California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 10, 1998
Student v. Sequoia Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 988-97, SN 1623-97 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote
Sequoia Union High School District offered FAPE for 1997-1998; guardian denied reimbursement for Palo Alto Preparatory School.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The case was bifurcated. The student's claims against Ravenswood District became SN 988-97B, which was dismissed after a final Settlement Agreement and Release was received on June 29, 1998. The district's December 1997 request to assess was consolidated with the student's case. The parties then agreed that a district school psychologist would assess the student.
Summary
The student's guardian filed for hearing on behalf of a 16-year-old ninth grader. He was eligible for special education because of learning disabilities in reading and written expression, and he also had a central auditory processing disorder. He had received almost no special education since fourth grade in his elementary district. For ninth grade, the guardian enrolled him at Palo Alto Preparatory School, a private school, and also paid for tutoring. She sought reimbursement from Sequoia Union High School District. The district had offered three resource specialist program (RSP) periods at Menlo-Atherton High School, in English, world studies, and study skills, with general education classes for the rest of the day.
The Hearing Officer found that the August 1997 and February 1998 IEPs each contained a clear written offer, as Union School District v. Smith requires. Witnesses for both sides agreed the student needed small, structured classes, multisensory instruction, frequent feedback, and accommodations for slow processing. The Hearing Officer found the RSP classes met these needs. They had at most 15 students, a teacher and an aide, and experienced teachers. The student's own expert praised the RSP English teacher. The evidence did not show a need for speech-language therapy. Concerns about peer influences at the public school were based mainly on other children's experiences. The Hearing Officer found that a case manager, counselors, and campus programs could meet his social-emotional needs. Menlo-Atherton was also the least restrictive environment. Reimbursement was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley and the least restrictive environment rule to a resource program at a public high school. It found that a parent's general worries about a school's peer culture, based on other children's experiences, did not outweigh specific evidence that the offered program met this student's own needs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the Sequoia Union High School District offer Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998 school year?
The August 1997 and February 1998 IEPs made a clear written offer under Union v. Smith, and three RSP periods (English, world studies, study skills) at Menlo-Atherton plus general education with aide support, accommodations, and a case manager met the student's academic, auditory processing, and social-emotional needs under Rowley and was the least restrictive environment. The evidence did not show a need for speech-language therapy.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is the guardian entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with Student's enrollment at Palo Alto Preparatory School, a private high school?
Because the district offered an appropriate placement for 1997-1998, the guardian was not entitled to reimbursement for Palo Alto Prep.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- All of the student's requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Larry P. v. Riles
People named in the decision
- Kenneth N. Frucht, Attorney for Student
- John C. Beiers, Deputy county counsel for district, San Mateo County
- Joyce Willett, Coordinator of special education, Sequoia Union High School District
- Karen McGee, School psychologist, Sequoia Union High School District
- Martha Rubin, Speech-language therapist, Sequoia Union High School District
- Tony Perez, Program specialist, Sequoia Union High School District
- Mr. Ida, RSP special education teacher and proposed case manager, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Ms. Grabic, RSP English/study skills special education teacher and proposed case manager, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Dorothy Burnside, Parent involvement coordinator, Sequoia Union High School District
- Jodi Keck, Assistant director of private school, Palo Alto Preparatory School
- Peter MacDonald, World history teacher at private school, Palo Alto Preparatory School
- Judith Paton, Private audiologist, witness for Student
- Michael Shore, Ph.D., Private psychologist, expert witness for Student
- Judith Cunningham, Speech-language pathologist (assessor), Children's Health Council
- Children's Health Council, Private assessing agency
- Palo Alto Preparatory School, Private school (unilateral placement)
- Edwin Villmoare, Chief Hearing Officer (presided over January 20, 1998 session in SN 1623-97), Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Redwood City, California, on February 24, March 24, April 27, 28, and 29, and May 21, 1998.(Footnote 1) Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by Attorney Kenneth N. Frucht. Also present on behalf of STUDENTwas his guardian/grandparent, Betty White. Respondent Sequoia Union High School District (hereafter “Sequoia District”) was represented at the hearing by John C. Beiers, deputy county counsel for San Mateo County. Also present on behalf of the Sequoia District was Joyce Willett, coordinator of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
(1) Did the Sequoia Union High School District offer STUDENTa free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998 school year?
(2) Is Ms. White entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with STUDENT’s enrollment at Palo Alto Preparatory School, a private high school?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old student who will enter the tenth grade in the fall of 1998. STUDENTis eligible for special education because of learning disabilities in reading and written expression. He has a central auditory processing disorder. STUDENT’s current individualized educational plan (IEP) drafted in February 1998, includes goals and objectives to improve reading, written language, mathematics, and classroom performance/success. The IEP also includes a transition plan. STUDENThas attended Palo Alto Preparatory School (hereafter “Palo Alto Prep”), a private school, since Ms. White enrolled him there in the fall of 1997. Ms. White has also funded individual tutoring two times a week for STUDENTwhile attending Palo Alto Prep. The tutoring, which is provided by a college student, addresses reading, writing, and organizational skills.
STUDENThas lived with Ms. White since his mother’s death when he was approximately two years old. STUDENTattended elementary and junior high school in the Ravenswood District. STUDENTwas initially found eligible for special education in May of 1990, when he was in the second grade. The IEP called for STUDENTto receive resource specialist services (RSP) for “at least 2 consecutive periods of at [least] 50 min. each for up to 50% of the day as needed for learning arts academic areas. . . .” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 7.) STUDENTreceived RSP services while in the third grade. When STUDENTwas in the fourth grade, Ms. White believed that STUDENTwas not receiving RSP services to the extent called for by his IEP and removed him from special education.(Footnote 2) She continued to request that the Ravenswood District provide STUDENTwith appropriate services; however, he did not receive any further special education services from the Ravenswood District. According to Ms. White, STUDENTcontinued to experience difficulty at school with both academic achievement and behavior. She testified that STUDENTdid not complete the school year in the second, fifth, and sixth grades, and was sent home multiple times during the fifth and sixth grades. STUDENTrepeated the sixth grade. While in the eighth grade, STUDENTwas involved in several incidents of inappropriate behavior. He was suspended on one occasion for having a knife at school and on a second occasion for being in possession of an explosive, causing or attempting to cause damage to school property, and wilfully defying school authorities. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 31.)
On March 26, 1997, Mr. Frucht requested that the Ravenswood District assess STUDENTfor special education services. Ravenswood agreed to have STUDENTassessed by the Children’s Health Council (hereafter “CHC”). CHC had previously assessed STUDENTin 1990 and 1994. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 27, 34, and 35.) CHC completed an assessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement on April 29 and 30, 1997. STUDENTgraduated from the eighth grade with an “A” in science lab, a “B-” in physical education, a “C+” in science, a “C” in health, a “C-” in both language and mathematics, a “D+” in social studies, and a “D” in literature. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 32.)
On June 13, 1997, the Ravenswood District convened an IEP meeting and agreed to provide STUDENTwith tutorial services during the summer “as partial compensatory services, for 8 wks. at 2 hrs. per. day.” The team agreed to develop goals and objectives at a second meeting scheduled for July 11, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 39.) The IEP team actually reconvened on August 6, 1997. The Ravenswood District invited Ms. Willett to attend the IEP meeting on behalf of the Sequoia District. (Footnote 3) The IEP team drafted goals and objectives related to spelling, reading, and improving classroom performance. The IEP team members from the school districts recommended that for the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENTreceive three periods of RSP at Menlo-Atherton, his neighborhood high school in the Sequoia District, and that a referral to Mental Health be initiated. They also recommended that STUDENT’s placement be reviewed in 90 days. The Ravenswood District also agreed to complete a triennial assessment of STUDENTby September 7, 1997. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 41.) Ms. White did not consent to the proposed placement and enrolled STUDENTin Palo Alto Prep for the 1997-1998 school year. During the fall of 1997, while attending Palo Alto Prep, STUDENTwas found in possession of marijuana. His achievement and behavior have otherwise been acceptable and STUDENTand Ms. White consider Palo Alto Prep to be the only appropriate placement for him.
Ms. White filed for hearing against the Ravenswood District regarding the alleged failure of the Ravenswood District to provide a free appropriate public education to STUDENTfor years prior to the 1997-1998 school year. During mediation on September 4, 1997, the parties agreed that a triennial assessment would be completed by CHC and that the IEP team would meet 10 days following receipt of the assessment report to review the assessment and to plan STUDENT’s transition to the high school district (Sequoia District). (Petitioner’s Exhibit 47.) On September 5, 1997, Petitioner added the Sequoia District as a Respondent to the due process hearing. CHC completed STUDENT’s assessment in October 1997. CHC assessment included measures of intelligence, social/emotional status, and speech and language. On approximately November 26, 1997, when the Ravenswood and Sequoia Districts received the written report of CHC assessment, the Districts first became aware of the fact that CHC assessment included the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, 3rd Edition (WISC-III), a standardized measure of intelligence. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 73.) Because STUDENTis African-American, the Districts are precluded from administering or considering the results of standardized intelligence testing such as the WISC-III. (See Larry P. v. Riles (N.D. Cal. 1979) 459 F.Supp. 926, aff’d in part, rev’d in part, (9th Cir. 1986) 793 F.Supp. 969, and Memorandum of Order Denying in Part and Granting in Part Ravenswood’s Motion to Dismiss and Sequoia’s Motion to Exclude Evidence, March 26, 1998, SN 988-97.)(Footnote 4) Ms. White denied Sequoia District’s request for an additional assessment and, on December 17, 1997, the Sequoia District requested a due process hearing to obtain authorization to conduct a “culturally appropriate” assessment of STUDENT.(Footnote 5) The parties subsequently agreed that Karen McGee, a school psychologist with the Sequoia District, would complete an assessment of STUDENT. (Sequoia District’s Exhibit M.) Ms. McGee completed her assessment of STUDENTin January 1998.
On February 6 and 10, 1998, the IEP team reconvened. The team drafted goals and objectives. IEP team members from both districts continued to recommend three periods of RSP at Menlo-Atherton with the remainder of the school day in regular education classes. The proposed RSP classes included English, world studies, and study skills. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 100.) CHC representative at the meeting concurred with the proposed placement; however, Ms. White disputed the appropriateness of the recommended placement. Ms. White contends that STUDENTrequires a small, structured learning environment. She also asserts that he cannot benefit from placement in a public school because of academic and behavioral needs. She asserts that if STUDENTattends a public school, he will revert to “socially deviant behavior.” Ms. White contends that the appropriate and least restrictive placement for STUDENTis at Palo Alto Prep. The Sequoia District contends that its RSP program combined with regular education classes at Menlo-Atherton High School offers an appropriate placement for STUDENTand that the placement can provide him with appropriate instruction to address his learning disabilities. The District also asserts that RSP classes have a maximum of 15 students and that an aide would be available to reduce the student-to-teacher ratio in STUDENT’s regular education classes. The Sequoia District asserts that at Menlo-Atherton, a case manager is available to coordinate STUDENT’s program and to monitor his progress and that there are clubs and school activities in which STUDENTcan participate.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Did the Sequoia Union High School District offer STUDENTa free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1997-1998 school year?
STUDENTcontends that the Sequoia District failed to make an offer of placement that complies with the requirements of Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) F.3d 1519. In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated, “this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously.” The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents to the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement is appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services; and (3) so to establish with clarity, the school district’s offer of placement.
STUDENT’s IEP written in August 1997 specifies that the placement proposed for the 1997-1998 school year was for three periods of RSP. The offer of placement was at his neighborhood school, Menlo-Atherton High School.(Footnote 6) The Hearing Officer notes that the parties were involved in a due process disputes regarding assessment and placement and that several interim agreements were reached through mediation. One item the parties agreed upon was that they would meet at an IEP meeting following an assessment. The assessment process was not completed until February 1998. The IEP written at the IEP meeting on February 6, 1998, which was continued to February 10, 1998, also includes the offer of placement at Menlo-Atherton for three periods of RSP in the areas of English, world studies, and study skills. (District’s Exhibit H.) The evidence establishes that a written offer of placement is contained in each of the IEPs related to the 1997-1998 school year. There was no ambiguity regarding the proposed placement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Sequoia District’s offer of placement for the 1997-1998 school year satisfies the requirements of Union.
Turning to whether the offer of placement for the 1997-1998 school year was appropriate, under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student's individualized educational program. (IEP) "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).
The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.
To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, to provide the student with some educational benefit, to comport with the IEP, and must be provided in the least restrictive environment.
In order to determine whether the Sequoia District offered an appropriate placement for STUDENTfor the 1997-1998 school year, it is first necessary to have some understanding of STUDENTand his unique and individual needs. There is no dispute that STUDENTpossesses cognitive abilities that fall within age expectancies. There also is no dispute that, because of learning disabilities and the lack of specialized instruction while attending elementary and junior high school in the Ravenswood District, STUDENTis not currently functioning at expected levels of academic areas. CHC assessors found that STUDENTexhibits difficulty in processing speed and in broad language functioning. Jodi Keck, assistant director of Palo Alto Prep, testified that STUDENThas difficulty with reading comprehension, and organizing his thoughts on paper. Ms. Keck also described STUDENT’s organizational skills as “weak.” She stated that at the beginning of the school year, STUDENTdid not know how to study for a test or how to ask questions. Peter MacDonald, STUDENT’s world history teacher at Palo Alto Prep, corroborated Ms. Keck’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s deficits. Mr. MacDonald described STUDENTas a “slow” reader. He also stated that at the beginning of the school year, STUDENTdid not use complete sentences on writing assignments and had poor organizational skills. Ms. McGee, Sequoia District school psychologist, testified that her assessment of STUDENTin January 1998, identified relative areas of strength in oral expression, verbal reasoning, long-term memory, attention and concentration, and awareness of social norms and expectations. She found relative areas of weakness in short-term memory, auditory memory when materials presented were unrelated, auditory sequencing, spatial organization, perceptual-motor integration, and planning. Based on the consistent testimony of the witnesses, it is concluded that STUDENT’s primary academic deficits are in reading and written expression. STUDENTalso has poor organizational skills, and perceptual deficits, as described by Ms. McGee.
The witnesses all described STUDENTas “friendly and social”; however, a number of witnesses expressed concerns about the potential for STUDENTto engage in inappropriate or “socially deviant” behavior. Other witnesses expressed concern about STUDENT’s self-esteem. Ms. White testified that STUDENThas exhibited some oppositional and anxious behaviors. CHC assessors described STUDENTas having an “immature coping style.” Their report states that STUDENThas difficulty understanding his emotions; however, they did not find evidence of a psychological disorder and noted that STUDENTmay be struggling with “common adolescent issues.” CHC’s report includes recommendations that STUDENTbe encouraged to engage in activities to build his self-esteem. The report also states that STUDENTmay benefit from the guidance of a mentor or Big Brother. Ms. Keck echoed concerns about STUDENT’s need to improve his self-esteem. Mr. MacDonald testified that if STUDENTdoes not find a niche, he “may float together with other students who also do not have a niche which may then lead to truancy, alcohol, and/or drugs.” Ms. McGee described STUDENT’s self esteem as “somewhat tentative” and also concluded that STUDENThas difficulty accepting responsibility for his actions. To address these concerns, Ms. McGee recommended that STUDENTbe provided opportunities to become involved in leadership roles within the school environment, to engage in community service activities, to gain work experience, and to participate in sports activities. She also indicated that STUDENTcould benefit from having an adult mentor. Based on the discussion of the testimony above, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENTexperiences low self-esteem and has difficulty accepting responsibility for his actions; however, the evidence does not establish that STUDENThas more serious social or emotional needs.
All of the witnesses appearing on behalf of STUDENTtestified that he requires a low student-to-teacher ratio and a structured environment to benefit from his education. Ms. White testified that STUDENTis distractible and disruptive when engaged in activities with groups of students. Her testimony is consistent with the observations noted in educational records by STUDENT’s elementary school teachers. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 35.) CHC’s report recommends that STUDENTbe placed in a structured and protective home and school environment. Judith Paton, an audiologist in private practice who assessed STUDENTwhile the hearing was in progress, testified that because of a central processing deficit, STUDENTrequires an educational setting that allows him to interact frequently with the adults in his classroom. The testimony of one of STUDENT’s teachers at Palo Alto Prep, Mr. MacDonald, substantiated STUDENT’s ongoing need to have access to a teacher or aide for the purpose of asking questions and receiving feedback related to his work. Michael Shore, Ph.D., a psychologist in private practice, was asked to observe Menlo-Atherton and Palo Alto Prep and to review educational records on behalf of STUDENT. Dr. Shore testified that STUDENT’s central auditory processing disorder interferes with the rate and adequacy of STUDENT’s understanding and processing language. Hence, STUDENTneeds to be educated in small classes and in an environment with limited distractions. Judith Cunningham, a speech and language pathologist who assessed STUDENTas part of CHC evaluation, concurred with Ms. Paton’s and Dr. Shore’s conclusions. Martha Rubin, a licensed speech and language therapist with the Sequoia District, also recommended that the following techniques be employed to address STUDENT’s central auditory processing deficits: speak slowly; pause during speaking; have STUDENTrepeat and rephrase what he has heard; allow STUDENTtime to negotiate the meaning of what he has heard; and allow additional time for him to respond.
Ms. McGee, school psychologist for the Sequoia District, made substantially similar recommendations regarding the components of an appropriate placement for STUDENTfollowing her assessment in January 1998. (See Respondent’s Exhibit M.) Ms. McGee’s assessment included the following: a review of school records and previous assessments; interviews of STUDENT, one of his teachers, and Ms. White; an observation of STUDENTat Palo Alto Prep; an informal assessment; and administration of the Developmental Assets Checklist, the Bender Gestalt, the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (upper level), and the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development, Social-Affective Behavior (selected subtests). Ms. McGee concluded that STUDENTresponds positively in a small, structured setting where consequences are clearly defined and where he is provided with opportunities to demonstrate his areas of strength. Ms. McGee made the following recommendations during testimony and in her report of STUDENT’s assessment: provide STUDENTwith remediation techniques to compensate for learning disabilities in reading and written language; place STUDENTin classes with a low student-to-teacher ratio; provide opportunities for STUDENTto use manipulatives, including a computer and a calculator; teach STUDENTorganizational skills; provide STUDENTwith opportunities for group interaction; have high expectations for learning and provide STUDENTwith clear rules and consequences; present curriculum in small chunks using a multisensory approach; provide opportunities for STUDENTto repeat directions; make frequent checks for understanding; extend STUDENT’s time for completion of work; communicate with home; provide opportunities for career exploration; and develop a comprehensive individual transition plan. Ms. McGee also recommended that STUDENT’s teachers have an awareness of his personal and cultural learning styles. Ms. McGee and other District witnesses testified that STUDENTneeds to develop compensatory strategies to address learning disabilities in reading and written language.
The testimony provided by the witnesses regarding the components of an appropriate placement was generally consistent and, in summary, establishes that an appropriate placement for STUDENTis one that is structured and has a low student-to-teacher ratio with limited distractions. The placement must include instruction utilizing a general multisensory approach that addresses STUDENT’s deficits in reading, written language, and organizational skills and provides him compensatory strategies. The placement must also offer frequent opportunities for STUDENTto ask clarifying questions and to receive feedback from his teacher and/or aide. STUDENTmust have access to manipulatives and to a computer for written work. Additionally, an appropriate placement must include modifications that take into consideration STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits as described by Ms. McGee and Ms. Paton.
Ms. White contends that STUDENTneeds speech and language therapy. Ms. Paton, who testified on behalf of STUDENT, identified a central auditory processing deficit. She made recommendations regarding an appropriate educational environment for STUDENT; however, she did not draw any conclusions regarding his need for speech or language therapy and recommended further testing. Judith Cunningham, who conducted CHC speech and language assessment, testified regarding STUDENT’s difficulty “taking in” information, particularly when the information is presented orally. Ms. Cunningham recommended that information be provided visually to STUDENT. She did not testify that STUDENTrequires speech and language therapy to benefit from his education. The District’s speech and language pathologist, Ms. Rubin, testified that her review of speech and language assessments administered by CHC and of other records related to STUDENTdid not reveal evidence of a speech and language disorder. Ms. Rubin testified that the only speech and language measure on which STUDENTobtained a low score was a subtest entitled “reading paragraph.” She testified that the need for speech and language services cannot be based on the results of a single test. Moreover, Ms. Rubin questioned the accuracy of the way in which the test scores were reported by CHC. In fact, the CHC assessor acknowledged during testimony that the reported scores were not consistent with the test they purported to represent on the report. The above fails to establish that STUDENTrequires speech and language therapy.
It is next necessary to determine whether the placement offered by the Sequoia District is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs as determined above. The Sequoia District proposed placing STUDENTin RSP classes for English, world studies, and study skills. Ms. White testified that three periods of RSP are more than STUDENTrequires to benefit from his education. She testified that the proposed program would preclude STUDENTfrom taking Spanish or other elective classes. Ms. Willett, Ms. McGee, and Tony Perez, program specialist, testified generally regarding the District’s proposed placement. They testified that three periods of RSP are necessary to provide STUDENTwith sufficient support to ensure that he successfully transitions from either the junior high school or the nonpublic school to the larger public high school campus. They testified that three periods of RSP are also necessary to address STUDENT’s reading and written language deficits and to provide him with support for his regular education classes. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of the District persuasive on the issue of the appropriateness of the three RSP classes for STUDENT. Their testimony took into account STUDENT’s academic needs as described by the assessors. The District’s proposed placement was supported at the IEP meeting by CHC. The fact that STUDENTmay wish to take additional electives is not determinative. At this point in time, given STUDENT’s reading and written language deficits, it is important for him to develop the skills and compensatory strategies that will enable him to be successful in regular education classes. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENThas not previously received special education instruction to this end. If STUDENTapplies himself and the instruction he receives in the RSP classes is successful, STUDENTwill be able to achieve academically in regular education classes.
Mr. Ida testified that the RSP provides direct instruction in subject areas utilizing a general multisensory approach and RSP classes have a maximum of 15 students and are staffed by both a teacher and an aide. Mr. Ida’s testimony was undisputed. Therefore, the student-to-teacher ratio in the RSP classes is sufficiently low to meet STUDENT’s needs. The world study’s curriculum for ninth-grade students generally involves a lot of reading and written assignments, which given STUDENT’s reading and writing difficulties, is a subject that is appropriately addressed in an RSP environment. Either Mr. Ida or Ms. Grabic would be STUDENT’s study skills teacher. Both hold appropriate credentials, are experienced special education teachers, and are familiar with the needs of students with learning disabilities. The evidence establishes that the study skills class will provide STUDENTwith opportunities to ask questions and receive feedback from teachers, to provide him with access to a computer for written assignments, to provide him assistance with mainstream classes, and to provide him instruction in techniques to improve his organizational skills. STUDENT’s perceptual deficits can also be addressed in the study skills class. The teachers testified that STUDENTwould be taught techniques to compensate for his deficits. He would also have the opportunity to discuss his assignments with teachers and to go over any information he may have missed in his regular education classes. The witnesses also stated that STUDENTwould be allowed to take tests from his regular education classes in the study skills class where time constraints would be waived. This modification takes into consideration STUDENT’s slow processing speed.
Ms. Grabic was proposed as STUDENT’s English teacher. Prior to coming to the Sequoia District, Ms. Grabic taught at Charles Armstrong for 13 years. Charles Armstrong is a nonpublic school for students with learning disabilities. The testimony of Ms. Grabic and Ms. Perez, as well as Dr. Shore, who observed Ms. Grabic’s English class on behalf of STUDENT, establishes that there are between 10 and 12 students in the class and that the class is structured and quiet. Thus, the class meets STUDENT’s need for a low student-to-teacher ratio, appropriate structure, and a relatively distraction free environment. Ms. Grabic noted the need for a quiet environment for STUDENTand other students and noted that students must sharpen their pencils at the beginning of the class and are expected to be quiet when she is lecturing and when other students are reading. Ms. Grabic testified extensively regarding the way in which she would address STUDENT’s needs. For example, to address his poor organizational skills, Ms. Grabic would provide STUDENTwith a binder with tabs and color-coded assignments. She would go over his assignments with him on a weekly basis. Ms. Grabic testified that she would provide instruction to STUDENTthat follows the regular education curriculum; however, she would provide him with modified versions of the reading assignments. Thus, she would address his slow processing skills by allowing him additional time to complete reading assignments. To address STUDENT’s need to receive ongoing feedback and to ask questions, Ms. Grabic testified that either she or her aide would be available to help STUDENT. Other students could also take notes for him. To address spelling, Ms. Grabic would develop a list of spelling words and their definitions for STUDENT. STUDENTwould then be required to write sentences incorporating the spelling words. Ms. Grabic testified that she monitors the students’ progress weekly and provides them with a weekly grading sheet on which the students receive points for being to class on time, for being prepared with a pencil and appropriate materials, and for completing assignments. Ms. Grabic indicated that she would employ similar techniques with STUDENTto ensure that he is timely completing his assignments.
Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENTexpressed concern that the number of students in the regular education classes at Menlo-Atherton and whether STUDENTwould have sufficient opportunities to ask questions and to receive adequate feedback from his teachers. As to the size of regular education classes available to STUDENT, Ms. McGee testified that STUDENT’s area of strength is mathematics. For this reason, it is concluded that STUDENTdoes not require a small class in mathematics. Mr. Ida testified that the football coach teaches algebra and that there is an RSP aide in the class to help with the RSP students placed there. Mr. Ida also testified that the coach is available before and after class to help the students. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENTrequires a small physical education class. The testimony of District witnesses establishes that either the special education teacher or a special education associate (instructional assistant) is available to provide assistance to STUDENTin regular education classes, thereby lowering the student-to-teacher ratio and providing STUDENTwith opportunities to ask questions and receive feedback from an adult in the classroom. Moreover, the District has proposed to made additional modifications in regular education classes to address STUDENT’s perceptual deficits. Those modifications include allowing STUDENTadditional time to complete assignments, providing him with preferential seating, allowing him to tape record classes, and allowing him to complete assignments or take tests in the RSP room. The witnesses testified that STUDENT’s regular education teachers may also seat STUDENTnear a peer who will repeat directions to him or take notes for him so that he will not miss out on information that is presented orally.
The testimony of STUDENT’s witness, Dr. Shore, regarding the RSP program confirmed that his own recommendations can be met by the RSP classes at Menlo-Atherton. For example, Dr. Shore testified that the RSP English teacher, Ms. Grabic, “captured and maintained the attention and enthusiasm of the students.” Dr. Shore was so impressed with Ms. Grabic that he stated he would like to “clone” her. He described Ms. Grabic’s class as “small and structured.” Dr. Shore also observed that there was a low level of distraction in the study skills class. Based on the testimony of witnesses appearing on behalf of the District and on behalf of STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the RSP classes at Menlo-Atherton offer instruction in STUDENT’s areas of deficit, are taught by appropriately trained and experienced teachers. The classes are small and offer opportunities for STUDENTto interact with staff. The RSP teachers also testified persuasively regarding the ways in which they would make modifications to address STUDENT’s perceptual deficiencies, including slow processing speed. They also testified that they would work with STUDENT’s regular education teachers to ensure that they also make appropriate modifications for STUDENTin the regular education classes. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s unique and individual needs can be met in the combination of RSP and regular education classes at Menlo-Atherton because the student-to-teacher ratio will be sufficiently low and there will be adequate support in the RSP and regular education classes from special education personnel to ensure that STUDENT’s academic and perceptual deficits are addressed.
Witnesses testifying on behalf of STUDENT, including Ms. White, Dr. Shore, and Ms. Keck, expressed concerns that STUDENT’s social/emotional needs could not be met at Menlo-Atherton. They were particularly concerned that STUDENTwould “hang out with the wrong kids” and engage in socially inappropriate behavior because of a lack of ongoing supervision at Menlo-Atherton. Ms. White testified regarding the potential for STUDENTto revert to “socially deviant” behavior at a public high school. Ms. White’s concerns were chiefly based on the experiences of two of her other children who attended Menlo-Atherton. Ms. White testified that their attending Menlo-Atherton resulted in “two very smart children barely getting out of there.” STUDENTtestified that he has known students who did well while attending school in the Ravenswood District and who then received “D” and “F” grades at Menlo-Atherton. STUDENTtestified that while attending a summer program at Menlo-Atherton, some adults engaged in a fight and someone set off an explosive device in the hallway. STUDENTalso testified that he believes that illegal drugs are available on the Menlo-Atherton campus. Dr. Shore also expressed concern about the risk at Menlo-Atherton for STUDENTto have social or emotional problems; however, Dr. Shore did not identify any specific concerns other than the possible availability of illegal drugs or alcohol on the campus.
Witnesses testifying on behalf of the Sequoia District, including Ms. McGee and Ms. Burnside disputed allegations related to the availability of illegal drugs at Menlo-Atherton. The possible availability of drugs on this or any other high school campus or community in the United States is most unfortunate. Ms. McGee testified persuasively regarding the way at Menlo-Atherton that STUDENTwould be taught how to make good choices for himself. She also testified persuasively that STUDENTwould ultimately derive more benefit from learning these skills than attending another school to avoid the issue. Ms. McGee further testified that it cannot be assumed that the same influences are absent from Palo Alto Prep or other environments in which STUDENTfinds himself. STUDENTacknowledged that illegal drugs may be available at Palo Alto Prep and, in fact, STUDENTwas involved in an incident related to drugs when he began at Palo Alto Prep.
To ensure that STUDENTdoes not fall into socially inappropriate behavior and to address his social and emotional needs, Menlo-Atherton offers him support from RSP teachers, from a case manager, and also from school counselors. A counselor from County Mental Health is also regularly available to STUDENTand other students on the high school campus. The testimony of District witnesses establishes that the case manager assigned to STUDENTwould be responsible for coordinating, consulting, and monitoring STUDENT’s academic and behavioral progress. The case manager also interfaces with the families. Either Mr. Ida or Ms. Grabic would be assigned as STUDENT’s case manager. Both indicated that they are available to students after regular school hours and on weekends. Mr. Ida’s testimony related to his involvement with the students on his case load demonstrated a level of commitment that is extraordinary. The case manager, RSP teachers, and counselors can help guide STUDENTto avoid drugs and to maintain socially acceptable behavior. Additionally, there are numerous social, service, and parent-involvement groups at Menlo-Atherton. Ms. McGee and Dorothy Burnside, District parent involvement coordinator, described the many clubs and activities available at Menlo-Atherton to support STUDENT. (See Respondent’s Exhibit N1.) Some notable groups described by Ms. Burnside include R.I.S.E. and Target Success. R.I.S.E. is specifically designed for African-American students. The students in R.I.S.E. are provided a tutor or mentor. Parents are also invited to participate in support workshops. The goal of Target Success is to get parents involved in the education of their children. Menlo-Atherton also has a Networking group, which promotes cross-cultural interactions. The group trains students to lead discussions related to the students’ similarities and differences with other students.
As to Ms. White’s concerns about Menlo-Atherton, the evidence establishes that Ms. White principally formed her opinion regarding Menlo-Atherton on the experience of her other children who attended Menlo-Atherton some years ago. Moreover, the appropriateness of a placement for STUDENTmust be based on his individual needs and the experiences of other students is of very marginal relevance. Therefore, the testimony of STUDENTand Ms. White on this point is not persuasive. Dr. Shore’s testimony was based on a review of STUDENT’s educational records and a brief observation of the RSP classes at Menlo-Atherton. On the other hand, Ms. McGee assessed STUDENTand is quite familiar with the District’s program. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT’s social/emotional needs can be met at Menlo-Atherton.
Based on all of the discussion above regarding the ways in which STUDENT’s needs would be addressed at Menlo-Atherton, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs in academic, perceptual, and social-emotional areas.
The second requirement of an appropriate education is that it must be designed to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit. In the past, STUDENThas struggled academically and has not made academic achievement that was expected given his cognitive potential; however, STUDENThas not received specialized instruction since the fourth grade. The testimony of Ms. Grabic and other District witnesses establishes that the Sequoia District’s program will provide STUDENTwith multisensory instruction and compensatory strategies in reading and written language. The modifications proposed by the District will address STUDENT’s deficits in auditory processing and will facilitate his understanding of the material presented to him. It is reasonably anticipated that STUDENTwill apply the skills he is taught to other areas of academics and, thereby, achieve academically. The District’s program also offers sufficient support to alleviate concerns related to STUDENT’s potential to engage in socially unacceptable behavior. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed placement is designed to provide STUDENTwith educational benefit.
There is no dispute that the proposed placement conforms to the IEP. Therefore, the District’s placement satisfies the requirements of an appropriate placement as set forth in the IDEA and Rowley.
The placement must also satisfy the least restrictive environment requirements. Ms. White testified that Palo Alto Prep offers a less restrictive placement than the District’s proposed placement at Menlo-Atherton because at Palo Alto Prep, STUDENT is in classes with regular education students rather than special education students. On the other hand, Mr. MacDonald described the students at Palo Alto Prep as “second chance” students. He testified that a majority of the students are enrolled at Palo Alto Prep because they have experienced behavioral and/or disciplinary problems at other schools.
Ms. Willett testified that Menlo-Atherton offers STUDENT the least restrictive placement because it offers him opportunities to be educated with nondisabled peers and to participate in extracurricular activities at his neighborhood school. Ms. Grabic testified that it is “good” for special education students to be at a comprehensive high school because they can receive specialized instruction as well as participate in regular classes in their areas of strength where they receive instruction from teachers who are experts in their subject matter.
In this case, it is undisputed that STUDENT’s cognitive abilities and strengths in some subjects allow him to benefit from instruction in regular education classes. STUDENT has friends at Menlo-Atherton, which is his neighborhood school. There are also numerous clubs and activities in which STUDENT can participate at Menlo-Atherton. The Hearing Officer notes that one of STUDENT’s interests identified on his transition plan is to play college football. Menlo-Atherton offers him the opportunity to develop skills in a football program, whereas Palo Alto Prep is a private school and does not offer a range of activities available at a comprehensive high school. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that Menlo-Atherton offers STUDENT an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment.
ISSUE NO. 2: Is Ms. White entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with STUDENT’s enrollment at Palo Alto Preparatory School, a private high school?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) and the private placement or services are determined to be appropriate under IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
Since the Sequoia District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year, Ms. White is not entitled to reimbursement for the private placement she provides for STUDENT at Palo Alto Prep.
ORDER
The Sequoia Union High School District offered STUDENT an appropriate placement for the 1997-1998 school year. STUDENTs requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Sequoia Union High School District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: August 10, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. A hearing regarding Petitioner and the Sequoia District (SN 1623-97) convened on January 20, 1998, before Chief Hearing Officer Edwin Villmoare. At that time, the parties agreed that the Sequoia District would undertake a "culturally appropriate" assessment of STUDENT. (Petitioner's Exhibit 96A). The parties agreed to continue the pending case brought by Petitioner against the Ravenswood Elementary School District (hereinafter "Ravenswood District") and the Sequoia District regarding placement (SN 988-97). Following completion of the assessment, the hearing in SN 988-97 convened on February 24, 1998, before Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote. Prior to the taking of testimony, the parties agreed to continue the hearing to allow the Hearing Officer to consider motions to dismiss certain issues under the statute of limitations and to exclude certain proposed evidence related to cognitive testing of STUDENT. When the hearing reconvened on March 24, 1998, a tentative settlement agreement was reached between Petitioner and the Ravenswood District. (Respondent's Exhibit Q.) The case was then bifurcated into SN 988-97 (Petitioner's case against the Sequoia District) and SN 988-97B (Petitioner's case against the Ravenswood District). The case involving the Ravenswood District (SN 988-97B) was placed off calendar by agreement of the parties, pending execution of a final settlement agreement. The case involving the Sequoia District (SN 988-97) reconvened on April 27, 1998. Following receipt of a final Settlement Agreement and Release on June 29, 1998, SN 988-97B was dismissed.2. None of STUDENT's educational records that were presented as part of the evidence for this hearing indicates the extent of special education services STUDENT actually received in the third or fourth grades. 3. The Sequoia District had responsibility for STUDENT's education for the 1997-1998 school year; however, the Ravenswood District continued to work to provide for STUDENT's placement for the 1997-1998 school year.4. For the reasons discussed in Larry P. and in the Order, the results of standardized intelligence testing administered to STUDENT are not considered in this decision.5. By agreement of the parties, the District's case was consolidated with the case filed on behalf of STUDENT.6.The IEP and the testimony of Ms. Willett and Mr. Ida, which was undisputed, establishes that GRANDPARENT/GUARDIAN and her attorney were well aware of the placement offered by the Sequoia District. Ms. Willett testified that she described Menlo-Atherton's RSP at the IEP meeting in August and also spoke with Mr. Frucht on the same matter. Mr. Ida testified that prior to the beginning of the 1997-1998 school year, he spoke by telephone with GRANDPARENT/GUARDIAN on August 25, 1997, regarding the RSP at Menlo-Atherton. Mr. Ida stated that GRANDPARENT/GUARDIAN indicated to him that she did not want STUDENT to attend Menlo-Atherton and that she was enrolling him at Palo Alto Prep Mr. Ida's testimony is supported by a letter he wrote on September 11, 1997, in which he documented the phone conversation with GRANDPARENT/GUARDIAN. (District's Exhibit D40.5.)
