California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 30, 1998
Student v. Lodi Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 996-98 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones
Lodi Unified denied FAPE by dropping counseling and behavior plan; eligibility extended to December 2001, residential placement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 19-year-old student with a developmental disability and serious behavior needs filed against Lodi Unified School District. A January 1998 mediated settlement had placed him at Central Valley Training Center (CVTC), a day program for adults, with added counseling, a behavior management plan, and after-school services. The Hearing Officer compared what the district delivered with the settlement. Two shortfalls were minor: sexual behavior counseling ended before ten sessions because the counselor found it was not helping, and the district psychologist cut weekly sessions from 60 to 45 minutes. But the district provided no counseling after the psychologist left on June 12, 1998. It also never put in place a consistent, individualized behavior plan. CVTC's general program was not tailored to him, and after-school staff did not use it. These failures denied a FAPE from January 28, 1998, through the end of the school year. The after-school services met the agreement. For 1998-99, the district offered a program to be designed later by Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA). The offer named no facilities, staff, or location, so it was not a valid offer. The parents asked for Centre for Neuroskills, a residential program in Bakersfield. The Hearing Officer denied it because its rigid, compliance-based, closely watched approach did not fit him and was more restrictive than he needed. The district must hold an IEP meeting within ten days, provide an interim placement, and serve him through December 31, 2001.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a mediated settlement as the student's program. Small departures were excused. Stopping counseling and never building an individualized behavior plan denied FAPE. An offer that left staff, location, and program design for later failed Union v. Smith. Compensatory education took the form of extra eligibility past age 22.
Issues and holdings
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEImplementation
Issue 1A. Was Student provided a FAPE from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year — whether the District provided the sexual behavior counseling (at least ten sessions) required by the January 1998 agreement
Fewer than ten sessions were provided, which did not conform to the agreement, but this was a de minimis violation because the counselor found further therapy would not help; no remedy.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue 1B. Whether the District provided the one hour per week of other counseling (impulse control, anger management, tolerance, self-control) required by the agreement
Shortening sessions to 45 minutes was a de minimis violation, but providing no counseling at all after the psychologist left on June 12, 1998 was a substantial violation.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 1C. Whether the District provided the behavior management component, shared with parents and providers to ensure a consistent approach, required by the agreement
No coordinated, consistent, individualized behavior plan was ever provided; CVTC's generic SET program was not adopted in an IEP, was not individualized, and was not used by after-school staff.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 1D. Whether the District provided the after-school services (programming until 5:15 p.m. with at least three hours per week of credentialed teacher instruction) required by the agreement
The District complied, providing continuous services and far more than three hours per week of teacher instruction.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Has the District offered Student a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
The August 1998 BETA proposal did not specify facilities, personnel, or location and left the program to be designed later, so it was not a valid placement offer and no FAPE was offered.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Is Student entitled to placement at Centre for Neuroskills (CNS) in Bakersfield, California?
CNS's compliance-based, restraint-using, closely observed residential program did not meet Student's needs, residential placement was not shown to be necessary, and isolation from the community made it more restrictive than required.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue 4. Is Student entitled to compensatory educational services?
Failure to address behavior management caused lost educational opportunity, so the District must serve Student through December 31, 2001, extending eligibility beyond its normal end.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within ten days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to develop a program with consistent, individualized behavior management; one-on-one support; vocational and independent living skills instruction; speech and language services; and counseling. If an outside agency designs the program, a representative must attend.
- Order to provide or change services. District must ensure Student has an appropriate interim placement until the new program is fully operational, with staff hired and trained and a location ready.
- Compensatory education. District must provide special education services through December 31, 2001 (beyond the December 31, 2000 end of eligibility); if an appropriate program is not fully operational by December 31, 1998, the duty is extended by the additional time it takes to become operational.
- District is not obligated to place Student at Centre for Neuroskills.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Rowley; Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Dept. of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a)
People named in the decision
- Joni Kort, program specialist, Lodi Unified School District
- Sherry Leonard, administrative director of special services, SELPA
- Joe Ninomiya, Jr., counselor; witness for Student, Centre for Neuroskills
- Jeffrey Miller, psychologist; witness for District
- Patti Uplinger, program director, Central Valley Training Center
- Frank Marone, director, Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA)
- Stephanie Platt, behavior aide, Lodi Unified School District
- Victoria (Vicky) Garibay, behavior aide, Lodi Unified School District
- Antonio Lopez, program coordinator, Central Valley Training Center
- Eric Sharar, credentialed special education teacher, Lodi Unified School District
- Thomas Johnson, speech and language specialist, Lodi Unified School District
- Sharon Lewis, psychologist; witness for District
- Robert Mattesich, school psychologist (counseling and behavior plan coordinator), Lodi Unified School District
- David Demetral, sexual behavior counselor
- Dr. Stillwell, functional analysis assessment (FAA) and BIP assessor
- Suzanne Brown, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
- Centre for Neuroskills, residential program sought by parents, Bakersfield, California
- Central Valley Training Center, adult day program
- Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA), behavior services agency proposed by District
- Devereux California, prior residential school
- Career Development Program, supported living organization
- Valley Mountain Regional Center, regional center
- Los Felice, board-and-care agency providing day supervision
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing on August 20 and 21, and September 17, 21, 22, and 23, 1998, in Lodi, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown attended the first day of hearing as an observer.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma. The Petitioner attended portions of the hearing. The Petitioner’s parents, FATHER and MOTHER, were also present at the hearing on his behalf.
Respondent Lodi Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Jan Damesyn and Cathy Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf were program specialist Joni Kort and administrative director of special services for the SELPA Sherry Leonard.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Centre for Neuroskills counselor Joe Ninomiya, Jr., and MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: psychologist Jeffrey Miller, Central Valley Training Center (CVTC) program director Patti Uplinger, Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) director Frank Marone, behavior aide Stephanie Platt, behavior aide Victoria Garibay, CVTC program coordinator Antonio Lopez, teacher Eric Sharar, speech and language specialist Thomas Johnson, psychologist Sharon Lewis, psychologist Robert Mattesich, and Joni Kort.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing arguments were received by September 25, 1998. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. Was STUDENT provided with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year?
2. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to placement at Centre for Neuroskills (CNS) in Bakersfield, California?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner asserts that the District did not provide all of the services specified in an agreement the parties reached on January 28, 1998, and thus did not provide a FAPE from that date forward. As a result of this alleged failure, the Petitioner proposes that he should be entitled to receive one year of compensatory educational services. The District contends that the program it provided from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year constituted a FAPE and that the Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory education.
The District has proposed a program of one-to-one support and behavior management designed by BETA for the 1998-99 school year, with the counseling and speech and language services STUDENT has received in the past. The Petitioner contends that the BETA program is not appropriate for him and that he should be placed at CNS.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a developmentally disabled young man who will turn twenty on October 4. STUDENT has been diagnosed with Klinefelter’s syndrome, a chromosome abnormality that results in a larger body size and developmental delays. STUDENT is six foot, five inches tall and weighs about 250 pounds. Klinefelter’s syndrome may also account for many of his behavioral and motor difficulties. (Dist. Exh. 171-174.) It has also been established that STUDENT has an abnormality in the pathways between the two sides of his brain, making activities that require both sides of the brain to work together more difficult for him. STUDENT has also had many other diagnoses over the years, including Tourette’s syndrome, oppositional defiant disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. However, the medications that generally ameliorate many of these conditions have not done so with STUDENT, calling into question the accuracy of the diagnoses. STUDENT is currently taking Haldol and Cogentin to treat Tourette’s syndrome. STUDENT’s IQ is reported to be approximately 60, but his adaptive behavior skills are relatively strong. Thus, STUDENT sometimes appears to understand social situations better than he actually does. (Dist. Exh. 359.)
STUDENT began attending special education programs in preschool. Through the years, STUDENT began to exhibit serious behavioral problems, including defiance, verbal abuse and physical aggression. In July 1996, STUDENT was admitted to Devereux California, a residential school specializing in treating young people with serious behavioral problems. While attending Devereux, STUDENT’s behavioral problems continued. STUDENT also exhibited sexually assaultive behavior at Devereux. In December 1996, STUDENT sexually assaulted his counselor. In January and February 1997, STUDENT fondled two different male residents. Finally, on July 24, 1997, STUDENT trapped a female staff member in his room and sexually assaulted her. On October 20, 1997, STUDENT had a violent outburst in which he put his hand through a window and was taken to the emergency room. STUDENT was then placed in a psychiatric ward for observation. At that point, Devereux discharged STUDENT from the program. (Dist. Exh. 637-638.)
In November 1997, STUDENT returned to his parents’ home in Lodi.(Footnote 1) The District arranged for STUDENT to attend Central Valley Training Center (CVTC) on a temporary basis until the parties could agree on an appropriate placement. CVTC provides a day program for developmentally disabled adults that includes behavior management, job training, social skills training, recreation and leisure activities. At that point, a due process hearing request was pending. At a due process mediation on January 28, 1998, the parties entered into a settlement agreement for that due process case. The parties agreed that STUDENT would remain at CVTC and that he would receive additional services, including sexual behavior counseling, other counseling, speech and language services, job coaching, a behavior management plan, transportation, before- and after-school services, and coverage for school holidays. (Dist. Exh. 238-240.)
STUDENT’s daily program generally followed the same schedule. At 8:00 a.m., two behavioral aides, Stephanie Platt and Vicky Garibay, picked STUDENT up at his parents’ home in a District van. The aides took STUDENT to get coffee or breakfast or to run errands, then dropped him off at CVTC at 9:00 a.m. STUDENT participated in the CVTC program until 2:45 p.m., when the aides picked him up again. The aides transported STUDENT to a District school site for “after-school” services. Frequently the aides took STUDENT shopping or to recreation activities such as swimming before they arrived at the school site. Eric Sharar, a credentialed special education teacher, arrived at the school site at approximately 3:30 or 3:45 p.m. to provide academic instruction to STUDENT. Mr. Sharar and the aides also engaged STUDENT in recreational activities, such as playing whiffle ball. FATHER or MOTHER would pick up STUDENT at approximately 5:15 p.m.
STUDENT received counseling from Dr. Robert Mattesich, a District psychologist, on Wednesday mornings at CVTC. At first, these sessions lasted for one hour, but Dr. Mattesich concluded that STUDENT could not stay on track for that length of time and reduced the sessions to approximately forty-five minutes. STUDENT also received speech and language services from Thomas Johnson twice a week during the afternoons at the after-school site.
STUDENT received several sessions of sexual behavior counseling from Dr. David Demetral during January and February 1998. However, the sessions were not successful. Dr. Demetral concluded that STUDENT was not able to benefit from sexual behavior counseling at that time. (Dist. Exh. 224-226.)
Although STUDENT was well-behaved during most of his time at CVTC, there were several occasions on which he lost control and became physically and verbally abusive. On February 13, 1998, STUDENT became angry while at a pizza parlor and put his hand through a window. STUDENT was taken to the doctor to have his cuts treated. On February 20, 1998, an IEP team meeting convened, at which the team determined that a daily communication and behavior management plan would be developed by Dr. Mattesich to ensure consistent behavior management at CVTC, at the after-school program and at home. (Dist. Exh. 218-219.)
On March 4, 1998, while at the after-school program, STUDENT indicated that he had sprayed a toxic cleanser in his mouth. The staff called 911, and the paramedics took STUDENT to the hospital. On March 12, 1998, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss this incident. The team determined that if STUDENT attempted to harm himself in the future, the staff would call MOTHER first, and would call 911 only if there was a serious injury. On March 26, 1998, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss the progress in using the daily journal. The team also discussed appropriate consequences for STUDENT’s behavior.
On May 4, 1998, STUDENT had a major behavioral incident. STUDENT became very angry while in the CVTC van and hit the staff and the van. When the van arrived at the CVTC site, STUDENT attacked staff members’ vehicles, kicked the CVTC building, and threatened the staff. The staff called the police, who charged STUDENT with vandalism. The police allowed STUDENT to leave CVTC with the District’s behavioral aides, but STUDENT was very verbally abusive as he was getting in the District van. Less than a block from CVTC, STUDENT unbuckled his seat belt while the van was moving. The aides put on the hazard lights and pulled over. The police, who had been watching, came to the van and took STUDENT into custody. The behavioral aides notified the District of the arrest, and Antonio Lopez from CVTC called MOTHER. MOTHER asked Mr. Lopez to find out where the police had taken STUDENT, but he was unable to get the information. MOTHER did not learn until later that evening that STUDENT had been taken to the county jail.
On May 6, 1998, STUDENT again sprayed a toxic cleanser into his mouth, this time while he was at CVTC. STUDENT was taken to by ambulance to the hospital in Lodi where FATHER works.
On May 7, 1998, the IEP team met and determined that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavior intervention plan (BIP) should be prepared for STUDENT. CVTC determined that STUDENT would be given a trial period of thirty days. If his behavior did not improve during the trial period, he would be given a thirty-day notice of discharge. (Dist. Exh. 200, 165-167.) On May 18, 1998, the District proposed engaging Dr. Stillwell to perform the FAA and prepare the BIP. (Dist. Exh. 188-189.) On May 21, 1998, the PARENTS signed the assessment plan, approving Dr. Stillwell as the assessor. (Dist. Exh. 182.)
On June 1, 1998, STUDENT hit one of the CVTC staff members with a croquet mallet. On June 5, STUDENT hit a staff member, threatened staff and clients, and damaged program property and a staff member’s vehicle. At an IEP meeting on June 12, CVTC indicated that STUDENT was being discharged from the program effective July 10, 1998. At the same meeting, Dr. Stillwell presented his FAA and a draft BIP for discussion. The IEP team determined that changes needed to be made to both the FAA and the BIP.
On June 16, 1998, STUDENT began throwing rocks at CVTC staff and clients, then tried to punch the staff and damaged program property. The CVTC staff called the police, who arrested STUDENT and took him to a Department of Mental Health crisis center. On June 19, 1998, the IEP team met again to discuss the revised BIP. At this meeting, the District proposed several placement options to be explored for STUDENT, including services from BETA. On July 3, 1998, the Petitioner’s attorney filed the request for due process hearing.
On July 8, 1998, MOTHER contacted the District and indicated that she did not want STUDENT attending the after-school program when CVTC services ended. MOTHER testified that she was concerned about the level of control the District staff had over STUDENT and did not want him to incur more criminal liability for his behavior. From July 10 through July 24, 1998, STUDENT was served by Career Development Program (CDP), a supported living organization that had served STUDENT for a few days at a time in the past. On July 20, 1998, the IEP team met to discuss continuing program options for STUDENT. The District again proposed looking into a program with BETA, among other options. However, the team did not have a definite plan for what STUDENT would do when services with CDP ended on July 24. MOTHER contacted the staff at Valley Mountain Regional Center (VMRC), who were also looking for placement options for STUDENT. VMRC arranged for STUDENT to be supervised by staff at Los Felice, a board-and-care agency. Beginning on July 27, 1998, STUDENT spent the day at a house which Los Felice was preparing to be a board-and-care home, but which did not yet have any residents. The District did not arrange the Los Felice placement for STUDENT. Although there have been some discussions between Ms. Kort and Los Felice about payment for the program, the District was not paying for the placement at the time of the hearing.
On August 7, 1998, the District made a formal placement offer to the Petitioner, proposing that BETA design a one-on-one behavioral management program for STUDENT. The offer included a proposal prepared by BETA director Dr. Frank Marone, which included a significant amount of general information about BETA’s approach to behavior management.
STUDENT continues to spend his days with Los Felice staff. In mid-September, he began attending a reading class designed for DD students at Delta Community College. He has been able to attend and focus for approximately two hours of the three-hour class, with occasional breaks.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Was STUDENT provided with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).
Petitioner contends that the District did not provide services that conformed to his individualized education program, as described in the January 1998 agreement, and thus did not provide a FAPE. Specifically, the Petitioner contends that the District did not comply with the following portions of the agreement:
A. Counseling related to sexual behavior.
B. Other counseling.
C. Behavior management component.
D. After school services.
Whether the District provided services in conformance with each of these provisions of the agreement shall be examined separately.
A. Counseling related to sexual behavior.
The agreement called for at least ten sessions of sexual behavior counseling to be provided by Dr. Demetral, an expert in the field of sexual behavior, with additional sessions to be provided if Dr. Demetral deemed them to be necessary. There is no dispute that Dr. Demetral provided less than ten sessions before he determined that sexual counseling was not helpful. Petitioner contends that the District should have proposed another counselor to perform the counseling. However, there is no evidence that the PARENTS expressed a desire to continue the counseling after Dr. Demetral ended his services. The record does reflect that MOTHER asked for more information about why Dr. Demetral stopped providing therapy, which he provided in a memorandum dated April 26, 1998. (Dist. Exh. 224-226.) In Dr. Demetral’s professional opinion, the therapy sessions were not productive because STUDENT refused to participate. However, the agreement clearly called for provision of at least ten sessions. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide services in conformance with the agreement.
B. Other counseling.
The agreement indicated that STUDENT would receive one hour per week of counseling to address impulse control, anger management, tolerance training and self-control issues. Petitioner contends that the District did not provide appropriate services because Dr. Mattesich arbitrarily shortened the sessions to forty-five minutes and because no replacement psychologist was provided when Dr. Mattesich left the District’s employ in early June 1998.
Dr. Mattesich testified that he began with one-hour therapy sessions, but found that STUDENT was unable to focus for that length of time, resulting in conflict and unproductive time at the end of the sessions. Dr. Mattesich also testified that, in his experience, the therapist uses his professional opinion to determine the appropriate session length. However, because the agreement specified that the sessions would be one hour long, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet its obligation under the agreement.
Dr. Mattesich left the District’s employ on June 12, 1998. The evidence is uncontroverted that STUDENT did not receive any counseling from that date forward. Ms. Kort testified that another psychologist is currently assigned to STUDENT’s case, but she also stated that the new psychologist has never met STUDENT. Although MOTHER did request that the after-school program and transportation services cease on July 8, 1998, she did not ask that the counseling end. The District did not ensure that the counseling continued after Dr. Mattesich left and did not offer continuing counseling services until August 7, 1998. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide services in accordance with the agreement because it did not provide any counseling services after the beginning of June 1998.
C. Behavior management component.
According to the agreement, STUDENT’s program was to include a behavior management component that would be shared with his parents and his service providers to ensure a consistent approach to handling his behavior. The behavior management plan was to be coordinated by the psychologist providing the counseling. The witnesses at the hearing from both sides testified that one of STUDENT’s most significant needs is a consistent, individualized behavior management plan. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Miller, Ms. Lewis, Mr. Johnson, Ms. Uplinger.) The Petitioner contends that there was never a coordinated, consistent, individualized behavior management plan for STUDENT.
Dr. Mattesich was the psychologist charged with coordinating the behavior management component. He testified that the IEP team determined that CVTC’s social effectiveness training (SET) program was to be the behavior management component. However, there is no IEP document that reflects that decision.(Footnote 2) Moreover, the District staff running the after-school component never used the SET program. Neither of the behavioral aides were trained in using SET. Eric Sharar, the teacher, testified that he received two out of three days of SET training, but that he never received the paperwork necessary for implementing the program. MOTHER was not able to attend one of the SET training sessions, and she testified that she was never given alternative training dates. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide a coordinated behavior management component for STUDENT.
Even assuming the SET program had been consistently applied, it was never an individualized plan. Ms. Patti Uplinger from CVTC testified that it is a program used with all their clients. There was no evidence that the program was modified to conform to STUDENT’s unique needs. The District did not propose creating an individualized behavior plan until May, after STUDENT’s behavior was clearly out of control.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, by failing to provide a consistent, individualized behavior plan for STUDENT, the District failed to provide services in conformance with the January 1998 agreement.
D. After school services.
The District agreed to provide STUDENT with afternoon programming from the end of the CVTC program until 5:15 p.m., with at least three hours per week of instruction from a credentialed teacher. The Petitioner contends that the activities the behavioral aides and Mr. Sharar did with STUDENT did not provide educational benefit. However, the evidence clearly established that the District did comply with the terms of the agreement. It provided continuous services with far more than three hours per week of instruction from a teacher (Mr. Sharar was with STUDENT for more than one hour every day). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided services that conformed to this provision of the agreement. *** The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide the full number of sexual behavior counseling sessions was a de minimus violation of the agreement that does not entitle STUDENT to a remedy. Dr. Demetral determined before ten sessions were provided that further therapy would not be beneficial. Dr. Demetral’s memorandum clearly states that STUDENT was not benefitting from the therapy sessions. Similarly, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mattesich’s shortening of the session length for the other counseling was a de minimus violation of the agreement. Dr. Mattesich concluded in his professional opinion that the additional fifteen minutes was not providing any benefit.
However, by not providing STUDENT with any counseling services after June 12, 1998, or with a consistent, individualized behavior plan, the Hearing Officer finds that the District substantially violated the agreement. This violation resulted in a failure to serve STUDENT’s unique needs for ongoing counseling and behavior management. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide STUDENT with services in conformance with the agreement and that, as a remedy for the contractual violation, STUDENT is entitled to a finding that the District denied him a FAPE from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year.
2. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
The Petitioner contends that the District has not provided a written offer of placement for the 1998-99 school year. The Petitioner asserts that the August 1998 offer of the BETA program does not constitute a proper offer of placement because the description of the BETA program is not specific enough.
The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes a placement for a student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A-B). In Union School District v. Smith, (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, the court stated, "this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." The court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parent of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer for the appropriateness of the placement. Smith, at 1526. In addition, California law defines special education placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs.” 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a). Thus, a written offer must adequately describe those elements to constitute an offer of placement.
The program described in the August 1998 settlement offer and the BETA proposal does not meet the California definition of special education placement. The proposal also did not specify facilities, personnel, or location for the program. The BETA proposal provided significant information about how BETA operates and its philosophical approach to behavior management. However, the very nature of BETA’s services make it impossible to describe the specific program for STUDENT until BETA staff have met and evaluated STUDENT. (Testimony of Dr. Marone.) BETA programs are very individualized. The approaches used and the daily schedule depend entirely on the specific client’s needs. Moreover, the BETA proposal clearly indicates that it may take up to twelve weeks to develop and implement the program. The District had no clear proposal for serving STUDENT during that time, other than to continue his monitoring program at Los Felice.
While BETA may prove to be able to develop a very successful program for STUDENT, it has not yet done so. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not met its burden of making a placement offer and, as a result, has not offered a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.(Footnote 3)
3. Is STUDENT entitled to placement at Centre for Neuroskills (CNS) in Bakersfield, California?
Although the District has not offered a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT is not automatically entitled to attend the program his parents have proposed.(Footnote 4) Rather, he would be entitled to attend CNS only if it can provide an appropriate education in the least restrictive environment. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 176, 200. At issue in this case is whether CNS can serve STUDENT’s unique needs and provide educational benefit in the least restrictive environment.
A. The CNS Program.(Footnote 5)
CNS primarily serves adults with traumatic brain injury (TBI), but it has had developmentally disabled clients in the past. The focus of CNS programming is to address the many problems presented by TBI patients, including severe behavior problems. The program has several components, including counseling, occupational therapy, physical therapy, educational therapy, vocational therapy, and behavior management. The program proposed for STUDENT includes three hours of various therapies in the morning, depending on his needs. Mr. Ninomiya testified that STUDENT would probably receive counseling, and that they would determine which of the other therapies he needed. STUDENT’s afternoon program would consist of activities taking place with other clients in an activity room. At the end of the day, STUDENT would be transported to the residential facility, an assisted-living apartment complex where the rooms are constantly monitored by video camera. STUDENT would have one-on-one support all day long, both at the therapy site and at the apartments.
CNS would develop a behavior management plan for STUDENT. CNS places significant emphasis on ensuring that the clients comply with instructions and commands. To obtain compliant behavior, the staff uses both positive and negative reinforcement. STUDENT would receive positive feedback such as verbal praise and the opportunity to participate in activities he prefers. The negative reinforcement would consist of the denial of privileges and physical prompts and restraints, including prone containment if STUDENT is presenting a danger to himself or others. If a client’s behavior is completely out of control, he may be placed in a padded time-out room, where the lights can be dimmed and the door held shut until the client is under control. CNS would also attempt to alter STUDENT’s behaviors by providing reality therapy to teach STUDENT the difference between reality and his fantasies. The staff would confront STUDENT with his behavior in an attempt to teach him to avoid it in the future. CNS would provide relaxation therapy to help STUDENT to learn to control his own responses and behavior. Mr. Ninomiya indicated that STUDENT would not be allowed to go into the community, participate in supported employment, or participate in large group situations until his behavior is under control.
B. Can the CNS program serve STUDENT’s unique needs in the least restrictive environment?
STUDENT’s unique needs undisputedly include consistent, individualized behavior management; one-on-one support services; vocational and independent living skills instruction; speech and language services; and counseling.(Footnote 6) (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Miller, Thomas Johnson, Sharon Lewis, Dr. Mattesich, Ms. Uplinger.) Although many witnesses testified that STUDENT needs a behavior program that is applied consistently by all the individuals dealing with him, only MOTHER testified that STUDENT needed a residential program. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not establish that STUDENT needs a residential program to benefit from his education. In fact, STUDENT’s sexually assaultive behavior occurred only while he was in a residential program. It has not recurred since he returned to Lodi in November 1997.
The Petitioner asserts that he needs a structured, safe environment with the rigid behavior plan offered by CNS. However, many other witnesses testified that STUDENT does not respond well to such an approach. In his detailed FAA, Dr. Stillwell reported that STUDENT reacts badly to authoritarian figures and to being ordered about. He determined that being compelled to perform a particular task can trigger STUDENT’s aggressive behavior. The District’s witnesses concurred, concluding that a program that emphasizes commands and compliance would not be appropriate for STUDENT. (Testimony of Dr. Miller, Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis.) Several witnesses testified that, because of his significant size, it is very important not to teach STUDENT that it is appropriate to use physical force to impose one’s will. As such, it is inappropriate to use physical restraints to compel STUDENT to comply. (Testimony of Ms. Lewis, Dr. Miller, Mr. Johnson.)
Dr. Stillwell found that another trigger for aggressive behavior was lack of flexibility in programming. MOTHER also testified that the people working with STUDENT must be flexible and willing to accommodate STUDENT’s activity choices, within reason. The District staff testified that the lack of flexibility in the programming at CNS would be very difficult for STUDENT to handle. (Testimony of Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis.) An additional behavior trigger for STUDENT is having a feeling that he is being observed. (Dist. Exh. 94-95.) Ms. Lewis and Mr. Johnson, both of whom visited CNS, testified that the program has a “fishbowl” atmosphere where the clients are constantly observed, even in the apartments. Mr. Johnson, who has worked with STUDENT since approximately 1994-95, expressed the opinion that the constant observation would intensify STUDENT’s behavior problems.
Psychotherapy is a significant element of the behavior modification program proposed for STUDENT at CNS. Mr. Ninomiya testified that he would use both reality therapy and cognitive therapy with STUDENT to force STUDENT to confront and take responsibility for his behavior. Dr. Mattesich, who has worked with STUDENT at various times since elementary school, testified that traditional counseling was not proving to be very helpful with STUDENT. Dr. Mattesich indicated that confronting STUDENT with issues and his behavior is not productive. Any such issues must be approached tangentially. Dr. Mattesich also testified that STUDENT was unable to attend and focus for a full hour of therapy, which is the session length proposed by CNS. Dr. Mattesich expressed the opinion that STUDENT needs a behavioral approach rather than a psychotherapeutic approach to learn behavior that will help him be successful in society.
The District staff also expressed concern about CNS not allowing STUDENT to go into the community for an extensive period of time. The evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT learns functional living and vocational skills best when practicing them in a real environment. (Testimony of Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis, Ms. Platt, Mr. Lopez.) Without an opportunity to go into the community, STUDENT would be unable to practice skills such as bus riding and grocery shopping and would not have an opportunity to learn vocational skills in a real work environment.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the CNS program is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The focus of the behavior management approach on commands, compliance, and physical contact are inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concurs that it is essential not to teach STUDENT that it is acceptable to use force to obtain compliance. The heavy emphasis on psychotherapy and the rigid therapy schedule also would not serve STUDENT’s need for a behavioral approach and flexibility. Moreover, the evidence established that the extremely restrictive, “fishbowl” environment is more likely to trigger STUDENT’s aggressive behavior than to eliminate it. The Hearing Officer further finds that separating STUDENT from contact with the community makes CNS a more restrictive environment than STUDENT requires. The evidence established that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior usually does not occur in the community and that he prefers to participate in activities in the community. According to the evidence, STUDENT is a cooperative, social young man at least eighty percent of the time. STUDENT takes great pleasure in participating in activities in the community, including fishing, bowling, and shopping, and is almost always well-behaved during those activities. The evidence did not establish that it is necessary for STUDENT to be isolated on a twenty-four hour basis in an environment consisting solely of disabled individuals.
The Hearing Officer concludes that CNS cannot serve STUDENT’s needs and does not provide the least restrictive environment, and, therefore, that CNS is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
The Supreme Court in Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Dept. of Education, (1985) 471 U.S. 358, concluded that parents may be compensated for expenses they have incurred in educating their child when the school failed to provide an appropriate program. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See, e.g., Lester H. v. K. Gihool and the Chester Upland School District (3d Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865, Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Courts that have adopted compensatory education as a remedy for children whose rights to a FAPE have been violated by a school district have traditionally analyzed the issue in terms of whether the violations resulted in a loss to the child in skills or educational opportunity.
The Petitioner asserts that the District’s failure to provide a FAPE from January 28, 1998, forward entitles him to compensatory education in the form of an extension of the period of time for which he will be eligible for special education. As discussed above, the District failed to serve STUDENT’s most critical need, behavior management, from January 28, 1998, forward. As a result, STUDENT’s behavior escalated on many occasions, denying him various educational opportunities. For example, STUDENT’s behavior made it impossible for him to work in a supported employment situation, which was one of his goals for the year. STUDENT’s behavior also resulted in his being discharged from CVTC, leaving him with no defined program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide a FAPE resulted in a loss of educational opportunity and that STUDENT is entitled to receive compensatory education. To date, the District has deprived STUDENT of appropriate services for at least eight months and does not have an appropriate program immediately available for him. Under the law, STUDENT will be eligible for special education services from the District through December 31, 2000, after his twenty-second birthday. Giving STUDENT an additional eight or nine months of eligibility would require the District to provide services into the first semester of the 2001-02 school year. The law requires districts to continue serving students through the end of the semester during which eligibility expires. Therefore, as compensatory education, the District shall continue to provide services to STUDENT through December 31, 2001.
ORDER
1. Within ten days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT that will provide consistent, individualized behavior management; one-on-one support services; vocational and independent living skills instruction; speech and language services, and counseling. If this program will be designed by an outside agency, the District shall ensure that a representative of that agency attends the IEP team meeting. The District shall also ensure that STUDENT has an appropriate interim placement until the program is fully operational, with staff hired and trained and a location ready for the program.(Footnote 7)
2. The District shall provide special education services to STUDENT through December 31, 2001. If an appropriate program is not fully operational by December 31, 1998, the District’s duty to serve STUDENT shall be extended by an amount of time equal to the additional time it takes for the program to be fully operational.
3. The District is not obligated to place STUDENT at CNS.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue 1: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3: The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 4: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: September 30, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing OfficeThis matter convened for hearing on August 20 and 21, and September 17, 21, 22, and 23, 1998, in Lodi, California, before Hearing Officer Keltie Jones of the Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office) located at McGeorge School of Law in Sacramento, California. Hearing Officer Suzanne Brown attended the first day of hearing as an observer.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma. The Petitioner attended portions of the hearing. The Petitioner’s parents, FATHER and MOTHER, were also present at the hearing on his behalf.
Respondent Lodi Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Jan Damesyn and Cathy Smith. Also present on the District’s behalf were program specialist Joni Kort and administrative director of special services for the SELPA Sherry Leonard.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Centre for Neuroskills counselor Joe Ninomiya, Jr., and MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: psychologist Jeffrey Miller, Central Valley Training Center (CVTC) program director Patti Uplinger, Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA) director Frank Marone, behavior aide Stephanie Platt, behavior aide Victoria Garibay, CVTC program coordinator Antonio Lopez, teacher Eric Sharar, speech and language specialist Thomas Johnson, psychologist Sharon Lewis, psychologist Robert Mattesich, and Joni Kort.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing arguments were received by September 25, 1998. The record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
1. Was STUDENT provided with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year?
2. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
3. Is STUDENT entitled to placement at Centre for Neuroskills (CNS) in Bakersfield, California?
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner asserts that the District did not provide all of the services specified in an agreement the parties reached on January 28, 1998, and thus did not provide a FAPE from that date forward. As a result of this alleged failure, the Petitioner proposes that he should be entitled to receive one year of compensatory educational services. The District contends that the program it provided from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year constituted a FAPE and that the Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory education.
The District has proposed a program of one-to-one support and behavior management designed by BETA for the 1998-99 school year, with the counseling and speech and language services STUDENT has received in the past. The Petitioner contends that the BETA program is not appropriate for him and that he should be placed at CNS.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a developmentally disabled young man who will turn twenty on October 4. STUDENT has been diagnosed with Klinefelter’s syndrome, a chromosome abnormality that results in a larger body size and developmental delays. STUDENT is six foot, five inches tall and weighs about 250 pounds. Klinefelter’s syndrome may also account for many of his behavioral and motor difficulties. (Dist. Exh. 171-174.) It has also been established that STUDENT has an abnormality in the pathways between the two sides of his brain, making activities that require both sides of the brain to work together more difficult for him. STUDENT has also had many other diagnoses over the years, including Tourette’s syndrome, oppositional defiant disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. However, the medications that generally ameliorate many of these conditions have not done so with STUDENT, calling into question the accuracy of the diagnoses. STUDENT is currently taking Haldol and Cogentin to treat Tourette’s syndrome. STUDENT’s IQ is reported to be approximately 60, but his adaptive behavior skills are relatively strong. Thus, STUDENT sometimes appears to understand social situations better than he actually does. (Dist. Exh. 359.)
STUDENT began attending special education programs in preschool. Through the years, STUDENT began to exhibit serious behavioral problems, including defiance, verbal abuse and physical aggression. In July 1996, STUDENT was admitted to Devereux California, a residential school specializing in treating young people with serious behavioral problems. While attending Devereux, STUDENT’s behavioral problems continued. STUDENT also exhibited sexually assaultive behavior at Devereux. In December 1996, STUDENT sexually assaulted his counselor. In January and February 1997, STUDENT fondled two different male residents. Finally, on July 24, 1997, STUDENT trapped a female staff member in his room and sexually assaulted her. On October 20, 1997, STUDENT had a violent outburst in which he put his hand through a window and was taken to the emergency room. STUDENT was then placed in a psychiatric ward for observation. At that point, Devereux discharged STUDENT from the program. (Dist. Exh. 637-638.)
In November 1997, STUDENT returned to his parents’ home in Lodi.(Footnote 1) The District arranged for STUDENT to attend Central Valley Training Center (CVTC) on a temporary basis until the parties could agree on an appropriate placement. CVTC provides a day program for developmentally disabled adults that includes behavior management, job training, social skills training, recreation and leisure activities. At that point, a due process hearing request was pending. At a due process mediation on January 28, 1998, the parties entered into a settlement agreement for that due process case. The parties agreed that STUDENT would remain at CVTC and that he would receive additional services, including sexual behavior counseling, other counseling, speech and language services, job coaching, a behavior management plan, transportation, before- and after-school services, and coverage for school holidays. (Dist. Exh. 238-240.)
STUDENT’s daily program generally followed the same schedule. At 8:00 a.m., two behavioral aides, Stephanie Platt and Vicky Garibay, picked STUDENT up at his parents’ home in a District van. The aides took STUDENT to get coffee or breakfast or to run errands, then dropped him off at CVTC at 9:00 a.m. STUDENT participated in the CVTC program until 2:45 p.m., when the aides picked him up again. The aides transported STUDENT to a District school site for “after-school” services. Frequently the aides took STUDENT shopping or to recreation activities such as swimming before they arrived at the school site. Eric Sharar, a credentialed special education teacher, arrived at the school site at approximately 3:30 or 3:45 p.m. to provide academic instruction to STUDENT. Mr. Sharar and the aides also engaged STUDENT in recreational activities, such as playing whiffle ball. FATHER or MOTHER would pick up STUDENT at approximately 5:15 p.m.
STUDENT received counseling from Dr. Robert Mattesich, a District psychologist, on Wednesday mornings at CVTC. At first, these sessions lasted for one hour, but Dr. Mattesich concluded that STUDENT could not stay on track for that length of time and reduced the sessions to approximately forty-five minutes. STUDENT also received speech and language services from Thomas Johnson twice a week during the afternoons at the after-school site.
STUDENT received several sessions of sexual behavior counseling from Dr. David Demetral during January and February 1998. However, the sessions were not successful. Dr. Demetral concluded that STUDENT was not able to benefit from sexual behavior counseling at that time. (Dist. Exh. 224-226.)
Although STUDENT was well-behaved during most of his time at CVTC, there were several occasions on which he lost control and became physically and verbally abusive. On February 13, 1998, STUDENT became angry while at a pizza parlor and put his hand through a window. STUDENT was taken to the doctor to have his cuts treated. On February 20, 1998, an IEP team meeting convened, at which the team determined that a daily communication and behavior management plan would be developed by Dr. Mattesich to ensure consistent behavior management at CVTC, at the after-school program and at home. (Dist. Exh. 218-219.)
On March 4, 1998, while at the after-school program, STUDENT indicated that he had sprayed a toxic cleanser in his mouth. The staff called 911, and the paramedics took STUDENT to the hospital. On March 12, 1998, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss this incident. The team determined that if STUDENT attempted to harm himself in the future, the staff would call MOTHER first, and would call 911 only if there was a serious injury. On March 26, 1998, another IEP team meeting was held to discuss the progress in using the daily journal. The team also discussed appropriate consequences for STUDENT’s behavior.
On May 4, 1998, STUDENT had a major behavioral incident. STUDENT became very angry while in the CVTC van and hit the staff and the van. When the van arrived at the CVTC site, STUDENT attacked staff members’ vehicles, kicked the CVTC building, and threatened the staff. The staff called the police, who charged STUDENT with vandalism. The police allowed STUDENT to leave CVTC with the District’s behavioral aides, but STUDENT was very verbally abusive as he was getting in the District van. Less than a block from CVTC, STUDENT unbuckled his seat belt while the van was moving. The aides put on the hazard lights and pulled over. The police, who had been watching, came to the van and took STUDENT into custody. The behavioral aides notified the District of the arrest, and Antonio Lopez from CVTC called MOTHER. MOTHER asked Mr. Lopez to find out where the police had taken STUDENT, but he was unable to get the information. MOTHER did not learn until later that evening that STUDENT had been taken to the county jail.
On May 6, 1998, STUDENT again sprayed a toxic cleanser into his mouth, this time while he was at CVTC. STUDENT was taken to by ambulance to the hospital in Lodi where FATHER works.
On May 7, 1998, the IEP team met and determined that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) and behavior intervention plan (BIP) should be prepared for STUDENT. CVTC determined that STUDENT would be given a trial period of thirty days. If his behavior did not improve during the trial period, he would be given a thirty-day notice of discharge. (Dist. Exh. 200, 165-167.) On May 18, 1998, the District proposed engaging Dr. Stillwell to perform the FAA and prepare the BIP. (Dist. Exh. 188-189.) On May 21, 1998, the PARENTS signed the assessment plan, approving Dr. Stillwell as the assessor. (Dist. Exh. 182.)
On June 1, 1998, STUDENT hit one of the CVTC staff members with a croquet mallet. On June 5, STUDENT hit a staff member, threatened staff and clients, and damaged program property and a staff member’s vehicle. At an IEP meeting on June 12, CVTC indicated that STUDENT was being discharged from the program effective July 10, 1998. At the same meeting, Dr. Stillwell presented his FAA and a draft BIP for discussion. The IEP team determined that changes needed to be made to both the FAA and the BIP.
On June 16, 1998, STUDENT began throwing rocks at CVTC staff and clients, then tried to punch the staff and damaged program property. The CVTC staff called the police, who arrested STUDENT and took him to a Department of Mental Health crisis center. On June 19, 1998, the IEP team met again to discuss the revised BIP. At this meeting, the District proposed several placement options to be explored for STUDENT, including services from BETA. On July 3, 1998, the Petitioner’s attorney filed the request for due process hearing.
On July 8, 1998, MOTHER contacted the District and indicated that she did not want STUDENT attending the after-school program when CVTC services ended. MOTHER testified that she was concerned about the level of control the District staff had over STUDENT and did not want him to incur more criminal liability for his behavior. From July 10 through July 24, 1998, STUDENT was served by Career Development Program (CDP), a supported living organization that had served STUDENT for a few days at a time in the past. On July 20, 1998, the IEP team met to discuss continuing program options for STUDENT. The District again proposed looking into a program with BETA, among other options. However, the team did not have a definite plan for what STUDENT would do when services with CDP ended on July 24. MOTHER contacted the staff at Valley Mountain Regional Center (VMRC), who were also looking for placement options for STUDENT. VMRC arranged for STUDENT to be supervised by staff at Los Felice, a board-and-care agency. Beginning on July 27, 1998, STUDENT spent the day at a house which Los Felice was preparing to be a board-and-care home, but which did not yet have any residents. The District did not arrange the Los Felice placement for STUDENT. Although there have been some discussions between Ms. Kort and Los Felice about payment for the program, the District was not paying for the placement at the time of the hearing.
On August 7, 1998, the District made a formal placement offer to the Petitioner, proposing that BETA design a one-on-one behavioral management program for STUDENT. The offer included a proposal prepared by BETA director Dr. Frank Marone, which included a significant amount of general information about BETA’s approach to behavior management.
STUDENT continues to spend his days with Los Felice staff. In mid-September, he began attending a reading class designed for DD students at Delta Community College. He has been able to attend and focus for approximately two hours of the three-hour class, with occasional breaks.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Was STUDENT provided with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year?
Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et sq.; California Education Code §§ 56000 et seq. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1402(8), “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that conform with the student’s individualized education program. “Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability ...” 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25).
Petitioner contends that the District did not provide services that conformed to his individualized education program, as described in the January 1998 agreement, and thus did not provide a FAPE. Specifically, the Petitioner contends that the District did not comply with the following portions of the agreement:
A. Counseling related to sexual behavior.
B. Other counseling.
C. Behavior management component.
D. After school services.
Whether the District provided services in conformance with each of these provisions of the agreement shall be examined separately.
A. Counseling related to sexual behavior.
The agreement called for at least ten sessions of sexual behavior counseling to be provided by Dr. Demetral, an expert in the field of sexual behavior, with additional sessions to be provided if Dr. Demetral deemed them to be necessary. There is no dispute that Dr. Demetral provided less than ten sessions before he determined that sexual counseling was not helpful. Petitioner contends that the District should have proposed another counselor to perform the counseling. However, there is no evidence that the PARENTS expressed a desire to continue the counseling after Dr. Demetral ended his services. The record does reflect that MOTHER asked for more information about why Dr. Demetral stopped providing therapy, which he provided in a memorandum dated April 26, 1998. (Dist. Exh. 224-226.) In Dr. Demetral’s professional opinion, the therapy sessions were not productive because STUDENT refused to participate. However, the agreement clearly called for provision of at least ten sessions. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide services in conformance with the agreement.
B. Other counseling.
The agreement indicated that STUDENT would receive one hour per week of counseling to address impulse control, anger management, tolerance training and self-control issues. Petitioner contends that the District did not provide appropriate services because Dr. Mattesich arbitrarily shortened the sessions to forty-five minutes and because no replacement psychologist was provided when Dr. Mattesich left the District’s employ in early June 1998.
Dr. Mattesich testified that he began with one-hour therapy sessions, but found that STUDENT was unable to focus for that length of time, resulting in conflict and unproductive time at the end of the sessions. Dr. Mattesich also testified that, in his experience, the therapist uses his professional opinion to determine the appropriate session length. However, because the agreement specified that the sessions would be one hour long, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet its obligation under the agreement.
Dr. Mattesich left the District’s employ on June 12, 1998. The evidence is uncontroverted that STUDENT did not receive any counseling from that date forward. Ms. Kort testified that another psychologist is currently assigned to STUDENT’s case, but she also stated that the new psychologist has never met STUDENT. Although MOTHER did request that the after-school program and transportation services cease on July 8, 1998, she did not ask that the counseling end. The District did not ensure that the counseling continued after Dr. Mattesich left and did not offer continuing counseling services until August 7, 1998. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide services in accordance with the agreement because it did not provide any counseling services after the beginning of June 1998.
C. Behavior management component.
According to the agreement, STUDENT’s program was to include a behavior management component that would be shared with his parents and his service providers to ensure a consistent approach to handling his behavior. The behavior management plan was to be coordinated by the psychologist providing the counseling. The witnesses at the hearing from both sides testified that one of STUDENT’s most significant needs is a consistent, individualized behavior management plan. (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Miller, Ms. Lewis, Mr. Johnson, Ms. Uplinger.) The Petitioner contends that there was never a coordinated, consistent, individualized behavior management plan for STUDENT.
Dr. Mattesich was the psychologist charged with coordinating the behavior management component. He testified that the IEP team determined that CVTC’s social effectiveness training (SET) program was to be the behavior management component. However, there is no IEP document that reflects that decision.(Footnote 2) Moreover, the District staff running the after-school component never used the SET program. Neither of the behavioral aides were trained in using SET. Eric Sharar, the teacher, testified that he received two out of three days of SET training, but that he never received the paperwork necessary for implementing the program. MOTHER was not able to attend one of the SET training sessions, and she testified that she was never given alternative training dates. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide a coordinated behavior management component for STUDENT.
Even assuming the SET program had been consistently applied, it was never an individualized plan. Ms. Patti Uplinger from CVTC testified that it is a program used with all their clients. There was no evidence that the program was modified to conform to STUDENT’s unique needs. The District did not propose creating an individualized behavior plan until May, after STUDENT’s behavior was clearly out of control.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that, by failing to provide a consistent, individualized behavior plan for STUDENT, the District failed to provide services in conformance with the January 1998 agreement.
D. After school services.
The District agreed to provide STUDENT with afternoon programming from the end of the CVTC program until 5:15 p.m., with at least three hours per week of instruction from a credentialed teacher. The Petitioner contends that the activities the behavioral aides and Mr. Sharar did with STUDENT did not provide educational benefit. However, the evidence clearly established that the District did comply with the terms of the agreement. It provided continuous services with far more than three hours per week of instruction from a teacher (Mr. Sharar was with STUDENT for more than one hour every day). Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided services that conformed to this provision of the agreement. *** The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide the full number of sexual behavior counseling sessions was a de minimus violation of the agreement that does not entitle STUDENT to a remedy. Dr. Demetral determined before ten sessions were provided that further therapy would not be beneficial. Dr. Demetral’s memorandum clearly states that STUDENT was not benefitting from the therapy sessions. Similarly, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mattesich’s shortening of the session length for the other counseling was a de minimus violation of the agreement. Dr. Mattesich concluded in his professional opinion that the additional fifteen minutes was not providing any benefit.
However, by not providing STUDENT with any counseling services after June 12, 1998, or with a consistent, individualized behavior plan, the Hearing Officer finds that the District substantially violated the agreement. This violation resulted in a failure to serve STUDENT’s unique needs for ongoing counseling and behavior management. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not provide STUDENT with services in conformance with the agreement and that, as a remedy for the contractual violation, STUDENT is entitled to a finding that the District denied him a FAPE from January 28, 1998, through the end of the 1997-98 school year.
2. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year?
The Petitioner contends that the District has not provided a written offer of placement for the 1998-99 school year. The Petitioner asserts that the August 1998 offer of the BETA program does not constitute a proper offer of placement because the description of the BETA program is not specific enough.
The IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes a placement for a student. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3)(A-B). In Union School District v. Smith, (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, the court stated, "this formal requirement has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." The court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parent of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the Hearing Officer for the appropriateness of the placement. Smith, at 1526. In addition, California law defines special education placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs.” 5 C.C.R. § 3042(a). Thus, a written offer must adequately describe those elements to constitute an offer of placement.
The program described in the August 1998 settlement offer and the BETA proposal does not meet the California definition of special education placement. The proposal also did not specify facilities, personnel, or location for the program. The BETA proposal provided significant information about how BETA operates and its philosophical approach to behavior management. However, the very nature of BETA’s services make it impossible to describe the specific program for STUDENT until BETA staff have met and evaluated STUDENT. (Testimony of Dr. Marone.) BETA programs are very individualized. The approaches used and the daily schedule depend entirely on the specific client’s needs. Moreover, the BETA proposal clearly indicates that it may take up to twelve weeks to develop and implement the program. The District had no clear proposal for serving STUDENT during that time, other than to continue his monitoring program at Los Felice.
While BETA may prove to be able to develop a very successful program for STUDENT, it has not yet done so. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has not met its burden of making a placement offer and, as a result, has not offered a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year.(Footnote 3)
3. Is STUDENT entitled to placement at Centre for Neuroskills (CNS) in Bakersfield, California?
Although the District has not offered a FAPE for the 1998-99 school year, STUDENT is not automatically entitled to attend the program his parents have proposed.(Footnote 4) Rather, he would be entitled to attend CNS only if it can provide an appropriate education in the least restrictive environment. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” 458 U.S. 176, 200. At issue in this case is whether CNS can serve STUDENT’s unique needs and provide educational benefit in the least restrictive environment.
A. The CNS Program.(Footnote 5)
CNS primarily serves adults with traumatic brain injury (TBI), but it has had developmentally disabled clients in the past. The focus of CNS programming is to address the many problems presented by TBI patients, including severe behavior problems. The program has several components, including counseling, occupational therapy, physical therapy, educational therapy, vocational therapy, and behavior management. The program proposed for STUDENT includes three hours of various therapies in the morning, depending on his needs. Mr. Ninomiya testified that STUDENT would probably receive counseling, and that they would determine which of the other therapies he needed. STUDENT’s afternoon program would consist of activities taking place with other clients in an activity room. At the end of the day, STUDENT would be transported to the residential facility, an assisted-living apartment complex where the rooms are constantly monitored by video camera. STUDENT would have one-on-one support all day long, both at the therapy site and at the apartments.
CNS would develop a behavior management plan for STUDENT. CNS places significant emphasis on ensuring that the clients comply with instructions and commands. To obtain compliant behavior, the staff uses both positive and negative reinforcement. STUDENT would receive positive feedback such as verbal praise and the opportunity to participate in activities he prefers. The negative reinforcement would consist of the denial of privileges and physical prompts and restraints, including prone containment if STUDENT is presenting a danger to himself or others. If a client’s behavior is completely out of control, he may be placed in a padded time-out room, where the lights can be dimmed and the door held shut until the client is under control. CNS would also attempt to alter STUDENT’s behaviors by providing reality therapy to teach STUDENT the difference between reality and his fantasies. The staff would confront STUDENT with his behavior in an attempt to teach him to avoid it in the future. CNS would provide relaxation therapy to help STUDENT to learn to control his own responses and behavior. Mr. Ninomiya indicated that STUDENT would not be allowed to go into the community, participate in supported employment, or participate in large group situations until his behavior is under control.
B. Can the CNS program serve STUDENT’s unique needs in the least restrictive environment?
STUDENT’s unique needs undisputedly include consistent, individualized behavior management; one-on-one support services; vocational and independent living skills instruction; speech and language services; and counseling.(Footnote 6) (Testimony of MOTHER, Dr. Miller, Thomas Johnson, Sharon Lewis, Dr. Mattesich, Ms. Uplinger.) Although many witnesses testified that STUDENT needs a behavior program that is applied consistently by all the individuals dealing with him, only MOTHER testified that STUDENT needed a residential program. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not establish that STUDENT needs a residential program to benefit from his education. In fact, STUDENT’s sexually assaultive behavior occurred only while he was in a residential program. It has not recurred since he returned to Lodi in November 1997.
The Petitioner asserts that he needs a structured, safe environment with the rigid behavior plan offered by CNS. However, many other witnesses testified that STUDENT does not respond well to such an approach. In his detailed FAA, Dr. Stillwell reported that STUDENT reacts badly to authoritarian figures and to being ordered about. He determined that being compelled to perform a particular task can trigger STUDENT’s aggressive behavior. The District’s witnesses concurred, concluding that a program that emphasizes commands and compliance would not be appropriate for STUDENT. (Testimony of Dr. Miller, Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis.) Several witnesses testified that, because of his significant size, it is very important not to teach STUDENT that it is appropriate to use physical force to impose one’s will. As such, it is inappropriate to use physical restraints to compel STUDENT to comply. (Testimony of Ms. Lewis, Dr. Miller, Mr. Johnson.)
Dr. Stillwell found that another trigger for aggressive behavior was lack of flexibility in programming. MOTHER also testified that the people working with STUDENT must be flexible and willing to accommodate STUDENT’s activity choices, within reason. The District staff testified that the lack of flexibility in the programming at CNS would be very difficult for STUDENT to handle. (Testimony of Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis.) An additional behavior trigger for STUDENT is having a feeling that he is being observed. (Dist. Exh. 94-95.) Ms. Lewis and Mr. Johnson, both of whom visited CNS, testified that the program has a “fishbowl” atmosphere where the clients are constantly observed, even in the apartments. Mr. Johnson, who has worked with STUDENT since approximately 1994-95, expressed the opinion that the constant observation would intensify STUDENT’s behavior problems.
Psychotherapy is a significant element of the behavior modification program proposed for STUDENT at CNS. Mr. Ninomiya testified that he would use both reality therapy and cognitive therapy with STUDENT to force STUDENT to confront and take responsibility for his behavior. Dr. Mattesich, who has worked with STUDENT at various times since elementary school, testified that traditional counseling was not proving to be very helpful with STUDENT. Dr. Mattesich indicated that confronting STUDENT with issues and his behavior is not productive. Any such issues must be approached tangentially. Dr. Mattesich also testified that STUDENT was unable to attend and focus for a full hour of therapy, which is the session length proposed by CNS. Dr. Mattesich expressed the opinion that STUDENT needs a behavioral approach rather than a psychotherapeutic approach to learn behavior that will help him be successful in society.
The District staff also expressed concern about CNS not allowing STUDENT to go into the community for an extensive period of time. The evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT learns functional living and vocational skills best when practicing them in a real environment. (Testimony of Mr. Johnson, Ms. Lewis, Ms. Platt, Mr. Lopez.) Without an opportunity to go into the community, STUDENT would be unable to practice skills such as bus riding and grocery shopping and would not have an opportunity to learn vocational skills in a real work environment.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the CNS program is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The focus of the behavior management approach on commands, compliance, and physical contact are inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer concurs that it is essential not to teach STUDENT that it is acceptable to use force to obtain compliance. The heavy emphasis on psychotherapy and the rigid therapy schedule also would not serve STUDENT’s need for a behavioral approach and flexibility. Moreover, the evidence established that the extremely restrictive, “fishbowl” environment is more likely to trigger STUDENT’s aggressive behavior than to eliminate it. The Hearing Officer further finds that separating STUDENT from contact with the community makes CNS a more restrictive environment than STUDENT requires. The evidence established that STUDENT’s aggressive behavior usually does not occur in the community and that he prefers to participate in activities in the community. According to the evidence, STUDENT is a cooperative, social young man at least eighty percent of the time. STUDENT takes great pleasure in participating in activities in the community, including fishing, bowling, and shopping, and is almost always well-behaved during those activities. The evidence did not establish that it is necessary for STUDENT to be isolated on a twenty-four hour basis in an environment consisting solely of disabled individuals.
The Hearing Officer concludes that CNS cannot serve STUDENT’s needs and does not provide the least restrictive environment, and, therefore, that CNS is not an appropriate placement for STUDENT.
4. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory educational services?
The Supreme Court in Burlington School Committee v. Massachusetts Dept. of Education, (1985) 471 U.S. 358, concluded that parents may be compensated for expenses they have incurred in educating their child when the school failed to provide an appropriate program. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See, e.g., Lester H. v. K. Gihool and the Chester Upland School District (3d Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865, Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. Courts that have adopted compensatory education as a remedy for children whose rights to a FAPE have been violated by a school district have traditionally analyzed the issue in terms of whether the violations resulted in a loss to the child in skills or educational opportunity.
The Petitioner asserts that the District’s failure to provide a FAPE from January 28, 1998, forward entitles him to compensatory education in the form of an extension of the period of time for which he will be eligible for special education. As discussed above, the District failed to serve STUDENT’s most critical need, behavior management, from January 28, 1998, forward. As a result, STUDENT’s behavior escalated on many occasions, denying him various educational opportunities. For example, STUDENT’s behavior made it impossible for him to work in a supported employment situation, which was one of his goals for the year. STUDENT’s behavior also resulted in his being discharged from CVTC, leaving him with no defined program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide a FAPE resulted in a loss of educational opportunity and that STUDENT is entitled to receive compensatory education. To date, the District has deprived STUDENT of appropriate services for at least eight months and does not have an appropriate program immediately available for him. Under the law, STUDENT will be eligible for special education services from the District through December 31, 2000, after his twenty-second birthday. Giving STUDENT an additional eight or nine months of eligibility would require the District to provide services into the first semester of the 2001-02 school year. The law requires districts to continue serving students through the end of the semester during which eligibility expires. Therefore, as compensatory education, the District shall continue to provide services to STUDENT through December 31, 2001.
ORDER
1. Within ten days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT that will provide consistent, individualized behavior management; one-on-one support services; vocational and independent living skills instruction; speech and language services, and counseling. If this program will be designed by an outside agency, the District shall ensure that a representative of that agency attends the IEP team meeting. The District shall also ensure that STUDENT has an appropriate interim placement until the program is fully operational, with staff hired and trained and a location ready for the program.(Footnote 7)
2. The District shall provide special education services to STUDENT through December 31, 2001. If an appropriate program is not fully operational by December 31, 1998, the District’s duty to serve STUDENT shall be extended by an amount of time equal to the additional time it takes for the program to be fully operational.
3. The District is not obligated to place STUDENT at CNS.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Issue 1: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 2: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
Issue 3: The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue 4: The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
Date: September 30, 1998 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. This was the first time in approximately seven years that STUDENT had lived at home. Previously, he had lived in various group homes. 2. The IEP dated March 26, 1998, does describe some discussion of recording behavior data and use of consequences, but it does not reflect the formal adoption of a specific behavior plan. (Dist. Exh. 213-214.) 3.The Hearing Officer notes that this is not a finding that a program designed by BETA would be inappropriate for STUDENT. In fact, the evidence at the hearing demonstrated that the proactive, preventive, non-physical approach BETA uses may be the best way to teach STUDENT how to control his own behavior. 4. STUDENT has never attended the CNS program.
5.This summary of the CNS program is based upon the testimony of Mr. Ninomiya, the CNS brochures (Dist. Addendum A), and the CNS proposal for serving STUDENT (Dist. Exh. 328-333). 6. Although Mr. Johnson and Dr. Mattesich questioned whether STUDENT’s current speech/language and counseling programs are productive, the appropriateness of these services was not presented as an issue for hearing. 7. As noted earlier in this decision, there is no finding that the BETA program is substantively inappropriate for STUDENT. Therefore, the District is entitled to engage BETA to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT
