Do I Have to Go through Due Process before Suing? (Exhaustion after Fry and Perez)
Last reviewed: November 2026
Sometimes, but much less often than before 2017. A family has to go through a special education due process hearing before suing under the ADA or Section 504 only when the lawsuit is really about the denial of a free appropriate public education and seeks a remedy the IDEA can provide. A lawsuit about something else, or one seeking money damages for discrimination, can usually go straight to court. (Fry v. Napoleon Community Schools (U.S. 2017); Luna Perez v. Sturgis Public Schools (U.S. 2023).)
The requirement to go through due process first is called exhaustion (the family must exhaust the IDEA’s administrative remedies). It comes from a provision of the IDEA that applies when a lawsuit under another law seeks “relief that is also available under” the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(l).) Congress wanted special education disputes decided first by hearing officers who know the field, and courts historically interpreted broadly the requirement that a specialized hearing officer hear the complaint first, so that later courts would have a record to review.
What Fry Decided
In Fry, a school refused to let a student bring her service dog to school. The Supreme Court held that exhaustion turns on the gravamen, or essential substance, of the lawsuit, not on the labels the family uses. If the lawsuit isn’t really about the student’s special education, exhaustion isn’t required. The Court offered two questions to help decide:
- Could the family have brought essentially the same claim if the conduct had happened at a public facility that wasn’t a school, such as a public library?
- Could an adult at the school, such as an employee or visitor, have brought essentially the same claim?
If the answer to both is yes, the lawsuit probably isn’t about the denial of FAPE. A claim that a school building has no wheelchair ramp passes both tests. A claim that a student wasn’t given enough reading instruction fails both.
What Perez Decided
Perez went further. A deaf student’s school gave him an aide who didn’t know sign language and told his parents for years that he was on track to graduate. Shortly before graduation, the school said he would receive a certificate, not a diploma. The family settled the IDEA case and then sued under the ADA for money damages. The Supreme Court held that exhaustion applies only when the lawsuit seeks a remedy the IDEA can provide. Compensatory damages aren’t available under the IDEA, so a lawsuit seeking them doesn’t have to go through due process first, even if it grows out of the same facts as a FAPE dispute.
What This Means in Practice
- A family that wants services (compensatory education, a change of placement, reimbursement for a private school) generally has to go through due process. Those are IDEA remedies.
- A family that wants money damages for discrimination can usually sue under the ADA or Section 504 without going through due process first.
- Many families want both, and the two cases can proceed separately. Settling a due process case doesn’t necessarily end a damages claim, but a settlement agreement’s release language may. Read any release carefully before signing.
Some lawsuits seeking services still don’t require exhaustion. The Ninth Circuit held that students challenging a county office of education’s systemic policy of shortening the school day for students with autism didn’t have to file individual due process cases first. (Christopher S. v. Stanislaus County Office of Education (9th Cir. 2004).) And since 2025, students bringing education-related discrimination claims don’t have to prove that school officials acted in “bad faith or gross misjudgment,” which used to be a major obstacle in these cases. (A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schools (U.S. 2025).)
Deadlines Still Matter
Choosing not to file for due process doesn’t stop the clock on the IDEA claims. A due process complaint must generally be filed within two years of when you knew or should have known about the problem. (Ed. Code § 56505(l).) The deadlines for discrimination lawsuits are different and can be shorter, and claims against a public entity under California law usually require a government claim within six months. (Gov. Code § 911.2.) A family considering both kinds of claims should get legal advice early.
Related:
Considering a discrimination claim? Request a consultation.
Legal sources: 20 U.S.C. § 1415(l); Ed. Code § 56505(l); Gov. Code § 911.2; Fry v. Napoleon Cmty. Schs., 580 U.S. 154 (2017); Luna Perez v. Sturgis Pub. Schs., 598 U.S. 142 (2023); A.J.T. v. Osseo Area Schs., 605 U.S. 335 (2025); Christopher S. v. Stanislaus County Office of Educ., 384 F.3d 1205 (9th Cir. 2004).
