California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 2, 1998

Student v. Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 986-98 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim

Tahoe-Truckee Unified must reimburse an independent OT assessment and put its therapy and aide offers in writing; technology claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 7 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision mentions an earlier mediation agreement (September 17, 1996) and an earlier state compliance complaint that resulted in make-up OT sessions.

Summary

The father of a 12-year-old boy with cerebral palsy brought this case against Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District. The boy was eligible for special education as orthopedically handicapped. He attended a special day class at Truckee Elementary School and spent part of his day in general education. The dispute covered occupational therapy (OT), physical therapy (PT), aide support, assistive technology, and payment for two independent assessments.

The Hearing Officer found procedural errors in 1997-98. The District's IEPs left out OT and the aide, and the triennial assessment was late. These errors did not deny a FAPE. The student still received OT and aide help, and the parents' delay in consenting caused most of the assessment delay.

The District never did a real OT assessment; its therapists wrote only progress reports. So it had to reimburse the parents for Dorina Martin's independent OT assessment. Susan Williams' PT assessment for the District was appropriate, so the parents' independent PT assessment was not reimbursed.

For 1998-99, the student needed only 15 minutes of consultative OT a week and one direct PT session a week. However, the District never put these changes in a written offer, so its offer was not appropriate. The student needed an aide on field trips and in small groups, but not during one-on-one therapy. His requests for a laptop, an IBM-compatible computer, and speech-recognition software were denied. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 20 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO applied Union School District v. Smith. A district may know the right level of services, but a therapist's report or IEP discussion is not a written offer. The case also shows that a parent's independent assessment can be reimbursed when the district never did its own assessment, even if the independent assessment had flaws.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to "complete" an IEP despite working on it for over a year, and thereby deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?

    The District left OT and the aide out of its IEPs and finished the triennial assessment late. These technical violations did not deny FAPE: the services were still provided, and the parents' delay in consenting caused most of the assessment delay.

  2. Issue 2a. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the occupational therapy assessment performed by Dorina Martin?

    The District never did an appropriate OT assessment. Its therapists' documents were only progress reports. Martin's assessment was an educational assessment, so the District must reimburse its cost.

  3. Issue 2b. Must the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the physical therapy assessment performed by Judy Kroeger?

    Susan Williams' January 1998 PT assessment met Education Code section 56320 requirements. Disagreeing with its conclusions did not justify reimbursement.

  4. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3a. Has the District made an appropriate offer with regard to occupational therapy for the 1998-99 school year?

    The student needed only consultative OT, once a week for 15 minutes. However, the District never made a written offer or gave prior written notice of this change, so its offer was not appropriate.

  5. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3b. Has the District made an appropriate offer with regard to physical therapy for the 1998-99 school year?

    The student needed direct PT once a week for 45-60 minutes, with make-ups only for sessions the therapist missed. The District never offered this in writing; its IEPs still listed PT twice a week, so its offer was not appropriate.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Must the District provide STUDENT with individual aide support during school field trips, small-group instruction and direct therapy sessions during the 1998-99 school year?

    The student needs individual aide support during field trips and small-group instruction because he needs help with transfers and toileting. He does not need an aide during direct therapy unless the therapist wants to train the aide.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Must the District provide additional technology services and assistive equipment to meet STUDENT's unique needs for the 1998-99 school year?

    The existing Macintosh desktop setup was appropriate. The evidence did not show the student needed, or could effectively use, a laptop, an IBM-compatible computer, or a speech-recognition system.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing, the District must convene an IEP team meeting and make a written offer of appropriate OT, PT, and aide services for 1998-99, consistent with the decision's findings.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receiving proof from the parents, the District must reimburse the parents for the cost of the independent OT assessment performed by Dorina Martin of Burger Physical Therapy & Rehabilitation Agency, Inc. The amount is not stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Education Code § 56329(b); Education Code § 56344; Government Code § 7572

People named in the decision

  • Michael Bowdish, coordinator of special education and school psychologist, Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Kay Atchinson, SELPA administrator, Placer-Nevada County SELPA
  • Dorina Martin, independent occupational therapist assessor, witness for Student, Burger Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Agency, Inc.
  • Judy Kroeger, independent physical therapist assessor, witness for Student, Burger Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Agency, Inc.
  • Jeanine Stewart, occupational therapist (nonpublic agency contractor), Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Susan Williams, physical therapist (nonpublic agency), District PT assessor, Truckee Physical Therapy
  • Mary Schug, SELPA program specialist, Auburn-Tahoe area, Placer-Nevada County SELPA
  • Michael Moser, speech-recognition technology evaluator, witness for District, EXAQ Micro Services
  • Marilyn Blom, occupational therapist, California Children's Services, Nevada County Health Department
  • Holly Hermansen, SELPA program specialist and technology team facilitator, Placer-Nevada County SELPA
  • Hillary Dembroff, occupational therapist (nonpublic agency contractor), Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Kristine Lucas, computer resource specialist and registered occupational therapist, adaptive technology assessor, Center for Accessible Technology, Berkeley

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), in Truckee, California, on June 25 and 26 and August 18 and 19, 1998.

STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his father, FATHER. The Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Terry Filliman from the law firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Also present on the District's behalf were Michael Bowdish, the District’s coordinator of special education and school psychologist, and Kay Atchinson, administrator for the Placer-Nevada County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA).

The following witnesses were called by the Student to testify: Dorina Martin, an occupational therapist with Burger Physical Therapy and Rehabilitation Agency, Inc. (Burger); Judy Kroeger, a physical therapist with Burger; and Michael Bowdish.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Jeanine Stewart, an occupational therapist employed by the District; Susan Williams, a physical therapist employed by the District; Mary Schug, the SELPA’s program specialist for the Auburn-Tahoe area; Michael Moser, the owner of EXAQ Micro Services; Marilyn Blom, an occupational therapist employed by the Nevada County Health Department to provide services through the California Children’s Services for Nevada County; Holly Hermansen, the SELPA’s program specialist for districts in Nevada County and the facilitator for the SELPA’s technology team; and Hillary Dembroff, an occupational therapist working with the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES (footnote 1)

1. Did the District fail to “complete” an IEP despite working on it for over a year, and thereby deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?

2. Must the District reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the following independent assessments: a. the occupational therapy assessment performed by Dorina Martin? b. the physical therapy assessment performed by Judy Kroeger?

3. Has the District made an appropriate offer with regard to the following related services for the 1998-99 school year: a. occupational therapy?

b. physical therapy?

4. Must the District provide STUDENT with individual aide support during school field trips, small-group instruction and direct therapy sessions during the 1998-99 school year? (Footnote 2)

5. Must the District provide additional technology services and assistive equipment to meet STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1998-99 school year?

PROCEDURAL MATTER

After the record was closed, the Hearing Office received a copy of a letter dated August 31, 1998, sent by the District to STUDENT’s parents. The letter was in regard to the provision of an aide and physical therapy. Given the date of the letter, it obviously had not been introduced into evidence by the conclusion of the hearing on August 19, 1998. The Hearing Officer notes that the record was closed for the submission of additional evidence at the conclusion of the hearing. For these reasons, the aforementioned letter will not be considered by the Hearing Officer in the rendering of a decision in this matter. The only evidence that will be considered is that which was introduced by the parties at the hearing.

FACTS

STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student currently attending Truckee Elementary School in the District. At the age of nine months, STUDENT was diagnosed with cerebral palsy and spastic quadriplegia. In April 1996, while STUDENT was in the third grade, he and his family moved from Ogden, Utah, to a residence within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. STUDENT had been found eligible for special education and related services by the local educational agency (LEA) in Utah and had an IEP developed by that LEA.

On May 13, 1996, the District held an IEP meeting for STUDENT. At the meeting, the District determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services under the category of orthopedically handicapped. STUDENT was placed in a special day class with participation in the general education program to occur during thirty percent of the school day. STUDENT received the following related services: physical therapy (PT) two times per week (one hour per session), occupational therapy (OT) one time per week, speech and language therapy two times per week, adapted physical education, and specialized transportation. He also received the assistance of an instructional aide.

On June 7, 1996, at the request of the District, the Center for Accessible Technology (Center) in Berkeley performed an adaptive technology assessment to evaluate STUDENT’s technological needs in the school setting. The Center recommended that STUDENT be provided with a desktop computer adapted with hardware and software appropriate to address his impairments and current level of functioning. Based on the Center’s recommendation, in July 1996 the District ordered the following equipment for STUDENT: a Power Macintosh 5260/100 personal computer with 16MB hard disk space, quad-speed CD-ROM drive, integrated stereo speaker, integrated microphone, and internet connection software; and a Hewlett-Packard DeskWriter 600 inkjet printer with a color kit. At the same time, the District ordered the following software for STUDENT: Write:OutLoud; Co:Writer; The Kids Can Read Family Pack I; There are Tyrannosaurs Trying on Pants in My Bedroom; KidPhonics; My First Incredible Dictionary CD; Word Tales; and the Living Books Bundle. In October 1996, the District loaned STUDENT an Apple Macintosh computer to use at home to complete homework assignments. (Footnote 3)

During the 1997-98 school year, while STUDENT was in the fifth grade, the disagreements at issue in this decision arose between the District and STUDENT’s parents. The disagreements related to the frequency and duration of OT and PT services, the technology services and assistive equipment provided to STUDENT, and the provision of an aide.

LEGAL ANALYSIS

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services, such as occupational therapy and speech-language services, that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA 1997). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200. According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

1. Did the District fail to “complete” an IEP despite working on it for over a year, and thereby deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year?

The Supreme Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 207-208. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. Id. at 1484. Procedural violations constitute a denial of FAPE where they result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.

In an issue statement dated June 13, 1998, the Student alleged that the District failed to “complete” an IEP despite working on it for over a year. After a careful review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that, while the District may have committed certain procedural violations, they did not result in the denial of a FAPE.

The evidence presented at hearing disclosed that the District offered the parent an educational program that failed to include either occupational therapy (OT) or the assistance of an aide, even though there is no dispute that STUDENT required both to benefit from his education. At an IEP meeting held on August 28, 1997, the parents gave their consent to a written educational program that included placement in a special day class with forty-nine percent of the school day spent in the general education program and the following related services: S/L three times per week, APE, and PT two times per week for sixty minutes each session. There was no mention of OT or the provision of an aide. In addition, none of the other IEPs drafted by the District during the 1997-98 school year included an offer of OT or aide services. However, notwithstanding the District’s failure to draft an IEP including OT services or an aide, the evidence established that these services were provided during the 1997-98 school year. Because there was an ongoing dispute as to whether STUDENT still required direct OT services, the District continued to provide direct OT one time per week in accordance with STUDENT’s IEP dated May 13, 1996. There is no evidence that STUDENT required more OT than this in order to benefit from his education. Also, there is no dispute that the District has provided STUDENT with individual aide assistance since he entered the District in April 1996.

The evidence also disclosed that the District failed to complete the triennial assessment by the time it was due, which was April 1997. Education Code § 56381 provides that a reassessment of a student shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant. District personnel, including Michael Bowdish and Mary Schug, testified that STUDENT’s triennial evaluation was due by April 1997. However, the process was delayed from the beginning. The District did not submit an assessment plan to the parents until late April 1997 and, because the parties disagreed as to what information the plan had to contain, did not receive the parents’ consent to perform the bulk of the triennial assessment until August 28, 1997. The District did not receive consent to perform a physical therapy (PT) assessment as part of the triennial assessment until December 12, 1997. Most of the triennial assessment was completed by October 1997 but the PT assessment was not completed until January 7, 1998, and, as will be discussed in greater detail below, the District never performed a formal OT assessment as part of the triennial assessment. However, notwithstanding these delays and omissions, there is no evidence that the technical violations resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringed on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process. The evidence disclosed that the significant delays in the assessment process were mainly caused by the parents’ unwillingness to consent to the assessment until August 1997. The evidence also established that the District tried to keep the annual review timely by using informal reports from school staff.

The IEP team met on May 28, 1997, to perform the annual review of STUDENT’s present levels of performance and his previous goals and objectives, and draft new goals and objectives. At that time, the IEP team had available to it recently-drafted written reports from all those working with STUDENT including his special day class teacher, speech pathologist, adapted physical education therapist, occupational therapist and physical therapist. From these informal reports, which were based on observations but did not utilize any standardized-testing, the team was able to evaluate STUDENT’s progress and draft new goals and objectives. Because the parents did not attend the meeting, the proposed educational program, as well as the reports provided by staff, were forwarded to them for their review. The team met again on June 10, but the parents again declined to attend. On August 28, 1997, the parents finally attended an IEP meeting, approved the proposed goals and objectives, and gave consent for the bulk of the triennial assessment. The District completed the triennial assessment, except for the OT and PT portions, and held an IEP meeting to review the assessments by October 30, 1997. Although the District failed to meet the 50-day timeline established for the completion and review of assessments contained in Education Code § 56344 by thirteen days, this was only a de minimus violation. In addition, the proposed educational program drafted at the May 28, 1997, remained essentially the same even after the formal assessments were completed in October 1997, probably because the proposed program drafted on May 28, 1997, was based on reports submitted by those working directly with STUDENT in the school setting.

As for the PT portion of the triennial assessment, the District would have met the 50-day timeline had it not been for the parents’ cancellation of the February 5, 1998, meeting at which time the team was to review the results of the PT assessment. The District received the parents’ consent for the assessment on December 12, 1997, and the assessment was completed by January 7, 1998. Although FATHER cancelled the February 5 meeting on February 4, the team was able to meet again on March 27, 1998, to review the PT assessment. Finally, there is no evidence that the absence of a formal OT assessment resulted in a loss of educational opportunity, because the findings and recommendations of the occupational therapists working with STUDENT remained the same from December 16, 1996, to March 27, 1996. Both therapists found that STUDENT, who had been receiving direct occupational therapy one time per week since he entered the District in April 1996, no longer needed direct therapy to benefit from his education and that only consultive services were needed. However, as the parties disagreed about whether STUDENT still required direct therapy, the District continued to provide direct services one time per week.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, while the District did commit certain technical violations that resulted in an incomplete IEP or an incomplete IEP process, the violations did not result in the denial of a FAPE for the 1997-98 school year.

2. Must the District reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the following independent assessments: a. the occupational therapy assessment performed by Dorina Martin? b. the physical therapy assessment performed by Judy Kroeger?

Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment from a qualified specialist if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. See Government Code § 7572(d) (stating that Ed. Code § 56329(b) is specifically applicable to OT and PT assessments). However, if the educational agency is able to establish at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent assessment. Education Code § 56329(b). For the educational agency’s OT or PT assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of Education Code § 56320. See Government Code § 7572(a) (stating that Ed. Code § 56320 et seq. is specifically applicable to OT and PT assessments).

Education Code § 56320 requires that the assessment be conducted by qualified persons; that tests and assessment materials and procedures be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and include tests and other assessment materials tailored to assess specific areas of educational need; and that no single procedure be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program. Education Code § 56320. Following the assessment, the assessor must prepare a written report detailing the results of the assessment. Education Code § 56327.

In addition, Government Code § 7572(a) requires that the student be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability by “those qualified to make a determination of the child’s need for the service.” Assessments for OT and PT must be conducted by “qualified medical personnel as specified in regulations developed by the State Department of Health Services in consultation with the State Department of Education.” Government Code § 7572(b).

Occupational Therapy Assessment

The Student contended that he is entitled to reimbursement for the OT assessment performed by Dorina Martin on March 26, 1998. The District argued that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement because he provided no grounds on which to find the District’s assessments inappropriate, and because the independent assessment was not an educational assessment. After a careful review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment performed by Dorina Martin.

There is no evidence that the District ever conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s OT needs in the educational setting, even though it is clear that such an assessment should have been performed by the District. Education Code § 56381 provides that a reassessment of a student shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant. District personnel testified that STUDENT’s triennial evaluation was due by April 1997. Due to a disagreement between the parties as to what information had to be provided in the assessment plan, the District finally received FATHER’s consent to assess STUDENT on August 28, 1997. The assessment plan consented to by FATHER included assessment in the area of motor development by the occupational therapist and physical therapist.

The record, however, is bereft of any evidence that the District conducted an OT assessment, appropriate or otherwise, after receiving FATHER’s consent to assess and before FATHER obtained his independent assessment. The independent assessment was conducted on or before March 26, 1998, a full seven months after the District received FATHER’s consent to perform a triennial OT assessment. That means that by the time FATHER obtained the independent assessment, the District had already had seven months in which to complete an OT assessment. The District’s failure to complete the assessment by that time was a violation of Education Code § 56344. Section 56344 provides that an assessment must be completed and an IEP developed within “a total time not to exceed 50 days ... from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension.” There was neither evidence nor argument that the parent agreed to an extension. Thus, despite its obligation to conduct an OT assessment for STUDENT, the District wholly failed to conduct the assessment before the parent obtained an independent assessment.

Shortly after the parent’s independent assessment was performed, the District’s occupational therapist did issue a report. However, even if this report could be considered the assessment performed by the District, the report itself could not be deemed an “appropriate” assessment. On March 27, 1998, Jeanine Stewart, a registered occupational therapist (OTR), prepared a two-page handwritten document entitled “Occupational Therapy Report.” (Footnote 4) This document has questionable validity as a triennial OT assessment for several reasons. First, it appears to be just a progress report, not an assessment. The report contained three sections: discussion, recommendations and comment. The discussion portion addressed only (1) whether or not STUDENT had met his OT goals and (2) CCS’s position that STUDENT needed only consultative services. The comment section noted that the make-up OT sessions ( footnote 5) had been completed and that STUDENT continued to receive OT consult once a week for fifteen minutes. The scarcity of assessment information contained in the report reveals that it was not an appropriate assessment and that it did not satisfy the provisions of Education Code § 56327. Section 56327 requires that an assessment report contain, inter alia, a discussion of the basis for making a determination and the educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings. Ms. Stewart’s report dated March 27, 1998, contained none of this information. Second, despite Ms. Stewart’s testimony that a proper OT assessment must include interviews with the school staff working with the child, there is no evidence that Ms. Stewart, in preparing her report, interviewed the school staff who work with STUDENT on a daily basis.

Neither of the other OT reports produced on the District’s behalf since STUDENT’s admission into the District could be considered appropriate assessments either. The first report was prepared in or about April 1996, by Hillary Dembroff, OTR. (Footnote 6) It was a one-page handwritten document entitled “O.T. report.” The report contained a brief description of STUDENT’s history, the adaptive equipment needed in the classroom, and recommended OT goals. On direct examination by the District, Ms. Dembroff acknowledged that this report was not a full assessment. She explained that a full assessment had just been performed by STUDENT’s previous school district. (Footnote 7) The second report was again prepared by Ms. Dembroff. It was prepared on December 16, 1996, and is a four-page handwritten document entitled “Occupational Therapy Assessment: IEP Report -- OT Update.” It was the most comprehensive OT report prepared on behalf of the District but it, just like the others, was not an assessment. During direct examination, Ms. Dembroff attested that this was a progress report and not an assessment.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not conduct an appropriate OT assessment.

The District argued that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement because the independent assessment was not an educational assessment. However, this argument was simply not supported by the evidence. According to Ms. Martin’s testimony and the assessment report itself, the purpose of the independent assessment was to evaluate STUDENT’s occupational needs in the school setting. During the course of the assessment, Ms. Martin evaluated STUDENT’s tone; posture while sitting and while engaged in tabletop activities; ability to position and manage his wheelchair (STUDENT always uses his wheelchair in school); ability to perform activities of daily living such as putting on and removing his coat, toileting, and self-feeding; fine motor coordination during activities such as writing and cutting; range of motion; vision; and tactile defensiveness. Obviously, these concerns did relate to STUDENT’s ability to function in the classroom and thereby benefit from his education. Additionally, Ms. Martin proposed goals to address issues that might arise in a classroom such as successful toileting, good posture and positioning while keying on the computer, and the ability to self-feed.

The District’s evidence established only that Ms. Martin’s assessment may be of limited use in an educational sense, not that it could be of no use in the educational sense. For example, Ms. Stewart testified that an educational OT assessment “should” be performed in the classroom in order to see how the child functions in the school environment. Ms. Dembroff testified that special education OT assessments are “normally” performed in the school environment, and that she would disagree that Ms. Martin’s report was “appropriate” for the educational setting. Despite this, Ms. Dembroff acknowledged that Ms. Martin had identified some appropriate goals for use in the educational setting. The District also submitted portions of a publication distributed by the California Department of Education entitled “Guidelines for Occupational Therapy & Physical Therapy in California Public Schools” in support of its position. However, like the testimony of Ms. Stewart and Ms. Dembroff, the publication does not prove that Ms. Martin’s assessment was not an educational assessment. The Guidelines merely state that, “generally,” OT assessments involve observation of the student in the educational environment, and that student performance cannot be evaluated “accurately” without such observation. Guidelines for Occupational Therapy & Physical Therapy in California Public Schools, California Department of Education, Sacramento, 1996, p. 36. Education Code § 56329(b) does not require that an independent assessment procured by a parent be appropriate for purposes of reimbursement, only that it be an educational assessment. While the criticisms of Ms. Martin’s assessment may be relevant to determining the weight to accord Ms. Martin’s findings and recommendations, they do not establish that Ms. Martin’s assessment was not an educational assessment.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student is entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment performed by Dorina Martin.

Physical Therapy Assessment

The Student contended that he is entitled to reimbursement for the PT assessment performed by Judy Kroeger on April 2, 1998. The District argued that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement because the District’s PT assessment was appropriate, and the independent assessment was not an educational assessment. After a careful review of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District conducted an appropriate PT assessment and that, therefore, the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment performed by Judy Kroeger.

The PT assessment plan was signed and received by the District on December 12, 1997. On January 7, 1998, Susan Williams conducted a PT assessment on behalf of the District. Ms. Williams graduated from the University of California and received her license to practice physical therapy in approximately 1976. She is certified as a “nonpublic agency” and was hired by the District to provide physical therapy services to the District’s students, including STUDENT. She has been providing direct physical therapy to STUDENT since he entered the District. On January 7, she evaluated STUDENT in the following areas: tone; reflexes; range of motion; flexibility; functional status in the developmental sequence; ability to sit, stand, walk, perform step-ups, and use a Rifton walker; wheelchair skills; transfers; and wheelchair mobility. Ms. Williams testified that she specifically tailored the assessment to assess STUDENT’s unique needs. She thereafter prepared a written report documenting and discussing the results of the assessment, and recommending goals for use in the educational setting. Thus, the evidence disclosed that Ms. Williams’ assessment met the requirements of Education Code § 56320 et seq. The Student provided no evidence to show that Ms. Williams’ assessment was inappropriate. He simply disagreed with the conclusions contained in Ms. Williams’ assessment. Standing alone, disagreement with the results of a school district’s assessment is not sufficient to justify reimbursement for an independent educational assessment. Since the District’s assessment was found to be appropriate, the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent PT assessment performed by Judy Kroeger.

**** Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District must reimburse the Student for the independent OT assessment performed by Dorina Martin. The Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the independent PT assessment performed by Judy Kroeger, however, because the District’s assessment was appropriate. The Hearing Officer notes that the IEP team should take into consideration the findings and recommendations of both Ms. Martin and Ms. Kroeger in formulating an appropriate IEP for STUDENT. Education Code § 56329(b).

3. Has the District made an appropriate offer with regard to the following related services for the 1998-99 school year: a. occupational therapy?

b. physical therapy?

Occupational therapy and physical therapy are designated instruction and services that must be provided to a student when the services are necessary for the child to benefit from his instructional program. Education Code § 56363. There is no dispute that STUDENT requires OT and PT to benefit from his education. Rather, the parties dispute whether OT should be provided on a direct or consult basis and whether direct PT should be provided once or twice per week. The Student contended that STUDENT requires direct OT twice per week for fifty-five minutes each session, and direct PT twice per week for fifty-five minutes each session. The District argued that it offered the Student OT on a consult basis (footnote 8) one time per week for fifteen minutes and direct PT one time per week for forty-five to sixty minutes per session, with no make-up sessions unless the session was missed due to the physical therapist’s unavailability. The District argued that this was an appropriate offer.

Occupational Therapy

The Hearing Officer finds that, for the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT requires OT on a consult basis once per week for fifteen minutes in order to benefit from his education. This level of services was recommended by both of the occupational therapists who have worked with STUDENT since he entered the District, Hillary Dembroff and Jeanine Stewart. Their testimony established that STUDENT’s OT needs are being met within the educational setting, and that OT is needed only on a consultive basis to help maintain what STUDENT has already accomplished .

Ms. Dembroff provided direct OT to STUDENT one time per week for thirty minutes each session from approximately April 1996 to December 1997. Ms. Dembroff has a bachelor of science degree in occupational therapy and is registered as an occupational therapist with the American Occupational Therapy Association (AOTA). She has twenty-seven years experience working as an occupational therapist and, for at least seven of those years, she worked with school districts and CCS. In working with STUDENT, she reviewed a physician’s report from the Primary Children’s Medical Center in Utah dated February 15, 1996, and various documents from STUDENT’s previous school district, including his IEP. Over the course of her treatment, Ms. Dembroff provided STUDENT with the following equipment to enhance his functional skills in the school setting: a Dycem non-skid mat, a molded pencil grip, a portable slantboard, an adapted spoon with a built-up handle and curve, and fitted bilateral soft hand splints. According to her testimony, her work with STUDENT and the goals she set for him addressed a number of OT concerns including transfers, rotation, stability, upper extremity dexterity, self-care skills, visual skills of tracking and scanning, and training of the school staff working with him. Ms. Dembroff testified that by December 16, 1996, the date of her progress report recommending consultive services, she had worked with STUDENT on a weekly basis in thirty-minute sessions for a total of five and a half months. She found that STUDENT, as a student functioning in a wheelchair, was able to function well in his school environment since he was able to maneuver around the school setting, access the facility, communicate with others, and perform his classwork in his workstations. Furthermore, he did not pose a safety risk to either himself or to others. She testified that, because the staff was sufficiently trained and STUDENT was no longer benefitting from direct therapy, the expertise of an occupational therapist was no longer needed on a direct basis.

Jeanine Stewart echoed the same sentiments after having worked with STUDENT since December 1997. Ms. Stewart received a bachelor of science degree in occupational therapy from San Jose State University and has been registered as an occupational therapist with AOTA for the last twenty years. She has been working for the District since December 1997 and has been providing OT services to STUDENT since that time. Ms. Stewart testified that she is not recommending any direct OT services, because STUDENT has the set-up he needs to function at school and the staff is trained to assist him with any tasks that he cannot perform independently. Ms. Stewart stated that STUDENT had met his OT goals, including the improvement of ocular motor control and written communication skills. She recommended that only consultive OT be provided in order to train staff and review the OT program, as appropriate.

In contrast, the Student presented only vague expert opinion without either an adequate evidentiary basis to support it or an explanation of how the opinion was reached. After assessing STUDENT for approximately one hour at her clinic, Dorina Martin concluded in a written report that STUDENT “would benefit from participating in occupational therapy on a 1-2 time a week for a period of 60-minute therapy sessions ... .” Although Ms. Martin is a fully qualified occupational therapist, her testimony does not establish that STUDENT needs direct OT to benefit from his education. Despite the fact that her avowed purpose in assessing STUDENT was to evaluate his OT needs in the school setting, Ms. Martin failed to either observe STUDENT in the school setting or speak with any of the school personnel who work with STUDENT on a daily basis. Furthermore, Ms. Martin did not review any of STUDENT’s educational records or have knowledge of any of the adaptive equipment or modifications that have been provided to enhance STUDENT’s ability to function in the school setting. Ms. Dembroff and Ms. Stewart both concurred that, unless an OT assessment is performed in the school setting, the assessor could not make appropriate recommendations about a child’s OT needs in the school setting. Even Ms. Martin agreed that a further assessment in the classroom would be “beneficial” in determining STUDENT’s OT needs in the school setting. Moreover, both Ms. Dembroff and Ms. Stewart testified that the goals identified in Ms. Martin’s assessment have all been worked on in the school setting and that, in their professional judgment, STUDENT has reached the goals to the best of his ability or to the extent that is necessary for functioning in the educational setting. With regard to the goal of cutting with scissors, Ms. Stewart testified that, at the age of twelve, a student does not need to cut with scissors in order to benefit from his or her education and that, therefore, this would not be an appropriate educational goal for STUDENT. Thus, in effect, Ms. Martin offered only a vague opinion with an inadequate basis and an insufficient explanation to support her opinion. Ms. Martin’s testimony and assessment do not establish that STUDENT requires direct OT in order to benefit from his education.

As STUDENT’s needs in the educational setting have been identified, the Hearing Officer now turns to the issue of whether the District has made an appropriate offer to meet those needs. The evidence does not establish that the District made an appropriate offer of OT services for the 1998-99 school year. The IDEA and special education law clearly require that the District offer a student with exceptional needs, such as STUDENT, a free appropriate public education. The IDEA also requires that a school district provide written prior notice to the parents of a special education student whenever the district proposes to change the provision of a FAPE to the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3); Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994). The court in Smith stated:

The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child. ... [¶] We find that this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.

Smith, 15 F.3d at 1526.

Although the District argues that STUDENT requires only consultive OT services and has been trying to convince STUDENT’s parents that only consultive OT is required, there is no evidence that the District ever gave the parents prior written notice of this proposed change in services. Even when the Hearing Officer asked the District during the hearing whether ir had ever given the required notice, the District could only point to the occupational therapists’ recommendations for consultive services. Generally, however, therapists’ recommendations do not constitute a recommendation or an offer of services from the IEP team itself. See Government Code § 7572(d). Furthermore, neither the IEP dated August 28, 1997 (which FATHER agreed to), nor the IEP dated December 11, 1997 (which FATHER did not agree to), provide for any OT services, direct or consultive. Nowhere, then, did the District make a written offer to STUDENT’s parents for consultive OT services one time per week during the 1998-99 school year.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make an appropriate offer of OT services for the 1998-99 school year. The District should have offered STUDENT’s parents, in writing, consultive OT services one time per week for fifteen minutes per visit. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District should convene an IEP meeting to make an appropriate written offer of OT services to STUDENT’s parents.

Physical Therapy

The Hearing Officer finds that, for the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT requires direct PT one time per week for forty-five to sixty minutes per session. The Hearing Officer also finds that the sessions that are missed due to the Student’s absence or unavailability for therapy need not be made up for at a later time. However, any sessions missed as a result of the therapist’s unavailability should be rescheduled. These findings are based on the following evidence presented at hearing.

Susan Williams, the physical therapist who has worked with STUDENT since his admission into the District, testified that, in her professional opinion, STUDENT’s PT services should be reduced from two sessions per week to one session per week. Ms. Williams also testified that some flexibility is required in the amount of PT provided to STUDENT during a therapy session, because he can become fatigued or lose interest during a session. Further, Ms. Williams testified that, after she made up some of STUDENT’s PT sessions missed during the 1996-97 school year, she found that an increase in the frequency of PT sessions causes STUDENT to become bored or frustrated, and that the extra sessions were not necessarily effective.

As noted earlier, Ms. Williams has a bachelor’s degree from the University of California at San Francisco and has been a licensed physical therapist since 1976. She worked for Children’s Hospital in Oakland for four years and is a CCS panel therapist. Currently, she provides therapy services on behalf of Truckee Physical Therapy and is qualified to work with the District as a nonpublic agency, which required a demonstration of knowledge of special education requirements. On May 7, 1996, shortly after STUDENT entered the District, Ms. Williams performed a physical therapy evaluation of STUDENT at the District’s request. Ms. Williams testified that, as part of her assessment, she reviewed some of STUDENT’s previous medical reports and school records. The assessment also included a physical examination of STUDENT in the school setting to determine the appropriateness of the wheelchair STUDENT was using, his muscle tonicity, reflexes, posture, postural reflexes and balance, mobility, ability to ambulate, and wheelchair mobility and control. Following the assessment, Ms. Williams identified STUDENT’s classroom needs and suggested a number of physical therapy goals for the educational setting. On May 13, 1996, during an IEP team meeting, the parties agreed that STUDENT’s educational program would include PT two times per week for sixty minutes each session.

Thereafter, the District and Truckee Physical Therapy provided STUDENT with the following equipment to enhance his functioning in the school setting: a safety belt, pivot disk, a seven-inch box to raise STUDENT when a toilet is too high, and a new walker. According to Ms. William’s testimony, by May 13, 1997, STUDENT had made significant progress with his PT goals: he was able to transfer from his wheelchair to the toilet with minimal to moderate assistance by one person instead of requiring two people; the length of time he was able to stand increased from a couple of minutes to twelve minutes; he could better control his wheelchair and only infrequently ran into door jambs and people; and he was able to walk greater distances than before.

After working with STUDENT for over a year and a half, Ms. Williams performed an assessment of STUDENT’s PT needs on January 7, 1998. She assessed STUDENT in the following areas: tone; reflexes; range of motion; flexibility; functional status in the developmental sequence; ability to sit, stand, walk, perform step-ups, and use a Rifton walker; wheelchair skills; transfers; and wheelchair mobility. In her report, she stated the following:

STUDENT has reached maximum functional status in the developmental sequence. He is capable of some increase in strength, speed and practicality of current skills. Independent or minimal assist from wheelchair to floor and back transfers is not within STUDENT’s motor capabilities due to his spasticity and subsequent lack of balance and freedom of movement. Independent ambulation is not a practical or realistic goal for STUDENT due to his spasticity and the tremendous energy cost of this physical task.

Her suggested goals for STUDENT included increasing his ability to stand with minimal assistance to ten minutes, increasing his ability to walk longer distances with his walker, and establishing and supervising a home program for repetition of skills. She recommended that the frequency of PT services be decreased to one session per week with no make-up visits.

This conclusion finds further support in the independent PT assessment performed by Judy Kroeger in April 1998. Ms. Kroeger’s recommendation at hearing echoed that offered by Ms. Williams. Ms. Kroeger testified that she believed STUDENT should receive direct PT one time per week for about an hour with re-evaluation of his continued need for direct PT in six months. It is noted, however, that Ms. Kroeger’s assessment has limited applicability in the educational setting, because her assessment did not include either an observation of STUDENT in the educational setting or interviews with any school personnel working with STUDENT.

Having identified STUDENT’s PT needs in the educational setting, the Hearing Officer now turns to the issue of whether the District made an appropriate offer of PT services for the 1998-99 school year. The evidence established that the District had not made an appropriate offer of PT services for the 1998-99 school year. As discussed earlier, the IDEA and special education law clearly require that the District offer STUDENT a FAPE and provide prior written notice of a proposal to change the provision of a FAPE to STUDENT. See Union School District, 15 F.3d at 1526.

On the last day of hearing and in its closing brief, the District made clear its position that the appropriate level of services for STUDENT for the 1998-99 school year is direct PT one time per week for forty-five to sixty minutes per session, with no make-up sessions unless a session was missed due to the unavailability of the therapist. From FATHER’s reaction at the hearing, however, it is apparent that this was the first time FATHER was aware that the District was proposing to continue direct therapy, with only a decrease in the amount of services from twice to once per week. After hearing this, FATHER stated that he would have accepted a decrease in the frequency of PT so long as direct therapy was maintained. This, then, is exactly the situation that was meant to be avoided by the requirement of prior written notice of a proposed change in the provision of a FAPE. Had the District just put its offer in writing instead of assuming that FATHER would figure it out through IEP team discussions or by reading the therapist’s report, disagreement on this issue might have been avoided. When the Hearing Officer asked the District during the hearing whether it had ever given the required notice, the District could only point to the physical therapist’s report recommending a decrease in services. The District is reminded that, generally, therapists’ recommendations do not constitute a recommendation or an offer of services from the IEP team itself. See Government Code § 7572(d). Furthermore, both the IEP dated August 28, 1997, and the IEP dated December 11, 1997, both indicate that PT is to be provided two times per week. Nowhere, then, did the District make a written offer to STUDENT’s parents of direct PT one time per week for the 1998-99 school year.

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make an appropriate offer of PT services for the 1998-99 school year. The District should have offered STUDENT’s parents, in writing, direct PT one time per week for forty-five to sixty minutes per session, with sessions that are missed due to the unavailability of the therapist to be made up. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District should convene an IEP meeting to make an appropriate written offer of PT services to STUDENT’s parents.

4. Must the District provide STUDENT with individual aide support during school field trips, small-group instruction and direct therapy sessions during the 1998-99 school year?

The parties agree that STUDENT requires individual aide assistance during the school day, but disagree about whether this also includes a need for aide assistance during school field trips, small-group instruction and direct therapy sessions. The District argued that there is no evidence that STUDENT requires individual aide support during all hours of the school day, regardless of the activity. The District has agreed to provide STUDENT with individual aide support during the entire school day except during school field trips, small-group instruction, and off-campus field trips. The Student argued that an aide is important for STUDENT’s safety and education, and that an aide should be provided during the entirety of the school day unless a therapist suggests a need for one-on-one teaching during direct therapy. Based on the record, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires individual aide support during school field trips and small-group instruction, but does not require an aide during direct therapy sessions unless the therapist wants to train the aide.

The evidence established that STUDENT has multiple orthopedic impairments as a result of cerebral palsy and is confined to a wheelchair. He requires assistance to use the bathroom, because he is not able to successfully transfer to the toilet and back to his wheelchair by himself. STUDENT uses a safety belt, a pivot disk, and a seven-inch box to assist him in toilet transfers. According to the physical therapist, STUDENT also requires stand-by assistance for safety and minimal to moderate assistance from one person to rise and stand, to lower his pants, and to lower himself to the toilet seat. Because STUDENT needs assistance in transfers and in toileting even in the school setting where modifications have been made based on his needs, the need for such assistance in unfamiliar settings on field trips would be even greater. Thus, it is clear STUDENT requires assistance during field trips. Further, by the same logic, STUDENT requires individual aide assistance during small-group instruction.

However, with regard to direct therapy, the evidence established that STUDENT does not require individual aide support when he is receiving direct therapy on a one-on-one basis. The occupational therapist testified that, while the aide’s presence is necessary during therapy sessions when the therapist wants to train the aide, the aide’s presence is not otherwise necessary, especially if the aide’s presence would inhibit the relationship between the therapist and STUDENT. Should STUDENT require assistance during direct therapy in transferring or toileting, he has a trained professional at his disposal to assist him with such activities.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires individual aide assistance during school field trips and small-group instruction, but not during direct therapy sessions unless the therapist wants to train the aide.

5. Must the District provide additional technology services and assistive equipment to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 1998-99 school year?

A school district is responsible for providing certain types of specialized equipment, including assistive technology devices, for use at school when the equipment is needed to implement the individualized education program. Education Code § 56363.1; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(1), 1414(d)(3)(B)(v). As noted earlier, the District has provided a number of assistive technology devices to STUDENT since he entered the District. This includes two desktop Macintosh computers, one for his exclusive use at school and one for home use; a printer; a trackball; and a number of software programs for word processing and instruction in reading and other academic areas. The Student contended that, notwithstanding the devices provided thus far, the District failed to fulfill its responsibility in a number of respects. The Student argued that the District should provide him with a laptop computer, an IBM-compatible personal computer, and a speech-recognition system. (Footnote 9) The District maintained that the assistive technology devices it has provided thus far are appropriate and that it has met its responsibility to provide assistive technology devices necessary for STUDENT to benefit from his education. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENT needs or could effectively use a laptop computer, an IBM-compatible personal computer, or a speech-recognition system in order to benefit from his education.

First, all of the persons who have assessed whether STUDENT should be provided with a laptop or desktop computer have recommended that the District provide a desktop computer. After performing an adaptive technology assessment at the District’s request on June 7, 1996, the Center for Accessible Technology (Center) in Berkeley specifically recommended that STUDENT be provided with a desktop, not laptop, computer for school use. Kristine Lucas, a computer resource specialist and registered occupational therapist, conducted the assessment at the Center and issued the subsequent written report to the District. The report stated:

At this point in time I believe that a desktop computer ... is the most functional tool for STUDENT. A desktop computer allows more flexibility in positioning the screen, the keyboard, and the trackball. These are very important issues for STUDENT. ... (¶) ... We do not recommend a laptop at this time. As is, it does not allow flexibility in positioning. While an external trackball, keyboard, monitor, and CD-ROM can be hooked up to a laptop to provide appropriate positioning, this would be extremely cumbersome. We’ve also found that keyboards break down with constant plugging and unplugging. We’re not enthusiastic about the current laptop offerings from Apple, and we’re extremely cautious in recommending laptops for elementary school children because of short battery life, high rates of repair, and theft issues.

The testimony of both STUDENT’s occupational therapist and physical therapist confirmed that STUDENT was, as predicted, working well with his desktop computer in the school setting. Holly Hermansen, a program specialist with the SELPA who is also a member of the SELPA’s technology team, concurred that STUDENT was working well with his desktop computer. Ms. Hermansen evaluated STUDENT in November 1997 by observing him using his technology equipment, speaking to his special day class teacher and reviewing his IEPs and reports. She found that his educational needs were being met by the desktop computer system because it provided him access whenever he needed it, it could run all of the programs he needed, and there is only infrequent transitioning of classrooms at STUDENT’s grade level.

Second, there is no evidence that STUDENT requires an IBM-compatible personal computer to benefit from his education. Both Ms. Hermansen and Michael Bowdish testified that a Macintosh personal computer, instead of an IBM-compatible computer, is appropriate for STUDENT because it can run all of the software programs he needs to accomplish his educational goals. Mr. Bowdish also testified that almost all of the elementary and middle schools in the District use Macintosh computers. Moreover, the Student presented no evidence that STUDENT was unable to accomplish any of his IEP goals or that his IEP cannot be implemented because of the lack of an IBM-compatible computer.

Third, there is no evidence that a speech-recognition system, in its present state of technological development, could work effectively for STUDENT. The District has had two people assess whether STUDENT could benefit from a speech-recognition system, neither of whom recommended that STUDENT be provided with one at this time. Ms. Hermansen, during her evaluation of STUDENT in November 1997, reviewed the appropriateness of such a system for STUDENT. She found that, because of STUDENT’s speech difficulties with articulation and intelligibility, the technology currently available would not prove effective for him. According to her report, students with speech difficulties tend to require a great deal of training to effectively use the system. Additionally, the system requires a skill level that STUDENT has not yet achieved in order to work well. For example, Ms. Hermansen reported that the system requires that a student participate in several tasks simultaneously, including orally composing a document while giving commands to the computer. Also, the student must have reading skills sufficient to detect when the system makes a mistake, as well as differentiate between similar words offered on a list. As will be discussed below, STUDENT is not yet performing at this level.

Michael Moser, who conducted a thorough evaluation of STUDENT on June 4, 1998, also did not recommend a speech-recognition system for STUDENT, because of STUDENT’s needs at the present time and the technology currently available. Mr. Moser owns EXAQ Micro Services, a business which provides speech recognition systems to people with disabilities and which services a number of state and federal agencies. Mr. Moser testified that he has been involved with the speech-recognition industry for the past seven years and has provided speech-recognition systems to about a thousand clients. He testified that he is frequently called on to assess the appropriateness of a speech-recognition system for individuals and to provide services to make the systems as productive as possible.

On June 4, Mr. Moser evaluated STUDENT’s performance with DragonDictate in the library of the school. Mr. Moser testified that EXAQ carries all of the major speech-recognition products on the market, but that he chose to work with STUDENT using DragonDictate because it offers totally hands-free control and has customizing options that are unavailable on the other primary products on the market. He assisted STUDENT in creating a voice file on DragonDictate, and then evaluated how well STUDENT was able to work with the system in dictating text and correcting errors. Mr. Moser found that STUDENT had a rather high-pitched voice, with which the speech-recognition systems traditionally have worked poorly, and tended to fatigue easily. According to Mr. Moser, grade school children tend to have poor results with speech-recognition systems because the system requires a particular amount of diligence to achieve effective results, which younger children often lack. Mr. Moser found that, although a speech-recognition system would probably work very well for STUDENT when he gets older, STUDENT’s present skills and his maturity level counseled against training him to use such a system at the present. In his report, Mr. Moser wrote:

As a technology, DragonDictate will adapt well enough to STUDENT’s speech patterns to be productive. Intellectually, STUDENT was able, in a short period of time, to understand and use many of the basic functions required for operating the software. ... STUDENT’s reading level (or vision) will require him to be VERY careful and diligent to avoid making corrections to the wrong words. It has been our experience that younger children tire quickly of the focus required to make proper corrections if the correction process takes intense concentration. It is my opinion that an attempt to use speech recognition for STUDENT, at this time, to produce school work would evolve from excitement and enthusiasm to frustration and eventual failure. (Emphasis in original.)

Mr. Moser testified that, at this time, STUDENT would have a fairly low probability of success because of the nature of the software and his maturity level. The Student did not present any evidence to rebut these findings.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the assistive technology devices currently provided by the District are appropriate to allow STUDENT to benefit from his education, and that the items requested by the Student are not within the District’s responsibility to provide at this time.

ORDER

1. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting in order to make a written offer of appropriate occupational therapy, physical therapy, and aide services for the 1998-99 school year in accordance with the findings of fact and conclusions of law contained in this decision.

2. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof from STUDENT’s parents, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the independent occupational therapy assessment performed by Dorina Martin from Burger Physical Therapy & Rehabilitation Agency, Inc.

3. All of the Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Did the District fail to “complete” an IEP despite working on it for over a year, and thereby deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year? The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Must the District reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the following independent assessments: a. the occupational therapy assessment performed by Dorina Martin? The Student prevailed on this sub-issue.

b. the physical therapy assessment performed by Judy Kroeger?

The District prevailed on this sub-issue.

3. Has the District made an appropriate offer with regard to the following related services for the 1998-99 school year: a. occupational therapy?

b. physical therapy?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

4. Must the District provide STUDENT with individual aide support during school field trips, small group instruction and direct therapy sessions during the 1998-99 school year? The Student substantially prevailed on this issue.

5. Must the District provide additional technology services and assistive equipment to meet STUDENT’s unique needs for the 1998-99 school year? The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

Date: December 2, 1998 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. The issues listed here differ slightly in wording and content from those noticed by the parties before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. Additionally, on a separate but related matter, in its initial statement of issues, the District presented for hearing the issue of whether the District was providing the Student a free appropriate public education during the 1997-98 school year. However, at hearing, neither the District nor the Student presented evidence on any aspect of the Student’s educational program and services other than those specifically enumerated in the issues presented below (occupational therapy, physical therapy, aide assistance, and technology services and assistive equipment). For this reason, the decision will deal with the issue of FAPE only as it relates to the services specifically discussed.

2. Initially, the Student had also presented as an issue the question of whether the aide assigned to STUDENT should be able to physically assist him in transitions. Before the hearing concluded, the District agreed that the aide assigned to STUDENT should be able to physically assist him in transitions. As the parties are in agreement on this point, the decision will deal only with the issue of whether the aide must be provided during all hours of the school day, which is still a matter in dispute between the parties.

3. This action was the result of a mediation agreement between the parties dated September 17, 1996.

4. Ms. Stewart is a registered “nonpublic agency” contracted by the District to provide occupational therapy to the District’s students.

5. During the 1996-97 school year, FATHER filed a complaint with the Compliance Unit of the State Department of Education (#S-348-96/97). As a result of the investigation performed by the Compliance Unit, the District had to provide STUDENT with additional sessions of OT to make up for sessions that had not been provided in accordance with the IEP.

6. Ms. Dembroff is also a registered “nonpublic agency” contracted by the District to provide occupational therapy to the District’s students.

7. Also, any report completed a year ahead of a triennial assessment will generally not be considered to be part of the triennial assessment.

8. The therapists testified that direct therapy involves working with the student one-on-one or in a small group setting, and that consultive services involve training the parents, teacher and other staff working with the student on how to carry out or maintain the child’s OT program.

9. A speech-recognition system converts what the user speaks into a microphone into a text document.