California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 28, 2001
Tamalpais Union High School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1089-01 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary
Tamalpais Union High may reassess an 18-year-old with autism without consent but must add speech and occupational therapy assessments.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated. The decision cites a related SEHO decision between the same parties, issued August 16, 2001, which found that the district did not provide FAPE for 2000-2001, in part because it did not adequately assess the student.
Summary
Tamalpais Union High School District filed for due process to get permission to reassess an 18-year-old student with autism without parental consent. For two years the student had lived in the district and attended the Can Do Home Program, a nonpublic residential program, under stay put. The district had never assessed him. Novato Unified's December 1998 assessment had been found inadequate in a related SEHO decision issued in August 2001. The mother and a co-guardian objected to the district's May 3, 2001 assessment plan. They wanted their own independent assessment done first and said the district was trying to harass them.
The Hearing Officer held that the district had the right to assess. A current assessment was needed, and the law did not require the district to wait for a private evaluation. There was no evidence of harassment, and a possible move out of the district did not make the case moot. The proposed assessors were qualified, and the tests they were likely to use were valid. However, the district wrote the plan without the IEP team review and parent input that Education Code section 56381 requires. It also left out speech-language and occupational therapy assessments, though these were known areas of need. The plan was approved only with those assessments added, and the Hearing Officer directed an IEP meeting limited to parent input on the assessment. The parents' request for a district-funded independent assessment failed because the district had not yet assessed.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to assess without consent. It upheld the district's right to assess but would not approve a plan written without parent input that left out known areas of need. It also held that parents cannot get a publicly funded independent evaluation before the district has done its own assessment.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 1. Does the District have the right to assess STUDENT?
The student's only prior assessment, from 1998, had been found inadequate, so a new assessment was needed. The district's right to assess did not depend on the parents first finishing a private assessment, there was no evidence of harassment, and a possible move out of the district did not make the case moot.
- Student prevailed in partDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue 2. Is the assessment proposed by the District appropriate?
The plan met the notice requirements of Education Code section 56321, the assessors were qualified, and the likely tests were valid. However, the plan was written without the IEP team review and parent input required by section 56381, and it left out speech-language and occupational therapy assessments. The plan was appropriate only with those assessments added.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. The district may assess the student without parental consent under its May 3, 2001 assessment plan, with assessments by a speech and language specialist or therapist and an occupational therapist added.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. In the body of the decision, the Hearing Officer directed the district to give the parent and co-guardian a chance to return to the IEP team review stage under Education Code section 56381. The meeting's sole purpose is to consider their input on the elements of the assessment; it may not reopen issues this decision resolved. No deadline was set.
Key authorities
Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District (5th Cir. 1995) 64 F.3d 176; Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; Cal. Educ. Code § 56321; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56506(e); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329
People named in the decision
- Sandra Piotter, Director of instructional services, Tamalpais Union High School District
- Karen Mates, Special education program manager; prepared assessment plan, Marin County Office of Education
- Joscelyn Boudreau, School psychologist; proposed assessor, Marin County Office of Education / District
- Kim Cochrane, Special education teacher (severely handicapped special day class), Redwood High School; proposed assessor, Tamalpais Union High School District
- Terry Sullivan, Special education program manager; alternate assessor, Marin County Office of Education
- Diane Martin, Ph.D., Assessor who conducted the December 1998 assessment, Novato Unified School District
- Can Do Home Program, Nonpublic residential program serving the student, Nonpublic program
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (“Hearing Office”), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Rafael, California, on July 5 and 6, and August 28, 2001.
Petitioner Tamalpais Union High School District (District) was represented on July 4 and 5, 2001, by attorney Kimberley Schulist, and on August 28, 2001, by attorney Jan E. Tomsky, both of the law firm Lozano Smith.(Footnote 1) Sandra Piotter, director of instructional services, was also present for the District on all hearing days.
The Respondent, STUDENT, was represented on July 4 and 5, 2001, by his mother, PARENT, and by his “co-guardian,” CAREGIVER.(Footnote 2) Ms CAREGIVER is also the director of the Can Do Home Program (CDHP), the nonpublic residential program in which STUDENT was enrolled at the time of the hearing. No one was present to represent STUDENT on the third and last hearing day on August 28, 2001.(Footnote 3) Having determined that STUDENT and his representatives were given proper notice and an opportunity to be heard at the hearing, the Hearing Officer allowed the District to present the remainder of its case. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Petitioner presented an oral closing argument. The Respondent’s written closing argument was read into the record.(Footnote 4) The matter was then submitted for decision.
ISSUES(Footnote 5)
1. Does the District have the right to assess STUDENT?
2. Is the assessment proposed by the District appropriate?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is an eighteen-year-old autistic student who is eligible for and receiving special education and related services. At the time of the hearing and for the two previous years, STUDENT was residing within the District’s jurisdictional boundaries and receiving special education and related services at CDHP. During his entire time as a resident of the District, STUDENT has never attended a public school-based program. The District had most recently been providing the CDHP placement as stay put in a related case.
According to the testimony of Sandra Piotter, STUDENT has never been assessed by the District. His last assessment was in December 1998 and was conducted by the Novato Unified School District (NUSD). A copy of that assessment was not offered into evidence at the hearing. However, in a related action between these same parties, on August 16, 2001, a Hearing Officer issued a decision that questioned the adequacy of that 1998 assessment and found that the District did not adequately identify STUDENT’s unique needs through appropriate assessments. Referring to the 1998 assessment of STUDENT, the Decision states:
. . . NUSD’s assessor, Diane Martin, Ph.D., wrote a scant five-page report that contained only cursory analyses of STUDENT’s functioning in the areas of self-help, social, communication, and academic skills. There is no evidence that STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills [were] assessed by a speech and language therapist or anyone else qualified to assess in the area, even though language is one of STUDENT’s major areas of deficit. Additionally, Dr. Martin’s findings regarding STUDENT’s functioning consisted mainly of generalities and qualitative comparisons without the benefit of supporting facts. . . . She also did not provide any analysis with regard to STUDENT’s abilities or the type of specialized instruction he needed because of his unique needs.
(Tamalpais Union High School District v. STUDENT (2001) SEHO Case No. SN01-01089)
On or about March 1, 2001, during the due process hearing in the other matter, Ms. Piotter delivered to Ms. PARENT an assessment plan dated February 5, 2001 (Respondent’s Exhibit A).(Footnote 6) Ms. PARENT responded with a March 14, 2001 letter (Exhibits 7 and B) stating her opinion that it was inappropriate to begin the assessment process during that hearing. She suggested that the parties discuss the need for further assessment of STUDENT when that hearing was over. Ms. Piotter responded by urging Ms. PARENT to reconsider, but ultimately the District agreed to postpone consideration if Ms. PARENT signed a waiver of the time requirements for the assessment and annual review of STUDENT’s individual education plan (IEP). Ms. PARENT signed the waiver.
Ms. Piotter testified that when she agreed to postpone the assessment and annual review, she believed the hearing in that other matter would be concluded by mid-April, 2001. It eventually became apparent to her that the matter would not be concluded until much later. In addition, CAREGIVER told her that the co-guardians were doing their own independent assessment. Ms. Piotter decided that the District needed to proceed with its own assessment without awaiting the conclusion of the other hearing. She testified that her decision was motivated by her belief that STUDENT’s interests would be best served by completing the assessment in time to provide information upon which the IEP team could rely for planning the upcoming school year. While the actual triennial assessment due date was not until December 2001, some eight months later, she stated that the annual meeting could have taken place in September 2001. Additionally, STUDENT had just turned eighteen on April 5, 2001. Ms. Piotter was of the opinion that this was a significant benchmark which justified the need for an assessment and review before the actual triennial assessment date. For these reasons, Ms. Piotter directed Karen Mates, a special education program manager for the Marin County Office of Education (MCOE), to prepare a new assessment plan. On April 24, she wrote to Ms. PARENT to inform her that the District wanted to proceed with the assessment. (Exhibits 4 and E).
Karen Mates joined the MCOE in July 2000 as a program manager. She holds a master’s degree in deaf education and education administration and California special education credentials in mild to moderate and in education administration. She has more than fourteen years of experience in the field of special education, including teaching the deaf, emotionally disturbed and learning disabled. She founded and operated a nonpublic school known as STARS for children with special needs before joining the MCOE.
The plan was not developed at or as a result of an IEP meeting, and there was no evidence that input for the plan was obtained from STUDENT’s parents. Ms. Mates testified that she prepared the May 3, 2001 assessment plan (Exhibits 3 and F) with the assistance of special education teacher Kim Cochrane and school psychologist Joscelyn Boudreau.
The plan stated that the purpose of the assessment was to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education as part of a three-year reevaluation. It provided that the assessment might include evaluation in the areas of self-help, cognitive ability and behavior. It did not include reference to possible testing in the areas of motor abilities or receptive and expressive language. The actual parent consent form indicated that the assessment would be completed by a psychologist and a resource specialist, but the attached pages also indicated the possible participation of the special day class (SDC) teacher. The consent form also advised that no educational placement would result from the evaluation without the parents’ written consent.
The plan does not identify the assessors by name, but simply states that a school psychologist, a special education teacher, and a resource specialist will complete the assessment. According to the testimony of Karen Mates and Ms. Piotter, both Ms. Boudreau and Ms. Cochrane had experience assessing autistic students, including another student from CDHP. At the time the plan was drafted, it was anticipated that Ms. Cochrane would conduct the portions of the assessment related to STUDENT’s achievement, which might include administration of the Brigance Inventory of Basic Skills (Brigance) and an observation and informal comparative assessment. It was expected that Ms. Boudreau would conduct those portions of the assessment dealing with cognitive development and behaviors, which might include the Comprehensive Test of Non-Verbal Intelligence (CTONI), Draw a Person, the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (Kaufman), the Stanford Benet Intelligence Scale - Fourth Edition (Stanford Benet), the AAMD Adaptive Behavior Scale (AAMD), the Comprehensive Autism Rating Scale, and the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales.
Joscelyn Boudreau testified about her involvement in the preparation of the assessment plan and her anticipated involvement in the assessment itself. Ms. Boudreau has a master’s degree and a California Pupil Personnel Services credential as a school psychologist. She conducts or participates in forty to sixty assessments per year. Since 1995, she has assessed twenty to thirty autistic students between the ages of five and twenty-two years. Approximately half of those were sixteen to eighteen years old.
Ms. Boudreau stated that she spoke with Karen Mates about the triennial assessment for STUDENT. From the information given to her by Ms. Mates and from her own review of the report of the last triennial assessment, Ms. Boudreau believed that STUDENT experienced global developmental delays in all areas, including language, social, independent living skills, fine and gross motor skills and academics.(Footnote 7) She believed that STUDENT was functioning in the one- to six-year-old range. Her recommendations regarding the planned assessment were based on this belief.
Ms. Boudreau confirmed that she had advised Ms. Mates to indicate specific tests which she may want to administer to STUDENT as part of the assessment. At the time of the hearing, however, she believed that she would be likely to administer only the CTONI, the Stanford Benet and the AAMD. (The others listed as possible on the assessment plan, while in her opinion valid for an assessment of an eighteen-year-old autistic student, were more appropriate for use with younger students or students for whom there remained some question about the autism diagnosis.)
According to Ms. Boudreau, the actual testing process would begin with an informal meeting between her and STUDENT, with his parents and guardian also present. Ms. Boudreau would observe and interact with STUDENT to achieve some level of comfort. She would also explore STUDENT’s general level of functioning, particularly his modes of communication. She testified that her efforts would be designed to ensure that the test results were a true reflection of STUDENT’s present levels of development and not simply a reflection of his impaired skills.
Kim Cochrane did not testify.(Footnote 8) Ms. Piotter confirmed the testimony of Karen Mates regarding Ms. Cochrane’s experience dealing with severely disabled students. She holds a master’s degree in education, and multiple subject and severely handicapped (SH) teaching credentials from the State of California. For the last five years she has taught the severely handicapped special day class at Redwood High School, where three of her nine students are diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. Ms. Piotter also testified that Terry Sullivan, a program manager for the MCOE, would assist with the assessment if Ms. Cochrane was unavailable.
Terry Sullivan testified at the hearing. He is a special education program manager for the MCOE. He holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology from California State University, Sonoma, and special education teaching credentials in educable mentally retarded (EMR), learning handicapped (LH) and SH. He has years of special education teaching experience. Most of those were spent in high-school-level SH special day classes for students aged thirteen to twenty-two years. His students have included those diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder, as well as students diagnosed as mentally retarded and developmentally delayed. His experience with autistic students goes back eighteen years. Since then he has taught twenty-five to thirty autistic students. He was responsible not only for teaching these students, but also for their ongoing, annual and triennial assessments, including the preparation of assessment plans. He has experience in all forms of communication relied upon by disabled students, including many kinds of communication boards and other forms of technology.
Mr. Sullivan stated that the tests or procedures identified the May 3, 2001 assessment plan were appropriate. For many years, his practice has been to rely heavily, if not exclusively, on teacher observation and comparative assessment. He would focus on “the individual critical skills model,” which is the basis of the MCOE SH curriculum, at least at the high school level. His focus would be on functional academics, motor skills, independent living skills, community skills and vocational skills. In Mr. Sullivan’s opinion, his observations and comparative assessment would need to be supplemented by an appropriate adaptive behavior analysis. He noted that it is unlikely that he would use the Brigance, though he believes it would be a valid assessment and perhaps useful for measuring STUDENT’s present levels of achievement.
The District filed for this due process hearing on May 22, 2001. On May 24, 2001, Ms. PARENT sent a letter (Exhibits 1 and G) to Ms. Piotter and Ms. Mates acknowledging receipt of the plan and explaining her position that she would not allow an assessment by the District because she did not believe that it could be impartial due to the adversarial nature of the relationship between the District and STUDENT’s guardians (Ms. PARENT and Ms. CAREGIVER). She further states that CAREGIVER was preparing to have STUDENT assessed by independent professionals, and she asks the District to pay for that assessment. Ms. PARENT also questions the qualifications of Ms. Boudreau and others who might participate in the assessment and the appropriateness of the tests and procedures. Finally, she asks why STUDENT was not to be assessed in the areas of speech and language and motor skills (occupational therapy).
Ms. CAREGIVER also wrote to Ms. Piotter on May 29, 2001, to indicate that she would not allow STUDENT to be assessed by the District until they finished with the independent assessment. There was no testimony or other evidence offered at the hearing regarding the status of that assessment or even whether any specific steps had been taken to start that process.
The District did not respond to either of the last two referenced letters. Ms. Piotter stated that even before receiving the May 24, 2001 letter from Ms. PARENT, she believed that the District would not be allowed to assess STUDENT without an order from the Hearing Office. In addition to the tone of the last referenced letters, she testified regarding a discussion between her and CAREGIVER on June 27, 2001. Ms. Piotter stated that she offered to sit down with Ms. CAREGIVER and Ms. PARENT to work out the details of the assessment procedures. The alleged response from Ms. CAREGIVER was a statement by her to Ms. PARENT advising against such a discussion and suggesting that they let the District continue to spend money on their lawyers.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Parties’ Contentions
The District contends that it has the right to assess STUDENT as long as it is required to serve his special education needs under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 et seq. It states that it has not had the benefit of its own assessment since STUDENT entered the District two years ago. Because STUDENT has not been enrolled in a District school-based program during that entire time, there is a need for reliable data regarding his present levels of performance and current needs. The District further contends that the urgency of its need to assess has been recently highlighted by the Decision of the hearing officer in the related matter which concluded, in part, that the District had not provided a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) to STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year due, at least in part, to its failure to properly assess STUDENT to determine his unique needs. It submits that the assessment plan was appropriate and that it should be allowed to conduct the assessment pursuant to that plan without the consent of the parent.
No statement of issues was filed on Respondent’s behalf. During a preliminary discussion of issues to be addressed at the hearing, Ms. CAREGIVER stated that Respondent had no objection to the assessment by the District. However, she stated that it was Respondent’s position that the District’s efforts to assess STUDENT were solely for the purpose of harassment and to interfere with the Respondent’s own, independent assessment. Ms. CAREGIVER explained that Respondent did not want the District to conduct an assessment before the Respondent’s own assessment was completed. The co-guardians also contended that, since it is likely that STUDENT will soon be moving outside the District’s geographical boundaries, the District should have no right to assess him. Ms. CAREGIVER referred the Hearing Officer to the May 24, 2001 letter from Ms. PARENT to the District (Exhibits 1 and G) for additional information regarding Respondent’s contentions.
The May 24, 2001 letter from Ms. PARENT to the District, in addition to the objections stated above: (1) objects to the District’s planned assessment before conclusion of the due process hearing on the FAPE issue in the related matter; (2) objects to any assessment by the District on the grounds that it would not be impartial or appropriate; (3) requests that the District fund the independent assessment; and (4) requests that the District provide additional information concerning its planned assessment. She requested additional information regarding: (a) the background and qualifications of Joscelyn Boudreau; (b) “the success rate with students with autism”; (c) the background of other persons who will participate in the assessment; (d) the familiarity of assessors with STUDENT’s primary mode of communication; (e) why the particular tests or procedures were selected for possible use; (f) whether the tests have been validated for their intended use; (g); what the testing conditions would be and (h) why there was no testing for speech and language and occupational therapy selected. While not mentioned in Ms. PARENT’ letter, Respondent’s closing argument also complained that she was not told that she had fifteen days to make a decision regarding the proposed plan.
The Right to Assess
Both federal and State laws governing special education provide that, before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); California Education Code § 56320. Federal Circuit Courts have held that, if parents want their child to receive special education or related services under the IDEA, they must allow the educational agency to assess the child. There are no exceptions to this requirement. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307, 1315; Andress v. Cleveland Independent School District, (5th Cir. 1995) 64 F.3d 176,178.
Reassessments are to be conducted at least every three years, more frequently if conditions warrant, and when the student’s parent or teacher requests that a reassessment be conducted and a new IEP be developed. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A).
There is no dispute regarding the need for an assessment of STUDENT, nor regarding the District’s right to conduct an assessment. The last assessment was almost three years ago, and that assessment has already been found to have been inadequate by a Decision of the hearing officer in the related case. Finally, according to Ms. CAREGIVER, the co-guardians have planned their own assessment and they have no disagreement with the District’s need for a current assessment. The Hearing Officer finds, consistent with the Decision by the hearing officer in the related case, that an assessment of STUDENT is necessary to fill what amounts to a complete void of data upon which informed educational decisions can be based. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District does have the right to assess STUDENT.
The Appropriateness of the Planned Assessment
A reassessment should begin with an IEP team meeting to review current assessment data (including the results of observations). On the basis of that review and input from the parents, the team should decide what additional data, if any, is needed to determine, among other things, the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs and whether additions or modifications to the student’s program are required to provide a FAPE. From that decision the reassessment plan is developed. The plan should be focused on producing the data identified by the team as necessary to its determinations. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b) and (c).
There was no evidence that the District prepared for the reassessment of STUDENT in the manner prescribed by Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. There was no initial IEP team review of current data on STUDENT. Nor was there a consultation with STUDENT’s parents (or guardians), followed by an informed agreement regarding additional needed data. In this case, the sparse data from the 1998 assessment was of little value, so there was no meaningful current data to review. But the IEP team meeting is also to allow the parents to provide their input regarding reassessment in a collaborative context. While the Hearing Officer has considered the Respondent’s objections and concerns regarding the assessment, the hearing process should not be a substitute for the IEP process . It would be better if the District provided an opportunity to the parents and guardian to return to the IEP team review stage contemplated by Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. The sole purpose of this IEP meeting would be to consider the input of the parents and guardian regarding the elements of a properly focused and successful assessment of STUDENT. It shall not be to reopen, discuss or determine issues disposed of by this Decision.
A proposed assessment plan must: (1) be in language easily understood by the general public; (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent or other mode of communication used by the parent, unless to do so is clearly not feasible; (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted; and, (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent. No assessment shall be conducted without the consent of the parent, who shall have 15 days from the date of receipt of the assessment plan to decide. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321. “Written parental consent pursuant to Section 56321 shall be obtained before any assessment of the pupil is conducted unless the public education agency prevails in a due process hearing relating to the assessment.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56506(e).
The May 3, 2001 assessment plan that was sent to Ms. PARENT (Exhibits 3, pp. 1-3, and F) is in plain English, the parents’ language, and is easily understood. It explains the types of assessments to be done, identifying the purpose of the tests in each area and the specific tests and tools that may be used. Finally, it states that no IEP will be implemented without the parents’ consent. The parents did not consent to the assessment within fifteen days. The District exercised its right to file for due process to obtain an order to allow the assessment without parental consent.
Cal. Educ. Code § 56321 also states that a notice of parent rights shall be attached to the plan. The Respondent admits that such a notice was included but complained that it did not specifically inform her regarding the fifteen days allowed to the parent to decide about the plan. There is no specific requirement that the notice of parent rights include that reference. The notice that was provided with the plan in this case was adequate to notify the parent of the procedural safeguards. The Hearing Officer finds that this particular alleged defect in the notice was, in any event, insignificant. The failure of the parents to consent within fifteen days caused no prejudice to the Respondent. It simply allowed the District to file for due process. Ms. PARENT could have consented to an assessment at any time after the District filed for due process. She could have requested additional time to consider the plan. She could have accepted the invitation of Ms. Piotter to sit down in an effort to work out the details of the assessment. She did none of these things.
Several of the Respondent’s complaints about the plan go to the absence of information regarding the identity and qualification of the persons who would be conducting the assessment. She asks about the background and qualifications of Joscelyn Boudreau and others who will participate. There is no entitlement to such information. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(b). The District can decide who will do the assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.
In her May 24, 2001 letter Ms. PARENT also questioned the thoroughness of the assessments contemplated by the plan. Specifically, she asked why no assessment by speech and language and occupational therapists were included in the plan. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381 requires that the reassessment be designed to generate the data specifically identified by the IEP team as necessary. In this particular case, the District was, in effect, starting over because it had no useful data to review. It needed a complete and thorough assessment, more comparable to an initial assessment than to a reassessment, if it was to move forward with the development of an appropriate IEP. The evidence showed that speech and language skills and gross and fine motor skills were areas of disability for STUDENT. Ms. Boudreau testified that he was significantly delayed in all areas, including language and gross and fine motor skills. Furthermore, language and motor skills are common areas of impairment for students diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder. While there were some indications in the testimony of Ms. Boudreau and Mr. Sullivan that these areas would be included within their assessments, the absence of any recent or reliable information about STUDENT’s needs in these areas should have alerted the District to the need to include specific assessments in these areas by appropriate specialists. The plan should have included assessments in these areas.
The District argued that the analysis should end with a determination of whether the plan and related documents complied with Cal. Educ. Code § 56321. However, in this case, the Respondent questioned not only the face of the plan itself, but also the adequacy of the assessment which the District proposed to do pursuant to the plan. Additionally, the Hearing Officer has already determined that there was a procedural error in the manner in which the District developed the plan and that the parents must be provided an opportunity to participate in a refinement of the specifics of the plan. Under the circumstances, it is appropriate for the Hearing Officer to go beyond the face of the plan to look at the assessment itself to determine whether it complies with the law.
The assessment must meet certain statutory requirements. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 provides, in pertinent part, that tests and assessment materials must be (1) provided and administered in the pupil's primary language or other mode of communication, unless the assessment plan indicates reasons why this provision and administration are not clearly feasible; (2) validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; and (3) administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist.
In addition, that statute requires that the tests and other assessment materials “include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need; . . . [and] accurately reflect the pupil's aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil's impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” No single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c)-(e), inclusive.(Footnote 10) The assessments must be performed by persons who are knowledgeable of the disability and competent to perform them, as determined by the district. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(g) and 56322. Psychological assessment of a student must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Educ. Code § 56324.
The testimony of Jocelyn Boudreau and Terry Sullivan demonstrated that they will be able to determine and utilize STUDENT’s primary mode of communication. Both are experienced evaluators who have had significant exposure to the communication difficulties common to autistic students, including all forms of communication devices and even facilitated communication.(Footnote 11) There was no evidence offered by the Respondent to suggest otherwise. While Ms. Cochrane was not available to testify, her education, background and experience were adequately shown through the testimony of Sandra Piotter and Ms. Boudreau and through documentary evidence. The Hearing Officer concludes that it is the intent of the District to take steps to ensure that the assessment will be conducted in STUDENT’s primary mode of communication and will reflect his present levels of development and his unique needs and not his impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills.
While there was some question regarding whether all of the tests and procedures described on the assessment plan would be appropriate for STUDENT’s assessment, the testimony demonstrated that those which would probably be used, the CTONI, Stanford Benet and AAMD by Ms. Boudreau and the observation and comparative assessment by Mr. Sullivan, were validated and appropriate for the assessment of autistic young adults of STUDENT’s age.
Ms. PARENT questioned the background and qualifications of Ms. Boudreau and other potential participants. The Hearing Officer is satisfied that the evidence proved that all the probable assessors have the appropriate education, background and experience and are competent and qualified to assess STUDENT.
The evidence demonstrated that the District does not intend to rely on any single test or procedure to determine an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. On the contrary, several procedures will be used, including a reasoned effort to determine STUDENT’s achievement through a nonverbal assessment (CTONI) and the gathering of indicative data from STUDENT’s parents and guardian and several hours of observation of him in various environments.
Ms. CAREGIVER and Ms. PARENT had a number of other complaints about the planned assessment by the District. They complained about the timing of the District’s assessment, what they viewed as the motivation of the District to assess, and what they characterized as the adversarial approach of the District. The District’s right to assess STUDENT is not subservient to the right of the parent or co-guardian to complete her own assessment. There was no credible evidence that an appropriate assessment had even been begun by Ms. CAREGIVER. There is no reason or law which would require a delay under the circumstances of this case. The allegation that the District sought the assessment to harass the Respondent’s co-guardians or to interfere with their own assessment also fails for the utter lack of evidence to support it.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the assessment planned by the District is appropriate with the addition of assessments by a speech and language specialist or therapist and an occupational therapist.
While there was no request for reimbursement by Respondent in this hearing, Ms. PARENT requested in her May 24, 2001 letter that the District pay for the assessment that she and Ms. CAREGIVER wanted to do. While a parent is entitled to have his or her child assessed at any time, a district is required to pay for an independent assessment only when the district has refused to conduct an assessment or the parents disagreed with the results of the district’s assessment, the parents pay for an independent assessment, and the parents then prevail in a due process hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501 and 56329. There has not yet been an assessment by the District in this case, so there is nothing with which the parents or co-guardians can disagree. Nor was there any evidence that the District had refused to conduct an assessment or that the parents had obtained an independent assessment at their own expense. There is no factual basis for a claim to reimbursement.
In her August 28, 2001 letter requesting a continuance of the hearing, Ms. PARENT states that it is likely that CAREGIVER will be moving out of the District. She concludes that if this occurs, there will no longer be a need for the District’s assessment of STUDENT. The letter does not specifically state that STUDENT will be moving out of the District. In any event, the mere possibility that the District will no longer be required to serve STUDENT’s special education needs is not enough to make the issue moot. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s obligations to STUDENT remain until STUDENT no longer resides within the District’s geographical boundaries.
In conclusion, the District has the right and the obligation to assess STUDENT, even in the absence of parental consent. A thorough reassessment is warranted to determine STUDENT’s present performance levels and educational needs, and is likely to provide relevant information that would directly assist in a determination of an appropriate individualized educational program for him. Furthermore, the assessment proposed in the District’s plan dated May 3, 2001, is appropriate with the addition of assessments by a speech and language specialist or therapist and an occupational therapist.
ORDER
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing Decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Does the District have the right to assess STUDENT?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Is the assessment proposed by the District appropriate?
Neither party prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).
Dated: September 28, 2001 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Ms. Schulist was also present on August 28.
2. Ms. CAREGIVER identified herself as STUDENT’s co-guardian. Her capacity as co-guardian was not an issue at the hearing.
3. There was a telephone request by Ms. PARENT on the afternoon on August 27, and a faxed letter received by the Hearing Office on August 28, both asking to postpone the hearing because of the possibility that STUDENT would be moving out of the District. The letter stated that CAREGIVER would not be appearing at the hearing. It also stated that, because her “advocate” would not be appearing, neither would Ms. PARENT. No good cause for a continuance was shown.
4. On the the last hearing day on August 28, 2001, Respondent’s mother personally delivered an envelope containing Respondent’s written closing argument with a letter requesting that it be read or otherwise entered into the record.
5. After a lengthy discussion with the parties regarding their respective contentions, the Hearing Officer concluded that all of their contentions could be adequately addressed under the two stated issue, which will be analyzed together.
6. References will be to both Petitioner’s (number designations) and Respondent’s (letter designations) exhibits when offered by both parties.
7. Ms. Boudreau stated that the 1998 assessment contained no information on age ranges or cognitive levels and was inadequate.
8. Sandra Piotter stated in her testimony that Ms. Cochrane had taken an indefinite leave of absence to be with her dying mother. While it was the expectation of the District at the time the assessment plan was presented that Ms. Cochrane would participate, the unpredictable date of her return to the District left her actual participation in some doubt.
9. This is the only indication in the evidence that there was a request by the Respondent for an assessment. Respondent did not request that the reimbursement issue be addressed at the hearing.
10. There is also a requirement in Cal. Educ. Code §56320(f) that the student be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability, but it is not clear that this is required for all reassessments. However, in this case, where there was a dearth of information upon which the IEP team could rely to develop an appropriate IEP, an evaluation in all areas related to the suspected disability is warranted.
11. There were suggestions in the District’s evidence that the Respondent’s co-guardians favored FC with STUDENT. There was also evidence that this was a controversial approach which is not widely accepted. The Respondent offered no evidence on the issue.
