Restraint and Seclusion in California Schools
Last reviewed: November 2026
California schools may physically restrain a student, or place a student alone in a room the student can’t leave, only to control behavior that poses a clear and present danger of serious physical harm to the student or others, and only when that danger can’t be immediately prevented by a less forceful response. (Ed. Code § 49005.4.) Restraint and seclusion are emergency measures, not teaching tools. They can’t be used as discipline or punishment, to force a student to comply, for staff convenience, or in retaliation. (Ed. Code § 49005.8.)
The rules exist because restraint and seclusion are dangerous. The Legislature has found that they can cause serious injury, long-lasting trauma, and death, even when done correctly; that there is no evidence they reduce the behaviors that lead to their use; and that students with disabilities and students of color are restrained and secluded at disproportionate rates. (Ed. Code § 49005.) A 2009 federal investigation found hundreds of allegations of abuse and death from restraint and seclusion at schools between 1990 and 2009, almost all involving children with disabilities, including at least 20 in which a restraint led to a child’s death. According to the U.S. Department of Education, students with disabilities are 12 percent of public school students but 75 percent of the students who are physically restrained at school and 58 percent of those who are secluded. Being restrained or isolated can be deeply frightening to a child who doesn’t understand what is happening and when, or even that, it will end. Staff who use these techniques are often reacting to behavior they weren’t trained to prevent. The law’s answer is to require positive behavior supports that address the reasons for the behavior, so that emergencies happen rarely, if ever.
What the Law Prohibits
California law prohibits schools from:
- Using restraint or seclusion to force a student to comply, as discipline, for staff convenience, or in retaliation.
- Locking a student alone in a room, unless the facility is licensed or permitted by state law to use a locked room.
- Using a restraint that blocks a student’s airway or makes it harder to breathe, including putting pressure on the student’s back or placing body weight against the student’s torso or back.
- Covering a student’s face with a pillow, blanket, mat, or anything else.
- Using prone (face-down) restraint.
- Keeping a student restrained any longer than necessary to contain the dangerous behavior.
(Ed. Code § 49005.8(a).) Staff must keep a student who is in seclusion under constant, direct observation, in person and not by camera, and must use the least restrictive form of restraint that keeps everyone safe. (Ed. Code § 49005.8(b)–(c).) Schools are told to avoid restraint and seclusion whenever possible. (Ed. Code § 49005.6.) Each district must report every year how often it used restraint and seclusion, and post the numbers on its website. (Ed. Code § 49006.)
For students in special education, California law separately prohibits behavioral interventions that are designed or likely to cause pain. It also prohibits spraying unpleasant substances near the student’s face; denying a student adequate sleep, food, water, shelter, bedding, physical comfort, or access to the bathroom; subjecting a student to verbal abuse, ridicule, or humiliation, or to anything else that can cause excessive emotional trauma; immobilizing all four limbs at once; leaving the student without adequate supervision; and depriving the student of one or more senses. (Ed. Code § 56521.2(a).) Corporal punishment, meaning deliberately causing a student physical pain, is prohibited in every California public school. (Ed. Code § 49001.)
Districts sometimes point to an older statute that protects teachers and other credentialed staff from criminal prosecution for using the same degree of physical control over a student that a parent could lawfully use, but never more than is reasonably necessary to maintain order, protect property, or protect the health and safety of students. (Ed. Code § 44807.) That statute is a limited defense to criminal charges. It doesn’t authorize restraint that the restraint and seclusion laws prohibit, and it doesn’t excuse a failure to follow a student’s behavior plan.
When a Student in Special Education Is Restrained
When a school uses an emergency intervention, such as physical restraint, on a student in special education:
- Notice within one school day. The school must notify the parent within one school day. (Ed. Code § 56521.1(e).)
- A written report. The school must immediately complete a behavioral emergency report and keep it in the student’s file. The report must describe the incident and the intervention used, where it happened, which staff were involved, whether the student has a behavior plan, and any injuries. The school doesn’t have to send you a copy unless you ask, so ask in writing. (Ed. Code § 56521.1(e).)
- An IEP meeting within two days. If the student doesn’t have a behavior intervention plan, an administrator must, within two days, schedule an IEP meeting to review the report and decide whether to assess the student’s behavior and whether an interim plan is needed. If the team decides against either one, it has to write down why. If the student already has a plan, the team must meet to review it when the behavior wasn’t covered by the plan or the plan isn’t working. (Ed. Code § 56521.1(g)–(h).)
Emergency interventions can never take the place of a behavior plan. The law says the school can’t use them as a substitute for the positive behavioral supports a student needs, and can use only the amount of force that is reasonable and necessary, and only for as long as necessary. (Ed. Code § 56521.1(b)–(c).)
Related:
When Restraint Happens More than Once
Repeated restraint or seclusion is a sign that something in the student’s program isn’t working. Federal civil rights guidance makes three points that parents can use:
- It can mean the student needs to be assessed. If a student who doesn’t have an IEP or 504 plan is being restrained or secluded because of behavior, the school may have reason to suspect a disability, which triggers its duty to assess the student.
- It can mean the current plan needs to change. For a student who already has an IEP or 504 plan, repeated restraint or seclusion suggests the student’s behavioral needs aren’t being met, and the school should reassess the student and revisit the plan.
- It can itself deny the student an appropriate education. Being restrained or secluded can be traumatic, and the effects, such as new behaviors, trouble concentrating, or more absences, can keep a student from benefiting from school even if it never happens again. When that happens, the team has to decide what services the student needs to make up for it.
(Dear Colleague Letter: Restraint and Seclusion of Students with Disabilities (OCR Dec. 28, 2016).) The Office for Civil Rights has resolved complaints about restraint and seclusion by requiring districts to adopt new policies, train staff, and provide make-up services to students. If your child has been restrained or secluded more than once, ask in writing for an IEP meeting and a new behavior assessment, and ask the team to address the effect the restraint has had on your child.
When Restraint Is Not an Emergency
When a student’s behavior plan calls for positive strategies and staff restrain the student instead, that can be a failure to follow the student’s IEP if it was not done in response to a real emergency. It can also be a basis for a claim for money damages.
In Student v. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District (OAH Case No. 2019090404), a nonverbal student’s behavior plans called for praise, reinforcement, and calming strategies, and included no emergency interventions. His aide instead held and twisted his arms, and used techniques intended to cause pain to make him comply. The judge held that this was a significant failure to follow his IEP, found that it caused him to regress, and ordered substantial specialized services to help make up for his loss.
In A.G. v. Paradise Valley Unified School District No. 69 (9th Cir. 2016), an Arizona case, a seventh grader’s IEP said she would not be restrained unless she was a danger to herself or others. School staff physically restrained her, and a police officer working at the school handcuffed her. Because there was evidence that she posed no danger on those occasions, the Ninth Circuit held that her claims for assault, battery, and false imprisonment could go to trial. California law recognizes the same claims.
What to Do If Your Child Was Restrained or Secluded
- Ask for the records in writing, including the behavioral emergency report, any incident reports, and any video. Ask the district to preserve the video.
- Ask for an IEP meeting if the district hasn’t scheduled one, and ask for a functional behavioral assessment (an assessment of what triggers the behavior and what purpose it serves for your child) if your child doesn’t have one. The goal is a behavior plan that prevents the situations that led to the restraint.
- Get medical care if your child was hurt, and photograph any injuries.
- Consider a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) if the district didn’t notify you, didn’t complete a report, or didn’t hold the required meeting.
- Talk with an attorney promptly if your child was injured or restrained without an emergency. Claims for money damages against a school district generally require a government claim within six months.
Related:
Was your child restrained or secluded at school? Request a confidential consultation.
Legal sources: 29 U.S.C. § 794; Ed. Code §§ 44807, 49001, 49005, 49005.4, 49005.6, 49005.8, 49006, 56521.1, 56521.2; A.G. v. Paradise Valley Unified Sch. Dist. No. 69, 815 F.3d 1195 (9th Cir. 2016); Student v. Santa Monica-Malibu Unified Sch. Dist., OAH Case No. 2019090404 (Feb. 18, 2020); Dear Colleague Letter: Restraint and Seclusion of Students with Disabilities (OCR Dec. 28, 2016).
