California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 20, 1998

Corona-Norco Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1137-98 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Hearing Officer approves Corona-Norco Unified's nonpublic school placement at Oak Grove Institute but orders an assessment of attention problems.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 5 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Corona-Norco Unified School District filed for due process to place a 15-year-old tenth grader at the nonpublic school (NPS) day program at the Oak Grove Institute for 1998-1999. The student was eligible for special education because of learning disabilities. He had a long history of aggressive behavior, profanity, and defiance at school, and a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) had been in place since April 1997. He had attended special day classes at Norco High School, Horizon continuation school, a brief nonpublic school placement, and home instruction. His father wanted him back at Norco High School with a one-to-one aide, a revised BIP, and new assessments for attention problems and dyslexia.

Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote relied mainly on the student's teachers, especially longtime tutor Paul Falsone. They said the District had run out of options and the student needed a small, highly structured setting with therapy on site. No witness supported a one-to-one aide. No evidence showed the BIP was flawed. The June 1998 triennial assessment had covered reading adequately. She held that Oak Grove met the student's needs, gave him educational benefit, and matched his IEP. The District knew about his attention problems and had told the parents to get an outside evaluation. For that reason, she ordered the District to assess his attention at its own expense. The District had to hold an IEP meeting within 10 business days, place him at Oak Grove, and provide transportation.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO weighed testimony from teachers who knew a student well, including one who had succeeded with him, in approving a more restrictive NPS placement. It also shows that a district could not shift an attention assessment to parents or mental health. The district was responsible for assessing in all areas of suspected disability.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Does the certified nonpublic school (NPS) at the Oak Grove Institute in Murietta, California, offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year?

    District resources were exhausted and the student needed a structured, therapeutic setting with a low student-to-teacher ratio; the Oak Grove NPS day program met his needs, provided educational benefit, and conformed to his IEP.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1a. Whether the student requires a one-to-one aide to benefit from placement at Norco High School

    No witness who worked with the student in school supported a dedicated aide; teachers testified he needed to learn self-control rather than have an aide control his behavior externally.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 1b. Whether the District must conduct a new functional analysis assessment and revise the student's behavioral intervention plan

    The April 1997 BIP was thorough and had been implemented; there was no persuasive evidence it was flawed or that revising it would make Norco High School appropriate.

  4. Student prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1c. Whether the District must assess the student's attentional problems and their effect on his education

    Because the District knew of his attention problems, had not recently assessed them, and had told the parents to seek an outside evaluation, the District must assess at its own expense; the assessment was not needed before deciding placement.

  5. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1d. Whether the District must assess the student's reading difficulties for dyslexia

    The June 1998 triennial assessment measured reading and processing well enough to write reading goals; there was no persuasive evidence that more reading assessment was needed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. Student's placement for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year shall be the nonpublic school at the Oak Grove Institute; the District shall arrange the placement immediately after the IEP meeting.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. District's proposed NPS placement at Oak Grove Institute upheld over the parent's objection.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 business days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to change placement to Oak Grove for the remainder of 1998-1999, including extended school year, and conform the IEP to the decision.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP shall state that the District is responsible for transportation between the student's home and Oak Grove.
  • Order to assess. At the IEP meeting, the team shall develop a plan to assess the student's attentional problems; the District shall then conduct the assessment and the parent shall make the student available.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031; Education Code § 56320(f); Education Code § 56363; 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h) (Hughes Bill); 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)

People named in the decision

  • Thomas R. Pike, assistant superintendent for student services, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Carol Donlan, director of special education, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Marie Gruenke, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
  • Victoria Baca, advocate for Student
  • Raul Wilson, advocate for Student
  • Jerry A. Kasdorf, Ph.D., private licensed psychologist and therapist (letter in evidence; did not testify)
  • Char McKasson, behavior intervention case manager, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Charles Robert (Chuck) Gustafson, Ph.D., school psychologist; behavior intervention case manager; conducted pre-expulsion assessment, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Paul Falsone, special day class teacher and home tutor, Norco High School, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Patricia Nelson, life science and art teacher, Norco High School
  • Yvonne Wolfe, special day class teacher, Horizon continuation high school
  • David Long, principal, Horizon continuation high school
  • Susan Stuelke, school psychologist; conducted triennial assessment; behavior intervention case manager, Corona-Norco Unified School District
  • Joe Almasy, assistant principal, Norco High School
  • Raymond Hurst, witness for the nonpublic school, Oak Grove Institute
  • Oak Grove Institute, certified nonpublic school (proposed placement)
  • Somerset, nonpublic school (prior placement)
  • Riverside County Department of Mental Health, AB 3632 mental health services provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Norco, California, on September 22 and 23, 1998. Petitioner Corona-Norco Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney John E. Hayashida. Attorney Cynthia A. Yount was present on the first day of the hearing. Also present on behalf of the District was Thomas R. Pike, assistant superintendent for student services, and Carol Donlan, director of special education. Respondent STUDENT was represented at the hearing by advocate Victoria Baca. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were his father and advocate Raul Wilson. Hearing Officer Marie Gruenke was present as an observer.

Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE

Does the certified nonpublic school (NPS) at the Oak Grove Institute in Murietta, California, offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student in the tenth grade. STUDENT is eligible for special education because of learning disabilities. He has a history of aggressive and impulsive behavior, and the use of profane and vulgar language. District members of the individualized education plan (IEP) team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a nonpublic school (NPS) for the 1998-1999 school year. STUDENT and his father recommended that STUDENT attend Norco High School, his neighborhood high school. At an IEP meeting on August 18, 1998, the team agreed that STUDENT would receive six classes through “home and hospital” study pending resolution of the dispute. (Footnote 1) STUDENT’s IEP indicates that he is eligible for extended school year (ESY) services and includes goals and objectives to address deficits in basic mathematic skills, reading comprehension, spelling, and written language. Additional goals and objectives are designed to increase completion of school work and homework, to increase appropriate social skills, to increase positive interactions with peers, and to resolve conflicts with peers in an appropriate manner. The IEP also includes a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) to address physical aggression including hitting, pushing, shoving or touching other students, and to address inappropriate verbal language such as cursing at peers and adults. (Student’s Exhibit 65; District’s Exhibits 24, 27, and 40.)(Footnote 2) STUDENT also receives weekly individual and family therapy, which is provided privately by Jerry A. Kasdorf, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist.

STUDENT entered kindergarten in the fall of 1988 in the Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District. STUDENT had difficulties with self-control, following directions, working independently, and learning preacademic skills. (District’s Exhibit 41.) For the 1989-1990 school year, STUDENT and his family moved to Arizona, where he was initially placed in a first-grade class and then moved to a kindergarten class. In March 1991, the family returned to California and STUDENT was enrolled in a first grade class in the District. STUDENT exhibited limited attention, poor work habits, and behavioral difficulties. STUDENT was determined eligible for special education in the fall of 1991 and was placed in a special day class (SDC) to address his learning difficulties. STUDENT also received AB3632 mental health services. STUDENT’s educational history throughout elementary school is permeated with reports of discipline for inappropriate behavior. While in the sixth grade, STUDENT was suspended for bringing a dangerous object to school, verbally threatening other students, and causing physical injury to another student. (See District’s Exhibits 18, 42 - 44.) Reports described STUDENT as “easily distracted, agitated, and annoyed.” In 1996, an assessor wrote: “[STUDENT] is very oppositional. . . . There is a continually confronting quality to he [sic] behavior and he remains provocative to those around him.” (District’s Exhibit 19, p. 5.)

STUDENT entered Norco Intermediate School as a seventh-grade student for the 1996-1997 school year. STUDENT continued to have behavioral problems. At various times, modifications to STUDENT’s school day were made, including shortening the school day. He was sent from his class for disciplinary reasons and then was assigned to alternative campus placement (ACP). The ACP is a separate classroom on the school campus where students are required to work on assignments from their classes. STUDENT has also been suspended and placed on home and hospital instruction. On January 23, 1997, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT should be moved to his age-appropriate grade, which was then the eighth grade.(Footnote 3) This was deemed a “social promotion.” The IEP effectuating the change of grade includes comments related to STUDENT’s continued aggressive behavior toward peers and his failure to complete classroom assignments. The team anticipated that by placing STUDENT in the eighth grade he would be around more mature students, who would serve as positive social and behavioral role models. (District’s Exhibit 21.) STUDENT was again referred to Riverside County Department of Mental Health for an AB3632 mental health assessment. On January 24, 1997, the assessment was completed. The assessment report states that STUDENT was suffering from depressive symptoms and “carrying quite a bit of anger, sadness and hurt, which may be presenting in an oppositional and defiant manner.” Mental health services of from one to four times per week were recommended. (District Exhibit 22.) The IEP team convened on February 4, 1997, and adopted the recommendations of Mental Health.(Footntoe 4) STUDENT’s class schedule was changed to a five-period day and it was agreed that the District would conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA). (District’s Exhibit 23.)

On April 3, 1997, the IEP team reviewed the results of the FAA and developed a BIP to address STUDENT’s physical aggression, “posturing” with peers, and inappropriate verbal language such as swearing. The BIP designates Char McKasson and Chuck Gustafson as behavior intervention case managers (BICMs). The IEP team developed goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s deficits in basic mathematic skills. The IEP also notes that “STUDENT needs one-on-one individual attention to keep him on task. Work needs to be presented in small sections and reviewed on a regular basis. He is very easily distracted and loses his concentration. A great deal of work is never completed or ‘lost.’” (District’s Exhibit 24.) On May 12, 1997, the IEP team met to evaluate the effectiveness of the BIP. STUDENT’s teachers reported that he had been competing his homework more frequently, had received an “A” grade on a science test, and had met a math goal related to addition and subtraction of multi-digit numbers. STUDENT also had not received as many disciplinary referrals as he had previously. (District’s Exhibit 25.)

On July 22, 1997, the IEP team agreed to provide home and hospital instruction for 15 days to allow STUDENT to complete course work he had begun during the ESY. (District’s Exhibit 26.) The IEP team met again on August 29, 1997, to update goals and objectives, to review the BIP, and to determine STUDENT’s placement for the 1997-1998 school year. The team agreed that STUDENT would attend Norco High School and would be placed in special day classes for 67% of his school day for instruction in language arts, math, life science, and arts and crafts. STUDENT’s IEP also called for mainstreaming for physical education and an elective class. The IEP includes a transition plan. (District’s Exhibit 27.) At a subsequent IEP meeting on September 23, 1997, the team concluded that STUDENT should be moved from the SDC to the resource program (RSP) for language arts. (District’s Exhibit 28.)

On December 5, 1997, the IEP team met to assess STUDENT’s current educational program. Comments indicate that STUDENT was being disciplined frequently because of the use of vulgarity and profanity. He also was showing disrespect for teachers. As a result of the meeting, the District agreed to provide STUDENT with three hours per week of home tutoring by one of his SDC teachers, Paul Falsone, with whom STUDENT had experienced some success. Mr. Falsone had previously provided STUDENT with home instruction while he was in the sixth grade. The IEP also indicates that mental health services would be discontinued because of FATHER’ dissatisfaction with the services and that STUDENT’s teachers would chart his use of profane and vulgar language. (District’s Exhibit 30.)

At the end of the first semester of the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT had earned two “F” grades, three “D” grades, and one “C” grade. (District’s Exhibit 1.) On January 22, 1998, the IEP team met to discuss an incident in which STUDENT pushed a pregnant teacher while pursuing another student. The District recommended STUDENT for expulsion. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed on home and hospital instruction pending a pre-expulsion assessment. (District’s Exhibit 31.) Dr. Gustafson, who conducted the assessment, concluded that STUDENT’s behavior was not a manifestation of his disability and that he was appropriately placed at the time of the incident. (District’s Exhibit 32.) The IEP team met on January 29, 1998, to review the results of the assessment. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT required a more structured environment and agreed that he would be placed at Somerset, a nonpublic school. The District rescinded the recommendation for expulsion. (District’s Exhibit 33.)

On February 2, 1998, STUDENT entered Somerset.(Footnote 5) Several days later, FATHER removed STUDENT, alleging that STUDENT had been mistreated by the Somerset staff. STUDENT stated that the staff at Somerset restrained him, which resulted in an injury to his back. At another IEP meeting on February 25, 1998, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT would be placed at Horizon, a District continuation high school, and that Mr. Falsone would continue to tutor STUDENT. Specifically, Mr. Falsone would provide instruction in language arts so that STUDENT could earn credit for one class. (District’s Exhibit 34.) The BIP remained in effect and STUDENT participated in an anger management class while at Horizon; however, he continued to experience behavioral problems.

At an IEP meeting on April 13, 1998, the team agreed that STUDENT would attend summer school and would return to Norco High School in September. The team also agreed that a second home and hospital teacher would be assigned to provide STUDENT with an additional two to three hours of instruction each week. The IEP reflects that the BIP needed to be reviewed and that a new BICM needed to be assigned, since FATHER no longer wanted Dr. Gustafson, the then-current BICM, to be involved with STUDENT. (District’s Exhibit 35.) On May 1, 1998, FATHER consented to the assessment plan for a triennial assessment of STUDENT. FATHER also agreed to extend the timelines for completion of the triennial until August 31, 1998. (District’s Exhibit 36.) Any possible revisions to the BIP were deferred pending completion of the triennial assessment.

On June 1, 1998, STUDENT was involved in a fight with another student. An intervening custodian was injured. STUDENT was suspended for five days following the incident. On June 16, 1998, a referral to mental health was made to reinitiate services; however, FATHER interrupted the assessment process before it was completed because of concerns about mental health’s potential use of drugs to treat STUDENT. (District’s Exhibit 39.) On June 23, 1998, the IEP team met to review the results of the triennial assessment and to consider STUDENT’s placement for the summer program and for the 1998-1999 school year in light of the new assessment. The report of the triennial assessment includes recommendations that STUDENT be educated in a “structured and tightly controlled one-to-one instructional setting with immediate access to a counselor or therapist (to aid him when he was angry or frustrated).” (District’s Exhibit 41.) For the ESY program for the summer of 1998, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT participate in one home and hospital class and also in one regular education physical education class at the high school, with Mr. Falsone as the teacher. District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in an NPS for the 1998-1999 school year. FATHER consented to the IEP except for the proposed NPS placement. He requested that STUDENT be allowed to return to Norco High School in the fall of 1998. The District offered, in the alternative, to provide six hours of home and hospital study and an afternoon sports program for the first semester of the 1998-1999 school year. (District’s Exhibit 40.) FATHER rejected the District’s offers of placement. On July 31, 1998, the District requested a special education due process hearing regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 1998-1999 school year.(Footnote 6) Pursuant to an agreement reached by the IEP team on August 18, 1998, the District has since provided STUDENT with home and hospital study pending resolution of due process hearing procedures.

The District contends that STUDENT requires placement in a nonpublic school that offers an intensive educational and therapeutic program and that can provide him with immediate access to appropriately trained mental health personnel. The District asserts that such a placement is necessary to ameliorate STUDENT’s serious behavioral problems, to allow him to develop internal behavioral controls, and to ultimately allow him to return to a public school. The District proposes to place STUDENT at the NPS at the Oak Grove Institute in Murietta, California. The school is approximately 30 miles from STUDENT’s home. STUDENT contends that the appropriate and least restrictive placement is Norco High School, which is his neighborhood high school. STUDENT asserts that the District must conduct a new FAA, assess his attentional problems and their effect upon his education, assess his reading difficulties for dyslexia, develop a new BIP, and provide him with an aide so that he can benefit from placement at Norco.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Does the certified nonpublic school (NPS) at the Oak Grove Institute in Murietta, California, offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 1998-1999 school year?

Under both state and federal law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8), "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the student's individualized educational program. "Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. . . ." 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).

The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education, and psychological services.

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services or that the services maximize each child's potential. The Court stated that "the 'basic floor of opportunity' provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit" to the student. 458 U.S. 175, 200.

Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular educational environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.

To summarize, under IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, comport with the IEP, and must also be provided in the least restrictive environment.

What are STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

In order to determine what constitutes an appropriate placement for STUDENT, it is first necessary to identify his unique and individual needs. There is no dispute that STUDENT requires specific instruction to address learning deficits in reading, written language, and mathematics. STUDENT’s problems related to staying on task and completing school work are also well documented and Mental Health has identified some emotional difficulties including depression, anger, and sadness. A number of STUDENT’s teachers and administrators testified similarly regarding STUDENT’s behavioral problems and difficulty getting along with peers and teachers. Their testimony and the documentary evidence also describe STUDENT’s long history of aggressive and impulsive behavior, use of foul and vulgar language, lack of respect for authority, and refusal to cooperate. (See e.g. District’s Exhibits 42-48) Patricia Nelson, STUDENT’s life science and art teacher at Norco High School during the fall of 1997, described STUDENT as follows: noncompliant with classroom rules, disrespectful toward peers and teachers, rude, bullying, and impulsive. She also stated that STUDENT used inappropriate language, refused to do class work, and constantly interrupted the class, which made it difficult for the other students to concentrate and to do their own work. Ms. Nelson testified that STUDENT required constant monitoring in both art and life science classes. She believed that STUDENT was able to achieve some success in the art class because the art class had fewer students and she was able to provide him with almost constant individual attention.

Yvonne Wolfe was STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Horizon in the spring of 1998. She provided STUDENT with instruction in arithmetic, language arts, science, and history. Ms. Wolfe was assisted by an instructional assistant. The classes averaged eight students each period. Ms. Wolfe testified that while in her class, STUDENT continually used foul language and was defiant and disrespectful to staff. His behavior was also disruptive to the other students in the class. Ms. Wolfe testified that STUDENT was also verbally aggressive toward students and staff; however, he was not physically aggressive. Ms. Wolfe testified that even when she or her aide provided STUDENT with one-to-one instruction, he had difficulty focusing on the task at hand. There was no credible evidence to the contrary regarding STUDENT’s needs.

District personnel described the characteristics of a program that would be designed to address STUDENT’s needs. Paul Falsone, SDC teacher, was STUDENT’s home teacher during the sixth grade and has been STUDENT’s home tutor since the 1997-1998 school year. Mr. Falsone also was one of STUDENT’s SDC teachers at Norco High School in the fall of 1997. Mr. Falsone testified that STUDENT also requires a class with a low student-to-teacher ratio. He recommended that STUDENT be placed in a class that has from four to six students. Mr. Falsone testified that STUDENT needs a highly structured, “non-traditional” educational setting where he can receive immediate consequences for his behavior.

Charles Robert Gustafson, Ph.D., school psychologist, serves Norco Junior and Senior High Schools, as well as Horizon Continuation School. Dr. Gustafson was involved in the functional analysis assessment and BIP developed for STUDENT in April 1997 and served as one of the behavior intervention case managers (BICMs) until “dismissed” by FATHER. Dr. Gustafson also conducted a pre-expulsion assessment of STUDENT in January 1998. In his opinion, STUDENT needs a very structured environment to ensure his safety and the safety of others. David Long, principal of Horizon also testified that STUDENT needs to be placed in an educational setting with a limited number of students because he is “very reactive to other students.”

The testimony of the District’s witnesses who have worked with STUDENT over the past several years establishes that he requires immediate consequences for his behavior and a structured educational environment with a low student to teacher ratio. He also requires a significant amount of individual attention. (See also District’s Exhibits 40 and 41.) There was no dispute that STUDENT requires the above to meet his education needs; however FATHER expressed the opinion that STUDENT also requires a one-to-one aide. FATHER also asserted that the District must revise STUDENT’s BIP and assess STUDENT for dyslexia and ADD.

As to the assertion that STUDENT requires a one-to-one aide, it has been established that STUDENT requires a significant amount of individual attention; however, none of the witnesses who have worked with STUDENT in an educational environment supported assigning STUDENT a one-to-one aide. Mr. Falsone testified that a one-to-one aide dedicated to STUDENT would not be appropriate because STUDENT needs to learn self-control rather than have an aide apply external control to his behavior. Dr. Gustafson, Susan Stuelke, school psychologist, and other teachers concurred with Mr. Falsone’s opinion. Neither STUDENT’s current therapist nor an educator testified on behalf of STUDENT. Therefore, the Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers in concluding that STUDENT does not require a one-to-one aide assigned to him.

As to the need to revise STUDENT’s BIP, California special education law provides that a functional analysis assessment and development of a BIP satisfying the requirements of the Hughes Bill are required whenever a special education student “exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP.” 5 C.C.R. § 3001(h). In this case, the parties agreed that STUDENT required a BIP and, in April 1997, District personnel conducted a FAA and developed and implemented a BIP. Based on a review of the BIP and the testimony regarding the BIP by the school psychologists, it is concluded the document is thorough and addresses STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors. The BIP calls for replacing the inappropriate behaviors of physical aggression, posturing, and inappropriate verbal language with positive behaviors. The BIP identifies a number of positive replacement behaviors and modifications to the environment. (See District’s Exhibit 24.) By agreement of the IEP team, the BIP in its present form has continued as a part of STUDENT’s IEP.(Footnote 7) Joe Almasy, assistant principal at Norco High School, testified that when STUDENT entered Norco, he provided all of his teachers with a copy of the BIP and discussed its implementation with them. According to Dr. Gustafson, the BIP was reviewed with teachers in each of STUDENT’s placements subsequent to its development. The BIP has been implemented at both Norco and Horizon. The BIP is comprehensive, thorough, and designed to meet STUDENT’s needs; however, according to all of STUDENT’s teachers who testified, the BIP has not been successful in alleviating STUDENT’s behavior. None of the teachers proposed revising the BIP and none expressed the belief that, even if the BIP were revised, it would bring about significant change to STUDENT’s behavior.

There was no persuasive testimony that the BIP is flawed or inappropriate There also was no persuasive evidence that revising the BIP would result in Norco being an appropriate placement for STUDENT.(Footnote 8) Respondent did not call STUDENT’s therapist or anyone else with expertise in behavioral intervention to testify regarding the inappropriateness of the BIP or its need for revision. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that Respondent has not established that the District is required to revise the BIP at this time.

In a letter addressed “to whom it concerns,” Dr. Kasdorf, STUDENT’s private therapist, addressed the need for additional assessments. He recommended an assessment to identify the nature of STUDENT’s learning disorder(s). (Student’s Exhibit 60.) Dr. Kasdorf did not testify at the hearing, and without knowing the basis for his recommendation and the extent of his knowledge of prior assessments, his recommendation is given little weight. The Hearing Officer notes that assessment was not raised as an issue in advance of the hearing by either party; however, given Ms. Stuelke’s recommendation in May 1998 that the parents seek a medical assessment to determine whether STUDENT has an ADD and the fact that the triennial assessment in June 1998 did not assess STUDENT for ADD, consideration of the need for an assessment is warranted. (See District’s Exhibit 37.) At the hearing, the District asserted that the parent is responsible for obtaining an assessment related to ADD because such an assessment is available through Mental Health and the parent has refused Mental Health services. There was no evidence that an assessment plan had been developed by Mental Health or by the District that includes an assessment related to ADD. Even if Mental Health had been requested to conduct an assessment, it is the District’s responsibility to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Education Code § 56320(f). It is reported that, at one point in time, STUDENT did not meet ADD criteria; however, in light of the District’s knowledge of STUDENT’s attentional problems, the fact that he has not recently been assessed in this area, and the recommendation of the District that the parents obtain an assessment, it is concluded that an assessment should be undertaken at the District’s expense to provide current information on the nature and extent of STUDENT’s attentional problems. However, there is no evidence that an assessment to confirm or rule out ADD is necessary prior to determining an appropriate placement for this school year. STUDENT’s attentional problems are well documented and are already addressed in the BIP and the IEP.

As to the need for an assessment for dyslexia, STUDENT is identified as a student with learning disabilities that include reading, written language, and mathematics. STUDENT’s IEP includes specific goals and objectives to address deficits in reading. The triennial assessment completed in June 1998 included measures of STUDENT’s reading skills on the Woodcock-Johnson Achievement Test-Revised and the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test. Additional measures were used to assess STUDENT’s auditory and visual processing, visual-motor integration, and vocabulary. (Testimony of Ms. Stuelke; District’s Exhibit 41.) Therefore, STUDENT’s current functional levels and the nature of his deficits in reading have been evaluated sufficiently to develop goals and objectives to address reading deficits. There was no persuasive evidence that a further assessment of STUDENT’s reading skills is necessary at this time.

Does STUDENT require placement in a nonpublic school to meet his needs?

The District’s witnesses all testified that the resources of the District have been exhausted in attempting to meet STUDENT’s needs and that he now requires more intensive services than can be provided by the District. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers from both Norco and Horizon establishes that, in addition to developing and implementing a BIP, the District undertook additional efforts to ameliorate STUDENT’s behavioral problems. For the most part, the interventions were not successful. Ms. Nelson testified that STUDENT generally was unresponsive to positive behavioral interventions while in her classes at Norco. She provided STUDENT with the positive rewards identified in the BIP including sodas, verbal praise, opportunities to lead the class in an activity, and favorable notes home to his parents. In her opinion, STUDENT generally was unresponsive to positive behavioral interventions. Mr. Falsone testified that he has established good rapport with STUDENT and did not find it necessary to refer him to administrators for disciplinary reasons; however, Mr. Falsone testified that it took an extraordinary effort on his part in order for STUDENT to be successful in the classroom environment.

Ms. Wolfe described modifications she made to address STUDENT’s needs at Horizon. She shortened work assignments and lessened the requirements for STUDENT to earn points in class. (Students earned points for staying on task and behaving appropriately.) Ms. Wolfe testified that if STUDENT worked successfully for 10 minutes, she would allow him to select an activity he wanted to do or to sit wherever he wanted. Ms. Wolfe allowed STUDENT to leave class for a couple of minutes if he felt he was going to have an outburst. She also engaged in discussions with STUDENT regarding his behavior and offered alternative ways for him to respond to students and to handle difficult situations. These interventions did not change STUDENT’s behavior. Mr. Long, principal of Horizon, testified that he established good rapport with STUDENT. Mr. Long testified that whenever STUDENT was sent to him by a teacher, he discussed with STUDENT the incident that resulted in the referral and provided him with suggestions for alternative ways to handle the situation. Mr. Long testified that STUDENT continued to be referred to him for similar behaviors throughout his tenure at Horizon.

The District has also changed STUDENT’s placement from a comprehensive high school, where he had a number of different teachers and classes, to a continuation high school, where he was in one SDC for a majority of the school day. At various periods throughout STUDENT’s education, he has also been placed on home and hospital study. On several occasions, the District has referred STUDENT to Mental Health for services, which were initiated and then discontinued by the parent. The District also provided STUDENT with anger management classes. The testimony of STUDENT’s teachers and the documentation of STUDENT’s behavior establishes that STUDENT has experienced the most difficulty when he attended a comprehensive high school, where he was required to move from class to class and to deal with a number of different teachers and students during the course of a school day. On the other hand, STUDENT has been most successful when receiving individual instruction.

Two witnesses testified on behalf of STUDENT--FATHER and STUDENT. They testified that STUDENT should be placed at Norco. They do not agree that STUDENT requires an NPS placement. FATHER concurs that STUDENT’s behavior can be inappropriate at times; however, he testified that STUDENT demonstrates outside of the school environment that he is able to control his behavior and is also able to get along with peers. FATHER testified that STUDENT is involved in a number of group activities including team sports and scouting. STUDENT recently earned a certificate for completing a leadership training course through his church. FATHER testified that STUDENT has been able to successfully work with other students designing a float and also got along well on a recent camp out. FATHER testified that he has not followed through with the last referral to Mental Health because of concerns about the potential use of prescription medication to treat STUDENT. Based on STUDENT’s previous experience at Somerset, an NPS, FATHER also expressed concerns about the way in which STUDENT would be treated by the staff at the NPS currently recommended by the District. STUDENT testified that he likes and respects Mr. Long and Mr. Falsone. He acknowledged that he does not like some teachers, especially those who have tried to “sweet talk” him; however, he believes that he can be polite to them in the same manner that he was during the hearing. STUDENT testified that he has been in fights because other students make him angry and he has difficulty controlling himself. STUDENT testified that he believes that the counselor he is seeing now is helping him more than anyone else has. He testified that his church and a spiritual advisor have also been helpful and he now believes that he is able to maintain self-control and refrain from swearing. STUDENT testified that he wants to attend Norco with his friends. Because of his experiences at Somerset, he also expressed concerns about how he would be treated at an NPS and whether the staff would physically restrain him. STUDENT also expressed concern regarding the possible dangers of traveling in an automobile to attend school out of town. The Oak Grove Institute is located approximately 30 miles from his home.

All of the District’s witnesses concluded that STUDENT requires placement in an NPS to meet his needs. Ms. Wolfe, STUDENT’s SDC teacher at Horizon, concluded that STUDENT could not work successfully in a regular school setting. Dr. Gustafson recommended that STUDENT be placed in an NPS that has an on-site therapeutic component and teachers and counselors who are trained to work with children with behavioral problems and who know the appropriate responses to aggressive behavior. Susan Stuelke, school psychologist, conducted STUDENT’s triennial assessment. Ms. Stuelke testified that if STUDENT remains in a public school placement, he will continue to have difficulty controlling himself in the classroom, will continue to fail to complete his assigned work, and will continue to engage in impulsive and inappropriate behavior. Ms. Stuelke testified that classroom aides in a public high school are not sufficiently trained to teach STUDENT how to change his behavior, which has existed for a long period of time. In her opinion, STUDENT requires an NPS placement that has qualified therapists and other appropriately trained personnel on site to provide him with immediate feedback.

STUDENT’s teachers testified regarding additional benefits offered by an NPS: STUDENT would learn the skills he needs to modify his behavior, which will facilitate his transition from home and hospital study to a placement on a public high school; the level of individual instruction available at an NPS would help STUDENT organize and complete his assignments, provide him with immediate feedback regarding his behavior, and help him learn to diffuse anger and frustration; and the appropriately trained personnel available at an NPS would help STUDENT clarify his feelings, teach him how to express his feelings in more appropriate terms, and help him recognize the cause of frustration.

Mr. Falsone joined STUDENT’s other teachers in recommending an NPS for STUDENT. Mr. Falsone considered the possibility of having STUDENT in one of his classes at Norco. Based on his previous experiences with STUDENT, he concluded that it would be quite challenging and exhausting for the teacher. He also stated that the task would be more demanding than an “ordinary” teacher would be willing to undertake. Mr. Falsone also understood that the other teachers at Norco were not as successful as he was in dealing with STUDENT’s behavior. In his opinion, STUDENT cannot presently control his behavior in the presence of peers or teachers and generally is responsive only to adult males who are larger than STUDENT. Mr. Falsone concluded that Norco does not offer a program that is sufficiently structured to meet STUDENT’s needs and that, for this reason, STUDENT requires placement in other than a “traditional” school environment to benefit from his education. Substantial weight must be given to Mr. Falsone’s testimony because he has known and worked with STUDENT for a number of years and in several different environments. Moreover, despite the fact that he had some success with STUDENT, Mr. Falsone held the opinion that STUDENT’s needs should be addressed in an NPS. The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, particularly the testimony of Mr. Falsone, is persuasive as to STUDENT’s need for an NPS. STUDENT’s intentions to improve his behavior appear sincere and should be supported; however, STUDENT has previously indicated that he intended to make positive changes to his behavior and failed to do so. Neither STUDENT’s private therapist nor anyone with whom he associates in the community testified regarding STUDENT’s ability to behave appropriately and to get along with peers. For these reasons, there is sufficient evidence to establish that STUDENT cannot make a positive change to his behavior without the support of a structured and therapeutic environment. The Hearing Officer notes also that STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior has been in existence for a long period of time. Moreover, Mental Health has identified some underlying emotional problems that need to be addressed.

Given the fact that there is some evidence that STUDENT is able to exercise some self-control outside of the educational environment, there is insufficient evidence to conclude that STUDENT requires a residential program. Therefore, based on Mr. Falsone’s testimony and the substantial testimony of teachers who have known STUDENT over the past few years, of school psychologists who have assessed him, and of school administrators who have worked with STUDENT in regard to his behavior, the Hearing Officer concludes that an NPS that has available the services described above would offer an appropriate placement for STUDENT at this time.

Is the certified NPS at the Oak Grove Institute designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs?

The testimony of Raymond Hurst from the Oak Grove Institute and written information contained in District’s Exhibit 49 establish that the Oak Grove Institute operates an NPS that is certified by the State of California to provide special education services. The NPS is a candidate for accreditation from the Western Association of Schools and Colleges. The school was founded approximately nine years ago. The school is fully certified and has staff knowledgeable about learning disabilities and emotional problems. In addition to teachers, the staff includes approximately 18 mental health professionals. Of those, four are fully licensed psychiatrists and four are psychologists. The remaining mental health professionals are licensed social workers or marriage, family, and child counselors. All of the teachers, except one who is already appropriately credential, will satisfy the requirements for California teaching credentials by June of 1998. All are currently employed on waivers from the State of California. One teacher holds a special education credential. The staff receives approximately 90 hours of training annually and Mr. Hurst provides monthly in-service training. Mr. Hurst testified that the cost of the program is negotiated with the school district of the child’s residence. He estimated that the daily rate is $110.

The school serves students between the ages of 9 and 18 years old who are experiencing social, emotional, school, and behavioral difficulties. Oak Grove offers a comprehensive therapeutic program that includes individual, group, and family therapy by licensed therapists. The school offers residential and day treatment programs, as well as a day program for student’s such as STUDENT. The District has proposed to place STUDENT in the day program and to provide him transportation between his home and the school. There are 34 students in the day program. All of the students have an identified disability. A majority of the students are identified as emotionally disturbed. Others have learning disabilities. The classes are small, and each class has a teacher and a professional child care staff member whose responsibility is to intervene with children having problems in class. School hours are from 8:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m. each week day. (The day treatment program extends each school day by one and one-half hour.) The students have a seven-period day. The school offers a full range of courses and follows the same curriculum with appropriate modifications that is employed by the Murietta Valley Unified School District. The school has boys’ baseball, girls’ softball, basketball, and volleyball teams that compete in the California Interscholastic Federation. The school also coordinates with a workability program.

Mr. Hurst testified that the entire school is geared toward returning the student to a public school. Mr. Hurst testified that the school follows a social-learning model developed by the Boys Club of America. The students are praised if they behave appropriately and are corrected if they behave inappropriately. Students are taught social replacement behaviors, and all of the students receive social skills training. They also practice the behaviors they are taught. The students work on a point system by which they are granted privileges for the points they earn. The school has a token economy and students receive weekly “cash” to purchase items at the school store. Each student’s program is individualized. Approximately three behaviors are targeted at a time. The students receive individual therapy weekly and participate in family therapy monthly. The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s difficult behavior is of primary concern. The NPS at Oak Grove offers a structured learning environment with specific programs in place to improve the student’s behavior, as well as social, emotional, and educational needs. The point and level systems employed at Oak Grove are designed to teach STUDENT in a positive manner to improve his behavior. These provisions and the accompanying therapy program would afford STUDENT support in his primary area of need--improving his behavior. The social skills program would also address STUDENT’s difficulties getting along with peers. The evidence establishes that the NPS has an appropriate level of staffing to address STUDENT’s need for immediate feedback and the high staff-to-student ratio would allow STUDENT to receive individual attention. The instruction available at the school would address STUDENT’s learning needs as a student with learning disabilities and also offer him access to the regular education curriculum. Additionally, the goal of the NPS is to return students to the regular education environment. The school serves students who have needs similar to STUDENT’s and who fall within his age range. STUDENT expressed his desire to play softball or baseball. Oak Grove has a baseball team that competes with other schools. In comparing STUDENT’s behavioral needs determined above with the program at Oak Grove’s NPS, the Hearing Officer finds that the program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.

Is the certified NPS at the Oak Grove Institute designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?

The evidence discussed at length above describes the ways in which STUDENT’s behavior has interfered with his ability to benefit from his education. Because of inappropriate behavior, STUDENT has been removed from his classes on multiple occasions and assigned to alternative class placement. His behavior has also resulted in his removal from a comprehensive high school to a continuation high school and then to a home program, where he does not have access to the curriculum offered in a regular public high school. Oak Grove offers an intense and therapeutic program that will address STUDENT’s behavior. The therapy component of Oak Grove is important because Mental Health services have been offered and then discontinued by STUDENT’s parent. The program at Oak Grove offers individual and family therapy, which will allow STUDENT’s family to participate in the process. The Hearing Officer notes also that STUDENT will be attending Oak Grove as a day student, which allows him to remain at home and to be involved in his home community. When STUDENT’s behavior has sufficiently improved, he will be able to return to a public high school program. In the meantime, Oak Grove offers STUDENT access to the general education curriculum and also offers instruction designed to meet his learning needs by a staff that is knowledgeable in the area of learning disabilities. Thus, Oak Grove will allow STUDENT to continue to increase his skills in reading, writing, arithmetic, and other subjects while improving his behavior.

As stated above, the NPS proposed by the District offers STUDENT access to the general curriculum and includes professional staff who are appropriately trained and who continue to receive training on a monthly basis. The purpose of the District in recommending STUDENT for placement at Oak Grove is to ensure that he is provided a program that is designed to meet his needs and that will allow him to develop the skills to manage his behavior so that he will be able to successfully return to a public school placement. The ultimate goal of both the District and the program offered by Oak Grove is to guide STUDENT to a productive adult life. These goals are consistent with the findings of Congress, which, in reauthorizing the IDEA in June 1997, concluded that a primary purpose of special education is to prepare the students to lead productive, independent, adult lives, to the maximum extent possible . . . 20 U.S.C. 1400(c). It is noted that STUDENT is rapidly approaching adulthood and needs to develop the internal controls that will allow him to benefit from his education and will lead him to a productive adult life.

For all of the reasons discussed above and given the failure of previous placements to ameliorate STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior, the Hearing Officer concludes that placement in the NPS at the Oak Grove Institute is designed to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Does the NPS at the Oak Grove Institute conform with STUDENT’s IEP?

STUDENT’s IEP includes goals and objectives in mathematics, reading, spelling, written language, and completing school work. The curriculum at Oak Grove offers instruction in these areas. The point system would provide STUDENT with positive rewards for completing his work. STUDENT’s IEP also has goals and objectives to improve social skills and behavior. The NPS offers a social skills program, specific point and level systems, support from appropriately trained personnel, and therapy to address STUDENT’s social and behavioral needs. Therefore, the NPS conforms with STUDENT’s IEP.

Because it has been concluded that placement at the NPS at Oak Grove is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs, is designed to provide him with educational benefit, and conforms to STUDENT’s IEP, it satisfies the requirements of an appropriate placement under Rowley and the IDEA.

ORDER

(1) STUDENT’s placement for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year shall be the nonpublic school at the Oak Grove Institute.

(2) Within 10 business days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to change STUDENT’s placement to the nonpublic school at the Oak Grove Institute for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year, including the extended school year. The IEP team shall also conform STUDENT’s IEP to the findings of this decision and shall indicate on the IEP that the District will be responsible STUDENT’s transportation between his home and Oak Grove.

(3) During the IEP team meeting, the team shall also develop a plan for conducting an assessment of STUDENT’s attentional problems. Thereafter, the District shall undertake the assessment and the parent shall make STUDENT available for the assessment.

(4) Immediately following the IEP meeting, the District shall arrange for STUDENT’s placement at Oak Grove.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The District prevailed on the issue of STUDENT’s placement for the 1998-1999 school year; the parents prevailed as to STUDENT’s need for an assessment of his attention problems.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: November 20, 1998 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

CASE NO. SN 1137-98 Footnotes: 1. In this case,"home and hospital"study is the term used to describe the instruction STUDENT receives at home. 2. The goals and objectives have continued from the previous school year. 3. Because STUDENT had been retained in kindergarten, he was older than the majority of seventh-grade students. 4. STUDENT continued to receive mental health services through December 1997. 5. STUDENT and his father had visited Somerset on January 29, 1998. 6. By agreement of the parties, the hearing was continued from its original hearing dates of August 25 and 26, 1998, to the dates on which the hearing was convened. 7. FATHER also asserted that the District needs to assign a BICM. The District assigned Ms. Stuelke as the BICM following the request by FATHER that Dr. Gustafson no longer serve as the BICM. Therefore, it is unnecessary to address the need to assign a BICM. 8. The District has agreed to review and revise the BIP with the NPS staff, if allowed to place STUDENT at the NPS. 9. FATHER has discontinued services from Mental Health because of an apparent misconception that medication would be the prescribed treatment for STUDENT. Medication cannot, in fact, be done without parental permission.