California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 28, 2003

Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District et al. (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 99-03 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals

San Dieguito Union High must reimburse private reading services and provide compensatory reading after dropping Lindamood-Bell in 1999.

Split decision: student prevailed on 7 of 29 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. NCCSE's prehearing motion for reconsideration of the denial of its motion to dismiss was denied. Footnote 1 limits review to claims after January 8, 1999, under the three-year statute of limitations.

Summary

The student's parents filed for due process in January 2002. San Dieguito Union High School District filed its own case in January 2003 after the parents did not consent to the 2002-2003 IEP. The two cases were combined. The student, age 19, qualified for special education under multiple disabilities, including autism and mental retardation (now called intellectual disability). The parents challenged parent participation, IEP goals, reading instruction, behavior plans, aides, related services and transition planning from January 1999 through 2002-2003.

The Hearing Officer found that the parents took full part in IEP meetings and that the goals could be used. A behavior plan was in place in 1999 and was not needed after that. Speech, occupational therapy (OT), assistive technology, aide support, the Mira Costa College transition program and the transition plans were all appropriate. Two missed weeks of extended school year services, and afternoons missed while an aide was absent, did not support a remedy.

Reading was different. In 1999, Lindamood-Bell instruction from Nancy Eggert produced some progress. The district stopped it in November 1999 without explaining why or offering another method. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE in reading from November 1999 through 2002-2003. The district must:

- reimburse the parents for private reading services from Eggert and Dr. Lynne Thrope's The Reading Room;

- fund vision and neuropsychological assessments;

- hold an IEP meeting within 21 days to set compensatory reading instruction.

All other reimbursement requests were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

Shows how SEHO handled a district that stopped a reading method that was producing documented progress, without recording why or offering another method. The Hearing Officer upheld the IEP goals and other services but found a multi-year denial of FAPE in reading. Parents were reimbursed for private tutoring, and the IEP team was left to set compensatory reading because the private provider was not shown to be state-certified.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1A. Did the District deny FAPE from January 8, 1999, through the end of the 1998-1999 school year by barring parental participation in the IEP process?

    Notices went out and the mother actively participated; there was no interference with parent participation.

  2. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP (1998-1999)?

    The goals had benchmarks and measurable objectives a trained implementer could use, and any flaw caused no lost educational opportunity.

  3. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit (1998-1999)?

    Special day class reading combined with individual Lindamood-Bell instruction met the student's needs and gave him some benefit.

  4. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP) (1998-1999)?

    A BIP was in place, as later IEPs show, even though the document was lost; its absence from the records was de minimis.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2A. Did the District deny FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year by barring parental participation in the IEP process?

    Proper notice was given, and the mother and the parents' consultant participated actively.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP (1999-2000)?

    The IEPs stated present levels, goals and measures of progress well enough to implement.

  7. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit (1999-2000)?

    The district stopped Lindamood-Bell instruction in November 1999 despite reported progress, without explaining why or considering an alternative, which denied FAPE in reading from November 1999 on.

  8. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2D. By failing to provide an appropriate BIP (1999-2000)?

    A BIP was being implemented and the student benefited from it.

  9. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3A. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by barring parental participation in the IEP process?

    The IEPs show full and active participation by the mother.

  10. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP (2000-2001)?

    The IEPs were somewhat abbreviated in places but stated present levels, goals and measures of progress well enough.

  11. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit (2000-2001)?

    Offering only special day class reading, without considering Lindamood-Bell or other strategies, did not meet the student's needs and denied FAPE in reading.

  12. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3D. By failing to provide an appropriate BIP (2000-2001)?

    No evidence showed a continuing behavior problem beyond attention span, so no BIP was needed.

  13. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 4A. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by barring parental participation in the IEP process?

    Proper notices were sent, and the mother attended meetings and stated her positions.

  14. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP (2001-2002)?

    The November 2001 and April 2002 IEPs were not deficient; the functional vocabulary and concept-word goals could be implemented.

  15. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit (2001-2002)?

    No other reading methods were considered, and Dr. Palmer's December 2001 recommendations were not shown to have been considered; FAPE was denied in reading.

  16. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 4D. By failing to provide an appropriate BIP (2001-2002)?

    No continuing behavior need was shown, so no BIP was needed.

  17. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 4E. By failing to provide a program for two weeks of the 2001-2002 ESY?

    The student lost two weeks of ESY services, but no lost educational opportunity was shown; the loss was de minimis and no remedy was warranted.

  18. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5A. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year by failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

    Incidental functional vocabulary in the transition program and computer software did not meet the student's need for continuous basic reading instruction; FAPE was denied in reading.

  19. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5B. By failing to provide a one-to-one aide?

    Classroom aides in the transition program met the student's safety and support needs; a shadow aide would undercut his independence.

  20. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 5C. By failing to provide an appropriate BIP?

    The evidence did not show a need for a BIP in 2002-2003.

  21. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5D. By failing to provide appropriate counseling services?

    No need for separate counseling was shown; the transition program addresses self-advocacy.

  22. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5E. By failing to provide sufficient speech and language and occupational therapy services?

    Based on the providers' testimony, the speech-language and OT offers were appropriate, and listing yearly totals did not mean services would be bunched together.

  23. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5F. By failing to provide sufficient assistive technology (AT) and AT services?

    The offer of twelve 30-minute AT consultation sessions, based on an unchallenged AT assessment, was appropriate.

  24. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 5G. By failing to provide an aide, causing the Student to miss afternoon instruction and services on October 14, 16, 17, and from November 7 through December 6, 2002?

    Services were missed when the aide was absent, but the effect of the missed sessions was not shown, so no remedy was ordered.

  25. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 5H. By failing to provide elective class choices for the least restrictive environment (LRE) at Mira Costa College?

    The Mira Costa College adult transition program was appropriate and in the LRE; electives were unavailable because of late entry and the private reading schedule.

  26. District prevailedTransition

    Issue 5I. By failing to provide an appropriate transition plan?

    The district prepared thoughtful individual transition plans from 1999 to 2002 and considered the mother's input.

  27. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 6. Does the Student require additional assessments in the areas of vision and neuropsychological evaluation?

    Conflicting vision results and visual-perception deficits justified a vision assessment, and an overdue neuropsychological assessment was ordered at district expense.

  28. Issue 7. Are the Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational assessments (IEE) and educational services?

    Parents were reimbursed for Lindamood-Bell (Eggert) and The Reading Room (Thrope) services. IEE reimbursement was denied because the district assessments were appropriate and no disagreement was expressed. Other services were denied.

  29. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 8. Is the Student entitled to compensatory education in reading?

    Compensatory reading was warranted, with the IEP team to set it. Prospective funding of The Reading Room was denied because it was not shown to be state-certified, and added speech-language and OT time was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team must convene within 21 calendar days of the Decision to design assessments, set compensatory reading, and set OT and speech-language levels.
  • Order to assess. Assessments of current vision, neuropsychological status, and reading skills, designed with input from the District and private providers. The District must complete them within 30 days of the IEP meeting; the neuropsychological assessment is at District expense.
  • Compensatory education. The IEP team must determine appropriate compensatory education providers and levels of reading instruction, considering the assessment results and methods that have proven effective, subject to review by at least July 31, 2004. No hours were specified.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP team must determine appropriate levels of occupational therapy and speech-language therapy, subject to review by at least July 31, 2004.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 days of receiving the parents' invoices, the District must reimburse the amounts on the Lindamood-Bell and The Reading Room invoices for services by Nancy Eggert and Dr. Lynne Thrope through the date of the Decision. No dollar amount was stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Torrie Norton, pupil personnel services director, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Bob Liang, Mandarin interpreter for parents
  • Nancy Eggert, Lindamood-Bell instructor (District consultant in 1999; privately hired by parents from 2003); witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
  • Dr. Lynne Thrope, private reading specialist; witness for Student, The Reading Room
  • Dr. Maryjane Palmer, District reading specialist and assessor (through NCCSE); witness, San Dieguito Union High School District / NCCSE
  • Dr. Paul Coyne, psychologist; parents' consultant; witness for Student
  • Lisa Krassny, speech-language pathologist; witness for District, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Vangie Birdson, school psychologist; witness for District, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Douglas Perelli, adult transition program teacher; witness for District, Mira Costa College adult transition program
  • Joy Bischke-Dodge, occupational therapist; witness for District, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Jacqueline Harrigan, student services specialist / special services director; witness for District, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Nancy Orr, special day class teacher, San Dieguito Academy
  • Bobby Groves, program specialist, San Dieguito Union High School District
  • Dr. Mary J. Baker-Ericzen, independent psychological evaluator
  • Sparks Literacy, private literacy program
  • State Diagnostic Center, transdisciplinary assessment (1993)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Encinitas, California, on May 13, 14, 15, and 16, 2003.

The Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Benjamin Y. Kim. Also present on behalf of the Student were his mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner San Dieguito Union High School District (District) and Respondent San Diego North Coastal Consortium for Special Education (NCCSE) were represented at the hearing by attorney Lauri A. LaFoe. Also present for a portion of the hearing on behalf of the District was pupil personnel services director Torrie Norton. Mandarin interpreter Bob Liang was present to assist STUDENT’s parents as needed.

The Student called as witnesses Lindamood-Bell instructor Nancy Eggert, reading specialists Dr. Lynne Thrope and Dr. Maryjane Palmer, his mother, psychologist Dr. Paul Coyne, and himself. The District called speech and language pathologist Lisa Krassny, school psychologist Vangie Birdson, teacher Douglas Perelli, occupational therapist Joy Bischke-Dodge, and student services specialist Jacqueline Harrigan.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for oral argument by telephone conference on May 20, 2003. After the oral argument, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District deny the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 8, 1999, through the end of the 1998-1999 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

2. Did the District deny the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

3. Did the District deny the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

4. Did the District deny the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, and extended school year (ESY)?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

E. By failing to provide a program for two weeks of the 2001-2002 ESY?

5. Did the District deny the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year?

A. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

B. By failing to provide a one-to-one aide?

C. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

D. By failing to provide appropriate counseling services?

E. By failing to provide sufficient speech and language and occupational therapy services?

F. By failing to provide sufficient assistive technology (AT) and AT services?

G. By failing to provide an aide, which caused the Student to miss afternoon instruction and services on October 14, 16, 17, and from November 7 through December 6, 2002?

H. By failing to provide elective class choices for the least restrictive environment (LRE) at Mira Costa College?

I.. By failing to provide an appropriate transition plan?

6. Does the Student require additional assessments in the areas of vision and neuropsychological evaluation?

7. Are the Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational assessments (IEE) and educational services?

8. Is the Student entitled to compensatory education in reading?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

NCCSE made a prehearing motion for reconsideration of the denial of its earlier motion to be dismissed on the ground that it never provided services directly to the Student. The same motion on essentially the same ground was made through NCCSE’s prior counsel on February 11, 2003. The Hearing Office denied the motion on February 28, 2003, as the documentation established that NCCSE was involved to some extent in decisions involving STUDENT’s educational program. As no new information or law was presented in support of the prehearing motion for reconsideration, the motion was denied.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a resident of the District who qualifies for special education and services because of multiple disabilities including autism and mental retardation. He is generally in good health but suffers from asthma and allergies. He will turn twenty on July 31, 2003. Although STUDENT is past the age of majority, his parents serve as STUDENT’s conservators in a judicially created conservatorship with powers to proceed in this due process hearing on his behalf. STUDENT enrolled in the adult transition program at Mira Costa College in April 2003. He was in a special day class at the District’s San Dieguito Academy until transferring to the transition program. He has been in District programs since the 1995-1996 school year and is well known to District personnel, who universally describe him as “happy,” “friendly,” and “well-groomed.”

The Student brought his due process request on January 8, 2002, raising issues of the appropriateness of the District’s reading programs and questioning the procedure and implementation of the IEPs. On January 23, 2003, the District requested a due process hearing because of parental failure to consent to the Student’s IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. The matters were consolidated and heard in May 2003. Although the Student raises a number of issues claiming a denial of FAPE including the content of the IEPs, the provision for a BIP, the provision of aides, and the level of services over portions of five academic years, the primary focus is on the reading program.

In early childhood, STUDENT was diagnosed on the autism spectrum. At that time, he also received diagnoses of moderate mental retardation, attention deficit disorder (ADD), and developmental delays in language and social interaction as a result of his disabilities. The record includes assessments of his cognitive ability from early childhood through the present. These assessments have tended to find his composite IQ to be in the 40 to mid-50 range. He has been qualified for special education and services since he was in kindergarten. In 1993 when STUDENT was ten years old, the State Diagnostic Center conducted a transdisciplinary assessment. At that time, STUDENT’s overall developmental level of functioning, cognitive skills, and motor skills was approximately at an age equivalence of four years. He demonstrated poor attention to task, impulsivity, and noncompliant behavior. When STUDENT was five years of age, his doctors prescribed a series of medications to combat the hyperactivity. As of 1993 he was taking Ritalin, which appeared to have some positive effect. He currently is not taking any medication for hyperactivity.

During the medical portion of the 1993 assessment, his eyesight was found to be 20/20 in both eyes for distance and 20/30 for near vision. STUDENT’s needs as determined by this assessment included a highly structured, supportive educational environment with predictable routines to develop critical skills and accommodate STUDENT’s behavioral and learning style. Community safety also received major attention in the recommendations at that time. The report concluded that “it is likely that it will always be the responsibility of an adult to be certain that he is able to move about safely in the community.”

At the completion of his triennial assessment in February and March 1999, when STUDENT was fifteen, an individualized transition plan was prepared to develop STUDENT’s vocational skills. STUDENT’s mother requested at the time that the proposed community involvement activities that were part of this transition plan be postponed in favor of an academic emphasis. His mother also requested additional assessments in the areas of speech and language and levels of functioning, which the District agreed to perform. In reading, STUDENT was unable to concentrate long enough to complete a formal assessment. The IEP team agreed that trying a Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Lindamood-Bell) program should be an option. STUDENT’s educational placement in 1999 was a special day class at the District’s San Dieguito Academy with speech and language and occupational therapy services. The District did provide Lindamood-Bell reading instruction on an individualized basis in his special day class for several months in 1999. STUDENT’s goals and objectives continued to stress money, basic reading, social communication, and gross and fine motor skills. All of these areas of need reflected STUDENT’s developmental delays and limited progress toward the goals over time.

At his mother’s request, the IEP team reconvened in May 1999 to review progress in speech, reading, occupational therapy, and money and time skills. The team emphasized moving STUDENT toward greater independence with concentration on practical life skills applications such as using money and telling time. In November 1999 the team observed that STUDENT avoided required academic work and lapsed into stereotypical perseveration behaviors. He still showed deficits in money and time telling skills. Strategies in his behavioral intervention plan (BIP) were being followed to curb obsessive behaviors, distractability, and self-focusing that impeded his ability to follow directions. Also in November 1999 STUDENT received additional aide support specifically for adapted physical education, occupational therapy, and computer skills.

In July 2000 the District agreed to MOTHER’s request for a full-time school aide during the next year, 2000-2001. At STUDENT’s annual review in October 2000, he showed progress in personal data response, quantitative concepts, and word recognition. His time and money skills were at the kindergarten level, whereas his reading and arithmetic skills were at the early first grade level. Although he could read basic stories at the primer level, he still had comprehension difficulties. STUDENT was doing “B” work in his elective cooking class and was working on the computer with mixed results. The District agreed to provide STUDENT the “Write Out Loud” software program to assist in language development. The team also discussed availability of the “Ed Mark” reading program software. This was not provided. By January 2001 STUDENT was using the “Write Out Loud” and “Looking For Words” programs furnished by the District. The District authorized the purchase of other reading programs if appropriate after the assistive technology consultant conferred with the special day class teacher.

The April 16 and 29, 2002 IEPs included several recommendations and service offers for the upcoming school year to which the PARENTSs initially did not assent. STUDENT’s parents later supplied an addendum entitled “dissent” that agreed to much of the IEP. This dissent, forwarded to the District through prior counsel in August 2002, accepted the services offered in the April 2002 IEPs but specifically objected to the frequency and duration of some of these services, arguing for more time and other variations. The IEP team learned from MOTHER at the October 2002 IEP meeting that she had unilaterally placed STUDENT in a private reading program for five hours a week and that STUDENT would not be in school during that time. STUDENT remained in a District special day class on the general education campus of San Dieguito Academy until the spring of 2003. In April 2003 he enrolled in an “everyday living” class at Mira Costa College that focused on community activities and practical skills such as using public transportation and purchasing items at stores and food in restaurants.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Did the District deny to the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 8, 1999, through the end of the 1998-1999 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

The District is obligated to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to meet his unique needs under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.)

This free and appropriate education includes special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) State law provides for similar services. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z).)

The standard by which the District’s instruction and services is measured is set forth in the 1982 United States Supreme Court case Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-200. Under this standard the District’s program must meet STUDENT’s unique needs, provide him some educational benefit, and conform to his IEP.

Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) placing the student to the maximum extent appropriate with normally developing peers. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.)

In addition to education in the least restrictive environment, the IEP is to prepare the pupil for employment and independent living including vocational training, supported employment, economic self-sufficiency and community participation. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(c) (1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1)

The United States Supreme Court in its Rowley decision does not require the District to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes his abilities. STUDENT is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet his unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”

The student’s academic progress must also be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his disability and must be gauged in relation to the student’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

The legal authorities discussed require a four-part analysis to see if the District’s program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit, conforms to his IEP, and provides STUDENT the least restrictive environment.

In addition, The Supreme Court has recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Rowley, at 205.) Therefore, a twofold inquiry is required in IDEA cases. The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. The second question is whether the IEP developed through the procedures set forth in the IDEA is reasonably calculated to enable the student to receive an educational benefit. (Rowley, at 206-207.)

The District bears the burden of proving that its program provided a FAPE to STUDENT. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No, 3, 35 F.3d 1396,1398 (9th Cir. 1994).)

Procedural appropriateness

Did the District bar parental participation in the IEP process?

Parent involvement in the IEP process is more that a mere formality. It is a vital aspect of the process. The IDEA at 20 U.S.C. section 1415(b)(1) confers on parents the right “to participate in meetings with respect to the identification, evaluation, and educational placement of the child, and the provision of a free appropriate public education.” The importance of these procedural safeguards “cannot be gainsaid.” Parents are to have a “large measure of participation” at every step. Rowley, at 205-206. The case law and statutory mandate for parental involvement is to ensure that the interests of the child are protected. Every procedural misstep, however, does not necessarily result in a denial of FAPE. The procedural violations must cause serious infringement of the parent’s opportunity to participate on the IEP team or loss of educational opportunity to the pupil. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 , 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992) .

The Student claims that his parents were not permitted to participate fully in the IEP process. As to parent participation, the evidence shows that regular notices went out for all of the IEP meetings in evidence (District Exhibits 21 through 36). Moreover, active parental participation as part of the team is evident throughout the IEPs. Frequent entries in the IEP notes document District action in direct response to MOTHER’s requests or suggestions. During the portion of the 1998-1999 school year at issue, the February 22, 1999 IEP team meeting (District Exhibit 20) documents active participation by MOTHER. The District noted and assented to the request of MOTHER at this session to conduct further speech and language assessments. This IEP reflects input from MOTHER on the content of goals and objectives and emphasis on academics. MOTHER testified that meetings were often continued because of the unavailability of District personnel or the lack of prepared goals and objectives that were needed to complete the meeting. The notes of the IEP meetings, however, reflect that many of the IEP team meetings, other than annual or triennial sessions, were held at MOTHER’s request.

MOTHER, who is not a native English speaker, testified that she did not understand some of the programs or services discussed at the IEP team meetings. MOTHER testified that she did not have knowledge of details or understanding of present levels of STUDENT’s performance at the IEP meetings. Nevertheless, her active participation in IEP meetings, often with her own prepared, written points for consideration, her extensive correspondence to the District, her seeking of independent educational evaluations, her unilateral placing of STUDENT for services, and her demonstrated ability to seek counsel or educational professionals for advice or attend IEP meetings with her, establish that she was actively and effectively advocating STUDENT’s interests and was fully capable of asking questions or even obtaining second opinions from sources inside or outside the District. Her avid involvement epitomized one of the fundamental reasons why parent participation was included by Congress in the IDEA. As observed by Chief Justice William Rehnquist in Rowley, at 209: “[P]arents and guardians will not lack ardor in seeking to ensure that handicapped children receive all of the benefits to which they are entitled by the Act.” MOTHER admirably has shown that “ardor” in pursuit of the benefits to which STUDENT is entitled. This was reflected in the IEPs dated February 22, 1999 (District Exhibit 20), March 9, 1999 (District Exhibit 19), and May 18, 1999 (District Exhibit 18). Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that there was no interference with effective parent participation in the IEP process from January 8, 1999, through the end of the 1998-1999 school year.

Substantive Appropriateness

The Student contends that for the relevant period from January to June 1999 his program goals and objectives in reading and language were unuseable; the reading program was not intensive enough; and there was no BIP. His educational needs arising from autism, mental retardation, attention and behavior deficiencies, and developmental delays must be identified. As of January 1999, he exhibited severe delays in reading and other basic skills. In the District’s reading program he had not progressed much beyond the “reading readiness” level. The Student’s primary academic focus for this year is his reading.

What were STUDENT’s unique needs?

The parties are in agreement that because of the developmental delays caused by his disabilities, in January 1999 STUDENT needed structured, small-group instruction to develop his basic reading, mathematical, and social skills in a manner that accommodated his behavioral and learning style to work toward functional living. He required teaching methods that accommodated his cognitive limitations, short attention span, behaviors that resulted in task avoidance, and need for constant repetition and reinforcement to reduce regression that witnesses both for the Student and the District referred to as a need for “overteaching” and “overlearning.” This expression of his needs has remained constant throughout his time in the District. His mother also testified that his needs have changed very little.

In determining whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, the Hearing Officer first turns to the Student’s contentions with respect to the February 1999 IEP. The Student contends that this IEP does not include useable goals or an intensive enough reading program. Specifically, he alleges that as a general rule the IEPs lack objective terms. This, he states, prevents effective implementation. He characterizes these IEPs as lacking statements of present levels of performance, lacking benchmarks and measurable goals, and lacking unambiguous specificity as to duration and frequency for designated instruction and services (DIS).

Was the IEP designed to meet the Student’s needs?

The IEP setting forth the special education program must contain, inter alia, present levels of the pupil’s educational performance, measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, directed toward “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability;” and the specific special educational instruction and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.)

Reading consultant Dr. Lynne Thrope stated that all of STUDENT’s IEPs lacked sufficient guidance to permit implementation of his reading program. She stated that the IEPs generally lacked benchmarks, understandable measurements of progress, and instructional strategies. As to the relevant portion of the 1998-1999 school year, she described the reading readiness section of the March 9, 1999 goals and objectives (District Exhibit 19) as unuseable by a reading teacher and said that she could not determine the baseline data. She questioned the reading readiness goals which were to identify the correct sounds of “fifty simple syllables,” to identify “25 consonant symbols and 23 vowel symbols” and then to produce the associated sounds at eighty percent accuracy per teacher-generated assessments. She found these goals “incomplete” or “inaccurate” or unuseable by a teacher or an aide.

District speech and language pathologist Lisa Krassny authored some of the challenged goals and objectives after the 1998-1999 school year and attended IEP meetings during the one and one half years up to the present that she was providing services to STUDENT. Ms. Krassny testified that as a matter of practice in her experience some of the specifics not appearing in the written IEP were regularly raised at the meetings or well known to the author of the objectives, who would also be the implementer. Ms. Krassny persuasively explained that the stated goals and benchmark objectives provided enough for a trained implementer to proceed. The reading readiness goals include a benchmark and measurable objectives. The baselines, for example, “Word recognition: Brigance preprimer,” tells the teacher, aide, or parent that STUDENT is developmentally delayed and needs very basic instruction. These goals and objectives, because of their very nature as fundamental skills, are simple, straightforward, and understandable.

Not only was Ms. Krassny’s testimony persuasive in this regard, the Hearing Officer finds that the parent fully participated in STUDENT’s education. The evidence indicates the MOTHER over the years has made great efforts at home to work with STUDENT and reinforce what he was learning in school. The PARENTSs could have worked on these goals without the need of any technical or specialized knowledge. Therefore, the IEP was understandable to the parents as demonstrated by their participation in implementation. Under W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, supra, at 1484, even if the IEPs were flawed in their content, such inadequacies must result in the loss of educational opportunity. There is no evidence that the contended shortcomings led to a loss of opportunity to work on the identified academic areas to address STUDENT’s needs. The fact that the Student is severely delayed and has made only slight progress during his time in the District cannot be attributed to the goals. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that STUDENT’s IEPs are sufficient through the end of the 1998-1999 school year.

Was the reading program appropriate?

In January 1999, the District continued to offer STUDENT reading instruction from teacher Nancy Orr in her special day class at the District’s San Dieguito Academy. In discussing the informal assessment of STUDENT’s reading levels, the IEP team at its February 22, 1999 meeting (District Exhibit 20) determined that Lindamood-Bell instruction “may benefit” STUDENT “over time.” This IEP also described the offered reading program to be twenty minutes per day “on a consistent basis” with a reading specialist to work with the teacher and aide. Reading consultant Nancy Eggert was hired by the District to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction shortly afterward. She worked with STUDENT separately in his classroom implementing Lindamood-Bell strategies for two hours a week in addition to Mrs. Orr’s reading program.

Ms. Eggert testified that when she first met STUDENT, he was “severely delayed.” As noted above, due to STUDENT’s disabilities, he had not advanced in the District reading programs much beyond the “reading readiness” stage from the time that he entered the District. The March 9, 1999 IEP (District Exhibit 19) shows STUDENT’s present levels of performance due to his considerable deficits in reading readiness at that time to be in the kindergarten range although the academic assessment referenced in the notes placed him at the first grade level for reading and spelling. After working with STUDENT for several months, Ms. Eggert noted in a written report to the IEP team in November 1999 that STUDENT “was beginning to learn” with the multi-sensory Lindamood-Bell approach. The Hearing Officer finds that during this period the District reading program was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs with the combination of the special day class program and the Lindamood-Bell tutoring that provided small group and individual instruction with a multi-sensory, repetitive approach that addressed STUDENT’s attention and cognitive deficits.

Was the reading program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?

The Hearing Officer finds that this program was also reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit and, based on the evidence, did so.

Did the reading program conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

The evidence shows that the District did implement a reading program in Ms. Orr’s special day class for STUDENT in reading from January 8, 1999, through the end of that school year. Ms. Nancy Eggert also came into the special day classroom to work individually with STUDENT in the Lindamood-Bell methodologies. This was consistent with the February 1999 IEP covering this time period.

Did the reading program provide education in the least restrictive environment?

For the period from January through June, the parties did not raise the issue of least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer does note, however, that the general campus placement gave STUDENT opportunities for interaction with normally developing peers between classes, at lunch, and in elective classes, while addressing his needs for small group and individual instruction in the special day class.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided to STUDENT an appropriate reading program from January 8, 1999, through the end of that school year in the San Dieguito Academy special day class with the offered program with the individualized services implementing the Lindamood-Bell strategies.

Was there a failure to provide a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

A behavioral intervention plan is “a written document” that “shall become part of the IEP. The plan shall describe the frequency of the consultation to be provided by the behavioral intervention case manager to the staff members and parents who are responsible for implementing the plan.” (Title 5, CCR § 3001(f).) The Student contends that there never was a BIP. There is no copy of a BIP in evidence. There are several references to a BIP in the record after the January to June 1999 period, but the plan or plans, themselves, are not included. There is no specific reference to a BIP in the IEPs in evidence for the 1998-1999 school year. There was a reference in the October 21, 1999 IEP (District Exhibit 17) that states, “Strategies outlined in his BIP are being followed. Obsessive behavior, distractability, self-focus impedes his ability to follow directions.” In the motor development section of this IEP it is noted that, “His behavior has improved and he is using socially appropriate comments to greet people.” The implication from earlier assessments and from the reference to an implemented BIP in October 1999 is that the behavior issues were an ongoing concern and were addressed in prior years including the 1998-1999 school year. The last IEP in the record for the 1998-1999 school year, District Exhibit 18 dated in May, sets the next meeting for October 1999 “to review assessments and write new goals as appropriate.” There is, however, no reference to STUDENT’s behavior in the IEPs in evidence for the relevant portion of the 1998-1999 school year. The fact the October 1999 IEP refers to an ongoing BIP suggests that the BIP was necessary and in place from January to June 1999 by virtue of the noted improvement in the October 1999 IEP. The Hearing Officer finds that the District had a BIP in place for the relevant period although the document is lost. The absence of the BIP from STUDENT’s educational records in this context is de minimis.

1998-1999 School Year

The Hearing Officer finds that the District has met its burden of proof that it did offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year.

Issue Number 2: Did the District deny to the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

The Student raises the same challenges to the 1999-2000 school year as he does to the portion of the prior school year at issue.

Procedural appropriateness

Did the District bar parental participation in the IEP process?

IEP meetings were the subject of proper notice during the 1999-2000 school year as shown in District Exhibits 30, 31, and 32. STUDENT’s parents continued to have ample opportunity to contribute and participate for this school year in the same manner as noted in the section concerning the 1998-1999 school year, above. The IEPs for this school year (District Exhibits 14, 15, 16, and 17) continue to show active participation by MOTHER. The November 5, 1999 IEP (District Exhibit 16) also shows that psychologist Dr. Paul Coyne, the PARENTS’ consultant, attended and participated. The Hearing Officer finds that there were no procedural violations in the IEP process with respect to parent participation for the 1999-2000 school year.

Substantive appropriateness

The evidence shows that STUDENT’s needs for small group or individualized instruction with emphasis on repetition and on practical living skills remained constant into the 1999-2000 school year. He contends, as he did in the previous school year, that the IEPs were unuseable with respect to benchmarks, and goals and objectives, that the reading program was not appropriate, and that there was no BIP.

Were the present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP appropriate to meet the Student’s needs?

Dr. Thrope termed the October 21, 1999 goals and objectives (District Exhibit 17) as “deficient” and “incomplete.” She stated that there were no listed present levels of performance or objective baselines. She dismissed these entries as “opinions” rendering them useless for implementation. She said “facts” and not “opinions” are needed to formulate a lesson plan to teach from this IEP although if she were called upon to implement the IEP she “could make a guess” as to what the goals and objectives called for. District speech and language therapist Krassny observed that trained professionals would be able to make use of these goals and objectives in October 1999 IEP. As with the prior year, the skill level is so basic, that the parents can implement and reinforce such objectives in this IEP as “STUDENT will identify 25 consonants.” STUDENT’s present levels indicated for reading readiness in 1999 were recorded as “30% accuracy” and “40% accuracy at K-level,” and “Below preprimer” in relation to four benchmarks. The benchmarks include “STUDENT will, at 60% accuracy when shown 24 pictures that depict contrasting directional and positional concepts (over/under) (far/near) (light/heavy; thick/thin) demonstrate understanding of the concepts by responding correctly receptively (by pointing) and expressively by speaking.” The District witnesses convincingly stated that this is sufficient to proceed to develop lessons and implement the IEP. With little in the way of materials, the parents also could implement the goals and objectives for these very basic tasks. The Hearing Officer finds that the 1999-2000 school year IEPs sufficiently stated present levels, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in reading.

Was the reading program appropriate?

At the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, the District continued to offer the same reading program referenced in the February 1999 IEP– a combination of reading instruction in the special day class at San Dieguito Academy and Lindamood-Bell individualized instruction. As determined above, this combined program worked toward advancing STUDENT’s reading skills. The program was designed to meet his unique learning style need for constant repetition and reinforcement. Within a few months after introduction of the Lindamood-Bell strategies into the program, STUDENT began to show progress.

The IEP team considered STUDENT’s reading program at its November 5, 1999 meeting. Ms. Eggert, who provided the District’s Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT, prepared a report (Student Exhibit 7) of STUDENT’s progress for the IEP team recommending continued Lindamood-Bell instruction using a multi-sensory approach that had shown some success. She advocated working on his visual motor skills and his behavior to allow him to keep the focus on his work. The November 1999 IEP (District Exhibit 16) acknowledges the report and notes, “Assessment shows some slow progress.” The IEP team, however, did not continue to offer the Lindamood-Bell instruction. Although Ms. Eggert continued as a Lindamood-Bell consultant for the District, the District stopped her work with STUDENT. This IEP and the ones following in evidence do not document this decision, reasons for this decision, or the termination date of the Lindamood-Bell services. The November 1999 IEP does not indicate any other methodology was considered to meet STUDENT’s needs in reading, especially for overteaching and overlearning.

The evidence shows that the combination of the special day class reading program and the Lindamood-Bell approach met STUDENT’s needs as a severely delayed reader. The addition of the Lindamood-Bell strategies, however, allowed STUDENT to advance incrementally. This is significant for a student who showed only slow progress from prekindergarten to preprimer over a period of six years. For STUDENT, with his need for functional living skills, reading is a vital element of his success. District reading specialist Dr. Maryjane Palmer testified that she found that STUDENT is capable of learning to read. The Lindamood-Bell program had the reasonable potential of continuing to help STUDENT in this severely delayed area. It met some of STUDENT’s unique learning style needs whereas other strategies apparently had not. Ms. Eggert indicated that the District deemed the progress “inadequate” after several months of two hours per week. Other than mentioning Ms. Eggert’s report in the November 1999 IEP, there is no showing in the evidence if the progress Ms. Eggert reported was evaluated or considered beyond finding it “inadequate.” There is District testimony also that the Lindamood-Bell program in 1999 did not provide adequate progress, however, the District did not provide further explanation. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s reading program failed to meet STUDENT’s needs and was not calculated to provide a benefit after November 1999.

Was there a failure to provide a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

As outlined above, the evidence reflects a BIP was in place in the fall of 1999. According to the October 1999 IEP, “Strategies outlined in his BIP are being followed. Obsessive behaviors, distractability, self focus impedes his ability to follow directions.” (District Exhibit 17). The Student contended, as discussed previously, that there was no BIP. As indicated above, however, the evidence establishes that a BIP was being implemented during this school year and STUDENT was receiving a benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT an appropriate behavioral intervention plan for the 1999-2000 school year.

1999-2000 School Year

The Hearing Officer finds that because of the reading program, as discussed above, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in reading from November 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year.

Issue Number 3: Did the District deny to the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

The Student continues to challenge the District’s program for the 2000-2001 school year on the same grounds as the previous two years.

Procedural appropriateness

Did the District bar parental participation in the IEP process?

During the 2000-2001 school year, the same pattern of notice continued as mentioned above (District Exhibits 29, 30). The IEPs for this year (District Exhibits 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12) continued to show full and active participation by MOTHER. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that there were no procedural violations in the IEP process for the 2000-2001 school year that barred parental participation.

Substantive appropriateness

The evidence shows that STUDENT’s needs remained the same for the 2000-2001 school year. He challenges, as he did in the previous school year, that the IEPs were deficient with respect to benchmarks, and goals and objectives, that the reading program was not appropriate, and that there was no BIP.

Were the present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP appropriate to meet the Student’s needs?

For the 2000-2001 school year, the District continued to offer reading instruction in the special day class setting. Dr. Thrope critiqued a portion of the October 25, 2000 goals and objectives (District Exhibit 11) which required STUDENT correctly to “state the sequence for selected recipes and events” with eighty percent accuracy by June 1. Dr. Thrope stated that this did not set a baseline or a current level of performance. Dr. Thrope also stated that there was a discrepancy between the baseline for the reading readiness goal that references “Brigance Diagnostic: Oral Reading Pre-primer” and the following benchmark/short-term objective measuring performance reading “a Fry-referenced story with a primer textbook-criterioned vocabulary of 33 words.” With regard to the speech and language goals in the October 2000 IEP (District Exhibit 11) “To improve expressive language skills for daily living,” Ms. Krassny said that this is not objectively measured. She pointed out, however, that the benchmark showing a desired performance level of eighty percent accuracy by March 1 was objectively measurable by teacher observation. Although the following goal “To improve pragmatics skills for daily living” is without a defined baseline, she stated that a trained professional would be able to clarify and work toward the benchmark. The June 6, 2000 objectives in District Exhibit 14 “To improve social language skills and maintain a conversation” is not difficult for a trained speech pathologist to measure, Ms. Krassny stated. The baseline, “Difficulty initiating, maintaining, and ending a conversation” without a defined present level, demonstrates, however, the extent to which STUDENT is delayed in his language skills. It also demonstrates that STUDENT’s parents can follow these goals and reinforce work in these basic areas. The Hearing Officer finds that the 2000-2001 school year IEPs, although somewhat abbreviated in places, sufficiently stated present levels, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress.

Was the reading program appropriate?

As discussed above, after November 1999 the District reading program omitted strategies that had helped STUDENT to progress. The multi-sensory Lindamood-Bell program from February to November 1999 showed some success with STUDENT after only a few months. This program clearly met some of STUDENT’s unique needs. The District did not consider Lindamood-Bell or any strategies other than the reading instruction that he was receiving in the special day class to meet STUDENT’s demonstrated needs and to provide to him a benefit. The IEPs for the 2000-2001 school year continued with the offer of the same reading program in the special day class. The October 20, 2000 IEP (District Exhibit 11) documents his oral reading and comprehension still to be at preprimer level. Although the October 2000 IEP does report some limited progress (word recognition moved from preprimer to early kindergarten), reading does not appear to be a priority. The Hearing Officer finds that for the school year 2000-2001 the District did not provide to STUDENT a reading program that was designed to meet his needs or calculated to provide benefit and thus denied him a FAPE with respect to reading.

Was there a failure to provide a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

After the statement in the November 1999 IEP that an implemented BIP was positively affecting STUDENT’s behavior, the subsequent IEPs and the testimony of teachers and service providers do not raise any issues of excessive self-stimulation or any other particular behaviors previously noted in past years as a current concern beyond accommodating STUDENT’s short attention span. The Student contends that a BIP was necessary for this school year. There is no evidence in the record that STUDENT’s unique needs included addressing a continuing behavioral problem after 1999 that impeded academic progress other than working within the limits of his attention span and focus. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that no behavioral intervention plan was necessary for the 2000-2001 school year.

2000-2001 School Year

The Hearing Officer finds that because of the reading program, as discussed above, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in reading for the 2000-2001 school year.

Issue Number 4: Did the District deny to the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2001-2002 school year, and extended school year (ESY)?

A. By barring parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process?

B. By failing to provide appropriate present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP?

C. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

D. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

E. By failing to provide a program for two weeks of the 2001- 2002 ESY?

The Student makes the same contentions concerning the 2001-2002 school year as with the prior school years. He additionally challenges the program for the 2001-2002 ESY.

Procedural appropriateness

Did the District bar parental participation in the IEP process?

Proper notices went out for IEP meetings during the 2001-2002 school year (District Exhibits 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27). The evidence shows that MOTHER continued to attend the meetings and expressed her positions (District Exhibits 2, 3, 4, and 5. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that, consistent with the prior years, for the 2001-2002 school year parental participation was not barred.

Substantive appropriateness

The evidence shows that STUDENT’s needs did not change for the 2001-2002 school year. He again challenges for this year the usability of the goals and objectives in the IEPs, the reading program, and the lack of a BIP.

Were the present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and measurement of progress in the IEP appropriate to meet the Student’s needs?

The November 2, 2001 IEP (District Exhibit 4) goal for STUDENT to learn one hundred vocabulary words “Commonly found in community/campus settings on schedules, menus, maps, etc.” was “unrealistic” according to Dr. Thrope. She said there is no reasonable designation of the words for the teacher to use, means of measurement, and no prior goals leading up to this goal. The record, however, places this goal in the context of developing transition goals for STUDENT. In fact the baseline section of the November 2001 IEP refers to “new program,” and “new words.” The clear intent of these “real world” benchmarks could be implemented by professionals and parents alike. According to Ms. Krassny, the term “concept words” in the April 29, 2002 IEP (Footnote 2), District Exhibit 2, refers to a fifty-word list familiar to speech and language pathologists. This list was attached to the IEP and is in evidence. The Hearing Officer finds that the November 2001 and the April 2002 IEPs for the 2001-2002 were not deficient.

Was the reading program appropriate?

As discussed above, after November 1999 the District reading program consisted of lessons in the special day class supplemented with some computer programs. The record reflects that no other methodologies were considered. The offer of a reading program for the 2001-2002 school year still had STUDENT in the special day class. Moreover, District reading specialist Dr. Maryjane Palmer, through NCSSE, assessed STUDENT in December 2001 (District Exhibit 42). She found STUDENT to have significant weaknesses in word attack skills, reading in phrasing, and comprehension. She made recommendations to implement a program emphasizing sight words, vocabulary building, reinforcement of a functional reading program with specified resources, and regular practice in these areas. The record does not indicate whether these recommendations were considered. The Hearing Officer finds that for the school year 2001-2002 the District did not provide to STUDENT an appropriate reading program and thus denied him a FAPE.

Was there a failure to provide a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

As discussed above concerning the prior school years, there is no evidence establishing a need to meet a continuing behavioral problem after 1999 that impeded academic progress other than working within the limits of his attention span and focus. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that no behavioral intervention plan was necessary for the 2001-2002 school year.

Were two weeks of the ESY missed because the District failed to provide a program?

In June 2002 MOTHER contacted the District about an ESY program for the 2001-2002 school year. The evidence shows that District program specialist Bobby Groves contacted MOTHER about a summer program. MOTHER was seeking a community-based program to enhance functional and independent living skills. She also was seeking continuing speech and language, occupational therapy, and adapted physical education services. MOTHER testified that she left telephone messages that were unreturned. Consequently, STUDENT lost two weeks of instruction and services during ESY 2001-2002 to which he was entitled. The record, however, does not contain any evidence establishing what STUDENT did receive during the balance of the ESY, what services were missed, or what services may have been made up. There is no persuasive evidence that the delay in services resulted in the loss of educational opportunity. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that this missed two weeks of instruction two years ago is de minimis and there is no basis for a remedy.

2001-2002 School Year

The Hearing Officer finds that because of the reading program, as discussed above, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in reading for the 2001-2002 school year.

Issue Number 5: Did the District deny to the Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 school year?

A. By failing to provide a reading program designed to meet identified needs and calculated to provide a benefit?

B. By failing to provide a one-to-one aide?

C. By failing to provide an appropriate behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

D. By failing to provide appropriate counseling services?

E. By failing to provide sufficient speech and language and occupational therapy services?

F. By failing to provide sufficient assistive technology (AT) and AT services?

G. By failing to provide an aide that caused the Student to miss afternoon instruction and services on October 14, 16, 17, and from November 7 through December 6, 2002?

H. By failing to provide elective class choices for the least restrictive environment (LRE) at Mira Costa College?

I. By failing to provide an appropriate transition plan?

The Student also challenges the District’s program for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT enrolled in the adult transition program at Mira Costa College in April 2003. The District is providing instruction and services offered in the April 16, 2002 IEP (District Exhibit 2) modified by the parents’ “dissent” as reflected in the October 30, 2002 IEP (District Exhibit 1). The April 2002 IEP offers the adult transition program with specified services in the areas of adapted physical education, speech and language, occupational therapy, and assistive technology consulting. This IEP notes the parental concern that STUDENT is not making progress in reading or functional and independent living skills. There is no provision for a reading program separate from the incidental reading required in the transition program. The April 2002 IEP reports that his reading is at the mid-kindergarten level. The parents also provided a three-page attachment to the IEP that expresses concern for the lack of progress in basic skills and outlines areas of strength and needs. The dissent accepts some of the offered services for speech and language, occupational therapy, and assistive technology but seeks more time from the providers in these area. There was an IEP meeting on October 30, 2002, but this session dealt with an assistive technology report and the specifics of the parents’ dissent. This IEP specifically offered the Mira Costa College transition program as a placement. The October 2002 IEP also recorded the fact that MOTHER had unilaterally placed STUDENT for at least five hours per week in the private reading program without District assent.

Was the reading program appropriate?

STUDENT’s needs for small group or individual instruction to work on basic skills and develop skills for independent living continue into the 2002-2003 school year. The District offer, however, does not provide for a reading program. The transition class does feature practical vocabulary to accompany lessons in the community such as shopping and using public transportation. Reading is also included in the computer assistive technology component of the programs. However, in spite of the statement in the April 2002 IEP that his progress in reading is limited to the mid-kindergarten level as of age nineteen, no additional reading is offered.

STUDENT is working privately with reading therapist Dr. Thrope in her “The Reading Room” program. MOTHER contacted Dr. Thrope in April 2002 to assist STUDENT in his reading. MOTHER unilaterally removed STUDENT from school for this program for five hours a week. Dr. Thrope testified that initially she was reluctant to teach STUDENT as she did not know if he could succeed. She did begin working with STUDENT after observing him and determining a strategy that she thought would be effective. Her assessment in February 2003 (Student Exhibit 9; District Exhibit 40) after six months of work for two hours per week, is that STUDENT’s “instructional reading level” is at grade two. She stated in her report that “His knowledge of words is increasing as is his ability to spell them.” Dr. Thrope said that although she can get STUDENT to achieve the second grade level in her clinical environment, at home it would be better for MOTHER to use first grade materials. Dr. Thrope credits MOTHER for contributing to STUDENT’s success with substantial reinforcement of her drills and lessons at home. Dr. Thrope recommends “overteaching” and “overlearning” to avoid regression. To make up for what she says is his not having an “opportunity to learn how to read,” she said STUDENT should receive a five-year program for four hours a day, five days a week. Dr. Thrope stated that she did not consult with any District teachers or staff in formulating her conclusions. She viewed basic reading skills as a necessary means for STUDENT to function in the workplace.

Since February 2003, Ms. Eggert, who through the District-provided STUDENT Lindamood-Bell services in 1999, has been directly hired by the PARENTSs to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction. She observed that when she last saw STUDENT in 1999 he had severely delayed language. In 2003 he had greatly improved oral language. After working with STUDENT since February at three times per week while he was also receiving instruction from Dr. Thrope, Ms. Eggert now assesses STUDENT at the second grade level in reading. Ms. Eggert said that STUDENT had regressed in reading since last working with him in 1999. When she first saw STUDENT in February, he could not remember his sounds that he knew when she worked with him in 1999 and had no awareness of phonics. She currently recommends three hours a week of one-to-one Lindamood-Bell instruction, a technique that she says is working with STUDENT. She does indicate, however, that it is unknown if STUDENT will ever master abstract language. She believes that the reasonable expectation for STUDENT is to achieve a reading level sufficient for functional independent living.

As indicated earlier, District reading specialist Dr. Palmer provided speech and language services to STUDENT in the special day class when he was in the ninth grade in the 1998-1999 school year. Schooled in the Slingerland teaching techniques and a certified instructor of providers in this method, Dr. Palmer assessed STUDENT in December 2001 (District Exhibit 42). This assessment, requested by the PARENTSs, was done through NCCSE. Using standardized test instruments, Dr. Palmer found STUDENT’s reading skills at the time to be in the first or second percentile. She observed that STUDENT would read “word by word” at the primer level without phrasing and without reading every word or correcting incorrectly decoded words. Dr. Palmer reported that after she read one of the primer passages back to STUDENT, his comprehension as shown by answering “wh” questions was twenty percent. She stated, “Without overteaching and overlearning, regression of reading skills will occur.” Her recommendations included practicing sight words and developing vocabulary based on prior knowledge and interests in an intensive reading program. Dr. Palmer said with STUDENT’s documented cognitive abilities, he is capable of functional skills necessary for reading such items as menus, signs, and bottle labels. Dr. Palmer is also trained in the Lindamood-Bell strategies. She indicated, however, she did not think STUDENT would progress with Lindamood-Bell techniques. She also said that she would be surprised to learn that STUDENT had progressed to the second grade level although his progress to the first grade level would be no surprise. Dr. Palmer believed that language services should continue as STUDENT’s cognitive ability is sufficient to benefit from that program. She said that STUDENT will hit a plateau in his reading progress. With his abilities, Dr. Palmer stated that the potential level that STUDENT could ultimately reach “is in a narrow range.”

All three reading experts who testified may have had different views on what is best for STUDENT, but they all agreed that he can learn to read through repetition and reinforcement, or “overteaching and overlearning” through a methodology that works with his unique learning style aimed at functional language. The District has no current reading program beyond the vocabulary and incidental practical reading skills for reading signs, timetables, and menus, presented in the adult transition program. Although these items are of significant importance, this limited program does not fully meet STUDENT’s needs for constant reinforcement and working on reading fundamentals. The October 2002 IEP does discuss reading software recognized for teaching basics. To this extent and to the extent of the reading component of the adult transition reading program, the program is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit. To the extent STUDENT’s IEP does provide for computer reading programs and provides for an adult transition program with a reading component, what STUDENT is receiving conforms to IEP. However, there is still the continuing absence of previously identified reading programs such as Edmark and Lindamood-Bell that are not accounted for nor are they part of the implementation.

Although in recent years the focus has shifted more toward functional skills and work ability programs, STUDENT’s needs still require small-group instruction in basic skills. Fundamental to his learning functional skills is a continuous reading program with “overteaching” and “overlearning.” The evidence indicates that without such a program, STUDENT will regress. Although the Mira Costa program teaches practical vocabulary, STUDENT’s slow progress in reading requires continual reinforcement. Since he transferred to the adult transition class, his need to have further individualized work on his reading skills has not been met beyond the incidental vocabulary drills. The evidence is that it is uncertain how much further STUDENT may advance, although Dr. Palmer testified that the expectation given his ability will fall in a “narrow range.” The independent specialists, Ms. Eggert and Dr. Thrope, have brought STUDENT to the second grade level according to their assessments. This progress deserves due recognition as an excellent accomplishment for STUDENT. However, the services of Ms. Eggert and Dr. Thrope have shown to confer a benefit on STUDENT. What is clear is that as STUDENT is in the transition to independent living, every small quantum of advancement in reading has significant impact on his ability to function productively and safely in adult life. The District needs to continue with basic reading instruction in addition to the practical vocabulary he will encounter in his current placement. The Hearing Officer finds that for the 2002-2003 school the District has not provided an adequate reading program and thus, to that extent, has denied him a FAPE.

Was there need to provide a one-to-one aide?

The District has continuously provided aides to STUDENT as part of his IEPs. As discussed in the section, below, the District aides have not always shown up for work. For what appear to be primarily safety concerns, STUDENT’s parents assert that a one-to-one aide is necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs. He has had a one-to-one aide in the past. In his current placement in the adult transition program, there are classroom aides available. This is particularly critical for community outings. Mr. Perelli, the adult transition instructor earlier this year, observed that although STUDENT was doing well, he could not do all of the work required in the program alone and needed the assistance of a classroom aide. Mr. Perelli, however, advised against a one-to-one aide for STUDENT as not necessary. Mr. Perelli stated that STUDENT was comfortable during the community activities. The aides, who are with the class at all times, can step in to assist in performing tasks, prevent or counter unsafe conditions, and correct inappropriate behavior. Speech and language pathologist Krassny pointed out that STUDENT becomes too dependent on his one-to-one aide and will not do things for himself. This runs counter to preparing STUDENT for functional independent living. With STUDENT’s delayed development and demonstrated needs, qualified aides should be available for the class activities and individual activities such as the computer. Obviously, for the one-to-one services such as occupational therapy and speech and language, no aide is necessary. A “shadow” aide, however, would be counterproductive to STUDENT’s needs and goals to work toward independent living. The record already reflects that STUDENT has met success in the work ability program with part-time work at Pizza Hut and Kaybee Toys. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a one-to-one aide is not required.

Was there a failure to provide a behavioral intervention plan (BIP)?

As covered in the BIP discussion for the previous school years after 1999-2000, there has been no indication from teachers or service providers that specific behaviors are impeding STUDENT’s educational progress. The limited references in 1999 to STUDENT’s behavior or to a BIP disclosed that he was progressing well in the areas covered by the BIP and was moving toward socially appropriate comments and conduct. The record also indicates that STUDENT is no longer on medication to control hyperactivity. This indicates the problems for which he received prescription drugs has ameliorated. Although STUDENT has an attention span problem, all service providers are aware of it and appear to be able to cope with it. BIPs or behavior issues other than attention span concerns are not raised in the IEPs in the record after November 1999. The evidence does not support the need for a BIP during the 2002-2003 school year.

Were there no appropriate counseling services?

There is no showing in the record that STUDENT needs additional counseling services. MOTHER testified that STUDENT needs to learn self-advocacy and other coping skills to be independent. This area of need is addressed directly in the adult transition program with its community experiences. No need is identified that requires separate counseling services. District psychologist Vangie Birdson questioned whether at STUDENT’s cognitive level, an abstract procedure such as counseling would be worthwhile. In the absence of an established need or a demonstrated potential benefit from such as service to meet that need, the Hearing Officer finds that additional counseling services are not appropriate.

Were there insufficient speech and language and occupational therapy services?

Throughout STUDENT’s IEPs, speech and language and occupational therapy needs, levels, and goals are discussed. The PARENTS are challenging the levels of service the District has offered for 2002-2003 and seek higher levels.

The April 16, 2002 IEP (District Exhibit 2) specified services for adapted physical education, speech and language, and assistive technology, and gave the frequency and duration over the course of the following school year.(Footnote 3) It did not indicate the time between sessions. The Student argues that this means that the District could aggregate the entire year’s worth of each category of services into a few days or weeks; however, nothing in the record points to a District intention or even ability to do so. A more likely probability, rather than a District intention to bunch services, is a District intention to give the service providers and classroom teachers more flexibility in scheduling to meet STUDENT’s needs with his proposed transition to the transition program as of April 2002. The record also indicates that with STUDENT’s part-time attendance on campus while he participated in the private, non-District sanctioned reading tutoring, the service providers had to exert extra effort to maintain a regular schedule. Although the Student correctly contends that the IEP should stand by itself within its own four corners and the District IEP team members could have been more accurate, the argument in this IEP context is unpersuasive as there was no reasonable expectation created in the record that the designated instruction and services would be provided in large blocks over a few days as opposed to being reasonably paced over the course of a year.

The speech and language therapy offer to STUDENT in the April 16, 2002 IEP is once a week in a thirty minute session with a provision for consultation and additional services. The PARENTSs requested more time. During the pendency of this due process hearing, STUDENT is receiving the last agreed upon level of services at twice a week for thirty minutes in the November 2, 2001 IEP (District Exhibit 4) as a stay put placement.

District speech and language pathologist Lisa Krassny has worked with STUDENT. She assessed him in March 2002 (District Exhibit 43) and drafted the goals and objectives for the April 2002 IEP in speech and language. Ms. Krassny reported that STUDENT is making progress on both his social pragmatics and social skills goals. Her assessment showed him to be functioning at a very concrete level of linguistic development. Abstract concepts are more elusive. Ms. Krassny recommended continuing current goals to emphasize words in his home and school environment. To work on generalizing information, she advocated a collaborative effort by the speech and language pathologist, teachers, and staff to address these goals with him for constant reinforcement to reduce fading. She stands by the proposed service level of no more than one session of thirty minutes a week along with this collaborative approach. There is no controverting testimony in the record. Ms. Krassny’s opinions are persuasive as a trained and experienced speech and language pathologist who has worked with many youngsters with autism and mental retardation during her sixteen-year career. Ms. Krassny’s testimony supports the District offer for speech and language. The Hearing Officer finds that this offer is appropriate.

As to the occupational therapy offer, District therapist Joy Bischke-Dodge has worked with STUDENT for the past two years and conducted the 2002 triennial assessment (District Exhibit 39). She concluded that he demonstrated a moderate impairment in visual-motor and visual perception skills. She provides a number of specific recommendations for staff and teachers to follow such as encourage upright posture, decrease ambient noise and distractions, and assist him with cues during written assignments to keep his writing within the lines. She drafted the goals and objectives for the April 2002 IEP for occupational therapy services. Ms. Bischke-Dodge verified the offer of occupational therapy services as appropriate. She pointed to STUDENT’s limited attention span during occupational therapy sessions as the basis for limiting each to thirty minutes. At the beginning of the time she worked with STUDENT, keeping his attention even for thirty minutes was difficult. Ms. Bishke-Dodge is a trained and experienced occupational therapist. The record includes no evidence to consider an alternative occupational therapy program. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s occupational therapy offer is appropriate.

Were there insufficient assistive technology (AT) and AT services?

STUDENT enjoys using computers. They have been used to supplement his reading and arithmetic, District professionals have also found that computers are an effective reward to keep STUDENT on task. The District did an extensive assistive technology assessment (District Exhibit 37) prepared by a firm that specializes in educational technology. This report discussed a number of computer programs and recommended assistive technology consultation services. The April 2002 IEP offered twelve thirty-minute sessions of assistive technology consultation during the year. No evidence was presented to challenge the assessment or the IEP-prescribed level of services. Student services specialist Jacqueline Harrigan indicated that an important component of the services provided by the assistive technology provider is to familiarize the aides with the programs and equipment so that they can assist the student. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer for assistive technology consultation is appropriate.

Was there a failure to provide an aide that caused the Student to miss afternoon instruction and services on October 14, 16, 17, and from November 7 through December 6, 2002?

STUDENT missed his afternoon program from mid October through early December 2002. From October 14 through the end of the month, the assigned aide did not show up on four occasions. MOTHER communicated several times with the District. In her first letter on October 17 to District special services director Ms. Jacqueline Harrigan (Student Exhibit 16), she complained about the aide not being on site when STUDENT arrived at 12:30 p.m., which resulted in no instruction or services. After another day in which no aide showed up, she wrote a letter on October 31 to Ms. Harrigan (Student Exhibit 17) in which she stressed that she did not want STUDENT left unattended for safety reasons. She took him home on the days the aide did not show up and kept STUDENT out of school after October 31. In this October 31 letter, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT’s private reading tutor was changing the schedule from mornings to afternoons and that STUDENT may be taken out of school because the IEP services were not being received. MOTHER again wrote Ms. Harrigan on November 5, 2002 (Student Exhibit 18 ). At that point following further conversations with Ms. Harrigan, MOTHER stated that she would keep STUDENT out of school until a new aide had been hired. MOTHER again stated her safety concerns and that she wanted STUDENT to receive the instruction and services that the IEP called for. On December 6, 2002, the District informed the PARENTS that a new aide was available and STUDENT returned to the program. Ms. Harrigan, however, testified that she told MOTHER that the District would transfer an aide from another school site to work with STUDENT during the interviewing and hiring process for the replacement but that no request for the temporary aide was made.

The record shows that STUDENT missed services because of aide unavailability. The record does not show, however, whether the District clearly communicated that an alternate aide would be made available if STUDENT returned to the school. The testimony of Ms. Harrigan that such an offer was made to the PARENTSs is not memorialized in a written document nor is there any written refutation or clarification by the District of what was in MOTHER’s three letters. District witnesses have stated that STUDENT’s unilateral removal for reading tutoring required them to take great efforts at rescheduling to provide services. STUDENT has been receiving services since he returned to school in December 2002. There is no evidence regarding what services STUDENT missed or may have made up. The Hearing Officer finds that although services were missed, the consequences of those missed sessions has not been established to support a remedy.

By failing to provide elective class choices for the least restrictive environment (LRE) at Mira Costa College?

The Student is challenging his current placement because as to date elective classes have been unavailable to him. Virtually every witness, including those called by the Student, stress functional living skills as the proper emphasis for STUDENT. The Mira Costa College program does just this. Teacher Douglas Perelli described the adult transition class as having five to eight students with three aides. Life and independent living skills are the context for lessons in money, time telling, social behavior, job applications, newspaper classified advertisement reading, and community transportation and shopping. Relevant vocabulary lessons deal with job skills, community signs, or the locations to be visited during community outings. At MOTHER’s request, the lessons also included cell phone familiarity. Mr. Perelli characterizes STUDENT as happy, well accepted by the other class members, and participating well. The college campus has course offerings that provide mainstreaming opportunities. Mr. Perelli listed keyboarding, computer skills, aerobics, and art as some of the offerings suitable for STUDENT. The Student has contended that the college classes have been unavailable. MOTHER stated that STUDENT liked elective classes. Mr. Perelli indicated that for this year STUDENT came into the class after the term started preventing enrollment in the electives. Additionally, Mr. Perelli stated that with MOTHER taking STUDENT out of the class for his reading program, STUDENT will have problems keeping up with the work or enrolling in elective classes. This limits the opportunities to take college classes. The adult transition class with its small enrollment and close supervision meets STUDENT’s needs for small-group or one-to-one instruction. This class is providing practical skills that are essential to independent living and maintaining a job. The college campus affords the opportunity for STUDENT to participate with normally developing peers in and out of class. The Hearing Officer finds that the Mira Costa College program is appropriate for STUDENT and provides instruction in the least restrictive environment.

Was there no appropriate transition plan?

The Student contends that there has not been an adequate transition plan. The IEP must contain a statement of “transition services” beginning when a special education pupil is fourteen and updated annually. At least by age sixteen the transition services shall include, where appropriate, interagency responsibilities or linkages. These “services,” based on the pupil’s individual needs, are to promote school to post-school activities including further schooling, vocational training, supported employment, independent living, and community participation. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1.

The IEP team did review an individual transition plan (ITP) dated March 9, 1999, according to the IEP of October 21, 1999 (District Exhibit 17) which refers to the plan. The IEP of November 29, 1999 (District Exhibit 16) did include a transition plan bearing the same date. This plan set forth post-school goals to explore job seeking, job sites, community college programs, cooking skills, and computer skills. A detailed ITP followed the IEP team meeting of May 16, 2001 (District Exhibit 7). This ITP listed in detail the skills that STUDENT must master for independent living including public transportation, money management, pay phone operation, food purchasing, oral and written communication, recreation, social and community activities, and personal care and hygiene. The work ability representative attended the May 16 meeting and explained the program.

The IEP team convened on June 8, 2001, and considered MOTHER’s concerns (District Exhibit 6). At that point the District informed MOTHER that no community activities in furtherance of the ITP goals would be available in STUDENT’s placement in the special day class at San Dieguito Academy for the 2001-2002 school year. MOTHER requested that STUDENT stay in the San Dieguito placement to see how the transition program develops. The ITP goals were the focus of the August 27, 2001 IEP team meeting during which the team heard from the teacher for the new Mira Costa adult transition program (District Exhibit 5). The team decided to adhere to MOTHER’s request to keep STUDENT at San Dieguito Academy with the work ability teacher evaluating STUDENT during the first quarter of the upcoming school year. MOTHER expressed concern that STUDENT at that time was not ready for a new program. The next transition plan appears as an attachment to the November 2, 2001 IEP (District Exhibit 4). This ITP dealt with work ability linkage and community exploration. The April 16, 2002 IEP team’s recommended placement was in the adult transition program with “functional curriculum with community involvement,” which was the stated goal of the November 2, 2001 ITP (District Exhibit 2).

As discussed above, STUDENT did enter the adult transition program at Mira Costa College in April 2003, and teacher Perelli observed that he is doing well although at a disadvantage because of his independent reading program that conflicts with class time. The District prepared thoughtful ITP’s and considered the input of MOTHER. STUDENT’s transition was considered continually from 1999 through the disputed April 2002 IEP. The plans included detailed treatment of personal skills and activities necessary for post-school independent living relying upon District resources and other agency programs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did adequate transition planning.

Although STUDENT’s needs are met in the services and programs offered, the exception is reading where no program is presented. Even as to the portion of this school year up to April 2003, when he was still in the special day class, the reading program did not meet his needs. As to the issue of reading, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied the Student a FAPE for the 2002-2003.

2002-2003 School Year

The Hearing Officer finds that because of the reading program, as discussed above, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in reading for the 2002-2003 school year.

Issue Number 6: Does the Student require additional assessments in the areas of vision and neuropsychological evaluation?

The District found STUDENT’s eyesight in March 2002 to be 20/20 in both eyes (District Exhibits 2, 44). One of the same assessors found STUDENT’s eyesight to be 20/30 in both eyes in October 2000, although STUDENT’s response during the testing was deemed “unreliable” and annual testing thereafter was recommended (District Exhibit 11). The Student, however, presented an independent vision assessment dated April 3, 2003 (Student Exhibit 2), showing STUDENT’s near vision to be “at risk” in every category with a recommendation of “a further visual/developmental evaluation.” Vision or vision-related issues appear elsewhere in the record. In the May 18, 1999 IEP (District Exhibit 18), the occupational therapy entries include the “possibility” of evaluating STUDENT’s visual processing. The District occupational therapy assessment of October 18, 1999 (District Exhibits, 44, 66) reports “moderate impairment” in the visual perceptual area although the assessor indicated that the testing accuracy was “difficult due to STUDENT’s impulsivity.” This assessment also includes information from MOTHER that STUDENT is “farsighted.” A progress report in February 2000 (District Exhibit 64) states that the occupational therapy emphasis for STUDENT’s sessions is “on visual-motor and sensorimotor activities.” These activities were continuing as of the next progress report on May 15, 2001 (District Exhibit 57). The April 16, 2002 assessment by District Occupational Therapist Bischke-Dodge (District Exhibit 39) found “moderate impairment” and potential hindering of visual-motor and visual perception skills by poor attention and impulsivity. In her testimony she acknowledged that STUDENT’s demonstrated visual perception deficiencies could be eyesight-related. Because of the potential for vision to be a factor both in STUDENT’s reading and occupational therapy performance and the discrepancy in the record of what STUDENT’s visual acuity is, the Hearing Officer finds that further vision assessment is appropriate.

As to a neuropsychological assessment, the evidence does not indicate that one was ever done. Dr. Coyne suggested such an assessment in his 2001 report (Student Exhibit 20). The testimony of Dr. Thrope and Ms. Eggert spoke of the neuropsychological processes in reading and how their methods dealt with these processes. The IEP team considered a neuropsychological assessment in May 1999 with the ambiguous notation that, “District agrees to evaluation with understanding that it may not be done.” A neuropsychological assessment may disclose some information that could help in advancing STUDENT’s reading or even occupational therapy progress. With such limited progress in reading since STUDENT entered the District in 1995 and with such critical importance of reading to STUDENT’s functional living skills, what appears to be an overdue neuropsychological assessment is appropriate. The Hearing Officer finds that a neuropsychological assessment at District expense should be conducted.

Issue Number 7: Are the Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for independent educational assessments (IEE) and educational services?

The Student’s parents may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified expert at the District’s expense if the following requirements are met:

1. The parents disagree with an evaluation obtained by the District;

2. The District is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was appropriate.

34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b)

STUDENT’s parents are seeking reimbursement for the assessments that they obtained prior to the due process hearing. These include five reading and language assessments and one psychological assessment “for strength and weakness, present level” (Student Exhibit 1). The threshold issue to cross before determining whether parents are entitled to reimbursement of an IEE is whether they have a disagreement with a District assessment. Dr. Palmer conducted a reading skills assessment for the District in December 2001 (District Exhibit 42). District speech and language pathologist Krassny performed a “speech-language evaluation” in March 2002 (District Exhibit 43). District special day class teacher Nancy Orr prepared a “present levels of educational performance” that included reading and language skills (District Exhibit 47). All of these assessments found STUDENT to be performing in these areas at approximately the first or second percentile and reading at a pre-primer or a mid-kindergarten level. The District evaluations were performed by qualified, experienced professionals who knew STUDENT and had worked with him. The results are consistent with the IEEs. The evidence establishes that these District assessments were appropriate to diagnose STUDENT’s needs and capabilities. The IEEs also found STUDENT with severe developmental delay and reading at a pre-primer level. As far as assessing STUDENT’s current levels, the IEEs and the District assessments are remarkably in agreement. Additionally, there is no indication in the record that the parents expressed their disagreement with the District assessments. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the reading and language IEEs.

The parents also seek reimbursement for a psychological evaluation performed by Dr. Mary J. Baker-Ericzen (Student Exhibit 15). District psychologist Vangie Birdson prepared a psychological report on April 12, 2002 (District Exhibit 41). Both assessors found STUDENT to be in the moderately mentally retarded range. The District results found STUDENT to be in 38 to 40 IQ range, whereas the IEE found his composite score to be 54. Ms. Birdson administered the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI). The Student has criticized this test as inappropriate. Ms. Birdson also testified that she would not have used this instrument if she were free to structure the assessment in her own professional judgment. The record indicates, however, that Ms. Birdson was limited to the CTONI by a stipulation between the District and the parents. The other assessments in the record suggest a composite IQ in the 50s may be more accurate. Nevertheless, Ms. Birdson is trained in this type of assessment and obtained a result that is within the same range of moderate retardation as the IEE. The evidence supports the District assessment as appropriate. As the District psychologist had no choice of measuring tools because of the agreement between the parents and the District to use the CTONI, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are estopped to challenge its use and further finds that no reimbursement for this IEE is indicated.

The parents are also asking for reimbursement for private educational services. The service providers include Dr. Thrope, Ms. Eggert, Sparks Literacy, music therapy, and instructor services for community experiences and functional skills needs when STUDENT was not in class in October, November, and December 2002 because of the missing aide. Transportation is also included in the reimbursement request.

A denial of FAPE by an educational agency entitles the student to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes of IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v.Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374; 105 S.C. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. Burlington provides for retroactive reimbursement as equitable relief for the denial of appropriate special education when parents provide an appropriate replacement education.

The Hearing Officer has already found that as to the reading program there has been a denial of FAPE since November 1999. Consequently, reimbursement is proper on an equitable basis under Burlington. There is inconclusive evidence in the record why or exactly when the District terminated the Lindamood-Bell services in spite of a written report showing that this approach was meeting some of STUDENT’s unique needs and learning style. The Lindamood-Bell services claimed are provided by the same teacher, Ms. Eggert, who worked with STUDENT in the District classroom with a one-to-one format. She testified that STUDENT had regressed from the time he worked with her in 1999 until she began the private work in 2003. Ms. Eggert persuasively reports progress in bringing STUDENT beyond where he was in 1999. The evidence shows these services conferred a benefit and met STUDENT’s unique leaning style. Ms. Eggert worked with STUDENT on the same skills in 1999 that she is teaching now. She is trained in the Lindamood-Bell methodology and described how she is addressing STUDENT’s unique learning style in order to have STUDENT enjoy progress. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer awards reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell services provided by Ms. Eggert.

STUDENT, according to the evidence, also has shown progress in Dr. Thrope’s program. Dr. Thrope testified to finding methods to meet STUDENT’s learning style. The evidence indicates that how far STUDENT can go in reading and language is unknown. The evidence, however, clearly anticipates that literacy beyond safety and community functioning is elusive for STUDENT. To achieve a basic functioning in reading for safety and community functioning is a recognized goal for STUDENT. District reading specialist Dr. Palmer testified that STUDENT had the capability of learning to read although his progress would be in a narrow range. The records shows that Dr. Thrope’s services have provided a needed benefit in the direction of reading for safety and community functioning during the time that the District no longer is providing a reading program. The District, except for reading, has provided a full and varied program for STUDENT for his entire post-elementary school experience. In view of the primacy of reading to meet STUDENT’s needs, however, the Hearing Officer awards reimbursement for Dr. Thrope’s services.

As to the Sparks Literacy program, there is no evidence how it benefitted STUDENT. Therefore, there will be no reimbursement for these services. Also, the Hearing Officer declines to award transportation expenses. The record also contains no explanation of the nature or the benefits to STUDENT from music therapy or instruction for community experience and functional skills needs. Therefore, no reimbursement is forthcoming for these items.

Issue Number 8: Is the Student entitled to compensatory education in reading?

The equitable principle of Burlington also provides hearing officers with the authority to award prospective placement or services in a private school or NPA at public expense. State law imposes the additional requirement that the NPA be state-certified. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2. This standard does not require, however, day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for time or opportunity lost. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.2d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994).

The Student is seeking District funding for prospective services for three years from Dr. Thrope as well as occupational therapy and speech and language therapy for more time per session than the District offered. As discussed above, STUDENT’s current reading program was not complete at least since November 1999. Reading is essential for STUDENT to achieve any level of independent living or employment. Some type of compensatory education is called for by the record. However, there is no evidence that Dr. Thrope’s “The Reading Room” is state-certified. As the proper emphasis is on functional living skills, the IEP team should determine what additional reading program can make up for the omitted programs. The IEP team has already established frequency and time for occupational therapy and speech and language. These services are meeting STUDENT’s needs. The IEP team can revisit this issue with input from the service providers who have been working with STUDENT whether more or even less time should be devoted to these services in light of the reading program that will be implemented.

ORDER

(1) The IEP team shall convene within twenty-one calendar days of this Decision to determine the following:

(a) To design and arrange appropriate assessments of STUDENT’s current vision, neuropsychological status, and reading skills with input from the District and private providers;

(b) To determine appropriate compensatory education providers and levels of reading instruction to meet STUDENT’s demonstrated needs, subject to review at least by July 31, 2004, considering the results of the assessments in paragraph (1)(a), above, and teaching techniques and approaches that have proven effective.

(c) To determine appropriate levels of occupational therapy and speech and language therapy, subject to review at least by July 31, 2004;

(2) The District shall complete the assessments referred to in paragraph 1(a), above, within thirty days of the IEP meeting; (3) Within thirty days after receipt of invoices from the Student’s parents, the District shall reimburse to the Student’s parents the amounts shown on Lindamood-Bell and The Reading Room invoices for services provided by Nancy Eggert and Dr. Lynne Thrope through the date this Decision.

(4) All other requests for relief of the parties are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

(1) The District prevailed.

(2) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issues of the reading program conforming to the IEP and the appropriateness of the reading program. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.

(3) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issues of the reading program conforming to the IEP and the appropriateness of the reading program. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.

(4) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issues of the reading program conforming to the IEP and the appropriateness of the reading program. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.

(5) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issues of the appropriateness of the reading program. The District prevailed on the remaining issues.

(6) The Student prevailed.

(7) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issue of reimbursement for Lindamood-Bell and The Reading Room services and the District prevailed on the balance.

(8) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The Student prevailed on the issues of compensatory education in reading and the District prevailed on the balance.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: July 28, 2003 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The wording of the issues here differs somewhat from the statements of issues filed by the parties before the hearing and stated on the record before the presentation of evidence. Changes in the language and in the order were made for clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made. Review of the Student’s program can go back no farther than January 8, 1999, three years before the filing date of the Student’s due process request. Anything before that date is barred by the statute of limitations in Cal. Educ. Code section 5505(j).

2. This IEP prospectively made an offer for the 2002-2003 school year including an adult transition program and services. 3. The occupational therapy is offered twice a week for thirty minutes a session. The speech and language is offered forty three times during the year for thirty minute sessions. The October 2002 IEP (District Exhibit 1) indicates that the implementation of speech and language offer was intended to be once a week for thirty minutes.