. The Hearing Officer does not find it unreasonable to require STUDENT to obtain counseling from a District counselor. There was no claim by the Petitioner that he could not attend therapy sessions near his home. Moreover, it is the understanding of the Hearing Officer that the private therapist sought by the Petitioner is located near the Petitioner=s home, so he believes that he can attend school at Summit and schedule counseling near his home.

The Petitioner makes a further claim for one hour a week of private compensatory speech and language therapy. The District=s speech therapist provided uncontroverted testimony that STUDENT=s conversational skills, grammar, semantics, and morphology were good. His primary problem was a processing difficultly with receiving and interpreting information. However, classroom accommodations, not speech therapy, was the primary method to address this deficit. Thus, there was no compelling evidence that speech therapy was a significant need or that its absence was sufficient to deprive STUDENT of a FAPE. Speech therapy was provided to STUDENT by the District until his junior year, when he refused further participation. A District cannot implement offered special education services without parental consent. California Education Code ' 56346. The District advised the Petitioner through correspondence to his parents that language services for STUDENT could be reinstituted upon their request, The Petitioner did not ask that speech and language therapy be resumed. His mother testified that STUDENT did not want to participate in speech services, nor did he find the sessions beneficial. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT cannot refuse an available service, then assert an entitlement to compensatory speech and language services.

The assistive technology assessment conducted by the District on April 9, 2001, recommended that computer software to assist with writing, such as ACo-Writer@ or AWrite:Outloud@ be made available to STUDENT. It was further suggested that ASTUDENT=s parents should receive training in the operation of these programs.@ MOTHER and STUDENT testified that he has access to a computer at Summit and at home. However, if the recommended type of software is not available for STUDENT=s use both at home and at school as part of his NPS program, it must be provided by the District for the remainder of the current school year to compensate for the District=s prior failure to provide necessary software. If needed, the District must also train Mr. and Mrs. PARENT to operate the program as recommended by the assessor.

ISSUE FIVE

Is the Petitioner entitled to an occupational therapy (OT)

assessment with the implementation of all recommended services?

A District must assess in all areas of suspected disability. California Education Code §56320. The Petitioner’s educational records frequently reference hand tremors and slow, laborious handwriting. This should have placed the District on notice that he may have a disability in this area that required an OT evaluation. STUDENT is entitled to an OT assessment and any OT recommended by the assessor. To comply with its obligation to evaluate all of STUDENT’s suspected disabilities, the District must conduct an OT assessment and provide any recommended services for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year at a location to be determined by the IEP team.

CONCLUSION

STUDENT was denied a FAPE from January 11, 1998, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year. This denial of a FAPE is longstanding. As a result, STUDENT is entitled reimbursement for that portion of the 2000-2001 school year he attended Summit and to compensatory education in the form of tuition at Summit for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT is also entitled to compensatory OT as determined by the IEP team, counseling services, and a computer software writing program as well as parent training in that program. The Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of any independent assessments, or compensatory speech therapy sessions. The Petitioner’s request for compensatory LMB therapy is also denied.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calender days of the date proof of payment is received, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents for the cost of tuition at Summit for the relevant portion of the 2000-2001 school year, and for transportation costs at the District’s regular milage reimbursement rate for two home-to-school round trips for each school day the Petitioner attended Summit during the 2000-2001 school year.

2. Within ten calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall arrange to pay for the Petitioner’s tuition and transportation costs at Summit for the 2001-2002 school year.

3. The District shall conduct an OT assessment, then convene an IEP meeting within the time prescribed by law for the IEP team to discuss the assessment and arrange appropriate OT services.

4. Within ten calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall provide STUDENT with the computer software described in the assistive technology assessment dated April 11, 2001, and arrange for monthly computer parent training as recommended in the same report. The District also shall schedule weekly counseling sessions with a District counselor other than Mr. Creighton.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the issue of denial of a FAPE, reimbursement for NPS tuition and transportation costs for the 2000-2001 school year, and compensatory education in the form of NPS tuition counseling, an OT assessment, and assistive technology. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Education Code §56505(i).)

Dated: November 9, 2001 ______________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific