California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 30, 1998

Escalon Unified School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 1161-98 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu

Escalon Unified may assess a sophomore without parent consent, including standardized testing, under its August 1998 assessment plan.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Escalon Unified School District filed for due process after a mother refused to consent to an assessment of her 16-year-old son, a tenth grader at Escalon High School. He had qualified for special education since 1990 with a specific learning disability in speech and language. The District believed he had been exited from special education after a 1995 triennial assessment, a 1996 mediation agreement, and about two years in private schools. A Department of Education compliance report found he had not been properly exited. The mother said she would agree only to a review of existing records. She argued he had been "tested out" and that more testing would hurt his self-esteem.

The Hearing Officer denied the mother's motion to dismiss. He ruled for the District on every point. Initial assessments and triennial reassessments are both required, so the District could assess over the refusal of consent. Federal law does not limit a triennial evaluation to a records review. The school psychologist, a resource specialist, the student's math teacher, and the speech-language specialist all testified without contradiction. They said the past assessments were outdated or inconsistent and raised questions about attention, visual memory, math and language. The mother offered little evidence to support her concerns. The assessment plan met Education Code section 56321. The order allows a full assessment under the August 27, 1998 plan. The mother must make the student available, and the assessment must be finished within 30 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how the Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) handled a district's request to assess over a parent's refusal. A parent's preference for a records-only review did not block new standardized testing. The district's witnesses showed the prior assessments were outdated, and the parent's concerns about harm to the student were not backed by evidence.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1A. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of Student (over the parent's refusal of consent)?

    Whether the assessment is initial or triennial, the District is entitled and required to assess, and may do so over the parent's refusal of consent through due process.

  2. Issue 1B. Can the District assess Student using standardized tests?

    Federal law (20 U.S.C. 1414(c)) does not limit a triennial evaluation to a review of existing records; uncontroverted testimony showed prior assessments were outdated and new standardized testing was needed.

  3. Issue 1C. May the District use the August 27, 1998 assessment plan to assess Student?

    The August 27, 1998 assessment plan met Education Code section 56321 requirements and may be used to assess Student.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district may assess without consent. Escalon Unified School District is entitled to conduct a full assessment of Student in accord with the assessment plan dated August 27, 1998.
  • Mother shall make Student reasonably available for the assessment; the assessment shall be completed within thirty days from the date of the decision.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist., 811 F.2d 1307 (9th Cir. 1987); Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist., 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir. 1995); 20 U.S.C. 1414(a) and (c); Education Code 56320, 56321, 56381, 56506(e)

People named in the decision

  • Judy Wentworth, director of curriculum and categorical programs, Escalon Unified School District
  • Sandee Kludt, SELPA director, San Joaquin County SELPA
  • Dr. Jim Sidey, school psychologist, Escalon Unified School District
  • Elaine Dison-Ugarkovich, itinerant resource specialist, Manteca Unified School District
  • Mark Loureiro, resource specialist, Escalon High School
  • Leon Kuhn, math (Algebra) teacher, Escalon High School
  • Joan Justice-Brown, language and speech specialist / special education director, certified speech pathologist, Escalon Unified School District
  • Arlee Maier, private assessor, Private
  • Valley Oak School, private school (unilateral placement), Turlock
  • Ripon Christian School, private school (placement; conducted achievement testing), Ripon

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

Case Number: SN 1161-98 Case Year: 1998 Petitioner: ESCALON UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Assessment CDS Code: 39-68502 District: Escalon Unified Disability Type: Specific Learning Disability Speech or Language Impairment

Case Details CASE NO. SN 1161-98 This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Escalon, California, on November 17 and 18, 1998. Petitioner Escalon Unified School District ("Escalon USD" or "District") was represented at the hearing by attorney Eliza McArthur. Also present on Petitioner's behalf were Judy Wentworth, director of curriculum and categorical programs for Escalon USD, and Sandee Kludt, SELPA director for San Joaquin County. Respondent was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Respondent's grandmother was also present at the hearing on his behalf. Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Judy Wentworth, director of curriculum and categorical programs for Escalon USD; Dr. Jim Sidey, school psychologist; Sandee Kludt, SELPA director for San Joaquin County; Elaine Dison-Ugarkovich, resource specialist for Manteca Unified School District; Mark Loureiro, resource specialist for Escalon High School; Leon Kuhn, STUDENT'S math teacher; and Joan Justice-Brown, language and speech specialist for Escalon USD. Respondent's mother, MOTHER, testified on her son's behalf. Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing arguments. Closing arguments were received on December 4, 1998. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. PROCEDURAL MATTERS At the beginning of the hearing, the Parent made a motion to dismiss the District's case. The Parent argued that no assessment of STUDENT is needed because STUDENT is currently eligible for special education services. To support her contention, the Parent cited a Department of Education compliance report which found that STUDENT had not properly been exited from special education services. The District, opposing the motion for dismissal of the case, contended that STUDENT'S prior assessments were outdated and that new assessments were needed to determine STUDENT'S current level of functioning. The District added that, even if STUDENT was still eligible for special education services based on the compliance report, new assessments were needed to determine what type of services to provide to STUDENT. Additionally, the District argued that the hearing was still necessary because MOTHER OF STUDENT had refused numerous requests for further assessments. The Hearing Officer found that the question regarding the necessity for further assessments could only be resolved following a full evidentiary hearing. As a result, the Hearing Officer denied the motion to dismiss the case. ISSUE Is Escalon Unified School District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT using the August 27, 1998 assessment plan? POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES The parties disagree as to whether the assessment requested by the District is an initial assessment or a triennial assessment and, regardless of what the assessment is called, whether the requested assessment is necessary. The District's primary position is that STUDENT was exited from special education services pursuant to a 1996 mediation agreement and when he was unilaterally placed by his mother in schools outside the district for two years, starting at the end of his sixth grade year. Furthermore, the District asserts that, whether the assessment is an initial assessment or a triennial assessment, a new assessment is needed because STUDENT'S prior assessments are outdated and raise a number of questions regarding his areas of suspected disability. Thus, the District contends that a full and thorough assessment must be done in order to determine STUDENT'S eligibility and possibly his current level of need. The Respondent's mother asserts that the assessment is a triennial assessment because STUDENT was never properly exited from special education within the District. She further states that she will consent to a triennial evaluation of STUDENT if the evaluation consists solely of a review of STUDENT'S existing records. MOTHER distinguishes the term "evaluation" from the term "tests." Based on her usage of the terms, the Hearing Officer gleans that MOTHER refers to "evaluation" as a review of STUDENT's records to determine his progress. Also, it appears that MOTHER equates the term "tests" to mean tools of assessment. (Footnote 1) The Parent opposes additional standardized testing of STUDENT. MOTHER OF STUDENT argues that STUDENT has been assessed on numerous occasions since 1990 and that these assessments provide the District with ample information to determine STUDENT'S current needs. Moreover, MOTHER OF STUDENT opposes further testing because she believes that STUDENT has been "tested out." (Footnote 2) In sum, MOTHER OF STUDENT argues that additional testing is needless, excessive, and would negatively affect STUDENT'S self-esteem. BACKGROUND

FACTS STUDENT is a sixteen-year-old sophomore who is currently attending Escalon High School in Escalon, California. STUDENT attended school within the District from elementary school through 1995. STUDENT had been eligible for special education services within the District as a student with a specific learning disability in the areas of speech and language since 1990. In 1995, while STUDENT was in the sixth grade, MOTHER OF STUDENT removed STUDENT from his school within the Escalon Unified School District and unilaterally placed STUDENT at Valley Oak School in Turlock. Despite STUDENT'S being placed at a school outside the District, Escalon Unified School District conducted a full triennial assessment of STUDENT in November 1995. The triennial assessment consisted of a language and speech evaluation, a psychological evaluation, and an academic evaluation. An IEP meeting was held in December 1995, one month after the triennial assessment was completed. At this IEP meeting, the District and MOTHER OF STUDENT disagreed as to STUDENT'S eligibility for special education services. The District concluded that STUDENT was no longer eligible for such services, while MOTHER OF STUDENT contended that STUDENT was still eligible. In early 1996, the District and MOTHER OF STUDENT reached a mediation agreement whereby the District agreed to reimburse MOTHER OF STUDENT for the costs involved in placing STUDENT at Valley Oak School. According to Judy Wentworth, director of curriculum for Escalon USD, the District understood that the mediation agreement called for STUDENT to return to the district for the 1996- 1997 school year. STUDENT, however, was not returned to the district during this time but was placed at Ripon Christian School, a private school outside the district. While STUDENT was attending school outside the district, three additional assessments were completed. (Footnote 3) On February 20, 1996, while STUDENT was attending Valley Oak School, a private assessment was conducted by Arlee Maier (footnote 4). During late 1996 and in May 1997, Ripon Christian School conducted cognitive assessments of STUDENT which consisted solely of the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement, Revised. On November 5, 1997, over two years after STUDENT was initially removed from the District, STUDENT returned to Escalon to attend Escalon High School. During the weeks following STUDENT'S return to Escalon, the parties met at numerous 504 meetings but disagreed as to whether STUDENT should receive special education services or 504 accommodations. In January 1998, MOTHER OF STUDENT filed a compliance complaint against the District with the California Department of Education asserting, in part, that when STUDENT returned to the District the District failed to conduct an IEP meeting to review STUDENT'S IEP. (Footnote 5) The Department of Education found the District to be out of compliance and ordered an IEP meeting to be held. (Resp. Exh. 1.) On June 24, 1998, an IEP meeting was held to discuss the compliance review. During this meeting, an assessment plan was created but was not signed or consented to by MOTHER OF STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 11.) The District sent a letter to MOTHER OF STUDENT on July 16, 1998, to again request consent for the assessment plan. (Dist. Exh. 15.) However, consent was again withheld. Due to the lack of consent, the District requested a special education due process hearing on August 4, 1998, to resolve the issue of its right to assess STUDENT. An updated assessment plan was developed on August 27, 1998. (Dist. Exh. 11.) Despite another letter from the District to MOTHER OF STUDENT requesting consent (Dist. Exh. 19), MOTHER OF STUDENT again denied consent to assess STUDENT. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW Is Escalon Unified School District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT using the August 27, 1997 assessment plan? A. Is the District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT? California special education law provides that "before any action is taken with respect to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs in special education instruction, an individual assessment of the pupil's educational needs shall be conducted." California Education Code 56320. Similarly, federal law also requires districts to conduct an evaluation (footnote 6) of a student prior to the provision of special education and related services for that student. 20 U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(A). In regard to triennial evaluations, California special education law provides that a reassessment of a student shall be conducted at least every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if the pupil's parent or teacher requests a new assessment. California Education Code 56381. Federal law also requires that each child with a disability be reevaluated at least once every three years. 20 U.S.C. 1414(a)(2)(A). Under both California and federal law, districts are required to conduct both initial and triennial evaluations. Thus, regardless of whether the assessment in this case is an initial assessment or a triennial assessment, the District is not only entitled, but is required, to conduct an assessment of STUDENT. The analysis now turns to whether the District may assess STUDENT when the parent has withheld consent for such assessment. Parental consent for an evaluation of a child is required before a school district can assess the child. California Education Code 56321(c) and U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(A)(i). However, a local educational agency can overcome a lack of parental consent for an evaluation by utilizing due process hearing procedures. California Education Code 56321(c), 56506(e), and U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(A)(ii). The District may assess a student, despite the lack of parental consent to assess, if the District proves at a due process hearing that an initial or triennial assessment is necessary. California Education Code 56506(e) and U.S.C. 1414(a)(1)(A)(ii). In Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1315 (9th Cir. 1987), the Ninth Circuit stated that "if the parents want Gregory to receive special education under the Act, they are obligated to permit such testing. In Andress v. Cleveland Independent School Dist., 64 F.3d 176 (5th Cir 1995), the Fifth Circuit concluded that "a parent who desires for her child to receive special education must allow the school district to reevaluate the child...there is no exception to this rule." The undisputed evidence shows that the District has attempted to gain consent and that MOTHER OF STUDENT has withheld such consent. (Dist. Exh. 19 and Testimony of Judy Wentworth.) Additionally, both parties contend that the evaluation to be conducted is either an initial evaluation or a triennial evaluation. Because the District is both entitled, and is required, to conduct initial and triennial evaluations, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has the right to conduct an evaluation of STUDENT over MOTHER OF STUDENT'S denial of consent. B. Can the District assess STUDENT using standardized tests? The Parent, opposing additional testing, argues that, unlike California law, federal law pursuant to U.S.C. 1414(c) confines the triennial evaluation to a review of the child's existing records. U.S.C. 1414(c)(1) (A) states that, as part of any reevaluation, the IEP team shall "review existing evaluation data on the child, including evaluations and information provided by the parents of the child, current classroom-based assessments and observations, and teacher and related services providers observation." Upon examining the federal law provisions relating to triennial evaluations in their entirety, the Hearing Officer finds that federal law does not limit triennial evaluations to only a review of the student's existing records. (Footnote 7) MOTHER OF STUDENT'S argument fails to take into account that U.S.C. 1414(c) does not require that the District rely solely on the existing record in conducting the triennial evaluation. U.S.C. 1414(c)(1)(B) allows for the IEP team to identify what additional data is needed to determine, among other things, whether the child continues to have such a disability, the present levels of performance and educational needs of the child, and whether any additions or modifications to the special education and related services are needed to enable the child to meet the measurable goals set out in the IEP. According to this section, the district is not limited to the student's existing record, but may request further testing be conducted to obtain the necessary additional data previously identified by the IEP team. In this case, an IEP meeting convened on August 24, 1998 where everyone but MOTHER OF STUDENT agreed that further assessments are needed to determine STUDENT'S current level of functioning. (Dist. Exh. 18.) An assessment plan was proposed on August 27, 1998 (Dist. Exh. 11), but consent to assess STUDENT was withheld by MOTHER OF STUDENT. Despite MOTHER OF STUDENT'S argument that no additional testing is necessary, the evidence presented at hearing supports otherwise. At hearing, a number of witnesses testified regarding the need for additional testing of STUDENT. Other than MOTHER OF STUDENT'S argument that the information the District is seeking may already be found in STUDENT'S existing records, the testimony of the District witnesses was uncontroverted. Dr. Jim Sidey, educational psychologist, testified that he reviewed the District's prior assessments as well as the Maier assessment and the Ripon Christian assessments and determined that further testing is needed in a number of areas. Dr. Sidey testified that the Maier assessment raised questions about STUDENT'S attentional difficulties that he concluded should be explored further. Additionally, he stated that STUDENT'S language scores are inconsistent on many of the standardized tests and that further standardized tests are needed to clarify these inconsistencies. Furthermore, Dr. Sidey testified that the Maier assessment mentions weaknesses in visual memory and that this weakness needs to be additionally explored. Finally, Dr. Sidey stated that he can not attest to the validity of the Ripon Christian assessments because no information was given as to the assessor's credentials. Moreover, Dr. Sidey stated that because the Ripon Christian assessors neglected to comment on STUDENT'S testing behaviors in the report, he does not know whether STUDENT'S test results were affected by STUDENT'S behavior when he was tested. Elaine Dison- Ugarkovich, an itinerant resource specialist for Manteca School District, testified that STUDENT needs an updated academic assessment. Ms. Dison-Ugarkovich explained that, even assuming that the last academic assessment done by Ripon Christian in May of STUDENT'S eighth grade year was valid, STUDENT is currently in the tenth grade. She stated that the eighth grade environment and demands are significantly different from those of the tenth grade and that a new academic assessment is required to determine STUDENT'S current level of functioning. She also stated that the new assessment is needed in order to appropriately determine special education goals and objectives for STUDENT. Thus, she stated that looking at the STUDENT'S grades and records alone is one dimensional and that standardized testing is needed to provide a fuller picture of STUDENT'S needs. Furthermore, she stated that the standardized tests are normed and provide standard deviations, which is information needed when looking at achievement/ability discrepancies for a child with a specific learning disability. Leon Kuhn, STUDENT'S Algebra teacher, testified that STUDENT appears to have problems with mathematical concepts. Mr. Kuhn further stated that, despite STUDENT'S being given accommodations such as 1:1 attention on tests and assignments and being allowed to use a calculator, STUDENT does not seem to understand how to do certain math problems. Mr. Kuhn stated that he questioned whether STUDENT understood the math concepts. Finally, Joan Justice-Brown, special education director for Escalon USD and certified speech pathologist, stated that she has reviewed STUDENT'S records and she recommends that STUDENT be tested in the area of speech and language. She based her recommendation on STUDENT'S history of speech pathology and stated that various areas of the 1995 triennial assessment signaled low scores that raised questions as to STUDENT'S current need for speech and language services. Although the Parent contends that STUDENT has been "tested out" and that further testing would negatively affect his self-esteem, little evidence was presented at hearing to support these contentions. Furthermore, the most recent assessment was conducted in May 1997, over a year and a half ago. The Parent also contended that the additional testing is excessive and unnecessary because the information derived from such tests can be found in STUDENT'S prior assessments. However, no evidence was presented at hearing to support such contention or to controvert the testimony that the prior assessments are outdated and do not reflect STUDENT'S current functioning. Because the great weight of the evidence supports the position that additional testing is needed, the Hearing Officer notes that, under federal law, the District may request that additional testing be conducted for STUDENT as part of his triennial evaluation. Although the Parent asserted that additional testing would negatively affect STUDENT, her contention lacked evidentiary support and, thus, can not overcome the District's right to conduct assessments of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer now turns to whether the District may conduct assessments of STUDENT using the August 27, 1998 assessment. C. May the District use the August 27, 1998 assessment plan to assess STUDENT? Pursuant to California Education Code 56321, a proposed assessment plan given to parents shall: (1) be in language that is easily understood by the general public, (2) be provided in the primary language of the parent, (3) explain the types of assessments to be conducted, and (4) state that no individualized education program will result from the assessment without the consent of the parent. Federal law is silent as to requirements for the contents of an assessment plan. In the absence of federal law, California law applies. In this case, the assessment plan meets all of the above California requirements. The assessment plan is written in language that is easily understandable by the general public. Additionally, the assessment plan is written in English, the primary language of STUDENT'S mother. Furthermore, the assessment plan sets forth that STUDENT should be tested in the areas of language/speech/communication development, academic/preacademic achievement, psycho-motor development, intellectual development, and social/adaptive behavior. (Dist. Exh. 11.) The assessment plan also states that vocational, and audiological areas should be examined and that medical history/records, previous assessments, inter-agency information, and/or independent evaluations should be examined. Finally, the assessment plan clearly states that consent is required before an individualized education plan will result. Because the assessment plan dated August 27, 1998, meets all of the legal requirements for an assessment plan, the assessment plan is appropriate and may be used by the District to assess STUDENT. ORDER 1. Escalon Unified School District is entitled to conduct a full assessment of STUDENT in accord with the assessment plan dated August 27, 1998. 2. MOTHER OF STUDENT shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the District to conduct such assessment. The assessment shall be completed within thirty days from the date of this decision. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: I. Is Escalon Unified School District entitled to conduct an assessment of STUDENT using the August 27, 1998 assessment plan? Escalon USD prevailed on this issue. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code 56505(i). DATED: December 30, 1998 ____________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnotes CASE NO. SN 1161-98 1. MOTHER OF STUDENT argued that section 1414(c) of the IDEA supports her argument because it confines triennial evaluations to a review of the student's records, where no additional testing is conducted. 2. MOTHER OF STUDENT asserts that frequent testing of STUDENT has detrimentally affected his self-esteem and that STUDENT dislikes testing and will resist further testing. 3. Neither party submitted these assessments to be admitted into evidence. Rather, the assessments were primarily used to "refresh" the witnesses' recollection during testimony. 4. No information was given either in testimony or documentary evidence as to Ms. Maier's qualifications or background. 5. Upon STUDENT'S return to Escalon, the district held a number of 504 meetings rather than IEP meetings, believing that STUDENT had been previously exited from special education within the district. The District's belief was, in part, due to its understanding of the 1996 mediation agreement. 6. The term "evaluation" is used in federal law, and the term "assessment" is used in California law. Both terms are equivalent. 7. If California law governs, there is no question that standardized tests may be used as part of a triennial evaluation. See California Education Code 56381 and 56320 et seq. Since federal law is discussed below and is found to allow for standardized testing to be used as part of a triennial evaluation, it is unnecessary to resolve whether California or federal law applies.