California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 14, 2002
Student v. Cypress Elementary School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1176-02 · Hearing Officer Trevor Skarda
Cypress Elementary School District may reassess a third grader without parental consent; parent's request to end resource services denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A parent and the Cypress Elementary School District filed separate due process requests, which were consolidated. The student was nine, in third grade, and eligible under speech and language impairment because of significant receptive and expressive language delays. At several IEP meetings, the mother asked for less resource specialist program (RSP) help. The District agreed even when staff believed she needed more. By December 2001, RSP was down to 25 minutes, three times a week, for reading comprehension only. The mother then sought to end RSP completely and refused consent to a May 23, 2002 reassessment plan.
The Hearing Officer found the student's reading comprehension was more than three years below her age. Her teachers testified she could decode at about a first grade level but could not understand what she read. Applying the Rowley standard, the Hearing Officer held she needs at least her current RSP services and denied the request to remove them. On the District's issue, the Hearing Officer found that conditions warranted reassessment before the three-year review in academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, visual/auditory processing and motor skills, intellectual functioning, and health. The mother had agreed to the speech-language assessment. The Hearing Officer noted that her records repeatedly described autistic-like behaviors, but she had never been assessed for autism. The District may assess without the parent's consent after giving ten days' notice. It must then hold an IEP meeting within the required timelines.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO allowed a district to reassess a student before her three-year review, without parental consent, when conditions warranted it. The Hearing Officer looked at each proposed assessment area separately. The decision also stated that a district must offer the program it believes is appropriate, even when a parent asks for fewer services.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue Student's Issue. Does STUDENT require resource specialist program (RSP) services to address her reading comprehension needs? (Student contended she needs no RSP services.)
Student has a unique need in reading comprehension and requires at least the RSP services in her current IEP; the parent's request to remove her from RSP was denied.
- District prevailedDistrict-filed: assess without consent
Issue District's Issue. Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the May 23, 2002 assessment plan?
Conditions warranted reassessment before the triennial in academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior, visual/auditory processing and motor skills, intellectual functioning, and health; the parent stipulated to the speech-language area. The District may assess without parental consent.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that district may assess without consent. District may assess the student under its May 23, 2002 assessment plan (District's Exhibit 161). The District must give at least ten days' notice of assessment dates, and the parent must make the student available. The District must take all reasonable steps to complete the assessments and convene an IEP meeting within the required timelines.
- Student's request for relief (removal from RSP services) was denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)
People named in the decision
- Troy Hunt, Director of student services and instruction, Cypress Elementary School District
- Silvia Gonzales, State-certified Spanish interpreter at hearing
- Joe Hernandez, State-certified Spanish interpreter at hearing
- Carol Mispagel, School psychologist (cognitive assessment, 1997), Centralia School District
- Ms. Quaack, Kindergarten teacher who made student intervention team referral, Morris School, Cypress Elementary School District
- J.P. Haley, Resource specialist (assessment, May 2000), Cypress Elementary School District
- James Konowal, School psychologist (psychological assessment, May 2000), Cypress Elementary School District
- Gabriella Raab, Regular education teacher, Arnold School, Cypress Elementary School District
- Mrs. Stockard, English language development teacher, Cypress Elementary School District
- Kathy Rokicki, School psychologist (assessor and witness; also spelled Cathy), Cypress Elementary School District
- Beth Sigma / Beth Sigman, Speech and language therapist, Cypress Elementary School District
- Ms. Age, Resource teacher (2000-2001), Cypress Elementary School District
- Ms. Pham, Second grade regular education teacher (witness), Cypress Elementary School District
- Teri Petrocco, Resource specialist (assessment, November 2001; witness), Cypress Elementary School District
- Elizabeth Kemp, RSP teacher (witness), Cypress Elementary School District
- Regional Center of Orange County, Regional center (screened student in 1996)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Cypress, California, on July 18 and 19, 2002.
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her mother, MOTHER. The Cypress Elementary School District (District or Cypress) was represented by attorney David Larsen of the law firm Rutan and Tucker. Also present on behalf of the District was Troy Hunt, the director of student services and instruction in the District. Also present on the first hearing day was state-certified Spanish interpreter Silvia Gonzales. On the final hearing day, state-certified Spanish interpreter Joe Hernandez was present.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties provided oral closing arguments on the last hearing day. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
STUDENT’S ISSUE
Does STUDENT require resource specialist program (RSP) services to address her reading comprehension needs?
DISTRICT’S ISSUE
Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the May 23, 2002 assessment plan?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a nine-year-old third grade student who lives within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Cypress Elementary School District. She has significant receptive and expressive language delays and is currently eligible for special education and related services because of a speech and language impairment, although in the past she has been found eligible under different categories including specific learning disability (SLD).
STUDENT was first found eligible for special education by her previous school district, the Centralia School District (Centralia), in June 1996. Her initial IEP states that she was eligible because assessments revealed characteristics that were “autism-like.” The IEP team noted delays in communication, socialization, cognition, self-help and pre-academics and pre-vocational skills. District’s Exh. 16. STUDENT was initially placed in a preschool special day class (SDC) at Dysinger School, where she attended for about one week. After one week, the PARENTSs removed STUDENT because the other children were “autistic.” District’s Exh. 20.
In late June 1996, the Regional Center of Orange County (Regional Center) screened STUDENT for autism and mental retardation. The screener concluded that STUDENT was neither autistic nor mentally retarded, and found STUDENT ineligible for Regional Center services. District’s Exh. 17.
Centralia held a follow-up IEP team meeting in September 1996. STUDENT’s eligibility category was changed to learning disabled. Goals and objectives were developed in the areas of expressive and receptive language, pre-academic readiness, and prevocational skills (to address STUDENT’s difficulties paying attention, following simple instructions, and remaining seated). Speech and language services in the amount of twenty minutes two times a week were provided to address STUDENT’s severe expressive and receptive language delays. The preschool SDC at Dysinger School was again offered and again rejected by thePARENTS, who instead, elected to enroll STUDENT in an afternoon Head Start program. District’s Exh. 19.
A follow-up IEP team meeting was held in November 1996 at which thePARENTS agreed to place STUDENT at Dysinger School. The records reflect that STUDENT attended Dysinger each morning for three hours and fifteen minutes, five days a week, through the beginning of the following summer. District’s Exh. 23.
In April 1997, Carol Mispagel, a school psychologist with Centralia, completed a cognitive assessment of STUDENT, who was 50 months old at the time. Ms. Mispagel administered the Southern California Ordinal Scales of Development and found that STUDENT was functioning at a cognitive level of 18-24 months, with a ceiling of 24 to 48 months. She noted that STUDENT had made some cognitive growth since the previous assessment in May 1996 and that her behavior had also improved. District’s Exh. 46.
After Ms. Mispagel’s assessment, Centralia convened an IEP team meeting. District’s Exh. 49. The IEP reflects that the District members of the IEP team believed that STUDENT displayed better expressive language skills than receptive language skills. Mrs. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT “understands everything” that was spoken to her and the team agreed to drop her receptive language goal and objective. Id.
On June 4, 1997, Centralia convened STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting. At some point in the meeting following a discussion of Ms. Mispagel’s cognitive testing, thePARENTS expressed their unhappiness with Ms. Mispagel and with the SDC teacher at Dysinger School. ThePARENTS indicated that STUDENT would “not be back at school” and left the meeting without signing the IEP. District’s Exh. 57. STUDENT did not return to the Dysinger School.(Footnote 1)
STUDENT received no special education or related services from Centralia during the 1997-1998 school year. It is unclear whether she received any special education services from any other entity, although there was evidence that thePARENTS placed STUDENT in a private school during at least a portion of this school year. District’s Exh. 74. ThePARENTS sought Regional Center services at some point during the school year, but later rejected a Regional Center assessment request and asked that they no longer be contacted by the Regional Center. District’s Exhs. 61, 62, 71 and 74.
STUDENT received no special education or related services from Centralia during the following (1998-1999) school year. Instead, STUDENT’s parents placed her in a private school, where she attended Kindergarten.
At the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, thePARENTS enrolled STUDENT in the Cypress Elementary School District. District’s Exh. 79. She was initially placed in a regular education kindergarten class at the Morris School with no special education services.(Footnote 2) STUDENT exhibited serious receptive and expressive language delays, struggled in all academic areas, and exhibited unusual behaviors. Her kindergarten teacher, Ms. Quaack, eventually referred STUDENT to a student intervention team (SIT) in January 2000. District’s Exh. 84. Ms. Quaack stated in the referral that:
STUDENT cannot orally communicate in complete sentences. [She] will tell students to stop when no one is there and nothing has happened. [Her] understanding is minimal.
District’s Exh. 84.
On March 3, 2000, after the SIT referral, Cypress convened an IEP team meeting. The team determined that STUDENT needed to be assessed for eligibility for special education, and developed an assessment plan. ThePARENTS signed the assessment. District’s Exh. 86.
On April 21, 2000, a speech and language assessment was completed.(Footnote 3) The assessor noted that STUDENT was verbal but often “echolalic,” a behavior sometimes associated with autism. The assessor noted further that:
STUDENT is a child who has reduced learning potential. She also has a home language of Spanish, although her Spanish is delayed as are her English skills. Her educational program should facilitate increased comprehension and communication skills.
District’s Exh. 91.
On May 5, 2000, resource specialist J.P. Haley completed an assessment report. STUDENT was 7 years and 3 months old and had nearly completed her second year of kindergarten at the time of his assessment. Mr. Haley administered the Brigance Achievement Test and found that STUDENT had weakness in the areas of general knowledge, reading skills, mathematics and manuscript writing. He also found that:
STUDENT should be able to identify quantity comparisons, read at least 50% of pre-primer site words, recite the alphabet, read color/number words, listen with attention to stories, count up to 20, understand basic numeric concepts, write letters in sequence and her name and age. Although STUDENT can write some letters in her name, her writing skills are indicative of student beginning kindergarten. STUDENT displayed echolalia and a general lack of understanding of questions asked of her. Testing responses were confirmed in both English and Spanish.
District’s Exh. 92.
School psychologist James Konowal completed a psychological assessment of STUDENT on May 5, 2000. He assessed STUDENT in the areas of intellectual functioning, achievement and adaptive behavior. Mr. Konowal’s assessment included observations, and parent interviews, in addition to standardized tests of intellectual functioning and achievement, and an adaptive behavior assessment. District’s Exh. 93.
In the area of intellectual function, Mr. Konowal administered two tests, the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children – Third Edition (WISC III), and the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test (K-BIT). On the WISC III, STUDENT received a full scale intelligence quotient score of 52, a verbal IQ of 52, and a performance IQ of 52. Overall, he found that STUDENT was functioning at a level at or better than only one percent of her same-age peers on the WISC III. On the K-BIT, which is designed to provide an indication of an individual’s overall intellectual ability based on tasks in the areas of vocabulary and the analysis of matrices, STUDENT received an IQ composite of 42, indicating that she was functioning at the first percentile as compared to her same-age peers. Id.
In the area of academic achievement, Mr. Konowal administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement - Form A (WJ-R). STUDENT received standard scores of 65 in broad reading, 24 in broad math and 76 in broad written language. Id. In the area of adaptive functioning, Mr. Konowal administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales: Classroom Edition (Vineland), which was completed by STUDENT’s teacher. STUDENT received an adaptive composite standard score of 61, indicating performance at or better than 1 percent of her peers in the areas of communication, daily living skills and socialization. Id. Mr. Konowal opined in the summary section of his report that STUDENT appeared to be eligible for special education in the area of “significantly below average intellectual potential,” and he recommended that she be placed in an SDC pending an IEP team meeting. Id.
The IEP team convened on May 19, 2000. Instead of discussing the assessments and developing a program for STUDENT, who appeared to be eligible for special education services, the District determined that thePARENTS had not yet established residency in the District, and the IEP team meeting was “delayed until residency requirements are established.” District’s Exh. 95.
In August 2000, thePARENTS established residency in the Cypress, and STUDENT was enrolled in the District for the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT was initially placed in a regular education classroom at Arnold School, taught by Gabriella Raab. She received no special education or related services from Cypress because she had not yet been found eligible for services. District’s Exh. 96.
An IEP team meeting eventually convened on October 12, 2000. The team agreed that updated assessments from a resource teacher, school psychologist, and a speech and language therapist were necessary. Although she had not yet been found eligible for special education by the District, a goal and corresponding objectives were developed in the area of expressive language, and the team agreed that speech and language services should immediately begin pending the assessment results:
STUDENT will begin services with the speech and language specialist for 30 minutes 2 times weekly. She also receives English Language development with Mrs. Stockard 15 minutes, [three times each week]. Another meeting will be held to add RSP goals after the assessment.
District’s Exh. 106.
Thereafter, in October/November 2000, Kathy Rokicki, a school psychologist, conducted a psychological evaluation of STUDENT. She assessed STUDENT’s intellectual functioning, achievement and adaptive behavior. In the area of intellectual functioning, Ms. Rokicki administered only the performance subtest of the WISC-III. On that test, STUDENT received a performance IQ of 50, at or better than less than .1 percent of her same-age peers. District’s Exh. 109.
Ms. Rokicki administered two versions of the Vineland to assess STUDENT’s adaptive functioning, a teacher edition and a parent edition. On the parent edition, STUDENT scored in the average range in the areas of communication (a standard score of 78), socialization (101) and daily living skills (84). On the teacher edition, completed by the classroom teacher, STUDENT received standard scores of 61 in communication and 66 in socialization. Her teacher reported that “STUDENT is easily distracted in the classroom, has [a] short attention span, has trouble concentrating, repeats one thought over and over, and struggles academically.” Id.
Two versions of the Woodcock Johnson Revised (WJ-R) were administered to assess STUDENT’s academic achievement. “Version A” of the WJ-R was administered in English to STUDENT by Ms. Rokicki alone, and “Version B” was later administered in Spanish with Mrs. MOTHER acting as an STUDENT’s Spanish interpreter. The scores were not significantly different on the two versions of the WJ-R in all academic areas but mathematics. In broad reading, STUDENT received a standard score of 58 in the first and second tests (her reading comprehension had declined from 60 to 57). In broad written language, STUDENT received a 73 on the first test and a 70 on the second. In broad knowledge, her score increased from a standard score of 52 to 53 from the first to the second test version. In broad mathematics, STUDENT’s score increased from a 24 to a 42 from the first to second tests, although this remained her weakest achievement area. Id.
In the summary section of her report, Ms. Rokicki wrote that:
STUDENT is a seven year old girl who demonstrates a below [average] general intellectual functioning on current and previous intellectual testing. Validity of such testing may be affected by her second language acquisition and vision needs. Parents describe STUDENT’s adaptive behavior at home to be in the average range. Using standardized measures of assessment, STUDENT scores significantly below age and grade expectancies in the areas of reading, math and written language.
District’s Exh. 109.
Speech and language therapist Beth Sigma also evaluated STUDENT on December 6, 2000. Ms. Sigma tested STUDENT using both Spanish and English and found significant expressive and receptive language delays in both languages. She recommended continued speech and language therapy, two times each week for thirty minutes. District’s Exh. 113.
On December 8, 2000, after all of the assessments had been completed, the IEP team reconvened and found STUDENT eligible under the category speech and language impaired. Goals and objectives were developed and agreed to in the unique-need areas of reading, math and written language, and her expressive language goal and objectives were updated. In addition to speech and language services, STUDENT was offered 145 minutes of daily pull-out RSP support to implement her goals and objectives in the areas of reading, math and written language. STUDENT’s parents agreed to the IEP, and it was immediately implemented. District’s Exh. 114.
Five days later, Mrs. MOTHER requested an IEP team meeting because she did not want STUDENT to go to RSP until 10:30 in the morning. District’s Exh. 116. The IEP team met on December 18, 2000, and the District members of the IEP team agreed to a drastic reduction in RSP time – there was no evidence presented at the Hearing that STUDENT’s substantial unique needs had changed in the interim period. Her RSP time was reduced from 145 minutes each day to only 45 minutes each day, essentially because Mrs. MOTHER had requested the change:
IEP team recommends change to 45 minutes daily in RSP based on mother’s request for less time. Recommend IEP team meet at beginning of February after new teacher has worked with STUDENT to adjust RSP times or goals as needed.
District’s Exh. 117.
Thereafter, STUDENT received 45 minutes of daily RSP support, along with speech and language therapy two times each week for 30 minutes, from the December 18, 2000 IEP team meeting through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.
On June 17, 2001, at the end of the 2000-2001 school year, IEP team convened to discuss STUDENT’s program and general progress.(Footnote 4) District’s Exh. 122. The regular education teacher, Ms. Raab, prepared a progress report prior to the meeting, which she shared with the IEP team. She noted in her report that, overall, STUDENT had improved in math, reading and written language, but that she often copied other students’ work. In the area of reading, Ms. Raab wrote that STUDENT needed to improve in the following areas: (1) understanding the concept of picture/word relationships, (2) recognizing/understanding words in a story as well as out of position in print, (3) comprehending a story with simple details, and (4) reading smoothly. She also reported that STUDENT could not blend sounds into words, nor could she write words in sentences that were dictated by the teacher. In math, Ms. Raab found that STUDENT was able to add and subtract to/from 18 using her fingers with assistance. Finally, Ms. Raab observed that STUDENT did not play with the other children and that she was sensitive. District’s Exh. 153. STUDENT’s resource teacher, Ms. Age, noted that STUDENT had a short attention span. District’s Exh. 122. STUDENT’s program was not changed; she continued to receive 45 minutes of daily RSP services, along with the same amount of speech and language therapy. Id.
During the summer of 2001, STUDENT participated in a summer school program in which she received 74 hours of instruction in the areas of language arts and mathematics. STUDENT took identical pre and post summer school tests which reveal that in language arts, she regressed in the test areas of following directions, sounds, sentences, naming words, and beginning a sentence. In mathematics, which addressed money, counting, adding and subtracting, and word problems, her pre and post tests scores were almost identical. The summer school instructor noted that STUDENT “put forth a great effort” but that she needed continued practice in language arts and basic math skills. She received no special education services during this period.(Footnote 5) District’s Exh. 128.
STUDENT began the 2001-2002 school year in Ms. Pham’s regular education second grade class, with 45 minutes of daily pull-out RSP services. Ms. Pham testified that STUDENT struggled in all academic areas throughout the year, except for spelling. In the area of spelling, Ms. Pham testified that STUDENT was unable to generalize spelling skills into other written work, i.e., she could spell words on the tests but not in other written work. Testimony of Pham.
On October 4, 2001, an IEP team meeting convened. Mrs. MOTHER requested the meeting because she felt STUDENT was able to complete more challenging work at home than she was receiving in the second grade classroom or in RSP. Mrs. MOTHER requested a reduction in RSP services. The District members of the IEP team recommended an increase in RSP services to approximately 75 minutes per day, principally because of STUDENT’s continuing difficulties in the area of mathematics. MOTHER resisted, and the IEP team eventually agreed to reduce STUDENT’s language arts resource time and increase her math resource time (her total amount of RSP time remained about the same). District’s Exh. 131.
On November 1, 2001, another IEP team meeting was held and MOTHER requested that STUDENT no longer receive any mathematics instruction in RSP. District’s Exh. 133. MOTHER signed an assessment plan which proposed to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement and speech and language development. District’s Exh. 134. STUDENT received RSP support to address only her reading needs after the meeting. District’s Exh. 136.
On November 11, 2001, Kathy Rokicki reassessed STUDENT in the area of academic achievement. She administered the Woodcock Johnson III Tests of Achievement (WJ III), and she compared STUDENT’s performance to the results on the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement - Revised (WJ-R) administered a year earlier. Overall, STUDENT’s standard score in broad reading increased from a 58 to a 62, her broad math score increased from a 24 to a 65, and her broad written language score decreased from a 73 to a 62. Comparing the “grade equivalent” scores, Ms. Rokicki determined that STUDENT had made about one year of growth in broad reading, seven months in broad math, and five months in broad written language over the previous year, although she remained far behind her same-grade peers, and even farther behind her same-age peers. District’s Exh. 136.
On November 21, 2001, resource specialist Teri Petrocco assessed STUDENT to determine her levels of academic achievement. Ms. Petrocco assessed STUDENT instead of her current RSP teacher, Ms. Kemp, because MOTHER did not trust Ms. Kemp. Ms. Petrocco administered the norm-referenced Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini Battery of Achievement (WMWMB) and the criterion-referenced Brigance Test of Basic Skills (Brigance). During the administration of the tests, Ms. Petrocco made the following observations:
Pronounced delays in language classification, language association, receptive language, and expressive language were evident during the administration of the instruments. Her answers to questions often were not related to the question. When asked her street, she responded, “Tree.” STUDENT did not conceptualize same and different or opposites. She had difficulty deriving meaning from words and relating the spoken word with the appropriate unit of experience. When she spoke, she spoke in clipped responses, almost telegraphic speech. She does not perceive quantity. She conceptualizes at a basic, concrete level, unable to operate at the functional level or the abstract level. STUDENT’s background information is extremely delayed. Her score on the factual information of the Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini Battery was comparable to a child not yet four years of age. STUDENT perseverates repeatedly. After reciting the alphabet, the answers for several responses, to any inquiry, consisted of letters. When asked where she lived, she replied, “P, Q B D.” When asked if she had any sisters or brothers, the letters were again invoked.
District’s Exh. 136.
On the WMWMB, STUDENT’s overall performance was measured to be the same as that of child aged 5 years and 10 months. STUDENT was 8 years and 9 months old at that time. At the end of her report, Ms. Petrocco concluded as follows:
In this examiner’s opinion, grounded in twenty-seven years experience and the information garnered from the assessment session, STUDENT is functioning as a preschooler who has memorized her alphabet. Placement in the second grade regular classroom may prove problematic for STUDENT. Yet, in her present situation, STUDENT appears well adjusted and comfortable and completely unaware of the discrepancies that exist between her and her peers.
Id. [Emphasis added.]
On November 28, 2001, a speech and language evaluation was completed by speech and language therapist Beth Sigman, STUDENT’s current speech and language therapist. Overall, she determined that STUDENT was making some progress, but remained 4 to 5 years behind in her language skills. District’s Exh. 139.
On December 3, 3002, STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting convened. Ms. Rokicki discussed her assessment; however, Ms. Petrocco’s assessment was not discussed as the team had not yet received her report. The regular education teacher, Ms. Pham, and the resource teacher, Ms. Kemp, were in attendance. Ms. Kemp reported that STUDENT had met her reading goals but had not met her math or written language goals and objectives.(Footnote 6) Ms. Kemp recommended an increase in RSP services and expressed that any reduction would be detrimental to STUDENT. Testimony of Kemp. MOTHER requested a reduction in resource services to three times each week for 25 minutes, and further requested that STUDENT only receive RSP in the area of reading comprehension. Goals and objectives were developed in expressive and receptive language and reading comprehension and the IEP team agreed to reduce STUDENT’s RSP as requested by MOTHER. District’s Exh. 140. Thereafter, STUDENT continued to attend Ms. Pham’s regular education classroom, with RSP three times each week, 25 minutes each session, addressing the area of reading comprehension only.
In February 2002, an IEP team meeting convened to discuss enrolling STUDENT in the English Language Learner program (ELL), a class for students who are learning English. MOTHER rejected the regular education ELL class because she preferred to keep STUDENT in the regular education class with English speaking peers. District’s Exh. 143.
In March 2002, Ms. Kemp prepared a report regarding STUDENT’s progress on her reading comprehension goal and objectives. She reported that STUDENT could read first grade level paragraphs, but that she could not understand what she had read, and she could not identify the main idea of a paragraph. She also reported that STUDENT had difficulty focusing on her work, that she is easily distracted, and that she “tends to laugh at herself.” District’s Exh. 145.
After the progress report, MOTHER requested that STUDENT be removed from all RSP services. District’s Exh. 146. An IEP team meeting convened on April 25, 2002 to discuss MOTHER’s request. Ms. Pham reported at the meeting that STUDENT was not currently passing in any subject but spelling, her relative area of strength. The team considered continued RSP pull-out services, and also considered changing STUDENT’s RSP delivery model to “push-in” model by which the RSP teacher provides instruction in the regular education classroom, but MOTHER rejected both options. No agreement was reached regarding STUDENT’s program. District’s Exh. 148.
On May 23, 2002, the District presented to thePARENTS an assessment plan in which the proposed to assess STUDENT in the following areas: (1) academic achievement; (2) social/adaptive behavior; (3) visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills; (4) intellectual functioning; (5) health and development; and (6) speech/language communication. ThePARENTS refused to consent to the assessment plan. A few days later, the District and thePARENTS requested separate due process hearings, and the two cases were eventually consolidated into the present matter.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
STUDENT’S ISSUE: Does STUDENT require resource specialist program (RSP) services to address her reading comprehension needs?
STUDENT contends that she does not require RSP services in the area of reading comprehension (or any other area) to receive a free and appropriate public education. STUDENT’s current IEP, developed in December 2001, provides for pullout RSP services, in the area of reading comprehension, in the amount of 25 minutes, three days each week.(Footnote 7)
The District contends that STUDENT must receive at least the same RSP services that her current IEP provides her to address her deficits in the area of reading comprehension. The District further contends that its proposed assessment will likely reveal numerous other unique needs which will require additional special education services (the District’s proposed assessment is discussed below).
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities such as STUDENT have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means special education and related services that are available to the student, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. Id. at 200.(Footnote 8)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, an appropriate program for STUDENT must be (1) designed to meet her unique needs, (2) reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with her IEP. Each of these factors will be discussed below in the context of the issue presented, whether STUDENT requires RSP services in the area of reading comprehension.
With regard to the first question, whether STUDENT requires RSP services to meet her unique needs in the area of reading comprehension, MOTHER testified generally that STUDENT has no such unique need and that STUDENT understands everything that she reads. The District presented substantial evidence that STUDENT continues to have a unique need in the area of reading comprehension. STUDENT’s reading comprehension was measured by the Woodcock-McGrew-Werder Mini-Battery of Achievement to be at the 6 year, 5 month level in November 2001, more than three years behind her chronological age at that time. Ms. Kemp, who oversaw implementation of STUDENT’s reading comprehension goal during the 2001-2002 school year, testified that while STUDENT is able to successfully decode words at about a first grade level, she is not able to understand what she has just read. Ms. Pham, STUDENT’s regular education teacher, testified similarly: STUDENT cannot understand what she reads. Ms. Pham explained that at the end of the second grade, STUDENT was still reading at a “pre-primer” level (the first few months of first grade). It was not disputed that STUDENT has not yet met her reading comprehension goal and objectives that were developed at the December 2001 IEP. Testimony of Kemp. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers: STUDENT has unique needs in the area of reading comprehension.(Footnote 9)
The next question is whether RSP is an appropriate program for meeting STUDENT’s unique reading comprehension needs. MOTHER provided no evidence that STUDENT’s current RSP services are not necessary to implement her reading goal and objectives – she simply wants STUDENT removed from the RSP program. Both Ms. Kemp and Ms. Pham generally testified that at least the amount of resource time STUDENT currently receives is necessary to implement STUDENT’s goal and objectives in reading comprehension.
In light of the need for a comprehensive assessment, as determined below, the Hearing Officer cannot determine whether STUDENT’s current RSP services provide her with a FAPE; it may be that she requires substantially more services to meet her unique reading needs. However, given current information, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires at least the amount and type of RSP services she receives pursuant to her current IEP to receive a FAPE. Therefore, her parents’ request to remove STUDENT from RSP at this time is denied.(Footnote 10)
In sum, it has been found that STUDENT requires at least the amount and type of RSP services that she currently receives to address her reading comprehension needs.
DISTRICT’S ISSUE: Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the May 23, 2002 assessment plan?
The District requests that it be allowed to assess STUDENT pursuant to its May 23, 2002 assessment plan to determine the scope and extent of STUDENT’s unique needs, and to assist the IEP team in developing an appropriate program for her. The District proposes to assess STUDENT in the following areas: (1) academic achievement; (2) social/adaptive behavior; (3) visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills; (4) intellectual functioning; (5) health and development; and (6) speech/language communication.(Footnote 11) MOTHER generally contends that no assessment is necessary because the District assessed STUDENT prior to the annual review in November 2001 (only achievement and speech and language assessments were conducted at that time).
School districts are required to reevaluate a student when conditions warrant a reevaluation, but at least once every three years. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). STUDENT’s triennial is not due until 2003. The District contends that conditions currently warrant an assessment in all of the above-described areas. The Hearing Officer will examine each proposed area of assessment to determine if conditions warrant reassessment in that area at this time.
Academic Achievement
The first area in which the District seeks to reassess STUDENT is academic achievement. MOTHER testified that the District had assessed STUDENT in November 2001, and therefore no reassessment is currently necessary. STUDENT’s teachers testified that she is faring poorly in all academic areas (other than spelling) and that she requires additional special education services. Testimony of Pham and Kemp. Kathy Rokicki, the school psychologist who last assessed STUDENT in this area (along with resource teacher Teri Petrocco), testified that STUDENT has deficits in areas of written language and mathematics, in addition to reading.
The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers who suspect that STUDENT currently has unique needs in multiple academic areas. To establish STUDENT’s present levels of performance and whether she has unique needs in areas other than reading comprehension, the District must assess STUDENT’s academic achievement. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that conditions warrant reassessment of STUDENT’s academic achievement at this time.
Social/Adaptive Behavior
The District proposes to reassess STUDENT in the area of social/adaptive behavior.(Footnote 12) Ms. Pham testified that STUDENT exhibited odd behaviors in the classroom, which included laughing with no evident cause, and attention problems. She also testified that STUDENT does not interact with other students on the playground. Elizabeth Kemp testified that STUDENT has difficulty maintaining focus and attention problems. Teri Petrocco observed what she described as perseverative behaviors during her assessment. As developed above in the background facts, there are numerous other references to autistic-like behaviors, to autism and to attention problems in STUDENT’s school records. The Hearing Officer finds that conditions warrant assessment in social/adaptive behavior.
Visual/Auditory Perception and Processing/Motor Skills
The third area in which the District seeks to assess STUDENT is visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills. As discussed above, STUDENT struggled in all academic areas during the second grade. There was also evidence that STUDENT may have a processing disorder that contributes to STUDENT’s academic struggles. Elizabeth Kemp testified that she believes STUDENT may have a processing disorder and that STUDENT has displayed peculiar decoding deficits, problems with blends and what she described as a “cut off” in comprehension. Cathy Rokicki testified that STUDENT may have an auditory processing disorder and that further tests in this area are warranted. The Hearing Officer finds that conditions warrant a reassessment in this area as well. The District must determine if STUDENT has an auditory or visual processing disorder that contributes to STUDENT’s academic difficulties.
Intellectual Functioning
The fourth area in which the District seeks to assess STUDENT is intellectual functioning. Cathy Rokicki testified persuasively that conditions warrant reassessment of STUDENT’s intellectual functioning. She generally explained that the District does not yet have a clear picture of STUDENT’s intellectual functioning and that different assessments should be administered in this area to determine STUDENT’s potential, in both English and Spanish. The Hearing Officer finds that conditions warrant reassessment in this area.
Health and Development
The final area in dispute is health and development. Cathy Rokicki testified that further assessments are necessary at this time to determine if STUDENT’s vision or hearing problems are impacting her education. In that regard, MOTHER testified that STUDENT wears glasses, but that she only needs them for certain activities, such as viewing a computer screen. The Hearing Officer finds that conditions warrant reassessment in this area; it may be that a vision and/or hearing screening will reveal areas of disability which require special education services and supports.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District established that conditions warrant a reevaluation of STUDENT’s academic achievement, social/adaptive behavior; visual/auditory perception and processing/motor skills; intellectual functioning; and health and development needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is entitled to conduct an assessment STUDENT pursuant to its May 23, 2002 assessment plan, notwithstanding the parents’ lack of consent for the above assessments to be performed.
The Hearing Officer notes that testing and observations over the past several years dating back to STUDENT’s time in Centralia reveal, among other things, that STUDENT has had significant deficits in multiple areas and that many of those deficits may have not been appropriately addressed or even assessed. It is also noted that at multiple IEP team meetings, STUDENT’s parents requested a reduction in services, and the District acquiesced, despite the belief of District personnel that more services were required. A district is required to offer an appropriate program that it believes will meet a student’s needs, even when a parent or guardian disagrees. There is no exception in the IDEA or State law. It is imperative that both the District and the STUDENT cooperate to ensure that the current assessments are completed and reviewed as soon as possible so that STUDENT’s unique needs can be identified and she can receive the services she needs.
ORDER
1. The District is entitled to assess STUDENT in conformity with its May 23, 2002 assessment plan (District’s Exhibit 161). The District shall schedule the assessments and shall provide the STUDENT with a minimum of ten days notice of the dates of the assessments. The STUENT shall make STUDENT available on the dates scheduled by the District. The District shall take all reasonable steps to ensure that the assessments are completed and an IEP meeting convened within the required timelines.
2. Student’s request for relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
STUDENT’S ISSUE
Does STUDENT require resource specialist program (RSP) services to address her reading comprehension needs? -The District prevailed on this issue.
DISTRICT’S ISSUE
Should the District be allowed to assess STUDENT pursuant to the May 23, 2002 assessment plan? -The District prevailed on this issue
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505(j).
DATED: August 14, 2002 _____________________________________ Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. After several invitations to attend an IEP meeting were rejected by thePARENTS, Centralia eventually held an IEP team meeting without them. District’s Exh. 67. Two days after the IEP team meeting, Centralia “dropped” STUDENT from the program at Dysinger “due to not being present in class as of September 12, 1997.” 2. A speech and language assessment completed the following spring (April 2000) notes that thePARENTS failed to tell anyone at Cypress that their daughter had previously received special education services when they first enrolled her in the District. District’s Exh. 91. 3. The speech therapist’s name is illegible on the assessment report. 4. The IEP reflects that the meeting was an addendum to the December 8, 2000 IEP, not her annual IEP. 5. STUDENT’s summer school program was not part of an extended school year (ESY) program. 6. In the goal area of written language, STUDENT had met her spelling objective but had not yet met her objective “to write a 3-5 word passage.” 7. The December 3, 2001 IEP was developed at STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting, in the middle of her second grade school year, and states that her placement is to continue to her next annual meeting in December 2002, the middle of her third grade school year. 8. Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that her removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and the severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular education classes with use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031. 9. MOTHER testified generally that STUDENT’s teachers were lying and that they wanted to “hold her back” and not recognize her true ability level in all academic areas. Her unsupported statements were not persuasive. 10. Again, it is likely that STUDENT will require significantly more special education services once the District’s proposed assessments are completed and reviewed by the IEP team. 11. At the Hearing MOTHER stipulated that the District’s proposal to assess STUDENT in the area of language/speech/communication development was appropriate. Testimony of MOTHER. Accordingly, this proposed area of assessment will not be discussed below. 12. The District last assessed STUDENT’s adaptive behavior the fall of 2000, and at that time, rating scales were administered, one to the parent and one to the classroom teacher. The teacher found STUDENT’s adaptive behavior to be significantly below age expectancies. The Hearing Officer notes that the District has never assessed STUDENT for autism (nor did Centralia, STUDENT’s previous district) despite educational records replete with reference to perseverative, echolalic and autistic-like behaviors.
