California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 31, 1997

Student v. Paradise Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 984-96 · Hearing Officer Carin N. Crain

Paradise Unified must transport autistic twins to Loma Vista School and repay parents' actual costs after missed speech therapy.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 2 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of five-year-old twins filed for a hearing against Paradise Unified School District. Both girls were eligible for special education based on autism and language delays and were nonverbal. Their IEPs called for three 15-minute speech therapy sessions a week with a speech-language therapist. In January 1996, therapist Kathleen Nissan was also assigned to Loma Vista School in Chico. From then until April 1996, the girls received only about half of their sessions at Mesa Vista School in Oroville. After April, any therapy they got came from an uncredentialed aide, and no one told the parents. The parents then sought an inter-district transfer to Loma Vista. They signed agreements saying they would provide transportation, but later asked the district to provide it.

The Hearing Officer found that failing to provide the speech therapy in the IEPs denied both girls a FAPE from January to June 1996. That loss was especially serious because they were nonverbal. The transportation waiver did not bar relief because the parents' only choices were transportation to a placement that had denied FAPE or a transfer without transportation. The district's claimed alternative placements were not considered because it never offered them in writing. The district must transport the girls for the rest of 1996-97 and repay the parents' actual transportation costs. Costs paid by the regional center were not reimbursed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a parent's signed waiver of transportation in an inter-district transfer agreement. The waiver did not bar relief because the home placement had denied FAPE by missing IEP speech therapy. Reimbursement covered only costs the parents themselves paid, not costs funded by the regional center.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1. Did the students receive a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?

    The district's failure to provide the speech therapy the IEPs required (about half the sessions from January 1996, then only an uncredentialed aide, with no notice to the parents) denied both nonverbal girls a FAPE from January to June 1996.

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. If the District did not provide the students with a FAPE at Mesa Vista, must it provide them with transportation to Loma Vista School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and reimburse them for transportation costs previously incurred?

    The parents' transportation waiver in the inter-district agreement did not bar relief because the only alternative was a placement that had denied FAPE. The district must provide transportation and reimburse costs the parents actually paid, but not costs funded by the regional center.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. District must provide both students with transportation to and from Loma Vista School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year.
  • Reimbursement. District must reimburse the parents for transportation costs to and from Loma Vista School that the parents actually incurred since the students enrolled there. No amount was stated. Costs funded by Far Northern Regional Center are not reimbursable.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Letter to Lutjeharms, 16 EHLR 554 (OSEP 1989); Seals v. Loftis, 614 F. Supp. 302 (E.D. Ky. 1985); Student v. Simi Valley Unified School District, SN 893-92; Helfand v. Southern Calif. Rapid Transit Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Frank Terstegge, SELPA director, Butte County SELPA
  • Roy Applegate, director of special education, Paradise Unified School District
  • Homer Johnson, Jr., behavioral specialist / behavior analyst, witness for Student, Families First
  • Kathleen Nissan, speech and language therapist and special education teacher, Butte County Office of Education (Mesa Vista and Loma Vista)
  • Cleophes Hill, special education teacher, Loma Vista School
  • Rachelle Linden, preschool special education teacher, Mesa Vista School
  • Debra Warren, classroom staff and in-home respite worker, Butte County schools; ARC of Butte County
  • Ron E. Leger, special education administrator, principal of South County Special Education programs, Butte County Office of Education
  • Sharon Bolden-Schleh, school psychologist, Butte County Office of Education
  • Corin Meester, principal and special education administrator, Loma Vista Elementary School / Butte County Office of Education
  • Jamie Handley, special education teacher, Paradise Elementary
  • Carolyn Knight, preschool teacher, Paradise preschool
  • Jim Presentati, teacher, Paradise class observed by parents
  • Brenda Sorensen, co-teacher, Loma Vista School
  • Christie Gore, uncredentialed speech instructional aide, Mesa Vista School
  • Diane Marley, part-time speech therapist, South County / Mesa Vista
  • Rosiland Sievert, special education teacher, Mesa Vista School
  • Marge Daddow, special education teacher, Sierra del Oro, Oroville
  • Mr. McCracken, special education teacher, South County
  • Far Northern Regional Center, regional center that funded transportation

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Carin N. Crain, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Paradise, California, on December 19 and 20, 1996.

Petitioners STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were represented by attorney Bob N. Varma. Also present on behalf of petitioners was their mother, MOTHER.

Respondent Paradise Unified School District (the District) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Also present on behalf of the District were Roy Applegate, District director of special education, and Frank Terstegge, Butte County SELPA director.

Petitioners called the following witnesses to testify on their behalf: Frank Terstegge, Butte County SELPA director; MOTHER, mother; FATHER, father; Homer Johnson, Jr., behavioral specialist; Kathleen Nissan, special education teacher; Cleophes Hill, special education teacher; Rachelle Linden, special education teacher; and Debra Warren, RESPIT Worker.

Respondent called the following witnesses: Roy Applegate, District director of special education; Ron E. Leger, special education administrator; Sharon Bolden-Schleh, school psychologist, Butte County Office of Education; Corin Meester, principal of Loma Vista Elementary School and administrator for Butte County Office of Education; and Jamie Handley, special education teacher.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open for written closing arguments. On January 6, 1997, closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Did STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 receive a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?

2. If not, must the District provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with transportation to Loma Vista School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and reimburse them for transportation costs previously incurred?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioners

Petitioners argue that because STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 did not receive free, appropriate public educations (FAPE) at Mesa Vista School in Oroville, California, they signed an "inter-district transfer agreement" that permitted them to attend Loma Vista School in Chico, California. Petitioners maintain that, unlike Mesa Vista, Loma Vista is an appropriate educational placement.

Petitioners acknowledge that the agreement that they signed contained a provision which relieved the District of the responsibility for providing transportation to Loma Vista.

However, Petitioners' assert that notwithstanding the agreement, the District must provide them with transportation to Loma Vista because they were deprived of FAPEs at Mesa Vista.

Respondents

Respondents contend that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received FAPEs at Mesa Vista and were also offered appropriate placements at other schools. Respondents argue that Petitioners agreed to waive transportation as a condition of attending Loma Vista; therefore, they may not now seek reimbursement for either transportation costs incurred or provision of transportation for the remainder of the school year.

BACKGROUND FACTS

The Butte County Office of Education (BCOE) administers special education preschool programs throughout the County. BCOE's special education programs are divided into North and South County regions.

STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are five-year-old identical twins who reside with their parents within the District in the South County region, but who attend school in a different District in the North County region. According to their most recent IEPs, diagnoses of autism and language delays qualify them for special education services. (Petitioners' "Pet." Exhibit C.)

In 1994, when STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 began preschool, they attended different schools: STUDENT 1 attended Pee Wee Preschool in Paradise, and STUDENT 2 attended a special education preschool class at Mesa Vista in Oroville. In January 1995, the IEP team transferred STUDENT 1 to Mesa Vista. From January 1995 through June 1996, both girls were transported to and enrolled in Rachelle Linden's special education preschool class at Mesa Vista.

(Respondents' "Resp." Ex. 8 and 17.)

According to their IEPs of June 6, 1995, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were to receive fifteen minutes of speech and language therapy three times each week. (Pet. Ex. D.) In January 1996, however, Mesa Vista speech therapist Kathleen Nissan also began working at Loma Vista Elementary School in Chico. Speech therapy staff shortages at Mesa Vista deprived the twins of at least half of their required speech and language therapy sessions.

Dissatisfied with STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's progress at Mesa Vista, in April 1996, MOTHER requested that the twins be allowed to attend Loma Vista, in another district in Chico. (Resp. Ex. 2 and 13.) The District complied with MOTHER's request for the transfer but refused to provide transportation to and from Loma Vista.

(Footnote 1) On April 23, 1996, MOTHER signed a document entitled "Inter-District Attendance Agreement," which stated that "transportation to and from school is to be provided by the parent." (Resp. Ex. 3.) When the District approved the PARENTS' request for a transfer from Mesa Vista to Loma Vista, the District informed the PARENTS by letter dated May 22, 1996, that "transportation for students attending a school outside of the attendance area is the responsibility of the parents." (Resp. Ex. 3.)

In July 1996, upon the advice of her nonattorney advocate, MOTHER withdrew her request for the inter-district transfer. One month later, MOTHER "reactivated" the request. Once again MOTHER signed an "Inter-District Attendance Agreement" that permitted STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to attend preschool at Loma Vista but obliged the PARENTS to provide transportation. (Resp. Ex. 2.)

In August 1996, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's IEP teams met and, among other things, agreed to transfer them from Mesa Vista School in Oroville to Loma Vista School in Chico.

Although the IEP team members agreed to place the girls in separate classes at Loma Vista, they disagreed about who should bear the responsibility for transporting them to and from Loma Vista. Both IEPs place the responsibility for providing transportation on the PARENTS, but state that if they are unable to do so, the girls may be placed in South County. Although MOTHER signed both IEPs, she wrote the following in the margins of both documents: "I am filing for a fair hearing re: the issue of transportation. I agree with the rest of the IEP." (Resp. Ex. 6 and 14.)

Since September 1996, a friend of the FAMILY family has transported STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to and from school using money provided by the Far Northern Regional Center through the Easter Seals Foundation. After December 20, 1996, the PARENTS will no longer receive this money.

SUMMARY OF RELEVANT TESTIMONY

Petitioners' Witnesses

MOTHER

In summarizing her daughters' educational placements, MOTHER testified that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 began preschool in Paradise in 1994, when they were three years and three months old. Although they were both enrolled in Carolyn Knight's preschool class, they attended class on alternate days because Ms. Knight told MOTHER that she could not manage both girls at once. Shortly after enrolling both girls in Ms. Knight's class, MOTHER transferred STUDENT 2 to Ms. Linden's class at Mesa Vista. For the next six months, the girls attended separate schools. After a parent-teacher conference, during which Ms. Knight told MOTHER that she was unable to give STUDENT 1 the instructional time that she needed, MOTHER transferred STUDENT 1 to Ms. Linden's class. Both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 remained with Ms. Linden until the end of the 1995-96 school year.

MOTHER testified that after the IEP meetings of April 9, 1996, she and her husband contemplated transferring the girls from Mesa Vista to Loma Vista because they were dissatisfied with the education that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were receiving at Mesa Vista. MOTHER stated that she was primarily concerned about the amount of speech therapy that Mesa Vista provided the girls.

According to MOTHER, after speech therapist Kathy Nissan left Mesa Vista for Loma Vista in January 1996, the girls received little or no speech therapy for at least two months. If STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received any speech therapy, MOTHER assumes that it was provided by an uncredentialed speech aide. MOTHER stated that she did not believe that speech therapy provided by an aide conformed to the speech therapy requirements set forth in the girls' IEPs. MOTHER asserted that no one from Mesa Vista informed her that the girls were not receiving speech therapy. But when MOTHER became aware of the fact, she complained to Ron Leger, who assured her that he would promptly hire a speech therapist. Nevertheless, MOTHER does not believe that a speech therapist was hired until after STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 left Mesa Vista.

In addition to her concern regarding speech therapy, MOTHER was also troubled by STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's long bus ride from Paradise to Mesa Vista. MOTHER testified that the time spent on the bus almost exceeded the time the girls spent in the classroom. When STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 attended Mesa Vista, they would sometimes spend an hour, one way, on the bus. Now that the girls are at Loma Vista, they spend between twenty and thirty minutes on the bus each way.

MOTHER testified that she was also dissatisfied because STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were enrolled in the same classroom at Mesa Vista. MOTHER would have preferred to have her daughters enrolled in separate classrooms at the same school. In MOTHER's opinion, this arrangement would have allowed the girls to progress academically and socially because they would have relied less on each other. MOTHER opined that, after attending Mesa Vista, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 should have been better able to communicate with other people in English. For example, MOTHER noted that STUDENT 1 only learned three words in the year she spent at Mesa Vista.

MOTHER opted not to place one of her daughters in the other preschool class at Mesa Vista, however, because she believed that the students in that class functioned at a much higher level than her daughters. MOTHER also worried that the teacher would not be able to discipline either of her daughters effectively.

MOTHER stated that when she signed the inter-district attendance agreements on April 23, 1996, she did not understand that she was waiving a right to a related service (transportation). She stated that she signed because she "had to in order for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to go to Loma Vista school. MOTHER testified that when she signed the agreement, she was "hoping that someone would come to their senses and realize that Loma Vista was the best educational placement for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2." MOTHER also hoped that the parties could resolve the transportation impasse in mediation.

MOTHER recalled that in July and August 1996, her daughters' IEP teams agreed to transfer STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to preschool at Loma Vista. The twins could have attended kindergarten this year, but MOTHER asked that they be retained so that they might acquire more language, self-help, and social skills.

Transportation was the only issue in dispute. Because neither district would agree to provide transportation, MOTHER refused to sign the July 1996 IEPs. Nevertheless, MOTHER signed the August 1996 IEPs noting in the margin that she intended to request a due process hearing to resolve the issue of transportation.

MOTHER testified that Mr. Terstegge refused to transport STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to Loma Vista for two reasons: (1)

transporting the girls would be too expensive and (2) if the twins received transportation, other families would expect the same services.

After requesting a due process hearing and participating in mediation, the District suggested that the PARENTS observe preschool classes in Paradise. The PARENTS observed the classrooms of Carolyn Knight, Jamie Handley, and Jim Presentati. MOTHER stated that Ms. Knight's class was still too crowded to be suitable for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. MOTHER felt that the students in Ms. Handley's class exhibited such a wide variety of disabilities and low level of functioning that the setting would not be appropriate for her autistic daughters. The PARENTS liked Mr. Presentati's class, but saw that the children in his class were older than STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 and, unlike the twins, were able to talk. In short, the students in Mr. Presentati's class struck the PARENTS as too high functioning. According to MOTHER, the District did not offer any placements in writing.

MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 have attended Loma Vista since the beginning of the 1996-97 school year. A friend transports the twins to and from school with funds for transportation provided by the Far Northern Regional Center. But as of December 20, 1996, Far Northern stopped providing money for transportation.

MOTHER has observed that since the girls have enrolled at Loma Vista, their self-help and speech skills have improved. For instance, MOTHER stated they are again progressing toward achieving bowel and bladder control. Additionally, MOTHER noted that the girls are now able to retain new words and phrases, rather than saying them a few times and then forgetting them. STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 are also better able to form words and sounds. MOTHER is hearing more babbling from both girls, even STUDENT 1, who rarely vocalized at all. MOTHER attributes their improvement to their being in separate classes and receiving three speech therapy sessions each week.

According to MOTHER, since the girls have enrolled at Loma Vista, their social skills have improved, especially STUDENT 2's. STUDENT 2 will now approach other children when the family goes to the playground or church functions. STUDENT 1 wants to play with others, but remains too timid. Overall, MOTHER observed that the girls are happy at Loma Vista and seem to have bonded with their new teachers and classmates.

FATHER

FATHER stated that the lack of speech therapy at Mesa Vista principally motivated the PARENTS to transfer STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to Loma Vista. At the July 1996 IEP team meetings, FATHER complained about the lack of speech therapy provided to the girls. FATHER recalled that during that meeting, Mr. Leger revealed that a credentialed speech therapist served North Butte County schools, whereas an uncredentialed instructional aide served the South Butte County schools.

Pursuant to the mediation agreement, FATHER visited classes in Paradise and, like MOTHER, found them wanting. FATHER rejected Ms. Knight's class because Ms. Knight had previously stated that she could not educate STUDENT 1. FATHER felt that the mix of severely handicapped children in Ms. Handley's class was not appropriate for his autistic twins. Because STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 had not completed kindergarten, FATHER objected to placing them in Mr. Presentati's combined first-, second-, and third-grade class.

FATHER asserted that since enrolling at Loma Vista, both his daughters have increased the number of words they use, and more often use words in the proper context. STUDENT 1 is now progressing toward being toilet-trained, and STUDENT 2 has become more interactive. FATHER attributes their improvement to their regular speech therapy sessions, their placement in separate classrooms, and the nearly two-hour reduction in travel time to and from school.

Kathleen Nissan

Kathleen Nissan is both a speech and language therapist and a special education teacher. Over her twenty-four-year teaching career, Ms. Nissan estimates that she has worked with approximately thirty autistic children and has received some training about autism.

Ms. Nissan is a classroom teacher at Loma Vista, where she and Brenda Sorensen currently co-teach STUDENT 1. Before being assigned to Loma Vista, Ms. Nissan provided speech therapy for students in both the South and North County regions. She has provided speech and language therapy to both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 since they started school.

Ms. Nissan stated that until January 1996, she provided STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with the amount of speech therapy that their IEPs required i.e., two or three fifteen minute sessions each week. From January 1996 until April 1996, however, Ms. Nissan testified that the girls received "about half" of the speech therapy indicated on their IEPs. This was so because Ms. Nissan's duties were increased to include a classroom teaching assignment at Loma Vista in addition to her assignment as a speech therapist for the North and South County regions. According to Ms. Nissan, Mesa Vista did not inform the PARENTS that their daughters were not receiving the amount of speech therapy required by their IEPs.

Ms. Nissan testified that after April 1996, the girls probably received speech therapy from uncredentialed speech aide Christie Gore, who worked under the supervision of the newly hired speech therapist. Ms. Nissan did not know when or whether Mesa Vista began providing STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 the amount of speech therapy required by their IEPs.

Ms. Nissan testified that since enrolling at Loma Vista, the girls are once again receiving three fifteen-minute speech therapy sessions each week. They receive, weekly, two sessions from Ms. Nissan and one from an aide whom Ms. Nissan supervises. Ms. Nissan observed that both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 can now "make a lot more sounds" than they did at Mesa Vista, but she suggested that their age may have accounted for this improvement.

Last year, both girls made progress with cause and effect, object permanence and sound imitation. This year the girls are a lot more vocal, as they are learning to imitate sounds and are moving forward slowly at their own pace.

Ms. Nissan could not recall who proposed to transfer STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 from Mesa Vista to Loma Vista. She remembered that the principal of Loma Vista approved the transfer but stated that the PARENTS would be responsible for the girls' transportation.

Frank Terstegge

SELPA director Frank Terstegge explained that both the Mesa Vista preschool program and the Loma Vista preschool program are run by the Butte County Office of Education (BCOE). According to Mr. Terstegge, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 did not need an inter-district transfer to attend school at Mesa Vista in Oroville, but did need one to attend Loma Vista in Chico.

Mr. Terstegge explained that BCOE regionalized its special education resources to reduce the cost of transportation. The North County Special Education Center which serves Chico and Durham is located in Chico, while the South County Center which serves Paradise, Oroville and Gridley, is located in Oroville.

The difference in the travel time from Paradise to Chico and from Paradise to Oroville is negligible, but Mr. Terstegge cautioned that the actual time spent on a bus varies based on the route and number of stops.

Mr. Terstegge testified that only "a few" students with low incidence disabilities attend school in Chico. Generally students who live in Paradise attend school in the South County region. At present, only one school bus travels between Paradise and Chico.

Mr. Terstegge further asserted that if BCOE allowed exceptions to this policy, it may have to add classrooms and purchase additional buses. Twelve South County families have already requested services in Chico but, to date, they have accepted the provision of services in their region. If those families were served in Chico, however, at least one new bus would have to be purchased. BCOE is reluctant to buy additional buses because, according to Mr. Terstegge's estimate, BCOE is currently striving to contain a seven hundred thousand dollar transportation deficit. The District's share of the transportation deficit equals one hundred thousand dollars.

Nevertheless, Mr. Terstegge acknowledged that permitting STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to transfer to Loma Vista has not burdened BCOE's fiscal resources. Similarly, providing the FAMILY twins with transportation to and from Loma Vista would not force BCOE to purchase another bus.

Mr. Terstegge stated that the inter-district transfer agreement that MOTHER signed was the standard form used when a student is offered services within her region but opts to seek services in the other region. Mr. Terstegge also asserted that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 could have received an appropriate education and transportation from a South County school.

Rachelle Linden

Rachelle Linden, a special education teacher at Mesa Vista School, had both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 in her preschool special education class. During her five-year career, Ms. Linden has received training regarding autism and estimates that she has taught seven autistic children.

STUDENT 2 enrolled in Ms. Linden's class in September of 1994, and STUDENT 1 joined the class in January of 1995. According to Ms. Linden, the girls made some progress in her class. For example, the girls increased their abilities to sit independently, but, "for the most part," they left her class with the same skills they possessed when they entered. For example, Ms. Linden stopped working to toilet train the girls, opting instead to focus on the mastery of other skills. Because STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 made little progress, their 1995 and 1996 IEPs contain similar goals and objectives.

Ms. Linden testified that neither FATHER nor MOTHER expressed dissatisfaction about their daughters' progress. She stated that the PARENTS requested the transfer to Loma Vista so that the girls could be in separate classes at the same school. Complaints from parents about the length of the bus ride from Paradise to Oroville were common, and Ms. Linden stated that the PARENTS may also have objected to the long bus ride.

By the end of the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT 2 began to engage in parallel play, i.e., play in the same area as other children, but not play with other children.

Ms. Linden could not recall how much speech and language therapy STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received during the 1995-96 school year. Ms. Linden observed that STUDENT 2 babbled and talked more than STUDENT 1, but both girls' abilities to remember words were inconsistent.

Ms. Linden noted that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 tended to interact with each other rather than with the other children. When only one twin was in Ms. Linden's class, she would be were more likely to communicate and less likely to disrupt others and engage in self-stimulation. Because STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 tended to rely on and interact with each other, Ms. Linden thought that separating the girls would promote their independence.

Cleophes Hill

Mr. Hill has taught special education for twenty-seven years and has been STUDENT 2's teacher at Loma Vista for three months. Mr. Hill has attended seminars in autism and over the course of his career has taught "two or three" autistic children.

Mr. Hill testified that STUDENT 2 has improved her receptive language skills more than her expressive language skills.

Nevertheless, Mr. Hill notes that STUDENT 2 imitates more sounds than when she enrolled and volunteers "m" and "b" sounds. Mr. Hill encourages STUDENT 2 to make sounds when she wants something and is trying to teach her to say "hello" and "goodbye" when entering and leaving the classroom.

Mr. Hill also encourages STUDENT 2 to track objects with her eyes and to match colors and shapes. STUDENT 2 is "a little resistant" to verbal commands, but will usually come when called, and stay when asked. STUDENT 2 will sit, but not stand, "on command." When involved with an one-on-one activity, STUDENT 2 will attend for three to five minutes.

According to Mr. Hill, the other children in STUDENT 2's class do not invite her to play because she does not approach them in a way that they perceive as friendly. STUDENT 2 does, however, engage in "parallel play."

Homer Johnson

Homer Johnson, Jr., a social worker and behavior analyst with Families First, has worked with STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 for three years. Mr. Johnson began working with the girls when the Far Northern Regional Center requested that he assess them because their parents could not control their behavior. Mr. Johnson currently works with them for two hours each week.

After assessing the girls' language and behavior, Mr. Johnson began working to eliminate the maladaptive behaviors that they used to communicate. For example, Mr. Johnson observed that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 would initially express themselves by running, crying, screaming, hitting, self-stimulating, or smearing feces.

Mr. Johnson reports that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's socialization has improved slowly but significantly. Mr. Johnson noted, for instance, that one year passed before STUDENT 2 would allow him to approach her without screaming and running. Now, however, STUDENT 2 runs to him. According to Mr. Johnson, the twins' greatest improvement has come in the area of sitting.

Neither girl has bowel or bladder control, so their increased ability to sit has also helped them progress toward toilet training. When Mr. Johnson first began working with them, they would not sit for "more than a second or two." Over the past year, however, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 have learned to sit on command for two to five minutes.

Mr. Johnson's program also focuses on teaching the girls how to express themselves in a socially acceptable manner and how to accept praise and other cues from others.

Mr. Johnson notes that, in the six months since STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 enrolled at Loma Vista, the girls have improved their ability to maintain eye contact with both people and objects, increased the number of sounds they make, decreased self-stimulation, and somewhat increased socially acceptable behavior. Mr. Johnson also observed that since attending Loma Vista, STUDENT 1 has acquired new sounds. Mr. Johnson attributes their improvements to their increasing abilities, their school environment, their home environment, and behavioral intervention services.

With respect to speech and language therapy, Mr. Johnson recalled that, while at Mesa Vista, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were to receive services two to three times each week in fifteen minute increments. He also remembered that, in the months before STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 transferred to Loma Vista, MOTHER "several times" expressed concern that the girls were not receiving speech and language therapy. According to Mr. Johnson, MOTHER stated that the girls were "losing the time" they needed to learn language.

Mr. Johnson has not observed STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 at Loma Vista but he is aware that they are placed in separate classrooms. Mr. Johnson favors separate placement because he believes such an arrangement would encourage the girls to act as individuals and prevent them from distracting each other. In Mr. Johnson's opinion, the girls' placement in the same classroom limited their progress at Mesa Vista.

To Mr. Johnson, it is critical that the girls be placed in a class that functions at an appropriate level. He notes that if an autistic child is placed in a class that is too stimulating or high-functioning, the child will "shut down." Conversely, if an autistic child is placed in a class that functions at too low a level, the child's skills tend to decrease and he or she may have to be retaught.

From a behavioral perspective, Mr. Johnson offered that autistic children between the ages of two and three develop language more quickly than older children. If children are taught language at a very young age, the quality of the language they produce will be better than if they are taught when they are older. According to Mr. Johnson, after age twelve, for example, it is difficult to teach children how to talk.

With respect to the FAMILY twins, Mr. Johnson stated that they are "way behind" in language. They can vocalize, but their sounds only sometimes represent words. A couple of times, however, the girls have spoken one- two- or three-word sentences. To the twins, language is mainly a means to stimulate their vocal cords, their bodies, and auditory systems. For this reason, Mr. Johnson uses the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS). Using PECS, the girls can trade a picture that represents water for a glass of water and, in so doing, learn the power of language. Mr. Johnson is also familiar with, but does not use, the TEACH program. He testified that the TEACH program may also be appropriate for STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2.

Mr. Johnson emphasized that autistic children require sameness of environment to succeed. Nevertheless, he recommended that the girls have two rather than one teacher because the girls will increase their abilities to respond to different people.

Debra Warren

Debra Warren, an employee of Butte County schools assigned to Ms. Linden's preschool class at Mesa Vista, began working with the FAMILY twins when they were enrolled in Ms. Linden's class. Ms. Warren also works for ARC of Butte County and has provided in-home respite services to the STUDENTS since September 1996.

Ms. Warren asserted that the girls' vocabularies have improved since they transferred to the separate placements at Loma Vista. According to Ms. Warren, since the transfer, the girls have matured to a point that they can be toilet-trained.

Respondents' Witnesses

Ron Leger

Ron Leger, principal of South County Special Education programs administered STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's special education programs. Mr. Leger assumed that the girls were "doing fine" at Mesa Vista because neither the PARENTS nor Ms. Linden expressed dissatisfaction with their progress. But Mr. Leger stated that the PARENTS were concerned about the lack of speech therapy provided to their daughters.

Mr. Leger testified that "towards the end of last year," he hired speech therapist Diane Marley to replace Ms. Nissan. Ms. Marley, however, "was actually working with us only one day a week." Mr. Leger did not believe that Ms. Marley worked directly with STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Instructional aide Christie Gore provided their speech therapy, but Mr. Leger did not know how much they received. Mr. Leger could not recall whether he informed the PARENTS that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were receiving speech therapy from an aide.

Mr. Leger hired a regular speech therapist to serve both Mesa Vista and Sierra del Oro in September 1996.

Because the PARENTS wanted STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 placed in separate classrooms, Mr. Leger suggested either Rosiland Sievert's class at Mesa Vista or Marge Daddow's class at Sierra del Oro in Oroville. According to Mr. Leger, the PARENTS visited Ms. Daddow's class, but rejected it. Mr. Leger also considered either Ms.

Handley or Mr. McCracken's class appropriate placements for the twins. During mediation, Mr. Leger offered the PARENTS the option of visiting these and other classes.

Sharon Bolden-Schleh

Butte County school psychologist Sharon Bolden-Schleh conducted psychological assessments of STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 in 1994. Since 1994, Ms. Bolden-Schleh has informally observed the girls about once a week. Ms. Bolden-Schleh described the twins as being severely handicapped without the ability to say words. Ms. Bolden-Schleh finds it difficult to establish eye contact with the girls, and they tend to stimulate themselves.

Ms. Bolden-Schleh recalled that after the April 1996 IEP meetings, MOTHER "was very concerned" because she believed that the girls were not receiving adequate speech therapy from Mesa Vista. Ms. Bolden-Schleh asserted that during STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's last semester at Mesa Vista, the instructional aide "tried very hard to continue" serving them.

According to Ms. Bolden-Schleh, MOTHER discussed the lack of speech therapy when considering transferring her daughters to Loma Vista. Ms. Bolden-Schleh stated that Mesa Vista lacked a full-time speech therapist until the beginning of the 1996 school year, but hired a part-time therapist about March 1996.

Ms. Bolden-Schleh, who attended the July 1996 IEP meetings, maintained that "it was clear" that the PARENTS were to provide transportation to and from Loma Vista.

In Ms. Bolden-Schleh's opinion, the girls have not improved significantly since enrolling at Loma Vista. Although STUDENT 2 is enrolled in Mr. Hill's class, Ms. Bolden-Schleh considers Mr.

Hill's class too "unstructured" to be an appropriate placement for her. Similarly, Ms. Bolden-Schleh did not endorse STUDENT 1's placement in a class with two teachers, because one of the teachers has an unstructured teaching style. Ms. Bolden-Schleh recommended the South County classes of Ms. Sievert, Ms. Linden, Ms. Daddow, Mr. McCracken, or Ms. Handley.

Corin Meester

Corin Meester is both the principal of Loma Vista and a special education administrator. Ms. Meester testified that from January until March 1996, Ms. Nissan spent one day a week providing speech therapy at either Mesa Vista or Sierra del Oro. In March 1996, a substitute speech therapist consulted with Christie Gore, the instructional aide, one day each week. Ms. Meester stated that Ms. Gore tried to fulfill students' IEPs, but Ms. Meester could not verify that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received the amount or speech therapy indicated on their IEPs.

Ms. Meester and MOTHER spoke several times before the July 1996 IEP meeting. Their discussions focused on STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's placement, goals and objectives, and whether to have them repeat preschool. Ms. Meester explained that because there were appropriate programs at either end of the county, transportation would not be provided from Paradise to Chico. In Ms. Meester's opinion, it was "absolutely clear" that the PARENTS were to provide transportation for their daughters.

Ms. Meester estimates that ten to fifteen South County families have requested transfers, with transportation, to Chico. According to Ms. Meester, the school bus ride from Paradise to Chico may take over an hour depending on the bus route and the number of stops.

Jamie Handley

Jamie Handley teaches a self-contained special education class at Paradise Elementary. Ms. Handley's class has eight students ranging in age from five to ten years. Despite their chronological ages, Ms. Handley estimates her students' skill levels at between one and four years. The students' disabilities include Down's Syndrome, autism, and blindness.

Having reviewed STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's IEPs, Ms. Handley concluded that she would be able to implement the IEPs in her class. Ms. Handley also offered that Ms. Daddow's class would also be appropriate for the girls.

Roy Applegate

Roy Applegate, the District's director of special services, testified that if students wish to transfer between districts, their parents must sign an inter-district transfer agreement. Mr. Applegate maintained that when the PARENTS signed the inter-district transfer agreement, they understood that they, and not the District, assumed responsibility for transporting their daughters to and from Chico.

According to Mr. Applegate, the PARENTS are the only parents requesting transportation from Paradise to Chico. The other families who have obtained inter-district transfers provide their own transportation.

DISCUSSION

1. Did STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 receive a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), the federal government provides monetary grants to participating states for assistance in educating disabled students. Under federal law, participating states must assure all disabled students the right to a free, appropriate public education (FAPE), which 20 United States Code (U.S.C) section 1401(a)(18) defines as special education and related services that (A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge, (B) meet the standards of the state educational agency, (C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved, and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under section 614(a)(5) [20 U.S.C. section 1414(a)(5)].

(See also Education Code section 56031.)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court emphasized that almost as a checklist for adequacy under the [IDEA], the definition also requires that such instruction and services be provided at public expense and under public supervision, meet the State's educational standards, approximate the grade levels used in the State's regular education, and comport with the child's IEP. (Footnote 2)

(Emphasis added.)

Both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's IEPs of June 6, 1995, state that the twins were both to receive three fifteen-minute speech therapy sessions each week with a speech and language therapist. (Pet. Ex. D.) STUDENT 2's April 1996 IEP reduces the number of weekly speech therapy sessions from three to two or three, but retains the requirement that the sessions be provided by a "speech specialist." (Resp. Ex. 16.)

In this case, the testimony of both the Petitioners' and the District's witnesses establishes that after January 1996, the speech therapy that the District provided to STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 did not comport with their IEPs. First, Ms. Nissan, the speech therapist initially responsible for providing speech therapy, testified that from January to April 1996, she provided the FAMILY twins with "about half" of the sessions indicated by their IEPs. Ms. Nissan did not provide the girls with speech therapy after April and did not know how many weekly sessions they received.

Ms. Nissan guessed, however, that whatever speech therapy the girls received after April 1996 came from uncredentialed instructional aide Christie Gore. Although Mr. Leger stated that speech therapist Diane Marley served Mesa Vista one day each week, Mr. Leger did not believe that Ms. Marley provided speech therapy to STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. Like Ms. Nissan, Mr. Leger assumed that from April to the end of the 1996 school year, Ms. Gore provided the girls' speech therapy, but he could not estimate how many sessions they received. According to Mr. Leger, the full-time speech therapist who might have provided STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with speech therapy at Mesa Vista was not hired until September 1996. Ms. Meester confirmed Mr. Leger's testimony and stated that although Ms. Gore "tried to fulfill their IEPs," Ms. Meester did not know how many sessions STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received from Ms. Gore.

In short, District witnesses do not dispute that both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 received fewer speech therapy sessions than indicated on their IEPs. Nor do the District's witnesses dispute that after April 1996, however many speech therapy sessions the girls may have received were provided by an uncredentialed instructional aide. Additionally, no one from the District disputes that the PARENTS were not informed that their daughters were being deprived of speech therapy.

Moreover, witnesses for both Petitioners and the District agreed that while the girls were attending Mesa Vista, they progressed little in the acquisition of language. For example, Ms. Linden remarked that STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2's IEPs were virtually unchanged from one year to the next because they made so little progress.

In contrast, since receiving regular speech therapy sessions at Loma Vista, Ms. Nissan, Mr. Johnson, and MOTHER have heard the girls "make a lot more sounds." While some witnesses have attributed their progress to maturation and being enrolled in separate classrooms, none has disputed that increased speech therapy may have spurred their improvement. Furthermore, Mr.

Johnson's assertion that nonverbal autistic children must learn language at a very young age was also undisputed.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's failure to provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with speech therapy as indicated in their IEPs resulted in a serious loss of educational opportunity to them and a denial of a FAPE from January to June of 1996. Because the girls are nonverbal, the deprivation of speech therapy is particularly grievous.

2. If the District did not provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with a FAPE at Mesa Vista, must it provide them with transportation to Loma Vista School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and reimburse them for transportation costs already incurred?

When a child transfers to an out-of-district school, typically the receiving district assumes responsibility for the transportation, if it is a necessary related service. Letter to Lutjeharms, 16 EHLR 554 (OSEP 1989). Here, by written agreement between the District and MOTHER, neither the Paradise Unified School District nor the Chico School District assumed responsibility for home-school transportation. Rather, MOTHER agreed to transport STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 from home to school. (Resp. Ex. 2.)

The District argues that an inter-district transfer was granted only because the PARENTS agreed to provide their daughters' transportation. The District suggests that it imposed this condition upon the PARENTS because transporting the girls would aggravate its budget deficit. The District also asserts that MOTHER's stated intention to alter the agreement by means of a due process hearing constituted a "material violation" of the agreement.

As explained in detail above, STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were denied a FAPE at Mesa Vista. Testimony from Mr. Leger and Ms. Bolden-Schleh establishes that despite assurances from Mr. Leger, after January 1996, Mesa Vista did not provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with speech therapy as indicated in their IEPs. These same witnesses also testified that MOTHER expressed concerns about the quantity and quality of her daughters' speech therapy to representatives of the District.

FATHER and MOTHER credibly testified that they requested the inter-district transfer primarily because the girls were not receiving adequate speech therapy. MOTHER less credibly testified that she did not understand that her signature on the inter-district transfer agreement contained a waiver of transportation.

Nevertheless, based on the evidence, it appears that MOTHER had two choices: accept transportation to Mesa Vista, a placement that had deprived her daughters of FAPEs, or forego transportation and opt for Loma Vista, which seemed likely to provide a FAPE to STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2. (Footnote 3) MOTHER chose the FAPE for her children.

Because the PARENTS had to choose between receiving transportation and receiving FAPEs, this case differs from the case cited by the District in its closing argument. In that case, which involved a formal settlement agreement, Student v. Simi Valley Unified School District, SN 893-92, the Hearing Officer observed that "the legal principles governing contracts do not constitute mandatory authority." In any event, that Hearing Officer relied upon principles of contract law to uphold the settlement agreement that allowed a student to attend a more distant district school instead of his home school provided that he waive his right to transportation to the more distant school. However, the facts of this case compel a different conclusion.

In Student v. Simi Valley, the Hearing Officer did not find that the student had been denied a FAPE. On this important point, Student v. Simi Valley is distinguishable from the instant case. Here the evidence establishes that both STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 were deprived of FAPEs at Mesa Vista. The evidence also shows that the PARENTS reasonably believed that the girls would not receive FAPEs unless they attended Loma Vista, which, unlike Mesa Vista, at the time of the transfer had Ms. Nissan, a full-time speech therapist.

Furthermore, nothing in the record indicates that the PARENTS have not complied with the agreement. As they agreed, the PARENTS arranged for their daughters' transportation. Until December 20, 1996, the Far Northern Regional Center provided the PARENTS with money to transport the twins to and from school.

The evidence also establishes that the PARENTS notified the District both orally and in writing of their intention to modify the terms of the agreement even before it went into effect. On both of the IEPs dated August 23, 1996, MOTHER wrote, "I am filing for a fair hearing on the issue of transportation." (Resp. Ex. 6 and 14.) In light of this statement, the District cannot now claim that it reasonably relied on the inter-district transfer agreement. No language in the inter-district attendance agreements prevents either party from seeking to alter its terms through a due process determination; therefore, the PARENTS are not violating the agreement by seeking its modification. (Resp. Ex. 2 and 13.)

Additionally, the District's legal argument to the contrary, Mr. Terstegge testified that transporting the STUDENTS to and from Paradise would not force the purchase of another bus. Mr.

Terstegge stated that if STUDENT 1, STUDENT 2 and another student were to require transportation, another bus may be needed. Because the District did not assert that an additional student currently requires transportation, it is reasonable to conclude that transporting only STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 will not cause the District financial hardship. Finally, the District cited no legal authority for its argument that it may deny transportation because provision of transportation may be costly.

The evidence establishes that the PARENTS are entitled to transportation to and from Loma Vista for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year. However, the evidence does not establish that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred by Far Northern Regional Center.

Citing no legal authority, Petitioners assert that the collateral source rule entitles them to reimbursement for funds provided by the Far Northern Regional Center. (Footnote 4)

Without evidence establishing that the collateral source rule applies in these proceedings and to these parties, the Hearing Officer will not order reimbursement of transportation expenses incurred by Far Northern Regional Center.

Furthermore, in Seals v. Loftis, 614 F. Supp. 302, (E.D.Ky.

1985), the court required reimbursement from a district to offset a decrease in the child's lifetime insurance benefits and to compensate the parents for the amounts directly paid to doctors that were not covered by insurance. The court so ordered "because of the [IDEA's] emphasis upon a free appropriate public education." Following this reasoning, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for only the transportation costs that they actually incurred since STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 enrolled in Loma Vista.

ORDER

The District must provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with transportation to and from Loma Vista school for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and reimburse the PARENTS for the costs of transportation to and from Loma Vista school that the PARENTS actually incurred.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

Issue 1:

Did STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 receive a free, appropriate public education during the 1995-96 school year?

Prevailing Party:

Petitioners prevailed on this issue.

Issue 2:

If the District did not provide STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 with a FAPE at Mesa Vista, must it provide them with both transportation to Loma Vista School for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and reimburse them for transportation costs already incurred?

Prevailing Party:

Petitioners prevailed with respect to the issue of provision of transportation for the remainder of the 1996-97 school year and retroactive reimbursement for transportation expenses actually incurred since STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 began attending Loma Vista.

Respondents prevailed with respect to the issue of retroactive reimbursement for transportation expenses not actually incurred by the PARENTS.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(i).

Dated: January 31, 1997 Carin N. Crain Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1) Loma Vista also agreed to allow STUDENT 1 and STUDENT 2 to transfer.

2) An IEP is a written statement for a disabled child that identifies the special education and related services necessary to meet that child's unique educational needs. The district must offer to provide those services at full public expense. (Ibid; 20 U.S.C. sections 1412(4) and 1414(a)(5); Education Code section 56040.)

3) At the hearing, the District argued that it offered MOTHER other placements that included home to school transportation. The District did not, however, support the argument with evidence of written placement offers as required by the Ninth Circuit in Union School Dist. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994). Instead, the District provided a mediation report that contained the following agreements: (1) parents will observe a preschool special day class, (2) Mr. Leger will coordinate the visit, and (3) parents will confer with the speech therapist at the observed program.

The contents of this document do not satisfy the Smith "requirement of a formal, written offer." Id. at 1526. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not consider these alleged offers.

4) "The collateral source rule was restated and reaffirmed in Helfand v. Southern Calif. Rapid Transit Dist. (1970) 2 C.3d 1, 13, as applicable 'in tort cases in which the plaintiff has been compensated by an independent collateral source -- such as insurance, pension, continued wages, or disability payments -- for which he has actually or constructively...paid or in cases in which the collateral source would be recompensed from the tort recovery through subrogation, refund of benefits, or some other arrangement.'" (6 Witkin, Summary of Cal. Law (9th ed. 1988) section 1390, p.859-60.)